ML20197J296

Advises That ANI Rept 371 Alleged That Welder Identification Was Not Traceable on Subj Supports & That Nov ANI Repts Will Not Ref Specific Rept Number Due to Qa/Qc Group Not Addressing Same Specifics in Rept

ML20197J296
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak, 05000000
Issue date:	02/07/1985
From:	Livermore H NRC - COMANCHE PEAK PROJECT (TECHNICAL REVIEW TEAM)
To:	Noonan V NRC - COMANCHE PEAK PROJECT (TECHNICAL REVIEW TEAM)
Shared Package
ML20197J178	List: IR 05000445/1985009 ML20197J173 ML20197J273 ML20197J296 ML20199G064 ML20199G070 ML20199G083 ML20199G092 ML20199G099 ML20199G107 ML20199G116 ML20199G119 ML20199G124 ML20199G133 ML20199G146 ML20199G154 ML20199G163 ML20199G179 ML20199G212 ML20199G284 ML20199G292 ML20199G298 ML20199G306 ML20199G318 ML20199G331 ML20199G343 ML20199G352 ML20199G363 ML20199G383 ML20199G391 ML20199G402 ML20199G420 ML20199G432 ML20199G442 ML20199G453 ML20199G464 ML20199G575 ML20199G614 ML20199G620 ML20199G624 ML20199G630 ML20199G635 ML20199G641 ML20199G645 ML20199G649 ML20199G655 ML20199G661 ML20199G670 ML20199G675 ML20199G681 ... further results
References
FOIA-85-59 NUDOCS 8502150355
Download: ML20197J296 (1)

Text

'

,v-

- /pu n s%

Q a

• UNITED STATES y

E j

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

~

L E.

WASHINGTON. D. C. 20555

%,*.c. /

R.M A

• TES 7 15 0/.c Lckb E (M W.:

,[\\

Docket Nos:

50-445/446 l"

rw MEFORANDUM FOR:

Vincent S'. Noonan, Director hkN Comanche Peak Project

[

FROM:

Herbert H. Livermore, QA/QC Group leader Comanche Peak Technical Review Team

SUBJECT:

CASE LETTER TO GEARY S. MIZUNO REGARDING ANI REPORTS AT COMANCHE PEAK A CASE letter of August 14, 1984, provided Mr. Mizuno an example of a Comanche Peak Class II pipe support that was upgraded to Class I.

The subject ANI 1

Report 371 (Exhibit 1056) was reviewed by the TRT while on-site at Comanche

~ Peak.

The infomation provided in those documents did not alter our assessment and conclusions in AQ 12 and 13, which considered the same subject.

The TRT QA/Oc crnuo investigated the program and nrne=d"*a< for

. upgrading material / ANI Report 371, pesides addressing material upgrading, specifica ly alleged that welder identific3.tjon _was__not traceable, on the subject supports.

(forwhichIcannotspeak.This area ~was th the purview of the TRT Mechanical Gro A. Vietti again forwarded the CASE /Mizuno letter, plus some 36 ANI reports to 1

the QA/QC Group for review in November. The subject ANI reports span a period of 1982-1983 and, as the CODE requires, a report to TUEC on the status and/or problems encountered with specifics in the TUEC ASME QA/QC Program. The TRT QA/QC Group has reviewed these ANI reports and notes that although we did not address the same specifics, our assessments and conclusions in the SSERs include the same type of problems and examples. The review did not' alter our assessment.

Since we did not address the same specifics noted in the ANI reports, our SSERs will not reference any specific ANI report number.

/NtY Z'H'<P2 U erbert H. Livermore, QA/QC Group Leader Comanche Peak Technical Review Team i

l l

cc:

C. Hale A. Vietti l

GA/QC Group V

85G3 5@355 Jp i

Xp 1

- - -