ML20236B854

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Motion on Notification of Meetings,Establishment of Seismic Review Committee & Govt Exam of Design Calculations.* Motion Undated
ML20236B854
Person / Time
Site: Diablo Canyon, 05000000
Issue date: 07/21/1987
From: Eissler F
SCENIC SHORELINE PRESERVATION CONFERENCE, INC.
To:
NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
Shared Package
ML20236A877 List: ... further results
References
FOIA-87-214 OL, NUDOCS 8707290259
Download: ML20236B854 (3)
v • d • e


Text

-

lllCLEN.. liGUL.*JunY CC;;UIESICN 4 o f- -r, N N

.- .-. -- . h In the .:atter of ' u\ "

f

_a 6-Locket !;os.

PACIFIC CAS AUD LLECTRIC Co. )) 50-275/323-0.L.} AF I, 1N)

- , , .. . s .. . .-v Diablo .anyon. Unf.tc 1 atd 2 s.. .j '

n v o

!!GTIO : 'd !!OT".?ICATION T !!!ETII:C'h ESTAILIS!!!:ENT OF A SEIFlfIC REMg CO!!1 TIT'4*;E. Al;D Co1LE!IMf:.T EXA*!INATIN: CF CESIC11 CALClfDJ10NS

1. Sc mic S.b:eline har learned of a necting betucen representatives e

of Paci!ic and HRC sched.ilcd in San Francisco inst ucck on the subject of scis2!.c man:ers. The uccting uan nu: announced to interveners and ucs evi1cntif closcd to the public and the press. 8 It is our unccr..

standin,; that a decisica var made to call upon ?!r. Nathan 1:cumerk to attcapt to raconcile interagency and Pacific differences over the scisode ir:pli:ntims of the Itoscri Fault.

On Fcbruary 10, 1976, tim. Scn Luis Obispo !!:thers fer Peacc for-warded : Ictter to !!:s.1)cucrs requceting informally that staff bc rcninds' to obscr.sc its agreecent for early notification of such meetir.p. Since bis mactinc of icot ucek is not thn f t: st occccion of fa?.inre ef pro.ccr notificaticr; to all partics, uc herebj st2bmit an a forn

  • motion that c'1 teetir.gs en geologi:21.scismic cmd other n2ttero be rubject to carly notification and that tl.ccc mectings ba open tc the press sad interccted parties. tic further requer,t that the minutes of the aforementioned r.ccting of last ucch be forwarded to all partier.
2. Ifc c1so would like to raisc questions about the advisability.of appointius !!r.1:ctraark as the arbiter of differences betucen agencies on Geological-ceismic mattere.

1:r. Fcucazk, according to our record, revicued and approved the orfrinal design of the Diablo facilitics. Somcone icos involved and B707290259 070721 PDR FOIA \ i

% CONNORB7-214 PDR V\

connected uit lens that have becn s*:ckn to 1 inadequate should

-, l.

nr. ore.cpprerprin*:cly esste. %e role of rederator in this inct:mcc.

, o /" , . .

.f.

Furaher,1:r. l'unsrh has . authored a book uith Mr. Blume, tbc c'esigner of .the Dict lo fccility. ' The s.ppearance of i.vartiality without .lutstioning the feet of ic?artiality is a :ssjor factor in the credibility of cny decision so significant cs Diablo scismic standardi in the present controversy.

Als), !!r. 'l!curark has been an in-hcuse EC-lMC witness and c: biter, uc understand, en similar occacicao and from this r.tandpoint 8

is not sufficiently distant from a special, interest sponoceship. .

Uc question, additier.nlly, the reliance upcn one pcrren, hcvavor l qualificc:, for counsci on this crucial incue.

Sccaic Shoreline, thereferc, requests that Mr. Newnark be re-l

.novcd frca the position of singic arbiter and becone a netter of an independ:;r.t fivo. person cccr:ittee of cninently galifica geolopirt-ceituologicts with c;9erience in northent and teethern Califctnic cnd cicerhere in the natic:n te provide the neccacary balen;e of en crties. Uc request that all pr.rties have the opportunity to review rad, if neccesary, challence the uedesein1s of the candidates f or the ce:snittee, that comittee deliberatier.s be open to all partics and rep).:w.:taticc:- of do prce, and that at one cacting at 1 cast interveners hcvc the opporttmity to cross-exar'.no the cocc.d.ttcc members.

3, It is our understanding that IEC desc-not raske c detnited check of ennlysco, design enicuintions, and construction plcas but "only chec14 critoria, method cnd procedurca" for carthqunko safety pro-visions and nucicar pouer plants, according sto !!r. I,arry Shou (San Luis Obispo hearing, February 18, 1975). As a basis for proposed seir.mic design cf the Diablo facility and any future retrofits,uc request that a detailed, independent review be conducted of the e

I

  • e, 9

1

., 'y 3 1

i analysii, design calculations, and ccustraction pisne for t.beso

- f acilitics, incinding a review by the stetc of california in the l public interent..

ITc submit thcsc ruoticas pursuant to the hesith, r.aiety, t.r.d i j

public uciferc, cnd other :pprcnrir.to coction:: of the r:aulatio.:s. l Ec.spectfully su'p4.< d, 7$$4 D ?'z'. 4 h .e

' Frederick Eincler ,

i

  • Prer i<.'ent i Sccric Shcrclinc: 7.n c. ')

ces Lii:.nboth S. Doucrs3 ESQ. )

11r. Glenn O. Erich:

Dr. Uillim L. Ihrtin Phili.p A. Cran-), Jr.. ESQ.

Elir:nbeth Apf ciborg Andrew J. Shnff, ES'. i Ecye Ficning Ifr. Frederich Eissler f 11rs. Sondra Ac Silve"

!!r. Uil)it .n T. C ernu .11 l Escheti::a ~4nd EcWice Sect. on Atortic Eafety cnd Licenrin., Lea::d l

James R. Tcurtellotte ,

4 l

i 4 i

1 1

1 l

l

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20236B854&oldid=3448280"