ML20199G343
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:Witut:LGMJutcr /,'. * / g 8 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION .s r o WASHINGTON, D. C. 20355 . g.a.. APR 3 1926 NEMORANDUM FOR: Herbert H. Livermore QA/QC Group Leader Comanche Peak Technical Review Team FROM: Yincent S. Noonan, Director Comanche Peak Project
SUBJECT:
ALLEGER FEEDBACK ACTION ITEMS I have reviewed the items you identified in the December 10, meeting transcript,in response to your March 22 memorandum. Based on this review, I feel that some of these items can be closed out after the QA/QC SSERs are issued, however, others may require imediate follow-up, resolution, and even additional feedback to allegers before SSER publishing. Please review the attached listing of these items and provide your schedule [ for clcse-out to me by c.o.b., April 12, 1985. c x w.. I s I Cg oo an AETtct Ph1TS IN L6 (Lose CL wrautLuJ ui& 4k6 AtascMs on 36< lo, /f f V.. .@.Lsd SCAD Hits Anneltco Se .rmPA cT or) SSCRs Ato &co (Ack-i I'- n AccestWI a ces eso63%y-9 gor gees .i-'...
/k C f/0Al l ^! C l'I L/5/ '/? S ff g 3 e!&, ur J / 2. lc- $// [~Ec3 EA [h'. ///TER V / E' W WIW ~A L L EG ER E b - l, A - 3, '9.6 ! A~b~Y ~ ' m ~- afy Po o,z 2 5) h c -/7j doein/, swr are je;<g used nirx' sb'v yrs,s: ... %. Ds & & ndes/ 8e.~ der. ~ s2s,a du j e i<.y a s e. f n o J.> ; fiam,s #s. o/s n. d' o r3 we ye sda M se sims }7 do a//ep, NTRT~ /u.) not ren ,p.j Uf Auriq 8eie investly.u%n o f da -/T. p9 lah-w d.ded a-e mig ys 6 /c dMa /so r a.' W iW.ce o,% sis y.c d.:cee. a>Ad, i;9eslus: ne. aw g e& snt s,{ /sssi<y at /Aem. Ofn,s s .N'o. DIQ 0 C 3, ? 8, 97, 306, f ) B C 7 w ere ))dlrfe) clariny f%. rQedM iriuvieu ) . /Lp 59 A a-m - see sha-c. A// eyer,q-s nhJ if NRc Ti2T~ iosd z'en f.%. b rm-ewr4 /;ss 4 euw, wer e exe a,..; a J w J ;, <>:n a i / wkJ t'irm. fr. . ZL wA &f M cen 04 'i
- "~*
/ t a es. He skid *So w e V/ si> e usa rW iwm Aer: JJ ik : & ~ -c., h eft 2A jg &yl3M 'r.* h/AA;f C/:d we w
- b.& 'h l..ts) l$k f
50 jndir/Mc YAd% 4 ec,.] ws,se.;,/ w!/s. , sn 9 Ofe<Yb f Y aa ~ 6 p / s o dr /n/ry ad puud'rCLds,7s:.wl Cer6'5'66 'n=. g kae-two Y b-*lk fJ ' lC'< 8 * /L.: Sil 14 e S $c* $ Ytd-4,GeoSb2 S/ ^W g $$h$h, k hN a$h f h,. ?hYh k'$f/n.li <ld-uA, _v.V i,. - k h ?w' 85 ftD g i i B '~~~ S ' I d I E [ l 'f l bla A d /s ea Ic 70L O e.- ei,uL) locak Me ~, s~l r '& in divld"J - w e ee.wl!!/~j s a> e u s al c e r t.. in. /;. A*c b zk)? 6 DE y 65en, b ta t,e b d ie,>;.
.... n. ,c.... ~ - ~ .ir. .a rar-.avi.r seinics s tact i .-AGc55 l7y; cr Df f 2, 93, , 0 C - lt3.:pe<$srs hs/(y /n,,cl_a c.ame_Q/on gp m. Noon ~ jszacs,,,,m);b) n-7-76A.6,,
- s,<,e & A g.,,,,n e Q.stainic.ss sey!sp c, 4 7-u c/
9 whe?Wut 0 Naa. ///2& SLc79 S f s s/ Hor; sn b'h er,g. at' bede & $s ~6 "eee sadf re/~ted l \\p o r-vto &. Aloons.,~.,orsmisel dop'er s f zG(h ar ~e r-da ,p } ?' pbit A//ye.,s. A- /, if-3, i9 -f and. A 5*f wAen ;c Je-I o s n i M /c.. T t {,- ..m... ~ fn 91 : A n-ss - se d,,e. .V A//e7er A-/.hyaestaJ per/s/u/or b &//ec NWLE6 ypr:- Y&cks for tw/ Le. extra-ch S m va.v-joes H.w?.E6 ~ r :s ett). J / Oncerniy spe.,2 hel po./ linbr: g refirred-S th s-Vece Usp-t.. A eI aad.ll7h & 'd a ' kl rWen 6 /Voone s
- a. s a
r can. .i/s na ~ 6 yesse n '& u. rW inab,/as 4 Aim; Ae w4
- u. e
. i si,,,,,iy .aM UA if sui it b & riyt p.y/c.. 7
- p. W+ 9'~ ~
. Oil ~ / 8
l -. ; .. ~., '~ 9 y jo2, j js.3, 0-7 /o/,; AG-5. /z. /31 Iy ist2 /IG sff.7e</ ;4f.a.ena.4,, a./ 2 aar ///c,a.ts, t ~ >yy<a42 -Nr~-.>n a b' 4.r~hvip[.Is4 (Z/nn).
- n/M wavaJ ase o f Jniee,fr %
em o, y Alleger A-s ss&d ,p ess/an. as w;1L O;y. 14.., b d1J P 6e J th -M tLt a, eye.: din;r uia s 4,:e
- ~'q ss 3
g wa.s nst on de corkrs/ dee.am d nse zu.< : L t/>!ro~ it e to an HCR mez6d u.sel i6 sisu) 24'.<A zWis sua s doc e f 4tl in wifa.& pauh'%,,, - A J-- ~ Jh. TXT, snisirleyen) Mt conies-o, s J y'iw' ae, Co d d no t.a, s wee t!i: p <.t;r. ' sh$g }. Allyev A-r asia.1 if hr rewed r%. McR% Lt codin fM n s e,v, 'sta Ji~ In &.in=tta i O anesd & cs/ - c o u w.-> ;r. 9pa-Tn.7 en a ey uw n s sa c,.s ee.r <d, s */ r,u de, >:: ' i &p wn~61 & h ~ &,si.cjul air esssa~t A -s d: do l 0 q u/w.7,z r data.i 6 da</,ty His diwe: n? a&. /h6 ie,e slid ne t-pas a>. Nso nw s..s,e:.d % -PM sur a 's: iL Ncp'n ? " A'An:~ re>ynt d: d "y e s *. e t
w ,,) 5 P c itt-n4; /1a </o ;. con-ty..z%-L'dy J de.d wa,:. n ~ ,& /bbsw.ss2h/ Way & Hz-he.<z'na& f,Dag.aA q coJr,I. " n/Aye< A-5 paesb'snul 0Do yan xnow whe~ t'm m A d/L 2 f determindim.7 * /?aksn did and-ww. EL sd k wi// /alu. %.f-AM & toe. witi 6'n) od w/M,N/s wo Am. Ye'{lga b & b z% Aeyinnih.~ .A-/ ast.eJ "Is it neeessq /r m.1ist6th? & & i/,y, sn w:/./ filler ins.te Os) on r2an ASt>fE //ner o r w e /ds ? * /M8me < - A tw sve5 t L t it e dr on 7%.,,sro cek,eou 'r-e er/np on s/re. /9-/ skW M-ies 7 % 4.n z h w i s )Jr was bs9/f suf 62 Gocuso es i quaDRed wd.Aws ~s t-d. L w o e.,. . b'w. /s >wHiay o % welds a J z%. stal,uless sfeel dhers 2LL rep aires mAris/ bue - abl/lbj. 2ah== Smim.) ; Eat //-/ was ton a, a ) s.1 & we:) 'weldig a M s,od Se/ po./ s J capihy YoA tru. Ll)Ny on f liher. /%bn.sen. ;.sfak) N zH.L,procek would hone. -{o be exa,ntned. Aar1rf acaal-M d -h e cl. o d (s h. ~ f 'k p#5[g
- e m
-ev.- -....--ee.. .w.,.- -.e.. e- -, = w.
ve:~. m ~- . it. ~ r (f4" /2/-I;-3; A62-77 And :7fl Uticerniy s>w% Sdr/&~ d. N ri u. & / y L.s g s n : ~ C p a r t : Sagl a.r e y a j o / h - A.f g ~ [ ..Ne.w fo st af:'ee recey in.yeedhn, d. G ss.1 t - y I. re/M pares were ir L in i % F L ' 5 4.,,, a y:. a y T*S'Icsd!cn instrudhn: 0-~ sn eye bo/b % /ost- [or-a. veNbe su,y%' eof /!u,., neckc A on e.ie bat,,&.?'%y.f.s.4 Sho Utey (Crdh hu.n) tusa).) tc29. . F.a %, w.? J n.s 2 i sn9 o mssian> a s a esa:n e R::, =- d u 6 e::6it'd/o ~ n:~ ' p5 w-y% .ZL ma a-s w a ma,;M-a.,4.mr st a mre /.JJ. ((s%$sai./ .:qs3 4% s A n eye 6th ad ,c,
- ~ ' '
0.oD. shou) 7x7~ some sn.[/ed'm 8(,0. g '~ ~ s ..i'. we .e, e.. k 9 4
s. n lU)g ursa O.- 1l Q) alleyes '3,b R p neem es kwe resultOln.,
- f < c des L- &~d yeview, Asms-L.:. ~
- V4labi n p
~ kcumedadim,,rnsnipa/ din of safel -rekted doca-y nie4~ati.m. TR7' csub u& Rd a y <a re wlaa 4 doca,ne,Mio,, tuas beinf ynanipd4ad. Fourfee.~,pn eek.c dddew Al1 ex A -f. s.sked whd z% >tu4 e es Yevised. 9 w e < e-g -Px %. Y evise).clo ca m eas; Ti~m 0vy d'dtwt A m w y L o ff bd.bu)~ G bid de U ?Wd~ Jr N< Era.Os rr /,, };s wate: so m ukuu. Z ku % szk. b A dt d' we '#
- y
.Y*D g e f /dz dscamed h A err 0< d't. a//yevc. 101Y J 0 9 t 9 9 9 e e ,r .e r-
fans /s.s-Act //o-80; coneeLs decic-ses.4'einy.rw<d A sn ..1~2% rs.thes z%.o.//cR%. - 7%is was a peser/c /kra<-. r e.'. wa-wed 6 h a. e CorJibisns' zLk as/d be vyaired u.ary ewsGy .froceh.uu1.. ZY Ne refair reguires an en;rkee </r-j e v.cl u M sn o{ f/zyPshk,~, s n /VCR ens & A'e. USed. Allue< A-/ s&.tedWdad o-n.r2 wM a Sry ~ ~ .sipshuu ak R &ir: ;M d &c ur euded zS y/re-to rer rt eodains ts o siu-s 2hl k synel l& o RC Z z L s6 des / h wsasi y a. v }A & n<r..s (II-il-eY) anJpic/c k up. % $nry s M J PA t-Pg,%s c L !se IR '. <ya,es in.Z~2 L. AHyer A-5 &n'ey 4.some. frdiny sf sJs: +- asaad sL2 d& tLk,omeda.u--- w 14o effeen. Laryy did..n.o?- k oa) tL' proadu~. /srae. Ate. .2 uls.is f romised b On[sut 6L. Israe. a'.a%. e 4 9 [ -g. 7
L,0 :.r r v @# ;y g ;- ~ ' ',P w p w a;bn i, 7c g\\; ~ V $.; t u m m u,o m voc :
- v. o O
E sd P.ad, e. % at b .. -.h bM 2! $ Y.'. N WW O V1i 1I; Vf@ M.' i ) ,L L I M %M.L.T l h4;E6t(L. Ytt.b'F.MM A C10b) I T 1 M.s R1PumNcu: wrracauuur s u.rrut.-H.t - . Yo \\)i docw:ui. , 3 / Lt. E', S 0 0.-t t c T ; LT+FF h c.c M.*t i T x t.wt s, 5 ATNkt.er.u 7 W rn.v
- v. >Uo %
No.k b etVu er, ~ ./.1) %u 0 +'t c-r. A atst.rt 4 3 lt n ue. m u n w. m nu (.gwy s maw y . r.) g r . Yes.c b [ 4-e.c -t \\ . d e x h a.. D -a &. ; J m.1 . GA sf. A
- m F
- a' %- P+/9e fmp w ~ 1( 0 7Xc i Eds/-14:ba%rka.4 x A c - i.co k f d~zL m-% p.u w 1 QR dhu. j myu.ak d. 7L rar / a' ~pc a$4 A ct 1 f'dh.m l}\\ ~~ ML.,af' u..,. M t 1j j.{ ; dx elu.u /1-;d-t um/ de/~~
f. ndMerw ndzh</ Ndf we Au./&&u (np-m). aw d ga 9 - i% -w a 4,.4 3 L C. K h A 4' ' ' % g a n,- w w a p. ~ W m ,a w &ee 9 p& sssw.9 m 6.w \\ Q ~a n d a 4 A. J ~ J al d.4 -Je dd.f & J.t y& a ~~t n M--!!i 21 I C W l Ok 4 :.do d a edm %qc -6//n % a c A t t - k. J L mw &s g- / ~~ l Of YL Ms~r E M 4/ &,#f A ~ 4 n d5dL 9F/M -f Aduf M py& I k Mt ws& a- - 5, d e /. A J f& !l ..........+,....s-...
7, r/c_ n-L y e .e wae-- % d &,. TL_. c +/9e A-A d J-/ e 7 [I stf h.:~L d/M: b.J-M ? L .a -t a Ld tl L d ce L V~ l 'S.fl 7 N '~" / 4 A o
- r" '~ 3
~ ~ g d. 4 g 4 P-g ud. i >Ue j.j (D A ._M& ma/m q^S"- '6 N Q [S% ,{ l. L ~ W hl q c C ' w y. { TILT el c?k y 10 o b+uw I ~ l g) any G.4 a anc-p w xc ma. p +4 A M g Aa-4 ~q{,e. ge scoy. ); s nu 1%wg G A /.WW -~ s=; ar ypup~ 5 m s ao~, L-g 15 dd a Ob g e'#/m*c % 4-ti p
- s,=d [ht%
}
[li( C hk<\\ h G _~ i.s uf)a/, .1.ul ^ w y 1 a -atz S. WJ \\ l u. (O A q V J/.. 2~~ A ' & m. ~
- f. <
4 W - Y L M EuNJ m.- 1' 7L. go e u.L - ~ / du Y u do 4 i e = Mdec/ w ( w r .2:~- su -n nu, M&n64 f .utQ puy&y // t f l .A aa -f LT p & q.de w k %5 Lit AQ f Aum /- L . -p wp. s n_- .+ - u, 'p JG,M f a' w-E - 4 -#d<
- A@Js f
ad t ~e/ w } ~ ed 3 j.f M 4Mh hM 2 @&vac-m ~LC & 7rr~ g tk* ~ 1
- t
-G%.J4 1, }k J n J J d' g~ ( a ln n.dui au-mluf. mqqe e, 4 4% u/ c >a
1 4 J &f ' d 4 7 m _, i cladyad JL \\ _Af A 2 ) ?! - pe/ge JA & n.CMZ & WWb Tu 2C - m$$ f 0 [ n+ As ~c & ner d&A ~ A
- x. h +
t n .u 6 x/g>6 fa2' p s 7L o & + 9 9 9' 6 p g x-J dan-4 J~ & n y~dd- ~ A -% -nrm ~ sam phd Ny4 d. p A &L x,,J 4 Ja y' d - ~~~1;&ffaL J a/ A ~ axw& vp - r r / w p/ p p M. ddb { e A ws X"-LX '1 1 w ar hm '_ m'd -. Jg,, i [ F_ ' ) __ ----= ~= w =ed A5 ,4 .mAM4h afM ^Y -C--
e m s k ---,a---m a + 9 9 h [,; - c l :~ ',,, j I[' Y & 4 +sdi o. L J p: p .s c. NJ dodr4 S'q glqc. W 3 ,4lA._ m m, ;e, &%i au ug am
- A l, f a sy+d AlaL/
~ A , s$17. ?- /% fik di Ap sy & cJ Di~ 'Y^~nnyyh{ \\ j.L9;...rl ! ;. y ; % '.:., <;i ' 7;;.,- j 5, ~ h W wr w!P%lE 4 AJ E bh/df,Ma/&.m?y$5Q n %fh r ai n,w gg O?k fl Ss%lL M977 s d4mst & T Jn.c w & J J., /a -,-~'c~ ~d dyl4 K A-yra,ma au n v uafw da m s & n/f f y 4 -ax A p !? ducfn. 7L ~a-Y u W Mf M sy n g y p / & / ~ + u %,.-. w / T +p / at e9 a c y,$N S _ % 6 W 9 9 9 m(/4-f5 ~ udd.Aud s~/- U ^
,g 7 c. h.. N [^ $$1k k
- ^-
A tL O A Aa 1 9ffi13 b t i "1 N gw-_n,sx. te -L -A m s - s,.,u. s l IJir k&- d d hL;, %. g& JJ w. 7 d )~ _r ad a / M."h Y l -d L rwve i A _ By s uTrt;+ n a N w. s 2 a n p- / f ~ s trL:ye A.d ~_ y -Aq n f ' Aw-s el d' d i f d
1 ) & '4 ?- ~CE? @ Ml % D a.L,/s. A c A qqw ms % E & J A g far-L 1 em, O h6 g A,// ddJl% d']y ccA Ad L "f Tnr sr A-dm g-/. ~ N" f $g! eab9Wf['ti 4 o g 7L. (B) M %&J K M p d e - ~ g /x x ? ~ ogf ZD -J~/M. m &/ 390 a ci - PP -/v, 6 . If d f f-/D - V Y. >h h &h TitrSf[ d 4 .f
[ * 9 = g... I I g, T } L%.- L) L= v tm 4 ty-h { 4 r5 4 fn Ad g A:A-a -Ack-m W v7 nd+ ; n s. Per t P Mi ,qdi y A Ad v. ~.. ~ -p (i k _ %\\.2 % f %0 V i<cr ' qwlq e. L eelct. 4 b, I f i t aae a i _7 di k 6~ .. -. ~
N i MAR 2 21985 . MEMORANDUM FOR: V. Noonan, Director I Comanche Peak Project 't i FROM: , H. H. Livermore, QA/QC Group Leader l'
SUBJECT:
OPEN TRT STAFF COMMITMENTS In the exit meeting with allegers conducted at the Granbury Inn on Dec.10, 1984, you and Mr. Zudans made commitments to perform additional work of an investigatory nature. Most of the verbal commitments were made while 2 discussing the QA/QC group allegations (AQ) and therefore may possibly Iy delay final release of the SSERs. These items are detailed in the transcript i on pages 23, 30, 81, 82, 83, 94, 98, 101, 102, 103, 107, 111-114, 121-123, 157, 158, 163-165. Please advise as to your or Mr. Zudans' follow-up or disposition of these items. cA c<.eer %- H. H. Livemore, TRT QA/QC Group Leader i cc: J. Zudans i C. Poslusny l A. Viett.i [ 4 I DISTRIBUTION: L. Shao H. Livermore 4 i t l U eh TRT QA/QC CP l H. Livermore i 3/ /85 5 v v :.. & ) ) $.. V P l... Q{i,(dI( [-VX.) - .}}