ML17303A454
| ML17303A454 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palo Verde  |
| Issue date: | 06/04/1987 |
| From: | ANDERSON M L, HAUSER D B, STICKLER J B ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE CO. (FORMERLY ARIZONA NUCLEAR |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML17303A453 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8707100215 | |
| Download: ML17303A454 (34) | |
Text
Arizona Nuclear Power Project HQK SLIImmevy Repel t UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR EDDY CURRENT EXAMINATION FEBRUARY 1987 8707g002i5 pDR ADQCK 0500@DR SL.
I I I'1 il PALO VERDE NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR EDDY CURRENT EXAMINATION FEBRUARY 1987 ARIZONA NUCLEAR POWER PROJECT P.0.BOX 52034 PHOENIX, AZ 85072 PREPARED BY: REVIEWED BY: APPROVED BY:-I DATE: 4'DATE: CP I'ATE: REPORT DATE: 6/04/87 0 4 INDEX 1.0 Summary 2.0 Examination Results 3.0 Examination Techniques and Equipment APPENDIX A-Summary Data Sheets APPENDIX B-Tubesheet Maps APPENDIX C-Form NIS-1 lt UNIT 1 STFAM GENERATOR EDDY CURRENT EXAMINATION 1.0
SUMMARY
On January 17, 1987 a tube leak was observed in steam generator ll (Unit 1, steam generator 1).Unit 1 was subsequently shutdown on January 18, 1987 and work began towards opening the steam generators for eddy current examination.
Following removal of the manway covers, the leak was visual-ly identified as being in the low numbered row/low numbered column corner of the tube bundle on the cold leg side.A full Technical Specification examination was performed with an initial sample of approximately 2800 tubes in each steam generator, with all examinations performed from the cold leg.All tubes were examined full length with the exception of row 1 and some row 2 tubes which were examined to the first support on the hot leg side when possible.The initial examination results fell into category C-2 in both steam generators and an additional 716 tubes were examined in steam generator 11 and 696 tubes were examined in steam generator 12.The tubes in the expansion program were examined to the fourth support on the cold leg.The results of the supplementory testing fell into category C-l.2.0 EXAMINATION RESULTS The examination results revealed wear indications at the lower eggcrates on the cold leg side of both steam generators in the low row corners of the tube bundles.A total of fourteen degraded tubes and seven defec-tive tubes were identified in steam generator ll, and thirteen degraded tubes and six defective tubes were identified in steam generator 12 (Unit 1, steam generator 2).The summary data sheets in Appendix A list all tubes in both steam generators with thru-wall indications from 0-100K and distorted tube support signals with probable indications (DSI).Several tubes were identified in each steam generator as having minor dings and dents.The majority of these had been identified during base-line examinations, however, the following tubes in steam generator ll showed significant denting at the feedwater flow distribution baffle that was not present during the baseline examination:
Row 1 column 50, row 1 column 52, row 1 column 54, rowl column 56, row 1 column 60, row 1 column 62, and row 1 column 64.In addition, row 1 column 58 was dented to the point of 0.540" probe would not pass.Steam generator 11 had sixteen tubes in the examination sample that were not explanded into the tubesheet while steam generator 12 had fourteen tubes with no tubesheet explansion.
Possible loose part indications were observed in both steam generators with steam generator 11 having five tubes and steam generator'12 having one tube.Sludge profiling was also performed during the examination and was found to be very minor.Less than 100 tubes in each steam genera-tor showed any indication of sludge with average depth less than an inch and maximum depth 1.5 inches.Page 1 of 2
The examination resulted in plugging an additional 20 tubes in steam generator ll, and 14 tubes in steam generator 12.The tube sheet maps in Appendix B show the total tubes plugged in each steam generator to date and the examination extent during this outage.The NIS-1 form in Appendix C lists each of the tubes, by row and column, plugged as a result of this examination.
The following Engineering Evaluation Requests (EER)were initiated to track the examination results: 87-RC-035, 87-RC-037, 87-RC-038 and 87-RC-039.
In addition,'
report on the steam generators, including root cause analysis, was transmitted to NRR by letter ANPP-40179-JGH/BJA/98.05.
3.0 EXAMINATION
TECHNIQUES AND EQUIPKBlT The eddy current examination was performed by Conam Inspection using Zetec MIZ-18 digital data aquisition and analysis systems.The following test frequencies were used during the examination:
550 kHz differential and absolute 300 kHz differential and absolute 100 kHz differential and absolute 20 kHz differential and absolute The majority of the tubes in the examination sample were tested with Zetec manufactured 0.610" and 0.600" SFM/HF probes.The tubes in rows 1, 2, and 3 were examined with either 0.590" or 0.540" SFM/HF probes.A Zetec SM-4 remote fixture was used for probe positioning and tubesheet templates were installed for tube location verification.
Page 2 of 2 f
APPENDIX A Summary Data Sheets
'l ROW: Indicates the row number of a given tube.LIN: Indicates the column number of a given tube.LEG: Indicates the tube leg from which examination was performed; either the hot (H)leg or cold (C)leg.EXTENT REQ: Indicates the tube length required to be examined, i.e., F/L-full length, 07H-seventh support on hot leg side.EXTENT TST: Indicates the tube length actually examined.REM: Remarks column used for comments relating to examination.
REEL: Indicates reel number data was recorded on.PROBE: Indicates probe diameter and style used for examination.
LOCATION: Gives indication location relative to known landmarks such as supports and batwings.VOLTS: Indicates the peak-to-peak voltage of a given indication response.DEG: The measured phase angle of a given indication response.Fo~The percent through the tube wall of a given indication based on the measured phase angle and the calibration curve established for that particular channel.CH: Indicates the channel used to measure and evaluate a given indication.
Page Al of 5 I, I I CUMULATIVE REPORT 81/87, ARiZONA PUBLiC SERVICE CO, PALO VFRD:", STEAN GEi4ERATOR:
1 LOCATION: ALL CRiTERIA: 8/TO 199'A, DSI UNIT 1 PAGE: 1 OF 2 DATE: 92/87/87 TiiNE: 98: 89: 14 I I t I IEXTFi4T I I I I IROMILINIHEATOILEGIREQITSTIRENIREELIPROBEI I I I I I I I I I I LOCATION I CURREi4T I IVOLTSliNILIDEGI
'/ICHI I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 21 I I 41 I I I I I il I I I I I 31 I I I I 21 I I I I I ll I I I I I 3I I I I I I 71 351 491 I I I I 11 I I il I I I I 21 I I I I I 21 I I I I 31 I I I I I 41 I'I I I 41 I I I I'41 16i 361 I I i I 187HI87CIRiTI 187HI87CIRITI 187HI87CIRiTI 187HIF/LI I 187H187CI I 187H197CI I 197HIF/Ll I 187HI87CI I 187HI87CI I 187HIF/LIPIDI 187HI87HI I 187HI87HI I 187HI87HI I 187H187HI I 187HI87HIRPII 187HI87HI I 187H I F/L I P ID I 187H I 87C I R I T I 187HI87CIRITI 187HIS7CIRITI 187HIF/LIPIDI 187H187CIRITI 187Hi87CIRiTI 187HIF/LI I 187HIS7CIRITI 197HI87CIRITI 187HIF/LIPIDI 197HI87HIPiDI 187HI87HI I 187HI87HI I 187HI87HIPIDI 187HI87HI.I 197HI87HIPIDI tF/LI97CI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIQ7CI i IF/LI97CI I IF/LI87CI I IF/Llc/LI IF/LI87Ci I i 94C195C i R IT I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I Ic/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I I I i I Page A2 of 5 CONAN 991 1618SN I 83C-881161QSiNI92C+
891 161QSN192C+
813 I 549BiiI I 82C+99 1 1 6 18SN I 83C-881 1619SN 183C-8341698SNI93C-881161SSNIS2C+
881 1618SN I 82C+8341688BNIS2C+
832154QSN184C+
8321549SN183C+
8321548SNI83C-8321549SNI82C+
8321548SNI82C+
8321549SNI82C-8131548SNIS3C+
8811618SN I 83C-881161QSN I 82C+881161SSNIS2C+
813154SSNIS2C+
8811618SN183C-881 1618SiN I 83C-8131548SNi83C-89116188NIS2C+
981161SSNIS2C+
8131548Stitt82C+
8481689SN183C-9321548Si%183C-8321548SNI92C+
8481689SNIQ2C+
8321548SNIQ2C+
8481698Biitl82C+
9911619SN I 94C+913 I 548BiN I 94C+991 i 618SN i 94C+9811619SiNi83C-9811619SNIG C-913I54QSiitt83C-991161QSiNi I 91C-9391699Biitl92C+
919 i 61QSN I 82H+919 I 619Sil I 92H+819 i 619SN192H+
8191619SNI94H+
I I Q.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 8.7 8.7 1~8 8.8 8.8 So 8 8.8 8.8 8.9 8.8 8.8 8.7 Se8 8.8 8.8 Se8 S.Q 1.8 1.8 1.8 S.8 SiS 8.8 8.9 8.9 8.9 8,8 8.2 8.8 8.9 8.9 9.8 8.9 9.9 8.9 8.3 14.9 9.8 13.3 16.2 6.4 8.61 2.51 2.81 2.3 i 8.51 8.61 8.51 4.31 4.21 4.81 8.51 8.41 1.8 I 8.81 8.61 2.21 Ss 31 Q.91 55.41 53.61 43.31 1.41 1.5i 1.11 7a 61 7 41 5.81 9.51 Q.21 l.31 3.11 3.41 7.21 8.91 8.81 Q.81 1~81 1.8)Q.81 Q.5i 2.71 l.71 2.61 1.71 11.71 I 11531<28 I Yi31 11261 36l Il 11271 361N31 11281 361 ll I 1371 26 I N3 I 11341 281 1 I 1157IDBilN41 11141 47 I lit31 11121 481 11 I iii I 511N31 I 1491<29 I Yi3 I 11481<28 I iN31 11181 37 liN31 11431<28 1 N31 I 881 63IN31 11181 37 liN31 11581 49IN31 I 1571<281N3 I I 371 951 1 I I 361 95IN31 I 331 951 il 11461<28 i 11 11461<28IN31 11431<291 11 I 981 681 il I 991 681iN31 I 971 68t il 11431<29 IN31 11441<29 IN31 I 1)51 39 IN31 11141 48IN31 11891 53li%31 I 981 64li%31 11411 22 I M3 i 11421 221 1 i 11481 231 11 11411 221 1 I 11411 22 I i"i31 11411 22l 1 I I 157 i DS i I Yi4 I I 14i 29t 1 t I 191 291 1 I I 131 29i 11 I 131 281 11 I 291 281 1 i I I I I s
I CUNULATIVE RFPORT 81/87, ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE CO, PALO VERDE., STEAN GENERATOR:
1 I OCATIOV,: ALL CRiTERIA: 8%TO 188/, DSI UNIT 1 PAGE: DATE: TINE: 20F 2 82/87/87 QB:89:14 I I I I IEXTENT I I I I I RGWILIHIHEATIIILEGIREGIITSTIREiNIREFLIPROBEI I I I I I I I I I LOCATION I CURREilT I IVOLTSINILIDEGI
%ICHI I I I I I I I 751 541 I I I I I I I I I I I I 971 641 I 481 831 I 391 861 I 15711841 I 7111881 I 7211111 I I I I I I 111511241 I I I I 8811371 I 57 11581 I I I 118611651 I 111681 I 1 11781 I 111721 I 111741 I 411871 I 1 11881 I I I I I I I 511881 I I I I I I I 211891 I I I I I I I I I I I I 411891 I I I I C I C , I C I C I" C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C C I C I C I C C I C I C I C I C I C I C I C I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/Ll I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/Ll I IF/LIF/LIRiCI IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I 187HI87HI I 187HIF/LI I 187HIF/LI I 187HIF/LI I 187HIF/LI I 187HIF/LI I 187HIF/LI I 187HIF/LI I IF/LIF/LIRiCI IF/LIF/LIPIDI IF/LI87CI I 187HIF/LI I 187HIF/LIRPII 187HIF/LI I 187HIF/LI I 187HIF/LI I 187HIF/Ll I I I I I 815159QSiNI82C+
8151598SN I 81C+8151598SNI82C+
8151598SM181C+
815159SSN I 82C-816161SSiN I TSC+8831618SNI84H+
SQ31618SNISSH+
8"61688SiNI82H-826168QSNIVS5+
827168SSi%182H-82716QQSNI85H+
827168QSiNI81C+
8291688SMI86H+
8P9168QSNI86H+
831168QSNIQ2H+
847159QSNI84H+
8471S9QSMI83H+
8441618SN I BW2-841 168QSN I SPC+8411688SMI83C+
841168QSNISiC-841168SSM I 81C-8461688SNI85C-8411688SN185C-84116SQSiNIQ4C+
841 I 68SSi>1 I 83C+858159QSNI85C+
8511598SliIISSC+
8461688SMI85C+
841168QSNI86C-84il68SSNISSC+
841168QSN184C+
84116SQSiN184C-841168QSMI83C+
84616QQSNI84C+
I I 5.5 36.9 2.4 33.8 8.3 2e 2 15.4 23.9 1.7 1.3 8.8 3o 2 9.8 38.2 39.6 5.7 3.4 38.3 1.8 2.8 8.8 8.4 8.3 l.1 8.9 S.8 8.8 8.8 8o8 8.8 8.9 Se8 8.8 8.9 8.8 8.7 3.8 I 3.31 3.61 1.61 2.61 1.41 2.11 8.91 1.71 1.11 2.41 2.P I 1.11 1.71 2.81 2.81 2.31 4.41 1.21 1~21 S.31 S.41 8.8 I 8.11 8.61 8.91 8.41 8.41 Se 51 S.41 8.51 8.31 8.PI S.51 S.31 8.31 I I 181 281 il I 71 281 11 I Bl 281 1 I I 71<281 11 I 21<2QIN31 I 131<281 11 I 121<281 11 11321 321 11 I 71 28liN41 11131 34IN31 I 81 281 1 I I 61<281 11 I 71<281 11 I SI<281 11 I 71<281 11 11781<281 1 I I Bl 281 il I Bl 281 11 11581<PS I 1 I I 181 PS I 11 11381 22 IN31 11351 DSi I M41 1151 I DSI I N41 I 98 1 DSI INi31 11381 251M31 11281 28INi31 1117 I DSI I iN31 11151 37 liNi31 li84I 41IN31 I 991 53IN31 11261 27 INi31 liiil 431N31 I 941DSil 11 1157IDSi I 1 I 11441<28 I Ni31 11211 27 iii131 I I I I iHUiMBER OF TUBES SELECTED FRON CURRE'AT OUTAGE: MO TREiilD ANALYSiS REQUESTED Page A3 of CONAN
CUNULAT IVE REPORT Gl/87~ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE CO, PALO VERDE, STEAN GENERATOR:
2 LOCATION: ALL CRITERIA: 8/70 188/, DSI UNIT 1 PAGE: 1 OF 2 DATE: 82/GB/87 TINE: 89:15:41 I I I I IEXTENT I I I I I ROW I L IN I HEATS i LEG I REQ I TST I REN I REEL I PROBE I I I I I I I I I I I LOCATION I CURRENT I IVOLTSINILIDEGI 8 ICHI I I I I I I I 31 21 11471 681 I 381 791 11281 811 1125 I 821 I I I I I I I I I I 7711881 I 4811111 I 2611131 I I I I 9311281 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 118911221 118311261 111211271 I lSQ11P71 I i I I 4711561 I 211831 I I I 1911841 I I I I 21185 i I I I I 411851 I I I I 11186i I i I!I I I 211871 I I I I I I I 111881 I I I I I I I I I i I I i I I I I I I C I C I C 187H I F/L I I IF/LIF/LIRPII IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LIRPII IF/I IF/LIRPII IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LiF/LI i IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/Li I 187HI87HI I 187HIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I 187HIF/LI I 187HI87CI I IF/LIF/LI I IF/LIF/LI I 187HI87HI I 187H187Hi I 187H187HI I IQ7HI87CI I 187HIQ7CI I 187HIF/LIPIDI 187HIBW2IRPII 187H187HIRPII IQ7HIBVi2I I 187HI87HiRPII I87HIBN21 I 187HIG7HI I I I I I 8381688SNI82C-834161QSNI84H+
886161QSN184H+
827 i 68GSiN I 81H+8271688SNITSH+
82716GQSNI82H+
827168GSN183H+
827168GSi%186H+
818161 QSN187H+847159GSiNITSC+
884161QSNITEC+
8841618SNITEC+
8161618SN184H+
816161QSiN I 84H+8161618SMI84H+
816161GSiill86H+
816161QSNIVS7+
816i618SiNiVS7+
8161618SN I 86C+816161QSN I 86H+815161GSiN I 8 iC+8141618Siii I GSC+812161QSM I 83C+814161QSN183C+
811161GSN I TSC+882161QSil I 83C+GP5154QSNI83C+
8881618SiXIQSC+
GG8161QSNIQ4C+
8251548SiN184C+
8821618SN184C+
882161GSiiII84C+
QGB I 61QSN I 84C+826154GSiiil84C+
826154GSiiiI83C-826i54QSNIGPC+
8821618BNIQ2C+
882161QSNI82C+
825154QSi%182C-837168GSNI82C+
826154QSNI82C+
83716GGSiNIG2C-826154GSNI82C-83716GQSiil I 81C+826154GSiX I 8 IC+I I 8.2 39.2 11.7 11.8 14.5 P7.8 12.2 8.4 37.3 8.7 12.1 9.7 8.1 18.8 48.7 24.6 4.5 7.7 13.6 35'16.2 13.8 2.8 2.8 4.5 8.9 G.6 1~1 13.9 8.9 8.9 8.8 Q.8 8.9 Q.9 Q.G Qo8 Ge8 Ge5 8.9 Ge9 1.8 1.8 8.4 8,4 I I.I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I l.21 1.11 3.51 G.61 7.71 5.41 18.51 6.41 3.61 8.71 32.51 41.11 4.51 1.41 4.BI 2.61 3.71 18.71 i.71 2.61 4.91 3.91 8.71 8.71 1.61 G.41 8.81 3.41 1.11 1.21 8.8 I 8.51 8.51 8.91 1.11 2.8 I 6.51 6.31 8.61 12.71 12 41 3.21 2.41 4.91 3.31 I 11581 11171 I 121 11361 I 13i I ii I I 141 I Bl I 131 11741 I 281 I 3SI I 51 I 31 I 61 I 51 I 61 I 91 I 71 I 61 I 161 I 151 11451 11481 I 91 11861 11481 I 91 I 181 I 1521 11411 11431 1143i 11581 11531 I 1 421 11181 11851 11191 11191 11121 11341 11211 11581 11271 I I<281>%31 531 il PQ I 11 321 1 I 281 11 281 1 I PGI 11<281 11 281 11<281 11 84IN41 99IN41 281 11<281 11 281 11 281 11 281 11 281 11 281 11 281 11 281 11 281 11 251 11 261 11 PGI 11'SI I i%31 DSI I N31 281iN3 i 281 11<28liN31 DSI I iN41<281N31 2Q I iYi3 I<28iN31<28 I iii3 I 221N31 491 il 55 I ii131 48IN31 5GIN31 54IN31 34 I iNi3 I 46IN31<PGIN31<2GIN41 I I Page A4 of 5 COhlAM h I CUiviULAT iVE REPORT 81/87, ARiZONA PUBI IC SERViCE CO, PALO STEAN GENERATOR:
2 LOCATION: ALL CRiTERiA: 8%TO 188%, DSi VERDE, UNiT 1 PAGE: 2 OF 2 DATE: 82/88/87 TINE: 89: 15: 41 I I I I IEXTENT I I I I I ROW I L iiM I HEATS I LEG I REQ I TST I REiN I REEL I PROBE I I I I I I I I I I I LOCATION I CURRENT I I VOLTS liNiL IDES I/I CHI I I I I I I I 4 I 189 I I I I I I I I 6 I 1891 I I I I I I I I I I I I I C I87HI87CIRPII I C I87HI87CIRITI I C I87HIF/LIP?DI I C IF/LIF/LI I I C IF/LIF/LIRPII I C IF/LIF/LIRPil I C IF/LIF/LI I I I I I I 882I618SNI82C+
8.8 882I618SNI82C+
8.8 812 I 618SN I 82C-8.6 882 I 618SN I 82C+8.9 8121618Sivl I 82C+8.9 882I618SNI82C+
8.8 882I618SNI82C+
8.8 I I I 11.2 I I 11.4 I I 14.8l I 1.9l I 9m3I I 6.4I I 6.4I I I I 186 l 59IN3I I 951 64IN3I l1281 53IN3I I 125 I 33 I N3 I l127I 47IN3I~l114l 53IN3I l181I 58IN3I I I I I NUNBER OF TUBES SEL CTED FRON CURRENT OUTAGF: NO TREND ANALYSiS REQUESTED 23 Page A5 of 5 CONAN i)I,,
APPENDIX B Tubesheet Maps
]I STEAM GENERATOR:
2 DATE: 03/05/87 LOCATION: ALL CRITERIA: PLG Oi/87, ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE CO, PALO VERDE, UNIT i PROC: 73TI-9RC01 REV 0 TIME: 09: 37 STAY 160 150 140'rl fD pg 130 1~0 110 100 90 60 70 60 PLG 40 EVALUATED FIXTURE TEMPLATF 160 150 140 130 120 110 100 90 80~70 60 aO 30 50~0 30 10 20 10 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 CONAM (I
STEAH GENERATOR:
1 DATE: 03/04/87 LOCATION: ALL CRITERIA: PLG Oi/87, ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE CO, PALO VERDE, UNIT i PROC: 73TI-9RCOi REV 0 TINE: 13: 04 STAY 160 150 140 130 120 110 100--.---.---PLG 28 EVALUATEO FIXTORE TEHPLATE 160 150 140 130 120 110 100 90 90 eo 70 80~70 60 50 50 40 40 30 30 20 20 10 10 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 CONAH
,I Ji APPENDIX C Form NIS-1 f J t FORM NIS-1 OWNERS'ATA REPORT FOR INSERVICE INSPECTIONS OWNFR ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE, et al ADDRESS P.0.BOX 52034, PHOENIX, AZ 85072 2.PLANT PALO VERDE NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION ADDRESS 4 MILES SOUTH, WINTERSBURG, ARIZONA 3.UNIT NO.1 4.OWNERS CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION N/A 5.COMMERCIAL SERVICE DATE 1/28/86.6.COMPONENTS INSPECTED:
COMPONENT OF APPURTENANCE MANUFACTURER OR INSTALLER SERIAL NUMBER STATE OR PROVINCE NATIONAL BOARD NO ,IMRCEEOlA Steam Generator ll Tubing 1MRCEE01B Combustion Engineering 78273-1..NA 22499 Steam Generator 12 Tubing Combustion Engineering 78273-2'..NA 22500 PAGE 1 OF 2 I I I I I t I i c FORM NIS-1 (BACK)7.EXAM DATES 1/27/87702/6/87 8.INSP INTERVAL PROM1/28/86T01/27/96 9.ABSTRACT OF EXAMINATION.
INCLUDE A LIST OF EXANINATIONS AND A STATEiHENT COAVCERNIAVG STATUS OF WORK REQUIRED FOR CURRENT INTERVAL.A total of,3,590 tubes were examined in Steam Generator ll and a total of 3,426 tubes were examined in Steam Generator 12.10.ABSTRACT OF CONDITIONS NOTED.'Steam Generator ll: 'ourteen degraded tubes and seven defective tubes.Eight tubes showed significant denting that were not present on the baseline data.Sixteen tubes were not explanded into the tube sheet.Five tubes had indications of possible loose parts.Steam Generator 12: Thirteen degraded tubes and six defective tubes were identified.
Fourteen tubes were not explanded into the tubesheet and one tube had indications of a possible loose part.ll.ABSTRACT OF CORRECTIVE HEASURES.The following tubes were plugged as a result of this examination:
ROW COL ROW 2 1 39 4 1 1 1 2 4 3 2 1 2 3 5 1 4 2 3 4 4 1 S/G 11 COL ROM 86 1 170'1 187 1 188 1 188 1 189 189 50 COL 52 54 56 58 60 ROW 3 147 128 26 150 2 2 4 1 S/G 12 COL ROW COL , 2 2 187 60 1 188 81 2 189 113 4 189 127 6 189 183 185 185.186 WE CERTIFY THAT THE STATEHEViTS HADE IAV THIS REPORT EXAMINATIONS AVLD CORRECTIVE iiIEARSUES TAKEN CONFORM ASHE CODE, SECTION XI.DATE SIGVAED ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE ARE CORPXCT AND THE TO THE RULES OF THE CO CERTIFICATE OF IiVSERVICE INSPECTION I, the undersigned, holding a valid commission issued by the National Board of Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspectors and the State or Province of AZ employed by Kem er Grou of Long Grove IL have inspected the components described in this OWiNERS REPORT during the period 1/87 to 2/87 , and state that to the best of my knowledge and belief, the Owner has performed examinations and taken corrective measures described in this OWViERS REPORT in accordance with the requirements of the ASHE Code,Section XI.By signing this certificate neither the Inspector nor his employer makes any warranty, expressed or implied, concerning the examinations and corrective measures described in this OWVLERS REPORT.Furthermore; neither the Inspector nor his employer shall be liable in any manner for any personal injury or property damage or a loss of any kind arisi from or co n ed with this inspection.
IViSPECTOR Viat'1 Board, State, Province DATE~PAGE 2 OF 2 J I 1 l~t