Text

Proposed Control Room Jpms for the Duane Arnold Initial Examination - December 2007, Perform Required Actions for Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted)
	ML081420555
Person / Time
Site:	Duane Arnold
Issue date:	02/27/2008
From:	; NRC/RGN-III
To:	;
References
	QF-1030-11, Rev 5
	Download: ML081420555 (84)
	v • d • e

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 DUANE ARNOLD ENERGY CENTER JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 2007 NRC EXAM JPM S-1 TITLE: Perform Required Actions for Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted)

Retention: Life of policy + 10yrs. Disposition: Reviewer and Approver Retain in: Training Program File CR JPM a.doc Page 1 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE (JPM)

SITE: DAEC JPM TITLE: Perform Required Actions for Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted)

JPM NUMBER: 202002-06 REV. 2 RELATED PRA INFORMATION:

TASK NUMBER(S) / 12.11 / Reset Scoop Tube Lockup TASK TITLE(S):

K/A NUMBERS AND 202002 A2.05 3.1/3.1 VALUES:

Justification (FOR K/A VALUES <3.0):

APPLICABLE METHOD OF TESTING: RO SRO STA NSPEO SRO CERT Simulate/walkthrough: Perform: X EVALUATION LOCATION: In-Plant: Control Room:

Simulator: X Other:

Lab:

Time for Completion: 25 Minutes Time Critical: NO Alternate Path / Faulted: YES TASK APPLICABILITY:

Developed by:

Instructor Date Validated by:

Validation Instructor Date Reviewed by:

Plant Reviewer Date Approved by:

Training Supervisor Date Retention: Life of policy + 10yrs. Disposition: Reviewer and Approver Retain in: Training Program File CR JPM a.doc Page 2 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 202002-06, Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted), Rev. 2 JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE VALIDATION CHECKLIST ALL STEPS IN THIS CHECKLIST ARE TO BE PERFORMED PRIOR TO USE.

REVIEW STATEMENTS YES NO N/A

1. Are all items on the signature page filled in correctly?

2. Has the JPM been reviewed and validated by SMEs?

3. Can the required conditions for the JPM be appropriately established in the simulator if required?

4. Does the performance steps accurately reflect trainees actions in accordance with plant procedures?

5. Is the standard for each performance item specific as to what controls, indications and ranges are required to evaluate if the trainee properly performed the step?

6. Has the completion time been established based on validation data or incumbent experience?

7. If the task is time critical, is the time critical portion based upon actual task performance requirements?

8. Is the Licensee level appropriate for the task being evaluated if required?

9. Is the K/A appropriate to the task and to the licensee level if required?

10. Is justification provided for tasks with K/A values less than 3.0?

11. Have the performance steps been identified and typed (Critical /

Sequence / Time Critical) appropriately?

12. Have all special tools and equipment needed to perform the task been identified and made available to the trainee?

13. Are all references identified, current, accurate, and available to the trainee?

14. Have all required cues (as anticipated) been identified for the evaluator to assist task completion?

15. Are all critical steps clearly identified by procedural guidance? If licensing, EP or other groups were needed to determine correct actions, then the answer should be NO. (ACE 1729)

16. If the JPM is to be administered for initial qualification, has the required knowledge been taught to the individual prior to administering the JPM? TPE does not have to be completed, but the JPM evaluation may not be valid if they have not been taught the required knowledge. (ACE 1729)

All questions/statements must be answered YES or the JPM is not valid for use. If all questions/statements are answered YES then the JPM is considered valid and can be performed as written. The individual(s) performing the validation shall sign and date this form.

Validation Personnel /Date Validation Personnel/Date Validation Personnel /Date Validation Personnel/Date CR JPM a.doc Page 3 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 202002-06, Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted), Rev. 2 SIMULATOR SET UP: (Modify table as necessary) (Only required for simulator JPMs)

1. Reset to any low power IC with Recirc at minimum speed and 20% speed limiter not in effect.

(IC 22 preferred.)

2. Go to RUN.

3. Lock BOTH Recirc MG Scoop Tubes. Take the following readings on a separate piece of paper: (To be given to the candidate for Initial Conditions.)

Percent Speed (P)

Percent Speed Demand (S)

Percent Output (X)

Millivolt output signal

Discharge flow

Controller deviation

4. Verify Master Feedwater Level Controller in AUTO, set at 190.6.

5. Advance/Push the recorder RESET Button for the following recorders:

Recirc Loop Flow FR-4635 Total Core Flow FR-4528

6. Insert malfunctions for both Recirc Speed controllers at 100% severity over a 2:00 minute ramp on Event Triggers 1 and 2.

7. When ready to start this JPM, adjust Percent Speed Demand (S) to a value of .2-.5 less than the value of Percent Speed (P) on both Controllers. (This will cause the controller output (X) to start decreasing and the deviation meter to shift to the negative side.)

8. Ensure neither deviation meter is pegged to the right (this will saturate, and take a very long time to respond).

EVENT TRIGGERS:

Trigger Trigger File Trigger Logic Statement Trigger Word Number Name Description 1 N/A AN:1C04A(23) .LT. 1 A Scoop tube lockup annunciator reset 2 N/A AN:1C04B(20) .LT. 1 B Scoop tube lockup annunciator reset MALFUNCTIONS:

Time Malfunction Malfunction ET Delay F. Sev. Ramp I. Sev.

No. Title When Scoop RR17A A Recirc Speed 1 100 120 Tube Locked Controller failure sec relay resets When Scoop RR17B B Recirc Speed 2 100 120 Tube Locked Controller failure sec relay resets OVERRIDES:

NONE REMOTE FUNCTIONS:

NONE CR JPM a.doc Page 4 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 202002-06, Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted), Rev. 2 Required Materials: 1. OI 264 General

References:

1. OI 264

2. ARP 1C04A (C-5)

Task Standards: 1. Controller adjusted to obtain a value of S higher than P until a positive deviation is achieved.

2. Percent Speed Demand(s) adjusted to slightly less than Percent Speed (P).

3. Deviation meter pointer starts to move slowly from the right towards 0 (center of meter).

4. (S) and (P) approximately matched or difference minimized.

5. When deviation meter reaches 0, A[B] SCOOP TUBE CONTROL HS B31A-S3A[B] taken to the RESET position..

6. The operator identifies that the unlocked Recirc MG speed is increasing.

7. A[B] SCOOP TUBE CONTROL switch taken to the LOCKED position before a Reactor Low level alarm is received. (1C05A, D-1)

CR JPM a.doc Page 5 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 TURNOVER SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS:

1. Reactor power is at approximately 25%.

2. Both Recirc MG set scoop tube were manually locked up for Group 3 logic troubleshooting.

3. The following readings were taken at the time of the lockup per OI-264 and ARP 1C04A, C-5. They may or may not be applicable at this time.

4. The troubleshooting is complete.

INITIATING CUES:

The CRS directs you to reset the Recirc MG set scoop tube lockouts per OI-264.

This task IS NOT time critical.

Inform the evaluator when you have completed the task.

CR JPM a.doc Page 6 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 202002-06, Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted), Rev. 2 I will explain the initial conditions, which step(s) to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this job performance measure will be satisfied.

DURING THE JPM, ENSURE PROPER SAFETY PRECAUTIONS, FME, AND/OR RADIOLOGICAL CONCERNS AS APPLICABLE ARE FOLLOWED.

INITIAL CONDITIONS:

1. Reactor power is at approximately 25%.

2. Both Recirc MG set scoop tube were manually locked up for Group 3 logic troubleshooting.

3. The following readings were taken at the time of the lockup per OI-264 and ARP 1C04A, C-5. They may or may not be applicable at this time.

4. The troubleshooting is complete.

INITIATING CUES:

The CRS directs you to reset the Recirc MG set scoop tube lockouts per OI-264.

This task IS NOT time critical.

Inform the evaluator when you have completed the task.

Page 7 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 202002-06, Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted), Rev. 2 JPM PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Start Time:

NOTE: When providing Evaluator Cues to the examinee, care must be exercised to avoid prompting the examinee. Typically cues are only provided when the examinees actions warrant receiving the information (i.e. the examinee looks or asks for the indication).

NOTE: Critical steps are marked with a Y below the performance step number. Failure to meet the standard for any critical step shall result in failure of this JPM.

Candidate may perform this task on one controller or on both at the same time, depending on his/her level of comfort. Only one is necessary. Whichever controller is reset first will initiate the faulted part of this JPM.

EXAMINER NOTE: Several Notes and Cautions precede performance of the first step. The candidate should review all of them prior to beginning at Step 10.2 of the procedure.

Performance Step: If A[B] Recirc MG is running with either a 20% or 45% runback in effect, Critical N then perform ARP 1C04A, D-2 [D-8] prior to resetting the Scoop Tube Lockout.

Standard: Determine that there are no runbacks in effect.

Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Comments:

Performance Step: If A[B] Recirc Mg is running, reset the Scoop Tube as follows:

Critical Y Start with Deviation Meter SI-9247A[B] indicating to the positive side of 0.

If necessary, adjust Percent Speed Demand (S) to a value greater than Percent Speed (P) until a positive deviation is achieved.

Standard: Controller adjusted to obtain a value of S higher than P until a positive deviation is achieved.

Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Comments:

Page 8 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 202002-06, Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted), Rev. 2 Performance Step: Adjust Percent Speed Demand (S) to a value less than Percent Critical Y Speed(P).

Standard: Percent Speed Demand(s) adjusted to slightly less than Percent Speed (P).

Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Comments: 0.2 to 0.4 less should be adequate.

Performance Step: Monitor the Percent Output (X) on the digital display. Confirm that the Critical N value of X is decreasing.

Standard: "X" value confirmed decreasing.

Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Comments:

Performance Step: When the indicator on the Deviation Meter starts to respond, verify that it Critical Y is moving slowly. If the deviation indicator is moving too rapidly, return to step (a) above and use a smaller difference between (S) and (P).

Standard: Deviation meter pointer starts to move slowly from the right towards 0 (center of meter).

Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Comments:

Performance Step: When the indicator on the Deviation Meter approaches zero, match or Critical Y minimize the difference between (S) and (P) to slow the rate of change in Percent Output (X).

Standard: (S) and (P) approximately matched or difference minimized.

Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Comments:

Page 9 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 202002-06, Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted), Rev. 2 Performance Step: When indication on Deviation Meter is at 0, reset the scoop tube by Critical Y momentarily placing A[B] SCOOP TUBE CONTROL handswitch B31A-S3A on panel 1C04 in the RESET position.

Standard: When deviation meter reaches 0, A[B] SCOOP TUBE CONTROL HS B31A-S3A[B] taken to the RESET position.

Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Comments:

Performance Step: Confirm amber SCOOP TUBE LOCKED light out.

Critical N Standard: SCOOP TUBE LOCKED (amber light) confirmed off.

Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Comments:

Performance Step: Confirm that the A[B] RECIRC MG SCOOP TUBE LOCK annunciator Critical N resets. 1C04A, C-5 [1C04B, C-2]

Standard: RECIRC MG SCOOP TUBE LOCK annunciator confirmed reset.

Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Comments:

Page 10 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 202002-06, Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted), Rev. 2 Performance Step: Verify that the Recirc pump speed is stable by observing the following Critical Y parameters:

Standard: The operator identifies that the unlocked Recirc MG speed is increasing by one or more of the following indications:

Percent Speed Demand(S)

Percent Speed (P)

Recirc Pump Discharge flow

Total core flow

Core pressure drop

APRM readings Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Comments: Examiners Note: Candidate should notice a change in one or more of the above.

Performance Step: (CAUTION) If Recirc MG speed becomes unstable during this Critical Y procedure, immediately relock the scoop tube by momentarily placing the A[B] SCOOP TUBE CONTROL handswitch on Panel 1C04 to the LOCKED position.

Standard: A[B] SCOOP TUBE CONTROL switch taken to the LOCKED position before a Reactor Low level alarm is received. (1C05A, D-1)

Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Examiner Note: It takes greater than one minute for the Recirc Comments: pump speed increase to cause a Rx low level alarm, and it is reasonable to expect operator action before this point.

Performance Step: Communicate the problem to the Control Room Supervisor / Shift Critical N Manager.

Standard: Problem communicated to the Control Room Supervisor / Shift Manager.

Performance: SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY Cue: Play CRS and direct operator to suspend Scoop tube Comments: unlocking activities.

Terminating Cues: Role Play CRS and direct operator to suspend Scoop tube unlocking activities.

NOTE: Ensure the turnover sheet that was given to the examinee is returned to the evaluator.

(CA 46394)

Stop Time:

Page 11 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 202002-06, Resetting a Recirc MG Scoop Tube Lockup (Faulted), Rev. 2 Examinee: Evaluator:

RO SRO STA NSPEO SRO CERT Date:

PERFORMANCE RESULTS: SAT: UNSAT:

Remediation required: YES NO: YES:

COMMENTS/FEEDBACK: (Comments shall be made for any steps graded unsatisfactory).

EVALUATORS SIGNATURE:

NOTE: Only this page needs to be retained in examinees record if completed satisfactorily. If unsatisfactory performance is demonstrated, the entire JPM should be retained.

Page 12 of 12

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 DUANE ARNOLD ENERGY CENTER JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE 2007 NRC JPM S-2 TITLE: Perform Required Actions for Manual Cooldown of A SBGT Train Retention: Life of policy + 10yrs. Disposition: Reviewer and Approver Retain in: Training Program File CR JPM b.doc Page 1 of 10

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE (JPM)

SITE: DAEC JPM TITLE: Perform required actions for manual cooldown of A SBGT train JPM NUMBER: 261000-04 REV. 7 RELATED PRA INFORMATION:

TASK NUMBER(S) / 7.10 / Perform manual cooldown of SGTS using OI-170 TASK TITLE(S):

K4.01 3.7/3.8 K4.02 2.6/2.8 K5.01 2.3/2.6 K/A NUMBERS AND A1.01 2.9/3.1 A1.07 2.8/2.9 A2.01 2.9/3.1 VALUES:

A2.05 3.0/3.1 A3.01 3.2/3.3 A3.03 3.0/2.9 261000 A3.04 3.0/3.1 A4.02 3.1/3.1 A4.03 3.0/3.0 Justification (FOR K/A VALUES <3.0):

APPLICABLE METHOD OF TESTING: RO SRO STA NSPEO SRO CERT Simulate/walkthrough: Perform: X EVALUATION LOCATION: In-Plant: Control Room:

Simulator: X Other:

Lab:

Time for Completion: 15 Minutes Time Critical: NO Alternate Path / Faulted: NO TASK APPLICABILITY:

Developed by:

Instructor Date Validated by:

Validation Instructor Date Reviewed by:

Plant Reviewer Date Approved by:

Training Supervisor Date Retention: Life of policy + 10yrs. Disposition: Reviewer and Approver Retain in: Training Program File CR JPM b.doc Page 2 of 10

QF-1030-11 Rev. 5 261000-04, Manual Cooldown of A SBGT Train, Rev. 7 JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE VALIDATION CHECKLIST ALL STEPS IN THIS CHECKLIST ARE TO BE PERFORMED PRIOR TO USE.