Latest revision as of 18:36, 17 March 2020

Text

Forwards Transcripts of Prepared Direct Testimony & cross- Examination of Jl Parks on Behalf of Delmarva P&L Co in MD Public Svc Commission Hearing on Facility
	ML18082A325
Person / Time
Site:	Salem
Issue date:	05/01/1980
From:	Russell W; WHITFIELD A. RUSSELL & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
To:	Russell W; Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
	NUDOCS 8005080461
	Download: ML18082A325 (153)
	v • d • e

{{#Wiki_filter:t:::::= }-----

~:_:~_:~:    ,.
                  * ' - - " ' ' <r

.:;.: ... *.*Mr. Wil:li a~:,".I ~*-; .Russe 11 * **., :,., * *

.::::~ "Chief.,;.,:Techpica1* Support Branch *

< NRC),*::k_i/

                                        * ::-:7920. Norfolk ;'Avenue
                                                                                 ~<

Offici;~r'jJ~l~~i Reactor Regula~ion i <{-{+_:: ~ :::~:,~ :::**::< {li:*. c J *!*'ki(:Y .t

                                     . :':'.Phillips"."Buiiding, *Room::,433 Bethesda*, Maryland 20023 ,., :.
                                                                                                                   -1*-*:::-... *
                                                                                                                                       ---, ,; : -l**,1*

, ,._,_. -*~

                                                                                                                                       *;:.~'
                                        .:. :-- .*.                    RE: Maryland PSC Hearing on Salem No. 1

Dear.Mr. Russell:

                                                                 .:..'"' -:. -~ ".;:<;:--. :_:   _:_: ~:..,.::: r.~          ~:- .; .{. _. _,.;:

_____ .i _: : /.:.:::.?:Encf6'se'cf please. find t;~ni~ript*s of the prepared direct

=====' ,

=!-:. , ~~~itim6~j 1 irid"cro~s examin~lion of Mr. Jame~ L~' Parks on behalf of Delmarva r&L Company in Marylan~ P.s~c~*case No~;7239G *. ,

. _ ~~-~*.:? ~ *:* ~ r; f.- -~::.;_*; :-:. *.: ~-- : _

                                   ~-: ;* .: ...--'.. .Mr: Gary* Alexand~/, . Sp ecia*l _Counsel. to . the .Mary land People's

- - - . -i Counsel, intends to request your attendance at an 2 _

r as-yet-unscheduled hearing in Baltimore concerning the performance of PSE&G of New Jersey in returning Salem No. 1 to service in late 1979. . . .

Would you be kind enough to review the enclosed mate~ial and call me to discuss it? Mr. Alexander can be reached at 292-3300. Thank you. Your very truly, C\ Russell

                                                 *,.* ~-:.' '    :

0 * -. L cc: ~John K~ Keane, Jr.

Gary Alexander Alvin J. Garber Bruce Louiselle

                                                                                                                                                                        . Dor.'.mt#50--~212..

C".,~r:J # .8'oo503o '1-t I fh'"P. .:r- 1-*s tJ of D1_1cument: rl:11mlAIC-:~Y DOCKET FiU

                                                                          -  *- --* -----*. -                  .-          -      -       -- *--* *-   . ------. ---   -----***- ----- -*--*-***-*-**- ----.------*** -~.----**-*--* ---.---*- - **- -----*----------~* --*--

                                                 *~*~.-i                              .**,.""*

WEBB, BURNETT cSc DUVALL ATTORNEYS_ AT* LAW:**::

1is BROAD :*STREET.:.:/

                                                             **,:~:- P.O.-~OX     910 ARE:A CooE 301 TELE:PHONE 74.2*3176 PAUL O. WILBER . '

OAVIO A,VORMIS

                                           *; ..                               March 28 ,. 1980
                                      **_*f .
                                        ., 1
                                                                               .i
                                           *::.                                 l Ronald E~ Hawkins Executive Secretary                           . ~-*--. .. .:.*\!

Public Service Commission of Maryland American Building *~ .,;, .. 231 East Baltimore ~treet Baltimore, Maryland 212.~-.-- Re:

Dear Mr. Hawkins:

Ple~se~find enclosed. for filing in the above matter t~~(- original and JO'copies of Supplemental .Testimony of James L._ Parks, concerning-the ~utage at the Salem generating station.2. Copies: of t~e Testimony are being mailed directly to all counsel of record and the con~ultants for the Office of People's Counsel. Very truly yours, David A. Vorhis ~ DAV:alb Enclosures xc: Gary R. Alexander, Esq. Ronald Decker, Esq. Alvin Garber Bruce Louiselle Whitfield A. Russell. J1 Paul N. Shellenberger James L. Parks Earl D. Krapf Paul S. Gerritsen

I

 \...__

4/3 . 6/27 W#&LWJ'

                                  *.****.:.'.,*.*.,[':.f'~)>',t,.*:. :.:,.**.
                                                       ~

o*.*:: ;

                                                                               .**1 ,;, .*.*                                     5/31      7/20 Controi Rod Rod lets * :{

4H4 4M 1,'.

~~ . t .j. ;-~*-* ~ .. ,

                                                                                    *~.:.., '*
                     .. :'i)<****

fi '. :~;:

       .,.,,                                                                                                                                 '.l :,

    ,,.              DELMARVA POWER     & LIGHT COMPANY SUPPLEMENTAL TESTIMONY OF JAMES L. PARKS BEFORE THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION OF MARYLAND P.S.C. CASE NO. 7239G

1. Q: Please state your name, title and address.

A: *My name is James L. Parks, Performance Coor-dinator,. Electric Production Department, Delmarva Power & Light Company, 630 W. Front Street, Wilming-ton, DE 19899.

2. Q: Have you previously testified in this proceeding?

A: Yes.

3. Q: What is the purpose of your supplemental testimony in this case?

\. - A: In its Final Order in PSC Case No. 7239F, the Commission retained jurisdiction to review the refueling outage of Salem No. 1 in a subsequent fuel.rate case. I am hereby responding to that request.

4. Q: What is the extent of Delmarva's interest in Salem No. l?

A: As the Commission is aware, Delmarva owns a 7.41% interest in the Salem No. 1 nuclear generating station, which is located in Salem, New Jersey. Salem No. 1 is operated by Public Service

Electric and Gas Company ("PSE&G"). Representatives

                 .from Delmarva participate with the joint owners in

several committees at Salem, including an Owners Committee, an O&M Committee, which oversees the station's budget and its operations generally, and a Nuclear Fuel Subcommittee. I am presently Delmarva's representative on the Nuclear Fuel Subcommittee. Salem No. 1 first began commercial operation on June 30, 1977. The outage which is under review*here was its first refueling outage.

5. Q: What was the planned schedule for the refueling outage?

A: The refueling outage for Salem No. 1 was original_ly scheduled for April 3, 1979 through June 27, 1979. After approximately twelve days of oyerspeed and power ascension testing, the-unit was scheduled to return to full power on July 9. In addition to the reactor refueling, other maintenance and inspection activities were scheduled to be performed during this period, including retubing of the main condenser, replacement of four rows of blades in two of the low-pressure turbines, and all the various required inspection and surveillance activities.

6. Q: What was the acutal duration of the outage?

A: Salem No. 1 was taken out of service, as scheduled, at 7:30 p.m. on April 3, 1979. The unit did not return to service until December 27, 1979, six months after its scheduled return date.

7. Q: Please summarize.the reasons for this extension.

                                            ,.. A:        Three factors were .generally responsible for the outage extension. First, a short delay occurred due to modification of some fuel handling equipment, and then some fuel element grid strap damage occurred during the fuel handling, which required a further extension. Second, a* number of broken**

rodlets were discovered, and this required replacement

                  .of all affected rod control cluster assemblies.

Third, and the governing fa6tor responsible for the major portion of the outage extension, the _Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") issued a number of Inspection and Enforcement Bulletins during this period; many of which were revised and supplemented by the NRC while compliance activities were underway, and the unit was not permitted to return to service until the work required by the NRC was completed.

8. Q: Please discuss the first factor which you have identified~ namely, the damage to the grid straps.

A: On May 6, while fuel*elements were being removed pursuant to the manufacturer's instructions, and with special equipment designed and furnished by Westinghouse for this purpose, the operators observed damage to some of the fuel element grid straps. PSE&G decided, as a precautionary measure, to remove and inspect all original core fuel

~-

assemblies. It discovered that 31 out of 193 fuel assernblies were, in fact, damaged. Extensive

analysis of the possible causes of the damage revealed that no single factor was responsible. A combination of inexperience with the thinner grid straps on 17 x 17 fuel, corner-to-corner inter-action between adjacent fuel assemblies, and assembly bow were all contributory factors. In order to minimize the risk of damage during handling, Westinghouse thereafter revised

its fuel handling proced~res,*and these procedures were followed for all subsequent fuel handling.

As a result of the grid strap damage, the core loading plan was revised to allow some fuel assemblies which were scheduled for discharge to e \ be re-inserted to take the place of fuel assem-blies which showed the most severe grid strap damage. This revision required a re-analysis of the performance.of the core and approval of the changes by the NRC before the re-load license amendment could be issued.

9. Q: Discuss the broken rodlets problem.

A: On May 31, ~hen a rod control cluster assembly was removed from a fuel assembly, two rodlets were found to be completely detached from the control rod spider. Again, as a precautionary measure, PSE&G decided to inspect all rod control

cluster assemblies for such problems. Special tools were designed and fabricated to expedite this work.

,r .                 PSE&G found eight failed rodlets, associated with six different rod control cluster assemblies, all of which were traced back to two production lots from the same manufacturer. Since 19 other assemblies in the Salem core also had rodlets from. the same production lots, PSE&G decided to replace all of these assemblies in order to insure against future difficulty in this area. The fuel supplier, Westinghouse, agreed to replace the damaged rod cluster assemblies free of charge.

10. Q: The grid strap damage and broken rodlet incidents, which you have just discussed, were considered by this Commission in previous fuel rate proceedings, were they not?

A: Yes, they were. The Commission reviewed these matters in PSC Case No. 7239E. Company witness Mr. Jack Urban sponsored several exhibits in that proceeding which are also pertinent here. These include the Six Month General Office Report, which covers the Salem outage through June 30, and arreport prepared by Mr * .Urban of events at Salem through July 31. In addition, the Commission has received weekly summaries of the outage covering the period July 31 through December 27.

11. Q: Have any additional reports been prepared concerning work during the Salem outage?

~.

A: Yes. A second Six Month General Office Report covering July 1 through December 31 was

prepared by PSE&G, together with a Design Change Report for the-same period. I am hereby sponsoring those reports as Exhibits JP-1 and JP-2, respec-tively.

12. Q: You mentioned earlier that compliance with certain NRC Bulletins was a major factor in the extended outage. *what Bulletins, in particular, affected the length of the Salem outage?

A: The grid strap and rodlet problems, which were principally responsible for the extension of the planned outage to July 20, were largely resolved and completed by late July. By that time, however, the NRC had just issued a series of Inspection and Enforcement Bulletins, due in part to the intense scrutiny of nuclear plants following the Three Mile Island incident. The NRC would not permit Salem to resume operation until PSE&G complied with the requirements of these Bulletins, including revisions_and supplements, to the NRC's satisfaction. The following NRC Bulletins required work which significantly affected the outage schedule at Salem: 79-02 Pipe Support Base Plate Design Using Concrete Expansion Anchor Bolts

      ..-.              (Issued on March 8, 1979; Revision No

1-issued on June 21; Supplement No. 1 issued on August 20; further revisions

issued on November 9) 79-07 Seismic Stress Analysis of Safety Related Piping (Issued on April 14, 1979; Revisions issued on July 5 and August 28) 79-13 Cracking in Feedwater System Piping (Issued on June 25, 1979; Revisions issued on August 30 and October 17) 79-14 Seismic Analysis for As-Built Safety-Related Piping Systems (Issued on July 2, 1979; Supplement No. 1 issued on August 15; Supplement No. 2 issued on September 7) Five additional NRC Bulletins were also issued during this period. Although they did not directly affect the length of the outage, they did have-an impact because personnel had to be diverted from the Bulletins listed above in order to do the necessary work and prepare replies for filing with the NRC. These Bulletins thus reduced the overall .) resources that were available for work on the Bulletins listed above. The additional Bulletins were the following: 79-01 Environmental Qualification of Class lE Equipment (Issued on February 8, 1979; Revisions issued on June 6)

~-

79-03 Youngstown Engineering ASME SA-312 type 304 Pipe (Issued on March 12,

1979) 79-04 Incorrect Weights for Swing Check Values issued on March 30, 1979) 79-15 De 7p Draft Pump Deficiencies (Issued on July 11, 1979) 79-17 Pipe Cracks in Stagnant Borated Water Systems at PWR (Issued on July 26, 1979; Revision issued on October

29) *

13. Q: Please describe in detail the requirements imposed by NRC Bulletin 79-02 and the activities at Salem which were performed in.compliance therewith.

A: *Bulletin 79-02 concerned the operability of safety-related piping systems during a hypothe-tical seismic* event. The NRC noted that increased experience had shown that the assumption that concrete base plates were rigid, which had been accepted by the NRC heretofore, was not always valid and that, in some installations, the design load on certain anchor bolts was consequently underestimated. It further noted a trend in the design industry toward more rigorous controls and verification of the installation of anchor bolts. The original scope of Bulletin 79-02, when it was issued on March 8, 1979, merely required utilities to verify the design and installation of concrete anchor bolts, baseplates and piping

                         ,. supports in safety-related systems. Subsequent revisions and supplements, however, which were issued on June 21, August 20 and November 9, greatly increased the scope of this work. As revised and supplemented, the Bulletin required utilities to do the following, among.other things:

1. The NRC established a new criterion, which it recognized was "conservative", for deter-mining whether pipe support baseplates were flex-ible. Based on this criterion the utility was required to recalculate bolt design loads using an appropriate analysis.

2. The utility had to verify that concrete expansion anchor blots achieved newly-specified

    *safety factors.

3. The utility had to describe the design requirements to withstand cyclic loads, such as seismic loads and high frequency vibratory oper-ating loads, and verify that the design require-ments were met, based on an approved testing program proposed by the utility.

In order to comply with Bulletin 79-02, PSE&G had to examine approximately 3500 concrete*anchor bolts. In addition, PSE&G and 13 other utilities formed an owners group to pool testing resources

and develop a computer program to analyze baseplate flexibility and perform tests to verify the design requirements.

                              ,.                PSE&G's initial response to the NRC on July 4 outlined a program for the testing and examination of anchor bolts in safety-related piping systems. This program included ultrasonic examination to determine the effective length of embedment and analytical calculations of 850 supports employing baseplates.

A meeting was held with the NRC on August 6 to review PSE&G's initial response. At this meeting, the NRC expressed concern that the pro-posed testing program did not adequately verify the bolt wedge set as required.by the Bulletin. PSE&G agreed to conduct further studies to verify the wedge set of the 3500 anchor bolts. The NRC also reviewed the test reports prepared for PSE&G and PSE&G's support of its conclusion. There were no exceptions to the reports. PSE&G then addressed the further studies and the changes necessary to comply with the standards set by Bulletin 79-02, including the revisions and supplements* thereto *.

Compliance was completed on November 26, and the Bulletin was closed on Dec-ember 5.

14. Q: Describe Bulletin 79-07 and the work performed pursuant thereto.

~ A: NRC Bulletin 79-07, which was issued on April 14, 1979, arose from discrepancies observed by the NRC between the previously accepted computer code

used to analyze piping stress during earthquakes and a new, more sophisticated computer code. According to the Bulletin, the difference between the two computer codes in predicting piping stresses resulted from the different techniques in combining predicted horizontal loads and predicted vertical loads. The computer code previously accepted by the NRC used an algebraic sununation of the loads for both the horizontal and vertical components, wi.th the result that predicted loads in the negative direction could offset predicted loads.in the positive direction. The *NRC Bulletin acknowledged that this problem had not been recognized at the time the original analyses were performed. The proper treatment of these predicted load com-ponents, according to the NRC, was to combine their absolute values or.to take the square root of the sum of the squares ("SRSS"). The Bulletin required utilities to identify the treatment that had been used to analyze stresses on safety-related piping. If the previously-accepted algebraic sununation method had been used, then the utility was required to re-analyze the safety-related piping, supports and equipment which might be affected by the change in analysis technique.

On May 1, PSE&G's first.response to the NRC confirmed that 15 safety-related systems had been analyzed with the algebraic summa~ion method. *one exception was the reactor coolant loop piping which had been analyzed by Westinghouse .with a different approach. On June 18, PSE&G submitted a re-evaluation of the residual heat removal system which showed no overstressed*lines. On June 29, the scope of-Bulletin 79-07 was expanded significantly to include, among other things, nozzle loads, penetra~ions and bench mark problem comparisons using a new 30 SRSS method. On August 18, PSE&G submitted a report to the NRC with 138 sample stress calculations using the new method. None of these analyses indicated overstressed conditions.

In the August 28 revision, the NRC specified certain conditions for returning Salem No. 1 to service. They required a 2-phase approach:

1. Complete the test on wall and ceiling mounts for concrete anchors for in-acce~sihle ~;t;eq$ (.c9nt?i,;i.nment ?1,nd ?\UX-iliary *f eedwatei.L. Subrci.i. t a pr9grP.I'!l for tes*ting anchor bolts* and basep*lates in accessible areas ouside containment and perform evaluation detailing the basis for resumption of operation.

2. Provide a basis for returning to service prior to completion of all the require-ments of 79-07.

On September 20, PSE&G reported that, based on its pipe stress analysis and pipe* support re-e_valuation, some degree of modification was

                                            ~equired for 372 of the 3,087 supports evaluated.

,. PSE&G thereafter .updated the status of its evalu-ation and began to complete support evaluations for the core spray, safety injection, chemical and volume control and main steam systems. The resident NRC inspector reviewed PSE&G's procedures and examined its documentation for the Bulletin. On October 30, the NRC authorized initiation of operation for Cycle 2 Mode 2 (start-up to 5% power). The continuation of Phase 2, given 60 days of power ascension, is still underway to complete the commitment to.79-07. Between the months of April and December, 400 ,*ooo manhours in engineering and design work were required to comply with Bulletin 79-07, involving as many as 220 engineers and designers who worked an average of 65 hours per week. Outside consultants accounted for much of this manpower since PSE&G's internal resources obviously could not handle such a massive commitment without outside assistance.

15. Q: Desc~ibe Bulletin 79-14 and the work performed pursuant thereto.

A: NRC Bulletin 79-14 was issued on July 2, 1979. It ~as revised on July 18, and supplements were issued on August 15 and September 7. This Bulletin required utilities to verify that stress analysis calculations, including seismic calcula-

tions of safety-related piping systems were compatible with as-built conditions. Where subsequent use, damage or modification may have. affected the condition or configuration of these piping systems, the utility was required to deter-mine whether the seismic analyses reflected the as-built configuration. To comply with Bulletin 79-14 as originally issued, PSE&G was required to check each of the 15 piping systems and verify that the stress analysis calculations represented as-built conditions. Revision No. 1, issued on July 18, required more specific documentation by September 14.* PSE&G's response to the NRC indicated that of the 883 calculations for the 15 systems, 237 had been checked, including 157 inaccessible and 80 accessi-ble systems within the primary boundary. The reactor coolant loop, which was not required to be checked for the summation of forces required in 79-07, was included for 79-14. Supplement No. 1, issued on August 15, required an immediate physical inspection of part of the

accessible piping. Where elements that were important to the seismic analysis could not be viewed because of thermal insulation or location of the piping, then the utility was required to remove the insulation or other material to provide access. Where physical inspection was not practic~-

                        ,,. ble, the utility was required to verify conformance

by inspection of quality assurance records.

NRC also stated that if a non-conformance were The found the utility must evaluate its significance as rapidly-as possible, through an initial engineering judgment followed by an analytical engineering evaluatio~ to determine whether operability of the system would be jeopardized during an earthquake. On September 7, *supplement No. 2 was issued. PSE&G was asked to measure or approximate the pipe support locations and to measure or estimate clearances between piping supports, integral piping attachments and supports, and piping and penetrations. The NRC also said that loose bolts should be treated as non-conformances if they invalidated the seismic analysis and that areas. where inspection was impractical, even with a reactor shutdown, would be addressed on a case by case basis. Supplement No. 2 was answered on October 29. Check of the 15 piping systems indic~ted 125 minor discrepancies, none of which invalidated the stress analysis. Some of these had been involved with the corrections performed on the support structures for Bulletins 79-07 and 79-02. In some

instances the work was done twice because of the dates the Bulletins were received and the times established for compliance. A total of 20,000

manhours of engineering and design work was required to comply with Bulletin 79~14.

16. Q: Please describe Bulletin 79-13 and the work performed pursuant thereto.

A: NRC Bulletin No. 79-13, issued on June 25, 1979, followed a letter from the_NRC on May 25 for operational information and analysis of the feed-water system. This Bulletin resulted from the discovery of cracks in the fee~water line at the No. 2 Unit of the DC Cook power station, which was** shut down on May 19, as well as subsequent cracks found at other installations. PSE&G was aware of the situation prior to receipt of the Bulletin and had begun to inspect the feedwater nozzles at Salem No. 1 early in June. Bulletin 79-13 required operators of PWR facilities to perform radiographic examinations, supplemented by ultrasonic examination as necessary, of all feedwater nozzle-to-pipin~ welds and adja-cent pipe and nozzle areas. In addition, a visual inspection of feedwater system piping supports and snubbers in containment was required to verify operability and conformance to design. Based on radiographic inspections, PSE&G found cracks in 3 of the 4 piping connections to the steam generators, and decided to replace the

        ~lbows with new elbows as quickly as possible.

Corrective measures consisted of removal of

internal notches and more tightly controlled welding procedures during the installation of new elbows. New instrumentation was added to monitor operational conditions. - PSE&G also inspected all of the piping joints between the containment and the steam generators, in accordance with the requirements of the initial Bulletin. Subsequent revisions to the Bulletin, however, reduced the inspection requirements in are~s already completed. Final reports for both Units 1 and 2 were submitted on November 14 and this Bulletin was closed. PSE&G is continuing to participate in an ~- Owners Group which was formed to study the condi-tions which caused the cracking. The study involves 10 utilities and 16 generating units that have shown cracking.

17. Q: Was any additional work performed during the outage relating to the Three Mile Island incident?

A: Yes. Three TMI-re+ated items required by the NRC were expedited and completed during this outage. *They were:

1. Installing a containment sump vortex breaker.

2. Providing a redundant pressurizer back-

'* 3.

up heater power feed. Adding limit safety valves. switches to the pressurizer

r.

The NRC did not require this work to*be completed until later in calendar year 1980. However, an outage would have been required to perform these items, so it was decided to do them during the extended refueling outage and thereby avoid an additional outage in 1980.

18. Q: What efforts were made to coordinate the various activities required by the NRC Bulletins?

A: PSE&G used a computerized project management program to facilitate the planning, scheduling and con~rolling of the outage activities. As various conditions became known which affected the return

             *date of the unit, time estimates were made based on a maximum effort, and a new critical path and return date were determined. Meetings were held on a daily basis, attended by knowledgeable repre-sentatives from all departments, to review the progress of the work, identify problem areas _and develop solutions to the* problems. Reports were reviewed and updated on a*1most   a daily ]Sa"sis.*

Personnel in the General Office Production Depart-

             .ment ot PSE&G were assigned to monitor the progress of the work and act as a liaison between the station and the Enginering and Construction Depart-ment.

All work was done on a seven-day work week, ..

full overtime basis. A maintenance contractor r supplemented PSE&G maintenance personnel in order to implement the changes and modifications as quickly as possible. Outside consultants supple-mented PSE&G engineering personnel for various analytical studies and engineering and design work. During the course of the outage, the critical path activities, i.e., those which determined the length of the outage, were examined on a regular basis to see if a rearrangement of activities could-minimize critical path delays. For example, , during the.reactor fuel shuffle/inspection, it became apparent that restructuring the outage critical path could minimize the length of the outage. After testing alternate arrangements, PSE&G determined that the optimum approach was to shift the entire steam generator sludge lancing operation into the current critical path instead of scheduling it after the fuel shuffle. The ISI inspection of the reactor vessel was also shifted to a future outage. The steam generator secondary systems were drained, and the sludge lancing operation began on May.20. This activity absorbed the critical path delay which would have occurred pending a delivery of the new fuel reload pattern from Westinghouse.

19. Q: When did Salem No. 1 return to service?

A: The unit was returned to service on December 27, and reached 95% of full load on January 10, 1980. Full load was reached for first time on January 20, 1980.

20. Q: Do you have any further comments regarding the Salem outage?._

A: Yes, I do. It is, of course, most unfortunate that the refueling outage at Salem No. l lasted as long as it did, especially in view of the low fuel cost. for nuclear generation and the consequent savings to all of Delmarva's customers. However, I believe the record is clear that the operating company, Public Service Electric & Gas Company, exerted its utmost efforts to bring Salem back into operation as soon as possible. And certainly it is in the public interest that every precaution be taken to make the operation of this complex and sophisticated nuclear plant as safe as human skills can make it. As my testimony has shown, the dominant factor*:throughout the outage was the Nuclear Regulatory Co~ission. Salem was caught in the aftermath of the Three Mile Island incident, which has subjected the nuclear power industry to unpre-cedented scrutiny by both the NRC and the public

generally. Fundamental assumptions concerning the design and operation of nuclear plants have been called into question, and parameters that were

previously accepted by the NRC are being re-examined. My description of what was required to comply with the various NRC Bulletins does not begin to convey the sheer magnitude of the work entailed. As I indicated earlier,* a totai of 220 designers and engineers expended 400,000 manhours working on Bulletin 79-07 alone.

The Sun newspaper carried a story on March 24, 1980, which illustrated the strain on the nuclear industry generally in complying with the NRC requirements. According to that article, work on new reactors has effectively come to a halt so that all available personnel, both utility employees*

and outside consultants, can work on the NRC Bulletins and keep the existing plants operating. The resources of the industry as a whole are clearly stretched to the limit when the NRC requires major design changes, which must be made inunediately, where the original design work may have stretched over 20 years. Salem No. 1 happened to be out of service on a scheduled outage when the NRC began its investi-gations, so that the outage had to be extended until all the various investigations could be completed. Within the constraint of the unfore-seeable actions by the NRC, however, the duration

                               ,..              of the outage was clearly minimized to the extent possible by handling the various NRC requirements in the most efficient and most. timely manner.

There was in no way any error or failure to per-form adequately on the part of Delmarva or PSE&G which prolonged the outage.

21. Q: Does this conclude your supplemental direct testimony?

A: Yes, it does.

~-

EXHIBIT JP-1 SIX MONTH GENERAL OFFICE REPORT MAJOR MAINTENANCE JULY 1, 1979 THROUGH DECEMBER 31, 1979 During the majority of this reporting period Salem I continued with its first refueling outage which started on April 3, 1979. The unit was taken critical at 1639 on December 1, 1979, and was synchronized at 1536 on December 27, 1979.

SIX MONTH GENERAL OFFICE REPORT MAJOR MAINTENANCE JULY 1, 1979 THROUGH DECEMBER 31, 1979 PRINCIPAL SYSTEM WORK PERFORMED Auxiliary ll/12/13/14AF21 (Auxiliary Feedwater Regulating Feedwater Valves) were reworked due to excessive leakage past the seat. Bleed Steam and Bearing oil leaks were repaired on both 11/12 Heater Drains Bleed Steam Coil Drain Tank Pumps. Chemical and 11/12 Boric Acid Pumps oil.seals were repaired. Volume Control - . Various non-isolable containment check valves had their bonnets seal-welded to their bodies to prevent leakage. 11/12 Monitor Tank Pumps had oil leaks repaired. 13 Charging Pump was inspected and certain internal parts replaced. Approximately forty valves were repacked. 11 Charging Pump rotating assembly was replaced with a spare assembly. Circulating All main condenser waterbox doors were inspected Water and repaired as required. No. llA through 13B circulating water discharge elbows were reconditioned while they were removed for the main condenser retubing. No. llA through 13B circulating water inlet waterboxes were reconditioned. No. llB circulating water discharge waterbox expansion joint was replaced. Additional cathodic protection was installed in all inlet and outlet waterboxes. Component 11/12 Component Cooling Water Heat Exchangers Cooling underwent eddy current inspection. Various relief valves were removed, bench tested and returned to service. A variety of valves were repacked and or repaired because of leakage past the seat. Page 1 of 7

PRINCIPAL SYSTEM WORK PERFORMED Condensate A full flow Condensate Polishing System was Polishing installed, tested-and put into service *

Condenser Air Removal and Priming Approximately fifty valves were reworked because of leakage identified during the main condenser.

hydrostatic test.

                  *13 Vacuum Pump was examined for possible block-age.

Containment A variety of valves were repacked and or Spr*ay repaired due to leakage past the seat. Control Rods 19 Rod Control Clusters were replaced after the reactor core was loaded because several control rods from a given material.batch were found to be cracked. Control Rod The rod position indication coil stacks for Position control rods 1A4, 2D4 and lCl were replaced. Indication Control Air No.*:12 Control Air Receiver was inspected. Diesel Generator All diesel generators had their fuel racks and Diesel inspected. Generator Auxiliaries Electrical Power 11/12 Station Power Transformers were inspected. All 4KV, 460V and 230V AC breakers were inspected and tested. 11 Station Power Transformer -was returned to the manufacturer for repair. lFL Lighting Transformer was cleaned and inspected 11 Station Power Transformer tap changer was replaced *. Fresh Water 11/12 Fresh Water Tanks were drained and inspected. Hydrogen Supply 1/2 Hydrogen Recombiners were inspected. Various hydrogen system leaks were repaired. Instrumentation Several incore thermocouple reducers were repaired after they were found.to be leaking. Main Condenser The main condenser underwent one full head hydro-static test and two partial hydrostatic tests after retubing. Page 2 of 7

PRINCIPAL SYSTEM WORK PERFORMED Main Generator The main generator hydrogen coolers were Cooling inspected *

Main Steam and Turbine Bypass All main steam safety valves were disassembled, lapped, reassembled and lift tested.

13MS12 (13 Steam Generator Safety Valve) was disassembled after it stuck open during lift testing. Various main steam valves that had been furminited were disassembled and reworked~ ll/12/13/14MS167 (Main Steam Isolation-Valves) were repacked. ' Approximately one hundred fifty main steam valves were repacked. The four steam generator high point vent valves were capped and tack welded in response to an NRC commitment. All steam generator secondary side manway covers and pads were inspected and machined as necessary. ll/12/14MS10 (Steam Generator Atmospheric Relief Valves) were disassembled and reworked because of leakage*. Moveable All incore detector thimbles were cleaned. Detector Five of the incore detectors were replaced.

Reactor Coolant The thermocouple column marmon clamps were replaced. Both pressurizer power operated relief .valves were reworked because of leakage past the seat. The three pressurizer safeties were removed, bench tested and reinstalled. J The modifications to the pressurizer over pressurization protection system was completed. This included the installation of additional air accumulators and larger tubing. /. 14 Reactor Coolant Pump seals were inspected. Thermocouples were installed on the steam generator primary heads to give differential temperature indication at low reactor coolant system temperature. Page 3 of 7

PRINCIPAL SYSTEM WORK PERFORMED Reactor Coolant The pressurizer steam space manway gasket was (continued) replaced due to leakage. Two reactor vessel head conoseals were replaced due to leakage. Residual Heat . 12 Residual Heat Removal Pump was disassembled Removal to repair a bearing oil leak. Leaking valves and flanges discovered as part of the inservice inspection examination were repaired.

 . Safety Injection 11 Safety Injection Pump had two sp,µcers and two impellers replaced after a 'rub' was discovered.

75 valves in the system were repacked. 11 Safety Injection Pump was disasseml:led to repair an overheated thrust bearing. 12 Safety Injection Pump had a bearing oil leak repaired. ll/.12/13/14SJ29 (Accumulator Relief Valves) were removed, bench tested and reinstalled. ll/12SJ 4 8 (Low Head s*af ety Injection Pump Relief Valves) were removed, bench tested and reinstalled.

Service Water 11 Nuclear Header bypass spools were replaced with stainless steel spools.

16 Service Water Pump strainer was disassembled, inspected and reworked due to excessive internal wear. The discharge p1.p1.ng in the containment from 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15 Fan Coil Units was replaced with stainless steel pipe. 14 Service Water Pump motor cooler was replaced at the factory with a titanium cooler. The service water strainer backwash piping for all six -service water pumps was replaced with stainless steel piping. Spent Fuel 1 Spent Fuel Pit Filter was replaced. Cooling / 12 Spent Fuel Cooling Pump had an oil leak repaired on the inboard bearing. Station Air 1/2/3 Station Air Compressor coolers were cleaned and inspected *. Page 4 of 7

PRINCIPAL SYSTEM WORK PERFORMED Steam Generator 1-2 Condensate Pump suction piping.hangers were Condensate repaired.

Steam Generator Feedwater 11 and 12BF32, the steam generator feed pump recirculation line isolation valves were replaced with valves of improved design.

12C Feedwater Heater was opened as part of an NML inspection. 40 steam generator tubes were plugged (10 per generator} because of denting caused by loose tube lane blocking devices. 11 Steam Generator Feedwater Pump was inspected. Cracking was discovered in the welds of all four steam generator feedwater nozzles. All the nozzles were removed and replaced with new nozzles *. Miscellaneous steam generator feedwater piping hangers were reset as a result of measurements ~. taken after the steam generator*nozzles were installed * . All the welds on all the steam generator feed-water piping in the containment were radio-

 \.                   graphed.

The eight steam generator manway covers and man-way pads were machined. Steam Generator The expansion joint for 12 Condenser was Condensate replaced. 13 Condensate Pump was overhauled. ll/12/13BF7 (High Pressure Feedwater Heater Stop Valves} were disassembled and inspected. All seats and discs were lapped. The seat on 11BF7 was ground. Steam Generator 12/14GB4 (Steam Generator Blowdown Containment Drains and Blow- Isolation Valves) were disassembled, inspected down and repaired due to excessive leak thru. Turbine 11/12 Turbine Auxiliary Cooling Heat Exchangers (. Auxiliary Cooling were inspected and cleaned. Turbine Control 12 Governor Valve had a control oil leak Oil repaired. The turbine control oil reservoir was opened for an NML inspection. Page 5 of 7

PRINCIPAL SYSTEM WORK PERFORMED Turbine The turbine lubricating oil reservoir was Lubricating Oil drained, opened, cleaned and an NML inspection performed

11/12 Turbine Lubricating Coolers were opened, cleaned and inspected.

Bearing lubricating oil lift capabilities were added to turbine generator bearings 9 and 10. Turbine Generator 11/12 Gland Sealing Steam Exhausters were Gland Sealing cleaned and inspected. Steam Ventilation - 12 Control Rod Drive Ventilation Fan was Containment replaced. Pre-roughing filters were replaced in 11/12/13/ 14/15 Fan Coil Units. Charcoal filter banks were replaced in 11/12 Iodine Removal Units, 1VC2 (Containment Purge Supply Valve) was repaired because of excessive binding *

* \

The containment successfully underwent an Integrated Leak Rate Test (Type A). Containment pressure was raised to 47 psig and held while the leakage was measured. lVCS/6 (Containment Pressure/Vacuum Relief Valves) were removed and sent to the manufacturer for rebuilding with upgraded materials. The containment ring duct flexible coupling was repaired. Ventilation.:.. Pre-roughing filters were replaced in 11/12/13 Auxiliary Auxiliary Building Exhaust Fans. Building Absolute filters were replaced in 11/12/13 Auxiliary Building Exhaust Fans. Charcoal filter was replaced in 14 Auxiliary Building Exhaust Fan. Service water leaks were repaired in 12 Residual Heat Removal Pump Room Cooler, 11/12 Component Cooling Pump Room Cooler, 12 Auxiliary Feedwater Pump Room Cooler and 13 Charging Pump Room Cooler. Page of 7

PRINCIPAL SYSTEM WORK PERFORMED Waste Disposal - 11 Waste Gas Compressor had a mechanical seal Gaseous leak repaired. Waste Disposal - 1 Waste Monitor Holdup Tank Pump bearing oil Liquid. leak was repaired. Page 7 of 7

PRINCIPAL SYSTEM WORK PERFORMED Waste Disposal - 11 Waste Gas Compressor had a mechanical seal Gaseous leak repaired. Waste Disposal - l Waste Monitor Holdup Tank PUinp bearing oil Liquid_ leak was repaired.

Page 7 of 7

. EXHIBIT JP-2

                               *DESIGN CHANGE WORK JULY 1979.

OCR NO. PRINCIPLE SYSTEM SUBJECT lED-0359 Yard Install Turbine Balancing Slab in South Yard lEC-0473 Main Turbine Vibration Setpo1nt Change - Turbine Vibration Monitoring lEX-0005 Service Water, Auxiliar Special Test Using AF40 Valves Feed Water and Chemical Volume Control lEX-0008 tirculating Water Special Te~t - Circulating Water: Flow Characteristics 100-0059 Main Steam Valve Position Change - MS28 Valves lS"C-0036 Univac Computer Code Computer Program.Change (1D043A: TOTE) lMD-0071 Chiller Unit Compressor Replace Chiller Compressor Pressure Switch lMD-00~5 Main Turbine Replace Main Turbine L.P. Rotor Blades in accordance with AIB7703 lPD-0011 Modify SSPS Power Supply Wiring lPD-0020 Radiation Monitori~g Provide Separate Power Supply to RMS Recorders

~-

DESIGN CHANGE WORK AUGUST 1979 DCR NO. PRINCIPLE SYSTEM SUBJ'F.CT lED-0248 Li,ghting Install additional yard lighting

  --lED-0318 Cont. Ventilation        Modify Fan Coil Unit Pillow Block Bearing Plates lED-0348  Reactor Coolant          Install F.eactor Coolant Pump Locked Rotor Relays lEC-0373  Con~ensate Polishing     Install Condensate PDlishing System 1EC-0523A Vital Bus Relaying       Replace Differential.Relays with Seismically qualified units lET-0389  Rad. Monitoring          Replace lRlS detector with Nancy Wood type for evaluation lPD-0089  Plant Vent               Install P-MS access doors lPD-0131  Chemistry                Change range of SGBD conductivity recorder lPD-0166  Sampling                 Install check valves in SGBD lines to prevent backflow lSC-0004  Circ. Water              Modify waterbox trap doors lSC-0084  Cont. Ventilation        Replace FCU expansion joints lSC-0148  Component Cooling        Replace CC pump internals with stainless steel rotating elements

DESIGN CHANGE WORK r SEPTEMBER 1979 .\ ..._ . . OCR NO. PRINCIPLE SYSTEM SUBJ'EeT lE0-0355 Various NSSS Replace EnvironmentAlly unqualified transmitters lED-0386 eves Reduce opening time of 1CV4 to reduc water*hammer lED-0387 eves Reduce opening time of 1CV3 lEe-0424 Containment Isolation Replace limit switches and modify controls

lEC-0431 Primary Water Recovery Install suction strainers on Monitor Tank pumps lEC-0432 Primary Water Makeup Install suction strainer on Primary Water Makeup Pumps lEC-0457 Heating Water Install valves to sectionalize TGA H.W. header for retubing lEC-0468 TGA Structural Install bolted work platforms for M.S. dump valve lEX-0481 Service Water Adjust wear ring lEe-0485 Various NSSS Modify NSSS panels in containment to (Containment)
allow proper venting 1Ec-os14 eves Reduce opening time of lCVS lEC-0534
SSPS Modify safety injection logic to delete level inp~t lEC--0535 Pressurizer Relief Install overhead annunciator alarm for PR1&2 lEC-0657 B.A. Recovery Add break flanges-at 1 1/2" eductor to facilitate cleaning

(

DESIGN CHANGE WORK i' OCTOBER 1979 OCR NO. PRINCIPLE SYSTEM SUBJECT lED-0310 Aux Building HVAC Modify Ductwork Sugport Brae ets lEC-0416 Spent Fuel Cooling Install Tie-in for Future Heat Exchanger lEC-0461. Floor Drains (TGA) Install Break Flanges for Condenser

                                     . Retubing iEC-0477  Main Turbine L.O.         Reset lTL67 Relief Valve for Seal Oil Pump            ,

lEC-0479 CVCS/RCP Add Check Valves in No. 1 Seal Leak-off Lines

1EX~0481 No. 11 Service Water Adjust Pump Clearances.

Pump lEC-0516 Circ Water Strainers Modify Backwash Controls for Timer Control lEC-0531 RCS/Component Cooling Setpoint Change RCP High Ternperatur lEC-0560 Service Water Replace Spool l-SW-50-1 with Upgraded Materials lEX-0577 Condenser Install Inlet Waterbox Wein on 13B lEC-0616 Main Turbine Counterbore Coupling Bolts lET-0626 Condenser Install Reference Electrodes lET-0670 Circ Water Install Apollo Skid for Engineering Study

  .1EC~0679  Main Steam*               Delete lMS917 and 918 lET-0682  eves                      Perform Charging Pump Head/Capacity Test lMD-0096  Circ Water                Reset Screen Wash Header Relief Valve lPD-0153  Operators Console         Replace Circuit Breakers to Prevent Tripping lSC-0023  L.P. Turbines             Reblade L-3 Stages lSC-0082  Aux Annunciator          Modify Alarm State for 1DR29 lSC-0129- Cond. Air Removal        Enlarge Loop Seal for Prime Tank Overflow lSC-0132  Computer                 Reprogram Circ Water Parameters for Analog Recorders (Unit 1) 2SC-Ol34  Computer                  Reprogram Circ Water Parameters for
                ~-                    Analog Recorders (Unit 2)

DESIGN CHANGE WORK NOVEMBER 1979 OCR NO. PRINCIPLE SYSTEM SUBJECT 0 lED-0333 Generator Protection Setpoint Change iEC-0392 Diesel Generators Add SEC Interlock to Manual Trip lET-0433 Safety Injection Retest/Reset Injection Flows lEC-0441 Circulating Water Install Condenser Gage Glasses lEC-0453 Containment Install Protective Basket on lVClS lEC-0464 Diesel Generators Modify Bre~ker Failure Trip . lEC-0484 Main Turbine Modify Bearings lEC-0519- Service Water Replace No. 14 S.W. Pump Motor-14 Cooler

lEC-0537 Containment Isolation Modify Control Circuit on 1PR14 and 1WL12 lEC-0616 Main Turbine Counterbore Coupling Bolts lEC-0667- Reactor Protection Reset SGWL Low Level Trip Setpoints lEC-0673 RHR Install New Flow Orifices lMD-0106 Containment Modify Penetrations No. 19 and 20 Test Connections
lSC-0009 Sampling System Install LRT Test Connections at 1SS107 and 110 ,

lSC-0023

Main Turbine Reblade LP Turbine L-3 Rows lSC-0035 Main Turbine Lube Oil Modify Oil Lift Pump Controls

DESIGN CHANGE WORK DECEMBER 1979 DCR NO. PRINCIPLE SYSTEM SUBJECT lED-0068 Chemical Treatment Add Filters, Valves*and Gages to Panel 380 (Chemical Treatment Panel)* 1EC~0452 Containment Various Install Upgraded Solenoid Valves IEC-0453 Containment Pressure - Install Protective Basket on lVClS Vacuum Relief lEC-0465 Condenser Retubing F.ernove and Install Control Air Pipin lEC-0470 Condenser Air Pemova1* Install Loop Seals on Vacu1:1111 Pump

                                     ~ains lEC-0471     Control Air              Replace 1CA129 with 2" Nipple lEC-0484     Main Turbine Lube Oil    Cut "Bow-Tie" Grooves in No. 1, 9 and 10 Bearings 1ET-0495A    eves                     Retest for OCP's lEC-038£, 0387 and 0514 ~1CV3, 4 and 5 M9dification) lEC-05.61    Main Turbine Lube Oil    Install MTLO Filter lEC-0568     Fire Protection          Install Additional Hose Reel in Aux Building El. 100 lEC-0623     Main Steam               Remove overload JUir,pers on MS-167 's Hydraulic Operators lET-0681     S.G. Instruments         NOE Testing of Instrument Lines lEC-0699     Containment Sump         Revise Setpoint of Level Transmitter 11'...0-0103 Containment TV           Install Ventilation to TV Cameras lPD-0087     DM Water                 Install Remote DM Level Indicators lSC-0009     Sampling System          Install Leak Rate Test Connections at 1SS107 and 110 lST-0137     Containment Vent         Temporary Modification for Type~

Test lST-0178 RHR Pumps Temporary DM Supply for C.C. Outage lST-0179 Charging Pumps Temporary DM Supply for c.c. Outage lSS-0011 Fire Protection Install New Cardox P.B. Station for Vital Bus Area co 2

115

                                                                 =  = =     = *- = = =                     m   =

IH THE 7'.'lf:\TTER OF Tr!'"E APPLICN.f IOa .

0!:' DE Il'*ft\I-t~Hs;. P-0:?ER 6,; LIGHT crn/iPAi:JY i.-.; OJ~ ~~r:rIJ~Y*11) £;~~;~~ E'L"E,f!TitIC IfU~I..: BJ\11E: CASE 7239G ADJUBTI7EiJI ~ Hff\~'iJAl'JT TO SECTION fZ,

                     !              54F OF* .f~F~TX(~LE. 73, I,             m    =             * ~  D   = = = = = -                  e      = = = -

Ii

               '?
                "                                                              lli-th Floor
               ~:..,                                                   Amar ic~n Bui 1..dmg I.                                            Bgltimore 9 Maryland April 17~ 1980 - 10:00 iO s~                                                                                                       Bom~

I. I.I

  )l.11
    ,,                  I           BEFOP..E:
            'J <;,
             " O:!C I

(~: o"'.

 .':;_.*    'i!~        I
*j]

I S:£( I

~~

f*

1, John Wo T~ Webb!) Es~ui.rer; i5 11 Da~,id. A; vo*:rhif11) Est1tiire fl

                      *1                                       Of Ccn.mael for .Delm..~rva Po;;1e&" & Light
            'f~                                                Com f!e..uy l

I 17 l Ps,.ul Go D~1iel 9 Es~uiK'el) I P.SC Staff Counsel

           *<,.*.!\'"!i-'".Z;o 2.1?.0n I dm.:a~ t

rj*. [! I if i 1_ I, I
~~(J IJ 11 * - - - - - - - - * - - 1 . _ 1 1__~~
~~I r. i.s of all I the .r:a.se. i,, SCH.IFTER.: 1! l~~
~~io ::II~~
~~!l 1~~
~~We will {;all I 11~~
*I 11 I I l ! last 1
~~c:.1e&~ J~'"J.g!~~
~~I 11!,~~
~~1 l~~
~~Ii!l l1~~
'I I I will ask you if J 11 ~'] Ii
I tb.ose II 11 l
-t1-*--- ::.:.Lc~;JN '.'la'i:PO!'l,lNG aiER\IICl:i: INC. . .i I !1 Ccu~-. R:c:>cn, rn.:1 .. 100 .E:-OUIT~\IJl.f: 3UtLDlN'O =.rr~va **
l
~~~J\L -rri.:Ci\::, MAR'lt...AJ~,;~~
~~H..~~
~~!I q~~
~~Ii d ______ _~~
-_ t" ll jl I! *1*' i Ij I
~~I - - - *------"---------------r-I l 2 1 I filed with~~
~~~1ovember .,. i, arrd Deceuilie:: of 1~~
~~I l A Yes., they area a 4 e~~
~~.~ "I C01'1t1ISSIONER SCHIFTER: So Ti:..arked., .3 ;~~~
IO itle&1tific&tiono) *' 11 1Z 1S 14 COI-ftn:ss IONER SCB:IFTER: He~rLng no objection~ I I* I6 I q* 't:i
~~-** IJ r ~-- -:~~
~~I_,, I!,.., Ii ti ii h3 II H~~~
~~i!O I~~
~~i1 o:E l~~
~~S.\LOM<..1N n:E~.OR.7fN'<.-::!tiR""ICIE INC.~~
~~J_ I iO'J ~QUl7..1.ZLC !Jun.O:Jlf] 6Al. 71~Ga~, :\1/~"tl.>.)!C :i! ~:;?_r, ~ li I~~
~~. ,-+ ~,, i ~ I~~
_.:..--ilfl-J_______---"- ___M_r_o_P_&_ri_:s_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 1_19_L t A 2 Q Do you have ~.ny co~rectlo~e o~ additions that 8 you wcu.lcl want to m~te "to. t..'hat pre=f !led tes t!mony?
~~-,4 A I do not,,~~
~~D Q ...-., a "1 (3 I I li 9 J 10 A 11~~
~~!2 :; '~~
~~j 1a I i~~
*:J;j j
I **; ~ 14 I I *f*! I
~~CONHI.SSIO&J"ER SCHIFl'ER: ,.iiJ I . *',;~~
15 I I .I I I; 1S 11 I 11 I
*17* 11 1 ...
1l ta ,.,:* II I :_* ,__ ._.*
~~.*. f9 I ~:: -.~~
\:*
~~. 2.0 I~~
~~(.:'~~
.'5**
~~-- I c,,......,,.,, _!lA!..01,(QN l'l.::l?OR,*INC3 !!'i:;IVIC!l: -INC.* _ Hlt) .!!.JUl'7..r.t:'I..D: B1.H1-~r~.:~~
~~~BAl.7'1MO.n:i::. MA.w"t'rl..A.,t;Cl ll iuoR~~
~~J' i (P:::epa~ed --e:a~s:s " 120 I 1 A 6 a:.-7: a Dela,...,;iaze 19899. 9 Q to I I.~~
~~.* *:*t I~~
~~' :,\)a of you'.lr supplemes.,.tal~~
**1s 14 A the 16 I
~~1~ II 1--,~~
~~." I l~~
~~I ta I~~
~~\;_;iSJ I-SALOMON RE:PORT!NG !l!;;rt'<'ICE INC, TOO EOUl"'i"AUL-;: 0UIL01rf0 UAL:."TtM0i1E. *M.t..n*Yt..A.1'1D. :? 1"i?02 1* :;.*,~~
I I i - A
(P~epared r~ 1=2) 121
~~..... ,- . '. ~~~
.* -.: . . '. ~:- '_:>.* gene:ratiri..g staticms,i which ia located in Salem;) Ne'lo>i Salem rfoo 1 is operated by Public Sezvice Elect:xic and Gas Comp.any;, PSE&G.. Rep:r!!ese'ntatives fa:om Delma~va pa~ticipate wi.t:h the join~ owinel:s in sev.z~al
~~,.0. 10 Q foJZ- the !tefuel~~~
ii II I 1eefu.e.lirRg:;:, ot:her SALOMON Rl!!>ORi"IMG ZERVICE INC:-*
. "*1oo--E'Q01TA~t.:::*Bul'-'D1HG * * *1 ** I'-: -* * * *-* S.AL.-Tl*~..iCOit!:i~-'-M..:-'l~/.l.riHO .?...l202 - . ll~V-'5760 ' (
I ,:~
(Pxepa~ed p& 2=3) 1~12 o Pa~k.s 122
.**t~*~. maintena~ce and i~@pection activities we~e scheduled to be -pe:ti:fa::,~med ciu~iil1g this pe:,,:iod~ including retubiag of the main con.de&:rnez i, :leplacerilein.t: of foux rm>1a of blades in two of the low=p~e§su~e turebines~ and ~11 the .vazious ~equi~ad inspection aud au~veillailce acti~i~ieso
~~, ' ,:~ :., *fl* . Q What ~11as the actual .,;iv.::catio:n of "Che out~ge?~~
~~A Salem 1fo. 1 was taken out .of se~vice 9 as f?:-*:c:.:2'.1:~~
*i.;*,a schedule~ at 7~30 pom~ o~ Ap~il 3 9 19790 The un:U:
~~did 9 inot ~etU~!ll t~ se!:'!Jice n:ntil Dec~mbeir 21,, 1979~ six motntha~~
*:*to after its scheduled ~eture:n date .. *::J)t; Q Please summa~ize the ~easous for this exte~=
~~12 *s:tono~~
~~,_*::13 A ThEee factors weze genercally 2:esponsible fo~ . 14 * :I..~~
~~Lltt:: (!. im.lt.ag,s S:il:'ii:BE'!Sl.Ol.la F:b:st~ a shozt: delay occux:-:ed ia .-:l uiJ.e ri:o~~
~~rn.01:c.J...Ll.eau::x.on o:.c sorr-~ im.eJ.~~
'9,(!~ ~. ,,. .~ '?. ~ ~~i i!.i.%:ll!ilu.l ng equ1.pmen~ ,,_ ': *1:
9
*~: te and then BOE~ £uel eleme~t gxid st~ap d~mage occu~xed t:11~1 ~.'. '.!
17 \ j clu1eiir~ ~.ca~-
~~'4°~~:=, -=*---~~
f:;*;p \-1-- hardi
~~... i 111<::~~
~~_:l,..,..,,..,,.e9,._,.,~~ ~ ......__ {;h~~
-:,1h~1 - '*'rl;i,.,j .... "'.ad* ~-..!.a.:!--.,., ;3 f**""'"*h~- ~..,_'ii.- '--.~ '***~, -_-.:*.*!?\ "k.l . ~~.~
~~te exteris:tcno Sec~~d~ a ~umba~ of b~oke~ ~ocllets we~e 19 lt~,~~~~
****.c disco . Jelfed~. ain.d this :t'.equi1:ed xeplacement: of all affec*ced ~od cont}!cl clu!3te~ aErner::.ih1ies.. Thill:d,,, and the goi1airni[1.g )!~'.?~, . '-" 2i. **<.** :,z~:~*.i!::'.:\i;~:.:. facto~ ~esponsible fo~ the majc~ poxtion of ~he outage SALOMON-REPORTINCl'S.;:R.VICE INC.
~~100 EQUITA!l~! '9Ul.!.oiu<. Cou11T ltitPORTE'.Rtl BAL T i:..coR,t";**MAn"ll.;Ai.10 ~.'~ 1202 !l:iJ-cn;o~~
~~/* --~,._. ;.*ii:*~,~~
.\
I 3=4) 123. l extension~ the Nuclea~ Regulato~y Commission~ NRC 9 issued this pe:ciod 9 m::11.i.'i.y of vihich ws'Ee ~eiJised am.d supplemented
*. by th~ NRC while compliance activities well':e unde:tWay I' and the unit was-~o~ per~itted to ~e~u~~ to se~Yice .;.i . **1:: . .. : ..:V*, ' "1 Q Please discuss the fi~st facto~ which you .,-:<a 9 .... 10 . . t~/-/{:;~/* /' .f,,:.::lt with spscial equiprae~t designed aud fu~nished by ./.(~~~- ~}\> \/}.12 .:.(}f(ts damage to scm2 of the fuel element g~id st~aps~ PSE&G
14
~~...1!5! !ill -.. ~ L. all o~iginal co~e fuel asaemblias~ It di~covered that "i."~~
TJ
.;/J *,.'.*<,\18 ,~ C" * *, ~ " .... ,.
~~i I I* _;i(;!(t:~~
~~. '-.-.*,:/.~~
~~SAL.OMON RE:;;PORTINQ SERVICE INC.~~
~~** * - *~~
~~100-E-QtJITI\OL'i':.,*B1'1LOING~~
~~...... ~our:a REPORTERS ** - ff - - O_A.LilMORF. *. Mi\aYL.AHo .. ;t:z.o.;.?.,.. *.-. :. -~ *---~i;~f~~~~
~~showed the most This zevision of the coze the :reload cluste:1: assembly ._ . 1();~~
~~.. s'",.L.PM.9"~-~~POR!~ NG sr.=:RVIC:::: INC~~~
100 F.<;UITAOLI!: SUlLOING [l°ALTIMO~E. M.AF.Y! *..O..:;!) 21~02.
1 (P,:epa,:ed p. 5) l,h,. Pa~ks 125 *1 -
~~,~---------i--~~
~~PSE&;G found eight failed ~odle~s~ associated td.th six diffe!eent ~od coR'.!.i::i:ol clustei: as1:3emblies I' all~~
~~. of which wei;:e t~acad back to two pz:oduction lots to ".i:eplace the d.flm~ged ~od cluster assembli.es fi:ee or cha~ge°'~~
~~Q incidents 1,~~
~~./hf"-~~
*. 14. '-~t - l7 .*::lt't-rt'::;rk"t; include the Sb~ Month Get!ereal Office Report~ *which
~~}J;.: ;:.: t:~ '~,t~f~~
~~ALOMON REPO-RTING l!ER'IIC:lc: INC.~~
* .... --e;,.1~~u,7o°r:'~~~f,:t.,[3~~~ 0l-~~O.! **,..:.,... i !,,~~-:..... ~ ...
~~I F ii~~
~~!f 11 i'., ,.1, _ _ _P~_~~
(P~epa~ed 5=6)_ _ f~o _ Pa~ks_ _ _ _!:_21!:._..,,_-J_*. ~ 1, 1I ~. ~ecei-Ied __ weekly _srm,ma:1::ie s 11 I :***
~
~~3 4 5 6 ii Repo~t cove~ing July 1 t:i:n:ough Decembe~ 31 was p~epa:red a 9~~
~~,l I~~
~~I I am he~eby sponao~ing those ~epo~ts as I' I~~
~~-:::11 1.2~~
ia "4

of the Salem
*us A 1e fo~ the e~tension of the . f.-, . J. / ~e H~. -~*{~.t* *:, '*- ,:hr~ee Mile Island ia1cidein.t o SAL.OMON REPORTIMC !SERVICE INC:. - -100 E'GUlT,'\!lL!!:. BUH.DT?Ja .. 0.ALTJMOil.E,. MAfCtLAf~D*::t*1202* ll3!l>6760
):':'L ,,- (P~epa~ed p. 6-1) 127 -~~-----.-~*fJ~--------___:__ _ _ _-=-j- .* *._.* *J The NBC would no~ pe~mit S~lem tc ~es~un~ ope~atiou until PSE&G comDlied with the ~equi~ema~ts of these Bulletins~ .:s; .*e *_
~~Salem:~~
*e .9 * . 10* Revision Nco 1 issued ., / ti on August 20; fu~thex .,z, 70=07 Seismic St~eas Analysis of Safe~y t4 sued o~ July 5 nnd August 28) *,,-~:~**.fe
~~"--~.~¥:~\-~:.~~
~~.:l., '~'a1 1__~~
~~-~.:~t~~*:fl',' .:::-'~--:-:1:t--'-~-------~-- -~ - .~~
~~.,};~t/1'~~
~~' 'SALOMON m:PORTING.!3E:f1 VICE: !NC, H)O EQUITABL.E BVILDl!;G~~
~~BA!*.'TU,,iOr?e,,M,...,o:n:LAN& .21~02~~
~~~j~},;::::~~~:-L__~~
~~;j ~f il I!~~
~~II.-------------------------------------- 128 \ t1 J.~~
~~?] issu8d du~i~ this pe~iod~ Althcugh they did no~~~
~~I: 1;;. .~'i: ~ rli:1!:ectly affect the length of_ the. outage g; they did have f. j* I: 4 -t~.~~
~~, ~~~
~~(,3 wo~k and piepare ~eplies fc~ filing with the NRC0 il l These Bulletin§ thus zeduced the ove~all ~esou~ces I I a. l~~
~~.* :9 lI I .. / ~ iI' § "1 I' ... o; 1~ . III ) ~t~ ~if!~~~
~~F~ I Swill1g Check Valuesj rs 11 i";; II II j~ II 11~~
~~'153 I~~
~~1* Ir~~
*1 I !I ~*~ I tu-~-~~cui n 0°=c~ ~~L_.
~~rl lit?.!') Pa:tks~~
~~!i ro \~&~pQ&- d/ !i I!~~
~~1i lt l n~~
~~~ ';'")S! -~~
~~r .,_ease descz1.De 1.n deta11.. ~na ~equ:t"..Zeme.rn:s~~
* * .* .* * ., * ~- .,,
~~f& II impoaed by NRC*Bulle~in 79=02 and the activities at~~
.. 3 I Salera* '.*Jhich we~e pe:rfot:med iu compliance the:i:e"¥Ji:tho 4 A Bulletin 19°02 conce~n~d the operability of s safetyQ~alated piping syateme d~~i~g a hypothetical I::,' ~ seismic eve~2to. The I'IBC not:ed drnt .-irctc::i:eased .z:11:pe~ience 1 had shown i::hl.3t the assumpti.ou that 6oa.1c:rt:ete base plates we~e :t z.g'.3.~ d ,, waicu ' . It.. n~o !leelfl. accepr.ed~ ~D:f 'Che "'= ... '-1.'l.eX:e\f::o:.:o'ii::e a 0 0 '
A *

tu-.~...
I was no~* a.s..,tJ237,;; "l ,, ~ ~ 'l &l- . i n, B(Dme ;J * ~ 'i1
8 I *,y.a1;.:i..a fl111Ci 11..ucl~,, .!l.tnm:a1 ... a;c2.o~sS) w
!O the dr..~~..!-,ob""'-" a *l a<n i=- oad .... o~ ce~tain ancbo~ boH:s -was {:!o_nsequetCTitJLy 11 u unde~estimatecl~ It fu:i:the~ oot.2d a txend in the d~sig:r-a
~~-.:'.. t:a ' industry tu::rwa~d mo~,e ltigoEous Cl:n.1tri:ols im<l ve:r if:lcatim.1~~
**1s o:c the iri.1sta 11.ation of airr.r.Jun:. bolts o 14 i \
~~j~[:.e ,~v1 ;:;**jr,-,,q1! \.s~r.p,o 1.:...:r- *.'-~,;:,:;~t;;.:.-c:- ..,. __ :.. ~ ~~ v..:i.~~
~'",~~~~~ -"~--<:.- ... ~..-.-.LI ~11@00? di liJi-.,... ~; '&1hen I
I I HJ i ~- *j ':\/'~'"r',-..t-, .~ 1~1'~ V mez:e .iLw g!etvl.li,i:ect ~ 0 ~ i
";JO:,~ -:. .. Cl:...... *"'"'S~~,.:1 ...,.,C:-,o*:;J..,"""'~"! f">**".l ,Ji:/-.li. l~~.:a;._ ~c..t. ...,. ?, .e..,;:, .. ;;, ~
~~ta u~~
* "1 t l..!..l.'CJ..e8 a * ~ * "l:D 1 ;JeIJ:1:ry u::e
~~fl"' ,.,..,~~~
desigfi1 .a!ild iustallatlon of {1 f1 ti ccnc':;"et>? a,?f,t"'o'.!t bo .---"" 'lits 9 ha *i ;;r:-;:ig ~1 r.,1. .::. ....... ors,o*
*,:;op o 3'!..11_::f}o"'~~s
1~*
'I - ... ~ *~ .. - ..-~c....,. "'*- ,:i;'i'Hj ,.,...,,. 6 ~~ '-""L. £:' ,.::. .... !t & '. (1 1,*,. .. I iu c:i,.,..
~~1i,,1cJ~~
..c .;- .!...e*~:v~ .1-.*2 1.2-a ;.,,~e~ ~-l ,,..1 Dy~trams .. Subseqi.1eu.1't Jl:er~il.SJ!.Oi13 and q
supplements r, bow,a1:Je:ir., -;z1hich we~e issr:.1ed OU'.! .Juue 21" A**-
~~uous~ . 2u .-..~ 21P.1a- ,,,.. :;;J0!.1e1I1.De"' * ... !!'l ';; z; ~.:<4 11 .. 1S1.£!.,,,;,;..&}? ~ "";; - .~ ~ "'"'~~
~~-..:.fo.C.!!.e.ESeu _,~~
~~the scope of this ..10:-:k., As ~e<lJiziecl a!l1.tl supplemelllted ~ the E1.:dle~i~~~
~~S*.\LOMCN 1H~*POR1'1NC--*5i;RVICE iNC.~~
C:euny -~~Po,nc11::i 100 ~QUITA.~LC Sun.. on:a SAL 'i"lt..:URE. *MAilYl,.AND :C. 'LZCJ;! 530*'57CO
J{ fi\*.*
~ (p zep1?Z6'2 tJe E': ~ ;i) Mzo P.a~l~s 130 !,,~::: \ ..-:'"" *,{fj::
t.*
*. <t . tequired utilities to do ~he followi~g~ among othe~ . . :./,,*i:,l., *'
~~1:- :::1,? ,. _:_* things~~~
]it ,_ 1 ,.I * * :which O o lo The rmc establiaherl a new crite:rioni*
~~it t:ecog1:r.i~ed was ncm1se~'t:'ative '\, fo:i:: dete:rmirt.iK>>.g~~
.:f\}f' * .>.L<- -*'* *' .,.~ "'*) .' . whethe~ pipe suppo:rct baseplates *we~e flexible., Based
~~_-,, on thia c~ite~ion tha utility ~as ~equi~ed to recal=~~
~~'?,:.' . culate bolt deaig~ ~~~
~~J..Oc:HlS~~
. using 8D. app:il':OpE:iate ainalysiaa *1t:_-l 2a The utility had to VeTCify tha~ conc:i:ete ~-- -~
~~expansi.oa ,m.?.dw:;:: bnlts a,chievecl ~ei1ly=sr;ecified safety .**:.~~~
~~'. -l~>~~
~~jQ,~~
~~. *a:.. ~ .f . . c ..~~
~~fcictm:s <> 3a The utility had to clezc~ibe the design :requi1Ce= me~rts to -::4iths~a!tld ~ye lie loads~ such as seismic loads~~
-*~ *;i:_:~
~~~:-k:~~
**_.~:_:,_ . i: *-.,ti* . :'-t* *-~\*.
and high fa::eq~.1eirrcy ,;ib~atm::y oper.atiug loadss ~nd vexify ': ;, *~j*
. t.c there* :the cs~2gn < " .J. ~equ~~em.e~~s
~~v:;e~e met>) based. on an *;~~~
'., '_' 1 .*t, app:.;::oved t,~m~i!~ p"log~~m px*nposed by the t1'tility a *-\A:
~~1, In crciez to ~G~;?ly i.<Jith Bulletin 79 ... 02,:. PSE&G~~
' 'fJ <~ .',{~ ,!.-:j
~~_,17 n~~
~~~ . lj ;'.)~~
~~o...;,.._ ct" ~,"\~~
.... v ~ ';.> - ~ :;': * -~ <p ';I e.:4.~:C£~.Jrre at}1;G~v~:1.mxi-tset.y ~.:J~Jo *:t;oJTI.c~el. ") .- r,,fll 'P 1~
~~anCKJ.O!C 0 "i1 ,'<, - 00~1!.:..~~ c~~
* . ;I i'"I,
+
~~tQ. ..~~
" In addition>) PS:Ef.a:G .sin.d 1.3 othe::r uti1itie§ fcn:me<l am . '-:'-.'1 *-~'---j *:'J**-
~~j,;*_:._.:>,* OYJne~s g~oup ~o po~l tes~ing ~esou~ces and develop a .:..e.-r:~~
'/:,}' *...:**>\. -~
compute~ p~cg~.s1m "£:[;) a:nalyze .basepl.a'J:e f1ex5.bil:H:y and Pe~ fozm ten~.:s to ~Jiell:ify th,e cli2sign ~eiqui:.i:eli.iernts .. r~**j~-~~;~~-* - >i...!
~~~11tr---------...:...------*---S-,l,_L_O_M_, ---~---*~--,------------Jt"'-,-,,::-:~~
~~__r_l_N_'r.-.-S-E_R_V_!C-E--*-,-N-C-.~~
-0,-N-R-.li:-P_O_fl ,'1_1 .,1 -f . Couay R"'P . 100 EQUl'l"i",ilLC 0Ull.DUIG f) ~ cnn_,1':.:, "Al.Tll,tORE:, ~iARY!.A:W_2.,12<l2_ *. o:m-o 7 co -:~ ',i l
_ _;!:~~:t;7'!Er~t~J+----- .._* ,1,(::.c..!f". ;
T
*1.
~~l ~}~-- .::- ..:~-=--=.. r3' 0 10) Yit! e r -::::: -~:S 131~~
---------------------------4-*
~~PSE&Gv ;a ira:1:i:ial =:s.:;:o:nse to t:h-~ NRC on July 4~~
)U'E::-'-:::...:=.2 *-::. .. -=: p11:og~am f- or .... . ~ue """ . . ~-3 :.::::1-:ng ana e~;...u.na11.~on* - -3 ~-<{
OL
~~.i:~~
~~1.cQ:-~:: ~=-:3..ts illl safety=lrela;t:E:d. pipirng systemso This~~
~~--=o:: -::-~~ :~eluded ult:!:aaonic ,e,::;~in.iuatinn tc detexmine the~~
~~tr~,..:'.:~--~ -1.engt:u a.. o:i: ,. emDeumen.!: ~ ~ . 2:1.a~ anaz.yt:.&.ca -a .JI' 1 ca 1cu1Bit i oina~~
~~~ -* ..,.. --*""- -~...,... - -----.-......... _.,,~~
~~c:>m'"' 'll~""' ying b"" -- - -:.. =-,;...._~~
....- -~-~ , ;;;::.,-~,.. -- u- . . _:_ :-:;::;~--*~.J .... b o - *a:-'.1:.V o A meet:tng was held -;;-it:h the rrac on August 6 ~, ..*. ~- 1>-~.~-~ . ?SE&G=s initial :respc:-::1seo At this meeti~g~ * " **!- . ._ ~- :;:::es!:':.H~d co¥J.ceic!Th th 2. t ~~~ --~ ~~o~n~~~
~~t_-~ s:-~--. ',-0~?1n~ fill*'\:;..;,:;)'w~c..~ -* -~ .i::; ~ :.?.qt:i. t:'~..i.~;: .::.2~=~~
~~~ -roe .,___ -~-,a; 0 ~.~'....!~-...;:>~~
~~[2.0~~~
~
adequat.ely ve.:.::i.£y t:he bolt 't*Jedge set as Bulletitn.o PS:Z&.-G 2gEeed 'i:D ccnduct to ,s1e'i!!ify t:he ec.ge set of the 3500*
,1
-

:;,~h~--:: "i'f!::~s" The 11-mc also :::.:e;;iewed the test xepo~~s
~~,::,7'=-*0::::*>>.;,,,-=~~
~~~"""~~
~~i~~¥i;&i3~~
~~... u~~~
~~aind PSE&Grs s::iz.mo:-.:t: - ~ of i."ts con.cluzicn~ rr:>~~
. _ . . ... .::-.;c~ .__ - :.__*,~--=- "'"'*n --~. - __.:;.__,. ~.,,,......,..<r;t*l ~"'h~\~!J: _ 0111!.S .. - to t£::.=.- ~~.:..-:o~ts -~;:" .:.,. ?5E&G tuia!tl !\.,,
~~a d"' 01:eaE-=:d* -cne _, - ru:ctnez: . stu~il.es .2~ a[lu _.Jj~~
/~l~ 2: ~ -- :::: _-:._...:._.:,, ;: r:.ee-;:~S~i:.n::y to comp :.7 -:. :Lth the stai:J.ds1:ds S$t 0 by .3~. _:_*= ~ 79=02 ~ inc1udiITT.g t b.2 ::evisio1.:.s an.d supple=
m:.::.:.:rts ~---~0 0 Compliim.ce was ~::-,mple~ed on rto~Jemhex- 26 9 an*,:§ t.:-~~ *-:,;:~= - ~t:i1t1 *was closed o:~ ~cercl:r~x 5" i-..u11e~:.'c-!..§:1
~~~eac~JLaJ.?. -* JI 1\... o:t .!i -""'~~
i ':!'=;.;;; ',,;. an.a"' t:tt;a *
~~"ko~k P""r:"'":~ .~~
SALOMON R-ll:PORTING ,~~,. *::,;: :NC. 100 .Eou.,."":',AaL:: -~t*:*~-::.:.-:-* c--:!**-- - ,,;;*;,:..07sc, OUllT *~PO~,**:-;:.;::_..._ !lAt.TIMORi;;, MAR.Y'-""' ::. *c:.c;;: 1 I (
*1 Il . -+-*:' 'I *---tlr!--(_P_1:_e_p_a_:.i:_e_a_~-~-""_"_1_0_-_1_1_)_ _¥=_*****_"_P_.:'l_~_k_s___________1_3_2__
~~I A N'RC Bulletin 79,:,07 ~ which *was issu,ed ol!l Apli:il Q 14~ 1979,, between the p:i!::eviously accepted computei: code used to~~
**1 . .. ** ... *i Bulleth'ls, the dif:le:t.:ence between the two comput:er codes i111 p~edict:ing piping st~esses ~esulted f~om 'the diffez.=
~~code pxe~iously accepted by the i.mc used an algeb~aic su!!illla~ion of the loads for both~~
~~. **,. 14~~
~~. >..\t_e NRC Bulletin ackiu.owledged that this p:toblem had not~~
~~.17 .,.1e iiittilf **- ** ~~~I .._*_._. --~~
~~SALOMON RE:P-~RTING SJ:;:RVICE INC.~~
~~-~.--,_~.tao ECL~-~et:~*,01,r1~01HG~~
~~BALT*H..::CRf.,;,*!*lARYLAtlD** 2-120 :Z.~~
~~"'*"' I l ~ ! __~~
~~it~ . *.~-.::_:.---------------------~~
-: \: . . -~ --. ~ plpi1.1g9 surr,ox:tzi c:fC!.d equipmev.t -whi,~h might be affected by tbe charrge in analysis tech~ique~ .'ft . 'fl I
~~1$ lineso~~
~~.:*,.:*:-.',ft~~
~~,.:. *. -. *~ -e:..-:..~~
~~.. . -* =-,. J:;;' __; '\~~
~~.SP,L..Ol',10N fUZPO~TINC: .SER'JJCI!. INC, -~~
~~I ,.. ,oo EOUITA~(;~ *au;L*oir:c- *---,---.~*""--*-----.. -~~
~~. ---*-DAL-TIMOl?E., MA.~~LAHC 21202 I~~
.;[:*~~~:;t~\-:~~(*t*:r/~*.:-. l, -* 1
lo Complete ~he test on wall and ceili~ Su.bmi:t a pxogx.am testing an.cho~ bolts ~Hid basep1.ates in accessible 79=07 .. on :tts 7>A1-0MON Nl:PORTIN~l *Sii:fJ, VICE: INC,
* * ,.., ........1/JO*'*EQUIT*A!1t.;,::£u11.01r1,;
~~6Al.l'lMOR!:.--MAiiYl.;A'll0 21202 -- 11311-6700~~
,~~~i;;pzoc:.:d~es and e~arrd.ll'.1.ed its documentation fo:: ~he -'U \.Bu.11e t: in,, ' - * .* i..:. .. ; ~' ?of -opez.:Btion ,?:1. .,
~~fll:re Cycle 2 Mode 2 11 sts~t:=up to 5 pe:ece~:a: .~~
~~}fc:i~"er. The c ontia>.!lll tio n of l'ha se 2 _,_ g:i.'le,;. 60 ~ days of without outside~~
~~l,:*t~*_{*:~~
~~~;\Zf:l'.'./ Q DescJJ:ibe :&t.r.11etin 79=1t:~ and th:e wo1:k pe:R:fo:iemed~~
~~.tf~:'.1( .* -:,1~~
~~'t * * ~.~~
~~pu,,,m:"1: ' "::t:~n. 1:1n 19-14 ""s issued on .1u1y 2, 19;9. I~~
~~} . /:,It was ~evised ton July 18~ af!ld suppleioorcrts were issued .. SA!..OMOM. RE:P..0.RT!NG 6~RVICI< .INC ...~~
~~. 100 EalJ)"r .... riL!'.: *.nu,*LDHiO_ .~~
El,V. Tl),101iE, MI\RYLA/10 ?. l?.:l:.! I
includiftl.;g seismic calcula'tio:n.s of S"'jStems we~e compatible with ~a=huilt conditionso* Q
~~. :~~t~~
~~,:,-1,*,'.~~
r' *,* f t . t* .t'*
~~.j ,~-,,.~~
To com.ply with Bulletin 79 ... 14 as* o:t"iginally_J i T*
~~. ,' **.-~. ';.~~
issued~ PSE&G was ~equi~ed to check each_of the 15 piping Revisicm. lio .. 1~ issued oin .July 189' requi!i!ed more speGific documentatio~ by Septembe~ 14. PSE&~~s EeSPOii1Be: J;o
~~- I t:he Tu~C im:Hcated that of t:he 883 calcula=~~
~~SAt:OMON -REPORTING .SEa:P. VIC:E INC.~~
~~-~*--:* ...,.-_. *100 .E.QUITAil!..r.:, Bvn .. 0111~ . .... ---- a ..'\L.l"IM_l;:me. 'iAAll"ILA::o 21402~~
~~i I~~
* : . . * - :____-ti_ _ _(_P_~_'e_p_a_Z'._e_r1_.-;_p_.~1_'!.,.._':_=_l_S_)_ _r,-i_-k_ ..._o-_P_a_:._,._k_s_________-'---1-3--'7----;-,,~
~~I *:., I II f,1~if 4 , ~_-:::**s. iin@pec~io.n was not:. practicable~ the ut.ilU:y \*Jaa 1:equ.ired Whei!e physical Ii~~
.*.;, 6 I I ,.[ , ,/ ,*.f . \ -rtJerte found the utility m~st: evaluate its. siguifica[n.ce ..
~~9 as >>:apidly as possible 9 10 11 to ciete~mine whethet ope:,:ahili.ty of the system would . . .~.~~ - -~ .. _ co~fo~mances if they in~alida~ed the seismic a~alysis I~~
****-Coun:..REPORTC:Rs SALOMON RuPORTING llERVICE: ltlC. *::: : ::*-. 100:*Eou1.r~a1.:c auu.otNa - -~ ....
6ALT1.~1'0RE. MAAYI.AUD 21.1-0, rI l
by case basis., ). *.: disc~epancies,, none of which inu-alidated the st:tess 6 a
~~. .*. . .*: 12.~~
~~Q Plaa~e desc~ibe Bulle:tiu 19=13 and the wo:rk~~
*.1~
~~.::Ji$~~
*:.rr syatem~ This Eulle~i~ xesulted f~cm the discove~y of as well I
~~SAI..OMON RCPORTING SocRVICE: INC.~~
~~- tCO E:OUl-l'*At!L!: ;)1J1LOliHl BA471J..%0A.£. :,...?.i..,*.:n.l~tO :=! 1.?.02~~
~~(P~epazed p. 16=17) 139 Bulle~in a~d had beguu to inspect the feedwater nozzles~~
~~,~; ~t\, .: - a~ Salem... No~ 1 eaEly in June~~~
~~facilities to pe~fo~m ~adiographic examinations~ i;"';\ _:'_... *6 8 9 Based on ~adiog~aphic inspections~ PSEE~ foutld c~acks in 3 of the 4 piping con~ections to the~~
~~'.*, ... I *I~~
~~( .~~
I
*.~ !7 I .r: *.;:
~~ta h-, *-'.. ,.._:~~
~~~~1 ***.~~
~~Ji*.~~
~~-t ':~~~
\
.. ~: ~** l . -.~ <~*
S.AI..OMON RE:PORTINC. SERVICE INC. . 1- *.c**.*
~~. . .. .. 100.E(IUITJ\~LE BUILDIIIO COURT RltPORT~as - - 8AJ. TIMOR'E;c'IAARYL'AIIC> Z 120:i!' .. -** '/~{~:.<: . ,' .~~
.t;;J~~c . _ _
1
~.
a.
**',:4.:;
~~PSE&G is conti~u.ing .to pa~ticipate in an Owiaers Gi.oup -which w.:Js fo~med to study the conditio:.1e~~
~~,., .-:_, . ~~ ..~~
~~which caused the c~ackingo The study in~olves 10 util:U:ies~~
~~arnd 16 ge~ie:rating units that h.a'i?e shown~~
~~*. 9.*~~
~~Q ~be 1~~
~~r~{1{ outage ~elating to the Th~ee I1ile Island incident?~~
~~Ji;}: A Yes.; 'l'hlcee Tifl"":;-;elat:ed items :s:equb:ed by~~
~~. ::*~~/~.11~/i ***.~~~
~~1 Ft!:.J:*i NRC *wer:e expedi'i:ed .aa'.l.d ct:m1pleted du?:ing this outage~ I l~~
~~. *' *.* -~ :.~~
~~ll.':'i II breake~"'* l back=~~
~~I i l~~
~~~:--~--;"---~~
~~"'-* .. : ~*.c5A'L.0MON - - - - -IN*c:.~~
REf'O:RTiN:c. *sEn vie!:'.*
~~- ': .- - - - - - - - - i - ,:'. :/ .-:-~RV011n:n.. 100 EQUITI\DLI!: eulLOlf"I~~
* . * ** * . , .... *---~~BAL7lMORE .. -MARYl...J.\UO~.a 12.0Z
II
~~>' . II (P,::epa:<e<'l ;;, , 18) lf"c: , ? a"lrn~~
~~~-~r-------------------------'-- 1~~
;g *u. '.il::f itemsv so it: waa decided to do . th~m du~ing tb.e extel!ded a . "-; 1 * .; f ; f ..4 d *,t*
~~6 6~~
~~] )( '.}~ *:~~
~~1 t~~
~~. .ri,1; ' .~~
~~a ... *. . pEog~am to facilitate~~
\
~~8 10 u 12 1S~~
~~'i~~~
~~i~ Hi I 17 II~~
~~,a ~~ almost a daily * >.-:la.~~
~~100 E:'~:.1** \~I...! BUtLOlrHI SALOMON A'C't"'.':.;,;: '!'?}IG Si!i1.VIC!l INC;**** 8ALT-1:-..10i;;.-*:.{.!~l.:YL>J10 212.02~~
~~- . *=-+-I a;;~-v.700 l~~
i
18=1_.~_-~)--~r-;i't__~~P_a_~_**_k_s__________~___________1_4_*_2~~~+-~
~~.the chail!ges BRid modific.aticm.s as quickly as possible o~~
~~"" *- . ;:}~- ,G *. -f~~ff}!- 9~~
*f: *~~* * ,".c/
~~i~ . ~~~
"$/ f *.~* -~ ~ *~- . ,:.
~~could minimiz~~~
~~'. **.operation it1t:o the cu~reen'fc cri~ica 1 pa-a::h instead of~~
~~.*.. _~~
~~scheduli;j"j(!l'~~
~~.*;:* -c, if"' !l.,~~
~~a.!!!.'!.*~""~~
<.i1..l..l\.1;;;.,_ -~~~,--*'"" .,:,,,,..,1 shuffle .. &......,;;. The ISI iraspec=
~~tion of the ~eac~o~ ~essel was also shifted ~o a future SALOMO~ R!;;PORTING Sli:RV;~~~~
~~-------~:: . :*.:*100-:C:QtHTA"Ot:~*.:tHJU.:t'TrJG INC.~~
SAi..; lMCR E ~ fAAA\"LAUY.~~--120 l! I j ____ l - -
which *wonld have occurll:ed pending a delive:i:y of the new -fuel :ireload patte:icn f~om Wastiinghouseo .-.
~~-~ . -.. .' **~ ',.~~
~~the Salefil ontage? do .. as it did~ especially i~ of the low fuel cost t,1f~iil;~~
~~.:* :7~~
~~ecord is clea:tc ti:rnrt t:i"'r.a opeEat:irtg company s:, Public Ser~~~
~~t>.-, . vica Elactr:lc & GasCorn.paP.ly~ er.e~ted !ts utmost:_effo:li:ts S_AI.OMON REP0°R,ING SE.l),VIC!i: INf .~~
~~. -,. -~~
~~100- EQUIT.-\Ol.;E "aUiLDHIQ ... *-**-.~~
~~,. * ............ -0ALTl!.IOR£,* MAR'l!.fv'UJ-2. ,202 2138*0760~~
~~144 e*orn:f)lel.lt and sophisticarted nuclea:t plant as safe as hum.am i .. s~~
*:,4 As my tesi:imi:my has showlfi,i the dominant , *..: .-:., :*s .. *--s /7/tit-*a*:->*-'
~~'.' . tt~~
~~~:I~~
~~_1.,,: .~~
~~, ___ ;_ .. 1;4 . *-*.. ,<>._:*:-*~':.*.;.;..< * * ; _ *:i.:::J,:::~~
.-> '*":,\?13:.i*
~~... ::}~};::;: .:'.'~~
~~145~~
~~-11 Ti 2 effectively co~ t0 a halt so .tha~ all agaila'ble per.::=~~
~~a 4 5 G iJ~~
-~
9
~~\* .. 10 a~~~
~~1~ extended until all the t co'iJ.ld be completed., Withi3.1 *, u.1.1.fo~esBeable acticK1s by the !iiRC;) of !:he oui:age ,ws dee,oly minimized I l~~
~~~equi~ements i~ the mos~ efficient a~c mos~ timely I th.e outage"~~
~~l 22)~~
~~~'-----------------~~
~~A s~~
~~,, '1":~~
'.. 'f i '<

-.-~.-1&i-
~~,~._. - ts** -----------,----~----=***=---,--~---:----~-7.~~
SALOMON REPORi"!NC; SERVI~;;; !NC *
~~.. . * .* IIJO...ECUI--U,D!.l!--BUILO!rl::J *--- ElA!. TIM<lll;:, Mr~l.':.'l.J'JlP 2. l.l.0?. __~~
~~~'il Do you~~
~~<'.-'. .2~~
~~!'*';;i . :/l~-. A Q MR., VORHIS ~ I ~ould ask then that these ba l'l.~irked for identification purposes ais; Dek"1fil~11J1a.~~
~~.*,,_-_:.<~}a*. Exhibita 25 ood 26 respectively .. . ~,:.;-~~
~~(Si:i~ ~onths Gr.mer~l Offic:E Repo'.i't _mo).rked~~
~~,,,~ !~~
I " ,*
~~Delm&b'V8 E::ili.iblt Noo 25 for lckmtlflc&ti.ono) No. 26 for identification.) o:c determine what the e~tent of his knowledge ls with regard to these exhib!ts 0~~
~~,--...._______ --'-~-,,,-------.--,--,--"-',------~~
~~BALCMON Z\EPORTIWG !3:2:RVICd. INC.~~
~~.-. '**!00 r.-'.QUITAl!i.:E 0 91JIL:C";*~**.-*... ., .._.... ,. .... . Ja ..\L..'!:"J.M:;.r.!: .. M;~rl.-JU:o 4-:.i:'.02.~~
~~II l i'~~
,:J.,,..,.,p.,,. 148 -.. . I*. M-.., !.:..'l..!n O .:-. ~&.~ii.tJ ~
~~m.sxkad t.hemp eo we w1.ll leaw-a~~
~~.,. ?*file AJ.EXAiNlJER:~~
~~th'Gm niarked., I have no objection to thei!.' 1-,~~
~~~: ~,~~
~~\/ L~~
~~_.*' .* he ing m~ked. i. ff~~
~~.' ' . '. ~*.~~
~~Q Mk~.. P&rks 0 h~ve you also .pxepared>> ... based on -~.- .~~
;:;}_:::: ~~.-' .. ;{0,tithe information ?{J?- ..* . in the pre=fi!ed te8 timony P an additionQ\1 ,. *-~ . *1* --~ -'-: '"exhibit wU:h the headiog Fet:tora
~~ill Qu_~.ge ExteMsio.n 0 S~lem ~~~
~~lg wich I ~ shoii-Zl.l~g to you uow?~~
~;10 *;-.;" l
~~~.: ;~~~
~t ~
A Yesp I haveo MR~ VOP.l:IIS: I wc;,.1ld .a~k that this b~ ll!'~~ked i~e.nt!.fic.stfon puxpogee M De ~rva 27 .. COJ:.iMISSIOlIBR SCHIFTER: So ma.rkedo (Factors in Out5ge Exte.nsion~ Salem Noo 1~
*;,r.,:::marked De~RT.'iJ& Exhibit lio~ 21 foz identification") .t:'.)*~.J[ . **..-. ~-::: ~-- ~<~* _:~. .. ~}
~~Q Mr. Pm:ks, the infon.mtion contained ii> !:h!.8 I:~~
~~'.,t.?._:)~:f-";/1.'\>.graph which h;,sw b~~n u1tA:s::kad .sis Del\'l]E,1:Va E&11ibit 27 °lg I~~
~~!*.-. *\*~'"*:_ .* .. ..-" . . ~;' . - ,. i:~:<' ?:>~:. ~- */t<\J*_::>1:*,::.~~
~~~~~.~~-.~: ~~*:*~~*-: ~~~~~*: .**.uas-sa~~
~~_*~ ,. . thQ on . ~ :h*-f\:n:m.atinin.~~
~~~= C.~~
~~coltli-gwed~~
~~<D ~~~
~~in ~vom: pre""filed~~
'.. :.:_.. : :ftt.*: *' . * : : ' ... O * * ' .. * ,-*:/ .... -.,,:*,*.0!St12cn7g .l,~ th.11.t li!Ot 1.':Ct1f'it'G'Ct? ~tt~\1":fli{:11: A* Yes1) it i.:;;10 MRo VORHIS: I* WS'.)U ld mowe .1) then 9 th.at thia.
~~it be 1:eceiv,ed w_to i:?J'WideiG.Ce SJ -&3 r.>Yello MR.. ALEXlwIDER ! I would lLlte to r~serVJe the~~
*. ---!!.n I-OMO I'/ *RE PO*Fi-'TI >l~..1£:,R*V-I C-E--IN C * . .. lOcl E:QUIY .. OLC !llUlt.Dll<G !:3ALT!MOA£, Y~.Jl.'/LUZO g !60;,t tl:!!loa7<YJ - 'l
_*__ J
and defer receipt until lateza A This la.at hsndout is not bssed on. L."1.form,.~tlou ln the exhibits p~esented earlier~ it is based on the
~~t' j l1i i~ that not correct?~~
~~I l i -::-1~~~
~~,. ri::~~~
~~Q Ia thia intended to be you.r t~st.lmony in. the SALOMON P.EPORTl:>lQ ll'1:RVICS: -IN';,~~
~~- ** -*~to() .E.Q1J1TAb:.A* *1Ju-u..01Ha~~
~~_Cll\.L.TlUAn[, !."CA!t"t"L:'lJ(O a tA:0~~~
~~... A It iso Q And if_you wer~ aBked these questions today~~~
~~A They would. I A I I I -would move9 j~~
~~.I thie morn.in.go 14 evidence.,, - ~* - *'~~
ts {' . _:l.A1-0MON r.t!:.r'OR1';'°'"£Q .SERVCC.:r: lNC *
~~.. . . \\'.:-J ~TJ::~.r:.1i"":'..\Ot;\t '@uH.. Dnlt; : --:..* ,"'::,~.-:; - .. ~A1.T\Mo.1n;: 1 ~ ..~Yt....r..HO . .C.120.:i __ .. ,- ..~~
~~the record as the additional Testimony* of J&?.es L.. Pax:ka o) 1 gradu.ated '% ith a Na21 ter of §eie!ffiee Degree in M:echruiical~~
~~. / E~gu.i.ee~.irag.~~
~~ai4,--~- ,r:'*_'-" '! If--~~
<::or.t.11.T.Rtl>cn-~n- *- '" 1 *-:l-A-.l.-0-b-lO-r-:_P._:Z_P-.0-R_T_l-,J-iJ-.:'.-l'::-H_.'/_!_C_S_l_tl-C-,---'--*----::-:-~-:-c::-----!,--- ,t,;~;
~~li .~~
~~. '* . ~t 1CO t'.CUIT,-\"CL;;; CU!LIJ!~li:..;~~
~~H. .~L7l.:O..hHH::,~~
~~. ~-1/~!'l:t!../\.!l~. :~ ::!O::. 7.i~_1_:i-;Co~~
I 1: I' I ir Po ~ l.-e. '}) 14~ "OQ-."31.,.~ 1.52 .I
~~- ~ * - ,,._.,,,ax*ecl 1*1* /-r,,.,._ ,.., ' ~~~~~--~~~~~~~~--~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~~~~~~~~--~~
~~G !!..,~.b.~~ J_~~
~~-'.< ._**.. i I In 1968v I was employed by the Public Service Comp&?:.J 1 '~~
~~of rJew Ho;,"lilllJShh:e~~
~ -9.t:?.d wa.s emDJ.o-oed ~ . J b.i various en.12:inee:l:'in.e - ' - <,o cape,cities on n.ucl.~ar and fo2sil plant generation.
projects o In 1972 s, I waa amp loyed by De lm~2.",JB Power & Light Ccmllp~11y <Rrld have ~mZ"k.ed ia rw,1:tcn1:J engilFt.ee~ .tng capacities up to th2 preaent t ~ . JBegln..~i£:1.g in July 1979 v I hav~ be~n ~~£l _t:Hoa1sible for developing &"'! in=};louse
~~~' *<*)1 monitori~g ~r.ogr~~ for the effi~lency of all our w,ite~~~
s.ndi). t;;ith another engiv.ee:: Tl the .slvail~bi.lity of the~e*
*:,'--**.. '\;~~~--. ¥ s;'*"'""' ..
~~}(!::":;/'"'fi1f~: ': .. units 9 with the ahe'l of establishing an mpro,~e~nt~~
~~prog:;:~ ~1here cost effectiiPEL Aa si. coKwequeJllce ii I regularly revie~ u~it pe~fcrfil~ce~~~
~~14 Q Has the eom~any utlli~ed the most ecoilofilicQl~~
~~- , :_,* -_- : 1~.' . i ,..,~~ of all t'l?per.;~~
~-
~~of 1"1-eStr.H:'::rstion autl~~
~
~~1)'1.:U:t;h,n~e 4 during the~~
< . *- ***r;~_- _ : three=month period ending Jc:lt\U.2-Z'Yv 1980?
-*~*}i-.l~i' .*
*)~.
~~1 A Ye.tL T'ne ~~oce{1tta."e3 1-Jl:15.. ch De lmru:\~S utilJ-:~~s to achie:;e the most economical mix of gener.2tion and~~
~~-Ptlrchases have be~n desc:ribed in detail in previou8 fuel rate CS.fH,HL, We* continued ti:i.esiE pirocedures du]:'lng t-he enti~i:a~~
~~_ ?erl.ad uo.o..,.-.-~~
, _ *~4 '"""!f'J*'1 o;_..v i. ..'.'Lo-.:~~;r-? ....... .. ~ ... u-~~.,,,..J<.al>-~v;_u:, ~~O"J",::, -i..~r.m- a *I"'.,.,, ~'i""l!!>!,'.'~.,a.
~~AJJ~~...._.. f;J Po,;,1er iB 3D.~~
~~>::ouu Rtl'onTsz:ru; EIALOMON REPORTING Si!:flVlCF.: INC,~~
***** ~ioo::EQUl-:' ...\!H.. s: '.!'3UILOIHG DkL..-u-Aonc .. M~::.-yL~Jo. :z.1202 -=1- *.1.
{: II I I .I I (Prepared p~ 2=3) ~fr e p .a&l:.s 153 r-. II. if: j::~ '* 1
-~
rI
~~,I associate member of th.e Penu:sy fa,ania=New Jersey=Mary l~,nd l~~
~~I Intercon.nectio:u.i PJM;, which dispatches the generation 2~~
~~-3 av~~* l a b..Le * ..i:...~ ~~om a~.. 1 Lts * .. *-~~
~~e~e~en . meuwex-'!\.. companies"~~
~~.1.nc~~
~~l u d .lllg 4 D~d.marva. vs own gene&"ation;i .sn.d the :resulting interchsm.ge 5~~
puxchases a.~d sales" to meet the entire PJM system load a at the lowest possible cost i,1i thin the con3 t1:aints of ii reliable operation"' Del~va s s generation" t.herefore1i is s cor!sta.ntly disf;D8tr~h~d on ~tie ba&ls. of the most economic.
~~e ~vBil2b ~ eueZ'gy,. with.in. or out2id~ the Delmarva. gyatem!)~~
~~ro while at the s~-:ne thu9 ~chieving the &equirem:~ntg of~~
.i 1 syste-~ ~eliabilityo *12' Q Has the c~~pany m.3intai~ed the productive 1S cap~city of all its gene~ating plants at a reasonable Uc.1 level during thi:g period? ~~'
~~1e A We h~ve msJ.ll1ta5;;-i.ed p1:oductlve ca.p2city at a ~<' ,:,,.,~.~~
,*ta reBsonabls le~2l during th~ pe~iod under lnveatig~tiono 17 DuEing ~ec~nt y~gr£, Del~~v~'~ average u.-~it avall~bility has cDn£ls tently beeiG. abowe PJM a:zyerag?-
~~ffi*fJ4;:. unit .a:va.ilabiliU:y .g,s ~b.o-w-n on Ezhibit JP=l, which indicat(:;z bs t r,:e :t" th;;m :r:ascn~bbe ~li!tenari.1ce ox p1:o,du{:tive~~
~ ~ . ~ ~ . I I
capacity. i'he outage ~eports regulm-:ly ~ubmitted to *
**--. SALOMON:-i'lti:PO;~*nN*G-*!Je:R*nci;; INC; ..... --CotJ:tTRtPC:Jl'!.Tl!RG -100 l!'.QUITA!lLC r:.lulLDIII.G .
Il
~~***:;.$A!;TIM.0?.Es r"tMl7L.A?lD .21202. ;:139-'1_7CO .I --~--.::..*~~
~~'ii ; II (Prepared p.3)~~
~~~-II-------_,____ _ i'./ .~~
~~.~::.~~
~~'1-'::: 1 t:rf.~~
.*f -.*._.,t. /'_. .f -l-t ~-
~~the productive capacity of all its genexating u~its 1.~~
* ~~,,. l t~. *; :? '
~~t*,. f:'* 6 f - :, .~~
,f l:\? -.. : ~ . :.JAl..0!*.!0N REPO?!TIN*G**,rn:RVICE INC, **100.EOUITA"LZ SUILOIIIG *---'- I 2At. TU..!ORE, M"r?""/t./..no *212(;,~ !,J:J9-6750 I . L
~~~-* ~.,~.. * .~~
~~...~~
l*
~~l*Ii~~
~~'I !1 J'I 155 ii II '1 "1 ~ 11 <'ll~~
~~£:,~~
~~I'I~~
~~~ comput2tion with t-1?.e~~
~~p'!:eceding ~olling l2=month perlod 0 4 l/ 1/79 - 12/31/79 o Theee t~qo e:¥'-11.ibits i..ndicate that the ii G~~
~)
~~Il ,--;jOa ? I'11 Q 11 for this l/19=12/79 rolling 12 mouth period? I II I ~ ~:'_' ~**.*~ SAL.OMON !UZPORTINO SER.VIC~ INC.~~
- * ,co t=:QU11'""'i.0Lr: 001Loruv * * - .BAt:.TlMORC:-.;*MARi'L'JU!O *Z.IZQ;t * *
l!
~.::., .i '
we utilized in our tefiltiilloD.J before this Commission in We have computed for each base load unit of 100 r!f.W o~ greate~ ~"ld ouz- - Indi.@s.r~ Rive'%' fi*Je 1 n O -,._**.r. c....**:."'~~~ 4
~~.-*:.-~.-*..-;~ ~~~~
r:h~3 ~-D~Ge test EP.J?",, the of RAF. ;.,i compario:Jon ... th.,~ most curreir~t a:.;elva month;*
!D:t:: ~A.I....OMON R:'i:PORTlNU SERVICE iNC., * ... fC-trE'tgJr7ASt.;:0-*cu1LPIK:; ..... .. __ *..:*.-~.-\1:.i.tMOFtt;;;.,.-.?,.1..e..R:'f.Z.. AHtLl..l.ZQ?- .G:.J!M17CO
I I. I. I I I I 31\L'.'M'.)N fl~PORTING ejEl*lVIC!.: INC *
~~..... ; .. *-*!OO**IZ<lUIT-1\ilLC-:.lUILU!IIO .. * . * .-* -* _ aALTn.10Ri::~ r--u~**,L,'\:'l!l .?.120.2 ***- .... - !3J:-l'.i76C~~
~~I°' ii II (p ._,., '"~**.,r.:,.:l ~ ~ c:" '\~~
!II . l ~=~mL~u ~* ~-~; MZ"o Pc1rks 158
~~-- ;*-'}* *.~~
~~'-,r- -~-~--~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-;-~~-~~
~~vi": 11~~
~ I!I to px:ec lud3 fu~ther operation of this rotor unless they r4 we~e machi~ed u cut. Slmi1~~1:, alt;;.~ough 1:.1.ot es gevere;) ~ cr.m,ck i.111diei!ilti.on[;l w;:;;za found ~!n. the R~P /I., P., !Coto~ b*o:r:e s; Q '° @,V.d a {focislou ~ia.3 tSiacte alzo to ..
~~macrs.:ute this rotox to rt!(iir;,;-: *:: _e$~~
' ~ ~ zeru.o,zy.s the er D.d-t3 o This m:1dition,@..1 wo:-rk extended o..,J~:o: '>'..
I; ~--- ".: .* od --~.:,, P.*,tl ,"'t:>.fn1lr -~ d ...r~ m;::,m:om;;e~*
* ,..'l ~ * ~ ~ tue e~~ o~ ~ne ye~~ ho]; ,1@*,7 ...... ....,._.. __ "'*r,p ~
~~QC>')-'l1~~
-,A;.J ~ ~;:;,.; 0 .,. . L C:.~--"'-}... ,_.._.,
~~J:_ "i availability problems in the vendors 9 shops ~a well as~~
,:{.'* '.*J,. *a for DP&L pi::rsor-illB l Ht the s t~tion o Conse.quently,.i a I : -~o .,_.-._. ~. . I. *j,, ,/*
~~,,(""'."'**': '~~
~~g II **l clee~tsion~~
~~. n1n.e ~.!-. .n.11 ,...,,~-,::~~~
~~1:'J,28 Yt:..:....:...~~
'IB!ad.(~ to do tl~*3 L~Po O.;~'h,e;,-;i*
~~Et.D.0.~'(p&Q>~~
<::.-.o'(R.a,"',<:!*'-s,,:"r,* ~*~,ll.!...4,.._~t.~:.!) =r .l, u f-n.._.,~ * .,..,..i1,~"""' ~,~~-..zt,,Jl.,,J~C.Ci ;;;I
~~outage cot1 t miueo t:_h :cougncusc~~
~-~ %--I' '"'O'<"
~~ul.~~
~~-.J-b.i.!~~
~~ii"'~~~
- ...:..&::I.~ £-h.e:.
~~b ... lo,.~~
"*"i'""""°'" ;:-'t,; ,w>.;.Gl'., 'l<",..,!nlAOr"g ~\~&,&'t,..S.
in
~~.oQ t,if:~~
~~_field wo~k fo:i:c~ .. -.rr.u.s O ~ 1,~~
~~Jsm.uary of 1980c Thi.Si unit t*.1ent in.to service in 1959~~
'I:* ~>. ta_. ,~tlrA f!Ut::h ~ ~rnble~£ c.~ be eEDected - 1D. unlts of this ¥"
~~j*. '14 vintage c These ~on.di.ti.cJis had to he Z'E;?~i-recl befor:e thra iJ~~
~~* *~~
~~II I 1.mit could oe Tetux11ecl to 88XViCeo ~~~
\* . ift ..,__ I,lj r, "'"' ---~- J --r,=*'*" *- d 7.... , ,.1.1:~pl;& *- ~~ Gl:-.B.u:~u.g1M- "\'f 1';."10 o ~ ~;vii ~1.11.~~e ~ D~ L.0;:;., l.t.~ lli.u.- **? ~.,_,.. 'If; r.:1* ~~ !in ...
ii
~~~llc*~!Bble p~:c~c~r.r:l,3llce l:211e l p~ .i~r i 1.:f (tue to the 2z~end2d~~
~~_;t,' .* li outage in t..he spring of 1979 foz: eonve:r:elon to b;J.llliJ.~ed f d-.:..ftt.i:t ope1.~a.t.1.on * * - ..._ -l..1..:~E ~oe-Bn exsm2.tne,.;1~~
~~A ?~~
=n 9 ~:i111.cn previous :fuel ~ate orcceedi~go ~ Sii7.C2 thfil: 9;_L~'=~ D t"°l18 ti.lli t tl8S COJ.1 tiD.iled to shoi;,;J imp:a;~ovement:::i in H:2 &\F i'.,Jith the cu:<:rent 12 month *\. .= . ~;.
~~__ !!~;::\? R:o,c~n::i~~~
--flAi..GlMON RCPOnTlNG SERVICS: INC. *: *-:*.** HJO**~Q-UITAr-t.~ OUILDI;~G *_.,:
~~DAt..TlMUn~. :-.-lt-.:l'"tL"AUD-~ 1206, !ij<Jll-07il0~~
**~ >*~*-ti ~
JII/ !*. . . *~, :~~
159 f-----'-------------------*-'~=~------~------;--- 12 month ,j.slue.,. We would submit that this continui!1.g Salem No o l continues to e~hibit a 12 month direct testimonj1
~~. -'!.~i..()?,lON REPOP.ilNG*si:::rnvfct;: iNC. -eidt?-f1iJo~~:'iJ):vi':~:~ ;.~~o;:~~
0
~~. "jl i!~~
Ii
.I If !I *I q I 160 iL ------------~--a-,f -
~~11 I~~
~~~ \;~~
~~l'I,~~
~~~ 11 lliZJ .<2 !i.?-.J A I do,., © f". *~ **::7 !t ;t. ~ ~~~
~~i ..... I~~
~~. &, I~~
!I ~~ .,,ie~e.,,_v,~ ~o,. <;:i O .~
di
~~!I . l j }..;-;),~~
~~l'1, l~~
~~!l 1;} I'1! I~~
~~(: 45 I',1 I~~
~~~ :7 ili,. Il i'~~
~~i: I Hi II I ll~~
~~!~ j.~~
~~l I ~ l* I.a *"""'"""*m,~~
>>,i~l...0!,40M fiEPORTJNt: :'J'"i:.:RV~CE: &NC. '** *****10:) *~QUl"i,.'Hl:..I<:: -GU1LOHJ*l .. ~i!,-..'-1"!~,~G:nc., M."".AYl..Al-(r,1 a :;to~ *1--*
~~I }-:*,*~.~~
~~'I I~~
l t . *~,.~-!;~v.-;-ik,,.._......... _.. *
"i l*
l
~-..1,. . ,, Pa::*?.;;s lGil J ....,i --. *--'-~--~~~--~~-~~-~~--~~~~~~--~~~~--i-~
~~I l I D~_lmarva E::11:hibit No o 30 and X'.'e~:e ived in evidence a)~~
~~'3 I~~
II g ...(Equivale~t Avail~bility ,~ctorsi, Majo1: I Gener~tL~g Uftit§ m§rked Delw~zva ~:<<:hibit No. 31 and
*i receiwed in ev.idenceo) ~
~~(Sta.~tla~d Daviation ma&ked Delma~v~ Exhibit ~'. , ~ "',\ Noo 32 ~ud ~ee~ived in ~vio~n~eo)~~
\ "J (Equiv~le~t Avail~bility F~to~ Ststigtics II ';.) 1! *filt;i~k~d D~ lfil~.:i,r*w.m E'.?~h.ibit No.. 33 and re~eii:Ped in eviclerie.e o) !I ,._~
Ij (Maj o~ Gene;s:atiug Urd.ts D Equiva.lent !.ivgilabili.t.:w I j Factor" >Mrked Delmarva F.>:hibit No. 34 "'1tl recehed L., ',', 1 1.iJ 'iJ ev idem:;e o )
! I ,ft~: ~J i MRo VONRIS: Mr~ Psrkg i~ then ~vail~ble fob I jJ-~
~~(<if'":;")~~
~~~; 0 ,....~~
1,
~~!1 q~~
ii ii croa~=e~~i~~tion on both the Salem te2tirnony a~d hiB direct testlmony in the H proce~dingo I 1 }.'~~ e> 11 (!
~~!1 COlft~lIS S IONEIi SCHIF-TER~ llir:,, A laxander.,~~
~~I ffJ~ J!tr ll! 11~~
;; I will o:y Q (By Mr o A leztand~r) ~iid §&'3B£t1l;: uro If you I have a £-", ~ 1-8D&~ throatv 1""' *-
~~80 I I~~
"'0 ;i.,,.0.~.t.. {lo ~.. ~.a.. ;::!I=- ... ,.;:;-j._.h -~<<o JL~ ~ 'I;;~
~~w,~~~
~~~.:.l-""='~~
k.:1ow" 1* I would like to review '['1ith yct!.,9 fi"Z:s t,, your
* ~ ,i1 !}ackl"..grcn1!1:atu., You &'.t'e not ~ ;r;.uclea:rJ: e1rn.gi.n.eer?
~~A I am a degreed mecharii~al engineer with ffi work 3ALQMON l'ii!;'.f"OR71NG 3ERVICE INC.~~
~~********* n,c* 1:£ov:TA~Lt* illisLOHse * *"'*** '"*~~
C:ou,n Rs:1>01,,. ER~ .. ,,*h--,~,.\t.:*T-J*:iwa,u:*,**M.-.._Ti .....-'\110 2i&02 * *
*.*c~-0;;39-fJl'~
-~
~~I h,S'll;e he.cl cor~espoiltlefil.tC_e t.jo:dt iH.!.\~ctlJv tcecb.no logy,, r Q i* I:, fj lj radiation dispersion model. _ :IAL07,!0N !qEPOl~TIN\3 .:l!ERVICl'i: INC.~~
~~-, - . dOQ,,£'::,CJ.1.!l"i','\SL*t,*t::UH~01N1 DAL LIM!'J;'I E" *. tAArl"t!-A.~O, :.f U!Dil~~
~~I I I l~ 16] 1.~~
*------~+-- ':l .**::1¥..*,
I
~~.r I;~~
~~('; fl,. 1.l~~
~~~.*,;~~
~~9 Q 1~1: ,... for the fuel.w.g a~tiwities ~t the ~,:;:.: '. ../*l .,.~~
~~\,.~~
1
~~---.:.,...,,,.:___-=,-..-___,...c.--------,-"'------"-"------,,.,.--:c__~~--- -*~~~~
_,.:_...._'-l,,.i,.;*...i1*1 _.<t.!.i---'G1*{ 'i tN G-::,t::H VIC:.::, )NC*
.... ,. .. ----*** lC~ ::E:!JU::TA~l.£ ~\.H1.DUH.i .- - -~ f'J.AI .. TIMO!:'~!:. MAel;"'tl..J'"..,117 ltt2.0.~ .. . ,,,~.,~ I I
I
ii j/ I
~~/I !~~
~~lt 11~~
~~------------ i !I*!I I~~
~~1) II~~
~~"' l g~~
A
~~~ ~ . l ~~~
~~a St£iff t~~
~~,."t~: *,~~
Ji
~~~ '1 ~~~~
~~II iO l I .I I~~
! -~ Q II II I 12.*
~~12 ., . ~4 Q i~ 16 "i7 !1 tiono ia II~~
~~~~:f l '11* ".~* --,n-.- - - - - - - *
I*.c'""*"<*oon.,

100 iS:(JUIT,Hll..z._Cun.01Nµ.
~~-DAL a:;.;...,:.nr.; ,-~&,.;i.yL~t) 2 ,;z,02. .. i j~~
~~2b mset.f.Jt1g~ Wt:.? ~egul~:g:oly did 'l\~1pi~~1 ope:t'@ltioo. of that unlt~~
~~~ ~~~
4
~
~~i1l cg~~
~
~~I point ~t ~n~ich Unit 2 h~d c~'mplet~cl bulk con~txuction~ £X!d~~
~~,1 '*. ~-~~
~~I, l! u . 1* f 12 I~~
~~~3 ll I~~
~~II _: rl~ 1~~ l l1 11 13 ii 11~~
~~.~~ il 1* 'Jo<!;)~~
~~Ii A These wer~ UnJ.t 2 In those p~rs;i~ul,3:,; m.42etitigs* p:ri~i*{iy:£~c11.s.~~
~~- * - * . ,.-., . . . . . : * * ** , : * * - --** ~*** * . '~~
~~t ., . -~' ' ., ** ***-*** * -~~
~~I -..~~
~~~...1',l....OM<..l~! nEFOP.1'1NG .'i!::.R.'JH.:rl iMC.~~
~~10-0 E:°Q1Jl1"A:!LE BUILOlf!*':i~~
~~- t!~~?.."i"ZMOnr:, *M!.rt\."l.)i::n ;{\2:)2.~~
I
i I I
~~--~--------------1-- I *1 l' l II~~
~~~ I .*.{~~
~~..\,l ; 0 *-r-.~~
~~~ 3.~~
' :.*,11.,*.*.*
~~~ . ~:- .~~
~~-an operational co~ittee r~ la.ting to Unit No o 1 'i' -o~~
~~~ g 8 e I We look at fue 1 budge ts 9 A Righto Di<t_you revie1t,1 _re?;>:.111",.t.fiJ,_______~~
!1~L!:}MON ~EPORTi.NG*-.zgsr.?VIC~- f~C: .. . JOO E:QUl,Aill.:l: DUILDINGl .._ . .,:io-c 7C~ ... !!IALTIMO<<f.:~ h'L~71.AH:J 21202 I .
~~'!i !l II ll i:}~~
. 1*::*
r.: '. 4 heci been l:eceived by us in the following ~1 committee i Q Did you t£lk by telephone with m.ese people the phcme o O*
-~
14 or did they juat talk to you o~ar the telephone? -(~** .. IiS A it up'.? A Thi£ testimo~7 W.filS ty?ed up by Delm.@rv~ Power & Light Comp&ny W-----------'-I 0
~~.. .SlAt.0:loON .;cie;.,on:ri.N r. *. sa!'l \/ICE: H.!C *. 1~~
10d *:;:,fufi"j\Ci.b B1Ja.nn1G

3-'J,TlMO!'lZ, M,\!l:'l.,\!!!> 21.!-:>;a 15311-6760.
I j
i,I/ II . :, II 11: I 7?1 i:. I
~~lff '§ II!I~~
~~/1 f1 *------------------------ L ~~~
ii
~~-=>~~
~~I lI - .,.~~
~~~- A That is correct.~~
4, I Q o-,.ver the ta le phone? me.a ting. The tea t.imony is of a 8umm.ary nature o from Gener~l Public Utilitiee t~stified before the District of Columbia Public Service Co...,,ission recently? A
.-.Ul c L'te Q*
~~Gn page 2 wh.e~e you say that the refueling~~
~~. t. <{~~
~~' ~~ ;- .~~
April 3, 1919 through June 27, 1979, whose schedule "'"" that '""""' Pt.ib l ic Service ? A Public Service~ s schedule O I guies~ this is Probably re pe tit foua , but I be lleve eve rybo.<ly is aware the;; I
---:-~~~-~,~~.~~-~~'~-\~ . Il .... - ...UA!..qM0~1-ne;;;,oA.nNci :J~Rvrcr;. rNcc. .... 100 E:QU17ADL1!; ~UJLDl"G 8A~!J!',<<,.R£, M'.\i':'lLAlll) ;:,?.Q;? .,.,,~-.*o;o~ r I
I
le'Wal8 without ~ctually seeking prior epprov.al of th~ of this facility through this delegation~ and~~ do not* ~;-._,..::.
~~~*..i~~
~~~!/1'7~~
~~.,** r' tJ~t -_.~~
~~1* ts~~
~~$A!..01<:0N RF-PORTIN.G srmvrcs: 11lC, 100 EOUITJ\u~,: ElUILClllHJ l3Al.T!l..i01H:,,MAA".'l..Al:0 2*.1.?0?.~~
~~2 achedulee th.at we~e published ehe-ad of time o Howe~er*~ s ,I 1 do knmi:-1 chat they are deve lo?"~~ on fairly loxig le.ad~~
* 'I tmes on the order of at l~ast a year before t..1-ie ~ctual 4 .~
~~6 Q Do you 1-tnow whe thez- o:?." not O.i"l-"'* th~t schedule ti~~
/
~~8 date for the original planned outage? That is ~hat!~~
*.~i e" f)
~~A To the b~~s t of my km,w ledge v they .ax-e o outage at Salem with ;,:rh.at: else i8 going to be done on the~~
~~,..",,. I .'JAI...QMON RE:-P-Ofl'flNGl !'!C:rlVICE: IMC.-.~~
1oo**~QUl"f'A1lL~ SU?lOIHG - El,\l."ill,!OR<:, MAl'l"fl.AIH) 2 j2,Q;,: - l J
11
~~!I II ~i ii~~
~~.} ii~~
~~'I Ii ti if !/ /1 f~~
~~cor:t"ect" thertE is on a PJ11 basig coordmation of I!!..aiuteKlOO.-<J:e I out.ages o A That ia t:E:ue.,~~
\
~~clo~e to $500~0000 Do you h~vB a Sifilil~~ estlmats~~
~~$AL0MON REE.0~;J':lNG**SE:*r1.VfCr::-- ;:{C**:-:~ **.~~
~~0 1co* ti:QUITf,l)l.l!: SUII.OJNIJ~~
*DA!..ilMOl'lE;, MAJWl**u,i;, 21"-0<<
~~n r n I1r, Pai*!:s 112 I~~
~~)11 , ~ll~~
~~_ _ _ __ _ ! ~~~
* . H
~
~~' B !~~
~~A Uh=hnho t e£, Q Ti"-1e f b:s t cause foz the prolonged rastu~e of~~
;a. the tm.t~gia you digcuss on pgge ~ ",;j'as what you call fuel &1,t elem~~t g~id ~trap d&ma.ge? ~ A Uh-huho ~ Q I i:9a.a iJcndsr w.g., I could not i.mde~stand == "I I ~y u.e~ex uncle~ea:.rmdi, but I conld. not understand frcwfi.
~~e you.ll: t*a51tWony *%*hat we a:t"e talking abcu.tQ~~
~ ,.:., 11 Wl1at i,:;; :fuel r9lew.~t1t grid St'ii:"Sp§I) f.i.rst of ~111 ii 1,* n~ i' A Do yon k1:u.:YI:Y :::~hat .s :fuel e.le~.r;i,t ls?
I I ~~ 'i ~ Ci f Q I:,.1.e-r:e 1.8 .~ no 1.... il.J.L?lc~t~>>o2rct
~~'1! - '~~
~~uel'.'e but :m;AJ be you~~
~~! 11 i~~
12
~~could de~cz:ibe it ao ~~1a C©.D. get: ~- ide~ wh.st ym.1 @1"'e 1$ tfJ. lk hag gbout.,,~~
~~i f £1 'I A Ok~y)) a Z'e@:ct0:t."; ~ ~, 1..L~t=2~~
~~;;!!- 1 -m 1,l)~ktc:;m~J h.~s a nu~ lear 11I 16 fuel ~m:e ti,.:;; ~ ~ a~ n Ro ,n,, 'll -~ r."'!'il ;~~ ... '-~~
193 fuel e l~ru.s~t.s I bi0.~:.'t1;: .1Lt~ t.;0Cll[Jw3G Db c1i;~*1.it, o ,T-*: :* i() I r.,
~~~~~n ? "l ~ =~~
~~kliai eLe~a~t ~Ob t..ie Salem ~ea~to~ ia a Bqu&ke~~
~~,. ,_,_ ~ 0 . 't;.: ~'~~
I
~~~t~ ";: .L,.~~
~~17 latti~e of l~dividnal fu-el &"otfa ~ The Salefil dssig~ w~ 17~~
~~'th~~
~~C', I ~oda DM a 8irleo The fuel ~l~~~~t is 2~out 14 feet lo~g~~~
~~I I! and it has£ st~uctukal configuxgtlon of top a~d bottom g~id~ efil~e~ti~lly joined by hollow tubss through "Which the collltbol rod fmge1rS1 pass,,~~
.---.-,---------1 *I --~ALOMOM REP'OrlTiHG ~:a;RVICf.:*INC. ...Cc111t'l"-Rl:l>,:m*l'E:ll-'l . ;,,;u ~,.'.PJtT,1t!;Lt: E:u:!.OIH_(; .I 0~0-d:"~, I .3"-S..TIMcn~, ~...t.Ar,ntt..:.r:o 21203 1 l
J j I
I
*---------------~---------*-------
~~173 L~~
~~';l~~
~~'W'* 2 I s* r 4~~
~
~~parallel to ~d perp-:endlcula:t> to each other o little spring clips .e1,~ paxt of theiz- const:a:uctim.1 which~~
~~,'\~~
~~I think J.4 they ~re not the~~
--;JALOMON REPOflTING ~iRVIC!:; lt1C.,. ~00 EQUliA~LZ nt:1l.nt!1~ * ,J)At.Tf~:ort~;*>M)\P.'t!..l.. :'tD *~ 1*202. 530-'Gi'50 ... -?=*:~.:- .
~~9t.~}?_-:;.f)tiSJ~r~iZI~~~
Ii II . .I i . _Jb-*-*- l I. 11 17t...
*1 I/ '1**.- l 1 ~
~~{* 1}~~-)'~~
$f At that time, the d.s

.:nDge 'i)J<?.S not,~d on t..h.eae
~~~;{\_1~. 2~ -_*rd ~ ..~~ ~~" £'""1. w1e J~~
~-~ ~~ \:1h £.ch ... - &-1,'"'J'i! ~"" -""'-,., I"\ *.* .-:..'J .,.,.
~~u;::,r.,zeg!2 ;;-?,::;:; ,-.~_ :-,...,.__ -2~~
~~~"' ..:.' - 'l""tl.i,;~~
~~v - "'""- -r_.. - .......... ~!::",.,,~~
.---1~ 0 th.st the ~-------------- .. *- .~A!..Olil,;,:.._~-R.E:P.OR Tl NW ;,,:,, \.' j.:;*~: lf'rc. *-1---
_.... .,.co r-"QUrTA4, :."*t::'u.,~.1"n,:i-. **
*-~Al..7'li,:DiH:~-~~--t.\:~.. L,\1..;;'l : 1.=:~)_4 . - -- .......:,no.-~J<>O !
j
ll p
~~- ~1'.,1*------------------------J ivrz t'ar.-.rn o~~
~~________________1_1_s__ j'r-H II l ,occ1.:n:red" *n ttJ.aEl&C yorn trying to a.ay? lI A~~
~~I I III I~~
1
~~!.\~~
~~/: .~~
;r' 17 I - -*-.* 3A*t.OMON REPOHTING :;;;:P.VICE !NC, I . .:oc &:QtJ1TA:'lLP. au11;01ua :-,-
~~B.A!.TCM.O.!:l£, ..M.:A.."'l'VL.",!'!O' ~ 120a~~
~~"' ""---- --B~~-eno I* . i~~
11 !1_ ,t--- 176 L II and at this point in to pro~esd against We~tinghouBe oz noto Q I all to be decided by Public Service? Ii
~~!I J~~
~~l! I to cheek I the Peach II~~
*I I
I May of lctBt -year? _I_ I _..!jA1-Ut~10N R,~?CRTiNG :~a~vtvrct;: INC. 1* iOO EOUZTAJ:11.E:. E!Jl!..DfirQ ,. I
* --*- :~A,..yJ;.,t(Jn,z;; MJ\<<*!~.-:.:zn * :'! l:Z:G2.. - !1.
1 I
li H II 1Tl ei'1,---------- 11 {;, 0
~~'I THE W1T~ES8: That is righto s thing to do..,~~
~~JG. t1* ray I~~
~~-*3*.,\i.0~\{*:":;1'*1 r"(2?0R.YlNG 2!::RV(CJ:; INC .. ;.co 2Q:.J1T:"-:::.t.F: :JUJLOHIG ~-~~
~~2,~ .. -;::e,:!'l:1%:, ...,v:11.a*;t..:.:.;~n i?.1::Zil:?~~
~~---:,:;~-C7G;J !~~
I I -
I j ji r k ,I Ii I~~ ':a l 2 C0Mr1ISSI(JNER 3CHu"'"'TER.: Could we just aek j
~~~ -1 Q I ~~~
~~Ti-IE WI'fi.IBSS ~ -Okay o ie the time~~
r. *
~~.cne the~~
~~~i'.,: Oi.ltag~ o in.D would isrn.1ed I all on I~~
'lr-------------*--..;..;.:....:;. -.* - - - ~ - ~ . : _ _ ~ ~ = =-.= = ~ - - ' - - - - ' - ~t 1 - ~A'L'OMON 'REP.OR1"JNG*!j£:;RV_1Ct;: INC. j * -~oo- c::cv.1-r:-.n1*.:.-::su11....::,1~0 E.M.Tit..~c:a:*,. !\i:.u:t*tr~.;U:o 2. 1202 Ii I
I I ....
II n "1 [C\ 1.n, l the J.ength
'to be out!) t:t*ue has ~eal.ly no bef.1:d.ng on. 'the 'IRE Hl1'NESS : -i;,: . .*;,Ji but the !.udi. cated bulletin I I othe:;:
~~. :Ii to be 1:"\ z11ow12d to~~
~~. ~~~
~~allowed to SCH IW-TER: the~~
~~r!Ues tion I~~
~~. (~ "$!,t.OMON RG:POP.'i'ING*~t:.:RVICF, *1NC,~~
___ _*_ltc;,on.-~s . * - ~- - :.--;CO* J!~Ul"l'A*UL'e -trni!.. OING *
~~-, , aJ'.!,:rU.!ORi.. M..r.t:Yl..,\U:J 212.0 ~~~
~~Hr., p.:;;n:ks uw S.alem @ute...ge of H.Ln.e months 9 approximately!'.) was just if i,ed 1..m.dez- >'::.UY 2et of ci1ec1.1msttmces o~~
~
~~iJow 9 ona of. the factors that we az-e considering igi~~
~~to "t-;;hat extent the 'idditional out~ge w.2s un.a.void@ble~~
~~.e ...~~
~~oa.ze to --~-~~
~~~;..1-!U .~~
zequ1..::-~--Bnt.e" ~ The fact* that Bullet.L.'1 79=02 e was is3t1fld on M~ch. 8 :ta r.aally !CO-;Jllple te ly .ir&:'e lev~nt to -/*
., that d.ate'Jr.'E.i.n&tf.c.:: l:rut I at le.azt £L~d i.t. difficult to 'l - l' ' - ! * . .see orn the L,;:nqer ~--'Lt:" ~;,.nes no~:? m1y oz tn.18 col!tr.1.Dw.tea 0~
t3
~ to the length of :::::2 outflge o ~~(% 1/c!--~~ ~zss: -
~~J. uoin. ..ll O t qu:2.~e * * " -~~~
~~!::oliow '~~
~~now you J. arr h1ed at t.11.a t Q:::;: i.:~drn:1o This * ' i~~
~~tL;.;,_:,fn::o.11v _,£.3 cu t J...&r1ec 7 .f ~~~
~~m" 6-h~~
~~~ _e t:eskim.01::-.y/)~~
~~1,S 'r';;J~~
~,, l -~ """*'" ~i -~1\.-.....~&W ...s !:J ~ ,r,n-' ~ ~ ,; ., *: ~ '-, -"' . ...,.~~ ..L.--*- '-~..._ ~ _.._ . le ,>:°ff,'1"",'; .a_:>-J,lJ~.:..c::-- ~** o"~ ,,... . ..:i.. ,,,,~a,.,. *-*4..:i~~
fl
*1 ;-">""P""'., ~~~~ UO..-~~ ~,;;, e::;,~~4" .ei ... ei ..:,;,, ~.,..~fi.::3.~'aJ... ,, v*!!
1~ a,.,;...,,.,- t~Jori-t ~ It also ~\2~--~ ~-r~;d .a_ ~ta~ge amount of in-=-plfl..nt 11 t~s ti!llg i:C; v~2:..,.if3-r ~-~ :J~]aly~:l.s i:eratii*z:es th.~b \ie~e 11
~~... . ,. *.....,~1 r, if"':,,.. ..-_;,.,-~A -~ .t:,., "*".'"_,."... ; ~ ~ t0 ."-t.._o rl~ r') o ~~~
11j. develo;p:2:d"' .£.:...Qt~1 2:-S:_ _ --~.;;U ..:-r-0.fil-~ ,ii.:!.1..-,*-b!J!a.~~.l.<e,...f;l;..~,.:.,.O~!~ L.W,:_. ~BrG..!:~'t"l ii. of the plant ~,ibict 2..;.: logg as 't.ii.~e pll.sr:i}.'i: wa_s dm*m ti1e NRC l
~~had ests'e.blishe<l t::, :-,.::.le that i t wou.td net start uniil 0 t.:.7,,is bullet:l:ra had :~~-,,,.;:1 closeci to ti.~eir 2atisf~ctioZ1:,)~~
~~so tu::u:111 the bull, 0 , __ c."t~1<l tb.e wo:;:-k i:r."1&t . they~ 'M'RC in this CaE,;'!>~~
. --S)--* h.aiJ ........ ;--i.,.~"'**~'""ct ~.__,*J:;:~:~:.::;;;*' ,,-"** ... _ *'.*"t'<~~EH:iiC"!.' --'C~"-'** . ..., *to 't,;;:,***,c;;-1],,p-ii;et,...!.:l** '-" ::~:.:::,~ .... _ ... .......,__ . , ~-- ~t*! 1 ;'I\, . . . . _
~~r!-.,,,~~
~~~~.l.;....~~
~~J ____ _~~
~~-i* . ------* .-"'~ ~~:iPO~:::-:~*IG :1E:-1ViCr.; lNC**..~~
i CO',"!lT }'.:;.>~;:*;:,:;:,, ~ /~;1,,:~:,;::!r:*~;_."}:1~::::,~Dl,ilo;( _]
11 II II 13! 11 ~: t~*'
~~~. lj Ii l~~
~~~-'~~
~~'i - unit could come back on ll.n.e::, th~~ ~~.nt in fa.ct could not ~ I come back.,. it.1 serviceo *I~~
~~I ca~ns S.IONER . SCH L."G"TER:~~
~~4 f.i w-ork to be <lorae but required the ploot to be dmm'l~~
~~@ I iJ to 3~~
~~1! o* II It is a little difficult H l~~
*i 'L2 Vil II 1cj *5 ~~'> .. t}]
~~1 ..... C -~~~
~~---,-~~~--------:-----:------;, *-~~
~~I L r* I II~~
~I I }tt? Parlts "f.l')L ~o~ I
~~~ i~~
~~.. ff I~~
I TIIE WI'D:ES3: The :NRG did not propose dat,as 2 of that nature o They Wf,'.;Ulcl set a 30-d.ay or acme time rr period limit w.H:hi!i %'-Jhich they required -& response, 41i ~d the respo~~e may or m&y not have been the final 6 responee that.was requir~d. It would depend on wh&t tue
'L.. C 0<::zID.1U32:i.m.1 ~ *
a rev1.ew

o:;:- tu.e'"' re&ipon0e to Eny 01.
~~c .~ weBe 6~~
'1 particular bulletins resulted .L.10 *. 8 CC£"1MISSI0~IBR SCHIFTER: Not,Yf) ~~h~t b.e.ppeued =""
0 1.-ihat does the date 12=5 me@n orr. th.ls line? THE 'frJITi'IBSS: That signifiea the date at which Public Ser.vice cloi:;~<l m.1t that bull-etilni; a.,d by closed
out, it meooa that they had ,rnl:iafied r.he NRC'" i:eq11ire~ . I mera~~ 1.) and* if th.at requirad t*mrk ill the plen.t!) modiflcatioj work Liil t.he [) l,,f;iu( t D thfit t11.at "*mu V: ld tl"'°ll
~~..=, ,.., t.,c; f. be ""'O'.fil!t) ~~~
1
~ red . . C. ..:..~ " .c, . ,:,:, cor-~IISSIOZ~;:;R SCHIF*1.~B. : In other wor-dm~ w.,e 7",'T"l}n ";I ,.mi.. illo~e or Le2s 8 :tgnet! Ob:t' o .., - ""'
~~ora ~ ., L-~cezru:er :, v ~d the plant - F,.:,~;C,"' 1i ~cu~~~~
~~,_ j..i,l r!~11e gor1.a ~r.h~=ireu~~~
L - *
.lJl1 to ::lG~'=ij ;:.ce ~ .r;;,1 ..._,_.Ht, tli~:1 t r1 .z;J te i.:~ .that w.as all _that h@d to be doBe 'i THE °i'-JI'Th"ESS: Tls~t -*'-' ir.i es sen titdly co1.*rec t. ill re:gazd to that bu11-Etlll o COHMIS3 I ONER SC1I IF'"TER: Nm,,.,, ~;;hai: abcut ti"'1.e 'S,\L<OMON RE:PORTIN.G !IE:Rl!IC5: me.
~~0 ecu,l'r R0>!>:fn:ri13 *-* -tOQ .E0.UJ7,t,O?a~ .D.UILDUlG~~
~~_::*.~ .. ~A~*j-lMO.!':C,. *MAnY~J"...~l.D .21202 - S::l9-67<*0~~
183 THE WIT£IBSS: That is essen;:ially the ssw.e basis upon which the bulletin w.ss handled o COMMISSiffi:;rER SCHIFIER: Ex:ept that :=":' THE WI'nlESS: Except th.at-~ two-phase appro~~h
~~.. J to on that bulletin ..~~
~~C(JMN:ISSIGJNER SCHIFTER: So that the cuts.ge it did go Oil befo~a April 4o I believe the ffue.1 1r---------------------.;.._:.----~--------------i'--~~
.... ** SAl.CMOl-1 RZ!POt'fi'ING !31l:ftVIC"~ INC. .. ..* .. , .. '*""100 ti'1Ul7A:l!;£*"*$0,711.;1Jr:IG ...... ~ **El-a,\~T.JMO~I::,~1..J~""iY.L:~tD.21202
~~.,1:~~
~~ji q~~
~~'l !f~~
~~lij '~~
}1X' o Pa£:"k8 184 ~
11 19=01. ox: -- in other a;D't'ds !) what I am tx:ying to really i ,, ..,. get ia a* p.ictuice of what your ch.art shoi-1s us o In other:
~~.2 ,1 wo:c-ds i, ~hat "{<;e:ire the outages" due to **what factor?~~
~~nm Wln!ESS: The intent of the*cha~t is to~~
~~-~ .eonvey the msgnitude of the ~a~iotis fa~tors that ~exe s~~
~~6 i.u'iJolvad .u1. this out.":J,ge. I don 1 t think.you could say any one of theee ~pecifically w~s the liw.it.L~g fa~toro~~
'1 There wer1:e s ~ ot:]h.er i:n.-.i.lletu1g . issued &:1d .which he.tl to "t,,. .. *1 . ,,, '"l ., b .
ua t,ntnv aone reiatr\ie to t ::.em.v tnat. t) q .. - ., CC"illif.,i2..e~ ~r:io ;:,m;s,~*t.;. 't<Y.!28
~~'ii" axe not shown OZ! he::::e bec21-we their i.~psct "li,m.sn ~ t q1.1ite as large butv no~eth2l~~aP t..~i~ all rsqui~ed Pnblic i::~~
~ '* '}" . Se~vi~e to focus a ls~gs <£mount ~ ~M~~ITT~~ri~C 0 .1,, ~.i:.a~ ......... ~ l ; i i l . g - ~ ~ $ ) --=-~ . rn~~-h,nur~ _J -~*si 1;~ f ieltl 1e!".:Hl"ll: ~-;ioz:k to satiafy all of the2:a various :fsctors
~~,t<; that entell:((;;d i~to it?~~
~~Q 1h"~~
., ie C{)t1MISS IORtto;B. SCEIFTER: 1.)!ee,, t~,~.ts l.S i~.u~t ~e
1. ~ * '.1 :! ,..
~~l~' a.UG\~J a,~7:e&O.}f ~~ i; 0 tll..e t~Jtle~!ll ~;2 mete !:Ic~i'J v 't~~~
*-~-
1r. _,;:,; "li1 ~ ~,*
~~.... Gr:J a!..~~~
~~t )' looks to mB 1.8 t:l1a t ~;0 'rtBlle a n_;,;;n,b:.er ,.,,_ n ..y... ism:i.es here ,and~~
~..,ie*. .I! n *
~~!:1.!:'ac wo1.1Jt~1 r2e~~
~~,i_ o wl~~tl'.183C tne* "~~
~~scneuuleu~~
~~.:J ~ ..'l outage~~
~~scned.UJ1.e<~~
* ,i :1 fo'i' 11 '@,Jeekg a re;;,,s o.r:1au " .
ti-'<1;a~ l.e le~gth of tim.~ to exp~ct 9 ehethe:r th.!.B 't-Y.:§.8 .a ze.fil:J.C~t.aible length -=
~~=:.r.: ..l\..A.-X..i.-. rs.,37 T'1"'.iJR.:::;..~~~
~~___.. ,,.1.!-~_i:-.~o,.* ___* .--_ ....... ~.,~-:-*- o=1~~
"f'h.,:, e 1.n.2,d--.. n,i~,;-,:;p-,-:i_ .!l..._-:--"l'~-- -w.i.~ ...... o ........ :c,*.f'~v:,,,-1,~ 1 ~ '? !,'.!).,...,. ............. - . . _ ~ - ...... ,Q
~~'.:ALOMO:,.: R:a:PON.7!NG !S~R"-JJ{;E IMC.~~
-:uo ~tlUIT.:.u:.!: cur:.:.01 w:; !((:_:\ )t .. ~.\)..;T !MOH::.:, r.1.~G"/t;,.'\!!D,: !202 ..... ...... . uJ,:.s,c.,
~~l 185 I~~
. --'-- I -- - I I*
~~r-I Yeac How many I tefuelings COJ!.11-1:ISS IOil:fER SCHIF'11ER: Therefore the length indiicates this was the f lrs t becm1.se it is somewhat~~
~~. I tlli.l1k th schedule *was probably t -.... ' ~ -* .a f- *~ 0 I .t l~~
~~r of the co:re is~~
~A!..CMO.N..-R~POR71NG SERVI.C*C: INC,. ......... fOQ, ~QUfTACLE. ~Ul.!..OIU_G C3~67GO ..c.JAZ.**1Mon::. r...W.YLt...!'JU .2 _J ~02.
~~ii II 186~~
~~-I' "),('-A P.szl-ca *I .;.-~ 0 .l II r~~
~~JU8 C Q~~
~~t"D.'Z."lee Wee~g < r=~~
~~S1.:t,2? ..' l.¥: Wa3 SupposeC\ t 0 come O[l aga.:tn. o_ O~~
~~C, O I~~
~~II Then ws have the aecoud half of the year". and the second~~
~~'I Ii h&lf of thJ year the unit WM dm,1r1v according to your testimony~ because of ~llC requirements~~~
~~THE WI'fiIBSS ~ That is corzect? CO!:{MISEIONER SCHJ.FTER: NctY., 'lljJh.i:!t the secofil.d~~
&]a:l:'agraph of th.st page doe§ not show me is if Public Ser-i..vice Electzi.c ru'lid G.as ha.cl acted ~s expeditiougly as th~y prm~:t~.z.y cou.~a)) t,:,lha.t would h.&.ve "~ - , sf' 'l,,,,,o.{!I,,..
~~w,.,.,,..__1.. r.. f,-hs-,~~
~~~,c,1..1..~.;,~~
~~v-,,,,:-., ,,, ; ;-.~1~~
'{ti~..,.. ,.;!,.""=5*.~ of time Salem Noo l h8cl to b~ outrlue to .~hose ~aquirew..entaD e.nd I am at a* little blt of a loss to completely unde1:"' ~to::m.dl) you ki!.'!to'w!) what the Gi~cm.1.d h2ilf of the ~heart the;:efore shows o. .
~~Nmv;.i it siee1U2 that the most crt1.eia.l one is H~~
~~1 the 79=02, *fghicli exte11ded it to Dacember 5 9 a.ud I gue88~~
~~~ 1 1~~
!l 1\ 19 - 01. 9 w1.u1.cn. ~ ~ * , .!.,,. am-1:,:sa1 you -but --J. ~ !l:iD£ii.
g
~~t t~ow ,~~
~~wnet.i..!er i.. you (* i knew the Bwer., ""tend1>d it to the aad of Dacambe,::, ~- ;1~~
~~! :,,hat ,.:>:Mls still the f,'!"cbl~av and then the t1uestioin I guess a~~
._._ 1 really. which is e2sential if'l ~11a.s t..his ::really the period ;(:* Which """ reqc,ir.sd or co,~ld it have been done aro,etchat I
~~and!' you laow v ~.:ihat iril.eeded to be <lone o~~
~~JJ\l..Or,:ON.J'!.!';?OR7-lN G*sr.;RVICI.: INC.~~
~~t*tll'IT R.EJ>OllTEl!S .-----:*too E:QUITAifr.r. SUIL:>i:tG~~
~~.i;.t.Tlt1om:,. M~!'.l_YLNJD 21:.02 Qj~:si7CO 1~~
i" I II 1..87 11 1 I The aecond part of the chart I find not as 2 I he lpfu 1... as the first half.
~
THE wITj;JESS: Wellv based on the info'l'mation 4 that I have received and the dlscusaiona that I have 5 engaged in with Public*Service Company~ the work w2s G i 8 Wa,:re 'brought in to do the WO!.'ko There Wf.n:e fairly 9 , I iL.* tended to be that cert~lin field fea.turee,, fi.eld construe-
~~~i*~i.*'. . . ,~\j,::-* tion of the plaB.t harl to be *verified~ and .if tests 1~~
~~.;,:r-- .~~
{;f ' "'"'"""~ :lAt.OW.O~l,.Ri'a?CR"!'.lN,G ~ZP.VICE: INC*
~~;;.%:','!i'i;:~,;E.:::a*;*:;.. *"'~'"" . i l~~
l.
I 11 ii I! I ii 18 8 ii _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _i:_,f_-z:__o_:?_.J_a_-r_I_~;._:i__~ - - - - - - - - - - - -____~ ,
~~,!/I ]~~
~~I I II l ,*.~~
~~~ ~ ,:i <.ip -1 ~ So.it waa not work That is rig.ht~ an<l I think this thing~~
~~and I think that I still don't ses 1-* .-~~
O:lS-C7~0 1 l** I I
ii II ti .189 (\. l l! 1 :t1I~" P2~r1ta ~' ~:~\-":- II
'll j'. sevez-a.l rie,?1Biot-is £;nd s-;,:;.ppler;,_es:rt§ .after the initial I issua..11.ce d&te which gz-e.atly changed the nature of work 2 .,.
that had to be dm1e du:;:ing that periodo 41, TBE WITNESS:. That is trueo c~~1ISS10t-W:R:R.~1IiToN: Hro Park31) you just A - *,.:o t b..e ba.!;'.;~ ,;: . ~n2.t -* '~.., tne *
1.nciael1,,:s e m.av.e :-ce:te:--:ence pro::NlDLY 2ud p~oblems that w~re faced in thi8 made it-~ guine~
*8 pJ.g 17 ~ncl let me e.lBbo:;:ate npon th.at ..
~~9 TBE WI'I'NES3 : Fi?.s t man~~
~~Ira liK?.e v let's ptit~~
~~.~b~~
~~v ... "-h *;:) ~ ,,t,;iu.©;.J~~
....... -,, T h<:>-*'-*.-a ;-.-,, """'l"L ~'!,,.,,,,, !l"li1 l;l09!"' "" ,...., ci, b.lj,,,f..;,,.~ Cl .'!. 1-~~!,...., ec.u ,.... ~ _.i1..!'..;E;.; ~-=~~ ~ ~ - b o.
~~CQ1,J11II8SifJt~~;R Hs.~17:L'I'Ol>i: I };,,,,.fm t to iaY.:p&nct ni:1 lto~~
~rHE 't~ITI::rESS: Go .sihesdo .. 1,3 C0}Yfr1lIS5Il}l;<lER tIJ:1IviIL~I:f}1YI :. Lg t ~ B S&ji' i.t ia tl~,3 *.. **us *!! ~e:.~
~~a:i i ';;01:.7" .!'- {t.~~
~~'irnat snou 1~~..s .,. "1 .., ......~~
~~1 ~~~17 ~=~~
~~...lf~~
~~tJ1..rst e~amp.ie ...~~
~~o:c'". $Ome~~
".""'?"'lo'.'>=~ ..~~v:J ,.;,.f.l~Q "" 1n""*"'" ~.:.uti.. =*<,:i,- -~'::....,....,""/ ,..,..,.,
~~LJ;_-:.,.~~
~~ .,.'"**1~ *-~; ....
~~La!..~.;",.~~~
;i-,.,,~.,.-----,:, ~t':f; 'i.~".<;;-;_. ,.,.,.,,:ii s,-,-, ~1;,2.1u. j vU ... ~"'" ~J~~.t1 1-h~s:-: *..,.,u-_;
1=ecogr1~e('} ~*~,. ~~iii,, ~= ~Bs.tir1gh0t£-3~ 9 . the F.}@:nL1~~;1e!ti.1~*ez- t_ the mooagEJmeut com!pl~.y:) n:a: "s-:Jho wairiS
~~you referz-uig tc?~~
1:11.E WI'IIfilSS: I belie"';e in th-E context of tht:'l.t Stateme,,..t;- ,r--,, ,.i.z.-~ T 4*
'"~,q.~ ~-/..._,.c.,,; ;c~f,.!.::,,,~-rJr,v::,* ,=, ...... =.,'..J-l;.. ..... ..&:..u.,4.;.;? ;.-.-. P11~?
~~P..,'t,,,1 """ ....... ~ .i<..----~~
~,~'lr',_:;n\'.,..~ ;,,, --.,)-~ ,&' ...... ~ -
~~v1~-~bc:,o,~~
~ ..-.i--;- *1r-1 .:....,:1 ..,,~ ...1 C}.j...a~
~~Gs.so~~
.i .'i ~----~~-~~~--~~~~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ -,Co;ntT Fl~l'onnm: *,G;\t.O:v!ON ~EPO~TtNf'r SEtlVCCE. .-- '**T100::r::QUITAOL4**.~_tpLO/UG rr.sc. *1-1*,;.*,
~.
~~L.i:_~~
*. *--:* qAJ..Tl:...lOR.~-.**!~J~~HYL!-U?--'2 J~-0~ .' *-* t<:!~07~0 ;,If' .'(,.*
~~v,*...~~
~~. I~~
~~190~~
C0l*1r-U8SI0h~R l-1AHILTON: The operator of the COMMISSIONER Et,..MILTON~ Nowi, from your p~ofegsional sta.~dpo.int a.~d obs~rving wh&t happened there the graphi, I would look .at your testimony == we t.(.QOW things I
~~I l.YI'i1'.N'ESS: I '(1ould sa3:; t+,at 'tfl:ls .11 combiu~tiott The design hatl been ch.::-it3'.l!.ged on~~
~~those I I~~
,',**,'"*11---- 1:lJ',l.Ot,!ON-1'l.1li?OrtTING SERVICE INC * . . . -* ... C:Ol!flT*Ri:l'or.iTl!P.ll ... 100 EQUITAti!.r.,.DUfLDl~G. * 'g,~~"i'UJSO~E' 9 ~fARJLA_:fD 2120,.:-***. .
~~,~ j '~~
11
~~..j.~~
l: ! i It .----i,l * ,.r"... v~~--1~r,:t
- . v * - . - - - *- - . . - L . - ~ - 0 ~ - - e - - - : . ~ - ~ ~ ~ - - - *1,1 I L 1' ?.
~~i.t is ~ever the scme tiYhen yo1.a do the actv.al tihilll~o~~
~
~~S*'l C0..'\1HXSS10NER HftJ,ULTON: You also saidl) though!}~~
~ as :a z~su.lt: of whet hapi)er~erl h:!:R:"e, West:.bignouse theasa 4 <lid t~z~ ~~~u~rl a~d p~e.sc~ibe a diffe~~il~ pxoce<lt'il:'eo ~ THE W1'I~1ESS : That: is cottee~ o .s i
Gm1M1SSJIONK~ :HAMILTON: Tihe:,7 Sliggested i p,roeedtl:ral ch..a~te:3 o 2 THE HX 'f11ES S : That is co~zec~" CO~MISS10I]1lli. E.t\HlLTOH~ i:J.1:c I ,:;;aa:1 tH:nclermtaail .: that tte~e u"JC@ld be c~?ta:L~ eCG1'dOmies while ~his is d@wt1 :i looki~~ w1: o~1h.er ~Z"ahlems that: e~ietecl oz developed Jhe~e i*Jit}-.a 4;e:rtf..!iza mG;:cltt~lfi'iical problems tha-t you ::relfrted I ei.s 'iEell 9 ~©t t1~cei:JSclrily diZ'C*H!~ly aifecfced h;r ~'!sae f~~l iI C ?H.~~!~c
~~.... ,,"'1~(6),~~~
3
~~?""":1!1-i:!"..'° ~~t.,~~
~~_-,:,.,,i-~*~~ ct~...;,.~~.o.C.:.~~
~~-:,:,i.., 00,,. .....i~o L*.!;...-:_:..:J*,c;,w a~d ce~taifl othe~ thin~s ~ere I!~~
in tht2: ...tmJ I I l prre2st:rE:'8 itt:~2:To: i?1G 1 0 I
'J.:dE 'Cnr11.m.s s ~ T~1e~t; -w-t,~k 12~1ti bee~ scO.edulecl I, o H
~~Cfi:-tM1ISSIONY&.l '.H.-~MXLTON ~ To ~un subs,~tien~ t:o I ~ho,*, 7'"'~*-fQ 1.Ji-§'?~~
~~.II - ....... '- _li::;..,...~'t>..,,-~O"'~~
~~THE l'1ITI?ESS : lt~ w8.9 to ?'lr-:il COl'llCi~.Cent ~.d.th the z-efu.:el:tn~, ec.11~ c101itdcrtH.ilmt :z:eteuning as well"~~
~~;: :JA!..QMON 'IH'..'.1>011TING ~C.l'l VIC~~~
~~iOO EOUl"'iADLI: nu1Lornc. f:1At."7I.::~Cr.::. M.:._rt'."LMIO 2..12C_?.. rue.~~
~!!!]-~7C,:) , ri~}f
~~e~te@ded t~e ~im~ ~@mc~h~~ ~y~~d th~ o~i~i~al plB!rufil\~d~~
~~ti:me?~~
~~!lAl.OM.ON ru::PORTING*$[;;~VIC!'; lrlC * . - ~00 t::QUITI\.Ot..i=: *ou1LDIUG~~
s~:.. Tl:.do~:::,.**1\f...~"ILAUO 2120a*
~~II L.___~~
~~,1 r,l 1931 i *----*-~-..-~.--=,,-*~-----*-~~
~~II l 2-.. !l fS::*.,*~------~~
~~. ;., .. . SA!..OMON R:if:P.OP?TING SZRVfc;;:. ."fNC:-* ~:~~
C:ou,. ._ *ioO e:ou1T.'\aLr:*ca11L~.!n~* **
;::**.. ij . ** -~ *~.i:n:o-cnTtn3 .. .._... - .. ~. : ~ _ o.-t.r.T1McRr..., UIAF..-v.r...u,c .... t-C.2 .. ~f
~~'f;;. ;:,C;;?~?*;Jf';~1;~-~~
->: froilm the ~!i:ilicty ~ s s1tai11clpoiililft O Ho~, tlhte :r:~sp@~siE? ~~ 3 SALOMON RE::PORTZNG *Si:i:R.\'lC'E: (NC *
~~. ~00 EQ~ITADL'! e!UJLDIUG il!AL ~U~Of;f:, .!'.~Al't",l.,"\;lO ;?. q~~~~
I I
Ii II I JI I* 1' ( _______________,__}_h-_-~_a_?_I.._.:1-_s:_k_s____~~------*----1_9_**_.s_ _!l ~ II t:".\ fJ.
~~'3 r I~~
~~1 l~~
~~~ I is the ~P.;~L'!t .,. of ~'hetcl'H::?: this is a X'eBeon.abl~ .m: rm:teaaem= ~:;,,~~
~~4 f.(. . G~~
~~\.'~~
~~.r.,.~~
~~~~.\ /~" *:\ t}, *~ /~~
SA!..oi:10N-RS:PORTINC :rn:RVICE INC *
~~. .c *:oo l:;:QUJTJ;OL:: ISUII.DlllG ... *-::l*;.!,TIM<JGC, MA.'Wl..'U:it*2 l~;)?.,c*.,,,, ,:JJ!l-<H~O~~
~~.1961 I~~
i ... --

':.:*.:.Ji**
~~JI,~~
~~?-:'~: Q . 3,U.OMON f!(;:POR'.i!NG -!lt::-ll v1c-i:;: .INC. .. . . ..~~
~~1.00. l!QUJT.:.:1;1.*~.-:ou1LOIIIG OAl.,IMORI:. f,IM:i!..'Jl:J ?. l:?.0~~~
~~l. I 191 I ,~--------"---------------------~~.:_________ 3A.L.0MON Rr.PORTl~IG SERVICE ltlC,~~
~~. 100 .*Eoui-.*A,,t:!; SUILOINO i3AI.TIMOP.t',. MA.J'1YL.t~Hn *2 tZO~* ** 531.l-G7i;O~~
l il, I 1 1 1 i:-f.~. P,a.:d;;:s 198 I! 1;_--~H------------*----- - -- -~-----------!...-- t I I l '
~~'.t:~~
~~i 'j~~
~'
~~1 J~~
~~,I .]~~
~~C~'°"'i<"{o)'"'~~
~~-Cl-e,te: s, ~IUil- :1..1m ~.g~@-%:1 0~~
~~tt;,:t t11ie~~
** ~ 1:&ct 'i:trna~ - 1h ~st o.t- ~ *"
~~ttlli3 ,-,11~ O~Kt.e:;:~~
"<lx!t '""~" ' I!: "'""' n l' \'i'& 1!:il1'ilf\ihause. '""" k - - ! ""'""' ' we sl!: Mil:!04" Wa3 no~ ~@l~~<l to~ ~filz~e eA~~~~ i~ this @th~ ~me <:oln\T R~ * * * * ****** ,. <:RT~AS . 3A!..Q:.-:O?~ RC,:?ORTING ZiERVIC!;; fNC. * *
~~100 EOUiTJ\Eli:E: V'UILOIIIG~~
.. ::...- .:*~:E!J\J.,,l!~ORt:9***M,'\RYLAJlD-*.z120~ ,-l I
~~i I~~
'i
t----':----------------------~--~---*
~
~~l' II~~
~~~ lj ~ ~ ~~~
I
~~~ ~ -~ ,I !I I~~
~~e:":'~~
~~,:I~~
~~{ £:,,.,,, , ,i*:.~~
~~-.:J I~~
~~l SAl,.OMON Ru.-'P.;. . O::..H. .::*~:.. IN:::..-~~:.. .~:.. :*~. :.R~*v::;.c. ::~::..--H~-c-.-.-_:_~~.::...._;_~-~_;:---,--,,.... .... .~~
. . !00 EQUIU,BL~ DUILOIIJG .:.**~ -*. * ,. !I.J0-*"1~ . rJ/\1..TIMO~S:., M..\R7L;\llD z1=0i!_
~~' ii ll u ,, q) I QiJ 1.I Q z... CS* t*8 3ALOMOl,l RS:PORTINs; SERVlca INC.~~
~~.. 100.'i;:QLJJ**rAnL:;:.OUILOlllG .. .sr..1.:;-;r~cnp:. M,?..tq\"L.AZ~c 2 l2C.l~~
~~q l, p I I --------~----2-(0_1_-11'---~~
~~-t:_,_~_~_-z_i_rn_.--*............~~
~~,_ _ _'"'_/I__~~
~~I i 1 I i m Q 8 4, g j1~~
~~'JI~~
~~p w~~
~~' :;;)~~
~~j(';'.*~ HJ~~
** .. ZAI..OMON P.E?ORTIN'G*!lE:RVICZ: INC * . 100 EQurr.1.or....Z- nu1lo1N*r.;;._
BA~i"IMO;u:~ MA!'i"'ll~~,o 2.120.?,_
cl@'im ~ kill©""<I] 3 Q Yo@
~~.... t~lhet\h.e~ J?~@lic Service delmyed cio del~y tfu.e me~t~~)Bo Q Way &id itt tt~ke i&"©ill R<I~~dh r.,~~
~~Ql) ~e~;i tlhe I~~
*I I
~~I ~.1a~~
.t9 SAL.o'~;loi'-Ff!E:PORTING Zl!:RV(Cg INC:, . 100 EQUITADt..C :3UILOIIIG -.: 'S~LTl~lOR!!: 9. ~tAJ?"tLt.r:D 21202 .*.;;/. ......
~~1":t-~~.~~
~~.I I~~
I
~~! 203 u~~
~~II 1 2 lHE WXTh'fESS ~ lfile~ J'ea;-sey o~~
~~3 CO}fMJISSXO;J,\:lER SC"dJIFffl~ P.illild 1PSE&G alB@ ~"'g11S. the 4~~
~~o*e e~~
'a .-AI-OMON R;F.i'OFITlNG SE:=lV.ICE IN~, . :...,to;;,. e:::iu1.TADL1: *auiLi:i111G * * ** . Fli!,L;i:ll',!Ci1_l!:. MA~Yl,.~ND 21Z02
~~II a II I Co~~2sic~ do ~b©@~ fuel coats associated with t@e S~lsn~~
~
~~I..~~
**'" **a*ALOMOM Rl::POflTING*SER,VICE -INc.* -*. ,.. ,. di!O EQUIT.tOLli: 13UILOl>:G
_ . 6.\1.:,moRI!:_,_ M,:-~YL_At.tl ~-1_20?. I I
II
~~,I i~~
~~I, II I*' I 4 .. ,~~
*~
~~I l I I~ !~~
~~-.;J 7l I I~~
I
~~,n~~~
~~t .. ..~.J . . I !~: ..,~ i.;:: : I~~
*., 13 I .
Q
;,;,L.OMON l"EPORTING SEP.VICEf INC. -~Q.(l .!£',JUl:r/,.JLl!:**::u1L!>nlG * ~A.I. T JM9_ilE:111. MAA~LAI.f~ .2..~2G4 t *-*- ---:*-*. :-~~ :::..*,,;_,_,.,, ,:
~~i-i cfi.z-c~~tc21rn:ie@3 c~mi ~ifil:e1: f!i:@ril 'IJ1.tillitjj' 8:@ @tt:i1ity l) @~t o~ly c~c~ws~ of~~~ pl~@i ~@Bi~~~~ b~~~~~~ of ~~e ~i;:nin~ of~~
~~. the b@l1~tiM.~~
l
- _C:oll>I, lt,:;.o~T *-----:--:---:-:---:::-"-~-.--.~,...-:-*,-11-* ---*- *lJAl.OMO!-l fl!:!PORTING.3ERVICE 1:-{c:. ;on f!°QUJ:YA~LI?;. SUJLOIUG - . . . . *~. " ~rt~ GA!.?IMOn:r: 11 M/ulYLAt~JD 21202 J
ij
)!
~~II ii~~
~~!I ~~~
~~11 l a ~3 4~~
~
~~s ii 9~~
- --------'---,-----~~--~~------.- - , Ct~ l'ltl'O!! ....*. Tita:i - !lAl.:OMON Rg?OR71NG !.-Et1VICE lN<C:* .-, .. t IZOUfTAOL'i?: .8UIL!>l7':G '*=* .. E.*A! .. ';ltAOn~1 -~M;Ji.Y1.YL.1.J'JD i! 1202.~. * \
I'
~~,I n~~
~~H ll I.11'I II lt II I' ~ jl q~~
.I
~~' $"g ii 11 i s I~~
~:
~~4 s~~
~
~~ii 11 11~~
~
~~19! II~~
*-~ !
~~11 I~~
~~.I ' ,........... , *: ..... .;,,\L.OMON Rr;;POR"ilNG S!!:RVICt" lt!G.~~
~~iOO EOt.H"rAOL'E: 81J1LOll~G~~
~~.0:-. -~-;---'---".'*::.- [:lA.t;TlMOAZ*a M.r..aVLAUO *?.120a~~
~~---~-~ ~---~~
~~1 __.,..........~~---------------:L-= I I~~
. :\ \ ,1
~~7. Q A 'Erra~t is p©~Sibleo 'fih~t i~ row: cc~cl@~i@~~ ~o~~~
*"'~""~e!) ~it tllidLa p@ilsmit c .SAL.Or,::;a:t fi.;:PORi'.ING 9ERVIC:l: JN<;. . 1-* '1'00 EC.iJ~.T,\t:LC BUJl~OlllG OAL.'.ifu,:.on~. _!.!__,\l~YL.\!lq. __ 212~::? i
~~11 il l~~
~
~~it hS'!.'l:l"<e teem fi:%etl e<fil'.[" li'2~-. t.1EM:i t@e Wi1it ~e put , ~mck imi~~
\, ~s ~1 _th~ v~©ao&, Westi@~o~e !@ this e~s~~ @~rl si~~e aopll>.is\l:ic"r.i= """'"' t!I.<> l"'""""3, &!ltd it b ,;e,cy l'""aib1e tlmIDt tfule:p- c(Q)@ld 1h8'aw2 -iJV'.?.;~fill 11.:llil.~E"G; ea&"l:lie~;- <fl@li1 RM'))~ ~!~ir.!oV{i:Z'eclj1 ~----~ . I S39-\'.o7."'1 !
~~li I~~

tt---------------------*,-----*

~~211 Q~~
*.-;,, 14 ,'t ,**** ..... : .. \ * - - - - - _____ .!~- *!lA~Orv~OI:l r'(S:PORTIN~ ~11!'.fl\/JC!~ ?:-ic .... ... I* .:.:-iii, :7oCJ;~ ;1?t~,E.~.;-~~~'i ~~;: *- *,:*,-1*,*' ! J'
?_J ~1~ o P\1l]C~~ .... !.:21 1l ,. The ~id sta~ap21 ~©ld toiethell:' the assembly o the
( 2 :&ll~l~~ods ~~emae1v~s 9 is tha~ cor.t"g~t? 1**
~~'f '.,~~
~~$ A Th~t is K"i~t: o t\h.e ~id stx[t.lps are t:he pO:-{'i:ioo 4 of tfme str@ct9.3E'~ th.mt ~e~wnlly plhysiceilly restzefu the~~
~~rodsp t~~~ is C@'Z'~ect. ;~i-Q -*~~~
*.l.!.!i1l'2 f@el x~da a~e ~~e sc~n.cce of the e~exgy th~t ~kes ~\he e1~ct~icit}7?
A Tthlat is &"i~'2lt o Q A@d tRice e@mit~ol 'lr<<>>~ ,g-©dlets a~..e the tlhi~.gs (;;&wt_ . c-i::ir©.@ect tfut~ c@@~X""CQ.)1 :c'@&~ t,g ae-v:.d,eres tb.£t p@ll th(!Wl i@ ~irud o@t ~-lhich c@@~r©l ~~e @~cle~~c!h.ai~ ~e~ctio~ 0 is t@at
*CO'fi'~~~'i IA li';'ii'b.Ci'l'?
~~Alli:..~ ',b Ji""~~
&,:~ """' 0,,ns,,.,_ .e:.. t.=.,.~;i:!.o.~ o =-
~~JU~ezr~ ~ 1L~ ~ I\~~
~op s1n.de~~ - ~ ~ssei..il@~y ',I, ff &:~s~ i<gi~fa::3 twrJ (Q;f 1:1tit~ ~ sttJ'.!,;'t)'.!tE'St ~t:fUTud ©~C thituSv a1rud !If: ~~s ~ll<O ((>>'.if fi:llil:r.:0~ ii,~~ili}':§.G@illl xod1c~ts Ofill e~c~ O:?aeo i"lho~e I . 'lodl('et~ tihemi ii@ll:t f~;t~ .©@ tlhle e©:oit~.::1 ~od g©ide
~~ti;d::i~s~~
~~~"'hi~~ ~E~ ~1~© ~ p~~~ @ft~~ a~~@ctU%e~~~
Q J~m:id Z:lh.ose 1rool<PJta ~K"e v:,;.,Mt lli!-:iJJd b~ok-efft? A '.rhey l-727:e @~@ke@ 2!.l9ld s ~ of the)!! .acit~ally
.ltl.Ths id~ u;:lh~ ~uide t~bes" Tb.er we'lL"<e sanbseqt1{;t'i:\'i: ly O\at; o ! ----.-,--------,,--.---~--'---~~---l- I 5AI.OMON l'IE:?0/'!TING S:C:Rv"ic*e INC. * * **
~~100 Enu1r,,01.t: euu.ourn DAL-;"IMOAC, :.iAst'tt.>.:lC>_ 21.20~. :-j~~-0.7dtl I~~
~~i' I I 11~~
~~..L~~
~~~ ~ ~ 4 6 "i thta top wl'ru@'R'~ 3}'@111\ ~111lk @b@@e: tlh~ tlhillli@e1r ~ir:ild Btir~pa on~~
~~l7 by 11 f~els, ~iru<l I( aun -s1c@de~i@~ ~1'M,1t ~he ~~i~ znt:naa's~~
~~-~~---~~~--~-~~~~~------~--~~~----~----1 SAi.. 01.!0rl'.llEPORTl.!-lG SER'l:c:-:. triC.~~
~~I J~~
~~~co i5:ou11AilL~ auu.:1111:. - .E.JJ~l*H401lt:, ?,fA;t\Y.L/...::O :.120*~~~
II*' l lir v Z oa:tl~ s 21~ l l Ir A Thimi~~r tl~@ ~~e o~si~s ©~ t~e 15 ~115 fuela i JP'w.R. ... fuel i2e~t tlhir©~~lh. a desi~ evol~tito'[J1 at abo@~ t!lie 2 l I
$ ~i~ t@.§Ilt the S©Il~ @i!lit bee~ruz comm-1...ta~Ci.ffil, ~©o l v.mit . ,. 4 lM!c~m,g c~~~ci.ml ii tE?.@d it:~i~ decli.siomi ~~ss mfilde go s iiffic©&'p~T.mfi;~ == well i, it ,g~s @©\t. eveim ~e.c1JU.Ly ~ f~e~ '*' 6 :deci!d,@G':1 9 i'a: w*.as ~ p,!1::i:tifill g-er;p,!!.!'!1."~@t @f the .m!C t@ i!..mp~@tre
1 emeir~e@~J Sfilf~~~d c3jrBteJJ! pe:tf©Xfil1'1illiC~ to ~C©X'JPOii'."cE'lte this e @W des '1~ f ~el :i m@ it w&1s G@i~"il.-:::li.' :@-Zit@ tlh.e eaz liex
~~.,:i .,,,r;:,.,; rr,""~~
Ui::;;c.,e~~Sc Q ~©@ 3~id X t~ii.ruk Ft-ra. f~elo Wllil~t is t@~t7 A I?z~ssi11~ izeil W21\b(e'l' :r,eIBe toz o Q Wh,mt otlhe1!:' ki-gacla a:11re theze? A E@iled Wffi~e&3 ~~~ f~Reo &e~~tc~~ == Q Y@i.1! ~ ls@ ims~ir.J a:t1~t eillz lier: ~1.-ie© ,~~ w~:ire
~~<lisc~ssi~~ ~it~ U&@o Sc~ifte~ ~A Mzo Al~~~derp ~~d X j~st!~~
~~i*u:,'l;l.<l~;;:-~:d 1vb.;;J.f(: it :::Is2t1.li'Tht o~~
,~ :-Ct !~ ~ ~eIIBelfi<<:.: desi;~.eati@rm f@g- t!limt t;ype ** ~li:!'2lC\t-QJ~ o Q K w~mld like~~ t~lk ~ little ~it ~~~@t t~e -~C b~llet:!@~ 0 a Ok$Ja .*~*;ALOMo'ri*RE*PORTINc;:; :;s:RVICE: INC *
~~t.~ficPo:n-cR:i .. 100 riou11.t.bt.E.: CUILOIJJti .~~
~~.O,.\~-r_,_:..;c ru:.e M.\n'/t.:.._n9.;i.1202. G2£...'l7f.0~~
~~II 215 II-----------------------~.":>:,O:'<'h'~~ II tl~~
~
~~OU., 4~~
~~~ © ii a~~
9 JL~c~t~L~@3 <:;-pfuiit,~)h ~nt."!i! ~@1t .§CC,BS3!~1~ <<x~~iE ::TilO?l.lE?dll @p@E.aJ.il;i@ar. ., fu:m~id~ tlhl~ C©Hilt~ilillill4:!fill1t r> 'CJ@~ !t!Ol if-~d:!md.orru le~.ve ls o 1 Q .. I
~~~ "G-.:1:.,p,r,, ':'-1;1 t> ............ - .::J,U.-OMON RE:POr?TlNG SERVI<:!'; INC,~~
~~_ .1.00 *5:1J'JlTAOL4 *6UILDIN'G 0,6!.1:_S~~r..:1.:: 11 .~.,AR'Y.LAJJO 2 !.20.Z *,~~
j.
~~Ii ll l ii.~~
*-n-1 I --------~~ ----*-21~6-+-
I
-'-t *~*
I
*t,;
~~' .*~-=~~ :* i\~~
~~. ,~-~~
~~I l I I~~
~c~ld ~@~ ~11@'~ s~l~m 1 ~© st~xi ~ ~~ffii~ ~~~il all ~~e 0 " rk ©inl ttllil.ese ifol!S?. Tuimll@tirm£i %'filS d,n,-iffie ~© :!Lits s~~isf&cll'-:i~?
5AL.OMOH-Ra:'POilTlNG !j;!RVICl::::'"INC *
~~. 1oc~.::nu1:rAUL~. ~IJJLOUJG *.. Bl-i..'..Tl:.1.:,n!:9 :.'!A,..'?'/LA!ID ~ s2:o~~~
~~f'!I,, l! II ---------------* 211~~
~~!I II Cl a~~
~~} 11 ~.~~
~~;a .~~~
~~I I~~
~~'l I~~
l
~~.:;J..LOMON Ri!:POl'\T.IN.G ~fi~ICtI.. ltilC.~~
~~100 [tQ':JITA&t..\'.: OUILOIUi:l~~
'"DAJ..TU.,,Oi'1C, !-i.,A'.,*tL~D ;11:02*-*
~~11 (; JI ~---H-i---------- j1 tti:' ~ I??.:i'.t:'ks~~
~~--------i---~~
~~116~~
~~! @~h@z pR@@tao ~i~t t~ ~~~ t@e pi~@t?~~
~~A 'f\1..~~
*.:..c:~.-.a,:.'::*.::'=*itll:E!1: ..,1 ~ Q ,;i "b I), .'1..il{CJ[.,{'.j_(:;![ii,.,/biJ1i.filr,. jJ '"'~,-,_o'=~\fn,.fil&e \\,,. W If:""-' __ .ffipp&"c-~c_ll1_'!.f'JU!d he .:::tALOMON REPORTING Sla:RYICti: l>JC.
~~TOO Ci:QU[TJ\Ot..~ nun.on.:~~~
~~!J.~.1...*r.JMO":,:;* t:,1Af'1'/LAr~l..l 2 J20:?~~
~~j I~~
~
t*~ I l ~ tf. ii I 1i'*1 acceptable I) 8.nd :i:h-:at ~,1as the basis upon which they pro=
~~~ ..3 Q When did Salem l start producing full power? ~ A Full powex: I believe wa..a January 20.~~
~~6 I~~
~~.Q Assum.ing that we hadn 8 t had the green linte ~ I/1 =w I 41 have zequired Salem 1 to be pulled out of se!'.'vlce to ~~~
I
~~9 I~~
~~I outage., ~,rhich I thix":k. lei 110*%' scheduled iox: I believe II th..: fall of th.is year o I, i t2 ts~~
~~- ~LJ .,~ I I~~
~~I Q I at~~
!J i ,3At.OM9N.HEPO~TH~G SERVIC!o:'111<;:. * ,100. :::.:0 1JJTAD1.Z .au1Lo1~u; * . . : ... ~Af.t1~.1onc, MAn"/!.AUO *~: 12Qf!
I: l
11 11 I IL --~-~~~--~--*-*~-~i-11 220 I I I Q Tb.at is every year? ~ II ~ I A It is intended to be on that cycle 0 that ia x-ight.
Q W-:'nen Public Ser*.1ice ~~ Public Se:-:vice is the com~an.y that operates this== when they were complying A No)) they did noto Q Do you know of any other ~= A We did not)) an.d I believe == ;;ell~ I shouldn;i: Q Wellv I have. it rlght here. A Oka.yo Q It is s om-9th~ rig I thought we might look at
JALOMON -m~POi!-'rlNG *SERVI CF. !t1c *
~~. *' *100*':ZQ<.!ITA!JLC GUILOJII<; .. ,._ .. ,. £lALT-a.to:u:. *MAA:tt..:i.?l!> -2 J20~~~
,Ii' p I 11 II. /( -------------------=-, Mr, Parka 211 L -
l
*a and maybe get 2
~~j into e?idsence since you do refer to it~ f illiat I am handing you now I would like to~~
~
~~I I~ this the article~~
~~.~ you are referring to?~~
~~COr~tMISSIO~-:ER SCHIF'l'ER: To_ be consistent., we~~
~
~~I 1,~~
"j*
t%
~~,;I~~
~~. 12 That is the Staff 0 ~ first this ;the~~
~~t.:.1.at ;>1ou_~~
I ~oulcl note ior the s:acord i:n Lo Case
1' II I I: II I i I ii 221 / J I
~~'ii I'~~
~~i 19800~~
~* ""' I (Az:ticle in the Sun we..a marked Staff Ex,.~ibit 4 Q I5 this the complete S.]:."ticle that you read? ~ A I be li~ve so o ~ NRc VORHIS; il it is complete i) l"1r" D.m.lel, but I noti.ce
~~at least the* lay=~~
~~e* 8 I,~~
~~/' It might be. I did it a little I~~
I I wanted to get all I the head liue.3 in the Jee o COHNISSIONER SCHIF'TER: f:?l:~*:1~' i than to quewtion Mr. Parksg concluaiona. the cu~rent ti!ne I
i* H
,i
~~~ ~* " 11 llIt~~
~~- ,I,Ii r ----------------~~,----~ 223 i!~~
ii
~~. ~ ~~~
r 11 with :reS1pect 'i.:o th.re availability of nuclear: engineers ll l 1,\,D..-, ii ' *
~~~ l ana* tne l..~.h.t, s proo1..ema I ~~~
9
~~~- ~ it' is cared to be given 9 11 ~~~
~~I and .in that respect I would like to offer it into I,~~
~~
~~11 II d I I~~
~~~ I, MR o AIE.¥...ANDER: I obJecta II ~ ',*!!' ti I~~
I I I I, I I I 1* I I I Ia i.t admitted? It l@ a couple of QUGBtiODSa
*-- *!i).!...OMON :.J.EPORTING SEP.v*act":: !~.fc.- .--. '.CC .EQUliKt..t...Z 0UILOIUG .. ** -0,'U.Ti:*~()-;q;:.; r,1~~-r_LA!!o** .. 21~9.~
Ii
~~,l II II 11 * ""'!l I'ii offered ~ny assista:m::e ~ technical aseiatanc.a to Public ii£ r Sezvice in expediting the Salem worko eZ3 assistance'!~~
A but are just not sitting around doing ~cithi.1:g == they all haue othe:r jobs: a'rid o.tb.er to lend out to anybody c Q thi'l t Pub 1 ;Lt.; Service could have at
. n*,\LOt. . (QN r-:ti.POF( TJN*c:- 5ER'VJcc:**u-ic~ . tO(.} E:.Ol.Jl"'i.~t?.L'E: .eu1LOIHG .Or..L"i"lf'407!:C 1 , M,;n"J'L,'U:o ~ 120?,. . .. -
~~H I' l,11~~
~~'I 225 11 lI i~~
I would like to request copies of the NRC bulletins a f referred to in your testunony 9 ~~1ong with any upd~te 8* ~. to those bulletlna 9 and sny o:c*d,ex:'$ or directives of the NP..C th.at were issued a~ -2', 1:esult of thoaa bulletins ~ 6 per taming to Salem No o lo 7l MR. W'lBB: s J-J
-eo_____-.. -.- - - - - - - . - .-11-Al-.O-i,I_O_:,-!-RE_P_O_n_:i~:~'-**~-s-s_n,'-v-,c-.e:---,tl_C_;~-----'--"'...;,,....-------,--*
~~llltf ~ltPonn,m.~~
~~100 !::Q'JIT.-.oL,;: !,1TJJLOIIIO~~
~~. ~}~.:;.U,lC:t4,. :O.~A.~"tl.A:10 Z tz.O~ c::H)..G7eo I~~
l
I --------------=-~---------- 225 11 Just one copyo 1
~
~~I II ~?..'il specifically intereeted 9 though~ in seelng what.~~
~
~~orders or cor~espondence we~e issued by* the NRC staff 4 to Salem itself not just the .gen~ric bulletLns that~~
~
~~6 . 11 Siid cloae the plant or £:1ything at all like that* du~ing 8 11 2 The plant was sb.u.t down at'*: the:* SCHIE*n:R: Iz the~e were dlz--actlv~s I~~
~~.spec.ifically directed to SaLam I If th.ere~~
~~/t II / ; / .r~~
~~_J -- --- f~~
~~----- ------ ~T . 221 / .~~
~~bulletins****--,-whicn ~r~ mentioned in the testimony but which did nOt have anywhere near as substantial effect on the duz-.stion of the outage'? I~~
~~. MR.a ALEXANDER: I think just the four o~~
_H
* *.L' *,.,~ ....
13
. 't-0 r',. I I 'tl3 I * / .**:le ... , ***~
~~ri I ta j l I~~
*,;,~Jaq
~~/~:f(f. * . :'I-.~~
~~;__:> "*,1,,-'i .*. I .;;:'.'d** *--........_,___ ____________ ____ ------------ I I~~
~~_,, ;c, t;t~\:P". --l'J. . c,~, "'"""" i.~~
~~"ACoM"'*'.'C'"o"""" """'" .,c. ,.,/a -~~::;W;~f,".:c~;g"~~
~~_/ l I}}~~

ML18082A325: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 18:36, 17 March 2020

Text

Dear.Mr. Russell:

Dear Mr. Hawkins:

Navigation menu

ML18082A325: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 18:36, 17 March 2020

Text

Dear.Mr. Russell:

Dear Mr. Hawkins:

Navigation menu

Search