ML20115A153
| ML20115A153 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Indian Point  |
| Issue date: | 12/07/1970 |
| From: | Mccool W US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML093631134 | List:
|
| References | |
| SECY-99, SECY-R-99, NUDOCS 9210140119 | |
| Download: ML20115A153 (1) | |
Text
- _ _ _ _ _
Iecember 7,193 f
i SECY-R 99;
(
i p
@kQ l
w b:
CONSOLIDATED EDISON _ COMPANY OF NEW YORK, INC.
g t5.
(INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENT. HATING UNIT NO. 2)
,g DOCKET NO. 50-247
{N g 3.'
Note by-the Secretary e.
M 11.' Attached'.forf.thef.'information' of the1C mmission are copies oL f
he following:
Q Q J { [1t
~: ~.
. j?,..Df;.$?L S(!$6
".-i
$.y 5.. PETITION OF STATE OF NEW YORK FOR INTERVENTION (
9 973$
- h.,., ',
Attorney General. Lefkowitz);
...s
/
0I ww (:
b ~ APPLICANT'S ANSWER TO PETITION FOR LEAVE TO IPT CITIZENS COMMITTEE FOR THE PROTECTION OF THE ENVIRO
[k
c APPLICANT'S ANSWER ~TO' PETITION FOR LEAVE TO INTERVE t-n ENVIRONMENTAL. DEFENSE' FUND, INC.J
'd:
-t
- d. Iatter requesting, permission to-intervene from'D. J. Pirc
(( ~
Eudson~ River 'Firshermen8 r Association;*" $&!.h E
- 6. Teletype and LETITION FOR LEAVE TO-INTERVENE BY THE STATE u&,' ~W NEW. YORK.
M.
of Commerc(from?J. Bruhe Mcdonald, 'New : York State Departmt
[4.: 4 d);$yi "T:
.'f. Atomic Safety an$'i'n.iU' f
' ' rr. A.+J z..
d-Licensing Board's letter to five persori f?n
.?
9 whose request' h, '8 s to..lntervene did not constitute petit.Lons
_ prescribed: by - Section'.2,.714; and
_1/. w-'-
Fi Jr _;f
'g. Atotic Safety ' arid ' Licensing Board's ORDER PERMITTING l
j
,A
-1 INTERVENTION by' Environmental Defense ' Fund, Inc., Citicer-p Committee for the ' Protection of the Environment, State ofi i
New York by the Attorney General, and Atomic Energy Counc:
of the State of New' York.
'2. Related documents in this matter have been issued as SECY-R nd SECY-R 95.
a W. B. McCool Secretary of the commicsio:
NO. 0F DISTRIBUTION N.
t COPIES DISTRIBUTION Secretary C;
27 Congr.' Relations t
General Manager 2
Environmental Affairs Deputy Gen. Mgr.
1 Inspection Director of Regulation 3
haterials Licensing Deputy Dir. of Regulation 1
Operational Safety-asst.01r.of Reg.for Admn.
1 Public Information "ech,Adv.to the Dir.of Reg.
1 Rad. Protection Standards sst.Dir.of Reg.for Reactors 1
Reactor Dev. & Tech.
-n Asst. Sen. Mgr.
1 Exec. Asst, to GM Reactor Licensing 1
Reactor Standards Spec. Asst, to GM 1
General Counsel State & Lic. Relations 6
New York Operations Comp 11ance-6 Chairman, AS&LBP i
I 9210140119 920520 PDR ORG NRCHIST PDR
-l
t 5-UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION In the Matter of
)
)
CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF
)
Docket No. 50- 247 NEW YORK,.TNC.
)
)
(Indian Point Nuclear Generating
)
Unit No. 2)
)
PETITION OF STATE OF NEW YORK FOR INTERVENTION Petitioner, the State of New York, pursuant to Section 274 of the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, and in accordance with the Atomic E >ergy Commission's l
notice of hearing dated November 13, 1970,- requests that it be permitted to intervene and become a party to the above entitled proceeding.
In support of this request, petitioner states as follows:
1.
The name and address of the petitioner _is:
STATE OF NEW YORK 80 Centre Street New York, New York 10013 (21 I f()/
[() Y E er
9 e <
I 2.
The State of New York is a body corporate and a sovereign entity and brings this petition on behalf of itself and as parens patri_ae, ttustee, guardia.. and representative, on behalf of all citizens and residents in the State of New York, to protect and preserve its environ-ment and its economic and natural "r. sources.
3.
As trustee and guardian of the interests of the people of New York, the State cf New York is uniquely responsible for -protecting the health, safety and we.lfare of its citizens and the quality of its environment.- This responsibility requires the State of New York to consider with utmost seriousness the questions that have been raised-concerning the operation of the applicant's Indian Point II nuclear power facility, and actively participate in the examination and resolution of these questions.
4.
This proccading was initiated by the Consolidated i
Edison C0mpany of New York, Inc. (Con Edison), which is before the Atomic Energy-Commission seeking approval of-an apolj cation for an operating license which would authorize the operation of the applicant's Indian Point II-nuclear power facility in the Town of Buchanan in Westchester County, State of New York.
I a
~
.l t
+,
l' 5.
This application has raised a number of
-issues of vital concern to the people of the-State of
~'
It has been alleged by-opponents of the application that the operation of the Indian Point II facility will adversely affect.the environment and
{
people of the State of New York.
More specifically, it i..
has been alleged that the operation of this plant will result in harm to the natural resources _of_the Hudson River through thermal and chemical water pollution and through obstruction of the natural, unimpeded flow of l
said river, i
4 6.
The National Env1.snmental Policy Act of 4
1969 requires consideration of environmental natters l
by federal agencies in their planning-and decision making.
It is therefore appropriate for the State: of' New' York to i
l-intervene herein so that it will be 'able to__ fully : participate in decision making which may have an effect upon its 4
environment.
l 7.
The name and address of the person on whom service may be made and to whom it is_ requested that I
)
\\
communications in respect to this Petition and proceeding
~
be addressed is:
4 l i
..a=
=
a
- pa u
-y.+a y; s en,o s.
.t uma>a.=
n
.a
, sa
.ur
.se-s mm...
.a w
,.ru,-
.e s - wa --
n
,s..e v,
Y I
f -',
..-L j
i Louis J.--Lefkowitz Attorney: General of the State of~New-York ~
l 80 Centre Street -
l' l
-WHEREFORE, the State of New-York respectfully prays leave to-intervene in-this proceeding and'be treated 4
4 f
as a party thereto.
i i
l Dated: - New York, New York j..
November 25,. 1970
?
- Respectfully submitted, LOUIS-.J.-LEFKOWITZ Attorney General of the State-of New York 80 Centra Street New: York, New~ York' - 10013
- (212) 488-7560 n
.m.g.a
. -..... -....---. ~..- __-- - _.,.. ~ _.-,,....__..... _ -
' )
4 1
BEFORE THE UNITED STATES ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION l
In the Matter of
)
)
Consolidated Edison Company of )
Docket No. 50-247 New York, Inc.
)
(Indian. Point Unit No. 2 )
)
APPLICANT'S ANSWER TO PETITION FOR LEAVE TO INTERVENE OF THE CITIZENS COMMITTEE FOR THE PROTECTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT By its Petition for Leave to Intervene filed with the Commission oa November 25, 1970 the Citizens 4
Committee for the Protection of the Environment (" Citizens Committee") seeks to intervene in the above-captioned proceeding to " challenge-the iscuance of an operating license to the Applicant."
Applicant does not oppose the admicsion of the Citizens Committee as a party to this proceeding.
As to all contentions, and especially as to that portion of the third contention involving population concentration and plant location, Applicant points out 4
4
./
C
- :a) s
t t
j that thn subjects of the Citizens Committee's concerns were evaluated by the Commission before issuing a construction permit for this plant.
Applicant denies the first,- second and fif th contentions of the Citizens Committee.
As to the fourth contention, Applicant asserts that the_ systems "for warning the general populace, etc." are such that there is reasonable assurance that the activities to be authorized by the operating license can be conducted without endangering the health and safety of the public.
As to the third contention, Applicant denies that the operation of the plant will be an experiment except to the extent that it is involved in the conduet of research and development leading to a demonstration of the practir.al value - of the reactor type within _the meaning of Section 104 (b) of the Atomic Energy Act of 1954.
as amended.
As to the adequacy of testing and study of the plant design and operation, Applicant asserts that all safety hazards associated with design basis accidents and other major accidents have been eliminated to the extent P
. - = - -
p.
,.i.
i j i-i-
f -.
. 2 l
necessary to provide reasonablefassurance that-the:
e activities to be authorized by the' operating license can-
}
be conducted without endangering'.the health and-safety It of.the public.
~
u
,1
!i-!
The sixth' contention;is more properly characterized I
i
~
~
as an observation than a contention.
Applicant' urges-that p.
!--J
'these contentions be clarified at the earliest ;possible-.
[-
,d a t e. -
i
-RespectfUllyrsubmitted, j:.
LeBOEUF, LAMB, LEIBY & MacRAE l
Attorneys for' Applicant a
' )-
- p
[D. - gl i.
-j L
t-f7 By f ^
// '%
4 Arvin E. ;Upton [-
j-
- Partner, l~
Dated: - November-27, 1970
(-p f
d i(
/
i' 1
n p
we s
My-v-
-sr y y eJ-fe e,'.y ea-ge,+w yF
,%-.-y-
-+p,----
yyw, t s-e, -t g-w w w- -q
. eve, aw+wynya e r ' w gep g,yw p-gy qr-gg,,,s=y-
--q1 nid4w 39g-Sg
-'y wr g ay-vy eg w e
e
(
" a c
ev
.c,, *,
. v.\\
.... +.,
..,p...
3..
... s.. '.. w
. s -.h.; i L v.~. '.. O.*.A V. 4 t
...,6
...... v.
u.*
e w.
)
a s.
w'..
<....w...s a
.n, w w..., e G.,,. S y v:
- I s v, ).. w.
,\\ v,
,,,,,,.g,,
.m m
e.;
=.
t
.s.-..
.p.
.,u
.w.
f n
.) g s
-. =.
, 3a.. w-Le....
.\\ v e
/
/
w ee.
4 4
1
% 3 3 *-.%....=
3....
. *s r, %
D ' ' r."i
- m.AU.','
r
.. w a..N.
.)
'....t=
.s
. U L
.A ed,s
- ..d,.,.,
,.,O
....y,.
..s A 4..y.-..., vs A :. t.,
s.' c.a,
1 m.
.. v....... m
..~
a-
.C
-..v..s.~C,..,.,
.Jca nSc ;,so. C,.
C.
(.....,. n -..
w...
w c..
.e c
...v uwa..:O
. h.
~,O c..L,. V G - C c h., ; w. C.
.J O C c...~.o...,
~..
~ -,
..c
..... as n
w..
.e
/w.4...
-O.
_v 1
w d.3
.O
.r
. w V C.r.w a
s
-. 3c s
4-c O.,.Cer o C
..A'c 3
v.
.w..
w
.c
~.:
e.
.s......ww v.
w.
C.O C.'" %'**'*.v*
.'.#." c'."..e w*
- " O ' k., 6
.-. j;J A'.' w"..' ".. *.
.;4
%w.
- w. t.
.e.
- m..u s
..C ca. s,.,..,,.,.
.s., e a.e.
e
-w s.e.
r
.C f
.Gw.4,, -.
s.
C:
., a.,-
vi c 3
. c.
aq
.~..J;;;O" COnOCrnGd With the environ.T,cnt a n d r e.o r c s c,,; i,,.
v.
Q. c, ;,.. 9.. w.. w. e..., C,.
- _ e
~..w-
.c s.
.e....r a r:....,:..,
..e
- 2...
- C.
%..a%. e..
. ~.
-, +...
C C.c,.,.O w.. ;.
.,,.a us.
.a a
.w w
.c r,.w
........ v
.w s,, w.....
pm
-.1C-1
~,.
...s.. L. O e.
wv ep.s.
se.,
u w.
C
.r.
. ~...
ww L., M,,..
.w-
./ i.._
s,.,..
w...
.w u.
.C
'" O. #.^. C
.'. y,D.I.4 w.^. ~..
'.~. u~ V C.**. '.*. C.' c' s s', c'.pp I.# '%'.~. ~.
~ **
S
.# * -s e c' i
w i
J f
[
u L
\\
/
J g
j,
.... n a es - s a
,Da- *5.' 'g'
.%...'i '
.'.' o c w w w"
..s..
.u
.C.4
-y
.s.
.w s.
- .....,e. v v,,..,, 4 e c*. b s.i ow.
4 i
....w w w
.c U.. ' o n.=
. a-i S ed
'Og"
- c..'.n
' #...e
,~e,...' C..
... -,..,...v..
-%.e ins.cem.cy c: + %.. c..... :..e.
n
.v.
e..
. c
--.en
,o s.
c w
s m
- .mf.c..;t.. ; ion of th National Environmentcl Policy Act of l
.,65 '"N;?A") cs-it relates to this proceeding, and the irek cf con.s'.i::.nce of the A.c.olicant 's environmental re. tort with I
the C a..: csio.. 's.cro.".:osed c uidelines for implementation of CC'A pub'.ished for comment en June 3, 1~970 (35 Fed. Reg. 8594).
C.c res of the con cntions allege various procedural c'cficicncies which follow frcm the above.
Applicant denies cach of CDF's first six contentions.
Applicant's position
.: th-: therc ~ :.s no noncompliance of the kind underlying c-venth ccatontion. and that therefore the hearing _ can-i.c.c e 11dly pro :ced and a valid.licenso' may bc issuod.
i:DP cugges ts that the ~ Commission has not - corr.ulied s
a with the requirements of NEPA unless the hearing in this i
I precec:.:.ng :.ncludes consideration of all environmental
- .c:crs ine,uding non-rac,:..ological ones such as thermal s -
<D n. w.O..
D*
4 i
i 4
i S
~
c f
S v-
- w r
-re,r<..mt e
,w-e. v-4
.ns>.'
m<-
M
+v
- snm, 4
p-w--
g-w'~-r
~~
,l.
s
" 9.
4 A.
)
Prior to the enactment-of NzpA it w;c ve;1 j
. ;_b1;.it. 5 tht: non-radiological-environmental factors worc
....,...;..,2......--_...m.a..e, w-.w, 4.,. s.4 o, In e,
.u v
2.
_4..4 y
w....
4 J
_ _;.c.uir.g proccad.ings.
State of New HaSoshira v.
'. comic F.crev
- --.; = ic., 40 6.'. 2 d 17 0 (1st Cir. 1969).
Enen NEPA became 4
1: w of.
Lnt;ry 1., 1970 a re-evaluation of the Commission 's
- 1c win't. respect to these othcr environmental fac crs.bscame nacassary.
20th in the April 2, 1970 uidelines and in the J
une 1, 197G proposcd guidelin.es the Commission has taken
- c.fferont approach to implementing NEPA on an intetim basis H
- c._n th:2 succes:cd by 2DF.
While not permitting. independent t
ccccrmint ;ons in a licensing proceeding on non-rac..lologicat 4
j.
- .:. ::c rs, the guidelines require, among other things, a likense ccndi.;cn which will be contained in.the Unit No.'2 license) s no bc imposed requiring compliance with applicable' state and
^
F6icre.1 environr.cntal standards and requirements.
It is E
Appliccat's'pcsition that these guidelines represent an 2
ndoquato interim implc*.cntation of NEPA penciing Commission 4
5 rr.lc making determination on tne complex matter of permanen:
impic.nsn:ttion of NEPA.
i u
__..,.,-r,,
.. ~ -
4 4e-1 r
,~ ColloW4 Ol.a t th e r.'.
E nO reason ;L ::.-/CtiOO i
a
-e IT. au l u
'C.*.C.;CL.*ing for the-reasons giycn by ;jf',
v i
r 0L i lilial,';'uO!.;; ion *,thiCh Can 'J ~.: A rgO *:.. O.*. i
/
.~.
t Coring ~.hc Course of the proceeding V/nich has ru. " ; ' pOO.
a.. c. va-.cly co=caccc unocr present commisci,n ruloc.
4
-!f LD-' prove ils on the legal question c'; ring the appropriata steps can be taken at that time l
- a s! ;*.r,
--..c....,
... ions or
.ne near:.ng (wit.t. an c= enc =en:
..-. ma 4
2 to chs Xotice of Harring, if ~ necer.;sary) to permit all parties
.2
. m. respect to non-radiological
-- w.
1y. wi.
oc.varon.c.catcl considerations..
4 i
Respectfully submitted, Le50EUT, LAME, LEI 3Y & MacRAE l
Attorneys for Ac.olicant 4
3 i
By A"._~
MV me Arvin E. Uunon.
- Partner J. :er' :
NoverJoer 27, 1970 s
h i
I
)
4 I
E i
t
.,w
,m.,<,...--,e-.y.,
--s-
,e--...-
, wa r tev e, r
- - e t ve * + v fd
- f-++t--T--**'y*we>-
t'ere
- s R
- ~'%D ETIL 5
': :GV2?. ?iC-:2?3.M5 ASCCC7L?.i*'C': *t'* 'u*"i !=': i~f'. !--
J.j '.
1 L
u_f p y'
Eox 71; f
]'
' Wy.,d e;n,.f.. =,,d.
e
//h, Ossininn. New York 105G2
. m,n m.us~. p o
w-Qa.v.nuc o.., u..u n.y o
,,;a _ t g c y, t, e c J
.u u u..co.
w g
Q ch 1si Estbl. SW45
($,f {
N C% c Y 35g $t Nov3 01970 m 5 9-tin : o e.: s::-c7 3
mu rc.-::::ns
$2, 480 Tuckahoc Road (9-B) g@
Yonkers, New York 10710 b
CD ts Hovember 24, 1970 Samuel U. Jensch-g yg, "M.@J *Q Chief Eccring Examinor g
MC.N U.S. Atonic Energy Commission,
Washington, D.C.
20545 1970 G V by 9 A
10
Dear Sir:
OTF EWm. Kt 0"-
Ep The Hudson River Fishcrnon's Association hereby pohg.-q. Tuns..
for leave to intervene in the proceeding at 10 a n., Dec.
17, 1970 at reekskill on Consolidated Edison Co.:s applic-ntion to " build" a second nuclear power generator at Indian Point in Buchanan.
The story announcing the _ hearing appeared in our 1cen1 newspapers on Friday, Novenber 20, listing a filing deadline seven days later. In a matter of such import,ue would have greatly appreciated a bit more notice.
Top A.E.C. officials have had letters printed recently in metropolitan area newspapers telling of your agencie's great interest in protecting the environment. We would like to detail for you hou Con Ed has slaughterod our Hudson P.iver fish with Indian Point No. -1, so nuch so that How York State has sued the company for fivo million dollars. Clearly, con Edison is not conplying uith "other applicable laws and res-ulations ".
4 To clear your agency,. Con Edison must give assurances that thay u113 pt oloct tho ouvivonmant. 'L%y hnvo accomplinhed
,Jun L Lho opposito, so no doubt timt "Lho pl:uit uill bo op-crated in'confornity with the application, filed, the law and the A.E.C. regulations". In its recent suit, Heu York State thoroughly agrood uith us in these matters.
Uc conside' r thernal pollution from Indian Point Two (& 3) i the nost serious problem for the future of our Hudson River fisheries. Uc hope you uill allow us" to be heard.
l Very truly yours, C.~h vm.d.:-.um/L -
7[v[ j Doninick J. Pirone, l
/
Consulting Biologist, ER?A.
M*
f 1
e s
s.
.y j
,3
/\\. G'ra.,
f,*4 g-
^
\\,t
/*N
- y s
M j
%,1 s
r.
)-
s.h.
s
.I i
- 3,.j7. Qs.,,s,'
('- '\\ *.
(
s.:,' ? I '/: ')
s,.
q m m,-,.3 h) i.
l l
,8 i
e
+
' i
'. 1 e
f 3
, i.) % ;.'s a 'q,.,)
.i <.
h.%/
j
'_" L '.
.'d
{
r j
t t n* *#..-~...
~N
=
m.Mr,s N
..(
-1 y
................,...w
.c a e.. e a. v e <
...,.......,u.....
$q-i ; "*-* i
's s.- - v.(.- *
.o
.. = > a. i., s i. *
~.
N..s,,
\\*
-)
-., u
/
i
.*:;.s, % ) # 'N'.t
(
/
1 y
1 M. i.
Q. -.
- .s,,
/n}
.->I.~v
/
./
J
. - #~'%
<."\\
o.
l I,.
,. '...y:_
n, y s.
i f
4 4
3
+
2.r
,t.
s
, 3 s i
1
/
,l
- a; 4
I g
j
/I
' N,,,./' (Gf#,.-3._,
l, i fg,,,
2 t
N 4
\\
1-8 *
.e
{'
}
~
-- i,...
--l sa - -
s~
f f,
k-}
l f...
.I
- l l
I
't i
f.g
--s
.r.
a.- O3l N., i ;/' }
! n x
"~1 j : -
.f4
- \\
I.. i 1
i
/...
l'
- g.
+
i l k.,. Y '.._I_ _',_! _i A.
. e N
I
.j
\\
g
..s pr
\\
\\_
__i_. I._
4 I
-.s _
1
^*
e r - -esa 1 i
, "1
"'1
- 1
- r.
7-y 9 i
r
/. i- (~-.,,r W~.,."n 1,
t i
k / P y,* -"A e.s,.., & 7 Te-..5
.r..
As....: / v.
s r
%,,y u
. /v-e*
.3
- r.-.I s
,7 g.-
y.
\\
F
- j *j l
[
,s 'N*r's "8.-
- -" s,s
, C,.~-
- I3 n.
g a.:L. c.i. n )m
" a.u.
.:.J v
.aJ Li --.
i l }-
i i i
ac f.
g w.
u
.a.
3-
~
--e C:esed Fer nche:b rvr' %"e.
-The p!cnt tne uOty car ~urt
t.c.unw:.:n Richard L 0:t.l.
h,.: q Og,.. G - 3.l:{.y{!.4, forms of mar.ine !!!e and to represe:.tstive said,.hu cec.-
ina:r. who has repesed!v cri':.!
h.
. y e
ggg.f.u ch;ht weeks "ict n-ciY:4 the mili:htomicv compd. p.
closed C:.;m;ts fp,,:sp,. as.
4
.triher woid c.darprir.: th 33a s reae.4 a-,eco'.e;y cf the Hudson Rwer,j to d's b~ u. nasa 'e a-Caign to ha' 19 hdM fnegy tnd v:s r# ex;. :t d tit 6:r - ce
-.h.
t.
p ::p g..,; erat,tr.; pt:r., a.c.sr...m,..fueaanan be c,.o3;j
.t shculd r.ot be aLowed to opc. ! cast any.her v.ei'c.
Pcint c ;: elas unti h et.: ect-n ate, tha A:tornty General siys.
Con I:"so c-ca dsm e to A c. ges$,.s #d g of de plant dr w s~n.h$i$":'s r[c' ^i3=.
1}4 e b+-"'ih;cn iEnf.) *[d'h
.o 7..s:(.. e oIhe f..
h I
Nr.
f tr en s6..
Atty. Gen. IAuls J. I.eikow. : k!!!s s. :'..d:::3a.o 60 cec!:;y
!.h"a b: fare ca Al'.C.
3
.:s
- 0. yL,, L. di.. Lo..c.
3 far bae..
Cong, u,.._., i - O._..t,..c pi.. I.
-; 7.2 sb.>...,
5
~
L
. d.... c.. 4 ;a 3:3,.e
,"o. re-a itz. anna 'a.c rg the sni*, Tuc3 dry,
.a, 4
'S p..
3, y,',* *(t.
b' p.. g y0 3., I.
I,-,, g I.
...,4 5 < '.;.'. '"' 5.'"I " " t
-o,.g. gU,", up g-,a s3i.3.1. 0 5310 W00.u 5%. y *3:i.
k i
b.k,#I-E2.7. 3...e[..,.[.."[~ h> a'3In f.;87. the %p.ar:,s cpra sysicm ze
. se, t
Vl3S r * *" '# * *
- I!M O
~%
- ' -.f[: "
E 3I 3h Od 18 thous [nEs"v re sS:al'ir 153 ' th's -$c'5st.[- c 5*
resu c d '"
O AS-Afeerd r,; = to Cn:.'...hu d.
lem was re;.orkd r'ved by R.w
~'d d n :!!!ch.!3, :::. :: din EcHe, has pen epstd 3_d screenin whnc rive wate i:
p;;r-,hr.t
'3 cc..r ;; ;- :s S.e': Uc:n Dama;;cs
{' id.e cgs (year n..,y, n*..o.03r drawn in:a ths phat.,,,
prod ee anr.: 3 p.: c;;t ci
[
In tha r:!: Ii'.ed >es:e: day.
^
fh L'0 IC5tt-~,5 6f as.2 a....s out ical pwn y,e 4::'.it; ca.;
th.e A ".:.:nev General.chargeo
+
eara..
.O.. 1.,.
pe._. C2,.g.
were re.cc:'.cd this.ven. esen
-,. N.. r.. a. -...t. s n t3 7....i 1..
.. -s i
.6.
..j,,, p g. g".g g g,3 y3 p...
c?. -;.3 cf Se.nal and chemini sur,"is'e'to c;ateta!r c., o nwee re.eulb.
.n "P -d,n a b.rai r.widowa e ' ;er:,1:* :;; :::o,the hct days.
r; i
- y a "es.a:"N* serk;s cen.
t;I3
't 'w-- [r_ g,g3'
" c, samc:7 we 3.re tr.rer.n.7, p'.c. a b :ho. liedsca Ritti"
,C..' fin.
'1 '.C.' C-
~"dise4 kilhn; cf 11' N Y.:sh and 9
" ~# "*
- 5 U
i ra 4.
a.u - :- -. 3.;d C- -u- ' - '
... +.:....i,. w,. e ~a,... a 7..
said va:ctday 2at ".we c:nnet **'* TCL, *' WE5 c'
'~'u th m**
syne".:: "I. "R.4.;.s.
JI" ^""'/0 ::
'5 - -
'"7 m
i
~,'f-"' sm:able me:c, us E.r.d i
comrr.ent on the
.It,.. o..ons
.u.---
reade. t:nause we ara s:!!! re. C'O fis'"3..,u l"ci%",,3 %*
p eed;. es are ir.s:i:u:ed venich werc 9"- IO D G C? u-C se
,,, Power $=1::ds b th or'.;
e a,-
- 2 a dt.cdant ;o w:th-view:n;;.u.. papers. As fa. o.s I d":re vet.e frc:n ar.d c..scharaa t$yo.e.. p h, 6 b-
.q.3 4
i know. :n is :M first inark n!
E S N-M'nservn.C A ic, l M k '. ~ i -.
,r-~ ~ I'.
r:3:e: ir.:e the Eudson Ratt
. U'#0 E31W 00 F# ' ~'
the R m t e r $ " ' " -
t e
b such a manner as to avoid J. :' l:dacir;< cy2:q of it.e sjesyr.
thn c a m J da k""""'1 cf f;sh and CSM
- cornp..".E n; JMf 0. IG,T3
- *. w.k -
ir a
co
- caen ra:meatr':.
, r,
. s.
..... e..a. s..
..a.e.
.n warr.ed cf pv.cr st::.;cs i:
pe.': p vier :,f haura 2.s s;=.
Ir.er.
i
.}
([9 D'
~~7 'T~'~ ~7 i. <. 4 Q< s s[,
x., 7 []
s ss s.,
ss
..e
( \\.,
. --Q
)
- S
'l jj
'\\ B s
,sgs.
a.
.N. s.,a 4
?
- j'l.:L. V). l t
i
.- g
- t. :. A.,
- e
.s a
'%g sN..,P G,.a./
L.
.!.v
.-. s.:._'
/
',)
PEEKSMLL. N. Y., WEDNESDAY, MAY 13, 1970
,r
....c...-.,,..ww
~
c
-,.c
,,w..,
y,,.-%r-y,=
.m
-.ir a-w
.o e-r -we&-
w s.ere~e
..a
-..--n_
~
- -. ~. -
4 4
.[
g
.f g S.
- g r
s,
/$
g e,
y.
g.
.}.
.,.y) e
..O P,t'n (Cl/(. A W. j.r.,
,!.*y *. /.-
- ' '/ -
8
. 4 e. i u { { j. { y } *u.ub. 7.M..*O,.,
M *
- 11,"
j s.,.,
.. s m J..'
I V *r
(,**
e U,
- e. w.
.(
-..%,=
- O..
W. - W,..
i w_.
5 J' li-5 '@.,,./.
Dox,u.f..a e
u 4
4 o.ssir.iy :wwa icm
~
gl......
v.,
assu.J i D,f
- =4 mp
,v.,
p. ;3 ee i*a X'
., h *; ]. h.
,'p q d [, [' '," sN w ' j.... V{,p ' [ i} %g &l( & ]
'6 r.:a : N Y
,[(;;{
'P N...,r::.;n+.
- v M /,.~
'v W ' v p.. j p m ,,.., d.., C r....... s E :.;7,3==: 4 f (c.... 0 v.... I'l Ccenny-to L r.;; 2. * , p'33!:.rg y-) q Md 7 N, bc.O. .vcMcrd V, is an-2ttanf1 tol I ~i th0 }.VII:n hir* ' n :,J.J 5 o U i4 / , l.: 1,JULU VW i Ld' 5: cal twr thunder." A. O::in i ?[ !:y's En:.n Mr.: =. : ' s g ii J
- c..
[, povgrTrnttur !:d::cd Edison offici.k.l g'r last r1cnth eM!doned thcisemnic I.ncr;y Lar.Qtion tol *
- h...
,." t.I...- .,". e,Ccr.ro'. ..ts a ec..e.n. s...,.. a c; . y,./, 3 - "*C"*<'^ f.' ,,y ; e 7.'.g "g; a"i~n 'W'c'.81 CPC'g'-m,*^ !'g'g:I, g.'.~ '.qa" g'...,,', ' '.," -- - but t'e P' u. a res.tramm,. 7.w#:4.' 7.t ' "--I. e c'7.. a. g;, W..,w i.e t" e.* *- j. .. sc.1.:,. i .t a, c i,., .,....,u....... _..,.. ps..aton of the p...t un,. op i e... as, c. c.. o. p.., r.m..... .s ....u .il ,.t. 'i
- w can demonstrate the opratkn! u,c.', P.'g'";.n.b s @ p nd:'-a 63 "l
- >u
n,...; " " ~ ~ ' ' " ~g" C r . ci "".In' the' suit f"de'd ves+'e'd"* l* 'r*->* c* [..r.s. $i. N. r,[..*.{ cg m.
- ayold c e...'a n - 'T.s*
- )! } fer t":
- " ' c'"u' - + f ' : ( c. ".;":h 4 '~ c*o!~%/ o* '". r,"
- ge At
- , 7ey cene j c33 ;:d l
.e,..:. c.;. 4.g qu p....v. *
- 3 Accord:.' "c l'ade.n Iw~Censo!:d:ted;; c:t. the Edit.n Point opct:.; ;
4 Co:: ;. ;;;,-.n; e: ci;cu,to n e n ls, the. Indani tion was "acatir;: r:rieus ecmi I to.. c m h; :.... : ' Edison p", s..,
- s p *. 3. m...;
Point pbnt is counted cn tC (!:!cns cf therm.1 and ch# ' ,I P3 n t: : r.ver. j . produce."about 3 p:: cent off pongtion in tha Uudson Riveri 5 t T;;rc vrt.s no im.. total power n:.cnt!n; ca-and "ents:: erin; :he eco,n;y"; y 'i comm;nt f.rs= Can If.:. l Cur,3y on an annus.1 basis :nd pt:. "Until suitAle r-ethods and Lut Feb.:L Cen 2li. - s ....O,., A,.., ,y., /.e ~ s::te h:s chst;:,.. i,ne, comm; up into de h0: d:ys procednes are insti:c:cc which; -* tha: :: !cu: I'O.C* l:- lC:n30..e:.:td Edi3:n Ccm".;ny 0$ 82nWCf WC Cr0 c:GramclY: w!Il enable dclct.c:nt to wid.i !.. b:ca k :cd it if:-C a. draw wa:ct frora. . Ju.12 s.: its Md ; eg.ce ned about shd.n? down! water !tto the Hudson Riveriand dis:h: :e! ! ' [t- %:n s.ons r:c: :.5:ns of st:u 1. ~ s 0;cration and ccprivt:0 s p:an oct 61; ic n.:r.rt s.- . v.."a c. c.ey. u. i., 3 gn M... g.c:.:~-.s.,; the sys:cm t.f the 235.000 ki'h in such a runner as to avoi ; . s. 0 i M :o r b. $ 5 ! ura:;ces :;;;t:reh:cd the fish /.:,. o a. d " 7"s" ".T,S the killi ; o' fish and otn ! . p vat:s y makes avanzbic to ine: ..c. forms cf ristina life rir.d tol l' I : insi;n ff::n: nuater.
- p
- r.:a :: EU:n Pcint and aske : sys:ent
- 11 P
furthcr evold endngerin:: the. IJ pic:ect 70'pwer den'. ands in the New jc n $3 ph n b: eksed un: " ' - - ~ ~ ~ ' " i eco! cry c! the Hudson n!ver.".c.. r . City rce:ropoh:an area "s2:ra in:2:7 t: ^ ~ it e ould o: hs- %we t. 1 e...a$... m. 3.c c2*4 y e mva o en taxin; the power,, ? -(I .o,n..u. 7, C2Paci.y of the Sys : 0 erm. tne A;;;;ncy General an =.. it l 4 tem for a num::r of yearst Tys- -- d h z. cem;11in f;:cd by Al-and t:th company and sute h'o d:te for t. he$ tin
- of the EJ I
+-c- .ts:re C.nt=1 Lo is J. Lef-o!Och!s have sarned cf power charges his been ret. {) ^y:t.6',l-hm.='s cffin in 5.ste Su; e=e do.'u;05 in pak.;;we;.us: Meanwhile. Consa;idatcd 3 6 (TC';. ~" 'd f 'Et.e i Edison o!!icials point cut ca 820d8? @N Ccnq the Edin pein:;12.: has been A02#8 W3 !C:;r;'r:e'p$2s.:::r.:I: te MC...f.~.T'."..J....,g...W U,u.'.jg: s3;M f a,r' b:ck 1 = M.. r.. ...o. < nc. Edison's b;str.:icas c: closed for ei;h: wecks tor rey i f, N a ...T.. " t... .....a,,. +..~ 79n Point drew ccmp;:!n2 helief ud is r.c: cicected t .j egn =nt.
- c. fjsh kil!s and d:m.;;2 to thei to be h ck in oprr.io : kr -*
[1 - Tar :: den by the Atta n2y. e:o.: he Hud!0n Mycr.. Ictst cncther wc:%. L " .-r. s c'...e r - s--....u.! b..J;q cf t,J I: was re :r;ed w
- h....,.s. $,,.,..;. &y
.... I W. c g. ..u..q 2 t o h h, A.,ous2nds mere 4r.,. e C. ,a.. c,...s o...u...u, c.33j ggg.cd ina de s. 3 m e s ~ 4 ' d.l 6 % D M h'd=frded Lff 1, cs 4 YOMIM, ' '., {:2: Os r ;e:ti cariier t'ir ye:r kiPed.. Ti.at
- 5 r.u:.a:: ;tr.:rning plut; ; cried '.so've:!proyei l
f 'j 'i'ijI3MY NC'c'." '. by mechan!c:1 001.???'7,.d.0 ': OTC:!?3 f- ,1 - - 'e t%3kr.: znd c: ~ " o ch2n;es l. f, j ..,inc% e tw 'l wo sep:rste ins:an:23 cf; 6. p , e [-. l,..]f " fish k!!!s were r:pened this! The American Meri*n;e 50- ~..y year. cath resu!:in; in a brief! ~ ciety,vir.o!3 members bciude
- s i.
y"-*. 1 *-b n--
- 4 of the c;erations. reader: and editors cf Ameri-n l
'n; '.cv.:r:Ta ?:M.ra, shmdown in J r w ary, resut:cd), can Mcri:2ge rn::::!..e. yes-dj "We ct.r.n ccmmen; on the "The first:lin; of about 150.C001 7 t e.," E & a s. s t g.,, _..,a........ i.c:ausa ve* b6c terday :nnounced the win. ' {' i ' ~in.? d? d-M d a chtn e in' nets. of - 12 conservation , 1, --~nw - ,.e s.n...,,p..,.:.,.sg.y-e. 3,J fish. It req i!;ned to filter fish-awards totah.n; $50,0CO.
- i.
4 gd : ;.n:n=:n !st CcnGil s:reens das.u re t e ..-s-y*~ ~ ! ~ cc: cf ee wa:er imeke sys:en.' The top priu2. 25.003, wad Id ".I.".I.. ..,..,,. J."~ T ~~t-mu Id;nn/As far as L h March 1'!0.000 f;;h vi:re ts.' awarded to the Alaka Cen- '1 h:: c'fi:his sc vnten 50:ic:y. The c,rc:;9 ....,,.u.. c.. ;-,e.,.s:! oned kmed for v.1 "un%:own is workb; to prote:t t;.e .. 9
- g. 3 3 e" y -v. g
}.'34.u'l. ;;i".'d,.T ~;- u... g3.m... 3 of. there s:y are 50. s:atc's natural c.vironment. reasons." D) j -^ g..r.. .... ~..... I d2027;I- ;; C> 1 .! g ' D III Der E U' * * * ** '9 4.
- f.
- e f. ths cyrs=n... u.
Thcu;h car:er fish hi'Is gen-which i: censiders to 1 e. N e n n W e* f. W : d t'.7 knt7th Cra ( ' C0m;!3!nt$ fr$m (03, thre1:ened by the regge:g dg. s -".a covery of c;I reserves en the i j h2= her P:r : Y r:rvnionis:s. '.aaf.. w."% c y nr v g;.uns u :: .n% . l ".Nor.n 5;ge, 3J Ca'IdI v.'-* - -m. ~ --. c " Lc,:tw; 2 " '~ ' " ' ' ' ac ccn* ! L* 52W WO SIME bl "In m ctd M2 f -
- rv c.d n:, *e.
-y . e va.n n:.s n:mne tn pars.. was cv r dad :o the Sq ,j 1 c;- i--d.? :s se.y a~... - -- i % w...ch is wor.L.ib 3 ?.e
- cm Asm::.:2.n cf n ::;:neS.nt.! nw-t.1
- r. aunt istee.
..Tn;c:ut s g w ced 3q r-ard m.;- : !..u. ........r...s.e u...........a .e; ss:,:a:rer
- b. hard L.
city ac. r. *,.e nu;n, cch!:,n was an 0 :".';cr. a ca-dikte fcr thei to s:.ve a *,23.D 2:re wi:d. 1i ~ f e ...+ r
- * :M :n : tddpr rs re, C ac:' Entet Sen te. phr.:: cci life r:fe;;c.
yl ,m' r 6 da r.elit: cal IA:t ca ti e s::te%. Third ;t:2e. ECO3 went to t J. t a: dan. Tha Attr.rnt y Generarr the M,- "@ pe 3 l t r".0i?. Mr. Oain. r's office said; twC- -.- x N I + ~, d_- f
- a a'*
0 ll 1,* * ' ..V- /g p(.,' 'J.Q .T* U. w W< s ."h'*".e.?.."h.i.t.r' .'.t -".. ' +'.*e*.s."*f' e. P. :e' "ma t.e. f * *." *w. 8' c .I n t' /\\ g J
- $[
Y..ls .. e 3 \\a u y,.,,- a E,,c.:; '{;. *.) 4
- ..i'1*** T **'
~e - * * * * " " ^ ' '. ' .t '.., J _ (==, gQ W e'.Ot d.*..g y....*..,,,,, e g)v.--* .9 dr5glb;,.,,.N,.,.),., * *C.,1..}r>+) t. ( *- g i
- ..a.,
u.> % e W *% y). ka ...a...... n..eio u.. ee i, j * -. i ee u m .. e..e e.i.. y u ;g :- t>.. ei w r y f% e.. . \\ /.,..;..:. v?..e. <, y c, y.g. c: v. e.e,..q. v t.; e c y.):::Lt.1 %.p, n v.. e a me..t,% r's a ....u....u... w*, - %. t <.: c.,.1 ~ ~
- . t-s
.:. 2,. s s _. s 4 'Ni 'D &p,.. s .-v N.T ADOUI' 'I'.C Mi.,~0SO.H ? l'on 3 t *.tc m:.:is t f n M thi:."' c 8: :. i.~. :. ? --.i-r_m unem.u.2.u- ---~.r--- p._, e,:,.s.g fs.,,y(C.O, e, p .r 1. p.,. e,.. e n,..,,,. v;.r n .g e_ \\)J l.:, q q Lr;al..~'. C..,y L.J.L r*, v 2, t C;.. f,.3 / n .t. Go ' L.t.?:;s v L p' Ca.s.. ~.7 :. 7 *.j b . - ~ . L,. > v... M,,) .i /. : .s i wot. L.' ncin;t fro!.s res:tk f: red to tco;t re;&.t! :.s by Tic ' h:;,1 g...
- j.;,., P. t,;4 s m.n.. ins i.. L
- t'ons h the presert sla.
- t!:a. n:..t.r:b. n.
- se n. e is. c ~..,~.~. a.1+.a.... ty s .s.. -.,.... w r g3 g"- e. p-. c;.. e..*y~u, w;t/cen 50&nMnion and two tc.g tenm.. us n:re..;;T :Tu > ' ' trait. Ohh cus. C o ' t w. e
- y. ;;
p. p.ts disettr;i.4 a 4 .4 ....at, rtti disett ;is .. ~ re,:.t u.d uJ.greil *? tit,sth:s i:en der: g:.y/ p;*:! y ; der!?r. E.T.t!.*a tout: c:r.t!nvr rt.
- . ::n. : :. :..T i s e.??"'"P. c ri;:rahy 1:.! : ::,. ';y.ia::1.:
t 2' s;t:lat requite netts re. p:mn sieb.. :rd!:: dis; ulos of thdr h;* r'* ~T *"'T!?.*7 T.*t'J#-.~s^ 5 trettr/ c1 th 1.;er:et ctt: tinci:.'.s u ce tr.::: 2:f;"at'.t * . & ~ [ ** ne. ' " L }lt!n.Wnoretbnd :Utt.!r J- - f 'l te.' m' s ,r::r.in to th: . tne ggg, jg g;;;. ; ;7,7 3 ;;,.;g
- c. u:*:.:1 ;C.::::n &l wt.tcr.
pm wgn a getjen ef she; ! e mm"% reca is yg;;r:: ct:gr ge 3 wntN.;ys h:m yppir q:r:a.*. $j 'reath:4 t O e nal ! );t 1:,t:1 Watcr cu;1:y tt: :n:: 6. g; rnd :=t/ t".iustra,. 2:1. ts.' of tvlo AHon I.T.t!/s per heter ..,.'r.r.a to 1.s, e..--t en u bel nter c!4 C :z. t w......, .i no HdMe ::1 dk:h tr.e.acr.ee..:c
- F.1.: ) ER/1D STWEDIA;;, YM. W..e. Y...*..*m. '*e4y.,a..w.".
y m.,'.s.se.**. t.*.t.n..*..1. t. - -. _ s j m.e c.m:- - -- n,.-~w1 .,.o... t t.
- i..g e. c~ s. t.. *(,;- -
rs e .....n..... .. b' s, m dr. 77s.f tj..!.y 3. e r. '.E./ C is v.'b a a...tc are now ,.A tov::: a a I..r.M C. ry
- ru::!1*
csdtt:ct =to a y! sei;re:4., T'-rte--cns of th:m r.uckr.r. d,C O@ ./ Ei e
- ct c' w:.tti fre a.
not Wattr into uke-R:!udit; trastar/ s:r:.: s 1..C :.!!chtssn.c:s:r.afgin;They e toent fer 1-l' nut!:!;21 sews;f tc:: at cst!yt ;.gg..,4,
- Mr.ts.
! thout 75 ;ct c r.t ! the A {g yQ }VQ.] TQy T1 'J P- - gg,,fgh T4.t amount o / gt!ng 1:to a w :er.v y.rs:al In c..-a /*r y'.* (E' i '.1 # n' h.. e '" u' estat!!shed dischttp saare:sl' IJe::n sencrat!n: facH!ttes in a given area thus w!3 do.j are dc.chnt every deette L./ v L h k) teri !ne v ht! Eddi br.f.1 ft:!! I throu;haut the country, and 4
- h
$g g y ga! f" u$ 8 ".I. Y.b [N h.a. w$, b M L 2 *- c dt P. r r .g c a w(/g;'y,3gg g'gg. ggg.;gggggW ra= = us a haf m n== = ae
- e. u G s:M, ta. mae
'#r CorrmWen tg tm:. msun::.y r.4% ht*:.4.*'d:E' "Y C"',-(- '" ** C - Jed E Q 0:'.5 :t 7,u dt;:tj is Te * *hid.1* =t . ad htv: - e e, rem r
- gpv--
n m'm***' P 40!!L20;.infri!:"I:s*YJ4;/.lh.e..:'iYdi!:I $'ghgg est'..ag A EU*TE*'#UI 0.*OUE NU8 (
- 91* ' " #
.e bgg (gh'g'*4. U.* IOI NI hdM P.tni r.UClear Me i.e..- h th3 f Zh jIw.... g....c 2!).....#...,.s.3 .e....#...*M.i', *k ?" Pe.....,:,5e J D f old g
- papCWer ',br.1 n;;mtcr ong gnt!)
a.rg g s:.r... y.ptg khe's c :: years, anc r.i.n" <the
- h* tt!c i
pp g, g.. m,..._ 3
- o. UCh W ;e. cures the: mal ph.
- y
- wo 7.g.. y, g. g.,,...g.,
s:ursts. \\'.*,P,,,'.I !: ar'r ;:*.! nt 33 a ho 5:45 is catted niver y;e.g7 3;.j, A,n:n.g., t'c:;h se:::= : h::J st::: entin f9h py---i wr.1 t e ~t-+ **_"N.. '**""_W.. IT *"O.".3,1. h e.. P.~' - *.r.. .1 08.1.. -. e '~ 7ho c!'ects of the proje::ed E'P 0.. n pr at,.d t$.r.t since .q lm", ;':.,!.L' *.2l!, rege'stiens on individual edst. the,,&. Cactano DeFasM.,a*.n ::,ng p' c : : o e ist Ps:nt par,t was y ;.......'..--.,31 N Joner E!2nts and in:Ns: rial, f.rs, p*:t bio c; err.t.on in it61tr.e AEC. gep, o:gt;,; 3 : p;gg,g3 g3 c....n _;_,;;;' W W W u h W W h has destroyed tv.re ti.an S in a re:a:td :n.we.*te;, c:. -h*.u~v. huh tu (t ;:i:r..b c. ecmmercLe valutne 15ger relemd tM:iy a re~.-- qu :t" ' w;th.* hr.h Mile.73,e..htt: 4 "3 2**".;"' g...,r!a"a Di.C.:s cf tri:fr :::h5-W b at lenst 3? u?arate pepard V t.'.)Itsar:: 7;n . g37... sp c,us. ng.gy, k:Ra. De rnet rerea.t Diseas - L*ter:a :y c the -:*,2 :::: u.*:e ce;*.tt :=: "~ M = b " M *- by k:3 inic!ved M.000 !sh and - T;sh and W;!!'..!c Sm.r. c: pvcer pt.-:s. re ht ty :::D a c D ct *.*L Ut - t* " ~ ~ 'd *Ifi,44 Ci L M .*d d u at a U!'*.cis. otetu'i t:1 Mmch *. Lad T. Reps the Depr :ner.t et the h::.. y. m.., a. c.. ",. '.-,.;r. o; t. 3, wage,g!n gn 3.. 0:n*. er sa;d. cr. gyC3,g,;Cnftt ,C, Whh c7 Ch1$ up y g y,p.,gwg, 7he 8! y. 2$ed C,. g., ;.,,......... w;:n':3rr Mcv::g i ci the Tedcral Water Qu:P" b^ t: e-m n
- k. 5.*.e:,e:al es.t.-.s (:'..,m:a tr.:j Admh!s:tsuen and the 7:::. a
'N "*"-'"N s!cs c Ish ecce: gut:::,,
- r "a
~W:~. <t - p; ant :J e p'.J'...d u'.. y '.'.i. 7.3 L,.., h:2 Mkk. Thu aday. "I88.'I re' ' e n "... a* *"+ e *- licuyer, *n eg,e7;,g e.,(.y* F . wgl, g n.k b m a . e. s;s... p; s;g... cs, * ~ L.::'t - L", m LL-t,. g.,,,.;,... .....u... n 0.,r..
- c...
th'e"Lt...ty a ccm':rc.u'tt!*' e'.! ,:::u, a.:n.t 't ct h, Ctr:: a* th v. U nt t a. "? . '** e y;i'-:
- ~
2 [e'"* gm....t.: n t.:s,..: ~ g.... c....o. c:,:.:...a.., ... :l.. ca n J.t gem. .,. e ccr.!?re: tttatlish:d a ters. pnc ::.n: l' T' '.*:; i{.'w.,. w... $3 ~- t~ ou : t:, t : :r.M hm:m 1::h*.h;l c: nche to we:k , E' 47>.m.v .,4.....1,3 cr. f ;; cut.d::f.:s, and t.he fort-c:n athel Ccn E "s tu. ...A. p.3,..,'. g, C, '.. *7 "* (: $ ccnu u t ec*, y g eg. p.,y,. .. 1. "o;. ..... are .s . ( s.... ht.. 1.m: *...*C Mg c.3 i red::2: re:rnesteeve: hee p e.i 73g. d t****<m* **Mt*^?-"*c h am m :s n' ....m. uus p< '" * '* "" ';" t n:. - etn!ct::s t.r g p.i"C N " ,~.. e..e..lir.,,* k.nt.* = i pic d. Ih 1:ct dac.sae u
- cd:Wy r :
72::: O..t3 c.,:th-. .r u. s 2 yng. g+W...e,..w-.....s.v. f.. ... y. ~~ (%.. ~M Wm us. W~., -m--_____ _ - - - - - _ - - 1 -~ a d k .s, n...,.n. I:1.c,, -.-....: s,..S
- t. c c. a
.,. -,. ~. J ., a.. m. a> Ol 6,s w. .,,.........'.'.'? / 7'1.7. Oss:::ing, N:ew ','od: 10582 ,E. '< r ..,....i.s.... 3,, D. 'j u. v0" I 5,. p '. ..)...j. = j s g N v '., . -9 r ~.. ,;,s ,,y-g :, is, '. .t.. s us,. ^g .s s a .s s i w r
- ,s
?+ 'g 8, ,.#g 1 '8 ~. J t 71!E ?IEW YORK TIMES, TUESDA Y. H.A.'?C ! 11, H10 1 ~= i C n'**.b.<' c*
- a '.vj' u<=
sy ? s ~ \\ i If Lgcy.pe r orce:.I ~ In answer to questions a$re,ut t' , fi.Sh Lills t..'ar the ladira Fo!nt 5 neck t.r ':nt. ;.*r L v s.a!d i J j 'htte h: L:en r.) n;: lear ecn. l tamht. lit,n hve,hc and he y,f. fered to re?l0cc the ft.ote gin 200.000 fish es:! ::ed to ha re been kmed in t..o separate b- ) fidtr.15 5L* C t h a.
- t.h* t v.** % Wi '_~%" *L..*.:*'j nnv c.w r.. :,., -,,. 3.,
wn . =-. cm., 4 i We have only been 8 j i screaning for i SEVE'i (7) n (4 7 YE!.RS I ! ! lW.5.h i '7 a e p - <ty i .,. r 6 l/-*. c' !\\ .u '.7f ,, L, .-4 +
- i 3
i .7 ( ,g 4 -) -...\\ i i } [ \\ e '\\ f~h C C {; .>. \\ s, .M FM ,3 s---..,... ._..,...,.,s-l. \\,<,. k. : :. -[ h \\ ,a. c, . > j. a... : s... ;. -:~ / \\ , s~ ~..... ..,f,......;..,. _ - ~ - _ ~ Oe. /- u. \\. ~ r e~.s, l u ..r. . C. p e r2 a
- 5 u
--~ U.'",.,.: . v;* ( .... s., p.-,. i ( .)- r ,7,q T r )- ~ r l " % tiw?', ui: n !!. -.' :.. :i, lY like to t/umb you fello=u for firinging t/ tis to n,y attentio :." J y y.e- -t T- ---fam--- e- + _*vei-'
- --e*-
w-r=er-w=' h = . n. m;.,, _ + ~ <
- i.u c' '++
i e,...... e
- v. ;,',
,,.t :,,
- E ^'.. s
'.(. , ~...n. 4 a ). u i t ..... a l.,. ;. 4. o. / c. 3 \\.. \\ 09 ns...,,.. o s > a r.a.- yj10 \\s:)'1,f,$ i'\\ i i r t s :.. 8l ,, :....w t - s ;. yst s.s,.. s..a < t n a 0.'J. I3",.. ir, i t:f itM O
- 3., c. l. i r, ). 91 e r o si - l-i le.it
. s t mi >, s. 1 [gy.O'3I - - -.. +. lon1 s n \\ n.. \\ xsm; . 18 s 1111. 1. t v.s. 3 a. i i ci1 t i :& v...* i i f.. l-9 '- ".) i s,. .i.i.,.sa. vi s: e
- t. :,v
.s ,1 4., e o i: 1 r-t.. #.1 0 - s e~ it + ' v i. t-it 4: et-r t/. t; v.d o f *. *. i * - r i i n l e. I 1. s i i-st s.- t c's - .r 64-t. w ?: :. tun e-) .n a v n.. <. n r v. - v, - ~.. a. so. - e r, a c'.s' I s. i. e- "1 .18: '-T r : t i s-i. ^- .s 1.. I - I m.lc : : . ic. ;. s.. t.o c.. '.
- i a: t e
.4 i... / -,i ..).
- 1c - v.. (
4 + i r.
- l e.
4 ) (1-etD3'l 1 i / tocrt1ts s rate 6 NOV S 0 1370 u -9 i i (!llf t f' f.*,' ".**;ry hll'? +. ff W..i'l la Imn { OR. 3/ l %.GE.f ~ k i 1:v?r id) .$.") c '/
- W 4
1.,, n
- f l 11'; % !; i s's v
.% L :.!bn I i e 1 .{ 4 4,g.,7*!* .g .. g - s + 8 i f.s,ii D... tell\\.4.... ti ...l..h .i 8 9 A 4 4 4 ,8 8 .,..en,-ty Yv,y 4 es a f w-m-, -+-,-,w . a, m .v-ee,.ws,---s y e-5.,,.w,my-w a cr e y+e cers p ws.. e g. ,,-g-n.m.-,.,.ip, y-. n-e m r',-e. ed ,.y,i.,+- .-s,--~+-ve t-yg e't-t- I j 3 ' ( ~o Q..., v..,, /.4 r. em. t, v.nt, nn. w vn .y i.... o [10V3 0 D70
- r 1..
p., n m t ~i'a Q T ugigG U.i1TED STATES OF V "RICA l \\%,. C1') e ATO?;IC E::EnCY CO.".::ISSION ff gg 'AM I In t he Matter of the ) l (OSSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY ) DOCEET NO. 50-247 j OF 1:EU YOPJ;, INC. ) PETITION POR LEAVE TO INTERVENE BY Tile STATE OF KE YORM Purnuant to Section 2.714 of t he Conmission's Rulen of practice, Section 274 i .x. -y of the t.tomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, and in accordance uith' the provicions 1 i of the Commiscion % Kot!ce of-Ucaring dated November 13,1970, :the State of Neu York, acting by and through its Atomic Energy Coancil, hereby petitions for 3 cave to intervene in the above captioned proceeding and become a party thereto upon the following grounds i 1. This proceeding is to consider the application of Consolideted Edison Company of Neu York f or an operating license which would authorite the operation of Con Edison's Indian Pojnt Euclear Genet ating Unit No. 2, in the Town of Duchanan, Ucstchester County, Ncv York State. f 2. The ' interest of the State of New York in the health and saicty of its { peopic requires that all raatters per taining to the saf ety of the nuclear pouer r I plant proposed in the above captioned proceeding be thoroughly considered. 3. Under Section 104 of the Commerce Lau of the State of Neu York, the-Atonic Energy Council is-given the functions of coordinating reguintory programs of the agencies and instrt.nentalitics of the. State aff ccting' atomic _ cncrgy L l-activitics in-New York, of coord1nating the participation of the agencics and- -instrumentalitics of the State in the regulatory processes oI the Federal', I Covernment aff ecting atomic _ cncrgy activitics in New York State, and of coo: dinating the presentation of vicus of such agencies and instrumentalities for consideration. { by approp:jate rederal agencies. _1 %[703\\P% o ,m.,,,_._ i ') i - 2 2 i + ( j t L The natac and address of tlic person upon Whon service in this pr 1 oceeding may be j nede 1st l. J. Druce MacDonald. Counsel Neu York State Departuent of Commerce o 112 State Street 4 Albany. New York 12207 3 1 Pctitioner respectfully 1equests the Corxnissjon to grant petiti 1 l oner status as intervenor and party to this proceeding. } 1 1 1 Respectfully submitted, 9 n n - / < . s,
- i. co,s.-
t ,,9 ,*r ( e' I J/. Druce HacDonald, Counsc1 ~ i-41ev York State Depcrtncnt of' Commerce t and Counsel to the Atomic Energy Council j DATED: November 27, 1970 .1 + 4 a 4 e i e l l 4 l a 6 N 4 e 'l t 8 f d 4 e 6 4 0 e i a 1 r
- -,-+----s
-+4e--e 14 -v - + - - - - -+ w-+* h-+------,--ev-e-e-+++--wi-+- <+r
- - e rw ~ w--
==,-em- ~i----~r-v-<r- -~t- --vv-+-w _~ -= - -. - - ~. '~~') W.L s 3.'. y l' Iff ' ',8 !,8 } ,;,r;(g N s't ; o c, -h UtilTLD 57A1 E5 ' " - - ~ ~ v = ' /s ',.s# v. u i ATOMIC E GRGY COMMIEGION
- p. ',1
.l ' jt wum ,,m. ur :.- [.. g I M!.V Dec c r.hr 3, 1970 L 14rs.1: cry }!ays Weik, Secretary Ccc.mittee To End Tadiologien1 Marnras Box 1h8, 150 Chrictopher Street liev York, reu Ye-k 10%h Mr. Dminich J. Pirene Conculting E1oleciet,1:udcon River 1:rc. Milton Kurt: Fishernen's Association Chaiman, CLE/J!, Inc. Box 725 liox 1087 Ossining,1:ev York 10562 Ilev P.ochelle, Ucv York 10302 Mr. U1111cm C. liitt Mr. Ronale Fritz Supervir.or, Town of Cortlandt IL48 Biverviev Avenue !!anicipal Building ) reckshill, : lev York 10566 Croton-on-1:vdcon, Ucv York 10520 In rc: Conco11 dated Edicon Company of Nov York, Inc. (Indian Point Station Unit No. 2) l Ibcket !?o. 50-2h7 [
Dear Mesdanos and Sire:
Ecceipt l'.; ecknowle6ced of your letter cc:=unicctions ctating en intention er desire to ir.tervene in the above entitled proceedings.
Your letters do not constitute petitione to intervene as prescribed by Section 2.71h of the Eules of Prnetice of the /.temic Energy Ccm-missicn end therefore connct serve as the basis of any cdjudicction i
regardir.g your participation in the prcceeding.
Uithout objection frem the precent parf,,ies to the proceeding, hovever, each of you vill be pomitted to ceparate3y file, even-though beycnd' the tice pemitted by the I 0tice of IIccring, n femal petition to intervene in the proceedin; in cccordance with the Eules cf Frne-tice, a copy of vhich is enclesed.
/.fter receipt of cuch a romal petition, under oath, cetting forth the interest you have tad the con-tentions you ranke, the precer; parties to the proceeding vill be
.s y $,y on k di
/
[
(' 's S ' [ ()
~.
., i. =8 66 97 I.{
4 1970 P J.3
- \\
p.,,,
A
.,m.
n C, - \\
< r.3 fh, Nh,[l 1
v
]f 4:T @ p a,-. ~
~
. - ~.
, '.o 4
i 2
pe:nitted to file cf.:. crr t.nd ti.e Atenic S:.Tety :nd Lit e: :ing Iourd vill ictue r.n crder < !t).er :;er.ittinc cr denyir.c ir.terve:.tien tend participatien in the pre::ec lin3 9
Verv truly yours, i
i e
e
}4
+
l Enclosures gemel it. Jen.nch, Chaira:e 10 Cril Port 2 Atc7,;ic gnpcty. no Li co: wing lienrd cc:
Arvin E. Upton, Esq.
l Anthony Z. T.oit:.:n, req.
t Joceph B. I'r.otts, Jr., Ecq.
(
Secretary, USAEC '. t.
/
)
l Nyron Kartmr., Etq'.'
corge C. Arcaro, Esq.
1 I
I r
l l
4 i*
4 t
t 4
e
?
8 i
4
-l
4.
^
I ocember 7,1970
/\\
SEcy-R 99 a)
Qi daw pG
@9 CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPA!N OF NEW YORK INC.
4 9(_
(INDI AN POINT NUCIEAR GENERATING UNIT No. 2)
DOCKET NO. 5d!247 y
'{N 8' )
~
Note by the Se'ereta g
- 11. Attached..for the infbrmation of the Commission are copies of
(
he following:
.- (y r
c g c c, L
- a. PETITION OF STATE OF NEW YORK FOR INTERVENTION (from 7 gf Q,-
Attorney General Lefkowitz);.
p
- b. APPLICANT'S ANSWER TO PETITION FOR LEAVE TO INTERVElE CITIZENS COMMITTEE FOR THE PROTECTION OF THE ENVIRON!GNT; b
o. APPLICANT'S ANSWER TO ~ PETITION FOR LEAVE TO INTERVENE O I
ENVIRONMENTAL'. DEFENSE FUND, INC.J t.
n
- d. Letter requesting. permission to intervene from D. J. Piror Hudton River Fishermen's Association;;-
- e. Teletype and FETITION FOR LEAVE TO INTERVENE BY THE STATE (
NEW YORK (from"J. ;Brube Mcdonald, New York, State Departmeg l
of Commerce);S z,O' m ',
f
- f. Atomic Safety and Licensing Board's letter to five persont whose requests to 1.ntervene did not constitute petitions a b....;,
- N
., i~
prescribed by S6ction 2.714; and te '
- g. Atomic Safety'and Licensing Board's ORDER PERMITTING i;
INTERVENTION by' Environmental-Defense Fund, Inc., Citizene committee for the Protection of the Environment, State of New York by the Attorney General, and Atomic Energy Counca of the State of New York.
2.. Related documents in this matter have been issued as SECY-R E nd SECY-R 95.
o W. B. McCool i
Secretary of the Commissior.
NO. OF NC DISTRIBUTION COPIES DISTRIBUTION CJ Secretary
'7 Congr. Relations Ceneral Manager 2
Environmental Affairs Deputy Gen. Mgr.
1 Inspection i
Director of Regu?ation 3
Materials Licensing Deputy Dir. of Regulation 1
Operational Safety
-hsst.Dir.of Reg.for Admn.
1 Public Information
- ech. Adv.to the Dir.of Reg.
1 Rad. Protection Standards Asst.Dir.of Reg.for Reactors 1
Reactor Dev. & Tech.
Asst. Gen. Mgr.
1 Reactor Licensing 1
TJec. Asst, to GM 1
Reactor Standards Spec. Asst. to GM 1
State & Lic. Relations General Counsel 6
New York Operations Compliance 6
Chairman, A5&LBF n
n
/l
/ I4
- 4) 4 /A /,/}"I' l
}
/
(I"l
s.
, s b
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA i
ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION In the Matter of
)
)
L CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF
)
Docket No. 50-247 l
NEW YORK, INC.
)
)
(Indian Point Nuclear Generating
)
Unit flo. 2)
)
2 PETITION OF STATE OF NEW YORK FOR I!1TERVENTION Petitioner, the Stato of New York, pursuant to Section 274 of the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, e
and in accordance with the Atomic Energy Commission's notice of hearing dated November 13, 1970, requests that 4t be permitted to intervene and become a party to the above i
entitled proceeding.
In support of this roquest, petitioner states as follows:
1.
The name and address of the petitionor ist 4
STATE OF NEW YORK 80 Centre Street New York, New York 10013 i
0 \\ \\w \\ S n e
wfen v u e.i >y
.. =
6.
i s
i i
s 2.
The State of New York is a body corporate and a oc.carcign entity and brings this petition on behalf of itself and as parens patriae, trustee, guardian and 4 -
representative, on behalf of all citizens and residents in
}
the State of New York, to protect and preserve its environ-ment and its economic and natural resources.
~
3.
As trustee and guardian of the interests of i
the people of New York, the State of New York is uniqurdy responsible for protecting the health, safety and welfare of l
its citizens and the quality of its environment.
This responsibility requires the State of New York to consider with utmost seriousness the questions that have been raised concerning the operation of the applicant's Indian Point II nuclear power f acility, and actively-participate in the-examination and resolution of these questions.
4.
This proceeding was initiated by the Consolidated Ldison Company of New York, Inc. (Con Edison), which is before the Atomic Energy Commission seeking approval of an application for an operating license which would authorize the operation 3
of the applicant's Indian -Point II nuclear power f acility in the Town of Buchanan in Westchester County, State of New York.
_p.
i
=. - -
a 4
5.
This application hac raised a number of issues of vital concern to the people of the State of New York.
It has been alleged by opponents of the application that the operation of the Indian Point II facility will adversely affect the environment and people of the State of New York.
More specifically, it has been alleged that the operation of this plant will result in harm to the natural resources of the Hudson xiver through thermal and chemical water pollution and i
through obstruction of the natural, unimpeded flow of said river.
6.
The National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 requires consideration of environmental matters by federal agencies in their planning cnd decision making.
l It is therefore appropriate for the State of New York to 1
intervene herein so that i t will be able to fully-participate in decision raking which may have an effect upon its environment.
1 7.
The name and address of the person on whom service may be made and to whom it is requested that
$\\
communications in r~spect to this Petition and proceeding
- l be addressed ist 3-
,,,,-e
.,,--e r
w-g,,
,r,,,,
a, o-.g
,-,,-g
_pw,,
...yno
.,e--
p~~
+&
t Louis J.
Lefkowitz Attorney General of the State of New York 80 Centre Street New York, New Yor3:
10013 Wile REFORE, the State of New York respectfully prays lea're to intervene in this proceeding and be treated as a party thereto.
Dated:
New York, New York November 25, 1970 Respectfully submi+,ted, LOUIS J.
LEFKOWITZ Attorney General of the State of New York 80 Centre Street New York, New York 10013
-(212) 488-7560 e
l '
i m.
. _ _.. ~..,
--.r --
s 4
DEFORE THE UNITED STATES ATOMIC ENERGY CO.vJIISSION In the Matter of
)
)
Consolidated Edison Company of )
Docket No. 50-247 Mew York, Inc.
)
(Indian Point Unit No. 2 )
)
APPLICANT'S ANSWER TO PETITION FOR LEAVE TO INTERVENE OF THE CITIZENS COMMITTEE FOR THE PROTECTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT By its Petition for Leave to Intervene filed with the Commission on November 25, 1970 the citizens Commi e for the Protection of the Environment (" Citizens Committee") seeks to intervene in the a'bove-captioned proceeding to " challenge the isss ance of an operating license to the Applicant."
4 Applicant does not oppose the admission of the Citizens Committee as a party to this proceeding.
As to all contentions, and especially as to that portion of the third contention involving population concentration and plant location, Applicant points out p0\\D L
s ij \\ v pv~
j
a 2
that the subjects of the citizens committee's concerns were evaluated by the commission before issuing a i
construction permit for this plant.
Applicant denies the first, second and fifth contentions of the Citizens Committee.
As to the fourth contention, Applicant asserts that the systems "for-warning the - general populace, etc." are such that there in reasonable assurance that the activities to be authorized by the operating license can be conducted without endangering the health and safety of the public.
As to the third. contention, Applicant denies that the operation of the plant will be an experiment'except to the extent that it is involved in the conduct of research and development leading to a-demonstration of the practical value of the reactor type within the meaaing of Section 104 (b) of the Atomic Energy Act of' 1954, as amended.
As to the adequacy of testing and study-of the A
plant design and operation, Applicant asserts that all safety hazards associated with design basis accidents-and other major accidents have been eliminated to the extent w,-
, +,
e r
e-
-e-- -,, - - -
4 d necessary to provide reasonable assurance that the activities to be authorized by the operating license can be conducted without endangering the he'lth and safety 4
of the public.
\\
i The sixth contention is more properly characterized as an
%servation than a contention.
Applicant urges that i
these tentions be clarified at the earliest possible
,da.c.
Respectfully submitted, LeBOEUF, LAMD, LEIBY & MacRAE Attorneys for Applicant
)
.,)
-l By
-^
N Arvin E. Upton ;
Partner
'l Dated November 27, 1970 l
1 6
6
+
0
s
. s u
v.'....'
.m v.
.w
...ws.
v.
.,w.
- w. w..., - w V
,.'.w
- i r ss%
e.
- *.- e j
.w..
,-.w....
v..
^
i m
f w..
..)
m
~
3
.. s '
,... s
-gi
.s),
4.-. T g r -
b'* 4 s..,.i..
7v) m
.\\
._- M %
..e4 a ss u.
.., _,a..a
. 1, a. 's.b L..
.,m s. '.),
..'.s.
3,.
- ,... i
. - -...v w.
. L..b.
~
.W
. ~
r,,
,L.awW a.L,
...L,
--- o
,wJ
_w.
.w w..a ww.....
v
.n_.w es ; A., u_ " C... D,,,. G a.,.vw.ww.....
c.
- s.. -.. w w
-3.
,. M-..v y...,,. \\, v.,,
, O.s. a t f.
.s..
.. s.,
s.
.-w.
..s..
wv L,.,....v..e. _ _.c me p
a ma aw w,.*w. -
.w w
w.
%gg,.
g.
&.-w.'...we
.w..e.
h., a ww.ec a,
p q
p.
g, q.
g
,-q,
_g
,e m
g w-7 ;-... -...
- 1.. La _.
m-e w <
w.
u..
..,..w...
'.,4-
.-3.-,
l L. w. L. w.
p?%
e ~
- d
+.
..w,,. U -.
4
, gs m *.. w.e w 4 h.=. A.a."e.
... - -w L=a
=
e a m.,
4 6
w.-.,
w-.w
-=.p v O.t..$.t6...u.h.*s.
gse v
e s
A 9
w.em. t, f*. gm.\\9..v.iw..t.s....
- c...i e
g.u :., u.....s.e, 4
p,%.gp e.
g s
yp g,
s
.g w.,
.v s.
g g
s,,
A eb d,i,.. -* * * *.,
- s. % 6' 2.
O.-
."-9e
- ..*.,*b,
,w.e a
y.
.+aei e
e ga 6-
.w'
..w 4*
d J8 A
n y
=
g i.
g et ww....
..w.
- w...
. ~.+..,
%. w.,.
t.
,,e.,%
6
. (.,. Cew O.s.
%,,. n.
w4 w%
w..-
w w
=
b.e e a w.e **
,.w,
.w e e.,
w#.
.ea a a %d ea g
4*
.s.
gr'#q%e ae+
.h 4L9
.' em 9**4me.a.
Me98.
k *
%8 5
sd.w" U b].9".s.--
i p.
F-P%
n.* s.
w bd 6
w
- = -
-pe g.
g ag,
u.I. w v. w.e.-.,.
- m..e
.wA ;
w.5
-6.
,, =,.
..e,
-- e
.o ww.
p
- gy p
.s e,
.a m
y..,
~w.".b
.". y.
W n' a *..
. = L b' 4.-
- v.. b V t, a.
n
.1 2
s v,
.w-.L wV w..
t e
w.
y
/ *,,vy r~$
5
. ~ -
L. I O.
w,.n#
l
.ff
. -. -. -.. - _ ~. -. _ -. -. -.. _ -. -. - - - -
.-... -._.=..~...._~. -
]
i i
s 4
o J
1 a,
i
- r. c s.:. ;. p.
a..c.,...
- cn h.
C'r as a psrty in this pcocccc. 7 J
c 1-i i
.c a :7. ;;. ec.: f_.:c,.srk outlined talow, i
- h roten cat.
- cn: ions raised by D r ir its pan:1ce.
4 0
1 j
c e r. n. :.r. c.ce
- ..e sc 2rtiot.s the inadoqu
- cy of the :::::nission's i
- .;. f_ c.n e t.. _ ; ; r. o f ut.: ;<acientl Environmen cl Policy ;ct of s
t 1 % ?.
- ";n.?;t" ) cs it relates to this pro
- ceding, and the lack i
4 A
j.
cf cc:c.%i::.nce
.? the Applicant's environmental report with I
the C.T..:.c sion's ' proposed guido1; Tes for implementation of p
i
- 'A published for ccm:.ent on Juno 3,1970 (35 Fed. Reg. 859t,).
t, 7t.c rest of the contentions allege various procedural f
l deficiencies whi.ch follow f cm the above.
Applicant deniec i
[
ca:h o'." CDF's first six contentions.
Applicant's position p
.; thwt therc is no noncon.nliance of the kind underivinc,;
c
/. e :-venth contcation and that thorofore the hearing.ci.n-i.
l m.auly procced and a-valid licenso may bo iusued.
l UDP cuggests' that the CoInission has not complied wi'_h the requirements of NEPA unless the hearing in this
.:rocacdine includes consideration of-a11' environmental.
j t'
F fr.c crs including -non-radiological ones such as thermal.
4 l
cffcets.
.u 1
7-y--*-1*
f g-p N w* m e - tg y y TV-v q
4-qwwyvNW g-ftyw g TM T*w* rwg 9w ypg gmm-f*T*f"E-
"**WC+%W'"*.*M'*FY N 4 W7 T7-43$T1F*
VV t. u' a s'*ss= 4=39#
v4WT e- *e'we--w-+2 e v' v'w-yw eir' = e w t 4 -e=t sww e=M4es t-w
M I
1, i
i 2 -.
r t
s i
s 9
L 1
4 t
e t
'i wi;r ;c t'.*.e encetment of NI1 A it v.c veil 1
i
..a :
.c.M th:.: non-radiological environmental factors worc l
)
1 4,, r.
.c.c ;;rin.ac ;on of the C0mmission in ;;a R.cility
[
t.
1
. ; ; t... ; t.c4 p r o c e : G i c.c s.
State of New lix crhird v. J.te ic E*.crev
[
- ~
l C.-
J c, 606.".2d 170 (1st Cir. 1969).
Wnen NEPA hocame
- w ot.
- :. nut.ry 1, 1970 s re-evaluation of the~ Commission'3
(-
4 4
1 r;;c with respec to those othcr environmental factors bschme 4
f.a c a s t e ry.
Ooth in the April 2, 1970 guidelines and in :the J
Juno L, 1976 propsccd guidelinen the Commission has taken 4
- . c. f ferent appror.ch to impicmenti.ng NEPA on an interim basis tc.-n the.t succccted by CD-'.
While not permitting independent e
i sc:crmint.tions in a licensing proceeding on non-radiological i
i m;;;crs, the guidelines require, among other things, a 31censo 4
- [
c e n d :.;.' c n,which will be contained in the Unit No.-- 2. licenso) to be impe scd rcyairing compliance with applicable state and i
4 Fedcre.1 environmental. standad s and requirements.
It is
?
App.'.iccat's pcaitien that these guidelines represent an f
4 a.
edaqucto interim implementation of NEPA pending Commissio!.
i re.lc en%ing determination on the complex matter of permanent 3
4
- mpiccantttion of NEPA..
- 1
,1 g
}
~
1 d
4 l
Yr l'
I
.1 e
J imm--,
rgr...--
,-y-
.a g
..,y w-
,,yvw3,-wp,f.q-,,,,
,.--rw.,y,%,-,,,ww-,wg,,,,fyr..,,,,%g.,, -.
ww,4,,-wr-ry,wi,,.m.,,,.....,
. - -. _ _ _ _.... _. _ _. _. _ _ _. _ _. ~. _ _ -
l 4
a.
I b.,
2 1
3 i
.v 4
,. n i,..
2.
.s.O w.
04.
..,4 C r...r.
.n..s 1
.w s
.a w a
.v w
4 4
..s
.g.<...
cg
. w g.
..,, 3. g.,.,. 4.,, s..
. f.,.,
.w L..g l
.r c,
.w s
...y g.
a 1
4
.... L
- 4. v... r.1 C,.4 C s. C s3
-C.......
1
... v 4.
.sw.
d M
e
...w egq s n 4.
"w. O p.'* 0 C O C d 4.. 4 C;' Y..i..d. A..
- ..w'a' e
,s v.w...
w i
v.:.
.ay commencen uno.cr present corcussion rulcc.
f If LD.' ;;rev ils on the legal questicr dur:.ng the
-t i
i c ro c. a d it.v, a.c.cro.ariata steps ca.n be taken at that timo s.
1 i
- ; n s :.u o.:u r:n t.;- scesions o:
nc near.g.ng (w,t.n - an t.=cr dmen I
j
- o the No ico of Her. ring, if ner.essu y) to permit all parties 1
s
,ta. :.r
- dec.uc.:alv. with respect to."on-radiological 1
oc.v aron.c.c.atc1 con.siderations.
1:&
F i -
Respectfully submitted, a
4
- 1..
j.
Lo3OEUF, IAME, LEISY & Macr;E i
Attorneys for A.t.elictat I
e J
2 r%
t jm.+
By - _ /.
~ ~--
Arvin E. U+oton 1
i Partner 4
?
9
-.:.:c d :
Novotier'27, 1970 i
t 3-i 4
3 4
}
1 M
3
.f 1
4 k
i
,w%'..-
.e,,,
v.. erc-e.-.--
,,-3:,we.,-.
n
, m -, ee a re w *._ 'r e-e
-.~~.,,,.-ww,,w.c.y, 1,,.
~. -.
y
%,b q.'., Y {N,6,:n
~.... y.. 2 : :.m w :.".:;.i..c.;m~ m,. i..?.:. n.. ?.m '..'x.", 1':. :.,m. - i
- -.r? e.,
j
~
- L box 75 m
s, p j i
e,s.I. x $. v x%,
,\\MA/ bOniaine, New Yo:h 10552 z
x o
+p
- s
, m;. su n,
,.8 te1stSnUdS4h8'
.,et jf
- o..in c o v. i.g.. s./
tety[,tc i......o... o
.mi um g
y
'C$3 fM t NOV3 0 F/0 D g-tmn a tu sme.
,3 hn fim::n;2
)
y'4 ht10 Tuckahoc Road (9-B) s b
W Yonkcrc, Hou York 10710
%y/T id novc=bor 24, 1970 Senuel U, Jonsch Chief Ecaring Exanincr Ap*.. s d'ifEP/E0 U.S. Atonic Energy Comniccion,
- "' ""M UMM C.N Un'hington, D.C.
EO$l $
t DD G 20 /2; 9 10
Dear Sir:
i Origt c.t C W r D:
The F.udcon River Fichernon's Association hereby pon/,@,:.*:Eu nonc.
for leave to intervono in the proceeding at 10 a.n.,
- Dec, 17, 1970 at feckokill on Consolidated Edicon Co.:s applic-ntion to " build" a cocord nuclear poucr sencrator at Indian Point in Buchanan.
The ctory announcing the hearing appeared in our locul noucpaperc on Friday, novenber 20, licting a filing deadlino coven days Inter. In a natter of-cuch import,uc uould have greatly appreciated a bit more notico, Top A.E.C. officials have had lettore printed recently in notropolitan aron neucpaperc telling of-your agencids-great interoct in protecting the environnent. Uc uould like to detail for you hou Con Ed hac claughtcrod our Hudcon Tiiver fish with Indian Point Ho 1, so much co that Mcu York Strto has cued the company for five million dollarc. Clearly, con Edicon ic not corglying uith "other applicable lauc and res-ulations ".
To cicar your agency, Con Edison nuct gisa accuranecc that thoy ui3 3 pt oloct tho env h otunant. '6'hoy hnvo accomp31nhad
,)uat the opposito, no uo doubt that " Lho plant uill bo ' op--
crated in confornity with the application, filed, the lau and the A.E.C. regulationc". In. ite rccont cuit, Ucu York Stato thoroughly agrood uith us in thoco nattere.-_
~
Uc concid'er thornal pollution from Indian point Tuo (& 3) the nost serious problon for the future of our Hudson River richorica. Uc hope you uill allou uc to bo heard.
Very truly yourc,
' O.s-
- o
- uvan.Vvtn w, t
O2,'h Dominick J. pirono,
[ -
9 Conculting Biologict, ERFA, 1.
x
e
+.,, :.m
.....:y
... ~
c.
I,a, m
u
\\
i t., -
t-1 f-]
ls
+
g
-i
. r
.f. : N.
1
_ _..,/,. T
~'
s-
.._,.s.
1
.(
n., U.
(, y.>
'S x
a j,.
s wt 7
,\\
+
t t
rn
~.#,
[.Q O/ u_ k.f.)(},,,./
C.,,/,,,,,.
. ',.j.,,,.., l*.
r*
j
. O' M_;-.JJ
.3 i
................... g~
l
.s a
., ~...............
g
....,...... u
, _ c.
/,,.
y
\\,
-)
i
. %.,,.% w 4
i -
t i,
(s.[,f l **]
',']
\\
j
- *. O V"
/
- N,
/
l I,
b)'=,i.t 4
qi e
i s
x.2 J
.u. M.... p., :.i l
\\
t 1
i i
h ll o
1 i :
.~., m 0s l
i.
o 4.
4 s
y 7,,.
7, lp ;3 g.- ~ q.-,g y,
.-) g ; g
- 4 1
\\'
\\
i.
s
(,/
I l
i j
l l l h j/..i I
..h'/.
.\\?
f N._l_ t._.. _!
.-._.i.
i 1
4 j
._ ~
-.s
.....,/ '_, g.,2 i
,,e
,, e,.
r,!..t - --
}
g W. q.t,.,. q, q.7,+
i
...,jG,. _t
,1
.. _..m.
.p...
- (. _,
.a i
-~ -..
1
'.N V
l. j.
1
,,*"N*q' n -w
+7,
=
.o i
(l. A2 4 k.. p.r. s,es,;. f. -
~.)
.U. e. )
n,,) % s 1
\\
f p.
s.
.o
\\ '(;M r} -.
t).%
,I
.,.i a.
,j }
a v
4 s
l i
e
.4.--
J.v a---.
1 m..,--
.-~.._..4.ov m~
f Chsed Fct Refrena;
/
.-The ph.nt, the LCdy comp *//
p"LQW.g.*1 Richud L CH-l.
ntw.e.
sa. %
Nr. uo has repes;cfy cr@
SEW YORK O _ New Yc:k forms of Inalir.e 1"e and so M'N8U M
Cd D "#T #"c eec E,. "U g"d e'[da r$n E" w r$ #
UW' F l
kri, his Ced suit askig tbt f tt'b' ol tri t
j[ds fue
" ixd ps r+ emed thd tM Mni M C:w.3:att Einn's tuekt.t.
4 cya on kr a:
Ccct::In!ca to tc the Mas i
y and pretatir: pt:n a: In.
- t sisc"S$ bt 1.e al'oned m op/t.
cia Nn Enchen be cloud uc.tb !.iterr.ny reneni nys..(ast n,ge,w u opacae.C eneg Ccn J...nn s cASn c, R2 -
Um et &mm o jm i
t=1 t 31Ee neicds are Mr.*;
No dato kr e he
. p" i:p3 3.* f Men s[r*g of t% f * "
- U'?
8 'I IUh dV" D N'S*n '8 T#1I Mb
^
I' to pre. the ',Wn Elvu and
- y. de'n. Lods 3. Leibv..
bY.b"P'Y'?"* N ' N TM N *# N l
I f J I.O
'n"jg ;.Q j;;l'y y g y ey b Q vl M ",j,n l"} b'f f# ' D,
,"h
" I'*
W" H '* D #7 f
[
fra 1.a. Ctd in state hparta tueTW-
'D r
- y'- ~-
s
' 'U ',' # gW V ' r - %
es fr* fish F~M ts 1Nnn nM Yta i C<.:.~.; e3u;n gr%s viW *n
- "8""'>
- cn in d.t'"c,+the p!;.ra,s "cpra. Musn'e.?'"s nie""sc.u f inh t )
i.
ci e - m m '.en e s e n E2 sys.ca t. 3 y..,.k d. '....*. p..*. )
' t "a#' "' 3. ""'.o"'*
"""~ ~6 * "Cw.m c.. %-... w y, e a resd:
,i -
.o rc..7 g.
g-F.<Uef L:s le e.wmt-d *- lem v.ts reprt(d v,acd by ;a.w
-o
. w es'.n "n
'.",y-",
~ r --
P*
n
"+
~
sexenin wba riv:.: wati.:
5.ex.tevv Duna;;ea o - s c'.-a
.'~.i
- .1. jng. cctnV.an** w"as bued c'" ws 4
- ' * ~ * * " -
~- 3 8.he drawn no tM thnt K0umt a o. ~. 3.m.
4
^
1*
t'. s t"*.~.
u".esi ) e s:e*. 'aa a
w-.
s.
ggg 4{ {j3h g;g3 yp 37ga
.4
- a ed, Ge:eral chargte yg. p.g gy g 9, M*r. *T*
i"
' cf fis,i kCS
.eg.!.#'.n5 tu.s year, cea -
cur ic.21 pw ;, int:c2 ca '.
j t'w
!.=:r.ey
. dm t#
gy. : e gn;g; m rg
- Pcb: cperp 4
t.:.t f
~ u""oc"".iab"d e-u 'a
.,u,, F.m r mum in a tmS tMdowa r!
C e. 2 v-
.E n
- r. wa *ctutir se:Re c;n, w0 w '
p~,. t"vs
,~
c e
- c e m twe-t&:s t' ter-M std chemit:a ;pr;1 LM c5ti'.0:5 fr2i=u in hn-ci mx: us ste w-u.1-q:
a 3
y..n. r.n in the IMsca.Jte" -
-A 8 c.C, m g,' C ~' '
- ~# sc *+
M (ah re.n.. '
OC E d N I,6h W D kuna ef N.)
. s.u, w.....,.., m d...;.,. %
. e.
,.3 3,. u. e. n..... -
a'-
satd.v* uur.) ""he "we c""e' c'.uaren ;t v2s dus.d the 4 55 A. :,,,. ~ w c "t
'e
.m 2 -
g.<.g; t.n g,.s3 3.s
- c q..n cornrr.cnt on t alle
- st!.s s"
7.:
"A"
-.... 2, J7
-~ "
4-p aci., es ne ;r.unded tr..ca rnade hen.sa we are $!ill re. c'3 r[CO N5
- 6%"'3 CEh4 W:an* 10 th iJ200 ".
- ?
Powe ca:necis in te M.r.
- m. 3 esth d*fedea to wah-
- u. nu<r.,,
.%... p pers.., s gA. as I yo.,... n t s.
'O- '3 %.,'
N.,..
I D c rce v ste in,m at.d chtharp. kr.ow. ;W is 16e first interb M s=
.g,'.,.','('.,e,.,.m.--.'.-
tu
- hy;o l.nn m no th p ;c : ;.
M*t
- t*Je tb INdHfi E M.t g o..,.g.,.,.,,. g g.
~
.,e.,...
p
- h. E.;C,S. 3 In&tt'r 45 t$ S VD d t.u..s c..,,a...
',~ 'r:
...4.-.-,';
dat h c;c na.v cf t,,e pre g.
r y.
.. ~..
tr.e..c.....g c ! !ah n.d c:sen a.: a ;;rm of n.,, r.: u y r comw.y cn:. s. :e,,.,i=a has snsnvm.on en t.mme n :rs wnia ct pv.a su::.ps ::
}
pc:.': ps;r..t2 haurs ta n.:J' trxr.
I
/T. j7'W f"%
g}1. 3
{
~~~~~R Q y^}'~ 'N
- }
9' N r
d Y,; 4 g N; g s\\ ] > % 2)
. _J
\\\\
n.<
- NN s
c g
1.
t y
. yt. x x 1
i s g-N.,g A
V 1
-.c.
L L:/
.LL. -.!::.
J.-.,. : &
PEEKSRILL. N. Y., WEDNESDAY. MAY 13. IMO -
-t
.e.-,.-,ere-,,,-,ve c----+c
=. -
,,y
,~--r w,--w.
,.reve.--t-e-y-w=*-
--w<..vea w
<-=,--v-~ea1*w w w-o m -e.
.s-%-
mw.v----*t
-r
-.--e
-e ma s r.w.
e-. " - - * = *
.e w r* 't
n.~-.-.~.
. ~ -
- - ~ - _... - - ~ ~ ~
a.n
---+n_._-
-n,
.. - ~ ~ ~. -,.. -
}
I r
f
-p*"'
.e a.
L
- .5 i
s
=e.
/\\
g
.f g ( tw n;.. - s.. w..i f.
- s. e e..9
- . '/
t,/,
y sa -
m i.b, l e e* o t. e m.t,.
l t
- 2. tu..,,. c. es, u. u, i.
,g ne.
m -
.u...u.
v
, ~ _ '
i 4
<}
f%l
' *-'*^~-..,;..,--..n.
.~
g
)
,yj \\'? f ~
[t g *y n..
h.D$IekY
- Ws' b
^
'l e
h.
[
y o,.
j s e tie, a a.',
p:.
i n,n p,.,
/
y,_,
t.
n-
. o. o.e y. / W av 4
v.
.,a.
a m
!p f
. m(ds....*g.. s ;i a.. -@' A v, 6j..'. W W s
i nw.om A:-
m s
.Nvvv'
- t. m...-:
...u m
s G-)
Ura :
.u'. M e l
w.
1
....-.~. # _
r,
c,,
=,,..
1
.,, "y 3.,...< '
n
[
f..., C e.....
C'\\
C=.:1 10 VW j
3 m"i,3lg t m'
. LIM,18,1 p 0 seuer k, is an m mt t9 17 thi.W.!mn;:..
+
~?i
.4 p
l v4 :t.:.M %:nt zu
?-
- c..
5 nl rst thunkt " L. O:Unj l
':h ; ;'.+r.t 7.:n :'.,
[i
. L, U U w C i);:)
o f.or lut rumb t.C'.7. MiDE totionce ite.
A...o..d e.,
}W,a c.n..,.,f-A OnUC I N' fly (
4
- s...
....*,..I..
C} i;: i,/ ', c.-,m.,n d ec.u..,.c.n m.
..t._.
. O.
- t cr W k'.
t "o k".d..
p'm'g g.,e y" ',",i "' "nt cFP"'"r:a' n Q"r.'M:.. _"* ;;r: *,*. "**
L' y."
-.. +4. y..
h t... i s.,.,.,i
....-..ptL(-
.l h r*e c m.' wM te t
a testra:ning rn naa.: y.
's p *.,. 3 9l.$ h N, t '6'
- k IM ~I' I ^ ! Y **"* " ' " ~ \\
,gy I
piratbn of tb p' Ant tatil it; i
f ey!'f j* *r C*
' D.U ' ' 2 i.J E.s * * -
i 4
can de.r.antt:A.c the., cpr.nm.J
- L.
Ia r
t*
v -
}
+,4.~ m ~..'c*.
- fu m f
- W,.~.
g.r e..
egymd g 7. y,.~..
.., 4.( f,.!,.g s, f f} r,ym^
m.
'!4 the $wt ided.<tsterd ",.
e u".
.u c'.cm, p.q 3. L.., p"y,"
6e Atte.r:u y Ger.a:.t 6,3:pe s
f+
+
g
.. ph... (t.
3 p...g
.)
ycer,heg, go. cinWh@d:an,,
.A InMa Po;nt o;:f tn { ;
Con Et t.n t.I,.
d 61 iM
.o
,.n g 7,..g n y.
t m a m s " n ean g 3..;; c cen.;
E_dison t a e ds, the-le g.p.. g4.,. s p g..g. s Po:nt P51 n cu;td c i w ce g me w meg,
gg
,m
. pro $e:e "aMut 3 par cuit of
- Wh:Uca in the lh. hon itiver"i S Thuc rt.t in ilta.
-nd "en&mrin the ccein;y."i t i com:nu l ram con IT q our to:011.ower pter:. tic.; cp "Uun raltWe r-ethods anh ' f I Lut ?ct.1 C:n R..*
w ' n:te Ms chr;:d i,A, paahy on an ante.1 bans ndpocedces :e knhe:ec *,Mh...*
.J L,.,, e.,O., g,..,
- O.at si ht R0.'/,0 f :'.
esaun; sp fraa de h:t d:ys I :en k.tef EC:M W."
j l
b l
will enaNe (!c!cndant to wM.*
i
- C.w Ord Idinn Cenpy of 53Wer we tJe n
- rem b :
j
%c..h 3.rba. v:cht::ns c.' 4ini f.o emd about shutW down' draw wa:ct from ud ditehtt:c'. f. h j An.10 e !:s P.M..
er an wat:r into the lh;dron Rweri !
pian: 3.;t thn tct.-
.* E
,,..s gn L.. c,.
. ; ina G.s.em.ttb,no, the,d cmvin::: in such a in:nner a to aw ( l s. s.t 7 m.....r. J...aj p w"at:5 3 in1kes av;9,.5.60 h.ga ; the kiiun; of dsh and other ' i.
!- tuat; cts WIM n ib u
c
._...s.o.
3w3 sy.
tehud the fN" n..
t.tbh to the I i ins
.r..
t.,
n.
c
.. a Pact demands in the Newl forms cf r'.atia life ud to$ ffurther avo;d enc':.n;:ering th urJh:nt ::;:r.Q:-
Sysar:L'*
,';.:::t at hi!:n Mit f td tub 3 i
{cs: th3 phr.: to c:ued un:!b
- ' " ' * ~ ' " ~ ' '
v ' *i
- aa rnthis" to picten, b!k City re.nroplian arca;i ecotory r,f the Hudson luver."
p
", s.v.:
& cu o:..h* c %
1 twe. tne Anc:r.cy Gu t 0.'-l M.va b:tn trsing the, power i.t
.ual- : *)
3.. a., c.. t:. a e can 9
..ro..,.a.: capteny c4 tae sys.
e.m 1
r a numt:t c.t yezrs ' his~~
[ t,*
1:; a ter;!&.! C.ed by M] tem %r 4, n,,.,- -.
s*.d tah cornNey n.d stue!
h'o dite for t he/tig t.f the' (i )
~ /
l i
l Ing. C;nt:d Loeis L Lth (J!Mals :me scaned cf pecu' charfes hss tern ut.
y:W#l
,?
..t;'sce nlntat>O pccr ShDN;M, in Fak Jcvee%s hittnwhi'e, Cen:Midated t
i "
p'r Edis:n ofhctals Mir.t out 0.tt hou:s thu su:raner ; r,p.,,,.
the Inht PciM s.hnt h.:.,s ban D.4 S
C:;;:. :. e"g.fu sine :.'r t u:g..#.. 3.,. y.. -- (.S I
fu brak tilG C n F,
- W..
s.
E n & d w n..mo
.y w
., ~..., g..
p..
.,..;g,u..Jud.,g. di o ;'t gc : m. ints ;
..a.- ia n r ir.t drew ccmpa fuenng"
.r.d it r c: rece:cd f
-r
.:l I
. :rs.
(4 f,ish kes and damp to tha; to te hc in car:m.n 'fcr at 3
ec t*
Ictst u.cth u w t d.
. [1
- c;<
h, p,,., $,,i,.,. '.
l
- ins :: tn by 0.e. N.t:,rney? h., A,,.3 cf the Matt:n hNer.?
. 1 w :
j
.r, IE*a 1: w
..g N *,,sbyt,40t,d,n ng ;g i
t Jg
. h...... r. 5 C e. c. _........ p i u
.. v....r ~ u u....g 4. a:p.3 d
33r.j! wcic cwe 1d w
4 t
.,,4 e,...u-hi'h im*.id t2iti th!:; year h, ;g iN.. e[ Oh 5 bb N
j YNIEr dT !
i.-
,a n t.u:.u ar.um: ;unt;. nne so:va ty nueunw
(.0_....., s... m.. L TO:!,%,
. q *;gt.4 Nfg ;, (,~
.s.
4.:
Terbk : n.d em u a: ch:rges;
'~'
n a
~r Two scntut Luances et I.
[ ~ a,[..i..w &
f:$h -hMla - wc'e r:pc;;ed this! ' ThC A**.t'iCEn Herite,'t iC*
f l
w -.i. q p
~ *.q.. W*
- t '-
year. cath ruuhin m a bricij cle:y, w' ors :mtters incMe a
4
- /.J./
/" 7 : _ :cra, t /
%. :.w d:K r shuidmyn of tFC cpernmns, j Tc cer: and eccis c4 Ar >
can 1:c:::;w rn:;nine, y.:s.
41
%. e ces.:.t ccr.~tSt en de The CrstJ in h uary, res.:h4 nnoun;t i the w:rb Ii
]A li Lh. ~ N., _
'%~
p y.u.s~ -.4 w
- In de Elig of ato;;t 151C06 terday :f l; ;,.g fish It rc:;uired a cher;c tr.; nets o Q conserv: tion 9 j
- p. e "s.7..!.es.'C..,'.I.
.,,.T:a gse scg
. re p.
3."
d th
%3.0C0.
5n.
- l. T.
t;.::nmn for Ccnt:ll sercens cas?;ned to futer fin' aw:r s to s t:
a
.e cut cf the we:er iMah ;s: era
. The top pib.,*:3.C*;D. vai l$ q,.,p.4 gnW U-j,.'T,
_. 3 l
Nd
~~j md ufa,J as far as. 1;- h V:..ch 120 E 0 fah t c re.j awtrdd' D 48 hh Cta..
3.gt b ?! firn Intet:s:! W kmed f:- en codis.
Servn.t 3 Sc:.cP/. n0 greg h, 3
},ff;;"',",,*/ - ~ " ~.C;; Z f g,
l, 5'.::! *"enktor,m is work:n; to po nt G.c j
- *'.. th
- ...~~.,.
- C ne ' 2"s ci j there s.y 39 T
sate's, r.nvr3. c v;r n: ent, "1 ' g
' W=I s
- , "th5 CVradn, e.1l tmOns?-Th:g3h g g [e. {j3h gj;*$ p n.Wh:ch N eCnWtts 10 I t.
b
"'?
e<
- f. ' OMSI ~' T N *25
- ~;-
.J.i
.f.:t
%. r,er d.: W d e v A t-r.. ern ta e-.phinu in n ecn.
thrensned by the recent c'r.
h 45: ~Cven-i.a L-covery cf oa rmeves en tre e:v ee,-. h u. k..-e. - y - m~ J Nct.h E.cp
~
3,d.
Con Id D.u ce ?
n - f...= s nn
~. -
p 7
m- -
4.tc ccn.t The sucnd 7. e. !!0.oA U rze en cr th ;
d M.,.vg..,..............,,4 c;t rv and w m. 5 +
......u..,.~.
b a.r.,a as
- m.ne r,n p t:..
wn ect:-d:d to the B1 i i a..
3 ]_ n,j7f;.p. n, npr2.n! ** rn &*. 3 t znt muc
- in n w x a. n cf w 33 f.c a ta;
. ; :.v a.::t Sr.c:mr.mt W.m mec,,
m:ha.f d city, n, er.rh i3 v.crky..;.
.m.M ;n 0,.:7.cipcs s req ( n;wa $:.aes-se.te, putt.6 hfe refuy _
. wi d l 1/
i-
.e<: n.r.. c hb _ a :n-2:.Tr. a candidu: kr the, to s ve a :;D.On.:
plj; i N Mt::M 1Ael cn tre c:te%
'I~n:::2 ;ri:c. O C03 wc-t to l
l.
D ~L
.t-sith 'The A:tmy G3ntren: the P;f f "W;m M.m 3
.'?
...mt $1r. Oair Nr't. cfike said-tW C ' -
.n.N e
'y i
t 3-c
- - - +
- - - ~ ~ _..,
m,,,. j J _,
_ ~._n.
.~ _ _ -
- - - -. ~ _ - - -..-.--..- _ -.,
i
'k g
r
- s + 4..g ! f.s (r
.s...r=
a
\\
./
%. h-
- g.wn.t. ? s. *...',.* ;s) :.E.*. * ".. < "*.N....f. v.;.', . s a..~
.1 t,y ti e
.s u
i
,,. /
y'.
s-
\\ W Q ?g.d 4 kW t L.s y*. s.,..
.e
.j.
h
.g W'
l U..
I.
One 6 4 4.
. 'Wa., * *L1 1 f **]o
- * = '
a
(,
-m
(..,..
e v.h A
.e.... -.
L : e,. e e e.s i i e n. u. e * *,;
. em
'n.,..o n..
.e. s y
7
.s
.,?
w
- c. f,,,.
,.-.s
.]
.:.7.u.;.,. c.
y,-
.,.4,ei>t,.s L..
\\ r.,.
1r.g.7 +v..s; >...,;v.
..eu..~..
v s,
.v G
./ c
~.
Q,
- te s,e w s s w -,.y us ar.s.
s
=e i
6.'l t* *,%,
g'O #
r-.eA.~..--,--
N.? 9 M
.U.W.T AUOUT E E.MOH ? *.mn 4 *.tc,c:-is t in..w hi.",t w. 8
- r. t. i ?
=
~
-,.v.
-.-.m...-
. ( y **
m.. & e, y
1 e
- y.m
.f p
p a
s...
j ' u v t c,S v m :.>
- w..,..;qv.no
,eu u..::..; u, s.,nns.,.,f a j M..O.. c.s. a,.r..-dqq e,
,. GT, n..
c.
n o
.x v u ca. p..
c n.:
u a
i
~
l
, v:dd U mup itu.1 tairk r.:wd to do:,1 tt:t,J:.ts ty m *,y; : c;a ~ ;;. y, t.,,
ty W.:Yl.T * *.!.L
, cons in the Fesert 2.!:uti:.n. to.: r:L M.
' ser.se is c cep *d: *.:0 :.
um..y r...y!
whde 7.F-ts disnt:W t.x
'O.
n !: * *c +- :. 0;;h (m dt:a! kn en f 1..:. 1 *f::
I
!.05 ASC%IS. C: L
-AN tusen !Dmmion en:! two bd tcE
- . = T:.mA tr.d thct: ":r,. ;*c*, m h ?
, nusuu wt c:u" : ant :r, urts em c: thu: uJ am.
t
_. :.v
,... m m crcn:hy bu:n An=t 4
b:s ben dm,nf 1/ Tent: 4ct s;ttial requirements ted ~Ti;~ ~~ O U. %v*"ch c' e.3=.d:.::':% YW ::r.tt
-- L Xim'..Y 'I U P'* I 6# CI'I I#'##!# I t
cfheT.* ts th: 2"::: ::=@0
- d4 6sp:mn M thir 1.,U y ph.....,, ".? 'tP! neEnL W L&T : v';:w.cus v ho! C,u t n !:n!y p W.::n :p th:
% w.
.Y -
pesan :!: w When a seet!cn c! she::;!r (CE1P -
rehn u Tc:.:::: (.:::: d-
?
j!:nt putrv:ys.r:m p.ar v..W ::thd r. ue ma! Ep; ::,td vcatcr c,u:!:y tr4,..:rth, n
t u.t ::ht: 1..:um:; ::.: ::.:::: c: ty;;,,;;&n g:;'.t) s y. hy 7
~
l'r.d,cr,:h3 p!:
- n 131c n M' }:ERALD 37AygntAn, yoggy, 3 y,,
ogg, j,g;, p,.
.. e..t%.c.3 L r, f rm....... ~.. e k.3 emic.. :.' c..u m :e we..j:c
-. w-.....cdnc,0.;g 3.,3~-
gny y
....C.o,..
g r
w - --
.........L,.o.. sA S t.
C.. L
...,. tv. I -.w
+.. -
9
- .=t < f but th:". cn th 'w~f.de ce now M C,W f.[O,d.ufp b %.) C. U L + b d'.d... N,O M
h
- '" ?e c. f.+
e3w3r n.
int 3 a p:.T:='ar g(2s:hu;ct U
/.
. :ca c! wae Sca. u mtss.j g-2.--4n1 of 1 hen 2.udE
. ca:nng2; het vmer in:o ute lhch din; ::M:s./ s:rn.s :.nd* :.!!ch!pn. Ecy a:ect.t it:
T'1 'l I
& Q )W [? Q [.[
by,:f)
Tr.c tmw L ci h:a :l.nu;yl ysq.,I thovt 75 ter ent cf the}n (AQ ),
l'mun!::;4 svare f.n.*s.
y plag in:o a wn::w:y ficnq 1.cr. y:.m.
estaM!sted dischi :e ::.:::a Ele :n: pneratin fac!nties f /? Qyf a v'i^b.M p*y[
i-y d^
fn a gitcn ares :%s w0 C:. ; 2re (c4hn: estry decade; p/ w p.
g",, y m a o,*.
- k33;t be ccwe'. ansl h,s n."...N;y"
- gg**l'"a !.Y.#3,i [ hem :m:! ear-tre a R!chttd L. Cat'.nprh!d W.:y tc.cre pwer p!stis.4 e c.; WasiWOTW 3C':Sb-Rtp.
'f'l u gY,. hak u J...
j I.t te
-[h EA $ $-[ N,. U.*'
D.
.b k sit 35. Ob[.:
$iI N
h*..
s y a Pem an whh the e.
p y%
Ato:nie L.ct:y CamW.on to
....... ; +-" p "c,u t..a& *.v r ~" r?",h.,.s. c"5, den)* Cunw".t v. y.,.s g..n._,
Ik e..a
. c../. o
~ye wt;, a gn r
ted o.enn Co.
3".a yp'Er','ta ". r * * &' ~y2
. cc. _. ".
.u.r..._<.
~...... L... n. $.
t the A.
...,,..(..,....,.. i. s..
n.
..,a...,..,.
w.. s. y,.
t, w
m gy o. A. t..g 3. s.'#
w. '.#,#
., w. u,-
t,6.
$.~..o..
....-.;2.......
s.a.Wa St.iite esh:'um, Tv 9 p'xcr' sla"nt num' 'u""r one un,til k","'-*.--^""
'* -L In the e (J h a " w:
1 u -- t -.-
.,L,.n. m.... ns.3
,.<...u. + e, u. :-'. ;,i,..r' int o La N *
- i;^"'
w y...-
m.
.s., F fc' s:ur:es, W ? ;1.l:Ma th:t; 'ce's cntmin fm" @'n yeps,s'nd M' 1 O't
- :.y n:.tn n:,:
^
's * 'cQa aoup"is caped.
thC j 10 >
'iuo :::=* n s 0l:u L : -
C wi.I t c w
- W MP *a m.
'~~":, t n L.
y Rher raner rn,3 /m:: n:.:
t'cdr s:::.r. 2:
'T W Nnk Inc.. h!chact J. Cs.rre:: ;nd N'2.p:np sdd tw sbee cac:gr3 p;,y,;3:e, 3.y ;;,g r 3Ld?dD.
YDe effects of the rch::ed In '.c : '. "..*..*.C..h...M, %..%,,
,.3.g s.g.indM,h;st..,ex.a.is. :.
th c
Pot p gas nep caz,7 3 ;;,7g;,33 3
' 1 rew!atlet on 4-m 1:
.+s ar.
- b. s. :1, nn,. r.at - ft.:o openten in *M t'.e n* cc.
y
..a _
tr.:dides ha*ce r.ct te:n..c :nM.]It h:ub
.4
..,-~m.
de:. raved ry.re ti.e.n 8 dA tC"a N ~ ^t h" w"-
c...,,
-.-~m--~-
% %.;.* Su *... a F"~. w' g.t :n.dcs c mmerch,?.y cawne thur rchut tcdir s te..:-
i wwn,.:. ue c: mnS.. ' " -
se-%*< ra.5h h.at ltat 15 uNtate preaud by ~ t '~"tsit - ~*"I "iL m.. ~..: c,.2.%....~ a..,.,.. v.....
Din"ase L:hwcry: s: t.e.
g,*y 7,*...n ' - a ty c; W W m *,to P:""f*,?" 5 by i
-:.nd :::m 1:.*;c c::.ven:::::.
g**
T tLve G.Tre m4*t rieen?
ard Er.He w,r. 'c; YJ.1 bodved M 0 !sh c.d T'sh i.
pvcer ;...:s, ure c n e r ps. W u + '.* * -.j cffi&:s c; We*
&*.cis, occuned.'. Wen G and *, ?.ep.
the Depriment c! t.Me h:er.
.., c,.ued cen,.at:nce uith efh,d*,a 0; tin er srode QSdn 2nd Indi25A g*
ore
- .cf..%
. tn i r - < > -. _ - a, ;,q V/st:
"'. c + +u" c" e" " -
u. r ' v' h e '
The study, bmd on sf.::,..
s s
o.,,..
.ct..,
e
.f p' " ' r "*"]
s!cs c, :.sh MceW p.:::n3 s.
E w *f.Mn
?:cy.l:g c! On Fedctd Water Qu:ll::.
_, ' * - r s ! t a i
' Ad'ni7dt:r0*.On nd the F;Ih &*.d
- I N T
">'1 D p*g g; g "., y *s- -.. '
- g.. a's-,,., 8
.te. %.. ! c. ~..r.. a' &e "..*
t".. _ % ;.gg
$ 7yg y _ gggg d:
- m s-,
's "rr s3
.g
' *,. g cf $uch. n~Y 14 3 s '. h;d - T - "w-* *u'"*.Cs
/
a ;tGre' t m'*e**of Ve r'. i.. A. 'f '?leS W.' "* *J
,C:1:
W Ct** 10 13 ;'t ctr*. c.; 3 7..
' e 7**M.I e3o.
ev.-
e o > - 1 pr la W.
l C
. +-
e
...%... L
.s...,.........
'u W.. %..~ v. c 0 c...
Gn.n x.t" P"c 7 ~~*"- "-* 44t-
.eed b; a n I' * *~a" "P. " --
g., m,....
W;**
g,7* i
.s w.u.
c.-.--
%. m., 4 m.,
g.e.....g...
1 tMhni:d c;mm%:...e cc.,ec s em
..w.
tl ters.
..a, w';. e emr.: ::, a.mni?l? :Sec:
to work
,Nge:en p...e7 py,.g m Q, 4 '; a
' q ; ;.,
'N,9..h. "2.l '.3. d ' %. L il p t, p:tt@.vl e r-"
t %+
- u' 8c "L";.* -
' 'I cc3 g3 ;; ;f,g! n p3 nt, g3
..v..s....... L....h..
..... c t... c.
- P-W. '
+,
e.e %.
....i, y,ed.:,ra: rcr:nn,tedvcs h:d pre.! f.~c 75 M
tna em" O C M m ' :
t C.
4 F
L:
.,A +-
a ve m. 7.
4. n.... g-. ~..,.., s.
J.u,. e,_.. m. $ u..,. E.g ; -.
o.
.u a
..6.
.2 i
..p..,..,.....
regnsX. 4: :*: 1.;.
r,.
.r.~.._...
w..
f'-
8
,l.--
.a=
d.m.
l l
2
-6 I
...m.
.,,_m,.
....m_,,,,.r,.
_m.,
_.,,.,w..,..,_,m.,,,
-,..,..,-,.m
,.~,...-~-.,..-y.
..v.
J l
a i
4 N',
\\.
a s.
i e is e* * ; ; }. t.t -. * ~. s.t.* ~. g *
- J
- ? s t-s-
e ( r e r =..y /...y r
- 1 a*a
- 1. v, s
.s s
.s s u s.
v.s s
t 00l iw f,
c,..g..,, oc. 3.
) g,- c.m
,t.,
4 x
~, -
v,-..n,.
-et' r.
g, f,
..,.,...i..
l~:::. ~
v.. on. -!
.p s
. m.
f s
v,.,.
w.
...j.
l
~
f) a
- 2. s.
1 e <
.g 1
,?*
~.
, y,s)o p
3
,(
s i,
.a.s v
i r
?.
i
\\
.e t.
i 1
4 1
.a
~.
i i
Tl!B !!!:V." YORX 71h'ES, s
TUESD/.Y *M.TC:l H, H10 q
r C ci.. W. ~ w% y.<, y; a.
a s,( w s,t, s r)YCw~'~$
- h. j d, a:.
n m
r2 t
6s m
o:s.
a In inawer to e,cenions aMut fish 1. ins r. car Lte Indian Po!nt j'
nt:lett p::r.t.
!.uce f. aid there hd Lun n.;c1rar ecs.
l terni=tica tr.vched and he fered to rep'ne the rt. ore th,tf.
n
]
2C'),000 f.sh esti~.::ed to b se i
teen kmed it, two seprate !.1 a
a cidents s'rce J:n.. P.. d t ht t v5 '"- H e' < -*"
- C.'* '
.- r,-. 6 pany (3 "+ =
s.*
{fj V.?' r; c i e i
.. - - - -. ~ _. _
{
We have only been I t
s cr e e...ing for
- i. m v a lz-,., \\ '[ }
l c,.,,
YE!.~4S1!1 N5
.n I)d'i7 ns ti y 4 7,,. t p i
n
.a T'
- l.-l14 ~
- j i idi ' *. *?m W
\\
j-
_.,.F....
. :;f 3
i g8i
, % ~ -..
9,~.
y :. ')
1
.(v.
~
j f
N 1
l
(.c)- '
5
(
N
\\ s,
.. ).
,.3
.ss - -,....,-. ~.,,,,,*- " **i,,
tf-s
< m, a
\\
,O
.t
. y.u;... p...- h,*~s
. ) ; e.. ::'. -
. 1 /,,
ar
\\ \\ r.*.
~.
a j '.,_..
C, c,
u
.-,.__.~
_~
gr,t*,
l
,j. *...t.
p
/*
',-..%,-~.
. C p r' C'
- ~ L '.', ;.,f*
-.~
... a i...
. L..)w z
,.y..r-..,
-p) -
%- e. -* v o
L
,l,,
.A
~
,.., )
~, a (l...?', ;j;,,, h J%l li!:e vi fliank you fcilo.:s for firinging fliis V, iny attentie.'."
~ n8 e-e i...,,,,,...,..
./
- i,,;
.m,.,.,,,
-:M.
-..i.,....,..a:.g;,;
.,1,.
...s..I.,,,.,.,....
L v,,,
. ~..
j g
L 09 4
\\-..
\\
n., '.,. < a 3 3 r. o,.
$q,' p \\.;.s., o..
,a
<g
- li v
,1 a
t. ;.. i. i f-
,g
- r. o r. i,s
...a vy n t
- e..d u.-. tq { P!n.n.c'ai
- l * '-
bl....it'
% i:
.jAls ). ' 41 e r e/ %l
.s: s '.
- 1 **
.1 1.
I41i 1 M su. I u:i o.
I s, s.
1111: ).,
f u.s.
.. s u i Utiu i t: t Oi... i i I :.
1-
.ir
,)
t-L: w s
.s
.e a
.se s -a -
>\\
t..
'* : s
.-,ai m,,,...;.i_
.....n-c...,
t:
- ,,. i
,1
.,iy
~
e
- c;,3s.,,.
, j e n.. i i. s., i.,.
1 i....
v,
-., i er
- .< r un <- 1 n e bu t.... n r r. ".
n - s
.7 i-ai.
-ic
..: 1 -
..i c.! r.
j
, l II. *'[ ! 's i 1 jT * *. )
.A }. l
- n :,:. v. :.
.,a. ;..., s.., < : > m - n. c
.v.o-
. x.. <
t-
. '. I 1.
('
tl*
-).
giDTL@
^
tocrtito t
- IGLC
~
Q NOVS 0 D70 La 9
tff'tt il 11* $** t'i?
ft'.) t it;tnis 1
trt n d d.
g\\
ra]L,8' i. a a i.s., > < <.
8,,
i n 1: tt';i ti i ct w I
.W d h t) a e
W
\\,(I t.g *I e, *l i s il \\. 4.. '.
g'. 7 J
- e
. )
{
.it.le..d g
.t, ii l
I 0
,i I
_ _ _ _. _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.. _ - _ =. _ _. _ _ _ _ _
%*l 7s!
l'303.bU.T}L,[%{>[,Q
!J/
e
- 'l...l. ' 3'.y
\\.*
.c i
1
- f!0v 3 0 ti7O ( ' c M'd n..w rm q
i n'gl 7
('
U U TED STATES OF /M.KICA 2
8 ATOMIC EMER, i CO:MISS]O;?
In t he Uctt er of the
)
-(05SOLIDATED EDISDN COMPASY )
DOCKET NO. 50-247 0F 1 EW YORK, INC.
)
PETITION TOR LEAVE 70.1HTERVEHE BY Tile STATE OF KEN YORK Pnt s.u nn t to Section 2.714 of the Conmission's Rules of Practice, Section 274 of the Atomic Encrgy Act of 1954, as amended, and in accordance with the provisions
.:w of the Co:tmirision's Notice of Ucaring dated Kovenbcr 33, 1970, the State of Neu
-York,- acting by and through its Atomic Energy Council, hereby-petitions f or leave to intervene in the above captioned proceeding and become-a party thereto upon the following grounds:
1.
This proceeding is to consider the application of Consolidated Edison Company of New York ior an operating liccuse which would authorize ~he operation of Ccn Edison's Indian Point Nuclear Generating Unit No. 2, in the Toun of Buchanan, Uestchester County, Ucu York State.
2.
The interest of the State of New York in the health and saf ety of its
_peopic requires that all matters pertaining to the saf ety of _the.nuc1 car power plant proposed in the above captioned proceeding be thoroughly considered.
3.
Under Section 104 of the Commerce Leu of-the State of Neu York, the Atomic Energy Council is given the functions of coordinating regulatory programs of the agencies and instrumentalitics of the State aficcting atomic energy activitics in Ucu York, of voordin$ ting the ~ participatio[ of the agencies and instrumentalitics of the State in the regulatory p.ocesses of the Federal
- Covernment aficeting atomic energy activitics in 'New York State, and of coordinating the presentation of vicus of _ cuch agencies and instrumentalities for consideration s
by appropriate. Tederal agencies.
4 L
A 10 ? f.
4,
~
2-1 The name and cadress of the person upon who.a service in this pr oceeding nay be made $s:
J. Bruce }!acDonald, Counsel Neu York State Departucut of Commerce 112 State Street Albany, New York 12207 Pctitioner respectful 3y tequests the Corrnission to grant petiti oner status as intervenor and party to this proceeding.
Itespectfully submitted, D
~
- ',.-, 9 i s
.,, _ s.,<
o /
t(f -
J,'. Bruce 11acDonald, Counsel meu York State Departncnt of, Commerce and Counsel to the Atomic Energy Council DATED:
November 27, 1970 G
we*
- e k
4 S
e s
a-..
-a.~
e i
o.
f~)
1 u: M i
< f. ?.? -
P F '), )
,p. k' l!)'
f.
ura1 r0 STATES
- ' - - * ~
.' ' # [
ATOMIC ENERGY COMMIEClON D
i, o
,/.,
- v., a. m., T e r., o c :. w, j
Q.s j <'
7gdLE '
reec ner 3, 1970 i
l i
!?re. Mar / Etyc Ucik, Secretarf Cor:aittee To End Endiologien1 Eazardo Box 1h8,150 Chrictopher Street New Ycrk, Ueu Ye-h 1001h Mr. Tcminick J. rirone Conculting Efolecict, Uudson River Mrs. Milton Kurt:.
Fici.ernen's Ascociation Chai22.an, C12AN, Inc.
Box 725 Box 1087 Oscining, Ucv York 10$62 Heu Rochelle, Ucv York 10802 s
Mr. Uilliam C. Uitt Mr. Ronald Fritz Superv$cor, Tovn of Cortlandt IhtB Bivervieu Avenue Municipal ?uilding Peekchill, Heu York 10566 Croton-on-Hudsen, New York 10520 in re:
Concolidated Edison Cc::.pany of Rev York, Inc.
(Indian Point Station Unit No. 2)
Docket Ho. 50-2h7
Dear Mecdanes and Sirc:
Eeceipt ic cckncviedged of your letter c:=unicctions stating an intenticn or decire to intervene in the chove entitled procee<31ngs.
Your letterc do net ccnctitute petitionc to intervene na prcccribed by Sectica 2.71h cf the Rules of Practice of the /.tcmic Energy Ccc-missicn cnd therefore connct serve as the basis of any cdjudication regarding your participatien in the prcceeding.
Without objection frca the present parties to the proceeding, however, each of you vill be permitted to ceparately file, even though beycnd the tite permitted by the Motice of Meering, a for: al petition to intervene in the proceeding in cecordance with the Eule cf Frac-tice, a copy of vhich is encleted.
/.fter receipt of cuch a formal petition, under cath, cetting forth the interest ycu have End the con-tentions you nahe, the precent parties to the proceeding vill be i i Sh C
g,?y.
L,4, /
e 0 ', O E s' i D y
1.
.a 91 72 4 1970 m 3 o
,e a;
/%
vk j
,ti
,e
~
f cp
\\k l
._p,w,-,
_ -.-.:--.~.-,......
9 ;..
i e-I.
. 2.-
.1 4
permitted to file cr.tverc a nd the Atcr.ic D.foty r.nd Licetring lonrd vill incue nn crder-either pera.itting. cr Ocnyinc-interventir n-und I
participatien in thr proccedin;.
t i ny truly yours,-
l
'1 4
t t
)
Encicsure:
Sarmel 'rt. Jcnach, Chirmn i
10 C'r'Ps Part 2 Atomic Safety :.nd Licensing Ecard
}7 cc:
Arvin E. Upton, Esq.
l I
l Anthony Z. ~ F,oic..an, Ecq.
_j j
Joceph B. Enotte, Jr., Esq.'
f-Secretary, USAEC's i._,,
l Nyron Karman, Ecq.w a
%.m s
George C. Arearc,-Esq.
l 1-i
-}
i
-1
-!.s
.- t
{
-6
-i I
l e
4 m
,- { /-
j j-
)
g I
_______._,___m___d
'\\.
>j. ;,,
c,
/f ' '.,:4.. ~,/
December 14, 1970 SECY-E 10; s
h.'
7~,
i.j f.
l.
f2 h+
CONSOLIDATED EDISON-COMPANY OF NEW YORK, ~ INC.
^
~7 7N
{-
1 INDIAN POINT-NUCLEAR -GENERATING UNIT NO. 2)
DOCKET NO. 50-247 Note by the Secretary
- 1. The attached letter and PETITION FOR LEAVE TO ' INTERVENE from Mrs. Mary Hays Weik is circulated for the inforatation of the i
Commission.
}-
- 2. An earlier letter from Mrs. Weik indicating her intent tc l
intervene was issued as a part;of SECY-R 95 4
i W. 3. McCool a
3 2
Secretary of the Commission 1
1 i
d i
NO. OF DISTRIBUTION-COPIES DIyTRIBUTION
~
Secretary 7
Congressional Relations
~
/'?
General Manager 2
Environmental Affairs Deputy Gen. Mgr.
1 Inspection Dir of Regulation 3
Materials-Licensing Deputy Dir. of. Regulation 1
Operational Safety _
Asst.Dir.of Reg.for Admin..
Public'Information Tech.Adv.to the Dir.of Reg.
1 Rad.' Prot. Standards Asst.Dir.of Reg.for-Reactors-1 Reactor _Dev. &-Tesch.
Asst. Gen. Mgr.
1.
Reactor Licensing Exec. Asst. to GM 1
. Reactor: Standards Special'Asit. to GM 1
-State _& Lio. Relations.
General Counsel 6'
New York Operations
- ! Compliance 6
Chairman, AS&LBP h'f) )g 39 !
__m ya vupp
C 0
.,g i
f Tommittee To End Radiological llazard5 Mory Hoys Weik '
Box 148,150 Christopher Street 3 * 'r GR 7d933 l
New York 14, New York h ed>or 7, 1970-Sanuel 4. Jensch, Esq., Chairman Rr* : Cou:o tidatd &lison 'Co.of N.Y. -
i
_ Atodc Safety 4: 1.iconsim r,oard i.pruie 'n for L x> rating : Liconse U. 3. Ator:ic cary/ Corrission for 2:.J an-rt.iMeloar bnit -
ninshimton, D, c. 205'55 Fedwt NO.50-P47_.,
U m Sirs
!I Th:tnk : ou for your 1ottor of Deconbor 3, vncies:c tho aent/W)
~
i Tados arid :wgulations." In accordance with your lettor,1 :.r. now subr1 cti rt; a-j soparcte j3tj tion For teavu i'o intorreno, whose stipulations i had prorioun17 thought j
(lackirz a_ copy of pmsont Comed.ssion stulos) to be fully. expressed in ray filirt letter of hov.'21, 1970,_ sont well in advanco of the state' filing dato of t-overbor 27.
Twenty copios of the Petition a2e enclosed horowith.
i Fleaso carden ry r:isunderstarxiing of the Comission's rul+s.
i i
f'gm 3
9 sincerely,
)({NV,,
C s
l
"'ky n r
}
- Ej LDEC 141970 * [g Pary Hays h Ome, at t>e 1: ::rt --
s P.tt 5.twiC(8.
1 (f34 h
9A'4 I
""'C N[Ehi!Naism
'/@
NO DiC * - n,I ~ 3 44 4
- i,c,0[q EX4psigggg fICE or i
t l
Copios of lottor and notition-sont ' to-.all Parties, board -nonbers and-Ragulatory Std f, D!~i
]t
3 C i i1970
- h
!V 6
gy,jy}_
s u << *.. " a jg w<s
- s
.. ~
~~
l'l3 N so}Q&
U. S. AT0!GC E!ERGY CO)MSSION:
Ro s Consolidato-ddison o t' Iw York Aonlicatio r for Omratiry Liennso for irsiisn Poira. tho loar Urdt ho.?.
LG 7C)
STATES OF A3 RICA:
Doc' cot lb. 50-2h?
p.titien Of PJLRY 111I5 WEIX For I/savo To Intervom In The Above Procoodings I
15 0 mtitioror, MA1Y llAYS WEIK, a citizen and ta.a-nayor of tho tinited States ano of the Cit:r and State of Ibw 'Zark, mqt.osts the privilor-o to anmar in her otm richt as a 'srt" at tho htblic hearinr, schodt-lod to be ha'Ld on Doconbor.l7, LWO at Mickskill, Im. York by tho U.S. Atonic Emrgy Cominston, to considor conso Lidated Alison's annlication for a mrrd.t to onorato a second nuclear roactor at j ndian Point in Buchaiun, Ibv York, just outsido tha City of Puokshi i 1.
II The mtitiomt affirns har norsonal interest in the nroco vline,s as a citizon artl r< sident of *.ho !ttrono litan Nou Iork aron affected by the har.ards anr1 no t tution of tho enlar 'od : 'ydian ; tint plant; as follo.c :
')
' he seenrity of horself atd her fandly, uho uou id Livo direct ly trith$ n tho.1 ndian i cint stant's oxnar:Jod hazard area - inemased now by Ibc Loar Raaetor 2 to many timou its cririna L sito - is of the closest ratural concern to hor as an individual citizon.
) iho safoty and purity of an in:portant part of ibw York and Jostchostoc County's nvblic nator sup,1y - so vital to her arti har fanily as it is to ovary one of tho ama's citisore - trou nd be mriled by the adjacence of Larro atonic plants, i
III A Comission decision to licenso this added nuclear roactor would directly affect the notit,lomr's intomsts: in that:
- 1) An accid mt or nalfunctiordng of plant facilitics after the grantirn of such an ndet ti o.dl licenso could subject her and her famly to the chaos of arca-wido disastor.
- 2) iho addod n.. tion radius ercated by-such a decision micht loavo no drinking-water su,,lios imuno to contardnation in her aron.
h
~ ho mtitierrr contends, after careful study of all the facts concormd:
That, a lthou'h ortonsivo plans havo boon nado by the apnlicant connarc' and-the U.S.
Atomic Encr.:V Conr:ission for cont $ rconcies that ni:'ht resu.lt from nossiblo roactor
.y._.-
a ~, - _
,. s w.... u.. 4 + a.: m wem,Maj
O
- o~ m M.
.ith stieb :uch r* rir-oncins oc ur von td -n ; in. m l'icinnt Lino fnr orinr
.d*e-a ration.
Ths' it tm.!d be a thoughtloss ard unforgivab.lo :overrmot action
- .o inrdet arcthor omr r
- oarco of radioactivo noUution on an aros alroady thnorm i ei hich, ley,toS.
,1 W1 a.ctintics meerds, in donths fron ]nukonia ard othor form ol ;ar.cor, wl in
.ir*.h i;orr ets of infar:t - born in this area.
Tint, in vinu of tho bad norfornanco meerd of the nmnent ; tr lan t'oint.i acactor, i
3rd of cvrmnt scientific dove teennnt of tou and cafor n. tons of non-alord o 'mmr, centi:.um! 0::norinontation uit! atonie nowr at Indian Poi nt 19fo'ttAatod, irxifficient, lanprous, and wactoful oxcorditure of
- sib' Lie funds: since the finarcia l nh M 7ation
-" t inevitab& falI en the ci ti en: thonsolvo;,, in the form of addoo, Loctrica i r.orvico ec.-tn aid of osca lating taxus to cover fodoral ard stato oronotion, m bnidion, and s einI nroti etion for thin ur moded arrl highly hazardous tvm or.vrur.
FDR THE REAS013 CITED ABOVE, iho petitionor contords that omration of this second nai lar or it.se tear mactor at the Iriian Foint 7 tant uov.id threaton the uo.ifero ard soevrit4 of every citicon of 4.norica 't lar.zost mtromlitan ama, Mar Yorl: aid its trictato cuourbs with a cor'ula tion er nom than 15 r:illion. She urco: thorofore that
~;
thn Onoratirc Licenso now at 1scuo 1e doaiod; with the added reconnondatien that nti nvc lear onorations at thi:: nost unfavorablo site bo declarod orded, as being imractica L, unstol'ul, and danad rg to citizen hoa:lth - as has boon r.o ch.arly provoo h*; nonrly 0 years ' dicastrous exporienco vith tho imsont irriian Point 1 doactor.
STATS OF iEW YORK ) ***
Co::nty of Ibn York) 1 the endor i: md stato that I an the mtitioner, MARY HAYS hED:, ard I affirn under nath that the statonants in the Ibtition above are truo ard cormat to tho cost of ru
}:r.o. le:bo.
-- MN n !bu York City.
- oc"tod or. A i
.. ~ j i r~
- k. % [(, '
f utitioner : PAjY HAIS W:J.K Joi 140, 150 Christopher ist.
Iow York, N. Y..l0014 STA!E OF IEJ YORK Cont c: lbv lork On, h ], /7 70 befom re, the urdersigned, a liotary Public in and for said Coul.tV ard 3tato, persorelly anocared MARY HAYS hED:, known to no to be the norson
.f.oso rn.r n crbscribed to the urosent instrurent, ard ackr.owlodcod that sho oxocuted tho cane..ET:ESS :ny hand ard official scal.
6/
eds n
Nota ~" Dubb c Ikaw York Court, !!. Y.
My co r.iccien oxviroa _
wi
,, u.. i.
%) \\ \\ f.* si f.. e t i s, us
-u Nn re,.
m-s,, g,, ; e,.,
_ i,n y, g,,,,g,,,,,,,,
Lunah.uu bauna h.h Jo,1972 0
.f *..;
L.*>h.h. u a %.
,y
--