Text

2012 Fermi Power Plant Initial License Examination Proposed Job Performance Measures
	ML12156A279
Person / Time
Site:	Fermi
Issue date:	03/29/2012
From:	Bielby M; Operations Branch III
To:	; Detroit Edison
Shared Package
ML11354A138	List: ML12156A279; ML12156A286; ML12156A295; ML12156A304; ML12156A313; ML12172A185;
References
	JP-OP-802-4101-406, Rev 2
	Download: ML12156A279 (131)
	v • d • e

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE Job Position No. Revision SRO / RO JP-OP-802-4101-406 2 JPM Title Duration Page Perform Thermal Limit Verification (MAPRAT) 15 minutes COVER SHEET Examinee: SRO/ RO/ NO/STA Evaluator:

JPM Type: Normal / Alternate Path / Time Critical Evaluation Method: Perform / Walkthrough / Discuss Start Time (Circle method used) Plant / Simulator / Classroom Stop Time Total Time:

PERFORMANCE EVALUATION

SUMMARY

Element S U Comments Element S U Comments 1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10. (SRO)

SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY OVERALL EVALUATOR COMMENTS:

Evaluator Signature / Date: /

Work Instruction WI 5.14 Job Performance Measures Rev 1 Attachment 1

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE JPM Title No.: JP-OP-802-4101-406 Perform Thermal Limit Verification (MAPRAT) Revision: 2 Page 1 Preferred Evaluation Method:

Perform X Walkthrough Discuss Plant Simulator Classroom X System:

N/A Task:

02A0006026 - Perform Shiftly, Daily, Weekly, and Situation Required Performance Evaluations.

References:

Required (R) / Available (A) 24.000.02, "Shiftly, Daily and Weekly Required Surveillances", Attachment 2 (p. 19 of 24) (R)

Tools and Equipment Required:

3DM Edit Printout Initial Conditions:

You are the Patrol NSO (RO) / CRS (SRO).

The STA has indicated that 3DM limits are reflective of the status of the MSR and BPVs.

There has been no TAU change. This is the latest 3DM edit.

Initiating Cue(s):

The CRS directs you to complete 24.000.02, Attachment 2, the Shifty/Daily Mode 1,2,3 Control Room Step 16, Core Thermal Limit Verification.

Terminating Cue(s):

Surveillance is complete (RO & SRO), and the appropriate Tech Spec and limiting time identified (SRO only).

Task Standard:

Perform Core Thermal Limit verification in accordance with 24.000.02 Attachment 2 (Step 16)

Licensed Operator Exam Information (required for NRC exams)

Safety Function:

N/A K/A

Reference:

(from NUREG 1123)

K/A SYSTEM: 293009 - Core Thermal Limits K/A STATEMENT:

GENERIC 2.1.7 - Ability to evaluate plant performance and make operational judgments based on operating characteristics / reactor behavior / and instrument interpretation. ............................... 4.4 / 4.7 Maintenance Rule Safety Classification:

N/A Maintenance Rule Risk Significant? (Yes or No)

N/A Work Instruction WI 5.14 Job Performance Measures Rev 1 Attachment 1

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE JPM Title No.: JP-OP-802-4101-406 Perform Thermal Limit Verification (MAPRAT) Revision: 2 Page 2 PERFORMANCE EVALUATION Start Time ELEMENT STANDARD CUE: Provide Examinee with CUE SHEET, a copy of 24.000.02, and 3DM edit. State that all communications will be directed to the appropriate individual(s) and you will respond.

1. [16.b.2)a)] Verify LPRMs are not failed 1. Verifies there are no failed LPRMs or (except for Bypassed LPRMs) and no other sensors shown on the 3DM edit.

other sensors are failed which affect the Heat Balance.

2. [16.b.2)b)] Verify Flow basis is "MEAS". 2. Verifies Flow basis is "MEAS".

3. [16.b.2)c)] If failed sensors exist (other 3. Verifies no other failed sensors exist on than Bypassed or PANACEA-rejected the 3DM edit.

LPRMs) or the flow basis is not "MEAS,"

consult with the STA/SNE for appropriate action before continuing.

4. [16.b.3)] Place a check in items a and b 4. Checks blocks "a" and "b". The review is when the review is satisfactory or when satisfactory.

discrepancies are resolved and logged by the STA/SNE.

5. [16.b.4)] Record Calculated Date and 5. Records Date and Time and verify Time (items c and d) of the Core Monitor complete within the last 24 hours2.777778e-4 days 0.00667 hours 3.968254e-5 weeks 9.132e-6 months Periodic Log and verify complete in last 24 hours2.777778e-4 days 0.00667 hours 3.968254e-5 weeks 9.132e-6 months

6. [16.b.5)] Record the listed parameters 6. Records CTP and Thermal Limit values.

(items e h) as they appear on the Core Monitor Periodic Log CUE: Acknowledge report that TS is not met.

7. Identifies that MAPRAT is > 1.0.

7. Notifies CRS that TS is not being met.

Thermal Limits are being exceeded.

8. Initial block.

8. Initials should NOT be signed as Acceptance Criteria is NOT met.

Candidate should place a Circled Number in the INITIALS BLOCK.

9. Candidate places a Numbered Note in the 9. Numbered Note is placed in REMARKS REMARKS Section . Section. (1E: Note 1 - Step 16.b MAPRAT

> 1.0 SM/CRS/RE notified.)

CUE: For SRO candidate, inform them they are now the CRS and ask what action is required.

10. Identify the appropriate TS and limiting *10. Reports that TS 3.2.1 APLHGR Condition time. (SRO only) A.1 is not met and must be restored within 2 hours2.314815e-5 days 5.555556e-4 hours 3.306878e-6 weeks 7.61e-7 months .

CUE: End JPM when surveillance is complete (RO) and TS and limiting time is identified (SRO).

SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Stop Time

Critical Step Work Instruction WI 5.14 Job Performance Measures Rev 1 Attachment 1

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE JPM Title No.: JP-OP-802-4101-406 Perform Thermal Limit Verification (MAPRAT) Revision: 2 Page 3 Evaluator Notes:

This JPM may be performed in the plant, simulator, or classroom.

Obtain a current 3DM printout.

ENSURE ALL INDUSTRIAL AND PERSONNEL SAFETY PRACTICES ARE USED AND ENFORCED AT ALL TIMES.

Generic Notes and Cues:

CMC switches will turn RED and amperage will increase when the switch is rotated to the start position started. The current should initially be five to seven times the normal running amps with the ammeter flashing. As counter EMF is developed, the amperage will lower to the normal running amperage and the ammeter will no longer flash. CMC switches will turn GREEN when the pumps are stopped and amperage will decrease to zero.

Ex.: Pump start: "Switch has been rotated to the start position, red light is lit, green light is out, amperage initially pegs out high, and is now indicating X amps."

Pump stop: "Switch has been rotated to the stop position, green light is lit, red light is out, amperage indicates 0 amps."

Remotely operated valve position is determined with open and close indicating lights. A RED light only would indicate that the valve is open. A GREEN light only would indicate that the valve is closed. Dual indication would indicate that the valve is in some intermediate position.

Manual valves are checked in the closed direction (M0P02 and MOP05). Valve stem position may aid in valve position determination, but cannot be used as Independent Verification (M0P02).

Ex.: Verify valve closed: "Valve handwheel indicates no valve movement in the clockwise direction."

Verify valve open: "Valve handwheel has been rotated slightly in the clockwise direction and returned to the original positions."

Closing a valve: "Valve handwheel has been rotated in the fully clockwise direction until no additional valve movement. Valve stem is down."

Opening a valve: "Valve handwheel has been rotated in the fully counterclockwise direction until no additional valve movement, valve stem is out."

Controllers have an Auto light that is GREEN when selected and AMBER (YELLOW) when Manual is selected. When in Manual, the open and closed pushbuttons control the parameter to be changed by adjusting position or speed. When the deviation meter is nulled, then the process can be shifted to Auto to allow the desired setpoint to control the process.

System Specific Notes and Cues:

NONE Task Performance and Cues:

The Elements of this JPM are step by step in accordance with the procedure. The Standard is that the procedure is performed as written. The Cues are as listed above for indication or as each step is completed the appropriate information is reported to the examinee. Notify Examinee that time compression may be used for activities performed outside of the Control Room.

Critical Steps:

Critical Tasks are identified by asterisk (*) and bolded steps on the cover sheet. Verify that the latest revision of the procedure is used and critical tasks are correctly identified.

Work Instruction WI 5.14 Job Performance Measures Rev 1 Attachment 1

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE JPM Title No.: JP-OP-802-4101-406 Perform Thermal Limit Verification (MAPRAT) Revision: 2 Page 4 FOLLOW-UP DOCUMENTATION QUESTIONS Reason for follow-up question(s):

Question:

Reference:

Response

Question:

Reference

Response

Work Instruction WI 5.14 Job Performance Measures Rev 1 Attachment 1

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE JPM Title No.: JP-OP-802-4101-406 Perform Thermal Limit Verification (MAPRAT) Revision: 2 Page 5 Simulator Setup IC#:

N/A Malfunctions:

Number Title Value Delay Ramp N/A Remote Functions:

Number Title Value Delay Ramp N/A Override Functions:

Number Title Value Delay Ramp N/A Special Instructions:

N/A Work Instruction WI 5.14 Job Performance Measures Rev 1 Attachment 1

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE Cue Sheet (JP-OP-802-4101-406)

Initial Conditions:

You are the Patrol NSO.

The STA has indicated that 3DM limits are reflective of the status of the MSR and BPVs.

There has been no TAU change. This is the latest 3DM edit.

Initiating Cue(s):

The CRS directs you to complete 24.000.02, Attachment 2, the Shifty/Daily Mode 1,2,3 Control Room Step 16, Core Thermal Limit Verification.

TRAINING USE ONLY PAGE 1 FERMI CYCLE 15 SEQUENCE NO 11 CORE PARAMETERS 3DM/P11 TODAY 09:00 CALCULATED POWER MWT 3430. PERIODIC LOG TODAY 09:01 PRINTED POWER MWE 1134. AUTOMATIC CASE ID FMLD1050609105759 FLOW MLB/HR 92.266 CALC RESULTS RESTART FMLD1050609095759 FPADPR 0.905 LPRM SHAPE - FULL CORE SUBC BTU/LB 21.97 Keff 1.0026 PR PSIa 1040.78 XE WORTH % -2.33 LOAD LINE

SUMMARY

CORE MWD/sT 23998.7 XE/RATED 1.02 CORE POWER 100.0%

CYCLE MWD/sT 3997.3 AVE VF 0.469 CORE FLOW 92.3%

MCPR 1.628 LOAD LINE 104.9%

CORRECTION FACTOR: MFLCPR= 1.000 MFLPD= 1.000 MAPRAT= 1.000 OPTIONS: ARTS 2 LOOPS ON MANUAL FLOW MCPRLIM= 1.350 MOST LIMITING LOCATIONS (NON-SYMMETRIC)

MFLCPR LOC MFLPD LOC MAPRAT LOC PCRAT LOC 0.829 29-10 0.985 51 4 1.008 51 4 1.011 9 5 0.826 9-30 0.975 33 5 0.975 33 5 1.006 9 5 0.814 29-14 0.955 51 4 0.925 51 5 1.006 13 5 0.812 13-30 0.867 51 5 0.900 41 5 1.006 11 5 0.805 27-12 0.862 53 5 0.747 51 4 1.005 7 5 0.803 11-28 0.861 41 5 0.747 37 5 1.005 27 3 0.796 27-10 0.861 31 5 0.743 51 5 1.004 7 5 0.790 9-28 0.854 53 4 0.742 53 5 1.004 13 4 0.786 25-10 0.854 37 5 0.734 31 5 1.003 19 4 0.785 9-26 0.849 51 5 0.727 47 5 1.003 23 4 SEQ. A002 C=MFLCPR D=MFLPD M=MAPRAT P=PCRAT *=MULTIPLE CORE AVE AXIAL NOTCH REL PW LOC 0.110 25 00 0.244 24 02 0.582 23 L 04 0.780 22 55 06 0.835 21 51 08 0.902 20 L 10 0.927 19 47 06 06 12 0.934 18 43 P 14 0.953 17 L 16 1.015 16 39 06 10 06 18 1.049 15 35 20 1.103 14 L

22 1.152 13 31 10 10 M 24 1.190 12 27 26 1.203 11 L 28 1.219 10 23 06 10 06 30 1.269 09 19 32 1.312 08 L 34 1.335 07 15 06 06 36 1.405 06 11 C 38 1.449 05 L 40 1.382 04 07 42 1.280 03 03 44 1.008 02 L L L L L L L 46 0.362 01 02 06 10 14 18 22 26 30 34 38 42 46 50 54 58 CORE AVERAGE RADIAL POWER DISTRIBUTION RING # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 REL PW 1.123 1.259 1.138 1.202 1.123 1.261 1.087 0.497 Page 2

TRAINING USE ONLY FERMI CYCLE 12 INSTRUMENT READINGS/STATUS SEQUENCE NO 11 CALIBRATED LPRM READINGS TODAY 09:00 CALCULATED TODAY 09:01 PRINTED 57 D 20.0 26.5 26.3 22.3 CASE IS FMLD1050609105759 C 23.8 32.2 31.1 29.2 LPRM SHAPE - FULL CORE B 26.0 38.8 40.0 35.3 A 23.3 41.5 39.0 37.5 FAILED SENSORS 49 D 20.7 27.9 30.1 30.3 29.7 24.7 LPRM ( 0 SIGNALS FAILED)

C 25.8 40.6 40.7 38.7 39.6 25.8 LPRM ( 0 PANACEA REJECTED)

B 28.9 49.3 49.8 53.9 50.6 43.7 OTHER SENSORS ( 0 TOTAL )

A 27.4P 58.9 56.9 63.8 62.1 52.3 SUB RODS NONE 41 D 26.2 29.7 31.9 34.2 30.2 28.8 22.5 C 35.9 39.5 42.4 40.5 40.2 38.7 30.2 B 46.8 48.9 53.2 52.8 53.2 50.5 36.6 A 64.8 55.0 53.7 52.7 60.6 63.4 39.4 T = T I P RUN RECOMMENDED 33 D 28.1 32.0 35.9 34.5 35.5 31.4M 25.3 C = MFLCPR LOCATION C 40.2 42.8 41.1 42.5 41.8 43.3 36.3 M = MAPRAT LOCATION B 50.7 53.7 50.4 50.3 53.4 55.0 43.2 D = MFLPD LOCATION A 69.7 56.9 50.7 58.9 53.7 43.4 41.0 P = PCRAT LOCATION

= MULTIPLE LIMIT 25 D 28.4 31.7 34.7 35.4 31.3 28.9 25.6 C 39.1 43.0 44.6 40.9 41.5 38.8 32.6 B 51.1 53.1 56.7 52.0 52.9 51.1 39.5 A 66.0 51.2 56.4 50.8 57.7 51.2 44.1 17 D 22.1 30.7 31.8C 32.9 29.4 26.9 19.4 C 31.2 41.7 43.7 44.0 38.4 39.3 23.7 B 40.1 53.4 54.3 54.6 49.4 49.8 26.0 A 51.7 61.6 49.6 54.8 58.5 61.5 24.6 09 D 23.6 28.9 29.5 26.8 21.1 C 39.3 39.6 41.6 38.6 25.5 B 42.4 50.6 51.4 47.6 28.8 A 51.6 64.7 66.3 63.0 28.0 08 16 24 32 40 48 56 CORE

SUMMARY

CORE POWER 100 % CALC SUB FLOW 94.1% DP MEAS PSI 13.681 CORE FLOW 92.3 % OPER SUB FLOW -1.0% DP CALC PSI 18.836 LOAD LINE 104.9 % FLOW BASIS MEAS FEEDWTR FLOW MLB/HR 14.81 APRM CALIBRATION 1 2 3 4 READING 99.9 99.9 99.8 99.9 AGAF 1.001 1.001 1.002 1.001 APRM - %CTP -0.1 -0.1 -0.2 -0.1 TIP RUNS RECOMMENDED STRINGS : NONE

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE Job Position No. Revision SRO / RO JP-OP-802-4101-408 3 JPM Title Duration Page Perform Drywell Air Temperature Calculations 20 minutes COVER SHEET Examinee: SRO / RO Evaluator:

JPM Type: Normal / Alternate Path / Time Critical Evaluation Method: Perform / Walkthrough / Discuss Start Time (Circle method used) Plant / Simulator / Classroom Stop Time Total Time:

PERFORMANCE EVALUATION

SUMMARY

Element S U Comments Element S U Comments 1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY OVERALL EVALUATOR COMMENTS:

Evaluator Signature / Date: /

Work Instruction WI 5.14 Job Performance Measures Rev 1 Attachment 1

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE JPM Title No.: JP-OP-802-4101-408 Perform Drywell Air Temperature Calculations Revision: 3 Page 1 Preferred Evaluation Method:

Perform X Walkthrough Discuss Plant Simulator Classroom X System:

N/A Task:

02A0006026 - Perform Shiftly, Daily, Weekly, and Situation Required Performance Evaluations

References:

Required (R) / Available (A) 24.000.02, Shiftly, Daily, And Weekly Required Surveillances (R) 24.000.02, Shiftly, Daily, And Weekly Required Surveillances, Attachment 2, Page 15 of 24 (R) 29.ESP.01, 14.0 Drywell Temperature Calculation (A)

Tools and Equipment Required:

None Initial Conditions:

You are the Control Room NSO.

The plant is operating at 100% power.

Initiating Cue(s):

It is Sunday morning at 0200.

You are in the process of completing Attachment 2 of 24.000.02, "Shiftly, Daily, And Weekly Required Surveillances."

You are to complete Step 13 of Attachment 2.

Terminating Cue(s):

24.000.02, Shiftly, Daily, And Weekly Required Surveillances, Attachment 2, Page 14 and 15 of 23 is complete.

Task Standard:

Calculation of Drywell Air Temperature in accordance with Attachment 2 of 24.000.02, "Shiftly, Daily And Weekly Required Surveillances."

Work Instruction WI 5.14 Job Performance Measures Rev 1 Attachment 1

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE JPM Title No.: JP-OP-802-4101-408 Perform Drywell Air Temperature Calculations Revision: 3 Page 2 Licensed Operator Exam Information (required for NRC exams)

Safety Function/Category:

10. Emergency Plant Evolutions K/A

Reference:

(from NUREG 1123)

K/A SYSTEM: Generic 2.1 - Conduct of Operations K/A STATEMENT:

2.1.7 Ability to evaluate plant performance and make operational judgments based on operating characteristics/reactor behavior/and instrument interpretation. .................................... 3.7 / 4.4 2.1.18 Ability to make accurate/clear and concise logs/records/status boards/and reports .... 2.9 / 3.0 2.1.33 Ability to recognize indications for system operating parameters which are entry-level conditions for technical specifications ........................................................................... 3.4 / 4.0 Maintenance Rule Safety Classification:

N/A Maintenance Rule Risk Significant? (Yes or No)

N/A Work Instruction WI 5.14 Job Performance Measures Rev 1 Attachment 1

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE JPM Title No.: JP-OP-802-4101-408 Perform Drywell Air Temperature Calculations Revision: 3 Page 3 PERFORMANCE EVALUATION Start Time ELEMENT STANDARD CUE: Provide Examinee with CUE SHEET and pages 14 and 15 of 24.000.02, Attachment 2.

CUE: When the Examinee describes the locations of Drywell Air Temperature recorders T47-R803A and T47-R803B, give the Examinee the sample printout to perform the calculations.

1. [13.a] Record Drywell Air Temperatures 1. Values are recorded for Drywell Air from T47-R803A and T47-R803B. Temperatures from T47-R803A and T47-R803B points 1 through 23.

2. [13.b] Record Drywell Cooling System 2. Drywell Cooling System Area Area Temperatures Div 1 and 2 Temperatures Div 1 and 2 Recorders Recorders T47-R803A and B, Point 24 T47-R803A and B, Point 24 are recorded

3. [13.b] Calculate and record:

3. Properly calculate and record the T47-R803A versus T47-R803B Abs following:

Difference [A-B] or [B-A]. T47-R803A versus T47-R803B Abs T47-R803A/B Point 24 Average Difference [A-B] or [B-A].

[(A + B) / 2 = C]. T47-R803A/B Point 24 Average

[(A + B) / 2 = C]. (0)

4. [13.c] Determine Drywell Average 4. Determine Drywell Average Volumetric Volumetric Temperature on Sunday or Temperature on Sunday or every 24 every 24 hours2.777778e-4 days 0.00667 hours 3.968254e-5 weeks 9.132e-6 months if recorder averaging is hours if recorder averaging is suspect.

suspect.

5. [13.c] From Step 13.0a, add points

5. Points below are calculated correctly.

indicated below and perform calculations:

Sum of Points 8 through 9 Sum of Points 8 through 9

/ 4* x 0.349 [A] 395 / 4* x 0.349 [A] (34.5)

Sum of Points 10 through 11 Sum of Points 10 through 11

/ 4* x 0.204 [B] 570 / 4* x 0.204 [B] (29.1)

Sum of Points 13 Sum of Points 13

/ 2* x 0.039 [C] 273 / 2* x 0.039 [C] (5.3)

Sum of Points 15through 16 Sum of Points 15through 16

/ 4* x 0.024 [D] 585 / 4* x 0.024 [D] (3.5)

Sum of Points 17 throughl8 Sum of Points 17 throughl8

/ 4* x 0.078 [E] 755 / 4* x 0.078 [E] (14.7)

Sum of Points 19 through 23 Sum of Points 19 through 23

/ 10* x 0.306 [F] 1129 / 10* x 0.306 [F] (34.5)

Drywell Average Volume Drywell Average Volume Temperature Temperature

[A+B+C+D+E+F+G] [A+B+C+D+E+F+G] (125.6)

6. [13.c] Record the following: 6. Drywell Average Volumetric Temperature Drywell Average Volumetric Temperature (from Step 13.0 c) [D] is recorded (from Step 13.0 c) [D] correctly (125.6)

Work Instruction WI 5.14 Job Performance Measures Rev 1 Attachment 1

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE JPM Title No.: JP-OP-802-4101-408 Perform Drywell Air Temperature Calculations Revision: 3 Page 4 ELEMENT STANDARD

7. [13.b] Calculate the following:

7. Recorder Average versus Step 13.0 c Abs Recorder Average versus Step 13.0 c Abs Difference [C-D] or [D-C] is calculated Difference [C-D] or [D-C] correctly (0.1)

8. Initials Step 13.0 b and 13.0 c 8. Step 13.0 b and 13.0 c are initialed

9. Verify Acceptance Criteria met. 9. Meets the following:

1) 145°F.

2) Each individual recorder, T47-R803A and T47-R803B, trends consistent with plant conditions, outside ambient temperature, and applicable cooling water source(s).

3) On Sunday, verify T47-R803A and T47-R803B average agrees within 2.0°F of Calculated Drywell Average Volumetric Temperature using Step 13.0 c.

CUE: End JPM when 24.000.02, Shiftly, Daily, And Weekly Required Surveillances, Attachment 2, Page 14 and 15 of 23 is complete.

SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Stop Time

Critical Step Work Instruction WI 5.14 Job Performance Measures Rev 1 Attachment 1

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE JPM Title No.: JP-OP-802-4101-408 Perform Drywell Air Temperature Calculations Revision: 3 Page 5 Evaluator Notes: