|
---|
Category:CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS
MONTHYEARML20216F6621999-09-20020 September 1999 Discusses 990804 Request for Renewal of Route to Be Used for Transport of Sf from Natl Inst of Stds & Technology, Gaithersburg,Md to Doe,Savannah River Site Near Aiken,Sc. Route in Encl 1 Meets Regulatory Requirements of 10CFR73.37 ML20210F6581999-07-29029 July 1999 Responds to Providing Comments on Proposed FY99 Annual Fee Rule & Requesting That NRC Reject Proposed Annual Fee Increases for non-power Reactors.Request for Exemption from 10CFR171 Annual Fee Requirements Denied ML20196K4551999-07-0101 July 1999 Forwards Ballot for ANS-1, Conduct of Critical Experiments. Scope of Standard Has Been Reviewed & Has Been Approved with Comments & No Objections ML20202J2301999-02-0202 February 1999 Forwards Ballots for ANS-10.2, Portability of Scientific & Engineering Software & ANS-15.4, Selection & Training of Personnel for Research Reactors. Author Voted Not Approved to ANS-10.2 & Approved to ANS-15.4 ML20199G7981999-01-21021 January 1999 Informs That Funding for Conversion of NIST Reactor Will Not Be Available at Any Time in Foreseeable Future.Schedule for Conversion of Nbsr Cannot Be Submitted at Present Time ML20195H8881998-11-16016 November 1998 Forwards Insp Rept 50-184/98-202 on 981006-07.No Violations Noted ML20216C5981998-05-12012 May 1998 Forwards Certificates To,Pa Bobik,Sc Pierce & SG Slaughter, Newly Licensed Individuals ML20217A1451998-04-16016 April 1998 Informs That on 980306 NRC Administered Initial Exam Rept 50-184/OL-98-01 to Employees of Facility Who Applied for License to Operate Natl Inst of Stds & Technology Reactor ML20216H1231998-04-16016 April 1998 Forwards Results of Operator Initial Exam Conducted at National Institute of Standards & Technology on 980408-09. W/O Encls ML20216J4371998-04-16016 April 1998 Forwards Initial Exam Rept 50-184/OL-98-01 for Week of 980306.NRC Administered Initial Exams to Employees of Facility Who Applied for License to Operate NIST Reactor. W/O Encls ML20217F3711998-03-25025 March 1998 Informs of Arrangements Made for Administration of Operator Licensing Exams,Scheduled for Wk of 980406.Matl Already Provided by T Raby Will Be Used ML20199J5881998-01-21021 January 1998 Informs That Funding for Conversion of NIST Reactor to LEU Will Not Be Available at Any Time in Foreseeable Future ML20198R3601998-01-16016 January 1998 Forwards Insp Rept 50-184/97-202 on 971006-09.No Violations Noted ML20203C9601997-09-29029 September 1997 Submits Advance Notification of Sf Shipment from Natl Inst of Stds & Technology,Doc to Doe.Shipment Will Consist of Three Loaded tractor-trailers,traveling as Single Convoy W/Escorts.Further Description of Shipment Encl ML20217B0891997-09-0909 September 1997 Forwards Ballots for ANS-6.1.2,Rev, Neutron & Gamma-Ray Cross Sections for Nuclear Radiation Protection Calculations NPP, ANS6.3.1,Reaffirmation, Program for Testing Radiation Shields in Lwr ML20198E9941997-08-0505 August 1997 Informs That Responsibility for Non-Power Reactor Insp Program Has Been Transferred from Regional Ofc to Nrr. Addresses Listed ML20149L4721997-07-30030 July 1997 Responds to 961015 & 970619 Requests for Approval of Route to Be Used for Transport of Sf from Natl Inst of Stds & Technology to Doe.Info on Law Enforcement Arrangements & Map of Route Encl ML20149E7651997-07-11011 July 1997 Forwards Insp Rept 50-184/97-201 on 970616-18.No Violations Noted ML20148U3851997-06-19019 June 1997 Requests Approval of Proposed Route as Outlined in .Route Must Be Approved No Later than End of Jul 1997 in Order to Make Timely Preparations for Shipments in Sept. Copies of Past Correspondence Encl ML20141J9591997-04-30030 April 1997 Forwards Revised Page of Nbsr Emergency Plan.Change to Plan Made in Order to Conform to Recent Change in Nbsr Tech Specs Authorized by Commission ML20147H3621997-03-31031 March 1997 Forwards Amend 8 to License TR-5 & Safety Evaluation.Amend Changes TSs to Change Name of Organization from Reactor Radiation Division to NIST Ctr for Neutron Research ML20138H5681996-12-30030 December 1996 Forwards Insp Rept 50-184/96-03 on 961105-08.No Violations Noted ML20129E3931996-10-15015 October 1996 Requests Approval of Proposed Route for Shipment of Research Reactor Spent Fuel ML20129G7081996-09-30030 September 1996 Forwards Ballot for ANS-15.2, Quality Control for Plate- Type Uranium-Aluminum Fuel Elements ML20100C8291995-12-18018 December 1995 Responds to NRC Requesting Info Re Features & Provisions in Effect at NIST to Control Access to Neutron Beams ML20071F8771994-06-30030 June 1994 Forwards Thank You Ltr Re Keeping Exposures Below Regulatory Limits ML20210F6731994-03-23023 March 1994 Provides Notice That After Careful Consideration,Commission Decided to Reinstate Annual Fee Exemption for Nonprofit Educational Institutions.Nrc Will Cancel Fy 1993 Annual Fee Invoices for Licensed Activities Exempt Under Final Rule ML20059E7651994-01-0404 January 1994 Informs That as Indicated in Encl Ltr from Doe,Funding for Conversion of NIST Reactor to LEU Fuel Not Available & That Schedule for Conversion of Nbsr Cannot Be Submitted at This Time ML20056E0661993-08-0303 August 1993 Forwards Results for Operator Initial Exam on 930713. W/O Encl ML20056E4411993-08-0303 August 1993 Forwards Initial Exam Rept 50-184/OL-93-01 on 930713 ML20127C8151993-01-0808 January 1993 Forwards to DOE Indicating That Funds for Converting Reactor to Low Enriched U Unavailable in DOE FY92 Budget & Request Has Not Been Submitted in DOE FY93 & FY94 Planning Budgets ML20126J5731992-12-23023 December 1992 Forwards Safeguards Insp Rept 50-184/92-02 on 921208-09. No Safety Concerns or Violations Noted ML20099E9181992-07-31031 July 1992 Requests Review of Encl Proposal for New Liquid Hydrogen Cold Source to Replace Existing Heavy Water Source. Development of New Source Represents Major Breakthrough for Us Science & Technology ML20091M6331992-01-24024 January 1992 Forwards DOE to NIST Advising That Funds for Conversion of Reactor to Low Enriched U Unavailable in FY93 & FY94.Schedule for Conversion Cannot Be Submitted at Present Time ML20081L8191991-07-0303 July 1991 Advises That on 910625 While Remotely Inserting New Fuel Element Into Position in Core,Element Fell Off Tool Onto Top Grid.Element Retrieved Undamaged.Element Cleaned & Minor External Scratches Polished & Reinserted Into Postion ML20070K0111991-03-11011 March 1991 Advises That Funding for Conversion of Natl Inst of Stds & Technology Reactor to LEU Fuel Not Available ML20059M6701990-09-28028 September 1990 Advises That Shim 4 Did Not Return to Normal Position on 900918.Bearing-seal Assemblies Replaced Using Stainless Steel Bearings ML20059H2121990-09-0707 September 1990 Informs of Error in Scheduled Quarterly Surveillance Test 5.6.1.Test Inadvertently Scheduled for Aug Rather than May, 1990.Error Occurred Due to Surveillance Date Changes Necessitated by Extended Reactor Shutdown ML20056A2651990-08-0101 August 1990 Provides Addl Info on Request for Change to Section 6.2 of Tech Specs.Basic Design Considerations Unchanged Re Performance,Matl,Design Pressure & Temp & Fabrication Code Requirements ML20055H3311990-07-23023 July 1990 Certifies That Congressional Appropriation for Decommissioning of Reactor Will Be Requested When Necessary. Amount of Appropriation Will Be Based on FY90 Estimated Cost ML20055G8441990-07-19019 July 1990 Forwards Safety Insp Rept 50-184/90-03 on 900605-07 & 26.No Violations Noted ML20055H3281990-07-17017 July 1990 Forwards Certification Verifying That Congressional Appropriation Will Be Requested Re Decommissioning Reactor. Decommissioning Estimated to Require Min of Five Yrs ML20012A4701990-03-0202 March 1990 Forwards Proposed Addendum 1 to Physical Security Plan,For Approval.Addendum Upgrades Plan Per Recommendations Contained in 1987 Nonpower Reactor Sabotage Study (U). W/O Encl ML20011E6751990-02-14014 February 1990 Advises That Funding for Conversion of NIST Reactor to Low Enriched U Fuel Unavailable,Per Encl DOE 900206 Ltr.Schedule for Conversion of NIST Reactor to Low Enriched U Cannot Be Submitted ML19332B8721989-11-15015 November 1989 Forwards Revised Section 7.5(c),Step 2,Page 14 of Emergency Plan,Involving Use of Search or Surveillance or Both as Alternate Method of Accounting for Personnel in Confinement Bldg During Site Area Emergency ML20245J2591989-04-26026 April 1989 Ack Receipt of Informing NRC of Steps Taken to Correct Violations Noted in Insp Rept 50-184/89-01 ML20247D6571989-03-24024 March 1989 Responds to Re Low Level Radiological Release from NIST During Aug-Oct 1987.Encl Insp Rept 50-184/89-01 Notes That Incident Involving Two Separate,But Related Events Pose Threat to Public Health or Safety ML20246P3111989-03-22022 March 1989 Advises That Research & Test Reactor Seminar Scheduled for 890418 & 19 in King of Prussia,Pa.Topics to Be Discussed Include,Nrc Research Reactor Insp Program,Operator Licensing & Fitness for Duty.Info Re Lodging Encl ML20063Q0541988-11-29029 November 1988 Discusses Transfer of Activities,Responsibilities & Obligations of Nbs to Natl Institute of Stds & Technology. Designation of Reactor Will Continue to Be Nbsr ML20154K0901988-09-13013 September 1988 Forwards Safety Insp Rept 50-184/88-02 on 880809-11.No Violations Noted 1999-09-20
[Table view] Category:OUTGOING CORRESPONDENCE
MONTHYEARML20216F6621999-09-20020 September 1999 Discusses 990804 Request for Renewal of Route to Be Used for Transport of Sf from Natl Inst of Stds & Technology, Gaithersburg,Md to Doe,Savannah River Site Near Aiken,Sc. Route in Encl 1 Meets Regulatory Requirements of 10CFR73.37 ML20210F6581999-07-29029 July 1999 Responds to Providing Comments on Proposed FY99 Annual Fee Rule & Requesting That NRC Reject Proposed Annual Fee Increases for non-power Reactors.Request for Exemption from 10CFR171 Annual Fee Requirements Denied ML20196K4551999-07-0101 July 1999 Forwards Ballot for ANS-1, Conduct of Critical Experiments. Scope of Standard Has Been Reviewed & Has Been Approved with Comments & No Objections ML20202J2301999-02-0202 February 1999 Forwards Ballots for ANS-10.2, Portability of Scientific & Engineering Software & ANS-15.4, Selection & Training of Personnel for Research Reactors. Author Voted Not Approved to ANS-10.2 & Approved to ANS-15.4 ML20195H8881998-11-16016 November 1998 Forwards Insp Rept 50-184/98-202 on 981006-07.No Violations Noted ML20216C5981998-05-12012 May 1998 Forwards Certificates To,Pa Bobik,Sc Pierce & SG Slaughter, Newly Licensed Individuals ML20217A1451998-04-16016 April 1998 Informs That on 980306 NRC Administered Initial Exam Rept 50-184/OL-98-01 to Employees of Facility Who Applied for License to Operate Natl Inst of Stds & Technology Reactor ML20216H1231998-04-16016 April 1998 Forwards Results of Operator Initial Exam Conducted at National Institute of Standards & Technology on 980408-09. W/O Encls ML20216J4371998-04-16016 April 1998 Forwards Initial Exam Rept 50-184/OL-98-01 for Week of 980306.NRC Administered Initial Exams to Employees of Facility Who Applied for License to Operate NIST Reactor. W/O Encls ML20217F3711998-03-25025 March 1998 Informs of Arrangements Made for Administration of Operator Licensing Exams,Scheduled for Wk of 980406.Matl Already Provided by T Raby Will Be Used ML20198R3601998-01-16016 January 1998 Forwards Insp Rept 50-184/97-202 on 971006-09.No Violations Noted ML20217B0891997-09-0909 September 1997 Forwards Ballots for ANS-6.1.2,Rev, Neutron & Gamma-Ray Cross Sections for Nuclear Radiation Protection Calculations NPP, ANS6.3.1,Reaffirmation, Program for Testing Radiation Shields in Lwr ML20198E9941997-08-0505 August 1997 Informs That Responsibility for Non-Power Reactor Insp Program Has Been Transferred from Regional Ofc to Nrr. Addresses Listed ML20149L4721997-07-30030 July 1997 Responds to 961015 & 970619 Requests for Approval of Route to Be Used for Transport of Sf from Natl Inst of Stds & Technology to Doe.Info on Law Enforcement Arrangements & Map of Route Encl ML20149E7651997-07-11011 July 1997 Forwards Insp Rept 50-184/97-201 on 970616-18.No Violations Noted ML20147H3621997-03-31031 March 1997 Forwards Amend 8 to License TR-5 & Safety Evaluation.Amend Changes TSs to Change Name of Organization from Reactor Radiation Division to NIST Ctr for Neutron Research ML20138H5681996-12-30030 December 1996 Forwards Insp Rept 50-184/96-03 on 961105-08.No Violations Noted ML20129G7081996-09-30030 September 1996 Forwards Ballot for ANS-15.2, Quality Control for Plate- Type Uranium-Aluminum Fuel Elements ML20210F6731994-03-23023 March 1994 Provides Notice That After Careful Consideration,Commission Decided to Reinstate Annual Fee Exemption for Nonprofit Educational Institutions.Nrc Will Cancel Fy 1993 Annual Fee Invoices for Licensed Activities Exempt Under Final Rule ML20056E4411993-08-0303 August 1993 Forwards Initial Exam Rept 50-184/OL-93-01 on 930713 ML20056E0661993-08-0303 August 1993 Forwards Results for Operator Initial Exam on 930713. W/O Encl ML20126J5731992-12-23023 December 1992 Forwards Safeguards Insp Rept 50-184/92-02 on 921208-09. No Safety Concerns or Violations Noted ML20055G8441990-07-19019 July 1990 Forwards Safety Insp Rept 50-184/90-03 on 900605-07 & 26.No Violations Noted ML20245J2591989-04-26026 April 1989 Ack Receipt of Informing NRC of Steps Taken to Correct Violations Noted in Insp Rept 50-184/89-01 ML20247D6571989-03-24024 March 1989 Responds to Re Low Level Radiological Release from NIST During Aug-Oct 1987.Encl Insp Rept 50-184/89-01 Notes That Incident Involving Two Separate,But Related Events Pose Threat to Public Health or Safety ML20246P3111989-03-22022 March 1989 Advises That Research & Test Reactor Seminar Scheduled for 890418 & 19 in King of Prussia,Pa.Topics to Be Discussed Include,Nrc Research Reactor Insp Program,Operator Licensing & Fitness for Duty.Info Re Lodging Encl ML20154K0901988-09-13013 September 1988 Forwards Safety Insp Rept 50-184/88-02 on 880809-11.No Violations Noted ML20151L8871988-07-22022 July 1988 Forwards Exam Rept 50-184/88-01OL on 880606-07 ML20195B2731988-06-10010 June 1988 Forwards Amend 6 to License TR-5 & Safety Evaluation.Amend Changes Tech Specs to Require That New Guide Tube Isolation Valves Be Either Operable or Closed Like Other Isolation Valves in Ventilation & Process Piping Penetration ML20150D8641988-03-18018 March 1988 Informs of Relocation of NRR to Rockville,Md.Official Mailing Address Still Remains Same & Project Managers Have New Locations & Phone Numbers.Ts Michaels Still Lead Project Manager for Facility & a Adams Will Serve as Backup ML20147D0421988-02-29029 February 1988 Requests That Recipient Resubmit Proposal to Convert to Low Enriched U Fuel to Meet 10CFR50.64(6)(2) or (3) Requirements by 880327.Identical Ltrs Sent to Listed Dockets ML20237D7931987-12-17017 December 1987 Requests Addl Info in Order to Complete Review of 870622 Request for Amend to Nbs Reactor Tech Specs Re Cold Neutron Facility ML20236M5561987-11-0505 November 1987 Forwards Safety Insp Rept 50-184/87-03 on 870908-11.No Violations Identified ML20237H5361987-08-26026 August 1987 Forwards Insp Rept 50-184/87-02 on 870706-09.No Violations Noted ML20235N3311987-07-0707 July 1987 Forwards Safeguards Insp Rept 50-184/87-01 on 870514-15.No Violations Noted ML20214T1001987-05-27027 May 1987 Informs of Realignment within Div of Reactor Projects Affecting Responsibility for Insp of Research & Test Reactor Facilities.Chart Indicating Responsibilities & 10CFR50 & 51 Final Rule Re Written Communications from Licensees Encl ML20210T1071987-02-11011 February 1987 Forwards Request for Addl Info Re 860919 Application for Unique Purpose Exemption from Use of Low Enriched U Fuel Per 10CFR50.64(c)(1).Requests Written Response within 30 Days ML20212D8411986-12-30030 December 1986 Forwards Request for Addl Info Re 860919 Application for Unique Purpose Exemption,Including Demonstration That Reactor Core Cannot Perform Intended Function W/O Use of High Enriched U Fuel.Response Requested within 60 Days ML20214G7631986-11-17017 November 1986 Forwards Exam Rept 50-184/86-02 of Exams Administered During Wk of 861001-02 ML20207J8061986-07-21021 July 1986 Forwards Safety Insp Repts 50-184/86-01 & 70-0398/86-03 on 860625-26.No Violations or Deviations Noted ML20210S0151986-05-0808 May 1986 Responds to 860401 Request for Approval of Spent Nuclear Fuel Route from Gaithersburg,Md to Aiken,Sc.Route Meets 10CFR73.37 Requirements & Approved.Sanitized Version of Spent Nuclear Fuel Route Encl ML20141A1351986-03-27027 March 1986 Informs That TC Elsasser Will Replace EC Mccabe as Cognizant Section Chief for Facility on 860331 Based on Realignment of Projects at Region I Ofc.Author Will Remain Cognizant Branch Chief ML20210H8871986-03-27027 March 1986 Lists Change in Telephone Number for H Bernard,Facility Project Manager,Due to NRR Reorganization.D Tondi New Nonpower Reactors & Safeguards Licensing Section Leader. Correspondence Should Be Sent to Listed Address ML20199F3511986-03-20020 March 1986 Advises That on 860127,licensee Transported Shipment of Spent Fuel W/O Proper License.Qa Program for Radiation Matl Packages Expired on 851231.License Renewals Must Be Requested Prior to Expiration ML20137A1711986-01-0808 January 1986 Forwards Safeguards Insp Rept 50-184/85-04 on 851031.No Violation Noted ML20138M9611985-12-17017 December 1985 Advises of NRC Understanding of Recipient Consent to Entry of NRC 850927 Order to Show Cause Why Excess High Enriched U Fuel Should Not Be Removed to Secure Facility Away from Reactor Site ML20138N0301985-12-17017 December 1985 Discusses NRC 850927 Order to Show Cause Why All Excess High Enriched U Fuel Should Not Be Removed to Secure Facility Away from Reactor Site.Consent to Entry of Order Understood,Since Hearing Not Requested,Nor Order Contested ML20138A6461985-09-25025 September 1985 Forwards Safety Insp Rept 50-184/85-03 on 850905-06.No Violations Noted IR 05000184/19850011985-06-12012 June 1985 Ack Receipt of Informing NRC of Steps Taken to Correct Violations Noted in Insp Rept 50-184/85-01 ML20129C8461985-05-15015 May 1985 Forwards Safeguards Insp Rept 50-184/85-02 on 850423.No Violation Noted 1999-09-20
[Table view] |
Text
,a g
February 2, 1999 Mr. Tawfik M. Raby Chairman, N-17 Building 235, Room A141 NationalInstitute of Standards and Technology Gaithersburg, Maryland 20899
Dear Mr. Raby:
h
SUBJECT:
ANS-10.2 and ANS-15.4 N-17 COMMITTEE BALLOTS Enclosed are my ballots for ANS-10.2, " Portability of Scientific and Engineering Software," and ANS-15.4, " Selection and Training of Personnel for Research Reactors." I have voted "not approved" for ANS-10.2 and " approved" for ANS-15.4. Furthermore, I
' nave reviewed the Scopes of the standards, and have no objections.
If you have any questions concerning these ballots, please contact Al Adams at 301-415-1127 or me at 301-415-2170.
Sincerely, ORIGINAL SIGNED PY, Seymour H. Weiss, Director Non-Power Reactors and Decommissioning Project Directorate Division of Reactor Program Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation NEIosbr$e.50-184 As stated cc w/ enclosure:
j See next page 1.
]
I 9N DISTRIBUTION:
E-Mall HARD COPY PDoyle TBurdick PUBLIC AAdams TDragoun MMendonca CGC (015-818) EHylton TMichaels CBassett DMatthews PDND r/f SHolmes Plsaac SWeiss WEresian (DocketFile"50184 PDN M P, ' ;LA HICB -
A on Stewart SWeiss A/ 9 / 99 .2,/ J /99 "),/ 3/99 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY DOCUMENT NAME: G:\SECY\ ADAMS \ BALLOT 2 -
9902090071 990202 PDR ADOCK 05000184 P PDR
(.me ,
3pf t"G (*, C[p,j7 k t.LL W- = ' ~ ~ ~ [ ')
m o
ps** %q, y- 4 UNITED STATES
- 8 ]
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ,
, WASHINoToN. D.c. 2055Hm01
% ,, # February 2, 1999 Mr. Tawfik M. Raby Chairman, N-17 Building 235, Room A141 NationalInstitute of Standards and Technology Gaithersburg, Maryland 20899 g
Dear Mr. Raby:
SUBJECT:
ANS-10.2 and ANS-15.4 N 17 COMMITTEE Ball.OTS i
Enclosed are my ballots for ANS-10.2, " Portability of Scientific and Engineering Software," and ANS 15.4, " Selection and Training of Personnel for Research Reactors." I have voteu "not approved" for ANS-10.2 and " approved" for ANS-15.4. Furthermore, I have reviewed the Scopes of the standards, and have no objections.
If you have any questions concerning these ballots, please contact Al Adams at 301-415-1127 or me at 301-415-2170.
Sincerely,
, {l Seymour H Weiss, Director Non-Power Reactors and Decommissioning Project Directorate Division of Reactor Program Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Enclosure:
As stated cc w/ enclosure:
See next page
7,.
q ,
. 3 '. '
u 1.w
~
LNationalInstitute of Standards Docket No. 50-184
' 'and Technology y.
cc:
!Wontgomery County Executive .
Donty Office Building Rockville, MD 20858
- Director
' Department of State Planning ,
301.. West Preston Street Baltimore, MD 21201 ,
Director Department of Nature! Resources Power Plant Siting Program Energy & Coastal Zone Administration Tawes State Office Building Annapolis, MD 21401 Mr.' Tawfik Raby, Deputy Chief Reactor Radiation Division NationalInstitute of Standards and Technology U.S. Department of Commerce Gaithersburg, MD 20899 Honorable Michael L. Subin Montgomery County Council
.. Stella S. Werner Council Office Building i Rockville, MD 20850 Dr. William Vernetson !
- Director of Nuclear Facilities I
Department of Nuclear Engineering Sciences l University of Florida l Gainesville, FL 32611-8300- 1 Mr. Jim Torrence l Reactor Radiation Division NationalInstitute of Standards and Technology {
U.S. Department of Commerce !
Gaithersburg, MD 20899
.m J
l l
ANSI N-17 COMMITTEE BALLOT DOCUMENT:
ANS-15.4 " Selection and Training of Personnel for Research Reactors". (Reaffirmation)
BALLOT DUE: February 17.1999 Y Approved Approved with Comments Not Approved Not Voting Comments:
(NOTE - all " Approved with Comments" and "Not Approved" ballots must include comments.
Seymour H. Weits-P int Name Retum ballot to:
- Signature 4M/
Tawfik M. Raby USNRC Chairman, N-17 Representing NationalInstitute of Standards & Technology Mailstop 8561 Building 235, Room A141 Gaithersburg, MD 20899-8561 N7 !ff l date'
l l
l ANSI N-17 COMMITTEE BALLOT DOCUMENT: ANS-10.2 " Portability of Scientific and Engineering Software". (Revision)
BALLOT DUE: February 17.1999 Approvad Approved with Comments X Not Approved Not Voting Comments: (NOTE all " Approved with Comments" and "Not Approved" ballots must include comments.
See next page.
Seymour H. Weiss Print Name Return ballot to:
/ 8ignature
~'
h Tawfik M. Raby USNRC Chairman, N-17 Representing NationalInstitute of Standards & Technology Mailstop 8561 Building 235, Room A141 / f Gaithersburg, MD 20899-8561 2/L/97 I Dath ' '
l
NRC Comments on ANS-10.2, " Portability of Scientific and Engineering Software" General Comments
- 1. We agree that it is good practice to design for portability - even though this is not an NRC requirement.
- 2. The proposed standard is vague in many areas but the greatest shortcoming is the lack of reference to the lEF.E software engineering standards or equivalent for software development. These standards were not written just for safety-critical real time applications but are well suited to development of computational code. j Several sources quote that the greatest contribution to portability / reuse is the use 1 of good general design practices which are described in these standards. The use I of data flow diagrams, entity relationship diagrams, data dictionaries and a structured life cycle (especially a good requirements specification) are useful in i
promoting portability. I
- 3. Additional good practices are available from many sources and would, perhaps, be worth referencing.
- 4. Perhaps the standard could discuss the pros and cons of commercial products that support multiple platforms, has a large user base, and has been at least if not more stable than several of the options. i
)
- 5. Some of the recommendations for portability / reuse include the generalizing of modules / objects as discussed in some of the work on domain analysis. The working group might wish to consider adding a discussion of the pros and cons of this.
6 Some more discussion of some of the potential trouble spots may be helpful. For example, computational modules in C and Fortran can be designed for stable portability but a similar high degree of portability in the remainder of the modules (graphics, interprocessor communication, network naming rules, and database interfaces) are in a state of flux. Some of these issues may require programming methods (such as using message passing interface for databases) that would not be the first inclination for the designer.
Specific comments
- 7. ' Foreword. The first paragraph states ".... practices recommended." It is not stated who provides the recommendation.
l l
4
t
- 8. Foreword. The first paragraph states "...have not been assigned sufficient importance." Consider changing this to "..have not usually been assigned sufficient -
importance." so as to not condemn the few that have done a good job.
- 9. Foreword. Consider placing the three referenced standards in either numerical or alphabetical order.
- 10. Definitions. Consider using IEEE 610.12 definitions when possible.
- 11. Definitions.' " Localization"is usually referred to as modularity or objects.
- 12. Introduction. The list of referenced standards and guidelines should reference the IEEE or other international software development standards and guides.
- 13. Section 4.1, Source and Revision Control. Source code and revision control should be referred to as configuration management and is required. ;
- 14. .Section 4.2.1, Program Structure and Flow. Output processing should be included in the last sentence.
- 15. Section 4.2.2, Subprograms, it is not clear what guidance is being provided here.
The same statement could apply to programs in general. .
- 16. Section 4.3, Programming Languages. There should be reference to some of the better guidelines that currently exist for programming languages.
- 17. Section 4.3.6, Assembly Language. This section should be reworded. The use of assembly language is commonly needed, especially for high speed requirements.
- 18. Section 4.4.3, Data Libraries. The guidance of the last sentence will be difficult to meet. How do you provide detailed instructions on how to generate a library for an unknown future hardware / software environment? The decision has alreaJy been rnade by this point that the existing library is not portable to the current known systems, i l
- 19. Section 4.5.1, initialization and input processing, item (6). In addition to the consistency checks, there should be checks on the standard items (out-of-range, null sets, wrong type, too many or not enough data points, etc.).
- 20. Section 4.5.4, Output and Termination Processing. Explain (here or in the definitions) what is meant by " edited." Does it mean putting them into a nice output format or actually doing calculations.
Section 4.6.1, Variable Names. This section could mention methods such as data 21.
dictionaries as tools to assist in this.
I
i
- 22. Section 4.6.3, Source Documentation.1his section should also include the need to keep the design and test tools current and available. The documentation should be required rather than recommended. The manuals and handbooks should also be required if they include any meaningful information not available from the source code.
- 23. Section 4.7.1, Interfacing with External Packages. Packages provided other than the computer program source should also include the items standardized by the program language. Test runs of different compilers, both set for standard C for the same target machine will not always yield identical code. It may not matter but should not be assumed.
1 1
1 I
t