ML20112C917
| ML20112C917 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Perry  |
| Issue date: | 01/07/1985 |
| From: | Hiatt S OHIO CITIZENS FOR RESPONSIBLE ENERGY |
| To: | CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING CO. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20112C914 | List: |
| References | |
| OL, NUDOCS 8501110479 | |
| Download: ML20112C917 (7) | |
Text
,
~
C U7;U'i poh()y s
ChjkTED January 7, 1985 c
g UNITED STATES,OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
'83 jg j j gg 77 Before the Atomic Sorety and Licensing 50ced
' f G!CE ;.1 0!CfiE TAP '
/
EU;y...,f.. 'M In the Matter or
)
THE CLEVELAND ELECTRIC
)
Docket Nos. 50-440-OL i
)
50-441 OL
)
(Perry Nuclear Power Plant,
)
Units 1 and 2)
)
OCRE85 FOURTEENTH SET OF INTERROGATORIES TO APPLICANTS Intervenor Ohio Citizens for Responsible Energy ('OCRE')
'hereby files its Fourteenth Set of Interrogatories to a
Applicants, pertaining to Issue M16, on Transomerico Delaval diesel generotors., The interrogotories herein concern replacement piston skirts for the Perry diesel engines.
Included herewith is o request for production of documents, seeking documents identified in' Applicants 8 responses to these interrogatories and documents identified in Applicants' October 31, 1984 submittal to the NRC Storr.
THE INTERROGATORIES FILED HEREIN ARE SUBMITTED PURSUANT TO
-10 CFR 2.7406 WHICH REQUIRES THAT THE INTERROGATORIES BE I
ANSUERED SEPARATELY AND FULLY IN WRIT NG UNDER OATH OR g
AFFIRMATION WITHIN
))
14 DAYS,AFTER' SERVICE. THE INTERROGATORIES ARE INTENDED TO BE 4
CONTINUING IN NATURE AND THE ANSWERS MUST BE SUPPLEMENTED OR e
e-AMENDED,-AS APPROPRIATE, SHOULD APPLICANTS OBTAIN ANY NEW OR N*
. l DIFFERENT
~
INFORMATION RESPONSIVE TO THE INTERROGATORIES.
j{g
, REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DO,CUMENTS ARE FILED PURSUANT TO SEC 10 CFR 2.'41, WHICH REQUIRES THAT APPLICANTS PRODUCE AND EITHER 7
I 9
s
~
FURNISH COPIES OF OR PERMIT OCRE TO INSPECT AND COPY ANY DOCUMENTS RESPONSIVE TO THE REQUEST WHICH ARE IN THE POSSESSION. CUSTODY.
OR CONTROL OF APPLICANTS.
REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS ARE ALSO CONTINUING IN NATURE AND APPLICANTS MUST PRODUCE IMMEDIATELY ANY ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS IT OBTAINS WHICH ARE RESPONSIVE TO THE REQUEST.
F'OR THE PURPOSES OF THESE INTkRROGATORIES. THE TERM
' DOCUMENT' MEANS ALL WRITINGS AND RECORDS OF EVERY TYPE IN THE POSSESSION, CUSTODY. OR CONTROL OF APPLICANTS, INCLUDING. BUT NOT LIMITED TO, MEMORANDA, CORRESPONDENCE REPORTS, SURVEYS, TABULATIONS,
- CHARTS, BOOKS, PAMPHLETS, PHOTOGRAPHS. MAPS. BULLETINS. MINUTES, NOTES, SPEECHES, ARTICLES. TRANSCRIPTS. VOICE RECORDINGS, VIDEOTAPES, COMPUTER PROGRAMS, PRINTOUTS, OR DATA STORED SUCH THAT IT IS RETRIEVABLE BY COMPUTER, AND ALL OTHER WRITINGS OR RECORDINGS OF ANY KIND. ' DOCUMENTS' SHALL ALSO MEAN COPIES OF DOCUMENT,5 EVEN THOUGH THE ORIGINALS THEREOF ARE NOT IN THE.
POSSESSION, CUSTODY. OR CONTROL OF APPLICANTS.
FOR THE PURPOSES OF THESE INTERROGATORIES, A DOCUMENT SHALL BE DEEMED TO BE WITHIN APPLICANTS' ' CONTROL' IF APPLICANTS HAVE OWNERSHIP. POSSESSION. OR CUST0DY OF THE DOCUMENT OR COPY THEREOF, OR HAVE THE RIGHT TO SECURE THE DOCUMENT OR COPY THEREOF FROM ANY PERSON OR PUBLIC OR PRIVATE ENTITY HAVING
_3_
t PHYSICAL POSSESSION THEREOF.
.WHEN IDENTIFICATION OF A DOCUMENT IS REQUESTED, BRIEFLY 4
DESCRIBEJTHE DOCUMENT,.I.E., LETTER.HEMORANDUM, BOOK, PAMPHLET,'
,ETC.
AND.5 TATE THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION A5 APPLICABLE TO THE PARTICULAR DOCUMENT:
'NAME, ~ TITLE, NUMBER.. AUTHOR,'DATE OF PUBLICATION AND PUBLISHER,
- ADDRESSEE, DATE WRITTEN OR APPROVED, AND THE NAME AND ADDRESS OF THE PERSON (5) HAVING POSSESSION OF THE DOCUMENT.
14-1.
When are the replacement AE piston skirts to be installed t
in the PNPP diesel generators ("DGs')?
14-2.
For each replacement AE piston skirt,. provide:
- ~(a) date of manufoetures (b) heot no.,
material properties, alloy type,,and chemical composition of the skirt material, and the methods by-which the
~
-moterial properties were determined (including the number of samples used):
6 (c) type and procedure of any 5ect treatment the skirt may have receiveds (d) type, procedure used, and results of ony non-destructive evoluotions performed on the skirt to identify flows, indications, defects, or stress raisers, whether Performed by TDI or by applicantsi (e) Whether the skirt hos any tir or copper-tin plating (or any f'b.
-4 other plating), and if so, how the plating was cPplied (i.e.,
-electroplating or dipping) and'why it was applieds s
-(r). the measured principol dimensions of the skirt,. including
- the boss oreo -and the gap between the outer ring and the crown 4
.-i.
4
- when:ottocheds
- (9) TDI's specified principal dimensions for AE skirts, I
. including'the ring-to-crown gaps'
+
the. skirt-to-crown bol'ts, and TDI's I'l
-(h)I ~ the torque recorded on l
.specified' torque, 14-3.
(a) Identify the quality standards under which the replacement AE piston skirts were manurcetured.
(b) Explain how Applicants have ensured that the quality stondords were met.
i 14-4. List all inspections made by Applicants or their agents or-a
'the TDI racilities during the time or manuroeture or the AE.
replacement piston skirts, and identify all reports or other documentation'or said inspections, 14-5, Identify any studies or calculations of AE. Piston side thrust in TDI engines.
14-6.
Identiry oil operating experience with AE piston skirts on TDI diesel engines, Specifically, identify each engine using AE skirts by location, serial number, opplication, horesepower, peak firing pressure, type of ruel used, engine speed, engine 6
type,-no, of cylinders, and hours operated, ' including hours at
.rull lood and hours above full load, and percent or overlood, I
- r--
14-7.
Identify all inspections of AE piston skirts from TOI engines.
Give the number inspected, the total number of skirts ovoilable, any.storistical onalyses performed, operating history of the skirt (including the information requested in Interrogotory 14-6), date of inspection, nome and offiliation of the inspectors, procedures and techniques used, and results of
+
the inspections.
14-8.
Hove any TDI engines been run with AE piston skirts
~
instrumented with Strain gauges 7 If so. Provide all details, inclu' ding date and locotion of the test, entity performing the test, length of test, type and raing of engine used, procedures and techniques used, and results.
14-9.
Identify ony prototype, developmental, or operational testing of AE pis. ton skirts performed by TDI before supplying them to' customers in the field.
14-10.
Provide oil measurements of peak firing pressures in each PNPP OG using AE piston skirts.
Explain the conditions (engine loading, operating time, and procedures).used to obtain such measurements.
14-11.
Please provide the information requested in OCRE's-Interrogatory 10-34.
f REQUEST.FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS 0CRE. requests that Applicones resp *ond in writing to the
'following request for production of' documents, and produce the original or best copy of each of the documents-requested below i
o-ot a place convenient.to OCRE.
OCRE requests that Applicants Produce:
1, each and every document identified or described in the onswers to the above interrogtoriess 2.
Letter dated July 25, 19E4 (PY/50-26339) from E.C.
Christensen to C.L.
Roy Jr. of the TDI Owners Groups 3.
Results and reports or all inspections conducted on the PNPP diesel generators pursuant to the Owners Group Program 4.-
DR/QR Report on Perry DGs Pprepared by the Owners Group 5.
Results and reports or all onsite besting and operation of the PNPP DGs performed pursuant to the Owners Group Program.
If any-or the items requested above contain proprietory information provide the documents pursuant to on oppropriate s
protective ogreement.
Respectfully submitted, I
7 A
1 Susan L.
Hiatt OCRE Representative 9275 Hunson Rd.
Mentor, OH 44060 (216) 255-3158
b jj, r
.v
.w F
i I
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE q
p'
.This is to certi'fy that copies of the foregoing.were served by-deposit in the U.S. yail, first class, posta'ge prepaid,. this
'7M day of
- Qua w
, 198E to tho;se on the i service list below.v G
.i.
s
,...{
Y {}
~
,[
Susan L'..Hiatt-
. q.d-C
'. ' i, t, '. -
'ls ; '... ' ' i i:, i.
SERVICE. LIST
...:.,[
l,
.I JAMES P. GLEASON, CHAIRMAN r
. Terry Lodge, Esq.
1
't
' ATOMIC SAFETY a LICENSING BOARD 1
618 N. Michigan St'
' 513 GILMOURE DR.
SILUER SPRING, MD 2090^
f Suite 105 I
,' Toledo, OH 43624
. 'c -
.'Dr.
Jerry.R. Kline Atomic Safety..&.Licen. sing Board.
U.S,._ Nuclear. Regulatory Commission i;
Washington,"D.C.
20555 c,,
Mr..Glenn O. Bright j;,
's
- Atomic l Safety &. Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission f.
1-20555
}iashington,D.C.
t Colleen P. Woodhead, Esq.
4 7 <
..g Office".6f'the Executive Legal Director U.S. Nuclear. Regulatory Commission Washington,.D.C.
20555 i,
[
Jay.Silberg, Esq.
Shaw, Pittman, Potts, & Trowbridge y
1800 M Street, NW
- i.,
. Washington, D.C.
20036 y
p i
Docketing'&-Service Branch
- L
.Offi~ce of'the Secretary U.S.. Nuclear' Regulatory. Commission
' Washington, D.C.
20555 Ato'mic. Safety.&, Licensing. Appeal. Board Panel
~
U.S. Nuclear. Regulatory Commission Washington,'D.C.
20555 j
I