ML17266A192

LER 80-016/09T-0:on 800411,engineering Evaluation Determined That Application of Two Rosemount Model 1152 Pressure Transmitters Resulted in Reportable Situation.Caused by Design Problem.Transmitters to Be Replaced

ML17266A192
Person / Time
Site:	Saint Lucie
Issue date:	04/16/1980
From:	Schoppmann M FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
Shared Package
ML17208A502	List: ML17208A501 ML17266A192
References
LER-80-016-09T, LER-80-16-9T, NUDOCS 8004240375
Download: ML17266A192 (3)

Text

I I

. 0 NRC PCRM SSS U *NUCLKARRKQULATCAYCQhlMISSICN IT.Tll LICENSE=" EVENT RCTIagy CQNTACI SLCCISJ I I I I I QI (PL~K PRINT'CA TYI'%LLRKCVIRKQ INI'CRMATICNI I

~QI 4

Zl r.lS IUC%454% COOS S I ll0,I4 2

'i5 I-' I I LIC1iNSS NVMSIIR I I IS 0 25 LICSi45% TY7% J0 OLLA00 57 CA ~ $4 CQN'T

~Q SQUROS ~XQK 0 5 IO 0 OI3 3 I IOO I ,'K I I I Q9 7 40 . 47 CCCXST tiUMS SR 61 41 SVStIT OATS KVKNTCKSCAIPTICN ANC PRCBASLK CCNSKCUKNCKS QIO joo1J Durin refue in u on vendo no

~a 3 see determined that the a lication of two Rosemount Nod transmitters resulted. in a re ortable situation T,S.

5 situation could result in the o enin of the Containment Vacuum Relief Valves with an overpressure condition in containment. Assumin a failure of a check valve in each vacuum relief line containment isolation ca a- .

~04 7 4 9 bilit would. be af fected. This is the first event of this t e. ~ .

IO 5YSTS>

" 'O COOS CAUS% CAUS%

5V5CQOS CCMIrONSNT COOS

' CQMr. YALYS

~

CCQ% SVSCOOS SU%COOS SHI4

'7 I

9 I0 L'JS II LJS ~~"

I2 I2 ~ IS S LES LOO I9 10 SSQVSNTI AL QCCVRRStICS RSPORT RSVI5IQN Q~SNrY~

~s 8 "'-"-" Loo !U LJIIJJJI

<<R,RQ RSPORTNO. CQOS TYSS Na,

~ ~

I I 24 ld L~l 27 LQJ2J 25 JS K~I 20 LJ 31 Ll 12

=rrw.'ll AC4cN PUTURS TARSN AciTICV p' SNVTocwN

'STIIOQ 'OURS ATTACIIMSNT SU%MITT%a NANO&

PCRYI >ADJS.

A RIM%

SvtrLI CQMr. CQM7ONSNT MAN4PA~RSR ls CNS R Q22 L' sLJs L-"s L'-Is Loo LJS I 14 1l ~

. 40 41 42 44 47 CAUSK Q SCRIPTICN ANQ CQARKCiIVKACTIONS Q27 0 The transmitter de n o u t e norma under the normal range. of -5 to 0 inches of water. These transmitters actuate the vacuum relief valves at -2.25 inches of water. The licensee 7

1 OO LJS 4 4

1 9

PACIU. v.

STATUS ACTIVITY RSLSASSQ QSQ

~l'S~

will replace these transmitters with a different type before'start-up.

IO

~NT24r '

ar RSL445%

~ZQSs 1~SR 5i IC IS QT7ISR STATUS QSO

. AMQUNrQr iCTIYITVQSS NA 44 MSTIIOO Or QISCOVSRV L~JQS 45 44 Vendor Not'ification NA oldcavSRv OSSORIATIQN LOCATION ar RSLSASS QSK 2

20 7 3 9 10 II 44 4$

rSR SON N SL 47I ACSIJR% 5 vUMSSil TY,S 04~lrnCaQ~

LoOIo ooiiQv~zlloi NA 7 5 II IT IS ASRSCtINSL INJUN 41 Crq

~o""b O'" '

NA Lcs5 YSS ar cR OAMAOS 0%5CRI STION w rsc:UTY Q~

'0

~

~Z'42 NA 7 4 1

>VSLICrv

,55USQ 045cRlrr:cv Q NAC IJSK CNl,V KK mN'0 7 2 1 NA 4$ 49 I0'AME CP PRKPARKA Schoccman (305) 552-3802 S004S SQ 57~

REPORTABLE OCCURRENCE 33~-16 LIGENSEE EVENT REPORT PAGE TWO Additional Event Descri tion and Probable Conse uences On April ll, 1980, an engineering evaluation determined that the appli-cation of certain Rosemount Model 1152 pressure transmitters resulted in a reportable situation. It has been observed by the manufacturer, and reported to the licensee on March 15, 1980 that in a'imited number of transmitters an input pressure either over or under the normal operating range causes an output within the normal range of 4 to 20 milliamps. The transmitters affected are Rosemount Model 1152 pressure transmitters with output codes "A" or "D". The manufacturer observed that due to a unique condition in the transmitter electronics, an overrange condition exceeding 140% of the upper range limit can cause a discontinuity in the trans-mitter output, resulting in an output less than 20 millamps. Due to a different unique condition in the t'iansmitter electronics, an underrange condition exceeding 100% of the calibrated span can cause an output above 4 milliamps. The overrange discontinuity was observed in 5% of a limited sample, the underrange discontiniuty being observed in 55% of the sample.

The model transmitter in parallel with a second transmitter from a different manufacturer actuates Containment Vacuum Relief Valve FCV-25-7 on one vacuum relief line. An identical control arrangement exists for Containment Vacuum Relief Valve FCV-25-8 on a redundant vacuum. relief line.

These valves also perform

• containmere isolation function in the event of a LOCA. Each containment vacuum relief line contains a check valve to prevent flow out from the containment.

The range of the affected. t=ansmitters is -5" H20 to 0" H20 for a 4 to 20 milliamp output. With an overpressure condition exceeding 140% of the calibrated span, equivalent to a positive pressure of 2" H 0 in containment, the Rosemount transmitters could open valves FCV-25-7 and 3CV-25-8 even though the second transmitter functions properly. Assuming a failure of the check valve(s); containment isolation capability would be affected.

This model- transmitter is also used to monitor reactor coolant flow. Four transmitters monitor the differential pressure across the reactor coolant pumps and four transmitters monitor the differential pressure across the reactor core. These transmitters are "Indication Only" instruments and have no control, protective, or safety function.

Corporate Power Plant Engineering has directed that the containment vacuum I

relief transmitters be replaced with Class 1E, Seismic Category qualified Rosemount Model 1153 pressure transmitters. The St. Lucie Plant Maintenance Department coordinated by FP&L Power Resources Department will be responsible for the transmitter replacement. This action is scheduled to be completed prior to the start-up of the unit (approximately April 30, 1980) . St. Lucie Unit 1 has been engaged in refueling since March 15, 1980.

The Licensee has determined that its other licensed facilities are not affected by this situation, and its Engineering Department will ensure that the unit under construction, St.

C Lucie Unit 2, will also not be affected.