|
|---|
Category:General FR Notice Comment Letter
MONTHYEARML14364A0122014-12-22022 December 2014
Comment (00011) of Anonymous Individual on Southern California Edison Company; San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station, Units 2 and 3; Post-Shutdown Decommissioning Activities Report
ML12032A0272011-12-19019 December 2011
Comment (4) of Raj Rana, on Behalf of Himself, on NUREG-1482, Rev 2, Appendix B
ML11354A1102011-12-14014 December 2011
Comment (74) of Lois Duvall & Faith Ruffing on Behalf of Themselves Supporting Draft Supplement 47 to the GEIS for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and Public Meetings for the License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11334A0682011-11-16016 November 2011
Comment (69) of Kris Watkins on Behalf of Tri-Cities Visitor & Convention Bureau, Supporting Draft Supplement 47 to Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station Operated by Energy Northwest
ML11325A3172011-11-16016 November 2011
Comment (60) of Thomas Buchanan, on Behalf of Washington Physicians for Social Responsibility, on Relicensing Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11325A1812011-11-16016 November 2011
Comment (62) of Theodora Tsongas Opposing Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants
ML11325A1822011-11-16016 November 2011
Comment (63) of Laurence Vernhes Opposing Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plant
ML11325A3152011-11-16016 November 2011
Comment (59) Jill Reifschneider Opposing Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and Public Meetings for the License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11325A3182011-11-16016 November 2011
Comment (61) of Allison Obrien on Behalf of Us Dept of the Interior, on Re-licensing of Columbia Generating Station
ML11334A0692011-11-16016 November 2011
Comment (70) of Christine B. Reichgott on Behalf of Us Environmental Protection Agency, on Draft Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement for the Renewal of Columbia Generating Station License
ML11325A3102011-11-15015 November 2011
Comment (54) of Gerry Pollet, on Behalf of Heart of America, on Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and Public Meetings for the License Renewal of Columbia Generating Stati
ML11325A2462011-11-15015 November 2011
Comment (50) of Delbert Mccombs, Opposing Draft Supplement 47 to Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants & Public Meetings for License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11325A3082011-11-15015 November 2011
Comment (52) of Leslie March, on Behalf of the Sierra Club, Opposing Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and Public Meetings for the License Renewal of Columbia Generating
ML11325A3092011-11-15015 November 2011
Comment (53) of Janice Castle Opposing Relicensing of Columbia Generating Station
ML11325A1842011-11-15015 November 2011
Comment (65) by James W. Sanders on Behalf of Benton Pud, Supporting Renewal of the Columbia Generating Station
ML11325A1832011-11-15015 November 2011
Comment (64) of Julie Longenecker on Behalf of Confederated Tribes of the Umatilla Indian Reservation, on Draft Supplemental EIS for License Renewal of the Columbia Generating Station
ML11325A2472011-11-15015 November 2011
Comment (51) of Eric Adman, Opposing Draft Supplement 47 to Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and Public Meetings for License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11325A3132011-11-15015 November 2011
Comment (57) of Mary Twombly Opposing Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants
ML11325A3112011-11-15015 November 2011
Comment (55) of Chandra Radiance on Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and Public Meetings for the Licenses Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11325A3142011-11-15015 November 2011
Comment (58) of Charles Johnson, on Behalf of Himself, Opposing Relicensing of Columbia Generating Station
ML11325A3122011-11-15015 November 2011
Comment (56) of Hafiz Heartsun, on Behalf of Himself, Opposing Re-Licensing of Columbia River Generation Station
ML11325A2452011-11-14014 November 2011
Comment (49) of Susan Nash, Opposing NRC-2010-0029-0015, Notice of Availability of Draft Supplement 47 to Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and Public Meetings for License Renewal of Columbia Gener
ML11325A2442011-11-14014 November 2011
Comment (48) of Steven G Gilbert, on Behalf of Himself, Opposing License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11325A2432011-11-14014 November 2011
Comment (47) of Jacqueline Sorgen on Behalf of Himself Opposed to Notice of Receipt and Availability of Application for Renewal of Columbia Generating Station Facility Operating License
ML11325A2422011-11-12012 November 2011
Comment (46) of Louisa Hamachek, Opposing NRC-2010-0029-0015, Energy Northwest, Columbia Generating Station; Opposing Draft Supplement 47 to Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and Public Meetings
ML11325A1902011-11-10010 November 2011
Comment (66) of Michelle Caird on Behalf of Inland Power and Light Co., Supporting License Renewal of the Columbia Generating Station
ML11334A0662011-11-10010 November 2011
Comment (67) of Stephen Posner on Behalf of the State of Washington Energy Facility Site Evaluation Council on Columbia Generating Station Draft Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement - Supplement 47
ML11334A0702011-11-0808 November 2011
Comment (71) of Commissioners on Behalf of Mason County Pud Supporting Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and Public Meetings for the License Renewal of Columbia Generatin
ML11308A0302011-11-0101 November 2011
Comment (2) of Tom Clements on Behalf of Friends of the Earth, on Draft Strategic Plan About Testing of Plutonium Fuel (MOX) Made from Weapons-Grade Plutonium Required for NRC to License MOX Use in Boiling Water Reactors
ML11318A2562011-10-25025 October 2011
Comment (45) of William Gordon, Et. Al., on Behalf of Franklin Pud, Supporting Energy Northwests License Renewal for Columbia Generating Station
ML11305A0132011-10-19019 October 2011
Comment (43) of Henry T. Bernstein on Behalf of Himself, Opposing the Relicensing of the Columbia Generating Station
ML11305A0122011-10-18018 October 2011
Comment (42) of Diana Thompson on Behalf of Public Utility District No. 2 of Pacific County in Support of Energy Northwests Application to Renew Columbia Generating Stations License for an Additional 25 Years
ML11291A1352011-10-16016 October 2011
Comment (38) of Linda on Behalf of Self Opposing the Renewal of Columbia Generating Station License
ML11293A0432011-10-13013 October 2011
Comment (41) of Leo Bowman, Shon Small & James Beaver on Behalf of Benton County, Wa, Board of Commissioners, Supporting the Relicensing of the Columbia Generating Station
ML11293A0422011-10-11011 October 2011
Comment (40) of the Board of Commissioners for Mason County Public Utility District, Supporting the Renewal of Columbia Generating Stations Operating License for an Additional 20 Years
ML11291A1572011-10-0505 October 2011
Comment (37) of Ken S. Berg on Behalf of Us Dept of the Interior, Fish and Wildlife Service, on Columbia Generating Station License Renewal Informal Consultation
ML11280A1162011-10-0404 October 2011
Comment (31) of Unknown Individual Opposing License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11280A1172011-10-0404 October 2011
Comment (32) of Scott Mcdonald on License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11280A1152011-10-0303 October 2011
Comment (30) of Holly Graham Re Draft Supplement 47 to Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11280A1102011-10-0101 October 2011
Comment (27) of Carol Hiltner Opposing Draft Supplement 47 to Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11280A1092011-09-30030 September 2011
Comment (26) of Kathleen Wahl on NRC-2010-0029, Energy Northwest, Columbia Generating Station; Notice of Availability of Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal
ML11280A1082011-09-30030 September 2011
Comment (25) of Martin Mijal Re Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11279A2462011-09-29029 September 2011
Comment (18) of Judy Ginn on Draft Supplement 47 to Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11280A2002011-09-29029 September 2011
Comment (22) of Theodora Tsongas Re Columbia Generating Station; Notice of Availability of Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal
ML11280A2032011-09-29029 September 2011
Comment (24) of Lonn Holman Re Draft Supplement 47 to Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Columbia Generating Station
ML11280A1202011-09-28028 September 2011
Comment (35) of Don C. Brunell, on Behalf of Association of Washington Business, Supporting License Renewal for Columbia Generating Station
ML11279A2412011-09-28028 September 2011
Comment (13) of Tom May Requesting Regional Hearings on the Draft EIS for Relicensing of Columbia Generating Station
ML11279A2432011-09-28028 September 2011
Comment (15) of Kathleen Bushman on NRC-2010-0029 - Energy Northwest, Columbia Generating Station; Notice of Availability of Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and Public
ML11279A2452011-09-28028 September 2011
Comment (17) of Anne Moore on NRC-2010-0029 - Energy Northwest, Columbia Generating Station; Notice of Availability of Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and Public Meetin
ML11279A2402011-09-28028 September 2011
Comment (12) of Gary Petersen of Tridec on NRC-2010-0029 - Energy Northwest, Columbia Generating Station; Notice of Availability of Draft Supplement 47 to the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants and
2014-12-22
[Table view] |
Text
Mendiola, Doris From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Attachments:
Rana, Raj [RRANA@energy-northwest.com]
Monday, December 19, 2011 4:58 PM Bedi, Gurjendra Rana, Raj; Smith, Christopher J.; Wolfgramm, Richard P.
Comments on NUREG-1482, Rev. 2 Appendix B COMMENTS ON NUREG1482Rev2.doc Mr. G.S Bedi:
Please see attached comments on NUREG-1482, Rev 2 Appendix B.
AS discussed during the December 2011 ASME OM Code meeting at Clearwater Beach Florida, I agree with having a stand alone document Appendix A for snubbers examination and testing.
Please call me if you need any clarification on my comments.
Raj Rana Snubber and IST Program Manager Energy Northwest Columbia Generating Station P.O.Box 968 4,
M/S PE 27 Richland WA 99352 PH: 509-377-4313 E Mail: rrana(*enerqy-northwest.com
/<,{ y5~5j~
'Ti
~~~1 S
.,J 7ZJ C.10 6-,~z~ k3xv-~
COMMENTS ON NUREG-1482, Rev. 2 Company: Energy Northwest, Columbia Generating Station Contact Name: Raj Rana Phone: 509-377-4313 Email: rraana@energy-northwest.com APPENDIX B COMMENTS No.
Section Comment Throughout Appendix B replace "IST and examination" with 1
"examination and testing", replace "inspection" with
"'examination" 1.1 & 1.2 Discuss Regulatory History before Regulatory Basis. Delete 2
duplication of requirements, most of the text in section 2.1 is repeat of section 1.1.
2.1 & 2.5 Delete relief requests information from section 2.1 as it is 3
provided in section 2.5 2.2 Delete introductory paragraph before section 2.2.1 as it will 4
generate confusion.
5 2.2.1 Delete 2 nd and 3rd paragraphs, repeat of information in section 1.1. Most of the other paragraphs are repeat of Appendix A pump and valve requirements and are not really applicable to snubbers.
Revise second to last paragraph to read as "Tables 2.1 and 2.2 (which appear at the end of this appendix) provide examples of systems with valves that licensees typically include in their IST program. These tables may be used for developing licensee's snubber program scope."
6 2.2.2 Last sentence of last paragraph; add "components" after
........ piping or other components may be...."
7 2.2.3 This section is copied from Appendix A. Delete last sentence of paragraph one. Delete 2 nd and 3rd paragraphs. Replace "ISI" with "examination" in paragraph 1 and throughout the Appendix..
8 2.3 Delete this section as it is already covered under para. 2.2.1 9
2.4.3 Please reference the snubber RIS and EGM here. There was no requirement in Technical Specification/TRM to submit Snubber Program Plan to the NRC. Owners updating the snubber programs IAW latest rulemaking using OM Code will have to submit snubber program plan to the regulatory authorities. Last sentence of this para. should be clarified accordingly.
10 2.4.4 Middle of the paragraph; delete "each" from.... where a list of each snubbers is kept....
11 2.4.4.1 Delete item 1, it is part of ISI program plan. All other items
are either ISTD or TRM requirements that are detailed in the implementing surveillance procedures.
12 2.4.4.2 Change title to "Inservice Operational Readiness Testing."
Delete items 4 through 7, these items are either ISTD or TRM requirements that are detailed in the implementing surveillance procedures.
13 2.4.4.3 Middle of the Ist paragraph; replace "in" with "is" in the sentence,.... every refueling outage, and is not Predictive.....
Delete last sentence of 2 nd paragraph regarding consulting with SNUG.
14 2.4.5 Delete the requirement to list revision date on each page of the bases document. Under test frequency change to read, list the frequency of visual examination and testing. Also delete the requirement to list relief request(s) in the snubber list.
15 2.4.6 Change "Snubber Programs" to "Snubber Program Plan" in the Title and throughout this section.
16 2.6 Change Title to read "Snubber Program Plan Update".
Change "program documents" to "program plan" throughout this section. Change "ISI and testing" to "examination and testing" throughout this section. Change second "ISI" to "NRC" in first sentence.
17 2.8 Revise first sentence by adding "or other applicable Subsection",.......Section XI, Subsection IWF or other applicable Subsection, ASME OM Code...."
18 Table 2.1 Revise the Title, "Typical Systems or portions of systems in
& Table the scope of 10 CFR 50.55a where snubbers are....."
2.2 19 Figure 1 Add "Preservice" to the Title.
