ML20056B181

Interrogatories & Request for Production of Documents.* Requests That Util Answer Interrogatories & Request for Production of Documents No Later than 900831.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence

ML20056B181
Person / Time
Site:	Perry
Issue date:	08/08/1990
From:	Hiatt S OHIO CITIZENS FOR RESPONSIBLE ENERGY
To:	CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING CO.
References
CON-#390-10720 OLA-2, NUDOCS 9008150153
Download: ML20056B181 (7)

Text

a QMid A ' ' MUM 000M$PONDENCE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 00CKETED VSNRC Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board L, ,'

In'the Matter of )

30 gg 13 P4 :19

)

Tile CLEVELAND' ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING ) t,rnCE C3 S!CiiEll#I -

COMPANY, ET AL. ) Docket No. 50-440rOl@-[7l#A r.-

3 (Perry Nuclear Power Plant, Unit 1) )

)

)

e INTERROGATORIES AND REQUEST POR PRODUCTION OP DOCUMENTS 1

Intervenor Ohio Citizens for Responsible Energy, Inc.

("OCRE")'hereby directs the following interrogatories and

,, request for production of documents to the Licensees. OCHE requests that'the Licensees answer these interrogatories and requestforhroduction-of'documentsnolaterthanAugust 31, ,

1990. These requests should be deemed continuing so as to require further and' supplemental responses as the Licensees receive or generate additional documents or information within the scope of these requests between the time of original response and the time of hearing, to the extent consistent with p 10 - CPR 2. 74 0 (e) .

t DEPINITIONS A. The word " Licensees" refers to the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, acting on its own behalf and on behalf of -

the Toledo Edison Company, Ohio Edison Company, Duquesne Light i

s' 9008150153 ADOCy 900008 05000440 :

PDR L

g; gT9 ge p,  % q' f ,

y ,

n' '

s. ,

e -

Company,,and Pennsylvania Power. company,Jits officers, agents, '{

t

~

F employees, vendors, contractors, consultants,~or others acting on its behalf.

i t

D. " Document"'iticludes-any, written or recorded or graphic '

. matter, howeverfproduced or reproduced, including but not

,7- limited tos correspondence,4 telegrams, or other; written,; typed q t

i or, printed communications, contracts, agreements, notes'in any

{

form,: memoranda, diaries, reports, voice recording tapes, ,

J ~ .

microfiIms,l microfiche, pictures, drawings,_ diagrams, books, .[

. computer, tapes?and'other computer generated or stored {

information1or: data base, calendars, minutes of meetings, or- '!

any writings-or. graphic matter, including copies containing.  !

marginal notes or variations of any of the. foregoing, now or 1 a

.previously in your possession.

, 1 C.." Identify," Lor " Identity," of " Identification" when used in [

.referen'ce to an individual person,-means to' state that person's 1 4

full' name'tandiresidence" address,' including;.; zip. code = and phone - j asn' .

'numberj71 f[known, and present.or last-known business position andfduties Land business addre's' s , 'if ' known.

'i i

D. " Identify," Lor," Identity," of " Identification" when used in i reference:to a document,'means to state the type of document (e.g..,1 computer 1 stored information, microfilm, letter, memorandumi policy circular, minute book, . telegram, chart, 3 ~

+

2 1

i

1. j: fm,o e . h ,

sm o e

, 1

, , em kh .,3 4

? '

J I Sh-

'Q f?bw -

p;[r&lO,'.  ;

+

etc.)',;or some other means of.identifyingL it,-its p'tesent-

~ ' '

c, y ..

k*,'

m. .

10 .

llocationf arid custodian, a description title, number, or another' meEns.ofLgenerallidentification and the date onlwhich it was-j l

p;m o,

, .g '

'made,fperpared, or received... If any such docuinent wasi but is l s yy W4 g+ <

1, fnoflonger in Licensees'. possession or subject'tr> Licensees,.'

l i. ,

i.

control,E state?what disposition wasLmade'of it, and.if. -

f <'

g/ \j .

p

• I 6, y dustroyed?or disposed of'by operation of a' retention policy, W',".g

. state'theiretention policy. :1 O , w ),. . w ,

g4 6 , ,,

u ,- , ., ,

pk .- u. g , . -.r -

+ a e

E.i" Identify,," orL. " Identity," of " Identification"'when used in' f4 [, ,

.; . . .t. '

K'.

' reference [to:a business organization means;to state the-  :

y 7,

m, m. . c'orporate namelor other names under which said organization a

~

1m ..

A }doesIbusiness,--and the location of its principal place of 1 -

}$ Yf .

'{

g *, -business'.- , ,

t

.s-q jP pk:O i O D. J"Persori"' or L '.' Persons" includes natural . persons',

mv. y. m pj n Mis i o.. . .- 3. ,> ,

Jcorporations, partnerships, ventures, unincorporated-s -

t m< %w. Hjngg %.

n y" , ,- .iD ,Lassociations'll1and'.allL-other entities.

o ,

&.{! w'

?

2+ - t . .,

o : i s 4 ,, , g% '

s

, j'j ,4 #+ /*' -

. WLO?W '

,;g * '

-y- i w

l

• 4

Dyh,M-i 0 <. ,, INTERTIOG ATORIES ,

s 2;i i+s-

-w"' ,

.c

' f:

f

< +

M p , 4 s

l .. .. .

1,.o.Identifyieach person Licensees intend to call as a witness-gj ~- -4 s s

R

- " ., a- .

'L in - this -proceeding, and identify the subject' matter on which -

1 C+; 4 .

b P he/sheijs'exp'ectedito testify, and the-substance of the

t ,. ,

J1

m

-g

, s. - .1- '

,%\# ,

testimony.

h. 'I N ,' '

y

[g 3. h s

} .Q ~

w- \

3  :

F

)-'

s, ,

j Yi -~I Y h > ' - , Ji- , r - ~

,, l

w n . < ,

+

+

. . g. . ,

- c'a . .. '

i@i DE ,,

' $ 2l. ; Identify # each' person having knowledge of the subject matter .

1 of this' proceeding' . ,

,l 3.. Identify all documents relevant to the subject matter of n ..

this; proceeding.- ,!

'A i

.4. For.eachLof the following parameters, Linear Heat  ;

y LG'eneration[ Rate'("LHGR"), Minimum Critical. Power Ratio j n;

i("MCPR")!, J Power -and; Flow Dependent MCPk, _ Maxiinum Average Planar

-LinearjHeat Generation; Rate ("M APLHUR") , Power and Flow Dependent /MAPLHGR Parametric Curves, identify and describe the I

analytical 1 methodology or methodologies used to calculate the 1

v-EvaluesCof;the' parameter. State whether tre methodology uses- d computerfmodelsiorihand calcule.tions. -

!. $ V  %-

xapf!Al -l

.. nv . ' :Y.. v- ..

<r

' 5 .3 . For;eachianalytical _ methodology identified in your answer: 1

-s OJ oX MM fij

.totInterrogatoryif4,Jidentify all areas of uncertainty in the.

. 1 4 m 4

.computa'tionalfm' o del:and input values, the reasons'for.the. {

uncertainity,?and any limits on the uncertainty.. .i 3

-i

. )t 6.<;For each analytical method' ology identified in your answer ,

l

- 'ta) Interrogatory #4,.' identify each instance in which the user y"

.of the: methodology.is--afforded discretion or judgement in its '

^ application, and any limits on this discretion or judgement. l

7. For-each analytical methodology identified in your answer

't 4  :

'I

- i.:

% . , , . .--. - .. - .I

Wy . ,

q .9, G y' >

f.

'g . }  ?' f y:

f ,  ; 't' Q.

,,m ,

r 1 *; [2 .k 4c, 8

0 toLId eb$d4 gat y:44hLidentify'all input variables and . ,

.t

.c w

.~v 3 ; . u ,,

- user-controlled or;i determined options, and any limits on'the

[

, wpm rang'ekAfhal'uesibfithese'vasiablesandoptions. ] ;

- .fl;_.- . 'l l ,

- , . , c,, .. ,

'8. For each' analytical methodology'; identified in-your answer. .;

.r .. ~

- tofInterrogatory;#4,Jide'ntify,the' person or business entity who' performs 7the, calculations..  ;

,i

. e

9. For'each analvtical methodology, identified in.your answer? l to Interrogatoryf#4,' indicate whether there ic'any, independent.

verification'of.the' calculations performed, and identify the .

- person 'or business ' entity who perf orms > this independent r

I verification'. .

]

3 D t

+

1 t

- 10. =For(each analytical methodology identified in your answer

t

, to-Interrogalory"#4_that uses computer models,findicate whether-'

y '

the compute'riprogram will reject input values that are <

q j

unreasonabl'e-or physically impossible. .If so, state ~whether h ;4 4j idefau1N Evalueskare used instead,-and the value of and basistfor t

't 4

. theidefaulttvalue.-

, Ji/ .,' ,

+

-TC  :;

-;a: .m il Nh;MjhsREQUESTFOR-PRODUCTIONOFDOCUMENTS 93mg ip ; 1 l

q4Q@W;4l%. S '  ;

n n.Q p 9 R .,, - n

".OCRE,,j+reguests:that-Licensees' provide copies or provide , i.

wg; htM ,Nd. .f '

-[

accessEfbr/ rep [ro, duction'ofeachdocumentidentifiedintheir >

p:E  :

- (t p@: y, y 4:. .

1

,L,,.

'answersjtoj.the y above Interrogatories. ,

R g,, :r

+

. _O 1

. 5 5

I 3

..~ _. . . . . _ . _ _ -_

T c .~ - . - , .- . _ _

. Y. *

~s A.

oedi

< .  ?

. -- "1 r f!mkA.M4

~

@1% mewme$4N S T.

-'. 1 0 ..,m,

i e' n- A . j op apl W '&i

, . *, 4

.a. ,

$yn pi . .d r0%s u c - a - v a:.

qm . ay n.e aw nv . . xw ~u-4 oy. ,. .

j v~h ; . I' c.

d u.L.

F sd 1 Q

• 3.. ,

.'\,',

, =

m.d:n-W 4 m'I)h?[ %M, e .a % h Nf [i I

s 7- -t*

tn%76wh y ,

FMW =,' 'V.-

1. v .-s,5 &, ,M>:ihTJr - s

';T

.% i( l, } '

.m g Y.[

• s

'{ >

'm y ? Q ' '"

M> kQ_sUNji 3

L ~ '

vut u,wni wl.QWc-

_. N N.

4rm < ,

w.ayM m%ngm n: y ,

• Respectfullygsubmitted; t.

Q$@sN ow e.&. . . ,,

t z s re,o..-

vy t QuQ s

N .

s. ,

o.

q

'. i) 1

. 'Q- ; u.m . ,

w%%j nf li.i.?.Ho k-

. d4 d E

r .

_g.,- ,

,,, s '

i %m s Susan-LAHiatt; , e MN W V , hp ,' .OCRE-Representative 1

, 3

!j 8275 MunsonnRoad.

q@&@@hjMgg O qMy p <

mN 7,

~Montorh OHL'44060 (216).255 3158 ,

4 s td 0,

My@ W @Gi,e ..r%* s' 4

.. . , S2 "y g .f -

1 C 0.^ l

+ Y , n .l Y

.<=

DNED N%[hD ' ,

_.-y (z

_ma.Ng',' I,i g; 6

-i99 au i Mdl 4 'w-I .. 4.T.,ief i

• M

~1 -

-} ,p

,d

' )M s3h it' b' ,O H. i f '

.fJf Q((&;- f-yg. .: ?. , Q WR ,

• L 1 <

a, 6,

ya&m% % " <

s n > ,

( c m' ' '- N^ g hlg-T C ; s t, 8 m ,

r p'

> , , m.

3" g@WW &.

r-

.' s _. ' , ".e&g , m i. -Y y ; ;.>m'. ' . '

's

• v ,

l O

. qn e s,[t 6j

Ofh. .

n I c a/;t3 , au ((n y%,

ft W ,- %'  : t 1; g .- 5 u

2 Msd'tpM,4 J.,1.c 9v= N

-3 r

il

,u- >

CmMY;b', o, ; pw e%e.0d f3.-O k :@f L & m;p:n, ,

i

'.L m; pje, vm u

l'.,'*,4- -1

^d )

engmcNw. aw y =. w. ev / - -

o i >

c

.j Jr( Tis %1 i ih- k <Yk- - gWm m 1 >

sf. . f, , e a y' WW :MV s+

??*im(%g%ng

5

.a

,ht 4c c$4%Wjn '

s %y ,4 t d@@D rg i' Jap-l.l:ff. Edi/ '

- m

• + ..y

$ s '

a

',,l$NgM.i q,;g;&,,g;jfb ' y$b;n

- a~m y%py, ) # @ y.W , N

@db,. y ,

%J. y; Us y

gy tl[hpHp Q 1 g

, -'L v i

%M.@Wynl3fg 3 r 4 S%i,Mh,u3y 4

VR @iQpiepik s 2,. r ." n. W f* ,

4~: %

!V ,(.' y

- .,,a w , > f, <

~g! mm(J

y. m M n,,

n . - '

,'a4li Q t U 8'; 4.yyj i y s WA ei' f

' pd,(? %,d ' g;Ap.N,.d- *Q'O y1,., y[/gdrwy '

,y.y e

d IUg. g\ ,QQ r nyr -4 ---

l' M if S 'kQM,Maf$ 'MN. ;kth MdFIYf iMMM'm a$

r g.: .

w iN'l_ em .

m m.,e  ! I eI ih.

')i h i cy) a y {. , 'k j Q q [.I - \ . t f ;I-i 4

<-4V .< ,

k d a ry u,; ,vg, V

.e

'3 s - * '

..W' F ,e W ' f f V ,y g"+ , . ,  ; & v *d 4l }i r* .,

2 y

.% .~ ~ ' s e c'

v Q..*;- f.!  ? Q , M. y ;:y ' ' ,s t; n,c r t

y - t -j43o.. m j- M,'!.f o

-.i aa7Mtp =(

,' C:ne yh Jm G 'g$ "; ' W :_n 3

4 . , ,

1

.n [5 k s,

i. p L ; v - N m . -m:- ..>

• 3 N'l *r W: e s F #

f c . - ,a

[w 3' [Ny id C,

--[h%1dh o y.4

\i ..

v i . ,

n p"'

' II S pl } .h m ' . h ,k .; * :

' ' - : '. i il I 4 t Y Ql * , ,

1

c g

/'t;p s ;p; k D rWU W. r.'h w -

JCL., ,

,D19:e if ; q , .P h4 i;;; >

1)s i ,

WMy!p .' 2,F v ,,

ti

. wme  ?,

'g'4

.n,9

".y s. s<) @.p li, , w . .

3 n- - a. 1'

'>.~ ' -l  ;

,.1.,

+1 .yi gh f' * '

d, U; s'M, -^ 2 :^i @ ';f *,

f,m&,h.4r ? ? Q_ t -

in '

" ', d.*

@s Wyg Wg#,

_.W, s,(

,U

' ^ '

d-;

3 .

'.<g

-@y&pw _*G , ' >

.j e %nQR m.

3y Q 'n4.

• 3. -

e,d , I . ' Y m

!q&:fm,y Y$y m;  ;}

.s I"l 'A l - ,i l) 4 xq cp lwU1;L _u v sp!!.- JN

}j 'i i

4 :l y k,'

r& ' 0 3

=i

. d wh ~ g'

Q:gg g 'g ,

&' p { , ,

fM-%g im m

.4 g

a 5t horiq y.;}V. ,9 g

, .-t

' 9f '"

.a

,y

> 1 q

Nl fhl (

h e ,l

, g

- w=

c< y

, y A. a e

'I u@m' g< 9 y t, ,

),Y f # ,..j r

.. h '

t hy _ Mq4 s-t M'M[(.p%y i.V >

j"R;Di QW:  ?.<p r ,

L t

y

'gc , G. Q '

.[&Q ,

t!%msy w % _.n p

~

dp hW ' g-O .. [

& . w . ,

)

W y[f ) h ,. QQ

.m.

/h '"if.4 -(-r . d(

• c< -. __ m u, .  : .

. - ,_ ,.m

fe r, CERT 1 PICA 1 E OF SUl(VIC11 E d hlill' UNC I certify .that copics of t.he fo.egoing were served byg g g, g .l9 in the U.S. Mail, first class, putage prepaid, this j day of _ M orff' ,

1990 to che following:

P 00 'CKfNG 1:!CL Of $(CM iMiv A ypyn

-IINANb" Secretary of the Commisuion ATTN: Docketing and Service liranch U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commlucion Washington, DC 20555 Administrative' Judge Administrative Judge John H. Frye,;111. Chairman Jerry R. Kline Atomic Safety'and Licensing Doard Atomic Safety and Licensing Deard U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washinoton. DC .20555 Washington, DC 20555 Administrative Judge Culleen Woodhead, Escuire

' Frederick J. Shon Ofilce of the General Counsel Atomic Safety and Licensing Boarc U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commissten Washington. DC 20555 Washington, DC+ 20555 s

Jay E. Silberg Ms. Carol O'Claire Shan,.Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge Ohio Emergency Management Agency 2300 N' Street'. N.W'. Technical llazards Branch

~

Washington',JDC -20037 2825 West Granville Road Columbus, Oli 43235-2712 kg -

'?I[i ;.;+

[E ' "

n; 4 ,,

4*+ -- t&h 1

,@ &g . /

Susnu L. liia tt OChE llep r e se n ta tive e

.