ML20211K559

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Package of Four Undated Memos Forwarding Part 21 & Deficiency Repts from Utils.Followup of Generic Aspects of Problem Requested.W/O Repts.Supporting Documentation Encl
ML20211K559
Person / Time
Site: Mcguire, Catawba, McGuire, 05000000, Hartsville, Phipps Bend
Issue date: 12/03/1986
From: Robert Lewis
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
To:
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
Shared Package
ML20011C460 List:
References
FOIA-86-656, REF-PT21-86 NUDOCS 8612110419
Download: ML20211K559 (15)
v • d • e


Text

.

d

%,o j

UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION o

i

,a REGION 11

~*

o 101 MARIETTA ST N.W.. SUITE 3100 j/

ATLANTA. GEORGIA 30303 MEMORANDUM FOR: Chief, Vendor Inspection Branch, Region IV FROM:

R. C. Lewis, Director, Division of Project and Resident Programs

SUBJECT:

CONSTRUCTION DEFICIENCY REPORT - CONFIRMATION OF TELECON (AITS NO. F02700316 )

Enclosed is a 10/CFR 50.55(e)/10 CFR 21 report received from Mississippi This appears to be a generic problem. Would you please Pnwar A l_ight. Co.

followup on the generic aspects of the problem with the AE/ Vendor? Should you have additional questions, we will be glad to discuss them with you.

E c.

R. C. Lewis

Enclosure:

As stated cc:

J. Olshinski, RII Director, DPRP, RI Director, DPRP, RIII Director DRRP&EI, RV B. Heishman IE 61203 g121hh PDB P

15s6-CONTAC1:

Ross Butcher (242-5584 )

i

a e.

' l" E December 16, 1982......._

iff I'

  • * ~ ' *.. ~:-

?E6lisut.n pr.i}On e

Hartsville 1, 2, 3, 4 Licensee Potential 50.55e.

Transamerica Delaval issued Followuo per DHS:

50-518 bere-12/15 a letter stating there was a possibility of 9

MC 2515 50![t-diesel generator failure due to piston skirt Region IV Notified Phipps Bend I & 2 cracking due to improper heat treatment. The

((()r;r$g7 DttS: 50-553 licensee is investigating.

HRC was notified by 50-554 Transamerical Delaval letter dated October 28, 1982 to the Director, Offit; of I&E.

_. m --. _: - --

m

/p u r,,'q,

')

a UNITED ST ATES 8'

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION o

D

.I REGION 11 T

6 101 MARIETTA ST., N W. 5UITE 3100

,/

t s.

Afl. ANT A.GEOmH A 30303 g

MEMORANDUM FOR: Chief, Vendor Inspection Branch, Region IV FR0'4:

R. C. Lewis, Director, Division of Project and Resident Programs

SUBJECT:

C0flSTRUCTION DEFICIENCY REPORT - CONFIRMATION OF TELEC0fl (AITS N0. F02700315 )

Enclosed is a 10/CFR 50.55(c)/10 CFR 21 report received from Minissippi..

Power A_ Light Ca.__..

This appears to be a generic problem. Would you plean follosup on the generic aspects of the problem with the AE/ Vendor? Should you have additional questions, we will be glad to discuss them with you.

T c.

R. C. Lewis fncicsure:

As stated

\\

J. Olshinski, Rll Director, OPRP, R1 Director, DPRP, P.ll!

Director, DRRPAEI. RV

6. Heishman. IE h

e. ass e-a.

Ar

-r'$

/

/

r :s - 1,4i ty f f i :..

i

.;6 f; ; i LAiE December 16, 1982-----___.____-..

/AC!! ! TY r!07jyj eA,ijp;

;j **__0P. J. djjl_I

.REGIOni1 Ar.T1%

Hartsville 1, 2. O, 4 Licensee Potential 50.55e. Transamerica Delaval issued Followup per DNS: 50-51 teurr 12/15 a letter stating there was a possibility of MC 2515 e

50-diesel generator failure due to piston skirt Region IV Notified Phipps Bend 1 & 2 cracking due to improper heat treatment. The h7 g DNS: 50-553 licensee is investigating.

NRC was notified by 50-554 Transamerical Delaval letter dated October 28 1982 to the Director, Office of.&E.

I Y

l d#

kn j

o UNITED STATES l'

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION n

e REGION 11

[

101 MARIETTA ST., N.W., SulTE 3100 o

'g g

ATLANTA, GEORGIA 30303 MEMORANDUM FOR: Chief Vendor Inspection Branch, Region IV FROM:

R. C. Lewis, Director, Division of Project and Resident Programs

SUBJECT:

CONSTRUCTION DEFICIENCY REPORT - CONFIRMATION OF TELECON (AITS NO. F02700318 )

Enclosed is a 10/CFR 50.55(e)/10 CFR 21 report received from Duke Power This appears to be a generic problem. Would you please 1

_comnany followup on the generic aspects of the problem with the AE/ Vendor? Should you have additional questions, we will be glad to discuss them with you.

T c.

R. C. Lewis

Enclosure:

as stated cc:

J. 01shinski, RII Director DPRP, RI Director, DPRP, RIII Director, DRRP&EP, RV B. Heishman, IE CONTACT: Al Ianatonis (242-5563 )

4 r-

, - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - -,

c

{'7 * &

f*

19 no-N'r 20, Ing?

.n !; !: :

.t -

. i'.s. -

la.T_!O*i r tawba 1, 2 Licensee CDR - i;naccept 3! le D.G. ri st on 5'< irts - Dola.al Followup per tic 2512 a

E !.". -

50-413 12/20 Part ?! t: port o' ! 0/ P' /:.

Upon insrectir,c rf 50-414 the Cat re.5a Dies' ! fe cerr tr r.i nan t, tno litenr.re REGIO 1 IV fiOTIFIED

.[ /

fo.md Distc" si iets haline t:

.r<.

brat nu,ber f..t c 6:a rre.,r.,2.

s i<fer.li fi. ' in tho P t c'

? ?

. net.

T! r affected u

a D ste.,' ; -t castings ho /r-t h+: :,o!.ential of early i

r,Af r : go. 3f; y r

50- 3'70 faticut cracting fran cyclic loads due to residual stress build-up tnat resulted from cooling during the casting operation.

For corrective action, the licensee plans to iraplement vendor's recort:nendation pendir.g completion of the ir.vestigation. ficGuire units are nat affecteil bccause they have different a

diesel cenerators. 'dritten recort due 1/19/83.

h i

s I

i 0

I

. [ T 7r * ' i.

._".; q -

n'*

-Tnice e !. 7.. i. t rat: r (Ori< + ol '

Di ' f i !.-

t.-i c :.r.ter

-}ric-i

';.ign Cbjef.

I;ronch Chief _

'r.

i r,

f

.~.

l sw <.u

./p

  • y o

UNITED STATES 8

7, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

{

- I REGION 11 o,

[

101 MARIETTA ST N.W..SulTE 3100 9

  • %.v y'

ATLANTA, GEORGI A 30303 MEf40RANDUM FOR: Chief. Vendor Inspection Branch, Region IV FROM:

R. C. Lewis, Director, Division of Project and Resident Programs

SUBJECT:

CONSTRUCTION DEFICIENCY REPORT - CONFIRMATION OF TELECON (AITS NO.F02700319 )

Enclosed is a 10/CFR 50.55(e)/10 CFR 21 report received from Duke Power __

Qoam any.

This appears to be a generic problem. Would you please follov.up on the generic aspects of the problem with the AE/ Vendor? Should you have additional questions, we will be glad to discuss them with you.

T c.

R. C. Lewis l

Enclosure:

as stated c.c :

J. Olshinski, RIl Dircctor, DDRP, RI Director, DPRP, Rlll Director, DRRP&EP, RV B. Heishman, IE i

I l

CONTACT:

a ino. w T242-~5563 I

.=

E? P i

1v

.tS rr RO,,1,[g2 t

i

^

... ! ;.,..., b.

3: ;.;

h.v. a

.., y..

g g Catauba 1. 2 Licensee CDit - Unacceptable D.L. iiston Skirts - Delaui Followup per MC 2512 I.if. -

50-413 12/20 Part 21 hport of 10/25/ K.

Upcn inspection of

~ 50-414 the Catawba Diesel Qenerstor Pi; tons tne licensee i:i.LIO:i IV riOTIFIED found pistcn skirts havir.e ti:e Ain. heat nas ber

.[

/*f c 6m*r<* k 2 as identified in the Part 1 re;. set.

I!.; affected LA/S * ^50-367 pister. skirt castings have the ;><Aential of early 50 3 7p fatigue cracking froia cyclic locds due i.c residual stress build-up that resulted from cooling during the casting operation.

For corrective action, the '

licensee plans to iraplement vendor's recon.~endation pending completion of the investigation. McGuire units are not affected occause they nave different diesel generators. Written report due 1/19/83.

i I

I

)

I

)

I W _'.y,.v._;.,.

.:.b *.1-1 enic9a l i.:.. ;ir.) - Irater (Oriqi.ial )

. r ~y' '

  • y

'~

pg rije

~*

t je,,,.,gp

.!riri n n ;-.-..-.

- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - - -

c.;,.93 cnjef. --_- --

Branch Cr,ief

-Q ' 4

e. 'e.-i 5

)

t MAC 70.as1W A 000KET sec. W Om WesSE Re.cm7 se00uLE =Usetts

  1. pq 7,

.?i9t 217 i J f 6 in WP ^

!i' Essa "8**"'

no.

eso INSPECTOR'S REPORT 9 9 9 0 o f 3 4 f L o i

a

  • * " ' * * " ' ' * " " o* Toa.jf m M

(Continuation) e

  • c Office of Inspection and Enforcement Q [
  • 0[

C

, g....

-.. ~

..e L

Codunu. 4 Cn dee.. v.c Am):

a 4, to e ra vs.,I r

~ J '

W I 4 I g ns a a. m e sr A n A I

I

-fi, O

l

/

l

% +'. s. ] _.j seJ:.8 +, dale) FeLa un a y a r, n tt,. f if. q s I:ty -

a,, -., a nn -, i, a s s,n.,, c.,,,,,,,,, c....n u s,.;,,, c ~;.n 4 ea 0, u )

.i t.,,-..er. i n -: :--,.,. a 13 4dn ee

/.

Ae:n al:Id 4 c. ny y u ; K 4 /< syt. a - J t

anuae eveny ye nni y

[

0[

ee'njw3 /

b e

e entme % / A%

RFwetw sh e n t% 4 e %

i (VQ Ps) yn.jnan.

7$:s war Pn. g n e. e.,L uy.

ev: Je,se ) b n Ve s L o qs /;ly y

L 0 hji f t ie Fe knva ny a s 19 7 '. A n wy J. ale) wk e'L M

tth Rn i

v 9 y -,, n,e:..; 2, m - n o., a,-,,,, y n u. 4.n-is e..np ele J b de vesd n a, J d.. e.s n.1 a n - n a d<insL:Id 1

l y

y Q } f l t Le LA $0 nl e n R t s/09G lh fthth A

e.h 0

C$h M

-ne NO O d O.

a b

U,4. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS$10N D//

.O macemas A.

-,,, r

.ont woov a tuossa

- y#

  • MI4171!16tR UI "

88 0.

SEC.

  • *em wasvym sk, W

s INSPECTOR'S REPORT 9

9 9 e a 3 3 4 I 1 o e

a e

vc.

(Continuation)

,c Office of Inspection and Enforcement

]

[eo[

c

,9 g

.~ _

L Candmenu le Cn' den!n U of Aonta d*v 8 M f o cfR Pant 70 An 1

v "

1 II E

8 e.

I

~

E; w!

t, n. p,t s. n.7 4 n, e. n l L,t:< a :>l V i o 7

e.

Yget ( w(t t 4 2 dNL 0

liIO J 18 0* 4 8'

7"7 I

i 1

f 11.

SS. '

R e Q lt (AI D ! $.

O% $

b Jk fE W

@M L'

bY L hL f

17.

l O N l't A $

f Oh t t k

i j

1e 30.

A t

L l

}

f U

E

A Jt QR t R, F mir L n

34 3

l as 37 ft 71 30 31 2

T*a l

n

_4l s,

3 U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

1409906 s

$7' T #4 M ">E""

=%ES':Efit INSPECTOR'S REPORT 9 9 9 oa J 3 re PL 4

/

a

  • '*" "a *" o'v.poa,,%

I (Continuation)

NC e

e e

ac Office of Inspection and Enforcement T [*oZ

-,7,

~

.m.

.. i a

w W g u h.

k:A) 8 t /0dFK ra xs' a= x

~

v en' g

penTTtMWT D

4t T w -d. M-4 k A ndeH Q%.s;ier/,>J anew & fAa Ain c.,(

~

W 07- %fo k a-4 A 9

M ///8sy A,7, /p,*/

e 7'o i. -ni A w %w l

8 Ph M J p 12e

&Y "7-W!/. &

b-naus O tat p-A%

Od=x duedd a -t4

.g/rn A du A 4 oj)' h.

The

.J W&

~

Wti 7m q a x + w.v>u n.u.

U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

i subc p @ A 00c.ts? No onucemet asw mu scumet4 j

a AftfdO[8 m,. erP

' '(J'em.

0 8 ***

d o:

2 INSPECTOR'S REPORT Y V Y D 6 3 I &

9 f,.o i 4

  • noa ave'"v oa oevy==.55,,

(Continuation) e Ac,,

,c

{

eo[

Office of inepection and Enforcement C

y. _ _.. _.

D00h-a WEu k en t> A 11 n.

tu._-

K 8 ft /Oc'FK forb a'

//

f6 Pau.

1, 3, / o p. s E m '; g de 4-t -rt, 4:n i n rL p~s.x W 2

t m

sbr < 74 p,A M

S.AuJ rAar py p - 6 co a= s w, cb w A q

~~

D h

n1-L, -L\\ m & h cw esAA f

& a M W L N.ob q p

A now ~%y vi-oi, s-a 1 G Mi? # N~ ^;$ % y

%1 uw w eu u gw kg A w%: :

y s' 99-ySr&

pad a No z vn-es9

- 3 o 2 r. 2il d d &

1 tw & Q S i Y

(A y wAw L)

}

l.A D

.a y Lua a a w w

'.J J L

a dL y% wq %

A%,%

~.

2. ck ( A 2~4 easL f 1

)

l alAC po.as 15 A gg7 g g.

iOA mesSE REPOnt WODULE NUMMA g.,

'dN'osa feo tev (13etyees M[i M M Nib @*'

^

eso.

800.

INSPECTOR'S REPORT

'TFF o o 3 3 4

  1. 2. o I

^

'*"'ea a*" oa o*T** 32,3 5

(Continuation)

NC.

ac a

Office of Inspection and Enforcement C

@ Z i' C yr 0,, 0.

tio,..,

.. ~.

j odon/

@MnlGu.L W V s1 lhis L__; 8 45 /6l'M P&d3D n

z 0

ff r

M Wo /00~ A ~3N b( '*

1_Qs

& i. l, 9 ctM u."04 /YMafk Q k a a&

w wp-

&0 A)>Ws w CL.- t' W eAN~ % Yh j

PI-0I

(,081

&N M MbMMh i.

b W dre ASt,

mo f,I A tx th a/ _ e.- J G

G _;

yw g

p m_

-2

, m, ~

=

j',

.3l31l'

~)O/P w.L f. A &

l M

w un:o s y

+ 9 e nm a

trA)

Tm e

~2 G

/fPZ-MW b-

/

c' n

did j

eu w 4 l-

c. Th M

M %9 4

hx f

Y un ~r wn i &

I unc Fo.m

' u.s.nucuAR REGUWORY COMMISSION PnimoEmsPECTom(Name mer ear.eenhasenrwi INSPECTOR'S REPORT l'

,w,,

Office of Inspection and Enforcement l **"' ""! "! f, u), Cn go A) l l

w.s w h>e l

"5*' *5c D^ l

'"^"5^*'*"

I l

l l

coCxtT =o. s.a = oa vCENst uCENsttivENoon v,

No.tev PaocuCTH13 w l

no.

sga uo vn l

ipa u r Amm ae*a, h@ ba u A b-l@l919 fold T TMI I I I l llII7J d f

' ~"""

I

's u o.

" - "oo*"

l~l~l'l i II I II I I I II II I

o - ontTE l l l l l l l l 1l l l l j l l l C

l A - REPLACg o

l mSPECTioN PEAFMMao er ORGANA 2ArloN Coot of REGlohiMo CONouCT-Pguoc oF sevisTIGATioNim5PECTioN l es f t - AEGloNALoPFICE STAM oTHER l

l FROM l

To a

n D%cN AAAnce.

l Mo.loav ! Yn. l Mo.

DAY vm. l l 2 - RES4oENT usSPtCToA 01111ln11cdi 29 212U ' - "" a"^"c' ^""^*^' "^"

l 4

8 C.

REGONAL ACTION q

TvPt of ACTivifv CDNouCTio tCheca ene nos onm ICheca one nom W l

02 - SAFETY Os - MGMT. Vist?

10 PLANT $EC.

14 - mQuinv 1 - NAC Fo#M Set 03 - WClotNT 07 - SPECIAL 11 - mytNT.VER.

15 - myESTIGAT1oN 2 - REGCNAL oFFICI LiiTEm Da - ENFoACEMENT

,08-vtNoon 12 - SMePMENT,EXPon?

~

OB - MGMT. AvoIT Os - MAT. ACCT.

13-adpom?

ENFonCEMENT CONFERENCg aEPoni N a

oF YOLATioNS ANo NELo mFopMATroN l Al elC ol otVIATCN5 NRC Fo8M Set mEPonTSENT l 1 l l 1 - CLEAR MO MC 0 A/hN%

onnEG TohaFOR LETTEn tssuto ACTCN g g ltl l l 3 - orviAfioN ardd/C M l A e

C o

Ale C ol lAlelClDl l Mo j DAv l vn l Mo j oav l vm l 1 l l * - VOLA'C"' DI*'ON l

,[.

l l i - vts l l l l l i _ vis f(M 151M l 1 i i i l' OE ]

Mooutt Rio. Followup l Q

Mooutt NuMcEn msr.

l N MoouLE NuMeta msP Og g MooutE P4 Followup 3y MMg !!

3o 3o lI

=

=

ii !!

=

si !!

s j e 9

9 iis s

=

=

l =i13 E !

E!$5! !!E s i 15 EE l ! !$ ! I lE S hi!!EI !!! !

E 15 E

e t 7 %g pl 7, g,7 f

f.

g lg ls g

l ll l

g g g g i g ll l

A g

l l8 l,,l e

I

, g g,

t t t i t

lt l

t I t t I

I I I I I I I

t l

ll t l t #

l U

D 1 !

I t t

t t t t t

e i 1 $i )gO gh 8 h l,g l*a l,,l lg l

^

g g g

lt l

8 I t i i t

I t I I t t t

i ll l

C t I t t t

t i i #

I t t

l I,t il I,,

1 o

o e

[ l ig )dMj h glh l

i!t

!t l

^

e I

I t I t I t

t i t

I t t

ll 1

f l I f I lt l l t I e i I

l, l

C t t t i t

l l

0 1 e i f i

1 t t i t i i

t t l.

liiI liill It l.

,liiI

^

i i

i i

, t t

i i

i lt l

!I l

t t I t t

t i t t i i

I lt t i I I t

t t t t i i t

t

  1. CIRCLE SEcuf%Cf is t

l D

C cctatioN ea oscarios g i i g l l l g

[

)

h T#2lEE"'

M$ggMk:

INSPECTOR'S REPORT 99 i o a 1 3 O

  • 'e. ave =r,o.a,gre erre

~

P 2 c 1

,l, s/g, $c (Continuation) e Office of Inspection and Enforcement c

.o[

g yg,._.

z._..-._.._,

whm A emn~~ v w A.ee=AL a ts

-Ice fs Auken n2 fa3 5 L_ l,.

n r

g-h t

l L91 *C -

.a.

i c..,. i 4

2

f M'? ?.L q Se=k er cA.K/

+ w i., w i n s4 9 m ashr., epa.4 % +

was k

^

N M Q k;;td &

u chek pp*a y 3

dm n K.

l :

  1. 4 ad,~e ik pnd &'

aa J w a M

&lu,:.af a,/ w

&y M

M#

7 M#~#W' 3

N l

n 1

s.

E 31 32 31 D

N 4

I s.

U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION l

- -

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20211K559&oldid=4006686"