ML20245B477
Text
__- - . . - _ .
1
?
AUG 171964 , ;
e MEMORANDUM FOR: Connie Pappas, Freedom of Information and Privacy Act Officer Division of Rules and Records Office of Administration
[, '
! FROM: _ Polly Schofield, FOIA Coordinator h Office of Investigations SU8 JECT: FOIA-84-291 '
I
- Attached are documents from 01:RIV and OI:HQ which are relevant to the subject request. Inventories are attached to the respective cases indicating .
the exemptions under which certain material should be withheld.
3 Attachments:
As stated
, Distribution: -
01 s/f F01A-84-291 cy to case files:
Q4-84-002
- 4-84-003 NQ4-84-018
. Q4-84-019 4-84-026 ,
- - 4-83-005 04-83-005 Q4-83-007 Q4-83-008 Q4-83-013 Q4-84-014 "
Q4-83-024 A4-83-002 A4-83-003 A4-83-004 4-82-008 4-82-009 4-82-016 4-82-018 Q4-82-012, 04-82-Or5 .
Q4-82-030 01 c/f PS r/f
. DW/FOIA2/84-291 I
l
~
Office : 01 #r 01 .
Surname: PSchofiel d:sk Hayes .
- Date
- 8/16/84 8/16/84 gg62n p 87o6os Qh"fl$"Ofl(n p-po BROSIUS84-291 PDR -/9
! e*
.* h JO f ,
j WC-AP-077.1-1 Rev. 12-1-83 $
a tied.^. "'f! -
1 NONCONFORMANCE REPORT (NCR) h
- eacwEcrm4M cNuMeEx. enow aEc'o er courncx. uEr>.co a w Nea m eEn !.-
- i
' h/et ce r n ~x 7)s.e / 2/- W r> L -2 n ts' s. - Ind./s Wz Pu/
ee, war,CN er :.su ne trEu
. sour //. 7 '-l" Wr.sr zz' m Eu e ]l y l fw- zoto' BM 231 y, 1 wet.bs W/7+y, n.s eeninewNo occuutxTs -
u .e,s , CooE g' noN-CooEO }
t=AvELEns No. ,
C WP .507 R/sy .;xva,) M 06 BB/E Cc;'o&,/z3/d2 m..- -
DESCRIPT1oN Cr NCNCCNPCaMANCE l WFLhIMA WA.s Pc2FoZmC.b CW Wflb.S W17, W / 8,4r A J!/41//2 AMP /RA//
') TNMJ T//er ra~cMM/<qud' Pf2M'Trc~bs r ic M N/ d u f A 6 6*k Y> % 3'- /* ** 9 # +-
A M P.5 Wflbsv4 Af%foRNe-b A Y JCL AMPS wir// Mf' 20bL.
o Withidh
- JV) ACH/df' 3rr ofJ 85 AMf'.s , htsCov 'Ro~f a DkAlN4
,.t JH EC CdLt .$ U 5 Lrcr*st t ris./Cf. J $ 9 >T /a,10=8f x in we.m.py ..
y.
$N=h& (h V lfm %eAW W N$ 0 U
, in f . JyZZ h lif b +17n- F Zf PW [. f _ hh &( ).) 9.f f , ?
CM)GhNATOR ' TITLE oATE
- _ RECCMMENCEO C
- $PCSITICN & SAS$ FCR RECCMMENCMICN;
] ggwcgg see gaat a C*T i s a au-i n C*T a O E um as is ,
,y R ui-);, a m eer
/,
Er's mi '?.h .
EOR INFORNiATION Y., m W Ml g:
EI /*#" @
AUTPICRtIED f4VCLDA thSP y
b ONLY /
l .
~
s ,- y'
_CCN 3 MEN *C CCPM NCNCCP#CRMANCE : %.. .
j
+
NOLD TAG l4dls /AAlm AAEA %
?
PCTDff'AL. 5o.SS(E)/ RAT 2 Y .
^
.s .
mO NoGT i NYS bt)m , /> > ROE //adW l/doNdst4 /dd~
RCtr"E *J r:A ACTIOP
/-2Md (
& , fJd,g/ pg .g ,/ gy ,,...,,,
M. S Tf/cg/.4/'/O sire c.m. ri LE C4 E 5%TEMENT CF COMP' E*f 3 aCTICm v.pM -A.s*ss gg.A'f3 j = S'~-f$ ~A " .
/
Yf D$' /~E7-BJ hi dA ACTION COMPLii&D IIILi d4 DAit d6 2ACilGN
/7YVin 1FilD] " S h / u a c.
~
):25-6d' lk
< IIILE LAIL j OISTRIBUTION g)f.5'd. E 7ML ,
kjll0w'+/ c d r G s 7)st<*'E' 4 ,* * ! ,'
i rms.wca o+ M ca. n imes '
COMPUTER CCo!NG (DIC INTERNAL USE CNLY)
MAJCAT ACTYC00E NCNCODE OCC'JRRENC1 CATE Q4- 84 -01 tr EXHIBIT (2)
L Q4-tr4 - oiff S -Ia i t
. os .-
.,,,,,e r ~
' \ -
~.
Wev.1/21/02) i (dpassa .
'M* b '8 NONCONFORMANCE REPORT-(NCR) Nhh h 2 . .__ - . . , .
NCLF CRI2X - 7158 /- .1/- 7 # /.5 N /53 42.-PW RECOMMENDED Dl5P65)TIDN RND BASIS t~6% WECDMMENORT/DN RECOMMEND TD U5E RS 15.
THE INTEGRITY OF THE WELD 3HOULD NDTBE BUE5 T/DNRELE DUE TO AN AMPEERGE DVERRUN Bf15 ANP5 THIS BE/NG DUE T6 THE CALIERRTION DF THE WELDl/Kr MACHINE.WH/CN WRS BET C/Y '
SGI;MPS. SECHTEL TO EVRLURTE RWD DISPDS/T/DN.
l.
MECCM'MEDRTfDN SA&ED DN /T BE/NG R PKDCEDUEE V/DLAT/DNs NDT GN E55ENTIRL VRE/R8LE,
. 1
~
/d8
p,?D-f Q Q D \-A O s 4 M '
FOR. INFORMATION ONLY q ,
t l
l E r
l' !
l i .
1
,/k ,?.$,
m.m**,m
- ~e c)
.e -
e * -
.. ,i.
N v/ i i
e
(..
f
. ,'s .'
- =
WC-AP-077.1-3(Rev.1/[ D [
~ME%'S$!
NONCON#0RMANCE REPORT (NCR)
PR6KCT NAME / NUM8EM ACTION REQ'O BY CONTROL METH00 Q N NCR NUMBER Wolf Creek /7158 Tag #26944 X iSN15342PW OtSPOSITION: "
IMPACT STATEMENT INCLUDED OYES ONo O APPROVD AS RECOMMENDED e
10lSPOSITicN PEVISED AS FOLLCwSi
. I-I
.g e-See Attached Sheet. -
s,?
l t
! l i { ,
- i. ,
- i
.)
- DOCUMENTS TO BE REVtSED >
L; -
_ ,. I ii s
4 None ~ n
, [ i t
. <WITQ R IN p o p,y ,[>;_,,Q.\ i
\ ON!.y m=
-~ A l . - '
o i 3 g 5-
./ !
/
}
i '- #
t[/f 1 C.M. Herbst Asst.
Project Engineer p 2 3 1984 -
' N/A N/A N/A i
A/E APPROVAL TITLE CATE .
$NUPPS CR UTILITY APPROVAL TITLE
, CATE i
! I I
_0LSTRIBUTION:
I .
1
- i a-1N$ /- at ,
l l
2
e-( ( '
Attachment to Nonconformance Report ISN15342PW l
In response to Nonconformance Report 1SN15342PW , .
1 The engineering disposition is revised as follows: "Use as is" l l
Discussion: ASME Section IX lists an increase in amperage as a supplementary essential variable only if notch-toughness is required. ASME Section IX QW409.1 "A change in the type of cur-rent or polarity, or an increase in the amperage or voltage'.' '
Welds W17 and U18 are ASME Section IIIj {
t Subsection NF partial penetration welds. The welds join pieces {
24, 47, & 48 on Hanger 0-BB15-C006/231. All three pieces are !
SA240 TP304 (P-8) austenitic stainless steel which is exempted from impact testing (notch-coughness) by ASME Section III Para-graphs NX2311.
i ASME Section IX also lists as change in the range of amperage as
. a non-essential variable. QW 409.8 "A change in the type of current or polarity, or a change in the range of amperage or voltage. '%n-essential variables do not require WPS re-qualification.
Conclusion:
- 1) Weldments joined by W17 and W18 do not require.
notch-toughness.
- 2) WPS N-8-8-A-4 does not require requalification.
It should be noted that WPS N-8-8-A-4 is qualified for an overall range of 60-160 amps. So welding was not performed outside of the WPS overall para-meters.
- 3) The amperage (15 amps) in excess of that allowed for 3/32" diameter electrodes is not detrimental to the system integrity.
This NCR was dispositioned by W.B. Phillips, M&QS Site Engineer, Extension 1702.
m g
. p . . ~
- d C . ,' s gi &
.< - */ C3 : :C. ' .- , , gf>@ C.M. Herbst $g 2 3 9994
. c' EORI O - - -
" - =
^=st. Project ensineer Ofv r~e '- =: !
( **;Y.
. \ ^*
f- .
s, ./ / W-6'4
% /
d
4 -
+ .
o -
+ ., 1 TO: W. D. Johnson - ' '
i
.FROM: '
W. S. Schum
']
L
SUBJECT:
ALLEGATION - February 7,1984 - 11:50 a.m. k i !
' .j j
- allegation. ')came into the RRI's Office with the following I On January 28, 1984, a mechanical / welding QC inspector was verbally -
! harrassed.over the phone and approximately one hour later - directly g 1
in front of his supervisor (Rich Booth. Senior QC Supervisor)'for 1 writing an fiCR dealing with improper welding amperage by Mr. Murphy, Hanger Superintendent.
The inspector, Rick Dossett, and R. Booth-QC inspector made statements *
- to Dit concerning this harrassment. #
j However, no corrective action has occurred.. ;
1 .
j The individual hanger superintendent, f tr. Murphy is still onsite with !
no apparent consequences.
to repeated}is concerned that no action was taken and this will lead '
.; problems.
i .
I The alleger is:
k 7C.
6 -
/ '
(khN)
L' S'.
Scht/m, RR1, Wolf Creek
's
/ ,
../. ';
- y. - -- -- .
g4-84-on8 Q 4 O D ~0 EXHIBIT (3) s . . . . . . . . ..
__.._______.______-.____.___._____.---_.--J
t .h I W artu w ns r li.1 'I t e n . i.: i i r ? hih. > j 1
lbl *:s s s s. ' ha,fo r?t % .'I'
- d 'I..' D n .o - .
k s, .. ,., .. .. o . c : . < - .
H Robert V. Eye,.Esq. APR 3 0 'l'<
Irigonegaray, Eye L Florez-1535 SW 29th Streete Topeka, Kansas.66611-1901 Re: QbE_yMEC,: Civi1:ActiontNo. 86-3976' TFH!and NAN v. NRC, Civil : Action iNo. 86+3201'TFH1 I
Dear Mr.. Eyes .
In laccordance with the orderi signed by Judge Hogan on March 23, 1987, the NRC has2 completed the processing.of all;of the-documents subject to your client's Freedom of Information Act requests which.were-previously withheld on the basis of Exemption 7(A). .
Enclosed are the inon-exempt portions of nine. OI case files.
Certain .information has been. withheld on the basis of Exemptions 5, 7(C) and 7 (D) , 5 U.S.C. 552 (b);(5) , . (7) (C) and !(7) (D) . Thece provisions: portain to certain inter-agency. memoranda subject to the deliberative process privilege, and to records orcinformation created for law enforcement purposes the release of which could reasonably.be expected to constitute an unwarranted invasion of persona 1' privacy or to disclose the identities of confidential -
sources and/or information provided by such sources. Additional J information. concerning the claimed withholdings will , : of course, be furnished in our Vaunhn affidavit which is to be filed with y our dispositive motion by May 31,' 1987.
]
1 i
)
Sincerely, 1
. q Amy Ed Krupsky l
Counseli for: Defendant l
Enclosures-1 l
._______________________________________a
y- . . . _ _ . _ . . . ._
t/ sits ) .
,.' E.e n -
Tk, AcAu ubniC '
J.rh % 4 Ka.m 60::, t ch&%
e ub wsM :M- h h11. b i tlu, d rs gw s.
.wd : N U
') .
t knc. Lad townx0 - h.E Fe s T E R . ;
- j (h) c.6 I - 49 is .
cn o, M, h Ed - wbn cahnaM
/ -
(zu) a61- 6s si .
h idamd M Ao toInj M jd LMpuJ.(
fin. K E S S L E ft d )
VP, X'G 4 E ,
a.lu dx,] 40 ufa.,s N.hau
%J rreo 1Lo I y. 0 a t.
ih j k6
~ .e w a d te o'L % u.n. 'O u.sU) he ab uA wA r PhiA thu). va.n .L e hJ ]ichw
- k. G , e m .
k L . +
ce n%S.L) . A eoasas A.u, Ln wvn) i < c. 5 g W wi ; k Lu:,
l Ls m M J % ~ .
t u-:.as a &k rp b LG&E, _b A tao ' O f.i.Lf A.u.A e__
m .a Ak pn a a ~4 cx m) tub %.
urud (-rkn.cwh Y s s s. u. e k r.cnukul % i; w 1 M M n:.ku.o vALL wu psa, k AJ :
wik. m bh M 412 A DA h J 4- Fo s r Ek. . Tk uM Anu, < t&Lu, L3 m na.
\
l
$ Q4Ef-08 [az) ;
04-74-6185 -x l, L I
l January 25, 1984 An event that happened January 20, 1984: ,
While conversing with Jim Murphy at the superintendent's trailer, Rich Booth approached Jim concerning a conversation Jim had with one of Booth's inspectors on the telephone.
Jim spoke with Booth about an NCR written for a welder welding with too many amps with tong tester. The amps were more than the setting on the welding grid. Jim told Rich about the surge in amps on the grids depending on how many welders are welding at once. Jim told Rich he needed tong testers in order to check fer amp !
s urge . Rich told Jim if he wanted tong testers to get your own. Jim told Rich that the inspector, should consider the surge when in his judgement of the violation. Jim told Rich that inspectors that hunt things to write up that will be closed in process because it isn't a code violation,is a hinderance, slowing down the completion of the schedule.
Rich told Jim if he had any problems with his people to see Rich. Rich told Jim if he wanted anyone' sass, to get his ass. Jim said he would talk with whoever was responsible for getting this procedure changed and solve this NCR problem. Rich-told Jim that this is a procedure violation and he would continue to write up this .,
violation until procedure is changed.
The above conversation went fast. I didn't hear Jim Murphy threaten anyone.
Michael Hubler, G.F.
bU l
I s
l l
I t
- 1 Q4-84-Ol8 cp4 - 194 - c>i gs 7
g . - .
@2 7t_..
r ,.
CONVERSA1:0N RECORD I. . WPE Routing n
- TELEPHONE O VISIT . ~ O CONFERENCE NAME/SyM80L__ JNT
.h " .
gg.
O. INCOMING ==
Location of Visit / Conference: '
.g ' O OUTGOING
~-
- Y,; . NAME OF PERSON (5) CONTACTED OR IN CONTACT l ORGANIZATION (ONice, sept tivreau. TELEPHONE N7 ,
, WITH YOU ets,) ;
f .
.,'*'#- i i
- SUBJECT +
, . . s.
SUMMARY
5 i
. l
, *,o
., 1.' . i 4
L .
r s
i .
1 l
i l
~
,~ .
ACTION REQUIRED
\!
i NAME OF PERSON DCCUMENTING CONVERSAff 0N i siCNATURE CATC l1% } l l . .
. ACTION TAKEN l
L'
, l l t '
SiCNATURE , TITLE ' DATE s a- u
., l l .
l e-r.
'7; 5o271-101 ez: tu: e . ns.us m? > CONVERSATION RECORD @[!'0,NA}
, y gR ,2 Ig jg.,7 )
i Q4 Ot fr 5' 1
-8
t
~~.-- *
%~.- a D'
, j i 5*
1 Yr . '
- p. .... . . TECl11 I
. f!* S.r.x..~.a:.t.:.~.n
).. .
FOR NUCLEAR POWER PL1NTS 7.tti
- r. s.u.i ca FOR WOLF CRECK suctT uvuuCn ncvi:,oy ,yyg;,
T .
oCt::s: SMAW 0
,, * - - - - - - - - - - - - - II* O*. 8.* A-4. . 3
$tainle5$ Steel ' ',""* - - ,
DAra Plate with Baching. Strap
%;,,,, , N'tiTDEsicN: , MATERIAL: * *
- 0' .
PAGE.
1 op_
2 l
II TOCCDURE QUAllFICATION TE:lT NO. (POT): PQT 94
- TNICKNC35: PIPE DIAMETCR: ,
05tT80N! .
^
&,
- All 0.188" 1.5" Over 24"'00 and Greater
- urn uA x: _.
- v, . ,
--- serem:::
g) , .
LAYER NUMCER t
WILDING PROCESS SMAW l
,, . ~
i gg{
, [.'+ .
'TUNCSTEN SIZE NA
- INSERT TYPE AND SIZE
- s i See Table i ELECTRODEAv!RE TYPE of pro:edure
~'
ELECTP.ODEAvlRE S!ZE 1/8" 5/32" -
WELDING AMPERAGs90-120 110-160
.(% ; z;
' ( jwELDING VOLTAGE 20-27 CU8 RENT TYPE AND POLARITY DCRP TOR H GAS TYPE AND FLOW g (CFHI BACKING GAS TYPE AND FLOW fM j
,- tCPut PREHEAT & litTERPASS 50F Hin.-350F Max. -
t, TEMPERATUAE itA
' TRAVEL SPEED (tPM) .
bC'. WIRE SPEED UPM) M i 4
'. A/ -
Uphill for WELD PRCGRt!SSION Vertical Welding .
b POS-' WELD HEAT TRGATMENT .
None .
- p. .
\s '
Ar -s t ov At.s DANICL INTEf tNATIONAL WCLOING CNGINCCM QAfg ,
, )DANICL DUILDIN ,
q J CllCFNylLLE,S,c,
,g/j -**
W4. WLauni. I LcinwLo'e v
. [*'"[ , f.'[// 8/
OATL s
'l " q. ,k , . t
- l' .
. . . 7l11k 5.1 Q 4-8$-01 E i Q4 - 8'4 - ot 85
~ll
[ -
i sevmou uvunun om: .,
-I
[V gg;--
H- B- B- A-4 0 8/11/01 .
PAC E-2 CF -
2 i
)
ae : 6. * .
(
~
I
. . l e .
~:. '
~ /0".r2 4' _ ng,y 1TPI C d . l Y TTPE D .
' ,. o ( I
~ .so~:2 tr
- e f.Gn .ua (A
- L4 g 575
- zif f, ,
\
'h*2 ;
l
'\ ,/
- ' Y a ct,r acio" {
- l. M .u LL h
-- g cr si
\
e
.. L sqt .
. m..
Q ,
<t- or <9 -m h c
- o.oro o.oe.s .
%ca. For nrminal wall thicknesses
- p% above 3/4* in: -
For nominti wall thicknesses .
f a) /Jis! B31.1 non critical systems above 3/B" in:
a) ASME Section III-C1 css 1,2,3 ..
c .W- +
b) AMEI E31.1 critical syste-*
M.Wc' Joint dd-
~
v .
s
?'~., n0WT: For joint design *in ' '
r
- s.
Tne above joint designs e-e based on Bechtel Specificat' ion MSS.
P systems of different criticality and wall thickness see Appendix 1 of the w'elding '
preced.:re.
- 2. Hisalignment prior to welding shall not exceed the following limitations: .
- , f S a 1/16* for pipe f abric
- ted to ktS! B31.1. '
' b .2/IE*..misma:ch of inside ditmescrs..f.cr., pipe fabr.icated +a .ASME.. Sect.ict !II 4--
F' c j/32* unifcrm mismr.tch in ws11 thickness.when..:he . pipes..are.roncentric for . pipe ~ '
I fabricated to ASFE-Section III.
. d) 3/32%c.ise.atch.cf-inside diameter::at~cny-one point when-*.he pipes are met concentric '"-
' for pipe fabrict ed to /.5MI Section I!!. -
y 3. Held reinforcement.of ASMI .5ection III single welded pipe butt jcints shall not exceed .,
the vt.iues tacled below. .
~~
- tAtInutt RllluCMir.ilG
'- .; MiiRIN. ItGCud.55
- OUT5fDE SURFAtE INSIDE SUEFA !
f . ~ 3/32* e 3/32- _,j va to lis" lnci.
I 1/2" 3/32-
' /. ' . .
Cee- 1/E" ce 3/16" in:1. ^
5/32* 1/8"
~ Ove- 3!iP to 1/2" ine 4. 3/16"
~
o/32' eve- 1/2" to 1" Ner 1 te 2 snc).
nca 1/4* 5/32- aQ be
> kcctTcncavi:y for singic weices pipe oute .)eints snai s not recuce Inc weio enterness
/~N to a value below the thinner of the bcse e.cterials being joined. Abrupt density changes Sec
- 4 or clong:ted indicatier.s at the rect es shown by Radiogrpahy are not acceptable.
(d 4. .
N3 5321 of ASME Section III subsection B.
Wold reinferccment cf NISI E31.1 s' ingle wc1ded pipe butt joints shall not' exceed the values tcbied below (applicabic to the outside surface only). ,
nu core wice. css .. nu rinaamnan von utsm TE+inemi ** !i
> / Mtf 3 bO- M O- i .c .MD*
/,_h I
} /. l G" 3/32" l' 3/66" 6 i
Un to liv incl. 3/16" I
( k 03r I /P' I 13 6' f j/c" t y - 3 / I,6," . n c l .
Over a/.6" - f/2" in:). t } / [4- 5/3g- j 3/16' .
h 3732" 3 /1~f - 1 J/iu" ,/
Wer 1/ 2" - 1" incl.
6ver 1~~ . 2 snel.
t 1/tt- W- l n/4- y 8
f or.bo"0er cuernal piping the column titled VS :.ncll be applico.
~
)
,3 S. Weld undercut shall not exceed 1/32" and shall not encroach on the rc:;uire.# scetion ,
e
.' [ m i thicLne;,s . , -
.V .
w ep. .WD88--
d'
- .-..- - _ . . . . _ , . _ , _ , 'raz;----' ga~; ---- -~ ~ , ,, ;. ', ; ;
.')
i '.
'hy
', / . .
k h/l D Ah /bo A* // ,
W 8
+ & de- Dei pc' ,
j A p>-C A n -j A 9 ,
3 mn-21 y /. ..
[ G. #. @
- t, .
1, b
e i
,i j >
Q4- 1r f -O I &
Q4- 8(- of F5
- Ib N .. - - _ _ _ _ _ _ - . - - _ _ . - _ - _ . _ _ _ . - _ - _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ - _ .- ~-
)
I FO! A44-291
.; INVENTORY OF DOCUMENTS '
]N WOLF CREEK NUCLEAR GENERAi!NG STATION 01 REPORT NO. 04 .'.4-018
[
WITHHOLD]NG E3EMrTIOr. No.
- 1. Undated Invest,igative Status Report (1 page) 7A a
- 2. Allegation Data Fom (1 page) Release
- 3. 2/7/84 Allegation Memo (1 page) 6, 7C, 7A
- 4. Undated Statement from an indivi4ual. 7A (2 pages) l S. 1/25/84 Deposition from an individual 7A (2 pages) -
- 6. Record of Event (1 page) 7A 4
- 7. 4/11/84 Report of Inquiry (1 page) 7A
- 8. 3/14/84 Hemo Regarding Welding Procedures (1 page) 7A
/ .
! 9. Undated Procedure Qualification Test (2 pages) 74 l
- 10. Nonconformance Report (4 pages) 7A 11 2/7/84 Allegation Meno (1 page) 7A. 7C, 6
- 12. 2/15/85 Memo Herr to Gilbert (1 page) 7A
- 13. 2/1 5/85 Supplemental Report of Inquiry (1 page) 7A 14 entated Investigator's Note (1 page) 7A 15, 3/19/84 Memo Driskill to File (1 page) 7A )
- 16. 6/1/E4' Meme Hayes to File (2 pages) 7A w/ attachmen't 1
~
,1
.l
)
,j
)
. Q4 0%
i qd- g4 - ot rS .
- IS L
+
U.S. NUCLE AR Rf GULATORY COMY!!UO8 N2" F0aY 3%
64:
INVESTIG ATL'" f "i ATL t I . .~. O r.D .
so.5f AUCTICA3 ; Tas a s
- 2. Functional Area (s) Involved: ,
scheca eooroonsie nos w a - operations onsite health and safefy N, construction offsite health and safety
,, safeguards emergency preparedness
_ other (seeo4fyl e .
3.
Description:
I st LI M 51 8l FT if t/l 2l1 l I l+I l l l I I l l l 1 I l l
- l l l l l l l l l l l l } l l l l l l l l l l l l l
'! II II II II I I I III I I II I I I I I l l 1 II IIIIII Il l l 1IIIII II IIIIlI
- 4. Source of Allegation:
ich eneroonow nomi d contractor employee security guard
_ licensee employee news media NRC employee ,
private citizen j _ organization tspecityl
.q ,
other (seestfy)
MM 00 YY
, 5. Date Allegation Received:
DI 3 ol? 8lf
- 6. Name of Individuai (mret wo indomas and tai nemen W. 4 F/65 T Receiving Allegation:
l, l' 7. Office: gg 4 l ACTION OFFICE
- 8. Action Office
Contact:
tmret wo in cas ena int neme: M'N N N
- 9. FTS Telephone Nummer:
l7jylg .,[ g 7 y g ic, E Open, if followup actions are pending or in progress Closed, if followup actions are completed MM DD YY
- 11. Date Closed:
l l l T2. Remarks: lgjyjg gjyj ,jglflpg l l l j l l ,l { j j jl l l [ j Nmit to 50 charseters) l l 1 l l l 1 l l l l l l l l l l ! l Orfles Year NumDer i 13. Ailegation Number: g ,
gl yl7 Q 4 0 4 T Q4 - g4- our s
7 -.
, ATTENTION: Ed L.avlin -
i .' ;
At approximately 4:20 P.M. my inspector, Rich Dossett, called me and informed me.that some Superintendent named Murphy had called him ,
talked to him about an NCR he had written. Mr. Dossett was upset due to the fact that Mr. Murphy had cursed and used rough language.
After hangi,q up the phone, I went to talk to Mr. Murphy about the incident. When I arrived, Mike Hubler (PFGF), was also present.
Mr. Murphy stated that inspectors should not write up something like that and he would get Mr. Dossett's " ass", whatever it took.
I promptly replied that Mr. Dossett was acting under procedural requirement and my direction, so if there was any " ass" to get it -
was mine. He then stated that inspectors like him (Rich) should not be working as they did not know what they were doing.
' I then told him that I disagreed with his statements and that Mr.
Dossett nor any other inspector worked for him and that if he has any future concerns about them, not to talk to them but to go through me. He then stated that there are too many inspectors in the field anyway so they need to run half of them off. Other statements he made includes g 1) "You need to tell the inspectors to be less restrictive and 2) quit shutting down craft on procedure violations."
"Who the hell hung the hold tag on the polar crane? They don't shut us down for that, it's ridiculous. (G. Payne, Receiving Quality, attached the reference. tag.)
Perry Latham (PFGF) arrived about ha1fway through the above con-versation. Mr. Murphy also stated that "we will get him (Dossett) run off no matter who or how many people we need to see.
Rich Booth MQS RB/pb 1
) -
n+ -g4- car q + oirs
-li
i ATTENTION: Ed Shevlin on 1-19-84, I wrote'an NCR (1SN'15342.- PW) to document a welding procedure violation. On 1-20-84, at approximately 3:50 p.m., a man ralled by tele Jim Murphy, Pipe Hanger Superi' phone and ntendent, andidentified wanted tohimself as the know what fuck I was doing Writting an-NCR and stopping craft from working. He said we should never stop working from shit like this. This better not happen again and if it ever does, to call him or come and see hin and he will take care of it. He wanted to know what I was doing going around and writting shit like this up. He said that I did not know my job, I do not know my procedures andd I was not doing my job, that there was no reason to write this up. 'He wanted to know if Rich Booth was my Supervisor and that he will talk to Rich.
After we hung up the phone, after approximately 20 minutes, I called Rich Booth to see if Mr. Murphy has talked to him. Rich-said no and I then began to tell Rich what Mr. Murphy said to me.
Rich then said that he would talk to Mr. Murphy. I then pro-ceeded to Rich's office. When I walked in the trailer, I saw Rich and went over to him. Rich was already talking to Mr. Murphy when I arrived. While I was standing there with Rich Booth,
",, Mr. Murphy and Mike Hubler, a Pipe Fitter General Foreman, Mr.
Murphy said that this should never have been written up. There was no reason'to write this up. This was only a procedural vio-lation and it should not have been written and he will get this changed in the procedures. There is no need for it to.be in j there. He already knows what the dispositio'n will be, that we should be less restrictive when we do these things. ,
Rich and I then went to our Senior Quality Supervisor.
Rich Dossett
, , _ Quality Inspector ,
PD/pb 54 I
i A
(pf-860/t
-- Q4 - 8+- 0/8S 4
L
-