ML20039E680

Rept on 811209 Ottawa County/Toledo Edison Siren Test.

ML20039E680
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	12/18/1981
From:	Cole K OHIO, STATE OF
To:
Shared Package
ML20039E675	List: ML20039E674 ML20039E680 ML20039E684
References
NUDOCS 8201110165
Download: ML20039E680 (5)

Text

DISPOSITION FORM Fee vse of this forai, see AR 340-15. the Proponent egency is The Adivront Generel's Oltice.

A*ff Af t4Ci OR OfflCE SYMSOL St'8 JECT AG0ll-DS SIREN TEST Fat 0E DATg CMT1 To

. JAMES 11. WILLIAMS KENNETil COLE 18 DECEMBER 81 NtlCLEAR PREPAREDNESS Oi:FICER NUCLEAR RESPONSE

1. Attached is the report on the Dec. 9, 1981, Ottawa County / Toledo Edison Siren Test.

l lk /?

DEOrilVED f7/[lj) ,

)

KENNE'111 COLE DEC 2 91981 Nuclear llesponse Officer TCLEDO EDISON 8201110165 811230 DR ADOCK 05000346 PDR F0pu REPL Aces 00 Ponu so. ExlSTING SUPPLIES OF *HtCH vlLL BE *n' D A 1 PES 62 ISSUED AND USED UNTIL 1 f t J GS UNLESS SOOMER EXH AUST ED. ivas o saa wm

_-. ~

7 Ohio Disaster Services personnel participated as observers for the Ottawa County, Toledo 1 Edison Co. siren test on. Dec. 9,1981. _ Host observers were pre-located at_ a distance of 2-2.25 miles from the nearest siren. This put thcm at or near the outer limit of expected coverage. Once the test was completed, all observers met at the Carroll Township itall where they discussed the results with Toledo Edison and Ottawa County officials.

( Observers were posted as follows: (See map, siren locations are approximations.)

Group 1 - Genzman Rd. G Toussaint South (inside moving auto)

Group 2 - 163 6 Tettau (outside/inside) l Group 3 - Locust Point (outside/inside moving auto)

Group 4 - Toussaint East Approx. 1/10 mile East of Rt. 19 (in moving auto)

~

l Group 5 - R. 2 at Station S.W. (outside) l l Group 6 - Carroll Twp. IIall (inside building)

Group 7 - Camp Perry (inside/outsidej l

l Results:

Group 1 - Traveled south on Toussaint south to Salem Carroll Rd. ; could not hear siren until reaching Salem Carroll Rd., and only then, if the vehicle was stopped.

Group 2 - Could slightly hear the siren while outside with automobile engine off.

Group 3 - Started at Locust Point outside vehicle, then traveled down to and east on Long Bench Rd. Did not hear a siren.

Group 4 - Started just east of Rt. 19, could faintly hear the siren from start to stop at Lentz Rd.

Group 5 - This group tested sound levels at the nearest public facility (approxi-

! mately 50 ft. from base of siren pole). The levels were below the maximum 123 db.

Group 6 - Located inside the Carroll Twp. Itall; could not hear the siren at all.

l Group 7 - See attached letter from Commander, 200th Civil Engineer Squadron, I

Camp Perry, Ohio.

+

/ T T T OHIO AIR NATIONAL GUARD HE ADQU ARTE R5 200TH CIVIL ENGINE E RING SQU ADRON (HR)

CAesP PE RRY ANG STAf ton , "s ** , , , ,

PoRr cuNroW.owlo 43 o -

1. , ;; p 9 Dece bk$8hlPH3;23 NEPLY To ATTW OF; CC sus >ccT Listening Results of the Siren Test 9 Dec 1981 10: AG0ll/DS-NPO

1. Three personnel from this unit were assigned the task of listening for the siren test to identify the results.

a. One person was jogging outdoors in the Air National Guard area.

The wind was out of the Northwest at 20 knots. Individual heard the siren faintly and he indicated that if he had not been listening for the l siren he would not have identified the warning.

( b. One individual was in the gymnasium alone playing basketball.

l lie observed the clock and stopped playing and listened for the siren. lie l faintly heard the siren and indicated that if he had not been listening l he would not have heard the warning.

1

c. The last individual was located in the Administration Building i

i and was waiting for the siren and at 12:00 did not hear anything. lie then went to the window where he could faintly hear the siren. lie then went to the door to verify the warning. Ilowever, standing in the middle of the building or sitting at his desk, the siren could not be heard.

I d. The personnel located in the lunchroom area were questioned l after the warning and they all denied hearing any siren.

j -

e. One of our supply personnel went home for lunch at 1145 hours0.0133 days <br />0.318 hours <br />0.00189 weeks <br />4.356725e-4 months <br /> to Lacarne and returned at 1230 hours0.0142 days <br />0.342 hours <br />0.00203 weeks <br />4.68015e-4 months <br /> and he also denied hearing any sirens or any warnings.

l 2. It is the opinion of this office that the warning system that was tested today was virtually ineffective for the Air National Guard area l

located at Camp Perry,0hio. We feel that the existing warning system i l cannot be relied upon for proper notification to this area. If there  !

are any questions or any further information required, please contact l this office.

, (' g!'(/ ] { -

PIIILIP , WILLIAMS, Col, OllANG Base Commander

,fMM v! :i s ' ~-* G A W s /dp c 4 @K y e. . .scei.7, . ,~ 3 q . cg-f$r . ,_--

' 5* l N*-

/ l

. y,jy ' $.y

_y !

nc

$wiJ\%4 " ,e 7', W e s r,+4 .-a}::: 4 l,- t. .

i yp ~ -5 1 5 \ fa

^

) ] ^% * . * ,,

'll

.v.

<w i x 1,m\ n

~

,,- ,w, , i ,i '

; i ;b

~ ft,'i , ,

I rT lh.,; t h dH'[:r's f .. : % F5, d

,,; .g $,9o);

s 4

+f,  ;{Nge 'j.;;o 5

)

s

xn a o[

Ng --g 2 .:v 5

t r*f ,, , : ,

{

i

(

k- .

I fgai7n_" ?mp ,7, ,i.,mrb,bDi  !

r , . 6. .

S -

. ~ - ,

w

.7.

., t.,6 . 7 c

$y g o

h, i

+

[ sai r- - %

7 w g l' (! p

g'&r. '. f ",

i . ,

',.;.is. e g ." [{iw p u[

2 tl c.

e 4

r, , l' 9 l V ',4 % <'

O 4 p r (. ,

. 3

..r. c]g

.vP s sia M, in W 1 e W N, .ii- ^, j[ _RJ 2

o h 3.-

.] la ll'h' ' to '. .CD%.. <L.a dr . f$n, D $e,f

,, v . - < o. m, a

. -,0 , #

q ,- j>

- . =

. emi ,,. g .e. ,

%{aq

.{

,f

$$i ,

Q> aE [

['i+u l.pic... n, 4-

[4 kN, ,.h I-

% 4 ,' '

J' ,i W' i,

lll Q3 ((*[$ l $s,4 & ,L 1 hOb ,& ,& 9 fAg

,o r a u m b.. )Y C

% p o .. .

x

,/h,*

ta N, g.'V 3 d d;. l & ffR ' CT ti l:

y n m.

./

ag n

,e ,. 57.- ga m.. $,e. -.

m 3 .. u s,, 9 e,( g-( .

4l .

h.'

h____51sr f4mk i 44.Ol?  ! h,f]ts'n'[  % ng ,~iiE '

Sqt !

o f,l,)=.p' y -

t,

, s q- y. .np, , s - i-lj m

,, .i  : e pl - -

e

,y' y-z

, g .3 i d -= -

-/

L'] d, ' '

'QL-t ,'t.phk 2,

.+ w A

. ,. 0 a . k, d a .: 1: s;=

vbi)L$,L___!..I...c a! s.J _ ;

.:n.

, p .,.

2.; _ *[,de . i

• . ;l L f ,, '$,f 5 _..=.a. ui

r. y ..-

3 < 3 - i

4 1, g; j/w h,f ,

p#3, 'i H WJ S ! = s'71 *

~._,. .es. s. x_, .ml[h ~. jf & ~> ,.a .,J

< u.

a. .m4 L_ 7

. I p( =-

y' m -m I kl n , lh,%i

/ } f'3 e gu. s

.h ,

...p .

g

,N y --

/ Lh xQ br'i , d'  ?  !

., r. - / z

,a s- C,.. Q,sJ.f."/ y,Qa p d.A <; / % <J'.. ,' p g

q . =

g, - b) 3 ).

f ,,,g - .,, l) ..

~

p M

y 'q) ,l, dllr. g:p w , s m* -

f; l ..

1 ,

a d "

i f, w(.,

(

j

.,. a '

2ic.nh, tm

{ R &m r.dI' . #. s~y

..w om .

- - m n ,.v w.

DD f

=in .p,m:..v; r

O g ,-} , >g ,- } g I ;

e,

y. y- .......l

-7 .c . -

1g., y. . ,7 ,.- ,

, Q > ,)

I l * * '

,O >

.,l(u.

L ,u, , . . ( . . . _ _,!y , _. 2 l

e -c .. . . . . J.k o. . . . . a.

u. , . ,

u ..

g,

.w. .t a ,i v

y ,,,t i3 ,4 1 .

, . m y .- -

\ .,a my > '\

y p... 1

)s i 'O

, 0 0 0 '. M l [f.) O F9 l

[:. ,71 .

~

- /

z

' Docket No. 50-346 License No. NPF-3 Serial No. 1-235 December 30, 1981-Attachment 2 i

Note: The preliminary airen locations have been transposed onto the map provided in Attachment 3. Map 1 referenced in the report is a USGS map and plastic overlay assembly.

It is available for examination at Toledo Edison.