ML20205F573

Summary of 850807 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Status of Seismic Qualification & Pump & Valve Operability Programs. Site Audit Scheduled for Nov 1985.Util Will Provide Followup on IE Bulletin 79-15.List of Attendees & NRC Comments Encl

ML20205F573
Person / Time
Site:	Seabrook
Issue date:	10/30/1985
From:	Nerses V Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
IEB-79-15, NUDOCS 8511120291
Download: ML20205F573 (11)

Text

.

e urg% " UNITED STATES

. 8 n NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION g E WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 t,, ,/ OCT 3 01985 Docket Nos.: 50-443 and 50-444 APPLICANT: Public Service Company of New Hampshire FACILITY: Seabrook Station, Units 1 and 2

SUBJECT:

MEETING

SUMMARY

On August 7, 1985, NRC and applicant representatives met in Bethesda, Maryland to discuss how the applicant's seismic qualification and pump and valve operability program's were put together and what the status was of these programs.

Enclosure 1 provides the list of attendees to this meeting.

The applicant noted the following about the program:

Balance-of-plant components were purchased by certain specifications. These specifications required that seismic qualification be provided by the vendor. Qualification was either by analysis, test or both. United Engineers and Constructors reviewed the vendor qualification packages.

There were about 5300 seismically qualified safety-related components.

Of these, about 2300 were valves.

The Nuclear Steam Supply System (NSSS) vendor (Westinghouse) developed a coupled ARS rodel and did an analysis to generate the response spectra to use for qualifying the system. Some NSSS components (about 70 to 100),

none of which are within the containment, were found to be outside the spectra generated. For these items, the NSSS vendor will perform a component specific review to assure these components are acceptable.

The applicant informed the staff of the following status.

The ARS verification program - 87% complete Anchor bolt load generation - 99% complete Anchor bolt load verification - 59% complete Seismic reports - 97% complete To date, no construction modifications have had to be made; The applicant and staff tentatively agreed to a November 1985 staff site audit. The applicant agreed to supply the master list 8 weeks before the site audit date. Given a November 1985 site audit, the staff noted that they will make their selection and provide the applicant a list of comoo,ents in October 1985.

h1120291e52o30 A ADOCM 05000443 PDR

The staff noted a concern about the documentation on components purchased and where the contract has been closed or the-vendor has gone out of business.

The applicant stated that for those contracts that have been closed and the applicant needs information the contracts will be reopened.

The applicant agreed to provide the long forms by two weeks prior to the

, staff's site audit date. The applicant also agreed to follow-up on IAE Bulletin 79-15 (regarding deep draft pumps). The staff and applicant discussed the staff comments provided in Enclosure 2.

4 0FUGINAL SIGNED BY i

l Victor Nerses, Project Manger Licensing Branch No. 3

Division of Licensing l

Enclosures:

As stated i

J cc: See next page i DE:EQ 4 oft, GBagchi 10/2f/85

/yt ton 10/g/85 107/85

3

^

Mr. Robert'J. Harrison  !

Public Service Company of New Hampshire Seabrook Nuclear Power Station j

cc:

. Thomas Dignan, Esq. E. Tupper Kinder. Esq.  ;

i: John A. Ritscher,_Esq. G. Dana Bisbee, Esq.

Ropes and Gray Assistant Attorney General

! 225 Franklin Street Office of Attorney General Boston, Massachusetts 02110 208 State Hosue Annex

Concord, New Hampshire 03301 i Mr. Bruce B. Beckley, Project Manager i Public. Service Company of New Hampshire Resident Inspector

. Post Office Box 330 Seabrook Nuclear Power Station Manchester, New Hampshire 03105 c/o US Nuclear Regulatory Commission 4

Post Office Box 700 ,

4

Dr. Mauray Tye, President Seabrook, New Hampshire 03874 Sun Valley Association .

Mr. John DeVincentis, Director

209 Summer Street Haverhill, Massachusetts 01839 Engineering and Licensing ,

Yankee Atomic Electric Company l Robert A. Backus, Esq. 1671.Worchester Road  ;

i 0'Neil, Backus and Spielman Framingham,- Massachusetts 01701 116 Lowell Street.

. Manchester, New Hampshire 03105 Mr. A. M. Ebner, Project Manager United Engineers & Constructors Ms. Beverly A. Hollingworth 30 South 17th Street 7 A Street Post Office Box 8223 j- Hampton Beach, New Hampshire 03842 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19101 i I William S. Jordan, III Mr. Philip Ahrens, Es'q. '

! Diane Curran Assistant Attorney General Harmon Weiss & Jordan State House, Station #6 -

! 20001 S Street, NW Augusta, Maine 04333

^

i Suite 430 l Washington, DC 20009 '

! Mr. Warren Hall

! Jo Ann Shotwell, Esq. Public Service Comoany of

Office of the Assistant Attorney General New Hampshire

Environmental Protection Division Post Office Box 330-l One Ashburton Place Seabrook, New Hampshire 03874_. l j Boston, Massachusetts 02108

• Seacoast Anti-Pollution League  :

I D. Pierre G. Cameron, Jr., Esq. Ms. Jane Doughty

~ General Counsel- 5 Market Street l Public Service Company of New Hampshire Portsmouth, New Hampshire 03801 1 j Post Office Box 330 i i Manchester, New Hampshire 03105_ Mr.- Diana P. Randall i 70 Collins Street  :

} Regional Administrator,. Region I . Seabrook, New Hampshire ~ 03874 '

i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

631 Park Avenue Richard Hampe, Esq. -

. King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 19406 New Hampshire Civil Defense Agency l 107 Pleasant Street

j. Concord, New Hampshire 03301 l

f

'^

. 1 t

i

~Public Service Company of -2. Seabrook Nuclear Power Station New Hampshire ,

' cc:

i Mr. Calvin A. Canney, City Manager Mr. Alfred V. Sargent,

! City Hall Chairman 126 Daniel Street Board of Selectmen ,

Portsmouth, New Hampshire 03801 Town of Salisbury, MA 01950 '

Ms. Letty Hett Senator Gordon J. Humphrey '

Town of Brentwood ATTN: Tom Burack RFD Dalton Road U.S. Senate j Brentwood, New Hampshire 03833 Washington, D.C. 20510 i

Ms. Roberta C. Pevear Senator Gordan J. Humphrey Town of Hampton Falls, New Hampshire ATTN: Herb Boynton Drinkwater Road .

1 Pillsbury Street-

Hampton Falls, New Hampshire 03844 Concord, New Hampshire 03301

) Ms. Sandra Gavutis Mr. Owen B. Durgin, Chairman Town of Kensington, New Hampshire .Durham Board of Selectmen

, RDF 1 Town of Durham j East Kingston, New Hampshire 03827 Durham, New Hampshire 03824 i ,

Charles Cross, Esq.

Chairman, Board of Selectmen Shaines, Mardrigan and ,

Town Hall 'McEaschern-South Hampton, New Hampshire 03827 25 Maplewood Avenue Post Office Box 366 4

Mr. Angie Machiros, Chairman Portsmouth, New Hampshire 03801 ,

Board of Selectmen for the Town of Newbury l Newbury, Massachusetts 01950 Mr.--Guy Chichester, Chaiman Rye Nuclear Intervention ,

Ms. Cashman, Chairman Committee

, Board of Selectmen c/o Rye Town Hall i

Town of Amesbury 10 Central Road

Tcwn Hall Rye, New Hampshire 03870 ,

Amesbury, Massachusetts 01913 Jane'Spector Honorable Richard E. Sullivan Federal Energy Regulatory Mayor, City of Newburyport Connission Office of the Mayor '825 North Capital Street, NE-City Hall-

~

~ Room 8105 l Newburyport, Massachusetts 01950 Washington, D. C. 20426

{ Mr. Donald E. Chick, Town Panager Mr. R. Sweeney .

Tcwn of Exeter New Hampshire Yankee Division i

10 Front-Street Public Service of New Hampshire i Exeter,-New Hampshire 03823 Company.

1 .

7910 Woodmont Avenue Mr. William B. Derrickson .Bethesda, Maryland 20814 Senior-Vice President Public Service Company of New Hampshire

. Post Office Box 700, Route-1 e Seabrook,'New Hampshire '03874

_ . , _ . . _ . _ _ . . - _ _ . - ~ . _ _ _ . . _ _ _ , _ _ _ - . , _ - . _ . ~ _ . _ .

ENCLOSURE 1

. W ,

%Gfdisah=an

+ fm a IAAe G&> ,&

/

/

(/ P m cs ev/wa/bc/ core /Byakg d bdo . ast6 zdaAo -nc ( r~ d e se D 19 o k- Me HTR Lig g c Vf/per /WSD

. #Ad.M, vNsO Arsf A ,. Mayr R Basseow NNY S o v. .Z M fa a e Aseur 1. cwisasy ss4sco 0cv7M4 04GCUL NRe/bE/B628 a s n. casa rees Ms k.(sorr)

Idoem w )~? % ons tJec/pe/596

ENCLOSURE 2 ma e P quc v . :. n v _a c a.s .n eirs s _- A rs e.oci c .. % c s.,o.?

(

/ kt .w mef :he.- 6<d ux' e.p,au e . J' /. <a c. y.1f.A ye<<QM ZA.c ..uaeyen.cp ,y'teAvaZe.s.

nn <-( ,4< a. / czf Zt c-g a p "-' p * , .Auu c ' ~

de ,e.u->~~ ~ls /:c e e,str s/' e. u Tca % 2.s(e)-<a -

H .- t8 (A-r ei a' . e<1 s a ) .  % egMrJ eLu4' tble. ,,c4- c.yteys- A e r lt t sira G & r tin Lad.

&6le. 2% cf.swoost+ b 4 Zlaf W.wt /jzarng ca.1

~

42' en o ernceivs2 v c e a s t c *r-Tc et.Y &<

Mdn7 3 . 9 69) . 3 . = c2, .

2. LE .42 rod eftcA.- f r>* d .C,.LlO e r t 4 Nt T Y 3 (B,h ~ 2.

p><</ S e 6 fsc>r  % .9 ( 5). 3 l (/2,or e r ot'sor e ~f 'l8 )

/Aaf 4 OCA bex <-d s As > e v

./res -sr / $7:t.r el. edef so v XXe c6, y .L+ocer c. uzh .o.c,//d w les S Of' C/ w .' f. c c cy c>re d o & c'erge-% .

714 c%Jdt.c Nc5 SAsicd.W fca 2*Sc~Y Z c)C

n + fe 5,,,,.,,. sou' m w , e . a

h. t% deeere darJ c:; ;s.le : ot,' p4 e: e r o;-cwavi: c < i W_L 4.c.c n'< n , 3. 9 (p! i. o gm asss 7q:-- e .i .

\

Ar - - - 4 - a e a -- e- u _ M --

q

@O 6

e s 3 Sc c f cenu 3. O 'I!>)  ? b- ' a '<> r ' ~ ~/ * * " # J V l') 4 J. ' ' i t-e J

.t g~;c A4cs.fd 41. ,t.s '. c l t~ --* s. C.C.

ffu re caYss'c (3 Q l' -) ds.*~<- J 2Dv-o &n.u emol .

in eye.t., . M a.p,.: loc c A

.4 A o<Aof L. r a c,.la.cf<., cd[ <e s e. d .J o!

u

&

• v'< l2 0.'

va-Gres co u h-< > qt a 6 c.l< /y~ ., a.m. ~xe- p. .o gAc -> ~/.

{ 9' YLa. a .,.,,2.t u h J ,,ut.c:<.lo/ y wc c<a spw.;&k o f'en. m al~en fev .a'e eol'  ;.:.e<> up .,n W'ua. % ,

n c. ~~ , w - n;s. s s a,y--c.u

,s.<.a. z+e'deo/' ,<. ,v h 6 f.e.s a c. , k-/ - <1 s . 9 0>)

2 , tJSSS v u o u# 24 c:.e.of Wa .j-e J ,

j. /

4 5' r ,, ce_e., 3. , < s) - 2. (,4,,, e ,.s , . . ,d u 7) f, u4 ~w.<e, e-,

v kJ. k t CA d e4& .* 1.

• 1 *^. f.4,'a .<3 . ("L,a Qgg I. ~2,. p ,y { 3 Sp?

co yoteJa o,w/ s ,g..a Jth . I' < ge. hec id s Amid

,t d<.-> ~7 r TAe /1 Cw c 3 4'. u c. e. as./ 4 yvoJ*y i

c/w L ?or rt > ._1, di[ Se9 fI3b

• b MO b . % ( tJ i *== 9 eb?.L'tA5 J.

s4 I&s cA$ cr lrft, Clcr.M 2 e - t c 3 , s<?. .

'>t - e2 C ho d '. 3 eo e c J n s = s p. -- q u , ,.c s.p L J e.lg.

. . ri e . .,i, de e : . t

-:, h m.r.loI J..dfAs3 TS e ae - o e*l w e

r. nt**  ;> c&'<41.a .

(

4. The applicant should clearly show the extent to which the regulatory 1~ '7' positions and guidelines of RG 1.143, ANS!/ASf1E N551.1 draft stan-cards, and ANSI B16.41 are met.

8'N The applicant should clarify the methods used for qualification.

Specific information should be presented in the FSAR, and be availaole for review at the site. The applicant should demonstrate:

a) -The extent to which operational testing is performed at design basis conditions (full flow, pressure, temperature, etc.)

b) The technical basis for qualifying equipment by similarity analysis and prototype testing.

c) Qualification of the equipment as an assembly rather than individual components.

()

1. The applicant should clearly show how implementation of the initial test program, maintenance'and surveillance, in-service inspection, and quality assurance programs will maintain equipment operability throughout the 40-year plant life. Specific criteria should be presented in the FSAR, and be available for review at the site.

1 i

1 1

(

. ., .w . 1

,- ic, ,1:e . ihX., se r9 sesua u .b;; D y,+ : 4 e .. . 7 i V V

(

} w>dd e <J c..ue 4 g g

• w ,acc & c/3 c{ c6 p/c ,J'.

a) ~rs e.- y$ & /2A .,4 oyeiJ TA . G 's a " D c -

' ~ '

e>,,wr 't. co CA r)I 5 ? t

)

Wl& M c w c/

.,~, 7,A s . 9 C a) G

(//~ ~.d - e d o } .

4) 7h <<py4ea J / tace efo/ me<./y< L aw av.h a s c.c A c x e n c k -o <&, o d inv pr%vs 3 'r('8)3.2 e sa .uo/' o (.c e-e & be'W

( c> v.o (.

fde A c'6-4 ' 8 01' ,p e o ap .

e) See.fe-s e s . 9 c r.) r . 2. .s- o- oc a . 9 (a ) a . z ~ '=.)

dad &c Bot' a ud N.5 s1 P Lep^a -a 58- 1ks 4'dd erl *2/a-1&cccs c{ca-e p+ )

f

a eo/w c/cen e .ecma l"r 27e/' ,de *s C7'ed c~;xu . m ,,. + , s , a s - u WJ rr rwso-l 9s,e "GG

'L/c -6 w1 lCL.- && s-s c -> y . f q 's Z/-t' a.a a m d.

i l

4

w e' .t .

+

e e '

O h $* -b d*** $ *$$ & C f5 8 9 'd * *

,zb z<>a n.a h; cf r]sss cA.u 4 vc.4s y N O A &volL * / f2 ~'<1 a n ce G.L < e lcw5v Y

( c.~s a.aJ o-g .fyce.2 e a 4Jsy, z w w g ( J fe.s/ cc.,& & - 6 at:

. ..m _ p, w a -c .

4 e

1 t

~

e:

N 3 01985 ll MEETING SUMM RY DISTRIBUTION DocketJo(s):t50-443/4441T't

'NRC~PDR local PDR NSIC i PRC System

LB3 Reading Attorney, OELD GWKnighton Project Manager VNerses JLee

! NRC PARTICIPANTS

. VHerses G0utam Bagchi Norman D. Roaney i

a i

4 i

4' bec: Applicant & Service List i

i

, _ . - _ _ _ . .-. _ .--_ - ,.-- _.___. __..,._ .,_-.. , _ . _ . - - , _ - , . _ , - _ . . - _ _ _ _ . . - _ _ _ _ . . . . - . . _ , . _ . _