ML20127N759

Transcript of Commission 850620 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote in Washington,Dc Concerning Denial of 2.206 Petition for Midland plant,SECY-85-60 Concerning Pressurized Thermal Shock Rule & Shoreham Order.Pp 1-4

ML20127N759
Person / Time
Site:	Midland, 05000000, Shoreham
Issue date:	06/20/1985
From:	NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
To:
References
REF-10CFR9.7, REF-GTECI-A-49, REF-GTECI-RV, TASK-A-49, TASK-OR NUDOCS 8507020113
Download: ML20127N759 (8)

Text

_

ORIGINAL ~

l UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

(~

In the matter of:

COMMISSION MEETING Affirmation / Discussion and Vote (Public Meeting)

Docket No.

(\

Location: Washington, D.C.

Date: Thursday, June 20, 1985 Pages: 1-4 0507020113 10CFR 850620 PDR PDR PT9.7 ANN RILEY & ASSOCIATES Court Reporters 1625 I St., N.W.

(

Suite 921 Washington, D.C. 20006 (202) 293-3950 l{k').(

1 D I SC LA I M ER 2

3 4

5 6 This is an unofficial transcript of a meeting of the 7 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission held on Thursday, e June 20, 1985 in the Commission's office at 1717 H Street, 9 N.W., Washington, D.C. The meeting was open to public 10 attendance and observation. This transcript has not been 11 reusewed, corrected, or edited, and it may contain 12 inaccuracies.

13 The transcript is intended solely for general 14 informational purposes. As provided by 10 CFR 9.103, it is 15 not part of the formal or informal record of decision of the 16 matters ~ discussed. Expressions of opinion in this transcript 17 do not necessarily reflect final determination or belief,s. No 18 pleading or other paper may be filed with the Commission in 19 any proceeding as the result of or addressed to any statement 20 or argument contained herein, except as the Commission may 21 authorire.

22 -

23 24 25

• . 4 1

t

• UNITED-STATES 2 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3

4 COMMISSION MEETING - - PUBLIC MEETING 5 .

6 AFFIRMATION / DISCUSSION AND VOTE 7

8 Room 1130 9 1717 H Street, N.W.

10 Washington, D.C.

11 Thursday, June 20, 1985 12 13 The Commission met at 2:28 p.m., pursuant to notice, 14 in open session.

15 NRC COMMISSIONERS PRESENT:

2 16 Nunzio Palladino, Chairman 17 James Asselstine, Commissioner 18 Frederick Bernthal, Commissioner 19 Lando Zech, Commissioner 20 Thomas Roberts, Commissioner 21 NRC STAFF SEATED AT TABLE:

22 S. Chilk, SECY 23 J. Malsch, OGC 24 25

r

'4 **

1 p ROCEED 1 N GS 2 CHAIRMAN PALLADIND: This is an 3 affirmation / discussion session. We have two items listed on 4 the agenda. I am going to ask the Secretary to lead us 5 through those two items.

6 in addition, we have another item that we'd like to 7 put on with short notice, and after we have discussed the 8 first two items, I will have the Secretary lead us through 9 that item.

10 MR. CHILK: The first item, Mr. Chairman, is SECY 11 85-169. It's the Director's Denial of 2.206 petition in the 12 matter of Consumers power. In this paper the Commission was 13 asked to approve an order which affirmed the decision of the 14 Director of ISE who denied a 2.206 petition by Billie Garde 15 related to the construction of the Midland Nuclear power 16 plant.

~

17 All Commissioners have approved the order. Would 18 you please affirm your orders.

19 CChorus of ayes.]

20 MR. CHILK: The second item is 85-60, entitled Final 21 pressurized Thermal Shock Rule. The Commission here is being 22 asked to approve a final rule on pressurized thermal shock.

23 Again, all Commissioners have approved the rule.

24 Commissioner Asselstine has provided additional views to be 25 published with the rederal Register notice. Commissioner

3 1 Roberts has proposed a modification which was not agreed to.

l 2 Would you please affirm your votes?

3 COMMISSIONER ASSELSTINE: There is one item on that 4 one -- I am not asking that we hold up this rule, but I note 5 that Mr. Udall has sent us a letter that bears on this issue, 6 asking us to set up an advisory group on it to look at one 7 aspect of the issue. I think wa ought to act on that fairly O soon, if we can, because it's at least related to the rule, 9 although I am not asking that we hold up the rule at this 10 point.

11 MR. CHILK: We will take that matter and handle it 12 accordingly.

13 Will the Commission please affirm its votes, all 14 agreeing to the proposal?

15 CChorus of ayes.]

16 MR. CHILK: The third itom is an order on Shoreham, 17 and before we can take the matter up, the Commission will have 18 to vote to handle it on short notice.

19 CChorus of ayes.3 20 MR. CHILK: The order the Commission is being asked 21 to approve here is identical to the order that was recently 22 approved, with one exception, and that is the order on pages 6 23 and 7, containing now the views of the majority addressing 24 Commissioner Asselstine's disapproval of the matter, and the 25 order also contains a deletion of several words as suggested

O 1 by Commissioner Zech on page 7.

2 It is my understanding that all of you have approved 3 -- agreed with this order as it is now presented, and I would 4 ask you to affirm your votes.

2 5 CHAIRMAN pALLADINO: Before we affirm the vote, in 6 affirming this vote, this is not to be precedent-setting, 7 inasmuch as it's not clear whether or not we are required to 8 do it, and to be on the safe side i suggest we reaffirm it and 9 ask as a separate matter that 03C give us a definitive paper 10 on whether this kind of thing needs to be reaffirmed in the 11 future.

12 Were there other comments? All right, are you ready 1,3 for us to affirm our vote?

14 MR. CHILK: Yes. If you are ready to affirm your 15 votes, four of you in favor of it, Commissioner Asslestine 16 disapproving. Would you affirm your votes?

17 CChorus of ayes.]

18 CHAIRMAN pALLADINO: All right. Anything more to 19 come before us?

20 MR. CHILK: I have nothing further.

21 CHAIRMAN pALLADINO: All right. We will stand 22 adjourned on this meeting.

23 [Whereupon, at 2:31 p.m., the affirmation meeting 24 was adjourned.3 25

1 CERTIFICATE OF OFFICIAL REACRTER 2

3 4

5 This is to certify that the attached proceedings 6 before the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission in the 7 matter of- Commission Meeting (Public Meeting) s 9 Name of Proceeding: Affir' nation / Discussion and Vote 10 11 Docket No.

12 Piace: Washington, D. C.

13 Cate: Thursday, June 20, 1985 14 15 were held as herein appea*s and that this is the original 16 transcript thereof for t h4e file of the United States Nuclear 17 Regulatory Commission.

13 (Signatura) , p,g (Typed Na;ne of Reporter) And Riley 20 21 22 23 Ann Riley & Associates. Ltd.

24

.25

G C i G G khki 5, hhhhkG hkkkg0g hghghghg(qhqhqhq(khph g(gl)g

~

12/82 TIW O TITAL TO: Document Control Desk, 016 Phillips

ADVANCED COPY TO

/ / ,

@e Public Document Ibczn e

DATE: _ 2 Y/7d cc: OPS File

! C&R (Natalie)

Attached are copies of a Cbmnission meeting transcript (s) and related meeting g doctznent(s) . W ey are being forwarded for entry on the Daily Accession List j and placment in the Public Document Ibom. No other distribution is requested 5 or required. Existing DCS identification numbers are listed on the individual documents wherever known, f

Meeting

Title:

h6 A //' b D d

///

3 h Meeting Date: 4 /Es /f d' Open X Closed 5 DCS Copies

~

(1 of each checked) 3 Item

Description:

Copies .

3 Advanced Original May Duplicate

~, ib PDR

• Document be Dup

• Copy *

1. TRANSCRIP" l 1 When checked, DCS should send a

• g' copy of this transcript to the

• LPDR for:

• 3 *

2. u_ma 2 *

/

l5

[

• I i

• t i

3. *

. l ll

• gj

• 4.

1 e

$e I

• b b

I

• h' (PDR is advanced one copy of each document, *

• Verify if in DCS, and h two of each SII'Y paper.)

• Change to "PDR Available."

) .

e g

$ $ $$ $ h$$ $ $ $ $$ _$ $ $