|
---|
Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20070E4671991-02-26026 February 1991 Comment Opposing Petition for Rulemaking PRM-73-9 Re Upgrading Design Basis Threat for Radiological Sabotage of Nuclear Reactors.Recommends That NRC Deny Petition to Increase Design Basis Threat for Security ML20207C1331986-12-18018 December 1986 Order Terminating CPPR-81 & CPPR-82,per Util 860711 Motion to Withdraw Applications for OLs ML20215E7301986-12-17017 December 1986 Memorandum & Order Authorizing Withdrawal of OL Application & Dismissing OL Proceeding,Per Applicant 860711 Motion. Served on 861218 ML20211L6181986-12-11011 December 1986 Response to Board 861203 Questions Re Util Request to Terminate OL Proceeding ML20211L6391986-12-11011 December 1986 Affidavit of Gb Staley Re Preparation of Answers to Board 861203 Questions on Termination of OL Proceeding. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20215B2071986-12-11011 December 1986 Responds to Questions Posed in ASLBP 861203 Memorandum & Order Re Conversion to gas-fired Facility.Imposition of Conditions on Withdrawal of OL Application Unnecessary. Certificate of Svc & Svc List Encl ML20214Q4431986-12-0303 December 1986 Memorandum & Order Granting Motion to Expedite Completion of Withdrawal Proceedings & Posing Questions to Parties.Served on 861204 ML20214G7941986-11-24024 November 1986 Motion to Expedite Completion of Withdrawal of Licensee OL Application & Terminate Pending OL & CP Mod Proceedings. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20214T7361986-09-26026 September 1986 Memorandum & Order Dismissing OM Proceeding as Moot & Deferring Action on Applicant Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application Pending NRC Preparation of Environ Assessment.Served on 860929 ML20212M7661986-08-25025 August 1986 Response to Util 860711 Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings.Board Should Hold Motion in Abeyance Pending NRC Review of Stabilization Plan.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20206M8171986-08-15015 August 1986 Response to ASLB 860716 Order Requesting Responses Re Termination of OM Proceeding.Termination of OL Proceeding & Withdrawal of OL Application Requested.Om Proceeding Should Be Considered Moot.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20212B0311986-08-0101 August 1986 Memorandum & Order Withdrawing Retention of Jurisdiction Over Radon Issue Presented in Facility CP Proceeding & Vacating ASLB Partial Initial Decision on Remedial Soils in Consolidated CP Mod & OL Proceeding.Served on 860801 ML20212B0521986-07-31031 July 1986 Order Extending Time Until 860815 for Util & Other Parties to Respond to Questions Posed by 860716 ASLB Order.Time Extended Until 860825 for NRC Response to ASLB Questions & Util Motion.Served on 860801 ML20203F8791986-07-28028 July 1986 Response Supporting Util 860711 Motion for Termination of Appeal Board Jurisdiction Over Proceeding.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20207H6871986-07-22022 July 1986 Motion for Extension Until 860815 to File Responses to Four Questions Re Util Motion to Dismiss OL & OM Proceedings. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20207E2851986-07-16016 July 1986 Order Presenting Questions in Response to Util 860711 Motion to Dismiss OL Proceeding & to Terminate Order of Mod Proceeding.Served on 860717 ML20202G0121986-07-11011 July 1986 Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings ML20202G1201986-07-11011 July 1986 Motion for Termination of Aslab Jurisdiction to Facilitate Termination of Cps,Withdrawal of OL Application & Dismissal of Consolidated OM-OL Proceeding ML20202G1621986-07-11011 July 1986 Notice of Change of Address for Washington Ofc of Isham, Lincoln & Beale,Attys for Util.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20202G0491986-07-10010 July 1986 Affidavit of JW Cook Re Conversion of Plant Into combined- cycle,gas-fired Power Plant.Plant Never Operable as Nuclear facility.Nuclear-related Equipment Will Be Sold ML20202G0281986-07-0808 July 1986 Affidavit of Ta Mcnish Re True & Correct Extracts of 860408 & 0618 Minutes of Meetings.Resolutions Recited Therein in Full Force & Effect ML20198J4651986-05-27027 May 1986 Notice of ASLB Reconstitution.C Bechhoefer,Chairman & J Harbour & Ga Linenberger,Members.Served on 860529 ML20198J3861986-05-27027 May 1986 Notice of ASLB Reconstitution.C Bechoefer,Chairman & J Harbour & Ga Linenberger,Members.Served on 860529 ML20137E0041985-11-21021 November 1985 Notice of Appearance in Proceeding ML20137D9651985-11-21021 November 1985 Notice of Withdrawal of Appearance in Proceeding.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20133F6421985-10-0909 October 1985 Notice of Withdrawal of Appearance in Proceeding.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20134N3771985-08-30030 August 1985 Notice of Withdrawal of Appearance in Proceeding.Certificate of Svc Encl DD-84-17, Order Affirming 840724 Director'S Decision DD-84-17 Denying Bp Garde 10CFR2.206 Petition for Action Against Util Re Plant Const.Const Abandoned on 840910.No Further Enforcement Action Required.Served on 8506241985-06-24024 June 1985 Order Affirming 840724 Director'S Decision DD-84-17 Denying Bp Garde 10CFR2.206 Petition for Action Against Util Re Plant Const.Const Abandoned on 840910.No Further Enforcement Action Required.Served on 850624 ML20127N7591985-06-20020 June 1985 Transcript of Commission 850620 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote in Washington,Dc Concerning Denial of 2.206 Petition for Midland plant,SECY-85-60 Concerning Pressurized Thermal Shock Rule & Shoreham Order.Pp 1-4 ML20133D9481985-05-13013 May 1985 Response to Aslab 850423 Order.Aslab Should Cancel OL Application & CPs Because Compliance W/Nrc Basic Requirements Not Met ML20116G5181985-04-29029 April 1985 Response to Memorandum of City & County of Midland,Mi Re ASLB 850405 & 0313 Orders on CP Mod Proceedings.Bechtel Should Not Be Granted Admission to Proceedings ML20115J4351985-04-19019 April 1985 Motion for Leave to Participate as Amicus Curiae,Per Aslab 850313 & 0405 Memoranda & Orders Requesting Response to Questions Re Proceeding ML20115J4751985-04-19019 April 1985 Memorandum in Response to Aslab 850405 Order Re Dismissal of OL Application.Application Neither Abandoned Nor Delayed in Dilutory Manner.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20115J5421985-04-19019 April 1985 City & County of Midland,State of Mi Motion for Leave to Participate as Amicus Curiae in Aslab Request for Responses to Questions Presented in 850313 & 0405 Memoranda Orders. Proof of Svc Encl ML20116G5321985-04-19019 April 1985 Motion to Participate as Amicus Curiae in Resolution of Issue to Involuntary Dismissal of License Application,Per Aslab 850405 Memorandum & Order.Granted for Aslab on 850422. Served on 850429 ML20115J5551985-04-19019 April 1985 City & County of Midland,State of Mi Response to Aslab 850313 Order to File Memoranda Re Whether Aslab Should Vacate ASLB Decision Re Certain Mods to CP Due to Mootness. Proof of Svc Encl ML20115J5501985-04-19019 April 1985 Response Opposing Aslab 850405 Memorandum & Order Re Dismissal of OL Applications.Urges Board to Permit OL Applications to Continue in Suspension Until Applicant Affirmatively Resolves Disposition ML20115J5461985-04-19019 April 1985 Motion to Participate Amici Curiae in Resolution of Issue of Involuntary Dismissal of License Application as Identified in Aslab 850405 Memorandum & Order ML20112J5281985-04-0101 April 1985 Memorandum in Response to Aslab 850313 Order LBP-85-2. Decision Should Not Be Vacated.Ol Should Be Dismissed.Based on Listed Changes,New OL Review Required ML20112J6301985-04-0101 April 1985 Memorandum Requesting Aslab Not Take Any Action to Vacate LBP-85-2 or Dismiss OL Applications,Per 850313 Order,Based on Current Intent to Hold CPs & Attempt to Sell Plant. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20112H0981985-03-27027 March 1985 Response to Aslab 840313 Order Re Whether ASLB Decision to Review Issues in Soils Hearing Appropriate Use of Public Resources.Concurs W/Decision to Remand OL W/Instructions to Dismiss OL Application for Failure to Pursue Soils Issue ML20106F6531985-02-0808 February 1985 Response Opposing Intervenor B Stamiris 841224 Motion for Evidentiary Hearings Re Litigation Between Applicant & Dow Chemical Co.Supporting Documentation & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20106D6631985-02-0808 February 1985 Response Opposing B Stamiris 841224 Pleading Requesting Evidentiary Hearing on Matter Raised in applicant-Dow Chemical Trial & Referral of Certain Matters to Ofc of Investigations.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20101S9421985-02-0101 February 1985 Motion for Extension Until 850306 to File Notice of Appeal of ASLB 850123 Partial Initial Decision.Granted by Aslab on 850201 ML20101S9111985-02-0101 February 1985 Motion for Extension of Time within Which to File Notice of Appeal of ASLB 850123 Partial Initial Decision.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20101F3191984-12-24024 December 1984 Request for Evidentiary Hearings on Matter Raised in CPC-Dow Trial & Referral of Certain Matters to Ofc of Investigations.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20107K8011984-11-0101 November 1984 Affidavit of Jd Selby Re Plans Concerning Facilities.Const Will Be Resumed Only If Proposed by Appropriate Governmental Agencies & Officials & If Funds from Some Other Source Become Available.Related Correspondence ML20106F5241984-10-24024 October 1984 Motion to Request ASLB to Cancel Const License & Application for OL ML20092J0361984-06-22022 June 1984 Reply to NRC Further Supplemental Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law Re QA ML20092J0241984-06-22022 June 1984 Reply to B Stamiris Second Supplemental Proposed Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law on QA & Mgt Attitude Issues. Certificate of Svc Encl 1991-02-26
[Table view] Category:TRANSCRIPTS
MONTHYEARML20127N7591985-06-20020 June 1985 Transcript of Commission 850620 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote in Washington,Dc Concerning Denial of 2.206 Petition for Midland plant,SECY-85-60 Concerning Pressurized Thermal Shock Rule & Shoreham Order.Pp 1-4 ML20082D9041983-11-21021 November 1983 Portions of Jl Donnell Deposition,Designated as Direct Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20090H3461983-10-15015 October 1983 Transcript of Jl Donnell 831015 Deposition in Las Vegas,Nv Re Alleged Violation of ASLB Order ML20076L6471983-07-11011 July 1983 Testimony of Ps Glass Re Cable & Conduit Installation for Underpinning Instrumentation of Auxiliary Bldg.Oversize Matrix Encl.Aperture Card Available in PDR ML20076L6361983-07-11011 July 1983 Testimony of R Black Re Events During Late Winter 1982 & Early Spring 1982 & Installation of Cable Related to Instrumentation for Underpinning Work on Auxiliary Bldg ML20073H3621983-04-13013 April 1983 Two Attachments to RA Wells Testimony,Inadvertently Omitted from Original Submittal.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20069J0621983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of RA Wells Re Recent Changes in Organization of QA Dept,Including Changes in Organizational Structure & Responsibility for & Direction of QC Function ML20073D7291983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Ja Rutgers on Qa.Responds to Specific Items Addressed in Attachment to J Keppler 821029 QA Testimony ML20069J0731983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Ja Mooney & RM Wheeler Re Alleged Violation of ASLB 820430 Order & Mar 1982 Cable Pulling Incident.Util Was Unaware NRC Required Explicit Review & Approval for Fireline Excavation & Excavation Below Deep Q-duct Bank ML20069J0761983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of WR Bird Re Qa.Installation of Trench Excavation Near Turbine Bldg W/Slope Layback Installed Incorrectly Due to Difficulty in Determining Ref Point for Horizontal Dimension ML20069J0861983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Bh Peck.Const Completion Program Addresses All Identified NRC Concerns Resulting from Insp of Diesel Generator Bldg.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20069J0571983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of JW Cook Re Util Qa/Qc Plans for Plant Completion.Completed Plant Will Conform to NRC Regulatory Requirements Based on Measures Taken to Improve Project Status Assessment,Sys Const & QA Implementation ML20069J0661983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Ja Mooney Re Remedial Soils Work.Discusses Events Up to & Including Major Action Announced in Util ,Implementation of Commitments & Progress Rept on Completed Underpinning Work ML20069J0821983-04-0404 April 1983 Testimony of RM Wheeler Re Qa.Discusses Util Preparations to Drill Well Hole in safety-related Dirt Using Unauthorized Technique ML20072S5881983-03-30030 March 1983 Limited Appearance Statement of Bp Garde Re Lack of Third Party Independent Review of Actual Plant Condition ML20073H4541983-03-28028 March 1983 Transcript of 830328 Deposition of AB Savage on Sinclair Contention 4 Re Steam Generator Corrosion ML20069F6201983-03-18018 March 1983 Testimony of a Savage on Contention 4 Re Corrosion & Sludging of Condenser Tubes by Pond Water.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20079N0161983-02-28028 February 1983 P 4 of Dh Evans & D Sommers 830214 Testimony Re Sinclair Contention 14 on Cooling Pond,Inadvertently Omitted. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20071A0321983-02-14014 February 1983 Proposed Transcript Corrections for Nov & Dec 1982 Hearings ML20071A0701983-02-10010 February 1983 Testimony of Dh Evans & DA Sommers Re Sinclair OL Contention 14.Bechtel Thermal Performance Study & Plant Cooling Pond Operation Study Not Improperly Influenced by Data from Substantially Different Climatic Region ML20071A0821983-02-0707 February 1983 Testimony of J Bradley Re Sinclair OL Contention 14 on Dresden Fogging & Icing Studies.Conclusions in Plant Fes Re Fog & Ice Not Inconsistent W/Dresden Cooling Pond Experience.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028E8641983-01-24024 January 1983 Testimony of P Shunmugavel Re Structural Evaluation of Auxiliary Bldg for Seismic Shakedown Settlement & Seismic Category I Duct Banks.Auxiliary Bldg Able to Withstand Effects of Shakedown Settlement ML20070R0411983-01-24024 January 1983 Testimony of Dr Anderson,Dt Perry & Gb Slade Re Sinclair Contention 3 on Potential for Water Hammer. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028E1471983-01-17017 January 1983 Testimony of C Hillman & T Postlewait on Sinclair Contention 4.Contention Has Faulty Premise.Administrative Procedures & Design Features of Plant Adequate to Meet B&W Specified Secondary Water Chemistry Limits.Related Correspondence ML20028E1561983-01-14014 January 1983 Testimony of Rd Woods Re Seismic Shakedown Settlement at Site.Reasonable Assurance Exists That Plant Area Including Piping & Duct Banks Will Not Suffer Excessive Settlement Due to Seismic Shutdown.Related Correspondence ML20028E1631983-01-13013 January 1983 Testimony of Bj Garrick & LS Gibson Re Analysis of Class 9 Accidents in Plant Fes.Conclusion in Fes That Risk to Public from Potential Accidents Is Small Not Invalidated by Precursor Study.W/Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence ML20070A1931982-12-0606 December 1982 Revised Testimony of RB Peck.Surcharge Program at Diesel Generator Bldg Eliminated Potential Future Settlement Problems Due to Compressibility of Plant Fill Matl & Lack of Homogeneity ML20069L9631982-11-15015 November 1982 Testimony of W Bird & R Wheeler Providing Addl Info on Nonconformance Repts Per ASLB Request in 820707 Memorandum & Order.Procedures Outlined Provide Adequate Controls to Prevent Damage to Underground Utils.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20069L9511982-11-0808 November 1982 Testimony of Wg Corley Re Plant Concrete Wall Crack Repair Program.Rept Entitled, Effects of Cracks on Serviceability of Structures at Midland Plant, Encl ML20069L9561982-11-0303 November 1982 Testimony of RB Peck.Surcharge Program at Diesel Generator Bldg Eliminated Any Potential Future Settlement Problems Due to Compressibility of Plant Fill Matl & Due to Lack of Homogeneity ML20065Q2201982-10-25025 October 1982 Testimony of a Boos,Em Burke,Jp Gould & P Shunmugarel Re Svc Water Pump Structure.Aperture Cards Available in PDR ML20065M9171982-10-15015 October 1982 Testimony of Rd Woods Re Liquefaction of Saturated Sand During Earthquake.After Remedial Measures Taken,Plant Will Be Safe Re Liquefaction of Sands.Related Correspondence. Oversize Drawings Encl.Aperture Cards Available in PDR ML20065M9031982-10-15015 October 1982 Testimony of Wc Paris Re Permanent Dewatering Sys for Site. Sys Will Provide Acceptable Method for Removing Water from Granular Plant Fill Matl.Related Correspondence.Oversize Drawings Encl.Aperture Cards Available in PDR ML20065Q2521982-10-14014 October 1982 Testimony of Wg Corley Re Cracking in Svc Water Pump Structure ML20027C1531982-10-0808 October 1982 Testimony of Aj Hendron Re Evaluation of Seismic Shakedown Settlement of Diesel Generator Bldg in Event of Earthquake. Prof Qualifications & Supporting Documentation Encl ML20063P2991982-10-0808 October 1982 Testimony of Aj Hendron Re Evaluation of Ultimate Load Carrying Capacity of Diesel Generator Bldg Footings.Prof Qualifications,Supporting Documentation & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20027C1631982-10-0707 October 1982 Testimony of DF Lewis on Behalf of Applicant Re Underground Piping.Affidavit & Supporting Documentation Encl ML20062K1011982-08-13013 August 1982 Transcript of 820813 Meeting in Midland,Mi.Pp 8,317-8,546 ML20062K0851982-08-12012 August 1982 Transcript of 820812 Hearing in Midland,Mi.Pp 8,100-8,316 ML20140H0021982-05-20020 May 1982 Statement of C Anderson Before ACRS Subcommittee 820520-21 Meetings Re Review of Application for Ol.Statement Addresses Soil/Structure Interaction Problems.Addenda 1 & 2 Encl ML20140H0131982-05-20020 May 1982 Statement of MP Sinclair Before ACRS Subcommittee on Midland Plant 820520-21 Meetings Re Review of Application for Ol. Statement Addresses Plant Design & Qualification Deficiencies ML20040F4141982-02-0404 February 1982 Testimony of Aj Boos & Rd Hanson Re Remedial Measures for Borated Water Storage Tank.Describes Analytical Work Performed on Tank Foundations,Soil Bearing Pressure & Settlement Predications.W/Affidavits & Prof Qualifications ML20040F4511982-02-0404 February 1982 Testimony of RP Kennedy & Rd Campbell.Uneven Tank Support Resulting from Soil Settlement Has Not Damaged Borated Water Storage Tanks.Design Basis Has Not Been Violated Nor Safe Operating Life Reduced ML20049J4861982-02-0202 February 1982 Errata to Transcripts of 820202 Hearing in Midland,Mi ML20040F4841982-02-0202 February 1982 Testimony of DF Lewis,Df Landers & Jk Meisenheimer Re Underground Piping & Tanks.Seven Oversize Drawings Encl. Aperture Cards Available in Pdr.Affidavit,Certificate of Svc & Prof Qualifications Encl ML20038A9381981-11-19019 November 1981 Testimony of EM Burke,Wg Corley,Jp Gould,Te Johnson & M Sozen Re Remedial Measures for Facility Auxiliary Bldg & Feedwater Isolation Valve Pits,Vols 1 & 2.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20005C0391981-11-0505 November 1981 Proposed Corrections to Transcript of 810805 Hearing in Midland,Mi.Notice of Appearance Encl ML20009D9181981-07-23023 July 1981 Testimony Re Stability of Dikes Adjacent to Emergency Cooling Water Reservoir,Per Stamiris Contention 4.B.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20126L8431981-06-0808 June 1981 Testimony of Ds Hood That If NRC Had Known How Util Was to Implement QA Program,Nrc Would Have Been Warranted in Not Issuing CPs for Original Application ML20126L8851981-06-0808 June 1981 Testimony of Ds Hood Re ASLB Question on Continued Const.Nrc Does Not Object to Proceeding W/Surcharging Valve Pits Adjacent to Borated Water Tanks If Acceptable Program Worked Out.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl 1985-06-20
[Table view] Category:DEPOSITIONS
MONTHYEARML20127N7591985-06-20020 June 1985 Transcript of Commission 850620 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote in Washington,Dc Concerning Denial of 2.206 Petition for Midland plant,SECY-85-60 Concerning Pressurized Thermal Shock Rule & Shoreham Order.Pp 1-4 ML20082D9041983-11-21021 November 1983 Portions of Jl Donnell Deposition,Designated as Direct Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20090H3461983-10-15015 October 1983 Transcript of Jl Donnell 831015 Deposition in Las Vegas,Nv Re Alleged Violation of ASLB Order ML20076L6471983-07-11011 July 1983 Testimony of Ps Glass Re Cable & Conduit Installation for Underpinning Instrumentation of Auxiliary Bldg.Oversize Matrix Encl.Aperture Card Available in PDR ML20076L6361983-07-11011 July 1983 Testimony of R Black Re Events During Late Winter 1982 & Early Spring 1982 & Installation of Cable Related to Instrumentation for Underpinning Work on Auxiliary Bldg ML20073H3621983-04-13013 April 1983 Two Attachments to RA Wells Testimony,Inadvertently Omitted from Original Submittal.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20069J0621983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of RA Wells Re Recent Changes in Organization of QA Dept,Including Changes in Organizational Structure & Responsibility for & Direction of QC Function ML20073D7291983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Ja Rutgers on Qa.Responds to Specific Items Addressed in Attachment to J Keppler 821029 QA Testimony ML20069J0731983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Ja Mooney & RM Wheeler Re Alleged Violation of ASLB 820430 Order & Mar 1982 Cable Pulling Incident.Util Was Unaware NRC Required Explicit Review & Approval for Fireline Excavation & Excavation Below Deep Q-duct Bank ML20069J0761983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of WR Bird Re Qa.Installation of Trench Excavation Near Turbine Bldg W/Slope Layback Installed Incorrectly Due to Difficulty in Determining Ref Point for Horizontal Dimension ML20069J0861983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Bh Peck.Const Completion Program Addresses All Identified NRC Concerns Resulting from Insp of Diesel Generator Bldg.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20069J0571983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of JW Cook Re Util Qa/Qc Plans for Plant Completion.Completed Plant Will Conform to NRC Regulatory Requirements Based on Measures Taken to Improve Project Status Assessment,Sys Const & QA Implementation ML20069J0661983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Ja Mooney Re Remedial Soils Work.Discusses Events Up to & Including Major Action Announced in Util ,Implementation of Commitments & Progress Rept on Completed Underpinning Work ML20069J0821983-04-0404 April 1983 Testimony of RM Wheeler Re Qa.Discusses Util Preparations to Drill Well Hole in safety-related Dirt Using Unauthorized Technique ML20072S5881983-03-30030 March 1983 Limited Appearance Statement of Bp Garde Re Lack of Third Party Independent Review of Actual Plant Condition ML20073H4541983-03-28028 March 1983 Transcript of 830328 Deposition of AB Savage on Sinclair Contention 4 Re Steam Generator Corrosion ML20069F6201983-03-18018 March 1983 Testimony of a Savage on Contention 4 Re Corrosion & Sludging of Condenser Tubes by Pond Water.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20079N0161983-02-28028 February 1983 P 4 of Dh Evans & D Sommers 830214 Testimony Re Sinclair Contention 14 on Cooling Pond,Inadvertently Omitted. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20071A0321983-02-14014 February 1983 Proposed Transcript Corrections for Nov & Dec 1982 Hearings ML20071A0701983-02-10010 February 1983 Testimony of Dh Evans & DA Sommers Re Sinclair OL Contention 14.Bechtel Thermal Performance Study & Plant Cooling Pond Operation Study Not Improperly Influenced by Data from Substantially Different Climatic Region ML20071A0821983-02-0707 February 1983 Testimony of J Bradley Re Sinclair OL Contention 14 on Dresden Fogging & Icing Studies.Conclusions in Plant Fes Re Fog & Ice Not Inconsistent W/Dresden Cooling Pond Experience.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028E8641983-01-24024 January 1983 Testimony of P Shunmugavel Re Structural Evaluation of Auxiliary Bldg for Seismic Shakedown Settlement & Seismic Category I Duct Banks.Auxiliary Bldg Able to Withstand Effects of Shakedown Settlement ML20070R0411983-01-24024 January 1983 Testimony of Dr Anderson,Dt Perry & Gb Slade Re Sinclair Contention 3 on Potential for Water Hammer. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028E1471983-01-17017 January 1983 Testimony of C Hillman & T Postlewait on Sinclair Contention 4.Contention Has Faulty Premise.Administrative Procedures & Design Features of Plant Adequate to Meet B&W Specified Secondary Water Chemistry Limits.Related Correspondence ML20028E1561983-01-14014 January 1983 Testimony of Rd Woods Re Seismic Shakedown Settlement at Site.Reasonable Assurance Exists That Plant Area Including Piping & Duct Banks Will Not Suffer Excessive Settlement Due to Seismic Shutdown.Related Correspondence ML20028E1631983-01-13013 January 1983 Testimony of Bj Garrick & LS Gibson Re Analysis of Class 9 Accidents in Plant Fes.Conclusion in Fes That Risk to Public from Potential Accidents Is Small Not Invalidated by Precursor Study.W/Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence ML20070A1931982-12-0606 December 1982 Revised Testimony of RB Peck.Surcharge Program at Diesel Generator Bldg Eliminated Potential Future Settlement Problems Due to Compressibility of Plant Fill Matl & Lack of Homogeneity ML20069L9631982-11-15015 November 1982 Testimony of W Bird & R Wheeler Providing Addl Info on Nonconformance Repts Per ASLB Request in 820707 Memorandum & Order.Procedures Outlined Provide Adequate Controls to Prevent Damage to Underground Utils.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20069L9511982-11-0808 November 1982 Testimony of Wg Corley Re Plant Concrete Wall Crack Repair Program.Rept Entitled, Effects of Cracks on Serviceability of Structures at Midland Plant, Encl ML20069L9561982-11-0303 November 1982 Testimony of RB Peck.Surcharge Program at Diesel Generator Bldg Eliminated Any Potential Future Settlement Problems Due to Compressibility of Plant Fill Matl & Due to Lack of Homogeneity ML20065Q2201982-10-25025 October 1982 Testimony of a Boos,Em Burke,Jp Gould & P Shunmugarel Re Svc Water Pump Structure.Aperture Cards Available in PDR ML20065M9171982-10-15015 October 1982 Testimony of Rd Woods Re Liquefaction of Saturated Sand During Earthquake.After Remedial Measures Taken,Plant Will Be Safe Re Liquefaction of Sands.Related Correspondence. Oversize Drawings Encl.Aperture Cards Available in PDR ML20065M9031982-10-15015 October 1982 Testimony of Wc Paris Re Permanent Dewatering Sys for Site. Sys Will Provide Acceptable Method for Removing Water from Granular Plant Fill Matl.Related Correspondence.Oversize Drawings Encl.Aperture Cards Available in PDR ML20065Q2521982-10-14014 October 1982 Testimony of Wg Corley Re Cracking in Svc Water Pump Structure ML20027C1531982-10-0808 October 1982 Testimony of Aj Hendron Re Evaluation of Seismic Shakedown Settlement of Diesel Generator Bldg in Event of Earthquake. Prof Qualifications & Supporting Documentation Encl ML20063P2991982-10-0808 October 1982 Testimony of Aj Hendron Re Evaluation of Ultimate Load Carrying Capacity of Diesel Generator Bldg Footings.Prof Qualifications,Supporting Documentation & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20027C1631982-10-0707 October 1982 Testimony of DF Lewis on Behalf of Applicant Re Underground Piping.Affidavit & Supporting Documentation Encl ML20062K1011982-08-13013 August 1982 Transcript of 820813 Meeting in Midland,Mi.Pp 8,317-8,546 ML20062K0851982-08-12012 August 1982 Transcript of 820812 Hearing in Midland,Mi.Pp 8,100-8,316 ML20140H0021982-05-20020 May 1982 Statement of C Anderson Before ACRS Subcommittee 820520-21 Meetings Re Review of Application for Ol.Statement Addresses Soil/Structure Interaction Problems.Addenda 1 & 2 Encl ML20140H0131982-05-20020 May 1982 Statement of MP Sinclair Before ACRS Subcommittee on Midland Plant 820520-21 Meetings Re Review of Application for Ol. Statement Addresses Plant Design & Qualification Deficiencies ML20040F4141982-02-0404 February 1982 Testimony of Aj Boos & Rd Hanson Re Remedial Measures for Borated Water Storage Tank.Describes Analytical Work Performed on Tank Foundations,Soil Bearing Pressure & Settlement Predications.W/Affidavits & Prof Qualifications ML20040F4511982-02-0404 February 1982 Testimony of RP Kennedy & Rd Campbell.Uneven Tank Support Resulting from Soil Settlement Has Not Damaged Borated Water Storage Tanks.Design Basis Has Not Been Violated Nor Safe Operating Life Reduced ML20049J4861982-02-0202 February 1982 Errata to Transcripts of 820202 Hearing in Midland,Mi ML20040F4841982-02-0202 February 1982 Testimony of DF Lewis,Df Landers & Jk Meisenheimer Re Underground Piping & Tanks.Seven Oversize Drawings Encl. Aperture Cards Available in Pdr.Affidavit,Certificate of Svc & Prof Qualifications Encl ML20038A9381981-11-19019 November 1981 Testimony of EM Burke,Wg Corley,Jp Gould,Te Johnson & M Sozen Re Remedial Measures for Facility Auxiliary Bldg & Feedwater Isolation Valve Pits,Vols 1 & 2.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20005C0391981-11-0505 November 1981 Proposed Corrections to Transcript of 810805 Hearing in Midland,Mi.Notice of Appearance Encl ML20009D9181981-07-23023 July 1981 Testimony Re Stability of Dikes Adjacent to Emergency Cooling Water Reservoir,Per Stamiris Contention 4.B.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20126L8431981-06-0808 June 1981 Testimony of Ds Hood That If NRC Had Known How Util Was to Implement QA Program,Nrc Would Have Been Warranted in Not Issuing CPs for Original Application ML20126L8851981-06-0808 June 1981 Testimony of Ds Hood Re ASLB Question on Continued Const.Nrc Does Not Object to Proceeding W/Surcharging Valve Pits Adjacent to Borated Water Tanks If Acceptable Program Worked Out.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl 1985-06-20
[Table view] Category:NARRATIVE TESTIMONY
MONTHYEARML20127N7591985-06-20020 June 1985 Transcript of Commission 850620 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote in Washington,Dc Concerning Denial of 2.206 Petition for Midland plant,SECY-85-60 Concerning Pressurized Thermal Shock Rule & Shoreham Order.Pp 1-4 ML20082D9041983-11-21021 November 1983 Portions of Jl Donnell Deposition,Designated as Direct Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20090H3461983-10-15015 October 1983 Transcript of Jl Donnell 831015 Deposition in Las Vegas,Nv Re Alleged Violation of ASLB Order ML20076L6471983-07-11011 July 1983 Testimony of Ps Glass Re Cable & Conduit Installation for Underpinning Instrumentation of Auxiliary Bldg.Oversize Matrix Encl.Aperture Card Available in PDR ML20076L6361983-07-11011 July 1983 Testimony of R Black Re Events During Late Winter 1982 & Early Spring 1982 & Installation of Cable Related to Instrumentation for Underpinning Work on Auxiliary Bldg ML20073H3621983-04-13013 April 1983 Two Attachments to RA Wells Testimony,Inadvertently Omitted from Original Submittal.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20069J0621983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of RA Wells Re Recent Changes in Organization of QA Dept,Including Changes in Organizational Structure & Responsibility for & Direction of QC Function ML20073D7291983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Ja Rutgers on Qa.Responds to Specific Items Addressed in Attachment to J Keppler 821029 QA Testimony ML20069J0731983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Ja Mooney & RM Wheeler Re Alleged Violation of ASLB 820430 Order & Mar 1982 Cable Pulling Incident.Util Was Unaware NRC Required Explicit Review & Approval for Fireline Excavation & Excavation Below Deep Q-duct Bank ML20069J0761983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of WR Bird Re Qa.Installation of Trench Excavation Near Turbine Bldg W/Slope Layback Installed Incorrectly Due to Difficulty in Determining Ref Point for Horizontal Dimension ML20069J0861983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Bh Peck.Const Completion Program Addresses All Identified NRC Concerns Resulting from Insp of Diesel Generator Bldg.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20069J0571983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of JW Cook Re Util Qa/Qc Plans for Plant Completion.Completed Plant Will Conform to NRC Regulatory Requirements Based on Measures Taken to Improve Project Status Assessment,Sys Const & QA Implementation ML20069J0661983-04-11011 April 1983 Testimony of Ja Mooney Re Remedial Soils Work.Discusses Events Up to & Including Major Action Announced in Util ,Implementation of Commitments & Progress Rept on Completed Underpinning Work ML20069J0821983-04-0404 April 1983 Testimony of RM Wheeler Re Qa.Discusses Util Preparations to Drill Well Hole in safety-related Dirt Using Unauthorized Technique ML20072S5881983-03-30030 March 1983 Limited Appearance Statement of Bp Garde Re Lack of Third Party Independent Review of Actual Plant Condition ML20073H4541983-03-28028 March 1983 Transcript of 830328 Deposition of AB Savage on Sinclair Contention 4 Re Steam Generator Corrosion ML20069F6201983-03-18018 March 1983 Testimony of a Savage on Contention 4 Re Corrosion & Sludging of Condenser Tubes by Pond Water.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20079N0161983-02-28028 February 1983 P 4 of Dh Evans & D Sommers 830214 Testimony Re Sinclair Contention 14 on Cooling Pond,Inadvertently Omitted. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20071A0321983-02-14014 February 1983 Proposed Transcript Corrections for Nov & Dec 1982 Hearings ML20071A0701983-02-10010 February 1983 Testimony of Dh Evans & DA Sommers Re Sinclair OL Contention 14.Bechtel Thermal Performance Study & Plant Cooling Pond Operation Study Not Improperly Influenced by Data from Substantially Different Climatic Region ML20071A0821983-02-0707 February 1983 Testimony of J Bradley Re Sinclair OL Contention 14 on Dresden Fogging & Icing Studies.Conclusions in Plant Fes Re Fog & Ice Not Inconsistent W/Dresden Cooling Pond Experience.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028E8641983-01-24024 January 1983 Testimony of P Shunmugavel Re Structural Evaluation of Auxiliary Bldg for Seismic Shakedown Settlement & Seismic Category I Duct Banks.Auxiliary Bldg Able to Withstand Effects of Shakedown Settlement ML20070R0411983-01-24024 January 1983 Testimony of Dr Anderson,Dt Perry & Gb Slade Re Sinclair Contention 3 on Potential for Water Hammer. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028E1471983-01-17017 January 1983 Testimony of C Hillman & T Postlewait on Sinclair Contention 4.Contention Has Faulty Premise.Administrative Procedures & Design Features of Plant Adequate to Meet B&W Specified Secondary Water Chemistry Limits.Related Correspondence ML20028E1561983-01-14014 January 1983 Testimony of Rd Woods Re Seismic Shakedown Settlement at Site.Reasonable Assurance Exists That Plant Area Including Piping & Duct Banks Will Not Suffer Excessive Settlement Due to Seismic Shutdown.Related Correspondence ML20028E1631983-01-13013 January 1983 Testimony of Bj Garrick & LS Gibson Re Analysis of Class 9 Accidents in Plant Fes.Conclusion in Fes That Risk to Public from Potential Accidents Is Small Not Invalidated by Precursor Study.W/Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence ML20070A1931982-12-0606 December 1982 Revised Testimony of RB Peck.Surcharge Program at Diesel Generator Bldg Eliminated Potential Future Settlement Problems Due to Compressibility of Plant Fill Matl & Lack of Homogeneity ML20069L9631982-11-15015 November 1982 Testimony of W Bird & R Wheeler Providing Addl Info on Nonconformance Repts Per ASLB Request in 820707 Memorandum & Order.Procedures Outlined Provide Adequate Controls to Prevent Damage to Underground Utils.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20069L9511982-11-0808 November 1982 Testimony of Wg Corley Re Plant Concrete Wall Crack Repair Program.Rept Entitled, Effects of Cracks on Serviceability of Structures at Midland Plant, Encl ML20069L9561982-11-0303 November 1982 Testimony of RB Peck.Surcharge Program at Diesel Generator Bldg Eliminated Any Potential Future Settlement Problems Due to Compressibility of Plant Fill Matl & Due to Lack of Homogeneity ML20065Q2201982-10-25025 October 1982 Testimony of a Boos,Em Burke,Jp Gould & P Shunmugarel Re Svc Water Pump Structure.Aperture Cards Available in PDR ML20065M9171982-10-15015 October 1982 Testimony of Rd Woods Re Liquefaction of Saturated Sand During Earthquake.After Remedial Measures Taken,Plant Will Be Safe Re Liquefaction of Sands.Related Correspondence. Oversize Drawings Encl.Aperture Cards Available in PDR ML20065M9031982-10-15015 October 1982 Testimony of Wc Paris Re Permanent Dewatering Sys for Site. Sys Will Provide Acceptable Method for Removing Water from Granular Plant Fill Matl.Related Correspondence.Oversize Drawings Encl.Aperture Cards Available in PDR ML20065Q2521982-10-14014 October 1982 Testimony of Wg Corley Re Cracking in Svc Water Pump Structure ML20027C1531982-10-0808 October 1982 Testimony of Aj Hendron Re Evaluation of Seismic Shakedown Settlement of Diesel Generator Bldg in Event of Earthquake. Prof Qualifications & Supporting Documentation Encl ML20063P2991982-10-0808 October 1982 Testimony of Aj Hendron Re Evaluation of Ultimate Load Carrying Capacity of Diesel Generator Bldg Footings.Prof Qualifications,Supporting Documentation & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20027C1631982-10-0707 October 1982 Testimony of DF Lewis on Behalf of Applicant Re Underground Piping.Affidavit & Supporting Documentation Encl ML20062K1011982-08-13013 August 1982 Transcript of 820813 Meeting in Midland,Mi.Pp 8,317-8,546 ML20062K0851982-08-12012 August 1982 Transcript of 820812 Hearing in Midland,Mi.Pp 8,100-8,316 ML20140H0021982-05-20020 May 1982 Statement of C Anderson Before ACRS Subcommittee 820520-21 Meetings Re Review of Application for Ol.Statement Addresses Soil/Structure Interaction Problems.Addenda 1 & 2 Encl ML20140H0131982-05-20020 May 1982 Statement of MP Sinclair Before ACRS Subcommittee on Midland Plant 820520-21 Meetings Re Review of Application for Ol. Statement Addresses Plant Design & Qualification Deficiencies ML20040F4141982-02-0404 February 1982 Testimony of Aj Boos & Rd Hanson Re Remedial Measures for Borated Water Storage Tank.Describes Analytical Work Performed on Tank Foundations,Soil Bearing Pressure & Settlement Predications.W/Affidavits & Prof Qualifications ML20040F4511982-02-0404 February 1982 Testimony of RP Kennedy & Rd Campbell.Uneven Tank Support Resulting from Soil Settlement Has Not Damaged Borated Water Storage Tanks.Design Basis Has Not Been Violated Nor Safe Operating Life Reduced ML20049J4861982-02-0202 February 1982 Errata to Transcripts of 820202 Hearing in Midland,Mi ML20040F4841982-02-0202 February 1982 Testimony of DF Lewis,Df Landers & Jk Meisenheimer Re Underground Piping & Tanks.Seven Oversize Drawings Encl. Aperture Cards Available in Pdr.Affidavit,Certificate of Svc & Prof Qualifications Encl ML20038A9381981-11-19019 November 1981 Testimony of EM Burke,Wg Corley,Jp Gould,Te Johnson & M Sozen Re Remedial Measures for Facility Auxiliary Bldg & Feedwater Isolation Valve Pits,Vols 1 & 2.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20005C0391981-11-0505 November 1981 Proposed Corrections to Transcript of 810805 Hearing in Midland,Mi.Notice of Appearance Encl ML20009D9181981-07-23023 July 1981 Testimony Re Stability of Dikes Adjacent to Emergency Cooling Water Reservoir,Per Stamiris Contention 4.B.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20126L8431981-06-0808 June 1981 Testimony of Ds Hood That If NRC Had Known How Util Was to Implement QA Program,Nrc Would Have Been Warranted in Not Issuing CPs for Original Application ML20126L8851981-06-0808 June 1981 Testimony of Ds Hood Re ASLB Question on Continued Const.Nrc Does Not Object to Proceeding W/Surcharging Valve Pits Adjacent to Borated Water Tanks If Acceptable Program Worked Out.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl 1985-06-20
[Table view] |
Text
___ - -
{}
%/
-
~ * ~ "
,. . .. * *
, , , , .
.
.
UdITED STATES OF AMERICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSIC:.
BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING BOARD ,
In the Matter of Docket Nos. 50-329 50-330 CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY SWORN TESTIMONY OF Midland Plant, Units I & II Ernst R. G. Eckert
_ ._ ....-- .....-- --...-...---.. ----.
I. .
I, Ernst R. G. Eckert, being first duly sworn, depose and say as follows:
My formal education, work experience, past and present positions, professional activities, membership in professional societies are as folicws: :
Educations Dipl.-Ing. German Institute of Technology, Prague. 1927 Dr.-Ing. German Institute of Technology, Prague 1931 Dr. Habil. Institute of Technology, Danzig 1938 Docent Institute of Technology, Braunschweig 1940 Positions:
' 1966- Regent s Professor and Director, Thermo-Present dynamics and Heat Transfer Division and Heat and Mass Transfer Laboratory, Department of Mechanical Engineering, School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, University of Minnesota
, 1955 ' Director, Thermodynamics and !! eat Transfer
.
Division, Mechanical Engineering Department, University of Minnesota 1951 Professor, Mechanical Engineering Depart-ment, University of Minnesota, tiinne. polis, Minnesota 1949-51 consultant, National Advisory Committee Aeronautics, Lewis Flight Propulsion
.
,
Laboratory, Cleveland, Ohio
.
.
.
8007150 Q y
-
~5 .
.
.
. . . .
L' 1945-49 Consultant, Power Plant Laboratory, a
U. S. Sir Force, Wright-Patterson Air Forcs osse, Ohio 1033-45 Professor and Director, Institute for Thermodynamics,(Jerman Institute of Technology, Prague
.
1938-45 Section-Chief, Aeronautical Research Institute, Braunschweig 1935-38 Lecturer, Institute of Technology, Danzig .
1928-34 Assistant, German Institute of Technology, Prague other experience:
Regist'ered Professional Engineer, State of Minnesota ,
Chairman, Honorary Editorial Advisory Board of _ International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer
. Advisory Consultant, Applied Mechanics and Heat Transfer Divisions of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers
'
U. S. Representative, Aerodynamics Panel of the International Committee of Flame Radiation Editor, Warme und Stoffubertragung,
- . . ... Thermal Science Series, Wadsworta Publishi'g n Company, Belmont, California Co-chairman, Advisory Editorial Board, U. S. A., of Heat Transfer-Soviet Research Vice President of Scientific Council, International Center for Heat and Mass
, Transfer, Yugoslavia Visiting Professor, Purdue University, Lafayette, Indiana U. S. Representative at Assembly for International Heat Transfer Conferences Membership in Societies:
American Society for Engineering Education American Institute of Aeronautics and Astropautics
.
Wissenschaftliche Gesellschaft fur Luft-und Raumfahrt
.
Amer'ican Society of. Mechanical Engineers v... . ,
-
.. .
L. / ., -2.,
..s. ..
-
- 1. . . .
..,
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ __ - _- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
f l
-
! .
,
.
.
Sicpaa Xi.
. Publications:
Articles: -
AIAA .Tournal A.I.Ch.E. J'u tal Applied Scler'ti'ic ner nrch AY, Jovencl
. Industrial Engineering Chemistry 1
International .Tou nal of IIcat and Mass Transfer
- Jct Propulsion Journal of the Aerospace Sciences Journal of Ipp' ' ed I:achanics Journal of Dacic Engincering i
Journal of Ilcat Transrol i
Mechanical Engineering National Advisory Com:nittee for As.ronautics National Acronautics and Space Administration Solar rneray Transactions of the AS:C Chemie-Ingenieur-rcchnik La Scuola in Azic:..
Forschung auf de:a Cabietc des Ingenieurwesens 1
Zeitschrift fOr angcuandte I:athentatik und l Physik
.
U"4rmo urd Scoff 0bertragung
.
Books:
Tcchnische Strnhlungaat::taucchrechnuncen.
IJerlin: Vul-Varlcig .
Introductien tc tim '"r.nns fer of IIca t and !! ass, (ua.1.a Awccr 'c ... Dr.J.c, Jr.). U:nt Ycrk:
McGrau IIill ro % Ccrporiy. 2E4 pagca (1950)
.
l l
1 4
, _ _ . --
l - .
. ;
I
, _(Russian Introduction to the Transfer translations of Heat ' and Mass.
Moscow-Leningrac:
~
l
.
National Energetic Publishing. 280 pages (19e7)
,Einfonr9ng Berlin:
in den Uarme-und Stoffaustauch.
Springer-Verlag. 3rd edition (1966)
HeatYork:
New and Mass Transfer, (with R. M. Drake, Jr.)
McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc.
2nd edition (1959)
.
Thacry of Heat and Mass Transfer, (with R. M.
ErEde, Jr.) 'ausslan translation). Moscow:
State Energetic: Publishing House. 680 pages Jntr oduction to Heat and Mass Transfer, (trongfer to English of Einfuhrung in den b'arme-und Stoffaustnuch, by J. F. GrofiT'
' New York McGraw-l!tll Ecok Company.
346 pages (1963)
,
Awards:
Fellow, tieu York Academy of Sciences,1959 Institute of Technolocy Dictinguished 1
' caching Award , University of Minnesota,1965 Western Electric Fund Award Excellence in Iristruction of Engineering Students, 19 6 Gold Medal, conferred by French Institute for Energy and Fuel for Important Contributions to Utilization of Energy and Thermal Sciences, 1967
<
Dr.-Ing. E.H.
(Honorary doctorate) Institute of Tecnnology, Munich, Germany,May 2, 1968' Doctor of Engineerina (honoris causa) purdue University, Lafayette, Indiana, June 9, 1968
.
} Doctor of Science (ttonoris causa) University
.
- of Mancnester, Manenester, England, September 10, 1968 Fellow, American Astronautics, 1968Scciety of Aeronautics and Fellow, American Scciety of Mechanical Engineers, 1969 Citations:
Regents' Professor of Mcchanical Engineering, University or Minnesota - Created Dy tne University of Minnesota Board of Regents in recognition of outstanding academic distinction judged of on the scholarly basis of the scope and quality contributions, quality of teach-ing,'and contributions to tha public good.
June 196G.
.
__
-
.
.
Max Jakob Award, 1961 (initial recipient)
- "For nis many and vital ccatributions to basic knowledge in heat transfer, made I directly by his experimental and analytical !
investigations and also in recognition of his I contributions as an outstanding teacher whose enthusiasm and understanding has contributed so widely to the advancement of this important field of engineering science."
II.
MY TESTIMONY. UHICH IN FART IS BASED ON INFORMATION AND BELIEF, IS AS FOLLCWS:
I have had the opportunity to review and refer to the following documents:
o
- 1. The Preliminary Safety Analysis Report
- 2. Letter, dated April 1G, 1971, from Mr. Jack O. Horton, i
Deputy Assistant Secretary for Programs, United States Department of Interior, to Mr. Harold L. Price, Dirje ctor of Regulation, United States Atomic Energy Commission.
- 3. Letter, dated August 27, 1970, from Harold Bosscher, General Manager, Midland Division, Dow Chemical Company, to Mr. Russell C. Youngdahl, Consumers Power Company, Jackson, Michigan.
- 4. Letter, dated March 18, 1971, from Dr. Sidney R. Galler.
Deputy Assistant Secretary for Environmental Affairs, Office of the Assistant Secretary of Commerce,'U. S.
Government, to Mr. Harold L. Prico, Director of Regulation, United States Atomic Energy Commission.
- 5. Statement, dated June 29, 1971, to the Michig a State Air Pollution Control Commission, from Dow Chemical Company.
6
.. Report, undated, from Environmental Protection Agency, to (apparently) U. S. Atomic Energy Commission, re Midland Nuclear Plant.
- 7. Statement, dated April 1971, from, Radiation Office, Environmental Protection Agency, to (apparently)
United States Atomic Energy Commission, re " Environ-mental impact review, Midland Plant Units I & II".
- 8. Statement, dated November 1970, from U. S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare,.Public Health Service, Environmaatal Health Service, Bureau of Radiological Health, Division of Environmental Radiation and Nuclear Facilitics Dranch, to (apparently)
United States' Atomic Energy Commission, re "Public health review, Midland Plant Units I & II".
.
e W W
.
e e
d I
-
. !
,-. , , _, _ . _ . - - -
-
.
9.
Letter, dated (received by U. S. Atomic Energy
,
Commission) March 31, 1971, from R. Y. Edwards,
, Rear Admiral, U. S. Coast Guard, Chief, Office of Public and International Affairs, Department of
- Transportation, United States Coast Guard, to Mr. Harold L. Price, Director of Regulation, United States Atomic Energy Commission.
Let me begin by saying that I will confine my. testimony to two subjects of concern to the Atomic Energy Commission Atomic Safety and Licensing Board: Site planning of the
applicant Consumers Power Company proposed nuclear power plant, Units 1 and 2 and, secondly, the proposed use of process steam produced by the proposed Midland nuclear plant by the Dow Chemical Company in Midland, Michigan. -
My testimony is offered under the auspices of the Mapleton
>
Intervenors, who have, among others, presented testimony to the f,
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board to support the proposition
,
that the Consumers Fower Company proposed plant should be
!
located at some distance fr'om the populated areas to minimize the risk of exposur s of the population to radioactive contamina-tion or danger from a nuclear accident.
l i
- On this first question of site planning, my testimony will I be directed to the question of the technical feasibility of f locating the plant at a greater distance than proposed by the
.,
applicant Consumers Power Company, while retaining the technical
feasibility of delivering process steam to the Dow Chemical Company.
From review of the preliminary safety analysis report and i the other documents listed in my affidavit herein, it is ;
.
evident that the applicant consum2rs Power Company believes it I is not technically feasible to deliver process steam to the Dow Chemical Company in the event the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board determines that the plant should be located at 1
.
a greater distance than proposed by the applicant Consumers Power Company.
l
. e i
I .
!
!
t
! *
- '
_
___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ - - -
t The apy.icant Consumers Power Cornpany has taken the
.
's position, as indicated in its Draft Statement, that "There is
\ no feasible alternative for using another site to produce
- process steam for Dov. . . . (S)uch a moving of the plant would result in a decrease in both the quantity and quality of
.
the steam supplied to Dow. Delivery of steam from such a distance would require the use of extremely large pipes, which could be considered unaesthetic."
l I
Hy testimony here is directed to this position of the applicant Consumers Power Company. I will briefly discuss some schemes which will permit the location of the Midland nuclear plant some distance from residential and population areas, I
while retaining the technical feasibility of delivering process j steam to Dow Chemical Company.
j According to the present plans of the applicant Consumers Power Company, the proposed Midland nuclear plant will deliver
{ electric power and process steam. Part of that steam
[3,650,000 lb/hr] is used to generate electric power by direct-ing the steam flow through the high pressure part of one of the steem turbines. Each of the nuclear reactors generates l
11,000,000 lb/hr.
l 1
The process steam used to generate electricity is, therefore,
-
) 16.6 percent of the total amount of steam generated by both l reactors.
The percentage of electricity generated by the
'
process steam is, however,. considerably less because this steam
'
flows through the high pressure part of the turbine only:
whereas, the rest of the steam generates electricity in the low pressure part as well as in the high pressure part of the steam turbines.
The percentage of the electric power generated by the process steam is, therefore, between 4 and 5 percent of the
, total electric power generated by the proposed Midland nuclear plant, depending on the temperature of the cooling water for the condenser.
!
I
. ,
_ .
__ _ _ - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _
r i
- FIRST ALTERNATE SCHEME FOR DELIVERY OF PROCESS STEAM FROM A PLANT SITE SOME DISTANCE
. FROM RESIDENTIAL AND POPULOUS AREAS
.
The first alternate scheme I propose would require climinat-ing the generation of electric power by the process steam. It is suggested that this is feasible because the process steam generates a comparatively small amount of electricity, to-wit between 4 and 5 percent of the total electric power which would be generated by the proposed Midland nuclear plant. In the event process steam is not used for the generation of electric
' ower, p the total process steam required by the Dow Chemical Company could be ducted from the proposed Midland nuclear plant to Dow Chemical Company at a pressure between 675 psia and ,
.
1 1050 psia, and could be throttled down at the Dow Chemical
, Company to the required 675 psia and 197 psia respectively.
, Under this first alternate scheme, the pressure at which the
'
steam is transported from the proposed Midland nuclear plan't
- to Dow Chemical Company is'sufficiently high to allow a reasonable diameter of pipes required for the transport of I process steam.
! SECOND ALTERNATE SCHEME l FOR DELIVER'1 OF PROCESS STEAM
'
FROM A PLANT SITE SOME DISTANCE
.
- FROM RESIDENTIAL AND POPULOUS AREAS
,
A second alternate scheme which would allow the location of
.. the site of the proposed nidland nuclear plant at some greater distance from residential and populous areas is proposed in the event that it is determined necessary that the same level of generation of electric power as proposed by the applicant Consumers Power Company be maintained. In this second alternate scheme, the reduction of the pressure of. process steam trans-ported to the Dow Chem' i cal Company from 1050 psia to 197 psia could be performed in a separate turbine which itself generates
.
electric power and would be locatcd at the Dow Chemical plant.
-
i I
i i
- .
t.
, .
THIRD ALTERNATE SCHEME
'
FOR DELIVERY OF PROCESS STEAM FROM A PLANT SITE SOME DISTANCE FROM RESIDENTIAL AND POPULOUS AREAS
,
i
.
i The third alternate scheme which would allow location of ?
the proposed Midland nuclear plant at a greater distance from residential and populous areas could be accomplished by complete separation of the electric power plant from the system of delivery of process steam to Dow Chemical Company.
The location of the electric power plant could then be planned independently of the location of the Dow Chemical Company. To meet the needs of Dow ' Chemical Company for process steam, a special power plant could be located at the Dow Chem'ical Company, powered by coal gas or oil, to ganarate steam at 675 psia.
A part of this steam could be reduced in pressure to 195 psia in a turbine or in a throttle valve. The electricity produced by a generator connected with the turbine could be used at the Dow Chemical plant or could be sold to Consumers Power Company.
In conclusion, concerning the question of site location of the proposed Midland nuclear plant, my testimony is not directed to the question of capital costs of the various alternate schemes, but is limited to the technical feasibility
,
of the location of tho Midland nuclear plant at some greater distance from residential and populous areas. In view of the 9
technical feasibility of locating the plant at some greater distance, it is suggested that the economy of the various alternate schemes proposed herein be given a detailed analysis by the applicant and the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board to
- determine their relative merits. *
.
O 4
9
f . &
'
l em
,
.
-
Further deponent saith not.
k
(
- _ & //$ V hk Eynst R. G. f.ckert / ,
i .
'
.
Subscribed and sworn to before
.
me this th day of August, 1971. .
'
, _ LYN'4.3......
C A971ste _
_. .... .. . ..,,
.
.
.
J . -
.
.
I e 44 .
f I . . . . ,.
'
I
.
.
9 A m a em.
l e 0
.
, f
"
5
'.
O %
-
f
.
.
.
.
. .