ML20090A804
| ML20090A804 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 10/08/1980 |
| From: | Hood D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML17198A223 | List:
|
| References | |
| CON-BOX-12, FOIA-84-96 OL, OM, NUDOCS 8012120258 | |
| Download: ML20090A804 (90) | |
Text
-a m o a
o e
l 1
S a - 321f.noox o t.
Exhilods ha io/ 7-7/ Tr Depo ed
~
o 0f l
DAnL N$
I z / Eth~4.
.,7_ J ? Xk q>.
l c
L m
t.
e e
1 4
'C (5Y d' /
her/ISc]Hu(f*
T*. -3 ; O. n.
t e
s-
/6/7/ -@ /N-
~~I-Mn
/
L s. c yh e
a o e
'7;;TE: STA IS CF Av.ER:"A Mh b-NCC. EAR RECT:.A707.Y CC.v.M:35ICS
~
Pefere the At:rir 52fety and Licensing Beard
)
In the Matter cf
)
)
CON 3UMERS PCWER CCMFA*;Y
)
Docket Ncs. 50-3 9-CL
)
50-330-CL Widland P;.nt, Units 1 and 2) 1 50-309-CM
)
50-330-CM 4
J A.V.I!.O E:: ';CT:CE OF CEPCS!! ION 7::
Each persen naref
. the attached Certificate of Ser:::e.
P:. EASE TAKE NO7:CI ~%T Censurers Power Cc. pan */
shall take the depositic.. cn cral examination of the following na.ed persens at the tires, dates and locations indicated.
9: 00 a.:s.
Oct. 7, 1931 Maryland Natl. Sk. Bldy.
Darl Hood, 7735 Old Cecrgetcwn Rd.
NRC Staff Bethesda, Md. 21:02 1:00 c.-
Cct.
9, 193:
Maryland Natl. Bi. B*.d?.
Lyr.an Meller.
7735 Cid Georget:wn Rd.
NBC Staff Bethesda, Md. 21:02 1
1:13 p.m.
Cet. 9, 192 Maryland NatlMk. B;dg.
Joseph Kane, 7735 Old Cecrget:wn Pd.
NPC Staff Eethesda, Md. 21:02 11:3 3. :r.
Cet. 14, 19!0 Patrick McNa-ara Bldg.
Jares W. Sir;se!
4 " MI:htgan Ave., it.t Fl. Corps of En:sts.
Cetrcit, Mich. 49 26 13:03 a..
Oct. 15, lii0 Patrick McNa.-ara Bide.
Williar Lavhesi.
l 4" Michigan A'te., 7th Fl. Corps cf Encers.
j Cetroit, Mi:h. 48226 l h :1 s.r..
Cet.
l', IMO Patrick McNarars Bld1.
Pen Erickson, 477 Michigan Ave.
7th Fl. Corps of Engars Cetre;t, Mi:h. 4!! 6
E3:h ' deponent is requested to make available, one bt:siness day pr:or te his deposition, the doen.~ents described in A;;endix A of the Neti:e Of Oeposition dated Septerter ::,
(
1750.
l l
he sut e t ratter of the dep.:sitiens sha*1 he all estters relating to tne issues : ret forth in tre :ieensing Beard's Order cf Oecerler 6,1979, order Modifying Ccnstruction Fer ts and the agreed to cententi:ns of int rvenors Star.ir:s and Warren a.d ite contentiens :f Intervenors Mars. tall and S :.- :; s t r.
Sincerely,
~-
' Alan 5. Farnell
- Cour.sel for Censurers Pcwer C.spany
- I S P.A.M. :.:NC*:.N & SEA.E Cr.e First': 54tional Pla:a Su:.te 4200 Chica;h, Ill:ncis 6C603 3;;/555"7503.
i f
/^
s s
4 I
e i
/
l
.n Y
0 L
t r
/
i y
s e
[
e
,1
'I
~
F (.h -
i i
,, '.. 'l
,e^
?
4 l
g
( *
/
J l$ L h
N sk eY
.j
(
t.
l 1
UNI"TD STATES CT A.v.EF*~A NUCLEA3 REG *J*JCCEY CC.v.:SSION 9efere the At:-i Safety and Licensin: Sca14
)
In the Matter of
)
)
C0!!SOMEFS P0hTR *0MPA'.7
)
Oceket 5cs. SC-329-0:.
)
50-330-CL
' Midland Plant, Units
- and 2)
)
50-329-CM
)
50-330-CM
)
C... ~. *. T *. u.'s'.'
'e.r S *t. R*.* *. a--
- , Alan S. Tarnell, herety certify that a py of Censu. ers Fewer Ceepany's A. ended *;otice of Oepes. tic. was serted upcn all persc.s shew. in the attached so:tice list by depesit in the United States mail, f t:st class, this ist day of Or t:ber,1980.
4 k-Alan 3. Tarne..
.e ch
['(
t
I
.e..c.
e..
. r
.c.aa.'.<..t..'*."..
" w-.
.:.. w...'.~....s..
A tt o rtef,.Oe.e r s ', :
- the m rs:,.:;e ;se., -.re :< s p i ;i::es
..a.e.
..:,2-.
..... a.
.c..e.
3:e.a:: H. 7 : e e - 1.~.. Es..
- '....-.~..~.v........c.-e<..
A 3. s s... J... -.. 4.-
se..e..*..~
.....e s.c '. s....-. e s.-.1
...,.....3.....
?. s..
Assistant Atterre 34.ers'.
A::=i: Sa'ety ; *.::e sa : :;es' 72.e'
.........r....
.........a......*.2....-..-. s s...
.r........,.3 r........
I
=..
4
...,.3.,
11.,,.4....,
a
. a n s..,.,
.v.
I
..:.3
- s.,.... ;.
4.e..e.,.
r s...-.
.s
. e,,... < e......e
.. e....e....
.s.
- e ;l' 7;a
- 2
- e..e e
e..e...3-
.e....e 4.c
....e1..es.....
.ss...
r
..u..
3.,
.,o s d..':-
l 43s..
i i
". We.de l. M.
.v.a rs ta '. ;
" s.
- 2 :.r S e ' n r
,7. 1:
--es.e....
.v. 4.3 4
.v..., a-4 :3..
. e. 2...'.,
.v...-. -. a.., : :. '. '.
w 1.....s s...e..e...
.r 3,.
3........es.
1a...
.. r 3...
3 3., f... g.....s..:..........
...s.
..e..: 3 3.4,
...,3
...e.....,..,. :
...;s3;..
ss....-*..-.....'...'.':.~.:..
3<..4...-....
a 4
in i
r.
.a
..e..,p..
3.
rs. - ;.
.e,,...
,....,**5*...* "..*#.
I I.'. e '
.e
... e.e. 1.
...,)
e...)...
9.3-3
-.A3.......,
?*...J
............. 3 1.;,*.t 3 g..a :...
- n. 3
.,2 3.c. 3.... s 6
- .....w.g.
3....3
. e.
-. 3. 3...
.....,....,. 3 3.4 A..........3,,....
g..... s.* 1.*
D e.. *.. 1
..5. a. 3. : q. '.,..
....1..
- 3
- e.,.,.s a..
y, o
.f.=.
9.::
.w:..tC,
.. 3 m
i l
.d 4. s : 1 A.
.s 2 C %u. 1
~
3
..- g.
.v.3. 3 o.e..
3,:
6
.. ige.
ed.4 me r
.-a.-.c..
= s.-..v a...e s
.:x 5 3 -i.a.r. n :.. t. 4iC3 e
r.
. ;.......,.,...,..a a.s.e...........
7 3t ::<. A..: a:e a.
..s.....ee....
'. : : 4 *:. 3.te r d a -
- t. a.- s..
.e.e.....:..=.
e s
.= 3.,...,
.v.
.. 3 ::..;
.a......,
.v.....a
.g. s r..
.c..
- > -. ; :... *.*
- e -
2........
2.v. s a.e a... s.....,
a 3... n.
.v.. 4.,..,. :..
.s 3a......,
....a s...
I 23 a.. d. 3 *.
.t e.43t
.c a....
~.s. ".1....
'.t.-4..
.c.
. t. ;. "r:. i..., s.
23.. w....
.v..i i g. 43-.;
.; 3 a.,
a.
4. ; g.,
y
..... 3 J.
.; e
- 1. e s I. Brunner. Ess.
- v..i.. 3. ' A. : 1..
/
I
~:".s J." e :S 7 :. e r.*:.- 4.-*.*
.-^..J
. e...a... 6 C.. e e *.
.s y,4 5.
.v.
..., 3.
g.....,
.=a............v.....s.,.-...:
y s
. ~..
.3... A s s..,
...e 3..
- ?.
...y
.. 2.7 ~...c...
.r.sg.
.g..-... a 3 <......eg.a
...: e
.J. S. 1:cle a:. e'.:la t e:T' cY' 4.....
i I
I I
- e *
- Q /Y'S
(
-+.
-r-s g,.,
?l-Y m.-
'f 9
~
,,. - v-
., ? r* {!'$.!
t s
- s. -
t 4:.
- 2. e. := ~
ti..--s s -
? '... - -- := e.,
- t. e s:: T t
?' N
.a
.e.r: :-+-
~ ~...
3..-. -
s-.....'.
W..r-n - :*;*
.* e. -
- ts.
. n.. : 1.
- e.s
^ :. :.. ::.1
'= C.-
- a -* ' * :
q.......
......,-.n;. m.
.. g%.
. ~ -
%-- ?
- t.-. : a l u is
'T.<
... ?C.s..
- a.W..sa i
I
...3.-
5.-
- ' s a.:.. s :. ::. : *.a; 't: ss. 1 !*sC w
. s r ' : m- - s e
L-,
a.- ?.. s.
. c. e f - i.C *-.
.g,
.s......re.
.a.. :._ e t-,
s i4 et eral.. 3 t.-!
S.
e --. ?st :r.s
-v.
es :-....i,,..:.' s.: :s;..-- :
's.
?,-* 4,rs'..
?"
J.45* s *. *i?.
6. ?.".,' s,s 1 *. *3 #f 44.* ' t,v **.. cr.
..'.. 4 2 -.. :. s.
u;. e!..sJe f : s..s.s ?v.c.- 4 ' '. *..% 2 :
. ? w. a s n..s ec e.:
s.
.:r- -
's. -*.
t.t;'s. %. 5. 4
.r:4e=*s -. * %.]i3
'ss.. ?
- r t. s '.. s.. :.
2 ?' *
- c. s e u :-** - --M--.*% ;c
' -. e*.'a. i s., ; 6, F a.S
>:cets ;3 J-.r...}2--)J 14, c at. :
a.-C..~t :' 2. *se st. ::: 2 4* :e
..4 ",ia-i. art !a'e:7 2 alys:s
,.-..- ;.7...-.
j s.s- -- '. :. ':.v :
t e >-*. a.14. * "es i- " t'a itas:a-.i
. 2.r C.2
...' v. t; ;...
se. 2,r,..*..
- - s S.:'-se *ce:etf j
e s.
' s., :.;... f 8
,,..3.,
- 2. :f..;.a ; '.:.5 s vi 4.
- s. s -
a:ta.1
. : ':. e - :e-5.:a
?-: 4v.. c..
i.e.
r t.~.4 j,
e
+-
cr:.*s:.- :.s.:targe
- =>e***
s 3.r.* *.,
- h..an=*$".**. ? *
. s 2 s.
ar. 3* A.:*.:*.l.1.9 :199 3C4Pt ei .*.S tet *:r *2:.l.*.et %ett.ot2 st "2.ar:1,
- ::"cc, "
';*]-;7*:
- r =*.:
t.
i I
,,,m,
Page 2 ESIRICCZ Aug2st, 13 Present 00:e;;;T; 1T. S. icles.- Rer latory Com;ssion
'4 ash:::fice, 3C P052-".33:
Meenstr.g Project Mansfer I.ignt Vater Tseectcrs, C3-l'.
SE;V-Y CIJTAPA!!CE: L JC3 ;E;3.~P"ICN:
Bis ;osition vitain the Divist:n of Pro;cet Ma..a,;c:r-t of the Office of 9.: lear ?cstor Regal.st;cn pr:v;:es tse pisania and cac.
at;ca of ral;shgical safet/ rev;evs of applicatior.s for 2.icecses and author 2 zat.ons to const:tet or operste lig.t water cuclear peser p'.aats. 21s midile sacagement 5.sitios co-orti::stes technical su;; ort f.-ca individt.als f.ms approd:stely tvesty-foar tec:sical :rancnes of the Offi:e of Nelear.oesctor Fegulatton assigned to the rey;ew of tr.e A;;h: ant's Safet/ Analysis heport. %e posi* ion coordinates preparatton of tr.e resalts of sne review acto a safety eva;aat.s: report and pr.v;tes s.;; ort of its conte:t iar.rg =cet..gs v.t: tne ;;v;scry Cec =4ttee on Seseter Sa.'eguards aca during pu'clic r. ear cgs associates v.*.a tre licens; 4 process.
! have served in snis pcs; tion for tr.e rol.1:n::4 prc;e:ts:
" cstingr.ouse Beference Oafety Acalysis Fe.crt Fi.:AF--14, Dcdet A. SI's $0-5'2, from tenderi 4 of ap;11 st'on in.k%:er,1970 to issua:ce of prel.=icar/ desifs a;;rovd in Nosetter,1370; C11and Plant, Units 1 & 2, Docket Nes. 50-9) a:d SC-DC, frus tenderig of operat.::g license a;pli:st;oo in Aus4st,1)77 to pres ent; Oatavata Nuclear Otation, Units 1 & 2, Nect %;. SC-.13 and $C-il*,
- f. xs Pectuary,19"7 to ;ovester,19I, and frca 0:totcr,1)?9 to present; and River 3e.d Station, ';cits 1 & 2, Docket Mos. 50 -56 asd 5M59, from Aug st,1978 to presest.
sa June,1^?4 to Augsst,1976 COMPA.tT:
Cc=busti:n T.ngineert y, Inc.
Eclear Power 5fste:s D;v's'en Vandsor, Cort.ecticat POSIT E:
(1) Ass;stant Pro,eet wa.;er for Nxe Po.er Pro;e:t (2) Safety e.r.d 1.:enstr4 Project E.4.neer JC9 3C?O'**0N:
After wen,197?, I was Assistant Project Mana.;?? for the Dee Pcwer Pro;ect. 2.s position pn)v;ied ass. star.ce in tirect.r4 C1 efforts by C-E to design, fsericate, purenase ar.d licecae the nuclear steam supply systaas, reactor core, and associated maillary systema for C;erokee 'Jnita 1, 2 & J l
and Scana 1. Perkins Units 1, 2 & J. De posittes assured that all aspe:ts l
of tse cont: acts were met acd ttat safe and rel.ac;e syste=s were prcvile$ to j
the required schehle and at a reasonacle prcrit to J-r.
I ass.sted Nae Power i
i i
i
-i Of e -j i
l Coctastion I::gineerirg Inc. Jcb De tri; tion C: tinued :
t in ;tepar;rg the Pre;1xicary Safet? Acalysis.%;cr (? /*G) asi previded for all 0-2 1.ce. sir 4 s.;pstt f:r thes.'.aits.
I also provided ::ord.:stic: of all : tr.er nuclear plants refe. :nce ; tne C-E 3 andars *,arety Analys;s Fep:.-t to n.sure ces;at;cihty wit: C-E s* se:ard reference design.
Until krch,1973, I was a Pru.'e:S Irg.:eer in C E's Safety ana I.icens.r4 Depar*.sent sai was repC3si:'e for 1 :ta.s*rf of ::. Clear power p'.asts.
I co-ord:.ated tr.e pre;4rati:n :f tne M;;.ato:e 'u* nit 2 PSA? and L? and tr.e Ca;ver:
Chirs Units 1 & 2 E!J an: interin:r: v.tn 'i?O, tne.ta..ty, at::::e:t ent;n c.-
ana al; C-E faaet.or.a; depart er.ts : licens;nc s2p;crt rute :.
- ecs.re: :nt.:
5.*t0 :r.teria, stant.a.-is, att gaises were inc:r;3 rated it.to *.ne ::a:;est stes:
su;;;y syste: desifP..
Aug.st, ;)d - Juse,1M COWielY:
Ma.rt.n Mar;etts,orporataos 1:; ear D:vis.sa, Nuclear Safety Unit Sa a.= ore, Marf'and
- 1v;s;on sutseper.tly ;,ar naac1 :y *s::spe:, Ir.c., a s.t:.i.ary of eLedy.e 0:rp., Ta.s:c, :*arylast P00 TIO:::
Erg;:cer, Nc' ear Safety and ?nt.;at;sr. ar.al;.:.s SEC'?!"f C;.f#A.10E:
- CD - Secre'.
AEC - 4 JC3 ;IS03;PT:;3:
Se ;st;cse of t...s ;;:; tion.as to peric =.a: art e.s1.s..ets far n.:lest
- cwar 22.r
- ea sp;.iec i: sitee 2;ss.2.:. My p. ::ary :.ty was to te.cr.nc er;cs.e to rad:stic: for :alf. :tions o::.rri:4 a r;rg the ;: tended pu :.. :
- ss;33. I also determined means by v.ia: the hatard ;otent;a; for su: lear s;nce systess could be cit;(a*.ed *3 tr.e exte:* tr.at n';: lent sa'ety :riteria vere :et. I :ond.cted reset.-:n vit.. rafards to ice develo; ::t of sa;;stle
- r;teria for ;er=;ssa:Le e.gesu.e '.evels and t..e.r protatilities, i:,ong into accc.r.: the ic endence of a::e;tacle r'.sa cr. tna te ef.t to te derivel.
FJ pri:ary assic cent as with tr.e $* LAP If Qyste:s for 3;cles dux.ha.y F,cVer, ;rcject.
.s eva;.at.cca of tr..s.~.aclear ;cwer s:urce.;;;.det sne w
fors..st. n a:2 a;;11:st.on of :c:puter;:ed acce;s for :ne t uspor of Pael released at h:4n altitudes,.n lee; ocean ar.4 in shallow water:. I derived acde;s for these re;*ase tress to iner,rporate the activ.ty.nts hu a: foc.1
- r.a. s a.51 deters.ned t e agected 1 gest.on dose, the f.ucter :f pe:;;e in-volve; ar.d the e.gr.s re ;retact'ities. Ir.haisti:3 dcse.'s: de*e: tised for rad.; active fallout from the nigh-alt;tude re' ease.
Fe t t.a y.
- 45 - Au.;ust, l'jte
- 0.4P;.T!:
I;ectrie 3 cat 01 vision of 3ecers; Dyn.u.:s Orot:n, Connett::ut PCG * **03:
re.gireer, 1:*.es: Qaahty Control CEC'J?l*Y C* fEJNCE:
Ocar;ientia; (*/.3)
JOB CCRIP! 3:
Se pur;cee of this pcsitico was to ; rov.de ccetrol af quality for.aval reacter 6fstess, cocponents, and shieliing d.ri:4 the esnstru::.oc of sut-marites cy th;s sh.pysed.
I l
l l
Page -
I. ectr.: Sont 0.vistor. :: Ze erai ?.ac:s Jo: Ces:r.;;io:
':..t..ue::
i l
Mj picary area of ; es;cem...:y v:s sh;eli.nI. 3.:.c: ::G.:e:
estati.sain.; precedures (cr t - ' at:ecu:n of fa: ries:1o : a.-
. : a.lanen of lesc a:d po'.yetnyle e snW.i. g and resCv ng ;re:;e:4 :n c::;.ytrg l
w.tr. tr.ese or otuer s.*.ield1=g ;K:e:.res.
Se pos.t.:: re : ad a <n:v'eige Of r2 dear the:-.t. S N trste:s :-:.g.,
3.rea. 2.' Ir..p :ontrs:*, and.es.g:. re;..re. cts,.o:-:estr.::.ve it::.r4 tect.n.;2es, a-d pal
- y con : ; ret.;te:-: s.
Nove=:er, 1)c3. M;; g ry, ',"fo$
L'ex.Y:
,ecrge C. v.s.all S;sce F1.gn "e:ter a
"fatio:a1 Aerer.a u:s and Spa:e A.:.:.nstrano:
Suntsv 11e, Alata:s
?OSITIO:l:
Aerona.:. cal E.ad;:eer..t: lear Pro;- ine: anc F:ver a
27.;*;?l Y C.E.AM?:05:
Secret ( C!
FrI:
A1:,ctv t I se ved in tne gr1;ie Of e ::d and F.rst Lieute. ant, :.v
..e eq2.vate:: i:: ue. eve.' or ver,;
perro::ed was a G3.'.1.
('J;on.-pest of *iA2A, s;e::C Orders fic: t e Ar:r/ release. :. t: :: : uv.'. u a a.:y.'
i J05 DE.~.0FCPT;0 I:
Se purpo:e of sms.osite: vas t: ;. :vice radest s :e:s ;eri:::ar.:e a:d s;;it:ation stui.es fo.- %3A.
Fy duties were ts perfor: the:rsti:C.svest;f ans:s of : e.atare a:d sag.itude of the nucles rad:st;on e:vire ::ent, s..eli;r4 syste=s, at:1 safety syste:: associated vit: 2Cear s;sce ven:les. O.a s.seluded analysis of t.e
. u.at.on envirc..=ent a: urg fro:
- lear pr0;ulsion 3r..i ;wer seur:es and
. stars', s; ace rai;.stic: warces enco.nter-c :n typ;:0 srs:e :issi:ns, 1:Cysis a:d design of meil.4 and safety syste=s f:r o.C:gi:C ans ver.;:le
- rctecuen, evaLatier. if spe
- ial is:ility sad operst.:.si reza;re:ects, at:1 overall cu: lear er41:ecing a:.1 veci:le des;gn aategrM.on ;rt'..*-..s.
As a nucles engiteering spec;alist, * ;erf:r:ed techn:a1 t.;ervis;o:
cf study c ntra::s v t/s indust:/ a:d prev;:ed te:n..i:a; adn:e ud consaitstica t: other.ctnir4 gt:n.;,s as: orgsr.it.aucts, := ar.:;; ion to ;eri:.~.c:g 1:le;e:Je:t st.dy act.vity is my specialty.
Apri,....
..cVe=ter, ly...;;
.rJ ;
O.y?AR:
'.'. S. A.~y Cr:r.ar.:e Ju;:ei.veesde :::o; 3edstcoe Artenal, Alstar.a 1
F;SITI;;*:
C.lef, k.vs..ced Cire.its *Jni:
I'JI.W: CFJ,3Y RC70:C;1;*. T: Inst:. ters. 23 Stude::s 1.0 eve:y 3 vee.:
I II?JM*Y C.ZARA.~.;I:
Secret ;;CO)
?MK: 3ees:a
- r.:.:..t J 5 CS-'* :F:':03:
As C.ief of tne Advar.ced 2.rcuits C:it under the assile.ce;oce:ts w
,.r.sien, I was :n cr.arge of :e tra.m:L.4 cf mhta:/ ;erse-re; ass.gr.et,o mssile syste=s and s;enalties.
hs tra.:..4 :nc'uie ele:;rce : syste s ist co==.catic:s, tra: air 4, guidan:e and est. re; as. sed : tr:7 defense nssiles.
I 1,
~M w. S. p.r:y w.
a*. t 1.e.a
- 4.......e
.s.C..
. e........
- ~._
w
- ...r....
xt..s. -. te $ n e 1
.....,o:*- a*-*y-
~-- ~ - -
~.
.,,;;, ;;;
- a:. *;..t &J.:.r..stit!.Or. s it N S 0" E?1 C00* #0 -
- J"f-Pr34rs: Of Instr.c*iCa to in.;,se ; e ewe. :.ss...s at t rapi '
.r w -...
te:.co;;g., ts.;f ed hee A17 g..eds of ;.s*r. t;sn, na.. ate:_:
.w t_:-
tr.;: a: CLOer.3 tS,
&** 33 I;O8 UI0 ' 'E
~
1
..e.
..g.e. me.T y......g
.e....
5...r.... s..... e,,,.
Z- *, t
- r*e :. 8.. ' s3 ::: rse t.73,
s.*.i e; f* ee". :...*. arf persOT' l
Ar~s a i a:: x..ts:....; : :: :... : u:s.
..n
- re r-i
- u. rrs.
n.
~
tr.xsa.:. sol.;sts.r.
e ;..;:e:* sr./. s.;;.;.:s.
~
Fe:t.ar, ;.w.i. AprG, IP.3
......y.
........... s...,
r
..a
.<...e.
q.-...n
- s..
~
h rse, 7:rt er: n, re:rf.a RA 3ee.:.
- e.t e.-1..:, *.
- 2. -r=.-
..... n....
t
"'. s.
M re:e.ee :.a tc. s po s.t.o
. *.:. 2 :ei f u. '. a. :4t.
u
- s... a.. r1 <...,.,.
....... s.
r.,..
..........,...r.-----..-
e'.e:tror..:s. r.: lev ar.: e;e:: r n.:.arra e..esiersa.;. ;:::c.._ --.s _.,_. _.. _. _
--m m
l a :.tas.: :.
.u s.:. e te..
1
- 1. r....a..
. m.. :et.~.a.!,.r.:
- M W
1cria;.< av C e.;..st'.
I 3r*. Or
- r., '*.:(...:.
Pl. Z ;1:
. ! *.e I?.,*,. e e r, Or*
- sat e ar.. ;; * *;al '*-.
L
.e s ;. ;.. #. s. *.
- .:..~, C.....%.'7
.0:.. e.. a r e :.
w:.
w.
..... m...%
B.s pes at.cs prev;ded ers:eer;.4 sem:es for cr: ssee w,s;cs : r.;:r.e:ts and syste== 'ar a;; ::a:ses of P.ava; ves:e'.s 2 ---
c is.s Gn;;Js!"'a.
Nt.es in:.'.M tr.e ic:ee;t.ac ar.: leve'a;:
.t of :es.g.s
=
- 1
- :1-.
';h.
' 2.- or*.as:e 1:12;ec:al.es;ar.2 ep.;:ent a--
~.__
- -tail s
- c sen.yent ;. ass were ;te;ared far nev :.es.4 s ane.
- . es.st. 4 sis.es: a-e. e;.s.;4aest.
,l
- s:.:.f.:3* f pre,ared tre ;; ass far meer :at:,o :f :es -- -
m 'l act.s.r:rs: t :t r.ars, g.v.sg taese resseis tne :=;a:G.:p ar
~_ -.
st:r...4 4.r e sa: 34cric s.ss.;es ar.: speciG 1e;te. :..arges.
'. _ y'mu at; st.-ess ts;r.lat;ons for ts.s wors an1 ;ter.ared ater;s; s;e.-e :- -
,;,c m.,.
s.:.r :.ata. :as:.er'.a. -epests for ;,,. : nase c f s;e:.a; sa:e.. = --
-_.,,._.R.,
m Se*.t.
a.s ;repa*e'i pre;.1. &:"y repCr* s 42.4 :.ata s..ee%3 *Cv e _...,,_ q-g.
- a:*1.:V e S *.f1*. 3.S 42.
- e s 14.
~~q 1
l l
l t
f.
j
I s......e s...
...r.e.e e.....r..
s,..
325
..w.. ~ sa *......
- ....e....>.....
...~.... =;
2....
...a
.. S.,..,. O.o
.4 3.
,.......~..C5
..e.
-,..... 5
. ri.. <.
.s. t a
.s..c....... ' n..55
,. 5
.............o
..e s
=......
.a 3.,
.,, e,..... :..,... a... 3
..a s..
... O (....... 3 n w.
...........a
..a
.n
.s2
........;..4.
.x.,....
s.,
....s
..w..;
...........s
..a
..e.....,..s....>...
.vl,
..A..e.....s
.....s
..a
".4 2
.'.e n e r.C;;e a
...a ce we.e..
WM S v
.. g.w, f.
r.. s. s.,.. v. c.,.
cC' r
.s
...................s...
,,.3
...a e.s.....
.s.....u....
r.
.s..
e.
....~s
...n...
3
..r,..,.
s r s..,......
.._...ia.....
..3
,..a r.
..a
...C........
__.,...c...
...e.. s. a
..u
<t
,.. )
.e.. r..5..s r i.
,s.
.,..,.....s......
....so....s..
..e.a.......s a.
<..,a..
pg. C0
......, c..-....... s
.?....-.. e e.-....-
s..............a
.3...s......
... an. )
r...,4
........ 5
..'-,6 s...........d...
. e.........,
.-..,2 "e.a
...s
.;...........s
..e a.. t... C.,..a..
.. 5
.,..A
.. a.. C a.
.s.,
..... @ 2..,.
w.,.....
3...
....a
... s'
.. v...,...
........a 3....
..'. w-.~. n.
..1...,.
.s
.a.........,
.- ;...3
.s.f 4...
..,.........a...
.-.t.
w,. g...
. s.........e.........
....2..;
.-. n5
....e.......
.s
....a,.
- *.'.5
- c a...,a..e 1.,
C o... e,....... a........,....
..a....
...a J...
3.
31,
- a. ?,
C,...e
,...a 5 e5 s..
.s
~.e 3.
......a y.e.C.e.C e6, i.
, i..
. "1.
wg
,.f
.a.
- c....
c....
1..
.;a.
P.tmr.:ect 2 As,.~.....
'1.
,.1:lest ?er late ?
C1 a.
,a
.u, n a
,.,.,..~.e a
.c.
. Ceca.ta.c-N.:.' ear Plas. Seba:
Bo'h 4 Vater PseacI:te:,ersota; Ss.111s fcr 111t f *ata Syste: (12 hcurs)
.e Mar. agers (32 nears)
.s. Tr:: sir 4 !*;es (ter (F.h Syste=s V.de:
1/ 76 TI j:*.e=s 1 (.3 l'. heat sj 12/Ts
?a F.a;at Fec.ilr4 vee 4
'.bcLear Power Pes:to C(2'.. ca.r)s )
c ~-
Eart ::
r a:e.y, X 7 Ce:eral Safet7: err.a1 F:ver Reacters i1 Pa.t II:
5, ~ ~~
F.iTt Protati.'istic lafety aEclear Syste:s Iseture weet
/ :ssues il vees.,
Te :.;Aes
,. *:ur:)
7, -
2:.::.:.n r...cer=.d cour:.4 P41 ati ;ty Acalys:s 9r Ti
)
Pr.001;1e: of
, Vi 2ce, k.ne:t.c..
12, 7s Cctro; Fo:c. S.: *ater hMa: age =ett - A:ericer h
!r.tred.ct.:n to 1 clear ?
a over. 'T.5 Cer;ce:c. Associa:.:r. '1-c
.. 06.:t.:r. to I:vir: : ental Prctectisn
.c..c (l weet). V.ieo Tape I.:(1.eerits Oc
- .u (..
.. ur:'
4 c. curs.
Effective ' rit'.r4 '12 a (2-P.ours urse,5C ours) curs)
- A -*. i n "'tr * * * *A, 'e c ;
- e ? "
- F.v.
- '.w - 0 ;r.*er Prver, v.ary11-d E;e trie i stII?..'10 OcciAter Pr:grar rs::.n; (26 to2rs) rotor. 2.r.e:..:.: r.,:; a:t 0,. erst;on (2 7
ic.-:e:t:.:tive Tast'r
.hcurs}
2 05V..*s:ter P.' ant PriaI qu.i Pe:etratics Te g to fav:c.:;a 2F 1 g M cc: )
500 1 Feita:2 Lit /k mentals Tra
(-Ccours)
Macase:est :=;gineer.:r v.e 4 (2 :ours)c. air 4 ProGro.2.'72 hcurs) var:. c.; h a:e i ; tr er
. Seni:ar (12 :ours)
M-/ i :
Car.se, 5:t:v11.'e P.E :: ;: C::p.*.er Pr:.:ra==.t,,tus:2 7
J:. C.fic *.sta I sterC;;;..ter Pr.ctsr.s.:;; ( ;;.oce:)
- ;tes ; ste:
/
icw s,'
.:. Ser.es f4 t.p.t.e Piedra:ru
- :v U. 3. At:
Mtc's :y 31 pal. Officers L' tic. tat;e C; s.t 4 erst.cr ( 0
.. r.nr:i estr':tt:0 ;E r. sts) sar:e(3'eeks) rf-ir. %al LP.L e'. sed Mar..e &.G :cerirg C i, Ports: cut, 7try. :a 4
r e::atloc c fere: e (24
- c. curs)
(h.uar >
64 C 5 I.,/'TS.fjf.
f""",,,
nf,(O Ca:xo) i k t 2,.$ 4 f I i
UNITED STATES s
%,.....f NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ANNOUrtCEMENT NO. 54 DATE:
- A y 3;, !930 TO
A;; sp; ge::c,,,.s
SUBJECT:
N:C 5?3*'07.:..:. 230 *.: i'!:N CF :'
- ts: e: u a rew'se t a::.ra* c ;3 ::sti:' :rar: f: *.:, ca ted J.If '950.
AdditiCrt' 00:'es of : Mis Char
- fray he Ot!!ite ' Of-
- e : s:-t:.: on Seevt:es E inc, Esteasion I'333, n F::- :"2 of t e :-C li:s !Niiding.
/V
\\
GluN v i a 4/s
%omn *. Ha"e, Cir*ct:r
[g,L.Cf fice :f.*a a:e-eat and Prog a:- Analys s Atta:*ec:
N:: Cr;3ri:tti:n Chart a./) $
/
O
/
/f r
4 W
t t
O
[
G 1
me:e,..,
<s.
f g
.s i
+
I l
g 1" ' '*
l.
a.
.... =.
1 --
I i
T
- .go..g.
l 3.1 g
g
. e 1
p-
.6 g
g
..:.2..
l
-3.w r
i I
i r
i i
=..
t
. =.. =.. ~ * *.
t 2
l
.....a.r.
h.i.. h.
.m'
- 8.""
L'.
E' w....
h
...6.
4 I
l w -
-.e. " n r :.
.r.
.wc.
4 e
3-I l
1 I
I i
I I
I
- .....r-
...w.-.
.2..
1
..e
-=
T
~ ~ ' ~
l
-?l,.
- i
~
1
) !
m r
l.......
,,,,,;,. g;g,;,
i
_ _. t
.... i w
a...
I e..
{
==
7 i...
' 'p. -. -
- i..
. -. - I
=.
d.
s.
. I t
e.
a
.w..
i -.
,i..........
e, i
,.,,,,,...j m.
g w..
i w.
1 t
.., f i
=
j
-.,,,.a
=-
q s.,.,..,..
......... j........
w
.a...
l.....
....c..
r-.,..,.,,,,
4, _, _
w
~
t I
. J=.
I
_,e.
2 t
,,i.=
i
.m....
=
. =- -
i i
.. =.
g r
....... i.
i
. = * *. = =
- I ~==
1 I (;....
m.
e...
~;
~~~
t
-....t u..
t f
s l -.....
i i
l
=
.,. wl l
l
{
set HCea. 388W
- a. ee.
i
.s
.e aan ese.
.e
.ee m e tw.se 6
.e ee e a..
m..
s..a.=ss e.s.
.e s e.
NUCLEAR REGLLATORY Cowl 5510N
- i-
~
i I
1 n...,. _
,u.
I I
I I
.m.
t i i
I I
g,3
...s**. 9 s.
.W......'A" 0'
h..e
,1
- w. e.
I I
I 1
g g
7......a....
....i i........
1
. g.-
, l I
..~..
i l
[
l
)
w
-.... m 7.
. e.... r. : e. l
..c.
1
... * ~.
i e
g f
m.a.'s j
,8
. = =.
en 1
rw r
w ra
- v. -
8
.mme
.m
. ~ * *
==5.*-.
h.m...
d.
t
.~
.m.. s,
e.m
"'**h.""
8*
.w
- .m.
.a
.m..
.a
.W I
q g1._m
.w.
a.8. *.. "s'.8 M
. h..mWE.
w gammy j
I f
D7"
.,,,g, a
e-.m i
+g,,
.3
~
e.
-W f
g g
,g w
i
- " " ' ' * =.i
". w p *.=.is.8.-==.e.-
3.
w j
=s r a 4
. e..
L.
e M.
a.
- *.--==,
4 e*
.=
p w.~*..,
E=
f
, m.~.
85*e.
l a
.'-.e
.u.
l a.
.... =
- g.. %.
.f' j. -
.4,
' " " ~ =
b=.
.=
-w
.W h gu.
l l
ms.
- F 4
e
n,
,,4..
pg l
. = =. = = = =
d.
a.
gg f'
I
.. ~.
~
t.
u.
.sen, e p.,.
.m
.u p'e.au ma.
- a su
. u.
.u.'
W W 8.
bal.
M u a..um..
- .Am.
M
- .=
p.
at
.e r e.
i e
- =.*.t-
= =. =. =
' s h.'8 0 11mm...m.
p g ~...08.
.h.
- g.. g I
g 8W.
g l
8""*W.*
.um.. es.mus.
4..e u -.
~
_ _. - ~
i Y
.W.EE..m ~
W l
y_
'.s 6,,
me l I es.
3 p
)(_
e w
h ww
$..igh.ang as.
. *... e.*
8.
f.
4
..... ~....
EhMNT!Pm"Pumm.me==w" ww
=wn.
-.-w
-2. -,, -__,.,,'
M'Mh g.mi nm'm-w-----.
g
Y.s M'
.,sd "$w )
w' : "...
f(
wun: sr. ts
)
8eUCLEAR REGUWORv CovvissIOps 2
{
aas m sres o e rasss
(/
i,...... -
G 4 *!!!
Oc:ke: Ncs.: 50-323/ 320
}
AP:L!Cl*.T:
C0'i3 M R 70.E4 CCC W
- C!L!'f-M!:i,Aac ptA.,, ;.; 5 1 2 SL5JEC':
pMA:Y 08 JWfARY 16,198: "EET!*.G C4 5.PPI.EFEr4. REO.ESTS I
Es.R...o P W. F '.t.
g n
E
?:":lan.2 y 16,1960 :ne isoC sta",er:s,ts censultartse ee Car:any and 3
ar i a :n n r
s :f Engi9eers ne:.ita Car s.
1 e Ortti:n in Setnes:a, arjian, ::ter:ees s listed ~ in Enc 1:s 1'
p*e:0r'nti:ai pur:cte of tnis mettir; was :o discuss t'e status :f ~e sta,, s,,su:c!e ental recuests fc ac: tt:nal in :n ati:n regareag s
11 settle e. and e fects.
3 ar;,
e es' re:uests were issued en e t. ir 1 s [ is h e** ( g) ga2 373.ere discassed to ss
- he sta"'s re%ests of war:3 21 sed de :er 19,1979 nem iss.ed oc :Pe
- as's :' Secti:S U.!A f) t: 10 C*4 E, 9 :n is a::liestle t: ::9st a: tion
- er-its
- y virt.e of Sec: ten 50.55(:
cdification of tre *1dland ::rist uc :n :er Its was su:secuent'yi e sta***s 50.Saf p
'ssued :ece-ter 6,1379.
Conse:.ent'/, t was recogni:ed 19at any
-=: lies cutstanding a'ter Deceme 6,1971 =ere no longer needed in
- e 50.!:'f) context, but trat re:ltes secald be sub.itted nevert eless stece t*e Dece ter 6 :rder states that the absence of certain frformation creetnts the staff fr:m reachinq esse-tial cea:bsions.
It was 5,gges:ed t9at tne replies te s.Onttted in 19e :r al O.1, Q-2~ centext t/:ically associate atti the radiological safet., redews cf nuclear power slants.
~
9e acclicait also re:ceted that t'e ece-er 6 ced.e*
i s subse:,ent t
request far hearing, and F5:4 ke'ine*: 72 :*ovides the tists fca c c 'ud'81 its SC.55(e) recoats regar. ng tris atter, as furthe-res:.ing w al: te ey FSAR amen:
T e asoli: ant actre.ledged its in. ant to far:9ents and by hea ing docuren:s, as ay be starc Per a:date tne FSAR to re' lect 1:cro:riste c*inges assec ite: wit' the mis settre'ent "atter at sa a::re:riate soir; in t e futare, in t*e interin, tacse FSAt secti:ns aics are s.t'e:t to trange atti te f* gget.
8hf c s based an review o' t*e a :licants reoly to cues:i:ns d'e Drevided as a >gnde,; ([n 1353 e 3 9e'eto)' 4 c:rrents relate to mecianical engi ee,g t'#ects of the soll $e e
^^^
m
\\
n~a -
., ; l '., T..* . ' E i__...' ',~ i [7 - ^'i i t. m
_* ~ h 7-.'.'-
'I ~. 14 [.A
- .v'o.-
- A!'
t ' ii ad.. -.
- +
e<.
'~-i.;
-2 FEB 4 583 wnici are Deia; ev e.e: witn t e issistance of a staf"s consultant.
E.nergy Tecnnoi:tf E ;ineerir; Ceater.
Se scocesed es:enses t: c.estiens 24 tn eugn 25, 4 ard 14 wre serarized Dy ime a:olitant a c Ee:htel. Since taese -soonses will be s a:- ::e on t*e de:ie:.t t.a +- t.o to tnree.eeks, ao strary of : ese
- reseatat':ns 's se:.i:e: ir :915 m::rt. Se res::nse to :;uesti:ns 25 and 25 tas Ive se's-'c ra'fses.*ich 'ecaire additiona! ti e to Corelete p ior t: ss:mittal c' a f si epi. C :les of the vu;ra:h 51 des ased during f
t eie presentati:ns 3-e aintaired by :ne staff's !. :e s'n; Project vara;er and are availa: e a::n eeues:
.2:r,4. #.. zd Carl S. see, Pe:;e:: "sna er Lignt sate :ei::ars 3 3r d.:
Oiv'si:n o' Pacje:t "3 37e ge,;
En:'asares :
As sta:ed See nest ;a;e I
a===,,
Coas rtes 0>*r >r say c:s
" taael I. "t!'e', h;.
Mr. 5. H. n:-ell 19t, '.* ac:la A 9e s'e O ce Dresident 5 pie 4:00 C:ns. ers :.er C: ;3 y Cae First N t :aat "*ata 2'2 -est Mr:9';an Ave"ce i
Chicago,11ao's M503 Jacks:n, Mi:nigan AID' 1 11 '.. Sa::a, h;.
- r. Lsery A.;e
" a;' g ati: e.
Erergy Tecve'agy En;ineeeing Ce-tee Cias cers :>er C:e, say Canoga Park, Califera's 913a4 2'2 West "tc9 ;s,A. ease J#ctsen, Mtti'gta 4)23I Wr. Will'3'1'awheld U
S. Corps :' Engineers
" r. O 'Jd 1 A. perry N.EE: - T Secretary 477 '::Sigar avenue C:as3me's 3.e C:.: y 7:1 ~!:ce 7
2'
- w. "t:v ;e-s ca.e Oe:r:it, Mt:9i;an 48:26 le:ksen, M't, gs 11:01
",*:9 ". C'e'r), B:.
!" Dia:s Chicago, Illino s $C611 "erf StaC14
511' 5 ere set "rt ve "t1'and, Mitilje9 28640 F r a-k J. t e'*ey, h a.
- e aef Geaaeit
$ '. !! e o f M 'C a ' ;4 a f *. t r CM nt il I'Ot eCli a *)* di s ' *a C
?!1 '. t w 8's ' I 11 a')
' aas'eg, M : 'Jaa 1313 "r..eadell Wars 94!'
c:.te 13 Midiard, Micatia, 1M40 Or t-* J. "a"i t t, S :.
- ' ;sta, '4'eMem. t's.e tsn: 5,*sces 1 : t !,'3 $ C o-a.-
M ', s'. 9 Ei;*
- t mat
"'arescol t s
- aaew, $5402
"*. 7:n van ! 3*:=e, l9'e' C * *'sica of Iaf':l71tCII Wealt'l
~~
Cesa't wit s' Putlic ' dealt's 8
- 7. ler 33035
- ias'ng, wit'i jan 1"?C) 3es' feat lms:ect:r "*1? e-1 W!
/: * !. Nu:' air SejsIate f Cvtatssten
". 3. 810s t??'
"..;' a ed, w ica. 74. t euc essur
ENCLCS:RE 1 LIST OF aiTENDEES Ja.NUARY 16,1923 Nam Cr:an8 zati:n Darl Food 0 */N'R Joe 4cinski C E Cetroit Dist.
W111'am Paris, Jr.
Se:ntel-Ge::ech Jo Wafzect Be:htel - Geo Tech
- 5. S. Afift Ee:9:et W. R. Fe rri s Ee:ntel worot.*well ie:tel
(,
'n e: nee Be:htel Gil veley Corsters See T. C. tocae Coasa ers ::.er F. Sc" luer N ~-SE3 J. J. Zabri:sti Corsuners 6er Co.
S. Le Be:htel t
- 7. E. Jahrs:n Be:htel Jonn. w r:ce e
CCE NC Divis'en :nica;c jams e.
St csen Ar-/ C:r:s N;J Ciicago mittt e Lawaeed U. 5. Ar y *:E,"4treit R. E. Lic195t*
NRC-SE3
- ,rne *alla;ne-NRC Regici !!!: IE Ross.andsn.n 3aniel M. 3tt'en NRC Degion !!!:!!
NRC - NwSS A. J. Ca::st:t NRC' CSS /"E3 R. O. Sosnak NRC/055/*E3
- w. L. E ranner NRC/CS!/*E3
s ENC.05AE 2 i
i i
l
..; r....,.. ;...,
1..s t,
A
- ret I
1 Jg} yy jgf g..;.
e
.s..
i
...,g. ).e......,.,. s. g % g o... j, g..
i i
5 l
...f.
e..
m.
u g g a.q(
...f
+
J, 3,.
e...
1.
.....t., 1. s....a
......r...,.,.e e.
l s.............
..2, 4.............*
i
.... ~..
i m...
e.
- g.. e :.- ~.
j
..t.....
1 i
...a.......s..
o. =. -....
s.-
A*if-
........(. m....
e.-
- gr.. :e,...
a
.....t
)
I 1;
?...,..c.,.. ' -
.... g a
y
...... 4.......
5
+4.
gt.
6.
..,.,....... 1..
t...
"1 Ted
.y...ta*
3** **e.......a,e 34 4.
.+T.
4
...'J.
.a 4
dCht'$ 0F
~
I i
l
~..
.e. g.... e...
.. os.
.....r.t,,
c.
g, g.
g s.
...e.c,,.. ; I
..,a.
I l
l l
l 14; *
- s ',
- r;... s
.e.
. a#
.....F.
..C*C
- = *
.4,.... 4.;
- r%.* M r.:. 4 '.
's t : ? ? r.
- 5...a..a*ff
- ?**t.3 s. s.
- t' e.
1t. **
w
. - ~
=
..a.-.--e.r-
I'lCLOSLEE 1 C* TE4*S ON 50.54(f) RESSONSES FJR MIOL2ND (wES) 1 GisECAL A review of toe tesponse to luesticis 16-23 of t'e $ abject doccert ta:lestes tas the a::litant proposes to impose t*e 3.0 $g criterion af s.:: ara;-a:* NC.3552.3(:; of the A!.wE !!P10, Se:tten !!! and tie 5' rs:tal :ef: cation limit of :9e AWA. Ad:iti:na? :riteria which i
a::*ess :.:611*; s' t*e cipirg shou'd :e ieposed since neit*er of 9e tac pe::ose:
- riteria are base: on tats 'ait.re mode. Additi:na:!y, C*lteria C r:llance ana*/ses shoul be based en maximut expected differ.
e*:'ai set:*e-eat over t*e Ide of ;5e slait.
l
- . Di'J0ME ** %E!*: ' 15, A0! 161 T*t res:: ate a::resses st'esies base: ce, representative si;es tein; pr:'i'ej, f.e. :n carrect local settle ents. The response siculd :e me:iff e: to incNde settiemeets over t*e life of the plant.
3.
RE5:0'45E ?? OUE57!0N 17, PAGE 171, 8As1.1 If all Setssic Category I pip'ng is 90t to te profiled, criteria for se'e:tica c' pi:ing to be pec'iled s'ou'd te documented.
4 8!'.:35E * *.Ui!*:C% 17, PAGE 17 2, 8A2). 2 i*e :al:.'ation astres *st ;5e cunat.re is cors:49t over the leegth of :'ce, b geatral, th's c:*ditica will e:t te ett. Criteria for caaajes 1* :.rvata e shawld be addressed.
r l
o
/
2 I
5.
8i!":%5 E ** ;'.E5 *:0N l'. P A*E l'- 3, Pi:A. 2
- ' t*e settleetnt stresses are based
- 9 c rre9t ;r: files oni, the aralysis f
sac.'d :e esteeded to **clude sett'er49ts Over t6e life of the plant and e"e:ts :' :Sa ;e in es vatwre !See item 2).
e 6,
8E58:NSE *O O'.TS*:0N 17 Tae : vest en etgar$1ng measures to se 14ke9 to alleviate :cecittoas if sett'ereat stresses as: *ach ca:e a'l: mattes or :3'not te deteami*ed has not :een accressed.
3E!***.7E ** 7.!5*!ON 19, 8AGI II 1, 81 A.213
!! 1: 9c :'es' that most of t'e a ti: :4tes ci"ereatial settleme9t wil'
- ar ti t'e t'*e of fi 41 ctos.re '8a's. 2). Fr:.ist:ns for effects of settie-eats Oc:Jef g after final ciss.re s'oald be specified. The e.s'.ati:as cf 8a a. 3 ataresses t9s 'ssue :artially.
5.
a!!80%!! ** OU!5!!!N IS, PAGE I!-2, 8A:4. 2 4 3 i
Crite is 'sr assessment sf t*e fles*bi'ity of pipt -; to at:3nedate mcre
- am tre es:ected differential sett'e e9t seculd te specified.
f J.
IIIS7%$E *2 7CEIIl0N 19. #A*Et Il I IC '9 ?
, g
't
, y,, 4
- e :'s:cs'tfon o' t9is aespc95e will te deiayed :eading receipt and
' i rev'e= o' eva'wat':95 based :a t*e ;re':ad :re;raa *!ee last paea;*3p' cr pa;e li 3:.
- 0.
ats20%5E *? }UE:!!!N 20, the f'rst ; ara;*s:6 of t e response is sc:estatle. Howevea. the remainde* -
Of '.he resDc9se rt;utres clarificatian.
g,k m
[t-:d.u...;
J,,.., A
.s e. - '......
p.,
- l. ;.; % O '-0 Q*V tc,,: b.$rd;
[, /
3;; 2.
MN'
.f(3 g ]i terTE::sn ss Ni.:ct.uR 4ECJLATC2Y C: %f.vlS3!CN Sc., M* -a,-
c nas orm.n neas 1
h.
- s,w
[ \\'
U*[.
'g
[,
(( k
' 5 iT3 g
L i
w octet N:s. 50-229 I
G
'.,1i.'4
{
g.0 4
anc 5:-323 4
,\\
- d..
.'R L
/
t.
AP91.10MT: C:nsura-s Power Company '.
b p
FAC:'.;TY: Midland 81 ant 'Jsits 14 2 SUE!**:
5;W2? :gr Jt.U 18,15'141***3 03 50:'. OET;-*INC*E3 A7 WI M::18t:0 80.'t! $!TE On J41., 13, 11'7 ne NR staff set in 3et est.a. waryland v':1 ~:ns;..'e-1 7cws? C ;any anc *e 8ecatel C:r :ra:*:n :s cts: ass cef':teac es in : e fill used at ce site for Nttland 8: ant, ';tt:s 1 & 2. Also ;rtsen: ee-e re:*tsenta:t ves s' ue AC23 staff. Meeting atte-cees are lis: : tn Enc?:sart 1.
In ts: case ta.'E recuests, the a:sli: ant 'ias ::c.vtec f n :etail t.*e artsenta: ens g1.e9 :aring tats ner.tng. Se artse-ta:::-s art ::nta. ec
- 5. H. dewe ! s letter to J. 3. se::'er catec tagust l'2,11'3.
- 1 i
in view of ste 161us: ':,1973 le :e, no s;. mary cf the artsanta:t:ns is centa' red 9t tin. taper, ef.sttler4121sc:ssten c:nststt g sf c--rents and quest cas given curing a.4 faltswing ::e prtsenta:fces art sessar*:ed.
During the presenta:'en regarding runedial vert in pr:gress or :*anced (ite:S 3 o' t?e Crtse-taticas', the sta*# n::ed :34% unce*; rop! 21;'99 froc t*e crt:ad eater storage tarus A*4 se vice water 11'41 ; ass uncea rettr:ad tenets, ard that t.'ese anc et3er : stag are sub;te: t: '.'ca cs due ts corsta cit:6 cranes ans etre* :*1 f c.
The s:aff t:yeste: :Me f
as licant *3 *ese-* e De dest 1n featuats a.ad c*.'er SeasE*ts w*t:3 ass."e '
, g'.
t*at saca 3 s*1g ts et suo'ected ts az:essive 1 sacs. The a:p*icant w*:1 res:or4 a: a later cate.
The a: cit: ant actet uat it is ;ted:r aing *atorst:ry inves:tga:':ns of t3e s:stn'est stet! :tsing renoved 'ecs tne ::sceasate s :rsje :ans.
This wedtage:.nd :':*19 was *ound to be heaetly ::rr::ti.' It was ncte
. cat Me in;e:: ten s'atng fr:s SkS~ ts af ue sam :::::cs ti:n anc is also cor:tected '-:s elect 3.cheart:al attict. N tut.:tts m ue tant 'ars arts we':n are ne'9g cug :s '9ves t gata 13e ef'ect ed te
, air af sche es f-:ri ederg tend sne:r.atte Mnes.as also :sser ted.
J.aesults wtII :e etscr e4 sact.ly.
M.
.,_..,.,4.-
9 *
.e
.e FL9L1/A ^l/
J c
C *~~ '* :* '*:~f 0.:ns m s 8>sr Can=ary
-2
- he sta** nc ed tsa: tre ressonse s *:s 1: ~~1 !C.!4 et:uests ':e ac: ::ance crite a f:e atme<*al ac tus le.g., :ves:t:es 4, 5, e :.) *ad ic etsa ttes in taeattfication af c-tte-ta 13 acva ce :* ue toodtal ac*:n. lattea De rtc?y 'stes :*4* *.he c'**erda viII te ste"T*ied fur *ng :* after t*e Pt'9e:*al aC* ton. *he s*af* sta:44 ma* *.31s a *r:ac Sy ue a: cit:Li* 2Ces ict 3rtstae f P tt3eI f s*A f #eectaCs at :Se ou*. set Su Pat *er L*e staf' snis* emai*
resul*s of ue 3r:grsa 13 3eter2*ne uPat ac:ect&*Ce Crite**a we*1. sed art If they art ac:ectante. Ns, tse rimecial ac f on is betig ::rcuced entrtly at us applicant's me rist.
N accMcAnt's artsentaticri e' the :ersane : site cewate-tig systa (3resen.
tation 'tes 3.3) meted ma: the systas is net castgree ta se'src Oategory
- recut enents. tu taa: the sen or* 9 as:ecs cf 3e sytten a t safety grsce.
te 1R0 staf' ncted that ac:e::ance :rtte*1a for ce gewatt *ng systes are steen in :Se Standar te. aw Ptas (!ec:f on 2.a.13, tev's en 1)
AN rec.estet that me a:Sitcart accetss 3rtren *eenical 7:s': on.*83/Z31,
- tafety tela:sc 8ersarent ewatering Systees', 2ev*s'en 1. attamee usat::.
Se a::can otti es: cad in :ne near fr.aat. *he :uaitty ass.raace staa
':r isc'e'untsg me newate*ing systes e111 a'ss 'ae ;r:v :e: ts f...ee ete:r:s.
Sectet ces:-*:ed :*e stracura! ano se'sa*: ana*ytical **ves:t;4:*:-s te g
- e ':r9e1 :r s'aered f:r :.*e afW.ec n ac. ts (ites a :* ue sesse:at :ns).
N sta** noted 24: furtnee rev*ew :' ue ac:ste a: ton (t) value asas fer site aestgn 'tas Sees tacacted by sta** ser::wer rest actar'ng f:r :2e *>I 2 investt14tt:es and 2a: use :f outst:e c:nt xt:rs far the wt:1and setta*c revf ew *s :rtsently betsg c:ssidered. De s sff also noted 2a: 1:s prese-.*g rtview 'M*:stes s:se areas of itsagattmnt e* 3 ue aco!' cant's :rt:: sed
/
1 cads c:retnattens and testyi crt:er a f:e $~1 aM aiffertettal sett eaunt, "
anc wiu ne treetsent of c sos in stractars! watts. De staff et11 fur:Mr document utse and other postttons at a later date.
Sectel recorted (ftes 7 of the resentattoes! the results e* f:s 'evestt-gattens tuo tre cause rf 12sufft: tert cossacten of :N :ta t aate 8111, anc t:eettf'ed fies : asses c:ns'deavd to de :ne us: 3r:cante.
- >e a::!': ant icted 1:3 agreement eith the locatel M137s. Becatel ictet Dat :e scere'
- eat 9ct 'nctucet as a sos procasie cause :ecause its riv*ew sf sualtcat*ons aN es:ee*ence
- seta lectal ane 'J5 *estieg ;enenret nat sacw9 lrtsence sf suff?cten ecuatten, erse eece, and triti 11 to car *y out ce :asas ass *;w3
'N illC sta" wtec eat 1 disartes stu !ectes ftM91 e4: :e-s:nne' i
s y :cualtf t:ation was 9c: 4 areetale cause, and statet 34: 'urt?er Ptv'ew of :se /
- asis f:r 2is 5ocatei f1M'.15 e111 be seeeed.
,,/,
- I I Staff cameats regarting :.N ONCC as:ects (:etse-:At'en ' tem 3) we t 34 sed u:en :se son'teant's 'O C74 50.54;f) res:enses :s :t.astion 1 :y le: er :f aar*1 4,;379:
i t
\\
I l
l C 'I U l
.ss4sers 7=se 0.amessy 3
l C
- % aesttease:'s resconee 's tas 3.! sf 4.=e e s ! (;ege !-3}
a na:es ts =nc'est:s pa: h f*:st*:ns :-Z'3 n=w :-211 ar: vise l
su'*tc er's crtier a sy wato :s e,s.re ne: ce ft!! ts asemate's a acee :s :re oet exasst e set !aset." *%e sta** suces :
- Sagrww-: etu ta's stateue-c. *% sta** secos, 'ar esameie, us: t a :E twes:?;e:1ces saan un ce sanct*tcetons ea set r5mtre amat*f? cation af es ammet ased ta causact ne:er*a!, t.as l. ts*camsses pe*T **.ad sure eacessive fa asemata cassac:tes.
!i me as s*.a-o capt='el ses esc!eer aM De Caucac:t se e**ar 2
l sese'ss Mi sf emusec:*se uns tscar=elty to ::wfite vt:ste Saectf :at*se C-t';.
i (2) Be ass *' car.'s ess orse is
- tan 1.2 ef A;oengts : !;4ge :-3:
$ctec ca: f ette's, *.t's, ta'econs, and smers-e4 are :*.m l
4sec :: :!s
- y so
- tent :f : e saec*ficat* res, es ma: **:
ts csr3*e* ca: 's sans s s.*ws ne c!ar***:4: n :re,* sse
?"x7 s.sc netwds my aw=e me"*ee t3e saett**:at sn w : ort
- r54"! ca rsg t'e oce +1 of :.*e s:ectf acatecas. 'Se sta**
i conpe-te Det a seat cst: se statement acceers ta to ee.-
-:ed 24 sed.:ce t's ",M'*;s of lIE.
%.se-xs exass'es see-o te ee: s anc i='s Na e-asas is eenge se receirene-ts rf me s.ect-I f :a:* ors **uwt *i, steg : e :xt- !'es :oc:.re-: : set
- oss c' sc t, :1E !9s:ec:tse tee:-: 9e. W I:3/*S.23 are W :~.C,*1-02.
- E ' ort en met anti ett esse sonoranda :senge ne sentre-acts v.ae spec *tenf ans, sut ?e same tistances, caef;!=as ett2 3rev*ous eng*see *Sg casc:t ves.
i i
(3)
- % sta'* 1stee Set *:s rev er af *.A aspects ses :ssttsf ag d
l and :3E Nruer resp.ests Pw Itf:esuttan weste se 'ssaes.
l l
at De canc? s m 3' De actssetat ses, ce W: C a** 1 stas :Se: se 4
'ef:rmat'sa :rvsentet een s'prtftem: ta ue preser:: rev'em, and vesestas 24: : e aco'*:arr esset see s.ast: 1:s presents *ans. *.ic!4ctsg tse*a of
.4 3iSeg Icn s M ses d ee.
+
^ p/
N a
,~
- arl deed, s. ;ec: se49er
' ',p dater teactors trases to. 4 3t tsise af 7.;ect seagnamt Esc'esnt 4s stated Csl: See 42. sege
yt
- j;f'<
- .1 V
I, Jg,
- seers hwr Oe:asy j
t r !'
gg*
If m:ssel :. *i 'er. Es;.
- r.
S. d. M =e'*
- ssa, Lt csis 4 3esie it:a 7 es :en:
j l
Iu?:e 4 0 Cons,,re s 8:w-S :ry i
l se Firs: 4:':na' 81a:a 2'2 '.es: 't;n pa Ave se 3
I..
Oi'ca;:,
.*1 acts SCEC Jacts:n..'i:stian 4;M1 I
bI Ju e L. !a::n, Esc.
Sesme s hwe Cm:any yl}.
l'2 des e:ht;4n Jeem.e Jacisan, F1C31543 a;MI "P. 8adl A. 7e-ry
-g Secretary Sasse-s hie-Qs:any
,r 2.
2 :2.. =t:-t ;43 Avese
-L Jaca:n,.tcat;an 4;201
"..n *. "N a y, Es :.
4
- ee 3.w. 7' a:4 14 "h *:4;o, :' t nct s it.61:
.tv
- a y st~c'a*r 5.*" !,sre-s et *et we m::a.ac, * :nt;an a!644 F*at J. Celley, (sq.
3:::r9ey *eaers' 24:e of.*tcat;an tivtr sen:41 7.tec. ton lh a tstan
'23 :aw lut!afng Lans*ng, wtcat;4n 44912
- 4. Wecet! m esn411 2: ate IC M :!and, =t :s t gan 44444
'd Gramt.'. %--1::, Es;.
?ca:sen,1'elsen, t: ave-cass 4 Jane 4144 :;5 Co.-ter
~
44 3cw:3 !!;."t3 2rwt w
.*snea:c:1s, Ptves::a !!442
+. en 'v an 3a a:ie, Ot t e*
O'<*s'en :f tac at:stea! wa;:a Oe:ar :ar :d A. ite g at:3
- 8. 3. Son 23:;35
'.ans?19, m::;4n ai;C9 1
l l
V[
,n
- - A jg z=
E3C:.05'4RE 1
_n...
- It0 tis Jaiy !8, 1971
$ f/ '4
.,y2 m.. q ll-M*iir Censuwes 8 M C:eca=v Sec%tel' G. 5. teeley T. E. Joans:n (SPC) m
- 3. E. %ri P. A. *artinez (57C) iNi T. Thir m neadas E. Wiedee-l3PC)
W d!.
T. C. Costa
- 3. Ria: (M)
~. j 1, W. R. Fe--is (SF)
If,('
N. Wan! ( AA)
- . I,#',.
't#C : *iRR A. 8. Arme:s (SF) s-'
S. Cear (M)
- 3. 5. Ned F. J. nsta (M) 3 O. M. Gillen
$.5.Afift(AA)
R. E. '.131nski G. Ricartson (IPC)
A^
J. Stirty A. J. Ices.,37*)
F. Sc.w er J. R. 34,ie (G)
- t*)
L. detter L. 3. 8.teesta's U;Y;.
8ete' *:asaitants f.
9R0 : 0E*.3
- 4. 8. Pect R. LOWResy
- 2. Moefling C. H. Sow!d
.=
49C:I!
M.
D. W. Mayes S. Ie1 Taper 3-l [.,
J. S. %Merson AC15 3.
atse
- 7. 7as SPC
- Sec.'ttel PMr CJrporttiOR M= Aen ar>er, etotgan 57
- San F*LnC11C3. Calif.
4* 141 t.'w=13urg. %.
m
- e k
.e 4
., +.'
+.
l_'(
t F
e
,, gl h s',
s',
, i t
i h
-Y Y
6-g
.,a
1 i
_. s.
b
- 4. y
.L.. / r..>
o
- u..
- l. x - t (.
- 2 )
- h. L u. 2 t..
3,. a ?., G D m,
(
r i
s
's P
e.
?
/.
.- k...
_ ', N /
f p
g 3'
---USAs W d '
V i
<p i,
c i
- /*- - 9 I
%.R AudL_f %,.t M_ti<'...g_,
L M 4L6 *( M i(-sk.
_.).. _._
4-m-
s 1.v
- A A.;L _3 _ [
a r
_-_..n_.__
% W %. u.u G.: s. J a 4._ d.--:. _ t s.
l
\\
\\.
i b..c L.t r.0 je
~-
\\
J -
u. _ - -..
F
,_..._ h._. st.
,..i 4 t s Ls. A, %.._.
..t a.
g
~ _. -
s.
s 3 a-
+-
--......m....
. W k h:J. s.L ns h.)J.k,..u.,. y w
' w,.. r,.e.
v.
c a
- - ~ ~.--- r. a ---
r.
\\
"\\
w A
/s c
e p
?r r
/
'd' N
l.i
.A 3 * *' E *
- k.
- .k,; * ** A f f JJ
- :.....,, r p
0 t
/
L,
/
\\
r
.n Y_ nd W U$
O % x. h LLue l
1 l'
- i. t L.
l
___. v l
- g.,\\ *' lf
@ %*h[
I
\\
se q
=-- g K-w w-
.r
-l-1 t
A _w _
Wr <,.,
~ 6 E-h%,, '. ',
%.. _.. ], Q'
. s __
. _. [.
4 j
,A.A '4 s
L_.
\\
i aa s m. e..
.g,
.wa. w p jg;;f.
PCL H4-A -
f,..
Q;fl n oc u a u su t M L..,s m
'.M t %~,.:./,!
RE GICN ils s,
...w
.e w,, <, w.,,. o.
... na,,,
January 21, 19s To:
G. Fiorelli, Chief, Engireeri.9 34;:rt ac or cCnstruction and DRU*
- 0. W. Hayes, Chief, Engineering $ gor, Se ti c ca 1
0*
E. J. Gattagher BJECT:
rgg;ING W:TH CCNtcrgas p.
RE3ARs!N,gg:.3,.g. g.
C PPA y c; YJARY 16, '9 M A eettie; was '.etd cm Ja uary 16 eain :wrcose wa;s to ciscuss tre licensee's resa.c 9
ecee.t issue. The 10 CFR 53.54(f) c;uest+cns '24 thrcash 35 issu s; case to the s.::*.etta Attached are the cresentatica materia's di e
on Novetter 19, *;79.
stritwted d. ring tie seetirg.
The fettewing caservatiers were made during th e rettingt 1.
Mictand fev dation eaterlat remain wresolv s y o f t *.e the situation since Cetoter 1978.
e, as has :een 2.
Since trarsfer of tea res; n e en N:ve.7.tr 17,1973, no cro;sititity fr:n ;E t: ?.4%.ns ea:e techni;at review of the outstancing clant finress has teen vade in th t
safety isswe.
3.
S'.nce the Cc ss of in;ineers has teen contacted b review the issues, in Oct:her 1979, no Drogress h y NRR to made regardi?g a technical review.
as been 4
Since the Nt: order of Deceter 6,1979 to C:ns
. due to the wceding of the order.Corsary was issued w trs P:wer nue b
""recuested by the Licensee the orcer sculd not beThat is, if a Y
i untit a 24te s;ecified foMowing a hearing.effective 4,
has re: vested a
- earing; therefore, the order is i The licensee 0
m and uctuitatte raterial as fewr.dation for thea nef testivt sswes s tructures and c: ;ca.ents.
s a 'e t y-re.a t ed (I.A f),A 4m.A-4 y
+ J f V 6 V 31 Q u
~.
.o
.. ~.
/
/
/
j G. Fiorelli
\\
/
2
- /Utc i
~
[
t 5.
Consars Po.er Cc.any and sechtet are orecee:in; mits t
I
}
construction of rececial etasures cn the taxatt:.-s of i
the plant withcut any review ty.ine Nec statf a-:
of the pr:cosed actions.any c:emittal by NAR as to the f east v'thcut f
i
{
d In view of the soeve, I believe that seasures stout: te takes to pr j
y further constructicn of the rece:tal measures on the ;Lant f tLL
{
j e:Lude 4 technical review sf the suitati'.ity is coctete witil i
l i
f kh osw2~' h k E. J. G4Lla7er i
Reactor Inspector Entlesure: As 5:ated i
i cc w/o encl:
l J. G. Ke:Gler O. W. Hayes R. C. Xttop T. E. Vandel R. B. L.andssan t/
j A
1 0
e
?
g i
i 4
A i
?
g I
1 I
1 s
-.~.
I I
i
(
, N.
s..
u-
~~ :. =,,,.
l t,~ l -
,... s g.g.
/ ***.**
Wft:rans r
/
WC,Lus ag: LA ;isv, ww.sacus
=-
anwes-Ja a c..wm f.
},
hei/!
. l
- 2 -i" 9 i
i g v9j
- ... t.
- CCC 'C5.
!!-!!i 50-23C A7":.:~A27:
Ors en 70.er 2 :42 t'C:.*. 5
- .dt a-c P'an:,. tits l' & 2
- g_-m,,.g
- t, 373 vgg :.; 3 5 :,,,:A
$;; *C-5:.'a$ '.e % 5 e.
n..
.c
- n :e:r:e* :.19 !. L'e M* su et 't ** ? 2*. **: ;ar..i'i
. !acr:e' ss::u:es, a
- es. n-s 2ns.e-s 7:.e* ::r: arf 27" in gec:r.':nini r;'reeri ; u : s:.ss u:esst.e se::!re-: :' t e a : :acesuis, es se::le ea: :" :t er 3tesel 3e-e ator.;G) hi*:t ;
Scie tManta :'s:.ss':-s ':": wee se's- :
- ate;:ry :
1:.::.res.
a s'u ::.e :n Oe:rter 3.1572 se eg.e*:- :*e V" su" use,e:
i I
esci :' :. ese s:~.::.ets. A::er.t.ees f:r : e :: r at: :e r u : s-
- .ss :ns are Itste: in Er:1:5.re 1.
E.ecks.re
': :*e a;e-a.se:
- .r ; : c tecnnt:.a! sis::.ss*:n.
I.
!act:r.:nd Nrsw.t :: '3 CT4 SC.55'e). ~7*.0 9::"t e: Reg := *:* :" : e Ea'
.e-ent ::1I: cn Ie: e-:e* 7.1i73.
- tee :f rs:ec:i:n at:
se::1 rent :f t e Halanc lG ! thte; ':.r n n a-: ;e e-sur 9a:
- e:4su'.s nas grta'er *.*an e2:ette ar.4 *A: 4 s; tis ::*t*] '
- cgrn ac teen surte to
- eur--re tee u.se : c enaa:
m
- e p-::les. An irter's sut.s ee::r:.as :r:<*:e: li! :f C7'3's et:r of Scote-:er 21. !973. :1I ::-:.::e:
- e::t:-s
- n nis rat:e-en Oct::e-24-:'. li?3 ar' iss.e: : s:en :e re:cr -#:e 50-3:3,73-12; 5:-33 /73-12.
2.
Hist:m Se ie: te' re:rtsrut ve 1:eatt' e:
- e Cne;: j
- s:.::. es a-: : e jpe :f ataria* s.:::-it 1 e s:..::.rt.
C:ntainmen: - 11actai Ti'l a.
3.
Scrate: 4:4-5::rste 71 s - 7:4n: F 11 f
- c. Oteset 5eneent:r 3 tiatng ano 7ecesui - Pian: 711' i
A.mit tarf hileing - 7ar: ;) acta' : il 1 ar. ** 2-; ~'11 a.
e
~
g Service ea:ar :suae - Gia:ts: *-:: 2 : e:e: ::r-
- j) e.
P;r:ri" s5.ai': : nfn.: a
- ns-e.::n ;
s i
=
4 "4
>, c) i m w p y'-
i
- /
'i
,..._,... -.,,,_.- --l
/
... ~..::
M 8s e sen:ce: x-t =*4 ; : :g r- :c,2 !2 : e rs. = :aa g
t e us. red sen'emeats are as #:".ws:
Sn u ea: - 1/4' = is 3* :.er !as: 1-I '! sea-s biita y 1.t!:' g
- ce:x ate'f !.3*(: ant-a: ur. :.
Ierv*:e eatec 7 s -c.se -
- s 1,5*
1esel 3e-e a u r 3. ;:t ; - 3 u ** st-ce fe :'as.4s sc.rt:
Octue-1T' t-
.atIs i1 S:rta; I97!.
Se 8:.r e' ectr?al 2.c: :4 as ts g te n :?e G !. *: ;. as:
or : este-: ?.v..e r:
u :?.a ;Ia:*a: ::*1,.e e :.: ::cte u reet :. e se::fre: res:rfett:n a.n : e t r:s s ce :' : e 3 ie ':* i.
.'e9 : e 1.c: :4 as.eae e.: 1:cse. se".'e e-: :- : e
- e* :* :* =c:.~. ec :m : e -c-t s :e e' : e ;G i. ': ; : i
-w: es:e. Ite eas:.a : envr:ec ra:t: s en
- re-:.:!'-
- re.eev'. %:
e.es:.4" sa:we: ee f 't :'e s.::e:.e-: :e::'e.
e":.
'Ys 194:a:es :4: 19e eas:.a:1 mes :e ; e::.: ::e 1.c: :etesul.
3.
!cils 6:':-::1:a
', lec-:e! dis: ass.: tav soit es;i:ratt:n :e:;rt, ' :*.:t ; : e urt9; :-:;-am 4-: 14:craury testta; :f : e 3:.r:a: :9 a:e-ais.
Tre c:nciasten t 4: mas saae Of !ec-tet is t.4: : e 4:ee*a, artes ac~.ss ve site is st eag:3 :re:er *es, t.e.,.-:: d ee :: :ress.,e 1:reefu *r:s 2'" 85~ s 40C: 81F ae: s ear s: t ;t- ' e ;; 35; O 2%~ PSF. *re sails clas:t* tati:n et ;e: ' :
- u' fecate: a'ss tis:.ssec sessi::e a.ses n:ec :a t-: : ' :e a ::=.
s unt. Or. 4. 8ect.
5,.~e :f ; ese :n.ses.e e:
'i'
'44-' at'e ::.4* *:j :* 4:se* a ?.se: t tre : an: ' *!,
- .e.e.
- e
- .,4:t:f ::r:-:: rec:r:s :c -c; -c: a:e : e,a-4: :.
22, F 'I u f. ave teen : a:ec :1 : e :rf st:e 3f :::~s.;- c s:. e, 4*: tre9 res :'e.4 e* u::e.54
.rea: ; ; e *t!', t e 114*4**aI *-af *4se OeC3RR *s;f*.*
t '.3I
- le* ftII 94f Save :ee1 :le:e:
54:!s# :urt'f :.* s'Me 1
iSsta
- tMg :':e treeOSes aSc 3.c: :a34s,
.e f1'1 af aie seen vs: rue.
g e
,.... - m-m_.
m m. s _ _ _. -.,............ -., _. _. _ _..
1 l
1 1
I i
3
.g,.,.e. s 4
- s.iti-:s 8e-*:ea:,e h, 4. 3. secs statec :.e 'cli:.**;:
I
- n. 7 e c:.4: e: :1 s
. se: 2 *!f :' ;*t:*a* :*" in
.es excava:ec '*:n : e ::::"; :ca: s'et.
l
- . I,*:e :a es's:s ' :: re ina ::*e :. ve : 4: re Inse" 2*:
i s.:'.e* t'ess are it ::ac = *:02: nres Or te**ses.
4:e* ::ste*: is it;*e :ra 4: : e : e ve 'ti? =es :'s:ec.
Ie:::e tr : :* : e :ti! as :et' :::.--: g s"ce :rt;:*a
- aceae : :' 'ti!. 2::e' era:ec :y -c'essed cisbre ::a:e :
- es.!:'*g f*ss ':*I c.g :'
- e *f s *2*;e n:? f e; :ce:. Sci!
se:: e*=*: ts :c.r*ta;.e:e* ' s.v.et ;-: 1*: : e a::ec 4'; : sf ee A17::rg is :e::e.e4 :: :e t.1si;at'ita.*::.
3.
e ;*4 3.t*:*r; ac4 : ;re:4:!f.:: i.e se::*e:' as.:- t' : e u:er*a" rad -c; :een s.s.e:. t2's.*e unau is 't:;*
e.
Seart ; :2:4:t:y is *:: a :r.:len ':e tre 'n:ir;1.
0.*c a: :# rie:cet *; a t :
e f
- a:c.e : e a*: ; acta: :til, a *:rt.:4c' ;r: gras.cC: te : e :es: 3:::r:a:3
- he :re: a:
Ar.;cse ac : :e :: nesclicate tre fi*: 4:eeials.
- . T*e sen*e ea
- =*:n :*e peti:ad =c/: tead u :e es:*:.'s few see1s : A few *ICr.*.3s }.
M.
7*e :*e*:4* *s a Pecessary firs: s*.e: evt* :*:47 :**er reis.res ei;?l: De *4 Cess 4Py.
t.
- e 4
- e.re:=rt 1:. 4: -*; : 4::e* :: tre este :f se".le e*.
As :*e mete" *.4:Ie r* ses a*4 54 Lek es :*e I.
. 3*eI:l!'*j.C. :::.P *
- e A*If I;*) !*: :*e sa": ese: As j
- *e s.**.*4 *j e aCd : e ' enc eet t r. ** :
- 37 3.
- r..*. 1.*.r3*:I# :' Y :e*i..*:!"
. !.-* * *: 5 3 3 :: t e s
- es:** :e; !*e "s:.*ca:J:!:r' :r";*1:'! :: c * * * * * *
- e s e f e"e a ;
3.' :*.e #Ma3!*:* u te*? !' **: sta. Lrts.** *; : e *re' *a:,
~~e.*:cte :f Pe tast.. e*:2:*:e t s :: :e:e"."e t' *e :.*: arie
- s :: * *$ ! *s * : :' *:*s ' * :4:* ;* 3*C t #
- s *1.s**; 1*/ "J**
O *.*e ::.*.:* res :r a:!Ii:/ I 1 ties.fCe* I"C 1**.9
- e %'I"I f:;.
Ye 4
e
l l-I
.I
. A.
I l*
a.
s: care-:stice f;r tre 5:ra :bre w ll incl.de :: ical sarvey i
i essare en:s as aeli as % nit:rii; :# : 3:<: as *; electri:a' cev :es'. *:gr ::ca::: s f:r :Pe eis::**:31 :evi:e5 ns.e :ee-d c?.csen; :.: or :Ne ax ari:r :f the eas:. ail f e ;u !si ::n; and :,c :n :ne.es:.s'1 Of tay ne.:e* #:ae in :te ;G 3/Iciri.
A n:pic; :f crscks wi:1 :e :evelo;ec.
2.
F:a-ca:i:n eni:cring will ir: ace devi:es u tessure se::le ect a-: ; ore.ater :ress;.re. A ::tal of 6 an: crs stil :e insullec.23 ; cu:s :' 3 at siffere9: e eva:::ns). A :::al of 20 pie::ceters are u be insullec to tensare tne acre wa*er press re.
T'e C:Psaltar:s in: catec :nat 6 se::lecen:.ca!d e t be a sur; rise a.: tr4: a; :s as. M as 3* :ca's cc:gr.
- ae ;re :ad wi I be n:e.: Of 13 u 2" 'est :' sand :41ed 19 ar.: ar:an: 9e CG 34ticing. 'i: cre : nan a i ': : :tfferen:ia; tr. :Pe sa.: :evel
- et een :ays.cule :e :er- ::ec.
- e 'GC Ouesti:ned :ne ef'ect ci' settleren: and re':a:Ing :n :Pe c:ncensa:e lines 1:ca:ec arcer the DG !a:! ding. Fize: ;oints f:r : e pipin;, suc. as tne Turbine hit:19;.ali, are also of interes: for :re pcten:ial of can:11ever e'fects. Se:N:e1 explai9ed
- a: t e 20-13:.1 ::rdensa:e lines are encasec in 22-ir:n lires s rro.nced by c:ncre:e and resting in well c: ;actec sard.
- str 9e9ta:t:n will be included to centur tne :encensa:e lines.
i De scssibili y of :atting the lires 10cse a: :ne CG !atiding ar:
tre Tse:ine 3;ildte; is aisa bein; stadtec. The c:acessate lines Mate no safety-rela *.ed funC:i:n f r the Midland design.
Tre M: sis: ex:ressed c:r:ern for the e"e:: of se::'e ent :n :ne
' el oil itne: ance- :ne :;.ilding. CPCC state: :na: re-reu::91
- ' lines can :e rea::lj acurr:da:e: if ne:essary. *his ea::er is s*s3. cer re'tiew.
- e MC tesiae-: lrs:e:::e asked ':r a ;is: :f :Pe e:.?:een:, =1:5 a is:.siten :f :ne ::e: acting ca:a:ill:y ac li 1:a:i:ns of ea:3, aw! ':r c:e:a:::ng :ne f:I; for : e DG Lilc ng fr:m eleva:::n 513 :s 623 feet. 3e:n:el.ill pec< ice Inis informatun.
5.
3 : et-Stat s
?e Sec.'itel s.r.ari:ed : e ac:isities :sepleted, in pr:gress, anc
- anned #
- e
- e fatare:
6 e
i l
l l
. m
- .>.s.
- .., 7
-g,....c ;. -..
- n. v..,;,;,-
r..
..s..:: :
5
- h. Activities ::- 'etee t
(I) heing : :gra.-
- 12) *sciati:n of e ele::rt:a : :: =anas on :ne ner:3 s :e of :ne ;5 Sai: c; b.
Acti<':ies is 2 eer.ss (or s:en to, in4Matee-
{I) Four:at':s se:::enen: xnt: rin; prcgen.
(2) Pre cad instr.rantattee pr:gra::
l3) Act.ai ;reicac Of the structare and f:.nca:icn (4) F11;ing ; e c:::ing ;;94 to 4steunt elevatica (Eleva::s527,
{5) Or:'ete ::nstr.::fon :f :ne res: er :.e G g.t :tng stractu e
- c. ktivities P't-rec (1) After rereval :f the s.r:harge, assure :entac: :e:,,ee.
footings and s t foundation m.a:ertai l2) veriff.: :ities and s:rac:ar,.-:egr.:j 6.
Pr::e:: S: ee.1e Be:*:el presentec :. e fc: Sin;:r:je::s:Seda'e ir.f:enaticn:
09str.ction *s 55 ::mlete: as of gegeeger 1973 tigineering ts 300 carciete hrac.rt c: : e:e es 37; ::r:1e:,
~
_.,.el 1:a: tae e: date is.*ic e :er 193-garliest requ rent ':P cre 41escl ;enera::e is Januar/ 115:
..rrea: cc. pie: ten ca:e for One diesel gene ater is Janware "i!O
,a'est da:e f:r :ne :tesel ;enera:ar is Jure 1933 t
e 8
4 t
4
I I
o I
JM ;; '373 5-Ee:n:e'. ee:9as :ec tha: :he tes:s!!ec ins:r renta:icn aill sn:w Ia ei
- e ;,reI:a sJrC9a";e 24y :e 'accettc anc tr4refore the Ortsent
% s-ec.'.e is sc~e ea* *entative. Ns* settle en is preci::ed ic
- ar ra:i:ij is :ne area is teing :rel.ca:ec and fret.en* *ea:irgs
=1I1 te !aten :.*1ng this e'i:c at: ased as a basis f P for: tr
- Je:: ices. T e ra:e :f se::!e-ett.:11 dec es:e tr.erea':er a-c : e t:ul 54::leter: ;s ecec:ed s te reacrec winin a few men:ns.
C? 0 s:1:e: :. a: if necessaay. :e"::ra y ::esels ::al: :e. ac
- . :ng :re:: era: :nal ustin; :ri:r :: fuel 1:a:: g ara :na:
- 9:s 4::e-is :-esentlf uncer stu:/.
7.
- es:: se :: ::e- ::eas e N:: es:e:: :n :e::r:
Be:9tel a:: esse: the ::en ite s in: laced in 4RC fr.s:e::icn re:ce:
'i;s. 50-32;/73 ': and i:-33 / 75-12. 07C0 s:a:e: tra: a.ri::en res::nse cald :e sent is :1E fe;i:- ::I :s res: Tee tre ::cf':::
te: een :ne F5AI and si:e ir:1 cent:n; precedures:
a.
Se'11:: te:.een F5 A Ta::e 2.~-If snc Tatle 2.'-1; rega-ding tne ces:ri;;::n o' ftll tauria: and wea =as ac:salif.sec in :ne ranc:: fill: Secn: ; s:1:e: tna: :nis ::r.fite: was an oversign: and that an FIAR a e*=en: would te isssed.
The NRC staf* State: tha: 41y 5.cr a:*ead ent secula accress Oc*n tre pred0us anc the a jus 4: entries sa:n tha- *ne tasis f:r tre previc.s staf# review is not cuscared in tr.e coc r.entatic=.
D.
Ocn'lic: tet een FS*4 Tatie 2.5-21 and Becite' 5:e:ica:icn C-210 re;ar: g nur:er of asses ':e c: :a::1:n: Ee:i:e1 sta:ed ::a: GR Ta:'e 2.5-21 is f:r tre e :: arc ~ en:s f r :Pe
- o ing ;onc :ikes.
c.
FSA;i See: ion 3.8.5.5 -egare'n; ee:ec:ec se: le.ent: Secs:e!
statec :na:M-inen incica:ec di n e F*AR.as a mistake arc tha: :ne FSA:.culd.e a v:ed :: ::rrec: :nt s -isuke, d
Snflic: :et.eer FSA2 Fipre 2.5-c7 and r:Jec-drawing
- egardieg fo.Matien eleeat*:n: Becnte: state: :ne ehva:icns in :ne FIAR ass also a misure 3 0 wuld te :: rected.
Can'iict ib secntel Seci'intien C-210 regarcteg c:r : active 6.
effort: Bec ul state:
a: Fie:d Chan;e F.ec.ast C 202 h
- atec 10/31/ i clarified :n s co fi :: and ser-i::e: :ne 3e:itei *cc ' ed Pr::ect:r' Jsi ; 23,3:0 f:-1:s co :ac:
1.e e
a effsr: ra: nee inan : e AS'M s:an: arc of 56,000 f:-1:s.
l
.~.
r i
N 7
.3..,.
/
f.
Conf! :: :et.een la es 1 tre rec: r ee:ati:n re;aa:' ; li':
I
- nictress :f 6 :: 3 c es and tne 3ece::: s ecif ta:i:n :e- ' : ng I
ap :: 2 ir: es: Seetal su:sc :na: tre ;reater :e:S :e -
ri:te: :j ee:r s:ec*'i:a: :n sne.:4 nc: :a::e* :e:3.se :'
- erf:r-an:e ;;a: 't:sti:n tes:s. -cwe, ea. : e R'
as :nen infer ed ea: tre :es: :.a ' fica:4:ns ;e ':r e:.e e f:- 2:-e '
- lay :nly, arc : 4: ec tes: ;ualif cati:es On : e rar::7 ' 1:
=a:eru. sing 12 ine es.as pe*' - ed u cua :'y s.:r. ! t ft 51c cesses. Or. Pecs suu ma* ue :-':4er : e af e.
I
- e c e Oi"erea:es in ::::a::t:n ure.;n *re e cees: Of
- "e lafer *C4': : Car.
3
- era 9ce :f : 2*. in cist: e c:nte-: :e-.d *ec ia Ie:-tel hect' :at'On "-::3: 3ecntet su:e :na::nis :: e ance is in lire wiu ind.stry pract :e.
i Or. Pe:t was ascec his v'ew :n :nis
- 2: ::Ierance. He I
state: :na: !?.e - crua: ; esti:
s ":.'*. :' mu: a:ee 3; Stece :*e a:er'ai used in e 3:".as.triat'e, : e : 2%
- era :e ::.'c :aase a ;re: ec if :ce ateria :s ::
- ns:s en:.
n.
"encks in :*e bui'.i ; struc are: iecntai sta:ed : a* ali
- raccs ;rea:er : Pan : e ACI 113-71 Tiet:. calc :e i:en:1 fled and re:4irec after tre ;rei:ac ;r: gram.
- i. F":.AR q.es ::n 362.2: 3ecnte; sutec :na: :ne a.s.er ra: teen sent t: MR via FMA revisi:n 15 in be-:ee 1373.
C2~.0 stated tsa: :ne repif :: :ne irs:ee:f n re::r is in :r::ess, ar: :na :ne re:ij vili
- 1 :e ::p'es of all dau, sities, and crs= ngs :rese tec :.rin; :sts :ee: g.
In ::9cl.cing re arts. 7*;! su:ec its i9:e : :: : ::ee:. : : e pre:ac:r; ;r:gra.: as :es:-t:ec caring ee ree:i ;.
In '.s c :s g ::crents.se i C sta" sta:ed : 2: tre :r:::se: s:..
1:n is 1: :ne -:sc :' : e a:::i:an: anc : 4: NR~ ! ate :s :: rev e=
anc e.g'..a:e s a::ee 3:: r:ar:e.::r : e :- ;t a ::. :a::::-
reca:*e t-:s as se: f:-:P n - e ::r:1: ents :n : e :SA4
- e su" als: stated tr.a:.n :e it:en :n :: e ec:s ac: :n is - :: unt.
dete 11na:1cn :' tre era:: :3.se is ais: :a e i : rtan: f: ee f,
- ne.3:e:acy Of :te rerec ai a::i:n assess ag : e ex e : Of re ra::er reis:t ve.: ::*ea s: uc: ares, and in : rec 1weing e:e:it :n :! saca j
.11a:* e-1
- n t
- e #J:are.
j M N ** /
arl.w ::, P-:;ec:
- ara;a-c 9n* 'mau r Ielt::Ps 3ra*;* 4
- b ist:r Of E*:;e : 'a aie*ea.*
Enc':sdres:
As su:ec i
.__,,,._._w.,.
.,-.,%_m y.
,.,e, p,g,.
-,y.,we
+w,m
,_-_.,-,,,,,,,,w-
---4 gr.--
cg-.
I a
w.
. s.
~~'..
=-
... s e s.
l w.
1
- s.e.. ::
A aes e
,....t
.re es: '.4: :-a: 2's:a Cn :4i: :: 1: o s 6.:::
4....,.
~
- s. e s 3:.e- :..e y
.v.. t g.........,
s.
J J'a s 37 T. O.*
- jr 4rI!.'
"P. -a..
we*Pf 3d**e:4f
- -s.ce-s ::.e- : ;a f 2'.2 e. * ;* p a :ee.e
- acts
- n
- c p 4.;;;
'f *. * #.
- t **f, 5 5 0.
.rt. b' I ' ti e "n : ;s,.;1: sts i 5M
- a*: $.c'a:e 5,.
me sa: r: ee 2.
Mt::4.c, *:ent ps 43540 Cra *s J.
- t I ; *?. i 7,.
- * ' tf W t's.
Ita:e :' **:n* p-Ine:c:n.e-ta:
-::ec: :n ;, si:1 e..
2= 3.....,.
L af.s'*g, * ~3 ' p M Mi' 3
- P. e Ce:I44 *L* 4 '. I 4: e M::'t c. M ca pn 464
,c.
.3
. -o.e 4::e _: est:ea O
I'
.es: * :v ;t, A.e,.e
-.a:a s:a. * :-:p-47201 9
4 i
/
3. <..::.
- e
.n. e
- 2 A ;3.r.r.e.e..rw r a, i.s. :. we.r-g3 P. A. *a **ine!. 3et-"1
- 4fI m'*t:*er, 34**:e'.
- 5. S. Aft #i, it:':*el
- 2. 3. :e:s, 5#.-:ei :es.*:ar:
'd. 4.. e-:s, 54: :ei M. O. 4: wit. Sec.stei
- 3. 3. * * *er, 7.
- 7 eof ect J. 7. Ee:.s Se: :ei
'a.
Saa::ay,ie:Ste:
A. J. Sc:s, Secs:e1 i
G.
. :': ares:r, Se: :e;
,.. e.
. y.. p
.,,A
- d. 4. Bi., C7~; ~A
- 9. M.
aeeier, ~PC3
- MO C. A. r*.r:, C?~0 - E9;'eee-i ; Iervi:es C. E. S':: sic. "J:0 P-:;ec:
Jc - 0.r.a*:1if'. Be:rtal Oc s.::an:
A.s 'n "4 s a'.*. Se ntei - Ge::ecn
- f. <. Lin, Sec :4' - Secte:S
- 3. :. "c~: me', 'e:nte'.
"ec:een
- 5 0 ar. Beca:e' N. ! war: erg, Ee: tel
- C.a *:
, ae-e.Cc.d.a,;NRC JM r*
ner, b...e;i:n....k.,
aa..
- Ov e' It' en,,~0:1:~ 3ecsc ences
' Lf-ar. att'. Ier, '."l/SER " cs:ie*ces A
- A0r.ald CDCE,.4A! 2esiCer.:.*r.s:ec*.CP
'Presen :.rin; : cts : e :2. 3. ?3 st:e ::we a-: : e '2 * '3 ee:: ;.
m' I
I i
i
- --T--"-
,,,-r-.e=r*-
--r*'
l l
t
/
,/.
gn elo s vre ?
i J
r a
5.......
w Co.,,..,. a. s,...
L....t 1 e.,
Itese; Cener::ar Iai; din:
.:., a,3 a
l C-
..ae:Ing vi:h 23C a: Y.idhnd Dan:
Seccaber.'., li'3 a.t A.... A 4.
b:::du::10 by C?:o i
1 II.
E:s:sry by Ze:h:e; (N. Svanterd a.
Plan: descri;:10:
h.
Se::le:en: e.::i:::1:g ;:sgets c.
3:lef his:ory of si:e f:11 pla:e e.:
d.
Se::le:en: of Ca:egory ; s::ue:ure e.
Se::le:en: of diese; ge: era::: b.Cd: ; and pedesta;s f.
Ravie. se::le:an: data a.d 4:av::ss (5s-C-520. 6:3) 3 Cc: sui:as:s I!;.
S:11 T.xplora:i:n t., Se:h:e1 '5. Af:.fi) a.
Soil ha:ings b.
a::h c:n: ; e e::4:isns c.
Labora: sty :es:s d.
Possible causes IV.
C::saha::'s ?e:o::e.da:ica by ::.1.3. ?en a 4 C. s,..~un.....s.e a.
Fre;oad b.
Ins:ru=en:4ti:s V.
5: stas reper: by !a:h:e; (3.0. P.:Connel','
a.
Ac:ivities ::pleted b.
Ac::vi:as in ;;;;;ess c.
Ac::vi:;es p;a naf f:: f.:ure 1)
C:::ecti.e a::ica i
2)
FSAR =cnt::::n::
i i
71.
h.ed.;c by.c:St e; (?. F. ::.:e:;
t a.
Cversi; proje::
b.
h;.::
=c. pra;e:: s:hedu;e c.
Scheh;e f ar re e.ia; meaaures 1
r I
I I
1
-e%y-w---
w--
---y.-www-
+ww--eme.eww wg, w--#im.-yw se-
--ww-w-:,e-tw-I
Vi!.
Respc ses to c;en i:e.s i: N20 *-spe::or's re;st:
da:cd IL 17/75 sy le:r.::1 (3. ::: )
gg 17, $73 les;:nses :o 0411:ghar's c:.cerns:
a.
1)
Con!!ie: te: vee: FSM !ab;e 2.5-11 and Tah;e 2.5-;; rep: ding f11; r:a:eria; des:::p:::n
)
Ca:fi; : :e:see: FSM Tab;e 2.5-21 a.4 Spe:ifica:i:n C-10 re;artir.g required nt. her of passes fs: c: ;a:: ion 3)
F3M Se:::sa 3.3.5.5 - ex;4c:ed se::le=e::
&)
Conflic: :e: vee: TSM Tig.:e 2.5-47 a:d pt:'ec: d:sv ::g regardL g founda:ica eleva:io:
5)
Osnflic: :n !;ecif1:a:ian -210 re;a:di:g co:; active effor: la tes: =e: hod 6) 0:nfh:: te:veen consal:ss:'s recs ::e-da:1:n aM S;ecifiestics C-21: regarding lif t tr.i:k:ess 7) 20 :olerance 1: =:is:.re con:ce: permit:ed in Spe:if.:a:ian 0-213
!)
- acks in :he bc;; ding s:r.cture b.
FSM ;ces::an 250.2 (!4c:1:: 2.5.4.5.1)
\\..,,
..wos:. g
.e..:s 5y C' o 9
s" 6'
e W3f'98W' "W"T M N "
P,,,..
E
-..g-i ry=vvN u'"M.JII'
wn..
- . wt c =>.
SHH t '.{ 5 f ' [,.'.5 I n
-[.
- .,,o,
)o.<~ d
/
UmeTID sTAtts g
Q NUCLEAR REGULATORY COWi&SION
/
3 1 -)r 7 i
- h7. f f
-~ mas actc=.o e mss
,~. '
DM6 63.s *.
%,.'"..t
.I
..-, 4 y.
a c q.,. c...
W~3 i - :,
gs
-x D :te: sos.: 50-223/3%
(
- r. 1 V b~ # -
I
~
g(1 c
t ss c
a g
A:st:.A'.T:
Censs ers P:.e Ch :ar.
j s.
y---
e F ~;LI!?:
Mif an$ Pi c.
.. "ri:s 1 1 2 4
S...r T:
SUir m-a r :--.'
c ', 1 n
.x.
.. 1 :,.:.:...' o* * *.O S i e.."'a R... i s r :-
CON ~ATA.' Ti ~; REV:E. SOIL SE. E' E *.-
M N
? ap *f Ce Februa y 27 aad 23,1950, t e W~ s:aff an: tr ee or;ari:stiens re:en:1 at: Life 0 s;*,* r t*e sta#f ta#e*y review #
rnters, e:.iti C:as. e s P:.er C: :any ; a.e a::lican:), Se:htel a-:9e::e~hn' *3I ar! IN*.e f!*i";
Se:::e1 ::as,1*. ants at : e site for vicianc 7:an:, Units 1 & 2.
The three or;anizat: s s.:::etia.; :ne staff review are tre U. S. : y Cer:s :' E*:i et**.,
E*e ;y Te:- :1 ;.e in;i et te Cante, a-d U. 5. Wai S. f a Tat ; :::e :f e vis' ns;t: rerew and ::serse s':e :a:<:e Wea::"s 'e.te-fili cecien:'es ar: e " 2:::.
T*. s was : e int: al visit f r : e sta*f's c: saltants a-d tae tree:ia;. s te': :: assis : test cars;1: ants.ith :neir review of ers::qq d::. e-ta:"a ca ta e ::::
'ee:in; a::en:ees; are :isted in Encicture 1.
- r:. re edial nc'< ar': cresen; sta:as of :nis er.;er.
The infee-c:n eviewed a: :nis reetin; is ::q:3 aet in A end en: 72 t the Mira-: F':3. Ce:e ::er 19,1979, for w'iich refere ced atarial is forate:e
?
in, v 1. e; b,, : e i d i:aa s le er of Fe: rug y 11,1950. Cae c' ; e vc'. es ea: :lec ;0 C-"I F. 55'e),1*:eri 1 Re;;rts. Settle ent of Diesei Geae*! tar FO.ndatiens arc Egild qq," ::rsists of t e 10 CFR 50.I'(e) e::r:s sert by t e a:cli:aat :: :'e sta'f's Of' ice :f Ins:ection and Enf:rce en; fr:n '.c se :e 7 1 "Re:::nses :: '.~,; "973 ter:.;n Secte.er 5,1373. The a:ner voture, e :t:!e:
e: ests R 10 ;0 5:.5r') ress:nses ::e;ar:tn; Diant Fil'.. ::nsists of the 3:f t:aat's
- e Cff
- e :f '..f. ear Desct:r "e;alati:n s..:::e:
Apr' 2', IFi :ar:agn ',cse-te
'3, li79.
Trese c:cu ents re;resea.: :e aW ct-:*s -e: r:s a: n.aten t e staf'*s or:e-o' Oece :er 6,1979 re:u e";
- re: 'i:a:4:- :f t e c:nst,::i:n :er-its is :3seg.
T.,e ee in; 315
-r,,cs:
a preview O' :nfor att:*. :: te ::qtaineffn :evis':n 5 to :ne a:p:':3 rs res*:ises ia : e 'atter vcice 5 ;ea*e: # r 5,:-i ttal abc.t the e-c' Fe:r.ary, ;i5;.
s,is::n 5 wd1 incl.:e res;: ;e5 ::
e re:ses ts cf '.:.e :e* 19, I??9. Cnly nf:r a: n n : co:se 5:aff's sa::*erea:a; ntained in :nese co, ea:s is in ! weed in tais 9etting s.,rrary.
In ::emin; e arts, Mr. a ele *!d :: :e'er aM re a::al wortfeeley anecanced tPat C:*su ers Dcaer CO :1 y nas n.
acce::aece :f :ne :r : sed wcrs is recetvec fe:-'on ina:etately sa::orted structures until
. tre staf f.
This actt:n is c q.:,.r ; i, R.....
3 a,
% 8-
'a C.e. :. S.9 f
..n-x---
,,ma
. _ - _ - - - - - = + ' " ' "
.~
,..x
,:..r.
4
\\
b.
31..
1 uns volge:ary :n tre a::it: ant's par: since the effective date for the staff's Oe:e-:e* e,197; Order is t: be es:ab' sred by :.e rearing Scard :urs a.: to l
10 CF; 2.204 The basis f:r this :ac sica was said to be to pre:1uce ;;;e9tial i
1:ss cf re.en.e ass::iated.ith es:e.2:: -es for nnien staff a::rcval has nc i
teen ;eantec. Ine sta#f c: serve: :na tr.*$ was a cr;:st: :e :s'en, =ar: :.larif i
in sie. of e si;r.i'icant slip in ::ss r,:ti:n co-- etton pre.'e: ec by fe:r*.el and c.crer:1/ ande* review 3/ tne a;pl :an: and ca: :: tner causes, pri-::;a;;f the T* -2 at:icen.
8 eseatati:ns were aise given by Bechtel ::nsalta9:s.
"r. C. H. hu!d ces:rited the Or: edure for :ia:e ent :f :aissons te esin :9e electricai :enetrati:- area (i.e., w:n; as :s' ' tre :wmiliarj 5eic: ; and ce-eat tre Fee:wa:er :s:*1:t:n Valve Pit area.
"r. M. T. Oaviss:e ces:ri:ed the Oe:ce:are for :la:e e : cf piles to s;.:::r: tre nce:nern p:r:':i :' :ne Servi:e Water Building. Cr. A. J.
ke :-:n,.;r. re,1e.ad tre preicacie; : :g a c:. :le:!d 'cr ne ::esei Geera::r 3.ii:in; an: discussed a':f :*e ;re::ad a;;;cn was eie::ed in lie., cf ct e-possitie car e::ive 21:eetatives. Or. 4. S. Peck su ari:ed t e re::: e-:st': s of t e Se:htel ::nsitar:s 3rd e-9:si:ed that tae ;-el:ad: ; :::i:, is ::c-side-ed to el' :cate : e ree: f:r 19/ far: ar testir or easure e-:s as a tas's for esta:Iis-ia; c:-'::e-:e f:r 'u.re se:::e en: sc:;er:ial cf : e Otese; Oc e 1::r 3. :: ;. : s.- a y of :.ese ciscussiens ey :ne Ie:'::e' c:ns;*.: arts will :e ss:- ::ed as an are-: en: :: : e FIAR.
C.rin; the reeting, re'eren:es were made to certain inf:r ation and re::r:s n-i:P 9 ave rct been a:e availa:le to t e \\RR sta#f, althou;9 sc e c' trase ha<e :een exa-nec :f I&E tnreu;n t e a. sit rechanis:. Exa ples include:
1.
So e of the f t;a*es listed in t*e drawing su : ary for t e ir.ter!r re:: :s to MAA *2 aht:h are n:t inclu:ed ei:n 09e c:rpilatten cf re:Or:s f:e arded
~~ by the a:cli:an:'s letter of Fe:*ury 11,1930, even af ter n ted fi;;re replace ents and redundancy are taken int; accour:.
2.
19stallatice de:a 1s of ea:n cie:c-=.te used to eni ce ::re. ate- : ess; es caring tre ;rel:ad progra:: (e.g., :ce and actual eleva:iars o' insta ted pieza eters, ba:k'ill esterials anc : re tnickness).
3.
Re: orts,"vetin; sa raries, or ::Fe* w-itten :::ani:st ens with Or ty i
c: sulta.:s re :- e9:in; Or sa:::rt'n; *eresial eassres ice s:rs: ures and utilities lo:ated u :n er in q.esti:,a: e soils.
2 Re: orts c' t e evalaatici (e.g., tases, precedure, ere:at'en a-d res i s!:f the initial quill'i:sti:n and s :se:aec: requalifica:icn of :::;a::icn e;.i:-
nect.
5.
The report " Tank Farn Investigation; Mi:1and Units 1 & 2 " issued Oct::er, 1979.
l w,_ _n?u._w-, - --- =<A N~
~U"-"""'"'~""~'~"'~~
I E
. 4-m T
w
,3, d.. J 1 9.-
g Efts 1c The staff n::ed that su:P doc. ents as ab:ve are neede: by its c:nsultants for l
their inde:e-dent assess ent :' the ace:at:y of e pr:Desed re edial reasures and req:.ested nat :Pase te.?ade p:.blicly availasle. ine a:piicant in:icated a rel;ctan:e :: :n's end, and c::e: t'at :nese were avai a:le thr:.;n : e :1I
?
audit me:haris. *ne sta#' w'i: issa. a 'or al e::.es: f:- t.ese :::. ents.
e staff als: rnec : at tae ::rta; ic;s ;r:<i:ed in :::e tii :: cf : e F ;; :i-not reflect :nese :ortn;s ass:::3ted with pie:o eter 1rs:alia:i:c; the a;;li:2.:
replie t inat these weal: :e ac:ed.
Site :ours were :r:vi:ed in gr:s:s based :en the felienie; e ;i.ee-in; dis:iplines:
(1) Geotechnical, (2) 5:r.::arai, (3) Mecrani al, and (4) dyd-oic;ic.
l Durin; tre t:ur the C:r:s note: that exce:: for :te use Of te9orary bl::ks, t e servi:e a:er pi:e was c ::ner.:se :e :n cire:: ::.: :: at:n :ne tese :' tre pece: ati:n :9r:.; :.e n:rtne-9.va;i :f t,e Seni:e a:er Bailcing. :: is
_ _ j postiated t at n's resaits fr:- t e cre ra:id se::le en: cf tre o.r'e: :i:e j
relat ve to : e aticing's cantilesere: set:Ie-ert. Tre C:rps e-:.as':ed :nat l
s l
special attenti:n sh:.ld :e gi.en t-is area t: a. i: s: essin; :ne pi:e a:
e Denet st'an, carti;aisely dari ; pile drivir; an: after at:a
- en of : e piles l
to the struc*are.
l The staf# *::ed :nat t e rese-st.:n y ?. C. P. Gould ircl. ded the s:e:ificatics of 30.e c:.an:itati,e criter
- ce a:: lie: darirg tre re 4 dial a: icn f:r tre Auxil try Buil:ing. P.e s:1-skes if similar criteria were sce:ifie: es t e otner 3ecq;ei c:ssalta-ts, 0.:.as advised trat these other criteria were rcre
~
of a :.alita:ive, s.bjective r.atare.
The staff sisa ee:.ested : e a*:licant to suMit a description of the se vices to be pe 'ar ed :y ::nsultants R. 3. Peck, A. J. Percron, Jr., C. H. Gould and M. T. Oaviss:n t r:.gn :ne c: :!eti:n of c:nstructi:n on tne re aining re ecial fi xes. This des:ri::i:n s :ul: identify tne extent of contint,ed irvcive eat of the c:9 sui:3-:s in Ove seeing c:nstraction caerattens a*d in e<al.atin; tre effectiveness Of cc ;1etec fixes for wrich tney ha,e pr: viced t.a':r cas';- in::.t.
~
e Carl 5. dood, re.e:: Ma-a;er Light Water Fes :: s fra ;, *;a. 2 Division of Fr: Ject %na;erent inclos.res:
1.
Attendees 2.
Agenda
- c w/e clcsures:
iee nest page.
Ccasu er s Pcwer Cor:any
.' /
f r
i ces:
Michael I. PtIIer, Esq.
Mr. S. H. Howel' IsFac, t.1 coln & Beale Vice Presiden:
j Suite 42::
Consumers o t.e-Oc :any c
Cne F'r st Natte-31 Plaza 212 k'est V ch';an A a se Chicago, Illinois fC503 Jackson. *: chi;an 4920:
Jued L. Sacc.a. Esa.
"aang ng ::::r-e/
j Cces,. er s Sewee Cc aay 212 kes: "tentgan A,er:.e Jackscn, "tCh192n 43201 Mr. Paul A. Perry Secretary b.
- Ccnsu*er s Pcwer Ccr-any l
212 W. Mictigan A, eat.e Jackscn, *:chtgan 4.:201 "yr on *. 09er ry, Esc.
Cre lE" P'na Chicago, :: 'acis f;611 4
Pary 5'ecTair 5711 5.me se: ttwe a
Pic'ar:, P chtgan 43543 Frark J. Felley, Esq.
Att:frey General State cf P'en gan Eaviren.v :a Frctect :n "t,isten 720 Law Belefrg Lansing, P:chigan t9913 Pr. ke' del! Par shali cute 10 Pidlanc, P chigan a364*
,Grar: J. Ferritt, Es:.
'>c :s:n, Ueisen, t!averka ; I James ata ICS Center
!? 1015 E gr:n Stree l
Ptnrea:ci t s, "iares::a 55402 Pr. OC" vaa FJ'Che, C5f e' C'visi:n cf Fact:f og ca! weal:r s
Cepar: rent of Public Health P. O. Box 32035 Lansing, M chigan 42?09
l l
i
'ers. w s *csee Ccn aay ces (caat ni.ec':
8es :eet ins ecter/*1cleac N 5 c/c U.S. % clear Reg.latory C: mission 1
P. C. E: 1927 Ficland, rich'gan 4P.4C Wi1*iaa J. Scaat:a, Esa.
203: Fa.!!ne !co'eva.c Ann At ter, M'c-isan 4;C3 Cervancer, Na,at surface Wes; ors Center ATT.i:
- 7. C. Huang G 4C2 65ite Cas Silver 5; ring, Marylanc 20913 "r. L. J. Auge, Yaaager recitity gesj;. g,;,,,,,ip; Ere';y Tec'nc'egy Eng:reer irg Cen:er P. C. 8: taa?
Canega Park, California 912C4
- r. hill a-La.6ea:
U. 5. C:r:s cf Ergir.eers
%CEE] - T III FTCh*gan A, tele 7t h C10c' Cetroit,Mtchtsan 4E225
ENCLOS'RE 1 J
_Arrtx::Ets Caesumer Power Rechtel Consultants C. S. Keeley Rarris Burke T. C. Cocke R. B. Peck Sherif Afifi T. Thiruvengada-Don liat A. J. Mendr:c, Jr.
C. R. Ceuld
- u. E. *:-n ainal char M. 7. Davissen Bill Paris Julius Rate l
Jim Wanzack Karl Wiefner John Rutgers Lyr.n Curtis A1 Boos Chuck McCennel Walter Ferris
";1E US Corp Cf Engineers j((gt L. Feller N. Cebrieg W. P. Chen 2, Tar.e J. Grundstrom J. Bra cer A. Ca:put:i y, ogga V. Lasheaf F. Riealdi R. Cer.za;.s P. Nadala J. Simpson D. H:ed C. Ca!! ;'er J. Norton R. C::k R. Erickson l'$ *:svv Vaareas Center P. Paang J. Matra on#
5 4 J.1
F l
l
)
t l
l e
f.
-s 3
- n. * *
,4
/
i p
.'t.
f,.., : s i a.a.' G.
\\v (o
- J
' :,.-.~ '.'
e
,3C u :. a.
~,
r =n i
...g$
i
.,.,,..e....
.,L.
m ;. ). C..i...,..
..... t s
..,.o
") C.
t l
88 %
. d
.g s..
.e. t.in L m. e..
4 a
- 7.,.
.* =.
. ?:.
...,z:.*
9.
=.
...?
e.
- -.., =
.e
=
a
% E,. *..
e e.
4,.
e.
J
.. ?
-.g..aa a.
--::3
..o.
... s..
.J i
.e.
- 2. - -..
s.
s...s e.
.-,.g49
..=..
... g.. e.,..
e.. '.
I
- .O...,... : I.. c w
...........,.v.
l
- b............a
~.
8.
.a *. *......
7 l
.g..,.
1
...e..
g -
s.
- * * : e
- 4
- a. r.
.=3.*.*...*
S. e
- I., 3 -
.e...
...... ?.
t,*.
....*. - s,, *
.**a e..t****3..,1 j
a.
- a. m... ;..,,...e..;.....
9,. ~,= =, ' r..
',n ~q
\\
3..
e-y.
6.
e.
...... s... sp. p...,*
t
- .,.. w.p2,...,.
.,o 3..
t.
J....
...'4.,e. s. g *.. {.a.-
2.,..
...j i. a.
- 3.*
."g.
. i.f w..,
L.
- g
.'5'.*".*'."..*.*.*.'..**.*.**.
g
..I
- { 3.,.
s.4.
3.3
,.,.3 3,.
J.t'...f..
..a.
' I e1
- rg.g...q
- p.,. ;
.g..,
4 a
-4.
ss...
... s
.6
.3.,
g h:
.. : :,... b..
...,......,.. c. 4. g,.e 4
4
.e
.u..
3.'
1.* 3 *. # # j.- a. e* *.
- * * * * =.
.,.1.,
.. s g a. *.
- p.#
- o..' # # * * )
..e,
- 7., #...... 3. g,.4
. 3 4 j,. 3....,
.. P t.*
.t
.6 4
c
..g 7
..e.-
.3 6
.c 4.
- ..,..-...s
- a...-.
j... 3..
.3 3.,.*..,..
- 4.. s, ;,,,
7 3.., -..
3.
4..
j
.a..
9
- 3...-
.*6/
.f****..
2
.3
.r...
3,. 3......; 3.g t V e.,.
- e r***
..2, 3
7.3 *.., 4 q,
S.
.. g 41
,. *l,.. C.. l.. a.,.
av e
$?...
s"l.s, e.
e a
,,s r
. ~.
s }L
".~. s.
,,.vJ * ~-<.
- .1 *.1.
....yo g
3
?.
..,.a o
s....
......C t.
,.:..... r t
=
- y e. c '.
l
.....j 7..
=,..
.e
,e e.
..,,f
.c.
J s.
4.
ay.
- 7.,. }.
e,...
}..=.....e,...4
?._ (, a. *
.4 l
f
).
7, 4,....,.
...j
}.,3
=
a
......,.,,. 3
- Jg.
l
.*....S..,i.'. AI
_ _. _...,.. _- -.-. - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ * ' - - ~ ' * * * * * ' * ' " ' * *
~ ' ' ' '
l
.,s ** " 4 9'o*
UMTE' STATES 3.g$,. )* 7.
i f UCLEAR REGULATORY CO*.**.ilSS!CN
\\
nasamic s. o. c. 2s+55
\\,,.W/ E
.....f L e; Ce:e :er 5,1973 0::ie: N:s. 50-329 53-33C l
C:ns :ers ocwer Cor.pany ATTh:
Mr. Ste:nen H. Howell Vice P esident 1945 ' dest Par.all Road Ja:< son,MI 23:01 Centiemen:
Tnis lette-trans:its : yea an Ceder Pccifyi.; Ccest uctist Pe-.:ts *.c.
C:P.i 31 and N:. CPPR-E2. Inis action is being taken as a result of fi :it;s i
Oy inspe: tors fr:: Re;ica I*I, Office of Insce: tion and E.fer:e ent t-ade
- .rir; t e pe-iod of C: :te-1973 to Jaca y li?9, an: tne can:'usicrs Of t'ie 4
- I'. staf
- af te revie.' g *es;cnses to t*e '.0 CFF. 50.5 (f) re:.est of "a :- 21,#
137", re,3rcirg t e pr:: se: rerecia! =crk unde
- and arecr: sa!+ty-re'Ite:
st-*.:tures an: sjs*ets at tre site, scte of wni:n is currert y.nder.sj.
The Cr::er pe-tains to the pr:blems associate: witn the scil fcancat'en materiais at tre site.
.O As ;2rt cf the Cader inere are t.c '.:tices Of 'lio:stien. Ice f rst N;f:s of kia atica is 4pe dix A.hi:n contai.s information cer:eet ; f:ur inf actions
=ith se.eeal esa ; es, all cf which relate to tne soil foc.:sti:n ; : 'ecs.
IPe se:Ord Notice of Violation, Appencix 9, cc-tains inf r atic c:nce-..n; an i en of n cc clian:e w'ich.3s detea-ined *o te a material false statt ert.
t
- ti: s ina: C:ns.ee*s 3:-e-Cc.;any nay tame as a res it cf tn's Or:e ore ces:-ite: in t*e Cr:er.
Si..cere j, S'.ce ei,
j
/
r f __;.f' A
GfLb d}'
E: sci G. (ase Vi:ter Stelio. s;r.
- cti g Dire: tar Director
(
Of'i:e cf N.ciear teactor Office of Irspect..n Re;t.lation anc E.ifor:ement E*.cl osures:
1.
Greer Mcdifyirq Construction Pemits, CFF4-SI arc C??R-22 2.
A::endia A 3.
Appencis B D
. :. *.. : :-.: %*
- L
??~., -r..:.;: :.c~.--.c.3 s
.et>
+
~
t i r-ua c
\\T m
F=-=
w b
E
=_
m LN 7EC 5'.ATES 3F 4'E:::A m
j
.s.....,... r.n.... n. y C s.. S.e....
.... s s.
e..
Js W
j in t e "atter at
)
_^
)
C;'.i."iR5 P 44 C;w?A.',?
)
Co: set N:. 50-33
^
1
( :*r: ? a:'ese Fe.er Pia-t,
)
50-12:
S i
n is 1 an: 2)
)
i s
C.. 9 v.....*.%....:..,......v......
3 s.:
i a
am I
i um 7 e 09s ers c er C:r;:any (i.*e Lice.see) is a r: er Of Ons r.:*.i:
'te: ts
-4 12j
%:. CFFR-il at: Nc. CPPR-30.-f en a.:no-i:e the ::ss -.: tics o' t.: ; enar':e:
-ate rea: ars in Pidia-0, Mi:niga-Tre :se.str.:ti:r :er-ts e.p re :-
3 ::er 1,1931 and Cet::er 1,1952, for U-i; 2 a
'.9
'. es:e::i ve'y.
EI i
C-
.;.s. :. 375, tre L::e s ee i.-': a: : e ',E
- es i:c- :ns;e:::r at : e i
"icianc si:e trat unasual se:tlerert of the Ciese: Gene ats-B it:ing ta:
[
- .rred. Tee Lf:ensee re::rted the natter under D CF3 50.55(e) af tte j
S.nissicn's re;atati:ns ej telegnene on Se;te cer 7, 1973. Tr.is notsfi:sti:n 3s f:110 ed :y a series of ir.teri recorts dated Se *.e-ter 29,1973,.Na ar:er 7, *.i75, ;ece::er 21,1572, Ja.ua y 5,1973. Fearuary 23,1:-79, ;;-il 3. 379, d
.re 25, 379. Augas 10, 379, Se;;e-ter 5,1973, a : '.:e :er 2.1973.
_=
=
a a
~ 1::.ing the Septe :ser 1978 notifi:stic,, ins;ectars fecm tne 8egica !::,
0'f':e of Ins;e:ticn anc E.far:e ent, conca: ec an investi;s:io. :.er tre 2
J
- e-::: et Oct::er li'S :nrougn Ja-1 y 1979. In's in.estigatica evestes a
=
Oreasacwn in quality assurance related to soil construction act:vities ut, er 4..d around safety-related structures and systems is tnat (1) certain casi.;n 43d corSt-*:cti:n spe:f fications related to fourcat'on-type material prece-ties a
i W
@/A e, mas /
v w i
.2-m o
2-i
~
and c:mpaction require ents were not fcil;-ec (2) taere was a ia:A of :: ear cirection and sacocet betweea t*e c:rtra:Or's eagireering of fice anc ::..;;r.:-
- !on site as me ; as within tne cor.tra:to 's e'g neering of fi:e; (3) t..ere as a la:i of control and se:erv'si:n cf plant fi:1 cla:ecent acti.ities *-';.
car.tributed to ina:eq. ate c::;a: tic. of funcation :.aterial; ( ) corre:tive -
a:ti:n re;arding ncecomfona ces re'ated b ;* int "f!1.35 insafficient cc inaceqtate as evicence by re:eated :eviations f r:m spe:i'i:atio.1 requ -e e-ts; i
tra (5) ce FSAs car.tains in cr.sistent, i :-- e:. 2-d caseroo -; sit:t e.ts
.ith res:e: to fci.edation ty:e, so ;r::ert es an: settle e t vi! es. Ine
- etai!s cf nese f cings art du:r te:
- irspec. ice. reac.ts 50-3 : H-12,
- w.4..,,.:..-
p.e er 14 h r o-, a r. e. n.....2, :.,a.. e.,. 3.-.., e.., a. f.
.r,,
4
. ~
1575) whien were sent to t.',e Licensee on Mwa-e- 17, 1976 an Ma* 7 22 1979 b
respectively.
e items :' n: :: ;1tance resu' tin; f res :ne *.E ir.estigatic. 3 e ces:ri:ed I
in :: ten:ia A :: tr.is Or:er. Ir ac:ition. as :et:ri:ed in A;;e-:5 E u this
~ :e*, a enerial f alse sta*.e ert was 3:e in ;.e FS;R i-thn tN 5 '
3'se',
r stated tr.at "A); fi 1 and tacif t:1 2re ;' :e: a::craing to Taole 2.5-5. ' ini; state ent is ma:erial in that tais cortice of the F528t w::Id have teen four:
ar.a :epta:1e wiuct.t f art.ter Staf f analysis and cuestions if tr.e Staff nad c.c.n tan ne;sry I strsctures hac eean :13:ed in f act on rarca fi;; racer taar. contr:: ed :s.g.ac ed carasise fill as statec in the F5AR.
i as a result of :2estions raised hr,g the NE: ireestignion c t?e Diesel
- enerator Builc ng settle ent, a
- ditional n':maticn was necessa t: e.a'uate
~ -.
i l
I I
I 1
t 9
Y t'e ir;3:t c ;:*3-: 53'e! ca.5e: :. 3:-
- 5. ;e. 3
- 3. :.. :
3..
....i...
4.'
5 3..,..e 3. e
- 5.....e a.
3 5.5.,..a
- 3... 3... e p. ' s
" e.1*.e : 0.3. ;. as:. t :e.-:3--$-
.-**3.-...
..W.... a....a.....
,- e. vwe,
l
- .0 ' e a-Es a:* J-4e '.' 3*.i c. f.-~ 3 s
s-
.s-.. a..t. a..-
e,
- e...t
.s-...
i CO*- :i SS'C1' S re 4 Jti: s it f;- J*.#:- -: ct--
g ; e;e 3 ti s ;; :eit-- e
..g..,e g.:.. g. *..e tJan.a
..... 4 s...a... -.
-e...sg
..s -..e...-.d..-.
E e **'i t. AOO t#C?al ' #0r*3 tic. was re.e!!!- s 1 4 13 ' ' ; 1 t '.; s 5
.1*3 -
c...E..e.
,i.
p.-- 3.q
.c er..ay,
- 3.
Tag.i;e let P45 0*:a; i: tna
.T*.
+ f**i 5
.? i-Cat, in 't;;eas ;3;g- :--- 2:. ".'. * :
.P..
.t *:
wa
-f
- .,.c..
.ta:..
q
..g.
3
- - -:.. 3...,....,.*:
.q..
2.,.
...s..3
- 3. 3..... )
..t g......;..: :
.a 3s....s
- e.,.
3.
3
?
.<..e 5..ese5,e. es.s c...
.......... e.e. e..., 3.,,,,, a ac
.4 a
..S. I <. I s. i. l o. re 0.
4.A.J 4 c 4..dr:.3...,.....,.-.c
........a.-s-s 4
c33,
- 3 *. i ' iP.
f::*Sec Oy the li;e see.
3.:= :.j;g.83, ::,;'q:
i;3.. ;g;3 t; s..,, e.e,. : 35 3..:..
3.g 7e 3,.3.,
dp..,.
.s
,.3
.3.g...
.....:.a*
1:e:.J:. t: ;; ::e-i~.,i e e-:n : :* ;
......... 3...,
...e
.. e,3 l
s....
m..e. g.....e. 3 9 3 s..,... 4 e s..a.. a.2.. 3.
- .e.e<.. ~.. 3,..y e
.oy,.
.].
3 *e.'e. :'
.e i-f:r atic. pra,':e: :, : e,.:.iee in res : ta *2 e 33.*
- .e5* ' ops tTse $t3'? C3nnot con *bde 3! this tw taat tne gafe;y 155 d5 31304i4142 wi;3 Pe9edial 4C'.icq 13ke9 er D an..dc ;g gg (4me4 Dy 14 O ce $et l
...e
...e sai; ceficiencies et.. :4 ra;a..ec.
aitae.t tre reic..t n :<
i 13ese is5ues t."e St3f' d:e3 n:t '3ve enseaao., 453 r3 ca t.g..e ass,.,;
si*it -*e' ate': ;;crtia s of t e.w:;3 : <3: i; 3..
3..
.a............t;....
.jss
...,,.e
......e3.,... 3 e..
O 3e,.,..... 1.
e l
...3 I
1 i
I l
,-T----
- v
---m-
--W
'-.--.i--eew----*---wegum
- .mu'-w,e-m,gerwy.mg-o-ee-ewweeis,-e--ww-.g.
,v.--yw-w---m-=,+ wee-%.mwyf ww. m ewe,-pw ow pirew-
-wws-.----.i--,-.e--w-----e-wm w
m-ww w s rwe.w T
l i
i i
e l
j l
l
%d
...e...e
..... :.i..
..4
.::.... a.
e..t.
1....e
- sa... s 3-
.:... a..
...t.
.a.
s... a.
... s a....... t.
..s.
..e..a
...a 2 :e s. :+ :e: sW: t e C: w: ss ci, 'm i- :--att:n -n :a -cu::.ar a..:
". a 0 r=:54:e :: t'.se :.; ar.t. a et..s:.:: :,:e-- : en an orig.4; a:s:ica-
- 3 2.e ::r::.:e:
a:
e :..:::, as s.ra.ce ee':: ec es i =o!..r.g te sett:c-ect o' tre ; e-.: C.-+-n:- !.:':: ; s-s:i1 ac:i. :ies a: :. e v.::2 :
s te. tre f alse stata e. '. t'e FDs. aae toe ur.rese'.ec saf e:, issue cancere... ;
L' d 4:eC'.4:y O' :*e M: l' AC*. Ott :3 ::--H":
-* CeC e*C i es in
.d sc i i
- a>;.:: r..:e r : i n.-: s e e:.-. 4:42 3:.
..r.5 at: 2,3:a:; a: e 3:e.3:e a 3,5.o
.,,.3........,...........,q.3..3
..a..,,.........,..e.3...
- :e-:4 - 2::, : e s -ce- :: s:-.:: :- se m ;s v :::t.i; a : : ::::.5
-r Pie:. : * :. e e:ste: sa'e:, iss.es a e es:.ec.
- s t
i
- 'f.
- . ;.r: :s : e 20:r: E e-,j a : :' ; cia, as e :e:. a. : re c
- ,,....27.....s.
.2
.3...
.::2 I
i i
3..
r.:: s. :...,......
(
- '-il :e ::
- e: as 'a:.s:
'. : :ea: ; : e s.em ss':
c' a-r=n. aec.: t: ne m en :e seeca; a:orow n:
2' e --e:t a' a::ic. s ass:ci a:ec.i:n t. e s:t - a::i. ties +: sa'e:j-reta:e: s:.::.-e> a : s s te s ':. :e: i,an: : : i..: 'f: n:eeia: a. c
- ? 3 5.4 :e Of P 4:4- *e t ::
- s;*.:: :n Fe-. ts N:. C?:R-i*. 4-:
~
1
- - - - - ~ - * - ~ ' - ~ ' ' ~ ~ ~ ~ "
~ ^ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ * ~ ~ ' ' '
\\
. f%
an: N:. CP:'-i2 aut :ri:i g tr.e re-e:ia: a t":, the fc ':.'ng act'vities t
are ; :i: i a::
t ia, 3 ;. :.3: n;. :: a:tiag, cr duca'.at g scii nd-f a's.-:a cr i
4* *r safety tlate: str.:: teres ard syste s;
'03 - ysi n' i :le entati:n :f re e:'a' a:t :n for ::rre:ti:n :f i
j s:i i-re' at t: ; : ale s un:dr ar.c ar:a-d t ese st-.:t. n a : g., t e 3,
I i c!aci ; t.t :t li:ite: 1 :
(i ce-tte-ir; syste s (i') uncerpinning of service water :uilei. g
.A t
(i :) re+:vai and replace ert of fill terrath t'e fee:wnea is:!ati:n vatee sit area (ii) ;li:ir; caiss;ns at t.'.e encs of the auxiliary bull:ing ele:tri:a ;e etrati:n areas j
(<.
c:; action anc ::a0' ; act it:es; i
1 J
(C) c: strs: tion wc-k in scii aterials unde-or at:und safety-re' ate:
s*
Cta ts and syste:s st.:n as fieIC installati:n of C:rdaits an:
(
- i. g.
Q 2 ara;ra 9 (1)at:4e shall not a::!j t: a y ex;;; ring, saglirs, or testing f sci' sa D ts ais::iated with deter.i n.g actaal sci; ;-:;trties :n I
f site. :n a.as t e a::reval of the Dire:::r of Region II, Office e'
- ns:e:t :n ar: E9'o-:ement.
i i
I
.3 i
i V
..e ' t. auce :r a y perser w.: e inte es; is af'e :ed :y this Orter may
.i.i., :] Jjs Of tre :ste of :nis 0-:er re:.es: a e3-in;.':n res;e:: c i
- a., :- ar;. :a s t.-is C :e. In t e e.en: a re3-i g is re:.e3,,.,
e iss.es :: te cc.3.ce.e.i;; 3,
'l (U
e he- :. e f s::s se: f:-in in ;:3- ::. tr:s 07:3 37, c 7.,c ;
a:
i i
1 (U
='t:re-this
- er s :u': :e s.s:a e.
7.-i s C r:e.i 11 te:: e e rre :i,, e,.
.,,,3 5 3 2.,
., t3, ;,,, c, g,,,
a hcari ; sy Oe e:i.,este:. cr in e eye-t a heari.; is rec este:, or. ;re
- ne s;+:ied in an Cr:er a:e fc'lo.:n; tre ne3ri ;,
F3 iE *.'.:. A: RE:;,L;. ::t c:y.. 35I:s
/
s
.I
/
v~
i.
/
. w,,.'
Ja.
y n
- y t.,.',asg ait;N s,i e
- :or v-<
t
.. cur 3te1:,s.,,h3ree;r ce ear.e3::ce y,fi
!*'0F 7,f.c, ;f ;ng;ec i,,
a.3 e-'C ce?e..:
.s
.e....
'.. 4:e 0 m A
. ~.
e..
- i B C3*a
- at Se: esca, w y1 3..c,
a ta i s 6 4-day c' Decerce, 19,*g, t
l l
l I
i l
i t
i. -,.. _,... _, _., _ _ _.,, _ _ _. - -,. _, _ - _, _ _,, _ _ _,, _,. _ _
. - - -. - - = = = ' - " "
i i
C..
o aa A: end's A pm N -* E OF 'i:CLAT :N w
i l
C:nst. ers
- -e- ::. ;a.y C:: set N:. 50-2 3 C:: set N. 50-22;
's re'ers to : e it.es: iga: :., c:re.:te: :y : e O'fi:e :f ! s:ect':n a : E-f: :e en: 4: tre
- at a : *,.::ea-Pc e-3'a.:. Lntis 1 a : 2, * :: ::,
". :- ;a,, at y:ur oi:e; in.'a: As:n. "icef;a, 3 a at Ee:Ste: se: -atici, A-- Ar:o, !*ic-iga. cf a::ivities aatr:ri:ec ::y MC Li:ense N:. CPPR-31 a: No. :P 24-32.
Ease: en tne res.' s of ;r.e i..estiga.'on co
- e du-ia; tre cer ::
i Ce:e :er 11,1H3.hr:ug Ja,.a-
>:;r a:tivities -ere c:: :: :.::y 25, ;979, it a:: ears tra: ce ;ain :f e: ia 'al: c: :::an:e.i t.. N;; ri:.' e-e:- 3 as nc:ed :e::. Trese.:6 s are inf ra::ic 3.
..s. 4 =.0, a.::,er. cia 3, s.eiterion.11 re:c:.res, in part,1 at sensures A.
.,v 4
534:1 te esta:iisne: anc eaccate: to assure t :at regulat:ry rec.;rer.ents an 1..e design casis as sce:i'ie: in : e li:ense 3:el ca on fo-str.:::. es are c:-eectly t aasla:ec i,to s:ecificaticas, :-a i ;s.
- r::e:. es a :
s: ;;t:: 5.
A s:, it : :,':es t* at eas.res s a:-
te es a: istec ':e tre icentifica: ion anc ceat-ci of ces gi inte--
f aces and for Coordination among articipating design organ):at ons.
D CD:: Ic ica: Re::rt CPCOA, Peli:y fio. 3, Section 3.4 s:a:es, n
- a-; "
- re assi; e: :eae :esign ; :cp :r or;a-i:ati:n (i.e., the NIS3 sc:siie, A1E s.:p:'er, cc - Co) assa e t'.at cesigns ard eateriais are suita::e a : :nat : ey :: sly.ita cesi;n criterii and regulate y require e-:3."
CD : is cc--itte: t: AN5: N'5.2 f.571), Se::f=n 4.1,.ni:9 states, in :i t, " eisares s 311 :e es+ 35 is.+d a.4 cc:.. ente: t: as t ur:-
trl tre a:: ica:1e spe:i'ied ces ;n re:.i e e-is, s.:r. as a ce; :-
tas's. eg.'at:ry re:uire ents.
are c: rectly trans'a:ed i :.
Specifi:at::as, cra. ngs, pr::eceres, cr instr;, tions
Cartrar, t:
,e atese, seasures c': not assure that design tases were in:lu e! in dra.ings and teecifications nor aid tney provi:e f or *ne icentificati:n a-c ccntrol of cesign interf a:es. As a resa't, inconsistenc'es uere icentified in :ne license acolicati:n j
anc in stner design tasis coca e :5.
Spe::'i eu oles a e set r
fcr r. telc.:
1 a.
- The F;4 is internat'y in::,s ste-; in ; a FIAR ig.re 2.5 *3
. indicates sett'esert af LPe esel ene at:r But:cfr; to te :n
' t*ie cr:er of 3* wh'!e FSAR 5e:ti:n 3.3.5.5 (stru:ta il ac:e:t-
,an a cc teria) nci:ates sett'eme-ts on snallow soreac footirgs D
l I
1 I
i I
l
\\
I Ca.:
?ppe+ dix A 2-s Of f:u :e :n cer.:4::a: fii' t Se ce t.te c-Oer Of *./I :* less.
Tre :'e:e1 :e.e-at:- iuticing is s.;; rte: by a :rti.:ws s'al*:- s:*!ad f 0:4.-*.
l 0.
Tre ces ;." se:e e ; et*:e* 3 i:ns f:r
- 4 c'esel ge e*1t:r ar -
- cate:. ate st: 3;e :3 *s -e e :e ':r e: :n tre as!. ::' 7 Of u 'f:r- :a: f:. rest : s.-Me : eie de.P:sti: s =ere :esi; e:
i a..
...s.,...e as s..es s.
. 4.,. <c...a..,.5.
..~
Tre set;:e ent esi:stati:ns
',e-tre.'.iese',e t e..... 0g Oe e at:- 5.:
3
- d':a:e: a lea: :. :e s: / o. a..u P:. r r:.
ra. r:gure
- 2. 5 . s. :.s a 1 :: :nte,5;;j Of *::: PS, as actua 'i s. s............e..
1 e.
y,.
3,....
.... 3 '.. ' s *. '.-. '.- *. e.' i e. <. >. *.c a. - a. - * *..- '. - '.,'
e e :ase: :a a, in:es :f c :ress tilit, Of e ::a ; :
- e**+en e..e.sti:es e.., a ; :... c, c...,. uv..
.hese set:.e en:
v.
i
.a..es.ere ss w, in F... Ft; re ;.
4u..
3.-
Hc.e e,.c;...
.sa:.e
...L..:....
3.,s a.. 44 c<.
....,ss13.
f..
- a...e 2.n.e
.a..
s
.y
- s..
. : e.. c..,. "
m e.
3.C : 3.. m - s...-- s. a. +. 1
'.-. 3. t.- * +. 3 *. i. s.
f j '. S.
3 3
- j.a.y-3 -
3.s
.s
.-y
.. 3
- 4..$ g7, 43.,.e..
a.
....,..e,.4....:
.. g.,s3..gp. g*.j
...~
.'r::e1 1:i' = cal: Se *e
.e: : re::c;a;;t pr':- t:
e res r:-
d 3....$..r,..,
. 4,. 4
- 3. : o... - *
.4 e 3.. g. e. j e..
jeg
- e..
tca'. / !*:'.de '. structi:ns for e : val c' f t::e-/ : Imed
- :2::e: a:er si a;:n res ::i: :( w:rt af r winter peri :s.
... 3:es ;'at c
+si:r..
+ :-.
! : rent 2
.1-
.ess s:i. (sa :1 0c.c
- e :: es:te: to Sit reiati.e ce sit / a::: ding :: AS** 3-2C03.
-c-ever, Ee:n:e* s:e:'*i: :t:, C-2;;, Se::icn 2.7. 2 e:'.'re:
- es':n'ess se:1 -:a te ::.?:a::e: :: nc: 'ess t an 5:1 ela:ive
- eisity, i
- .. A :encix 8.- Criterien v re;. es,1 pa-:, tra activities af f f Ci t 'Q C'J e h t-f sh3)) De cresCrtDec and aCC080lisFe4 in 20: Orca *Ce wit.i coc.:ented astractions, procec.res or crewings.
- 2:a ~c:tcal Re::rt CP A, 3:licy $3. 5, Se: 'cr i : s:stes, in
- t :. t at. *:as rac t:rs f:r :Orte: ;i ; inc :=e':,:,g s vities i
4'#e::i-cvdet*y :( equi: t.
or J:e-3 21. :* :es c. ::ns *.:-
1
- 2
- e at:a s : ase * : e.:: ear ::ser :ta :.:n as ar :; e-re.; a af t:.rir;, c:ns:-.::':n, i 5:si'at'ce, its:e::'c. testi g o
... a *e
.?e".* e fr i.*st-4-* ic.7s,
- CC *bres. 5:e-i'i i #Cs Inefe :::s e9*s D* W i *e 42 ';ati s e a-* :.3* *
- i tis e 3-*!**1r:e C*iteria f:t cete*3ining ir*0r*ar.t a* is ** t es.ase tees sat'sfa;*:rily a:C:*:litstL
- s t
\\
. __ ~ ~- -
.,-.L
-af.. --.
A is J
j 4::e..:', a 3-l 1
.:.,.... :. e.. :.,.. g..
..*:-*...g.....3i.
- 3. 3. e 5 in a
t*
3..
.a... 4.es. 4. sa.
- 4......j
- 1...f
.3
.,... g
- 4.. e.
...e....
3
.f
.c.
4. s......:...
- a. C*.'**..*.*..5.3r.**.*='.-*.s'.
C.
1*..**.a.***.**.**.2**.... e s
- .'.ta* e5 4*: 5'5' te 4:*:-*' 'i'ed ir a*::*0a*Ce ='t* Ireae i.:......*$,,*,**..*e.*.*.*.2 C*.*.*.*3.*.*..,*5.*
4.
20*t*!*. I: !*e 3 :.e. St*wCt 605 0*:w cec t3 fieIJ 0 W **.:'
a-
.z.....n.,
sera
....t.e f.,.
- .., s.g....s*
.r..
2: *it; 1:e *;'f er rg f *catica De: ** ties.**: -:.'* *!5i t ir : '*4*e*t a! 5ett!e e*;
- t*e 0:eie! 24"e at:r i.' ':'*g.
- 3 3..
. 3.
3
..,z...,.
4
........ 3....
4.......... s 3....,.
.e s. i.. 3 p... e 3......,..
( *. )
I*'t C*.0:3 ti:* gr ta 83 ;;pd f-, fii; mate ;at.3; y,C;*.
i it-:05 i 3ec. tei e, : 'iec e-:C t e-t e s t '
- n =- t' i' +
C0:04 !'ve e%r?f
't.dE*.* f t
- I: 5 as 1:* * ' * ' ?". T i,c;* 1c '
Specif :at e-C-212 Secti:n 13.7 i
i:: 5:e:s a:U.it as -e e ot accc oi'saan urder t'.e :entin.:.5 5.:e *,; s i c n e'..a t.3 : ' e0 s e '.i i
1 ea * *
- e? *.* *,.;.' **ted :"*a.
1.....l a....f.. e. 5 a....e
..,..e e:
-e....
a.
j
.3. n *,. s.... a
- 3.....;3.
3.
3......&..e
.. t...
1.,.
.';* 5:e:ifi:stic : rite ;a.
T '.i ' 5 is requirec :y 2+:-te'
.cceC:,::a*.ica
.. 45 =e.. as r.,.,s. A e ::a :t a. s.r s
-s.
O ar.:.Mccre Re rt. ;..,e 16; 3.
R ::: 52. A::eacia 8.
- rite on ( r= uire5 ir pa-t, ttat a cc:.; ::
fcr in::e:ti:r. Of acti.itte5 of fe:tn; cua it, SW1 te esta:'11ae:
4 g.,..,, e.., o 's e r. a. y.. <. g.......
.....gg j
.....w...
....... 5 a. C. 3. :.
,.5.e A.C,'.4.5...g..e a..
1..
....f.
- . 7e 31 p..... b p - *.. A.
- '......
.a a,
......,.1.*.
$.3.,g.
j.
.f
..w
- 3...., g.;e:.:. 8.5 4*a. 2".~.~~'.' *a.3.**.*.*.*'",*..*1.****.e.*
g..
".',f...:*f*.*e3:* in51* jct :?.5 =31:n inCNCe '".!:eC'.iCT NIO ** * *ts
.a.5.....
.....e.
...ji............3 a
.t
.e.
- r ="#
- te" C "s ?*t 'O* :y" 35 5*'ig t'e .i:e :*.* ;" Mai tean *ec e'.e3
- s.... *
- e.' * *,1 't i.* a *. '. C ". &.*. *.C *. i..' *. d *..*.* *. * '. 3 '" *.*. e i *. *
- e.* *. i.'.* 5.
.a,
(
l i.e. : 'S
- .5:te* tC 4.o.. b.5..*
'. *7 's..,
- .*t'* States, in :a**.
- 4 l
- r:; 2. f:" irsce: tic.i Of aC; eities af'e:t g tua'it.s s'a-: ce e5!!:IiS*e: l'id *O: te: Dy Or f:* t*e Cr;3*'23 tic't :er#:~ir.; !'ie u
3.:.......
.. bep.a.j
.n P.J...,. 4...e..e3 '95*.*..**.***.5 a
w 3r::e:.res, and Cr2=in;1 f or ACC: cl 3?.ir.; t'e ICt;vity. '
- " t rJ */ : t'e a :se. *.aalit.v C:ataal Instruction C-1.02, tne program for ins:ectien :# coxacted 34Ckfill issueo ca CCt:eee 19 196 cia not pr:vice far ins:ection Mold pcints ta verif f 10:a; Sci
=4rh 45 54115fa*t*riIf a:03:eil5Med ICC3* diad; to SCC;.*e*te 05 t **JC ti ce s.
.n_
armusmurms:.aum -.
j J
e
.e
- W % z.a.
~ ;.....,..
- e-: s a
.z.
.m,:,4.
a.-
.A.
y: e w sM.
s
"; :::.5: 1.::eec= 2. C-te-':.r.:
-c.
es.
e 4-.
4: ea-V;n.Y.*
- 1. + ; v 4.. :e esu: 5 +: *: a s s. e t a :: :. : s ir.e-s e ::
, 1
- .i :, i.:- n o te v.s. e e-: es. :e ec: i. sete-s a; 4 c
.Y d
ta ::
- -u. :es s a cr -c ': ~:e-
- e: 1-: :--- ::ec. Is case :*
Q:,Qj s ;-
- c: cc ':*: s at e te :- ::st :. e n c --< s i M a s s.-*
y' J/
.; ::~e-:v.e a::.:: i s 4.e. ta avec' ee rece: :
~d
.3..
,- g:.
M.*
3- :4....:.. ; :...
g.
..y....... 5 3. g.
., ::,.f..
-,y
,j.,,
- 3..
3.... : 3.. g. 3.. g.. s s a........... A...e-
__(
5.,...<. g...
.........s t,. e..e.:..e
,../.
..,..e e.
s
- e :5 c* ::e a'. : s. - C:- e:1.e 3:
e i ', es a evn',3
- .9 3*
(g g.
.'..........s
..A.
j
,.. 3........ 4.e.
..........e c
..... _3. t g. s -. e.....,,.
..e n....s.e..
,.A,....t.e..
e:.: : e mW n:f e e:.,e :..-
g44
...._t
... 3......
4;..ve.,.,if..,..... A s k..... A.. 5..1........
..a s.
g....
- 3. e..e J...f so. t,..... f....e.e 4.ee....9.
a' 1:
t
. : e 1 :.e-
- ' ' a 31 1
a s :*.1-.e y 25,13'3. wh:.ce c:.n.i m f:'; nat,- e' e
i
- +e '
- u * : e: c r:ew4.+ :. e:: p ;., - <. ix..:e-;
q.<
c,;
in s s:e: * :st*:- -ecr e e-:.
, ;. ef.; t 4: t <e r:e::.33 vi
" ' o -
.,: serfer.i. ; w 5: re ::..vi. tests,as er:ui,.:
3,, s:,c m.
ca: sa CT..J.
45 :eer.:sf;4c in q,.41it a t - s st i:-ac, 1
l.
c e
f s.e u.1 a.
m
...,.+....,,.:...
g....,.
,s e..... 3
.,.3.,....
t
...m.
.t.,......i. -4 3.s
..,.,.,..,. 4...e..
,.e 6
e.
5
- Is es :4 ce: O - *e:este 2 c4.iat m f-:.x 5:4::? :at::-
/ %,
f
~
~
" '..e :. *t
- e... 4.' - f P 4A2*4'.I4.. iga 46479eACf -ec0*:S 40 (3!:
Eh -
r * :. d-:2. ?*...*ee, t,'* *.4,. 0*. 1 4. $'. l. 443 'c.... :**: 31 *
'r
- /
- ec J.
. q i
tsvEe".s eh D el.,D:eI e7 "C#
- d* TIS l'1 $. ag $4Eg 4
,<,.. g 4
,e.....-..&..
s
.y.g.. s.....
. -,1
.es AI. - -
p 3
)
r
- t w
f' s
m g.
4 M
-3 W
- -M w
l
.le j
~
e n
,s
,.,e y;
4-g c
,.r-f
.,p t.
y<..,,
f
-.[
/
. Jid, f'
' W
- .r L--
I, t
I b
u y
.+7 g
nl$
Y y
- (?
- J*
'}
g n
/"' p
.o. c s.
1
.,.ac e
g*
e
- a p
,f d
It
/
. _..>.r4>
f,,,
/,
a f
p
~ aE
'd, p f f.'
'y" f /
.s,,,
. _ ~
m_.
__.m___
~
r l
l l
I C..
t.
! *. 4 g
g.....
........g M
a t.5 ;......
..,3... g.
....t..
b..
.,.s.>
....,..,s..
9..
...d..
..t..... e *.,.......
a
- 1.....
.. g 1, :...yJ..
.....a
's..
e g..
,.1 a.
.f4
.t...
)... 1. :
..e
...J...
......t.
.e
....ts.
i.......t..., ; *... t. gt..=..
hw..
s..
i* %
.. ? s...,.
...f 4 4......:
- l. a. i
- a.. a f a..
.fot. f* *...
o g... s...g.j..a...-.
..t e
... g.&...... f.. s........ g g.. t o
s s
.f t
I t.
3-
.g..
24*...g:....
...J
.g..e e
.f
.g
- 3. r
..e.
j e...
..e,-
.+.+. s.r
- 3.t
.?
1 3
l
~. ',
. J'.
e s......4%.
4.*
.. -.e. e.
....4
..e..*
N..e,.
s t
a L........
.......a
- f a
..g..
g;*w*,..1.._
.. If T'.=.
g3,
e..
- t*J.
\\ *. *. * *.. ~ t h
' ew t e *G ; ' '
......ta,.
3....
gtt.3..,
4..
- p,
...,..... et.
e...
.,.g 4s.
V,
,OS..,.G,
.,.e
.,4.,....g e.e..
1.,... 3 w
. e 3j
- ,........ e
- ,!.....s g..
g.3...
- 4.
- l.......,
..&.....e
.a
- 4., 3.. e...
5.a.
l.
3.1..
.s.
f
.....J.
t - fe...,
4......f
.f.? J.
- k...,...,
.d
.s
..,.n.
... 5..'..
a.
a.
.... ta.
90 +. :*... J Jr J r*f
- .Je* tim g * **
- 191 46:3.s. t.e t t e M a
- 3. 4 0. *.j e
.g.
.,. g.........,...
.3..,..
g.,
,4 >..
.w
.f 3.a.
3 g...
..t e.,
J
- t1
- I
. ; * *. co ' iM c:: ass *e:
..v1.e.
1 E
a I
i
.,ne,,,., -...
,._-.-m.,,s..---
l 1
1 l
l i
6..
1..
4 l
t 1
l D-
"?
?.*.
at'; :
e'se * * ;* e est.6'i 4,; e* t..e
'e
-a-
!!+'.+*..
w+
...: N g. --
- ,;a :...' p..,... ; - ;;
ti.
a.*. tat !!! 4. ed*t...- *.?d..;.< rt..s; w.5
- C 'sen +;
g 4:*.,, n l
O b
l l
l l
l l
- i. --
p m--
g ru
'u i'
I Mi i'
P' s
4 174,. pg: - y.y.%.m tf;- @., $ ; g,4e.< c wr-4 3 i 1,
.,,,...g.....v
....{.r (t*:".7f.)
t.
y f..
8 t sito sr
- Es i
i MC1. ear REGJt.l.77 Y COT.:ISSIO.4
~.
t us w a
- .ws pi,.
.c 4, Q.g'
,t
...
EU3 3~;
],h n.,,
t
.i.
&-r g
e
,v...,.....-:.,..e m
F40*:
ar' me:.*:j te: wara;e, ti;:.a:er teact rs 3 rec.
M.
Fw 5 3JI.7 tu *.;*EG A!;A:::':3 IV;;;I.T. :c ;;; cs w; to s ::,
-c..- - r.%. r-a
.... e : a-d -.-:- J. <e:::e-u r.
r-.r; i:en-fie-et,e i:
su:rea.:s,
s 1 te ani: 3: ::: e IA; re.2-:4; e :3:s.;t :3,4-ter., 3.. e y..g
.u si:e-e: a :e fa';e, 3-: e.;aes:e: 3 :e:,,-j.a* :n as e. ate-a, :j :' : ase :n:re-:3, :: ::..;,,,:n :f :.,j s rcra-:
- f.:: :n waf 7, 373, :.3
- ss et:. 3.:.3.r,f 3;.e,q e,
- aec es #:-
- e. e= a-1 ee: ;.as e;- :As *.: r, e,:: ne.3,
'eett ; ana neh :':'s e: : E ::n.re ;, f.:,,ce: :::3 ;g g
$N/ 0' e i= =
eau as :: re atee a:::f O' : e 't,e sa:e-n.:ered su*re:u :' t e (e::.ee r: is ;.en in E c1:s.re 2.
.7.0 ce9e:
- au dati:j.-' FE,ta ;u:e e-u.
Nis cefie. :::n se vec as t.9e 2s15 -:r.:; e*:s in :*e eetir.g. A s u.e ea: mas dee-M :: ::e
- aterial-
,', *.., Or ::..y: 4.e as t ".e :e a;; a ufe j ::y : e IE investi;ati:n,
. n;: *1:3su-01 ; *.:'e 'an :=4 ::.as :e:e::e: :
n: 4s :n :" : e 's.; sufs
- 8.. I ' i t c:.a. We -es. ;e: isar 4 : :er a:-gi.; 2r : :s ;.,ngjp,.
s
- a /s',5 Of tre su".'s T e tes n'u; s:;n:'ic3.:e are..*;*allness O' an/
1,:* 'a se su:r e.:
re' nan :: se:en :n of :.e 3;, <,
,3<,,g,,
aut:- 2e r e: O :e a::r:;;r ate.
}*.=as::e::4:,sare :' t e te: r a: re, e.ers.3:. : j,
- ..,3 7, p,,,
1.Te :# **e 't e e t-: uta;-;.r,4 :a ur4 3,3rc : e e#:*t 'Si 1-ary A s.:se:.e : ee: ; f ;re! :
- *'**
- s C.,, : e 31 s ea a: : e tet: 9g.
- n, a:c -
A-;'.St 4 -r: =4s s. e:. e: :: ::n'ia Or ::::t ',. : ese ; t ::'naej :mu.
5 m
,z.
~
Oael 5. ac:c. rtjen 'Eagee
'.1 ;* : =d:er e2Curi 3racen \\.1 Ot eis :n ;f 7-;je : ' ara er en:
L*C. *.i.*eS :
AS stated See e d u;e c::
[
- br jgsf ' ~.
s 4
J i
c:: El A::entees
.:wer 4.
a L. R.:easte'n 5.'.arga C. 'iassait:
W. " stead u..
- s. sa::.... ;
.er
'a. d23ss
.. e.i 5..
a
- 3. *.rraf 4
i a
e I
emme *
-m,ymm,r.pm--e-w-- - * - - - -....-... - =,.., - -,, - -
v.--
,_v,,
-,,-.-,. ~.
.o
/
/
/
.j l
I 1
l
\\
.N..ac..:r 1 l
l
\\
.=
1 1
,.e,
.:. s
. 5 vaser
- :1E <-
3 4..
td..
f..k.
3 0-
,.s a..,
.... f, -3,..
i...
.... 4
,. ~
g%....,.,.
=.
L. -t.e*
(
- E Q '43,
.....If
.. S e3.'
....3 s..
g.,...
- . 34 1
- g
- 3.,..a.,s.e.
4 I. h.l.t*
.%~Q t::
1 *.g...e..t'
- e.
- g p*
si...m ma,.*;*g..;,,
=4
,* *g g'g.
o......
( MM 4.r,. ". t t g.,
.d*
D i
l l
a El.g.... - 2
-,E
/
1RA **"*NI
't U4:', 2 'i 9 G:s.iq we%:1.a;:,y I.
s s*3*ev* is : *sicert: Of li.? U *e ?dtecta!; :.g #20: **at *e * :Ignd
- i-
- 1-# t*4 ise: ; *; e 'r1 ::E: # *!
e-ses 1:.c. 3I 3:i7 '
g**.es c;
- -=;e.s.'* : e-:p: e:.. :n:ee s ee.e: :, -a; is : e ::., :. : e se::,.,,:
8 : is :- :
,::. n: u. : :e s.: e,3 :f,,:.,..-, u.s
- P s ce*?s, :-::'c: 4-: 1U s.;;esa: :: s : erat::n :e ; e =
1 C r',
- * ; a *.* **, e #: *C:gs.
... s*3:e ;*at e Oe-ta:e :e.eea.se
- 3, q
- g.., g,3 q: 47 ;.,
a
,u : :e s':f 3:- : e : ese* "fe-au-3.
- ; a::. n :, ea :.:
.ea:e a sa'e:f ::r::.s :n :f ; e m sues, a.: :.,,,e-
, 4 3..
- es :n-e: :: :e
- 4:er a;, tat er,
,e <.ci.; 33 c,,,e 43
- -: a u r :' :::
- :e e - a e.
a 3.
.: su:ec :4: -, : <<e e n a ee,.se -* :. ' a :,, r 3 e, -,.. m O' :: : tssi:::f ':r : e ::ese' 3*'er2Or ie'::a; a':.*ni Or **: :: a* e :e a sa'e:f ::r:F.s :n :f ye saa s:3 <, r: :.,,, :,,
4
-es :: ::.ns :e e: :: :e
- 4:e-a!.
- ta;e,cefr:r;s, M na-
- : :.c :' :cce ;;. :,,<: aan.
4..
t ;nt:ts :*e su:e e :s :s :3;.a se.: :.s ;,5,s.
,3,5 3.: 3,3,3,,2
- t A*- *; :.** f:e s' m: *:e t e ::ese' weraur Za *:t.sg u w
!'C:Ps's:ent.
-:=e.ee :. ej 3, ac: * :se es:<a a
-as a::.4.f :cne.
, u, w, m <,u.:re u u.s : ey at*'e,ct. ra:
e s, 3 2...u
- *t: esen a r.a: fz.rea:<:n,.re-us ".1J se::1:n 3.3.4,;,2 ne:,,,.3a f
- er* ' r: *e :.t:'ta; u 3.e :,r:. g.: a c.. g, y,
'*:' M* ut:.ia:t:n is e'emec :j 4 I as an f- 'ut:r :* ::ce j u,< r.
- s..r.
5.
S ts su:e e : :s ::rst:e-,: :: :e a s,en,: :, s3 m.
, :.,.33 a,:*ars :: :e s'e :e: u :ce J :e,d:-4 :,,
O W
e
l l
i a
qC'..c
~LS ~
/
i t,. I.
- g.
.2 E.
~
t s
l
,gd #4 t
/
.'l.
MTE3 s*A*ES i
' i e fY
- NUllil A 4EJL.;*.s*. TORY CCWt$$;O.*4 W
E e Ms= %*.* s a.Osas
- &/!
\\
.T e:-3., E,3
- 4e: w. 5:.::3 n:
I w..
-A-
.e *
.sd ;*7G...
43.t*,
- i-* LAeO
- tyt 3ff ur f r *
- g-t
!.:.:rt, E R *!:
Ma*i: 2.
- --:. ;, *,i T :
c,,' vi s43. :f :s3 :;. _
.~1:t:. 7, s;
.e.1..; -..
-.w
~.a,..:..;,...
.,..,. 3 :..... g..
w
.u
- Or21 ::u: at: e ':r:n t-: :::ca;e :- e uu: ;:-i; 3, *; ; e
- 8:22;e e set: :: 1:^.5 as :: setec :j :. :4,t s's re :ra: :.. :$ q_
. = ~
p+ ?' t
- 13'*E*.:1 31 t*t t*#:r:e!"ta: *a*algt ** 4 e ce r,t.! u,,,,,,_
':t.3
,n s see -r:!:5.'T I) *: 1003 f:r :: rat *4:*m.
'de agg 3'ff2 11:10-* *1.rt ?f:g fr:gt ',RR
- e sa:e aje. 5i*:t :at 4*e
~
- At* see*t? *et.f r.gs (3/l, 3d ar: 3/16;
,,n cy 3::Pt119, a: It AS :;-
~
ve :.tsr: : :=*:a*-*; ar 9: fort er ac m cr :. e e.<:m m_4~
- e *et* *S ;s at *t 4*u*:d: y
- t **, ~.r tl
- a. *E'4, Ei,*, a:tg l{,
"' gy t tr~t't:s "e:AssL*y *: Saxe a fi?ci?3 cr. 4.4 tr:41 false suu 4*: _
- ~
ua::tne:.
a.
- s :*.4 su:ee-: * 'se?
2.
- s Ve lutee.: *ater*aI?
. l.t*
- A:
- ' *
- s u"C 4%
- e
- A*, # * ' t :# :* P4.gs : e s u: --
- t'.41 1,4,.. CL*t,. tS s ;* s *Tj aat. '
.e As 4 *t%*.'*
- *eit 1st:13;1 rd l'e s.:14:*.ta :1101s*ms :1g*--_-
_~~
w-l
.., *t *
- ta s** 1**
- tt, se a *1 :f t*4 ::* ?.17. ra: :.*e ga.* :e: g g.
- 3. =
'A It utt'l.*r
- 22 I :# Te :4:ah;e 43 4 ild:te*AI 8&I14 SM:& ate *.:
- 4 e'
~
I'
.54:1t ?e s' u.as c; re :f:e staut in :*e *IAA as "a t'--
~"
- r:7: e s ta1* et t : s:- xt.rs; f **;.
e W :: :'.s*:r.s a =
T_~. ~_
- .acs.4 e 24: ce sa:Acact. ee t ac: 34ar 4; an: ias*ca u s %
- er':r wu' an ne par *. :f :~e itu-sae.
~l:hT C :
- 1. E. I'tescasar *E a*. CHI t
i I
i
,w
~ _. -. -
i
[
.o r.
l
.... mr 2
S =.**. *~n..
i i
i r J
.e.
- 4..
s 3;P
.~.4.
- 4. 71.
- 2....
e.3;.. 3....
3
<3,..*..,4......s i
(
a...
- s. y 4.. 4.,. s.g...t'..
....g i.t. j g..a *.
- LL 2.* *~.' '. ' f."."*.. *., '. *s *n*.a...s.
-3,
.a 3.. 4.. g..
3
.. ~. 4.3 3 4
... s 4. *i i,. y.........4
?. 4. 2.. p...
gg3...... s. rg.s 4.a
,~. y.
.a.4...
....z..
2..... s..s....s.
& 44.....,..a.... 1 4,......., :
~.e s,....
- 4.....
e 444 4 sA.
.t s............... s. c.
a
'9 :are'ess : s"?;a : c' : e. :#s::s..
7..is -a.k :ac
?r::ef ns *:- ':r :. e 'se:r.: :. a*/ vs act cr.s a..e - e a:tai 4
sta:e t*
s ::t: :: a ::v$ i ena.:
. s cw:..:t* t e =t.:strative
- 4.*
1
.g g..
,. h.
7 g..
. 3...
- 4. 3 3;,4g i "..* *..*.. g a..a.
s 3. 3 u...... g., i.3 e.
4.
..a s.... u.. i.... S. ut.. t...... %. s =. *. '. s
- a *.*.4 *.
4'.*..**.**.*..****.*.&*.
..,. s a
.. 2
- 4. g. s. 3. g,. g........vs. * ' n *.8 *sn*.* a *s.* '..a. s *. #. 4. C 4 '. '..* ' ~ ~y
... ~.
1..&*.*.***.'..
....4,
....,4.,..g,....s *.. s
- t *:.'.*~,~r.**.*
.a
",2..
,4.,.
g a.... g4...~. $..7
~.4.......
4.
...s
... a Of
- .*e
- E 172 Ott** :*f'si*tet' #
- 4 C*.i G"..
IS 3.P Ci*.* T :*e in: **4 **2 *$
art
's** *.;*. L* *. * ?. $*:::.M ***: tad al t.'1 *J.4 ini*,ilti 2 Of ind:r".r4** 4:*.i O!
- 1
- t 31st s*.4* 5*t".*.
i i
- j s: ave rf cesti=s, :' ease :7.:20: as.
/
s r...e,
/
, '.'*M.T //. U.,f *s i%* t e Ef... ~...f*.
w a. w a...
.3
- i fe C* f"
';t<isiT cf "sa ::r
.e t's.
. 1
....E
- 4...:
- 4.
. f.
3,.:
C..
4,.
e.
(
8,.,
e.
4.
s.
- Ps e*,..
s. a.
n 3....
.s e.......,:,
a
- 1.4..s. n.s,
w I
h f
l t
l l
I I
I l
l 6
i O
^-~--~~ ~ ~~
~'.
6g.. w.,,,. %.,1 :. i. s j
i < s' ( -
fA,,
- l. 'i.I sC h.:M j
r..a a u
mt. m u g
f.
N t.,C.E /.: 9 ECUL TCRY CC* '.*;SS;;t.
i.g,,[ /
i
<.as w:v : e.::sss N
- 4, 3..,.:, s
- ctet%:s. 50-20:
.C 22.
e.yu,,
- ~ g
- p. '. 5.c,
.c.a es.. se::.er,. e:::..,e; :...
,m...
_ e ygg ve.,.e.. a.e,
s.e ra. 4..s s o... ~.,,.
.ne... e..........
v
..a.
a,,~ c
-1. :.:.-.
2--..
7.. :. :,,.
.....:.. y...:.-.:....,..;.:.
4r::,.w?
. s.. %.. u.....
" p..s
-:.a.... :..-.
.m. g n w
m.mG
-a s., <,. s..,..,... a....
.. e s.e
..a. a.a e..e.s e.e..e.e......e...e.........--,
c..
......ef..<...
zateria' fa'se statar.ents.
- .. : e.. s e..s..e e...,.... e. _.:,. -.
2...
..s..
2..
.... re..e..s
..s..e...
a.
<i,.:. s...e....
.. =,
......s....e
.s......
.. 5,a..,s.....e..s.....e....,.. :
..a
..c.
...s...e
.... e 3
.. e...,............ e., s
.ese......
..z.... 4 rea::.a ;e s re< e. is s
..a
- e:
Se::e :e C', 0579; a c:;j is e :1:se:.a e crenc.x f r.
.;.,:or; cate:
n.
. g g... t 1. e., *.,... & o..sa;e s..
..,..e s.e A..
s.
3.....
o..
- e.e. e. a.
w..,..r.
4.. 4..se....e.. -
...s
.c 4
'e. e* t~ 1*e I'"e*s
.ac." *... ~... g.... e e a.I; Pi. e 1.7 r ee &O:e":' :e s.
.e
- le*:
.;.': e&
,,.,.e.,...e..,.;,. <,1se s.a...e..'a
...a a
,.s.. A :
e 4..e...e o.
.c.
- ...., e. *. 3 s i... a. o * ; a. :e9&..ea..
.e..:a
.....e a.
..s.
a m....e r..... e C s.
V.., s... s t. 4 4. f..., t re g J P.. s.....:...
s...
4
... 2 I.s q ;'. y d yI!! i?. vest'g&*.':n.
E&se: QT
- e i #
......,..e ae *:1
.. '. e ' :.. *.. g... a3* 4*..
.*is***.tC..e C **1
...e..e.e o.6p
- 4. 94 4 e....S
..., s.
p
- e
- 4 ' *., "f1'.efia 4 C. t'e ef0 e. w:.?: a.C t :1*'*) -- "t t i'*
- e f i' *.* e s
, ye..3
.. e. s. ; *
.e. :e stP: t st /:. fas : a <e a eeti ; at -es::.J-:t s ' t e 44*
.. 1 1:
C'sC1.ss Cine
- 4:*ic s that *:3y *e !!<e* # t
- e j!*O 10 !?.e W :" &P.:
oa.:.,
.i.
..s.e...a..
1
'..ses
..e.
.. ss
,u
.*1 e
.. e A
../ ou 4.
de3r*e.a. acae*, A*t*P; p.e".!'<e.os;Cer
,3r.~.e.a....s.c......
=
.gf..e
- o..n s,.e e. t.
, a a..
- s. P ete..
Enc':sare.
(See ?. ext na;e)
E
- ces G. Aa:;)1er y,
2-e..,......
....s ye : fr:: -C*hcr-ar;
- S/27B
..'a.:':s.re:
Re...
- ~..s..
r:.:9 a.
. e F....... s t.s-
- e.. srocu::, a 5 e
t 0
O
/#
e e
9 9
0 0
4 0
I o
.j
, g, 4 i.w A 2 ka N '
s/., ses,'*g g
,l i l1
( Mi%
d ua.4?ta s*a rts j
y-
%C1.1A4 AsGMT;RY COMwis2CN
- g,4 l
w a s?.s.o.c.::sss W/el s..v p 13.ed 1
i lc:ket No. 50-323/330 r
l a
i PE";:A'i. f:R:.:.tley T.:. ;s:n, Exe: tive Cffiere f r ;;tra: ces l
S.:p:rt II
~
1 l
)
FA:M:
Heroit 3. Th:en:.r;, Dire:::r l
Civision of tes:::r C:cstracti:n Ins;e::f:n,.I
)
4 1
S'3JE T:
CO*E C S CN 4.**: E.' F;;;D'E'J PA*GIE C'. M:: LAC 4
1 j
SE~iLEw!.sT F;;5. EMS DATED APRIL 3,1975 t-c-
We have reviewed :*e abcse referenced ;ackage whi:5 i.nce-J. Ca. 's's rne :-ard.
f Parch 21,1579.as f:ma-te: : IC I
c:: :t a 'r; gros; itair IE. Trese c: re.:s ar I as :*e res;:ssi:le e :r:vi:e: :: :e ::..
s t s:er.:.'
- nis 4mera :.m and the f:11:w.:
t: f:ur er.f:r:e.mn: pers:r. el ais en Par:n 21,157).ee : and.: jc; ; :v: e:
In smef, it is :.7 c;ir. ion tha: f:ce of :=e fhe faise s:a:re.:s icea:if tec ty the Regien will ;r::abif te sa:stantiate: t: e catertai fa!!e state e-ts art tha: they we's race in careless disre;&r
- f :.e facts.
Therefore, it wet.id fcile. tnat thert woald cro:et'y et f:.r instances Of a f"4:enal false sta:eee9:
c1.'l penalty of $5,*00 i::: sed f:r it. eacn o' w*. ten w: 1: ha,e a c; inion, a raterial false statare.t.
The fif tr.1:e is not, in our 1
The ecciosare presents cut deutled reco:r.enda:io..s en tais ratter.I yew have qsestices please ::nuct us.
vf 4
/ ;d
.M ::.
.M harci: D. Thcen: rg, Di e:::r
/
__ Sivision of Rea::Or Cons -.::icn s
Ins;ecti:n. IE Enci:sur.
e:
Cc. rents er Midland Enfor:eme9: Packa;e CCN7ACT:
- 2. E. Shewnaker. IE
.45-2 551 i
t l
A g A n E.A n G.
.=
a v iwer
l l
l
/
C.*"IN*3 C.1 P.!1AN: !%FO "D' INT F: GGE Tuh"M.:-~C TO Tr ;B5.K3 FCi G,?'IR, CATC 4/3/79 1.
Tre a:erial fa se s:a:e e-t ite s (:r:batly 4) sn:.le :e ;ut in::
A;;encix A entitle:, "%::::e Of.t:la: ice," a-4 will te t. :se tiers. :,
3.
a civil penalty. As A;;e cix 5 entire:, "N:: ice of Pr:;: e: :.::st: n of Civil Pe alt.ies" sh:;i he ; e:ared.
shoule :e a::ressed in an A;;encia C, *N:: ice of ticiation.* *The c:he-1:e s i
i 2.
Ai! sta:ezents tuoted fr:*
icentified by a?en:.ent ceu=:er 4.:/ r revisi:n neeer and es:et*e SAR in 3.
is a;;1 er:iy fr::s :ne origin 11 versici of te FS;4A caeck of Stat
, :-d sute en and is ne c rrent versica.. Revis :n I, 11;;2/77 p.t[ nas a :iffe en:
statements referen:ed have been revised new after the inves: iga: ice..Scre :f cus be reexamined. If tne statements cacte: in ce R I! draf: can te This utiti:ed in as ea.'Or:e en 4:: ten then we ju:;e the su:eme-: ::
catarial false state ent.
te In re :ntng tnis :n:1w:n we n::e :na: a C-45 statics sta: I: e 2 aterial is to be used as Class
- nstr.::':n dra.ings
- nere citatics is :: he pr:;erly su;;;r:ed.
a O'n 4 Sta: ament f2 can ;rouciy te classed as a mate-ial false su:erea.:
-M-a the ressits Of the 1::erview wita the c:qni: art engi if s>5*"Y lation snee: pr:ve ttat 3.0 ksf was usec in the se::lement calcalaticas neer anc, r :*e calcu-J 5.
Su:ement f3 is viewe t: he a cate-ial false sutamen:, but :neae is a need t: full
-*T cal:alations. y de:u:ent. hat was actually c:ne in the executien of :ne
.y Again a c:;y of the calculati:n sheet a.4 4f the c snt: ant engineer is needed to prcperly su;;;r: /:r a statacen:
the finc:cg.
6.
Statenea.t la can ;robably be c'assec as a material false state ent if
'" $ ', se;;the results of the interview an:/ r ce calculaticas are p v :e:
ort the finding.
t:
7.
5:stement f5 is j4dged t: n : be a sa:erial false state 4-:.
is du_e.t:
Thi future value f:r set:*ement.tre fact tnat ce staterent que ed is wri::en as a ;re: ::e F:e Sc'se statteents =nich will tec:4 material false st 8.
a :iv't ;enalty, remen cem from the draft A;pendia A at:d ecse t e renainder to the new ? pesetz C.
9 9.
All state ents jue;ed t: be material false sutem:s mus:
t: see in what " state Of sinc
- cr in what circumstan:es the li:entet 4:eDe exa-inec,
tne statraent.
This is. relevant t: the cuestien of
- civil per41:f* vs.
"sec:nd : nance."
In car judgwn: t?ese instances a:: ear t: be si*Ja:1 9s I
of " careless disregar:* of ue facts which would war ant civil penalty.
1
=
6
,_-,----,,-,.--.,_,..m.,--.,,,..-...--m__,w.,.,
.--_...,,--,.,-%~,,-.wr,.m...,
e,-.-me...
. - ~, _.. ~,, - -... -,..,
/V 2
y;w. I.,.
e J
/
c w/en:les re:
a D.W. Hayes,RIId:'i J. G. Xe ::er,li i -
c-T. W. Br::te::, xc;c G. W. Rei_4:3. RC:
I R.' E. S.4eaker, Rc;,
p"-
L.
C-mi.
h o
e.
GO P =
e b
=
f r- <
{-
l a
1 ~. ;
r-0 4%*
i t
3 e
g,.
O e
,?.'
- L 4-
- 1 I
v4 6
2 *. i
. :9 O
l o
- ]wl.y,IS
,!=.
3 T
l
.I.
e e.
E.*
g.
e 9 e*
- m. *
.e e
- d m
- W
- E "a.asar. mr6. ~ _.
k l
l
c s N I s t 4:.
"g..,...,,;,
- g. 3! L U' : - i. /
w -
..a e-.
q.........
...q.
-n.-..
c
..t l
I-f..,54:#~ser.: :s ons. ers P:.er 2 a j i. wa r:n ; g 3, 2.3 e m e,:ee e m ea: a s 3 :3.se 3,.s, ee.. s...
It als aireed (W/II) :ta: 50.54(f) cid :e s.ffiEie.-Z
'~,'s.,...,~
2-
'e'e*2'j estica :f ;A ace:.a:j cf '; tit :y,t:I.35 cise ;see: tq:,,n37 y by.t '.:s e,y,;;.s: 1.
II =as :s as. *egi:n :: aae a fit:
I 9; as :s a: eta:f c; sA. : :_e er:3:icn. 5:e:j3; r,s;;,,3 3.,33 =,,,y,n soils satt.emen: atter in re'a:t:n :: ee rep;rts cf ;; :ef t:ie cies in o:ner areas,
_~i
~
'~
3-La:est res::nse t: 10 C R 50.5:;f: fa* :,.cn : es:1:n3 7,g37,.n
- g f..
j
- o...ac.. iil re:eived :n 11/:3/7;.
(r n:3.tve ;A Scan:n p s::i n ci (
e si.g;ests res;cnse still ansatisfa:t: j.
.g i t.t.
4-Revied { "idian: Eciis Se:::e en: s,3 :::3:s ;;,,, ::
r33 3f g3 3,,,,3 bif a
cuer. (ic.c of s::e ae, 3f cer33 :f g,:;jn,,,3 ;,; g,,ff 3-IC date. % I M re:11es a 50.54 f) have re ceserj3,3 3:,
,,c, I
.'h crite-ia r:r re w: al action. : rice to s.cn ac:1:n. :sslican v e s
.ne re e:ial ac:1:es as "pr:of tes:s*. Hen : ec: ace ree. f:r sse.,
l cr.,.eri a., Staff ecisi:n cs t: ac:ep:3: 1::/ 0' re e:ta; s-
- 5..
01:n O' the ;rc;ra. and a- 'ica-: ::.s: ;r::ee[a--d -e.$irdy' awa : c S
In a nee:ing cn N; venter 23. II develope: a new positi:n:
o.
4M
[e'er{encies;i OA perf:rmar. e acce;:a:1e :e:3ase t: feengjfjes q; 8-7
- gy;n
. fi..
b.
II c:d raises :Jesti:n as t3 t'e ac:ectasility of :ne cest;n fi, 4*d craws tee conclusion that the noef fication constitutes a
.ecar re from :he principa; arenitectural and engineering cri:eria; c..
I~ suggests Steilofaengen :ng,;4ng g3;3 t0 develc a decisien far
.e ent act'ons relative t: app'i:an:'s failure to co:M:1y wf:..
.i. a,, rove,my CP, e
9.
Ov.
tA p'
i 4
M.
s.'....
. t* *e: h*a l.
{&
.L.
. a h.s.,,...
w:w-. a :.:
.:: w.
...g. pr.....
.s g..
.... ag..e :.22...$.:,3r......
s...
.=
S.:.....*
.......i. -
- ie. :,0....a....g.,.. g.-... -..
....... 5...........
. r...
..) 3::ia...
9
.. 7,.. e..
......a.
sr.2.,.>
.....2..
- ...,.....g..i.5
.3 5.
5
- e..3 5..se.5,,.. 3.d 4..:....
5g..
....e
.i....:
5..e.
c.. r*..
ac aa5.....e.,e.,e..e S.A. 5.a..e.
3 e s. 5........
- 5. 2 e..
.e.
.c.
a...
4 a.....a,....5........
t a. 4..........a
.. i.......
.a 9
..g,..,...3*...2......
2...$.. 3 2
.r*.
5*...* '"..*.*'.**.*e "c".*.*.**,
l 2.,
3,3
.. 3....
.5.,2
.v p....,.........e
..g.
.............e... 4 5......,.
.3
.. sc..;
d... 4 4.r..e.4 Or 5.....
re$ !
43.*a....e 5...
y..,.,.......-e..
..... w.
2..
l
,r..e/... '. t.er.. e....e.'
,.,.e es;e.e
...r
... s. 3 e
..c. a.... 1 '.
.c
.w... e
.4.
s.
..&.1.
5.....
r' e.....
..c..
.. c.c,
..&.. wer.3,..,.
4
.3
...1
... 5
.. a rg '., ap,y 7..
...a.s..geg.. $. e e...s.,
.. c. e.. n.... a.
.,,t...c e.,.... a. 3 4 n.
e '.
. s s
- ,r 6:4,.,'e,..e we.31'5 a
..e 4..
CA.. 5 *. a
.....*A..,.....
.4....
3...
5 1..
r.
^$ tress I
!$ a;;it:4:le *.3
- ffere* 11I 5ettle"2*, 'Ji'; *et
- f r i T:re G.a". tit 3*i.e 455c55 t'.t t Ce*er tire tra* "; :le 'Ga *5 tr3* Snit *.eJ f*: Se**Ie1.
31
- e5 *3 *.*e 4 *13
- red V4..e s. : :*:5. t&*k!, e *:.t'. * *e 1ti" ***i'; C'I CO*4 n,.
4...,A
.e1. 33 3.ee
...r.
..,...ej
, cOgpL...
- e...,.... 6 :C7...Ce
.~
........ +...
i l
..,3....
., e S e ". * * *,* 5.* *.* #. r *.* e r
- e *. 2. 5 *. 5.*
- e.* c' *. *. *.*.*.*. e * *. e.* 1 *..*
e
.e
... e.e,, 'a.e.
5 a
3..
I v l5-5.aa55 a-c si: ray c ci,s n te: trat 5::.e i m:e5 af :::e e ': arce n e
e
- * &Pfl5 rest 4It: i't tSe 3E nvest ;&*iOS *e;;:r*
1*. *. 1005 t*at 200* ::*41 3 Te25.*e5 eyC*C tro$e I/31: ally 't;C5ed 3y tre *.E! *4y :e air tr!!:. @i's f e'.1 e d IS ** i 5 f1*a 5 lje5 Of $O.T*eO*d**0r. I** $*:. $ *e :!* tie 14 l
ea
.,e
... O a.,.. g.
~. - -
/
.f
.. e.
n,;
ep,. **f*..*.**y ***6..-
- I~
. ' * * * * $
- S.,
- a. a
- 4
. e. #
- 5**a
.& *
- 4..* *. 4
.a.
J...
- =a.**
t
- 9..e *
- r 4.*.. l.*..*.*.* *.f *
- 2. * * * * *
- tf $.***$ $C..
- '*~** *'**** '.O
- t'..
9 C C.
...C.
- 8 3
3 2
K.... d e.
. f $..... d e d,g3$.
V.p.
...,e.
,g g*
g "o. * *..g&
- .d.
.3
....4
.3 24..
..$......5....a
.y
.... sa..a...d
=..
i
.e.
.....e c... 4 A,c
.,1..
4..
,..,e s. 4.. ;. :..$. * *-*:,,....
...c P-s 4
&.a 4 c *, r. J.....,
- ,.. e. 53. 88 1
.e.....
- 8
,;.s a
.......:....,.. 5 *.* s e *...
- .3
....,d............ z. :...
- g.d e..g$.O.
.1
.$f.
===.*.* "*
A*=.
32.C.
. 3
.....=.
- s..
- s.a.e==.C
..e. 1..se $,.,.5......:
a.....,
..t 5.,e.
- 1....,., c-4. :...
.2
.. c.
... a.
a..
5 &
.x
....g.
............e**.**.**..***.**.*t*.... '.**3.*.'*.*.*.*a* ~.'s**,* a.1 *..,.... r.**...
...,............e,...,...2..... -
as..
v,.....,...... a.
.r,.,,:.
,,t....)....e....
l
.. y l
..q.gce, *:
.,e..
,- g..,,.g.....s.,
5.......,,..
a...
...a
- 1...,.
t
.r..
e. 1 Ch..
.a J
l v,
- e*..**.**..**.*.**'..*6.**.*.*3-~,**.*.*.*..*..*.***#
4, a... *>.:-.-
4****..*.*.y*
8 *.
J
.; q q..$ j..... n *.*. e *. e *..* *. *..* s *. 4 & ". # ' C a *
- Cr # ' *
- L'
- 5 #..*r
- a.C.*.
. re A *., r. 3.*.*
..w..
s is
- 3 ce
- re: *.'i a W. Ma a s s e-* ca ta: 1*/*iC5,nri;*.;3*.;5 8
. 3
- i":.;$ fr**
. * *.,.n.. 9 dr*
w..,*..
)
We.
..t. 3
- g g...g a... e.* *..* *.
- c* *..* #. P * *
- e '... * *
- 1 *. * * $ *..* *. 6
- c.~.*
- s.*.* / *.
- t 2.1
.a c,
...P..A.
S.ta...,....,a
..e..e...
,6.
a a.
s.....
i
[
/
A*, ff E.
i
/
r#. Cwe I
I I
,e--.-
. -,...,,. -- ~.
}
/
T. -
.'M.. : ?.
1
.. s.
/ /
/ /
- =w*.*....
%.....i*...
s..... *..
4,.3....,4*.d.....**., ** **
4.,
ss a..
l rd,......ca.a s... ~.
.c.
t l
3,. g *, * -... j r.
.,... e '
,2.*.*.*.*.*.***.*5...*'./.*.*..'.'E.*.***.
.'I,
a y.
1
- .:. ela., :.e
- . aj 4..
2s:
v.
,rt.............J:.
- :, ~.......
.a s....
(
p.7..t.
.p.s. m....,La.,...... ]
..t 3..
22........a
.........]
s
..c t
.... a ; d... : q. v4,. : &,
..f i.
.,. J...........
a,.2..
.. s.,.
i
'A'i ".v.15 rahe 5*f:
- .. It:* r. i:3 Or3*C*t5 35 *: 't ** **i W *i.'ta
.u I
1,
..e.
e.
4g..g..,
- s... g...= :s :.w*. :..s.,'
7g dg...a... gag,,.
- a.
.r
- er, n d...t.,. 5.
.c..& v. 4...
4
.a.]
5.&e.s...
5c.,.c.
.....3....e. a:,
4.c
.a in s ac..
.v4 r,.
4.,.
. e
- s, s..,,or~.
.t e, 3,.: 3.
.?
.r.....
- c...
s.r.. a.,. 5 t,.
s t.3 a-
. s
.c..a....
- e....
- 4....] a....
- L a.
.a 5....
.......de f..s.e
.,,A...e5 45....s &........
d........
.. u5....
a..>....
...;te :er c.7,
....s ::.
.i 4,
- 23.....,...,,.
3...,
.....t
.p....a3 3 :..:.:.......<; u..........,.
.,.............s
~,
tse a:;licant catec Sep ccer 23,1175, for e.1C. 5'a tr.te-i: re::-:5 ra e i
teen iss.e' :o : ate t i vr:er... lc...-c; e:e ce. 2 is. :;.an.arj
.:, s; 4,
i a
Fesraarj 24, l...y. s; april
,,w.
.:. ; a9:..r.e
.,r,.
. L. rai c:*:.::e: a
..,74.
- 4. 3,j
..V,a..3 4.....,... A r..a 25
...e.de.55
&f. <... r,1,.* *.., a. ')
s 1
..g g...
3..."a C ' '.'.1 a* i C*.* f *.* e s t. *. *.* *. r.
- 5 '. *. & ***tr*..**.***..****..*4*.*.
a 3
- 4*0: 'A r *....:,. :. r.
. *.,:"C e*e9: IC** n1 c.e * ;;*tatia. *a ti a t a.,1 5 g i
5:4 :d*e'. 1 in t*e E3M. 45 **.4f !4 5;;II:2:le I: 50.~e :# : nile lil #**:!ris are presca.;;y un;er Inter *.41 review, AS$iste: Of.*iE* 5 Aff 45 4:;*:;*i4:4.
l 1
1 i
l I
i m
I s
e.
.l t sw-.,.- t. 2 a...... 5
. ~....
%4.g..
u.
...e....ns.. s.
W. *1315.,;
....5154..
- 5..r.a..,
.m. e*1:0**
...d d.
- .-7.....
...... 3 9
f *ibe 2 e ar E. 34:c1P.
......a.c..
a.
E. i.t CE 4*.
4*
be Ne
- to, O. 5;;*a.:
e e
s' e
e 0
e s
m Mumu
,,.w-m
.a.,,
w Oh, g gg e
,T I
l
' & w - 0 J I,i 18 0 l
- I#
&NS
&p
- Mby}ns
~
g,9, 1
DG Bld3 p,
SvVShfx 40 91Q g}"A?
Gol M oice l
m atg w, P'p 01
\\
L ~ m % &L P:q s n u. n t e a%
s d a n / e y b h.,,
jon s-S W e d b 6 p e i-w L & ty {(q T r1+M he~s t &, a th o
wI rua, f
GA kk g,
l l.i%'
i 1
flN uk~
I l
A C~ff' I
i e'
s 3 { ~l ! O O /_
L... m L.'
c%
,/ *** r,'s. ! $ I C ( d c
Z' W.--* Gm
/
Ues4TED STATE 5 6/ !.
, i NUCLEAR REGULATCRY CCMMISSICN
! g, '"
i ~,
y 3
e ease =*sCT3nn D C 3rMS W
- %f.!
SEP h. as s.,,
m r
U.
e...e e
- t. :. = a m n.. '..
g.
. 6
- g..
e..,. o.
~-
... e. 4s..a.
.s a r. e K. ~..
- J
- r.,,*:..
j
-~
".:.* : c:
l L,,.,,
..s.
a.
1
...p
- eo. 5 s a.e
- l
- ns. eas E:.e* C:'":a'iy
.~ U 345.e5: :ar-all R:a
-._c
- i ;an 292.1 l
.'3 : k 5 : i.
], t..
C
- ea,ve. C:cs:
M *.::t t
?..
-..:e...-.....................................,
..,,..... S...
i
- . e-: e-: '.:. *: : j:.r a::14:at :- :atec *e:e.a w
'8 11'.*. :*:.**e*
':-a-':
e;ar:'ag a :e-aaent :estte*:r; Seite* : :::le: ':" t*e e g; t a,: site ** re5:Orle t: 3 e:.e 5 ; \\,.* *. ' *';- * *. L.
2.* e* 5
- e *
- 5 I
'e tee ;# '.c.e :e* ?9, 1979.
- e 'ev'ew O,. t*e "f:"I'!';*: Se:t';* :#
l
- .*,.te:I:g1: de: e':teC**iCa' E*C'*ee*i 3r!*:" te:' a*e5 I*e **e 8:e #.* tate tr#:,r a: ice regarain; t* tat re5*;*$e 33 *:e*1*#'t: le
!"C':g.re 1.
- his. in#:r-ati " 15 in a
- ia *: re'att0 *e0.es:5
- nta 9e': in Car.et*er Cf A.;aS* 4...':..
_ _. - -.3 0..
1 l
.e..! : 100re iate fe,r re*If t0 E"C' 5.re I a* f *.* e !' ' 4 5 * * ** **I +*'
- d -
- ' a* i*i:*aI 1*#*" 37**.
.a c.
f s ree: C'trif
- Cat'Or Of !"eSe re%est5 2
- e die ::"ta *. 'J 5 1
i
$**Ce'ef.
f I
A, / %e.A.
~.
~
.e,. v..e:e5., =..
5....
- r *'"er$'mq 1
"4 5., a.4Ce 5..-
4 3
4
(
E*'C I :Isee:
- :.eSt ':e a::it :ral e
br:r ati:9 i
- .' encl:
- ee 9ent *tge l
9AAd ie ?,
., c (v vu
< v wf._ l _ f_
r l
,. s. 3
.o
.... is
- r.
. k. Csci
'.*:e : es :e :
- s.,e-s ::.5- :: :4
. -:a:.
. r-:.es: a Ja:e s:. * :- ;4-49*;'
CO.
- 4 e * *. ' ' ' ! e *. 5 s0
- sra,
!- & Ees:e
.c...e
- -s: sa : a: : 4:a
- :4;:. :" t-: s :::23
.......a......r.. s..
~ :as. e s ::.e- ; :4 f
,e..
.a:.s:. * :- ;a-49;;'
- .24.
- . :e-. Sec e:a y
- s. e s ::.e* :: :4.,
.es: * :- ;a- :.s.e
. ace s:. - :a :- 4);;;
- f :- *.
- e
- y. Es:.
.: - 4:s v..ae,... = '-..c...,
- s.. a.. s.
- s. Pa*/ S *CIate i' ? ! 5.Td9e: CF?se
. c;ar:. * :at;be titLO
-4 s.. *t,ty. L5:.
- rref ~e e-a:
5:a:e :' * : ;a. *r,*rer ar:4-p.. e '. *. * *.'. *. s
- P g..
.a. :.
...g
.ansir;. * :.9 ;4a tii!3
- ..e cel *a sma
a:v:e ;;
- clare. **:.a t ;aa 146 0 Gran:...*e**1::. is:.
Por :s:n 1 elsea, ala.e ia :: 8 o'a =s 4t42 ::5 C e-:e *
- . eC.. e.
,... M.
...v.
P 9eea:ct's. F. e:c a $5* 2
l 1
4 4
k 4
3...
27,*..a3 a.
.s.
. e. ".3.E m
..o p. g.
.f..
g
....".t.o 3..
"e e
- '.3 S'**
d
- 6.*
I l
3,,..,...
4 *.
. C.,
.4 i
j 3
2 l
.a s
i.
l
-a s...
i,
)
- 3..,,
aa.
j
- 3.
a.....e
.d4..,
l
.. 3 j
- i
,l g
J j
I i
i i
i i
r e
i i
l
'l 1
1 f
l t
I F
f
s lNu:.k a.
e i
t
.3 Augast 27, 1980 e
e e
e e
6 e
e I
e e
e e
O e
b O
e O
l e
l a
e e
e O
e 4
e
'g 9
e e
9 0
6 9
8 4
e O
6 4
e O
O S
9 G
S e
9 9
Aug;st 27,1930
. a.
- .2..
.c....,
. :.s. *....
..e
=*
-2.,
w e... ".
,3
..a
- .].
go..... ;. =.;**..
.),
w g.
EK LC5 lee 1 l
StDPLEMNTAL RE" WESTS DEGARO:NG PLA1T FILL
- 49. Your response to our Request 24 states that if the dewatering systen shculd fail, mre than 90 days would cccur before groundwater levels would rise to elevation 610 feet, the groundmater etevatten at eich liquefaction would become a prebism. Ide are comer,ed that this water level rise might occur over a period conside* ably less than 90 days in view of the following apparent discrepancies in equations and input parameters:
I l
r The error function solutten to the partial differential equation a.
4 describing unsteady groundwater flow which you used to detemine 1
j pemeability, appears to be incorrect; tN carrect form should have l
a 4 in the denominator testead of a 2 as you have shewn. The l
correct equation is:
- [4K5 tin )
e where:
h = water level rise at I=0 H = water head at I=0 5 = average depth of water erf error function
=
K=
penneability I=
distance t=
time.
ne = effective porosity 1
L 1
l z-b.
In the above esation since h is the average cepth, its value should Ile between h and M.
'n applying this ecuati:n to conste a pemeabilit/ K of 11 feet per sec:nd and a corres:ending reco#4 time cf 90 days, you used 0.1 (cat for h,1.6 feet for H bat 20 feet for h.
Use of a smaller value of h (somewhere between 0.1 and 1.5 feet) would result in a higher permeability and a rebced time considerably shorter tun 90 Jays.
c.
Your value for a in the above equation is 325 feet, which ycu j
say is the shortest distance between the critical area and the recharge scarce, i.e., the distance between the southeast c:rner of the diesel generator building and the southwest cornee of the circu* sting water intake structure. However, Figure 24-1 shows i
this cistance to be about 240 feet, tlse of this smaller value i
for a vill also result in a rebound time shorter than the 90 days which you have con 1Nted.
(1) please justify or correct the above apparent discrepancies and,
{
if appro;*iate, provide revised analyses to better define the rebound t't.e to be expected following a prolonged dewatering system failure. A more con ervative analysis might involve utilizing the recovery data from the appropriate pwnp tests, i.e., x. u f,t.
(2) In determising rebound time, it is our position that you should also postulate failure of non-Seismic Category I piping at critical lecations. This should include the circulating water i
conduits.
,n
.., - - ~.
n
.-,,,,--,~-.-,,,.,_-.----.e.,n--~vo,,-av nzw,, av-w----- --
l A
5 (3) Cencestrate that t.ere remates adecuate ti*e to install art isolament a back-ve dewatering systen to prevent gr:umtwatee from rising above elevati:n 610 feet.
- 50. Y u-Res:anse to :equest 24 :: claces t*at trere is ge:et ate-ec*a ge free the cooling ;ond in the area of t9e intake are cit o str';:ta*es becasse pumping tests at well PC-15A resulted in ve*y lettie draw::wa at ceservation wells SW-1, $W-4 and RS-1. Mcwever, fce several indiated rt.sens, ycJ also c:ncluded that t tre is very little recha ge in the 47s ef the dis 5arge str.t*:.re and cre cf t*ese reas:es is tnat t'tre is very littie e swcewa at etservatt:n mel s PO-3 and DC-20S as sh:wn by Figwre 2414 Dese a;: ear t: te centradictory ccnclusiens (i.e., hcw can very littie drawcewn incicata i
'e' recharge at one locstion and no recharge at another nearby locatt:n?).
Provide additional inf:r'natten to sappert and clari'y ycur conc 1ssion
<f that there is negligible recharge in tN area of the circu?ating mater discharge stvture. (AlsoseerelateeRecuest47(2)).
- 51. Your response to :e;uest 24 regarding tne ares well sewate ing sfstem c:nct. des tPat 22 ells aning at an average rate :f 5 gp wcule be needec to remove g* urorater st:eed witnin the backfill an natural Two more wells are cc:vided for infiltration and pi:e leakage.
sands.
You have not de'enstrated whether 24 wells would also be a suffic*ent num6er to maintain the area grtundwater at the desired eleistien fo11 ming removal Of the groun&dter already in storage. Provide 1
1 3
~-
J r
h, 4
6 neditf =na? ?=':rvati:n to decastrate t'.4128 me*15 v'il meteu's
}
grs.Nwetee ice's Wan e'evatt:s $10 'ee aN se:v' e t'e des';n hasis used f:r '.** s :ttemt att:=. 2c t':rai'f. ;asti's fe'.7 ase af 14 ;e-: sat f:e as evere;e 5t;n ' :a-t 'te': ~. "*: eat.
52.
'w res:c'se :s te-w: 24 sis: asses the 50.- e sf ;wie'
- 1cm few iave setemi ed fr:s :urcias tests in t.*e vi:ist f :' t'e l
te-v':e 'este- % 5:rxture sad tse ***:.'s *5.atee ntate aN 1scsa ;e 5:~.4: ares. cete, as tests a:cear to '4,e seee ::acxtes to deta **ne t* Dew : vical s teetta y meter Trea:: sea.* Med, s':=a :n
@2 T'7.re 2.I ' A a td 10cated jus
- mest :P t*e a CIetr ;'aa*.
u re rese9:s a Dctantial scu':e :# ;nuecma'.er. ee are ama*e c# fu c:sciastop tsat f e:ne cf getuecmate* From outside the 3 aet area is 1
preciade1 by se cooltag ;cns dite saitM eac:wcasses t.% %ctear plant site; eemevec. feu % Ave ;revided no tafermation ta suppert t3f s carclus1on w1th respect ts the Dow pend. Also lachi99 is in'cenetton ca the dotatis o' four ses: P'aat "t he sN== :n F.,12 F t rare 2.5-a6. Prov'se ta'o*estien ts destest.-ste eN:*e* t.at b poed fs or will Se a source =f gro.nomater at fcur 3' ant 19 tee as e
a sistaus, fpctace
- e fsilcut9g-(1) P-ovies a gene-al descrf ttee af the Dow pond (stze. sects.
capacity persese, csnteats, sea' tag net.ws, etc.). $aectff esatsus elevation of the meter in the he paid with relattanssip
[
ta t.% growmheter levels belos tDe plant. Include a sket:s shoming distances and etevations of t.% 3ew pond re'ative ts the ies: Plant Dike.
I I
5-(2) 8m*:e detat's ce co r mes: 8'aa: Otte. C.n are the ses: 8'an:
>te t: f:.r :x'*ng =cen: c'se, f ci. *3 any sfMiar :y 's t*e -
d
~
- .a* :f :' :: s:.c:'en nac :*e e s: vee :* cys:. cit:n aate-ta's.
- a:oes s t 4: s' art c: ave:,m ate er: ts : e a u se e t e hes* Pf art 3ieg is IXa'ed. c'sCas ePe*47 sad %cw UCava*':H #Ca t'e :'a't 8'#ectee c7s**Jc:':" $f t*e 'sest 37 ant 24:3.
(!*, 8m*:e as-%t't crawiPgs 3f 13e mes! 8!att 01:4.
- 8-:. :e : e -es.its s' ry tests c:re.:te: :: va:* a ::ac! ston 4
3R t*e e# #M: 3# **e h sord M t4 ythmbater beaeati t*e staat.
(5' tr : e b :ord $s a :c: eat'at sew.e s' rwns.4:e seov':e a:'a'fses 2f tre t'ee4stry cf e's ete* (wt.9 artsent and '.t4et) ane :ese-,:e its e'*e:s sa : v m:erta, sys:e= aae ::ae
,,e e.
F:W :y:ccee s f alstag taats, et:.). !sentify say W w.its er s'ans yes beve to senttar and cyt 21 me catents or taf1wa of De Jew 3CM 2. Pia 1 Staat Oce'at*0s.
(6l Pe:v':e y: rew te+ e'evettens in De marvaa.se area emicP ts lxated W.meen t*, *cw Sece aad t3e best 8 tant 3'ae.
4 13.
fc.r dis:sss':n :' :*, lateete:t:r self sistre ces'y *a retxese ::
sea,es: 24 ass,md tMt seepete acu14 f'sw to:s a 300 fact sist f:catee 150 feet
- rom tN caelig sond. fou ass,smed cat part of tMs si t no.is be 'nef'ective :scause tse tstate and pop sta ctares useid c4:
a of' part of t*e seeooge f-se the cooltsg popd. Te acesunt for tats cat ff, the sis't westd be located 450 feet from tse esothq you assJed 04:
pond ies:aad sf '50 fset. Thts assgtise reeced the osantity cf infion I
t1 !.'.e s! :.
a aam,m.o
-sa aa-a-.
a._Ams-+2
.u__m-.amm emm,nm a.a
---a 9
8 t
6-F'7.*tt !*-3 et 24-10 'w*cate t.N; 5 ts 10 feet :f aea si ug:
l l
82f S11 W> t*e f atate and see stexta es
'!,, a ::,est 4,'(3;),
c U" tnt'/. ke strac* r.s nef gc; c. :sa :r,,ey, t=,, gg,;9
,- = =.n c.ex. = ss:, m e,:,, mmu
.=2, nx.
i, 4t** '1U38 ** SClot 887 PTCJCtf on F:* *M str'actorgs y.d m,*g D' Me' 2f 'atte ector me!Ts evivf eg. 3,cestt.3 n.: g:,:, 41 t g T
- CO T *1 f.
A:*e etet, w e,,eggg4,,3
,,, 3,.08 t: 1.:::-
f AF CapCIdice N; Se g*=.Cter,S $4719 413C1titut cat 388 1, i
o 5
1 b
i
.et'
.* u *.. s
. s.
s i
y *.
,a scifu si*. i1. N'247.".I'M u e.
u
- w. :. : :.vam s
.,.': g.. a r
..s
.e e..
.cces:.cs. :...:
....e..
- .,.e. r..
.t. :
.,........ o.., n...s........ '.
.a 4...
- q4............,,
.a
....c.....
...,.,.....p3...
........,.: ~;
,r.
)
t.
4
..v
.s
...s
.I
^
.o s,.~ ; ;; ;.e.eea' :'.. - t.~.- :-* ' ~ : : e *n:s s : ; s.< - '
- e
.:.: s c: ".. a : :
. ~. ~ ~ :
s:.- ~ s.:
,,e
.e.s..
.a
....i.....
...t.
.s.e. t i a.1
- 5...
..s
..,.....e
. ;4 : *. e 9:s* :.:
- 4 *f *.* e I : ta w n 'e : r-:4-i. 's7).
- 4.s.4
.as....
.. *<f
..f'.f
,..* W ett
..f....
c,4....,.
.4
.J 14 4
- 4 Id *1 ** ' ;* e* *1 24 ' *] *T e w! 61 *C' 3*( *4*J" 4I 'A*;d
- 4*? ca;&.
- f..
- T '. 1i
....,. a.. f 4,...,...
.. f. 5. 4..t. 4.A l..f,.
i
.a.
%. % 4 *s '.t
- e ' *.* s* i1****be *t# ' tC
- e* b ;.4
- 71 *.R * *a *.4 **e et).. ** T S f;. *Jf *s** !; #:*.1 * * * * ** !
- .3
- 4# ' '9.*41 !*4 111.it e4*f.
y:. *dt:
s....,..,.g'.
..o 3.,y
,.4
... g.4..g,. ', J,.g,.,... Js....
4....=.
~......,
... t*... !
.e
- .s..,
e
..5.,..
...,....6
.'ee.
t o.*..e
.. n,
o,.s e,.
l
....f..
..~ar *
- 4 f'. 1 %.* !*4 J ' 4*4 i
- 2I:. % !';A 3*.f. I eP5 l
2.
1 ;
- J4.* ***
- 1 ' 6 *.4 4 :,:? E T ;1.*v I
.. i....
I. :..
.*dw. dad *,. r.
a
- h*.,.
,....--,,.--.,--.w-nu n.--,--
3
'M.f 4
.1*
. ?. '
- ; * ; *.. ? I
- e
- * ;F, J$
e;t. 'J4 3
. ' '. u n, '.; 4 4. J '
- 2.
'.4 4
.'.. ;.t. V4 s;*t,
.44 I
't 1?s *, 154
,est.
'01
.
- I. T$ I e
- **st.
- . 7 7*.44. l.3
- ,. 3:::
.... 4,;;
I 4 e
r
I i
....~.....
......,,,,. - 4 :.,
-i-l I
l
'. *: M i'il e' r: r s.
.. cts. 2 ;e : z.
- s re
- :
- ' >: : r :.e
- .: n - a-: :n :.--X ea s.
- 4 a t :n * 'e
- lI.
i a.
- a' #::-.. u 'e::e-n:r: i :i '3
~~
- . ;.4- - 3 ::-: *:. - Te:.4-n:e: ; *. 7. 'l 4
.e::.e-n :t: **
*1
- . :-:4-, :4::r #1. :- Te::e s.e: ' i 'i
- e.
- -:a-1 :e:cr: 84 = u Te: 4 u:c*
- i
- - s-- :e:r. *5.* : ' et:#- n:#: 4 '. 'i
- .
- e 1 :::: : ei. o **::e :a: : 1. :5, '!
..e::e a:4: !/ ". 'i. : e-::ss. v
- -te- : e::r. e'. u *e::ar a :n } i ?;
- ?
';. : :t- - :4:,:e: *!. ' 'e::e-n:e: i;
'1 i
- t :#e- :#.u: :ss;:es
- tj :: u; a:r: I' '" 'I
- . zu-: u:
u: u s i
]
.,, : -e n : :
.e m =.
i
- m * : ;. ; :: k.e,
- a 'I 4
's :: : yss :: 4assa?'s,iJ/?!
- . 'em. 4 s :4': :: E ;e *4-::. ::
- 1; '3 e.
- ru ee:o'ea u %: :.r;, 4/ "s ?)
- 4 c r :.q ::
- : :t, 5/ s -)
'e :
- :s:s s astsa :, 5/:?/71 a
9
'e-:: Iss:s"2 ::
r s:r v /. 5/:3 7i
- . %.- Scr : r, ts 4:; e, 6, f/71
- . : *
- s s.:ee : t:- te::r s
,4.
.z,.
.,..3
..i,.
6
..,.3
'3 *4
- * ). Il
... 3*
....I e.
- 2.~.*.*.
- 1..*,
- I e
1.11 9 14
+s 1
e.
g
.1.
s s r 1
. r.l. 1.
..,.1 1
- .s. 5 3-.)
f.
'.2 *:. i. 6/ ?)
4.
73 *3, 5/,2 s 79
- . z...s.,..,/ '3 i.
s.
71 *i, ?/3/73
- ,. 7r-ti. : /t/77 5.
I ':r:ed.: Ac:tses
'a.
'e e 4;; er : 7 c.%ri, :/15/79
':. 4::: ::s't':n 8a:er. 2/:J/71
'c. Nw u::.e :: Nrn.wr;. 3/ 2/79 l
/
a d'
w
- .-.- a r. :s=, sm[.9
~*~3 ** C# 48Y, 2/;L'73 a.
. e:- e y
m
- i-
- T -:: m F:*e, g3t;3 9-N : ~~;-.h r3 u 3w, 3/;, 3
"~
M- *e T *: t* u <4:::e-,I ;;; 3
- l- 'er W; er = S.ce.:.-, :;/;3, 3 g-
.., C.'4.....,..,...es., a. <
w :....
'e e :.e ~~~ e,~.
.... :".. e s...s es 3:e.,3 _>. ~..aw..,-. art *.c. :nc*. M N 2rt :- ftie ir. ;;,)
e - C.
- a.
'e:tra ent:., a %,*.,.,,5.~tri 3 e*.:::gry* 3/2}#g
.e. 2* omei,. I:
0450:*, 4 ';;j 73
'e::e- -: weit 3,..,,
g,g c.
.!::e* -:.e'! u :e-n, ;3 ;
j-
!**f" 3.:tistein u -o.e
, e,,*;3< 3 8,-.4* 3.:eista.1 u -o.e", 3/ ;f 2 i-24* -: e:1 :: Ce ::,
.e::e.., ;..
4....,.3 J. 73
....p s g / 3 1
- * *d-i.:e s ta s :: c.e ;, ;;;;3, 3
't,1*t : 9.A ::r es;cf.cece a.
- r : 4.:e.s.afn a t.3 -.4,.. 3.r.*,,<*. 3
-
- 3 3 =4 y frs: 7/ 3/73, :a:ae IC/15/73 MT 1 34ry #r:: S/!/71, ta:eq icf;s,73 Mi 1-=2r/ fra 11/14.73, ca:ed 12.'3/7; 4.
- .er 1
a.
.- e u o:tej :.,e cc. :c, $3,
,,,,1,.. p,5/7 e.... 2,. c,. A t-te-; # 72, ' 2/13 er. e.. 3 e,.
...e 3.,3r e - g :f
.; __,. :,,,.;,,;gf.;
4
/
f 6
4
i
\\
i i
1 a.
w
.i.
s.
I 1
.% *i: Z*A*tS 5
b;.*.
.... 3,. ~...,...
g,.,,,,
t a r : a..
.t :%
,f ;r u a::4s.s.
4:
3.a s s - s se s 64 -
.. *eoo*
A... *
.t.
..-*3
.e.-.-.%n.. % ;.-
.A
- 4...
=........
...t
=..s...
...g.
- .a.e
?.
r
..e
- ?..
.4 e4
--he.. 4.,...e....
rg.......
..3..
A...,..
&.A..
... - al J _ g.
2.......
A J s...... 2.
b...
.e A5.* *. 4 4 4 '. 4
- e..re
- 4 e J e ; ::
J.=t;s c.t;. : Tar *
.-s..-_.._.
i
.... ee.... s. e......... e.... &.t....
.J..$
..ea.-
...e...
..e
- 4. S es 4
..e
.eSe. a.9 4 6...
...*e...
... ---*- e se.. e.a.
. v.*......
.g*=?.
g
..,.s e.s...
4....
3 f
- g. g.
.t. a _... _.. _ _.
... e.. S t s..... {.c...... s.... e a... A....
..a
- . v. r. s... ' s._.......ica.
4
..e.e...
- 4..ss.es.... _,
u.
..e. e e... a. e. a
.a,.. a s.... e :4. e
- 1..., -..
6 ve :::s
- Je :s le '4'.se, se are 2:.: a,,csi::.:: a: :. :.s 1
~.
.e..
4:e s;e..a. e:.>
e a.
4........s...e.4-A::4:14: ts :::.s
.4 ::a-2.= are :.e s;e:: ': H A1 s:2:ezer -- - -
has's !:: :.;: c:-::.s :: :.ta: ::e-r are f a'.sa.
A;s: 4::4 - ~ -
_ m
,.....e....
- 4. g
.o,...
6 v. v...... a. 3.... e...e
._m m
.e.-...
..e...eaes c.a a
.a.s. Ic..e
- ... 4....... s e.
- e.:e=s :f -:::.::'.:4::e 54 sed :: :. e.na s:.;a:.:. !:.:.1 -
-- =
4.s.............a....... 3....
...e5 4
a a.
..e.....s.e.
m_
r.s....
tS
...e
.. A..a a..
42 en: $ es,............. a. e... -
- f
- n 3, a;;e.::.x 1.
- f.
- a 'e:e:: :34 :.a: a..
Q e4::ers :::4::: :e.a: era'. 'aba s:a:e:4::s
-e ass. e :
s-
- e: te ::sa:ed 54;4:a:e.y. a:: re:: vet, as au:;' es :f ---
...e.
4 M*
4 wvtv /v-
_ _. -. - ~... _... - _.._. _._..... _
.m.......,.
34..*.
..4
.y.. 2,
.7 7
- at 4.
45
.1..e 4.
4....... 1.e 4 3.. 4.
.a
. t.... 4. A. 4
.4g.a.
. t..
t' Aa
..&. 4.44 4.
1....
4.A.a42.. 4 4 4...
4 l
..,....s.
s.$.
.t.a.S.
45 3
... 45.......
2
.t 4
3 5.. e s.. 4... -
i
. r..
l
.o. A.. S.. <... 3 75.. 4...... =,... 4 4...... { 40.s.. t.4. A... 4 l
r.
r...r......
.am l
'A.
~== =' p-.. ;; 4w a
.a:ts t.e 4-
-...t J
.A4...5 II.O. Ia.&4 h a
- t:4.* 3
. 1.e......t 1
4 1 4
.45...&.... Ad....
t,
..g r...
3..A
..t..$.
)
....f....l.
..?
M f
f 9
M*
I i
i 5
T l
1-
- w--e -se-=we wwer-emw w v ew&www e n--.e
-eewvs'vv'"+e.Twd'.w-.1r N-*T.'v'-
t
\\
l I
\\
t 1
I l
Mid:a.d 75.u 5: ate:e :s 1.
3:i:4:e.:
1 Se::i::.".3...
.3, 7:11, sta:es:
".C fil; and ha:if 11 vare pla:ed a...........a.. e c,. :. a
.......3
.a... e s.:
.v a......,a.<......e a.
...a s.u.,
.z
.y....
a.
.......a......
..,..a
...e n....,..
,s,.
_3..
.... e
.... e x.- s.....n...
.e..
.J G....
a.s.2..
gr.
.M.v.....t.t *. ; -
I
- 5......... t s g... s. e.A. '* /
v.
\\
l
(".* ) ?.... e 4 s. 4 e.... S e e. a. e.=..r.. a s
3
(.i. e.e.w.........a s.. a 4.e e... g e.. r.:..a.a. s
....,.....s,s
, a 4...e a
2 e:a...,.,.e s...a......s<,-
Se::::: 2.5...;*.1, 3eartag "a a:i:y, s:a:es: " Table
.5.' c:vs
.., e...,.. g..,,,,,,n e a...
.s.....s s
..e... s.a.<. a.a
...s.,...
.,..s oy.a.<..ca.u gs,. e.a. a4.a. e.eva...:, a a 2
.-.ae..re:
,.... a.... g 2,3. a.,.,,.<.;4 p., a. s....... s. ~
.c r....
Table ;.3-14 S.=:ary of Cc.4:: 5:: esses 4:1 ;: 2:e 3esri:s C4~,a:1.v. '. s. *..a =. ~< c '.a..'.~ ~. s.=.- ~..~ ~. ~..'...- S e.' s:.'.- Ca *. g.~.~.*
a.~.'
.. S
......es.....a,.s..a.
-.a f a....s.e.., ov g.
a..
.2.......<.
.. a.s Diesel e: era:c:
S:::alled ::::a::ed 3.u.4. a.. g
. s.es..ie.,.,.
- v..., a. a.
s S:s::ue:io: 3:aving C-J.I. Class
- fi*l :a cria*. areas, spe:aftes
- he fau:da:1:: :a:erial f:: Class s:::::::es :s he :::e ; ca:erial
.which is ide::1f:ed i: TS.G !sh; 4 2.5-10, G:ada:i: !.anges f:: Til;
- a:arial, as R.a:d:: Till a:d is des::thed as "A:y a:e:14.* f:es of
.s,
...a.. c. c... e. > e.e.e >.us.a. e. a =....as 4 ce..a..e.
a tha: =a:erials ::he :ha: " clay" c: "c::::s!*.ed ::-;a::ed ::hesive fi'.1" ve:s used !c: supper: of s::.c:. es.
s A::a :.:a : ;
B
m
.- u-am imw.m-e.
--m
- s....
-..a.. -.... ta:e:e::s - s a.u a 2.
5:2:e:e.:
M.......~
4...
..... a..,
.3 5:.ay : 4:3 ;:44s. s:2 es.-
". e...*.-.-
5
- 4gs su;er=pesed.:y ::e str.::;;es :: c: ns: :hed s: C :: ::::a::sf
-- are siva.7 c ::e s:C ;:ess. e ;;,2, 7 g;.
- ,3.,,...
T gure 2.5-4*
I:i' ?:tss.re Ciag: 2.a:eg:; ;
4.. - 5..,...;.,3,
s :ws
_se su;er=:: sed ;;a: c e.,3 7 g.:.,
- ,3,;,..e a- -
,4 hti he. 0137 '.: C ; s. ;e sq. 3.
2 "i-t g
.- sas as:er:ai:ed :t :.; a ey,.. :
gg, 3,;;.
t.... -. a.. a,. _ s j
'.. '},'}erv:,et. 3, : e inhv gga* u : pegg :.
.,. 3,. g...,.
.l 4,.... ma: vas use:.
4.
_.:a a:e.:
i w
g r
S e....
- n....,.....:, a::. P4:a:e:e:3, 3:,:,,:
-. e s.....,
e
..ess..,,.,:7 pa:2:4:ers. sed a the se:Ce:e-: -4: a:::: are
- ese
- ed ::ge: :..:h s:i; ;;;f Ce 1: *aEe. 5.' 6."
-y
~'fe2.5-16,IA.,-s;a:s ae::.ge4;;:
3::: y,,g,,.,g 7,,.,,,,,,,g ce:: a-g ga4.:
33,;7,g,,
,;,=, g.,
1 t
- e:a;e Ilevati::
C..
'~'
{deali:ed
- erval
- h :ksess
,ner
- 1. ~ e
's.,
.a..
A Till (C) 634-609
.'S
..-a s.-
3 Till (C) 6C9-6:3 6
.s-3 y*.I. :
.,04 3::=fva:e:.able is :ake: 4: e;e a:ie: C*.
8
.,.. a aes vere as-i a:ei *::= the :athe:a:ical re'a::::sup 3e:ve _,
..u_g s.~du..a a:d.::;:essi:: a:4 :e:cuni 1 :,3es,:3
,y,;,
,2 vi:1 :hese :::2:.:ed !::: c::s:1.da:i:n tests. Y:=g 's *-d
- s IV' was es:1:a ad f :. cpiri:4 :a;a:icts: p v.:h shear s: e:g-5.
Iff N
p l
.,y
- =.
.;.y +-
sg'
. L ' c c L.; = a
,,y.
L :.'>
Lw..-L..
I
.n.
(
I
- d;a-- 75A15
- a:ezes:
3-
.r a.. s a..
I M was as:ertai:ed :h :.;h a reviev :f :he s:a:e en: :ah dati::s
....w...e %..ese.
e.e.a..
3.
.s.. 4:d 4.
...e.v.'e.
.'. -'..s *-.-
-^
vidual v:: ;erf:::ed ::ess :al:C a:is:s :ha a: ::dex :f ::: press-i ihC::y f C.;-* ::: 3.;*2 vas used is: :..e eleea::c: in:e:Ja; 6. ha..
s.
E.
f*2*e:f**
ae.s.....
e.........s. A a s.s, s.a.es..
..w... s e... e.... c..,..
s
.a.4..s. a...a.*
. f, *. se..*...e:e..
.....s o.e es.a *.5*.e2
.a.J c..
e...
4... a. se.e.e. s......e
..a....s as s.._..
.4...e
...t..:.
.. =. a C..u.. s.... s s %..* e. a e-d e. e.. e... e '.4. s. s............e f.
7.......
e s...A. e.4...a.* se..*e e..s a. ca
- 4...
..e
.. ;w..s..e.e
.....e.4 es ; e.....e.;
%.,.. a.a <......t*.. c...e
- a...
-.e.a se..'e e...a..es s
^
- had :g : ass A :: the :a*:Cated ult :ata se:Ce:e : ta k es cf hadi:g.ase 3.
Oase vahes are ; ese::et.1: T' gur e !. !.3. "
Se::t:: 3.S.:.1.2 ::ese; erera:s: 341h: 3. s a:es:
"Se vC's are s.;;s :ed b.v ::.:isue:4 'ec:1:3s vi: bases a: elevati::
5:!'-0".
E4:5 diesel genera::: res:s :. a s'-s" :hi:i rei:for:ed 4
cc: crete peces:C veich is ::: s::u::2:Cly ::::e-:st :s the b w... a.< 3.a u..> a.a....
..,....,,.ses c.s..a.s..a.a..... s a..s..
r.
2... e
- was ascertai:ed th:: ugh a review of :-e se:Ce:e:: :a h ::a:tets fc: the Oiesel. enerat:: 14ilding and 4: is:e:vir.: vi:t :he inda-vi:;al who ;erf:::ed ::ese calcCa:ic:.s :ha: the da:a : Tigu:e 2.!--3 regardi:3 :ta ::esel Genera::: 3uddi:3 are based c:
ca...
....s pe.s e.a c.,.he e
..e...s ass..,....
..a..s.e a..
n esel Oeserat:: 3.Cding was ec::: 2::ed c: a a: f munda ::::.
3.
Sca:e e::
=* Se:: ion 3.3.5.5, 5::ue:gra; A::e;:4:ce :::e:*.a. s:a:es: "se:Ce-
- ::s of shall:v s;:ead f:o:1:ss fou:ded := c::;a::ed fC is are estica:ed is be a: the stier sf.i 1::h :: les s.
S ese se:C o-
=e::s are esse:: 4 y e.as::: a:3 cc:2: as ::e.: ads a:e a;;., ed..
b l
l l
r I
.s.
.".icla.' ?!al 3:a:e es: l l
i
,i f.a a. e_
l
- o. Was as.e a.s.s s..
i 4.* --- - 4. a=' I.....u--*aA a. a...... A..
vro:e : s se:n:: :f : e ?!AR tha: tha at:ve s:a:e:e :.as :A e:
.a....e
,a:es a.4.......e.e.... s.s.4..e.a s., a... :.. e ;.;n.?..
He ass.:ed ::e s: ate:t.:.as vah: f or i::' s ::.: :he TI.G. He said there.as :c ::her basis to su;;::: -he s:a:a:ent.
..n...
.s.esa..s..e...e:s e e..as s... s e...t..- s:a:e
...s
.. a u
s.
3 3.gg g...
3..
g..
4 3.
e..
..g gg.....*.
.....g....g a..' c.-..- -.. ~ s. '... e.- ' es e.'. e:e a..~. '.-...'.-. S A..~..as.a e eL'_-
~
l i a:ed.4:: :he 75aK :: Rerisi:: *.3.**)
I l
i.
1 I
i 1
l a
., h 5
4 9
l l
l l
l l
I i
i i
I I
l
A::e-dix A
......,...,\\..
..s R.su:ers.cwe:
.::sa:,.:.......-;.:
2 :;a:y
- .e: N:. 10-3 2,
lased :: :ha res '. s :f a: 71* i:ves: iga:::: :::du::ti ::
. : :he:..
.2,
,.3,
- 9...:. at: an ary 4.-...
e
..r.:. ::
ap; ears.ha: :e::at: of y.: a::ivities vere :: :::.i.::a: :: fall
- Gian:e wi:h ::10 re ; ire:ents as ::si tehv. ~ hts e.:ess 4:e
- .fra::1::s.
1 ;yR 50 A;; tad:.x 3.
- 1:e-10: ;** : equi:es, = ;4::. :..a:
=easures shall be es:a':'.isied a:d exe:::ed :s ass;;e tha: regula-
- 7 requirace::s 4:d :he desig: basis as specif ed in :he li:e:se a;;;icatis: for s::ue:ures a a ::::e: y ::atsla:ad is:: s;e:ifi-l ca:ic:s dravi:gs, pr::edures a:41:s::ve:i :s..Cs, i: provi:es
- ha seasures sha'd be es:ah'.ished f:: :he den::f t:a::.:: and c:a:::1 =f desig 12:e: faces a:d f:: ::::i:: ares a::.; ;artici-pa:isg design c ga:iza:i:ss.
-- OS opical Repor: C?;.1-A ;Chay 54. 3. S'::::: 3.4 states, ::
part, "the assigted lead desige g:: ; :: :rga:1:a: :: a.e., :he 3535 supplier A&E, supplie; or C?C:) assare tha: desig:s uk
=aterials are sui:able a:d tha: : hey :::;;7 vi:.. f esig: ::::e:14 a:d regala:::7 :e:.tre e::s."
A::achte:: 2 M
6 W
+
e'g+,
a
!? a :s c::::::ed :: X.Il ::.3.1 U ;;. Se::.:...", vr. :.. s:a:es, 4
t in part, 'ressures s-a'; he es:a:hshed a-d i::.:e:: d :: ass.re tha:
- he a;ph:ab;e spe:af;ed des:g. requi eze::s, s.:.. as a des:;: basis, iegv.;at::7 re;. :e::::s... are ::::e::;y ::a:s.a:ad :::: s;e::fi-c a., c.s..a.a..... s,.,... e.a.. e s,
- w..,.s........s..
... 5 1
S :::a:/ :s the ai:ve, :eas;:es :id n:: assa:e :.a: :es:;. : asis vere
..c.
.e.a
.a d.a..<.. s a _. a. s;e a.o..a....s.....s.........e...,..i<..ae.s.
- he ice.:: fica::st. A.d ::-:::1 s' des:g: :::e:fa:as. As a :ss ;:,
severa; it::: sis:en:ies were.det: fied.. - e h:e se a;;;.:at ::
I a:d := c:ho desig: basis d::=e::s. I; e::.f.: ext:;.es are se:
.n... s. a...
a.
Uns::uc:iss haw.:g C.5 (Cass ! fil; =a:eria; areasi specifies :he f:;-da:::: =ateria; ':: C; ass s:r.::ures :o be See 2 a:e:ia., defi:ad as 4:7:4:erial free e' h.:as.
- ga:ic :: c:5.e: ieleterious =a:e:ia;.ith :: res::ie::::s c:
gradati:: while ?SAR Tab'.as 1.5-9 and 1.5-14.1:di:a:e :he f:unda:1: =4:eria; f:: su;;c : cf Class ; s:::::. es :: he
- n:: 1;ed c:_;4::ed ::hestre (:147) =a:e:ial.
us -
I i
9 i
4
-__..-_________--e-,,-,.,-r-
..---,,----#mm
,-.,.--,-w
_--,-,-_-me_
m
A: e: dix A l
- .suze
- s ?:ver C::ie: I':. !!-209
- pa:y
- .e: N:. i;-33 ~,
\\
l l
3asei :: :..a results af as FI; i:ves: iga: :: :::d ::ei ::
. :a:he:...;,,.'J, 9... :, a:: ancary 4. :...
.r.v.
1:
.e ap; ears tha: :er:at: of yc.: a::ivi:1es were ::: ::.d.::ai :: fall
- ias
- e vi:h **1C re;; ire:en:s as ::: 1 hel.v.
7..6ae ::e:s a:e d
i
..e.a
.,..s.
1; 071 f, A;;s d x 3, ~:1: erie: *;* equ::es, :: ;4::, :..a :
=easures shall 14 es:ah;isted a d exe:::af :s ass :e :ha: regula-
- 7 requi:ece::s a:d :he desig: basis as specified in :he li:e:se a;;*icati : for s::ue:::es a:e :strec:;y ::a:sla:ed i::: s;ecifi-catie:s, dravirgs, p ::edures a d 1:s::ue:i: 3.
Alss, i: ;;ovi:es
- ha: measures shall be as:ahlished f:: :he iden::fi:a:::: and c::::a1 :f desig: 12:e:f aces a:d f : ::::i :a:es 4::.; ;artici-pa:1:g design cega:1:4: ions.
C?: "sp;eal Repor: C? A pol;;y No. 3, 5 9::::: 3.4 s:stes, i:
part, "the assigned
- ead desig: grou; :: ::;a:1:a:1::
- .e., :he 5533 supplier, A&E, supplier or C?C ) ass::e tha: desig:s and
=a:erials are sui:able and tha: : hey :::;;y vi:- desig: ::::eria a:d regl.a:ory :e:: ire::::s.
A::ach e:: 2
_. _ - - - - ~.. _ _ -.
- e 1
ilI 4;; e" A *.I A
-I-e ;.5,.*.s._..e a.*.*.,
4
...,,3.e
..a.
2.s3
....e.=..e...3 3
- s..
..a.a.es se..* Ce..
.a..e. gse* wa..s.....
..*2..e s.8 i
i I
C
..e..a...e..a
- * *. <
- e...e.. e..... J. 2...,e a.......a.
n T,
a
.e.,.a..e 4..A...a..a.es a.t..* Ce..s..
s.a**... S..ea.4 f.
.s......s
.s....e2..
....a.e.a s.. *
- k.e
...e
..e......... '.
......g
..... r.
= e.=., t s e..s e e :4... s. 4 *......... s s s.......t
.a
.ess.
.r s a.*.*
5..ca.4.s.....
..........a
..3
. e.ae s... s e.. a...t e...a.
a....s.s.. s.e
.2 4
.ese. e..e 3...
.e.
.n ae..a. e.a.... e. s...a h e. 4...
.44
.e.s. 3 e.2
.....e ass.
..e
.a.
- . r 3.s.
.s _
.s..:a....s V.,*e
..est s..a
.a....J Va.e l
d e s..u e.,s a.2 2.s......ed as s..ea.a s.. o..s.s.. aa.s..a.s.
.g r.
(
i d.
Se se :;eze-: ca'.:da:1::s h: :.= hese; Oe:e:a :: 1.i;A'.3
- o. a.,,
e,.a._..,3,.y 4.s-w s.e-y < e.s.e.n.,.,....,...e
- 0. 5.7. sh ws a 1:a' i.: ens;:y 's'.;~," ?!.7, as a::.a';7 c
.s. ac.e.2 e.
Se se::;eme:: cal:Ca:i::s h : :he d:esel ge era::: hi;:i:g ue.e w,.a
. a.. g s...,.......,... y...
s..e..a.a be:veen eleva:io:s 6;3 a:d o3. s' 3.0;;. "hase se::*.e.e::
.-----,.-e.---.+-=----
l_ _ _
l dy e".d*.a $
i
's.
Se 75A1 :s :::e:.a;;y i:.::::1s:4:: : : a: 73 J T.i;; e *.3 4 3
- .a.a.es se...... ce...... e.. e s e. m. e... :.......a.... s.e
..e
..a...t a.*.
e.t
.e.
.:e..e..........a..r s........a.
4 M
a
.e..a..e
.e..a3 44 a.es a.t..* Ce..s.. s.a*... s.,.ea.a r.
.s......s
.s....e.
....e.a s.. * *.. k.e
...e
..e..:....-"
a
......g
..ra..
.-.ess.
. e.a.e,s4.
ee dra..
3.e.=
- s s s....... e... a
..........s s a.
....ca.4.a.....
a..
.n.
i l
i
=. e.aes...
se..'t e...a.
a....s.s...e.a s.e s e.* e.t. 4 a...
.g.
a..
...a.e2
..a.e. s...a.e
.a. s.4 4.e.a..s e.s.....a ass...,.e.
of =if::: =a: f:..ca:::.s v.Ce : ese *:u:da:.:.s were i
1 1
g e s..,e.s a.a
...s......,g a s s.,.e a.a a........s.
2a..:.s.
I d.
?.e sa:Ce:en: :al: dati::s f:: t e : ese; Oce:a::: 5.iir.ng i:di:a:e a ; cad :tersi y :f 100 ?ST v.ile :he.%2, Fir. e 0.5 7, s'. vs a ;:ad in: ens::y a!.;- ?!?, as a::.a;;7 c.-..s.~a c ~. a.'.
e.
S e se::le=e:: ca;: da:1::s #:: :he d.ese; ge: era::- Wil:i:g ue.e base.'.-. 4:...^ ex..'.-.-,. e s s *..'..'.v.
e
.a... "
between eleva:ists 6;J a:d 43. of.;;;. 2.ese se::;e:en:
4
I 1
.,..,,ye.,,w._...;g....
...c..,..
....:.s..
e..
. -. e.. r..
.A.
.....a..b.ts S.
ea.eK a C...esS............:..e e.,
.y.
i 34**
a 3A.t e.3..
s.e.. *.
.s.
..., t\\.e.a.t.
t,
..a 3.t.a. i.. a.e.4.*.*.e.gA4.. L
.e **..g L
. 3 a:.
.e.a....S 4.e.a.s.......e.a a
...g pe...e$
s
.*...e4..e
- 4..-.s...e. s..*
..r r..
...~
- b..... s.s. e.... e.4
..e
...a 4.a
... 4
.e,.......
.s 2s....,
a..a.ag.a..... a,;
S.e.a.s4
..... a.e
.s.
......,. s.. e2
..&.=
- . s.... e..f y
r...
. 4We.a
...a.e.a :4. e. &.
.es........
.s b... A a.s.e
..e.
..r
.r.
., e
- s. J.s.
.I
.x. n. A &.J.e.
3.. s..J.t_
..4
.s.ds...'ess s.4.=
-5 4. a
- e.
W......a.
.=r
.e.=*.f*g..Vg =ag.,3 *4 '/
a
. g *... 4 =.. g. 3
- m..=.. a...
g *..,..... 3 a...
.: '.'e7er, qe d*e. spac:se.:at::: C..
See::::
.2.e.. rew :ed C..tJ.s.'eSs s s*
3 '3 e..a.e.a
.A
- tS s. 4. : a *
.r a
e.4.. ve e.s.s.y.
=..=.= n.. 5 4.,.e a.z 2
~
~
....a..s...eq....es, a
.,a
.,..a. a. v.,s.es r
A.a.se C... g,... i..e..f s A.. as f.es.as.e.a Aa. L.
...s.t.2 s
a....a.....n..e I
w.
- b..s.
.a... e.. e a.s.......s. p... e.... es 4.a... g s.
a a..
p 0 a *:pt:41 Ke;or-G -;-A Po" icy %s. 5, Ie::.:: ;." s:aies, i:
pa..,..a.
... s.
..... S *3.
..g a.
,.e e._... a..s.... es a.a.ae....g.4a.
, a e... <
......, e.a. a...a......
.i, s <..,... s. ra. a -
s..,.
- a...., e.a....s,.. as e. e..e
....e4...e..
..a..
s... as
.......a e.,
__.-,_.wa,.,,..-we-w-ww e-'-
.e
' " * * * " ~ " * ~ ' ' ' " ' ' '
g -.
i si r
q 0
r-
~
.W&
w 3, M.-
,+.-
.s
..V..
,s.
3=
h 4;
- 4.".
- LX A
=
.n a%-
1 i
- ' N
.a. s...a......g,
..s.....e 4.. s. 4 *.. a....
., '.' f-
.......sp4..
.es.......
s.v.. f &w.
...x,
..s...a.
....d
. 4s, s4.,.t..a.e.s 99 V.Ai a, c.u #.
a
... are.
..e.
4.2 v
+4 7
e.-
s
.s.esg.a...,. 3
....t..a 39
- i. =
s e. a.2..g. s.*/a a a
...a.......e a.e.,.g.e g,,_g.u.
3
(
n, w:,:
1 b:. f h.,
2
.e.e..a.
2.t's e.e.g a
....a.. as.....e...ts
..a e.te. sa.. 2...n. a... e.
u s
..r....
....)
p.;, c ;
!.'.,sf.
- 9 9
.,5 c
4....,. s.*. e.a.
c.,
~ a.
_n t
.... -..', j,5
..y_
g~
- 7.. p $g' k '.gh.,.
re_
_r i
t
..s
... 2.J is.;....:.
.d....
...... s.a.2s.
W TP.A F
.a..,..a....a.. e s 4.m.at.....
. a..
s.4.... e
..t s.... e2.. a... 4..d.a s..
y g..
....g 3
.g e.
=
p$'
5 4 s.... 4.. s..,... t.a... t s.. a. a.. :.. s,
s.
.s
.,e 4.....,.
4 4.... e
..... 3 4
k:'
<.. l C.....s a.e5 a.a 5..a e 4.... 4s e.2
.w a....... t.... s.
- .. ye.+. '
.....a...
...ese
,3 2
E
,.f v
..,....<.:,,.,..e,.a...n,
. a a..<
w 4p s.
w
.x V
i-m
_[.
a.
0:st:try :: :le aheve, i:s:r.:::o:s p::vided :: fie;t.
.% f c a s..u.-. '.-.*:. s.^. s. '.-. ' g
- e a....- e. e.'.-. '.. _ e *..a. e. *.a.*
y t,
6' p",k';e:n ;.
- s.,
g <.g... ad.a.es s..e.a.<.s.ee.a.g..a.a..a.....,...,e es s...c..
u.go.h o
u m
3,
. o, m.
vould resd: :.: d.'#ere::ial se :le:e:: :f :he 'iese'. "e: era:::
Y* hI.7
-[ $s.w-x 3.u g. a... g.
p-r m
n
,e 5.
Aisc, cc:::ary :: :he above, car:ai: a :iv::es were ac: a:::e J
.'a 9
,... :y j,(.
. 4 plished a::::1'ng to 1:s::u::ia: a:d ;;::thres,1: ::4:.
. sh A e
=
43,; vg
(.)
".he s.
.,a
....e.<a se.a.e. s...a. e.. a. vas....
s...
t U
.o....
. s (,.ec..e
...s.a.ed........es.).a._.e..s.4 a
s.
c......
r W
"w r
i J
4;;4:nx A 3-
~
.a.. s 4.s.a*..*4 4
5p4.........es...... g
...a......$
..s.....e a
... a.e.c
..e. 4.a..
..s.
....e
..es, sa......a....s r.....
... :hese d::. e::s ;;: vide ;.a'i:a:ive a.i qua n::.ve a::eptan:e
.,.e..a.s.
4 e.e_....g
._..,..a.. as....<..es.4re.se. sa..s.e s
6 a...
a::: ; hshed.
- ? ~
- :s ::=:.::td :: nJI: ::.i. :
3*;.. Ie::::: i v.:. s:a:es. :
.,....a..a.es a..e.....
a..... s 4...e..es...
a a
e.
.. a....e.e.a s.
bst:u::i::s, ;:::edu:ts, :. drav2;s, :f a ::;e a;;;;;:.2:e :: :he c.::.:s:4..:es a:t s..a'.
he a::::;;: s. ed ::. a:::::4..:e v.:h these
- s:::::i::s, ;::ceduras :: d r aw.: g s.
a.
0:stra.y :: :ha above, i:s::uences ;;:vided := field c::s::ue:1:: for subs:1:u:23 lea: :::::e:e f:: 0::e : =2:e:ia; g g...,e.a.,,,
.. a.>.<.s.se. a. g..a. >,.....,..., e _.. e s v.. c.
s v:uld :esal: :.: h!fere::ia; se::le:e:: :f :he :tese; ;4 era:::
d I
3uildi:3
. ir.-
..C,
'4
.a b.
Also, :c:::ary :: the a': ve, certad ac:iv :es were :.c: a::::.
- j[
u,-
g ;.g
- 11shed a
- ::::ing to 1:s::.::ia: a:d ;;::ehres.
- .a::
- .5bND
- M;;pa
' 1% -
- ..... x G) "he c: ;ac:1:n en:eria esed f:: f'.; =a:ena; vas ;;,*:0 4,,:
- d, J s..-s
\\
m.
f:-lis (!ach:e; :::1fted ; ::::: :es:) :a::e: :ha: a j
aw ry.. Y[h h
.e....
k.
go _. '
4' t
c=;a :.ve a:ergy :f 56,~;0 f:-lis as s;e:.fied in 3e:h:ei 5;e..z..a....
............., Se.<o.
s!) S:ils a::ivi:es ve:e c: ac:::7.'ished.:de: :he ::::1: ::s s ;ervis : :! a qualified scils e:;1:eer v:: vs.4 pert:= =-;;a a de:s.:7 :es:s : : e :::;a::ed fill ::
ve::fy :.a: al' =a:eria'.s a a :'a:ed a-d : :;4-:ed is a.,..a
.e.... s:e., 4...............e.......
2
..s.s
......e.
.s...
u-by 3e-h:e; 5;e:ift:a:ie: 0 5;; as ve'. as ?5.G. A=e.d-
- ?9
, $s-
- c: 3 Ja:es a:t P.:::e Fe;:::. ; age ;O.
Y 3.
- 0 07110, A;;enda 3.
- .:eri:: I requires, i: Par:. :ha a ;;;;;a:
fe i=spe ::.:: ef 4 :ivi:es af fe::i:g qua'.i:7 shall be es:ailished a:d exe:::ed to ver:.fy :::f st:ance vi:h the 4::::4::ed us:::::i::. ;:sce-dures a:4 dravi:gs is: a::::p*.ishi:s the a::Wi v.
!?.o :pical Re;c:: ;?;-;-A Policy M. ;;. Se::1:n ;.1, s:a:es, i=
pa::, tha: work a::iv :ies are a::::;;uhed ac:::d;..; :: 4;;;:ved p...e.2... es.. a s. a... s v.s.
..........a..e
.s;ec.a.. s2...,...s bey:.4 whi:: v::k does ::: ;;scoed anti; :he 1:s;e::::: is :::p* ate
~.
s: writtes :::se:: f: hy;assing :ha 1:spectis has see: re:eived f t:s :he.orgasi:a:Los au:h::::ed :: perf::= :he inspe::.::s.
MJ h, #=e F
'g
=
- ~
4 4G..y f%
+
'h,',.
j
~-
M.,;.,
A$
,<g
.[ i.' = *, i
O s
A.;e:: x A
- J. -
.3,.s..,....,A.:.c.
....,...,.. s a.ts,..
.,a..,
71.)
.. s..
.y
.A.,...:a s...s;e........ a...a...es a..s*....... s a..t.... : 4 he es:ablished t:d exe:a:ef by c fc: :;e ::gs:i:a:i:: per':::.:;
., 4c.s,....., e...s.... e.,...a :,....,
.s....,.,.a s. s. -..- *... s.
... e _. es, s. a
.a.
- s.. a.
.>s
_....e a......
...g
-::::a: :: :he a:: a, ;.ah:7 ::::::;
4::.:::::...:: :. e e...a. s.. s., e..... a........., a. e:...a : z...... s s. e..............e..:
s
- 975, :id ::: ;::..ie !:: ::s;e::.:n h:;d ;nt.:s :: v n!- that sei. w::k vas sansfa :::Cy ac:::;hshed a:::: ding :: :::2:e::ed
..s.....<..s.
'O C7130, A;;e. dix 3 *:i:erun.7! staires, i ;& :, tha: =tas;;es shal:. he es:abhshed := assare :ta: :sndi:1::s adverse :: q.4 h:y such as fa.hres, define:nes, dade::ive a:erta'. a:4 ::::::':=a::es are p:=p:1y ide::1f:.ed a:d c:: e::ed.
- :ase of si;..f.:a::
1 I
I
- di: ass adve se :s q;4h:r. =casures sha 1 assure :ha: ::::e: nve 1
ac:is: is :ake: :s 3:e hde re;e:.:1::.
l I
i 7.s 7:;ical Ze;::: ?".;.A ?:11:- No. ;i, Ie::i:=.; s:a:es,1:
- 4rt, "
- or se:ive a::1c: is ::a: 6::u n take :s ::nec: a:4 ;;echte s
- ecur ::e :! s ;:ihta:: ::: :.:ims adverse :: :he q ah:y of ne:s s: :; era:1:ss..arre: nva actio: in: hess a: ava ha: ion s' :he E
e A y
- 4
+,
% J, y..,
..v p;
C,:::.. t
.s n
.y y-g!
n.. f,..'p -
e.c
.u.
r;L 3..s.n
......4
.4.
.e.J.4
......s
.,a..e.
4.$..t....
4
..e 3., w
..s.
<..,,9
". ' '. ' i ',- Q
.~.e.a
.s
- 4...e 4....s.e*e66.
.. e. e..
......s a..e a_..
.... ~..
g.
w s,.
h,1.7,,5 N
- :et.c.e tha ;:ss :*;;.:/ :f :a:.::e.:e.**
.! i ',-;
Ac;',4 ;
- f Apg ;
. s s-
, +
- I.. - -
C :*:ar* :: *
- e 4 * :'.* e.
a as'. e5 ::* : * : es4. e *.*a: $* 14 *:: :*
- h n... t 4
.m., >.a e
g.
.w e, e,:
y. <.. g.'.
- a. 4.4.. t. s e.. 4.
.. e
- e...... *...... e. e.... e *..4e.e : e......
3 c.
-a.
' 9.SM
- 3..
A,.
4.-.., ?
T:: exa:r.e:
, e
., g. :.
W W..;1 a.
As :f 14.a
- !. *.Fi,
- ::s:.:e :::::: :: f 1. :4:e 4.
Mad ::: bea: es :.:h 4. e: ::: ale;.4:e :::.::.: ;;.en ::
....ece....'s s.e.....a...-.
a-.. s.e...
...e '.'.....
- a*.
l k
..e.s.ae..a. sas...,.e a
.... s..e
.......es.s as w
1
&.. 1 l
reg ired by spec ft:a:i:: C ** *, was id e::: f ted = *.41. 7
(
l J.- g.p.
, i. j-A:: ::.e:;.es: a.
... da:ed
.y
,.. #g., ity.
s n
.r.
.g
-r
_.,Ju o. a w,,u 74 4.-f-A, F
.p,
,a..%.)
b.
C:::ee:ive ac:::- regarding ::::::f:::z :e re.::s rela:ed to
~. u*.
p *. s e: fil; was.:s.f'i::e : : 1:ade;.a:e := ; :1.de re;e:1 9, yr p.n-g
- as ev:de :e: by re;ea:ed dev.a::.::s f:::: s;e::f t:a:i::
g;.
. e ?
y,
. \\;
- equire e :s.
T:: ex4=;;e..::::.f:- 2::e :e;:::s ::o. C?;
4-3.. :.
e,:.
....., a c. G.. 9
- y..e.
.t 1.,
9,..,.,:... %:-:.,.
- -6
,1
.3
.g.w r
_ fi. f y
- 4i: n :er:us exa:;;as f re;ea:e!. :::c::h:.4::ss i: :. e l
. u-sa:e a:eas :f ;;4:: fi*; :::s:r.:::::.
Q 7.;
" ] 7%y'-(;
- o w..~.,_
..w
. ai;.g yll 4
g -
"" k e,.
..w,4
-ww- - -
e
... u-n... ~.....,
..,;,. + :..,:.. : 3 ;,f e
. y.
. =......
.=
y..]
, n>
6.
3 g
4
- v. -- : __o~c _
9 fW,' Of 4- - W
- a Q;h!l' g
~*7"-%W *i 2 " ku756 c/ % t /
i'3 7 g[,I z
~
~,m. w _ w ; a _,.
j_
~ - J==: d~==ss.
2
,. :n_s_x, ij 3y y... - 1
{,,
k,b&.
r,~~..,.
Y 57
{
4 y
f$ $
QN f
~^
C
.+9 v +gs
.y s
_e.
- [
R g
- g og 6
)
.f Uy ps.,
s
, S :': 1
-4,
.g j:[ /es y'.
- e ft s.
f * ~
~ - -
$)
f
~
p
-b!~y, A rGtff./_6L c.
- f k.
j yk j
m
__.- w a, h a.--. n-. > _,aw if s.
g-9.
s-v 3-i-
- -~* d OE,Q,__.7A_ykw..<_
(g:
~
k_
1 j.
g;.
p.
a i
~
- -1 2
}%
J
.s
.. p. ~,,k, ;
~~
{
t 4 n...4 e,,
h
'_-f'*:J..
!I sf
}
- ,)f. *. f, ':*.[l}
- ~ ' ~ -
w e
l s..
l 41
~ K) !
b g
I
_g-I
, l3l'
l
~
A'cD j
i-........ '-ani
\\.,. c L :- A i
(.,
s.-r C -.
......u 17 S' jfA wii/y s u M% 9'
/%ttn w C.f & J y
. ? An f
.
- 4 g w '.i 4,}. c.rt.
1 v'd. y' l
9
+
/%. - eM~ p* k /mL*iA dd% e-L,,. w '.ht.,,
f..D G-p w.
L p l
... p s. 4 4 - Ap. cp p ~
n q.
- s.$ yE L,.J Z:, L*
-ML,s
(
f J k.-(. 94 cog'~,yn AJ
..c., a )> a p
-..-.. -.fm J+4 ln D G B'f,a. 3,L,M J s,.7.: '_i p
(
4 Bu' rn,.~.. M 4p '.J-n,f y, n y
O h 5 & ~ < <~y-4*4 3,u g b y..
f 0(whk n.&%tp~&L...
~
- hL\\ - - f M r.. % 7 y,La Lc A vfu, n.
J i
L-.--
m.
__=---- MM.&p..FA. 4 ;
p ie.s..
- y k s k.? 0 6 J A -. u w s.
b t
GN* Y #
- }' & 4 j'r.ef &. y s,
. h.6A-J t
- 47
=.-.. %:~ r-y %. m 4 4f.r 4. w. 4<AU M. !
1+~ % ).,,, h.
- g. h-------
w- - k-. p.
.r h : *. --- /" $
dixf:s is A* J.
.b t'-fgfJ_h.,&L.7,..: _'_ _. f g.
-7=
- w&- CL hs SM,& 4 &_.. _...:.
+-4e WM '-
P*
o' s
- p 3
k
w g
e
,r e
y ri i
..'JL.i
..dL
- s
_ m 2.k>lf4 }ks~,r
,,.n
% wa LLr
. n,.,
t.4 H 4 1
- - - - ~#% 4 A +-h P.y J4 m.s A. J:
i
.-.-..A % 4D~,p.c.,.4,t - A ci k.
/
s r
2 f,c..ty F
h P
'f '&~ ' ~
fh..
- t. e Y
~ ~ - -p,4 -
~~-,,.s"
\\
p I
Lwr )
(,,a;I
- - -.-.-- - -............ 9. t t.
V M
--. - M & p.% #1.. p M ~ -.nr &-v.
9
.4 % ~
4 $ ~ %. A,
-M JhM...,=Ra 5 &x b4,4 y s x iy.w-t
- ,. e, s p tL. ;2. ra c
(
r
- lf..-
%@..t hiu n?: _. _ c g. ma,. _ N(..
% L% =,. %'.CSRs cr &.tA m. r r
. ~l-G.w.
%. m or_ cp
.J, f,.
M.p.cz 9 $_ M /4./A p.
' A..+r7.kLA4ba.~ n w..M.=_
g 7..
e-pri,ccm +c rs.
y r
g
^ub.~h-%.pg: oc-s 2hs M h
.. L-.%.A op C A~t-a,a. 4_
y N '.
Q.:.L'
' M.& % r,1s. m._ %
== w --4.
t A s > ~# ~. +. w u. m....
f !....
~
~*
9 rkC
^
E '-
gi.2:s &
.u. & :.k +.
.s._
L
+'
c w.= m.?_
. r.. ; n; i W;.xy ; Tg. ~ ;.:.:
' J..;,;. ' y g ', ;;.i ;. ; g y
..; ;.._._, y ;;-
.y.,
+
_.... ~...
.,a
,...s
~.
c.:
b
~.,$$.I
~
n
.g b W m # v S V J 2 k J M, w Q,,.
' ~ W % 'h % r~5
/b.- M M A J b[/.4,.Jiy a./A A,4 l
.fr/[, N )*4 & Ob.--
cI
- k.,
p W /p., ef_ a NfJ 4 d's.,4r
[_
Rh l
.4 ~py p9.%. v~ a,..
y h M b~ t a s:.~.s n w.
W-L g.y..
- Q$h4
..-- -..-- --..i _ -
S*
' d.~ i m - 5 + A
,Zdt n L )
{
f'k.;
. 4. & _ q.,,L ~ t-+.yf M N t k. ?.... v ; u..
L A
..p'
.----.....-e-.N y M %.d)/*. s.cc.
i.
- ~/
a.
..g-a?
[
-A'~,.~. Yh.>~ &/ r=
u, -
I_I9_;]JLv pr9
. A-& Y M 4 D h # a -- A /,
- ~'~>-p h m..V C Z.-.hy,.s., fs.rll}.
i;-
L WV d*-Ja-pAhM_(Mr) wg_k (
h ;r
- AM
- --y 3 b.,_M.n & Z s
--- ---- Q, 22' & 4. Azur q _.Zr_ _q.
r* *
.=
- vbr./h.M.-. ~(q,._cae m.4, a, y.
i I.
G 5 ' E~~-W
~
s,..
- F y k... j.
M 6 A i 3 i f._. i J g u u m a y; w;6. m. W. p A -,
g _g~ ~ ~ ~
,L.a Au,- L.;.ce.-Lp-i.p, cr.
.n._.,J..M..
v.
.. =
_ f. *.
l t
et O
I I
6~
b s
w
... d AO
,s..
s p
l i
I h. r% N.l-J
- aL,.c! n-yyd
/y1 m-a s sen -
r.
y & Jh 4 A w J4 } & J-r ~.
.a..
j e
m..
..e t
.N s
"N l
e 6
w.
F
..M h
. ee, P
l g
I I
re b
a g
=,
L
)
ee. y a.
m..
.....m a
W
= -
[
F e-..
e 1
,. y w
,y
.w
~.....
p e
n t
E w
e.
b
~-
m e
_6
- h O
g h
b at p
4
. E" '
4
'. s e.
=
e 8
1
.m.
_. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. _.. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _