ML18018B256

LER 78-024-00 for Nine Mile Point Unit 1 Regarding Discovery That Test N1-St-Q2,4,5,7,8,9, and 10 Had Not Been Performed During a Review of Quarterly Surveillance Test Results

ML18018B256
Person / Time
Site:	Nine Mile Point
Issue date:	06/21/1978
From:	Schneider R R Niagara Mohawk Power Corp
To:	Grier B H NRC Region 1
References
LER 78-024-00
Download: ML18018B256 (4)

Text

~+REGULATORY DISTRIBUTION FORVREC:GRIERBHNRCINFORMATION DISTRIBUTION'YSTEM INCOMINGMATERIALeORG:SCHNEIDER RRNIAGARAMOHAWKPWR(RIDS)0-220'DOCDATE:

06/2i/78DATERCVD:06/27/78DOCTYPE:LETTERNOTARIZED:

NOCOPIESRECEIVED

SUBJECT:

LTRiENCLiFORWARDING LICENSEEEVENTREPT(RO50-220/78-024)

ON06/i4/78CONCERNING REVIEWOFQUARTERLY SURVEILIANCETESTRESULTSFOUNI3THATTESTSNiST92't5s7i8s9ii0HADNOTBEENPERFORMED.

PLANTNAME:NINEMILEPT-UNITREVIEWERINITIAL:XJMDISTRIBUTOR INITIAL:~+++++++++++~~++++

DISTRIBUTION OFTI-IISMATERIALISASFOLLOWSINCIDENTREPORTS(DISTRIBUTION CODEA002)FORACTION:INTERNAL:

EXTERNAL:

BRCH.ORBN3BC++W/4ENCLREGFILE~/FNCL/2ENCLI8(CSYSTEMSBR4<W/ENCL NOVAK/CHECK+4W/ENCL ADFORENG4+W/ENCL HANAUER++W/ENCL AI3FORSYS4PROJ~+W/ENCL ENGINEERING BR++W/ENCL KREGER/J.

COLLINS<wW/ENCL KSEYFRIT/IE++W/ENCL LPDRSOSWEGO'Y+4W/ENCL TIC++W/ENCL NSIC4~W/ENCLACRSCATB~+W/16ENCLNRCPDR44W/ENCL MIPC+~W/3 ENCLEMERGENCY PLANBR<<W/ENCL EEB>+W/ENCL.

PLANTSYSTEMSBR<<W/ENCL ADFORPLANTSYSTEMS>+W/ENCL REACTORSAFETYBR+<W/ENCL VQLLMER/BUNCH>%W/ENCL POWERSYSBR4%W/ENCL DISTRIBUTION:

ITR45ENCL45SIZE:iP+iPCONTROLNBR:78i800023 THEEND MASTERROSTERPUBLIDATIONS[SIONEST~ZIPDISTRIBUTiIONCODESDISTRIBUTIONQTYDISTRIBUTION CODES1-17-~-m-'l-17--~-.'I18-34--~-II-----DISTRIBUTION CODES35-50--~-IDISTRIBUTION QTY.35-50-~-IQQQ+4+QQQQQQQ+~~~~~~~kg~~g~~~

~~~~~QQAgig+QQQ>gQQQQQgQQQQQQQQQ+QQ~~~~~~EFLIBRARIAN'-TAN325ECTORPEI106TAIWANTAIWANSNSRSFSESMSPSTSOSASG1111111111111111111L91111213Ic1516LTHPYSICSSEGW'IONCHU300TAIWANSNSRSFSESNSPSTSOSASG1711'9202122324iHICPOWERDEPARTMENT ECTOR.RETARYGENERALPEI106TAIWANSNSRSFSESHSPSTSOSASGN411111l1111252f2728283r3132333838373f3S40fPEI106GKOKTAIWANTHAILAND4144544454f4748495f5152RARYRARIANTENN-HN41CW1THENETHE57588L60el626364e5ee67eeVAKLIDEREANKAR'ATURKEY'CLEARENERGYDIVI.SION11111113.SNSRSFSESMSPSTSOSASGes0127374757i'iKARATURKEY NAP-0171NIAGARAMOHAWKPOWERCORPORATION/300 ERIEBOULEVARD WEST,SYRACUSE, N.Y.13202/TELEPHONE (315)474-1511June,21,1978h4..Boyce,H.Gru.e/L&alecto/L UnitedS~e5Nucleo/LRegulato/Ly Comm@a~onRegionI631PuckAvenueKmgo(PruLbaia, PA.19406RE:SocketNo.50-220Geo/Lh(/L.Gtu.e/L:gth()fC)lnacco/Ldance uLLthNineNlePointNuclemS~onUnit>1Technical Speci.pcation5, we,hunchyaubIktLicentee,Eve&Repo/Lt,LER78;24,wctu'chke inviolation eu'.hSe~on6.9.2.b(3) o(XheTec1uu,col Speei.pcatLon5.

TRQ/LepojLtwa5complied~nChefotunatde5Lgnated inNUREG-0161'ated July1977.VefcyWulyyouJth,ORIGINALSIGNEDBt/R.R.SCHNEIOER R.R.Schneide/L ViceP/Lu&eILt-Ele~cP/Loduction Encloau/Le (3cop~e5)xc:gi/Lento/L, 0(pceo(ISE(30cop~e5)Nrce&o/L, 0()meotIWIPC(3cop~e5)78l800O>p NRCI'ORM3GG(777)U.S.NUI'LI:AH HtuULAIOHYCIJIYII77IIbSILIIu

~OI78CON'T~o78CONTROLBLOCK:INYNNP9LICENSEECODE1415soURcEMLQG050002.2006061DOCKETNUMBER6869EVENTDESCRIPTION ANDPROBABLECONSEQUENCES QIOAreviewofquarterly surveillance tests61478QBO6217QBEVENTDATE7475REPORTDATE804resultsfound,thattestsLiCENSEE*EVENT REPORTQI(PLEASEPRINTORTYPEALLREQUIREDINFORMATIo~m'~

600000-00Q3411"11QR~QELICENSENUMBER2526LICENSETYPE3057CAT58Nl-ST-g2,4,5,7,8,9,10 hadnotbeen,performed.

TechSpec1.15allowsa+/-25percenttestinterval, however,thefailurewasdiscovered threedaysafterthisinterval.

Subsequent performance foundallGtestresultsweresatisfactory.

Thisconditi'on resultedinminimal~o7safetyimplications.

~OB78980~OB78SYSTEM'AUSECAUSECOAIP.VALVECODECODESUBCODECOMPONENT CODESUBCODESUBCODE~ZZQllAQ72~AQ13ZZZZZZ04~ZQEE~ZQls910111213181920SEQUENTIAL OCCURRENCE REPORTREVISIONLFREROEVENTYEARREPORTNO.CODETYPENO.Q17REERRE~70+~QZ4+~~03~L~~02122232426272829303132ACTION.FUTUREEFFECTSHUTDOWNATTACHMENT NPRD.4PRIMECOMP.COAIPONENT TAKENACTIONONPLANTMETHODHOURS+22SUBIEIITTED FORMSUB.SUPPLIERMANUFACTURER

~QQ18~NQER~ZQ25~ZQ270001~NQ23~NQ24~ZQ25Z999Qs3334353637404142434447CAUSEDESCRIPTION ANDCORRECTIVE ACTIONS27pThemastersurveillance scheduledidnotspecifically assignoneshifttoperformtests.Achangehasbeenmadetorequireallquarterly testsbeperformed onthe8-4shiftunlessplantconditions warrantre-assignment withpermission ofOperations Supervisor.

METHODOFDISCOVERY

~BQ3IReview4546NA45D.K.NacVittie NAMEOFPREPARER~l4789FACILITYSTATUS99POWEROTHERSTATUSQ~l5EQ28~099Q28NA78910121344ACTIVITYCONTENTRELEASEDOFRELEASEAMOUNTOFACTIVITYQ~ZQ3~ZQ34NA789101144PERSONNEL EXPOSURES NUMBERTYPEDESCRIPTION Q39~l7~000Q37ZQ38NA789111213PERSONNEL INJURIES7891112LOSSOFORDAMAGETOFACILITYQ43TYPEDESCRIPTION BZQ42NA78910PUBLICITY ISSUCDDESCRIPTION

~4KZLJNSNA8910DISCOVERY DESCRIPTION Q3280LOCATIONOFRELEASEQ3B80808080NRCUSEONLY80o686980o315-343-2110 ext.15580PHONE:L