ML20090B099
Text
,..
[_.
(,
TWrby 9
V 131981 Noy1 g 1981u t 8.*
u.s. aM.
=T'*"
Docket Nos:
l o>
P n
-MEMORANDUM FOR:
Elinor G. Adensam Chief Licensing Branch No. 4. DL FROM:
Darl S. Hood, Project Manager., Licensing Branch No. 4, DL
SUBJECT:
NOTICE OF MEETING - MIDLMID PLANT, UNITS 1 AND 2 DATE & TIME:
November 17..
1981 8:30 am - 5:00 pm LOCATION:
Room 5709 Maryland National Bank Building Bethesda, Maryland PURPOSE:
To integrate the licensing and construction schedules for the remedial foundation activities for the Midland Auxiliary building.
~
PARTICIPANTS:M NRC Consumers Power Company J. P. Knight
~ G. Keeley, et al.
E. Adensam, et al.
Bechtel A. Boos, et al.
gwo f
Darl S. Hood, Project Manager Licensidg Branch Nci. 4 Division of Licensing co:
See next page J/Neetings between NRC technical staff and applicants for licenses are open i
for interested members of the public, petitioners, intervenors, or other parties to attend as observers pursuant of "Open Meeting and Statement of NRC Staff Policy", 43 Federal Register 28058,6/28/78.
l
.QLJ.LBfA -
..dRM..... [....M ome6 am..M.
e
..iiM
...w..).y.e.1.....qu acosy
- s....
t we w.a.a.t.....
e
, ann ~ ~~-
p s.
, jsk'!"44g
(
UNITED STATES
-f g
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION g
a WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555
'%, Y Q 4,$
NOV 1 3 1981 Docket Nos:
50-329/330 OM, OL MEMORANDUM FOR:
Elinor G. Adensam, Chief, Licensing Branch No. 4. DL FROM:
Darl S. Hood, Project Manager, Licensing Branch No. 4. DL
SUBJECT:
NOTICE OF MEETING - MIDLAND PLANT, UNITS 1 AND 2 DATE & TIME:
November 17; 1981 8:30 am - 5:00 pm r
LOCATION:
ROOM 5709
~ i M,aryland Nationsl' Bank Building Bethesda, Maryland PURPOSE:
To integrate the licensing and construction schedules for the remedial foundation activities for the Midland Auxiliary building.
PARTICIPANTS:1I NRC Consumers Power: Company J. P. Knight G Keeley, et al.
E. Adensam, et al.
Bechtel A. Boos, et al.
ye,m #o o / -
Darl S. Hood, Pr ect Manager Licensing Branch No. 4 Division of Licensing cc:
See next page 1/ Meetings between NRC technical staff and applicants for licenses are open for interested members of the public, petitioners, intervenors, or other parties to attend av observers pursuant of "Open Meeting and Statement of NRC Staff Policy", 43 Federal Registe_r 28058, 6/28/78.
'6
(
e er r
i.
(u '.
h,. '
MIDLAND-Mr. J. W. Cook Vice President
. Consumers Power Company 1945 West Parnall Road Jackson, Michigan 49201 cc:
Michael I. Miller, Esq.
Mr. Don van Farrowe, Chief Ronald G. 'Zamarin, Esq.
Division of Radiological Health Alan S. Farnell, Esq.
Department of Public Health Isham, Lincoln &.Beale P.O. Box 33035 Suite 4200 l
Lansing, Michigan 48909 1 First National Plaza
- Chicago, Illinois 60603 William J. Scanlon, Esq.
2034 Pauline Boulevard James E. Brunner, Esq.
Ann Arbor, Michigan 48103 Consumers Power Company 212 West Michigan Avenue U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Jackson, Michigan 49201 Resident Inspectors Office Route 7 Myron M. Cherry, Esq.
Midland, Michigan 48640 1 IBM Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60611 Ms. Barbara Stamirls 5795 N. River Ms. Mary Sinclair Freeland, Michigan 48623 5711 Summerset Drive Midland, Michigan' 48640
. Mr. Paul A. Perry, Secretary Consumers Power Company Stewart H. Freeman 212 W. Michigan Avenue Assistant Attorney General Jackson, Michigan 49201 State of Michigan Environmental Protection Division Mr. Walt Apley 720 Law Building c/o Mr. Max Clausen Lansing, Michigan 48913 Battelle Pacific North West Labs'(PNWL)
Battelle. Blvd.-
Mr. Wendell Marshall SIGMA IV Building Route 10
. Richland, Washington 99352 Midland, Michigan 48640 Mr. I. Charak, Manager 2
Mr. Steve Gadler
- NRC Assistance Project 3
2120 Carter Avenue Argonne National Laboratory St. Paul, Minnesota 55108 9700 South Cass Avenue Argonne, Illinois 60439.
Mr. Roger W. Huston Suite 220 Mr. R. B. Borsum 7910 Woodmont Avenue
- Nuclear Power Generation Division
.Bethesda, Maryland 20814 Babcock & Wilcox
. 7910 Woodmont Avenue, Suite 220 Bethesda,' Maryland 20814-p fi l'
, ~,. _ _
^
~
[as no,,),
UNITED STATES y 3, e, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION wAsumaTom. o. c. 2osss
=.,
p NOV 2 31981 Docket Nos. 50-329 CM, OL
<NJ-and 50-330 0:1, OL APPLICANT:
Consumers Power Company FACILITY:
Midland Plant, Units 1 & 2
SUBJECT:
SU WARY OF NOVEleER 12, 1981 MEETING ON CONSTRUCTION SCHEDULES FOR FOUNDATION MODIFICATIONS TO AUXILIARY BUILDING On Noventer 12, 1981, the NRC staff met in Bethesda, MD, with Consumers Power Company (CPCo) to discuss construction schedules needed for the planned remedial actions to the Auxiliary Building at the Midland plant.
The remedial action, underpinning, results from the settlement potential of the backfill soils beneath the control tower and electrical penetrations area of that s tructure. Similar action is planned for the adjacent Feedwater Isolation Valve Pits and was included in the meeting discussions. Meeting attendees are listed in Enclosure 1.
Vice President J. Cook of CPCo reviewed the development history for the proposed remedial action which had initially been based upon use of jacking caissons, but which by September 1981, had been changed to a structural wall extending to the glacial till. Mr. Cook emphasized that the construction schedule for the Auxiliary Building underpinning was critical to the July 1983 fuel load date for Unit 2.
For this reason, Consumers had earlier asked the Licensing Board to rearrange the hearing sessions to consider the Auxiliary Buildinn before the Diesel Generator Building session.
To prepare for implementing tne under-pinning, a vertical access shaft on the east and west ends of the auxiliary building and adjacent to each feedwater isolation valve pit and the turbine building needs to be started by mid-Decenter 1981, and a freezewall by Decenter 29, 1981.
Staff approval of these two matters were requested by Mr. Cook's letter of October 28, 1981.
The schedule for start of drifting beneath the structures is February 15, 1982. Mr. Cook further emphasized that continuing staff review throughout the underpinning process was needed, ra ther than a traditional two-step staff approval process. He felt that more staff review and observation in the field should be considered to expedite the review process.
Review procedures such as that which had been followed during the staff's structural design audit at Anne Arbor, Michigan, in May 20 - 24, 1981, l
were also recomended.
Mr. D. Eisenhut agreed that staff approval prior to implementing the fix was needed.
In view of the construction schedule, he suggested specific approval points by tha staff or other conditions be defined based upon the planned construction activities and sequences comprising the underpinning scheme.
He noted that establishment of acceptable conditions could assist in the authorization to proceed.
It was agreed that a working meeting the following week wouH be scheduled to this end. To the extent possible, such conditions would :w %cted in hearing testimony.
' :::.w 1
l l'eeting Summary Midland, Units 1 & 2 Nr. ii. Miller. Esq., noted that conditions could not be established witnin the existing schedule for filing testimony (due Noverter 17, 1931) an ! that Consumers would like to ask the Board to accent a delay of a few days in the filing date. Mr. W. Olmstead Esq.
replied that the staff woull not ob.iect to i
such a request.
Messrs. G. Keeley and D. Budzik of CPCo described the preliminary analysis of the Auxiliary Building to be provided for staff review on Novetter 20,1%1.
The preliminary analysis will consider selected critical structural morters ant selected loading cortinations. An analysis of the construction sequence for the underpinning scheme will be comleted January 1.1082. The final analysis will he provided for staff review February 15. 1982.
It was noted that the latter tate corresponds to the start of drifting beneath the structure.
The final analysis is primarily for the electrical penetration area and control tower portions of the s tructurw. The analyses for the overali structure will be comleted April 15, 1962. June 1.1982 is tne earlist date that the FSAR can be updated to reflect the results of the completed analyses.
At the conclusion of the meeting, and in preparation of the working session planned for Noves6er 17.1931, Mr. Budzik nrovided the following schedule drawings to the staff's project manager:
(1) Drawing 7220-PPS-020. Revision 0, dated 11/06/31. " Project Production Schedule: Auxiliary Building Underpinning Schedule", sheets 1 and 2.
(2) braving 7220-PPS-021. Revision 0, dated 11/96/81. " Service llater Punn Structure Remedial Action - (Underpinning Wall)".
Darl Hood. Project Manaqer Licensing Branch #4 Division of Iicensino
Enclosure:
As stated cc: See next page l on.ce p! OLitg.4 p,( DL:LB 4 DL.
I l
' >== = 6 Dioed:1b.
' I:DuncarI..
EA6engan.
I I
~
nmp
. l l/l.*/6 L 11/..,/ 8)
II/
/RI l
l
.c eev ve a s. %w w OFFICIAL RECORD' COPY
i MIDLAND l
L Mr. J. W. Cook Vice President Consumers Power Cospany l
1945 West Parnall Road Jackson, Michigan 49201 l
cc: Michael I. Miller, Esq.
Mr. Don van Farrowe, Chief Ronald G. Zamarin. Esq.
Division of Radiological Health Alan S. Farnell, Esq.
Department of Public Health Isham, Lincoln & Beale P.O. Box 33035 Suite 4200 Lansing, Michigan 48909 1 First National Plaza
- Chicago, Illinois 60603 William J. Scanlon, Esq.
2034 Pauline Boulevard James E. Brunner, Esq.
Ann Arbor, Michtgan 48103 Consumers Power Cogany 212 West Michigan Avenue U,S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Jackson, Michigan 49201 Resident Inspectors Office Route 7 Myren M. Cherry, Esq.
Midland, Michigan 48640 1 IBM Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60611 Ms. Barbara Stamiris 5795 N. River Ms. Mary Sinclair Freeland, Michigan 48623 5711 Summerset Drive Midland, Michigan 48640 Mr. Paul A. Perry, Secretary Consumers Power Cogany Stewart H. Freeman 212 W. Michigan Avenue Assistant Attorney General Jackson, Michigan 49201 State of Michigan Environmental Protection Division Mr. Walt Apley 720 Law Building c/o Mr. Max Clausen Lansing Michigan 48913 Battelle Pacific North West Labs (PNWL)
Battelle Blvd.
Mr. Wendell Marshall SIGMA !Y Building Route 10 Richland Washington 99352 Midland, Michigan 43640 Mr.1. Charak, Manager Mr. Steve Gadler NRC Assistance Project 2120 Carter Avenue Argonne National Laboratory St. Paul, Minnesota 55108 9700 South Cass Avenue Argonne, Illinois 60439 Mr. Roger W. Huston Suite 220 Mr. R. B. Borsum 7910 Woodnont Avenue Nuclear Power Generation Division Bethesda, Maryland 2C814 Babcock & W11cox 7910 Woodmont Avenue. Suite 220 Bethesda, Maryland 20814
Mr. J. W. Cook cc:
Commander. Naval Surface Weapons Center ATTN:
P. C. Huang White Oak Silver Spring, Maryland 20910 Mr. L. J. Auge, Manager Facility Design Engineering Energy Technology Engineering Center P.O. Box 1449 Canoga Park, California 91304 Mr. William Lawhead U.S. Corps of Engineers NCEED - T 7th F1cor 477 Michigan Avenue Detroit, Michigan 48226 Charles Bechhoefer, Esq.
Atomic Safety & Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory.Cosmission Washington, D. C.
20555 Mr. Ralph S. Decker Atomic Safety & Licensing Board.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.
20555 Dr. Frederick P. Cowan Apt. B-125 6125 N. Verde Trail Boca Raton, Florida 33433 Jerry Harbour, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.
20555 3
i
ENCLOSURE LIST OF ATTENDEES MIDLAND MEETING 11/12/81 NRC
- 0. Eisenhut J. Kane R. Vollmer F. Rinaldi J. P. Knight A. Cappucci E. Adensam G. Lear W. Olmstead F. Schauer J. Rutburg R. Landsman W. Paton D. Hood i
Consumers J. Cook D. Keeley D. Budzik M. Miller (IL&B) e w e
F*w--
T
- W W H A' W:
DDkWhs' ~
^
%f
,,.4 ksR*' W %y.,...
.D " *. "7 * ' v - ~
~~
~ ~ ~
- ~~
7 y.m.
m 3
. W: h fk
..s. gb, y,,
kp 1
- 3{ 4
.fi k.!
- i. '
y
- ]
fA
!.x
.t 1
Y
'h;Y=Shlhk;cfIhilijf]V'.,k[f}y;'('kNA, h N:;k 5
'I g
lf.
b 9
[p y [ [
[.
t l,'h 5
'k
~ ~ ~ '
r h:.
s.
px
.y
)q.
-.%v g;. ;T; %w..
y "
c
.v I'k
^
.j
}
y
(
n,4
- pe,$ r e
,p.
p %.
.n-r
- j it,. g.*.
.N
... gQ
.e. hn n
p.s t-
[E.M3.
.g jv" '. 9 f'
y' Mg s
I j h. e.d.,7 4 J g
. ;y hh 5.
L :.9 ?.h Y
ggp#4/
l
[)
r 1
i k--
Q
~
4 -
5,yyhQ-h.;
- f } " i,,,, l]% [h M "
5 a 7F 4
- l. -
3 1 fg,' -
m 3w e
i
+
c a
L, t t Q.. 2 r, +,
se~
4;,, f (+ _;lqg 97q -uggf i,,
l 4$
~
y,q".gr g
1 m-g 4
N, A.il.sIMih{g$,YMM
,,, o o u
,l1
,i i I I l.
kW h,h ' ;$.keih.'pl, f f':, s f b % } &gy E
i ),!,},)
1:dpi h a.
- ).es -
.u d ': "
- f l
hlf l
(:'.-l
- h;
~
t
$,y.M ': f M,.h N i f t T i
.Iv i
QgaTj,' + 14 p,g,0d. cib Sg.[h------
h M,- ;'
s sd 4
r-E a
o g,
.e A
oj m-d< J,;hp yp5 h
g.q -
- o....u.c i
3 WP s
r d C 5l s'..
,q 3 4 l
o
, o m
<}
.y F,
_7 y,j
,p.. [of.o
- j e
.A
< q f
M
,{
j i l M
is i
u i
,7
,, V m,f! + :.T,i J e
- t.
i 4
1
,u 31
]}
j j I
f8; I m;}$
f i,
l
>g
.hgap t o; La.1:13.lg3...t..;
. 3, p, i 4
j-4 i
j)1; A,;-VMh.shtthik J g if u
g..
L e
i i
w x
w w
-. mxgc.. -
.t e.p,.
~, ir,d, k g.-
. N # ' M j%g,
7Af ' ~ *@&, @y :ww11ghg4.;
Wy:.
i E
3 6
4 8
p i - ' '"-
t i*j.
= q' I 5-a!Is 3
.s
\\
9 I'
4 I
1.'
-4 t
t
't f -4 3-- i t l
- t i.
f Il l
'i g
a
--.~7 h g
g
! I j
l a
i E
~<!
.i 3 :3 a
a C 0 9 9 f
p y g. gI '4 i
- i.. g.;
I a
.I
. s,4 n
.. n,
.'S"
,- I 4
e 3.j. _
,.L a
.:)..,.................i..
.t a
2
,t =
_l'.
- g_ _ '_t_
1-r-,.
.......sp.'>'>4
....l_. 4 _--
g
?
s.
m
.8
{
....g,"i.14..
1j
- L.
g i
h.
r
. ~.
AI J$
> 7.
.e
- f..
og y>.>g- 'e..>...; q ; p.
n..,
i 3
4.
4.
i m e,
- - r
", e,. 4,.,
,...t.
a 3
o f
,,,am..
l,*
, '.1 j,
~
4,
..s
. l m.
r t.
p ky i
. r.q-m -
m, i
n,
." I e
ii 4
l
- ,I.
...i i
.e
>I.
. # ; i.
I..!.
l e
e5, i1 i
t si:l i.
!. ; l ' j I{
..ill.;l.l....'til'I:'
' : :j!, l ' D. ; '
l'l
'i le!!
i l
1 i
i
..3j.
.n.
l
~.
'a
^"1 1
J l.
t.
3g.
--~
e 9
, j ey 5-
=,e...,
(s.y,.,.- '.. :.
'
- g,,- '-. s,r,, '--...
q-
-g -
.:. c m m - -
..,t u t'%
<,: -, ~. -
p.
w s
l I
I l
i, l
0,, j
}'
II,
i l
i p
lfl?
I
/
1 31 ns h
!h I
a I*
l
't
?
.e r
~
jl I
e op a
y r t y gr. '
l p
Up -
p
- l. l.._
g%.
9 i
l L,.
l l
mr l
- v. m.
> r.c _
n L.1 n da' E1
____ i
.j
[****,54*6 g i
_. a.
1 1
i >.
- v.. w i e,
c -~.,
_3.*_
9 R__
L %4 > ___._6. K g h.~,
j l
'.'1..D n
E E Mt. a d N
- = M hn*
r-r t
y
, ~.,. ~. -
-- - q -
.:3._-
,.i.,
go.. r.- - -
., !,t
- e..:;,,
-L..
.... L -..;
.. i
,9 ' g
,4 I
g
.**e g'/.
m t
- m. t t "
g -.
.'9 d
t
ed >-.e.
e oe y.
W
't W ~~
l
- y f 3
_v_e ;.;w_4 IEg f.,
g.
i, p a, g g m
__-w-
-m-e r
b'bI "I b eN y
_ _.3
+.2.y 4
4p.
g-Tj g gg y-n.Amr 9 e,g:_
.y.
.c%-
t_._
+r-
-n
,,,g__
yd*e 4._..
9?d W __ _ w
--_;:j ;
em m ;pg p
,,j ~
...t.3, - m"+t
___ _r X' v..
..,. y..L
. M W
HYM dhe s
-K
.-= =W.3 f
'f]
.p,;.y #
T
- , M h ' 4 ir.
..y.
h g.,
n -
v.waqc,
- n-
!pgm
..f.
5p.
w w pM" y
l
'.. 'J 1
....s c.u.Q yjf'? _ -
-t pr
_A-ing y.wsm. ~. y. w, 4.
w e.
v a
a za
- e
.7 ? ~ ~ g,%
I
.g p..
Q
> - -, - s p.p.g v-
- t. -
.. s f
.ys
-[. p.
4,7..
. g.
h g' [+>l J
g;
}f;. g.s.
l
.s
-. zu m
g
^s
,M m
.: n
'D
.c I
1
~
., g,w,.
?upMp-$Y?
ad
~
^ h :!{ k & - f. - ' f "
1
?
^
-N Y
m' 3, E.n:
l r4
+
" q~p
.. > v.2 n.
l u' "k.
-g r.,; yh
^
'+ -
T h*:y4,?.' ll y
.;m.
m
\\.
f,.
d,
.E' l
n.*
-t.,
w.
' hr '.
/d O
- 6..
I.
.b 5k N i
~ -
4 y[s. 'go p
j-w.s.
.a g g.n,'
lp
%q%%%; W. # yo a,54:2 f,s' y
'figi i a;Q QQ
-s e.
4..
m
~
<c_
W d.
' WQQf9/i%f,5;j f
~
.z-s 3.~.
db. n$ i " sg"W; ' A
%e e.. w A
a 2Y WS.N.g
.u
. m.
s y" *
%g 4 3-n
..s..
?
i; i
op.rii;.i;,i.!J
,i ii
- ' t "...
- ;t:
l l
r
~il!id;l'.!'ll'!'
li!!!
l ii!!
i i
' '! I it
.? !.' :: : '
e i,3 m >.. :.
. it !
- j.:
I t
Fl r:i s i,
- e. i s
t 4
.< s l
k i
.)
...., n }':. : * "-,,
y 5
l 3
i
..................I
.<i s
I f
I 8-r 4--
[ ]-
i I
l n.
a r ;.
1 e
i;
,,,t..............<
g,.
1 l
.lg!
fj!,;:' f-F 4- --
l
=
t,,)*
i; ii,
---4-.
i a. 1;-
s..-
h
<r [. Ii "I
l1 y's, op
- i......,g.. 1,g.',
E. l 5
e J
P r
-...+..........,.a, l y i
,i
. t.
I !h 4
p,y j
8 i
t l i
.i 3 l
'E n
e ;
'3 f
l g
j_
l i
i
. i.
i.
3
. !' f <.
~Vi i,
i n
!.* l.
.'l
.e l
.I 9
'h
\\
e.,;!
-;J e.-
u1'
.- g Ni 1,; I s'
, 3: g i
I
(',:
- r t
i,
,y I
i
- e, e l*
b
^
..