ML18031A343: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 17: Line 17:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:ATTACEKNTPage1of6TERMINATION MODULEFINALRESOLUTION Conductor Insulation DamageofT-HODSLocatedInTermination Cabinets.
{{#Wiki_filter:ATTACEKNT Page 1 of 6 TERMINATION MODULE FINAL RESOLUTION Conductor   Insulation Damage of T-HODS  Located In Termination Cabinets.
ThePowerGeneration ControlComplex(PGCC)isdeveloped andsuppliedbyGeneralElectricundertheH-1NSSScontract.
The Power Generation Control Complex (PGCC)     is developed and supplied by General  Electric under the H-1 NSSS contract. The PGCC uses termination cabinets to interface between field cables. Most cables interface on a termination module (T-HOD) which consists of an AN connector for the cable from the PGCC floor section and a terminal board for. the incoming field  cable (see attached Figs. 3-4, 3-5, and 3-6). NCR 3030 was issued on September  28, 1978 to identify damaged conductor insulation within the T-MOD connecting an AN connector and the terminal board. The damages were first observed during an implementation of rework of termination cabinet ITC-621 at the SSES site. Of the -total 450 T-MOD units for SSES Unit 1, 127 units were found to exhibit one or more of the following defects:
ThePGCCusestermination cabinetstointerface betweenfieldcables.Mostcablesinterface onatermination module(T-HOD)whichconsistsofanANconnector forthecablefromthePGCCfloorsectionandaterminalboardfor.theincomingfieldcable(seeattachedFigs.3-4,3-5,and3-6).NCR3030wasissuedonSeptember 28,1978toidentifydamagedconductor insulation withintheT-MODconnecting anANconnector andtheterminalboard.Thedamageswerefirstobservedduringanimplementation ofreworkoftermination cabinetITC-621attheSSESsite.Ofthe-total450T-MODunitsforSSESUnit1,127unitswerefoundtoexhibitoneormoreofthefollowing defects:1)Severeindentations ontheinsulation (noexposedwire).2)Abrasion(scuffing) oftheinsulation (noexposedwire).3)'Nicksanddings'ntheinsulation; i.e.,minor1/32"to1/8"long)lateralandlongitudinal cuts(exposedwire).4)Severelongitudinal gouging.Hirewasexposed(1/8"to1/2"long)andthegougedinsulation indicated sharpedgecuttinginbothdirections.
: 1)   Severe indentations on the  insulation  (no exposed wire).
GeneralElectric's QAverification procedure forthemanufacturing processwasinsufficient todetectthedamageinsulation.
: 2)   Abrasion (scuffing) of the insulation (no exposed wire).
CauseItwasdetermined byGEthat95%ofthedamagedunitswereHi-Density Termination Modules(21and48pinassemblies whichusetwistedshieldedpairandtriplecables-20awgwirewithferruleterminations ontheshields).
: 3)   'Nicks and dings'n the insulation; i.e., minor 1/32" to 1/8" long) lateral and longitudinal cuts (exposed wire).
Duringthereassembly (i.e.,pininsertion andextraction usingthestandardAmphenoltoolingofthetermination modules)continual difficulty wasobserved.
: 4)   Severe  longitudinal gouging. Hire was exposed (1/8" to 1/2" long) and the gouged insulation indicated sharp edge cutting in both directions.
Theferruleedgeduringextraction, andthesharpinsertion tooledgeduringassembly, impactedonthedenselypackedwiresattheconnector area.Furtherdamage(3abrasions outof900con-ductors)wasobservedduringthereassembly operation.
General Electric's QA verification procedure for the manufacturing process was insufficient to detect the damage insulation.
Theassembled unitswerethenre-inspected andthethxeeaddeddefectswerenoted.
Cause It was determined by GE that 95% of the damaged units were Hi-Density Termination Modules (21 and 48 pin assemblies which use twisted shielded pair and triple cables  20 awg wire with ferrule terminations on the shields). During the reassembly (i.e., pin insertion and extraction using the standard Amphenol tooling of the termination modules) continual difficulty was observed. The ferrule edge during extraction, and the sharp insertion tool edge during assembly, impacted on the densely packed wires at the connector area. Further damage (3 abrasions out of 900 con-ductors) was observed during the reassembly operation. The assembled units were then re-inspected and the thxee added defects were noted.
ATTACEBKHT Page2of6ItwascausedItwasofonemoduledamageother.alsonotedthatthesharpedgesofthetermination moduleframesindentations onthewire.insulation ofimproperly stackedunits.seenthatthiswascausedbythesharpedgeofthesteelframemodulelaidagainsttheunprotected wirebundlesofanadjacentHandlingprecautions arerequiredtopreventthistypeofsinceitcanpotentially occuranytimetwomodulescontacteachInsummary,thepossiblecauseofinsulation damagecanbeattributed to:1)2)3)ImproperAssembly-PinInsertion/Extraction HandlingandStorageProducibility
 
-Hi-Density modules-Conductor freelength-FerruleconceptAnalsisoftheSafetImlications Thesystemdesignwasreviewedandthefollowing wasconcluded fortheworstcondition.
ATTACEBKHT Page 2 of 6 It was    also noted that the sharp edges of the termination module frames caused    indentations on the wire. insulation of improperly stacked units.
Theinsulation damageoftheT-MODsvariesfrombarelyvisibletotheunaidedeyeto1/2"exposedbarewire.Althoughnoinsulation breakdown wasobservedduringthehi-pottesting(standard 2.2KVDC)ofindividual conductors toconnector shellandotherpinsofthesameconnector, thefrequency ofoccurrence issuchthatifthedefectswereleftundetected/uncorrected, shortingofconductors mustbeassumedpossible.
It was    seen that this was caused by the sharp edge of the steel frame of one module laid against the unprotected wire bundles of an adjacent module      Handling precautions are required to prevent this type of damage other.
SomeoftheaffectedsystemsareRHR,RCIC,andCorespray.LossofT-MODconductors maypreventthecircuitsfromperforming theirdesignedsafetyrelatedfunctions.
since  it can potentially occur any time two modules contact each In  summary,   the possible cause of insulation    damage  can be  attributed to:
Suchaneventuality presentsanunacceptable condition eventhroughtheremayberedundant subsystems remaining unaffected.
: 1)     Improper Assembly  Pin Insertion/Extraction
InadditionGeneralElectric's QAprogramhadfailedtodetectanydefectsduringthemanufacturing process.ProjectEngineering hasdetermined thePGCCT-MODsdeficiency tobereportable under10CFR50.55(e).
: 2)     Handling and Storage
Corrective ActionSAllUnit1defective unitshavebeenreturnedtoGESanJoseforrework.Toprecludere-occurrence onthereworkofUnit1T-NODS,thefollowing actionshavebeentakenbyGE:l.ImproperAssemblyThemethods,planningprocess,andoperatortraininghavebeenupgradedsincetheSusquehanna IT-MODSwerebuiltinthefirstquarterof1976.This,withtheproducibility changes,willminimizedifficulties observedduringthereassembly operations forT-Mods.GeneralElectric's qualityprogramappliedtotheUnitItermination moduleswasdefective inonemajorarea.Thein-process inspection systemdidnotincludethephysicalinspection ofthepininsertion process.(Theassumption thatcontinuity andinsulation testingwoulddetectallfunctionally significant insulation damagehasnotbeenconfirmed).
: 3)     Producibility    Hi-Density modules Conductor free length Ferrule concept Anal sis of the Safet        Im lications The system design was reviewed and the following was concluded for the worst condition. The insulation damage of the T-MODs varies from barely visible to the unaided eye to 1/2" exposed bare wire. Although no insulation breakdown was observed during the hi-pot testing (standard 2.2              KVDC) of individual conductors to connector shell and other pins of the same connector, the frequency of occurrence is such that          if the defects were left undetected/uncorrected, shorting of conductors must be assumed possible. Some of the affected systems are RHR, RCIC, and Core spray.
Addedin-process inspection pointsandareviseddetailed.inspection
Loss of T-MOD conductors may prevent the circuits from performing their designed safety related functions. Such an eventuality presents an unacceptable condition even through there may be redundant subsystems remaining unaffected. In addition General Electric's QA program had failed to detect any defects during the manufacturing process.
.-planhavebeenaddedtotheassemblyoperation oftheT-Mods.
Project Engineering has determined the        PGCC T-MODs  deficiency to    be reportable under 10CFR 50.55(e).
ATTACE4EIQ'Page 30I62.HandlingandStorageOperatortraininginthehandlingofT-Modswithproperphysicalseparation and,stackingwillreduceobservedproblemsinthisarea.Inaddition, theT-Mods,whencomplete, willbestyrofoam wrappedandtapedtoprecludestorageandshippingdamage.(Thispracticewasimplemented inearly1977.)3~Producibility OntheUnitIreworkoftheT-Nods,severalproducibility changeswhichhavebeenimplemented onsubsequent projectswillbeapplied:a.Tensolite wirewhichislesssusceptible, toabrasionand'dinging'ill beappliedtoreworkedT-Mods.b.Analternate methodofshielding whichdoesnotrequiretheferruleconceptwillbeappliedtoreworkedT-mods.c.Longerfreeconductor lengthforeaseofassemblywillbeappliedtoreworkedT-Nods.Conclusion Therepair/rework andre-testoftheT-NODSforSSESUnit1hasbeenaccomplished perGEprocedures andcriteria.
Corrective Action S
Thedeficiency hasnowbeencorrected andthepotential safetyhazardhasbeeneliminated.
All Unit    1  defective units have    been returned  to GE San Jose for rework.
TheSSESUnit1reworkedT-Nodsh'avebeenshippedandinstalled atthejobsite.AportionoftheUnit2T-Nodsweremanufactured inthesametimeperiodastheUnit1T-Mods.Inspection willbeperformed atSSESperaGEdocumentFDIMDBC.Defective unitswillbereturnedtoGEforrepairbeforefuelload.GEfabrication personnel training,.
To preclude re-occurrence on the rework of Unit 1 T-NODS, the following actions have been taken by GE:
inspection andrevisedfabrication techniques hasprecluded reoccurrence ofsimilarproblemsontheremaining Unit2T-Nods.Theinspections tobeconducted inaccordance withFDIMDBCincludea100$visualinspection ofterminalstripsforcracked.,
: l. Improper Assembly The methods,   planning process, and operator training have been upgraded  since  the Susquehanna I T-MODS were built in the first quarter of 1976. This, with the producibility changes, will minimize difficulties observed during the reassembly operations for T-Mods.
brokenormissingbarriersandconductor insulation fornicks,abrasionandcuts.Theexistence ofanyoftheseconditions iscauseforrefection.
General Electric's quality program applied to the Unit I termination modules was defective in one major area.         The in-process inspection system  did  not include  the  physical  inspection  of the pin insertion process.     (The assumption  that  continuity  and insulation    testing would  detect  all functionally    significant insulation   damage  has not been confirmed).
SK:po2873 QAYAREDO50455OASISbAXPdtGAY0L%th'3.08420ATTACKZNTPage4of6l,r)~taTKNWOVLKGAYCtarviaDAf5nERBAYDtIihR~i'>~lJOARRCRCONIECTOR
Added in-process inspection points and a revised detailed .inspection
~TE$TATlONARY QAttltlERS FUXRFlATKt4PPCltTFCSTAgee04,Assembled Tarnation Co%~(Doomremovodlotch~-~~reels~iai~p~'pie~eI~~O~iii'".S~~a'~iver~.a:'S''r  
  . -plan have been added to the assembly operation of the T-Mods.
'sA"208420ATTACHMEHT Page5ofI~~~~y~y~~CCNNECTO'asmuoM~~817 HED0.10468'TTAC Hi~ITPage6of6v~~vIrv'(IPrvfILLSCASLC0000~~o~i'000~~~~~~1~~~o'~~~~~~~~~~V~~~~~~~~~~0lPt>.~~~I~~~~~~~4VNCTlOMSOX
 
'I}}
0I ATTACE4EIQ'Page 3    6
: 2. Handling and Storage Operator training  in the handling of    T-Mods  with proper physical separation and, stacking  will reduce  observed problems in this area.
In addition, the T-Mods, when complete, will be styrofoam wrapped and taped to preclude storage and shipping damage.         (This practice was implemented in early 1977.)
3~   Producibility On the Unit I rework of the T-Nods, several producibility changes which have been implemented on subsequent projects will be applied:
: a. Tensolite wire which is less susceptible, to abrasion        and
            'dinging'ill be applied to reworked T-Mods.
: b. An alternate  method of shielding which    does not require the ferrule  concept will be  applied to reworked T-mods.
: c. Longer free conductor length    for  ease  of assembly  will be applied to reworked T-Nods.
Conclusion The  repair/rework   and re-test of the  T-NODS  for  SSES Unit 1 has been accomplished per GE procedures and criteria. The deficiency has now been corrected and the potential safety hazard has been eliminated. The SSES Unit 1 reworked T-Nods h'ave been shipped and installed at the jobsite.
A  portion of the Unit 2 T-Nods were manufactured in the same time period as the Unit 1 T-Mods. Inspection will be performed at SSES per a GE document FDI MDBC. Defective units will be returned to GE for repair before fuel load. GE fabrication personnel training,. inspection and revised fabrication techniques has precluded reoccurrence of similar problems on the remaining Unit 2 T-Nods.
The inspections to be conducted in accordance with FDI MDBC include a 100$
visual inspection of terminal strips for cracked., broken or missing barriers and conductor insulation for nicks, abrasion and cuts. The existence of any of these conditions is cause for refection.
SK:po 2873
 
REDO 50455 L%     th         '3.08420 ATTACKZNT Page 4 of 6 OASIS bAXPdt QAYA                                                    GAY 0
                                                              ~taTKN WOVLK GAY C tarvia DAf5nER BAY D l,r
                  )
tI ih R~i'>
                                            ~
lJ eels OARRCR CONIECTOR  ~TE
                                                                                      $ TATlONARY QAttltlERS FUXR FlATK t4PPCltT    FCST Agee 04, Assembled   Tarnation Co%~ (Doom removod lot ch~
        ~~r                  ~ i ai  ~ p ~ 'pie~eI ~~O     ~ i i i'".S ~ ~a' ~ iver   ~. a: 'S ' 'r
 
A" 208420 ATTACHMEHT Page 5 of I  ~
                        ~ ~
y
                  ~   y ~
                            ~
CCNN ECTO'asm uoM                                      ~ ~
817
 
HED0.10468'TTAC Hi~IT Page 6    of 6 v~~v rvrv' I
(IP fILLS CASLC 0    0 0
0
~ ~   o
    ~   i' 0
0          0
                        ~ ~ ~             ~ ~ ~
                        ~ ~   ~1          ~ ~   ~ ~
                                            ~ ~ ~
o
                        ~
                            ~ ~
V               lP          t>.
I
                          ~ ~ ~             ~ ~ ~
                        ~ ~   ~~           ~ ~ ~ ~
                          ~ ~ ~             ~ ~ ~
0 4VNCTlOM SOX
 
I}}

Latest revision as of 16:11, 3 February 2020

Final Deficiency Rept Re Termination Module Insulation Damage.Caused by Improper Assembly,Handling,Storage & Producibility of Termination Module.Methods,Planning Process & Operator Training Upgraded
ML18031A343
Person / Time
Site: Susquehanna  Talen Energy icon.png
Issue date: 01/08/1980
From:
PENNSYLVANIA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To:
Shared Package
ML18031A342 List:
References
NUDOCS 8001150438
Download: ML18031A343 (7)
v • d • e


Text

ATTACEKNT Page 1 of 6 TERMINATION MODULE FINAL RESOLUTION Conductor Insulation Damage of T-HODS Located In Termination Cabinets.

The Power Generation Control Complex (PGCC) is developed and supplied by General Electric under the H-1 NSSS contract. The PGCC uses termination cabinets to interface between field cables. Most cables interface on a termination module (T-HOD) which consists of an AN connector for the cable from the PGCC floor section and a terminal board for. the incoming field cable (see attached Figs. 3-4, 3-5, and 3-6). NCR 3030 was issued on September 28, 1978 to identify damaged conductor insulation within the T-MOD connecting an AN connector and the terminal board. The damages were first observed during an implementation of rework of termination cabinet ITC-621 at the SSES site. Of the -total 450 T-MOD units for SSES Unit 1, 127 units were found to exhibit one or more of the following defects:

1) Severe indentations on the insulation (no exposed wire).
2) Abrasion (scuffing) of the insulation (no exposed wire).
3) 'Nicks and dings'n the insulation; i.e., minor 1/32" to 1/8" long) lateral and longitudinal cuts (exposed wire).
4) Severe longitudinal gouging. Hire was exposed (1/8" to 1/2" long) and the gouged insulation indicated sharp edge cutting in both directions.

General Electric's QA verification procedure for the manufacturing process was insufficient to detect the damage insulation.

Cause It was determined by GE that 95% of the damaged units were Hi-Density Termination Modules (21 and 48 pin assemblies which use twisted shielded pair and triple cables 20 awg wire with ferrule terminations on the shields). During the reassembly (i.e., pin insertion and extraction using the standard Amphenol tooling of the termination modules) continual difficulty was observed. The ferrule edge during extraction, and the sharp insertion tool edge during assembly, impacted on the densely packed wires at the connector area. Further damage (3 abrasions out of 900 con-ductors) was observed during the reassembly operation. The assembled units were then re-inspected and the thxee added defects were noted.

ATTACEBKHT Page 2 of 6 It was also noted that the sharp edges of the termination module frames caused indentations on the wire. insulation of improperly stacked units.

It was seen that this was caused by the sharp edge of the steel frame of one module laid against the unprotected wire bundles of an adjacent module Handling precautions are required to prevent this type of damage other.

since it can potentially occur any time two modules contact each In summary, the possible cause of insulation damage can be attributed to:

1) Improper Assembly Pin Insertion/Extraction
2) Handling and Storage
3) Producibility Hi-Density modules Conductor free length Ferrule concept Anal sis of the Safet Im lications The system design was reviewed and the following was concluded for the worst condition. The insulation damage of the T-MODs varies from barely visible to the unaided eye to 1/2" exposed bare wire. Although no insulation breakdown was observed during the hi-pot testing (standard 2.2 KVDC) of individual conductors to connector shell and other pins of the same connector, the frequency of occurrence is such that if the defects were left undetected/uncorrected, shorting of conductors must be assumed possible. Some of the affected systems are RHR, RCIC, and Core spray.

Loss of T-MOD conductors may prevent the circuits from performing their designed safety related functions. Such an eventuality presents an unacceptable condition even through there may be redundant subsystems remaining unaffected. In addition General Electric's QA program had failed to detect any defects during the manufacturing process.

Project Engineering has determined the PGCC T-MODs deficiency to be reportable under 10CFR 50.55(e).

Corrective Action S

All Unit 1 defective units have been returned to GE San Jose for rework.

To preclude re-occurrence on the rework of Unit 1 T-NODS, the following actions have been taken by GE:

l. Improper Assembly The methods, planning process, and operator training have been upgraded since the Susquehanna I T-MODS were built in the first quarter of 1976. This, with the producibility changes, will minimize difficulties observed during the reassembly operations for T-Mods.

General Electric's quality program applied to the Unit I termination modules was defective in one major area. The in-process inspection system did not include the physical inspection of the pin insertion process. (The assumption that continuity and insulation testing would detect all functionally significant insulation damage has not been confirmed).

Added in-process inspection points and a revised detailed .inspection

. -plan have been added to the assembly operation of the T-Mods.

0I ATTACE4EIQ'Page 3 6

2. Handling and Storage Operator training in the handling of T-Mods with proper physical separation and, stacking will reduce observed problems in this area.

In addition, the T-Mods, when complete, will be styrofoam wrapped and taped to preclude storage and shipping damage. (This practice was implemented in early 1977.)

3~ Producibility On the Unit I rework of the T-Nods, several producibility changes which have been implemented on subsequent projects will be applied:

a. Tensolite wire which is less susceptible, to abrasion and

'dinging'ill be applied to reworked T-Mods.

b. An alternate method of shielding which does not require the ferrule concept will be applied to reworked T-mods.
c. Longer free conductor length for ease of assembly will be applied to reworked T-Nods.

Conclusion The repair/rework and re-test of the T-NODS for SSES Unit 1 has been accomplished per GE procedures and criteria. The deficiency has now been corrected and the potential safety hazard has been eliminated. The SSES Unit 1 reworked T-Nods h'ave been shipped and installed at the jobsite.

A portion of the Unit 2 T-Nods were manufactured in the same time period as the Unit 1 T-Mods. Inspection will be performed at SSES per a GE document FDI MDBC. Defective units will be returned to GE for repair before fuel load. GE fabrication personnel training,. inspection and revised fabrication techniques has precluded reoccurrence of similar problems on the remaining Unit 2 T-Nods.

The inspections to be conducted in accordance with FDI MDBC include a 100$

visual inspection of terminal strips for cracked., broken or missing barriers and conductor insulation for nicks, abrasion and cuts. The existence of any of these conditions is cause for refection.

SK:po 2873

REDO 50455 L% th '3.08420 ATTACKZNT Page 4 of 6 OASIS bAXPdt QAYA GAY 0

~taTKN WOVLK GAY C tarvia DAf5nER BAY D l,r

)

tI ih R~i'>

~

lJ eels OARRCR CONIECTOR ~TE

$ TATlONARY QAttltlERS FUXR FlATK t4PPCltT FCST Agee 04, Assembled Tarnation Co%~ (Doom removod lot ch~

~~r ~ i ai ~ p ~ 'pie~eI ~~O ~ i i i'".S ~ ~a' ~ iver ~. a: 'S ' 'r

A" 208420 ATTACHMEHT Page 5 of I ~

~ ~

y

~ y ~

~

CCNN ECTO'asm uoM ~ ~

817

HED0.10468'TTAC Hi~IT Page 6 of 6 v~~v rvrv' I

(IP fILLS CASLC 0 0 0

0

~ ~ o

~ i' 0

0 0

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~1 ~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~

o

~

~ ~

V lP t>.

I

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

0 4VNCTlOM SOX

I

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML18031A343&oldid=2418559"