ML070320567

E-mail from Vinikour Regarding the Environmental Report Acceptance Review on the Susquehanna Steam Electric Station Application Review

ML070320567
Person / Time
Site:	Susquehanna
Issue date:	10/07/2006
From:	Vinikour W Argonne National Lab (ANL)
To:	Monette F Argonne National Lab (ANL), Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
TAC MD3021, TAC MD3022
Download: ML070320567 (3)

Text

Monette, Frederick A.

From:

Vinikour, William S.

Sent:

Saturday, October 07, 2006 1:26 PM To:

Monette, Frederick A.

Subject:

RE: Susquehanna ER Attachments:

Susquehanna Aquatic Ecology Information Needs.doc Susquehanna Nquatic Ecology In...

Fred:

I generally found the Susquehanna ER acceptable in regards to its discussion of the aquatic resources; description of the plant cooling water system and its operations; the rationale for not evaluating the effects of the plant cooling water system operations to aquatic biota from entrainment, impingement, and heat shock; and evaluation of the effects of microbiological organisms on public health. Attached is a list of additional information I would like the applicant to provide, including selected references cited in the ER.

I also think you should order at least one copy of the DeLorme Gazetteer for Pennsylvania (you can order directly online from the company).

It would show the transmission lines on it, and I would be able to get a listing of the streams and rivers that the lines cross.

Bill William S. Vinikour Environmental Scientist Environmental Science Division Argonne National Laboratory 9700 S.

Cass Ave.,

Building 900

Argonne, IL 60439 Voice: 630-252-5419 Fax: 630-252-6090 E-mail: vinikour@anl.gov

---

Original Message-----

From: Monette, Frederick A.

Sent: Friday, October 06, 2006 1:22 PM To: Monette, Frederick A.; Avci, H alil I.;

Moret, Ellen N.; Lazaro, Michael A.; Wescott, Konstance L.; Vinikour, William S.; O'Rourke, Daniel J.;

Quinn, John; Metz, William C.;

Allison, Timothy; LaGory, Kirk E.

Subject:

RE: Susquehanna ER Please provide your acceptance review of the Susquehanna ER by Monday morning. Thanks.

Fred

---

Original Message -----

From: Monette, Frederick A.

Sent: Friday, September 29, 2006 10:28 AM TO: Monette, Frederick A.; Avci, Halil I.;

Moret, Ellen N.; Lazaro, Michael A.; Wescott, Konstance L.; Vinikour, William S.; O'Rourke, Daniel J.;

Quinn, John; Metz, William C.;

Allison, Timothy; LaGory, Kirk E.

Subject:

Susquehanna ER We have received cd copies of the Susquehanna LRA, a hard copy of the LRA, and a cd copy 1

of the original FES for Susquehanna.

Please see Ellen if you want your own cd version, or to view the FES.

The LRA has also been placed in the project folder on the p: drive.

Fred Original Message -----

From: Monette, Frederick A.

Sent: Thursday, September 28, 2006 12:54 PM To: Avci, Halil I.;

Moret, Ellen N.; Lazaro, Michael A.; Wescott, Konstance L.; Vinikour, William S.; O'Rourke, Daniel J.;

Quinn, John; Metz, William C..; Allison, Timothy; LaGory, Kirk E.

Subject:

Susquehanna ER Hello Team, I haven't received disk or hardcopies of the Susquehanna ER yet.

However, it has just been made available on the NRC web site at:

http://www.nrc.gov/reactors/operating/licensing/renewal/applications/susquehanna.html Please start your acceptance review and let me know if your sections are acceptable by Oct.

6.

Thanks, Fred 2

Susquehanna Additional Information Needs Aquatic Ecology and Microbiological Organisms (Public Health)

We need a complete copy of the applicant's current NPDES permit. The ER only has the front page (page F-3 of the ER). We would also need to have a copy of Parts A, B, and C of the permit that actually provide the specific permit requirements.

In addition to the above, copies of the following reports or correspondence cited in the ER are requested:

• From Chapter 2, Section 2.3:

o Ecology III (1987),

o Ecology 111 (1995), and o

Ecology III (2005) PPL Electric Utilities Corp (2004).

From Chapter 4, Section 4.2 1:

o Ecology 111 (2001) o Ecology III (2002),

o Ecology 111 (2003),

o Ecology I1I (2004), and o

Fields (1982).

It would also be beneficial to have copies of all of the other Annual Reports prior to that published in 1995, those published from 1996 thru 2000, and the most recent one published in 2006 that contain information on the aquatic resources in the Susquehanna area. However, if the annual reports are lengthy documents (e.g., over 100 pages) or are not currently available on CD or electronically, then those besides the ones requested above should be made available to us at the site audit. At that time, I can decide whether it would be necessary to have copies made for us.

I