ML20210L769

Transcript of Commission 860925 Affirmation,Discussion & Vote in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-6

ML20210L769
Person / Time
Site:	Erwin, Shoreham  File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png
Issue date:	09/25/1986
From:	NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
To:
References
REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8610030123
Download: ML20210L769 (10)

Text

-

e .

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION In the matter of:

MTIRMATICN/DISCUSSICN AND VOIE I41BLIC MEErlNG Docket No.

9 r

e i

1 I ^' Location:

Date: Wasliington, D.C. Pages: 1-6 Thursday, Sep* h 25, 1986 ANN RILEY & ASSOCIATES Court Reporters 1625 I St., N.W.

Suite 921 Washington, D.C. 20006

_. (202) 293-3950 et,10030123 860r/2S PLn LOOFR P DR-P T9. 7 - -

e ,

9 1 D l SC LA I MER 2

i S 4

5 6 This is an unofficial transcript of a meeting of the 7 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission held on S . In the Commission's office at 1717 H Street, -

9 ' N . LJ . , (Ja s h i ng t on , D.C. The meeting was open to public 10 attendance and observation. This transcript has not been 11 reviewed, corrected, or edited, and it may contain 12 inaccuracies.

13 The transcript is intended solely for general i

14 informational purposes. As provided by 10 CFR 9.108, it is 15 not part of the formal or informal record of decision of the 16 matters discussed. Expressions of opinion in this transcript 17 do not necessarily reflect final determination or beliefs. No 18 pleading or other paper may be filed with the Commission in l 19 any proceeding as the result of or addressed to any statement 20 or argument contained herein, except as the Commission may 21 authorize.

22 I 28 1

24 25 l

1 IJHLIED STAFES OF At1 ERICA NUCLEAR REGULOFORY COMM1bSION AFF]RMAf1ON/DISCllSSION AND VOTE PUI5L I C ilEETING Nuc1 ear Regulatory Commission Coinmi s s i on er s ' Conference Room Room 1130 -

1717 "H" Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C.

Thursdoy, September 25, 1986 The Commiusion met i si open session, pursuant to aiutice, at 5:J.5 o' clock p.m., THOMAS N. RODERTS, Actini)

Llien r man, of t he Commi sai on, presiding.

L OfIM I'3 G I U N E R S Pli L S E N f :

I HullAG M. R ()T;E R f S , Action Chairman of the Commission

.)At1ES k. ASSELSflNE, Member of the Coinin t s s i on FREDERICK H. B E R N'l H A L , t1embor oF l.h e Co'omi esi on KENNETH M. CARR, 11emb er; of the Co.e.oi wion STAFF AND PRESENFERS SEA' LED AT cut 1r11 SS L ON i sd::L E :

J. HOYLE W. f > AF:L E R AUDIErit:E SPEAKERS:

M. MALSCH

F

. l l

l

- J 2

PROCEED I HGS COMMISSIONER ROBERTS: Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. This is an afftrmation/ discussion and vote session, public meeting. I need to ask a vote to hold on less than one week's notice action on the following: SECY-86-2/3, Governnr Cuomo's hay 15 request for termination of Shoreham proceeding and affirmation of proposed order terminating NFS-Erwin proceeding.

11ay i have such a vote? Those in favor, say, "Aye." -

CChorus of ayes J COMMISSIONL.R RODERTS: Opposed?

ENo response.1 COMillSSIONER RODF_RTS: I ask the secretary to head as through the items on the agenda.

ASSIST ANT SECRETARY HtT(LE: Mr. Chairman, the first item ve have is SECY-86-250. The title is "Shoreham Intervenors' Nation to Reconsider CL1-86-11."

The Commission is being asked to respond to a June 21, 1986 niotion by intervenors to reconsider CL.1 1 1 in which the Commission directed the appointment of a Licensing board to commence a hearing on the February 13, 1986 emergency preparedness exer:1ses for Shoreham.

the i n t er <c:nor s arque that subsequent developments demand termination of the exercise hearing and the whole proceeding ori LILCD's emergency plan.

r

. 1 l

'e; 3

All Commissioners have approved an order denying the

. inotion.

Ilay I have you affirm your votes, please?

CChorus of ayes.3 ASSISTANT SECRETARY HOYLE: Second is SECY-86-267.

The title i s, " Commission order regarding several

miscellaneous filings by parties to the Sequoyah Fuels informal proceedings."

The Commission is being asked to approve an order -

responding to motions from parties to the two informal adjudicatory proceedings convened by the Commission to consider Sequoyah Fuels Corporation's request for licensing action.

All Counnissioners have approved an order which we circuiated earlier tcday denying the motions. In addition, thie Conimi ssi on or der authorizes the Secretar y to act for the Caiomission on minor procedural matters with respect to these informal pr oceedings in accordance with the authority the Secretary already has under 10 CFR Part 2.772.

May I have you affirm your votes, pleace?

CChorus of ayes.]

ASSISTANT SECPETARY HOYLE: The third paper is one of the add-ons. SECY-86-273. entitled, " Governor Cuoma's May

15. 1*786 r equest f or termination of the Shoreham proceeding."

The Commission is beinq asked to approve an order in

= ,

i

<l response to a I1a y 15, 1YS6 letter f roin Governor Cuomo of the Etute at New York, lhe letter r equested that the NHU t er na n a te the proceeding on the Shoreham Nuclear Power Plant prinierily on the basi n of ctatements inade by White Hottse Chi ef af Staff, Donald 1% jan, on the TV program, " Meet the Press."

Al1 Commi ssi on er t, have approved an order which was circulsted today denying this request.

May I have you af firm your votes, please?

CChorus of ay es . .)

A'dS I C f AN F SECFETAki HUYLE: The final paper is the NFG-Erwin matter of the staft's request to terminate the proceedinq.

The Connn i sn i tin in b e .i n r) n ked to respond to a request. f r oin the NfiC s ta f f to terminate a hearino coinmenced ist 19UU oti an amendo.ent to It'.' ' af uguardu r equirements of the Gpccial fluc l ear flaterial licenn h.e l d by t IFS-- Er w i n .

ihu staff notes t iia t all r e qu i r enies i t s of a se t t i e.nen L -* g r eetnen t between the partictpants have oeen met.

611 Coi)mi nioisers he m _4pt.r o v e d an c .r d er which we Cit ~culated Ve5terday to Close the proceedin.j cidays from ene date of tho uruer is .24t.in 2d (tril m s any patticipant ob j rac t s t> y filing Jn oppO5illon Vei Lli tiie SoCtetery w L i.h i n 30 days of the ddte OE l Ile C a r ii Frt .

tiny I lism ycoi .tfirm yuiir- vo te e , olt me'

[Chor us of AVOL. I

i s

• r' 5

ASSISTANT SECRETARY HOYLE: That is all I have, Mr. Chairman.

COMMISSIONER ROBERTS: Does anyone have anything further'?

COMMISSIONER ASSELSTINE: I have just a quick question. Wasn't there another item on the agency?

MR. PARLER: The General Counsel asked that that Liine be withdrawn. That was SECY-86-263 because a paper was filed in the Supreme Court yesterday saying t.h a t that -

particular matter was still being considered.

Our solicitor and I acree and would preter that because of that filing that the Commission not affirm this paper today right at tisis L i .rie . I t et k e it you all are in rasor.

LOMMISSIONER ASSELSTINE: I take it t h eit steps will be t al:en to inform the Justice Department of the current u t L u s t. i on.

I IR . PARLER: The paper that was i11ed with the Court did reflect the currect current sttuation. -

COMf11 SS I ONER ASSELS f li'lE : F9 d not ihe situatiois 1 :nined i a te l y as of action on thin paper, i 's that correct' t1R . PARLER: Right.

CUMttISS IUt E R ASSELS f li4E : ni1 r i olit . so ui,a l we at e doing is holdina up action on 1.he paper. anittnue to make the t,r i +f that ie bufore i.he Court accuratm.

r W

6 MR. PARLER: If you put it that w -a y , do you have anything else to add to what I have said r' (1R . t1ALSCH: It is just a matter in the historical t> cec k g r ou n d section, there is reference made to the fact that the Commission initiated a rulemaking.

COMt11SSIONER ASSELSTINE: All right.

MR. t1ALSCH : All the briefs have been filed. At this point, we might as welI wait for the Supreme Court to act before issuina the rulemaking. It is not going to be much -

1 onqer .

MR. PARLER: Or if somebody would prefer, the other w a'/ around ts all right, too. It is siv of one, half a dozen u l- the other. We are not trying to hide anything from anybody.

COMMISSIONER ASSELS I Ilif: AlI right.

COMt11SGIONER ROBERTS: AlL right. We w111 adjourn.

( Wher ettpon, l_ h e Connui uni on meeting was adjourned at J:41 o' clock p.m., to reconvene at the Call of the Chair.3

s .

li 1

2 REPORTER'S CERTIFICATE 3

4 This is to certify that the attached events of a 5 meeting of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission entitled:

7 TITLE OF MEETING: M' '

8 PLACE OF MEETING: Washington, D.C.

9 DATE OF MEETING:

W ' #f )I h h ,

10 11 were held as herein appears, and that this is the original 12 transcript thereof for the file of the commission taken

{ 13 stenographically by me, thereafter reduced to typewriting by 14 me or under the direction of the court reporting company, and 15 that the transcript is a true and accurate record of the 16' foregoing events.

17 is

. tt/hY t) '/7),3gg 19 j 20 21 l 22 Ann Riley & Associates, Ltd.

23 l

24 25

NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNkNQ0kkkk_00kkkkkkkkkkqQ & QgQgygQy & Q Q g TRAt!SMITTAL T0: y Document Control Desk, 016 Phillips ADVANCED COPY TO: The Public Document Room DATE: 9 ;;tl. Ir(,

FROM: SECY Correspondence & Records Branch Attached are copies of a Commission meeting transcript and related meeting I, document (s). They are being forwarded for entry on the Daily Accession List and placement in the Public Document Room. No other distribution is requested or required.

If M D t S C (c,t i m 0-

• A. okt Meeting

Title:

Meeting Date: 9 M k la Open ( Closed Item Description *: Copies -

Advanced DCS Copy 'a to PDR 1

1 1

1. TRANSCRIPT I

I it:

2.

CE 4.

h 5.

6.

l

• PDR is advanced one copy of each document, two of each SECY paper.

C&R Branch files the original transcript, with attachments, without SECY papers, alRS Y kh lYb lYbY kb $Ya h

-__