ML19351F512
| ML19351F512 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Fort Saint Vrain  |
| Issue date: | 09/26/1980 |
| From: | Glover F, Johns J, Swart F THORNE ECOLOGICAL INSTITUTE |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19351F508 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8101130400 | |
| Download: ML19351F512 (256) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:. ; O Final Peport covering the period 9 1972 - 1979
~
ECOLOGICAL MONITORING FORT ST. VRAIN NUCLEAR GElERATI?iG STATI0ft 9 for Public Service Company
- of Colorado e
by Thorne Ecological Institute le 4860 Riverbend Road Boulder, Colorado O Dr. Fred A. Glover Project Director 4
- g io iI59 4w
l D 1 l D D FORT ST. VRAIN NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION ECOLOGICAL MONITORING PROGRAM D Final Report covering the period D 1972 - 1979 Prepared by:/s/ " N- k' y 7F. Fred A.' Glover, Project Director, Thorne Date Ecological Institute Reviewe k . 7 ent [
/
[8 D6te 3 Fort ~3t. Vrai& H Q Physics D Reviewed by:/s/ ( es- 7/26/80 N g/ogetDeparf.me Dite y:/s/ xi Ao . tm OfEG Nplear Project Department ' ' Date' D D D
8 O TABLE OF CONTENTS O Pace 1 Summary . .............................. 7 () Introduction ....... . ..... ....... .... 9 Investigator Reports ................ .. . .. Aquatic Section ..... .................. 10 11 () Invertebrates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 75 Avian Section .... .... ............. . 99 Terrestrial Section . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 116 C) Vegetation ............... . . . . . . . 117 Ecophysiological Characteristics ............138 q) Mammals, Amphibians and Reptiles ............163 Invertebrates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 91 Literature Cited ........................ . 215 s () 1 O f O O nv
l 6 iO . 1 I i iO 1 I !O l i i J 'O !O i 4
SUMMARY
2 iO sO l i !O !O i f iO 4 } e
- O
O 2 General Sumary 9 This final report present, non-radiation, environmental data covering the general period 1972-1979. For the most part, the Fort St. Vrain envi-rons have maintained comparable quality over the years monitored, with local area and environmental component independent, natural variations. All environmental components have experienced difficulty in determining c?use and effect relationships because of the intemittent, irregular, and limited operation of the Nuclear Generating Station. Based on the information available, no discernible, harmful effects on the biological environment are evident. O Aouatic Section Invertebrates The macroinvertebrate corrunity is composed of taxa tolerant of g moderate pollution. The various collection stations had similar faunas each seasor, eacn ; ear. Eight orders of irsects and six non-insect inver-tebrate groups were collected with Dip +pa and Oligochaeta dominating. O Chironomidae were the most abundant in numbers and taxa. Ai.alysis of tne chemical parameters of the aquatic environments did not reveal any abnormal or unexpected conditions. Because of data vagaries, analysis O of water temperature regimes possibly created by Generating Station operation and the effects on the macroinvertebrate aquatic community was inconclusive. 9 Fish Collections have been m.ade in both the St. Vrain and South Platte Rivers over the years. Species composition has rerained about the same. G 9
O 3 Most of the species are regarded as being pollution tolerant. Fish foods have varied but in the main the items taken (numbers, kinds, and volume) have reflected relative availability of the organisms. O ^I9^* There has been a general similarity in species composition and numbers with variations seasonally and by sites, while species diversity g has remained consistently low in all aquatic habitats. The algae present indicate polluted conditions and apparently no direct effects from the Generating Station. O Avian Section Regular censuses were conducted from 1972-1979 of the birds utilizing the Generating Station area. During this census period avian populations O fluctuated widely and no specific trend was apparent. A seannal pattern was evident with species pre;ent usually highest in May. Avian diversity has remained rather constant. Environmental impacts other than the O Nuclear Generating Station have had the greatest effects upon the birds. Terrestrial Section Vegetation O Data obtained from pennanent exclosures have indicated an increase in production values as a result of release from grazing pressure. However, the native perennial grasses apparently have not had sufficient O time to increase. To date, the Nuclear Generating Station has had little or no apparent inf.dence on the vegetation communities of the area. It is believed that Station operational consistency 'over a longer period' O of time will be needed to evaluate probable effects on vegetation. O
~ 4 O Ecophysiological Ch m eteristics In general, leaf area injured decreased with time during the growing seasons for most years of study. Elemental concentrations in samples of kochia and cottonwood were influenced little by distance or direction from the Generating Station. Five chemical constituents (P, Ca, Zn, Fe, O and SO 4
-S) in pinto bean plants from the controlled experiment increased in concentration after Station startup. Heavy metals (Hg, Pg, and Cd) did not change with Station startup. O Mamals, Amphibians and Reptiles Mammalian species composition has been similar over the survey years, except that the thirteen-lined and spotted ground squirrels have not been observed recently. Deer mice and house mice are the most comon species and their numbers appear to have stabilized. The other mamals have O ! hown greater fluctuation. Amphibians and reptiles have remained about the same in response to temperature and moisture conditions. Few seasonal or yearly differences occurred in heavy metal (Pb, Zn, and Cu) concentra-O tions in Microtus tissues. In amphibians the heavy metal situation was affectea by local water conditions. Changes in numbers and species of mamals, amphibians and reptiles cannot be related to Station operation, O
but rather, seem to be influenced by agricultura, activities. Terrestrial Invertebrates Collembola, Formicidae, Silpha ramosa, and Araneida were used as e biological indicators of stress conditions from operation of the Nuclear Generating Station. Collembola distribution was generally uniform but population levels varied considerably. Formicidae populations were g 9
() 5 similar from three sample areas. Both Collembola and Formicidae O experienced variations, which were regarded as natural fluctuations. Silcha ramosa populations are related to the availability of small mammal carcasses. Over the survey period there were population decreases and recoveries; all regarded as typical, natural variations. The general populations of Araneida are declining in the vicinity of the Station but the cause is not kncwn.
. C) o e O
iC) i ' C) i i i i() l t l l O t O
6 C Fort St. Vrain Generation Sumary 9 Dates witn Number of Gross 51ectric Da- Without Generation Year and Month Generation Generation MWH 1976 g December 11-31 10 23,842 1977 January 1-30 1 49,580 Februa ry 0 28 0 8 Ma rch 31 30 587 Acril 2-8 23 8,333 May 8-12, 14, 16-22 18 13,743 June 0 30 0 July 22, 23 29 1,150 August 6, 8-13, 17-18, 20-24 17 15,468 9 September 4-8, 12-30 6 46,519 October 1-25, 27-31 1 79,146 November 13-17, 20-30 14 46,509 December 0 31 0 O 1978 January 13-23 20 34,290 February 0 28 0 March 0 31 0 April 4-19, 21-30 4 65,850 May 1-8, 10-26, 28-31 2 99,073 9 June 1-6, 12-29 6 98,459 July 3-14, 17-31 5 85,839 Aug'us t 18, 19, 21-31 18 14,496 September 1-8 23 25,147 October 5-12, 14-17, 31 18 24.880 November 1-29 1 110,594 g December 9-31 8 92,583 1979 January 1-19, 23- ll 3 109,306 Februa ry* 1 27 546 g March
- O 31 0 Apri1* 0 30 0 May* 0 31 0 June
- 0 30 0 July
- 23, 26-28, 30, 31 25 4,522 August 3-17, 20-24, 26-31 5 88,079 ,
September 1 29 1,828 October 2-14, 24-26 15 46,367 November 0 30 0 December 0 31 0
- Refueling outage February 1 - July 22, 1979. ,
I
J - O 7 a 4 0 i i 1
;O 4
1 1
!O
) .O 1 1 1 4 INTRODUCTION
- O 1
O i i
- l
- O l
lo i I lo r O
.. - .- . .- , . -_,,.. --.. - .- ...-~ _..- -.-.-- . - ..-___-_ -. - - . _ - . _ _ _
8 Introduction O This final report presents summarized, non-radiological, environ-mental monitoring information concerned with the period 1972-1979. Baseline environmental studies were conducted at the Fort St. Vrain site 9 in 1971 and a pre-NEPA environmental recort was prepared. Additional background information on soils, vegetation taxonomy, water chemistry, and hydrology was obtained about the environs of the Nuclear Generating O Station and reported upon (Glover, 1976), which provided a biological benchmark for the initiation of the Station monitoring program. Throughout the period covered by this report there have been only minor changes in personnel. The Thorne Ecological Institute has been the sole contractor involved. Each investigator has operated on an individual field schedule and program. However, there are many instances of interdisciplinary, coordinated, cooperative efforts, The Thorne team has met with Public Service Company representatives as needed for reporting, interaction, coordination, discussions about progress, and the resolving of operational problems. The intemittent, irregular, and limited operation of the Nuclear Generating Station has made it difficult or impossible to develop usable cause and effect data. Based on the information available, no discernible, O hamful effects on the biological environment are evident to date. O O O
a ,__ n, a, . --._.- m A _ ,-- - .u. - a.- -a-P 9
.O 4
1 4 i 'O l l I a .1
,0 l
} I NVESTIGATOR REPORTS
- O n
! O i } }
- O t
t i i .o } ) .'O I i
!O 4
I
l i O 10 O O 1 i O e AQUATIC SECTION e O 9 l 9 O O
t iO j 11 4 i + i 1 l IO l t t J t i O i 1 1 1 AQUATIC INVERTEBRATE MONITORING
;O l
t I !O i O by ' Clarence A. Carlson O and l David L. Propst i 1 lO i lO O 1 1 'O
O 12 INTRODUCTION 9 Routine monitoring of the aquatic fauna of the South Platte and St. Vrain Rivers in the vicinity of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Colorado, began on a regular basis in May 1974. Baseline studies e on the aquatic fauna were initiated in 1971 and continued intermittently through 1973. The baseline data were presented in several reports, theses and publications (Galat and McConnell 1974; Eder, Carlson and Fronk 1974; e Carlson 1976a, Carlson 1976b; Johnson 1972; Eder 1974; and Eder and Carlson 1977). An environmental impact analysis was completed for the Public Service Company of Colorado in 1971. g Biweekly macroinvertebrate and annual fish collections were made to determine if the effluent discharged into the South Platte River by the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station would have a discernible effect g upon the resident macroinvertebrate and/or fish communities. Detectic, of changes depended upon the resolution ability of the techniques employed. Confounding analysis of possible effects of Station effluent was the , import of various organic and inorganic pollutants from upstream. Near the Station, the South Platte River (and the St. Vrain River to a lesser extent) is tremendously modified from its natural, histcrical ,- condition. Industrial and municipal wastes are discharged into the river _ , at a number of points. Runoff from agricultural lands exacerbates the enrichment of the system. Dams and irrigation withdrawal and return O reduce the amplitude of natural seasonal and diurnal flow fluctuations. Diminution of spring runoff reduces the flushing capability of the stream. Higher than natural summer flows expand available habitat for aquatic 9 fauna. O
O 13 Near the Station, both streams have been characterized as being in a recovery phase (Stacey 1977). The natural restorative ability of the South Platte enables it to pror.ess a portion of the pollutants introduced upstream, particularly those introduced in the vicinity of Denver. g However, this characterization is relative. Runoff from agricultural l lands and municipal wastes from several comunities along the river introduces additional pollutants that retard the natural processing O ability of the stream. Water for power generation is drawn primarily from the-South Platte River. After its utilization in the Station, it is directed to Goosequill Pond via Goosequill Ditch. From Goosequill Pond, it enters the South Platte River approximately 120 m upstream from the confluence of the South Platte and St. Vrain Rivers (Figure 1). Utilization of St. Vrain River water and contingency discharge into it are permitted by the Station's license but have not normally occurred. Thus, the primary monitoring emphasis has been on the South Platte River.
- O The heated and nutrient-enriched character of the effluent was con-sidered most likely to cause changes in the macroinvertebrate and/or fish comunities. Although algicide was used to control algal growth in lO the cooling towers, no specific effort was made to detennine its relative effects on aquatic invertebrates, Addition of heated effluent tends to dampen natural thermal cycles
- O or may increase normal sumer highs. The particular effect of the heated 3
effluent depends upon the degree of change, the season, and the rate of discharge. Altered temperature may manifest itself in several ways O' depending upon the magnitude and duration of the change. Ward (1976)- f
, ,,v,-+ , w .- , , + , e.m,.--w ,w , -mr - ,. _ . - - - .-,,#- -.--.c .. . - , , - , ,+-_-m ..r,, - ---- ,
C 14 e
\
Cl
// -
SP4B C SP4A-0
/ SP40 1 e
~~
SV5 ' Goose-quill SP4A-N
) Pond 9
I' I L
) .
Fort St. " SV2 g Vrain _ 1
) Nuclear j senerating g u
-> Station s o cr. :
C es 5 \
?
a
- v. a .
>
- e L
Figure 1. Location of sampling sites on the South Platte and St. Vrain Rivers in the vicinity of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station near Platteville, Colorado, May 1974 - December 1979. O O
D 15 reported reduced diversity but greater biomass of the macroinvertebrate D conmunity in a themally-constant environment below a reservoir. Many foms are keyed to a particular temperature for initiation of different
, phases of their life cycles (Khoo 1968). Other foms are synchronized with rather specific numbers of degree days for initiation of different developmental stages (Hynes 1970a). Many invertebrates are adversely affected by very slight changes in temperature (Knight and Gauflin 1963, Lehmkuhl 1972, Brittain 1977, Coricum 1978 and Elliott 1978). Sweeney and Vannote (1978) found that warmer-than-nomal temperatures accelerated nymphal development; this resulted in more rapid maturation but smaller adults that were less fecund than their relatives in more " natural" e nvi ror.ments. The manifestation of varied temperature requirements is continuous replacement of one species by another throughout the year.
D Such a replacement series results in a more diverse invertebrate com-munity as interspecific (and intraspecific) competition is reduced. Goosequill Pond serves as a cooling sump for the heated effluent from the Station. The constant (or relatively constant) pulse of water through the pond creates a polymictic lentic ecosystem in which nutrients are continuously cycled. Agricultural runoff augments the enricnment of the system. Such a situation in association with the introduction of heated water from the Generating Station prolongs the growing season of the phytoplankton. Thus, the discharge from Goosequill Pond is enriched J by the nutrients circulateo from the bottom of the pond and by phyto-and zooplankton nurtured in the pond. The impact of the heated and nutrient-enriched discharge upon the fauna of the South Platte River D depends upon the extent of the dilution of the effluent. Enrichment D
O 16 may enhance a nomally comparatively-sterile environment or may " overload" e it to the detriment of all but the more tolerant forms. Distinguishing the relative effects of altered thermal regimes from those of increased nutrient load is probably impossible in the present O study. Indeed, the effort may be specious as the two are intimately related in the studied system. The effect of the effluent is obviously dependent upon the extent of dilution; tne periodicity, timing, and 9 duration of the discharge; and the characteristics of the effluent as compared to those of the South Platte River. Station operation began in December 1976 and has continued inter-mittently since then (Table 1). Level of operation per month has varied greatly. Suca irregular operation makes correlations between Station operation and changes in aquatic faunal communities rather difficult. Changes noted may be an artifact of nomal, " natural" cycles, or they may be the result of the effects of the effluent. O 0 l e l l 9 9
O O O O O O O O O O O Table 1. Number of days of power generation per month of the fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. 1976 1977 1978 1979
# days w/ # days w/o # days w/ # days w/o # days w/ # days w/o # days w/ # days w/o generation generation generation generation generation generation generation generation January --
31 30 1 11 20 28 3 February -- 29 -- 28 -- 28 1 27 March -- 31 1 30 --
- 3) -- 31 April --
30 7 23 26 4 -- 30 May -- 31 13 18 29 2 -- 31 June -- 30 -- 30 24 6 -- 30 July -- 31 2 29 26 5 6 25 August -- 31 14 17 13 18 26 5 Septenber -- 30 24 6 7 23 1 29 October -- 31 30 1 13 18 16 15 Novenber -- 30 16 14 29 1 -- 30 December 21 10 -- 31 23 8 -- 31
O 18 METHODS Aquatic macroinvertebrates were collected by two methods and com-bined for analysis. A triangular aquatic insect net was suspended in the water column below the worker as he traversed the stream for 10 8 min. A " kick sample" consisted of those invertebrates disturbed from the substrate which were washed into the net. Organic debris was
" picked" for 5 min. The kick sample was typically subsampled with a 8
rotating carousel. However, occasional lack of availability of the subsampler required placing the sample in an enamel pan divided into eight equal sections, spreading invertebrates uniformly throughout the pan, and picking one randomly-chosen section. Kick-sample invertebrates were stained with Rose Bengal to facilitate enumeration. The inverte-brates from the kick subsample and pick sample were identified to 8 lowest feasible taxonomic level (usually genus or family). Carlson et al. (1974) established pemanent collection sites at SP4A-0, SP48 and Cl in May 1974. Samples were taken at these stations (except SP4A-0) for the remainder of the study. Station SP4U was established as a 9 pemanent site by Carlson, et al. (1975) in April 1975. In July 1977, SP4A-0 was discontinued and SP4A-N was added as a pemanent site 9 (Carlson et al. 1977). Sites were selected to enable assessment and evaluation of possible effects of Station effluent upon the aquatic macroinvertebrate fauna in the South Platte River. Thus, one control site was located above the discharge points of Goosequill Pond, and 9 several experimental sites were below. Beaver activity below Goosenuill Pond and abnomally-high discharges occasionally caused Goosequill Ditch to empty into the South Platte River at points other than its nomal e O
G 19 discharge point. Such exigencies required site movement, discontinuation, O and/or addition to ensure the integrity of the control site. Annual fish colleci. ions comenced at two permanent stations each on the South Platte and St. Vrain Rivers in 1975 and continued until the O termination of the project. Fish were collected with electro-fishing gear of various models. All fish collocted at each site were identi-fied and enumerated. On several occasions, weights and lengths of some 3 or all fish were taken. Fish sampling was nomally done in the autumn of each year. Chemical and physical data were collected at each pemanent station O on each macroinvertebrate sampling date. Dissolved oxygen and alkalinity were measured according to Standard Methods (APHA et al.1973). Turbidity and pH were measured with a Hach Turbidimeter and a Corning O pH meter, respectively. Hardness was measured with a Hach Field Ecology ki t. In 1975, filtrable solids, conductivity and dissolved carbon dioxide were added to the parameters measured. Filtrable solids were O calculated according to Standard Methods (APHA et al.1978), conductivity was detemined with a Bechman Conductivity Bridge, and dissolved carbon dioxide was estimated with a nomograph. In July 1978, dissolved solids detemination was added and was measured according to Standard Methods D (APHA et al. 1973). Air and water temperature were measured with a mercury themometer. From 1975 until project temination, the Shannon-Weaver Index of 9 General Diversity (Wilhm and Dorris 1968), MacArthur's Index of Equitibility (MacArthur 1957 and Lloyd and Ghelardi 1964), and Brinkhurst's (1968) Trophic Condition Index values were calculated 3 D
O 20 quarterly for macroinvertebrates using a Fortran IV program, ECODIV, O developed by Galat, Keefe, and Bergersen (1974). Analysis of variance tests (A0V) were perfonned to determine if there were significant differences in selected macroinvertebrate numbers per month for each station for different years and among stations for the Jame year. The same test was applied to ECODIV values on the same basis. Water temperatures of the South Platte River were rec 'rded every 8 hours by Public Service Co. cany personnel. These data were made available to the authors for assessment of the effect of possible temperature regime alteration upon the structure of the macroinvertebrate community of the South Platte River. Temperatures were averaged for am and om readings for each day. Monthly means were calculated for above and below effluent discharge readings. Analysis of variance tests were performed to datermine O if there were significant differences in water temperatures for each month, 1974-1979 ( am and pm; above and below effluent discharge), between stations above and below effluent discharge ( am and pm ) for each month O (1975-1979), and for each month ( am. and pm; above and below effluent discharge) before (June 1974-November 1976) and after (December 1976-December 1979) initiation of Generating Station operation. O The data presented herein are a synthesis of work done by five researchers from 1974 through 1979. Whenever one worker replaced another, the two worked together for at least 1 month to ensure continuity of methods. However, some difference in techniques and skills were unavoid- O able. Standardization was enhance by one person (C. A. Carlson) reviewing all work and constantly assessing the methods and techniques of each W. Don Frank served as a special consultant to confirm ioentiff- O worker. cation of unusual or difficult-to-identify macroinvertebrates. O
O 21 RESULTS O Macroinvertebrates The macroinvertebrate comunity of the South Platte River near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station is composed primarily of taxa O tolerant of at least moderate pollution levels. The series of collec-tion stations had similar faunas each season and each year. Differences resulted primarily from rarely-collected unusual forms and changes in O the relative abundance of some more-common forms. Similarities were more marked prior to power plant operation than after. Within the sampling area, the habitat was rather uniform among stations; thus, O differences would normally be minimal. With the initiation of effluent discharge into the South Platte River from Goosequill Pond, changes were apparent in the macroinvertebrate comunity below the discharge O point. An annual periodicity of abundance of individuals and taxa was observed (Table 2). Fewest taxa were collected at all stations in 1975 O and 1976. Relatively-low numbers were collected at SP4B and Cl in 1977. In 1978, there was a marked increase in taxon numbers at all stations. In 1979, fewer taxa were collected at all stations, except SP48, but O' numbers were not as low as in 1975 or 1976. Seasonal cycles in taxon numbers were observed. In sites unaffected by Station effluent and affected sites prior to Station operation, O an early peak in numbers occurred in February with a subsequent diminu-In July, taxon tion in March and a gradual increase through June. numbers reached rather high levels and generally remained high through O October. By November, taxon numbers began to decrease and reached low levels in December comparable to those collected in January (Figure 2). O y i
C 22 Table 2. Number of taxa collected each month for each station during the stuay, 1974-1979. O Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec SP4A-0 1975 14 12 10 11 10 12 4 16 14 14 11 10 , 1976 8 8 3 9 5 9 15 19 13 12 12 9 1977 2 8 9 7 11 12 SP4A-N 1977 18 14 17 18 13 12 , 1978 9 9 12 10 14 i 17 21 21 18 18 7 1979 10 11 14 11 14 -- 16 16 14 14 10 5 SP4U 1975 6 9 2 7 12 16 10 15 10 1976 8 8 3 9 5 8 20 21 10 13 13 5 1977 5 10 6 8 11 15 16 14 14 16 14 9 1978 10 11 12 13 9 13 16 19 18 22 12 8 1979 12 15 12 13 -- 15 15 13 14 12 11 11 e SP4B 1974 10 17 18 23 20 18 14 16 1975 12 17 14 10 11 4 9 13 13 13 13 10 1976 7 12 9 8 8 9 13 16 15 9 9 10 1977 5 11 8 8 8 15 17 10 15 16 15 12 1978 8 11 7 10 12 14 17 16 17 20 17 7 1979 12 16 11 16 17 -- 17 16 IS 19 12 10 C1 19 16 19 11 13 1974 11 15 19 1975 19 15 12 16 11 3 6 17 15 15 19 10 1976 9 13 7 5 9 11 13 13 9 11 11 8 1977 6 10 5 7 10 10 13 11 10 14 11 12 20 21 17 16 4 8 1978 10 9 10 7 11 16 15 1979 12 14 11 12 11 -- 17 15 14 13 16 10 0 0
23 O o a) g 16 . ,s
\
\
o / s ' s v 14 . __' s' ' O = x \ [
/ ,
e \
~ -
e 12 s \ u ' ' S= s '
-- ~
' ' \Cl-before Statica l j 10
\' ' operation
'O e Cl-after Station E / operation
=
1 i e a a a a L b) O 2 -18
".; s i- s i e #
! - 16 r
- f s b '
i g
- I4 -
's -
!O /\ i s / \ / s s s- 12 -
' s s
f ' _SP48-before Station e i t . s operation I q , s r f 1 m i l i: 10 . i
- SP4B-after Station g
. peration
!O
? )
i I . . . . . . . . . , , , l l l lO 7 . c) a 8 16 - (.s,
- r. ' . s.,
5 la . jf k #k.. m ;\ jF '% C 4 12 -
' /../ ' .s ./s $'.s
- s. .,i # ,.
-'.~i 0:s.SP48 (1974-1979)
\.*
o i
. /
y 10 _'\ '..# 1,, ~ s i U.Cl (1974-1979) p/ -- X
= s. .. . \.
~~
SP4U (1974-1979)
/ SP4A(1974-1979)
O z J F M A M J J A -S 0 N O r Figure 2. Mean number of taxa collected each month at'each station during the study, 1974-1979. lO i i ' .~_-...,,.,,w,_..._<,., .v_._,. ,, .,.- m. .. ,- .-_ _. _.,,.,... ,. m -y .~ .,+,..,~,,.,.,.,,m.,...-,~mg.,,,.-,,-,,,-,-....._a
O 24 The nomal cycle of tn .n numbers changed at SP4B arid C1 after Generating Station operation b.et.1,although the pattern persisted. Taxon number g increase occurred earlier, and the high number lasted longer. Normally, the macroinvertebrate comunity of a site was composed g of a few rather-abundant organisms and a number of rarer, less-comen foms . Since 1974, 133 macroinvertebrate taxa have been collected in the South Platte River (Table 3). Of these, 83 (62%) were very rare, , 28 (21%) were rare,12 (9%) uncomon, 7 (5%) common, and 3 (2%) abundant. Although eight orders of insects and six non-insect invertebrate groups were collected in the study area, two groups, Diptera and , Oligochaeta, dominated the collection. Dipterans were the most speciose group, and Chironomidae were the most abundant in numbers and taxa. Simuliidae were generally comon. Of the remaining insect taxa , collected, only Baetis sp. (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae) and Hydropsyche sp. (Trichoptera: Hydropcychidae) were comon. Hyalella azteca (Amphipoda: Talitridae) was the only common non-insect besides the , Oligochaeta. Cladocerans were extremely abundant in the autumn of 1979 but were quite uncomon or absent in all other years. Differences in diversity and biotic index values were often 9 significant for the same quarter among years (Figura 3), but similar trends in values were observed through tne year for each site (Figure 3a). Thus, the second quarter (April - June) nomally had the lowest values and the 9 third quarter (July - September) had the highest. Analysis-of-variance tents did not demonstrate significant differences in index values for a particular site for each year (except EQUIT in 1979) (Table 4). Hew-O ever, significant F statistics were frequently obtained when A0V was e
4 10 25
< r i
Table 3. Aquatic macroinvertebrates collected in the South Platte River in the vicinity of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating O Station, sites collected, years collected and relative i ' I abundance. Taxa Sites Years Relative collected collected abundance jO - . . Collembola. f Isetomidae , l Is m murus palustris SP4A SP4U.SP4B,C1 74,77,78,79 VR ; a' Plecoptera ' 40 Periodidae SP4A(.N),SP4U 78 VR Ephemeruptera Siphlonuridae Siphlonurus sp. SP4A,SP4U.SP48,Cl 74. 6,77,78 R 75 VR Ameletus sp. SP4B O 8aetidae ' Baetis_ sp. SP4A,SP4U SP48,C1 74,75,76,77,78,79 C VR i Callibaetis sp. CP4A(N),SP4B,Cl 74 Centroptilum sp. SP4A,SP48,Cl 74,75 VR ! Paracloeodes sp. SP4A SP40,SP48,Cl 74 R Pseudocloeon sp. SP4A(0),SP40,SP48 75 VR Heptageniidae lO_ t Heptagenia sp. SP4A,SP40,SP48,C1 74,75,76,77,78,79 UC i Leptophlebiidae , Paraleptophlebia sp. Cl 76 VR Traverella sp. SP4U,Cl 77 VR , l > Tricorythidae ,O Tricorythodes sp. SP4A SP4U.SP48,C1 74,75,76,77,78,79 UC Caeridae Caenh :p. SP4A(N),Cl 77 VR 4
- Odonata Gomphidae Ophiogomphus sp. SP4A,SP48,C1' 74,75,77 -R ,
10 76,77,79 ; i Coenagrionidae co4U,Ci VR Argia sp. 3P4A(N),SP4U.SP48,C1 74,75,77,78,79 R i [ 74,75 Hyponeura sp. SP4B VR. ! Amphiagrion sp. .SP4A(N),Cl 78,79 VR Ischnura sp. SP4A,SP40,SP48,Cl 74,76,77,78,79 R-Enallagma sp. SP4A(0),SP40,SP48,Cl 74,75,76,77,78 R !O SP48,Cl. 74,77 VR
- Anomalagrion sp.
Hemiptera Gerridae Gerris_sp. SP4A(0),SP4U.SP48,Cl 74,77. R lO Velitoae Microvelia sp. SP4A(0),SP4USP48 76 VR Notonectidae ' 74,75 Notonecta sp. SP48,C1 . VR i
- O I
. . _ _ . _ _ . , _ _ _ _ _ . . . ~ . . _ _ . _ _ . . . . _ , - _ _ - , . . . . _ _ . , _ . ~ . _ _ . . . . _ . . , _ . _ , _ . . - _ _ _ . _ . - . . . . .
O 26 Table 3. Continued. Taxa Sites Years Relative collected collected abundance Corixidae SP4A,SP4U,C1 75,77,78,79 R Trichocorixa sp. SP4A,SP4U.SP48,C1 74,77,78 R Corisella sp. SP4B,Cl 74 VR 9 Cenocorixa sp. SP4A(0),SP4U.SP48,Cl 74,76,77,78 R Trichoptera Trichoptera pupae SP4U 78 VR Hydropsychidae Hydrophyche sp. SP4A,SP4U,SP48,C1 74,75,76,77,78,79 C e Hydroptilidae Mayatrichia sp. SP4A(N),SP4B 77 VR Agraylea sp. SP4U,Cl 78 VR Ochrotrichia sp. SP4A(N),SP4U.SP48,Cl 78,79 UC Coleoptera e Haliplidae SP4U 77 VR Peltodytes sp. SP4A(0) 75 VR Dytiscidae SP4U SP48,C1 78,79 VR Dytiscus sp. SP4A(0),SP4B 74,79 VR Laccopnilus sp. SP4A(N),P48 74.7S,79 R Agabinus sp. SP4U 79 VR e Agabetes sp. SP48,Cl 78 VR Matus sp. SP4A(0) 74 VR Noteridae SP4B 79 VR Corrhydrus sp. SP4A(0),SP48,C1 74 VR Coptotomus sp. Cl 74 VR Rhantus sp. SP4A,SP4U,SP4B,Cl 77,78 R g Hydrophilidae Helophorus sp. SP4A(N),SP4U.SP4B,C1 78,79 R Tropisternus sp. SP4A(0),SP4U SP48,C1 74,75,76 R Hvdrophilus sp. SP4A(0) 76 VR Enochrus sp. C1,SP48 75,76 VR Laccohius sp. SP48,C1,SP4A(0) 75 R , Hydrooius sp. Cl 74 VR Diptera Tipulidae SP4A,SP4U,SP4B,C1 75,76,77,78,79 R fipula sp. SP4A(N),SP4U,SP4B 77,78 VR Pedicia sp. Cl 79 VR , Hexatoma sp. SP4A(N),SP4B,C1 78,79 VR Psychodidae SP4A(N),SP4U.SP48,C1 75,76,77 R Psychoda sp. SP4A(N),SP4U.SP48 79 VR Simuliidae Simuliidae pupae SP4U 78,79 R Simulium sp. SP4A,SP4U,SP4B,C1 74,76,76,88,78,79 C SP4A,SP4U SP48,C1 78,79 8 Chironomidae UC Chironomidae pupae SP4A,SP4U.SP48,Cl 77,78,79 UC Tanypodinae Tanypus sp. SP4A 77,78 VR Procladius sp. SP4A(0),Cl 75,76 VR O
O 27 Table 3. Cor.tinued. O Years Relative Taxa Sites collected collected abundance Clinotanypus sp. 75 VR SP4A(0) Conchapelopia_sp. SP4A,SP4U,SP48,C1 7",76,76,77,78,79 UC G Diamesinae Diamesa_sp. SP4A,SP4U.SP4B 75,76,77,78,79 R Pseudodiamesa_sp. SP4B 76,78,79 VR Pottnastia sp. SP43 77 VR Monodiamesa sp. SP4B 78 VR 3 Orthocladinae Brillia sp. SP4A(0),SP48,C1 74,75 VR Thienemanniella sp. SP4A(N),Cl 78,79 VR Smittia sp. SP4U 79 VR Eukiefferiella sp. SP4A(0),SP4U.SP4B Cl 75,76 VR Psectrocladius sp. SP4A,SP4U,SP48,C1 74,76,77,78,79 R g Cricotopus sp. SP4A,SP4U.SP48,C1 74,75,76,78,79 A Orthocladius sp. SP4A,SP48,Cl 74,75,76,77 R Nanocladius sp. St. Vrain Heterotrissociadius sp. SP4A(0),C1 74,75,76 VR Trichocladius sp. Cl 79 VR Diplocladius sp. SP4U 78 VR g Chironominae Chironomus sp. SP4A,SP4U SP48,Cl 74,75,76,77,78,79 C Cryptochironomus sp. SP4A,SP4U.SP4B,Cl 74,75,76,77,78,79 UC Glyptotendipes sp. SP4A,SP4U.SP4B,C1 74,75,76,77,78,79 UC Dicrotendipes sp. SP4A,SP4U.SP48 74,75,76,77,78,79 C Polypedilum sp. SP4A,SP4U SP48,Cl 74,75,76,77,78,79 C [g Stictocnironomus sp. SP4A(0),SP4U,SP4B,Cl 74,75,77,78 VR Kiefferulus sp. SP4A(N) 77 VR Phaenopsectra sp. SP4A(0),SP4U SP48,Cl 75,76,77,79 VR Parachironomus sp. SP4A(0),SP4U,SP48,C1 74,76,78,79 VR Paracladopelma sp. SP4A(0),SP48,Cl 74 VR Micropsectra sp. SP4A SP40,SP4B,Cl 74,75,76,79 R O Paralauterborniella sp. SP4A,SP4U.SP48,C1 75,76,77,78,79 UC Tanytarsus_ sp. SP4A,SP4U,SP4B,C1 75,76,77,78 UC Rheotanytarsus sp. SP4A(N),SP4U,SP4B,C1 77,78,79 R Pseudochironomus sp. SP4A(N),SP4U SP48,C1 77,78 R Endochironomus_sp. SP4A(N),Cl 75,76,77 VR Goeldicrironomus sp. SP4U 79 VR O Ceratopogonidae SP4A(N).SP4U 76,79 VR Palpomiyia sp. SP4A(0),C1 78 VR Stratiomyidae SP4A(N),SPau,SP4B,Cl 74,79 VR Tabanidae SP4A(0),SP4U,SP4B 74,75,76,78 VR Tabanus sp. Cl 75 VR Athericidae SP4A(0),SP48,C1 VR O Atherix sp. 74 Dolichopodidae SP4A(0),SP4U,C1 75,76 VR Empididae SP48 76 VR Syrphidae SP4B 74 VR O
C? 28 Table 3. Continued. Relative ID Taxa Sites Years collected collected abundance Ephydridae SP4A,SP4U.SP48,C1 76,77,78 R Brachydentera sp. SP4U 78 VR Muscidae SP4A,SP4U.SP4B,C1 74,75,76,78 VR gp Limnophora sp. SP4A(N),SP4U,SP4B 77 VR Scatopnagidae (=Anthomyiidae) SPAA(0),SP48,C1 74 VR Coelenterata Hydroida SP4B,Cl 78 VR O Turbellaria Tricladida Planariidae SP4A(N),3P4U,SP48,C1 77,78,79 VR Ducesia sp. SP4A(0),SP4U 76 VR Nematoda SP4A(N),SP4U.SP48,C1 79 VR g, Nematomorpha SP4A(N) 79 VR Annelida Oligochaeta SP4A SP4U.SP48,Cl 74,75,76,77,78,79 A II Hirudinea SP4A,SP48,C1 78,79 VR Pharyngobdellida Erophdellidae SP?A(0),SP4U 74,78 VR Eroobdella sp SF46,C1 74 VR Crustacea 8 Cladocera SP4A N),SP4U.SP48,Cl 79 A* Daphnidae SP4A N),SP4U.SP48,C1 78,79 R Daphnia sp. SP4A N),SP4B 79 R Copepoda SP4A N),SP40,CP48,C1 78,79 VR Cyclopoida SP48 79 VR Ostracoda SP4B 78 VR Isopoda Asellidae Asellus sp. SP4A(N),SP4U.SP4B,Cl 77,78,79 VR Amphipoda Talitridae Hyalella azteca SP4A.SP4U.SP4B Cl 74,7S,76,77,78,79 C G Gamaridae Gammarus sp. SP43 79 VR Crargonyx sp. SP4A SP4U.SP48,Cl 74,75,76,77,78,79 UC Decapoda Astacidae Camborus sp. SP4A(0),SP4U.SP48,Cl 74,75,76,77,78 R O
*Cladocera extremely abundant on dates collected.
O
O 29 Table 3. Continued. __ 9 Sites Years Relative Taxa abundance collected collected Gastropoda Physidae db Physa sp. SP4A,SP4U,SP48,C1 74,75,76,7/,73,79 UC Lymnaeidae Lymnaea sp. SP4A(0),SP48,Cl 74,77,78 UR 133 taxa total db 83 taxa VR = 62% 23 taxa R = 21% 12 taxa UC = 9% 7 taxa C= 5% 3 taxa A= 2% 3 Very Rare (VR): collected in only one year in very low numbers (<10) on one or more sampling dates at one station and/or collected in several years on one or more sampling dates at one or more stations in extremely low numbers (<5). j Rare (R): collected at one or more sampling sites on one or more sampling dates in several years in low numbers (<25). Uncommon (UC): collected at several sampling sites on several sampling dates in most to all years in generally low to moderate numbers (10-100). Comnon (C): collected at most sites on most sampling dates in most years in moderate to high numbers (25-250). Abundant (A): always (or almost always) collected on all sampling dates at all sampling sites in all years in moderate to extremely high numbers ( 25). 3 q ~_/ e.
wO l L i o
'T I
- - )
- e g
a p n_ . l
- t.
x e l rl I e n
- _ e h
r n t o n d e o u s n n 1 i t n i o e
- _ t o a c I C
( t s
- _ g
. I n 8 i 4
l E p m a o 3 - s
. : i - .
F r r u o 1 f t a r l l t e e
- r r r a u
_ l q
~ I h i c a
n T f e l c_ 1 r o e f F r s e u l a . vo d xa er d o e nl I o C c i , m. A t r P 4 oe S i v Bi R d ne e at t ya tl iP s rh et vu i o l
~
l DS e r [ 3
- ]
e r
~ [ u l
l g 0 [ fr i 4 _ F 4 V l e h _ 0 0 0' 0 5 0 0 0 5 m, i 1 1 0 2: r e
- _ . . - -f (
31 r- F r- 6 j- ,,
, i i t_ '
i F i n . .
, I l
[ F. I i i ~
, ., i i I L '
Q* d i I r
, I I t I
I y
- r- 4 -
O , i
~
i , i : M M ! :! i
- m o
, '-,. ..y i ~ . '
i i 3 i F F II ~ y
, s -
- i. r i l L L F
rd I ,w . n r_4 i r *e - I I & t ap. . w m.,.._m., :- Q ' i i M ! E
' ^
..i g .- n + 'I a r.
t 3 8 i l f I i, m_ i ' a ..a~ i i L b5 r1 i r
~
s. O I F g s m~.~ t i
! F f""
a- r_. m1 e , r lQ i i g I F y r- s i. . .a y t-I' i [ I I n . .
,. > . -, ~
I !
. .= ; -
r O i ' t CJ
. . . B.
e-
?
8 8 8 8 5 8o o Y e o o a C A U b o U v !O , r n b s % 3 I es 3# @ E. # L :: so 6 I V e eo
- Os r - o 3 i ; o-l Th
- a s
.O ,,,, 2,4, sesi i
.,tP9-
32 O Table 4. A0V comparison of ECODIV values by year in a downstream di rection. ECODIV values are for all sites and all quarters. H F F g Reject? g s TCI 1975 No difference in ECODIV value 0.0469 3.59 No , for year among sites 1976 0.5339 3.49 No 1977 0.0933 3.36 No 1978 0.1676 3.49 No , 1979 0.0779 3.49 No DBAR 1975 0.1193 3.59 No e 1976 0.1367 3.49 No 1977 1.4298 3.36 No 1978 0.2534 3.49 No g 1979 0.1154 3.49 EQUIT 0.0212 3.59 No G' 1975 1976 1.1985 3.49 No 1977 0.8634 3.36 No 1978 0.3871 3.49 No 9 l 1979
" 4.2415 3.49 Yes 1
I H = null hypothesis. g O 2 Fs = calculated F statistic. 3 F = table F statistic. O O. t
I O 33 perfomed to analyze differences for th( same quarter among stations g (Table 5). Statistical analysis of other aspects of invertebrate nu".bers, reMtive abundance, and taxon numbers by several approaches failed to i l demonstrate significant changes among stai. ions or through the years at y a particular station. Fishes O Annual fish collections at two sites each on the South Platte and St. Vrain Rivers showed no significant changes in the fish comunity of either stream in this study. Twenty-five species representing eight O families were collected (Tables 6 and 7). Four species (Sabo gairdneri_, Hybcgnathus hankinsoni, Fundulus sciadicus_ and Micropterus dolomieui) I were found only in the St. Vrain River. None was comon. Minnows O (cyprinidae) were the most speciose family and most numerous fish in both streams in all collections. The number of species collected bore a strong relation to the intensity of sampling effort. Never were all (O species collected during the study present in one sample. Notropis stramineus was normally the most abendant species. Game fish were never l l abundant, and the few captured were always rather small. !o Sampling Stations SP4A-N and 0 The iocation of SP4A was moved in 1977 because of effluent dis - O charge near SP40. From 1974 through June 1977, SP4A was immediately above the primary effluent discharge point. In July 1977, SP4A was relocated opposite Goosequill Pond (SP4A-0 designates the pre-July 1977 O and SP4A-N the post-July 1977 location of SP4A). Although major differences in the macroinvertebrate communities of the two sites were O i
34 O Table 5. A0V comparison of ECODIV values of four sites on the South Platte River. ECODIV values are based upon quarters, and F Statistics are calculated for comparison of sites in a 8 downstream direction for each quarter. I F F Reject? Hg s t TCI J-M Each site is not 59.7157 3.11 Yes significantly different A-J " 454.3557 3.06 Yes e. J-S " 45.4451 3.06 Yes 0-D " 45.5131 3.06 Yes DBAR J-M 47.8563 3.11 Yes 8 A-J " 36.1712 3.06 Yes J-S " 66.0255 3.06 Yes 9 0-D " 58.2430 3.06 Yes EQUIT e J-M " 2.3120 3.11 No A-J " 1.3645 3.06 No O J-S " 17.3845 3.06 Yes 0-D " 11.8146 3.06 Yes 9 Hg = null hypotbasis. Fs = calculated F statistic. 3p = table F statistic. t O
35 f l l Table 6. Ichthyofauna of St. Vrain Creek in the vicinity of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generation Station, 1975 to 1979.
- L 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979
#/% #/% #/% #/% #/%
Dorosoma cepedianum 1/0.3 3/0.3 3 Cyprinus caroio 6/1.3 64/18.9 496/44.6 26/1.9 62/1.4 i Pimechales promelas 39/8.7 12/3.5 43/3.9 250/18.3 106/2.4 Notropis lutrensis 66/14.7 11/3.2 6/0.5 14/1.0 595/13.6 N. dorsalis 15/1.1 73/1.7 g _N. stramineus 270/60.3 88/26.0 164/14.8 939/68.6 3288/75.4 Hyboanathus hankinsoni 9/0.7 12/0.3
-N. stramineus x
_H. hankinsoni O Semotilus atromaculatus 1/0.2 4/1.2 3/0.1 Rhinichthys cataractae 6/1.8 2/0.2 18/1.3 62/1.4 7 Campostoma anomalum 4/0.3 4/0.1 Cyprinidae hybrids 37/10.9 ) Catostomus catostomus C. connersoni 41/9.2 4/1.2 59/17.4 172/15.5 75/6.8 2/0.1 53/3.9 8/0.2 88/2.0 Ictalurus melas 1/0.3 5/0.1 Fundulus kansae 1.0.3 10/0.9 23/1.7 11/0.3 b F. sciadicus t Culaea inconstans 3/0.7 2/0.1 1/>0.1 Lepomis cyanellus 22/4.9 39/11.5 117/10.5 13/1.0 34/0.8 L. humilus 1/0.3 2/>0.1 l h L. macrochirus 1/0.1 l Pomoxis annularis 3/09 4/0.1 P. nigromaculatus 2/0.2 Perca flavescens 5/1.5 13/1.2 Micropterus salmoides 1/0.3 1/>0.1 ; O M. dolomieui 2/0.6 7/0.6 , Total # specimens 448 339 1111 1368 4359 Total # species 8 18 14~ 13- 18 h , ?
36 O Table 7. Icht"yofauna of the South Platte River in the vicinity of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station,1975 to 1979. O 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 t/% t/% 4/% 9/% '/% Dorosoma cepedianun 1/0.5 O Salmo gairdneri Cyprinus carpio 18/5.2 54/29.0 75/17.4 23/3.2 133/5.1 Pimephales procelas 52/15.0 20/10.8 35/8.1 217/29.8 123/4.8 Notropis lutrensis 38/11.0 2/1.1 6/0.8 290/11.2 32/4.4 147/5.7 8 N. dorsalis
-N. stramineus 172/49.7 31/16.7 197/45.6 388/53.2 1759/68.6 Semotilus atromaculatus 2/0.6 1/0.5 1/0.2 2/0.1 Rhinichthys cataractae 10/2.9 2/1.1 16/3.7 1/0.1 5/0.2 Carpostoma anomalum 5/0.7 9 Cyprinidae hybrids 45/13.0 Catostomus catostomus 7/3.8 12/2.8 3/0.4 2/0.1 C. comersoni 5/1.4 57/30.6 72/16.7 4/0.5 54/2.1
-C. catostomus x e
~C. comersoni 2/0.1 Ictalurus melas 1/0.3 6/1.4 2/0.1 Fundulus kansae 6/1.4 53/7.3 28/1.1 Culaealnconstans 2/0.1 ,
Lepomis cyane11us 3/0.9 9/4.8 12/2.8 1/0.1 29/1.1 L. humilus L. macrochirus 8/0.3
-L. cyanellus x #
L. gibbosus 1/0.1 Pomoxis annularis P. nigromaculatus 1/0.5 Perca flavescens 1.0.5 Micropterus salmoides 1/>0.1 9 Total # specimens 3461 186 432 729 2587 Total # species 10 12 10 12 16 O O
O 37 l not observed, some differences were detected and are at least partially O explained by the relocation of collection points. i Dipterans and oligochaetes were the preponderant groups found at both SP4A sites. Chironomidae was the most speciose dipteran family. More genera of Chironomidae were found at SP4A-N than at SP4A-0. How-O ever, none of the genera unique to SP4AM was very abundant or found throughout the year. In 1975 and 1976, Cricotopus sp. had two periods of mr.A; mum abundance, but the 1975 peaks were more equal in numbers and l g duration (Figure 4). In 1978, they were extremely abundant from June through November, but in 1979 peak abundance occurred early in the year foll wed by a lower peak in late sumer. Polypedilum sp. and O Paralauterborniella sp. had abbreviated periods of peak abundance in the ; sumer at both SP4A sites (Figures 5 and 6). Chironomus sp. nonnally had a cumer high but were found in other months in varying numbers O (Figure 7). Dicrotendipes sp. was usually more abundant earlier in the year than at any other time, but the pattern was not absolute (Figure 8). Conchapelopia sp. had no obvious pattern of appearance or abundance I (Figure 9). At SP4A-0, Simulium sp. were never particularly comon; . they were frequently abundant at SP4A-N and evidenced two periods of high numbers (Figure 1(). No other dipterans were comonly collected at either SP4A-0 or SP4A-N. Mydropsyche sp. and Baetis sp. were the only non-dipteran insects comonly collected at both SP4A sites. Baetis sp. were normally collected in a rather restricted period in moderate to high numbers at both sites (Figure 11). Hydropsyche sp. were found in most months but were typically most abundant in the first and last quarters' of the year (Figure 12). j- !O
38
... n b wo..
Q* _ Q.- 1 aQ-3
- ni m,-
n ; , m , - n . 8 54 n - 4 - ~ nw -%, ' Q e 34 nr -
\- -
f- _ 4 J '-
' I"L ' - , TL Q Q22 R
I! ' M s2d in 13 or 3 io r 2 +4- j
*w + _
- , _ e
+
,e il,tf. 5 - F 5 x '~
[5 J h7 _r R C~ k'. k'. E.C. fi S.SS,
. . ., , ; !!!!!! SE E : : -
- L : rifL A
_ Q k . 2 121
!!353E E r , . J i
9 1 5 J- -
- /
] . / _
_J" _
~
9
~
k'. gas 9:n G. e e 1 [ 1 - J r - h _D - Figure 4. Number of Cricotopus sp. collected each month at four stations on the South Platte River. 1974-1979. e
39 D ~ - - . ,, E, 120
- j n .
in . . - ] en- ~ W* a - ,
= .
29 { 19 - ) f _ J 5_ . M =
~
'd : - l -
,_ J'1, O D ", ; _
n- ? _ 3 I N -
= .
is -
- , ~
.i D
E_ J~ I __ b _ n -k-m. ) -S re-w w - i m- ~
*~
! n F B, n f- - nm _ _fl-_
,,. r1 3 , , , ,.
iia = in.
,a-
! n.estas
- sa.me.. .,. _
j s on . ex. g- , [ _ _ m _ ll _
- rlm Figure 5. Number of Polypedilum sp. collected each month at four stacions on the South Platte River, 1974-1979.
) \ l
41 yee ce u
- pu.a yes yu-a _
.$ h f e i
[ 1
= -
. : e n_ -
n - 2 kE ks . k t iao .
= -
i - _ g a - g a . n , - _ mr , 4" R g e e -
- . e n , -
- n , , - q k k'. k'. Q i : as -
zis a 3 _ 1 , n r e, n - c n r, Q. . _ e 32 g c, [nn : n r, n n Figure 6. Number of Paralauterborniella sp. collected each month at four stations on the South Platte River, 1974-1979. O
41 D ,,,,, m, vu. *** "
- c. ,
l
. I 3 - -
h _- -- 3 - S a s
- M-- - _
, _O -
7
, P D : -
n, 3 J - I rt _
-, _ __n%r _. D D 3
~
[- f _ g _ rt _ _ c-- - Q ' R i !! ! l 5 i - [ ,p q pfl.J] n k. i e D * - Cate unes -
'O P __f*1 m n ' m __ '}
Figure 7. Number of Chironomus_ sp. collected each month at four stations on the South Platte River, 1974-1979. O
42 O va-a = v. _. o E E
~
F ,y : g - O
' Oe _ f n l R -nd f _ n E O
- nn- n_ 1_ 1 _
bEJ _ 3 b b _ ___J" _ n fl_ E' N - _nn -.n _ n __b __ d 9tgetteettges E e J Aq P,_ _n fn n , Figure 8. Number of Dicrotendipes_ sp. collected each month at four statior.s on the South Platte River, 197'-1977. O
a 43 9 9
,,.m ..~ y a e O '
E~ e S.et t s m C . __ m l d
} .
_~
"r r
f - . F1 - Q QR
= .; ~
e _
,0
= '.
a _
~
- m
,-.,__r, l i.
1 -
~ "
ag etMee - - ,s i
,,.c peres to . ~= *- .J ,
M
- a .
i. 1 n_ , c f"
!a
<.cromeet,,
,. the. m,e
,,.r. .
, .o.n _ - m . N _ h _fl - M l Figure 9. Number of Conchapelopia sp. collected each month at four stations D on the South Platte River, 1974-1979.
l 44 n O, m vaa _ v _ v.. 2 9 __ e h g , - m !"" _ _
'm _b k
a G E 13 . ~
"m __
"m s "k %7 ~ _
l Q-g e g
. ~f N
~
~
n
~
-. n_ -
_M _
,., w J FnaRJ JASO59 m
m
=. m.-
== g
_ s
,. . === 2 110f .
100 f gop . 2 80f 70 I $ d Sol" 3 _ scl* IC" L k , _ all
,_tec.ryvets the m ...
g n _ u _
. r :
e 4 _ vs _ r
. t -
g a - _
- L #
- 4 n n
_ 1 / 1 _ JpnaeJJanaue
.JFnanJJa80#9e JFRanJJa1eae JF naaJJaseae Figure 10. Number o'f Simulium sp. collected each month at four stations on the South Platte River, 1974-1979.
O
45 S m ..g v. ** o 9 - - [L ,_ _ - - e 5-
- _ FL _ .n ~C U I -
J e 5 nl , F m r - -- m J
=
=
If _]] % _r r 1___. n n_ F- _-
-l t u.
m 1 ._ 1 -
, _ n m !
e J . _
' [ , n_ L nw n - m- C -
Figure 11. Number of Baetis sp. collected each month at four stations on the South Platte River, 1974-1979. L_ g-1
n v 46 O u w -- .. v., e
= -
w . 5 . E 1F Il r9 - P-- O
=
5 E M b _ # - r'ln N n_ ~ m e 3 . at n it - _~ m_ - l rnJ ! _
- Am-- _
Q-e s . j 1 ik, -
~
_= - - - [ - n-k = k e = tacroseats sa
.~ n .
g . n . . m " MF _ 7 _ _ E 1 . O b ._ n FLn J 1, N rm - M e Figure 12. Number of Hydropsyche sp. collected each month at four stations
- on the South Platte River. 1974-1979.
O
iO 47 Hyalella azteca and 011gochaeta were the only non-insect macro-
- O invertebrates comonly collected. Hyalella azteca_was found throughout the year at both sites, and bimodal cycles were evident in most years at both sites (Figure !3). At SP4A-0, Oligochaeta had dish nct bimodal
'O annual cycles with the second oeak much narrower and lower tnan the first and preceeded by very brief periods of extremely-low numbers. ' At SP4A-N, peaks were considerably lover than at SP4A-0. The annual ^O pattern at SP4A-N was similar to that at SP4A-0 but less distinct (Figure 14). Odonata, Hemiptera, and Coleoptera had relatively few representa- .O tives at SP4A, and none was comon. One representative of Plecoptera (Periodidae) was collected at SP4A-N in 1977. Cladocerans were found in very high numbers in October 1979. O Slightly more taxa were found at SP4A-N than at SP4A-0. Most taxa found at SP4A-0 were found at SP4A-N, but most rare taxa at SP4A-N were not collected at SP4A-0. r uon numbers were normally greater in the second half of the year at both sites. O Comunity diversity index values were usually highest in the third quarter and lowest in the second (but occasionally the fourth) quarter of the year. Biotic index values approximated diversity index values. o f The patterns were similar at both sites. SP40 -- lg Data collection was initiated at SP40 in 1974. The sit' was selected to provide a control site above any possible influence of ef fluent from Goosequill Pond. Unfortunately, seepage from the pond was observed in the vicinity of the site in June 1977. Since then, flow g has only been detected a few times entering the South Platte near SP4U.
- O
48 v wa ,w v.. ci O
! _ e m.
1 _ ] - Q 3 _ e Iw. - II _ .
;h I 1P 1 J r-A
'l lP
~
e
~
. 7.
?
$ 5 I e 4
.%, 4 J, e ,
. Fa M)&Ga3
% N -
h_ e ? e E m O M b r L t_ n_ . O g 5 n . - aira .'
, , Ov N_
e E tf Ox.A ..... ..... A N ^ _. lM e Figure 13. Number of Hyalella azteca collected each month at four stations on the South Platte River, 1974-1979. e
49 9 m, v., 'w, a k R n , C 3 O i - - r , r - t K' M M e b.'
-451 k
?! i!E fL 1 m 25
- J Ess
-~ ~ 2- -
3n - f E _ 1 _ g :[ D ~
- [ h F -
kk k kC, k Mk J i !!'1 i s 'i: i m ai in! : J _ L 5 3 ,,
= -. :: ,J
- -J f X 1 m=r- ;;; , ~ . . ~, , ~ ,; -- T- , , -
U D _5 flr r t- w A - .- a t ,_[l_ % n D ......
~
m_r _ J - D E An bA O M___ 9 . . . . . . . . . . ..... ,,,... Figure 14 Number of Oligochaeta collected each month at four stations on the South Platte River, 1974-1979.
50 0 Despite possible contamination by water from Goosequill Pond, the effect was probably negligible. g Station SP4U was the least speciose of the four stations, which is at least partially a function of the short time samples have been taken from it. However, the channelized bed morphology would tend to , make the environment less tenable for many forms. Numbers of taxa collected each year at SP4U were similar to all other stations every 3 ear (exceptSP48,1979). , In most respects, SP4U was similar to all other stations. Dipterans, particularly Chironomidae, and oligochaetes dominated the invertebrate fauna. A relatively-high proportion of the chironomid genera present O at SP4U were classified as comon. Six of 22 genera occurred every year, and two were common in all years except 1975 (Table 3). Thus, SP4U had a rather small number of very rare genera of Chircnomidae. O Cricotopus sp. was found in all months of every year but was quite abundant June - November; in 1979 the greatest number of Cricotopus sp. was collected in February and March. Thus, except for 1979, Cricotopus 0; sp. abundance followed a constant pattern through the study (Figure 4). Polypedilum sp., Paralauterborniella sp. and Dicrotendipes sp. had distinct, short periods of occurrence, when their numbers were high. O Their periods of abundance remained relatively invariable throughout ! the study (Figures 5, 6 and 8). Concht.pelopia sp. followed a similar pattern during the study, but in 1979 they were collected more randomly O and in generally low numbers (Figure 9). Chironomus_sp. had a pattern of peak abundance similar to those of the above genera, but its periods of abundance were not as sharply delineated and tended to vary among 9 years (Figure 7). O l
O 51 Early in the study, Simulium sp. occurred in relatively-low numbers and demonstrated no readily-discernable pattern. However, in 1978 and O 1979 they were significantly more abundant and had two periods of peak abundanceeachyear(Figure 10).
;g Baetis sp. had a fairly-consistent, strict, seasonality of appearance. However, numbers were much greater in 1978 than in other years (Figure 11). Hydropsyche sp. were most abundant in the winter lg months (Figure 12).
Hyalella azteca did not follow any obvious pattern at SP4U. A i trend detectable one year would be essentially reversed the next (Figure 13). Oligochaetes were extremely abundant in several months in 1975 and O 1976. Their numbers were quite high in early sumer in all years except 1979 (Figure 14). All groups found at SP4U had few taxa per group. Comunity g i diversity was nomally greatest in the third quarter of each year and lowest in the second. Biotic index values roughly paralleled diversity index values (Figure 5). SP4B -- Station SP48, located immediately below the discharge point of I ! Goosequill Ditch, was considered to be the site at which the possible
- O effects of effluent upon the macroinvertebrate comunity would be most readily detectable. More +.axa (,108) were collcated from SP48 than any other site. However. '.n each year the number of taxa collected at SP4B was not significantly different from the numbers collected at other
{ , stations. All major groups had representatives at SP48. As at other stations,
- O dipterans were the most speciose group; they and oligochaetes dominated
- O
52 O the invertebrate community. A rather large number of dipteran families were collected at SP48, but only Simuliidae and Chironomidae were com-O monly collected. Cricotopus_ sp. was frequently the most common organism collected. They were found throughout the year in large numbers Mt were most abundant during the summer and early autumn (Figure 4). 9 Other chironomids typically had more distinct periods of seasonal appearance. Polypediluin sp. and Paralauterborniella sp. were collected primarily in the summer and in high numbers (Figure 5 and 6). The e timing of their short period of abundance did not appear to change over the years. In contrast, Chironomus sp. and Dicrotendipes sp. were present in low numbers when found early in the study; they generally became more seasonally restricted but present in much higher numbers later in the study (Figures 7 and 8). Conchapelopia sp. occurred through-out the year but in rather low numbers (Figure 9). Simulium sp. abundance during the study followed a more complex pattern. Early, they were present in most months but in low numbers. In 1977, they were distinctly more abundant in November and December. However, in 1978 and 1979 they were Nst abundant in January and February, indicating a slight shift in time of hatching (Figure 10). Baetis sp. were present in relatively large numbers only in the O sumers of all years (Figure 11). Hydropsyche sp. were usually present throughout the year in varying numbers. A tendency towards peak abun-dance in early spring and late autumn-w1r ter was noted (Figure 12). 8 Among non-insect invertebrates, only nialalla azteca and Oligochaeta occurred consistently throughout the study. Oligochate numbers were extremely high in the spring and early sumer of 1975-76. In subsequent years, numbers decreased and were roughly similar in all seasons (Figure 8 14). Hyalella azteca was normally present during all seasons but 9
O 53 typically had two peaks of abundance; late spring and early-to-late-O autumn (Figure 13). Cladocerans were extremely abundant in October 1979 but were not collected in any other year. Odonata, Hemiptera, and Coleoptera had no representative that was O found every year. Most taxa within these groups were found irregularly and often only once. Heptagenia sp. (Ephemeroptera: Heptageniidae) and Tricorythodes sp. (Ephemeroptera: Tricurythidae) were considered O uncomon inhabitants of SP4B but were collected in the summers of all years in low numbers. Ochrotrichia sp. (Trichoptera: Hydroptilidae) were collected only in the autumn of 1978 at SP48. The mean number of taxa collected per month during the study was O generally slightly greater at SP4B than at other stations. An early peak in taxon numbers occurred in February and was followed by a low in March. Subsequently, taxon numbers steadily rose through September and 9 then declined to a December low comparable to the January low (Figure 2). When the average number of taxa per month before initiation of Generating g Station operation was comparedto the number after initiation, the patterns of abundance were the same but the phase was different (Figure 2b). Community diversity as measured by EQUIT and DBAR followed a seasonal pattern similar to taxon numbers, as would be expected. Prior O to Station operation, diversity was lowest in the second quarter and increased to a maximum in the third quarter. After Station operation began, the trend changed. Beginning in 1977, the lowest diversity index g values were in the first quarter and steadily increased through the ( year. However, in 1979 the fourth quarter values were lower than the s third quarter values (Figure 3). Except for 1977, TCI values followed the same pattern every year. O 1
54 O SP48 had a lower percentage of very rare taxa than recorded for all c ner stations but a highe. proportion of rare and uncomon taxa. O C1 -- The location of Cl, imediately below the confluence of the South Platte and St. Vrain Rivers, is such that possible effects of the 9 effluent would be mitigated by the St. Vrain River. Thus, themal and nutrient introductions to the South Platte via Goosequill Ditch are diluted by the St. Vrain River. Cl had the most monotonous substrate 9 (sand) of any station, the highest average flow, and the lowest deposi-tion of organic debris. For these reasons, it might be expected to have tne fewest taxa and the lowest diversity of the stations sampled. O However, Cl harbored the second-highest number taxa of the stations, and community diversity there was comparable to or higher than at all other stations except SP4B. All major groups had representatives at Cl, but O total number of organisms collected wa> generally lower than the number collected at other stations for any specific sampling date. Dipterans were the most speciose group at Cl, and Chironomidae O had the most genera (27). With oligochates, chironomids normally dominated the macroinvertebrate community of Cl. Cricotopus_ sp. were generally present throughout the year but in widely-fluctuating numbers. No obvious pattern of seasonal abundance was discernable prior to 1979; peak abundance periods changed from year to year in a rather random manner. In 1978, Cricotopus sp. numbers increased to a late-summer or early-autumn high and rapidly decreased in November (Figure 4). Polypeditum sp. occurred from May to November. However, in any particu-lar year they were collected during a much briefer period (except in O 1976, when none were collected) (Figure 5). Paralauterbornfella sp. was usually collected in a short period of the year in high numbers. O
- O 55 However, in 1979 they were only collected in January in low numbers g (Figure 6). The Dicrotendipes sp. abundance pattern changed perceptibly during the study. In 1974,1975, and 1976, they were collected through-a out the year. In 1977, there was a marked shift to October-December.
In 1978 and 1979, they were found only in the early months of the year ]g (except one species collected in August 1979) (Figure 8). Chironomus sp. were irregularly present in high numbers prior to 1970. However, in 1978 they appeared more consistently throughout the year in moderate numbers, O j In 1979, they occurred less frequently in rather low numbers (Figure 7). Conchapelopia sp. were found in all years in low numbers in most seasons. f 4 No discernible pattern was observed in their occurrence (Figure 9).
- O The Simulium sp. abundance pattern underwent rather distinct changes during the study. Early (1974,1975, and 1976), they were present most of the year in low nuray.rs. From 1977 through 1979, peak abundance LO occurred in the winter (Figure 10).
Hydropsyche sp. generally were found throughout the year, but i i rarely in high numbers. Their abundance increased slightly in the later iO j years of the study (Figure 12). Baetis sp. -generally had a rather restricted period of occurrence (July-October) and were not particularly I Conion. 'O ! Hyalalla azteca had bimodal cycles of abundance in most years, but
- the pattern was more evident early in the study (1975 and 1976). In 1978, they appeared throughout the year in relatively constant numbers.
-O In 1979, a bimodal pattern appeared to be re-establishe.d (Figure 13).
i i iO O
56 O In 1974, 1975, an 1976, oligochaetes were extremely abundant in several months of each year; they decreased to (cmparatively low 9 numbers in 1977 and never occurred in excessively high numbers in the remaining years of the study. Relative late-sumer or early-autumn and early (January-March) lows were mticeable in all years (Figure 14). O No Odonata, Hemiptera, or Colecptera taxa were comonly collected or found every year. Other than taxa discussed, none was found regularly during the study in significant numbers. Heptagenia sp., Tricorythodes sp., Crangonyx sp. (Amphipoda: Gamaridae) and Physa sp (Mollusca: Physidae) were the only other organisms to occur every year. However, their presence was generally irregular and their abundance nonnally quite low. Cladocerans were found in very high numbers only in October 1979. Monthly taxon numbers followed a pattern similar to that at other stations. Prior to Generating Station operation, periods of high taxon numbers were slightly more restricted than they were after (Figure 2a). Diversity index values followed a pattern similar to taxon numbers. Index values were generally higher for comparable quarters after Station operation began than before (Figure 3). SV2 and SV5 -- O Regular, biweekly monitoring of the aquatic macroinvertebrate comunities of two sites on the St. Vrain River was initiated in July 1979. All major groups except Coleoptera and Hemiptera had representa-tion at both sites, but SV5 was considerably less speciose than SV2. 8 Forms comon in the South Platte River were also dominant in the St. Vrain River. No taxon found in the St. Vrain River was unique to it. No further analysis is possible because of the brief St. Vrain collec- O tion period of 6 months. O
O 57 Water Chemistry and Water Temperatures O Analysis of the chemical parameters of the South Platte and St. Vrain Rivers did not reveal any abnormal or unexpected conditions (Table 8). Monthly water temperature means (am and pm) were calculated for O above and below effluent discharge (Table 9). Analysis of variance tests revealed significant differences in water temperatures for each month (am and pm, above and below effluent discharge) O among all years (1974-1979) (Table 10). Water temperatures were not sig-nificantly different above and below effluent discharge (am and pm) when Water temperatures were compared for each month, singly (Table 11). O temperature differences were significantly different among months prior to the initiation of Generating Station operation (J"ne 1974-November 1976) and after power generation began at the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating However, the temperature O Station (December 1976-December 1979) (Table 12). i Some data were often question '.e and frequently deemed inaccurate. obviously-incorrect data could be eliminated, but the remainder could be O accepted only with extreme reservation. Much was probably improperly recorded. Thus, analysis of water temperature regimes did not reveal if Generating Station operation (and the associated effluent from Goosequill O Pond) had a measurable effect upon the aquatic macroinvertebrate community of the South Platte River. O O .O
58 O Table 8. Mean chemical and physical parameters at four stations on the South Platte River, Colorado, 1974-1979. SP4A-0 SP4A-N SP4U SP48 C1 Air Temp. (C) 13.4 16.6 15.0 15.1 15.3 WaterTemp.(C) 11.0 12.4 11.7 11.8 11.9 g 7.5 7.3 7.2 7.3 7.4 Dissolved 02(mg/1) 13.7 29.1 20.2 18.6 18.4 Dissolved CO2(mg/1) 7.9 7.6 7.7 7.8 7.9 g pH Hardness (mg/1) 339 331 339 338 319 Total Alkalinity (mg/1) 255 39 5 31 8 301 31 2 Filtrable Solids (mg/1) 774 498 572 644 647 , Dissolved Solids (mg/1) -- 805 785 808 815 Conductivity (micrombos/cm) .c/2 540 867 928 948 Turbidity (JTU) 31.5 15.8 29.5 22.2 24.7 , O 6 4 O 4
Table 9. South Platte River water temperature ('C) recorded by Public Service Company of Colorado in the vicinity of fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. 1974 1979. JANUARY FEBRUARY MARCli APRIL am pm am pm am pm am pm A* B** A B A B A B A 8 A B A 8 A 8 Mean
.e R
Range N Mean 0.4 2.4 2.3 4.7 5.8 8.4 8.2 12.8 R 0.6 0.0 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.6 2.2
$ N'"9' 3.9 8.9 6.4 10.0 12.0 13.3 15.0 19.4 N 30 29 28 28 30 30 27 26 Mean 2.2 2.1 3.3 2.7 4.3 4.5 6.3 6.7 5.4 6.0 7.8 8.3 9.4 9.3 13.5 13.4 0.6 -0.6 -0.6 0.0 0.6 -0.8 -0.6 0.6 0.0 -0.3 1.1 1.1 0.0 1.1 5.6 5.6 3"2N'"9' 6.4 6.7 8.9 8.6 8.0 8.5 10.0 10.0 12.2 11.9 13.3 13.3 14.4 13.6 18.6 18.6 us N 31 22 29 22 27 27 26 25 29 29 31 31 30 30 30 30 ua Mean -1.0 1.0 0.2 -0.3 2.6 2.6 4.8 4.6 4.1 3.8 5.8 5.6 7.3 7.2 10.1 10.1 R 3.3 3.3 3.3 -3.3 0.6 -0.6 0.0 0.0 3.3 -3.3 0.6 0.6 1.1 0.8 2.8 2.8 Range 9.4 10.8 13.3 12.8 16.7 16.7
% 3.1 3.1 3.3 3.3 5.0 5. 0 8.9 7.8 10.0 10.8 N 30 30 30 30 28 28 28 28 31 31 31 31 30 30 30 30 Mean 1.4 0.9 1.2 0.9 3.1 2.9 3.1 2.9 8.4 8.1 10.1 9.8 11.9 11.9 12.9 12.9 R 0.0 0.0 -4.4 -5.0 0.3 0.3 1.1 1.1 0.3 0.3 1.1 1.1 7.2 1.2 7.8 7.8 Range 15.8 15.8 17.2 17.8
% 3.9 2.5 2.8 2.2 5.0 5.0 6.7 6.7 17.8 17.8 18.3 18.3 N 31 31 30 30 28 28 28 28 31 31 30 30 30 30 30 30 Mean 1.7 1.4 1.9 1.2 4.4 3.9 G.9 5.1 9.1 8.5 11.0 10.3 13.1 12.6 15.3 15.1 R N'"9' -0.6 0.0 0.6 6.7 1.1 0.6 1.7 -6.1 5.0 4.4 5.0 4.4 5.6 5.8 5.6 4.4 3.9 3.3 4.4 3.9 8.9 9.4 17.2 16.1 12.8 12.5 16.7 15.6 18.9 17.8 21.1 22.2 N 31 31 31 31 28 28 28 28 31 31 30 30 30 30 28 28 GRAND MEAN 1.0 0.9 1.7 1.1 3.3 3.5 5.0 4.8 6.6 6.6 8.6 8.5 10.0 10.3 12.9 12.9
- -1.0 ' -0.9 -1.5 -3.0 0.0 0.2 0.4 1.1 0.4 0.2 1.6 1.4 2.9 3.1 4.8 4.6 GRANO RANGE 15.0 18.6 18.7 4.2 3.9 5.7 5.4 6.7 6.9 10.6 10.1 13.0 sc.7 14.5 14.3 15.5
- Above effluent discharge.
" Below effluent discharge.
Table 9. Continued JULY AUGUST
- MAY JUNE ga am pm am pm am pm am 8 A B A 8 A 8 A* 8** A 8 A 8 A 8 A 20.1 24.2 18.1 22.4 Mean 18.8 24.0 16.4 18.9 15.3 17.8 15.8 21.1
;I 24.2 28.3 22.2 26.7 Ran9e 23.3 27.8 % 22 26 27 10 7 23 N
20.3 20.3 21.3 21.4 24.5 24.5 18.9 18.9 22.5 22.5 Mean 12.9 13.0 12.6 12.7 16.1 16.0 18.1 18.1 17.8 17.8 14.4 14.4 17.8 17.8 9.4 9.4 8.9 8.9 11.1 11.7 14.4 14.4 28.3 N Ran9e 16.7 16.7 20.3 20.3 25.0 25.0 26.7 26.7 31.1 29.4 23.1 23.1 28.3 R 20.6 20.6 27 28 27 28 29 29 30 30 N 11 11 11 10 25 25 28 28 19.4 19.5 11.8 17.8 22.4 22.3 17.4 17.4 _.................... 21.7 21.6 Mean 12.5 12.6 16.4 16.3 16.3 16.2 13.3 13.3 17.8 17.8 12.8 11.7 17.7 16.7 7.2 7.2 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 13.1 13.1 N 25.8 21.7 21.1 28.3 28.3 20.8 20.8 26.1 25.6 Ran9e 16.9 17.2 22.8 22.8 21.1 21.1 25.3 R 31 31 31 25 25 30 30 31 31 28 28 31 N 29 29 30 30 am 19.5 19.5 22.9 22.7 20.5 20.4 22.8 22.6 O Mean 13.9 13.6 16.6 16.4 18.2 18.2 22.0 21.8 15.6 15.6 18.3 18.3 16.9 16.9 18.3 17.8 8.3 8.3 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 12.8 12.8 27.8 S Range 21.1 26.9 26.9 24.2 24.2 27.2 26.1 24.2 24.2 27.8 R 20.0 19.4 25.6 25.6 21.1 21 25 25 31 31 30 30 31 31 31 30 30 30 30 27 N 31 19.5 19.4 23.0 23.0 24.7 24.7 20.3 20.3 22.0 22.1 Mean 14.0 13.8 14.8 14.6 18.2 18.2 20.0 20.0 21.1 21.1 16.9 16.9 15.6 16.7 7.2 6.7 6.7 6.7 14.4 14.4 16.1 16.1 R Range 21.1 22.2 22.2 25.6 25.6 25.8 25.8 27.2 27.2 24.2 24.2 27.2 27.2 R 20.6 20.6 21.1 31 31 30 30 31 31 29 29 N 31 31 29 29 29 29 30 30
...__..................................................................... 20.0 18.6 20.7 20.4 21.1 20.6 18.3 18.2 19.5 ...........
19.3 Mean 15.9 14.5 18.4 16.7 18.9 17.6 18.1 17.2 18.3 17.2 8.9 8.9 15.6 15.6 7.8 7.8 8.3 8.3 11.7 4.4 12.8 9.4 25.0 R Ran9e 21.1 24.4 23.9 24.2 23.6 25.6 24.4 22.2 22.2 24.4
% 23.1 22.8 26.7 25.0 22.5 31 31 31 31 30 30 30 30 N 31 31 28 27 29 29 30 29 ....._........................................................ _......._........ .........._..................................__............. 21.6 20.9 19.9 20.4 20.4 23.3 23.0 18.9 19.0 21.8 GRAND MEAN 13.8 13.5 15.8 15.3 17.8 17.2 16.8 18.7 18.5 14.2 14.2 17.0 17.1 8.3 8.1 9.1 9.1 12.2 11.1 15.1 14.5 16.9 24.5 24.3 28.0 27.3 22.8 22.8 26.8 26.8 GRAND RANGE 19.5 19.4 22.3 22.1 21.7 21.4 25.8 25.8
- Above ef fluent discharge.
** Below effluent discharge.
O *
- O e e e e e e e
. g -. _g. g -g U g- g- g-i Table 9. Continued SEPTEMBER OCTOBER NOVEMBER DECEMBER 4
am pm as pm am pm am pm A* 8** A B A 8 A 8 A B A B A B A B Mean 15.3 19.2 11.3 14.8 5.6 7.1 1.1 2.5
% 8.9 13.3 6.9 8.3 0.0 1.1 0.6 0.0 g Range 19.2 24.4 15.6 20.6 8.3 12.2 5.3 6.7 N 30 27 29 28 28 28 30 31 Hean 15.4 15.4 18.7 18.7 11.8 12.0 15.2 15.2 5.1 5.2 6.9 6.6 3.4 3.3 4.8 4.5
= 11.9 11.9 11.7 11.7 5.3 5.6 7.2 7.2 0.0 0.0 0.6 -0.6 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 N8"9' 19.4 19.4 22.8: 23.3 17.2 19.7 20.6 21.1 11.1 11.1 14.4 14.4 6.7 6.7 9.4 9.4 N 28 28 30 30 31 31 30 30 27 26 28 28 31 31 29 29 Mean 16.3 16.3 18.3 18.0 10.2 10.0 12.8 12.6 5.9 5.7 7.9 7.8 2.4 2.1 3.1 2.9
= 11.0 11.0 12.8 12.8 6.1 4.4 6.0 6.0 0.0 0.0 0.10 0.0 -1.4 -1.4 -1.1 -1.1 Range 12.5 11.7 14.4 14.4 6.7 5.0 6.7 6.7 3 24.2 24.2 22.5 22.5 15.0 14.7 19.0 19.0 N 28 28 28 28 31 31 29 29 28 28 27 27 30 30 29 29
... ................................ ......................................................................................................... g Mean 15.3 15.4 18.7 18.5 8.4 8.3 10.9 10.8 4.0 3.9 6.3 6.2 2.9 2.8 2.9 2.3 c,,
g 7. 2 7.2 13.9 13.9 4.2 3.1 3.9 3.9 0.0 0.0 2.8 2.8 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
- Ran9' 21.4 21.4 23.1 23.3 15.6 15.6 17.8 17.8 6.1 6.1 12.2 12.2 6.7 6.1 7.2 7.8 N 30 30 30 30 31 31 30 30 30 30 28 28 31 31 28 28
... ......................___....__.= ............__...................,........__........................................................
Mean 17.1 17.0 19.2 19.1 12.5 12.4 13.4 13.3 5.7 5.6 5.9 6.0 2.1 2.0 2.1 1.9 m 11.9 11.9 10.6 10.0 8.9 8.9 7.2 7.2 1.7 1.4 2.2 2.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Range 12.2 13.3 4.4 4.4 5.0 6.1
% 23.6 23.3 26.7 26.7 17.5 17.2 18.3 18.3 11.1 11.1 N 30 30 28 28 31 31 31 31 30 30 29 29 31 31 31 31
... ....................-- -. . . . . . . . . - - - -=.............__....................................__....................................
Mean 16.1 16.0 17.1 16.9 11.5 11.3 12.8 12.7 3.8 3.8 5.1 5.1 2.4 2.4 3.3 3.4 m -1.1 g 13.1 12.5 13.9 13.3 3.6 3.1 3.9 3.9 -0.3 -0.3 -1.1 -0.6 -1.1 -1.1 -1.1 Range 10.0 10.0 4.7 4.4 6.1 7.2
- 18.9 19.4 23.3 22.8 15.6 15.6 17.8 16.7 7.5 7.5 N 30 30 29 29 31 31 31 31 31 31 29 29 31 31 30 30 GRAND MEAN 15.9 16.0 18.5 18.2 11.0 10.8 13.3 12.9 5.0 4.8 6.5 6.3 2.4 2.5 3.1 3.0 1 .7 0.6 12.7 12.5 5.8 5.3 6.1 6.1 0.2 0.2 0.7 0.8 0.5 0.5 0.4 0.4 GRAND RANGF 21.1 21.2 23.9 23.8 16.1 16.4 19.0 18.9 9.4 9.3 12.6 12.8 5.7 5.3 6.9 7.3
- Above effluent discharge.
** Below effluent discharge.
62 O Table 10. Analysis of variaxe (A0V) of water temperature of the South Platte River in the vicinity of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generiting Station, Colorado, amng the years (1974-1979) for each month (am and pm, abuve an! below effluent discharge). H,I F,2 F Reject? g t January (am) above effluent dikharge, 1975-1979 There is nu temp. 18.9809 2.37 Yes difference among years January (pm) above effluent discharge, 1975-1979 13.6242 2.37 Yes January (am) below effluent discharge, 1976-1979 25.4362 2.68 Yes January (pm) below effluent discharge, 1976-1979 9.9808 2.63 Yes February (am) above effluent discharge, 1975-1979 6.3243 2.37 Yes February (pm) above effluent discharge, 1975-1979 6.2462 2.37 Yes February (am) below effluent discharge, 1976-1979 5.4141 2.68 Yes February (pm) below effluent discharge, 1976-1979 7.7796 2.68 Yes March (am) above effluent discharge, 1975-1979 12.0299 2.37 Yes March (pm) above ef fluent discharge, 1975-1979 9.6184 2.37 Yes March (am) below effluent discharge. 1976-1979 12.7726 2.68 Yes 4 March (pn) below effluent discharge, 1976-1979 10.8719 2.68 Yes April (am) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 17.7985 2.37 Yes April (pm) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 7.3807 2.37 Yes April (am) below effluent discharge, 1976-1979
- 20.1591 2.68 Yes April (pm) below effluent discharge, 1976-1979 9.4003 2.68 Yes May (am) above effluent discharge, 1975-1979 5.2827 2.37 Yes g May (pm) above effluent discharge, 1975-1979 4.0189 2.37 Yes May (am) below effluent discharge, 1976-1979 1.6174 2.37 No May (pm) below effluent discharge, 1976-1979 2.2800 2.37 No June (am) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 5.0874 2.21 Yes June (pm) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 5.3686 2.21 Yes June (am) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 3.7640 2.37 Yes June (pm) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 "
4.7728 2.37 Yes g July (am) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 24.7798 2.21 Yes
- Yes July (pm) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 12.0614 2.21 July (am) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 31.6222 2.37 Yes July (pm) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 20.7043 2.37 Yes
" Yes August (am) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 11.5165 2.21 August (pm) above effluent discharge, 1374-1979 7.0309 2.21 Yes August (am) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 12.4339 2.37 Yes O' August (pm) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 9.9568 2.37 Yes September (am) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 2.0894 2.21 No September (pm) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 2.0640 2.21 No September (am) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 "
1.6294 2.37 No September (pm) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 2.4929 2.37 Yes October (am) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 10.5088 2.21 Yes G October (pm) above effluent discharge. 1974-1979 6.2252 2.21 Yes October (am) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 11.0476 2.37 Yes October (pm) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 6.1350 2.37 Yes November (am) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 3.3642 2.21 Yes November (pm) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 2.6019 2.21 Yes November (am) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 2.9652 2.37 Yes November (pm) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 2.4528 2.37 Yes g Cecember (am) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 5.5375 2.21 Yes Cecember (pm) above effluent discharge, 1974-1979 6.7393 2.21 Yes December (am) below ef fluent discharge, 1975-1979 2.8609 2.37 Yes December (pm) below effluent discharge, 1975-1979 6.6583 2.37 Yes H a null hypothesis. n O' Fs = calculated F statistic. F
- tabit F statistic.
O
8 63 Table 11. Analysis of variance (A0V) of above and below effluent discharge water temperatures of the South Platte River for each month (1975-1979) in the vicinity of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Colorado. p 3 g,3,gg7 O H,I F;2 t June, 1975 (am) Above to Below There is no temperature 0.0697 4.04 No difference betweE.. above and below effluent discharge June, 1975 (pm) Above to Below 0.0058 4.02 No July, 1975 (am) Above to Below 0.0305 4.04 No July,1975 (pm) Above to Below 0.0086 4.02 No August,1975 (am) Above to Below 0.0019 4.01 No August,1975 (pm) Above to Below 0.0000 4.01 No September,1975 (am) Above to Below 0.0058 4.02 No September,1975 (pm) Above to Below 0.0066 4.02 No
]
October, 1975 (am) Above to Below " 0.0405 4.01 No October,1975 (pm) Above to Below 0.0016 4.01 No November,1975 (am) Above to Below 0.0026 4.04 No November,1975 (pm) Above to Below 0.0382 4.04 No Oecember,1975 (am) Above to Below 0.0046 4.00 No
] December,1975 (pm) Above to Below "
0.2040 4.01 No January,1976 (am) Above to Below 0.0501 4.04 No January, 1976 (pm) Above to Below 0.8665 4.04 No February, 1976 (am) Above to Below 0.0710 4.04 No February,1976 (pm) Above to Below 0.0138 4.01 No March, 1976 (am) Above to Below 0.0023 4.00 No March,1976 (pm) Above to Below 0.2022 4.00 No April, 1976 (am) Above to Below 0.1203 4.01 No April, 1976 (pm) Above to Below 0.0337 4.01 No May, 1976 (am) Above to Below 0.0004 4.01 No 0.0253 4.01 No 3 May,1976 (pm) Above to Below June , 1976 (am) Above to Below 0.1226 4.04 No
" 4.01 No June, 1976 (pm) Above to Below 0.0191 July, 1976 (am) Above to Below 0.0013 4.00 No July, 1976 (pm) Above to Below 0.0793 4.02 No August,1976 (am) 0.0002 4.00 No
] August,1976 (pm) Above Above to Below to Below 0.0440 4.00 No September,1976 (am) Above to Below 0.0057 4.02 No September,1976 (pm) Above to Below 0.0848 4.02 No October,1976 (am) Above to Below 0.0802 4.00 No October,1976 (pm) Above to Below 0.0474 4.01 No November,1976 (am) Above to Below 0.0249 4.02 No l November,1976 (pm) Above to Below 0.0098 4.04 No December,1976 (am) Above to Below 0.5538 4.01 No December,1976 (am) Above to Below 0.2024 4.02 No a
64
" O' Table 11. Continued p 3 Rejece H F,2 t O
January,1977 (am) Above to Below There is no temperature 0.0330 4.01 No difference between above and below effluent January,1977 (pm) Above to Below 0.0637 4.01 No February,1977 (am) Above to Belcw " 0.0272 4.03 No February,1977 (pa) Above to Below 0.2843 4.03 No g March,1977 (am) Above to Below 0.1128 4.00 No March,1977 (pm) Above to Below " 0.0911 4.00 No April,1977 (am) Above to Below 0.0103 4.01 No April,1977 (pa) Above to Below " 0.0000 . 00 No May,1977 (am) Above to Below " 0.0769 4.00 No g May, 1977 (pm) Above to Below 0.0610 4.01 No June,1977 (am) Above tc Below " 0.0043 4.03 No June,1977 (pm) Above to Below " 0.0496 4.01 No July,1977 (am) Above to Below " 0.0000 4.00 No July,1977 (pm) Above to Below 0.0894 4.05 No August,1977(am)AbovetoBelow " 0.0905 4.00 No O August, 1977 (pm) Above to Below 0.0480 4.01 No September,1977 (am) Above to Below 0.0059 4.01 No September,1977 (pm) Above to Below 0.0513 4.01 No October,1977 (am) Above to Below
- 0.0201 4.00 No October,1977 (pm) Above to Below 0.0205 4.01 No O
November,1977 (am) Above to Below 0.0995 4.01 No November,1977 (pm) Above to Below 0.0128 4.02 No December,1977 (am) Above to Below - 0.0718 4.00 No Cecember,1977 (pm) Above to Below 0.2169 4.02 No January,1978 (am) Above to Below 4.9189 4.00 Yes @ January,1978 (pm) Above to Below 0.5584 4.01 No February,1978 (am) Above to Below 0.3879 4.02 No February,1978 (ps) Above to Below 0.2195 4.02 No March,1978 (am) Above to Below 0.0344 4.00 No March,1978 (pm) Above to Below 0.0639 4.01 No April, 1978 (am) Above to Below 0.0123 4.01 No April, 1978 (pm) Above to Below 0.1327 4.01 No May, 1978 (am) Above to Below 0.0315 4.00 No May, 1978 (pm) Above to Below 0.0172 4.02 No June,1978 (am) Above to Below 0.0102 4.02 No June,1978 (pm) Above to Below 0.0090 4.01 No July, 1978 (am) Above to Below 0.0124 4.00 No July,1978 (pm) Above to Below 0.0254 4.01 No e i e
i l i 65 } Table 11. Continued ! p 3 ,,3,gg7 H F,2 g
.O There is no temperature 0.0177 4.00 No i August, 1978 (am) Above to Below difference between above and below effluent discharge
" 0.0167 4.02 No August, 1978 (pm) Above to Betow
" 0.0187 4.01 No September,1978 (am) Above to Below " 0.0113 4.02 No
'O september,1978 (pm) Above to Below i
" 0.0255 4.00 No l
October,1978 (am) Above to Below " 0.0525 4.00 No ' October,1978 (pm) Above to Below
" 0.0330 4.01 No November,1978 (am) Above to Below " 0.0130 4.02 No Novemeer,1978 (pm) Above to Below
" 0.1343 4.00 No
- O December,1978 (am) Above to Below 4.00 No
- 0.3037 December,1978 (pm) Above to Below 1
l " 1.7407 4.00 No January,1979 (am) Above to Below " 3.6670 4.00 No January,1979 (pm) Above to Below
- 0.7931 4.02 No February,1979 (am) Above to Below " 0.8543 4.02 No February,1979(pm)AbovetoBelow Q
- 0.8076 4.00 No March,1979 (am) Above to Below " 0.5309 4.01 No March,1979 (pm) Above to Below
" 0.2217 4. 01 No April, 1979 am) Above to Below " 0.0611 4.02 No April,1979 pm) Above to Below 2.0702 4.00 No May, 1979 (am) Above to Below ". 4.03 No l0 nay, i979 (pm) Above to Beiow 1.s80s
! " 2.1788 4.02 No June, 1979 (am) Above to Below " 2.3569 4.01 No ! June,1979 (pm) Above to Below i
" 0.9778 4.00 No i
July,1979 (am) Above to Below
- 1.3280 4.00 No July, 1979 (am) Above to Below l 4.01 No
" 0.0207
!O August,1979 (am) Above to Below August,1979 (pm) Above to Selow
" 0.1547 4.02 No
" 0.0246 4.01 No September,1979 (am) Above to Below " 0.0930 4.02 No September,1979 (pm) Above to Below
" 0.0329 4.00 No October,1979 (am) Above to Below " 0.0060 4.00 No October,1979 (pm) Above to Below O November,1979 (am) Above to Below 0.0000 0.0036 4.00 4.02 No No November,1979 (pm) Above to Below
" 0.0027 4.00 No December,1979 (am) Above to Below " 0.0238 4.01 No December,1979 (pm) Above to Below IH = null hypothesis.
,O 2a F calculated F statistic. 3F, == tao e F stadstic. t lO i i l 0
66 O Table 12. Analysis of variance (ACV) of water te-perature in the vicinity of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Colorado, fee each nonth above and below effluent discharge (am and pm) before Station operation (Jat vary 1975-tiovember 1976) and af ter Station operation (Oecember 1976-December 1979). H F,2 7 3 Reject? O January, 1975-1976 (am) above effluent discharge itere is no temp. 7.4876 4.00 Yes difference tetween years for the same temp. collection site Janua ry, 1975-1976 (pm) above effluent discharge " 3.2631 4.00 *io S Februa ry, 1975-1976 (n) above effluent dischrage " 10.4267 4.00 Yes Fe brua ry, 1975-1976 (,n) above effluent discharge " 4.8545 4.00 Yes March,1975-1976 (n) above effluent discharge " 0.0664 4.00 No March,1975-1976 (pm) above effluent discharge " 0.2038 4.00 No April,1975-1976 (am) above effluent dischage
- 1.7187 4.00 No g April,1975-1976 (pm) above effluent discharge
- 0.5729 4.00 No May,1975-1976 (am) abcve effluent discharge
- 0.0000 4.00 No May,1975-1976 (pm) above effluent discharge "
3.6533 4.00 No June,1974-1976 (am) above effluent discharge " 3.8947 3.15 Yes June,1974-1976 (pm) above effluent discharge " 7.3644 3.15 Yes June,1974-1976 (am) below effluent discharge " 0.0550 3.15 No g June,1974-1976 (pm) telow effluent discharge " 1.1655 3.15 No July,1974-1976 (am) above effluent discharge " 21.4519 3.15 Yes July,1974-1976 (pm) above effluent discnarge - 5.5664 3.15 Yes July,1975-1976 (am) below effluent discharge
- 43.6828 3.15 Yes July,1975-1976 (pm) below effluent discharge "
13.7327 3.15 Yes August, 1974-1976 (am) above effluent discharge " 4.0375 3.15 Yes August, 1974-1976 (pm) above effluent discharge
- 1.82S0 3.15 No O August, 1975-1976 (am) below effluent disenarge
- 7.9461 3.15 Yes August, 1975-1976 (pm) telow effluent discharge "
2.4062 3.15 No September, 1974-1976 (am) above effluent discharge " 1.3647 3.15 No September, 1974-1976 (pm) above effluent discharge
- 0.5799 3.15 No September, 1975-1976 (am) below effluent disenarge "
1.8921 3.15 No September, 1975-1976 (pm) below effluent discharge
- 0.9942 3.15 No S
October, 1974-1976 (am) above effluent discharge
- 3.8333 3.15 Yes Octo ber, 1974-1976 (pm) above effluent discharge "
3.4883 3.15 Yes October, 1975-1976 (am) below ef fluent discharge " 7.2620 3.5 Yes Octo be r, 1975-1976 (pm) belcw effluent discharge " 7.6086 3.15 Yes Novembe r, 1974-1976 (am) above effluent discharge " 0.387 3.15 No Novembe r, 1974-1976 (pm) above effluent discharge " 0.5358 3.15 No November, 1975-1976 (am) above effluent discharge
- 0.3262 3.15 No g Novembe r, 1975-1976 (pm) below effluent dischanje 10280 3.15 No December, 1974-1975 (am) above effluent discharge "
20.5833 3.12 Yc December, 1974-1975 (pm) above effluent discharge
- 16.7355 3.12 Yes Janua ry, 1977-1979 (am) above effluent discharge "
43.1377 3.12 Yes Janua ry , 1977-1979 (pm) above effluent discharge " 14.7188 3.12 fes g January, 1977-1979 (as) below effluent discharge
- 36.2471 3.11 Yes Janua ry, 1977-1979 (pm) below effluent discharge "
6.3438 3.11 Yes Feb rua ry, 1977-1979 (am) above effluent discharge
- 7.2803 3.12 Yes February, 1977-1979 (pm) above effluent discharge "
9.0839 3.12 Yes Fe brua ry, 1977-1979 (am) below effluent discharge
- 3.9063 3.13 Yes Februa ry, 1977-1979 (pm) below effluent discharge 4.3764 3.13 Yes 4
4
~ _
67 O Table 12. Continued 3 H F,2 F g Re9ct? O March,1977-1979 (am) above effluent di5 char 9e There is no temp. offference between 20.7935 3.11 Yes years for the same temp. collection site M.Mh,1977-1979 (pm) above effluent discharge " ;7.0337 3.11 Yes March,1977-1979 (am) below 2.~ fluent discharge 19.5550 3.11 Yes March,1977-1979 (pm) below effluent discharge 14.8039 3.11 Yes O April,1977-1979 (am) above effluent discharge " 28.7645 3.12 Yes April,1977-1979 (pm) above effluent discharge " 13.7148 3.12 Yes April,1977-1979 (am) below effluent discharge 27.2842 3.12 Yes April,1977-1979 (pm) below effluent discharge 12.9279 3.12 Ves May,1977-1979 (am) above effluent discharge 3.C531 3.11 No May,1977-1979 (pm) above effluent discharge 4.74
- 3.12 Yes May,1977-1979 (am) below effluent discharge 0.55b 3.11 No O- May,1977-1979 (pm) below effluent discharge "
2.5605 3.13 No June,1977-1979 (am) above effluent discharge " 0.7131 3.12 No June, 1977-1979 pm) above effluent discharge 6.0639 3.12 Yes June, 1977-1979 am) below effluent discharge
- 0.4412 3.12 No June,1977-1979 pa) below eff1t.ent discharge 8.4953 3.12 Yes July,1977-1979 (as) above effluent discharge "
29.3634 3.12 Yes O July,1977-1979 (pm) above effluer.t discharge " 26.0263 3.13 Yes July,1977-1979 (am) below effluent discharge " 29.9934 3.12 Yes July,1977-1979 (pm) below effluent discharge 35.1136 3.13 Yes Augt.st, 1977-1979 a above effluent discharge 10.2649 3.11 Yes August, 1977-1979 above effluent discharge 14.1640 3.12 Yes Augu st, 1977-1979 below effluent disenan;e " 26.7108 3.11 Yes August, 1977-1979 (pm) below effluent discharge 16.7154 3.12 Tes O September, 1977-1979 (am) above effluent discharge " 2.8545 3.11 No a September, 1977-1979 (pm) above eff1"ent discharge 3.7462 3.13 Yes September, 1977-1979 (am) below effluent discharge 2.1056 3.12 No September, 1977-1979,(pm) below effluent discharge 3.8262 3.13 Yes October, 1977-1979 (am) above effluent discharge " 16.9197 3.11 Yes October, 1977-1979 (pm) above effluent discharge " 4.1161 3.11 Yes Q October, 1977-1979 (am) below effluent discharge
- 19.0860 3.11 Yes October, 1977-1979 (pm) below effluent discharge 4.3455 3.11 Yes November, 1977-1979 (am) above effluent discharge 5.5778 3.11 Yes November, 1977-1979 (pm) above effluent discharge 1.5040 3.13 No November, 1977-1979 (am) below effluent discharge 5.0858 3.11 Yes November, 1977-1979 (pm) below effluent discharge 1.4489 3.13 No December, 1976-1979 (am) above effluent discharge 1.24b8 2.68 No O December, 1976-1979 (pm) above e' fluent discharge "
2.4397 2.68 No December, 1976-1979 (am) below effluent discharge 1.3239 2.68 No December, 1976-1979 (pm) below effluent discharge 3.4498 2.68 Yes l H = null hypothesis. 2F , = calculated F statistic. , O h,e'$2$1e'5t*ti5 tic-l I I O l O
68 DISCUSSION O Exact delineation of specific effects of Generating Station operation are virtually impossible. Several factors obfuscate an examination of cause and effect relationships, not the least of which is the unreliability 9 of the temperature data for the South Platte River collected by Public Service Company of Colorado. Slight differences between above-effluent readings and below-effluent readings were frequently recorded and were 9 not abnormal. However, many extreme readings reported seemed improbable (e.g., -3.3 C and lower in winter months, 26.0 C and higher in summer months). The rapidity with which water temperatures often changed in O less than 12 hours (e.g., a 10.0 C or more change was frequently noted) indicated what was considered to be an unreasonable water temperature variation. Because of such vagaries, the temperature data were treated 6 circumspectly. For example, temperatures at high or low extremes can be immediately detected as faulty, but mid-range values cannot be categorically discounted. For example, a value of 8.0 C in March is not unusual, nor 9 is a value of 4.0 C or 12.0 C. Sometimes only one value was recorded for a scheduled measurement with no indication as to whether the reading was above or below the effluent discharge. Occasionally, no readings O were made for one day or several days in succession. Some greater-than-anticipated differences in temperature were reported between stations above and below effluent discharge when there was no discharge from 9 Goosequill Ditch. These differences were probably because of a lack of uniformity in selecting temperature-measuring sites. If the inconsistencies G 6
69 in the data are ignored, most differences among the same month of different O years may be explained by different meteorological conditions. The possible unrealiability of the temperature data makes detailed analysis of the effects of temperature changes upon the aquatic macroinvertebrate q^ community largel; conjectural . Significant differences among months (am and pm, above ar.d below effluent discharge) and among months before and after initiation of power generation would normally be expected because of varying meteorological conditions. If the discharge from Goosequill Pond altered the thennal regime of the South Platte River, the change should have been detected by comparing water temperatures above and below (am and pm) effluent discharge. However, no significant differences were found. Nevertheless, some discernible changes in the macroinvertebrate community were detected after Station operation began. A discussion of observed changes in this community requires recognition ci several factors that may qualify the results. Changes in personnel definitely were reflected in the data, llowever, the length of the study 1 tended to average aberrations and diminish the affect of problems that might arise in the final analysis. The level of taxonomic identification uasks, to a certain extent, the diversity of the macroinvertebrate ~ communities. For example, Cricotopus is a very speciose genus, and some representatives normally would be expected throughout the year. In contrast, Paralauterborniella has relatively few species and would
?
naturally be present for a restricted period. Nor can the fact that some species occur throughout the year be ignored (e.g., Hyalella azteca). Cycling of populations is certainly a natural ohenomenon. Thus, a group abundant one year may be rather rare the next, and
10. O changes in abundance may be explained by natural cycling. Drift may account for the repopulation of the area (hynes 1970). , Associated with drift population is the constantly-shifting substrate. Within a station, required (or preferred) habitat components may be lacking (or in short supply) one year but present the next. Import of , upstream components (organic and/or inorganic) influences the structure of the comunity (Vannote et al.1980). The effect of the heated effluent depends largely upon the differ-O ential between the discharge and the ambient water temperature of the South Platte River and the ratio of discharge volume to within-stream volume. Obviously, the season is an important consideration. Associated O with physical considerations is the category of the invertebrate. El e-vated temperatures may accelerate the development of summer species but retard or stop development of winter species. 6 The salient features of the 6-year study are the increased number of macroinvertebrate taxa and greater comunity diversity of the below-discharge-point stations after initiation of power generation. Annual e patterns of community diversity changed markedly after Station operation began. At SP4B, diversity was lowest in the first quarter and greatest in the last, with a steady increase in the intervening O quarters. The altered pattern was not so obvious at Cl, but changes did occur. The dilution effect of the St. Vrain River mitigated the affect of the Station's effluent. 9 The increase in macroinvertebrate taxon numbers may be explained I by either improved identification or an actual increase in number. Both factors may be invoked to explain the change. Hcwever, slight temper-ature increases above normal levels and nutrient introduction may have O
!O 71 altered the environment to the benefit of previously-marginal or absent
- O forms but not caused sufficient deterioration to preclude typical foms.
Since discharge was intermittent and certainly did not cause severe eutrophication of the South Platte River, it seems reasonable to suppose i0 that slight alterations enabled some forms to successfully invade the area. As unusual foms were responsible for the increased taxon numbers, this explanation does not seem implausible. Fish species indigenous to 'O the area were found in fairly constant numbers during the study. Histor-ically, most foms found in the area were warm-water species. Slight changes in temperature and nutrient load would typically have little
- O effect upon them. The mobility of fishes enhances their ability to escape unfavorable conditions if such should occur. However, more constant and greater effluent discharge may significantly change the patterns observed to date.
'O Station operation was more constant in 1978 than 1977 or 1979, and observed changes in macroinvertebrate comunity structure were most O marked in 1978. The relatively low level of plant operation in 1979 was reflected in the diversity indices. Patterns similar to those prior to Station operation were rapidly re-established. It appeared that the g comunity was able to revert to its pre-operational structure after only a short period of operation. Interestingly, plotting the cycles of abundance of individual macr invertebrate taxa did not generally reveal any altered patterns. O Patterns within one site changed for several forms during the study; but, if the pattern for a particular year was compared to the pattern for that species at other stations, differences Were negligible. Only O
R O Polypedilum_ sp. and Chironomus sp. had obviously different patterns at' stations affected by effluent. Such observations support the axiom , concerning the trees and the forest. Virtually no comparison can be made between the EIS and the data collected from 1974 through 1979. Information on macroinvertebrates in , the EIS is very vague, The data derived from the annual fish collections offered no unexpected results. All forms present were those to be expected in a g high-plains stream. Most foms inentioned as possible denizens in the area in the EIS were found during the study. Altered temperature regimes and increased nutrient load were g postulated to be the most probable causes of any detected changes in aquatic macroinvettebrate corm 1 unities in the study area. However, the unreliability of the temperature data essentially negates any intelli- , gent interpretation of changed temperature patterns and aquatic macroinvertebrate comunity responses. No effort was made to relate nutrient loads to aquatic macroinvertebrate community structure changes. g Thus, virtually nothing can be said about whether altered themal regime or increased nutrient load was respcasible fcr the observed changes in the aquatic macroinvertebrate community. No evaluation of the effect of , the effluent will be possible until the Generating Station operates on a more continuous basis, water temperature is reliably collected, and effects of nutrient introductions are evaluated. G 9 4
lO 73 4 REFERENCES O American Public Health Association. 1971. Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater, 13th ed. Amer. Publ. Hith. Assoc., Washington, D.C. 874 p. Brittain, J. E. 1977. The effects of temperature on the egg incubation period of Taeniopteryx nebulosa (Plecoptera). Oikos 29:302-305. Carlson, C. A. 1976a. Aquatic invertebrates, pp. 30-37. In. F. A.
; Glover, ed., A biological survey of Fort St. Vrain Nui: Tear j Generating Site. Thorne Ecological Institute, Boulder, CO.
I'
. 1976b. Fishes, pp. 40-50. In. F. A. Glover, ed., A !O biological survey of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Site.
Thorne Ecological Institute, Boulder, CO.
, W. D. Frank and P. E. Stacey. 1975. Aquatic macroinverte-brate, Fort St. Vrain Ecological Investigations. 1975 Semi-annual
- Report. Report to Thrne Ecological Institute. 64 p.
- O
, W. Don Fronk and S. Cressey. 1974. Aquatic invertebrate monitoring, Fort St. Vrain Ecological Investigations. 1974 Arnual Report. Report to Thorne Ecological Institute, Boulder, CO.
. W. D. Frank, D. L. Propst, R. L. Fahrer and P. E. Stacey.
- O 1977. Aquatic invertebrate monitoring, Fort St. Vrain Ecological Investigations. 1977 Annual Report. Report to Thorne Ecological Institute. 38 p.
Corkum, L. D. 1978. The nymphal development of Pa aleptophlebia adoptera (McDunnough) and Paraleptophlebia mollis (Eaton) (Ephemeroptera: lo Leptophlebiidae) and the possible influence of temperature. Can. J. Zool. 56:1842-1846. Elliott, J. M. 1978. Effect of temperature on the hatching time of eggs of Ephemerella ignita (Poda) (Ephemeroptera: Ephemerellidae). Freshw. Biol. 8:51-58. Galat, D. L. and W. J. McConnell. 1974. A quantitative baseline inven-tory of the aquatic macroinvertebrate and periphyton communities of the South Platte and St. Vrain Rivers, Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. Final Report prepared for Thorne Ecological Institute. Thorne Ecological Institute, Boulder, CO. 188 p. Hynes, H. B. N. 1970a. The ecology of stream insects. Ann. Rev. Entomol. 15:25-42.
. 1970b. The ecology of running waters. Univ. Toronto Press, Toronto. 'O
- O
74 C Johnson, M. D. 1972. The aquatic biota of St. Vrain Creek and the South Platte River adjacent to the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. M.S. Thesis, Colo. St. Univ. , Fort Collins, CO. 151 p. , Khoo, S. G. 1968. Experimental studies on diapause in stoneflies. I. Nymphs of Capnia bifrons (Newman). Proc. Roy. Entomol. Soc. London, Ser. A. 43:40-48. Knight, A. W. and A. R. Gaufin. 1963. The effect of water flow , temper- , ature, and oxygen concentration on the Plecoptera nymph, Acroneuria pacifica Banks. Utah Acad. Proc. 40:175-184. Lehmkuhl, D. M. 1972. Change in thermal regime as a cause of reduction of benthic fauna downstream of a reservoir. J. Fish. Res. Board Can. 29:1329-1332. , Stacey, P. E. 1977. Diversity and heavy metal content of South Platte River invertebrates. M.S. Thesis, Colo. St. Univ., Fort Collins, C0. ll2pp. Sweeney, B. W. and R. L. Vannote. 1978. Size variation and the distri-bution of hemimetabolous aquatic insects: Two thermal equilibrium hypotheses. Science 200:444-446. 8 Vannote, R. L. , G. W. Minshall, K. W. Cumins, J. R. Sadell, and C. E. Cushing. 1980. The river continuum concept. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 37:130-137. Ward, J. V. 1976. Effects of thermal constancy and seasonal displace- ' 8 ment on community structure of stream macroinvertebrates. In. Thermal Ecology II, G. W. Esch and R. W. McFarlane (eds.), MDA Symposium Series (CONF-750425), p. 302-307. O O 9 O O
e 75 9 3 ALGAL MONITORING 3 3 l by i i Paul Kugrens l l) i l l 0 l l 3 o O
O 76 INTRODUCTION e For eight years algal data have been collected from aquatic habitats utilized by the Ft. St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. This study has O followed the objectives outlined by Public J$rvice Company in the original environmental impact statement (1972). The objectives for algae were the following:
- 1. To include detailed investigation of algae.
a) Baseline evaluation of important species b) Inventory of algal species c) Effects of effluent on biota, including algae, to be of prime consideration
- 2. Growth of algae which might be toxic to livestock will be identified.
- 3. Specific studies of the effects of NALC0 water treatment chemicals
- will be included in the ecological program.
All of these objectives, except M, have been fulfilled for the algal program. Additional data on algal ecology and possible toxin production have also been provided. The reason for the lack of data for h is obvious. The Generating Station has been operational only for intermittent, limited times during the course of this sti fy. Therefore it is difficult to ascertain what direct environmental impact continual operation of the Generating Station has on the algal component of the biota. Nevertheless, there were some notable alterations in habitat at specific river sites that influenced or changed algal populations. G 4
O 77 Predictions for changes in algal composition were also made in the O original impact statement. Many of these predictions were not correct. Furthermore, from the initial, cursory observations taken in 1971 it is now apparent that different algal groups should have been sampled and O this was done in subsequent years. However, the macroscopic forms that were identified initially show that some significant changes in algal populations may have taken place. O This report includes a sumary of findings from the past eight years, a discussion of the validity of initial predictions, possia'4e reasons for observed changes, whether the objectives have been met, and an evaluation O of the methodology. MATERIALS AND METHODS O Concrete blocks were set up at seven river sites for sampling peri-phyton, because these are most indicative of local conditions. Monthly collections consisted of scrapings from 25 cm2 areas of the blocks and O adjacent natural substrates such as mud, bricks, etc. Identification and counts were made imediately following collection, using a Leitz com-pound microscope with phase optics. Counts were taken in a Palmer counting O chamber or a Sedgwick-Rafter counting chamber using a Whipple ocular micro-meter. Actual numbers and living: dead cell ratios were recorded. Photo-graphic verification accompanied all counts and identifications. O Phytoplankton samples were taken in Goosequill Pond and the rivers by collecting water in one gallon bottles. Direct counts were taken from the water since sedimentation involves a long time period and the counts, thus, O O
78 0 might not be representative of the actual sample due to cell death or reproduction. Furthermore, killing cells for sedimentation interferes with determining which algae are living. Phytoplankton populations are most reliable in Goosequill Pond because periphyton are often eliminated due to lack of light penetration because of large numbers of phytoplankton. Periphyton, huwever, were sampled for cualitative reasons. Conversely, phytoplankton were sampled in the rivers for the same reason. O Specific lists and counts were correlated with temperature, pH, turbidity and current velocity. Of these, currents and extremes in temperature were most useful . There were four sites that potentially could be affected by Generating Station activities in several ways. Either water removal or discharge i would occur at these sites. As a result of water removal or discharge, 0: the six sampling stations were selected to determine the effects of generating activities. The potentially affected sites are Goosequill Pond (GQ), the South Platte River above plant-effluent entrance (SPI) and O' below effluent entrance into the river from Goosequill Pond (SP), and St. Vrain River at pumping station (SVI). CONCLUSIONS AND DISCUSSION O
- 1. Species Inventory A total of 280 species has been identified during the eight year information gathering period. There were 130 species of diatoms, 91 greer
- algae, 27 blue-green algae, 14 euglenoids, 9 golden-brown algae, four yellow-green algae, two cryptomonads, two dinoflagellates, and one red 9
9 L
D 79 alga (Table I). Many of the algae are either representative of upstream areas and were carried in by the current, or they did not constitute signi-ficant growths in any population sampled. Most of the algae are pollution tolerant organisms that can adjust to a wide range of temperatures. S Only seven algal species are cocinon and important in local algal popu-lations (Table II) and are present in samples throughout most of the year. These algae are the diatoms Navicula cryptocephala,flitzschia palea and D 5tephanodiscus hantzschii; the green algae, Cladophora olomerata, Rhizoclonium hieroglyphicum and Scenedesmus quadricauda; and the euglenoid, Euglena viridis. A description of these algae is provided in Table II. D Distinct algal populations (indicator species) were recorded for all sampling sites. For instance, a diatom, Nitzschia palea was the most dominant periphyton in the South Platte River, followed by another diatom, D flavicula cryptocephala. While the St. Vrain River also had the same dominants, the order of the two diatoms was often reversed. Furthermore, during the warmer months, large, benthic populations of Cladophora glomerata, D a filamentous green alga, grew profusely on any available rock or concrete substrates. On the other hand, during the winter, large populations of Euclena viridis were evident at all sites, although its appearance is 3 delayed one or two months in the St. Vrain River when compared to the South Platte River. Other algae commonly found in certain rivtr sites during late summer included Enteromorpha intestinalis, Rhizoclonium hieroglyphicum ) and Hydrodictyon reticulatium.
- 2. River Habitats There are basically three localized habitats in both rivers that sup-port distinctive algal populations--standing water, moving water (current)
D
80 0 Table I. Algal Species List for Aquatic Habitats Near St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station g Division Bacillariophyta (Diatoms) Achnanthes conspicua Gomphonema intricatum Achnanthes exigua Gomphonema lanceolatum g Achnanthes inflata Gomphonema parvulum Achnanthes lanceolata Gomphonema subclavatum Achnanthes linearis Gomphonema truncatum Achnanthes minutissima Gyrosigma sp. Actinella punctata Gyrosigma acuminatum Amphipleura pellucida Gyrosigma attenuatum g Amphiprora ornata Gyrosigma exilis Amphiprora paludosa Gyrosigma macrum Amphora ovalis Gyrosigma obtusatum Amphora pediculus Gyrosigma scalproides Asterionella formosa Hannea arcus Biddulphia laevis Hantzschia amphioxis , Brebbissonia sp. Melosira ambigua Caloneis amphisbaena Melosira granulata Caloneis silicula Melosira italica Cocconeis disculus Melosira varians Cocconeis placentula Meridion circulare Cyclotella compta Navicula sp. , Cymatopleura elliptica Navicula acus Cymatopleura solea Navicula capitata Cymbella affinis Navicula cryptocephala Cymbella lanceolata Navicula cuspidata Cymbella minuta Navicula exigua Cymbella tumida Navicula graciloides
- Cymbella turgida Navicula iridis Cymbella ventricosa Navicula minima Diatoma elongatum Navicula pupula Diatoma hiemale Navicula pygmaea Diatoma vulgare Navicula radiosa Diploneis elliptica Navicula rhynchocephala Entomoneis ornata Navicula tripunctata 8 Epithemia sorex Navicula viridula Eunctia pectinalis Neidium iridis Eunotia vanheurckii Nitzchia acicularis Fragilaria capucina hitzschia amphibia Fragilaria construens Nitzschia apiculata Fragilaria cratonensis Nitzschia dubia e Fragilaria vaucheriae Nitzchia fonticola Fragilaria virescens Nitzschia gracilis Gomphoneis erieuse Nitzschia holsatica Gomphonema sp. Nitzschia ignorata Gomphonema acuminatum Nitzschia linearis Gomphonema affine Nitzschia palea 9 Gomphonema angustatum Nitzschia paleacea Gomphonema constrictum Nitzschia ?igmoidea O
) 81 Nitzschia sublinearis Closteriopsis longissima ) Nitzschia triblionella Closterium sp.
Nitzschia vermicularis Closterium acerosum Pinnularia sp. Closterium lunula Pinnularia gibba Closterium setaceum Pinnularia latevittata Coelastrum microporum Pinnularia microstauron Coelastrum sphaericum
) Pinnularia viridis Pleurosigma sp.
Cosmarium sp. Cosmarium botrydis Pleurosigma delicatulum Cosmarium costatum Pleurosigma elongatum Cosmarium subreniforme Pleurosigma strigosum Crucigenia irregularis Rhizosolenia eriensis Crucigenia quadrata
) Rhizosolenia longiseta Rhoicosphenia curvata Dactylococcus infusianum Dichotomosiphon sp.
Rhopalodia gibba Dictyosphaerium planktonicum Stauroneis anceps Dictyosphaerium pulchellum Stauroneis phoenicentron Dimorphococcus lunatus Stephanodiscus hantzschii Dysmorphococcus sp. D Surirella angustata Enteromorpha intestinalis Surirella biseriata Francia ovalis Surirella capronii Gloeocystis botryoides Surirella elegans Gloeocystis gigas Surirella ovalis Gonium pectorale Surirella ovata Golenkinia radiata 3 Surirella patella Haematococcus lacustris Synedra acus Hyalotheca mucosa Synedra actinoides Hydrodictyon reticulatum Synedra amphicephala Lobomonas rostrata Synedra delicatissima Micractinium pusillum Synedra filiformis Microspora floccosa Synedra minuscula Oedogonium sp. 3 Synedra rumpens Oocystis sp. Synedra tabulata 00 cystis borgei Synedra ulna Occystis lacustris Tabellaria fenestrata Pandorina morum Pediastrum boryanum Division Chlorophyta (Green Algae) ) Pediastrum duplex Pediastrum sculpatum Actinostrum hantzschii Pediastrum simplex Ankistrodesmus convolutus Pediastrum tetras Ankistrodesmus falcatus Phacotus lenticularis Carteria sp. Planktosphaeria gelatinosa Characium ambigua Pleurotaenium sp. ) Chlamydomonas sp. Protosiphon botrydioides Chlore11a sp. Pteromonas aculeata Chlorogonium sp. Pteromonas farotidrus Chlorogonium elongatum Pteromonas sinuosa Chlorogonium euchlorum Pyramimonas tetrarhynchos Chlorogonium spirale Rhizoclonium hieroglyphicum 3 Chlorococcum sp. Scenedesmus acuminatus Chodatella sp. Scenedesmus armatus Cladophora glomerata Scenedesmus bijuga ,)
, _, _ . . . _ . - - , . _ _ - - - _ _ , - . _ _ _ _ , , _ - - - - . . _ _ ~ _ ,
O 82 Scenedesmus dimorphus Gloeocapsa sp.
- Scenedesmus quadricauda Gomphosphaeria sp.
Selenastrum gracile Lyngbya sp. Selenastrum lacustris Lyngbya nana Selenastrum westii Lyngbya spirulineides Sorastrum sp. Merismopedia sp. Spirogyra spp. Merismopedia punctata
- Spondylosium plana Microcystis aeruginosa Staurastrum sp. Nostoc sphaericum Staurastrum chaetaceros Oscillatoria sp.
Staurastrum paradoxum Oscillatoria limnetica Stichococcus bacillaris Oscillatoria limosa Stigeoclonium tenure Oscillatoria minnesotensis # Stephanosphaera pluvialis Oscillatoria princeps Tetraedron lunula Phormidium sp. Tetraspora sp. Phormidium tinctorium Thoracomonas phacotoides Rivularia sp. Ulothrix sp. Spirulina major Ulot;irix subtilissima e Ulo trix tenerrima Division Euglenophyta (Euglenoids) Ulothrix zonata Volvulina steinii Astasia sp. Wislouschiella planktonica Euglena acus Zygnema sp. Euglena caudata Euglena viridis & Division Chrysophyta (Golden-Brown Hyalophacus sp. Algae) Phacus brevicauda Anthophysa vegetans Phacus heliccides Chrysameba radians Phacus longicauda Dinobryon sp. Phacus pyrum Dinobryon actminatum Phacus tortus S Dinobryon camp!.nulostipitatum Peranema sp. Ganyostomum semen Trachelomonas sp. Heliapsis mutabilis Trachelomonas gibberosa Synura sp. Trachelomonas hispida , Synura sphagnicola Division Pyrrophyta (Dinoflagellates) Division Cryptophyta (Cryptomanads) Ceratium hirundinella Chilomonas sp. Massartia-like sp. (unident.) Cryptomanas ovata Division Rhodophyta Division Cycnophyta (Blue- n Batrachospermum (Chantransia) sp. # e) na na c cinalis Division Xanthophyta Anabaena flos-aquae Anabaena limnetica Botrydiopsis sp Anacystis ridulans Ophiocytium sp." Aphanizomenon flos-aquae Tribonema sp" 9' Chaemos1pSon curvatus Vaucheria sp* Chaemosipion incrustans Chroococcas sp. O
%, u u; v $ L $ G G Table II Description and Occurrence of Connon Algal Species Species Description liabi tat Cladophora glomerata Course, branched, filamentous green alga. Grows on sulx.ierged rocks or other substrates Euglena viridis Fusiform, unicellular, microscopic alga; Grows encysted on exposed mud or sub-green pigmentation. Euglenoid, changes merged fine silt. Found as extensive rhape. green patches along banks of rivers during late winter months.
tlavicula cryptocephala r Diatom. Golden-brown bilaterally- Grows on mud or submerged areas. symmetrical unicell. Boat-shaped with Golden-brown patches on surface of sub-round, inflated ends. Motile. Raphe strates. Grows in same areas as (groove) along midline of top and bot- Nitzschia palea. tom of cell wall. m w Nitzschia palea Diatom. Narrow , fusifonn unicell . Same as Navicul_a_ cryptocephala. Raphe (groove) along edges of cell wall. Rhizoclonium hieroglyphicum Unbranched, coarse filamentous green Form free-floating, extensive mats in alga. Goosequill Pond and in stationary waters in the rivers. Scenedesmus _quadricauda Four-celled colony with two spines Planktonic in Goosequill Pond. eminating from end cells. Stephanodiscus hantzschii Radially synynetrical diatom. Thin Usually planktonic as in Goosequill Pond. spines along edge of cell walls. Sometimes growing in Cladophora popula-tions.
84 O and riffle areas. The most common habitat involves current over sand or fine silt. These areas support large diatom populations throughout the G year and include euglenoids during late winter months. Most samples were taken from this extensive habitat. Standing water occurred in backwater areas or behind dams. In addi- 9 tion to having a diatom flora characteristic of flowing water, these sites fomed large floating mats of the green algae Hydrodictyon, Rhizoclonium, and Spirogyra. Such was the situation at sites SVI, SV and backwater areas e at other sites during late summer. The rif*le areas are shallow water areas passing over rocky substrates. These rocks supported large populations of Cladophora glomerata which in turn g might support epiphytic diatoms such as Diatoma vulgare and Stephanodiscus hautzschii . During the colder months or periods of swift currents only the basal portions of Cladophora survived. Quantitative sampling of this alga g was not feasible due to its restricted growth patterns within a given area.
- 3. Goosequill Pond Goosequill Pond represented an unusual habitat since it was man-made and manipulated more than any river site. Scenedesmus quadricauda_was the dominant alga through most of the year (Fig. 3). In addition, from April O
to October, the filamentous green alga, Rhizoclonium hieroglyphicum, formed extensive floating mats around the edges of Goosequill Pond. Some possible deleterious effects from these algae on other living organisms have been observed and will be discussed later. 9 e
) l 85 l l ' l
- 4. Species Diversity
) Species diversity was low in all aquatic habitats, indicating polluted conditions. As mentioned in the initial environmental impact statement, the rivers collect large quantities of industrial and municipal wastes and D dissolved solids before reaching the site. This was reflected not only in low species indices but also the types of dominant algae.
- 5. Fluctuations and Seasonal Succession _in Algal Populations Figures 1-6 represent algal population numbers from 1977-1979. The fluctuations are representative of previous years. As reported previously, the rivers primarily have diatom ropulations dominated by Nitzschia palea 3
and Navicula cryptocephala, although sporadic, temporary increases in other , diatom species might occur. These sporadic increases were insignificant l during a year's sampling period. 3 The figures for sites showed that warmer temperatures tended to l increase population numbers but these did not show any optimum temperature l ! ranges. The diatoms have a wide tolerance for different conditions. Rather, D it appeared to be an interaction between temperatures and current that affected the populations. ! The figures also showed a general similarity in population numbers and b species composition. This indicated that the sites and method of sampling l were valid. This was particularly true for 1979 where there was a general decline in algal populations. Even the sites that were not affected by ) Generating Station activities displayed similar declines. If the Generating Station would have been responsible for this decline at specific sites, the other sampling sites should have shown significantly higher population P l 6 O t _
86 O numbers. Furthennore, there were no correlations between Generating Station operation dates and population fluctuations. O Another interesting feature of river populations was the appearance of the euglenoid, Euglena viridis during late winter months (Figs.1, 2, 4-6). This also was a comon feature of preceding sampling years. G
- 6. Effects of Generating Station on Aquatic Habitats There are four sites that are apparently affected by Generating e
Station activities: the areas behind the dams in both rivers, which create stationary water environments when the dams are in place; Goosequill Pond which receives Generating Station effluent; and the area downstream from the discharge of Goosequill Pond water to the South Platte River, which is affected by Goosequill Pond. The lake-like conditions behind the dams creatad areas of debris deposition which provided unfavorable growth conditions for most organisms. Anaerobic e.onditions were created causing death of algae and consequently further sedimentation. The sediments might reach several feet in depth. O Other features of this habitat included large growths of large pond or lake algae such as HydrodQtyon, Enteromorpha and Rhizoclonium. Since Goosequill Pond received effluent from the Generating Station, O obviously the fluctuations of water levels, lutrients and temperatures were affected by the Generating Station activity. The conditions seemed to favor Scenedesmus quadricauda. However, if the pond remained unfrozen during the winter, a shif t to the diatom Stephanodiscus hantzschii, took # place. The site downstream from the entry of Goosequill Pond water into the South Platte River often had significant numbers of algae representative # 9
O 87 of Goosequill Pond. Other river sites did not show this tendency.
- O 7, NALCO Effects While NALC0 was identified as a toxicant in the original environmental O impact st?tement, this did not appear to be the case in laboratory studies on algae, which were conducted in 1973. Under different conditions--axonic, unialgal, autoclaved vs. non-autoclaved NALCO media--we obtained several results. In axenic non-autoclaved conditions, there was no increased growth O
of algae. However, using autoclaved NALC0 or NALC0 media in which bacteria had been grown, a significant increase in the test alga Scenedesmus quadri-cauda ccurred. The results indicated that NALCO is biodegradeable (by O bacteria in our experiments) and heat labile. It also is an organophosphate, thus the phosphates are released upon degradation and utilized by Scenedesmus. Using phosphate-free media with autoclaved NALC0 enhanced the growth of -g Scenedesmus. Therefore the release of NALCO into aquatic systems could promote the rate of algal growth. O 8. Toxic Algae Three species of blue-green aigae that have been reported to be toxic to livestock were identified during the course of this study. These algae
- O were Anabaena flos-aquae, Aplanizomenon flos-aquae, and Microcystis aeruginosa. However, none of these grew to " bloom" proportions during the past eight years, so there was no danger to livestock.
O Other algae that were not considered toxin producers have recently been determined to produce phytotoxins. For instance, Scenedesmus quadricauda, the dominant alga in Goosequill Pond, Hydrodictyon reticulatum, 'O ,O
88 O and Nitzschia palea release compounds that can affect other organisms in various ways. Scenedesmus, Hydrodictyon, and Nitzschia have been shown O to p.oduce plant toxins that affect growth and development cf higher plants. This could be a factor in stressing plants and reducing plant growth in areas irrigated with water from Goosequill Pond. Knowing that this parameter p exists would permit proper identification of biological vs. Generating Station effects.
- 9. Comparison of Environmental Impact Statement (1972) With Recent Data The following observations were made prior to 1972:
A. The farm pond (Goosequill Pond) had a heavy growth of Hydrodictyon reticulatum, Oedogonium sp. and Rhizoclonium hieroglyphict..a during the 1971 season. B. Cladophora glomerata (found during all seasons), Stigeoclonium flagelliferum, Olothrix tenuissima and Spirogyra sp. were dominant in the rivers and clogged the riffles of the river when the water level was low. O C. St. Vrain River was similar to South Platte River. The gr *. test obvious difference was in the presence of Enteromorpha intestinalis-- the dominant algal species. This grass-like alga is normally found O in saltwater habitats. It grew in the irrigation ditches. No Enteromorpha was found below confluence of streams. D. Below confluence of South Platte and St. Vrain, water was swift; attached algae were not as abundant; Chadophora glomerata was 9 dominant. Some diatoms and zooplankton were collected but not identified. O' O
- O gg E. Salinities of the rivers were high, as evidenced by growth of
!O Enteromcrpha intestinalis. The initial samples involved only macroscopically identifiable algae at all sites. For instance, the identified large green algae were slow growing and not O reliable indicators of rapidly changing conditions and were restricted to a few months of growth each year. Rather, the diatom flora, which was mentioned in statement D, should have been
- O sampled since these have been the most reliable indicators of lotic ecosystems. Consequently, the listing of green algae did not provide a good data base for comparison with recent data.
O
- 10. Comparison of Predictions with Actual Results A. Algae are subject to thermal impact. High temperatures tend to restrict the number of species of periphyton. Each species has an optimum temperature range.
B. Blue-green algae likely would become the dominant species in irrigation ditches and discharge areas. -O C. The biocide (NALC0 321) is toxic. D. Blue-green algal toxicity. Anabaena sp. potentially serious problem for livestock.
- O As indicated in the previous sections, these predictions did .not come true. One component that remained untested was the effect of high tempera-O ture on algal populations. It was predicted in 1972 that excessively warm temperatures (99 F) would cause a drastic shift in algal populations to blue-green algae. Since such temperatures were never reached, this popula-lg tion change still remains speculative.
O
90 O
- 11. Environmental Trends and Changing Situations The abundance of green algae in the rivers prior to 1972 indicated some changes since that time. The only alga that grew abundantly after 1972 was Cladophora glomerata. Enteromorpha occurred sporadically in If Enteromorpha is an indicator of salinity as stated O localized areas.
in #5 then the salinities of the rivers have decreased. Stigeoclonium flagelliferum may have been misidentified since our samples yielded only S_. tenue. Stigeoclonium was never a significant # component of the river flora. Goosequill Pond has undergone a drastic change with regard to Hydro-dictyon reticulatum and Oedogonium sp. Our initial observations in the 9 sumers of 1972 and 1973 also indicated large growths of these two algae. In subsequent years, however, both algae disappeared from Goosequill Pond. Whether the current dominant, Scenedesmus quadricauda, was present prior G to 1972 is not known. Obviously there have been some changes in these aquatic habitats since 1972 and it might be due to a change in current velocity. As recent data e suggest, Hydrodictyon, Enteromorpha and Rhizoclonium are quiet water algae, therefore the observations prior to 1972 in the rivers may be due to slower currents and lower water levels. g Since 1972 algal populations have not shown much change throughout the years and no changes in dominants have occurred. Fluctuations in populations can be explained by temperature, current, ice formation, water levels and g shifting substrates in the rivers. Goosequill Pond probably is more affected by temperatures , water levels, nutrient availability, and diversf or. of water. g O
O 91
- 12. Generating Station Effects on_ Environment O There are no direct effects of the Generating Station on the algal flora. As mentioned previously this critical aspect is lacking due to intermittent operation of the Generating Station. Influences other than O operation of the Generating Station have been noted in preceding sections.
- 13. Factors Influencing Environmental Quality g There do not appear to be any new factors that influenced algal populations. The stability of the populations over an eight year study indicate that conditions have remained the same.
g Non-generating station influences include municipal waste discharge, upstream sedimentation, farm drainage, and drastic changes in currents. All these conditions contribute to a polluted stream. O o O l 1 I O lO 1
92 O Figure Legends O Fig. 1. SVI - St. Vrain Intake Fig. 2. SV - St. Vrain Below Intake Fig. 3. GQ - Goosequill Pond 8 Fig. 4. SPI - South Platte Above Intake Fig. 5. SPGQ - South Platte Below Intake Fig. 6. SP - South Platte Below Intake and Discharge from Goosequill Pond O Abbreviations used in Figures. O EL - Extremely slow currents ES - Extremely swift currents O L - Slow currents M - Average current flow S - Swift currents O O l O O O
C h O o s lD4S IN1 S 3 L IO 1 O IS 8 1 S 3 IA 2 S IJ 4 S 9 2 7 7 9 IJ 1 S 1 1,1 6 S 1 1 O % lA5S 1 [ lM IF 1 1 7 S S IJ01 0 4 O 9, 4 9 1 3 ID1 1 I N 7 S
) l 3 i 8 I O 5 L 1
O I S 2 01 1 I A 6 2 S I 1 I J 2 L 8 . 7 I J8S 9 1 1 G
\
IM 4 1 S I F O - I A 61 S f I M 7 L
't 1 IF 4 I
I 4 J1 1 8 2, O 2 8 5 l I I I D2S l 1I I N6L I 03 L 1 O - I S7 S 1 II 3 I A5S 2 I J4S r 2 I J3S 2 M3 L g 1 \ 2 O {o ' y I A7 L 1 9 3 7 7 Il , I
! 7 S 9
8, 1 I F8 S 8 I 6 J0S 5, . O , 3 --- .-------_--------~---- 5 43 21 0 98 7 65 43 2 1 0 98 ; 6 43 y1 2 22 22 2 1 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 s .tn h s e t pr nmr de55 e 3 8'o 8 {a- 5 5 j ~ '$ h. ~ oe u MTC O
e m
% O I D4S O
_ I
! 1 S 3
d I O 1 L a S 8 n . I 1 S e l 9 I A3S g 7 2 E u 9 1 I J 4S 2 O 7
- I J1 S I
M 61 S s
^ I A 51 S
, 1 2
1 M 1 S 5 1 F7 S O 4, 3 l J01 2 0, 8 4 7 9 1 l D1 1 l I i N7 S O I I O 5 L 1 1 S 2 M 0 l A 26 S 1 l J 2 L l J1 S 8 O 2 l M1 4 S
\ l A 6 S G
1 s
^ l M;L
,/ ? I l
F4' F 0 7 5, I J1 I O 2 9 9 3 I D2S I N6L 7 1 03L 1 O 7 l 7 9 S 1 S 1 l A 25 S q 1 l J 24 S 1 [ l J3S 2 t' g t l M 3 2 L O
\*
/
I A7 L 1
/
_ / I M7 S
/
I F8S l J0S O
-------~--~--------_~----
543 s . n t 222 22 21 0 9 876 S 4 3 2 2 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 09 8 7 1 5 4 3 21 h se t pr nmr m 333 gq 8 a uj oeu g7j33[ sO . MTC O
( t il
\
\ l j ; 1
' i,* ID5 1
(sliiI,i i e' , s i i ' I I N3 t '
* , 1 O 3 n ,,'s' 1 o i l' s - lS 3 t , , 1
' k fl . 5 9
- n . ,g.* lA 2 7
" a \'
i 9
" l p
i lJ 8 1 2
" o 0
" t y
lJ 3
"" h P
l H 3 2 I'
' l l
A8 1
" a
' M9 f
t 8T o llF 7 _ ~ lJ4
~
~
- - I D2 i ) \ \ l k) ' i I N5 0 41
;t I l Ij I Ii Ig!
i i 1 6 l S 1 I t 8 l i, I i A 2
! - 8 3 J 24
! it I 7
- 1 9 -
1 IJ 8 1 2 t u8 , lt I l l I H 2 2 G I l i
/\ I A 1 1
F
^, IM6
/ 1 I
F1 0 I J2 0 0, 0 2 3 I D3 ii[ IiiIl i g \ l
! l 1 \L I N3
\ il,! I I O 1
. 1lI 1
% rI 8 8 8 8 l' I
S 7 1
, ; g I g r ,
' ' i l I A6 f
I I 2
'I I J 4 i ,
1 2 j , 4 7
,l 1
I J 2 7 e,e 0 9 lI 1 i Ie I H 2 1 . i I I, , I A7
\
" I M8 1
$ I F6 l ' I JI
. - - _ - s .
h s t p 0 0 o 0 0 nm 0 5 c 5 oe 2 1 i HT R3 3y+ 8 S b;= - a j g=5 &c"
3,045,739 688,164 2,744,065 -----Euglena viridis i j , i ll 3
. 25 -
Q 24 - 23 - 3 22 - 2 21 - o 20 - 8 19 - g' 18 - 7 17 -
}"
16 - 15 -
-. 1977 1978 1979 g4 _
*i! 13 -
} 12 - g
~
S 11 3 10 - 3 9-M 8- J
. 7- I E 6-5-
4-
- / t, 3-2- ,
1- ' t,_ ,f'N IIIIIIIIIIII IIllllllll 4 Months J P !! AM JJA S0 ND J FM AMJ JA SON D _1 1III Ii1III Temps. 6 8 9 17 232425 2716 12 6 3 J FMA HJ JAS ON D 2 617 161728 24 272416 7 4 2 71119 20 20262418 13 2 6 Current L L L L EL L L M EL M SS S SS S ELEl. L L LSS S S S S S ES ES L S L SS S
' (
,F I G. 4
( C O O O O O O O O O O _
4,270,506 3,230,160 3,960,008 I i 7,650,285
~
1 si 11 g l I 1 1 I I I ' 25 - Euglena
.$ 24 -
3 23 -
] 22 - 'd 21 -
h 20 - g' 19 -
~
18 - a g7 _ j 16 - 3 15 -
~
14 -
~ l3 -
a 12 -
} gg _ 1977 1978 1979 g 3
10 - y 9-
}
8-7- o 6-g 5-2 4 - - 3 - 2 - /. O
/ N, /g',
i Months IIIIIIIIIIII J F M A 11 J J A S0 N D III IIIIIIIl l 1III IIIIII Temps. J F M AH J J AS ON D J F MA M J J AS ON D 6 8 9 17 2324 25 27 1612 6 3 2 6 17 1617 28 24 2724 16 7 4 2 7 11 19 20 2026 24 18 13 2 6 Current LL L L EL L L M EL M S S S S S S EL EL L LL SS S S S S S ES ES L SL SS S FIG. 5
\ ,105,822 3 \N s 4,075,552
\
l ii I
- 25 - !
T ' y', Euglena j 24 T g 23 - q 2 2 --- M 21 - g 20 - J 19 - ! O 18 -
, 11 -
g 16 - S 15 - f 14 - 13 - y 12 - 3 11 - $ 3 10 - 1977 1978 1979 3 9-f M 8-7- g 6-5- !
- S 4-3- p 2- / \y l- ' \
i,l
\ ^
s_ , s l Month IIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIII IIII IIIIIII J F MA MJ JAS O ND J F fl A M JJ AS ON D JF 11 A M J .I A SO N D Temps. 6 8 9 17 23 24 252716 12 63 Current L 2 6 17 16 17 28 24 2724 16 7 4 27 1119 20 20 26 24 1813 2 6
- 1. I. L El. I. L M EL M SS S S S S EI. EL 1. LL SS S SS S S ES IS 1. S 1. S S S O
F 1 G. 6 o ('
10 99 !O I l l l
- O l
i I l i l 'O lO AVIAN SECTION O lO l l r i O l i
'O I
I l JO
- O
100 O e e l AVIAN MONITORING e e e by Ronald A. Ryder e l o l e e e
'O 101 2
Introduction
'O Studies of avian populations were conducted at the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Power Generating Station Site near Platteville, Colorado, from April 8,1972 to December 1,1979. This investigation was part of a l0 multidisciplinary research program to gather baseline information about the biota near the nuclear facility (Ryder 1976).
The goals of this study were to determine the status of the avian O population and possible pathways of contaminants through that population in the cottonwood riverbottom ecosystem surrounding the nuclear facility. Hopefully, data from this study would provide a means to evaluate environ- 'O mental quality in the environs of the facility and contribute to the knowledge of avian populations. Also, if collected after_ the plant reached full operation, these data would give an indication of the impact 'O of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station on the avian populations. Objectives The objectives of this study were as follows: lO
- 1. To prepare (or acquire) maps showing the dominant vegetation and surface water to facilitate identification of habitats important to birds at the site; fg
- 2. To establish procedures for periodic counting of the various 1
I species of birds utilizing the site; J
- 3. To prepare, by means of field studies and subsequent analysis lO of the data, annotated lists of the avifauna.
- 4. To gather infomation on nesting success of dominant species of birds utilizing the site; g
r iO
102 0
- 5. Where possible, to gather information on food habits of O
dominant avian species. Food sources may be pathways for contaminants to the avian population; and
- 6. To detennine the impact of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear O
Generating Station on the indigenous avian populations and their habitats. Study Areas Bird populations were monitored on three study areas within 3 km of the Nuclear Generating Site which are referred to as St. Vrain River, Goosequill Pond, and South Platte River areas, consisting of 71.6, 8.5 e and 52.2 hectares (177, 21 and 129 acres) respectively (Fig.1). See Ryder (1976) for a more detailed description. Methods # Standard avian census methods were used with some adaptations (Ryder 1976). Data were gathered and analyzed in accordance with the widely-used North American Breeding-Bird Survey (International Bird S Census Connittee 1970) and the Audubon Winter Bird Population Study (Kolb 1965). Censuses began at sunrise. The St. Vrain River and South Platte 9 River areas were systematically searched by ground reconnaissance aided by 7 X 35 or 7 X 50 binoculars, and the pond was censused with binoculars and a spotting scope, observations being made from the surrounding dike. O Birds flying into, from, and contained within the study area were recorded. Spot maps were kept for territorial males during the breeding season. All nests encountered were marked and revisited to record nesting attempts e and success. O
g RR 1{ > S. PLAT T E , j ,' ( ( w -
)" PROPERTY BOutIDARY s ~
1
- N. s- 3 Ptx11e nivea PObD '
RJ
,/ ~'
N,' , , . 3
'~~,,,- ,
d-v DITCH
- r. , , '
s
' ' -s 1
S T. [
- e
' flUCtEAR FA VRAlN y__,' <S9e? s.CILITY I -
s 8 2<;2.... _/,.. ~ . ..,' S
< ROAD
\ >
v s l ST. VRAtH RIVE R ,p , 9,s J
, e, O
gigure 1. t.ocation of three bird census areas (St. Vrain River Soutli Platte River and Goosequill Pond).
104 O An intensive search for Red-winged and Yellow-headed Blackbird nests was conducted at Goosequill pond and a slough and pond complex on ' the St. Vrain unit. Censuses were made with varied frequency throughout the year. Basically, weekly counts were made from May to mid-June and bimonthly
- counts during spring and fall migrations. Monthly or less frequent counts were made in the winter. All three areas were censused 16 times each in 1977,1978 and 1979. Earlier censuses numbered over 20 per year. #
RESULTS Avian Abundance and Species Composition G One hundred eighty-seven species (plus 3 subspecies) were encountered during the eight years of study (Appendix A). This is 34 species more than reported in the initial " Biological Survey" (Ryder 1976). 4 Species present were usually highest in May just prior to nesting, somewhat lower but consistent during nesting, and lowest during winter. Avian species diversity was calculated using Simpson's formula, e
. s D=1- (pi)2 i=1 where pi = proportion of sample belonging to ith species, s = number of a species, and D = index of diversity.
A seasonal pattern was evident for total diversity among the three study areas. In 1972, for example, diversity consistently ranged from e 0.88 through 0.93 with a median of 0.91 for 15 counts f om April 25 to August 3 (also see Benson 1973). Other periods showed a lower diversity index (as low as 0.55 in October). Diversity indices in 1979 were not g much different from those in 1972 (Tables 1, 2, 3, and 4). O
20 105 I Table 1. Species Diversity Indices for Goosequill Pond. O Dates 1972 1979 1st week in May 0.73 0.88 2nd week in May 0.76 0.84 40 3rd week in May 0.76 0.64 j 4th week in May 0.83 0.80 1st week in June 0.81 0.56 2nd week in June 0.85 0.64
- O
- Table 2. Species Diversity Indices for the South Platte River Area
- O Dates 1972 1979 lst week in May 0.89 0.83 2nd week in May 0.89 0.8a lO 3rd week in May 0.86 0.83
! 4th week in May 0.87 0.90 4 1st week in June 0.90 0.88 l 2nd week in June 0.91 0.86- !O l l Tables 3. Species Diversity Indices for the St. Vrain River Area O Dates 1972 1979 l 1st week in May 0.89 0.88 2nd week in May 0.89 0.88 3rd week in May 0.92 0.99 iO
- . 4th week in May 0.88 0.89 l
1st week in June 0.91 0.90 l 2nd week in June 0.?! 0.93 io u I O
~
T 106 O Table 4. Species Diversity Indices for all Three Study Areas Combined Dates 1972 1979 9 lst week in May 0.91 0.90 2nd week in May 0.92 0.91 3rd week in May 0.91 0.91 4th week in May 0.91 0.91 e 1st week in June 0.93 0.90 2nd week in June 0.93 0.91 O Species diversity indices reflect not only number of species but
" evenness" of individuals within species. Thus, a few species and many of one species would yield a low diversity index. Many species with a
- uniform number of individuals for each species would result in a high species diversity. Many ecologists believe corrounities with high species diversity are more stable (less sensitive to ecological changes) than 8 cornunities with low indices but this concept is being challenged.
Cormon Grackles, Red-winged Blackbirds, Yellow-headed Blackbirds and Starlings were difficult to census because they were often seen in 8 large flocks, or some of the latter three species were on nests and not visible during the census periods. However, Starlings and Red-winged Blackbirds were abundant pemanent residents, and Yellow-headed Blackbirds # were abundant on marsh habitats from their first occurrence in spring until departure in fall. Starlings were usually the most abundant nesting species throughout 4-the study and, in general, increased whereas red-wings and yellowheads - decreased as nesters (see Table 7). Starlings are better adaptcd to dis-turbed sites, abandoned buildings, and probably to heavy grazing and e O^
O 107 large numbers of livestock. They cor.monly feed around cattle, especially O following fledging of the young starlings, and in winter are a serious pest in nearby feedlots. The native blackbirds seem less attracted to grazing cattle although redwings, but not yellowheads, commonly visit feedlots to the west of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Site. Total individuals and species seen are summarized in Table 5. Summer, fall and winter populations have fluctuated widely, and no O specific trend is apparent. Spring populations, however, show a fairly distinct pattern of an overall decline in avifauna in 1973 followed by a steady recovery to 1977, with declines in 1978 and 1979. The sharp O decline in 1973 can probably be attributed to habitat deterioration due to flooding. The recovery is probably attributable to a natural return to pre-flood conditions. Grazing of livestock was reduced in 1977 but 0 increased in 1978 and 1979 When a marked decline in redwings and yellow-heads was noted (Table 7). The non-breeding seasons for all eight years were marked by irregular O fluctuations of populations, but breeding bird numbers are believed to be a more sensitive indicator of the state of the habitat. Breeding birds declined during the last two years of the study. Yellow-headed and Red-lC winged Blackbirds, particularly, had a very poor breeding season in 1979 with low hatching success. Most other species fared somewhat better. l See Tables 6 and 7. lO The only obvious differences noted in the habitat in 1978 and 1979 were the reduction in vegetative cover due to grazing, and perhaps lack of runoff water either from irrigation practices or operation of the Fort O St. Vrain Nuclear Generationg Station. No data were collected on the 4
Table 5. Ei9ht-year tabulation of species numbers and population levels from monitoring at the fort St. Vrain fluclear Generating Station (number of species seen per count followed by total individuals), lime Period 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 197fl 1979 January No count 19(762) 19(319) 20(335) 10(340) tio count tio count No count February rio count 19(2884) 24(15,474) tio count 23(422) 24(478) 30(1121) 29(847) tiarch No count 32(709) 25(14,063) 29(709) 33(627) 30(715) 31(546) early April 28(823) 26(326) 32(487) 34(6811) 38(720) tio count 43(622) 34(498) late April 50(871) 34(561) 37(441) 44(719) 46(903) 40(717) ist wk Hay 47(574) 33(381) 45(534) 45(591) 48(729) lio count U 37(488) 2nd wk 11ay 47(583) 39(382) 62(833) 52(533) 47(777) 50(640) 54(510) 3rd wk May 48(593) 45(543) 43(563) 55(728) 54(855) 43(522) 38(397) 45(466)N a' 4th wk May 48(691) 38(450) 46(523) 50(635) 49(656) 45(565) 44(451) Ist wk June 35(500) 39(373) 40(641) 42(491) 38(569) 49(614) 43(518) 40(426) 2nd wk June 41(558) 33(414) 42(583) 40(419) 42(513) 46(660) 42(450) 40(416) 3rd wk June 38(551) 38(426) 33(469) 34(340) 39(5fl5) 44(635) 40(457) 43(536) 4th wk June 37(509) 32(324) 34(426) 37(373) 110 count 4 0( 5119 ) 41(510) 37(378) ist wk' July 36(704) 33(421) 32(537) 32(483) 311(731) tio count 40(560) No count 2nd wk July 37(681) 29(433) 34(541) 36(522) fio count tio count tio count tio count 3rd wk July 36(680) 34(437) 37(47fl) No count 41(600) 38(534) 37(503) 29(409) 4th wk July 37(588) 30(779) 36(550) 40(1145) No count tio count No count J e e e e e e e e e e
O O O O O O O O O O O Table 5, continued. Time Period 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 19/9 lst wk Au9ust 37(658) 28(838) llo count flo count ilo count 11 0 count tio rount 38(750) 2nd wk August 38(851) 34(1123) 40(386) lio count 110 count 34(571) flo count 3rd wk Au9ust 42(757) 33(997) 35(565) 46(685) 37(2289) flo count tio count 4th wk August No count tio count No count tio count tio count flo count 37(1299) 1st wk September 43(1080) 36(1287) 40(879) 110 count tio count tio count flo count 38(897) 2nd wk September No count No count No count 43(1917) No count flo count 110 count 3rd wk September 45(605) 43(879) 47(2392) llo count 37(1046) 41(980) 33(46M 1 31(1008) 4th wk September No count 39(963) No count ilo count No count No count ilo count October 36(1190) 29(1402) 29(532) 31(442) 46(596) 34(856) 30(1692) 25(1737) b November 32(1642) 23(455) 23(2057) 27(387) 33(580) 26(458) 26(565) Ho count December 23(611) 22(283) No count No count No count ilo count flo count 22(192) H Hay 1973 counts probably not comparable to those in 1972 and 1974. Due to floods, it was not possible to complete counts of all 3 areas weekly in May 1973. U Early May count in 1978 delayed by unusually late snowstonn.
110 O Table 6. Sunnary of the 1979 intensive nest search on the St. Vrain Study Area and Goosequill Pond. Total Percent Percent Percent 8 Area and Species Nests SuccessfulE Unsuccessful Unknown SJ. Vrain Study Area American Bittern 2 0.0 100.0 0.0 83.3 16.7 8 Yellow-headed Blackbird 6 0.0
.Nd-win 9ed Blackbird 22 4.5 77.3 15.2 Mourning Dove 3 0.0 66.7 33.3 8
Gooseouill Pond Yellow-neaded Blackbird 3 0.0 0.0 100.0 Red-winged Blackbird 3 0.0 0.0 100.0 MEggs to fledglings. e Table 7. Total nestings of Red-winged and Yellow-headed Blackbirds at the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, 1972-1979. Number of Nests Followed Species 1972 1973M 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 0 Red-winged Blackbird 27 25 27 16 26 68 23 25 53 100 33 9 GD Yellow-headed Blackbird 54 20 31 56 1 MoosequillPondwas drained in May 1973 and May 1979. l l e i l l e 1 e l
r O f lO
- 111 avian census project regarding water levels nor changes in water flow.
O Cattle numberc were recorded on all plots during each bird count. Environmental disturbances increased throughout the study, particu-larly in 1979. Rather heavy grazing of the areas was seen in early 'O spring and late summer. Goosequill Pond was drained in May of 1973 and .t 1979 "in an effort to control muskrat and beaver activity in the peripheral dike." The low water level of the pond favored migrants but not nesting birds. Waterbirds were able to feed there most of the winters and many of the falls. Waterfowl hunting probably affected local wood duck production in the South Platte area. Irrigation in the O adjacent field caused pronounced fluctuations in the water levels of the t.eaver ponds throughout the summer. Efforts were made during at least two :u=ers to poison prairie dogs. Prairie dog numbers, however, O usually recovered by fall, so it is believed the prey base they provide for raptors such as Great Horned Owls was not seriously altered. Food Habits of Birds O A special study of the contents of regurgitated pellets of Great Horned Owls was conducted, as they were the dominant year-round bird of prey on the areas and a study of their food habits might indicate possible pathways of contamination. 'o other food habits data were collected as it would have involved F. filing birds which would have altered census data. O The results of the Great Horned Owl will be the topic of a special report to be developed. But, it is important to note 8 species of resident mammals, 4 resident bird species as well as carp, crayfish, O ,
O 112 and insects wera eaten. The invertebrates, particularly, might be the logical pathways of contaminants through the ecosystem. If abnormal levels of contaminents were reported in any of the small mammals, bio-magnification could occur in the foods of owls. Production of young owls was remarkably consistent (2 to 3 young each year) so no immediate adverse effect of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station is suspected at this point. Our study indicates that contrary to their primarily nocturnal habits, the Great Horned Owls fed to a large degree on the diurnal black-tailed prairie dog (21.2% biomass). Perhaps future consideration employing poisoning to control prairie dogs should recognize that Great Hornw Owls are helping control these rodents and that there may be a danger of poisoning non-target species. O
SUMMARY
Eight years of repeated censuses of birds indicate that avian species diversity has remained rather constant but that total numbers of individ- 8 uals (especially nesters) has been declining the past 2 years from a peak in 1977. Similar declines in nesting Red-winged Blackbirds were reported in the Dakotas by U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service biologists (J. F. Besser, 8 I person 1 com.). Also, reductions were noted in Yell headed Blackbird nesting populations in 1978, and to a lesser extent in 1979, in an inten-sive study of a large marsh approximately 13 miles east (Ryder, unpub- 9 lished data). There drawdown, burning, and hailstorms seem responsible. Declines on Goosequill Pond were, no doubt, largely due to drawdown 9 9 L
iO 113 during the territory-establishment phase of nesting. Continued heavy
' C) grazing of the St. Vrain River study area is considered more detrimental to nesting birds than observed effects of the Nuclear Generating Station operation so far.
- C)
LITERATURE CITED i Benson, D. E. 1973. Avian monitoring at the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear i C) Power Site in Colorado. M.S. Thesis, Colorado State Univ. , Fort Collins. 71pp. International Bird Census Committee. 1970. An international standard
! C) for a mapping method in bird census work. Audubon Field Notes 24:
722-726. Kol b, H. 1965. The Audubon winter bird-population study. Audubon Field !() Notes 19:432-434. Ryder, R. A. 1976. Birds. pp.120-129 In A biological survey of Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station Site. Thorne Ecol . Inst., , C) Boulder, Colo. 138pp. f O l C)
- C)
{
114 O APPENDIX A. Additions to Checklist of Birds of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Site (Ryder 1976). g. Species Status Common Loon (Gavia immer) M, r Horned Grebe (Podiceps auritus) M, u e-Double-crested Cormorant (Phalacrocorax auritus) R, c Green Heron (Butorides striatus) M, r Snowy Egret (Egretta thula) M, u e Common Goldeneye (Bucophala clancula) M, u Hooded Merganser (Lopbadytes cucullatus) M, r Sandhill Crane (Grue, canadensir,) M, r g Semipalmated Plover (Charadrias semipalmatus) M, r Black-bellied Plover (Pluvialis souatarola) M, r Willet (Cetootrophorus semipalmatus) M, u g Pectoral Sandpiper (Calidris melanotos) M, u Baird's Sandpiper (Calidris bairdii) M, u Common Tern (Sterna hirundo) M, r g. Black Tern (Chlidonias niger) M, u Burrowing Owl (Athene cunicularia) S, u Poor-will (Phalaenoptilus nuttallii) S, r Tree Swallow (Iridoprocne bicolor) M, u Long-billed Marsh Wren (Cistothorus platensis) S, u Bewick's Wren (Thryomanes bewickii) M, r Veery (Catharus fuscescens) M, r Townsend's Solitaire (Myadestes townsendi) W, u Blue-gray Gnatcatcher (Polioptila caerulea) M, r O Golden-crowned Kinglet (Regulus satrapa) W, r 9
O 115 APPENDIX A, continued. O Species Status Philadelphia Vireo (Vireo philadelphicus) M, r Warbling Vireo (Vireo gilvus) S, u O Tennessee Warbler (Vermivora peregrina) M, r Blackpoll Warbler (Dendroica striata) M, u Yellow-breasted Chat (Icteria virens) S, c O American Redstart (Setophaga ruticilla) M, u Orchard Oriole (Icterus spurius) M, r House Finch (Carpodacus mexicanus) R, u Lesser Goldfinch (Carduelis psaltria) S, r White-throated Sparrow (Zonotrichia albicollis) W, u 'O
- R - Resident a - abundant M - Migrant c - correnon
'O l W - Winter Resident u - unconinon S - Suniner Resident r - rare
- O o
.O O
V O 116 O O O l l l 9 TERRESTRIAL SECTION O O O' O l ' O
O 117 O O VEGETATION MONITORING O O O by Charles D. Bonham O and Deborah Grace Steward O O O O
118 O INTRODUCTION The vegetation adjacent to the St. Vrain Nuclear Power Generating Station was investigated from 1972-1979. The purpose of these investigations was to inventory and classify the veyt? tion, and to test for directional change in the vegetation as a result of changing # environmental parameters, especially those caused by the Generating Station. Early efforts focused on vegetation inventory and classification; # from this work seven general categories of vegetation were recognized: 1.) Cottonwood 5.) Native pasture 2.) Willow carr 6.) Irrigated and seeded e 3.) Cattail-sedge pasture 4.) Abandoned cropland 7.) Roadsides and fencelines Specific information on these types can be found in the 1972 and 1973 reports as well as the Biological Survey report of 1976. If the vegetation samples taken during the inventory period are grouped according to dominant and sub-dominant species the following classification emerges: I. Undisturbed Lands (or, more specifically, less disturbed) A. Short-grass prairie with shrubs B. Mid-grass prairie g C. Saltgrass coninunities D. Moist to wet communities II. Disturbed Lands A. Extremely disturbed weedy communities B. Pastures and fields C. Modified short-grass prairie D. Modified mid-grass prairie These groupings are very general and have a high degree of inter- g gradation. 4
'O 119 Western wheatgrass (Agropyron smithii) was the species with g greatest mean ground cover at the time the initial inventory was made in 1972. It was followed in importance by saltgrass (Distichlis stricta),
and, at a considerably lesser cover value, cheatgrass (Bromus tectorum). The relative importance of cheatgrass is a strong indication of a dis-turbed environment. The ten most abundant species of the St. Vrain Nuclear Power Generating Station area at the time of the 1972 inventory are given in Table 1.
- O The vegetation of the St. Vrain area is fairly typical of that for the region; human land use practices such as farming, livestock grazing, and irrigation ha ! had a marked impact on the structure O
and composition of the vegetation. In order to separa3e possible effects that the St. Vrain Station might have on tne vegetation from other effects of human and animal disturbance, exclosures were placed in the primary vegetation types found around the plant. These exclosures were used to measure vegetation cover, which is defined as the area of land surface upon which the shoot biomass is projected, 2
- O and production (oven dry grams /M ) of aboveground plant material.
These quantities from inside the exclosures were compared with values of the same variables taken from outside, and adjacent to, the exclos-O ures. The location and names of the exclosures are shown in Figure 1. Ten exclosures were placed at the beginning of the research period; two were temporary and used only in the early phase of the investigation
- O to measure the characteristics of the cattial-sedge and willow carr communities. These results have been discussed in earlier reports.
Of the remaining eight exclosures, one was destroyed during the course
'O of investigation. One study area, the St. Vrain River Loop, was not O
120 C e TABLE 1. Mean cover, standard error, and range for the ten most important herbaceous species encountered in the inventory sample. O Species Mean S.E. Range Agropyron smithii 5.1 7.1 31.0 9 Distichlis stricta 4.1 9.4 30.0 Bromus tectorum 2.6 6.5 40.0 Poa pm tensis 2.5 5.7 29.0 e Equise::en kansan:m 1.6 10.2 70.0 Kochia scoparia 1.6 4.8 26.0 Sporobolus cryptandrus 1.3 2.0 10.0 O Andropogon gerardi 1.0 5.4 36.0 Tararacam officinale 1.0 1.9 8.0 Bromus inermis 0.9 4.0 26.0 O O 9 9 O
O 121 KEY TO SYMBOLS: X) = Confluence Exclosure X = Irrigated Pasture Exclosure 2 X3 = ,Goosequill Exclosure X = St. Vrain River Loop 4 X ng pers xc sure 5= j X6 = Ben Houston Exclosure J
\
X7 = South Platte River Exclosure N
- 9 83 = Willow Carr Exclosure (temporary) 3 = Cattail-Sedge Exclosure (temporary) 2 8 = oefunct permanent exclosure site i 3 l
t (
- O Xi l
N
, 8: N
} Coosequitt Fond lO se. vxin aiver 1
i FLztte River g2 X l X.
- O cooling towers 7 ]powerplant s.
1 0 X.
. Xr M
(O Figure 1. Line drawing of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station study area. lO i
'O 1
122 O really an exclosure, but was an area naturally isolated by the St. Vrain River on one side and property boundaries on the other. This O area was treated as an exclosure because of its separation from the rest of the comunities and the human and livestock impact on them. The six remaining exclosures were periodically subjected to O stress during the course of investigation. All exclosures except the Cooling Tower and Irrigated Pasture were flooded in May and June of 1973. Livestock broke into some of the exclosures early in the course O of the investigations as well. Because of such problems, all exclosures were re-fenced and re-established during late 1973 and early 1974. Results given in this report are based or. information O collected since spring of 1974. METHODS Fifteen plots 20 x 50 cm in size (0.1 M 2) were systematically placed on a 3 x 5 grid within each exclosure to sample herbaceous production. Fifteen 0.1 M2samples were also taken outside of and adjacent to the exclosure. Each of the plots were clipped in 1 August of each monitoring year to estimate standing crop. This estimata was made by species or by growth-form. Clippings were l Results are presented as O all converted to an oven-dried basis. total production by g/M 2. Data from 1977-1979 were analyzed using discriminant function analysis to test for significant differences between inside and outside the exclosures. O 2 Vegetation cover was measured by twenty-five 20 x 50 cm (0.1 M ) plots placed on a 5 x 5 grid within the exclosures. Vegetation cover outside the exclosure was measured using the same number O O
l 1 10 123 of plots systematically placed at 2 M apart at a 10 M distance from the exclosure. Cover was estimated using cover classes: 1 = 0-5% 4 = 51-75% 2 = 6-25% 5 = 76-95% 3 = 26-50% 6 = 96-100% O and results were tabulated using the mean value of the class (i.e. 2.5% for cover class 1) as the numerical value reported for cover. Cover sampling was conducted in June and August of each year. Results were lO reported by summing mean species response into the following categories: Perennial Native Graminoids Perennial Introduced Grasses (including those used forseeding) Perennial Native Forbs Perennial Introduced Forbs
- O Annual Native Grasses Annual Introduced Grasses Annual Native Forbs Annual Introduced Forbs Shrubs Total g This grouping was done in order to facilitate recognition of change in community structure as a function of plant growth-form. A differ-ence value was calculated by subtracting the sum for each category O f r each year utside the exclosure from the sum for each category for each year inside the exclosure. This difference value is pre-sented in bar graphs.
O RESULTS AND DISCUSSION A number of factors influenced the vegetation results reported here. One problem with any long-term study is the turnover of field and laboratory personnel. Another confounding factor is environmental variability, which can easily mask, over short periods of time (up to fifty years), any significant changes that the vegetation might be undergoing. Environmental oscillations are reflected in the production O
124 O and cover values, as well as the relative importance, of vegetation species and growth-forms. The influence of these factors cannot O be easily identified, but must be considered to have an effect on the variability and error levels of the data. The use of exclosures presents problems of another nature. Often, O especially on the plains where wind is an important environmental factor, the fences themselves act as catchments for many weedy species as they are dispersed across the landscape. This, in conjunction 4 with the moisture that may possibly be present as a result of a " snow-fence" effect, can bias the apparent response of the vegetation to release from grazing pressure. In addition, when cover classes are e used to estimate vegetation cover (a technique that is used to minimize differential estimator abilities), it is necessary for a species or growth-form to show at least a 12.5% change in cover before 9 any effects become apparent. Results presented in this section were interpreted with these factors in mind. Production Table 2 gives total production values during the monitor years of 1977-1979 for all exclosure sites and the St. Vrain River Loop. The most productive exclosure was the irrigated pasture; this is not surprising in light of the supplemental watering it received. Ben Houston Exclosure, located in a seeded pasture, also showed greater productivity than most sites. The remaining exclosures, and the St. Vrain Loop, showed similar production values. O Table 3 shows the result of discriminant analysis on production data for 1977-1979. The variables used to make the discriminations are given in column 2 of that table. Once, again, the Irrigated O O
9 125
- TABLE 2.
Total production values for exclosures in grams / meter for the three monitor years. O 1977 1978 1979 Exclosure in out in out in out 4 Confluence 67.5 36.3 84.1 80.0 172.8 169.6 Irrigated Pasture 525.7 209.7 277.8 165.3 31 2.3 285.1 ~~, Goosequill 62.5 51.1 62.2 68.4 108.7 160.1 Cooling Tower 147.3 103.5 72.4 92.6 82.0 56.4 Ben Houston 462.3 270.2 511.2 48.9 336.6 161.0 South Platte 292.9 59.5 152.1 104.4 162.6 180.4 St. Vrain Loop 333.4
- 183.0
- 72.7
,
- value not taken 3
D 3
126 O Table 3. Discriminant Analysis using two variables to show differences between inside and outside the exclosures. Exclosure Variables Used Year Significance S. Confluence 3rocas tectorw./ 1977 - 3* Sympn.0"PC' or:carpos #"# 1978 - occidentalis 19/9 - 9 Irrigated Pasture 3roras inermis 1977 .01 So!ygor.am coccine.c: 1978 .01 1979 .01 4' Goosequill Broras cectorz./ 1977 .05
- 3. Japonicus 1978 -
Sporobolus cryptandrus 1979 .05 Cooling Tower Ar.brosia coronopifolia 1977 - e 3porobolus cryptar.drus 397g ,93 1979 - 1 South Platte !Uras radicans 1977 .01 U~P #*'P
- occidentalis 1978 -
- 1979 -
Ben Houston Agrapyron elongatum 1977 .01
%stichlis stricca ,93 3979 1979 .01 O
O 9
O 127 Pasture and Ben Houston exclosures were prominent; in this case because of consistently significant differences between inside and out. These differences may confidently be ascribed to grazing practices. The South Platte River exclosure shows significant difference in 1977 based on shrub production. The Goosequill exclosure shows signifi-cant differences in 1977 and 1979 based primarily on differences in annual grass production. Cover O St. Vrain loop. Although not an exclosure, thit: area is of interest because it was not much influenced by humans or livestock. It is, however, subject to periodic flooding, which has a disturbing O effect on the vegetation. Recovery from flooding is somewhat evident in the increasing total cover values (most evident in the graph of June cover values) from 1974 to 1979 (Figure 2). Native perennial 'O grasses and introduced perennial forbs dominated this location, with a seasonal peak of annual grass cover in June. Confluence Exclosure. The shrub category best illustrates the O trend effected by release of grazing pressure on the vegetation of this exclosure. With the exception of 1978, there is a general upward climb of shrub cover within the exclosure compared to cover O values outside the exclosure. This is reflected by the positive difference values shown for shrubs in Figure 3. Weedy perennial forbs clearly seemed to do better inside the exclosure than outside
- O it. A slight trend toward an increase of perennial native grasses and graminoids within the exclosure could be shown in the August graph; this should certainly not be taken as strong evidence for O directional change.
- O i.
i . w h , 4 g ggg g $1. M4 Afdh tilr
, , , , , , , . ma avets was a
i i 42 ! = s* E A l 5 j i l. !" a b --* h2 5" i ,.
.__ _. . l. _ !.] _ _ _
--- k, - - ' , ,, , ,,,
l l-igure 2. Percent of ground covered for St. Vrain River Loop saniple. WEvlMIms: 1 Each bar within each group represents a year in the following t us: r<rennial native crass or cracainoid
"#Y JUNE: 1974 - 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1978 - 1979 : Perenial Intmfuced Grass
" k; Perean'ai native Ford AUGUST: 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1979 FFI; Ferennial Introdx ed Forb l Ab!: Annual Introduced Grass i
o e o e o e o e o e e
i 1 1 m a uN tilfil 15 U2444 ae .
,, ameunisseas j me swin soies 3>
! , seems ['*l I 1 3
$ N
$ 't ns y
y aa r^1 n g g L-i g au
; y. y
- r 2, n.
V "8 ma j 19 ma i 3
;; e B f'~ '
.- sE, _ _. _
r" ~ 1 y*-
~ -
-h- 8 r',
/ - ----
- 5 Y** t g g-J y y ~s*8 a
gg O.m E ne
==
S,$ a E w. m y6 na to
= u
~
E
~. h -88 i
~
l_, _ J
.. E h .se g -es E E ABBRE VI AT10tl5:
88 PGis: Perennial Native Grass or Graminoid 1 PGl: Perennial Introfuced Grass
,, Pfra: Perennial Native Forb PFI: Perennial Introduced Forb AGI: Annual Introduced Grass Figure 3. #"* ^""" '" "*
Difference values for Confluence Exclosure. Each bar within each group represents a year in the following way: JUNE: 1974 - 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1978 - 1979 AUGUST: 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1979
130 0 Irrigated Pasture Exclosure. It is very clear from looking at the negative difference values that the vegetation outside this exclosure is dominated by introduced perennial grasses (Figure 4), especially meadow g fescue (Festuca elatior). Diversity appears to be higher inside the exclosure, as shown by the greater number of positive difference values for categories other than perennial native grasses. Perennial native forbs g were uniformly more abundant inside the exclosure. A trend toward increasing cover within the exclosure can be seen by looking at total difference values in August when the early flush of perennial introduced grasses due to g irrigation has been moderated. Goosequill Exclosure. No easily interpretable information can be drawn from this exclosure. Differences in cover between inside and out are , more marked in June than August; perennial introduced grasses and annual introcuced grasses seem to dominate the exclosure (Figure 5). This could be attributed to the effects of the exclosure itself, as mentioned earlier. g Cooling Tower Exclosure. The data from this exclosure are incon-clusive. The ambiguity of the results are perhaps due to the proximity of this exclosure to construction activity and heavy grazing. The June and , August results seem contradictory (Figure 6). Ben Houston Exclosure. The high negative difference value (Figure 7) for perennial native grasses may be due to western wheatgrass, which is , being called a native grass, in a pasture seed mix. Another possibility is that saltgrass, an unpalatable range grass, had a high cover outside the exclosure because of reduced competitive pressure from other, more heavily 9 grazed, species. Competition within the exclosure wculd keep the cover of this species and consequently the perennial native grass growth-form low. In general, no conclusions abcut the effect of the exclosure can O confidently be made. O
O~
~
O O O O O O O O O O i 1 i ' a .- n d i l* Malls imitK lEARAM j .. -c.., l Ig;3AllB IEltM IMitr4R
..>c..=.,
j s. g . i. j g r" , ! n' I r d as j
,, I i, ;
s 3 a _a _ - m ~ -~ ~~ n d L- g a , a E- *'Iy " n;. no g
- n v
.. s ge i
__. 8. .. . _ . _ s.
- ./. t'
- g. g we t_,I__s C i
I j h E 'a I E i { y U
?.
i i h - 0 a g.. a ..,.. m. sein
-le i
1 ABBREVI AT10r45: j m PGN: Perennial Native Grass _ , ._3 L ,., 8 PGl: Perennial Introduced Grass 58 PIN: Perennial Native Forb PFl: Perennial Introduced Forb Figure 4. Difference values for Irrigated Pasture Exclosure. Each Art- Annual Introduced Forb bar within each group represents a year in the following way: JUNE: 1974 - 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1978 - 1979 AUGUST: 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1979 i
i
=
- GU3Will I A11ER ama tuvie = w s
- n. unlelli tultum mee,I tosia vasuas 34 _
y 3 i .. !- i ~ * ~~l si ej f I r 3 a g , na h "' r*s X . , 2, ,,, y -
' ,7 l
n
= - ,-_ %
<_,_, r ,sp d in-j _sn
.. 8 '7 l e __M * 'i i, . u ,. 3 ai l .,. i lllI__
g
- n. g e l
= m" g ~*
t
~"
U
- te ABBREVIAT10 tis:
l E ' ' ' n PGN: Perenntal Native Grass
- 3' PG1: Perennial Introduced Grass PFN: Perennia) Native Forb PFl: Perennial Introduced Forts
.=
AGl: Annual Introduced Osass Afi: Annual intro (aced Fws fi9ure 5. Difference values for Goosequill Exclosure. Each bar within each group represents a year in the followin9 way: JUNE: 1974 - 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1978 - 1979 AUGUST: 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1979 O e e e e e e e e o e
m ae , OHIL kMAIXhf2M-2' ans. cena amas g" .. n N st 8 u n' f L* y
= ,.. .
r', ou I"1 g-S r-S .
- g. _ _ _. 6, _ _ m _ _ g _ ,i _ g m - l _ __
J __. _j .. _ 3
,,, -. .. l e,a w "I
.6 g %,,J L__,_J l i evim .. LJ E est rts s
.gg 5
n la . ABBREVIATIONS: PGN: Perennial Native Grass
-n PGI: Perennial Introduced Grass PFN: Peren:alal Native Forb PFI; Perennial Introduced Forb AGI: Annual Introduced Grass AFI: Annual Introduced Forb Figure 6. Difference values for Cooling Tower Exclosure. Each bar within each group represents a year in the following way:
JUNE: 1974 - 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1978 - 1979 AUGUST: 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1979
es e 113 tittlin iMNJat and tevaa sm ua b ** H 31str gim l s][tJs3 anuss teve s stias
= ,
24 N s': ,_, , <, E M t
.! e ! r-m if, it ,__u_, @ ,,
3 $ U U E , u --.
$ E $
- k" y
h u_ ____ _ . . LT8 l .. __ 6_ , _J ____.E___ - - -- w L-r - M [' , , t_, _2 Aa E v a E .. t 5
$. E -se L,3 a
. as ABBREVIATIONS:
31 4
.. PGN: Perennial Native Grass PGl: Perennial Introduced Grass figure 7. Difference values for Ben Houston Exclosure. Each bar Pri: Perennial introduced forb within each group represents a year in the following Art: Annual Introduced Fort
"'Y JUNE: 1974 - 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1978 - 1979 AUGUST: 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1979 O e e e e e e e e e e
O 135 South Platte River Exclosure. This exclosure is similar to the Confluence exclosure in that directional change in vegetation O as a response to reduced grazing oressure is evident in the positive difference values for shrubs (Figure 8). For somt reason, the cover inside the exclosure in August wa; uniformly lower than that outside
- O the exclosure. It may be that increased cover of shrubs leads to a more severe competitive situation fo,- the grasses and forbs, a situation that would be more evident at the end of the growing season O
(August) than at the beginning (June) when resources such as water would not be so limiting. CONCLUSIONS AND INTERPRETATION O From the information generated, it can be concluded that, to date, the St. Vrain Nuclear Power Generating Station has had little, if any, influence on the vegetation communities adjacent to it. This is excepting, of course, direct disturbance that is a function of construction activity. O Some indication of a trend toward increasing cover as a result of release from livestock grazing pressure is evidenced by the increase in production values for some of the exclosures over their adjacent O outside areas. This is somewhat corroborated by the increase of shrub cover within the Confluence and South Platter River exclosures. However, long-term changes, such as an increase in importance of O perennial native grasses within the exclosure, are not yet evident. As mentioned earlier, the exclosure itself may play such a role in modifying the environment that response to reduced grazing pressure O may be confounded. The only solutions to this problem would be to O
SAJ111QAlE klWR11U011 a ama cavia =ms 982 RAIE RAWR talthat 2 f aines tais seus M
~
1 i m s ? >< y 8' E e M H 'd 5 2 'a ! v" 5 a 32 5 it ? E E n E s a
- E $
2 E -# V .__ 2 '1 _l i. - . .j !- '^ y r' ' - - - i I g _ .d '_h . .'_l, ,_4
'i_ui.it i t__ y _4 o
q LrJ s .
e '
} .. t__ , __s k g g J j
5 t h L ,a
- 7. -er I AbbPfvlATIO45:
i ,, PGN: Perennial Native Grass PGI- Perennial Introduced Grass PFN: Perennial N.itive Fort, Figure 8. Difference values for South Platte River Exclosure. PFI: Perennial Introduced Forb , Each bar within each group represents a year in the AGl: Annual Introduced Grass i following way: - JUNE: 1974 - 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1978 - 1979 AUGUST: 1975 - 1976 - 1977 - 1979 O e e e e e e e e o e
jO 137 l increase the size of the exclosures or prohibit grazing over a large O portion of the study area. Even so, significant changes might not become evident for many years. O O i ,0 ^O O 'O !O O 'O
138 O 7 9 EC0 PHYSIOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS 9 9 9 by i M. J. Trlica l 9 9 9 0 9
O 139 INTRODUCTION O Terrestrial vegetation surrounding the St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station may be directly or indirectly affected by the plant's operation. Operation of the Generatics St4 tion will probably result in releases of O small amounts of radionuclides. Heat, water vapor, and salts will also te lost to the atmosphere as a result of cooling tower operation. In addition, water effluents will be released from the station which could O affect vegetation along the water courses, or this water might be used for irrigation. The environmental impact statement relatir.g to the operation of the O St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station indicated that approximately 2300 gpm of water would be lost from tne cooling towers as a result of evaporation and drift. Of course, the actual amount of evaporation and O drift would be dependent upon atmospheric conditions including wind speed and direction, atmospheric stability, air and water temperatures, ambient humidity, and Station power level. Since make-up water for these towers comes primarily O from the polluted South Platte and St. Vrain Rivers, concentrations of salts and other toxic chemicals could be expected to be high. These chemicals enter the rivers as a result of geological processes and because O of industrial and fanning activities upstream from the Generating Station. Biocides will also be injected into cooling tower water to control algae growth. These chemicals also will be a constituent of. the drift and will 3 be deposited in an area around the towers. i Drift depositions from these towers may result in changes of chemical constituents within the vegetation. For example, deposition of 3 some salts on vegetation may result in their absorption and a reduction l of root absorption of other essential nutrients. This could result in l a i
O 140 less vigorous plants. lieavy metals may also increase in vegetation as a result of drift deposition. These heavy netals may then be passed on to g consumer animals in the area. Little research work has been conducted to evaluate cooling tower drift effects on vegetation. It was, therefore, considered desirable to have , an inventory of the ecophysiology of the vegetation which might be affected bv Jater vapor and salt deposition as a result of cooling tower operatic is. Since all animal life is dependent either directly or , indirectly upon vegetation as a source of food, decreased productivity or palatability of vegetation may be detrimental to animal populations. In addition, operation of the cooling towers may result in increased humidi- g ties and temperature changes in the immediate surrounding environrent. Since the St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station is in the Denver Air Pollution Corridor, increased humidity could interact with vegetation, , resulting in increased leaf injury caused by the air pollutants. Numerous studies have indicated that a significantly-detrimental interaction exists between air pollutants and humidity which can cause severe damage to , photosynthetically-active tissues. OBJECTIVES O The objectives of this study were:
- 1. To determine leaf injury by pollutants, disease, and insects for certain species surrounding the Generating Station.
O
- 2. To determine concentrations of important elements in foliage of several species as related to distance and direction from the Generating Station.
O O
- O 141 LEAF INJURi Leaves of cheatgrass (Bromus tectorum), echia (Kochia scoparia),
and cottonwood (Populus sargentii) were collected from a maximum of 32 locations on four radii at distances of 1/8,1/4,1/2 and 1 mile from the Generating Station during rapid spring growth from 1972 through 1979 (Figure 1). Sampling of kochia and cottonwood at these same locations was again repeated when vegetation was mature in August. Fifty leaves were taken from each location at each sampling period. Estimates were O made of each leaf sampled for total leaf area, leaf area injured by chew- t ing insects, and leaf area spotted caused by air pollutants, disease, nutrition, and sucking insects. O A literature search indicated that pinto bean plants were sensitive i to air pollutants. As pinto beans are an important crop produced in the area around the St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, they were utilized
- n during 1973, 1974, 1976, 1977, 1978 and 1979 in a controlled experiment !
to determine effects of air pollution and drift at varying distances and directions from the cooling towers. ! Pinto beans were planted in polyethylene-lined #10 cans in the greenhouse. All plants received similar treatment in the greenhouse until mid July, when plants and containers were transported to the O St. Vrain study site. Sixty-four containers with bean plants (four containers / location) were placed at two distances and eight directions from the cooling towers. Distances from the towers were 50 feet and .O 1/4 mile. The bean plants all received similar amounts of supplemental fertilizer, insecticide, and water. They were allowed to grow for approximately six weeks during each year at the study area. At that
;O time, leaves from each plant in each container were sampled to determine 1
- O
142 O s e p
, . x . . . e . .. . .
#p A.....-
,/ .,_ . J ........ ..,2...._,
/ ..............,,,
w s, A-s. N l e u....,y,, < i
- s
%., , a i;R%" . s .,,i... sf.
ona p.oiemg Peo. d i e o L- , , 'ra' )erN. Il 4' 1 a" , 6 % *s. ) y*r, . i ;
-,,..... I,
,i a a, ,,.....
gl l .
. ....l ,
,a 6 l._ _
= k, e L_ _ _:rT~ uv ____ -v^__ eM . \,
iy O sc a r iis vices
./3 i Figure 1. St. Vrain study area showing locations of collection sites. e 4
O 143 leaf injury. Ten to 20 leaves from each location were collected each year. H wever, because of large numbers of grasshoppers feeding on the O plants in 1979, only enough samples remained for chemical analyses. Wet bulb and dry bulb temperatures at each location for pinto beans O watered. Data were collected using a portable psychrometer. Utili:ing these data, relative humidity and dew point temperature were calculated to aid in detemining the sphere of influence around the cooling towers. Cultural practices such as crop rotation, fertilization, irrigation, and use of insecticides that could influence leaf injury and chemical constituents of vegetation were beyond the control of the investigator. Therefo, a, quantitative data for agronomic species grown in the study area were not taken. The three naturally-occurring species utilized in this study were selected because of their wide distribution and abundance on the. site. In addition, other studies have indicated that Bromus tectorum and Phaseolus vulgaris are sensitive to air pollutants. O ELEMENTAL CONCENTRATIONS IN FOLIAGE Chemical analyses were conducted on foliage samples of kochia and ! cottonwood collected at maturity from each of the permanent sampling !O l locations shown in Figure 1. Aboveground biomass samples of pinto bean I plants in the controlled experiment were collected after six weeks of growth. All samples were dried at 60*C, ground to pass through a 40-mesh lO screen, and stored in glass jars. Chemical analyses indicated concen-trations of nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), potassium (K), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), zinc (Zn), iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), copper (Cu), sulfate lO (SO -S), mercury (Hg), lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd) and boron (B) in plant 4 l o L_
144 O tissue. These analyses indicated whether concentrations of various nutritive and toxic elements were influenced by either distance or 9 direction from the Generating Station through the years of the study. However, not all chemical detenninations were conducted for each species during each year. A brief description of the analytical tecnniques 9 utilized by personnel of the Front Range Laboratory in Fort Collins, Colorado, in analyzing these samples is given in Table 1. 9 DATA ANALYSIS Data on leaf injury and chemical constituents of vegetation prior to electric power generation (1972-1976) were compared with data collected e during the station start-up phase (1977-1979). Analysis of variance was utilized to determine if statistically significant differences for any chemical constituent of vegetation or leaf injury occurred as related to e year, distance, or direction from the Staticn. When significant (p < 0.05) conservative F values were found, Tukey's test was utilized to separate significant (p < 0.05) mean differences, e. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Blowers on the cooling towers were usually not in operation and water , was only being circulated through the towers during 1973 through 1977. However, the blowers generally were in continuous operation in 1978 and 1979. Ambient environmental conditions (relative humidity and temperature) , surrounding the cooling towers were found to not vary significantly (p 0.05) during the study in 1976 and 1977. In 1979, wet bulb and dry bulb temperature was found to increase significantly (p 0.05) with distance from the towers, whereas dew point temperature decreased O
- _ . _ . . . . __ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ ___ . ._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - , = _ _ _
i [ .I .. J Tamle 1. Procedures and equipment utilized t,y tne Front Range Lao. Inc. In analyzing plant samples.
'O Para:eter Procedure Instrumentation References Calcium Mitri:-Peren1oric Acid Pertin-Elmer 5000 colorsco State University Soil (Ca) Digr,stien. Atomic A.A. Spectropnotometer Testing Lac. Plant Analysis ARserption (A.A.) Procedore. August 1971; Guantificattor. Persin-Elmer A. A. Metncos Manual. 1979.
,O Magnesium Nitric-Per:nloric Acid Perktn-Elmer 5000 "olorsco State university soit pig) Digestion. Atomic A.A. Scectrconotometer Testing Lat. Plant Analjsis Absorption (A.A.) Procecure. Augast 1971; Quantification Perkin-Elmer A. A. Petacds Nnual . 1979. Potassium Nitric Percnloric Acid Pertin-Elmer 5000 colorsoo State Untversity soit jo (<> cisestien. Atomic Ansorption (A.A.) A A. Scectroencev.eter Testing tao. aiant Ansiysis Procedure.Aupst.1971; I Quantification Perkin-Elter n.A. Metnces 1 Manual. 1979. ! Zine Nitric-Peren1oric Acid Perkin Elmer 5003 Coloraco State Universit/ Soil (In) Digestion. Atomic A.A. Spectroonotometer Testing Lam. Plant Anal / sis i Absorption (A.A.) Procedure. August.1971; Quantificat n Perkin-Elmer A. A. Methods 'O Manual. 1979. Iron Nttric-Perenteric Acid Pertin-Elmer 5000 colaraco state Universit/ Soil (Fe) Digestion. Atomic A.A. Scectrocnotoceter Testing Lac Plant Analjsis Absorption (A. A.) Procedure. August.1971; Quantification Pertin-Elmer A. A. Petneds Manual. 1979. uO Cc,per nitric.Perenioric Acta Pertin.Eimer 530o Coior,ec st,te uni,ersity soil (Ca) Digestion. Atomic A.A. 5;ectropnotometer Testing Lac Plant Analysis Absorption (A.A.) Precedure. August 1971; Quantification Perkin-Elmer A. A. Metteds Manual. 1979. Nnganese Nitric-Peren1oric Acta Perkin-Elmer 5000 colorado 3 tate University soil (Mn) Digestion. Atomic A.A. 5;ectroonotometer Testing Lao Plant Analysis
- O Absr ption (4.A.) Procedure. August. 1971; O u.tification Perkin-Elmer A.A. Petnods Manu al . 1979.
Lead Nitric-Peren1eric Acid Pertin-Elmer 5000 Colorado State University Soil (Pb) Digestion. Atomic A.A. Scectroonotometer Testing Lab. Plant Analysis > Kosorption (A.A.) Procedure. August,1971;
, Quantification Pertin-Elmer A.A. Petacas xanual. 1979.
lO Cadmium Mitric-Peren1eric Acid Pertin-Elmar 5000 coloraco State University soil (Cd) 3tgestion. Atomic A.A. Spectroonotometer Testing Lao. Plant Analysis Aesorption (A.A.) Procedure. August 1971; Quantification Pertin-Elmer A.A. Petnoes Manual. 1979. Percury Aqua-Regia Digestion. Jarrell-Asn 310 coloraco State 'Jniversity soil
- Q (Hg) Atomic Absorption A.A. Scectrconotometer Testing Lab. Plant Analysis (Cold Vapor Metrod) Procedure. Aurust 1971.
Jarrell Asn Metneds Manual. 1971 (Fisner Scientific Co.) Soron ;ry Asning. Curcumin Coleman Linear Coloraco State ;niversit/ Soil (3) Colorimetric Scectroonotometer Tasting Lac. Plant Analysis U***'"" "****" ^"S"5 - "'i-
!O Coloraco Stata University Soil Sulfate . 311ute .<C1 Extracticn. Coleman L*near (50.* 5) Turoidimetric Scectroonctometer ~4 sting Lac Plant Anal/ sis Ceterm* na cion Fincecure. August,1971.
I
- O
O 146 Taele 1.--Continued Para eter Procedure Instreemtstion aeferexes Phospnerus Vanadomolybconnosenoric Coler,an Lirear Colorado State ontverstty Soil (P) Yellow HNO Me thod 3 Scectropnotome ter Testing Lao. Plant Analysts Procedure. August.1371. '41 troge n Micro-telcan1 Sargent aelsn A.S . A . , Monogr. :4o 3. (N) Recording Titrator o. 1196. IMS. 9 0 ? lIL 9 O O O O 9 9'
O j47 significantly with distance (Table 2). Relative humidity was slightly greater and dew point temperatures were slightly lower near the towers as O compared with data collected at 1/4-mile distance in 1976,1978, and 1979, whereas the reverse was true in 1977. It therefore appears that the maj r sphere of influence around the cooling towers is within 1/4-mile lO distance of the towers. Water samples were taken in 1979 from the cooling towers to compare with makeup water from the St. Vrain and South Platte Rivers, and irriga-
- O tion water in Goosequill Ditch where blowdown water is received. The four locations were sampled once in both July and August. These samples were analyzed for total phosphorus (P), magnesium (Mg), sulfates (504 -S) and electrical conductivity 'EC) by the Front Range Lab., Inc. Although sample size was small, these data indicated that total phosphorus, I sulfate, and electrical conductivity (i.e., salts) were at leatt twice as
- O high in cooling tower water as in makeup water or diluted blowdown water (Table 3). We might therefore expect drif t from the cooling towers to have a higher concentration in several elements and salts. This drift would be 10 deposited on vegetation, other objects, and on soil in an area surround-ing the towers. Drift at any one time would, however, be highly dependent upon prevailing weather at the time.
LEAF INJURY CAUSED BY POLLUTANTS, DISEASE AND INSECTS Natural Vegetation O Statistical analyses of all leaf data for each year of the study have been completed. As expected, highly significant (p<0.01) differences existed for most leaf measurements among the eight years of data collec-O tion even when a conservative F-test was utilized. This indicates the O-
148 O Table 2. Average environmental conditions during a six-week period in 1979 at varying distances and directions from the cooling towers of the Nuclear Generating Station. , Ambient Environment Distance Direction Wet Bulb Dry Bulb Rela tive Dew Point Cooling Cooling Temp Temp Humidity Temp Towers Towers (op) (op) (;) (op) , l 50 feet 67b 83b 47a 59b 1/4 mile 69a 87a 45a 61a e il 67a l 85a 45a 60a ilE 67a 84a 46a 59a E 68a 85a 46a 60a O SE 68a 86a 45a 60a S 67a 86a 44a 59a SW 69a 85a 48a 61a O W 68a 86a 46a 60a NW 68a 86a 45a 60a I Numbers in a column followed by similar letters are not signifi- O cantly different at the 0.05 level of probability. O O O O
'O 149 Table 3. Chemical concentrations in water samples taken from four locations near the Nuclear Generating Station in July and O ^"9"St' 1979-Location Month Total P Mg SO4-S EC (mg/1) (mg/1) (mg/1) (mhos/cm) O St. Vrain River 1.2 68 51 3 1421 South Platte River 1.4 18 304 1137 Blowdown ditch 1.4 22 436 1452 g Cooling towers I 2.8 52 1296 3789 July 1.7 40 850 1950 August 1.7 40 425 O I The Fort St. Vrain cooling towers are designed to operate so as to utilize water 3 to 5 times to conserve water. This will, therefore, concentrate chemicals within the cooling tower water. O O O O O
- O
150 O high degree of yearly variation that influences leaf growth and injury. Distance and direction from the Generating Station were usually not g significant (p>0.05) variables in affecting leaf injury, either before or af ter the Station began to generate electrical power in December 1976. In general, leaf area of cottonwood increased from May or June , through August. Kochia, however, had smaller leaf area per leaf in August than in May. No significant trend in leaf area per leaf for cheatgrass or cottonwood was found as related to distance from the station. In some years, leaves were larger near the Generating Station, whereas in other years they were larger at the 1/2- and 1-mile distance from the station. Leaves of kochia tended to be somewhat larger during O the eight years of sampling at the 1/i- and 1-mile distance from the Generating Station. Cheatgrass leaves were larger in a south through a northeasterly 9 direction from the Generating Station. Leaves of both kochia and cotton-wood were often larger in a southeasterly direction. This may be related to intensive farming and irrigation practices occurring southeast of the O Generating Station during the years of the study. The percentage of leaf area removed by chewing insects increased for both kochia and cottonwood between rapid growth and maturity during O six of the eight years of study. This was very evident during 1979 when large populations of grasshoppers fed on kochia. Cheatgrass leaf area removed by insects was about the same near the Generating Station as at O\ greater distances. In contrast, chewing insects usually removed more leaf area of kochia at the 1/8- to 1/2-mile distance from the Power Station. Leaf area missing for cottonwood as related to distance from O the Generating Station showed no trend. Removal of cheatgrass leaf area O
G 151 by insects was greater in a south and southwesterly direction from the Generating Station in five of eight years of sampling. No consistent directional trend in leaf area removal among the years was found for kochia or cottonwood. Therefore, there was no consistent distance or directional influence from the Generating Station affecting insect leaf S removal among the three species. Brown tip leaf area and leaf spotting for kochia was greater by an order of magnitude in 1978 and 1979 than in previous years. This e resulted primarily from storage problems in 1978 and insect feeding activity in 1979. Brown leaf tips of kochia were also often greater in a south through west direction. This same trend was also noted for cotton-O wood. This trend might be related to less intensive agricultural activity in a southwesterly direction from the station. Leaf spotting may be the better indicator of leaf injury caused by D pollutants or cooling tower drift. A significant (p<0.05) effect as related to distance from the Generating Station was detected for leaf spotting of cheatgrass and kochia. No significant differences for leaf O spotting of cottonwood were found as related to distance from the station. Although there was a difference in leaf spotting of cheatgrass as related to distance, no consistent trend in the data were apparent. Leaf spot-ting was sometimes greatest at further distances from the station for the June collection of kochia, but spotting was greatest at 1/8 to 1/2 mile by the time of the August sampling period. Leaf spotting of cheatgrass and kochia was not related to direction from the Generating Station. However, leaf spotting for cottonwood was related to direction from the station and was usually more pronounced in 3 a north through east direction from the station. This would be downwind D
152 O from the station as the prevailing wind during the growing season is from the southwest. Data for various leaf characteristics were compared utilizing a 8 conservative F-test for two time periods: before (1972-1976) the station generated electrical power and af ter (1977-1979) startup of limited power genera tion. Leaf area of cheatgrass was similar for the two time periods; 8 whereas, leaf area of kochia declined and that of cottonwood increased significantly after the station began operation (Table 4). A greater percentage of leaf area was removed by insects using kochia after the 8 station began operation, and the opposite trend was evident for cotton-wood. Leaf spotting and brown tips were both greater for cottonwood before the station began power generation. However, percentage spotted # leaf area for both cheatgrass and kochia were greatest after the station began operation (Table 4). These data clearly illustrate the varied species responses that were obtained in this study. No apparent trend 8 was evident among species, and it appears that the differences resulted primarily from causes other than operation of the Nuclear Generating Station.
- It appears that leaf injury of the three naturally occurring species during the past eight years has been happening somewhat at random about the Generating Station. Intennittent and limited Generating Station 8 operations varying from shutdown up to a maximum of 70% have not as yet resulted in the type of data that would be suitable for response analysis in detemining leaf injury. Microclimatic differences, site characteris- S tics, and agricultural activity appear to be the major factors causing any significant distance, directional, and yearly effect observed to date for leaf injury. S-O
GD 153 Table 4. Average leaf characteristics for three naturally occurring species collected at maturity near the Nuclear Generating 4D Station before (1972-1976) and after (1977-1979) beginning of operation of the station. Before/After Leaf Area (mm) % Missing % Spotted % Brown Tip 4D Bromus tectorum Before 109a l 0.8a 5.0b 14.8a After lila 1.4a 15.2a 20.2a i; Kochia scoparia l 0.9b 3.3b 1.9a Before 115a After 70b 6.0a 7.8a 2.5a 1, Populus sargenti I 0.2a Before 2837b 1.4a 3.9a After 5555a 0.3b 1.6b 0.lb I i Means for a species in the same column followed by a similar letter are not significantly different at the 0.05 level of probability. ^' i rd O I
154 O Pinto Bean Experiment Analysis of data for various leaf characteristics of pinto beans in g the controlled experiment indicated that neither distance nor direction from the cooling towers significantly (p<0.05) affected most leaf characteristics, except for leaf area. Leaf area of individual leaves g were smaller (360 mm) near (50 feet) the cooling towers as compared with leaves that had grown at 1/4-mile distant (460 mm) from the towers. As expected, significant differences among years for several leaf charac- g teristics of pinto bean plants were probably caused by differences in growing conditions, insect activity, and status of tower operation during the five years of study (Table 5). , ELEMENTAL CONCENTRATIONS IN VEGETATION Kochia scoparia Analyses of data for elemental concentrations in foliage samples of kochia collected each August during six years indicated that nitrogen (N), sulfate (S0 4-S), mercury (Hg), lead (Pb), and boron (B) all varied , significantly (p<0.05) through time (Table 6). However, only sulfate varied significantly with distance from the station when a cor,servative F test was used in analyzing these data. Sulfate was often more concen-O trated in kochia foliage at a one mile distance than closer to the s tation. No other chemical constituent varied significantly with either distance or direction from the Generating Station. Sulfate concentrations O increased in foliage through time resulting in a greater concentration in foliage after the Generating Station began operation (Table 6). Scmewhat of a reversal of this trend was noted for nitrogen and mercury as higher O concentrations were recorded before the station began operation. O'
n . O 155 Table 5. Average leaf characteristics for pinto bean plants (Phaseolus vulgaris) collected at maturity at varying distances from the Nuclear Generating Station for 1973 through 1978 Distance t Year 50 feet 1/4 mile O Leaf area (m ) 2 1973 775b] ll29a 1974 921a 1086a 1976 253d 403bc g 1977 478c 460b 1978 205d 320c j
; Leaf area missing (%)
1973 0.79a) 4.31a 0 1974 0.27a 0.78a 1976 0.74a 0.49a 1977 0.59a 0.15a 1978 0.81a 1.33a lO 1 j Leaf area spotted (%) j 1973 6.74a) 3.92a 1974 1.32b 1.25a O 1976 2.39b 3.04a 1977 3.73b 3.34a 1978 1.45b 1.61a i Brown tip leaf area (%) [g 1973 1.88a) 1.77a
~
i 1974 0.74a 1.05a
- 1976 1.16a 1.07a 1977 1.24a 0.91a O 1978' l.64a 0.79a
, - n.. , - I Numbers in a columt 6,h r, by similar letters are not signifi-cantly different at the 0.R5 levei vf probability. O i l
~
o.
156 O Table 6. Average concentration of various elements in foliage tissue of Ecchia (Kochia scocaria) during six years and as related to before (1973-197@ and after (1977-1979) beginning of operation , of the Nuclear Generating Station. Year or N SO4 -S Hg Pb Cd B Operational (g) (pgjg) (gjg) ( gjg) (,,g jg ) e 1973 --- --- 0.23a 1.42b 0.38a 74.lbc 1975 2.81c 2 0.40c 0.14b 0.70bc 0.31a 51.6d 1976 4.29a 0.37c 0.12bc 0.23c 0.29a 92.5ab , 1977 3.62b 0.47bc 0.09bcd 0.12c 0.25a 102.2a 1978 2.72c 0.53b 0.12bc 0.82bc 0.62a 69.2cd 1979 1.26d 0.97a 0.05d 3.04a 0. 51 a 63.6cd Befora 2 (1973-1976) 3.56a 0.38b 0.16a 0.89a 0.32a 73.0a After (1977-1979) 2.58b 0.64a 0.09b 1.26a 0.46a 78.9a 8 Data were not collected in 1974 because an insufficient amount of leaf material remained for analysis, 2 O Numbers in a column followed by a similar letter are not signifi-cantly different at the 0.05 level of probability. 9 9 e e
- 157 Populus sargentii b Elemental concentrations in foliage samples of cottonwood collected each August for 1974 through 1979 are shown in Table 7. Nitrogen (N),
phosphorus (P), potassium (K), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), iron (Fe) U and copper (Cu) all exhibited varying concentrations through the six years. Nitrogen, potassium, and boron were all higher in foliage before (1974-1976) the station began operation, whereas phosphorus, iron, and 3 sulfate were more concentrated in sampus after (1977-1979) the Generating Station began operating. Potassium and calcium were usually more con-centrated in cottonwood foliage near (1/8-1/4 mile) the station, but D magnesium, zinc, manganese (Mn), and baron were usually higher in foliage at a distance of one mile from the station. It then appears that station operation to date has had little direct effect on elemental concentrations D as related to distance from the station. Significant directional effects were detected for concentrations of nitrogen, magnesium and zinc. Nitrogen was usually higher in a northeast D through southeast direction from the station. Magnesium was more concen-trated in cottonwood located southwest through northwest of the Generating Station. Zinc concentrations in foliage were consistently lowest in a 3 northerly direction from the station. It therefore appears that the limited station operation to date has not affected directional distribution of elements in cottonwood foliage, as prevailing winds are usually southerly 3 or westerly during the growing season. Phaseolus vulgaris g More elements were different in concentrations among the six years of study for pinto bean plants in the controlled experiment than for 9
Ta bl e 7. Average concentrations of various elements in foliage tissue of cottonwood (PopA sargentii) over a six year time period and as related to before (1974-1976) and after (1977-1979, ginning of limited operation of the Nuclear Generating Station. Year or Ca Mg Zn Fe Mn Cu SO4 -5 B N P K (ngfg) UP rational s () (3) (3) (g) (y) (ygfg) (,gfg) (ygfg) (pgfg) 1974 2.39a I 0.07d 1.41b 2.51a 0.53a b 109.4a 81 8b 41.2a 7.4b 0.46a ll3.5a 1975 2.15ab 0.25bc 1.26bc 1.57b 0.33c 83.9a 82.2b 40.la 10.7b 0.49a 117.8a 1976 2.37a 0.32b 1.85a 1.64b 0.36c 75.4a 93.7b 41.4a 10.4b 0.51a 104.la 1977 1.88bc 0.51a 1.43b 1.77b 0.48abc 86.7a 68.3b 32.Sa 5.9b 0.70a 94.6a 1978 1.85c 0.18c 0.98c 2.41a 0.57a 102.Sa 85.8b 44.0a 7.7b 0.78a 105.5a 1979 0.80d 0.17c 1.24bc 1.45b 0.39bc 81.4a ll39.4a 37.9a 19.3a 0.83a 74.6a Before (1974-1976) 2.31a l 0.21b 1.50a 1.92a 0.41a 89.9a 85.8b 40.9a 9.Sa 0.49b 111.8a After 1.56b 0.29a 1.22b 1.89a 0.48a 90.3a 417.8a 38.2a 10.8a 0.77a 91.9b (1977-1979) INumbers in a column followed by a similar letter are not significantly different at the 3.05 level of probability. ' # # # e e e e e e e
1 ) 159 either kochia or cottonwood. Nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, calcium, magnesium, zinc, iron, manganese, copper, sulfate, mercury, lead, and cadmium (Cd) all varied significantly through time (Table 8). In fact, the only element that did not show any significant concentration changes during the study period was boron,as boron concentrations were highly variable. The only obvious trend in these data was the increase in sulfate concen-trations from 1974 through 1979. Sulfa'tes increased from 0.20 ug/g to 4.37 ug/g during this five year period. This same significant trend was also observed in the naturally occurring kochia and cottonwood species , (Tables 6 and 7). This significant increase in sulfate concentrations in all species may be related to increasing sulfur dioxide air pollution in 3 the Denver metropolitan area which is likely affect.ing vegetation near the Nuclear Generatina Station. Phosphorus, calcium, zinc, iron, and sulfate were all more 3 concentrated in aboveground biomass of pinto. bean plants after (1976-1979) the Generatino Station began operation than before (1973-1976) (Table 8). Nitrogen and potassium concentrations in biomass were. 3 however, higher before the station began operating. Various salts in the drift from the cooling towers were probably at least partially respon-l s,1ble for the increased concentrations of the five constituents. A pre-3 liminary study indicated that cooling tower water was at least twice as high in phosphorus, sulfate, and electrical conductivity as was the makeup water from the St. Vrain and South Platte Rivers (Table 2). Less nitrogen and potassium in the plants may either be a dilution effect or may be related to smaller leaf size of plants grown near the cooling towers. J l i l i
lable U. Average conceritrations of various einnents in aboveground bioniass of pinto bean plants (Phaseolus vulgaris) during six years and as related to before (1973-1976) and af ter (1977-1979) be9 innin9 of operation of the Nuclear G!nerating Station. Year or p Zn fe Mn Cu SO -S II9 Pb Cd 8 il K Ca 5)
"""'[[""'
ta t (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) ("9/9) ("9/9) ("9/9) (99/9) () (99/9) ("9/9)("9/9)("9/9) I 1.4b 0.Sc 59.0a 1973 2.96b 0.40b 2.75b 1.49d 0.56b SS.3b 30ld 52.0cd 10.2c --- 0.25a 1974 3.08b 0.38b 2.39b 3.26b 0.6Sb 38.0c 410d 37.Sd 8.4c 0.20c 0.09c 1.4b 0.7b 60.9a 1976 4.26a 0.36bc 3.61a 2.04cd 0.39c 49.7b 968b 75.3b 15.2b 0.50c 0.10bc 1.lb 0.2d 76.4a 1977 2.94b 0.78a 2.52b 1.60d 0.39c 58 h 317d 35.3d 8.Ic 0.58c 0.I1bc 0.3b 0.2d 1S.0a 1978 3.06b 0.30c 2. 34d 4.18a 0.88a 120.?a 589c 65.0bc 10.6c 1.59b 0.10bc 1.lb 0.7b 65.2a $ 1979 1.30c 0.34bc 1.50c 2.56c 0.57b 122.4a 3004a 146.0a 38.4a 4. 3 7a 0.21ab 12.Sa 1. 3a IS2.Sa Before l (1973-1976) 3.311a 0. 311b 2.94a 2.02b 0.53a 50.0b S25b S6.0a 11.3a 0.38b 0.17a 1.29a 0.4a 64.6a After (1977-1979) 2.58b 0.53a 2.22b 2.61a 0.58a 92.Sa 10Sla 71.2a 16.2a 1.80a 0.13o 3.48a 0.6a 63.Sa I llunibers in a coluinn followed by a similar letter are not significantly different at the 0.05 level of probability. D 9 9 9 9 9 4 9 e e e
9 161 There was a weak trend in these data which indicated that concentrations of nitrogen, magnesium, iron, manganese, copper, and 3 sulfate were greater in pinto bean plants grown near the cooling towers (50 f t) as compared with plants grown at 1/4 mile distance from the towers. This was expected as drift deposition at 50 feet from the 3 towers was heavy at times. The amount of drift deposition had certainly declined by 1/4-mile away from the towers. O
SUMMARY
AND CONCLUSIONS In general, leaf area injured decreased with time during the growing seasons during most of the years of study. This was anticipated as leaves are more susceptible to injury while they are growing and before they reach maturity. Some leaf injury measurements for the three naturally occurring species showed significant differences for distance from the St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. But, it appeared that leaf injury was not related to direction from the Generating Station. Therefore, it appears that most variations in leaf injury were caused by
.)
microclimate, site, insects, and species differences and were little influ-enced by the intemittent, limited operations of the Generating Station to date. Leaf area of pinto beans in a controlled experiment were often smaller when grown near (50 feet) the cooling towers. However, increased leaf spotting near the towers was observed only in one of the five years of study. Cooling tower blowers were usually not in operation during earlier years and humidity near the towers was only slightly greater during 1978 and 1979 than at the 1/4-mile distance from the towers. These relationships might become more pronounced when the Generating Station reaches full power operation. The Nuclear Generating Station has
/
I h
160 O had only intermittent, irregular, and limited operation to date (1977-- 137 days 1978--201 days, and 1979--77 days). , Elemental concentrations in foliage samples of kocnia and cottonwood were little influenced by distance or direction from the St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. Although significantly higher con- , centrations of some elements were found in foliage from some local sites, there was no consistent trend in these data among the elements and sites or as related to prevailing winds during the growing season. The most O obvious trend in these data is the significant increase of sulfate in foliage of both species during the past few years. Sulfate concentra-tions have nearly doubled during the past six years. This is probably O indicative of increased levels of air pollution in the Denver Air Pollu-tion Corridor. Sulfate levels in vegetation may prove to be a good integrated index for monitoring ambient levels of air pollution. O Five chemical constituents (phosphorus, calcium, zinc, iron, and sulfate) in pinto bean plants from the controlled experiment increased in concentration af ter startup of the Generatino Station. Since water 9 samples from the cooling towers had levels of phosphorus, sulfate, and salts that were at least twice as high as makeup water from the two rivers, it is probable that drift deposition on foliage was at least 9 partially responsible for this increase. Heavy metal concentrations in pinto bean plants of mercury (Hg), lead (Pb) and cadmium (Cd) were not different before nor af ter station startup. However, a significant 9 increase in all three of these heavy metals was detected in 1979. A larger difference in temperature and humidity also was detected around the cooling towers in 1979. O O l
0 163 O O e MAMMALS, AMPHIBIANS AND REPTILES O O O by Bruce A. Wunder O lC r l
- O 1
( (O o
164 C INTRODUCTION O My participation in and initiation of the Mammal, Amphibian and Reptile portion of the Fort St. Vrain Biological Inventory and Monitoring Program began in Spring 1972 to determine the effects of the Nuclear g Generating Station operations on these ve-tebrates. At that time (March 1972) it was expected that the Station would be in full operation by Fall 1972 and that monitoring might extend for one year beyond. g The goal was to determine which species were present on the Station property and where they were found, as the species lists given in the initial impact statement were obviously based on outdated species dis- g tribution maps and little or no on-site evaluation. One month was spent trapping and observing in the various habitat types, reading reports on how the Station was to function, hypothesizing how the Generating Station g might affect the environment and hence the animals. We decided to assay species presence for large mamals, reptiles, and breeding amphibians and to concentrate numerical population analyses on small mammals. Large mamal densities on and use of the Station property and surrounding areas seemed low enough that for a 1 to lh year study, species presence seemed sufficient. Furthemore, since large mammals are so mobile and range over 9 large areas, it would be difficult to confine influence on their numbers just to factors on the Public Service Company (PSC) property. Given the apparent densities of reptiles and amphibians, we settled on assaying 0; species presence. I Short of a major radioactivity or reactor mishap, it appeared that the major aspects of the Station operation which might affect vertebrate O O
10 165 i populations were those associated with cooling-tower water. Water is
- O evaporated taking with it salts and other materials which may be subse-quently deposited on neighboring vegetation and then be consumed by foraging mamals. Additionally, heavy metals and sut:-biocides could O leach into soils along the irrigation ditches and in Goosequill Pond, subsequently to be ( ncentrated in plants eaten by animals or taken up by amphibians in the water. Consequently, amphibians breeding in Goose-
- O quill Pond and along the ditches were assayed. For these reasons and because small mammals and amphibians provide a food base for mamalian and avian predators in the areas, we also studied heavy metal concentra-
,0 tions in the two groups to provide baseline comparison with similar data obtained during operation of the Nuclear Generating Station.
METHODS 'O Items Sampled The goals of this section of the monitoring project were as follows:
'O 1. Monitor species presence or absence of large mamals, reptiles -
i and amphibians, particularly breeding populations.
- 2. Monitor population numbers and trends in small mamals. The lO reasons for eghasizing small mamal populations were as follows:
- a. There are good data validating population sampling
- O techniques.
- b. The animals forage on plants and their seeds, which may be affected by " drift" and/or " blowdown" water
!O from the Generating Station.
- O
166 O
- c. The animals do not move great distances and thus changes in population densities should be due to factors in the 9 immediate environment.
- 3. Detennine concentrations of copper, zinc, and lead in various tissues of prairie voles (Microtus ochrogaster) and Woodhouse's 9 toads (Bufo woodhousei). These three heavy metals were reported in the water to be used for cooling and hence could pctentially be concentrated during Station operation. All are toxic in 4 high concentration to vertebrates. Prairie voles were common in dense vegetation along the irrigation ditches and fed on that vegetation. Woodnouse's toads were comon breeders in e most of the water areas.
The detailed methods of determining species presence and small mammal population parameters have been presented in progress reports on the Fort g St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Static (December 1973 and June 1974). Like-wise, details of sample preparation and heavy metal analysis (performed by the Colorado State University Analytical Chemistry Lab) were given in the g December 1974 Fort St. Vrain Progress Report. The present techniques for s all mammal population analysis have remained the same since 1972. , Sampling Periods One or two trips per month were made to the PSC property O to assay species presence. And, three times per year, five-day sampling periods for small mamal densities were undertaken: (1) late May-early June (lite Spring) to determine numbers following Spring breeding; (2) 9 9
O 167 early September (early Fall) to assay population levels following summer breeding; and (3) late November (late Fall) to determine population numbers entering the winter. Sampling Site Placement O Sampling sites were located as indicated in Figure 1. These locations were chosen compromising two factors: equidistant points and compass directions from the Nuclear Generating Station. However, the symetric g selection was influenced by the need for large blocks of similar vegetation for trapping that would not be affected by day-to-day farming activity. In addition, because of some species specificities, as many vegetation O types as possible were trapped. Where there were large enough areas of homogeneous vegetation,10 X 10 station trapping grids were established. Where areas were not adequate, then North American Census of Small Mammt.1 Lines were established as indicated in the December 1973 Progress Report. CHANGES IN MONITORING PROCEDURE
- O During the course of the study, three major changes in monitoring procedure occurred:
l 1. Elimination of two sampling sites--Following the Sumer of (O l 1973, Grid 2 and North American Census Line 6 (Fig.1) were i abandoned as sampling sites. The Spring of 1973 was wet with considerable flooding and these two sites (in the South Platte .O River floodplain) were completely under water during the June sampling period and had large areas of surface ponds into j Sumer and Fall. 'O O
168 O le k - N
~.
9 : o .'
\.,....,
5 s........,
)
i i0 3 )) # 3 - -
< /
E: . o j
...., . . . . . .; . 3 ,
al # O. --..5.!O 4 - 2 w4 .
- ~p . . . . . .o. .
2
/ :j .
- E 1 M FIGURE LEGEND e
Transect 1 - Cropland . pasture
- 2. Vegetation along irrigation ditch
- 3. River bottom
- 4. Vegetation along Irrigation ditch
- 5. River bottom
- 6. River bottom
- 7. Vegetation near farm pond 8 - Cropland - pasture g r
Grid 1 - Cropland (Old fleid)
- 2. River bottom
- 3. Posture B GRID O NACSM S Figure 1. Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station study area--
permanent trapping areas and habitat descriptions. g 9 l
.--,n
O 169
- 2. Elimination of March (early Spring) Sampling Period--We had O initially planned four trapping periods each year with one scheduled for early Spring to assay population levels following the winter and before Spring breeding. These were scheduled O for early March. However, in March 1973 weather was so incle-ment that many animals died in the live traps during sampling. ;
Because many deaths at this time would affect the Spring g breeding populations adversely, the sampling period was dropped.
- 3. Heavy Metal Analysis--Following our conclusion that concentra-tion of materials in " blowdown" water may be amplified and o increased in concentration ir small mamals and amphibians and have adverse environmental effects, we proposed to monitor levels of copper, zinc, and lead in these animals. These studies were initiated in 1974 and ended in 1977; however, g
we were able to analy.t animals collected and frozen from 1972-1976. Monitoring ceased in 1977 primarily for financial g reasons but also because good baseline data were available for comparison s, RESULTS AND DISCUSSION O Mammals: Species Presence Table 1 lists the mamals which we have confinned to be utilizing the Nuclear Generating Station environs from 1972-1979. All of these O species were still determined to be present on the PSC property during 1979 except those species listed in Table 2. For reasons discussed in g the December 1979 Progress Report, most of those species may still be found on the property with the exception of the thirteen-lined ground O
170 O' Table 1. Manc.als present in the vicinity of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. O Cormion Name Scientific Name Presencel Abundance 2
- 1. Shrew sorer sp. 1. C R
- 2. White-tailed jackrabbit zerus co;nsendi: 2. V P
- 3. Black-tailed jackrabbit Ichus californicus 3. V P
- 4. Cottontail rabbit Sylvilagus sp. 4. V AP
- 5. Thirteen-lined ground cpemophilus 5. C P squirrel :ridecemlineatus
- 6. Spotted ground squirrel Spemophilus spi!asonc 6. C P
- 7. Rock squirrel Sper-ophilus variegatus 7. V R
- 8. Black-tailed prairie dog cynorgs Iudovicianus 8. V A(locally)
- 9. Fox squirrel Sciurus niger 9. y A
- 10. Beaver castor canadensis 10. T P
- 11. Pocket gopher ceorgs bursarius 11. C P(locally)
- 12. Harvest mouse 2cithrodontoegs sp. 12. C R
- 13. Deer mouse ?croegscus mniculatus 13. C A
- 14. Northern grasshopper cnyd.orgs Zeucogaster 14. C R mouse
- 15. Prairie vole vierotus ochrogaster 15. C A-R
- 16. Meadow vole Microtus pennsylvanicus 16. C R
- 17. Muskrat endate: =ibethicus 17. V-T P
- 18. House mouse las casculus 18. C- A-R g
- 19. Norway rat Rcttus noroegicas 19. C R
- 20. Meadow jumping mouse :cpus hudsonicas 20. C R
- 21. Coyote canis Iccrans 21. V-T R
- 22. Red fox 7alpes vulpes 22. V R
- 23. Raccoon Procyon totor 23. T-S P
- 24. Long-tailed weasel 3ssteIc frenata 24. V R g
- 25. Striped skunk xephitis nephitis 25. T-0 P
- 26. Domestic cat Felis domesticus 26. V P
- 27. Domestic dog canis fartliaris 27. V-T P
- 28. Mule deer cdocoiIeus hemionu3 28. T-S-D P
- 29. White-tailed deer cdocoiIeus virginianus 29. V-T-S R-P
- 30. Badger Tacodea tcrus 30. T-S P-R g I C = Captured 2 R = Rare D = Found Dead P = Present (moderately cormion)
S = Scat A = Abundant T = Track g V = Visual Observation G 9:
- O 171 Table 2. Mammal species previously noted near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear O Generating Station that were not censused in the first ten months of 1979.
Connon Name Scientific Name 'O
- 1. Shrew Screc sp.
- 2. Black-tailed jackrabbit Lepus actilcrnicus
.O 3. Thirteen-lined ground squirrel spe mophilus evidecemlinec:us
- 4. Spotted ground squirrel Spemophilus spitcscmc
- 5. Rock squirrei spe mcphilus variega:us O Northern grasshopper mouse Cnychengs ledcogcscer 6.
- 7. Noraay rat =c::us ncrvegicus
- 8. Meadow jumping mouse 2cpus hudsonius
- 9. Long-tailed weasel .wsrela frenc:cE O V May have been present, as tracks were recorded, but species identification was not possible.
!O lO l lO !O
172 O squirrels and spotted ground squirrels. Both squirrels were common in the vicinity of Grid 3 and Transect 8 in the early years of the study 9 but have not been seen since 1976. The reason for the disappearance is not known. Since both are diurnally active and fairly conspicuous, I must assume that our not seeing them is justification to conclude they e are no longer present. Also, since no other species seem to be greatly affected and the prior relative numbers or presence-absence of these squirrels were greatly influenced by agricultural practices, I must g conclude that they have been driven out by changes in agricultural prac-tices and not by any direct function of the Nuclear Generating Station. Mammal s: Populations Deer mice and house mice continue to be the most common small mammals on the PSC property. Their numbers have stabilized since late 1976 (Figure 2), thus these values provide a good baseline for future measurements. One major population change since the initiation of the study was the reduction of the prairie vole numbers at the trapping sites. In the early O years (1972-1974), prairie voles were always the second most numerous species; but following their almost virtual disappearance during late 1975 and again in 1977, they have been low in density. This species is O known to show periodic population fluctuations and to need relatively moist habitat. Thus, it appears that the dry years on Grid 3 and the manipulation of Transect 7 (where many of these animals were caught) may 8' have reduced numbers to levels from which the species has not been able to recover. At present we have no reason to link this reductien to the intermittent and irregular operation of the Nuclear Generating Station. O O l
- O 173 O
l l 1 l
- O l 1
280 - _. _.- Dee r Mice , Western Harvest Mice
- Prcirie Voles
----- House Mice l
;O 24 -
. O R W
e ./ i. R 200 - { / / 1, k
" \\ / l\ f \
- o i\ l \ i \
2 t60 - j 5, [ i ,f I, 1 e 1 1-1 ! lg jl j g i. S 120 - -
.i i I.
\ !
~
;O o \ s.
i k. 8 t t A-1 1 80 - L ! Y'jd\ \. f \. 4 1 s l \ \ V.Ai / r
\./.
iv E A
\
- O ao .l\, fN , ,~
hf '\ g ~ , } A ,y % ~
l A,.,
'v' _ A _.
~*
-, v
.u' <^
1972 ' 1973 1974 I 1975 1976 1977 ' 1978 ' 1979 ' 'O YEAR l O 1 ! Figure 2. Total number of small mammal individuals captured at the l f ort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station: late Spring 1972 - I early Autumn 1979.
- O l .
iO i
-- , ,--. + - -
,. - ,-,-- ,,, .n , - . . .- ,
174 O Table 3. Amphibians and reptiles present in the vicinity of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. O Comon Name Scientific Name , Presence l
- 1. 5padefoot toad sca=hiccus bombifrans 1 V-C 9
- 2. Great Plains toad Sufo cograms 2. C
- 3. Woodhouse's toad Sufo uoodhoused 3. C 4 Western chorus frog ?seudacris :riserict a. C O
- 5. Bu11 frog Rar.a ca:esbiana 5. C
- 6. Leopard frog Rcna pipiens 6. V
- 7. Tiger salamander M bye 0.a tigrimer 7. V O
- 8. Snapping turtle Chelydre serpentina 8. D
- 9. Painted turtle C 6jse gs picca 9. V-0
- 10. Spiny sof t-shelled turtle M onya spiniferus 10. V O
- 11. Racer Coluber constrictor 11. V
- 12. Common garter snake "namnophis sir:alis 12. C
- 13. Plains garter snake 3.cnnophis rad;: 13. C O
14 Bull snake Picuophis melanoleucca 14 C
- 15. Western rattlesnake Crotalus viridis 15. V I C = captured 8 0 = found dead S = scat I = track V = visual observation O
9 O
O 175 Amphibian and Reptile: Species Presence O Table 3 lists the species of amphibians and reptiles that have been observed on the PSC property. Virtually all the amphibians and reptiles previously inventoried on the PSC property were inventoried during 1979. O The lesser earless lizard (Holbrookia maculata), with only one previous sighting, and the western rattlesnake (Crotalus viridis), which probably still occur in low numbers, were the only reptiles not recorded. Spiny
- O soft-shelled (Trionyx spiniferus) and snapping turtles (Chelydra serpen-tine) were not seen but have never been abundant on the rivers since the floods of 1973. And the tiger salamander (Ambystoma tigrinum), not O recorded in 1979, has only been seen in the Nuclear Generating Station settling ponds which were not censused in 1979. Thus, it appears that Station operation has had no apparent effect on amphibian or reptilian O presence in the area.
Heavy Metal Analysis We were especially interested in answering two questions concerning M heavy metal concentrations in mamals on the PSC property: (1) are there differences in tissue concentration of specific metals for animals from different sites? and (2) are there differences between years in these O concentrations? To answer the first question we compared (using 2-tailed T-tests) levels of copper, zinc, and lead in liver and kidney of animals from Grid 3 and Transect 7. These sites were quite far apart and are O affected differently by water discharge patterns from the Nuclear Generating Station. No significant differences in any metal concentra-tions in either liver or kidney could be demonstrated (Tables 4 through 6). O O
176 O Ta h 4 Copper (Cu) concentrations in Microtus ochihaster (po,g). O Month Group N Tissue I S.D. Tissue I S.D. Tissue r 5.0. June All Sites 1972-74 11 Liver 16.5 3.6 Kidney 19.4 2.5 LBones "9 - - All Sites 1975 9 15.7 1.9 " 16.3 1.9 0.2 0.1 Grid 03 1972-74 5 14.4 2.1 " 19.0 2.9 " O Grid 03 1975 2 17.5 3.5 17.5 0.7 0.2 0.1 Tran 07 1972-74 5 17.0 3.5 16.7 2.4 - - Tran 07 1975 4 15.8 1.3 " 16.2 1.3 " 0.2 0.1 Sept. All Sites 1972-74 6 Liver 17.3 3.4 Kidney 17.3 1.9 '0"9 - - Boges All Sites 1975 7 16.1 2.2 " 16.3 1.1 0.3 0.4 e Grid 03 1972-74 3 16.7 3.1 " 16.7 2.5 Grid 03 1975 5 15.0 1.0 16.2 1.3 0.1 0.1 Tran 07 1972-74 2 15.5 .7 18.0 1.4 - - Tran 07 1975 0 - - - - - - Nov.- O Dec. All Sites 1972-74 4 Liver 13.4 ?.e Kidney 17.0 1.8 ' "9 0.3 0.1 All Sites 1975 6 15.3 4.2 " 17.5 1.8 Boges 0.1 0.1 Grid 03 1972-74 2 17.0 2.8 " 18.5 0.7 0.2 0.0 Grid 03 1975 1 17.0 0.0 19.0 0.0 0.1 0.0 Tran 07 1972-74 0 - - - - - - Tran 07 1975 2 13.5 2.1 " 19.0 0.0 " 0.2 0.1 e. Nov. All Sites 1974 3 Liver 12.9 5.4 Kidney 16.7 2.1 s 0.3 0.1 O e 9 e.
i C) 177 l Table 5. Zinc (Zn) concentrations in Microtus ochrogaster (pg/g). .C) Month Group N Tissue X' S.D. Tissue X' S.D. June All Sites 1972-74 11 Liver 86.7 26.3 Kidney 84.3 19.6 ! All Sites 1975 9 102.0 9.0 " 76.2 7.5 ! . C) " Grid 03 1972-74 5 83.2 14.2 90.4 28.0 ) i Grid 03 1975 2 98.0 2.8 75.5 13.4 ' Tran 07 1972-74 5 83.4 34.9 " 80.6 8.6 Tran 07 1975 4 102.0 12.4 73.0 7.3 j c) Sept. All Sites 1972-74 6 Liver 105.0 13.8 Kidney 87.2 6.2 All Sites 1975 7 1 04.7 12.2 96.8 24.5 Grid 03 1972-74 3 96.7 11.7 83.0 2.7 l Grid 03 1975 5 100.6 6.1 87.2 '4.4 l Tran 07 1972-74 2 110.0 14.1 " 88.5 5.0 Tran 07 1975 0 - - - - i C) Nov.- Dec. All Sites 1972-74 4 Liver 87.0 21 . 5 Kidney 86.3 2.2 All Sites 1975 6 96.0 12.8 89.3 24.2 Grid 03 1972-74 2 97.0 18.4 8F 5 3.5 Grid 03 1975 1 91 .0 0.0 " 52.0 0.0 C) Tran 07 1972-74 0 - - Tran 07 1975 2 106.0 19.8 112.0 21 .2 Nov. All Sites 1974 3 Liver 88.0 26.2 Kidney 87.3 0.58 i C) O C) . O l
)
l t
_ e 178 (; Table 6. Lead (Pb) concentrations in Microtus ochrogaster (pg/g). O Month Group N Tissue 7 S.D. Tissue T S.D. Tissue T S.D. June All Sites 1972-74 11 Liver " 0.3 0.2 Kidney 1.5 1.8 Pel t 0.2 0.2 All Sites 1975 9 0.3 0.1 1.1 0.9 0.4 0.3 gp Grid 03 1972-74 5 0.2 0.2 2.0 2.7 0.2 0.1 Grid 03 1975 2 0.3 0.1 1.6 1.3 0.6 0.2 Tran 07 1972-74 5 0.3 0.2 1.0 0.5 0.2 0.2 Tran 07 1975 4 0.2 0.1 0.7 0.6 0.2 0.1 Sept. All Sites 1972-7" 6 Liver 0.3 0.1 Kidney 2.5 1.1 Pelt 0.1 0.1 gp All Sites 1975 7 0.2 0.1 1.5 2.8 0.4 0.3 Grid 03 1972-74 3 0.2 0.2 3.2 1.2 0.2 0.1 Grid 03 1975 5 0.2 0.1 0.6 0.4 0.4 0.3 Tran 07 1972-74 2 0.3 0.1 2.1 0.1 0.1 0.0 Tran 07 1975 0 - - - - - - Nov.- Dec. All Sites 1972-74 4 Liver 0.6 0.3 Kidney 4.3 2.5 Pel t 0.4 0.2 All Sites 1975 6 0.6 0.3 2.8 3.3 0.5 0.4 Grid 03 1972-74 2 0.7 0.1 4.6 3.0 0.4 0.0 Grid 03 1975 1 0.6 0.0 1.2 0.0 0.5 0.C Tran 07 1972-74 0 gp Tran 07 1975 2 1.3 0.1 1.3 1.0 - - ilov . All Sites '.974 3 Liver 0.5 0.3 Kidney 4.9 2.7 Pel t 0.3 0.3 0 9 9 9 O
) O 179 Few seasonal or yearly differences in heavy metal concentrations were !O observed (Tables 4 through 6). The only significant seasonal differences were the higher concentrations of lead in liver that occurred in November 1974 and November 1975 when compared to the June 1975 and O September 1975 samples respectively; the June 1975 zinc concentrations in kidney tissue that were lower than those observed in November 1974 ) or September 1975;and,the June 1975 lead concentrations in kidney tissue
- 0 that were lower than those observed in kidneys from November 1974. Lead concentrations were higher in November than earlier in the year. The few significant yearly differences were the high June 1975 kidney copper
- g concentrations for all trapping areas and for Transect 7 when compared to the composite 1972-1974 results, the high Grid 3 lead concentrations in kidneys during September 1975 as compared to the composite 1972-74 results, and the low concentrations of lead in September 1975 pelts when
- O compared to those of 1972-74 animals.
l Adequate numbers of measurements have been made in Microtus tissues, given the inherent seasonal and yearly variability of such measurements, !O so that reasonable comparisons to baseline conditions can be determined. In order to detennine how baseline levels of heavy metals from animals on the pSC property conpared to other animals studied, we com-g I pared concentrations of both zinc and lead in prairie vole kidneys col-lected from 1972-76 to the few values in the literature. The only data i we found suitable for comparison were for gray squirrels trapped in the
- 0 Gulf Hammock Wildlife Management Area of Florida (a relatively undisturbed area) and Jacksonville, Florida, with some degree of industrial pollution (McKinnon, et al. ,1976, J. Wild 1. Disease, 12:367-371). ' Kidneys from i voles caught near the St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station had higher i
(O l L .
180 0 concentrations of zinc and lead than did the kidneys from squirrels col-lected in rural Florida but less than the kidneys from squirrels exposed O' to light to medium levels of industrial pollution in urban Jacksonville (Table 7, Figures 3 and 4). At this point, it is not evident why :inc and lead are found in higher concentrations in kidneys of voles from the O PSC property than in those of squirrels from rural Florida other than species differences. However, the levels of zinc and lead in kidneys of voles from St. Vrain are considerably iower than levels of kidneys of G squirrels from urban Jacksonville. If the St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station becomes a significant producer of airborne or aquatic heavy metal contaminants, which enter or are deposited on plants, the levels of heavy 9 metals in vole kidneys should rise toward the levels observed in the kidneys of urban squirrels. Amphibians were usually collected from Goosequill Pond or the ditch G draining into it so comparisons were only made between years and species. The differences in mean concentrations of ilver zti: in laboratory frogs (Rana pipiens) supplied by a commercial dealer, when compared with either e Woodhouse's toads (Bufo woodhouseii) or spadefoot toads (Scaphiopus bombifrons) from PSC property, were significant as were the mean copper concentrations in the liver of spadefoot toads when cor, pared with Wood- g house's toads or the laboratory R_. pipiens (Table 8). The yearly l l differences in the means of metal concentrations of liver copper and zinc in Woodhouse's toads also were tested for significance (Table 9). g The copper and zinc content of livers from Woodhouse's toads captured in 1975 were significantly lower than the contents found in 1973 and 1974 which are not different from one another. We co not know the reason for 6 these lower levels but suspect they are the result of rainfall and O
O 181 Table 7. Kidney concentratiops of zinc and lead in gray squirrels captured in Florida and in prairie voles captured at the 3 Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Colorado. Number Zinc 3 Lead 3 Groups Animals Mean:S.E. Mean:S.E. O . Jacksonville (squirrels)2
<1 year 75 27.72:1.21 1.32:0.17 1 year 69 29.68:1.80 1.28:0.24 2 years 20 30.54:2.49 1.1 8 :0. 31 0 3 years 10 25.99:3.14 0.47:0.16 4 years 6 23.04:2.69 0.86:0.33 Gulf Hamock (souirrels) 1 year 5 14.32 1.64 0.2020.02 h 2 years 7 18.61:1.43 0.26:0.04 St. Vrain (voles)
All animals 70 22.36:0.56 0.56 0.15 O Grid 3 33 22.79:0.96 0.64:0.12 Transect 7 16 21.81:0.93 0.41:0.11 IFrom McKinnon, et al. ,1976. O 2 Equals animals of different age classes. 3 Parts per million, wet weight. O D D e
'" P.P.M. WET WElGHT ( Mean i S.E.)
m C - - N N u u u O " O "
$ o u O u
N 75 AGE ( l YEARS OLD l l
$3U 30 3
> ~
Q
- 3. " gg N 69 AGE: I YEARS OLD l ;
e o. n > r+ m o
- a. 3
<2 <
SESn3
$r cm N320 AGE 2 YEARS OLD l 3 us x et ct -* "1 s'-
3 't W
,3
- N 10 AGE 3 YEARS OLD : i m5
- a. o 2 o3 o 6 3* 3 >
- m N6 AGE 3 4 YEARS OLD l l m
rt -*. 3 m a
--* X W
. a. m
_. m h r ev ou FC oo N ut 22 O% N 9 Ei ' N:S A GE a YEARS OLD l- l mo $~,i E I 3 a cr > g 0- 5g $ I N 7 AGE 2 YEARS OLD l l g
$C Af r eS x r, a m r, z eo -t a
vn m . rt 3
*C
< v Ns70 ALL ANIMALS F-j 22 .o !. =.n "2 E, $,$, N 33 GRID 3 F- --j C (D <-
na oz s. m3 E, N :16 1RANSECT 7 F-l O S 9 9 9 9 e e e e' e
O O O O O O O O O O O 2
.a P. P.M. WET WElGHT ( Mcon i S. E.)
C 9 o 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 r r .- r - - m - m u a u a % e e o - m u a u 5 5 5 5 a 3 a 3 3 g g 5 8 5
- N 75 AGE a ( l YEARS OLD i ;
E3m soa kx
*1" wan $$ N 69 AGE I YEARS OLD I ""S "z5 5 jSQ $E N x20 AGE
- 2 YEARS OLD l !
na s.m mxa a N$E $ N alO l ;
'* S U. F :o AGE = 3 YE ARS OLD o3o a 3*
3
, N s6 AGE s 4 YEARS OLD s
a
~
.--*W (D
. ct ai w n p:
S "* E 8 M* w% > $ m; G,
< Na$
hd,
, 2 AGES t YR.
- o. o m o 's E >
sa er>E Ns7 "x o 5S$oE AGE:2 YE ARS WS 3 --* Eb86gO r a r+ m Soa k w to rt 3 C v NATO ALL ANIMALS I mn b D* > a$.
-n -
"E k$ Ns33 GRID 3 l l E5 <h 2"
at -a. E" m N 16 ma TRANSECTF 7
184 O Table 8. Metal concentrations in amphibia (ug/g). O Animal Group Analysis Tissue N I S.D. BBf Cu Liver 10 153 92.5 58 3 1973 Cu 10 45.3 41.3 e SW All years Cu 33 238.1 206.1 BW 1972 Cu 3 233.3 118.46 BW 1973 Cu 11 328.2 304.9 BW 1974 Cu 10 245.0 130.8 BW 1975 Cu 10 119 65.5 O BB --- Zn 9 217.8 132.6 SB 1973 Zn 10 117.3 24.6 BW All Years Zn 33 121.9 40.3 BW 1972 Zn 3 13.3 15.3 BW 1973 Zn 10 142 37.1 BW 1974 Zn 9 137.8 47.5 e BW 1975 Zn 10 100.4 29.0 BB --- Zn Whole 10 129.0 22.8 Body BW All years Zn Whole 10 133.4 27.7 3 Body I BB are samples of tissue from commercial frogs (Rana pioiens) used to work out analysis techniques. SB are samples of tissue from Scaphiopus bombifrons, the spadefoot toad, from the Fort Saint Vrain Farm Pond. Samples were taken in 1973. BW are samples of tissue from Bufo woodhousei, Woodhouse's toad from the Fort Saint Vrain Farm Pond. Samples were taken in 1972, 1973, 1974 and 1975. e l O O O
C) 185 Table 9. Heavy metal concentrations in Bufo Woodhousei (pg/g).
! C)
Group Metal Tissue N X S.D. Tissue N R S. D. 1972 Cu liver 3 233.3 118.5 -- -- -- -- 1973 Cu liver 10 351.0 311.3 -- -- -- -- C) 1974 Cu liver 10 245.0 130.7 -- -- -- -- 1975 Cu liver 10 119.6 65.5 kidney 10 13.8 4.7 1972-75 Cu liver 33 229.0 204.6 kidney 10 13.8 4.7 1976 Cu liver 8 66.8 89.9 kidney 8 5.2 1.5 1972 Zn liver 3 93.3 15.3 -- -- -- -- l C) 1973 Zn liver 10 142.0 37.1 -- -- -- -- 1974 Zn liver 10 132.0 48.0 -- -- -- -- 1975 Zn liver 10 100.4 29.0 kidney 10 93.8 16.6 1972-75 Zn liver 33 122.0 40.8 kidney 10 93.8 16.6 1976 Zn liver 8 83.6 7.4 kidney 8 82.4 13.0
- C)
' C) l I
j i C) t i ! C) i C) ! C) l
186 OI l collecting patterns. In 1973 and 1974, rainfall was scattered in the Spring and pools of water were readily available to toads for breeding. 9 Thus, we simply collected during May when we could make time for such collections. In 1975 Spring rainfall was sparse and we could not collect toads easily. Therefore, we concentrated our collecting efforts following 9 what little rain there was. Thus, the animals were probably inhabiting more bodies of water in 1975 with lower levels of metal concentrations than in 1973 and 1974. It is encouraging, for baseline information, to O note that when rains are scattered and the available ponds receive fresh water infrequently, there is no difference in year-tn-year liver zinc and copper content in Woodhouse's toad. We also note that there are real 9 species differences in liver copper content (compare 1973 Spadefood toads with Woodhouse's toads, Table 8). Scaphiopus is a more opportunistic breeder than Bufo and may come out to breed only following rains when 9 ponds have low metal concentrations. Thus, it is interesting to note that Scaphiopus liver copper content is lower than Bufo. However, liver zinc contents do not differ; thus, suggesting that the two species g concentrate these heavy metals differently. TRENDS, ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY AND INFLUENCE OF THE STATION 9 As indicated in the Results and Discussion section, there have been a few changes in the vertebrate component of the environment surrounding the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. Most of the changes seen 9 in the past 7h years can be ascribed to or associated with climate or agricultural practices and none by direct link to effects of the Nuclear Generating Station. 9. 9
O 137 Over the 71s year inventory and monitoring period there have been no JO obvious changes in species presence nor habitat use patterns by reptiles e or by large mammals, except for beaver. Initially beaver were present i ) in low numbers and minor activity. However, with a continuous and moni-40 tored outflow of water from Goosequill Pond their activity became i localized in the pond effluent stream flow area. Small mammal populations have shown more fluctuations. It has
- O appeared that most of these fluctuations were associated with various agricultural practices, particularly those related to irrigation. When Grid I was allowed to go to the old field condition, ground squirrel O numbers were reduced and prairie voles increased. The burning of the field reduced the voles and allowed deer mice to increase. The bulldozing and burning of weeds east of the fence and along the irrigation ditch on O Transect 4 in the Spring of 1974 resulted in the reduction of the popula-tions of deer and house mice. The channelization of the Goosequill Ditch along Transect 7 several times was coincident with a decline in voles
.O and a rise in jumping mice. Flooding of the south ends of Grid 3 and Transect 5 by irrigation water runoff from neighboring fields preceeded declines in the numbers of voles captured in those areas.
Indeed, prairie voies (Microtus ochrogaster) were initially present O on our sampling areas in fair numbers but since _1975 have been caught only in low densities. Likewise, deer mice (Peromyscus maniculatus) numbers have decreased through the years from their initial high densities !O but have been stable since 1976. There have been periodic f rruptions of harvest mice and jumping mice but in both cases these seem to be related to weather and agricultural practices. Prairie dog (Cynomys ludovicianus)
- O - - -
188 O towns have periodically been poisoned and hence greatly reduced temporarily in numbers, but have always recovered. And lastly, ground squirrels are the only species which seem to have disappeared from the environment. Such fluctuations have given rise to discussion about whether sampling areas should be protected from all activities. The area was historically agricultural before the Nuclear Generating Station was built. The chan-nelization of irrigation ditches, burning of weeds, poisoning prairie dog towns, etc., are all traditional agricultural practices and are part of O the " environment." To leave areas unattended by man does not mean they will not change. Natural succession along unburned irrigation ditches and in old fields would, in itself, bring about changes in species com-
- position. Allowing prairie dog towns to increase without the natural predators that were present 100 years ago (e.g. , black-footed ferrets) would also be somewhat " artificial." Thus, since the goal for the area O seemed to be to maintain agriculture as previously pursued and not to establish a " natural" wildlife park without human intervention, the con-tinuance of nomal agricultural practices and the fluctuations they cause #
seemed the more " natural" course to follow. The species presence of breeding amphibians and their apparent relative densities have varied from year to year depending upon tempera- O ture and moisture conditions. The only obvious trends have been: (1) the appearance of leopard frogs (Rana pipiens) in 1977. Given several years of no sightings and now several years with sightings becoming more frequent, e I conclude they are a new addition and not a species trissed in the inven-tory phase. However, I cannot correlate their appearance with any obvious environmental change as all other amphibian species are still present and g 9
189 1 were breeding in good numbers in Spring 1979. (2) Spiny soft-shelled
;O (Trionyx spiniferus) and snapping turtles (Chelydra serpentina)do not now seem as abundant in the rivers as in the early years of the study. But, 5
again, this downward trend in numbers does not seem to be correlated with !O any obvious changes in the environment, especially due to the operation of the Generating Station. MONITORING PROGRAM
- O Effectiveness It is difficult to conclude how effective an environmntal monitoring
- O If effective means that the program measures well those fac-program is.
tors that have been affected by operation of the Nuclear Generating Station, then it is difficult to conclude that the program (or any monitoring pro-O gram) has been effective. The major problem here is in not being absolutely certain, a priori, what environmental influences a given modification (e.g., establishing a Nuclear Generating Station) will have. Indeed, if
'O anyone could ciefinitively answer such questions, we would not need moni-toring programs. Hcwever, if effective means--does the program measure those parameters it is designed to measure--then I .n conclude that O monitoring has been effective in measuring specie. presence and certain
, population parameters. Since the ultimate effect of a modification on these animals should affect these parameters, then we have an index to O whether the populations have been adversely or beneficially affected. The major disadvantage of the monitoring program is that it simply notes when and whether species are showing population declines and/or O local extinction. We do not have good measures of causations, except jO
190 () for the heavy metal analyses, but rather they must be sought as we see ID numbers changing. However, this is a problem common to vertebrate moni-toring. By sampling more often (monthly or bimonthly) we could follow population trends better, determine if numbers were changing because of 45 mortality or natality factors, and have a closer coupling of number changes to weather, agricultural practices and variations in operation of the Nuciear Generating Station. However, such sampling would be d> extremely expensive and probably economically unwarranted. e 9 8 9 O 9 9
O 191 O O TERRESTRIAL INVERTEBRATES O 3 0 by J. Wayne Brewer and 3 Judy Bodenham O 3 3
-w,,--~ ,
y ,,- - - - - -.-- ,_, ,,, . _ _ _ _, _ . _ ,,__ , _,y_. ,,. , . , , _ _ , , , _ , , _ _ _ , , _ _ _ _ , , _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
192 O INTRODUCTION Operation of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station could # create environmental .hanges that would alter populations or biological cycles of terrestrial invertebrates in the area. According to previous reports (1, 2) the minor increases in radiation levels expected near the G Station probably would not affect most invertebrates. However, hot water discharged from cooling towers into man-made or natural drainage systems could affect them since studies have shown many species of inver- e tebrates to be sensitive to even minor changes in temperature (3, 7, 8). An inventory of invertebrate species was conducted near the Station and six groups representing different ecological habitats were selected for 9 monitoring from 1972 through 1979. This report presents a summary and analysis of the data collected on those groups. O METHODS A description of the study area was presented in an earlier report (4). The location of pit fall trap rows 2, 3 and 4 is shown in Figure 1 (row 1 was abandoned early in the study). Details of the procedures used have been presented previously (4), however, the following changes have since occurred: In January,1974 the Malaise trap was discontinued for diurnal invertebrates when it was destroyed by a storm. It was felt that the data obtained did not justify replacement cost. In January, 1975 the sampling period was changed from weekly to monthly intervals. It seemed reasonable that the large data base available made it possible to monitor populations adequately with reduced sampling periods. In January, 1976, Ms. Bodenham assumed responsibility for identification of the Formicidae O when the services of Dr. Snelling were no longer available. Beginning January,1979 the black light trap was not established during the winter because reduced activity at that time made collection unnecessary. I O
O 193 0 9 O
~ -
\ I
.\' l Y. . . . . . . . . ...... i -
O ,, a
\; , ,,
,l >
.f I7'y=
I', u .,,, r,.. . . -- n I " T,'.'. .'s" I ~ !I_ l M ol.a.. r,.. O I$ ll P li ! O 8 !!
- 0 I '
I 5 % 8 i:.# l i 0
.....r,..
-. /'/ ,n // a l \. ,.,
l , O' G.,e. ,, 0 l
' I*
y l .a !!
.ou,; ,-r *+
g , ,,, [
,, i
______4 t.: 7 %. .,. N .e jg y=( , i
. l1 O . .,
g, L,
, l,
. , . . - .. ,,.<<,,, . a,
.....o,, I I
_______r,... "- .
,, o4 ,p. ,,) ' -
1 , . A-- 1 * ;%'f" O . O Figure 1. Fo'rt St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station and environs, showing. invertebrate collection sites. O
194 C RESULTS AND ANALYSIS Collembola O A list of the species of Collembola collected from three rows of pit fall traps near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station site and serviced from 1972 until 1979 is presented in Table 1. The distri-O bution of Collembola was quite uniform in that all species were col-lected at all three of the sampling sites located at varying distances from the Generating Station. Population levels of the different species O varied considerably during the study but that seemed to be primarily a function of natural population fluctuations. Species diversity of Collembola in the area was analyzed using Sorenson's quotient of simi-O larity (5). The procedure for calculating this similarity index has been previously reported (4). The similarity index for two areas having identical species composition would be 1.000. The index for two O areas in which only 50% of the species were found in both situations would be 0.500. We compared species collected each year to all years to detemine if species composition of the area changed over the O course of the study. As shown in Table 2, the similarity quotient for all yearly comparisons was high, ranging from 0.928 (1973 versus 1975) to 1.000 (several couplets). This indicated that the species O composition of Collembola did not vary substantially from 1972 to 1979. Since the Nuclear Generating Station was partially operational at various times beginning about 1976, these results suggest that the operation periods did not adversely affect species composition in the areas surrounding the Station. We also compared total collections from all years from the three different sampling sites as shown in 9 O
0 195 Table 1. Species of Collembola collected from pit fall traps at the
;O rt St. Wain Nuclear Generating Station Site, PlatteviHe, Colorado, 1972-1979.
4 lO Collembola Entomobryidae Entomobrya nivalis (L.) 10 Entomobrya unostricata Stach , Entomobryoides guthriei (Mills) Lepidocyrtus cyaneus Tu11 berg
;o Tomocerus vulgaris (Tu11 berg)
Hypogastruridae Hypogastrura armata (Nicolet)
- O Hypogastrura matura (Foisom)
Isotomidae Isotomurus palustris (Muller) .O Proisotoma minuta (Tullberg) i Pseudachorutes subcrassoides (Mills) Pseudosinella rolfsi Mills g Sminthuridae , Bourletiella arvalis (Fitch) Sminthurinus elegans (Fitch) Sminthurides pumulis (Krausberger) !O Xenylla sp. l l fp l O
O 196 Table 2. Matrix of Sorenson's quotient of similarity comparing species composition of Collembola collected in the environs of the Fort St. 9 Vrain Nuclear Generating Station by year from 1972-1979. N R R R R R R R e E $ $ $ E $ $ $ 1972 - 1.000 .965 .928 .965 1.000 .965 .965 1973 -
.965 .928 .965 1.000 .965 .965 g 1974 -
.952 1.000 .965 1.000 1.000 1975 -
.962 .928 .962 .962 1976 -
.965 1.000 ' 100 e
1977 -
.965 .965 1978 -
1.000 1979 - Table 3. Matrix of Sorenson's quotient of similarity comparing species composition of Collembola collected in the environs of the Fort St. O Vrain Nuclear Generating Station by pit fall trap row. m m e , 3 $ $ e e a Row 2 -
.965 .965 Row 3 -
1.000 g Row 4 - t e
l ) l 197 t Table 3. The results indicate that the species composition of those , areas was similar over the seven years of the study with quotients of similarity ranging from 1.000 to 0.965. Annual variations in populations of Collerat,ola collected from pit ) fall traps are presented in Figure 2. Mean monthly collections of l Collembola were over 60,000 individuals in 1973 but diclined t to a low of slightly more than 9,000 in 1975. Thereafter, populations generally 3 increased and remained at approximately the 1973 levels for 1977 and 1978. A comparison of numbers of Collembola from the three rows of pit fall traps is presented in Figure 3. It is evident the ) number of individuals collected varied considerably from the three ! areas sampled during the study. Collections from Row two, the sample site located furthest from the plant, were low compared to Rows three D and four, which were much closer to the Generating Station. General population trends, however, were similar from all three areas, with the exception that populations around Row three did not recover from l the 1975 low as quickly as populations from Rows two and four. As with species composition, it appeared that population levels of Collembola in the general environs of the Nuclear Generating Station have not been affected adversely by operation of the Station. Present population levels and species composition are now comparable to those occurring in the area at the beginning of the study. ) P l - P
O 198 9 100.000-- a : @ 50,000 - u : j 20 000 - g H 10,000 -- 3 E 5000 ~ S - s Z 2000 - 9 1000 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 Date Figure 2. Total number of Collembola collected from pit fall traps near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. Platteville. Colorado. 1973-1979. 9 9 100.000 7 50.000 } Row 4 O.
, 20,000 -
Row 3 E a 10,000 -- D 5000 -
?
w2 O
? 2000 L
E 1000 : E : 3
' 500
/ .
200 -
' ' ' ' ' i 10 0 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 Date 9
Figure 3. Number of Collembola collected from pit fall traps near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. Platteville. Colorado. 1973-1979. O
lO igg 1 Fomicidae
;O A list of the species of Fomicidae collected in the vicinity of the Nuclear Generating Station during this period is presented in Table I
- 4. Species distribution varied for the th
- areas but most species i
10 were comon to all areas. Annual variations in population levels of Fomicidae collected from all three rows of traps is presented in Figure 4. Populations were
;O low in 1973 and 1974 but began a general increase in 1975 that continued, with minor exceptions, to a peak in 1979. A comparison of collections from the individual sample areas is presented in Figure 5. As with the O Collembola there was variation 4 the number of individuals collected from the different areas. Population levels were highest from Row two, the area most distant from the Station. In general, trends o in population shifts were similar in collections from the three areas.
An exception was in the collections for 1979 where numbers decreased slightly from Row 3, and drastically for Row 4 but increased greatly O for Row 2. Since Rows 3 and 4 are much cimer to the Generating Station than Row 2, and thus should be more affected by any environmental changes ( produced by its operation, it is possible that the population declines g observed from those areas were related to increased activity of the Station in 1977 and 1978. Population changes in biological systems are ! rarely imediate. It is possible that the above changes are lagging O influ n s f earlier environmental effects caused by operation of the Station. Such changes could be caused by various interrelated environ-mental factors such as an increase in temperature or humidity, a modifi-I cation of vegetation composition, an altered food chain, or a modified 'Q. l trophic level response which in turn create invertebrate stresses.
- O
0 200 Table 4. Species of Formicidae collected from pit fall traps at the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station site, Platteville, Colorado, e 1972-1979. Formicidae 8 Formicinae Lasius latipes (Walsh) Camponotus nearcticus Emery 8 Camponotus sayi Emery Camponotus vicinus Mayr Formica bradleyi Wheeler # Formica fusca Linne Formica lasioides Emery Fomica limata Wheeler # Formica cinerea lepida Wheeler Formica neoclara Emery Fomica neogagates Emery S Formica perpilosa Wheeler Formica subnuba Emery Lasius niger neoniger Emery G Lasius pallitarsis (Provancher) Polyergus breviceps Emery Formica obscuripes Forel e Formica pallidefulva nitidiventris Emery Lasius murphyi Forel Lasius interjectus Mayr e O l
--- ___ - __. _ _ .-- - - _= - . _. - ._ - ._ . ._. _- .-
() 201 Table 4.(Cont.) Dolichoderinae
)
Corymyrmex pyramicus (Roger)
- Tapinoma sessile (Say) 4 i
Myrmicinae l C) Myrmica brevinodis Emery { Myrmica brevispinosa Wheeler i i Myrmica sabuleti americana Weber
! C)
. Pheidole pilifera coloradensis Emery Pheidole bicarinata Mayr Pogonomyrmex occidentalis (Cresson) IC) : Solenopsis molesta validiuscula Emery Stenamma brevicorne Mayr Ponerinae I C) Ponera trigona opacior Forel i. O 1 l l l (C) l i ! C) l C) l t f
202 0 10.000 -- , fto 5000 I - b-tc 2000 - e H g 1000 -- t : 2 500 - E 3 e 200 - 10 0 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 Date g Figure 4. Total nuriber of Formicidae collected from pit fall traps near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station Platteville, Colorado, 1973-1979. 5000 - e 2000 - a a 1000
~
g 5 : fC 500 - H - B 5 200 - [ ~ RowRow3a j
/
r_ /
~
50 -
/ ,
e 20 - I I ' ' ' ' ' 10 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 Date g Figure S. Number of Formicidae collected from pit fall traps near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station Platteville, Colorado, 1973-1979, e
O 203 Silpha ramosa O Biological studies showed thr.t both adult and immature carrion beetles feed on dead animal carcasses, mainly small rodents (4). Conse-quently, this insect was considered important to the study because of O its high level in the food chain and the possibility of biological
, magnification of changes caused by operation of the Station. Population levels of adult and icinature forms of S. ramosa collected during the g study are shown in Figure 6. The number of adults remained relatively constant with peak levels occurring in 1975 followed by a slow decline through 1978 and a resurgence in 1979. Population levels of the ininature O f rms followed a similar pattern but with levels fluctuating more than those of the adults. The data from 1979 indicated that populations were increasing and that the declines seen earlier were probably a result of O natural variation rather than an influence of operation of the Generating Station.
Data on collections of S_. ramosa adults from the three areas sampled. by pit fall traps are presented in Figure 7 and similar data on the O immatures are shown in Figure 8. Both forms were collected in high num-I bers throughout the study from mws three and four but infrequently from ! row two. Since populations were consistently highest from row three !O I, (Figures 7 and 8), and that is the row most likely influenced by hot 1 water discharge (4), it seems unlikely that S. ramosa populations are i being adversely affected by operation of the Station. Thus, data on iO L general population levels and those collected from' specific areas indicated l l that populations.of_ this species have not been reduced by operation of the Station. lO l 1
- O
1 l 204 Cl l l 100 - O m 3a 80 - Immatures E 2 2 60 e o 40 u _ E Adults 5 20 - O I ' I I I i O 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 Date Figure 6. Mean ntsnber of Silpha ramosa collected per month from pit fall traps O near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. Platteville. Colorado. 1973-1979. O 40 - 2 m 3 0 E 30 - 2 1 D l C H
,_ 2 0 -
o L Row 3 l $ 30 __ Row 4 E u 3 I I 1 I O I t i 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 197 O Date Figure 7. Mean number of Silpha ramosa collected per month from pit fall traps near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station, Platteville, Colorado, 1973-1979. (Adult form.) O O
D 205 3 3 3 100 - y 80 - S 5 D E 60 - O Row 3 15 t 40 - 3 l z 20 - Row 4
/
O ! I I I I
! Row 2' 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 D Date Figure 8. Mean ntsnber of Silpha ramosa collected per renth frors pit fall traps near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. Platteville. Colorado 1973-1979. (! mature form.)
D D D D
206 O Arareida The number of Araneida (spiders) collected during the study is pre- O sented in Figure 9. Population levels varied considerably in the area beginning with relatively low levels in 1973 and reaching a peak in 1975 followed by a consistent decline through 1976,1977,1978 and 1979. S Thus, it is evident that population levels in the vicinity of the Generating Station have been reduced since 1975. It is not possible to determine the reason for the decline from our studies but it seems # correlated with increased activity of the Generating Station. We must note, however, that even after several years of declining populations the levels are still comparable to those at the beginning of the study. O A comparison of collections from the three sample areas is pre-sented in Figure 10. Collections from Row two, which is located at the greatest distance from the Station, followed the general trend of total e collections discussed above. However, collections from Rows three and four varied and the population declines were less severe. Collections from Row four showed numbers increased from 1977 to 1978 with a moderate e decline in 1979. Population levels from area three declined from 1977 until 1978, then increased slightly in 1979. Consequently, although the general populations of Araneida are g declining in the vicinity of the Station, the data from individual sample areas suggest the cause is probably not due to the operation of the Station, since collections from the areas most immediate to it do not , follow the general trend. O O
) 207 400 - 350 ) to a j300 - 5 H ] _ 250 - O b g200 - ) 150 - g i I I I I I i 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 Date ) Figure 9. Mean number of Araneida collected per month from pit fall traps near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. Platteville. Colorado. 1973-1979. 16 0 - ) 14 0 - 120 - ) $ P100 - ROW 4 H
/ /
) o __ Row 3 L f60 3 Z ) 40 - ROW 2 20 - ) O ' 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 Date Figure 10. A cusparison of collections of mean number of Araneida from the three sample areas near Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. Platteville. Colorado. 1973-1979. J
208 O Tricoptera Tricoptera, or caddisflies, are nocturnal, aerial invertebrates that were collected in large numbers in a black light trap during the study. The maximum number of individuals collected per month for the years 1973 through 1979 is presented in Figure 11. Population levels O were high in 1973, declined in 1974 and 1975, increased slightly in 1976 and 1977 and remained stable in 1978 and :379. Population levels of Tricoptera vary and it appears likely that the O observed changes in numbers were a result of natural fluctuations. For example, the low levels in 1975 may be a result of the lower than normal moisture levels that occurred that year. However, the fact remains ti nt O the population has declined since the beginning of the study and although increased numbers have been collected in recent years, levels are still below those at the beginning of the study. Since the immature stages of 8 this organism are aquatic, they could be affected by changes in water temperature causec, by the hot water discharge by the Station. For example, Fey (7) demonstrated that increased temperature of a river caused by a 4 power station eliminated the quiescent stage of one species of Tricoptera and advanced emergence time three to four months. Earlier, Nebeker (8) showed that premature emergence could eliminate species if air tempera- O tures were lethal, as would be the case for Tricoptera during winter months. It cannot be demonstrated that the decline in numbers of Tri-coptera was due to the operation of the Station, and in fact, numbers e have increased somewhat fron 1975 until 1979, a period when time of Station operation generally increased. Population levels have not approached those at the beginning of the study; however, and it is pos- g sible that the reduced numbers are a result of changes caused by the Station. O
v-- 0 209 ? 3 10,000-- 5000 - g - 2000 - O M 1000 - to - 3 v _ 3 g SCO - M 0 3 g 200 - o t E o l Z 10 0 - 'O : 50 - 1
'O 20 -
l
' ' ' ' I I I l 10 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 Cate
.O Figure 11. Maximan number of Tricopters collected per month frun a black light trap located near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. Platteville. Colorado. 1973 1979. i O O
v 210 CJ Heteroceridae The heterocerids, or mud-loving beetles, live in the mud shores of ID the slough near the Generating Station. The maximum number of beetles collected in the black light trap per month for the years 1973 through 1979 is presented in Figure 12. Population levels of this beetle declined ID from a high in 1973 to a low in 1975, similar to the trend in Tricoptera populations previously discussed. However, beginning in 1976, population levels increased about to the 1973 levels. In 1978 and 1979 population tp levels were somewhat lower than in previous years, but higher than the low of 1975. Thus, it appears that the fluctuations in population levels of heterocerids is not correlated with operation of the Station but rather Ep is the result of natural factors. For example, it is likely that a major factor causing the low populations recorded in 1975 was the low moisture level that occurred during that year, as discussed for the Tricoptera. gp 9 , 9 9 9 9
0 211 l 1 iO { iO! 10,000-- 5000 - :
~
iO - i i 2000 - 1
- O m 1000 -
rs - 2 v - 5 E 500
; c _
H lO 4 3
'o 200 a
E
=
Z 100 - O - , 50 - t O 20 - I l i ! I f f i 10 1978 1979 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 Date Figure 12. Maxima number of Heteroceridae collected per month from a black , light trap located near the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station. Platte-ville. Colorado. 1973-1979. I O l l l l O i L.-,-,.. .- .-- . . _ - . , - . - - - ~ . - - . . . - , ~ . . - . - , , , , . . . . . , - . - , , - , , _ , . . . , _ - _ . . - - , _ . , . . . , . , , . . , . . . . - , , ,,
21 2 O
SUMMARY
G Population levels of terrestrial invertebrates collected in the environs of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station varied con-siderably during the study period of 1972 through 1979. However, the variation in population levels of the six groups monitored during that time seemed to be a result of natural fluctuations rather than operation of the Station. There are, however, two possible exceptions where O adverse influences to invertebrate populations might have resulted from operation of the Station. First, a general population increase of Formicidae occurred during the latter stages of the study when collections from all areas were considered. e However, a comparison of the individual sampling areas near the Station revealed a decline in numbers of individ-uals. The population decline was minor from row three, the site con-sidered most likely to be influenced by heated discharge water, but greater from row four where the effect should be less serious. If the reduction in numbers of Formicidae was due to the operation of the Station, the opposite situation would be expected. We believe that the population decline ,in the area near the Station could have resulted from natural factors and not Station operation but it is not possible to rule out the latter possibility.
- The second possible exception was in collections of Tricoptera where population levels declined compared to those at the beginning of the study. The Tricoptera is the group most likely to be affected by O heated discharge water because the imature forms live: directly in the water of the slough, and possibly, that of the concrete-lined drainage ditch. Thus, the population reduction of Tricoptera might be a direct #
O
'O 21 3 result of the operation of the Generating Station. Some evidence to the O contrary is that populations of heterocerid beetles followed the "mid-study" decline similar to that of Tricoptera but have since recovered to levels approximating those early in the study. Since these beetles live O in the mud shores of the slough the effects of the heated discharge water would be less dramatic than for Tricoptera, but the similarity in popula-tion trends suggests that the fluctuations might be natural ones. Also, O population changes in Tricoptera are known to fluctuate widely in natural situations and it seems probable the changes seen during this study were natural ones. .O In general, we believe that the limited operation of the Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station to date has not causec' changes in species compos .' tion nor population levels of terrestrial invertebrates considered O in this study. In our opinion, construction of the Generating Station, and the loss of former suitable terrestrial invertebrate habitat in the area, have had more serious effects on the terrestrial invertebrate O p0Pulations than the operation of the plant. Certainly, construction of a ten-story building with acres of parking lots and associated facilities is a drastic change from a fomer prairie environment.
- O The benefits of the monitoring program have been excellent. The monitoring provided a rare opportunity to follow changes in populations I
of terrestrial invertebrate species over an extended period of time. 'O i I i i
)
- D L
O 214 REFERENCES (1) Skaife, S. H. 1968. Experiments on the effects of radiation on , ants. Australian Natural History. March:27-28. (2) Cadwell, L. L., and F. W. Whicker. 1972. The arthropod community. In Radioecology of Some Natural Organisms and Systems in , Colorado. Tenth Annual Report on Atomic Energy Commission Contract. (Available from Department of Radiology and Radiation Biology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colo. 80523). , 84 pp. (3) Wurtz, C. B. 1969. The effects of heated discharge on freshwater benthos. In Biological Aspects of Thermal Pollution. Krenkel, P. A., and F. L. Parkers, Eds., Vanderbilt University Press, Nashville, Tenn. 199 pp. (4) Brewer, J. W. 1976. Terrestrial invertebrates. In A Biological Sure;y of Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station Site. Thorne Ecological Institute, Boulder, Colorado. 138 pp. (5) Southwood, T. R. E. 1966. Ecological Methods. London. 391 pp. 9 (6) Wunder, B. A. Personal communication. Department of Zoology and Entomology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colo. 80523. 9 (7) Fey, J. M. 1977. Die Aufheizung eines Mittelgebirgsflusses und ihre Auswirkungen auf die Zoozonose-dargestellt, an de Lenne (Sauerland), Arch. Hydrobiol. Supp. 53:307-363. (original not seen, cited by G Ward and Stanford 1980. In: The Ecology of Regulated Streams, pp. 35-55.) (8) Nebeker, A. V. 1977. Effect of high winter water temperatures on O emergence of aquatic insects. Water Research. 5:777-783. O
3 215 J i 3 D LITERATURE CITED P l I 4 I i b i i J i D e I
-r.----- -
-,n,,-,--+ - - - - - - - , , - - - - c, ..- ,..- - , - - .-- - - ----. . . ,, _ - , , . . - - - , . . , , , , , . - - , . - , - - . , - - , , , - - . ~ . - , , , - - - . - - - . - - . . . - .
O 216 LITERATURE CITED g Glover, F. A. 1976. A biological survey of Fort St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station Site. Thorne Ecological Institute, Boulder, , Colo. 138pp. O O O O O t O O O
ATTACHIENT_ 8 COPY OF NPDES PERMIT NUMBER CO-0001121 25 Pages l l l l l t t , ______3
1 e .e R(. CCLCAACO DEPARTMENT C : HEALTH -; 4210 E.11TH WENLE CENVE;9 EC2EO P O E 3ee-6111 ANTHONY ROB BINS. M.D..M.P. A. EXECUTIVE CtPECTOR July 20, 1978 CERTIFIED MAIL: 715853 Public Service Company of Colorado Fort St. Vrain Facility C. K. Millen P.O. Box 840 Denver; CO 80201 Re: Final Permit, NPDES Permit Number: CO-000ll21, Weld County Gentlemen: Enclosed please find a copy of the permit issued under the Federal Water Pollution Control Act and Colorado Water Quality Control Act. Issuance of this permit constitutes a final determination by the Division of Administration of the Colorado Department of Heal th, in conjunction with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and may be subject to administrative review proceedings pursuant to the State Administrative Procedure Act, including an adjudicatory hearing. You are advised to consult this act and particularly to consul t Sections 24-4-104, 24-4-105, 24-4-102(7) , and 25-8-401, C.R.S. 1973 for more information. In addition, the Regulations for the State Discharge. Permit System contains material that is pertinent to any administrative review of the issuance of this permit. Your NPDE5 Vaste Discharge Permit requires that specific action be performed at designated times. Failure to meet these requirements constitutes a violation of this permit and can result in civil and/or criminal action (s). Please read the permit very thoroughly. .
- 1. All municipal and industrial facilities are required to sudnit self-monitoring information. (PART 1. 3. Monitoring and Recorting).
Frequencies and types of sel f-moni toring are summari::ed in PART I A. Ef fluent Limitations and Monitoring Recuirements.
- 2. Monitoring and reporting requirements for feedicts are described in PART l. A. Effluent Limitations and Monitoring Recuirements (see 2. c.)
and in PAAT 1. S. Moni torino and Recortina. t i 3 In .seme instances a schedule of ccmpliance is to be submitted if required by your permit. Please note the required date as specified in PART I of the permit. . i 1 J
Pige 2 Final Permit (Cen t inued) 4 PART I! A. Manacement Recuirements and S. Resconsibilities, contains in format ion that explains furtner requirements which are enforceable as are all other provisions of the permit.
- 3. PARTill Other Recuirements specify certain reports that are required and/or noti fica tions that are necessary.
Please read very carefully the enclosed memorandum regarding annual NPOES permit fees. If you have any questions, please contact the Permits Program, Water Quality Centrol Division at (303) + 388-6111 Ext. 231. Very truly yours, FOR DIRECTOR, VATER QUALITY CONTROL DIVISION [[U Fr=.d W. Ma t:er , P . E. , Chi ef Monitoring & Enforcement Section FWM:ky cc: U.S. Envirenmental Protection Agency District Engineer Health Department 208 Planning Area Enc!crures (2) l s
~
i \ . 9 e wq-?tli (205) J
COLORADO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
'i4ctor quality Control Division '
4210 East litn' Avenue Qenver, CO 80220
SUMMARY
OF RATIONALE PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY OF COLORADO FORT ST. VRAIN FACILITY PERMIT NUMBER: CO-0001121 WELD COUNTY TYPE OF PERMIT: Major Industrial SIC NO.: 491,1 LOCATION: - Facility is located near Platteville in the following sections: Section 34, 35, Township 4 North, Range 67 West; Section 3, Township 3 North, Range 67 West: See page 3 of permit for discharge locations. CONTACTS: Mr. C. K. M111en, Senior Vice President P.O. Box 840 Denver, CO 80201 (303)+571-7475 OR Mr. H. L. Brey Superintendent of Operations
, Public Service Company Ft. St. Vrain Nuclear Generating Station P.O. Box 361 Platteville, CO 80651 (303)+758-2253 (Denver 571-7436)
Denver Contacts: George Brown 571-8280 Mr. H. G. (Bill) Brines 571-6717 RECEIVING WATERS: Discharge points 001, 003: South Platte River, 82 , effluent, limited segment. Discharge points 002, 004: St. Vrain Creek, 32 , effluent limited segment. . The facility is designed to generate 330 megawatts of electricity; facility is classified a's a High Temperature Gas Cooled Reactor (HTGR). Primary source of energy is the nuclear reactor which is rated at 842 megawatts of thermal energy. 4
, , _ _ _ . . m.- . - < #- -- 4%-+.- -s -
c Pass 2
, Summary of Rationale Public Service Co. of Colorado, Ft. St. Vrain Facility (continued)
VATER SYSTEMS : The attached schematic (Figure 1, Summary of Rationale) outlines the facility's ~ nonradioactive liquid discharge system. , The condensate /feedwater system is a closed Icop demineralized system providing feecwater to the secondary coolant system. The demineralizer regeneration backwash is discharged to evaporation ponds lined with 30 mil PVC. The water supply for the condensate /feedwater system is domestic water from the Central Weld County Water District. -- The circulatino water system provides coolant to the main condenser for use in condensing steam from plant sources, and transfers the heat to the atmosphere by means of a cooling tower.. The system also serves as a water. reservoir for the fire protection system and is a backup to the service water system. Makeup is normally the South Platte River and/or the St. Vrain River. Shallow wells are used as a backup makeup source. Blowdown is routed to the north yard drain which discharges to the South Platte River (001) or to the alternate St. Vrain Creek (002). Flow rate for the circulating water blowdown averages at full load 2,600 gpm or 3.7 million gallons per day. The service water system serves to provide cooling for various Individual pieces of equipment and/or closed cooling systems within the reactor or turbine generator supporti:ng systems. The service water makeup is normally the shallow well system. Presently, the service water cooling tower blowdown is discharged to the main cooling tower system. The blowdown can be routed to the north yard drain and discharged with the circulating water system blowdown to the South Platte River (001) or through the alternate (002) to the St. Vrain Creek. Flow rate of the service water tower discharge averages 120 gpm (173,000 gpd) . Approximately 175 persons contribute to the domestic wastewater treatment system. Effluent flows estimated at 4,000 ggd are treated in an extended aeration plant followed by a polishing pond. The overflow from the polishing pond is discharged to the north yard drain. (See Figure 1, Summary of Rationale.) Public Service Company is considering using the treated effluent in the main cooling system. (Approximately 0.1 percent of the main cooling tower blowdown.) Water supply for domestic purposes is the Central Weld County Water District. LOW VOLUME WASTES
- Wastes from- the turbine building sump are pretreated by an oil separator; the effluent from the separator is conveyed to the diversion box, where it is discharged with the main cooling tower blowdown. The oil is disposed of as solid waste. The turbine building effluent derlies from the miscellaneous drains within the turbine building. Total discharge from this building averages 72 gpm (100,000 spd).
Contents of the reactor building sump are normally filtered, monitored, and discharged at a restricted flow of 10 gpm. The filters are capable of removing potentially radioactive particulate matter from the effluent. This effluent passes to the liquid was.te disposal line through an oil separater and out to the cooling tower blowdown. Batch discharges from the reactor building sump may be made at a flow rate of 50 gpm. The water source for the reactor building sump is miscellaneous drains within the reactor building. Normal discharge frem:this sumo averages 10 gpm (less than 15,000 gpd due to intermittent use).
f Page 3 Summary of Rationale Public Service Co. of Colorado, Ft. St. Vrain Facility (continued) This intermittent effluent is monitored for any radioactive materials prior to - discharge; the discharge of any radioactive materials, including liquid wastes, are regulated by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and will not be included in ' this permit; hcwever, liquid effluent reports required by the Nuclear Regulatory Commision will be submitted as a part of the quarterly NPDES report. The major effluent is frem the main cooling tower bicwdown, which is discharged after about 2 1/2 to 5 cycles to the diversion box and through 001 or 002. Sources of this water are the South Platte River and the St. Vrain Creek. Slowdown ficws are listed below: Present Average: 1,600 gpm (2.3 MGD) Estimated at Full Power: 2,600 gpm (3.7 MGD) Minimum: 1,100 gpm (1.6 MGD) The above minimum is based on the 100 to 1 dilution requirement'for the intermittent discharge from the reactor building sump. The water scurces to the facility are summarized below:
- 1. South Platte River and St. Vrain Creek: 3,000 gpm (4.3 MGD) average estimated at full plant load; supii lies the main cooling system.
- 2. Six (6) shallow wells, 40 to 120 foot depth, total rated capacity of 8,000 gpm; average pumping rate of 200 gpm (0.3 MGD). Supplies the service water system; flows can be diverted to the main cooling system if required.
3 Domestic source is from the Central Weld Water District, estimated at 100,000 gpd. Self-monitoring data: These data may not be true indicators of the actual discharges to the receiving waters due to the locations of the monitoring points for the various parameters. A summary for the period of January, 1974 through October, 1977 is listed below: l l Parameter Averace Rance Flow (MGD) 1.9 0.11-3.4 TRC and/or FA (mg/1) 0.21 0-6.75 TDS (mg/1) 1,270 , 755-2,030 l TSS (mg/l) 13 ' 1-58 Temperature (CF) - 33-83 pH (units) - 6.9-8.7 Ammonia Mitrogen (mg/l) 2.3 0-12.3 The previous permit was issued prior to the issuance of Steam Electric Power Generation Regulations (40 CFR, Part 423) . Limitations were: TSS (mg/l) 30 (gross) TOS (mg/l) 2,300 (gross) Ammonia Nitrogen None (net lbs/ day) Chlorine Residual (mg/l) 0.1 (gross) Temperature - If Farm n ond discharge exceeds 30 F due to atmospheric conditiens, blowdown snall be discharged from the cold side of the circulating water cooling tower. _.. _ ~_ _. .-. d
Paga 4 Summacy of Rationale Public Service Co. of Colorado Ft. S t. Vrain Facili ty (continued) The TOS limit and ammonia nitrogen limits were imposed to assure that little . degradation of the receiving waters would occur. Figure 1 of the permit shows - the property boundaries of the Fort St. Vrain plant site. Public Service leases land not used for the power generation facility operation to farmers for , agricultural purposes. Irrigation water is supplied by the Goosequill Ditch, Seeman Ditch, and Jay Thomas Ditch. The plant discharge may be intermingled with these waters during irrigation periods. Stream background data are listed below:
- 1. St. Vrain Creek (data near mouth) average di'scharge (51 years of record):
203 cfs. Minimum flow (4/13/35): 12 cfs. 7 day - 10 year low flow: 39.8 cfs. TOS (mg/1) average concentration (water year - 1976): 1010. Ammonia nitrogen (mg/1): average of 1.7, range of 0.2 to 2.7. Nitrite nitrogen (mg/1): average of 0.077, range of 0.01 to 0.14. Nitrate nitrogen (mg/1): average of 2.63, range of 1.5 to 4.1. i Total Phosphorus (mg/1): average of 0 52, range 0.07 to 0.76
- 2. South Platte River (data at Henderson)
Average discharge (50 years of record): 366 cfs. Minimum flow (4/1/50): 4.4 cfs 7 day - 10 year flow: 46.7 cfs. TDS (mg/l), average concentracion: 686. t Ammonia nitrogen (mg/1): average of 11.5, range of 2.3 to 21.4. Nitrite nitrogen: average concentration of 0.35, range of 0.16 to 0.85 Nitrate nitrogen: average concentration of 2.81, range of 0.7 to 9.7 Total Phosphorus: average concentration of 3.0, range of 0 34 to 7 i Note: Chemical data from Colorado State Health Department stream sampling data. The intake waters account for the h'igh ammonia nitrogen values IIsted in the
. quarterly self-monitoring reports. .Through the use of the water, the facility does remove some ammonia nitrogen.
The following additives are now being used at the facility: Additive Concentrations Quantity Added I. Service Water Cooling System Chlorine 0.5-1.5 mg/l ** Polyphosphate 1.0-1.5 mg/l 1300 lbs/ month Zinc 2.5-3 5 mg/l 260 lbs/ month Quaternary amine 20 mg/l ** Antifcaming agent ** l Dispersant 20 mg/l 1024 lbs/ month l H2SO4 pH 6.5-6.8 **
** Total included in circulating water tower number.
t
Page 5 Summary of Rationale Public Service Co. of Colorado Ft. St. Vrain (continued) Addltive Concentratlens Quantity Added
- 2. Circulating Water System Chlorine (slug treatment) I ppm 840 lbs/ month
- Polyotester 10-40 ppm 650 lbs/ month quaternary amine 20 ppm 287 lbs/ month
- Antifoaming agent 114 lbs/ month
- H2 SO4 (for pH control) pH 7.6-8.0 29,942 lbs/ month *
- Total amount used for both water systems. ii.e., circulating and service water systems)
Discharge flows are summarized below:
- 1. Low volume wastes - 100,000 gpd.
- 2. Cooling towers blowdown - 3.87 MGD (at 100 percent power) .
Permit limits will be based on the above flows; guidelines used will be those attainable by the application of the best practical control technology currently avaiIable (40 CFR, Part 423.22). These limitations are:
- 1. Low volume wastes l
TSS l Daily maximum, 100 mg/1; 37.86 kg/ day (83.40 lbs/ day) 30 day average, 30 mg/1; 11.37 kg/ day (25.05 lbs/ day) l Oil and Grease Daily maximur6, 20 mg/1; 7.6 kg/ day (16.7 lbs/ day) 30 day average, 15 mg/1; 5.7 kg/ day (12.5 lbs/ day) .
- 2. Cooling towers blowdown; ,
Free Available Chlorine . Daily maximum, 0.5 mg/1; 7.3 kg/ day (16.1 lbs/ day) 30 day average, 0.2 mg/1; 3.0 kg/ day (6.5 lbs/ day) Zinc Daily maximum, 1.0 mg/1; 14.7 kg/ day (32 3 lbs/ day) 30 day average, 1.0 mg/1; 14.7 kg/ day (32 3 lbs/ day) Discharge limitations on other corrosion inhibiting materials used in the cooling tower shall be established on a case by case basis (CFR 40, Part 523.23(i)). Currently, st. Vrain is experimenting with a group of new chemicals. These materials include Calgon CD-1247, Calgon C 004, Calgon Ct.5 and H-212. To control toxici ty on these materials, net increase limitaticns have been placed on ein and iron. The limitations are 0.2 mg/l net increase of tin and 1.0 mg/l net incra=<. nf_ienn _ __ _ _ _ . _ _ _ . . .,.
'Page 6 '
Summary of Rationale Public Service Co. of Colorado, Ft. St. Vrain Facility (conti.nued) Phoschorut
- A future limitation of total phosphorus, based on the 8ATEA limitations (40 CFR, Part 423.23) will be imposed. Permittde will be reg sired to meet this limitation by June 30,1984 Future total phosphorus (net) limitations shall be:
~
Daily maximum, 5.0 mg/1; 73.3 kg/ day (161.4 lbs/ day) 30 day average, 5.0 mg/1; 73 3 kg/ day (161.4 lbs/ day) Permittee shall monitor the net total phosphorus discharged from the facility monthly.
' TSS Daily Maxmium, 100 mg/1; I498.2 kg/ day (3,300 lbs/ day) 30 day average, 30 mg/1; 449.5 kg/ day (990 lbs/ day)
A total suspended solids limit will be imposed; this will be based on the concentratio: limits listed in the guide lines for low volume wastes and will be applied to the total discharge. Temeerature Temperature limitation will be that of the proposed stream standards (in the process of being finalized) Discharge shall not exceed 32cc (900F). The cold side circulating water blowdown clause will be included in'the permit. There shall be no discharge of polychlorinated biphenyl compounds. The pH shall be within the range of 6.0 to 9.0. Chlorine Neither free available chlorine nor total residual chlorine may be discharged from . any unit for more than two hours in.any one day and not more than one unit in any plant may discharge free available or total residual chlorine at any one time unless it can be demonstrated to the regional administrator, EPA, and the State of Colorado that the units cannot operate at or below this level of chlorination. Miscellaneous Permittee will be required to continue monitoring total dissolved solids, intake and discharge, and ammonia nitrogen, intake and discharge. Locations of discharges will be those described on page 2 of the permit, and indicated in Figure 1, page 3 of the permit. Discharge point 001, the Farm Pond, is the normal discharge point. The discharge to the St. Vrain Creek, 002, may be used when ditch maintenance or repair is required. Monitoring for specific parameters shall be at the following locatiors: 001 Olscharces Temperature, and free available chlorine 001-A Farm Pcnd outfall
._ _ ~. , _ _ _ _ _ __ _ a
Paga 7 . Summary of Rationale Public Service Co. of Colorado, Ft. St. Vrain Facility (continued) All other parameters shall be monitored at 0018, the Goosequill - (See Figure 1, page 3, permit, for Stub discharge to the Goosequill Ditch. locations of 001A and 001B.) Flow will be measured at the Farm Pond outfall until a flow measuring device is installed at the Goosequill Stub. 002 Discharces All parameters shall be measured at the Parshall Flume located on St. Vrain Drainage Ditch (see Figure 1, page 3, permi t) . Discharge points 003 and 004 will be limited to South Platte River water and St. Vrain Creek water respectively, for the purpose of cleaning the trash screen. Permit shall expire June 30, 1983 Paul E. Williamson March 16, 1978 4 7
- 9 Y D 9*]D D
1J e o A\ e u .
- 2
((sustrut2Cm s.CCC1.*l1ATCf 6&CavMswC3 --- - tvarvtat:07: rwet I . r- 06L Cat'acSAL tgomt gapLDs4 (WL%4 Pts 7 Cat Strt.nATCtt
;;.*t's %:.M*.+* *=*dl- - %
l ec.n. us.o ou;:.s > [ EVt.*G:ATC*d . _# Cglif7 l / 3 ELCt*F?arMis*0f t_.
,, . e . ,,
.J c:c.=4 23*ta
.: , n*;
I . mc mo
?E IMLQ*
yug.. 2;s; TU.tcir.C.. u.c car
~
vattn rrrv4 \ t*.*.a v
~
CAMf8 - E AE' ** Lig/4LC.'d L'tLLb[ i SULrut:C Ac!O I (1%fh'4M FOLTPHQ$n ciATCS (CPef 5ffC g. hy'g "~ IEMM ft.t3Jair, tvfm t** _ r.Al t a ,' > g g,.gg,q,y - IM AIU!f4 T 3 s.oraQ St%fCid Let t.af.4 EW'I i f ..CY'M
' otFT Nk
/
H -4y eu, ff.i.,ien Ruf . a.m v.= cu ,o BM. I W!.I 8 I
.%,','. . __gg ALTCfte:Aff C'.CwOO/.M (CC'.01, I t m0 a.:q l lkky
'.*.0 _,*k
-d 1 t :. U.*!)E
'??':
LPfW' Pt$ud ? te.c=.L:pr, ec.. , CCTOC'4* sca f,.,.c, ( ,. _ U i e t i* civt%Cv #.tt{gt SULFtrhc #C10 v C % Cw:t g j FCLT3 *W14JNAT C5 ,g, , e, SLCAfJ8 (C0$fCuiLL Cettes III.I.L?* := SCU0$ CISP0114. l , 6% .$ .3 Inn.:rtoe ILN $( AWel JAf THCr/A1011Cs4 vtttf? r@w St vf".*sCMCC A%3 *,0=J f H i*. Al!L ChC E ,
$f. vfWse CRCCE TftfLOW 4 .,
MAstes sg At70 k.v49 OTATlON'S NONI.ADICACT!VE LIQUID WASTE SYSTEM Figure 1 Summary of Rationale w
F Renewal Permi t No, CO-0001121 l l County: Weld l AUTHORIZATION TO OISCHARGE UNDER THE NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM j in comoliance with the provisions of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, as amended (33 U.S.C. -1251 et. seq;. the "Act"), and the Colorado Water quality Centrol Act (25-8-r01 et. seq., CRS, 1973 as amended) the Public Service Company of Colorado is authorized to discharge from their nuclear steam electric generation faciliy, located near the confluence of the St. Vrain RI'ver and the South Platte River, near Platteville, Colorado, to the South Platte River and the St. Vrain Creek, in accordance with effluent limitations, monitoring requirements and other conditions set forth in Part I, I I , and 1 I I hereof. ! This permit shall become effective thirty (30) days after the date of receipt of this permit by the Applicant. Should the Applicant choose to contest any of the effluent limitations, monitoring requirements or other conditions contained herein, he must comply with Section 24-4-104 CRS 1973 and the Regulations for the State Discharge Permi t System. Failure to contest any such effluent limitation, monitoring requirement, or other condition is j consent to the condition by the Applicant. 1 . This permit and the authorization to discharge shall expire at midnight, June 30, 1983 Signed this J [ day of
. ( , pf COLORADO DEPARTMENT OF H LTH J' '
Division of Administration di,J / William M. Auber e Associate Director, Department of Health Environmental Protection 5/31/78 - . . .
i i l PART 1 t Page 2 of 15 Permit No. CO-0001121 ; A. EFFLUENT LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS - SEE ANY ADDITIONAL REqutREMENTS UNDER PART !!!. Location of Discharges: There are four (4) discharge points, which are l located as shown in Figure 1, page 3 These are described below: 001A: Discharge from Farm Pond to South Platte River; the monitoring point is located at the Parshall fiume at the Farm Pond overflow. 0010: This point is at the end of the Goosequill Stub, just prior to discharge to the Goosequill Ditch. This is the primary discharge point and will be used at all times except for ditch maintenance and repair. 002: Discharge from the drainage sicugh to the St. Vrain Creek; monitoring point is at the measuring device located prior to discharge to the St. Vrain Creek. This point is to be used when maintenance is being carried out on the ditches leading to 001. 004: Discharge from the trash screens to the St. Vrain Creek; located at the raw water intake on the St. Vrain Creek. l 003: Discharge from the trash screens to the South Platte River; located at the raw water intake on the South Platte River. l i
. _ _ . _ _. . . - _ - - ~ . -
u q
) w& O. . . ~3
- < .. . ,;-N -Q r -
/ 7 .-' ' "%.% s .y l PART l
- Page 3 of 15
/ f s
. . .w
.em Is I- -
y. s/
,p,
/ 7"' -
Permit No. CO-0001121
':*: v.-
W j 9 i l.c .. .
. .; j g ,s. ,
\ ,e
. . ~l..
i-y i;~ .' a
- s. j,' d 3p p ' / ,
. .?c.--;: 001 [ E
,,. 002 s
..g '
s h h h '- \ ! '
- = ~ - . .,'
v.d."",7-"----*=
,' 1 ,.
f ;; r. 1ic Service Company P ' t a d s , ,.
*' ( Ft. St. Vrain Nuclear "J,';.i .:
.' .,/,,' '3
- 's's. Generaeing Station
.'s / ) '
., Discharge Points o .v a,- 2. ./";; -- -
.7.
. t
^s o .
h
, -p ,- .
., ....r
. - - - . y %- ~
" ,' 001A #
ume 4% s *\ t 3
% .... i rf m .
/
m< ,i gf
\.. 3
.-=
- s. .
- 1. '
l
+ t/
b / l -) !. g'
.s q
/
l
.f j' --
~
s ;
,s , ;. . .
/ '- / 3 .
t, l 4 l
\ *-.i. d' '
l % \.,
'},.s,. I !
, _ \ .
\ q> e
,,. w .. ) ,,/
*- O-g l
\ \ 2 ~. .,
f ) *
-[,./ 0
\ . ( *
~=--
h\ \* g 4I 1 ,. t-ist - l
\' 002 4 h f*'
,3,(j g. .- 0018 g l.
i -% , y p 2 gp t 4. :v m. . L4 -004 9a ( w'r .r '. - . - c " = .. , '!: : _ f :';;:.: , . g s f 4 . (. % -- ' Q;'a.j . ' - - - i- .- ' .' T *" h -
~~~z a
.i , .~~./i
- f. -
3 .-g. - ic- 4 y. ) u).
; r 4 . c : !ph.t. w. . ., _ .~ - ..:;y-- :- -*A, t .ms u--
.Nr / 9,. i s.-'., . _-l. . .
- g. . :=::.a..#.. ,., . w 2. .,
c,.i... sd. . . . _-...__
~y
,,, .a/ st v gi. a p+9 a .
, , . , -r.
. . ~ . . . .. -.. . _ . , . , . , . .
. ~: .
.. 6 . , . .
A _ &
./_ ;
s s.,,, _m..
'(. c---
. I
;" v -
4 003 3 n,, -_ - g ,)'
" ~ ~ - - -*-
l.i -- '
- 3. .'
i .'. . .r--"----,*** I s-W"" ' - ". A ..
~ .
hpw.m,.e . :, g,., ,e w.:.q ,(, .i p::': ::".*. ~ 7 5 -
~ ~ . . . ~ . . .
j
..q, 1 H.
f:*4*
~
].
l t ; < ~~- \ ! ... - - ~ ~ ~ -
- 3. i. . . a' _,.. -- .r =. .e = ..A-,.. (2---.~~
g e =.'::,..r 1, :-
'j p -
,. ;l \. 3%. . - , ..
g \ . . w.. . ... . . . . . . . n . . . . W.. gr .e
. s. . uc . -- me. Sy_sa s.<._* t w9 4 c ... a. . .*.=
's
.-c........... . . . . . . . . . . ....
During the period baginning July 1, 1978 and lasting through June 30, 1983 tha parmitten is authorized . to discharge from outfall(s) sarial number (s) 001, 002
- 1. Effluent Limitations Effluent Parameter Discharge Limitations Haximum Weight Haximum Concentration kg/ day (lbs/ day) mg/l mg/l 30-day avg. af Daily max. ,b/ 30-day avg. a/ Daily max c/
j flow - m /3Day (HGD) N/A N/A N/A N/A Total Suspended Solids 449.5 (990) 1498.2 (3,300) 30 100 011 and Grease 5.7 (12.5) 7.6 (16.7) 15 20 Zinc 14.7 (32.3) I4.7 (32.3) 1.0 1.0 AFree Available chlorine 3.0 (6.5) 7.3 (16.1) 0.2 0.5 1 *
*AHet Total Tin N/A N/A N/A 0.2 l
^^ Net Total tron N/A N/A N/A 1.0 At no t,ime will the temperature exceed 32 C (90 0F). I f, because of atmospheric condi tions, the farm pond discharge temperature exceeds 27 C (80"F), blowdcwn shall be discharged from the cold side of the circulating ,J water cooling tower.
The pH shall not be less than 6.0 standard units nor greater than 9.0 standard units c/. ) 3 There shall be no discharge of floating solids or visible foam in other than trace anounts.
')
-a/ This limitation shall be determined by the arithmetic mean of a minimum of three (3) consecutive samples taken on separate weeks in a 30-day period (minimum total of three (3) samples); )
b/ This limitation means the total discharge by weight during any calendar day, as determined by an 8-hour ') s composite sample. I
) ! c/ This limitation shall be determined by a single properly preserved sample as required under monitoring $
requirements - Sample Type. " 3 There shhli be no discharge of polychlorinated biphenyl compcunds from this facility. 3 ANeither free available chlorine nor total residual chlorine may be discharged from any unit for more than two u o s. hours in any one day and not more than one unit in any plant may discharge free available or total residual chlorine at any one time. l{k AAThese limitations will be on a net increase over the concentration present in the water supply, am E i . S L p . .,
A. EFFLUENT LlHITATIONS AND HONITORING REQUIREHENTS - SEE ANY ADDITIONAL REQUIREHENTS UNDER PART 111. During the period beginning inmeidately and lasting through June 30, 1983 the permittee is authorized to discharge from outfall(s) serial number (s) 003, 003
, l. Effluent Limitations 003 - This discharge shall consist of South Platte River water and shall contain no heat or other chemicals or material other than that removed from the intake screens.
00's - This discharge shall consist of St. Vrain Creek water and shall contain no heat or other chemicals or materials other than that removed from the intake screens. No monitoring will be required at these points. l 1 (t u 3%i
$ U) -
5 *,,
.g G; o a i 8 1 :
e a .- .
- PART I Pags 6 of 1,5 Permit No. CO-000ll21 A. EFFl.UENT LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS (Continued) ,'
3 Monitoring Requirements in order to obtain an indication of the probable compliance or non-compliance with the effluent limitations specified in Part I, the permittee shall monitor and report all effluent parameters at the following required frequencies, as a minimum. Effluent Parameters Measurement Frecuency d/e/ Samole Type f/ Flow Weekly Instantaneous or continuous recording Total Suspended Solids Weekly Grab or Composite Oil and Grease Weekly Grab Free Available Chlorine c/ Veekly Grab Total Dissolved Solids (intake) h/ Monthly Composite Total Dissolved Solids (effluentT h/ Monthly Composite (reported as micrombos/cm and/or total dissolved solids) Zine Monthly Grab Phosphorus, total (as P), net Monthlj Grab or Composite Ammonia Nitrogen (as N), net Monthly Grab or Composite pH Weekly Grab Temperature Weekly Grab Total Tin i/ Monthly Grab Total tron 1/ Monthly Grab Self-monitoring samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location (s): 001, 002 d/ Monitoring is required only during periods of discharge. If "no discharge" occurs, this shall be reported at the specified frequency. (See Part B.) e/ Quarterly samples shall be collected during the months of March, June, September, December, i f a continual d!!scharge occurs. I f the discharge occurs on an intermittent ba. sis, all the samples shall be collected during . the period when that intermittent discharge occurs. ff See definitions, Part B. ej Monitoring is required only when chlorine is used in the treatment of cooling waters. Samples shall be collected and analyzed when the cooling waters are ch lo ri na ted . l h/ Analysis may be as total dissolved solids (TDS) or by electrical conductivity where a satisfactory correlation with TDS has been established. The correlation shall be verified be a minimum of two (2) per quarter, if there is a deviation of more than ten (10) percent, a new correlation shall be established. _i / These parameters will be morri tored while the following chemicals are added to cooling water systems: Calgon CD-1247, Calgon C c04, and Calgon CLS. Vater supply and the cischarge will be monitored.
PART 1 , Page 7 of 15 Permit Number CO-0011~21 A. EFFLUENT LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REqulREMENTS (Continued)
- 4. Monitoring for specific parameters shall be at the following locations:
001 Discharge , Flow , tem 0 era ture and free available chlorine, at 001 A, Farm Pond outf all . l All other parameters shall be monitored at 0013, (see Figure 1, page 3 for locations of 001 A and 001B) . 00'2 Discharce All parameters shall be monitored at the Parshall Fiume ~1ocated on the St. Vrain Orainage Ditch. (see Figure 1, page 3) Within three (3) months after the date of permit i ssuance, a flow-measuring device shall be installed to give representative values of effluent volume for determining the parameter limitations to be monitored at 0018. When installed, flow will be measured at Point 001B. e 9 k n,
4 PART l . Page 8 of 15
?wimit No. CO-0001121 .
30 MONITORING AND REPORTING
- 1. Representative sampling Samples and measurements taken as required herein shall be representative of the volume and nature of the monitored discharge.
- 2. Reporting
( Monitoring results obtained during the previous 3 months shall be summarized for each quarter & reported on applicable discharge- monitoring report forms, postmarked no later than the 28th day of the month following the completed reporting period. The first . report is due on October 28, 1978. I f no discharge occurs, "No Discharge" shall be reported. Duplicate signed copies of these, and all other reports required herein, shall be submitted to the Regional Administrator and the State at the following addresses: Colorado Department of Health U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Water quality Control 0! vision 1860 Lincoln Street - Suite 900 l h210 East lith Avenue Denver, Colorado 80203 l Denver, Colorado 80220 Attention: Enforcement - Permit Program 3 Definitions
- a. A " composite" sample, for monitoring requirements, is defined as a minimum of four (4) grab samples collected at equally spaced two (...
hour intervals and proportioned according to flow,
- b. A " grab" sample, for monitoring requirements, is defined as a single
" dip and take" sample collected at a representative point in the discharge l
stream.
~
- c. An " instantaneous" measurement, for monitoring requirements, is defining as a single reading, observation, or, measurement using existing monitoring l facilities.
l l 4. Test Procedures , , Test procedures for the analysis of pollbtants shall conform to regulations l published pursuant to Section 304(g) of the Act, and Colorado State Effluent Limitations (400), under which such procedures may be required. l 3. Recording of Results For each measurement or sample taken pursuant to the requirements of this permit, the permittee shall record the following information:
- a. The exact place; date, and time of sampling;
- b. The dates the analyses were performed;
- c. The person (s) who performed the analyses;
.m
l PART l Dage 9~ of 15 Permit No. CO-000ll21 ;
- d. The analytical techniques or methods used; and
- e. The results of all required analyses.
- 6. Additional Monitoring by Permittee if the permittee monitors any pollutant at the location (s) designated herein more frequently than required by this permit, using approved analytical methods as specified above, the results of such monitoring shall be included in the calculation and reporting of the values required in the D.Ischarge Monitoring Report Form (EPA No. 3320-1),
or other' forms as required by the Division. Such increased frequency shall also be indicated. I
- 7. Records Retention
! All records and information resulting from the conitoring activities required by this permit including all records 'of analyses performed and calibration and maintenance of Instrumentation and recordings f ecm continuous monitoring instrumentation shall be retained for a i minimum of three (3) years, or longer if requested by the Regional Administrator or the State Vater quality Control Division.
- 3. Radiation Monitoring '
The permittee shall transmit along with the monitoring report, a l duplicate copy of the reports on radioactive liquids dischar( ._ i required to be submitted to the NRC. This report shall include the date(s) of discharge (s) and volumes of each discharge. l l
? age 10 of 15 Permit No.Ca-000ll21 A. MANAGEKENT REqu!REMENT3
( 1. Changa in Discharge All discharges authorized herein shall be consistent with the terms and - conditions of this permit. The discharge of any pollutant identified in this permit more frequently chan or at a level in excess of that authorized shall constitute a violation of the permit. Any anticipated change in discharge location and/or facility expansions, production increases, or process modifications which will result in new, different, or !ncreased discharges or pollutants must be reported by submission of a new NPOES application or, if such changes will not violate the affluent limitations specified in this permit, by notice to the State Water quality Control Olvision of such changes. Process modifications include,. but are not limited to, the introduction of any new pollutant not previously identified in the permit, or any other modifications which may result in a discharge.of a quantity or quality different frem that which was applied fo r. Following such notice, the permit may be modified to specify and limit any pollutants not previously limited.
- 2. Noncompliance Notification I
- a. If, for any reason, the permittee does not comply with any maximum effluent limitation specified in this permit the permittee shall provide the Regional Administrator and the State Water quality Control Division j with the following information, in writing, within five (5) days of l beccming aware of such cenaltion:
'l) A description of the discharge and cause of noncompliance; and
- (2) The period of noncompliance, including exact dates and time; or, if not corrected, the anticipated time the nonecmpliance is expected to continue, and steps being taken to reduce, eliminate and prevent recurrence of the nonccmplying discharge.
I
- b. The permittee, as soon as it has knowledge thereof, shall notify the State Water quality control Division of any spill or discharge of any pollutant, not otherwise authorized in this permit, which may cause pollution of waters of the State.
t .
- 3. Facilities Operation The pe)mittee shall at all times maintain in good working order and operate as efficiently as possible all treatment or control facilities or systems Installed or used by the permittee to achieve compliance with the terms and conditions of this permit.
4 Adverse Impact i The permittee shall take all reasonable steps to minimi:e any adverse impact to waters of the State resulting frem nonccmpliance with any effluent limitations scecified in this permit, including such accelerated or additional monitoring as necessary to determine the nature and impact of the noncemolying discharge. 77 _ __ _ _ _ __ _ _ --- o
Pag 11 of 15 Permit No. CC-0001121
- 5. Bypassing (see additional requirements under Par: !!!).
Any diversion from or byp. ass of facilities necessary :o maintain compliance with the terms and conditions of this permit, or any'activi:y that results in - the avoidance of any required treatment for any process or run-off water, is prohibited, except (i) where unavoidable to prevent loss of life or severe property damage, or (ii) where excessive storm drainage or runoff would damage any facilities necessary for ce=pliance with the effluent limitations and prohibitions of this permit. The permittee shall promptly notify the Regional Administrator and the State Water quality Control Division in writing of each such diversion or bypass.
- 6. Removed Substances Solids, sludges, filter backwash, or other pollutants removed in the course of treatment of control of wastewaters shall be disposed of in a manner such as 'to prevent any pollutant from such materials from entering waters of the State.
7 Pcwer Failures in order to malatain compliance with the effluent limitations and prohibitions of this permit, the permi ttee shall ei ther:
- a. Provide an alternative power source sufficient to operate the wastewater control facilities; or, if such alternative power source is not in existence, and no date for its implementation appears in Par: 1,
- b. Halt, reduce or otherwise control production and/or all discharges upon the reduction, loss, or failure of the primary source of power to the wastewater control facilities.
- 5. Any discharge to the waters of the State from a point source other than specifically authorized is prohibited.
- 3. RESPONSIBILITIES
- 1. Right of Entry The facility is subject to strict security regulations imposed by federal agencies. All persons entering upon the facili:y site are required to comoly with such security regulations. Subject to comoliance with said regulations the Permittee shall alicw the Director of the State Water quality Control Division, the E.P.A. Regional Administrator, and/or their authorized representatives, to enter the facility ucon presentation I of credentials:
- a. To enter the permittee's premises where an effluent source is located or in which any records are required to be kect under the terms and conditions of this permit; and
- b. At reasonable times to have access to and cocy any records required to be kept under the terms and conditions of this permit and to inspect any monitoring equicment or monitoring method required in the permit.
._ __ _ _. _. _ . _ q
an as
. Paga 11 of 15 Permit No. C0-0001121
- c. To enter upon the permittee's premises to reasonably investigate any actual, suspected or potential source or water pollution, or any .
violation of the Colorado Water Quality Control Act. The investigation may include, but is not limited to, the following: sampling of any
- discharge and/or process waters, the taking of photographs, interviewing of any persons having any knowledge related to the discharge, permit, or alleged violaticn, and access to any and all facilities or areas within the permittee's premises that may have any affect on the discharge, permit, or alleged violation.
- 2. Transfer of Cwnership or Control in the event' of any chance in control or ownership of facIIItles from which the authorized discharges emanate, the permittee shall notify the succeeding owner or controller of.the existence of this permit by letter, a copy of which shall be forwarded to the Regional Administrator and the State Wat,er quality Control Division.
3 Availability of Reports Except for data determined to be confidential under Section 308 of the Act and Regulations for the State discharge permit system (506), all reports prepared in accordance with the terms of this permit shall be available for public inspection at the offices of the State Water Quality Control Division and the Regional Administrator. As required by the Act, effluent data shall not be considered confidential. Knowingly making any false statement on any such report may result in the imposition of criminal penalties as provided for in Section 309 of the Act, and cps (1973) 25-8-610.
- 4. Permit Modification Af ter notice and opportuni ty for a hearing, the permit may be modi fied, suspended, or revoked in whole or in part during its term for cause including, but not limited to, the following:
- a. Violation of any terms or conditions of this permit;
- b. Obtaining th,is permit by misrepresentation or failure to disclose fully all relevant. facts; or
- c. A change in any condition that required either a temporary or permanent reduction or elimination of the authorized discharge. Changes in water quality standards, control regulation or duly promulgated plans would quality as a " change in any condition."
i
- d. This permit may be modified, or alternatively, revoked and reissued, i to comply with any applicable effluent limitation issued pursuant to the order the United States District Court for the District of Columbia issued on June 8, 1976, the Natural Resources Defense Council.
Inc., et. al. v. Russell E. Train, 8 ERC 2120 (0.0.C. 1976), it ene effluent limitation so issued:
- 1. is different in conditions or more stringent than any effluent limitations in the permit; or q
Paga 13 of 15 Permit No. CO.-000ll21
- 2. controls any pollutant not limited in the permit.
5 Toxic Pollutants Notwithstanding Part Il, S-4 above, If a toxic effluent standard or prohibition (including any schedule of compliance specified in such effluent standard or prohibition) is established under Section 307 (a) of the Act for a toxic pollutant which is present in the discharge and such standard or prohibition is more stringent than any limitation for such pollutant in this permit, this permit shall be revised or modified in accordance with the toxic effluent standard or prohibition and the permittee so notified.
- 6. Civil and Criminal Liability Except as provided in permit conditions on "Sypassing" (Part II, A-5) and " Power Failures" (Part 11, A-7), nothing in this permit shall be construed to relieve the permittee from civil or criminal penalties for noncompliance.
7 Oil and. Hazardous Substance Liability Nothing in this permit shall be construed to preclude the institution of any legal action or relieve the permittee from any responsibilities, liabilities, or penalties to which the permittee is or may be subject under Sectien 311 of the Act.
- 3. State Laws Nothing in this permit shall be construed to preclude the institution of any legal action or relieve the permittee from any responsibilities, liabilities, or penalties established pursuant to any applicable State law or regulation under authority preserved by Section 510 of the Act.
9 Permit Violations Failure to comply with any terms and/or conditions of this permit shall be a violation of this permit.
- 10. Property Rights The issuance of this permit does not convey any property rights in .
either real or personal property,'or any exclusive privileges, nor does it authorize any injury to private property or any invasion of personal rights, nor any infringement of Federal, State or local laws or regulations.
- 11. Severability The provisions of this permit are severable, and if any provisions of this permit, or the application of any provision of this permit to any circumstance, is held invalid, the application of such provision to other circumstances, and the remainder of this permit shall not be affected thereby.
- 12. At the request of a permittee, the Division may modify or terminate a permit and issue a new permit if the following conditions are met:
n
- Adi ii Page 14 of 19 Permit No. CO,-000ll21 (a) The Regional Administrator has been notified by the proposed modification or termination and does not object in writing ~ within - -
thirty (30) days of receipt of notification, and . (b) The Division finds that the permittee has shown reasonable grounds consistent with the Federal and State statutes, and regulations for such modification or termination and
;(c) Requirements of public notice have been met.
OTHER REQUIREMENTS There shall be no discharge of polychlorinated biphenyl compounds from this faci l i ty. Discharge limitations on corrosion inhibiting materials other than those listed on page 4 shall be established on a case by case basis (CFR 40, Part 423 23(I)). Additional Bypassing Requirements if, for other reasons, a partial or complete bypass is considered necessary, a request for such bypass shall be submitted to the State Vater quality Contrni Division and to the Environmental Protection Agency at least sixty (60) days prior to the proposed bypass. If the proposed bypass is judged acceptable to the State Water quality Control Division and by the Environmental Protection Agency, the bypass will be a!! owed subject to limitstfons imposed by the State Water quality Control 0! vision and the Environmental Protection Agency. If, after review and consider-ation, the proposed is determined to be unacceptable by the State Water quality Control Division and the Environmental Protection Agency, or if limitations imposed on an approved bypass are violated, such bypass shall be considered a violation of this permit; and the fact that application was made, or that a partial bypass was approved, shall not be defense to any action brought thereunder. Testing Test procedures shall conform with those procedures specified in the Federal Register, Volume 38, Number 199, October 16, 1973 These procedures involve the use of the latest edition of one of the following references:
- 1. " Standard Metheds for the Examination of Water and Waste Water",
- 2. " ASTM", Annual Book of Standards, Part 23, Water, Atmosphere Analysis, 3 " Methods for Chemical Analysis of Waters and Wastes", Environmental Protection Agency.
Discharge Point (s) Discharge points shall be so designed or modified that a sample of the effluent can be obtained at a.coint af ter the final treatment process and prior to discharge to State waters.
.i .
. : PART lli Pagel5 of 15 Permit No.CO-0001121 OTHER REQUIRE!iENTS (Centinued)
' lit 5in three (3) men:hs af ter :he date of permit issuance, a ficw-measuring device shall be installed to give representative values of effluent volume at some point in the plant circuit, if not already a par: of :he wastewater plant.
The folicwing locatiens of ficw-measuring devices are required:
- 1. Facilities with detention times within the treatment' system of 24 hours or less: on. the influent or effluent line, or within the system.
2.- Facilities with detention times within the treatment system of 24 hours or more: en the effluent line. If permit:ee desires :o locate a flew-measuring device in a location other than in I or 2 above, then permittee shall submit a recuest to the Ol'/isien giving the specific location (by map). The request shall include a Justification that the location will give accurate measurements within ten (10) percent of the ac:ual flew being discharged. Ins:allacien shall be subjec: :o approval by the 0! vision prior to installation. At the request of the Regicnal Adminis:ra:ce of the Environmettal Protection Agency or the Direc:ce of the State Vater quality Control Divisien, the permittee must be able to shcw proof of the accuracy of any ficw-measuring device used in cbtaining data submitted in the monitoring report. The flow-measuring cevice must Indicate values within :en (10) percent of :he ac:ual flow being discharged frem the #acili ty. The limitations stated in PART I, Section A, are calculated en :he basis of gross measurements of each parameter in the designated discharge regardless of :he quantity and quality of these parameters in the plant flew unless otherwise specified.
- If the permi: tee desires to contidue to discharge, he shall re-apply at !aast one hundred-eighty (180) days before this permit expires.
Within sixty (60) days of :he issuance of :his permi:, the permi::es shall file a statement with the Environmental Protection Agency and the State Vater Quality Centrol Division which shall contain the names of the persen or'persens who are designated to recort conditions as noted in ? ART II, Sec-icn A, Paragrach 2a (Mcncemcliance Notificatien), and as noted in PART li, Section 3, Paragraph 7 (0!! and Hazardous Substance Liability). The permi::ee shall conti ually upda:e '
- his list as changes occur at the facility. ,
The permittes is required to submit an annual fee as se: for-n in Tec:icn 25-6-5C2 C.R. S. 1973 as amended. Failure to submit the recuired fee is a violatien of this cermit and will result in the susoensicn of said permi: and enforce.een: ac:Icn pursuant :o Tecticn 25-3-601 el. sec., 1973 as amended. l _ _ . St.}}