ML17037C261

Letter Responding to a Request for Additional Information Concerning the Drywell Vacuum Breakers

ML17037C261
Person / Time
Site:	Nine Mile Point
Issue date:	07/20/1973
From:	Schneider R R Niagara Mohawk Power Corp
To:	Skovholt D J US Atomic Energy Commission (AEC)
References
Download: ML17037C261 (10)

Text

.AEC DIS BUTION FOR PART 50 DOCKET MA~AL'TEMPORARY FORM)CONTROL NO: PILE: 'RON: Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation Syracuse, N.Y.13202 R.R.Schneider'-20-73 7-25-73 DATE OF DOC DATE REC'D MEMO RPT OTHER TO vh CLASS UNCLASS XX PROP INFO ORIG 3 si~ned INPUT CC OTHER NO S REC'D 40 SENT AEC PDR X SENT LOCAL PDR X DOCKET NO: 50-220 DESCRIPTION:

Ltr furnishing requested info re drywell vacuum breakers at the Nine Mile Point Nuclear Station Unit 0 l.......PLANT NAME..Nine Mile Point Unit 8 1 ENCLOSURES:

NQJil/>ggg Do,go<Remove~t~FOR ACTION/INFORMATION 7-25-73 AB BUTLER(L)W/Copies CLARK(L)W/Copies GOLLER(L)W/'Copies KNIEL(L)W/Copies SCHWENCER(L)

W/Copies STOLZ(L)W/Copies VASSALLO(L)

W/'Copies SCHEMEL(L)

W/Copies NIEMANN (L)W/6 Copies DICKER(E)W/Copies KNIGHTON (E)W/Copies YOUNGBLOOD(E)

W/Copies INTERNAL DISTRIBUTION REGAN(E)W/Copies W/Copies'W/Copies W/Copies G PI R OGC, ROON P-506A~MUNTZING/STAFF CASE GIAMBUSSO BOYD MOORE (L)(BWR)DEYOUNG (L)(PWR)~SKOVHOLT (L)P.COLLINS REG OPR~ILE&REGION(3)MORRIS STEELE TECH REVIEW HENDRIE SCHROEDER MACCARY KNIGHT PAWLICKI SHAO STELLO HOUSTON NOVAK ROSS IPPOLITO~TEDESCO LONG~LAINAS BENAROYA VOLIMER DEN TON GRIMES GRMILL'ASTNER BALLARD SPANGLER ENVIRO MULLER DICKER KNIGHTON YOUNGBLOOD REGAN PROJECT LDR HARLESS LIC ASST BR(MN (E)DIGGS (L)GEARIN (L)GOULBOURNE (L)LEE (L)MAIGRET (L)SERVICE (L)SHEPPARD (E)SMITH (L)TEETS (L), WADE (E)WILLIAMS (E)WILSON (L)A/T IND BRAT IMAN SALTZMAN PLANS MCDONALD DUBE INFO C.MILES~J.RIESLAND W.BUTLER+STOLZ CLARK EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION

~l<<LOCAL PDR~1-DTIE(ABERNATHY)(l)(2)(9)-NATIONAL LAB'S~-NSIC(BUCHANAN)

'1-R.Schoonmaker,OC,GT,D-323 1-ASLB(YORE/SAYRE/

1-R.CATLIN)E-256-GT WOODARD/"H" ST.1-CONSULTANT' 16-CYS ACRS HGMRHG SENT TO LIC ASST.NEWARK/BLAT/AGBABIAN R.DIGGS ON 7-25-.73 3."GERALD ULRIKSON~ORNL 1-PDR-SAN/LA/K(1-GERALD LELLOU0 BROOKHAVEN NAT.LAB 1-AGMED(WALTER KOESTER RM-C-427"GT 1-RD MULLER.F-309 GT C o t~t l, I'

.AeIYutatory

'NIAGARA MOHAWK POWER CORPORATION NIAGARA~MOHAWK 300 ERIE BOULEVARD WEST SYRACUSE, N Y.l3202 July 20, 1973~III'r"g Jul g5)gg~

Dear Mr.Skovholt:

Re: Provisional Operating License: Docket No.: 50-220 DPR-17 Mr.Donald J.Skovholt Assistant Director for Reactor Operations Division of Reactor Licensing United States Atomic Energy Commission Washington, D.C.20545 O0,<<~)8 jp jogg 6'OIIQggIIII II~idltlf Regarding your letter requesting additional information concerning the drywell vacuum breakers at Nine Mile Point Nuclear Station Unit 81, the following is submitted:

ITEM 1 The present position indicating system utilizes two sets of limit switches, the snap lock limit switch manufactured by the National Acme Company and the Honey-well Model DTE6-2RN heavy duty, micro switches.The snap lock limit switch is used to determine and indicate the open position of any one valve'to the control room.The Honeywell micro switch is used to determine and indicate the closed position of any one valve to the control room.This system was reviewed during the Spring",.I973 refueling outage and the Honeywell micro switches installed at that time.Since the purpose of these limit switches is to provide the control room operator with information regarding the position of the breaker valves, physical separation of the control wiring or indicating lights is not required.However, an additional Honeywell limit, switch will be installed to detect the closed position and provide an alarm to the control room in the event any drywell vacuum breaker valve moves off its seat a predetermined amount.Redundances in the alarm circuit will thus be provided and IEEE 279 criteria satisfied.

The pretravel on the Honeywell'switch is.065" maximum and measurements have shown them to be.04" of pretravel.

The vacuum breaker position is detected by those limit slvitches and are actuated by small arms attached to the valve shaft.The disc must travel approximately

.2" before actuation of the limit switch is achieved.Thlerefore, the full potential accuracy cannot be realized due to the existing mounting of the switches.At, the present time, the system is under a staff review to determine what must be done to achieve the desired accuracy of.05"-.06" of disc movement.This review should be completed within a month and actual implimentations will take place, after appropriate reviews, within 30-60 days.The drywell vacuum breakers are completely accessible during the II Mr.Donald J.Skovholt United States Atomic Energy Commission Page 2 7/20/73 power operating condition and thus on line modifications can be made.Until the accuracy of.05"-.06" disc opening can be met and the alarm redundancy completed the following will be done: a.Each reactor transient involving the suppression chamber will be followed with an operability test of the drywell vacuum breaker valves.b.A dial indication will be installed on each valve accurate to indicate.06" move-ment of the disc.This system will provide a daily surveillance of valve closure within the acceptable limits as in ITEM 3 below.These indicators will be installed prior to August 1, 1973.'ITEM 2 During the valve operability test, when air is released from the air test cylinder the valve rapidly closes leaving operating personnel no action to take to manually close the valve.However, to preclude against manual closure.of the valve following testing a management person will be monitoring the testing at the test site (i.e.the valve location)to:assure that no manual intervention takes place.See Item 1 response regarding valve operability test and other additional surveillance to be done until ITEM 1 is complied with in full.ITEM 3 The limit on each individual valve will be set such that with all valves at their limit the maximum value of cumulative leakage will not exceed the maximum allowable.

The value will be approximately

.06" of disc'ravel off.its seat and will be alarmed in.the, control room.The torus instruments that would be used for surveillance testing and leak rate testing of the drywell vacuum breaker valves read out in the auxilary control room.Their range and accuracy are as follows: Pressure: 0-50 psia+.05 psi.Temperature

0-200'F+1'F PSID 0-1.0 psid+.001 psi The instrumentation used by the operator during an LOCA are in the control room and include not only an indicated pressure instrument but a recorder as well.Their range and accuracy is as follows: Pressure: low 0-4 psig+.1 psi high 0-75 psig+1.5 psi Temperature

50-300'F+5'F The computer.also records the drywell and pressure suppression chamber pressure and temperature as follows:

e~~P P Mr.Donald J.Skovholt United States Atomic Energy Commission Page 3 7/20/73 Pressure: 0-40 psig+.1 psi-alarm at 2.5 psig Temperature

50-300'F+1'F alarm at 100'F Torus, 120'F Drywell ITEM 4 Td'chnical Specification Considerations Proposed Technical Specifications will be submitted separately, after the necessary reviews are complete.Consideration is, being given to adding the following conditions and surveillance requirements.

Limiting Conditions for Operation 3.3.6 Drywell Pressure Suppression Chamber Vacuum Breakers a.lien primary containment is required, all drywell-suppression chamber vacuum breakers shall be operable and positioned in the closed position as indicated by the position indication system, except during testing and except as specified in 3.3.6 b and c, below.b.Any drywell-suppression chamber vacuum breaker may.=be non-fully closed as indicated by the position indication system provided that a drywell to torus pressure differential can be maintained greater than 1/2 the initial differential pressure for 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br /> with no N2 makeup.c.Up to one drywell-suppression chamber vacuum breaker may be secured in the closed position.d.If Specifications 3.3.6 a, b or c cannot be met, the situation shall be corrected within 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> or.the xeactor.shall be placed in a cold shut=down condition within 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br />.Surveillance Requirements 4.3.6 Drywell-Pressuxe Suppression Chamber Vacuum Breakers a.Each drywell-suppression chamber vacuum breaker shall be exercised through an opening-closing cycle monthly.b.1&en it is determined that any vacuum breaker valve is not fully closed as indicated by the position indication system at a time when such closure is required, the apparently malfunctioning vacuum breaker valves shall be exercised and pressure tested as specified in 3.3.6 b immediately and" every 15 days thereafter until the apparently malfunctioning valves have been returned to normal service.c.Once each operating cycle, each vacuum breaker valve shall be visually inspected to ensure proper maintenance and operation.

E, r~~I~~~~~~~~

her.,Donald J.Skovholt United'tates Atomic Energy Commission Page 4 7/20/73 d.A leak test of the drywell to suppression chamber structure shall be conducted during each refueling outage.Ne believe this report to be responsive to all items enumerated in your letter.Very truly yours, 1 e1 e Vice President-Electric Operations RRS:pw-0 0'I 4