ML19259D111

RO 2-79-40/1P on 790821:while Cardox Sys Was Disabled, Continuous Fire Watch Not Maintained in Diesel Generator Bldg.Caused by Failure to Follow Procedure Designating Duties of Fire Watch.Personnel Reinstructed

ML19259D111
Person / Time
Site:	Peach Bottom
Issue date:	08/22/1979
From:	Ullrich W PECO ENERGY CO., (FORMERLY PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
References
NUDOCS 7909070459
Download: ML19259D111 (2)

Text

_.=:_ . . .- - --.

__ .

s,

,

l' * *? *

' " ,

• - /

• FHtmit A Et.ECTRTC rI99PANY * - ' /

. ._-.

.%..

.

~'

-

-

~ " ' ' '

s . 7

.*

.

,,..',-

u. - <

~' % . FeschDsita . . Botten FenrsyIVanin Atmic Pcwer station .

-

.

' t ~ E f',. '

. .

. , . , : l :; ... .. . g73g4 , , ,, 4 gw'

.. '

.~ .: ... ... _ . , .. & ; ;_ .. . - .. . . . .': i

.

- - '

_

;. ;.

. -y; *;;r.' e Angust 22, 1979

. J ,' , 7 ' .' ; . . . ' ' . . ._g ,

- -_ ,'

-

4.. ;i, ,7.'.7.

., .._,n...-. . z.

,

.

.

~

. . . ,

_

.

. .

,

-

,

, . .

-

.

.

.. .--

.

-

.n..

-

. ,; . 3 .

. . . . . .

.

. . . . . , .

.

._ ..

-

v

. " ' # '?. . -.^. . . ~ 'j3'

'

Mr. Scyt:e H. Grier " . . . .

D '{P -

'

'. ' -

-? .. g

-

Ofilce of Inspection and. Enforcement ..>. . . . X.J.

Region 1 -

" - :- : r. , , . - : - ~. ": ..m g -, -f . - e Q

...t ' 3

- g,..

O c-f'y.

' '

tktLted States Nuclear Regu.1 story Ccessissiec.

631 Park Avenue 'i o_. , *.. . .u, c . .r < . . $ .. Y.] y d '

-~.

19406-

.

.

.

/.f".4 .. _ ' . . .

. ,

'.. m* . .

.

.

.

~

_ P . W, .J. .

- . . - -- l . .% . - : .

..

, King af Prussis. PA '

l :. <~M.W - , < -.-3

-

4 .44 b .-

-

.

,,- . , , ;n .,.,.c-

..

,.. .

.

. - y;. y ..

SUBJECT:

- M.. .' y.i. -

PEPCKTAELE OCCURRENCE - PRL*TT .WT,TFICATION -

..

. .. .

-. . ~.

- - . .' e, .E : -

Conforming. R. 5. Fleistfutsnn's conversEtion with Mr. Grectman. Itegisnt 1  ?.lQ thtired. States Nuclear Regulatory Consismicn ctr F/27/~9. -

- 4 'f, .

~

- "

. . < .

Reference r Docket No. 50-277/278 "

.

. .

-

3.'iiU

-

.

--

. - - Pesch Ecttes Units 7 stwI 3 m sTechnicst. 5pecificatim

Reference:

-

' '

3.14.5.4.2

-' .# L ,

-

- Y!:% +',."

,. .

.

. .

,,,_

g.

.;

. .

.. ..

Report No. 2 / Le .

-- -- -

.

Occurrence Date: August 21, 1979 .,.

,

.

Identificaticn. of Occurrence; . . ..

- -

.

._

.

.'

Failur- to maintwin <:entinuous fire watch. i.n the diesel generator tuilding. ~ ~ "

while the curdox systes was disabled . . .. -

.

- . . . , . .'.

-

,. . , . . y - i.---., ,g,...,.,,'... .

.7 . . -

.~..'"

.

. .

- " "

Conditions Frior to Occurrence:. .

. ' . . . ' .N. y

. .;..

. . . .

._

~ ~'. ' ..

. .. .' ,I, -

..

.,, ., q,' . . g..

. ..-- , - - ,_. . , . . .

..t .

Unit I operating st rated power

, - , _ -

.s Unit .3 eparating at 90% ; e er.

.,- .

'.-

.

'fN

..

.*

• * ' -

- -

. v . . . . , . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . ,.

Apparent Cause of Occurrence. '

.

.m .

-

.. .. . .

F=1ture to foticw procedure which design =tes duties ef a fire. watch. . .'

. . .

. .

Anslysis of Occur.r-nce r - . - - . _,

._ ._ o ,.s._. . ..- ,

on the norning, nf 8/ 21/79. twr seprtr.st e Jr.b5 ---- wi g re .r.ree-d by centrset p rsonncI in. the dieset generator hqildhng. Each of th*=e. Jehs

-

revit*ed that a fire watch be po*ted. The fire watches wre rested per procedure. I.mter that scyming ce? grimp cv. latel.it= task med the fire watch for that greerp fe.iled to restt're the 0.?: =y=r m to term.M in tha EZ diesel generator- hav. He assu=*ed rhet the fire wstch. fer the accend grtwq re raired t.*mt the G)g syste = r* mio cut cf serv 3 ca. Tha tec.rmd groun had..pp, knew. icd t e that thi.s particular secties of the fire protection.

systsvr was put of service vivee th-r were wding in eacther ar-a. As a resutt of these actions the EZ diesel Rener.nor area was,withcet a fire .

_ watch for a per19d of ebout ten almstes

. .

,

.

• L

($w

..

- -

._ . s.

.

.

...,,.. .

-

., .... .... ..s,.......... . ..",,,....... ...... .

7909070 Y59

.n.. -

..  :.~;....,....c  : . '.:-

'

. . , . . . ...- w . . .~. . . -e 4 y .+ .<?. - .: % .' M s_ - O< -J y *.^6..;.,".. * .

. :. . .+>. s., .: ,,.. . ..- ~ . . , . - . .

~. .. .... .. .g > .;s ;x m

. ;. . ". ; y. * , , ~. ~m y m>

. .

. ,,.. .v a. .:

-

.1. s . ,.mp,..: .m. n . . :...... .,.- q; . ~.. .. : + . s .; . : .g.

..

.

. , ., .. . .

.. ~ , . . . .

..,. .

. .n . . . .

.

s .....;

..

,

duxtysis of UmifMEN ~ 6.o6t'Inued) ... - .-

'

. ..

• '

-

a ;. ,

,

. .

'.s ., a. N: s i:..e . :~:v.' ' c..

, .

u *n.--*'d ..

--

..,.. . . . . , . * :e v.. ), . .- N .; .iL . .2y- '..3 . , - , / --!. '- ;" s * . - .x- 3; ' = - < .

.f . . . g. .' c. .,(. 47. e g y .~, . ., N,. .. g;y' .' -

,

. . . . ... . . . . .. .: ... .: .  %. ' . - . ,<

? ,

.,..

.

P,- .

• . *

,. . . cS .

.

---

T ;,. :.. ~5.~=

.

-

--There is no safety significance to this occurrende since there was no T

.e working being dene in the diesel 3-nerater bay during the period that ~

%-f.,. .

rs, the fire watch was not present. In addition a guiard remained pested . aUs

' at _the only open entrance- te the diesel g-nerator. building. 'Ibe guard ".f}$'$ "'[

M. stated that had she detected's sache for fire situation she would have C-reportesi the same to shift supervision. I:nother noteworthy fact is '

'

• 9;7C' C wthat during n IDCA start of the diesel generators,. the C07 systen is 7 E ^-%W W(anatomatically disab.l,ed. ~ ' ~--@%dhW5.OM'.9

, .. . v- C': C 7+ A ;S V W u - c .

'

. - -w

. .

.

a -

v :. s a ; M. s.w w.... ~nW. . : . .m.:j,.e.a. ~.m i

-

.s 4..

. ..%m +,-;m.< w; . 4. .~ e s.~.

i.T. ' + .t.r .y ,. m.

.

-+. .~ . c n ., .w . .. .:p

.

m..

.,r i:W.

s:.- . . . >. ac, e

-

i . .n .

... Corrective Action:.. . v ,.7".,"d+~...,,.;.

.. . .

.. .,. . .. .

v .

_

4 . .- - - .- - '

.- J

.

,. .

.. . . n g'. . . . /,

.

, . .. ' f -y.. . G. '9.. W. #.Ctrw. .

.

-

. ; . . . w. . - 49. . cr ... J. ..

,t s.. -.'...#.. - -

. .. ". . W y.- c--.,d,,'

.. -

r* . ,,

, , .y. - *. - .

-n Ienedistely upen ' discover.v of .t.his .incide tt r the CW. systrw in the E2 . . . -e .

v..S '

- diesel. generator bay was restored to service. The total ti.wr that the - ,Ns. r systes vss. Inoperable coincident with no fire Matth pr se st was about. .'

. . - . .u .

-i.>j/e W

. - . .

ten m mutes. -;,.- w,1::,w'*:.

.

.. 1...s ~ , ,<'m z .f e.

s

-

.

- . -

.

.' .. .v g-

o. c rv .

..

. + ;, . ~ . .% 4:....r.

-

t. ,. 3, s.m.,,,.,

.,. .u. y.aa . , gr e.a ; :. . -. ....: .:

m . ..g...,:.. ..

. . _ . ..,-~,.e

,  : . . . . .

..

2. c.,.. .

.

..w.a. . 7. ..x. ., . .

._~

. .- , .. , .

• s-

.

• u, ~ >

.

.

. ,. g. . .

..

g_..

. . Upon disernery of this incident all wert in the diesel generster building- . - 4 (.R 7

, rwas halted until all personnel involved. were ninstructed. en the r quirenents- [..T of perfor-ilng work in an ar-s' when a fire watch was r -sted . Afditional.

- t "' ..'

-

centract perse:nnet have also bestr reinstructed in this se=s =atter. -

.,

It is felt thSt with the currecti're acticas autmE ha.e t.hur._xi.11 b

~

--

.

no reoccurrence. of this typ . -

- -

~

. . . . ...g s. .,..

, _.

. . . .

'.

- .

-

'n. .. . . -

-

'

Previous Failures: - - . -

_..

" '

.....

.

. ..

• - e. *' .,._r*e .-s- ~,a ,' ,

. \ ;. - -l , . .

. Q . *

.._ , , , , . * * ,-e*

- , ,

• '

'2-79-2. M. s. .. i ,# '.4* s . ; 5. [ #,., .J I f. f, .s. c/ ; ; ... - Uf.,- dd ' --l<..o .l.D ".- ~. ' c - *\ ,' *,.1 , .

,,...L.;.  ; _. .~..f..o..

.

. . . ,.r . . s

.~.. ~3;. ..v.*.-' .

,s. . .

a

.. .. .

.

. ,-n

.L .

<.W

.. . ., -

. ~ .* ..v~_*-,...'&

...,',-.m__:+_ ..

. -

' ^~L ~.

. w',m. .9, ' *~ K ,. \, f _. + -n ' ,w:Q.~ . ,,)

..

_m

, .. d.y v.m ,. ,,YSr7 tru17'JUur5 __-.>.~. .r+. .e ,A;

, .

_

... , - ...+,f.,c.. .

... p.3 y .

e

.

- ' . .

~>

.t.. * . '.,,.,a g< ,

.

.w'. .s , ,  ;.c sq.t. .  ;*e- l>.c A.

• o s W~ . .:.'s a . r w; '.'

'

,- ~ m. ~~

, , ,

a. ~ . m .- .

..... - ~ c. . - m ~. '.: '.~ . ~: *-r- ~*1:

..' ..

.

• *,  :~. -

.

.c

^,c.apy s c. , .;.,r .n.w'-,9.,<,j,;.,

. .

. r ; :.. y.} a

. . ., ;. g n. '. .t~ . . . . . v

...- . . . ., .n r,y . y. -> .

........--

,e , ,

n.

_ , _

,, j

,.- .

. .'./ . 7 ' .,...

.

-

', I..*)% ~.f/;.4 y+ [ d. u,

• y' ". .

. .. ,

, ' .. . . .-. , .7 .

. . :, . 3 , . . .

. . =. 7 .?

.

-

.

'1:c * % 2: - W T Ullrich . .-w y

-

. , . . ,,

. . . - - : 4-

.-* . Statlert .Superirtendent-

' '

e

., .r-...

i-. 2 , .. . , J' , .

.... .-....g.  ; J

.w..,, ._

.-

,-

-

, .. . . -

.

,., , *

.. --

,~ . ,. , . , _

. ' , . V.

.

' .f ey . .' -

.

. .

'

wty?cznq1n '.%

- - ' - -

.

' - '~

m ._ , w.., . . .~ .3.. m,. . ,,e ,t, f c r.w ....a.4 +.m.... , x-w 4. .. 1 ~

,,, .,. --

. . . . .

-

., p- .,

.. . . . . . .

,

.. .

--p= fv' . .

3. , . ,, , ~ * ' . dj .

, {;* ! .'. ,. y . k. y.'.s ., ,,,,{,..,M.e.".. ,

_ .,c ,

* .

..

-

' . . ,

'.'^,

.

.

w.

_

. ...

. .

.m..,..,..._.... . . .- w. <

.

n... . - ,.

.

. .

. . . .

.

. . .. ,. . . .

> -* ' ,.

.

.,.,  ? ,,.. . ~ . .

-

g "% g ,g b* . M d$ . g

,

'

T " T. _ ; ../. ", ' * '

,,,,.. U' .. : , , .

.g -

e-

.

.< . . . ~ . . , ,

.

si

,, M . *%

• 29 -

.**.gg iD".4 ,47 (

• T g, .

9

.

. . .

g8 . . P.a + . g.

a yv - -

+

. -- , . . .

9 , *%. pE . _ -

..

p 8.h %b p.' g, e  % .

! . gg - .

4

-

^

.

-

.;u . . . .

...[j'..

.

9_ q q ,

_

.. . .. 9 _

.s j y

.. ,

. . . -

n. , . , .

. .;; _.

.

.- _ ,

-

.. _

,

.

.

,

.

...~,.~,....,, .

_

.,_.- - .:.

.

ca *

. . . . - y ^i . .

m ,

.

.

.

'

-

. . .

p\ -q

-"

n> >

..

.

. , . . .

e

- . .- . , # .

>, .. : -- U} -

.-

' _.~,

-

',' "(

.

.'

'

9

..

1. .

,.

, .

F

.g '

.

,.

4 .* . ,.

-

,

. . .

-

.

. * ..e.

[ ' **

• d 8.J % J' 6

. *,, . , ,

.( *'f ,C 4* . . #g, . , . . -g'.

~

. .., ' ^ * \'

, .

9

u. .

. .

• O.

-

-,, . _

_

. , **_ s'*

- . ..- ' * *

.* . .

., a be

.i.

'

s r -

'"'

.

. . ,, . . .-

,

, .

,m mm , , . , - - - **-*m- - - * * * * * =, wyvig n - =mww =.m e e rre n - -

, _ . ,,,,y _...,r- ,r- .-- r - .

, . .