ML11192A076: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
| issue date = 04/06/2011
| issue date = 04/06/2011
| title = E-mail from Vonna Ordaz, Subject: Fw: Plan for Addressing Stand Alone SFPs for Charlie Miller'S Task Force
| title = E-mail from Vonna Ordaz, Subject: Fw: Plan for Addressing Stand Alone SFPs for Charlie Miller'S Task Force
| author name = Ordaz V L
| author name = Ordaz V
| author affiliation = NRC/NMSS/SFST
| author affiliation = NRC/NMSS/SFST
| addressee name = Benner E J
| addressee name = Benner E
| addressee affiliation = NRC/NMSS/SFST/LID
| addressee affiliation = NRC/NMSS/SFST/LID
| docket = 05000295, 05000304, 05000409, 07200001
| docket = 05000295, 05000304, 05000409, 07200001
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:Benner, Eric From: Ordaz, Vonna Sent: Wednesday, April 06, 2011 3:42 PM To: Benner, Eric  
{{#Wiki_filter:Benner, Eric From:                       Ordaz, Vonna Sent:                       Wednesday, April 06, 2011 3:42 PM To:                         Benner, Eric


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Fw: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Fyi From: Ordaz, Vonna To: Moore, Scott; Haney, Catherine Cc: Lewis, Robert; Camper, Larry; Kokajko, Lawrence; Weaver, Doug Sent: Wed Apr 06 15:41:37 2011  
Fw: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Fyi From: Ordaz, Vonna To: Moore, Scott; Haney, Catherine Cc: Lewis, Robert; Camper, Larry; Kokajko, Lawrence; Weaver, Doug Sent: Wed Apr 06 15:41:37 2011


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Re: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Appreciate your quick response, Scott. So, I understand that you or Cathy will share the info w/Mike, Marty and Charlie.I'd suggest you include Mark Satorious and Bill Dean as well. Region Ill will need the green light from someone to proceed.Thanks, Vonna From: Moore, Scott To: Ordaz, Vonna; Camper, Larry Cc: Haney, Catherine; Lewis, Robert Sent: Wed Apr 06 09:52:08 2011  
Re: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Appreciate your quick response, Scott. So, I understand that you or Cathy will share the info w/Mike, Marty and Charlie.
I'd suggest you include Mark Satorious and Bill Dean as well. Region Ill will need the green light from someone to proceed.
: Thanks, Vonna From: Moore, Scott To: Ordaz, Vonna; Camper, Larry Cc: Haney, Catherine; Lewis, Robert Sent: Wed Apr 06 09:52:08 2011


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
RE: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force I also think that the approach looks good, and I agree with Cathy's point that we should inform Mike and Marty (in addition to Charlie's TF).Scott From: Haney, Catherine Sent: Tuesday, April 05, 2011 5:40 PM To: Ordaz, Vonna; Camper, Larry Cc: Moore, Scott  
RE: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force I also think that the approach looks good, and I agree with Cathy's point that we should inform Mike and Marty (in addition to Charlie's TF).
Scott From: Haney, Catherine Sent: Tuesday, April 05, 2011 5:40 PM To: Ordaz, Vonna; Camper, Larry Cc: Moore, Scott


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
RE: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Vonna and Larry Approach looks good to me. In addition to informing Charlie, we should inform Mike Weber and Marty. I believe this is best done at the Office Level. Once we know Scott agrees with the approach, we can inform others.Cathy From: Ordaz, Vonna Sent: Tuesday, April 05, 2011 5:03 PM To: Haney, Catherine; Moore, Scott Cc: Camper, Larry; Lorson, Raymond; Boland, Anne; Lipa, Christine; Weaver, Doug; Benner, Eric; Ruland, William;Mohseni, Aby; Kokajko, Lawrence  
RE: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Vonna and Larry Approach looks good to me. In addition to informing Charlie, we should inform Mike Weber and Marty. I believe this is best done at the Office Level. Once we know Scott agrees with the approach, we can inform others.
Cathy From: Ordaz, Vonna Sent: Tuesday, April 05, 2011 5:03 PM To: Haney, Catherine; Moore, Scott Cc: Camper, Larry; Lorson, Raymond; Boland, Anne; Lipa, Christine; Weaver, Doug; Benner, Eric; Ruland, William; Mohseni, Aby; Kokajko, Lawrence


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Importance:
Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Importance: High
High Cathy and Scott, Larry Camper and I pulled together a conference call yesterday with Region III to finalize a decision on whether a TI should be performed on the stand alone SFPs, comparable to the newly issued TI 2515/183 on reactors in order to support the NRC Task Force on the US actions due to the Japan crisis (Charlie Miller's Team). There are 3 facilities that fall under this category including Zion, LaCrosse, and GE Morris. We understand that Millstone 1 will be addressed by Region I under the reactor TI 2515/183 because of the collocated operating reactors.A summary of our decision is below. We recognize that there is limited time to implement this and factor the outcome into the Task Force effort. We plan to forward this to Charlie Miller, unless you have any comments or wish to discuss it further. Please advise.Thanks, Vonna From: Lipa, Christine Sent: Monday, April 04, 2011 4:49 PM To: Camper, Larry; Louden, Patrick; McConnell, Keith; Watson, Bruce; Ordaz, Vonna; Benner, Eric; Boland, Anne Cc: Slawinski, Wayne; Edwards, Rhex; Learn, Matthew; Rodriguez, Lionel  
 
Cathy and Scott, Larry Camper and I pulled together a conference call yesterday with Region III to finalize a decision on whether a TI should be performed on the stand alone SFPs, comparable to the newly issued TI 2515/183 on reactors in order to support the NRC Task Force on the US actions due to the Japan crisis (Charlie Miller's Team). There are 3 facilities that fall under this category including Zion, LaCrosse, and GE Morris. We understand that Millstone 1 will be addressed by Region I under the reactor TI 2515/183 because of the collocated operating reactors.
A summary of our decision is below. We recognize that there is limited time to implement this and factor the outcome into the Task Force effort. We plan to forward this to Charlie Miller, unless you have any comments or wish to discuss it further. Please advise.
: Thanks, Vonna From: Lipa, Christine Sent: Monday, April 04, 2011 4:49 PM To: Camper, Larry; Louden, Patrick; McConnell, Keith; Watson, Bruce; Ordaz, Vonna; Benner, Eric; Boland, Anne Cc: Slawinski, Wayne; Edwards, Rhex; Learn, Matthew; Rodriguez, Lionel


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
FW: Course of action for inspections at stand alone spent fuel pools As discussed on today's call between reps from Region Ill, FSME, and NMSS, we have determined a course of action to provide us with additional assurance that the stand alone spent fuel pools have adequate measures in place to ensure adequate protection of public health and safety. We also plan to discuss this plan with Region I to ensure alignment.
FW: Course of action for inspections at stand alone spent fuel pools As discussed on today's call between reps from Region Ill, FSME, and NMSS, we have determined a course of action to provide us with additional assurance that the stand alone spent fuel pools have adequate measures in place to ensure adequate protection of public health and safety. We also plan to discuss this plan with Region I to ensure alignment.
Specifically, we discussed that Region III would conduct an inspection at each of our 3 stand alone spent fuel pools (Zion, LaCrosse, and GE Morris) by the date of April 29, 2011. The scope of the inspection would be to ensure site specific coping strategies for the loss of fuel pool cooling and water supply are developed and maintained in a state of readiness.
Specifically, we discussed that Region III would conduct an inspection at each of our 3 stand alone spent fuel pools (Zion, LaCrosse, and GE Morris) by the date of April 29, 2011. The scope of the inspection would be to ensure site specific coping strategies for the loss of fuel pool cooling and water supply are developed and maintained in a state of readiness. We would use the existing IP 60801 ("Spent Fuel Pool Safety at Shutdown Reactors") and expand the scope to include the applicable elements of TI 2515/183. By using TI 2515/183 as our guide, the focus will be to evaluate and verify the licensee's capability to mitigate conditions that result from station black out (SBO) conditions, seismic, flooding, fires, and beyond design basis events. These include an assessment of licensee procedures, capabilities and actions to ensure:
We would use the existing IP 60801 ("Spent Fuel Pool Safety at Shutdown Reactors")
SBO (1) Materials/equipment (for pool cooling/makeup water DC power) are available and maintained (2) Procedures for SBO response are developed (3) Personnel are trained and procedures are executable Seismic, floodingq and fires and Beyond Design Basis Events (1) Strategies (ad-hoc or otherwise) are developed to mitigate the impact of fire, flood and seismic events from adversely affecting the spent fuel (2) Materials/equipment are adequate and staged (i.e., barriers such as curbing/walls/doors, penetration seals, fire protection equipment)
and expand the scope to include the applicable elements of TI 2515/183.
By using TI 2515/183 as our guide, the focus will be to evaluate and verify the licensee's capability to mitigate conditions that result from station black out (SBO)conditions, seismic, flooding, fires, and beyond design basis events. These include an assessment of licensee procedures, capabilities and actions to ensure: SBO (1) Materials/equipment (for pool cooling/makeup water DC power) are available and maintained (2) Procedures for SBO response are developed (3) Personnel are trained and procedures are executable Seismic, floodingq and fires and Beyond Design Basis Events (1) Strategies (ad-hoc or otherwise) are developed to mitigate the impact of fire, flood and seismic events from adversely affecting the spent fuel (2) Materials/equipment are adequate and staged (i.e., barriers such as curbing/walls/doors, penetration seals, fire protection equipment)
(3) Procedures to implement the mitigating strategies are developed (4) Personnel are trained and procedures are executable 2
(3) Procedures to implement the mitigating strategies are developed (4) Personnel are trained and procedures are executable 2
Christine A. Lipa Chief, Materials Control, ISFSI, and Decommissioning Branch U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Region III 630-829-9834 3}}
Christine A. Lipa Chief, Materials Control, ISFSI, and Decommissioning Branch U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Region III 630-829-9834 3}}

Latest revision as of 18:35, 12 November 2019

E-mail from Vonna Ordaz, Subject: Fw: Plan for Addressing Stand Alone SFPs for Charlie Miller'S Task Force
ML11192A076
Person / Time
Site: La Crosse, Zion, 07200001  File:ZionSolutions icon.png
Issue date: 04/06/2011
From: Vonna Ordaz
NRC/NMSS/SFST
To: Eric Benner
NRC/NMSS/SFST/LID
References
FOIA/PA-2011-0223
Download: ML11192A076 (3)


Text

Benner, Eric From: Ordaz, Vonna Sent: Wednesday, April 06, 2011 3:42 PM To: Benner, Eric

Subject:

Fw: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Fyi From: Ordaz, Vonna To: Moore, Scott; Haney, Catherine Cc: Lewis, Robert; Camper, Larry; Kokajko, Lawrence; Weaver, Doug Sent: Wed Apr 06 15:41:37 2011

Subject:

Re: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Appreciate your quick response, Scott. So, I understand that you or Cathy will share the info w/Mike, Marty and Charlie.

I'd suggest you include Mark Satorious and Bill Dean as well. Region Ill will need the green light from someone to proceed.

Thanks, Vonna From: Moore, Scott To: Ordaz, Vonna; Camper, Larry Cc: Haney, Catherine; Lewis, Robert Sent: Wed Apr 06 09:52:08 2011

Subject:

RE: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force I also think that the approach looks good, and I agree with Cathy's point that we should inform Mike and Marty (in addition to Charlie's TF).

Scott From: Haney, Catherine Sent: Tuesday, April 05, 2011 5:40 PM To: Ordaz, Vonna; Camper, Larry Cc: Moore, Scott

Subject:

RE: Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Vonna and Larry Approach looks good to me. In addition to informing Charlie, we should inform Mike Weber and Marty. I believe this is best done at the Office Level. Once we know Scott agrees with the approach, we can inform others.

Cathy From: Ordaz, Vonna Sent: Tuesday, April 05, 2011 5:03 PM To: Haney, Catherine; Moore, Scott Cc: Camper, Larry; Lorson, Raymond; Boland, Anne; Lipa, Christine; Weaver, Doug; Benner, Eric; Ruland, William; Mohseni, Aby; Kokajko, Lawrence

Subject:

Plan for addressing stand alone SFPs for Charlie Miller's Task Force Importance: High

Cathy and Scott, Larry Camper and I pulled together a conference call yesterday with Region III to finalize a decision on whether a TI should be performed on the stand alone SFPs, comparable to the newly issued TI 2515/183 on reactors in order to support the NRC Task Force on the US actions due to the Japan crisis (Charlie Miller's Team). There are 3 facilities that fall under this category including Zion, LaCrosse, and GE Morris. We understand that Millstone 1 will be addressed by Region I under the reactor TI 2515/183 because of the collocated operating reactors.

A summary of our decision is below. We recognize that there is limited time to implement this and factor the outcome into the Task Force effort. We plan to forward this to Charlie Miller, unless you have any comments or wish to discuss it further. Please advise.

Thanks, Vonna From: Lipa, Christine Sent: Monday, April 04, 2011 4:49 PM To: Camper, Larry; Louden, Patrick; McConnell, Keith; Watson, Bruce; Ordaz, Vonna; Benner, Eric; Boland, Anne Cc: Slawinski, Wayne; Edwards, Rhex; Learn, Matthew; Rodriguez, Lionel

Subject:

FW: Course of action for inspections at stand alone spent fuel pools As discussed on today's call between reps from Region Ill, FSME, and NMSS, we have determined a course of action to provide us with additional assurance that the stand alone spent fuel pools have adequate measures in place to ensure adequate protection of public health and safety. We also plan to discuss this plan with Region I to ensure alignment.

Specifically, we discussed that Region III would conduct an inspection at each of our 3 stand alone spent fuel pools (Zion, LaCrosse, and GE Morris) by the date of April 29, 2011. The scope of the inspection would be to ensure site specific coping strategies for the loss of fuel pool cooling and water supply are developed and maintained in a state of readiness. We would use the existing IP 60801 ("Spent Fuel Pool Safety at Shutdown Reactors") and expand the scope to include the applicable elements of TI 2515/183. By using TI 2515/183 as our guide, the focus will be to evaluate and verify the licensee's capability to mitigate conditions that result from station black out (SBO) conditions, seismic, flooding, fires, and beyond design basis events. These include an assessment of licensee procedures, capabilities and actions to ensure:

SBO (1) Materials/equipment (for pool cooling/makeup water DC power) are available and maintained (2) Procedures for SBO response are developed (3) Personnel are trained and procedures are executable Seismic, floodingq and fires and Beyond Design Basis Events (1) Strategies (ad-hoc or otherwise) are developed to mitigate the impact of fire, flood and seismic events from adversely affecting the spent fuel (2) Materials/equipment are adequate and staged (i.e., barriers such as curbing/walls/doors, penetration seals, fire protection equipment)

(3) Procedures to implement the mitigating strategies are developed (4) Personnel are trained and procedures are executable 2

Christine A. Lipa Chief, Materials Control, ISFSI, and Decommissioning Branch U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Region III 630-829-9834 3