ML20091F548
Text
1
'\\
ps"* "%,
t UNITED STATES f
,; e..((7c, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
+
h REGloN ill 3J of"M C
799 ROoSENELT ROAD A f, d
U GLEN ELLvN, ILLINOIS 60137 HAY 2 h 983 i
MEMORANDUM FOR:
R. F. Warnick, Director, Gffice of Special Cases FROM:
J. J. Harrison, Chief, Midland Section
SUBJECT:
THIRD PARTY LONSTRUCTION IMPLEMENTATION OVERVIEW FOR THE MIDLAND PLANT CONSTRUCTION COMPLETION PROGRAM DATED APRIL 1, 1983 The Midland Section has completed a review of the Stone and Webster proposal submitted by Consxners Power Company letter to J. G. Keppler dated April 6 1983. The plan as written appears to meet the requirements to be able to provide a proper approach, schedule, and organization to assure proper overview of implementation of the CCP while maintaining a third party statas.
Tha weekly and monthly progress reports appear to be adequate to keep the NRC informed. The NRC staff will also have the opportunity to attend the site daily meetings.
This memorandum therefore constitutes approval of Stone and Webster proposal for program content. The competence and independence review is being accomplished by a separate Region III office.
f.1
- J J. J. Harrison, Chief Midland Section cc:
J. R. Miller i
lt I
t k
l l
l
'f n y....,
i PDR
[ "Uh,h UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION S
REGloN lli
- l 1 vs 1 2 799 MoosEVELT moAo
[
3 i
/g oLEN ELLYN. ILLINots P0137 Junu 13, 1983 MDiORANDUM FOR:
R. F. Farnick, Director, Special Cases Staff FROM:
J. R. Miller, Chief, Materials and Safeguards Branch
SUBJECT:
ASSESSMENT OF F&W TO WORK AT MIDLAND (DOCKET No. 50-329; 50-330)
As regt.ested. I have completed an audit of the competence of the individuals assigned by Stone & Webster to work on the " Third Party Construction Implementation Overview" at Midland.
Based on my discussions with given references tnd discussions with developed references. I could find nothing that would indicate that these persons should not perform the subject work.
In addition. I discussed the overall S&W effort with those persons in NRR who were responsible for developing Secy 82-414 (Diablo Canyon Design Verification Progra;. - Phase II Reconsnendations). These NRC persons, in
.. 0 to Secy 82-414 indicated that S&W (and others) were acceptable.
Based on my review of affidavits for all parties concerned and my review of presented documentation. I cannot find any reason for not approving S&W' to perform work at Midland.
f 6
d*j*,
' N.*~ s n./
- c. _,G",,
- 3. R. Miller, ief Materials and Safeguards Branch
+
i i
I w
e y
t 1
i f
L d Ud'N gggggggyg 3 v--
' ).
o
1 8
l STONE & WEBSTER MICHIGAN, INC.
P.O. Box 2325. BOSTON. M AssAcHusETTs 02107 Mr. J.G. Keppler, Administrator, Region III June 15, 1983 Nuclear Regulatory Commission J.0. No.
14509 799 Roosevelt Rocd NRC File #83-06-14 Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 RE: DOCKET NO. 50-329/330 MIDLAND PLANT - UNITS 1 AND 2 OVER/IEW OF THE CONSTRUCTION COMPLETION PROGRAM Attached for your information and files are four (4) copies of the Stone &
Wetster Engineering Corporation Construction Implementation Overview Organ-ization, Rev. O dated June 1, 1983. Revised copies, as updated, shall be transmitted to your office.
If you have any questions with respect to the Organization chart, please contact me at (517) 631-8650, extension 486.
Very truly yours,
- hg g
S.W. Baranow T
~
Program Manager
/M Enclosure
- -- j t
IN cc: JJHarrison, NRC Glen Ellyn, IL RCook, NRC Midland (site)
OBMiller, CPCo Midland (site)
RBKelly, S&W Aramaruso, S&W l
l i
I
^
w
~
i Jun t 01983
s CFCo MFqAD Manager of gesality As-R A welle j
sarance - Boston
.t e
e CFCo site l
Manager -
j D 5 Miller 8
e e
S e
e e
t 159 Resident Frogram Manager S U Baramow Inspector-Committee-Boston R Cook I
FROGRAM EVALDATION FNYSICAL VERIFICATION I
Superintendent J C Thompson Supervisor -
F. Bearham Support Engr's i- )
AA5mith, JFChawls l
Evaluator W Sienkiewicz Fiping/Nechanical R S Scalles
?
M E
R. N.
Evaluator CONSTRUCTION IMPLEMENTATION OVERVIEW (Later)
J R Langston OECANIZATION
!8E'"*""'*I l
JUNE 1, 1983 Rev. 0 W M111er Evaluator (Later)
Inspectors (4) t (Later) 4 i
CFCe MFqaB Manager of quality As-R A Welle j
aurence - Boston
,~
e e
0 4
e 0
4 CFCe Site l
J Manager -
B B Miller j
i.
t e
8 IRQ Resident, 8
Program Manager Overview Review 8
S U Baramow Inspector-Committee-Boston j
R Ceek i
4 I
i ynnemans NVAIJATICII PNYSICAL VERIFICATI0It I
Superintendent Supervisor -
F. Bearham l
Support Er.gr's l
AASmith, JFChawls Evaluator W Sienkiewicz Fiping/ Mechanical R S Scallen Bangers / Welding i
Evaluator Npf COIISTRUCTICII IMPLEDENTATIOIl OVERVIEW (Later)
J R Langston i
nacamIZATICIE i
2 i
Civil / Structural l
JUNE 1, 1983 Rev. O i
i W Miller j
1 Evaluator i
(Later)
Inspectors (4) l (Later) 1 I
4-l
CFCe Mrgaa Manager of quality Aa-1 R A Welle j
aarance - Boston e
l l
Crce site j
Manager -
B B Miller l
e i
e 154 Realdest l
Program Manager Overview Review Inapector-
4------------------
S U Baranow Committee-Boston K Ceek I
I yanceaag RVAIRATIOII FfiTSICAI. VERIFICATIOtt I
I Superintendent Supervisor -
F. Bearham l
Support Engr's AA5mith, JFChawla Evalustor W Sienkiewicz Fiping/ Mechanical l
R S Scallen l
M
& UE Rn. CMr.
Evaluator C00tSTRUCTIOtt IMPLEMENTATIOff OVERVIEW Later J R Langston OECANIZATICII l
JUNE, 1983 Rev. O W Miller Evaluator (Later)
Inspectors (4)
(Later)
CFCe NFESN Maneger of @lity As-R A Mella j
aursace - Bestem CFCe Site l
Manager -
---j 3 3 Miller l
l l
l.
em; Realdect l
Progree Manager, Overview Review S U Baramow
-a--
Iompector.
e Committee-Roston R Ceek I
I FWYSICAL YERIFICATION PROCEAN ETAIAATION f
Superintendent J C T1eoepson Superviser -
F. Bearham l
l Support ingr's AA5mith, JFChawls
- Evaluator W sienkiewicz Fiptag/dechanical R S Scallen Mangera/ Welding 7,
I I
JR gatos JUNE 1, 1943 Rev. O W Miller Evaluator Inspectore (4)
(Later)
.m.,
STONE & WEBSTER MICHIGAN, INC.
P.O. Dox 2325. BOSTON MassAcHuscTTs 02107
\\
Mr. J. C. Keppler, Administrator, Region !!!
)une3,1983 Nuclear Regulatory Commission J.O. No. 14509 799 s.oosevelt Road NRC File #83-05-01 Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 RE: DOCKET NO.
50-329/330 MIDLAND PLANT - UNITS 1, AND 2 OVERVIEW OF THE CONSTRUCTION COMPLETION PROGRAM REPORT NO. 1 Attached is a chronology of ftone & Webster Engineering Corporation (SWEC) participation in Consumers Power Company, (CPCo) Construction Completion Pro-gram.
In addition to addressing various meetings attended by SWEC, a status of the development of various phases of the Construction Implementation over-view Program (CIO) is provided. We will advise your office on a weekly basis as to meetings attended and will report on our program development. Current-ly six members of the CIO Team are on site and are supported by two writers, from Boston, in the preparation of evaluation and ' verification checklists.
I If you have any questions with respect to this report, please contact me at
\\s.
extension 665 (Bee!;tel), 517-631-4286.
Very truly yours, 6
lNbMW e
Stanleyd.Baranow Program Manager Enclosure SWB/dmh 4
ces RCook, NRC Midland JJHarrison, FOC Clen Ellyn DBHiller, Midland RBKelly, SAW APAmaruso S&W I
4 9
i I
oh (j 'l
\\)
' The initial visit to the site by the undersigned, was made on April 28, 1983 for an introductory meeting with CPCo management personnel. Throughout this period numerous meetings were attended by CIO personnel, listed by dates showns
- 1) April 29, 1933 - Management Review of the Construction Completion Program.
- 2) May 5, 1983 A.M. - Introductory meeting with key members of the Management Review Committee CPCo, Bechtel and SWEC.
- 3) May 5,1983 P.M. - Meeting with R. Welle, 5. Palmer, MPQAD. Discussions on Training and CCP, received handouts of electrical NCRs. NRC correspondance, Inspectors Training Program and a copy of the CPCo Nonconformance procedure.
- 4) May 11, 1983 - Introductory meeting with Mr. R. Cook, NRC site Senior Inspec-tors briefly discussed the philosophy and implementation of the CIO program.
The subject of weekly pr~ ogress reports and meetings with NRC and CPCo was raised. Mr. Cook advised that weekly reports and meetings would not be re-quired during SWECs development of the overview program, but would cosumence with the implementation vf the CCP.
- 5) May 12, 1983 - Heating with the ?fRC, CPCo, pechtel and SWEC for discussion of the Construction Training Program PPC-2.000 Rev. 1 Program requires re-vision to J!rese hnw " Trainers are trained."
- 6) May 17, 1983 - Meeting with NRC regional and site representatives. The Quality Verification Program Document was reviewed in its entirety.
Numer-ous areas were judged by the NRC to be unsatisfactory, particularly, the
(
95/957. acceptability plan. Alse addressed were NRC concerne to responses by CPCo in letters dated April 6 and April 22, 1983 which were judged to be inadequate. NRC requested that the CIO perform an overview evaluation of.
the Interaction System walkdown of Safety Related equipment.
6
- 7) May 18, 1983 - Management Review for Preparation and Statusing of Bulk Han-gers organisation and training of supervision and craft personnel.
In at-tendance were representatives of CPCo, Rechtel and SWIC.
l
- 8) May 23, 1983 - Meeting with R. Wells, Executive Director, HPQAD and the undersigned to discuss documentation required by C10lPQC1s, status of l
PQCI development, INP0 audit findings and responses, tsaining matrix.
CPCo commitments to the NRC. Also, discussed was the vehicle to be used to identify CIO concerns noted during reviews of PQC!s where attributes appear to be ambiguous and/or not in compliance with Code requirements.
Method of Cosununication/ Notification is under consideration.
i
- 9) May 23, 1983 P.M. - Heeting with Roy Wells, Executive Director, to discuss setting on copy for various documents i.e. PQC1s, Inpo Audit findings and 6
{
status, training matrix, status of PQC1 development.
i
- 10) Hay 27, 1983 - Heating with Bruce Peck, CPCo Construction Superintendent and j
Bechtel Representatives to discuss Construction Completion Team organisation.
Topics included background and Ihilosophy, Bechtel Construction Organisation, CCP Organtastion Team Organisation, Communications between Bechtel, CPCo y
EC10. C10 Team organisation Objectives and Philosophy.
}
STATUS OF PROGRAM DEVEt,0PMENT A.
C10 Plan transmitted to the s'te NRC Inspector and CPCo on Thursday, May 19, 1983.
i J
y,,
- + -
- B.
Evaluation Plan (sof tware assessment), in rough draf t-awaiting cosuunts.
C.
Checklists under developments
(-
- QC and Construction Training = Evaluation
- Management CCF responsibilities - Evaluation
- Bulk Nanger Organ 14ation - Evaluation
- "N" series procedures - Ivaluation
- Reinspection of Pipe Component Supports F119/P129 walkdown - Evaluation and Verification r
Se p I.
6 f
(
h s
l i
l
-l r
t "A
r l (L) i t
J
I s 6* * *w
\\
unitso stAfst J
I%
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COAAMISSION r(
I necios sie (h
roe noosevs67 nome
/
e6s= e66v=, e66emois war I
,'..s.*.**f N-hM23M3 i
i l
MEMORAND7N FOR:
R. F. Warotek. Director. Office of Specisi Cases i
FROM J. J. Marrison, Chief. Nidland Section l
SUBJECT:
TNIRD PARTT CONSTRUCTION IMPLEMENTATION OVERVIDf FOR THE MIDLAIS PLANT CONSTRUCTION COMPLETION PROGRAM DATED APRIL 1, 1983 l
The Midland.1ection has completed a review of the Stone and Webster proposal submitted by Consumers Power Company letter to J. G. Keppler dated April 6, 1943.
The pl.an as written appears to meet the requirements to be able to provide a proper approach, achedule, and organisation t.o assure proper l
overview of implementation of the CCp while maintaining a third party status.
The weekly and monthly progress reports appear to be adequate to keep the NRC informed.
The NRC staff will also have the opportunity to attend the site daily meetings.
[
I This neuerandum thereforo constitutes approval of Stone and Webster proposal for progree content. The competence and independence review is being
{
accomplished by a separate Region !!! office.
g 6
J. J. Marrison, Chief Midland,Settion cci J. R. Miller l
l i
l 4
l r
4 j
i k"
t,(*e t-q
,W f
..l
'f 1
1 e)
ENCLO5URE 2 q
-a
~
s.
~ & a,. Q l 464V (OL *~JQq.A g) 6 j
.s j
STONE & WEBSTER MICHIGAN, INC.
/_1!EC il ' l
'i A
b-
\\
3 b
P.O. Box 2325. BOSTON. MASSACHUSETTS O2107 Mi
-) $I' A /.i" i o l
{y D.
I DR;GN I
DE.
I e
i l
ML f
OL FIL Q -
Mr. J. G. Keppler May 19, 1983 Administrator, Regicu III U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, Il 60137 RE: DOCKET NO. 50-329-330 MIDLAND PLANT - UNITS 1 AND 2 THIRD PARTY CONSTRUCTION IMPLEMENTATION OVERVIEW Stone & Webster Michigan, Inc., forwarded to your attention on April 11, 1983 resu=es and signed affidavits for most of its proposed team members. Signed affidavits for Messrs. S. B. Barenov and J. Chavla vere not available at that time.
In accordance with the direction provided to Mr. C. F. Sundstrom of our offices on April 6,1983 by Mr. James Miller, the two missing affidavits are now beir.g forwarded to you.
Mr. Baranov is replacing Mr. W. MacKay and Mr. Chawla is replacing Mr. J.
Hannvacker.
If you have any questions, please contact Mr., C. F. Cundstro= at (617) 589-2780.
~
i Very truly yours, f
~~
'j P. A. Will Vice President Enclosures i
g',
r/ j '
y py g 993~
D x
~
s
.,1 /...
r g
'; - >s'
>.3 -
.g Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA i
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY 50-330 ON (Midisnd Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL April 1, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF J. P. Chawla My name is J. P. Chawla I am employed by. S_ tone & Webster Engineering Corporation as uesigner, Electrical Divisi,on I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Overview at the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Con mrs Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I will be reviewing. I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
I do not oc any shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock. Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel-stock, of which I am unaware. A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached.
I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Con,sumers Power Company or Bechtel.
Signed
- pv y
j Sworn cnd Subscribed Before Me This I Day of April 1983
~
~
i l.
/
f)6 tar Public I
l PnfLIP J. TALAMO e 52 3927 75 Geellfied la suffett coenty i
My Commission Expires e i tie. me se, io6
' ',y
. ~,.... - -...,
h O
m'
...~
Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION i
ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL AFFIDAVIT OF d4/. M8#A/Ded My name is d4s/.&dAhy)
I am employed by.SIA##/M42 M AggenAs M M as 4ymsg pg I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Overview at the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I will be reviewing. I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel. I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company
~
or Bechtel stock. Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of j
Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware. A list
}
of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives
}
which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
Signed Sworn and Subscribed Before Me This [ 7tarDay of 3CN., / f8 3 N g ry Y4blic m ;.7 J. %?!;.'. SKI
&cW,
' W YC'k ogn C-J638996 v *:. h; 1Y pq ww.
u My Commission Expires e 3C),/9/S il
.oel b 2>7;)$
?llUjfb
[W. js7, STONE & WEBSTER MICHIGAN, INC.
/
c.;
P.O. Box 2325. Boston. M AssACHusETTs 02107 I
^
4 l*
h
.Cf I.......
s
,v.
L
._...b Mr. J. G. Keppler April 11, 1983 Administrator, Region III U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission J.O. No. 14358 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 RE: DOCKET NO. 50-329-330 MIDLAND PLANT - UNITS 1 AND 2 THIRD PARTY CONSTRUCTION IMPLEMENTATION OVERVIEW Stone & Webster Michigan, Inc. has determined that the Corporation and the individual members of the proposed Third Party Construction Implementation Overview Team satisfy the re pirements for independence.
In particular it has been determined that the Co.poration and team members satisfy the following criteria:
The Corporation or individuals proposed far tM = * ::k do not have any direct previous involvement with Midland activities that they will be reviewing.
The Corporation or individuals proposed for this work have not been previously hired by the Owner to perform design, engineering, construction or quality work relative to the Construction C m letion Program.
The individuals proposed for this work do not have present household members employed by the Owner.
i-The individuals proposed for this work do not have any relative j
employed by the Owner in a sanagement capacity.
i l
The Corporation and individual proposed for this work do not l
control a significant amount of Owner stock, i.
1 1
l i
l 3
i APR131983 1
.4.;R 13 1933 WJCt h L
JGK 2
April 11, 1983 Attached are signed affidavits for each proposed member of the Team. If you have any questions, please contact Mr. C. F. Sundstror at (617) 589-2780.
7
...m
'.T dk P. A. Wild Vice President Swornandsubscribedtobeforeseonthis//
day of April, 1983.
-'I1 a-.'sn Y?. b.-E Y -
Notary Public Suffolk County Massachusetts My Copumission Expires January 23, 1987 cc:
H. R. Denton, NRC (w/att) i 4
a j
1-
~
l.
I l
le !' 3 3 K,3:.
,j-
B3-4220700-LP249J Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSUMERS POWER COMPAhT 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units I and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL April 1, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF W. MACKAY My name is W. MACKAY I am employed by Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation as PROGRAM MANAGER I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Overview at' the Midland Nuclear Plant site.
Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I will be reviewing.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock.
Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have, a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumtrs Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
k! L kad.
Signed
/
Sworn and Subscribed Be re Me Thic
[ Day of April 1983
&wu/
j
' Notary Public 9
B
?
i t'j i
e
% 5. m I~
My Commission Expires i
-i I
B3-4220700-LP249J Figure 3-1
)
UNITE 3 STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGt:LATORY COTfISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
'In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL April 1,1983 AFFIDAVIT OF C.O. Richardsoa My name is C.O. Richardson I am employed by Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation as Engineering Mananer I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementatior. Overview at the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being given -this. assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I'will be reviewing.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company or'Bechtel.
I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company or. Bechtel stock.
Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a
.1 beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
f Signed O
4 d
'g
/
y l
Sworn and Subscribed Before e This 7_th, Day of April 1983
/LfCL/Y /
Asserl
~
9-Notary Public ~
~'
~
I i
t a
r
- l
'.My Commission Expires.
- 4'a Mer 5,1989 -
4
~~,
'le l
.[-
'.1 3 -
.E_
4 4
we
-m
,--i 7
w-u.
e
B3-4220700-LP249J Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD i
In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM l
CONSUMERS P0kER COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL j
50-330 OL April 1, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF My name is N. B. CLEVELAND I am employed by Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation as DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF CONSTRUCTION.
I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementrtion Overview at' the Midland Nuclear Plant site.
Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the hidland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I will be reviewing.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock.
Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have,.
beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or
~
Bechtel.
j Signed Swo and Subscribed B ore Me This 7DayofApril1983 Am1w]-
f j
F Notary Public'
.- l M Comminien Enires May 5. W:7 F
f My Commission Expires j
i I
'"4
B3-42207(,0-LP2!.9J Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOAPO
' In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSLMERS P0kT.R COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No. SC-329 OL 50-330 OL April 1, 1983 i
i AFFIDAVIT OF G. M. SCHIERBERG i
~
My name is G. M. SchIERBERG I am employed by Stone & k'ebster Engineering Corporation as MASACER, PROCUREMENT QUALITY ASSURANCE.
I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Overview at the Midland Nuclear Plant site.
Prior to being given -this assignment, I have never worked on any l
Jcb or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I will be reviewing.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company er Bechtel.
I do not own any sharer of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock.
Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a
' l beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of j
Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Compan/ or Bechtel.
Signed f4..
i Swor and Subscribed Be re Me This '7 Day of April 1983 1/9&usr/
YL Notary 15bli.c 4
d er -..: n g,,;,,, u,y 3, i;n e
My Commission Expires 1
l 4
i
- i
,l~
B3-4220700-LP249J Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
~In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSUhT.RS POWER COMPANT 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL April 1, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF M. GIANNATTASIO l
My name is M. GIANNATTASIO I am employed by Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation as ASST. CHIEF ELECTRICAL ENGINEER.
I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Overview at the Midland Nuclear Plant site.
Prior to being given -this assignment, I have never worked on any Job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I*will be reviewing.
I have never been er:: ployed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company 1
or Bechtel stock.
Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own share: of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
Signe h -
SE ~
+
A Sworn nd Subscribed Before Me This I Day of April 1983
~w?eMMA C"~
Notarf hr511e i
i My c;
- Exsm my 5.1989 My Commission Expires i
e r
wi
B3-4220700-LP249J e
Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION i
ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSUMERS P0kIR COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL April 1, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF E. A. LONG My name is E. A. LONG I am employed by Stone & k'ebster Engineering Corporation as ASSISTANT ENGINEERING MANAGER I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Overview at'the Midland Nuclear Plant site.
Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I will be reviewing.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock.
Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have, a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am uneware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
/
4 Signed y
Sworn and Subscribed Before Me This Y Day of April 1983.
2k Ands
- ~'
Notary FEb'1re' '-
~
My Consnission Expires t
)
e 1
e v'*
m w^
=
.,e y
_q
B3-4320700-LP249J m
Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL April 1, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF JAMES CAVELL THOMPSON I am employed by Stone 6 Webster My name is James Cavell Thompson Engineering Corporation as Superintendent of FQC I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Overview at the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associa-ted with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I will be reviewing. I have never been employed by Consumers Power C0mpany or Bechtel. I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock. Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a beneficial interest, bot over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or ha e been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
ft[g/L Signed
/
[
i l
Sworn ad(d Subscribed Before Me This Day of April 1983 1
/$
A 111.
A
~
/
Notiary Public
~~
y amm 1. c% wuen j
% Pute. state og 3,, ge7g Cowqr tf Osacgo
'J, Ewires Earch 33, gg My Cons'aission Expires 1
i l
I
~
=$
f
(
M M
B3-4220700-LP249J Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM i
CONSUMERS P0kT.R COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL S0-330 OL April 1, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF W. D. MILLER My name is M 3 //7. / (M gus u,I,ro e I am employed by Stone & k*ebster Engineering Corporation as /Mswr e 7; s r
i I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Overview at'the Midland Nuclear Plant site.
Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any Job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I will be reviewing.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock.
Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have, a beneficial interest, but over whfch I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am enaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
Signed Ms).
Swor p d S bscribed fore Me This Day of April 1983
//?/i U$b I
" Notary Public
' ~ ~
- I I
i
- 0*, '4.
- s ' " U E.IC r
My Commission Expires W M '" * " *
- s Y
__m 6
m o
I s.
.e.
y.,',,.
g
[6 B3-4220700-LP240J
)
- c.,..
l-p
),1
. Figure'3-I l
s I,
UNITED STATES Of A' ERICA l
SUCLEAR REGULATORY COM'1TSSION j
ATO:!!C SATETY AND'LICESSING BOARD L
4 g i In the Matter of
. Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSUME.h5 POkT.R COMPANY 50-330 OM 3
,' ~
('lidland Plant, Units I and 2)
't Docket No. 50-329 OL, 50-330 OL
' ' April 1,,1983 I
AFFIDAVIT OF _RJ.L 4 5. Sieb by name 'is. k..) 8 L Mon I ao employed by Stone & '.ebster I
' Engineerir.g Corporat,Lo,3 as.SeWot o.c TA ya d oc a
I a:n i urrently assigned'-to the " team which is propo' sed toiconduct a Third Party.Constructica Impicmentat. ion Overview at the Midland Nuclear. Pla.t s'Ite.
Prior ',tolbeing 'given this assigr. ment. I have never verked on any
' d 'or task
- ass'ociated with the ' Midland Project, or any' job or task for' i
j
, or on ; behalf' of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I
- vill be reviewing.
I have never been_ employed b'y Qonsumeri P-ee i
Cc':pany' c'r Bechtel.
I do
- nbt.own any shares of Consumers Power Company l
' ;/:
.or Bechtel ' stock.. Mutual funds' or 'other ' funds in ' 'which I say have a
~
..b.eneficial int' rest,' but over which I hav'e no control, may own shares of e
i
- Consu:ser,s Power Cocipany.or Bechtel stock,' of' which I as ' unaware. ' A m
i 4j list of su' h e' funds
'I have no'8
-).' Dig relatiye's'whi h a'ie;!1n. which I.have an inte' rest ire attached.' lori h e
c S
}
Sworn and Subscribed Before He This d' Day of ' April 1983
~
. j ;', s'
{
i l
CCO..
~
Notary Public
,1
- < a g
t
't i
MyConrsissbnExpirus
.' di.
l s
.l.-
I
~. -
+
i s
l
~.,,.
i
'I
~
B3-4220700-LP249J Figure 3-1 i
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA hTCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSLMERS POWER COMPAhT 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units I and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL April 1, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF J..R. LANCSTON My name is 7/4. /-/wc.:c57E4/
I am employe3 by Stone & Vebster Engineering Corporation as %hMaLe. Set rs'v.%M
/
I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Overview at' the Midland Nuclear Plant site.
Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I will be reviewing.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock.
Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have, a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
Signed
_ u t
y a r-Sworn and Subscribed Before Me This L* Day of April 1983 h-1 '. W
$m_
y Notarf Public JACQUEUNE A. IVONE
)
NOTARY PUBUC. Sess of New YM e
% OllV4601469, sanok Cowey Tam Empires March 30,19//
My Consnission 1^xpires _a - _h-M l
l
)
1
~
Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD Docket No. 50-329 OM In the Matter of 50-330 OM CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY Docket No. 50-329 OL (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2) 50-330 OL April 1, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF Albert A. Smith I am emploved by Stone & Webster My name is Albert A. Smith Control Systems Engineer Engineering Corporation as I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Overview at the Midland Nuclear Plant Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any i
site.
job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I will be reviewing. I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel. I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a or Bechtel stock.
veneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of ii A
Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware.I have no list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached.
relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
Signed 86
[
g Sworn and Subscribed Before Me This 7-Day of April 1983 A'
7 Notary Public PWftlP J. TALAlso e na uY,I,I.rs
'O. a.. - My Commission Expires --
- r.% - - =
Il ti 4
..3 A
j-
)
B3-4220700-LP249J Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION i
ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
' In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSUMERS P0kT.R COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units I and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL April 1, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF J. HANNWACKER
~
isJmaPH MMMwACKdst.
I am employed by Stone & Webster My name Engineering Corporation as &rtrmeAL Ea/csorte I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Overview at the Midland Nuclear Planc site.
Prior to being given -this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I"will be reviewing.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company i
or Bechtel stock.
Mutual funds or ather funds in which I may have a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
Signed f[ /
h Sworn a Subs bed Before Me This9'N Day of April 1983 l
M
. = eL-l ocary T blic FEUX 'J. COLAN ";ELO j
Notary Public. State of New York No. 30-4766212 i -
Oselified in Nassau County ComuWesion Empires March 30,1984 My Commission Expires Nue# Sosfr/
i i
. d e
m
O B3-4220700-LP249J 1
Finure 3-1 1
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD t
' In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSL?E.RS P9kT.R COMPANY 50-330 OM (Mid:.:nd Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL April 1,1983 AFFIDAVIT OF F. BEARHAM is PRED kNLR A M My name I am employed b Stone & k'ebster G $. E.NC le/9 d/2 y Engineering Corporation as
?
I am currently assigned to the team which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implemer.tation Overview at the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I*will be reviewing.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
I do not own any shares of Consumers Powcr Company or Bechtel stock.
Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a beneficial interest, but over whica I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware.
A list of such funds in which.I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
3 1
Signed
/
i I
Sworn and Subscribed Before Me This /6v Day of April 1983
'4 3
/
.JLo.
L :_-
~
Notary Public 1
pcQubNt e In k.a NO! ARY PUEJt. Sw+ cf Ne= V
l
~!
% Oby Ant 469. Su*s toi -
~;
tr t ec.m. e2 < 30 1' /Y
)
01 tiy Commission Expires _E _ra-> V j
11
+
+
r
~
r, ye
--4 e
syv,r-#-
w e-
-6y-r.r-;
e+
w y e-
- q B3-4220700-I.P249J i
Figure 3-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSUMERS P0kT.R COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL April 1,1983 AFFIDAVIT OF WJ. Sienkieviez My name is W.H. Sienkiewicz I am employed by Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation as Assistant District Manager, PQA.
I am currently assigned to the teem which is proposed to conduct a Third Party Construction Implementation Lverview at' the Midland Nuclear Plant site.
Prior to being given this assignment, I nave never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel relating to issues that I will be reviewing.
I have never been ewployed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock.
Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have, a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company or Bechtel stock, of which I am unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company or Bechtel.
Signed b af87z, M e Un.
l i
Sworn and Subscribed Before Me Day of April 1983 l
t c~efw e.- A*. hs-0'-
Notary Public i
ALMA flWIRAFFB,Netsy Pdes L
j wormamoson Tep., evens ca.
My Conrzission Expires 1
l
- i i
a l~~
'\\
i V
-$~*N f
~
[ga nac,(o oc UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION g
g REGloN lil
.g I-
=*
,E 799 RoJSEVELT ROAD
)
0,
[
GLEN ELLYN, ILLINols 60137
,e 1
FEB 2 4 883 t
Docket No. 50-329 Docket No. 50-330 Consumers Power Company ATIN: Mr. James W. Cook Vice President Midland Project 4
1945 West Parnall Road Jackson, MI 49201 Gentlemen:
i We have reviewed your proposal to have the Stone and Webster Corporation (S&W) perform the third party independent assessment of the soils remedial work activities.
The staff has received sworn statements from the S&W Corporation and from the key S&W personnel (Attachments A and B respectively) attesting i
to corporate and individual independence.
The staff has also reviewed a letter, J. E. Brunner to W. L. Paton, 4
dated November 15, 1982 (Attachment C) which describes the contracts undertaken by S&W for the Consumers Power. Company and indicates that s
S&W or its subsidiaries have no holdings of Consumers Power Company stocks. The attachments to this letter have been subsequently notarized.
The staff has considered the qualifiestions of both the S&W organization and the individuals proposed as team members te conduct the independent review of Consumers Power Company's management of the Midland soil project.
j Inputs to this review included the information supplied in the above i
submittals, the staff's existing knowledge of S&W performance at other
~
nuclear power plants and information as to S&W personnel competence.
Our evaluation of these documents revealed that the competence and independence criteria have been met as set forth in Chairman Palladino's l
letter to Congressmen Ottinger and Dingell of February 1, 1982.
}
Based on our-reviews we have datermined that the S&W Corporation is
)
an acceptable organization to perform the third party asse::sment of
}
the soils remedial work; however, the scope of the S&W assessment should 1
be broadened to include the following:
a r
T
.L N 6,p 4
e P
-6 v-v-
b- -a v +-
w Mm, e ope e
^
Tr'F9' T'
+*
5 W*"'-eP-W^*'Tu*
9 W
e e
W
O f
l
\\
r.
~
2-Consumers Power Company
~
l l
(1) Provide a QA overview and assessment of the design work packages,
to ensure accuracy and adequacy.
(2) Provide a QA overview and assessment of the QC inspector requalifi-cation and certification program.
(3) Provida a QA overview and sesessment of the training conducted for all personnel in the soila remedial work effort.
i (4) Expand the work contract to include an assessment of all underpinning work on safety-related structures on which underpinning work is done while your contract with Stone and Webster is in effect.
In addt. tion, the Midland Sec. tion has reviewed Consumers Power Company's performance regarding the installation of Piers W12 and E12 and has concluded that no major discrepancias were identified during this work (Memorandum, R. Landsman to R. P. Warnick, dated 2/15/83 Attach===t D).
Stone and Webster in their letbar dated February 14,1983 (Attach==at E) also indicated that no major performance problems have been identified.
They have stated that in their opinion additional underpinning work could be released for construction.
I Based on the inclusion of' the previously described contract chansies, your performance record regarding Piers W12 and E12, and the acceptability of the Stone and Webster Corporation as the third party independent reviewer, we conclude that underpinning activities of safety-related ' structures may proceed. Please submit documentation of the expansion of the third party assessment to include the four areas identified above.- The work activities will be authorized in accordance with the approved NRC/CPCo Wctk Authorization c
Procedure.-
i Should you have any questions regarding this letter please contact Mr. R. Y. Warnick of my staff.
Sincerely, Originalsignedg A. Bert Davis I
James G. Kappler Regional Adefnistrator Enclosures As stated l
cc w/ encl:
See attached distribution list i
we 2M3 k K1,
,8,,
N,,,,,,,,
a=c4. RI,II,
,,,,,,)
,,,,j),,,,,,,,,,,,
,,p
~
sunname). @. Q
..s....
19.......L....
.............. Davis
,Kej... er Eisenhut
..........k..........
....a......
....l.2...... 63 om>. m
,3......
.2....t.[.........
...>..v. 3 %
p i
unc ro u m iio... uncu os o OFFICIAL RECORD COPY m.
---e.
e m
y-T-
t-
--g-y
.-.--v-
-vm-
O f
~1 Consumers Power Company FFA 2 4 G33 cc w/ encl:
DMB/ Document Control Desk (RIDS)
Resident Inspector, RIII The Honorable Charles Bechhoefer, ASLB The Honorable Jerry Harbour ASLB The Honorable Frederick P. Cowan, ASLB The Honorable Ralph S. Decker, ASLB William Paton, ELD Michael. Miller Eonald Callen, Michigan Public Service Commission Myron M. Cherry Barbara Stamiris Mary Sinclair Wendell Marshall Colonel Steve J. Gadler (P. E.)
O i
t.
f i
mr.
~
b r
a e
ATTACHMENT A STONE & WEBSTER MICHIGAN, INC.
f,[,'~f[ d 4 *S 3/L '. !
- c. s, -
P.O. Box 2325. BosroN. MAssAcHusETrs 02107 y,n, g 7
MfI.. ~i e,
. A. 9. I
' ~ l e
'i:
i l
t i
.M~t i
67 IA _ _ l i
_17
%...M.,
d.t.
i Mr. J. C. Keppler February 14, 1983 Administrator, Region III U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Consission J.O. No.14358 799 Roosevelt Road MPS-7 j
~
Clen Ellyn, IL 60137 RE: DOCIET No. 50-329-330 MIDIAND PIANT - UNITS 1 AND 2 INEPENENT ASSESSENT OF AUXILIARY BUILDING 131E RPINNING INDEPENEN2 & ASSESSENT TEAM Cons m ers Power Company Specification CC-100 originally issued on September 20, 1982, set s forth the criteria for indepen:ience for the Ass essment Tean.
Stone & Webster Michigan, Inc.,
determined that the Corpration and the individual members of the Team satisfy the requirements of the Specification. We have also determined that our subcontrctor, Parsons 4
Brinckarhoff Michigan Inc. seet these requirements as set forth in a letter signed by Thanas R.
Kuessel, Senior Vice President of Parson Brinckerhoff Michigan Inc., dated November 4,1981.
In particular both Corporations satisfy the followies criteria The Corprations or individuals assiped to this work do not have e
my direct previous involvement with Midland activities that they will be reviering.
I The Corprations or individuals ass' ped to this work have not been j
e l
previously hired by the Owner to perform design, construction, or quality work relative to the soils remedial program.
i e'
The idivichaale assiped to this work have not been previously q
employed by the Owner within the last 3 years.
The individuals assiped to this work do not have present household e
l members uployed by the Owner.
i l
e The individ*:als assiped to this work do not have any relatives i
employed by the Owner in a management capacity.
The Corpretions and indivichaels assiped to this work do not con-e trol a significant secant of Owner stock.
j f
FEB15 E83 ix21435 4 g p
u-
]
JGK 2
February 14, 1983 Under separate cover we are sending signed affidavits for each manber of the Assessment Team.
If you have any questions, pleas e contact Mr. A.
Stanley Lucks at (617) 589-2067.
P. A. Wild Vice President Sworn and subscribed to before se on this 14th day of February,1983.
t: $ 'N XC..
_ m7 v1 N' Notary Public i
Suff olk County Massachusetts My Consission Empires November 8,1985.
Catherine Trabucco NOTARY PUBLIC For the Commar.veealth of Massachusetts f.:y Coram:ssica Exo:ses Nov. 8,1985 4
9 l
I, t
i I
i i
I 4
s i
31214358-4
+. ~ -
,,,y,...
'5 s
f-*ACHMENT B y$."ll'3.l Sld gag.gi e t
v JT II.id tY
][,1.Lj 8
~.W STONE & WEBSTER MICHIGAN, INC.
3.F..3 1
.;,. g
.j
" ' F-!--
i....
P.O. Box 2325. DosTON. M AssACHusETTs 02107
.n' ; -
'A9 I
~ 5'- h Mr. J. C. Keppler February 15, 1983 Administrator, Region III J.O. No. 14358 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Conunission MPS-9 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 RE: DOCKET NO.
50-329/330 l'IDLAND PLANT - UNITS I AND 2 INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT OF AUXILIARY BUILDING UNDERPINNING ASSESSMENT OF WORK ON PIERS W12 AND E12 l
TEAM MEMBER AFFIDAVITS I*
Enclosed with this letter are signed affidavits for the Stone & Webster and Parsons Brinckerhoff Assessment Team members.
t If you have any questions with respect to these affidavits please call j
me at (617) 589-2067.
A.S.Lucl.a Project Manager ASL:PJC i
i t
i i
, a 7~
FEP.16 t993
.!.7-4 e-,
......y.
s
T UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2 Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL i
February 14, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF
/
\\
My name is A.S. 1,ucks I an employed by Stone & Webster Engineerina Corporation as Proieet Manager I am currently assigned to the team which is conducting an independent assessment of soils work at the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with 1
i the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power i
Company Bechtel, or the Mergentime Company relating to soils of underpinning.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentine Company. I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or j
Mergentine stock. Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of l
Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentine stock, of which I am unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentine Company.
l j
Sworn,and Subscribed Before Me This 14th Day of February 1983
?
'll'4L
/2d W Notary Public i
Suffolk County, Massachusetts
\\
.j My Commission Expires November 8. 1985 i
I Catherine Trabucco 4
NOTARY PUBLIC For the Comrronwealth of Massachusetts afy Commission Empires Nov. 8,1985
.E e
_.z...m
,e
-m s.~
s
\\
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 ON CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2 Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL February 14, 1983 d.
AFFIDAVIT OF My name is W.E. Kilker I an employed by Stone & Welster Entineerina Corporation as Project Engineer I am currently assigned to the tesa which is conducting an independent l
assessment of soils work at the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being given this assignment I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland vroject, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power company, Bechtel, or the h rgentine Company relating to soils of underpinning.
i I have never been employed by Consumet's Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentina 1
Company. I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentine stock. Mutual funds or other funds in which I any have a r
beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or k rgentine stock, of which I an unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtsi, or k rgentine Company.
j I
Sworn and Subscribed Before h This 14th Day of yebruary 1983
'?l llLOC Suffolk County, Massachusetts l
My Commission Empires November 8. 1985 4
Catherine Trabucco j
Norm rueuc com n My commission Empres Nov. 8,1965 l
1 i
4 e
7 '
~
a e,
h
l l
's l
IlNITED STATE! 0F AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATONIC SATITY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No 50-329 ON CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY 50-330 ON (Midland Plant, Vaits 1 and 2)
Docket No 50-329 OL 50-330 OL yebruary 11, 1983 AFyIDAVIT OF,C/[8m V
Hy name is fnyt. F&1pH. I an employed by stowr elvrt$57Ff fndi~ M o n Mff' as a $7tewsk M4wns'..
I as currently assigned to the team which is conducting an independent assesseest of soils work at' the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to beirs
~
given this assignment. I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Conpany, Bechtel, or the Mergentine Company relating to soils or underpinning.
I have never been employed by Consumern Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentine
' Company. I do not own any shares of Cc tsumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentine stock. Hutual funds or other f. ands in which I may have a beneficial interest, but over which I have no centrol, may own shares of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime stock, of which I an unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have as interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Con.sumers Power company, Bechte1, or Mergentine Company.
Sworn and Subscribed Before Me This //
Day of 2
n1% n $-
n J
i Notary Piiblic (N
l N -H = County, Michigan daf
+
My Commission Empires A -t/*fle
.a i
af0283-0349a100
^
~
~
A
\\
s'. T,
~~'
4,.
1-
,U.. g 1
\\.
N UNf17.D STATES'0F AMEkICA
- NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC
.TY AND LICENSING BOAmi i
In the Matter of m
Dockst' No 50-329 OM CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY
'50-330 CM s
(Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2) x Docket No 50-229 OL u
50-330 OL 3
t A
g 'i k
'q y
Febrdry 11, 1983 3 -
i AFFIDAVITOF/d_)_
f h
'N, g
7 y
j My name is AR Scott
.I an employed'by ' Stone & Webster as vr.p re ar.
sr
./
I
~
I as currently assignadsto.the' eam which'is conductin[sn'inderendent assessment of soils worY'at' the hidland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being
~
given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, 'er any job or task for er on beiulf of Consumers Power 3
Company, Bechtel, or the Mergentime Company relating to soils go underpinning.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company,- Beshnl, or Mergentime Company. I do not cyn any shares of Consuawes Power company, Bechtel, or Mergentine ste,ck. ifutual funds or other funds in which I may have a beneficial interest,. but over which'I have no control, *isay own shares of j
Consumers Powed Company, Bechtel, or MergeIntime stock, of whilch I an unaware.
A list of such funds lin which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been eeployed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime Company.
-3 Sworn and Subscribed Bef6 e Me This*/4 bay of b
/
nzida dbbv l c
j Notary Public 5(/g/ -
1*
_ County, Michigan y
My Commission Expi R-t/~((,c
-t
.j N
s.
s j
I was employed by Bechtel Corporation froc March 1450to July 1958 ar.d frge June 1972, to Saptunber,19.76., g,
'[,
N
's,.
g-
]
x t
z ~%
4 -
, g, j
/
,' s
'/_s p
l af0283-0349a100 1-h
~r.
+
h~=-
A'
=
4 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORT COM!iISSION ATOMIC SAFETT AND LICENSING BOARD in the Matter of Docket No 50-329 ON CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY 50-330 CH (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No 50-329 OL 50-330 OL February 11, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OT X e w / [ [ ftr t i
My name is bur ene. T. nnum I as employed by Stone and Webster Engr? Corp.
as u-gr oi,23 u,.
a..,ir2r.. Engineer.
I as currently assigned to the team which is conducting an independent assessment of soils work at'the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being
~
given this assignment, I have never werked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Constwrs Power Company, Bechtel, or the Mergentime Company relating to soils or underpinning.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime
' Company.
.I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime stock. Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime stock, of which I as unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, i
or Mergentine Company.
i Sworn and Subs ribed Before Me This L ay of h avat 0 sa j.
Notary Public (/ (/
j 1
9---e r County, Michigan J-V- [ds Hy Commission Exp s
I 1
l l
af0283-0349a100
~
1
.- e
's UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD in the Matter of Docket No. 50-329 OM COMSUMERS POWER COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units I and 2)
Docket No. 50-329 OL 50-330 OL February 11, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF 1
v Inger. f-34 A
My name is Barr
. Hol la m employed by Stone & Webster as 0.A Enginefr I am currently assigned to the tear which is cunducting an independent assessment of soils work at the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any Job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or M behalf of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or the Mergentime Company relating to soils or underpinning.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime Company.
I do not can any shares of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime stock. Mutual funds or other funds in which I re4y have a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of j
Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime stock, of which I am unaware.
l A list of such funds in which I have.an interest are attached.
I have no relatives which are or have been err. ployed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime Company.
' h4lf < Y}C l
Sworn and Subscribed Before Me This e d Day of Y. cit n a.o, 1983 s
_q n
.' A 4 l -
/ et a <: u i
/
Notary Public NANCY $. NORE se.ns, e.w m m. si, at see. Tat w m o s c n 3+ :snp 1
My Commission Expires m, w im w M. PM
. ^I
~
r
-D.-
l {\\ \\%
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCI. EAR REGULATORY C0t2 FISSION AT0t1IC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Dockat No 50-329 ott CONS 12fERS POWER CotiPANY
$0-330 0t1 (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Doc.kat No 50-329 OL 50-330 OL February 11 1983 ATTIDAVIT OT
/
r _ _..
My nzme is Thomas R. Kuesel. I am employed by Parsons Brinckerhoff Ouade &
as Senior vice President Douglas, Inc.
I as currently assigned to the team which is conducting an indepenAnet assessment of soils work at' the Midland Nuclear Plant sita. Prior to being
~
given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on betalf of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or the Bergentime Company relating to soils gr underpinning.
I have never been amployed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Merg* tim
~ Cogany. I do not own any shares of Consumars Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime stock. Natual funda or other funds in which I any have a beneficial interest, but ever which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company, Bechtal.. or Mergentine stock, of which I am unaware, A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime Company.
I
- 9 FD Sworn and subscribed Before He This / 4 Day of/4o JS8f i
l h
No$yPublic j
A h e C. ;ty, T.i Lig-e- :
i t;oTARYts-a '.
W 3N%
omnission Expires ccA.l.Ank+'"'"*"je g
- From 1963 to 1967 I was employed by Parsons Brinckerhoff-Tudor-Bechtel, General Engineering Consultants for design and construction management of the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit System, in the capacity of j
Assistant Manager of Engineering.
1 l
f l
(
!j
_ sf0283-0349a103
~
h UNITED STATES Oy AMERICA NUCIZAR REGUIATORY CottfISSION A11:lt1IC SAFETT AND LICENSING BOARD In the liatter of Docket No 50-329 ott CONSIM'ni POWER CotfPANy
$0-330 Otf (Mid1==1 Plant,t!aits 1 and 2)
Docket No 50-329 OL 50-330 OL yebruary 11, 1983 ATTIDAVIT OF _
My name is Louis G. Silano I as. employed by Parsons Brinckerhoff Quade &
as Techni cal ni vor.y Umiglas, Inc.
Major Structures I as currently assigned to the team which is conducting an independant assessment of soils work at" the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Compa.7, Bechtel, or the Mergentime Company relating to soils or underpinning.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime
- Company. I do not oun any shares of Conssaars Power Cosqpany, Bechtel, or Mergentime stack. Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a beneficial interest, but ever which I have no control, may oan shares of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel. or Mergentim stock, of.which I an unaware, A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been~ esployed by consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime Company.
I 9 f)
Swa :n and Subscribed Before Me This /4 Day of fe6 agar
~$
Notadry Public l
-h r Cm*, ".iu.
s r n c.c:Vo j
My C sion Empires "U " ". N '. ' " *
- ew.... a. i.... n c: o cer.ure..v. t p... ;,;a....s. 4..a t
i af0283-0349a100
~*
3 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCIEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFET! AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No 50-329 OM CONSUMERS POWER ':0MPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket No 50-329 OL 50-330 OL February 11, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF 4 do My name is jV C PA/2Jts. I an employed by Sons $rreftdf/ChrdfSA as L sjnssi 4_w.
I as currently assigned to the team which is conducting an independent assessment of soils work at' the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being
~
givsn this assignment, I have never worked on any jcb or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, er the Hergentime Company relating to soils or underpinning.
I have never been employed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentine
' Company. I do not own any shares of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentine stock. Hutual funds or other funde in which I may have a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime stock, of which I as unaware.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Corgany, Bechtel, or Herkentime Company.
Sworn and Subscr ed Before Me This[/
Day a
//
i
.i d
i Notary Public // v l
'- ' :: County, Michigan 8-(/'!b My Comnission s
i
. l
. I I
~.
af0283-0349a100
~
s
.,,_m
. ~.,.
.. _. _. _...... _, ~.
I T
UNIIT.D STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETT AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of Docket No 50-329 ON CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY 50-330 OM (Midland Plant, Units 1 med 2)
Docket No 50-329 OL 50-330 OL February 11, 1983 AFFIDAVIT OF
/
/
My name is Jerrold Ratner. I an employed by Parsons Brinckerhoff, Quade and Douglas as Nanager. construction l
I as currently assigned to the team which is conducting an independent assessment of soils work at'the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Prior to being given this assignment, I have never worked on any job or task associated with the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or the Mergentime Company relating to soils or underpinning.
I have never been employed by Consumern Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime
' Company.
_I do not own any shares of Consuadrs Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime stock.
Mutual funds or other funds in which I may have a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own shares of
(
Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, or Mergentime stock, of which I am unswere.
A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached.
I have no relatives which are or have been employed by Consumers Power Company, Bechtel, i
or Mergentin Company.
4 1
Sworn and Subs ribed Before Me This ///bDay o d a M 0 adho Notary Public County, Michigan My Csamission Expires
.3 - t/- N, 1
l l.
I i
1 i
af0283-0349a100
~
4
.e
.-+~w+
' - ~ ~ ~
~
a,
INITED STAIT.S OF A!fERICA NUCI. EAR REGUIAIORY C0t2 FISSION ATotiIC SAFETT AND LICENSING BOARD In the W tter of Docket No 50-329 ott CONS 12fERS POWER CatfPANY 50-330 Otf (Midland Plant,t!aits 1 and 2)
Docket No 50-329 OL 50-330 OL February 11, 1983 I
AITIDAVIT OF _
c8
'r-U My same igincent J. Madi,111 an emplayed by "" arsons Brinckerhoff Ouade &
P 1
t
" Douglas, Inc.
as _seninv rngino v
~
I am currently assigned to the team which is conducting an indep-aA-t k-assessment of seile wek at' the Midland Nuclear Plant site. Price to being 5
given this assismaant, I have never worked on any job or task associated with V
the Midland Project, or any job or task for or on behalf of Consumers Powe 2.<3 Cogany, Rechtel, or the &rgentime Company relating to soils or anderpianf nr.
2.
I have ne'rer been employed by Cosaumers Power Company, Bechtel, or krgentime
?-
- Cogamy. I do not own any shares of Consumars Power Company, Bechtel, or 2..
& rgentine' stack. ttatual funds or other funds in which I may have a beneficial interest, but over which I have no control, may own sharea of p
Con.sumers Power Company, Bechtel.. og kegenti,me. sto.ck, of.which I an.up==re, A list of such funds in which I have an interest are attached. I have no d.
relatives which are or have been~ employed by Consomers Power C.'.spany, Bechtel, or h egentime Company.
gi t
197)
Sworn and subscribed Before & This /4 Day cf /*6.1982'
"?
-h I
Notar/Public J::h:2 C:
- .y, ml.i.
My ( ssion Expires _
i.----3 h e n.. m e....
s,
.::: York
- . 31.:.
Q.:.t. n.
cc,n.,u....a o u...1:.i.. c:vty
..i... i.:.: a ;.,, i;,33 l
\\
i i
L af0283-0349a100
~
i F
l
~
Copy ATTACHMENT C tsaat ca,Ams,n t
x s..-
38 c.-
- d. A c
-a-
"S,7 o*.*.*.*.*.**
26s 7..',.'.*:l'.
C',"o" '""
a-, o,
og,,,L,,,
= s : a-n Rems. J Swo Se Een O's,."*
""**llO**
~ "*~"
ll " "/"c.*~
ca A Meh.sene.
o.n.,e om sis w www.an 4 J m n, m assot. (si7) 7se4eso November 15, 1982 oU ase y A Same.
4.es O She.n.e.
PRINC!PA' STAFF "T"d*"' '""'
l 0l I
a M
a.
ID ; +. 1 i- -.
William D Paton
.It"
_f. L,&l_M O,
i Ti si..l ! [2 Counsel for the NRC Staff
[f'foi,{
11.]
U S Nuclear Regulatory Conunission l.hyp {
l e
Washington, DC 20555 r ;~
g
_i 6
MIDLWD NUCLEAR C0 GENERATION PLANT
~
l f I L E U (d)
~-
MIDLAND DOCKET NOS 50-329, 50-330 STONE & WEBSTER (S&W)
Recently, questions have been raised concerning the use of the Stone and l
Webster Company (S&W) to conduct an appraisal of underpinning of the Midland auxiliary building. A public meeting regarding these issues, among others,
, as conducted in Washington on, November 5, 1982.
w During that meeting, representatives of the NRC Staff asked certain questions touching upon the independence of the Stone and Webster Company. To respond more fully to these questions, Consumers asked Stone & Webster to describe jobs undertaken by S&W on behalf of Consumers Power Company and to determine S&W's holdings of Consumers' securities. The attached letter is S&W's response to those questions.
According to the attached letter, Stone & Webster has carried out, and is carrying out, no work for Consumers Power Company in relation to the soils remedial project, other than the present audit. S&W has undertaken two relatively limited assignments not related.to soils on behalf of the Midland Proj ect.
The letter also indicated, that Stone & Webster's or its subsidiaries have no holdings of Consumers Power Company stocks.
Wf i
ames E Brunner O
l CC DSHood, NRC I
Billie Gardie CM/0L Se:vice List I,
Mia =
.,w 1,
PDR-ADOCK 05000329 A
PDR oc1182-0270a100 fi."."*.'.'*-) 2 7UAL
.,.., D S N
I
l 0
t
\\
SERVICT L T.
Frunir J Kaller, !sq Atcaic Safety & Licensing 2torner General of the Appeal Pacel Statecof Mi-bd==a II S Nucleer Reguistcry Cema Carole Steinberg, EscL
's--h4n= ton.,. D C 20555 i
Assistant Attorney General Ettrironmental Protection Div-Mr C R Stephens T20 Leur Building Chief, Docketing k Services.
Iansing., Mr h8913 IT S 3belear Reguistory Coma Cffice of the Secretary Mrron M Cherrr, Esq Washingecir, D C 20555 Cne IBM Plasm Suita h5CI Ms Mary N' =4-Chicago, IL 60611 5711 Sumerset. Street 1
.w aiana, MI h86ho Me Wandall E Marshall RFD.10 William D Pscoe, Esq Midland,. Mr.h86ho
- Counsel' for the 3RC Staff U S Nucisar Requistory Cannt.
Charles 3echheefer, Isq Washington,D c 20555 Atcaic Safety & Licensing Board Puel Atensic Safety & Licens1=g IT S 2nciame Hagulaterr ccain Board Panel Washingsca,.D C 20555
'tr s'3aclear Requiscerr cc:=a Washington, D C 20555 Dr Frederick.? Cawtn 6152 I verds Trail,
Barbars.Stamiris Asp 3-127 5795 North River Road.
3cca Racca,. FL 33k33 Re 3 Freeland, MI k8623 Jerry Earbour i
Atcate Safety & Licensing Bo'ard Panel Carroll'I Mahaner tT S Nuclear Reguistory Cama 3abcock & Wilcox washington, D C 20555 PO Box 1260 Lynchburg, Virgini 24505 Ice L Bishop Har:mme & Weiss Jese E Brunner,. Ist 172 "I" Street, 3W #506 Consumers Power ?---
Washington, DC 20006 212 West MLehigan Avanne Jackson, MI k9201 M r Miller, Esq j
Isham, Lincain & 3eale Mr D T Judd Sree.3mtionsi Plaza Babcocir, & Wilcaz.
52nd Floor PO Box 1260 Chicago, IL 60603 i
Igachburg YA 2kf05 John Demeester, Esq Steve Gadler, Zag Dow Chemical sids 2120 Carter Avenue-Kichigan Division St Paul, MN 55108 Midland, MI kS6ko 4
I am
.e e SNeS em
.w4 Aa--
e v
r--
--m,-
,y,. -.,,,, -,,4 g,
yv-
-ye-p--.ee----9~-b--gy-g*-
y-p.-t
e...
3
~
x!m2< TELEC::P:EP 495; 9-11-5u 3:29PM 51-- -acs ::= 2 STONE & WEBSTER MICHIG AN. INC.
P.O. mex 2325. sesroe. Massacmuscris 02'07
- iove=ber 9, 1982 t
Mr. John R. Schaub Project Manager Consumers Power Co=pany 194$ V. Parnall Road Jackson, Michigan 49201 4
Dear Mr. Schaubs Per your request to Mr. Carl 7. Sundstrmn I am cnclosing a list and description of John that Stone & Webster Michitan Inc. has undertaken
.f or Constaners Power Company (CPCo). I a= also prewiding the results of my investigation of our holdings-!n C?Co securities.
If we can be of further amaintance. pleano cal! Mr. Carl F.
Sundstros at (617) 389-2780.
Very truly yours, P. A. Wild
- Vice Prcnidant
[
1 1
i y
I, I
e 9
I V0 4
e
~.
4 e.
6 TELECPIL't 495: 9-11-52; 3:34PM 2
51':""8 SCC 343 m 3 r
Start D e M an brii.! N s.riveien
.hev Por.sen 3/78 12/81 Reviev 'tidland Plant ] Int of equip ent and PSevitt recosusand spare parts.
RMontross GSleigh 6/78 6/80 Prepare an outagt critique report on the KSpencer Palisades Station second outage and provide planninC support for the September, 1779 re-4 feeling outage.
11/78 6/80 Procure a cobile security access module to K5 pencer be used for outage work forces at Palisades.
3/82 7/82 Evaluate and cake rece=endat fun for train-RDeane ing and implementation of the Midland Sita 51towell Emergency Plan.
- W8eclean Perfor. an independent asses *:e c of con-JCook 9/82 struction activities related to the auxili-JP. coney ary building and feedvater (valation val _ve JSchaub Pit rasedial.sork at the.MJdland Site.
Provide a=crzency planning cuenulting services RSinde ann 10/82 for the Big Rock Site.
Wille-10/82 Perform vibratien analysis on the boiler feed JTord pump at the J. H. Campbell Unit 3 and recom-TMehl nend and 1.platent corrective actions.
GKuller Provide scrvices and materials" to coordinate TIlvc,od l
10/82 i
the 1983/84 Palisades refueling oucase.
JSchneider i
i i
l
- Note - SW did the review but WTECK who van already working in P.ichigan for Detroit sdisse at the Fermi Station is doing the detailed planning.
j O
k t
a f
i I
.3
, n ::
e oo
)
3 E*Cx TE ECCPIER 495: 9-11-32: 324PM 51 7 eCO 43m 4 w
H01.D10.C5 CT CPC.* A! c*.7.T*7!5 Stone & Webster. Inc. the parent ro:pany of St one & V=bster Engineering Corporation and its subsidiarine (including SWEC) havw no i
holdings of CPCo securities. The Employee Savings Plan of Stone & Webster.
Incorporated and participating subsidiariva is administered by the Chana Manhattan Bank, K.A. as trustee. Tunes may be invested in the Employee Banafit Investment Tunds, Equity Fund of the Chase Manhattan Bank which is a commingled fund. Stone & Webster c.sercises no direct control over the invi.stment of such funds.
The Chemical Bank of.tav York is trustee for the Employee Retire-nant Flan of Stone & Webster. Inc. and for participating subsidiaries.
Thors are no CPCo securities held in the plan.
t i
e s s.
t,O g Q
h i
q.
I l
g i
.~-
e
~n...
p-m.
I
...c.,
t 3
'IACHMENT D l
February 15e 1983 i
NEtt)RANDUM 701:
- 1. F. Warnick, Director. Office of Special Cases f
TERU W. D. Shafer, Chief. Midland Section i
~
FRON:
R. 3. Landsman, Reactor Inspector, Midland Section j
SUBJECI:
LICENSEE PERFORMANCE ON FIERS 12E and 12W EIII on December 9, 1982, authorised CPCo to initiate work activities pertaining to the drift, excavation and installation of Piers 12E and 12W. Subsequent to that authorisation the licensee began work on December 13, 1962. Due to the Diesel Generator Building Inspection I have had only enough time to perform five inspwetions to detarmine the q
acceptability of the licensee's work in regards to these piers including removal of fill concrete, shaf t excavation and bracing, bell excavation and bracing, and reinforcing details and proposed concreting activities.
I have identified three concerns since underpinning work began which have been subsequen:.ly corrected or are in the process of being corrected by the licensee. They ares l
a) That the craf tworkmen were not receiving the required amount of 1
J specialised remedial soils underpinnine training. The licensee has agreed to expand the scope of craft. training, but does not have the details worked out to date.
b) That the licensee wanted to use a super plasticiser as an additive to the concrete six in lieu of good concreting prac.tices, i.e.,
consolidation by vibration. The licensee after what I consider to be excessive discussions finally agreed to vibrate all underpinning concrete in accordance with good engineering practice.
e l
2 c) That the third party independent assessment tema is not reviewing the design documents for technical adequacy. They are only doing j
implementation review to assure that the design documents are being followed. From discussions with Stone and Webster personnel, it a
I was determined that this important parameter was not included
~
in their contr.ct. The licensee is presently considering including this in the montract documents.
j Besides these three concaras no other issues or deviations from regulatory requirements have been identified.
i (0
)
- x...
O'WWMI.I M4 tar. 18speMter..............
......p.
58**'" > L4R49M R..5%
l
.k
.............e.......................*...**..
.......t.*******..**.......*......*..
............e
......a,.a no-e-see a e rse e n es n e n esu
,l'
. m.-
+
.,m,m.
ATI. OtENT E N3.FNAL f'Ml vCiri WU i
$ $- h a;f,f H 4 O m.i HM.b l
STONE & WEBSTER MICHIGAN, INC.
j jpp:,-- g-.n mr P.O. Box 2325, mosToN. MassacMuseTTs 02107 g
?
- np i
e r
l~ %
lFito u s xL w
i l
l
'~
Mr. J. G. Kappler February,14, 1983 Administrator, Region III J.0. NO. 14358 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Consission MPS-8 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 4
RE: DOCKET No. 50-329/330 MIDLAND PLANT - UNITS 1 AND 2 INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT OF AUXILIARY BUILDING UNDERPINNING ASSESSMENT OF WORK CN PIERS W12 AND E12 l
As of February 11, 1983 the Stone & Webster - Parsons Brincherhoff Assessment Team has observed the excavation, placing of reinforcement.
and concreting of underpinning pier W12, and the excavation, and
'j placing of reinforcement for underpinning pier E12. In addition, the Assessment Team has reviewed the drawings, procedures and other documents j
pertaining to the underpinning work and has observed the performance of the Quality Assurance and Quality Control Organisations during the pro-grass of the work.
t i
During the period that the Assessment Team has been on site, daily i
meetings have been held with Construction Quality and Engineering personnel to obtain additional information and discuss observations.
The Assessment Team has issued twenty Weekly Reports to the U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission. These reports have described the activities of the Assessment Team and summarised their observations and findings.
The Assessment Taan has issued a total of five Monconformance Identification Reports. Four of these Nonconformance Identification Reports have been closed out to the satisfaction of the Assessment Team. The remaining open Nonconfdrasace Identification Report was issued on February 10,1983 and the Assessment Team feels that it can be closed out in the near future without faracting the progress of the underpinning.
The underpine.ing work is being perforasd in accordance with the construction and quality procedures. As the work has progressed.the procedures have been modified based upon experience gained during the construction of t
piers W12 and E12. The Assessment Team feels that these minor changes are appropriate and will have a positive effect on the quality of the under-pinning work.
l t
4 4.
-l FEB 15199'-
- mwwn,
o=>e 2
February la, 1983 g
o Based upon these observations and findings, the Assessment Team is of the 1
This opinion that additional piers could be released for construction.
will benefit the quality of the work by allowing the Contractor to main-tain the experienced labor teams from piers W12 and E12.
t If you have any questions, please contact me at (617) 589-2067.
A.S. Lucks Project Manager t
if 4
k 1
e..
e A
i i
1 l
l
1 U.$. NUCLEAR REGULATORY Co m!S$!0N REGION 111 GlTG0!IG TRANSMIS$10N SERVICE REQUEST Date Miaf[f3 ilu%er of Pages To (Name :_
. [, den ie h h5 ham )
Freas Description ion >
OMa n
8fase e
- Ma b EN a, L m a.
c Pc
+n in.D. Sknseu Air Rights 81dg.
FOR WP & 0/C USE E/W Towers System 6(WP)
H Street Repidfax MNB8 3M Ext #727 Phillips Bldg.
3M Eat #728 l
Silver Springs FTS (WillsteBldg) 8 Connercial Landow B1dg.
Time Started Region I
~
-Time Completed Region II Trans. Time Region IV (Actual Minutes)
Region V Operator Resident at it$AC INPO Corportate Office (Identify recipient & faz nester Other (Designate-include fox number l
l m.
_