ML20091N259
| ML20091N259 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 11/23/1982 |
| From: | Lucks A STONE & WEBSTER, INC. |
| To: | Cook R NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML17198A223 | List:
|
| References | |
| CON-BOX-10, FOIA-84-96 MPF-9, NUDOCS 8406120248 | |
| Download: ML20091N259 (8) | |
Text
.F'
)
STONE 6 WEBSTER ENGINEERING CORPORATION 245 SUMMER STREET. BOSTON. M ASSACH U SETTS Aoonses ALL connsspoNosNCE TO P C. BOM s329. BOSTON. M A SS. 03107 w u telex S4-000t w con c N.towCTION f"..'.""'.""
"' T L o~.
- "'u*.',"o",
'O'.%'.*.
7."..'E/vo "'o*c7 1
United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission November 23,19&I Midland Site Resident Inspection Office Route 7 J.O. No. 14358 Midland, MI 48640 Ref. MPF 9 Attention Mr. R. Cook RE: DOCKET NO. 50-329/330 MIDLAND PLANT - UNITS 1 AND 2 INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT OF AUXILIARY BUILDING UNDERPINNING REPORT NO. 9 A cooy of the Independent Assessment of 'the Auxiliary Building Under-pinn ug Weekly Report No. 9 for the period November 14 through November 20, 1982, is enclosed with this letter.
Included, as an attachment, are the minutes of the daily meetings held between members of the Assessment Team and S' te Engineering, Coastruction and Quality Assurance personnel during the week.
If you hav e any questions with respect to this report please contact me at (617) 589-2067.
av A. Stanley Lucks Project Manager
,i Enclosures i
i ASL/nb l
6 I
0406120248 840517 PDR FOIA RICE 84-96 PDR
\\
J.O. No. 14358 3
/
Midland Plant Units 1 and 2 Independent Assessment Auxiliary Butiding Underpinning Weekly Report No. 9 November 14 throuah November 20, 1982 Personnel on Site Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation (SWEC)
A.B. Scott 11/15 - 11/19 W.E. Kilker 11/15 - 11/19 L. Rouen 11/15 - 11/19 Parsons Brinckerhoff Quade & Douglas J. Ratner 11/15 - 11/17
- v. Nadill 11/15 - 11/19 Activities Team members continued monitoring the results of test mix designs for mudmet concrete. A surveillance was made of the performance of the slump testing, f abrication and testing of the concrete cylinders. The review was conducted of the implementation of the MPQAD Precedure on Qualification and Certification of Inspection Test Personnel.
A QC training session for general welding was attended.
A CPCo Quality Assurance performed an audit of SWEC compliance with the CPCo Specification CC-100.
Meetinas Attended Date Represented Purpose 11/15 Stone & Wbster Daily Meeting through Parsons, Brinckerhoff 11/19 Quade & Douglas Consumers Power Bechtel 3
11/16 Stone & Webster Update on Quality-Consumers Power control Recertification
}
Bechtel 11/17 Parsons, Brinckerhoff ASLB Soils Hearings Quade & Douglas (Midland Co. Court House) 11/19 Stone & W heter Weekly Soils Review I
cons. ors Power Meeting Bechtel Mersentime
. l
~:
~.
t
'N J.02 No. 14358 3
Midland Plant j
Unite.i1 and 2 Independent Assessment Auxiliary Building Underpinning Observations j
he surveillance of tho' concrete testing indicated schar. testing was
~
being' performed in accordance with the respective ASTM procedures.
The review of certification activity indicated the procedure was being properlys implementated.
Re' CPCo audit of SWEC implementation of.the CPCo specification for an independent assessment.resulted in one finding on cataloging of project documents. Re Project Precedure 7-2 will be revised based upon this f ind ing.
g Non-Conformance Identification ' Reports No New Issues.
Status of previous issues:
NIR No.
Date Status 1
10/21/82 Open 2
10/29/82
.open
-Toeg g
Project Engineer Project Manager i
k s
t 7
f i
}
t k
u t
e;
)
+
-~
J.O. No. 14358 T
Midland Plant Units 1 and 2 Independent Assessment Auxiliary Building Underpinning I
INDEFENDENT ASSESSMENf TEAM MEETING KITH ENITL i
l Date: November 15, 1982 Attendees:
SWEC Bechtel CPCo MPQAD A.B. Scott C. Cviki G. Murray B. Sevo W. Kilker J. Fisher D. levelle R. Weight 1.
J. Fisher introduced D. Lovelle, Field Soils Manager, and R. Weight, direct hire supervisor on soils remedial work.
2.
J. Fisher described to new personnel the role of Assessment Team to date.
3 Meeting today at 10 A.M. on QC re-certification,being chaired by A. Boos.
k.
J. Fisher gave E. Cviki copies of Assessment Team questions on Soil Stab-ilization.
J. Fisher will provide answers to be forwarded to P. Parish, originator of discussion items on soil stabilization.
5 Bob Sevo said CPCo feels welding will have to be qualified by the 1980 AWS D 1.3 standard for the soils remedial work. This requirement will apply to the 12 gage lagging. Discussion with Bechtel Engineering will
{
ensue.
6.
Question by A. Scott on receiving materials without certified QC inspectors.
B. Sevo and J. Fisher replied that Bechtel QC people not associated with j
Soils Remedial presently receive the materials but that no material can be turned-over to subcontractor until re-certification is accepted.
7.
Testing of concrete mixes for mudmats continues. Goal is to obtain a 300 Psi strength in 3 4 hours4.62963e-5 days <br />0.00111 hours <br />6.613757e-6 weeks <br />1.522e-6 months <br />. Engineering and field to resolve the issue if this requirement is not workable.
8.
Assessment team comment items still open (exclusive of the soil stabilization comments) are those that will produce a procedure (3 items) or specification (4 items) change.
9 G. Murray said CPCo feels re-certification is the only restraint on work release. Issues of QA records and EPA settlement appear near resolution.
}
i t
4
)
J.0, No. 14358 Midland ' Plant Units 1 and 2 Independent Assessment Auxiliary Building Underpinning
(
INDEFENDENT ASSESSMENT TEAM MEETING WITH BECHTEL T
I Date: November 16, 1982 Attendees:
SWEC FBQD Bechtel CPCo MPQAD A. Scott J. Ratner J. Fisher G. Murray R. Sevo W. Kilker V. Medill E. Cviki L. Rouen D. Lavelle R. Weight 1.
J. Fisher stated the intent is to start the Auxiliary Building Under.
pinning with one 10 hour1.157407e-4 days <br />0.00278 hours <br />1.653439e-5 weeks <br />3.805e-6 months <br /> shift on 11/22/82. No work would be done 11/25 through 11/28. One shift schedule will continue until QC can support 2 shifts, probably the first part of December.
2.
N. Svanberg is pursuing effect implementation of 1980 AWS code on lagging velding.
3 Some legging materials are presently on-hold that need release prior to use.
B. Sevo will resolve.
h.
Daily meeting time will change once the actual underpinning work commences.
1 l
1 i
i 1
J.0a E3. -14358
)
Midisad Plant Units 1 knd 2 Independent Assessment Auxiliary Building Underpinning l
INDEFENDENT ASSESSMEFf TEAM MEETIEG WITH EECHTEL Date: November 17, 1982 Attendees:
SWEC PBQD CFCo Bechtel MFQAD A. Scott J. Ratner R. Wieland J. Fisher R. Sevo W. Kilker V. Nadill E. Cviki L. Rouen D. Lavelle 1.
J. Fisher stated that Field Engineering is still planning on a 11/22/82 start. Materials will be brought to the access shaft locations this week so actual work can start Monday-pending receipt of written ERC approval.
2.
B. Sevo said MFQAD is completing close-out on release of lagging that had previously been tagged. Coupons and welding have been tested and approved.
3 Once construction commences the new daily meeting time will be 9:30 AM.
t 4
Any construction procedure medificaticas being made now will not offset the start of construction according to J. Fisher.
5 E. Oviki is checking with consultants as to:
A.
Which ones and B.
How they want to review Field Change Requests (FCR) to specification.
i I
I i
J.0. No. lh358 3
Midland Plant
/
U2its 1 and 2 Independent Assessment Auxiliary Building Underpinning I
l I
IEEFEEENT ASSESSMEFf TEAM MEETING WITH BECHTEL Date: November 18, 1982 Attendees:
SWEC FBQD Bechtel CPCo MPQAD A. Scott V, nadill J. Fisher R. Wi6 land R. Sevo W. Kilker E. Cviki L. Rouen 1.
Legging hold issue should be closed out by the end of this week.
2.
Welding issue still pending. Lagging and drin sets een apparently be welded by 1972 or 1974 code. Project Engineering is presently holding these drawings but will likely relesse them now that they have been checked out.
(
3.
Tuesday, November 23, a acek-up of a tell pier will be constructed and concreted to assess flow of concrete into corners through rebar without vibration.
l i
i i
I j
- 1 e
i M
i j
INDEFERENT ASSESSMENT TEAM MEETING WITH EECRTEL Date: November 19, 1982 Attendees:
SWEC SWEC FBQD CPCo Bechtel MPQAD A. Scott V. Medill R. Weiland E. Cviki R. Sevo W. Kilker L. Rouen 1.
E. Cviki confirmed that consultants receive copies of the specification documents once they are revised and signed-out.
j 2.
The underpinning work will not start on Monday 11/22/82.
3 Discussion on status of settlement monitoring.
h.
Mock-up of bell still scheduled to be completed on 11/23/82.
Assessment Team will observe placement of concrete.
i f
I f
l i
i 4
A 3
...~..
9 STONE 6 WEBSTER ENGINEERING CORPORATION 245 SUMMER STREET, BOSTON. M A SS ACH U SETTS ADDRESS ALL CORRESPONDENCE TO P.O. BOX 2325. BOSTON. M ASS. 02107 W U. TELEX 94-0001 I'L*" ocr,0N
"::::,,0N.
- '.',*ON
- il'.=".b
- 0NTLAND. On EGON wasMINeTON, O C.
United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission November 29, 1982 Midland Site Resident Inspection Office Route 7 J.O. No. 14358 Midland, MI 48640 Ref. MPF 10 Attention Mr. R. Cook RE: DOCKET NO. 50-329/330 MIDLAND PLANT - UNITS 1 AND 2 INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT OF AUXILIARY BUILDING UNDERPINNING REPORT NO. 10 A copy of the Independent As.sessment of the Auxiliary Building Under-pinning Weekly Report No. 10 for the period November 21 through November 27, 1982, is enclosed with this letter. Included, as an attachment, are the minutes of the daily meetings held between members of the Assessment Team and Site Engineering, Construction and Quality Assurance personnel during the week.
If you have any questions with respect to this report please contact me at (617) 589-2067.
A. Stanley Lucks Project Panager Enclosures ASL/nb d
i I
i I
l l
- ^
,,er i m c,
e.
l
^
J.O. No. 14358 3
j Midland Plant
/
Units'1 and 2 Independent Assessment Auxiliary Building Underpinning Weekly Report No. 10 November 21 through November 27, 1982 Personnel on Site i
A.B. Scott 11/22 - 11/23 i
Activities Observed the performance of concrete placement at the mock-up pier bell simulation within the Poseyville Storage Yard. The intent of the concrete placement in the pier bell mock-up was to demonstrate the effectiveness of flow of the concrete to all portions of the bell and the consolidation of the concrete without use of vibration.
1 Meetings Attended Date Represented Purpose 11/22 Stone & Webster Daily Meeting and Bechtel 11/23 Consumers Power 11/22 Bechtel Update on items requiring Consumers Power resolution to start of Stone & Webster construction - Specifications Procedures, PQCI's,-QC training Observations Our observations indicated that the flow of concrete in the pier bell was not hindered by the presents of reinforcing steel. On November 27, 1982, the forms will be removed in order to assess the degree of consolidatien.
l Non-Conformance Identification Report No new issues.
Status of previous issues:
NIR NO.
Date Status 1
10/21/82 Open-l 2
10/29/82 Open i
I 4
W. [.
- h..
Qj Project Engineer [ Project Manage #'
e
s q
l l
l INDEFEMDENT ASSESSMENT TEAM MEETING WITH EEChTIL Date: November 22, 1982 1
Attendees:
SWEC Bechtel CPCo MFQAD 1
A.B. Scott J. Fisher R. Weiland-H. Sevo E. Civkl R. Weight 1.
J. Fisher directed E. Cviki to have a meeting with J. Meisenheimer of QA to discuss the impact on the QC program if there were any minor changes to design documents.
2.
R. Sevo was to provide answer on the hold now on lagging due to the M
[heten Lab issue. Hold tags were to be removed this date per R. Sevo.
3 RE: Weld code year.
E. Cviki was to contact Project Engineering to issue a SCN to limit the velding to fillet velds on the steel lagging.
4 A concrete placement was scheduled for November 23, 1982, to
~
deromstrate the pouring of a pier bell without vibration.
5 A meeting was scheduled at 10:00 AM today to review all items that were outstanding and required per directives given to CPCo by the NRC prict to start of work for piers E/W 12, (and to schedule completion deten).
l 9
I i
i
i D
i I
i INDEM3EDENT ASSESSMENT TEAM MEETING WITH BECHTEL i
Date: November 23, 1982
~
Attendees:
SWEC BECHTEL CPCO MPQAD I
A.B. Scott E. Cviki R. Weiland R. Sevo 1.
E. Cviki reported that the meeting with J. Meisenheimer of QA concerning minor changes to design documents had not taken place.
2.
R. Sevo reported all hold tags (due to Phanton issue) had been removed from steel lagging.
I 3
Mock-up of pier bell concrete placement was to be made at 12 noon.
h.
It vss reported that all outstanding items required for pier E/W 12 construction were listed and responsible parties were to provide ecmpletion dates by November 2h, 1982.
4 l
I I
l l
i 4
l l
l