ML20094E517

Thirteenth Set of Interrogatories Pertaining to Issue 8 Re Hydrogen Control.Interrogatories Concern Generation,Release & Combustion of Hydrogen Gas in Degraded Core Accident. Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence

ML20094E517
Person / Time
Site:	Perry
Issue date:	07/30/1984
From:	Hiatt S OHIO CITIZENS FOR RESPONSIBLE ENERGY
To:	CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING CO.
References
OL, NUDOCS 8408090231
Download: ML20094E517 (20)

Text

.-

m 3

& O C0111S?C::DENG'

'}G$

July 30, 1984 NITED STATES OF. A.'4 ERICA NUCLEAR-REGULATORY COMNISSION i

~

f~%

Before the Atomic Safety and Licensine Board

?

.In'the: Matter of-

)

.g

.)

CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING

)

Docket Nos. 50-440 LCOMPANY, Et A1. j

)

50-441 Ob m

-)

(Operating License)

(Perry Nuclear Power Pla'nt,

)

. Units 1 and 2)

)

)

\\

OHIO CITIZENS FOR RESP 0HSIBLE EIERGY THIRTEENTH SET OF INTERROGATORIES TO APPLICANTS

-Intervenor Ohio' Citizens for Responsible Energy ("0CRE")

hereby files its Thirteenth set of Interrogatories to

~

~

? Applicants, pertaining to Issue #8-in this proceeding, on

. hydrogen.. control..The-following interrogatories concern the? generation,-release,.and combustion of hydrogen gas in

'.a. degraded core' accident and the effects of.such combustion

-lon the integrity of the PNPP Mark'III containment and the

survival _ of equipment within containment.

The purpose of these_ interrogatories'is to_ ascertain the design, operation, c

g

' and adequacy _of Applicants' proposed hydrogen ' control system e

and the bases for Applicantst-analyses in support of said

system.,

Also included herewith is a request for production of C

.' documents _ identified in response to the interrogatories.

p.

8400090231 840730

~j PDR ADOCK 05000440

(~

, rs - _0-PDR

x v

2-OMNM THE INTERROGATORIES FILED HEREIN TABULATIONS, ARE SUBMITTED PURSUANT TO 10 CFR HM 5,

NO 2.740b, OHICH REQUIRES THAT THE INTERROGATORIES BE ANSUERED SEP

-ARATErY AND FULLY IN URITING UN DER OATH OR AFFIRMATION WITHIN -

14. DAYS AFTER-SERVICE. THE INTER ROGATORIES ARE'IFENDED TO BE

~

CONTINUING IN NATURE; RND THE AN N

ECMD SUER 5 HUST BE SUPPLEMENTED OR RHENDED, AS APPROPRIATE, SHOULD APPLICANTS' OBTAIN ANY NEW OR DIF FERENT INFORMATION RESPONSIVE TO THEREOF ARE NOT IN THE POSSE 5-THE INTERROGATORIES.

SION, CUSTODY, OR CONTROL OF REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCU ppPLICANTS.

-HE W 5'ARE FILED PURSUANT TO 10

\\

ESE M ER

CFR 2.741, WHICH REQUIRES THAT O

APPLICANTS PRODUCE AND EITHER HNA IC M S' FURNISH COPIES OF OR PERMIT OCRE

~TO INSPECT AND COPY ARY DOCU-

'MENTS RESPONSIVE TO THE REQUEST UHICH ARE IN THE POSSESSION, CUS SECNE TODY, OR CONTROL OF RPPLICANTS.

M OF RECUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCU MENTS ARE ALSO CONTINUING IN NA TURE RND APPLICANTS MUST PRODUCE

-IMMEDIATELY ANY ADDITIONRL DOCU HENTS IT OBTAINS UHICH ARE RESPO UHEN IDENTIFICATION OF A DOCU NSIVE TO THE AEQUEST,-

HENT IS REQUESTED, BRIEFLY DES FOR THE PURPOSES OF THESE INTER ROGATORIES, THE TERM ' DOCUMENT'

MEANS ALL URITINGS AND RECORDS N

EPMI OF EVERY TYPE IN THE POSSESSION, M

LE, CUSTODY,'OR CONTROL OF APPLI-E T NBRCA CANTS, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMIT-

m y

[

-3

'. TION AND PUBLISHER, ADDRESSEE, 13-3. IDEEm Em M NW DATE _ URITTEN OR APPROVED,J AND.

CMSUAM M MNE, MN THE-NAME L AND ADDRESS OF THE' PER M ES, COMEMM, M MS

• ) SON (5)' HAVING POSSESSICN OF THE NC

-DOCUMENT.

OTHERUISE ENGAGED OR RELIED 113-1.

STATE THE NAME, PRESENT UPON TO PROUb>E ASSISTANCE OR OR LAST.-KNOUN-ADDRESS, PRESENT SERUICES PERTAINING TO THE GENER LOR'LAST KNOUN EMPLOYER, AND ATION, RELEASE, AND COMBUSTION

' EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL OF HYDROGEN IN A DEGRADED CORE 00ALIFICATIONS OF EACH PERSON ACCIDENT, AND THE EFFECT OF SUCH

.KNOUN TO YOU-TO HAVE FIRST-HAND 3

COMBUSTION ON CONTAINMENT INTEG

-KNOULEDGE CONCERNING THE PRODUC RITY AND THE SURUIVAL OF EGUIP TION,, RELEASE, AND COMBUSTION MENT IN CONTAINHENT. FOR EACH OF HYDROGEN IN A DEGRADED CORE SUCH CONSULTANT, DESCRIBE THE 1 ACCIDENT, AND THE.EFFECT OF SUCH SERVICES PROVIDED, AND IDENTIFY COMBUSTION ON CONTAIMMENT INTEG ANY STUDIES, REPORTS, ANRLYSES, RITY AND SURUIVAL OF EQUIPMENT OR OTHER DOCUMENTS GENERATED BY

,UITHIN? CONTAINMENT.

THE CONSULTANTS PERTAINING TO 31 (R) ' STATE THE NAME, TTTLE, E WBMW MMR F NW E

, EMPLOYER,'RND EDUCATIONAL AND-O*

.PROFESSIONRL' QUALIFICATIONS OF 13 -4.. IDENTIFY ALL DOCUMENTS IN ERCH-PERSON YOU INTEND TO CALL YOUR POSSESSION, CUSTODY, OR CON AS AlUITNESS ON ISSUE NO.: 8.

TROL, INCLUDING ALL Pf=ffUANT

.-(T)2 STATE THE SUBJECT' MATTER ON PAGE CITATIONS, PERTAINING TO

. WHICH ERCH SUCH-PERSON IS EXPEC T'

THE GENERATION, RELEASE, AND COM j. ED TOl TESTIFY. -

BUSTION OF HYDROGEN IN A DEGRAD

?(C)' STATE THE SUBSTANCE OF-THE' ED CORE ACCIDENT AND THE EFFECT JFACTS AND: OPINIONS-TO UHICH EACH OF SUCH COMBUSTION ON CONTAIN-SUCH PERSON IS EXPECTED TO TESTI MENT INTEGRITY AND SURUIVAL OF bW5 EQUIPMENT.IN CONTAINMENT.

.(D) STATE : A.

SUMMARY

OF THE iGROUNDS-FOR.SUCH OPINIONS,;AND 5.

ID N IW h DOCUM N S

[ IDENTIFY ALL' DOCUMENTS UPON-

"I "

IUNICH EACH SUCH PERSON'UILL RELY UNIO

-TO SUBSTANTIATE'SUCH OPINIONS.

USE DURING CROSS-EXAMINATION

~ ~ ~

-ON ISSUE NO. 8 IN THIS PROCEED ING.

'N

{ i.' 6

-4 V

4-

.w-413-6bJIDENTIFYLEACH CND EUERY

- UMOLE OR PART, FOR THEIR DEFENSE

.PROBABILISTIC' RISK ASSESSMENT,-

ON ISSUE 8,

OR UHICH IS OTHER gINCLUDING BLTT NOT ; LIMITED 1TO UISE RELEVANT TO IS5UE # 8.

b ANY, HINI--PRA PERFORMED BY OR

{[FORfAPPLICANTS, UPON'UHICH 13-10. IDENTIFY EACH AND EVERY STUDY, ANALYSIS, REPORT, ASSESS

-APPLICANTS INTEND.TO RELY,.IN i

UHOLE;OR PART, FOR-THEIR5 DEFENSE HENT, EURLUATION, OR OTHER SUCH

,ON' ISSUE NO. 8,.OR bHICH IS 1

DOCUMENT PREPARED BY OR FOR THE GENERAL ELECTRIC CO.,

ON WHICH j OTHERU15E. RELEVANT,TO '. ISSUE _ # 8.

APPLICANTS INTEND TO RELY, IN f13-7.LIDENTIFY EACH AND EVERY-WHOLE OR PART, FOR THEIR DEFENSE

' STUDY,.. ANALYSIS,-REPORT, EUALUA ON ISSUE # 8, CR UHICH IS OTHER

~

TION,1A55E55HENT, OR OTHER SUCH-UISE,RELEUANT TO ISSUE ?! 8.

DOCUMENT PREPARED FOR OR BY 13-11. IDENTIFY EACH AND EVERY HISCISSIPPI POWER AND' LIGHT, TUPONJUHICH APPLICANTS INTEND TO STUDY, ANALYSIS, REPORT, ASSESS

-RELYi IN:UHOLE OR PART, FOR HENT, EURLUATION, OR OTHER SUCH DOCUMENT PREPARED BY OR FOR THE THEIR. DEFENSE ON ISSUE # 8, OR UNICH!IS 0THERUISE RELEUANT TO BUR OWNERS GROUP, ON UHICH AP-

-I?5UE # 8.

PLICANTS INTEND TO RELY, IN UMOLE OR PART, FOR ITS DEFENSE

?13-8, -IDENTIFY. EACH AND EVERY ON ISSUE.# 8, OR UHICH IS OTHER STUDY,. ANALYSIS,. REPORT, ASSESS UISE RELEUANT TO ISSUE # 8.

1.HENT,!EURLUATION,.OR OTHER SUCH 13-12..ZDENTIFY EACH AND EVERY

-DOCUMENT PREPARED 18Y OR FOR THE STUDY, ANALYSIS, REPORT, ASSESS fHYDROGEN' CONTROL.OWNERSGROUP, ON UHICH APPLICANTS INTEND TO MENT, EURLUATION, OR OTHER SUCH DOCUMENT PREPARED BY OR FOR THE

' RELY,. IN ~ UHOLE. OR* PART, FOR NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION,.

THEIR-DEFENSE ON ISSUE:# 8, OR, UPON UNICH APPLICANTS INTEND TO JUNICH IS OTHERUISE RELEUANT TO

~

RELY, IN UHOLE OR PART, FOR

-ISSUE #~8.

THEIR DEFENSE ON ISSUE # 8, OR (13--D. IDENTIFY EACH AND EVERY UHICH IS OTHERUISE RELEVANT TO STUDY,' ANALYSIS, ASSESSMENT, ISSUE 8.

~ REPORT, EUALUATION, OR OTHER 13-13. IDENTIFY EACH AND EVERY

.SUCH. DOCUMENT' PREPARED BY OR FOR

THE IDCOR PROGRAM, UPON UNICH STUDY, ANALYSIS, REPORT, ASSESS RPPLICANTS INTEND TO RELY, IN HENT, EURLUATION, OR OTHER SUCH

Q i

.a,-,

s m

3 c

l-.

^

4 DOCUMENT PREPARED -BY.OR FOR.THE OR PART, FOR THEIR DEFENSE ON

ELECTRIC' POWER RESEARCH INSTI-ISSUEE# 8, OR UHICH IS OTHERUISE TUTE - (EPRI),. ON UNICH RPPLICANTS RELEUANT TO ISSUE'# 8.

IDENTIFY

^

4INTENDTTO, RELY,s IN UNOLE OR PART IN EACH CASE THE PERSON OR

'FOR THEIR DEFEN5E ON ISSUE:# 8, ENTITY CONDUCTING AND SPONSORING JOR-jUHICH :IS1OTHERUISE RELEVANT THE RESEARCH.

HTOTISSUE #;8..

13-17. FOR EACH OF THE ABOVE 113-14....iIDENTIFY EACH AND: EVERY INTERROGATORIES 13-6 THROUGH

PROGRAHJOF RESEARCH, AND THE 13-15, IDENTIFY UNETHER THE RESULTS,1 CONCLUSIONS, AND EURLU DOCUMENTS OR RESEARCH UILL BE RTIONS, THEREOF :-(RND L RLL RELATED~

RELIED UPON BY APPLICANTS OR I5 5 DOCUMENTATION) CONDUCTED BY OR HERELY RELEUANT TO ISSUE # 8.

a..

-FOR EPRI, UPON UHICH APPLICANT 5 I

13-18.' IDENTIFY EACH AND EVERY INTEND _lTO RELY,.IN WHOLE OR PART CW M G CODE, SIHULATEN, M FOR THEIR DEFENSE ON. ISSUE-# 8, HODEL UNICH UILL BE RELIED UPON TOR UNICH'IS OTHERUISE RELEVANT

[TOfI55UE:#'8 1 BY APPLICANTS, IN UHOLE OR PART, TO EURLUATE THE GENERATION, 13-16.:; IDENTIFY EACH-AND EVERY RELEASE, TRANSPORT, AND COMSUS PROGRAM OF;RESEARCH,;AND THE TION OF HYDROGEN IN A DEGRADED

'RESULTS,: CONCLUSIONS,.AND EURLU CORE ACCIDENT, AND THE EFFECT OF 3RTIONS ITHEREOF :(RND ALL RELATED SUCH-COMBUSTION ON CONTAINHENT DOCUMENTATION)bCONDUCTED BY OR INTEGRITY AND THE SURUIUAL OF FOR NRC,;UPON UNICH~RPPLICANTS EQUIPHINT IN CONTAINHENT. FOR INTEND-TO RELY,EIN WHOLELOR PART i

EACH SUCH CODE IDENTIFIED,

FOR 1THEIR DEFENSE AN ' ISSUE # 8' (A) DESCRIBE THE CODE'S PURPOSE

ORlUHICH

IS OTHERUISE RELEVANT.

RND HETHODOLOGY;

' TO ~I55UE # : 8. :

(B) STATE UNEN AND BY UNOH IT h1Nid.'IDENTIFYRNYOTHERPRO-5 DE R WED, IDNW N AMMM DOCU GRAM OF._RESERRCH,-RND THE.

HENTATION OF THE CODE; RESULTS, CONCLUSIONS, AND EUALU 5

TE WUHG THE ESUS J RTIONS _THEREOF- - (RND ALL RELATED SENSME W NW EUES

DOCUMENTATION) CONDUCTED BY OR ASSWPT ENS, USS @TIMS, FOR;RNYf ENT*TY,a UPON UHICH APPLI 1

TIME MP SM M OEM FMM5; (CANT 5cINTENDjTO RELY, IN UHOLE-,,

(E) STATE UNETHER THE CODE IS l

)) ~

~

I RURILABLE IN THE PUBLIC DbMAIN; 6

13-22 IDENTI*Y ALL PENETRATIONS

'.(F) STATE THE USAGE._OF THE CODE OF THE CONTAINMENT PRE 5SURE

1(NUMBERS AND TYPES OF USERS);

BOUNDARY; FOR EACH PENETRATION (b). STATE UHETHER THE CODE HAS IDENTIFIED, GIVE:

UNDERGONE INDEPENDENT EUALUATION-(R). ITS NUMBER AND LOCATION IN

.OR REUIEW AND.UNETHER IT HAE THE CONTAINMENT SHELL;

~

=BEEN UERIFIED UITH EXPERIMENTAL (B). TYPE (ELECTRICAL, MECHAN-

-DATAE ICAL, UACUUM BREAKER, URLUE,

..i-1%

LIST _ALL ' ESSENTIAL GR HATCH) AND FUNCTION OR SYditM EQUIPMENT' LOCATED.IN THE DRY-(C). SIZE OF THE PENETRATION; UELL OR CONTAINMEKT UHICH APPLI-(D). HOW CONTAINMENT ISOLATION

' CANT 5-INTEND TO EURLUATE FOR IS ACHIEVED;

-ITS CAPABILITY TO SURUIVE HYDRO-(E). U m ER THE PENU N IW GEN BURNING.

USES ORGANIC, POLYMERIC, OR RESILIENT SEALANTS, GASKETS,

13-20.. LIST ALL EQUIPMENT SEAT 5, OR SEAL 5; iLOCATED IN THE DRYUELL OR CON-

'LTRINMENT'UHICH'IS USED TO :

OF REINFORCEMENT AROUND THE PEN-m

'19 MAINTAIN CONTAINMENT INTEG-

~

ETRATION; ITY;

2. ~ MITIGATE THE CON-l (G). WHETHER THE PENETRATION WAS SEQUENCES OF AN ACCIDENT; ANRLYZED IN THE PNPP ULTIMRTE MAINTAIN THE CORE IN A SAFE 2

STRUCTURAL CAPACITY OF MARK III CONDITION; 4.. ' MONITOR THE COURSE CONTAINMENTS REPORT, AND IF NOT,

< OF AN ACCIDENT.

UHY NOT.

.13-21.

(R). DO APPLICANTS HAVE 13-23. IDEIRIFY ERCH T/PE OF OR-J IN THEIR POSSESSION-(OR IN THE GANIC, POLYMERIC, OR RESILIENT POSSESSION'OF ANY OF THEIR SUBSTANCE USED A5 A SEALANT, AGENTS) A THREE-DIMENSIONAL GASKET, SEAT, OR SEAL OR OTHER-

SCALE'MODEL OF THE PNPP MARK III UISE RELIED UPON TO MAINTAIN THE CONTAINMENT AND THE STRUCTURES INTEGRITY OF THE CONTAINMEt#

AND COMPONENTS WITHIN'?

~

' : C). IF SD, IDENTIFY THE STANCE IDENTIFIED, STATE UHERE LOCATION OF SUCH MPDEL.

AND HOU IT IS USED, UHLTHER IT

- (C). - IF NOT, IDENTIFY ANY OTHER IS FLAMMABLE, UHETHER IT UNDER-MODEL OF THE CONTAINMENT WHICH GOES THERMRL DEGRADATION OR APPLICANTS POSSESS.

' J DECOMPOSITION (AND AT UMAT TEM-C ^_.,Fuam A'", "t. N

'n'a"~...

^ "HE.-

-,~w_a'-

m u.

- ^

Iti PERATURE), AND TO UHAT TEMPERA-c n c,

,cc

n.. c,,_7

,,_,R D d,

u.._

cAc u._-

u, ww TURE THE MATERIAL OR COMPONENT URLUE DISCHARGts AND CHUGG INu_

USING THE MATERIAL HAS BEEN a

LORDd.

CUALIFIED. GIVE THE BASIS FOR YOUR AN5UERS.

13-28. IDENTIFY ANY STUDIES, CAL CULATIONS, ANALYSES, OR EU^tLUA-13-24. IDE MIFY ALL CORREbPOND-TIONS PERFORMED BY OR FOR APPLI-ENCE OR COMMUNICATIONS BETUEEP ANTd _,_ O D u, t_ -,. r > _ nu Tr.. c_

m.Au_ d

.u n -

u APPLICRNTS OR ANY OF THEIR POSED ON THE DRYUFt ! AND THr_

AGEhT5 AND THE AMES LABORATORY STRUCTURES AND COMPONENTd THER_-

t OF IOUR STATE UNIVERSITY (OR ANY IN (AND THt__ CAPABIL M OF SUCH PERSON ACTING ON THE BEHALF OF STRUCTURES AND COMPONENT 5 TO UITH5TAND THESE LOADS) BY THE S.3-25. CONCERNING THE DOCUMENT FLOU OF THE SUPPRESSION POOL IN-E ENTITLED ' ULTIMATE STRUCTURAL TO N E DRYUF!I DUE TO PRES 5URE CAPACITY OF MARK III CONTAIN-RESULTING FROM HYDROGEN COMBUS-MENT 5' IDENTIFIED IN APPLICANT 5' TION IN THE CONTAINMENT.

SUPPLEMENTAL AN5UER TO OCRE IN-13-29. HAVE HPDLICANTS IN THEIR TERROGATORY 5-49, GIVE THE DATE ANALYSIS OF CONTAINMENT CApr'lC TTY OF THE DOCUMENT, AND SUPPLY THE CONSIDERED THE VARIATION OF NAMES, ADDRESSES, EMPLOYERS, AND MATERIAL PROPERTIES UITH THE PROFESSIONAL QUAL.'FICATIONS OF TEMPERATURES ASSOCIATED UITH RLL PERSONS RESPONSIBLE FOR ITS HYDROGEN COMBUSTION? IF 50, PREPARATION.

IDENTIFY ALL SUCH ANALYSES. IF NOT, UHY NOT?

13-26. UHAT IS Tty DOMINANT NATURAL FREQUENCY OF THE CONTAIN 13-30. HOU DU HPPiICANTS DEFINE HENT STRUCTURE 9 OF THE DAYUELL9 COhTAINMENT FAILURE? STATE UMAT EXPLAIN HOW THIS UA5 DETERMINED.

CRITERION (E.G.,

LEAKAGE, FRAC-13-27. IDENTIFY ANY CALCULATIONS TURE, DEFORMATION, ATTAINMENT OF ANALYSES, EUALUATIONS, OR A CERTAIN PRES 5URE OR STRAIN) IS

}i STUDIES PERFORMED BY OR FOR AP-CONSIDERED CONTROLLING AND WHY.

PLICANTS TO DEItRMINE THE CAPA-

f 13-31. IDE4TIf Y RLL CALCULATIONS

~t DILITY OF THE CONTAINMENT AND ANRLYSES, EURLUATIONS, OR DRYUELL TO UITH5TAND LOADS PE-STUDIES PERFORMED BY OR FOR AP-h-

SULTING FROM HYDROGEN COMStt5T ION E

h, 3,

2.,

PLICANTS CORRELATING LEAKAGE

~

PLAIN HOU THESE EFFECTS UERE

.FROM THE CONTAINMENT WITH INTER-CONSIDERED. IF NOT, UMV NOT?

1 PRESSURE.OR SHELL DEFORMA-13-35. (A). UHAT IS THE NUMBER

?TIONi OF UELDS IN THE CONTAINMENT 13-326 IDENTITY ANY : STUDY, EUAL-SHELL?

a LURTION, CALCULATION, OR-ANALYSIS (B). DID EACH UELD UNDERGO TEST-

..PERFORHED-BY:OF FOR APPLICANTS ING OR EXRMINATION? IDENTIFY THE TO DETERMINE T_HE. DEGREE OF -

TYPES OF TESTING USED.

ELERKAGE FROM ELECTRICAL PENETRA-

.(C).

IDENTIFY THE UELD PROCEDURE TIONS, UACUUH BREAKERS, PURGE /

USED IN THE CONTAINMENT SHEL_,

kUENT' VALUES,; HATCHES, AND RIR-AND ANY POST-UELD TRERTMENTS

. LOCKS DUE TO THE1 PRESSURES AND USED.

TEMPERATURES RESULTING FROM c tfVORUGEN - COMBUSTION.

THE PNPP CONTAINMENT FOR GEOMET-

--1^-333: GIVE THE UALUE OF EACH RICAL IRREGULARITIES OR RLYMMET-JUARIABLE,IN THE EQUATIONS ON PP.

RIES?

IF SO, WITH UHAT RESULTS?

19 4MD 11 OF ULTIMATE STRUCTURAL IF NOT, UHY NOT?

CAPACITY - OF HARK.7II CONTAIN-N CM-

HENTS REPORT USED TO SOLVE SAID EGURTIONS, AND' EXPLAIN HOU THESE TAINMENT UESSEL OR OTHER COMPO-NENTS RELIED UPON TO MAINTAIN 13-34.? IDENTIFY ALL SOURCES OF THE INTEGRITY OF THE CONTAINMENT

~ UNCERTAINTY IN ALL OF THE ASSUMP PRESSURE BOUNDARY.

1TIONSo -JUDGEMENTS, CALCULATIONS, (B). IDENTIFY UHICH OF THE ABOVE

.AND HODELS EMPLOYED IN-THE UL-HAVE NOT BEEN CORRECTED, AND TIMATE STRUCTURAL CAPAC. TTY OF UHY NOT.

HARK III CONTAINNENTS REPORT,

~AND EXPLAIN-UHAT EFFECT THEY HAVE ON THE RESULTS AND CONCLU-

, EMMMS, M NCRA-SIONS.THEREIN.

~

NEERING SERVICES CONCERNING THE

1',-35.1DID THE ANALYSIS OF STRUC PHPP CONTAINMENT OR OTHER COM-TURAL CAPACITY INCLUDE THE PONENTS RELIED UPON TO HAINTAIN EFFECTS OF DEFECIENCIES IN CON-THE INTEGRITY OF THE CONTAINMENT STRUCTION AND FABRICATION OF THE PRESSURE BOUNDARY.

CONTAINHENT UESSEL7 IF 50, EX-

y -

m- -

w,

_9_

4 g

ULTIMATE STRUCTURAL CAPACITY 13-48.-DIDLAPPLICANTS IN THEIR REPORT- **SINCE THE YIELDING IN

[ ULTIMATE STRUCTURAL-CAPACITY RE-THE KNUCKLE OCCURS ONLY AT ONE PORT CONSIDER THE EFFECTr5 OF ANY POINT RLONG THE MERIDIAN, THE CHMMBES IN MATERIAL PROPERTIES PRESSURE CAN BE INCREASED RBOVE tGR THE CREATION OF' RESIDUAL 68.0 PSIG TO 78.0 PSIG, THE STRESSES RESULTING FROM UELDING LEVEL AT UHICH HOOP BUCKLING OF THE CONTAINMENT UESSEL? IF.50 OCCURS IN THE KNUCKLE."

EXPLAIN HOU THEY UERE ACCOUNTED I

13-45. EXPLAIN AND SUPPLY THE FORvEIF NOT, UHY NOT?

BASIS FOR THE STATEMENTS AT P. 7

[13-41k DEMONSTRATE'THAT THE CAL-1 OF THE ULTIMATE STRUCTURAL CAPA-CULATIONS AND METHODOLOGY-EM-CITY REPORT THAT LOCRL AREAS AT l PLOYED;INTHEULTIMATESTRUCTU-DISCONTINUITIES HAVING STRESSES

' RALL CAPACITY REPORT ARE IN AC--

EXCEEDING THE YIELD STRESS UILL CORDANCE WITH THE' PROVISIONS OF NOT-AFFECT UESSEL INTEGRITY f

THE ASME CODE,-SECTION III.

BECAUSE THE STRESSES ARE ONLY ON i

.13-42.

(A)?. UHEN AND BY UHON-l THE INSIDE SURFACE OF THE VESSEL t

(UERE.THE CONTAINMENT UESSEL

! MATERIALS ~ (INCLUDING PENETRA-13-46. DO APPLICANTS CONSIDER I

THE PRESSURES IN PARENTHESES IN TIONS) NANUFACTURED OR SUP-TABLES SA AND-6B (SOME OF UNICH

' PLIED 7 -

ARE QUITE LOU, E.G. MAIN STEAM (8) b STATE THE PERSON AND/OR EN-PENETRATION) TO DE THE CONTROL-

' TITY SUPPLYING LTHE MRTERIAL CER--

1 LING PRESSURES FOR THE CONTAIN-

. TIFICATIONS FOR-THE CONTAINNENT NENT? EXPLAIN UHY OR UHY NOT.

UESSEL.AMD PENETRATIONS ~THEREIN~,

l f (C) cc STRTE'UNEN-'AND BY UHON THE l

13-47. EXPLAIN THE DASIS FOR THE COffTRIfetENT - VESSEL (INCLUDING FOLLOUING ASSERTIONS APPEARING

' PEBETRRTIONSh. URS CONSTRUCTED.

ON P.

9 OF THE ULTIMATE STRUC-TURAL CAPACITY REPORT:

113-43b IDENTIPY ALL PORTIONS OF r

(R). INITIAL YTFf D PRESSURES CAN ITif CONTAINMENT UESSEL'UNICH l'

SE INCREASED IF THE PLASTIC ZONE M HEAT 1TRERTEDc IDENTIFY h IS LIMITED TO ONE RADIUS FROM fERT TREATING PROCEDURES USED.

THE PENETRATION SLEEUE. SPECIFI-13-442: EXPLAIN AND SUPPLY.THE CRLLY EXPLAIN HOU SUCH LIMITA-

'SRSIS FOR THE FOLLOUING STATE-TION OF THE PLASTIC ZONE CAN BE MENT APPEARING ON P. 6 OF THE ASSURED.

y

~

-..'5 ' 1 Q:

TRATIONS HAS BEEN CONSIDERED IN (T) V IT IS EXPECTED THAT THE-THE ANALYSIS OF CONTAINMENT 1UE55EL STRAINS RESULTING FROM CAPACITY. IF NOT, UHY NOT?

(ONE~ RADIUS YIELD REGION AROUND 13-51.

(A). HAVE APPLICANTS PER-PENETRRTIONS UOULD MOT. RESULT IN-FORMED AN ANALYSIS OF THE CAPA-OBJECTIONABLEiDISTORTIONS. - DE-BILITY OF THE DRYUELL UALL TO

-FINE'.OBJECTIONRBLE DISTORTIONS,.

.SUITH -REFERENCE TO PROPER ALTTHOR-UITHSTAND A LOCAL DETONATION?

ITY,?AND EXPLAIN THE' BASIS FOR H

TS OF WOUR EXPECTRTION.)

THE LARGE NUMBER OF CONCRETE 13-48.DUERE HYDRODYNAMIC LORDS EXPANSION ANCHOR BOLTS INSTALLED

,RESULTING FROM HYDROGEN COMBUS-IN THE WALL AND THE VOIDS UHICH

-> TION CONSIDERED'IN THE ANALYSIS HAVE BEEN DISCOVERED IN THE UALL

OF'THE LOUER CONTAINMENT PENE-CONSIDERED? IF NOT, UHY NOT?

~TRATIONS?-IF NOT, WHY NOT?

.13-52. IN YOUR 5-10-84 LeiltR TO 13--40. IDENTIFY RLL DEFICIENCIES THE NRC CONCERNING POST UELD HEAT TREATHENT OF CONTAINMENT

' RSSOCIATED WITH THE INCLINED FUEL TRANSFER TUBE. AND. PENETRA-ATTACHMENT UELDS (REPORTED UNDER

TION.JINDICATE UHICH OF THESE -

10 CFR 50.55 (e) ) YOU STATE THAT l

DEFICIENCIES HAVE NOT BEEN RING STIFFENER FLANGE TO UEB JCORRECTED',.AND FOR EACH UNCOR-UELDS UOULD BE MODIFIED 50 AS TO

RECTED DEFICIENCY IDENTIFIED, REMOVE THEM FROM THE ASME CODE EXPLAIN WHETHER IT HAD BEEN CON-JURISDICTIONRL E 7UNDARY. EXPLAIN

'IDERED IN THE 6NALYSIS OF THE HO'J THIS MODIFICATION WAS HADE L FUEL TRANSFER PENETRATION IN THE (PROVIDING DRAUINGS AS APPROPRI-

" ULTIHATE STRUCTURbL' CAPACITY RE-ATE) AND HOW THIS SOLUES THE f PORT, AND IF'NOT, UHY NOT.

PROELEM.. STATE UNAT EFFECT THE l_,

LACK OF POST UELD HEAT TREAT AND

' 13-58. (R). EXPLAIN IN DETAIL PREHEAT HAS ON THE CAPACITY OF

'THE POTENTIAL DEFECT REPORTED TO THE CONTAINMENT TO UITHSTAND (THE NRC UNDER-10 CFR 50.55 (e)

HYDROGEN' COMBUSTION LOADS.

CONCERNING ELECTRICAL PENETRA-TION BULKHEADLNATERIAL.

13-53. ARE THE PENETRATIONS USED C). INDICATE.UHETHER THE DE-IN THF DRYUELL URLL CONTAINMENT FECTg ASSOCIATED WITH UESTING-GRADE? IDENTIFY ALL THOSE PENE-HOUSE CLASS.1E ELECTRICAL PENE-TRATIONS IN THE DRYUELL UALL

V gg g_%

3 1Qy Ai@,

1 '

-c

_11_

.4

.,t sWHICH RRE NOTuCOKrAINHENT GRADE WITH THE HYDROGEN HIXING SYSTEM UNICH RRE OF A LESSER' GRADES ON, AND CONSIDERING THE EFFECT5 1

kGURLITYbOR:STRNDARD-THAN'THOSE OF THE CONCRETE EXPANSION ANCHOR

USED:: IN: THE.CONTRINHENT. UESSEL. -

BOLTS, LEAKAGE THROUGH DRYUELL PEMETRATIONS AND LINER AT POINTS 13-54.LIDENTIFYgRLL PENETRATIONS UHERE-THE RNCHOR BOLTS PENETRATE

.;gy:THEjDRYUELL'URLL, AND FOR ERCH DIVE:'

THE LINER RND THERNRLLY-DU ED CRACKING IN THE DRYUELL (R).xITS ' NUMBER 'RND LOCATION IN URLL. EXPLAIN THE BASES FOR THE

THE DRYWELL-URLLL ANSUER*

C).. :TYPEp(ELECTRICAL, HECHANI-CAL, URCUUN BREAKER, HRTCH,-

13-57. PROVIDE A DRAUING OF THE TE M )CAND FUNCTION OR SYSTEH; IGNITER RSSEMBLY UITH SPRAY /

S;

.n.

' at (C).. SIZE 10FATHE_ PENETRATION; SPLASH 5HIELD TO BE USED AT

[kD) s HOU ISOLNTIONlIS RCHIEVED; PHPP.-

, J(E) W UHETHER.THE : PENETRATION

U5ES ORGANIC,uPOLYMERIC, OR'.

13-58. IDENTIFY ALL THOSE IG-1 RESILIENT $5ERLANTS,' GASKETS, NITERS UHICH ARE PLACED BELOW OR IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO CEILINGS, cSERTd,;OR: SEALS. '

.SLRB5, FLOORS, I-BEAMS, OR OTHER A.

.. IDENTIFY.ERCH TYPE OF OR-213-55.

OB5TRUCTIONS OR CONFINEMENTS.

<OkNIC[ POLYMERIC, y

OR RESILIENT

~

~ 59. IDENTIFY RLL EXPERIMENTS, I iSUBSTANCE USED A5 A 5ERLRNT, GASKET,fSERT,' SEAL ~.ORlOTHERUISE TESTS,-OR OTHER PHYSICRL RE-USED':INiR.DRYUELL PENETRATION.--

SEARCH ON HYDROGEN COMBUSTION 7FOR ERCH' SUBSTANCE IDENTIFIED, WHICH HAVE BEEN CONDUCTED USING THE SRME TYPE OF IGNITER RSSEH-STRTE UHERE~RND HOULIT I5 USED,.

WETIER lITs15 FLM, UHETHER BLY, INCLUDING SPRAY /SPLRSH J27 upgM5tGOES THERHAL DECOMPOSI-SHTFIn5, TO BE USED AT PNPP, IN

~

w~

.STION;OR DEGRADRTION-(RND AT=UHAT:

THE SRHE GEONETRICAL ARRANGEHENT p

UITH REGARD TO CEILINGS, SLABS, TgpgDERRTURE),' RND TO UHRT: TEMPER RND OBSTRUCTIONS AS CITED RBOVE.

NTURE THE'HRTERIRL.OR--COMPONENT (USING'THE..HRTERIAL'HR5 BEEN 13-60. IDENTIFY RLL EXPERIMENTS, guRLIFIED. GIVE THE BASIS.FOR TESTS, OR OTHER PHYSICRL RE-1YOUR'RNSUERS.

SEARCH OF UHICH RPPLICANS ARE I13--56m uMRT, IS$THE RHOUNT OF DRY.

UARE CONCERNING THE COMBUSTION OF HYDRUGEN IN IONIZING RADIA-UELL LERKAGE,.IN SCFM, POST-LOCA b*

F010 MING THE: UPPER POOL ~ DUMP, 1

6

m j.

g#w

.t.

L* 3.

DEMONSTRATE THAT THE CGCS COM-PRESSORS OR LEAKS ACCOCIATED 13-61. IDENTIFY.THOSE CONTAIN-

~

UITH THE HIGH POINT UENTS OR MENT. PENETRATIONS UNICH ARE SA. W RELIEF URLUE DISCHARGE

NORMALLY KEPT INTERNRLLY PRES-LINES OR UACUUM BREAKERS WILL

-SURT7FD, AND STATE THE PRESSURE NOT INTRODUCE HYDROGEN INTO THE

, LEVEL.

DRYUELL.

$13-62.OIDENTIFY ALL ANALYSES OF 13-55. OPS-38A92, P. 2 STATES CONTAINMENT PRESSURE AND TEMPER-THAT MARCH CODE UALUES FOR HYD-

'ATURE RESPONSE TO M(DROGEN COM-ROGEN, STERM, AND ENERGY RFIFASE BUSTION FOR PHPP PERFORMED BY, UERE MODIFIED FOR INPUT INTO FOR, OR TO THE KNGULEDGE OF AP-CLASIX-3. CONCERNING THE HARCH PLICANTS,-USING ANY OTHER COMPUT ANRLYSIS:

. ER CODE THAN: CLASIX-3, OR USING

( A). STATE UHERE, UHEN, AND BY

~ANY SCENARIOS, ASSUMPTIONS, UMOM THE MARCH CODE RUNS UERE

~ INPUT UALUES OR OPTIONS OTHER

~

PERFORMED.

THAN THE ONES EMPLOYED IN THE (B). STATE THE VERSION OF THE OFFSHORE-POWER SYSTEMS REPORT, MARCH CODE USED.

, 10PS-38A92, OCT.. 7, 1902.

(C). DESCRIBE IN DETAIL THE 10-63. FOR THE 2 CLASIX-3 RUNS ACCIDENT SCENARIOS CONSIDERED IN

' DESCRIBED IN OPS-3SA92, PROVIDE THE MARCH ANRLYSIS.

THE FOLLOUING INFORMATION: A (D). IDENTIFY THE UALUE USED FOR

' DETAILED SEQUENTIAL DESCRIPTION EACH AND EVERY MARCH INPUT UARI-

'OF :THE ACCIDENT SCENARIOS ANA-RSLE FOR ERCH SCENARIO RUN.

(LY2ED, INCLUDING THE TIMES OF (E). STATE UNEN EACH MARCH RUN ALL~ SIGNIFICANT EVENTS, BREAK URS TERMINATED AND UHY THIS TIME

'CIZES, OPERATOR ACTIONS AND UAS CHOSEN.

ERRORS,-ECCS FLOW RATES, INITIRL (F). EXPLAIN IN DETAIL HOW THE

POWER LEVEL AND DECRY HEAT AS-MARCH CODE RESULTS UERE " MODI-SUMPTIONS, ETC.; AND THE BASIS FIED."

FOR CHOOSING hMESE SCENARIOS.

(G). WAS THE HYDROGEN SOURCE TERM FROM MARCH CONSIDERED CON-

10-24. EXPLAIN WHY A DRYUELL STANT OVER A TIME INTERURL, OR BURN URS NOT MODELED IN THE SORU UAS INTERPOLATION BETUEEN DATA

. TRANSIENT (OPS-08A92, P. 2). IF POINTS USED? IF SO, EXPLAIN UNY IT IS YOUR POSITION THAT HYDRO-AND UHRT TYPE OF INTERPOLATION GEN UILL NOT ACCUMULATE IN THE UAS USED.

DRYUELL IN THE SORU TRANSIENT,

4 13-66'.= EXPLAIN WHY DRYUELL

~

'UACUUN RELIEF URLUES UERE HEG-ATEMEE F WECTEN h EMS

.LECTED-IIN THE CONTAINMENT TO U.E.

MMCI ME OMM M

' D R Y urrt i FLOW PATH TOPS-3BA92, 6500 SECONDS INTO THE TRRNSIENT p,_

(OPS-38A92, P.

2).

13-67. ' IDENTIFY THE " PRIOR 13-71. DEMONSTRATE THAT THE SIMU RNALYSES" SHOUING THAT THE CON-

.LATION OF A DRYUELL SPRAY (OPS-TRINNENT-PRESSURE NEVER DROPS

38A92, P. O DOES N N E DELOW RTHOSPHERIC (JUSTIFICRTION ARTIFICIAL RESULTS.

FOR MEGLECTING-CONTAINMENT 13-72. EXPLAIN THE BASIS FOR THE URCUUN RELIEF URLUES, OPS-38A92' PASSIVE HEAT SINVs NODE CRITERIA Pe2 3). =

ON PP. 4-5 OF OPS-3BA92.

13-68. DID THE OPS ANALYSIS CON-13-73. WAS THE UPPER POOL DUMP

~'IDER THE. APPARENT. CONTRIBUTION ASSUMED TO FILL ANY PORTION OF TO. CONTAINMENT PRESSURIZATION THE HOLDUP UOLUME BEFORE REIN-OF,BELOU ATHOSPHERIC PRESSURES STATEMENT OF UESSEL INJECTION?

--IN THE.SHTFff> BUILDING ANNULUS?

IF SO, SPECIFY THE AMOUNT OF IF fD, EXPLAIN HOU; IF NOT, UHY UATER I*

'HE DRYUELL POOL DUE TO NOT?-

THE UPPER POOL DUMP. IF NOT, WHY (13-69. EXPLAIN THE BASIS FOR THE

1. 7 b RSSUMPTION (OPS-38892, P.

4) 13-74. WAS THE UPPER POOL DUMP THAT SHEET FLOW HAS HALF THE ASSUMED TO CONDENSE ANY STEAM

-COOLING CAPRBILITY OF DROPLET IN THE DRYUELL? IF SD, STATE AOU2 - NDERTE U THE UNETHER DRYUELL BURNING OCCURED

,'RSSUMPTION HAS ANY BASIS IN AS A RESULT. IF NOT, UNY NOT?

!EXPERIMENTRL DATA..

13-75. RECONCILE THE ASSUMPTION 13-78. - ( A). DOES THE OPS REPORT THAT THE DRYUELL POOL UILL DE RSM TM BOW CNAmHENT FORMED WITH ENERGENCY PROCEDURE

,'SPRRY RHR LOOPS ARE OPERATING GUIDELINES THAT INSTRUCT OPERA-TO MITIGATE HYDROGEN BURNING 7 TORS TO MAINTAIN UESSEL LEVEL (B) o ' RECONCILE - THE ASSUMPTION BELOW LEVEL B.

THAT CONTAINMENT SPRAYS ARE RURILABLE AND OPERABLE AFTER 13-76. EXPLAIN THE BASES, INCLUD THE=FIRST BURN (OPS -38A92, P. 4)

ING SUPPORT FROM EXPERIMENTAL p

f.

l+_

o y

,1

-14

?

y 5

• 1 (R). WHRT TYPE AND S N SPRRY dDATO, FOR-ERCH,AND EVERY-BURN NO77f F IS USED?

h PRRRPETER GIVEN IN TABLE 4 OF (B). WHRT IS THE DISTRIBUTION OF 5-M2.

SPRRY DROPLET SIZE 5 PRODUCED BY THAT NO771 f ? 77. ' EXPLAIN ' UNETHER THE 'INI-(C). UHRT I$ THE SPRRY PRTTERN p iTIAL: CONDITIONS' IN TABLE 5 OF

~

.. OPS-38RGF RRE, PRE-BURN CONDI-DISTRIBUTION IN THE CONTAINMENT 1TIONS-OR ARE' CONDITIONS EXISTING-ANSUER FOR ONE AND BOTH SPRRY PRIORLTO THE: TRANSIENT. IF THE LOOPS OPERATING.

-FORMER,; EXPLAIN UHY NO INCRERSE'

=IN CONTAINMENT PRESSURE, TEMPERR 13-83. EXPLAIN THE BRSES FOR TURE,'.OR STERM FRACTION RESULTED.

THE' PARAMETERS GIVEN IN TRSLES PROM'THE TRANSIENT; IF THE LRT-10, 11, 12, 13, RND 14 OF 095-

-TER,; EXPLAIN HOU PRE-BURN RISES 38992.

~IN TEMPERATURE, PRESSURE, AND e STERM.AND HYDROGEN FRRCTIONS lRRE CALCULMED*

13-85. EXPLAIN THE BASES FOR 13-70.'

EXPLAIN THE BASES

/POR THE-FLOU PRTH PARAMETERS' c

mIUEN-IN TABLE 6 OF OPS-3SR92.

13-85. DESCRIBE AND QURNTIFY (13-79.1 EXPLAIN'UNETHERDRYUELL OYPRZ5 LERKAGE URS NODFYFt1 IN THE CLRSIX-3'RNRLYSIS.'IF NOT, sW NOT7, 13-87. DESCRIBE IN DETRIL RLL

'M,13-88.' EXPLAIN _.THE BRSES FOR THE NODELING RSSUMPTIONS AND

^

~

ERCH RND EVERY PARAMETER LISTED IN TABLES 7 RND 8 OF OPS-38R92.-

~

RTED UITH HYDROGEN COMBL85 TION, 13-81. EXPLAIN THE BASES FOR INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO ERCH.RND EVERY PARAMETER FOR THE GAS HIXING U1 THIN RND EETUEEN CONTAINMENT /UETUELL SPRRY LISTED COMPARTMENTS, FLRME SPEED, CCH-IN TRSLE 9 OF OPS-38R92.

PLETENESS OF COMBUSTION, AND 13-82. FOR THE CONTAINHENT SPRRY SYSTEM RCTUALLY INSTALLED IN

PHPP,

it s

~,

j e

13-92. IDENTIFY EACH AND EVERY 613-88.. DESCRIBE AND QUANTIFY ALL STUDY, ANRLYSIS, REPORT, TEST, SOURCES OF UNCERTAINTY IN THE EXPERIMENT, EUALUATION OR OTHER CLASIX-3 MODELING ASSUNPTIONS SUCH DOCUMENT PREPARED BY OR S MULATIN S.

FOR CURDREX CORP.

" 89. IDENTIFY ALL STUDIES, ANALYSES, EURLUATIONS, OR RE-THEIR DEFENSE ON ISSUE #8, OR PORTS PREPARED BY-OR FOR AP-IS O M W ISE RELEU M TO PLICANTS CONCERNING THE LIKELI 0

0 HOOD, MAGNITUDE, AND EFFECTS OF

5ECONDARY. FIRES UHICH HIGHT BE 13-93. IDENTIFY EACH AND EVERY CAUSED.BY THE COMBUSTION OF HYD-STUDY, ANALYSIS, REPORT, TEST, EXPERIMEKT, EURLUATION OR OTHER

" 90. - ( A). IDENTIFYANY AND ALL -

STUDY, EURLUATION, REPORT, OR C N ER WSAC) 44RLYSIS PREPARED BY OR FOR AP-PLICANTS CONCERNING THE LIKELI-HOOD, NAGNITUDE,-AND EFFECTS OF DETONATIONS, LOCAL OR GLOBRL, IN EMMM

-THE PNPP CONTAINMENT OR DRYUELL.

(B) e IF IT IS YOUR POSITION THAT DETONATIONS ARE IMPOSSIBLE OR 13-94.. IDENTIFY EACH AND EVERY IMPROBABLE, EXPLAIN THE BASES STUDY, ANALYSIS, REPORT, TEST, FOR THIS POSITION.

EXPERIMENT, EURLUATION OR OTHER

.13-91. IDENTIFY Ef%CH AND EVERY

. STUDY, ANALYSIS, REPORT, TEST, M UE W hGHMSE EXPERIMENT, EUALUATION OR OTHER h SUCH. DOCUMENT PREPARED BY OR I FOR COMBUSTION ~AND-EXPLOSIVES

'RESEARCH,.INC. ON UNICH APPLI-CANTS INTEND TO RELY, IN UHOLE 10 E

OR PART, FOR THEIR DEFENSE ON ISSUE:38, OR UNICH IS OTHERUISE 13-95. IDENTIFY EACH AND EVERY RELEUANT TO ISSUE #8.

STUDY, ANRLYSIS, REPORT, TEST,

~~~

EXPERIMENT, EURLUATION CR OTHER

TIES RATHER THAN ACTUAL MEASURED

. SUCH DOCUMENT PREPARED BY OR MATERIAL PROPERTIES.

FOR ACUREX CORP.

ON UHICH APPLICANTS INTEND TO 13-100. IDENTIFY ANY AND ALL RELY, IN WHOLE OR PART, FOR TESTIMONY, DECISIONS, ORDERS OR THEIR DEFENSE ON ISSUE #8, OR CONCLUSIONS D4 ANY OTHER NRC UNICH IS OTHERUISE RELEUANT TO PROCEEDING ON UMICH APPLICMTS ISSUE

• 3.

TO RELY, IN UHOLE Of PART, FOR THEIR DEFENSE ON ISSUE #S.

.13-96. IDEMTIFY ERCH AND EVERY STUDY, ANALYSIS, REPORT, TEST,13-101. IDENTIFY ANY AND ALL EXPERIMENT, EURLUATION OR OTHER STUDIES OR EUALUATIONS PERFORMED SUCH DOCUMENT PREPARED BY OR BY OR FOR APPLICANTS CONSIDERING

~FOR FACTORY MUTUAL RESEARCH THE EFFECT OF LORDS ASSOCIATED CORPa UITH THE COMBUSTION OF HYDROGEN ON UHICH APPLICANTS INTEND TO ON THE INACCESSIBLE AND POTEN-RELY, IN UHOLE OR PART, FOR TIALLY REJECTRBLE LOCATIONS D4 THEIR DEFENSE ON ISSUE #8, OR CONTAINMENT UELD JOD4TS i-1, UHICH IS OTHERUISE RELEVANT TO 2-1, 1-4.,

1-7, AND 1-9.

ISSUE #3..13-102. (A). IDENTIFY ALL PARA-1_ '-17.

IS DEPRESSION OF THE SUP-M!TERS IN THE CLASIX-3 CODE PRESSION POOL LEVEL IN THE UET-UHICH, AT THE USER'S OPTION, MRY

! UELL ASSUMED TO MITIGATE THE EITHER BE CALCULATED INTERNRLLY i

! PRES 5URE RISES ASSOCIATED UITH OR SUPPLIED IN THE INPUT.

l HYDROGEN COMSU5 TION? IF 50, TD (B). FOR EACH PARAMETER L.ISTED l

UHAT DEGREE 7 PROUJDE THE BASIS IN YOUR AN5UER TO (A), IDENTIFY FOR THE ANSUER.

UNICH HETHOD URS USED IN THE CLASIX-3 ANALYSIS FOR PNPP.

~J3498. IDENTIFY f.NY BUCKLING (C). EXPLAIN WHY THE CHOSEN ANALYSES OF THE MARK III CON-METHOD URS USED.

TRINNENT OTHER'THAN W E ONE IN (D). EXPLAIN THE EFFECT ON THE THE ULTIMATE STRUCTURAL CAPACITY RESULT 5 IF THE OTHER METHdD HAD REPORT.

BEEN USED D45TEAD.

13-99. IDENTIFY ANY ANRLYSES ON 13-103. DOES THE CLASIX-3 CON-CONTAINMENT CAPACITY PERFORMED TRINMENT SPRAY MODEL ACCOUNT FOR FOR OR BY APPLICANTS USING HINI-( A). DISTRIBUTION OF SPRAY DROP-MUN SPECIFIED MATERIAL PROPER-

V

~

e :,

TIONS, HEAT SINK DATA [ AND BURN LET SIZES; PRODUCED FOR PNPP,

/ (C) o INTERACTIONS BETUEEN DROP-LETS,:E.G., AGGLOMERATION;13-108. IDENTIFY ANY AND ALL (C). DECREASE IN DROPLET SIZE -

ANALYSES PERFORMED FOR OR BY DUE-TO EURPORATION; APPLICANTS OF INUERTED HYDROGEN

-(D)e= INCREASE INLDROPLET SIZE FLAMES IN THE DRYUELL.

1DUE TO-. CONDENSATION;13-109. IDENTIFY RLL OPERATING (E)o. FOR EACH PHENOMENON RBOVE PROCEDURES FOR TURNING OFF OR UHICH IS NODF1Fn IN CLASIX-3,

' EXPLAIN THE MODEL-EMPLOYED; FOR CONTAINMENT SPRAY TRAIN ACTI-EACH' HOT NODELED, EXPLAIN UHY W HI H COMAM

.IT CAN BE IGNORED.

PRESSURE. 194. DID ANY CLASIX-3 ANALYS-ES FOR PNPP ASSUME THAT HYDROGEN AND MAJOR ITEMS OF

.IS BURNED AS IT IS ADDED OR EQUIPMENT IN THE CONTAINMENT AND RF1FASED TO'THE CONTAINMENT OR EEH, G E:

DRYUELL? IDENTIFY ALL SUCH ANALYSES AND EXPLAIN UHY THAT MODEL UAS EMPLOYED.

(B). S M AND MASS; p-13-195..DOES CLASIX-3 MODEL (C). NATERIAL FROM UHICH IT IS FLAME PROPAGATION THROUGH UACUUH MADE;

, THE DRYUELL PURGE (D). THE FRACTION OF AREA AT THE ISYSTEM, OR'UNCOVE, RED POOL UENTS7 ELEUATION UHICH IS BLOCKED BY IF SO, EXPLAIN THE MODELS USED; THE FLOOR OR ITEM.

IF_NOT, UHY NOT?13-111. FOR THE 1/20 SCRLE HYDRO 13-186. LIST THE URLUES OF RLL GEN COMBUSTION TEST PROGRAM, INPUT PARAMETERS (INCLUDING DESCRIBE:

DEFAULT URLUES) USED IN CLASIX-3 (R). PURPOSE OF THE TESTS; ANALYSES OF PNPP, AND EXPLAIN (B). DETAILED DESIGN OF THE TEST E

UHY ERCH UALUE UAS USED.

FACILITY;10-117. IDENTIFY ALL-CLASIX-3 OUTPUTS, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO CONTAINNENT CONDI-

_18 r

(D)L SCALING OF THE FACILITY AND 13-113. ( A). IDENTIFY RLL PER-

THE BASIS FOR USING THE SCRLING SONS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE AMSUERS

[ MODEL;;

TO THE RBOVE INTERROGATORIES; (E)o. TESTS PERFORMED IN THE-FOR EACH PERSON IDENTIFIED, LIST FACILITY; THE INTERROGATORIES ANSUERED BY (F)o THE DATA OBTAINED FROM THE.

THAT PERSON AND GIVE THE ADDRESS TESTS AND ANY ANALYSES OF THE EMPLOYER, AND PROFESSIONRL QUALI TEST DATA; FICATIONS OF THE PERSON; (T) e ANY CONCLUSIONS DRAUN FROH (B). IDEKTIFY ALL DOCUMENTS USED

'THE TEST 5; IN ANSUERING THE RBOVE INTERROGA

'(H)0 ANY. COMMENTS OR EUALUATIONS TORIES.

OF THE TESTS OR THE FACILITY BY THE NRC OR ANY NRC CONTRACTORS.

REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF 13-112. FOR THE 1/4 SCRLE HYDRO-DOCUMENTS

-GEN COMBUSTION TEST PROGRAH, OCRE REQUESTS THAT APPLICANTS g

RESPOND IN URITING TO THE FOL-

(A)o PURPOSE OF THE TESTS; (B) c DETAILED DESIGN OF THE TEST DOCUMENTS, AND PRODUCE THE ORI-FACILITY;

(^) o -LOCATION OF THE TEST THE DOCUMENTS REQUESTED BELOW FACILITY; T) a SCALING OF THE FACILITY AND OCRE REQUESTS THAT APPLICANTS THE BASIS FOR USING THE SCALING PRODUCE:

NODEL;

1. ERCH AND EVERY DOCUHENT IDEN-

'(E) e _ TESTS PERFORt1ED IN THE TIFIED OR DESCRIBED IN THE FACILITY; (F) o THE DATR OBTAINED FROH THE ABOVE;

' TESTS AND ANY AMRLYSES OF THE

2. DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF TEST DATA; STEEL CONTAINMENT UESSELS AND C)e ANY CONCLUSIONS DRAUN FROH RELATED 1TEMS FOR REACTOR ' BUILD-THE TESTS;-

(H). ANY COMMENTS OR EUALUATIONS POWER PLANT, UNITS 1 AND 2, OF THE TESTS OR THE FACILITY BY

~

-THE NRC OR ANY NRC CONTRACTORS.

v ULTIMATE STRUCTURAL CAPACITY REPORT);

W si N'

ki,.

19,

3. DESIGN REPORT FOR UPPER AND LOUER PERSONNEL AIR LOCK, PERRY NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNITS 1 AND 2, SEirr. 8,-1982 (REFERENCE 8 IM ULTIMATE STRUCTURAL CAPACITY REPORT);

4.

DESIGN REPORT FOR CONTAINMENT EQUIPMENT HATCH ASSEMBLY, PERRY NUCLERR POWER PLANT, UNITS 1 AND 2, SEPT.-22, 1982 (REFERENCE 9 IM ULTIMRTE STRUCTURAL CAPACITY REPORT).

g.

IF ANY OF THE ABOVE REQUESTS CONCERN' PROPRIETARY DOCUMENTS, PROUIDE THE DOCUMENTS PURSUANT TO AN APPROPRIATE PROTECTIVE AGREEMENT.

RESPECTFULLY SUBHITTED, fY dA~

SUSRN L. HIRTT 3

OCRE REPRESENTATIVE 8275 MUNSON RD.

MENTOR OH 44868

.(216) d55-3'158 49' p'

-w.,

.. =,.,3 f

.f'

~ t -

s CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE This;.is to certi~fy that copies of the foregoing were served by

~

deposi~in the U.S. Mail ~, first class, postage prepaid, this p.y 3, N. day'of n /d 198tr to those on the E

service list below.

/-

b:

,a

~f Susan L.

Hiatt

[

c

,e-y SERVICE LIST u

7 Peter'B. Bloch, Chairman Terry Lodge, Esq.

' Atomic'Sa'fety & Licensing Board 618 N. Michigan St.-

h[

U!S.' Nuclear Regulatory Comm.,

Suite 105 Washington, 'D.C.

20555 Toledo, OH 43624 Dr. Jerry'R. Kline Atomic Safety.& Licensing Board.

-U.S.? Nuclear. Regulatory Commission i

WasEington, D.C.

20555 V.

[

Mr./Glenn O. Bright Atomic Safety &, Licensing Board U

sU.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

20555 Colleen P. Woodhead, Esq.

N office of the Executive Legal Director U.S.tNuclear Regulatory Commission Washington,.D.C.

20555 Jay.Silberg, Esq.

r

. Shaw, Pittman, Potts,.& Trowbridge 6

1800 M Street, NW JWashington, D.C.

20036 Docketing'& Service Branch k

.Offi'ce of'the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory,Commiss' ion Washington, D.C.

20555 Atomic, Safety.&, Licensing. Appeal.Bo'ard Panel

.U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

20555 g

_