ML071570118: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Created page by program invented by StriderTol
StriderTol Bot change
 
Line 18: Line 18:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:iRort Palla - Cost Benefit Equation Terms                                                             .....        Page 1 From:               Robert Palla To:               jojones@sandia.gov Date:               05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM
{{#Wiki_filter:iRort Palla - Cost Benefit Equation Terms Page 1 From:
Robert Palla To:
jojones@sandia.gov Date:
05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Cost Benefit Equation Terms Joe - I am not sure whether I had provided you with this table previously. Itshows how each of the terms in the cost benefit equation are derived, and their relative significance for Pilgrim. Bob CC:                 nbixler@sandia.gov
Cost Benefit Equation Terms Joe - I am not sure whether I had provided you with this table previously. It shows how each of the terms in the cost benefit equation are derived, and their relative significance for Pilgrim. Bob CC:
 
nbixler@sandia.gov
1.C':\t6&#xfd;ip\GW)00001.&#xfd;&#xfd;T&#xfd;&#xfd;&#xfd;'M''P&#xfd;-'                                                                         -P-aiWi11 1<
: 1. C':\\t6&#xfd;ip\\GW)00001.&#xfd;&#xfd;T&#xfd;&#xfd;&#xfd;'M''P&#xfd;-'
Page Ic:\te1~n p\GW}OOQOl .TMP Mail Envelope Properties     (46557288.5A6 :18 :10412)
-P-aiWi 11 I c:\\te1~n p\\GW}OOQOl.TMP Page 1<
Mail Envelope Properties (46557288.5A6 :18 :10412)


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Cost Benefit Equation Terms Creation Date          05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM From:                  Robert Palla Created By:            RLP3 (@l)nrc.gov Recipients                                       Action              Date & Time sandia.gov                                       Transferred          05/24/2007 7:10:30 AM jojones (ioiones(asandia.gov) nbixler CC (nbixler(asandia.gov)
Creation Date From:
Post Office                                         Delivered         Route sandia.gov Files                           Size               Date & Time MESSAGE                          505                05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM Cost benefit equation and description of terms.wpd 9603               02/21/2007 11:13:12 AM Options Auto Delete:                     No Expiration Date:                 None Notify Recipients:               Yes Priority:                       Standard ReplyRequested:                 No Return Notification:             None Concealed  
Created By:
Cost Benefit Equation Terms 05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM Robert Palla RLP3 (@l)nrc.gov Recipients sandia.gov AM jojones (ioiones(asandia.gov) nbixler CC (nbixler(asandia.gov)
Action Transferred Date & Time 05/24/2007 7:10:30 Post Office Delivered Route sandia.gov Files Size MESSAGE 505 Cost benefit equation and description of terms.wpd AM Date & Time 05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM 9603 02/21/2007 11:13:12 Options Auto Delete:
Expiration Date:
Notify Recipients:
Priority:
ReplyRequested:
Return Notification:
Concealed  


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
No Security:                       Standard To Be Delivered:                 Immediate Status Tracking:                 Delivered & Opened
Security:
To Be Delivered:
Status Tracking:
No None Yes Standard No None No Standard Immediate Delivered & Opened


                                                                                                                                                  .3 4
.3 4
Net Value = (APE + AOC + AOE + AOSC) - COE, where APE     = averted public exposure costs AOC    = averted offsite property damage costs AOE    = averted occupational exposure costs AOSC    = averted onsite costs averted cleanup and decontamination costs (ACC) + averted replacement power costs (ARPC)
Net Value = (APE + AOC + AOE + AOSC) - COE, where APE  
COE-      cost of enhancement Cost     Significance   NUREG/BR-                           Related Parameters                       Value If All Internally-Initiated Core Factor                     0184 Section                                                                     Damage Events at Pilgrim Are Eliminated APE     Offsite exposure     5.7.1     AP-Rem (from MACCS2)                                                             $314K AOC     Offsite economic     5.7.5     AOffsite Economic Cost Risk - OECR (from MACCS2)                                 $566K From 12/12/2006 Entergy letter, Attachment C, Table E. 1-15:
=
                                        - CAPB-12: $4.85E6/event
AOC
                                        - CAPB-14: $4.96E9/event
=
                                        - CAPB-15: $18.0E9/event
AOE
                                        - frequency-weighted sum for all CAPBs = $8.21 E9/event From NUREG/BR-0184, Table 5.6 (1990$ costs, within 50 miles):
=
                                        - average for all NUREG-1 150 plants = $2.46E8/event -
AOSC =
                                        - highest NUREG-1 150 plant (Peach Bottom) = $2.71 E9/event AOE     Onsite exposure     5.7.3     Immediate occupational dose (3,300 P-Rem)                                           $2K Long term occupational dose (20,000 P-Rem)
COE-averted public exposure costs averted offsite property damage costs averted occupational exposure costs averted onsite costs averted cleanup and decontamination costs (ACC) + averted replacement power costs (ARPC) cost of enhancement Cost Significance NUREG/BR-Related Parameters Value If All Internally-Initiated Core Factor 0184 Section Damage Events at Pilgrim Are Eliminated APE Offsite exposure 5.7.1 AP-Rem (from MACCS2)  
ACC     Onsite economic     5.7.6.1   Onsite cleanup and decontamination cost ($1.1E9.single event, PW)                 $76K ARPC     Onsite economic     5.7.6.2   Plant power level.                                                                 $51 K}}
$314K AOC Offsite economic 5.7.5 AOffsite Economic Cost Risk - OECR (from MACCS2)  
$566K From 12/12/2006 Entergy letter, Attachment C, Table E. 1-15:
- CAPB-12: $4.85E6/event
- CAPB-14: $4.96E9/event
- CAPB-15: $18.0E9/event
- frequency-weighted sum for all CAPBs = $8.21 E9/event From NUREG/BR-0184, Table 5.6 (1990$ costs, within 50 miles):
- average for all NUREG-1 150 plants = $2.46E8/event -
- highest NUREG-1 150 plant (Peach Bottom) = $2.71 E9/event AOE Onsite exposure 5.7.3 Immediate occupational dose (3,300 P-Rem)  
$2K Long term occupational dose (20,000 P-Rem)
ACC Onsite economic 5.7.6.1 Onsite cleanup and decontamination cost ($1.1E9.single event, PW)  
$76K ARPC Onsite economic 5.7.6.2 Plant power level.  
$51 K}}

Latest revision as of 23:21, 14 January 2025

E-MAIL: (NPA-PD) Cost Benefit Equation Terms
ML071570118
Person / Time
Site: Pilgrim
Issue date: 05/24/2007
From: Palla R
NRC/NRR/ADES
To: Jackie Jones
Sandia
References
TAC MD3698
Download: ML071570118 (3)


Text

iRort Palla - Cost Benefit Equation Terms Page 1 From:

Robert Palla To:

jojones@sandia.gov Date:

05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM

Subject:

Cost Benefit Equation Terms Joe - I am not sure whether I had provided you with this table previously. It shows how each of the terms in the cost benefit equation are derived, and their relative significance for Pilgrim. Bob CC:

nbixler@sandia.gov

1. C':\\t6ýip\\GW)00001.ýýTýýý'MPý-'

-P-aiWi 11 I c:\\te1~n p\\GW}OOQOl.TMP Page 1<

Mail Envelope Properties (46557288.5A6 :18 :10412)

Subject:

Creation Date From:

Created By:

Cost Benefit Equation Terms 05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM Robert Palla RLP3 (@l)nrc.gov Recipients sandia.gov AM jojones (ioiones(asandia.gov) nbixler CC (nbixler(asandia.gov)

Action Transferred Date & Time 05/24/2007 7:10:30 Post Office Delivered Route sandia.gov Files Size MESSAGE 505 Cost benefit equation and description of terms.wpd AM Date & Time 05/24/2007 7:10:00 AM 9603 02/21/2007 11:13:12 Options Auto Delete:

Expiration Date:

Notify Recipients:

Priority:

ReplyRequested:

Return Notification:

Concealed

Subject:

Security:

To Be Delivered:

Status Tracking:

No None Yes Standard No None No Standard Immediate Delivered & Opened

.3 4

Net Value = (APE + AOC + AOE + AOSC) - COE, where APE

=

AOC

=

AOE

=

AOSC =

COE-averted public exposure costs averted offsite property damage costs averted occupational exposure costs averted onsite costs averted cleanup and decontamination costs (ACC) + averted replacement power costs (ARPC) cost of enhancement Cost Significance NUREG/BR-Related Parameters Value If All Internally-Initiated Core Factor 0184 Section Damage Events at Pilgrim Are Eliminated APE Offsite exposure 5.7.1 AP-Rem (from MACCS2)

$314K AOC Offsite economic 5.7.5 AOffsite Economic Cost Risk - OECR (from MACCS2)

$566K From 12/12/2006 Entergy letter, Attachment C, Table E. 1-15:

- CAPB-12: $4.85E6/event

- CAPB-14: $4.96E9/event

- CAPB-15: $18.0E9/event

- frequency-weighted sum for all CAPBs = $8.21 E9/event From NUREG/BR-0184, Table 5.6 (1990$ costs, within 50 miles):

- average for all NUREG-1 150 plants = $2.46E8/event -

- highest NUREG-1 150 plant (Peach Bottom) = $2.71 E9/event AOE Onsite exposure 5.7.3 Immediate occupational dose (3,300 P-Rem)

$2K Long term occupational dose (20,000 P-Rem)

ACC Onsite economic 5.7.6.1 Onsite cleanup and decontamination cost ($1.1E9.single event, PW)

$76K ARPC Onsite economic 5.7.6.2 Plant power level.

$51 K