ML102430118

License Renewal - Comments on SER with Open Items

ML102430118
Person / Time
Site:	Kewaunee
Issue date:	08/30/2010
From:	Hartz L N Dominion Energy Kewaunee
To:	Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
10-450
Download: ML102430118 (16)

Text

Dominion Energy Kewaunee, Inc.5000 DominionBoulevard,GlenAllen,VA23060 August30,2010UnitedStates Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attention:

DocumentControlDesk Washington

,DC20555-0001SerialNo.: 10-450 LR/DEA RODocketNo.:50-305LicenseNo.: DPR-43 DOMINION ENERGY KEWAUNEE, INC.KEWAUNEE POWER STATION LICENSE RENEWAL-COMMENTSONSERWITHOPENITEMSByletterdatedJuly15,2010 (Reference1),theNRCprovidedDominionEnergyKewaunee(DEK)a SafetyEvaluationReport(SER)withOpenItemsrelatedtothelicenserenewalof KewauneePowerStation(KPS)

.Intheletter transmittingtheSERwithOpenItems,theNRC staffdescribedtheirplanstoreviewthe formatoftheSERto furtherimprovethecontent,whileincorporatingcommentsandresponses.Tothatend,DEKhasreviewedtheSERwithOpenItems for consistencywiththeKPSLicenseRenewal Application (LRA),LRAsupplements, and subsequent informationprovidedinresponsetoNRCrequestsforadditionalinformation.DEK's commentsarelimitedtoitemsthat,ifnotresolvedforconsistencywiththeLicenseRenewal Application,areconsideredtohave implicationsonthebasesofthe conclusionspresentedintheSER.DEK

's commentsareprovidedin Attachment 1.Separately,Section1.5oftheSERlistsfouropenitemsand identifiestheinformationrequiredto satisfactorilyresolveeachopenitem

.Attachment 2 summar izes theinformationthathasbeenprovidedtotheNRCtoresolveeachofthefouropenitems.

SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305Page2of3'-VICKI L.HULL Notary Public Commonwealth of Virginia 140542 My Commission Expires May 31.2014 C0MMONWEALTHOFVIRGINIA I C0UNTYOFHENRICOShouldyouhaveany questionsregardingthissubmittal,please contactMr.PaulC.Ai tkenat(804)273-2818.IVerytrulyyours,L Jslie N.Hartz Y I Vice President-Nuclear Support ServicesTheforegoingdocumentwasacknowledgedbeforeme,inandfo rtheCountyandStateaforesaid,todaybyLeslieN.Hartz

,whoisVicePresident-NuclearSupportServicesofDominionEnergyKewaunee,Inc

.ShehasaffirmedbeforemethatsheisdulyauthorizedtoexecuteandfiletheforegoingdocumentinbehalfofthatCompany,andthatthestatementsinthedocumentaretruetothebestofherknowledgeandbelief.Acknowledgedbeforemethis

.3 tL?!'day of2.010MyCommissionExpires:

v11 Aa 31,,)0 It(6Gb'LJ!t{fLNotaryPlie Attachments:

1.CommentsonSERw ithOpenItemsRelatedtoLicenseRenewalofKewauneePowerStation2.StatusofOpenItems

Reference:

1.LetterfromNRCtoD.

A.Heacock(DEK)

,"Safety EvaluationReportwithOpenItemsrelatedtotheLicenseRenewalof Kewaunee Power Station,"datedJuly15, 2010.[ADAMS AccessionNo.M L 101190345]

Commitmentsmadeinthisletter:

None.

cc:U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission Regional Administrator

,RegionIII 2443 Warrenville RoadSuite210Lisle,IL 60532-4532Mr.K.D.Feintuch

, SeniorProjectManager U.S.Nuclear Regulatory CommissionOneWhiteFlint

,MailStop 08-H4A11555RockvillePikeRockville,MD 20852-2738Mr.DanielDoyle Environmental Project ManagerU.S.Nuclear Regulatory CommissionMailStop 0-11 F1Washington,DC20555-0001Mr.JohnDailyLicenseRenewalProjectManagerU.S.Nuclear Regulatory CommissionMailStop 0-11 F1Washington,DC20555-0001NRCSeniorResident InspectorKewauneePowerStation N490 Highway 42Kewaunee,WI54216PublicServiceCommissionofWisconsinElectricDivisionP.O.Box7854Madison,WI53707DavidHardtkeChairman-TownofCarlton E2334 Lakeshore Road Kewaunee ,WI54216SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305Page3of3 SerialNo.10-450 DocketNo.50-305 ATTACHMENT 1 COMMENTSONSERWITHOPENITEMS RELATED TO.LICENSE RENEWAL OF KEWAUNEE POWER STATION KEWAUNEE POWER STATION DOMINION ENERGY KEWAUNEE, INC.

SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305 CommentsonSERwithOpenItems Attachment1/Page1of10 CommentsonSERwithOpenItemsRelatedtotheLicenseRenewal of Kewaunee Power Station Comment#1Section2.4.2.11.1Page2-129 1st paragraph:Add"(areashousingservicewaterfacilities,equipment,andpiping)"following"ClassIstructure"inthelastsentence.Withthischange,theSERwillbe consistent with ,theKPS LRA,Section2.4.2.11andKPSUSARTableB.2-1

.Comment#2 Section 2.1.4.4.2Page2-22 2nd paragraph:Deletethephrase"alistingoffunctionsperformedbythesystemorstructure"inthesecondsentence.Withth ischange,the sentence will accuratelydescribetheKewauneeLicenseRenewalTechnicalReports,whichonlyidentifiedthe intended functionsperformedbysystemsorstructures,anddidnotlistthosefunctionsthatfailedtomeetthescopingcriteriaof10CFR54.4(a).

Comment#3Section2.4.4.2Page2-133 DEK recommendsthatthissectionbe supplementedtoindicatethe waterproofing membraneiswithinthescopeoflicenserenewal,asdiscussedintheresponsetoNRCRAIB2.1.31-3aprovidedinDEKlettertotheNRCdated December28,2009(SerialNo.09-760).

SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305 CommentsonSERwithOpenItems Attachment1/Page2of10 Comment#4Section3.0.3.2

.19Pages3-136through3-152Removethe statementsregardingan enhancementtothe WorkControlProgram(WCP)fromthissectionandelsewherewithintheSER.Withthesechanges

, theSERwillbe consistentwiththeresponsetoRequest4providedinDEKlettertotheNRCdatedMay13,2010(SerialNo.10-286),wh ichclarifiedthatthereare no enhancementstotheWCP.Comment#5Section3.0.3.2.19Page3-140 4thparagraph(singlesentence)Replace"four "with"one".Withthischange

,theSERwillbe consistentwiththeoneexceptiontakentoGALLAMPXI.M38,asdescribedinDEKlettertotheNRCdated September 25 ,2009(SerialNo.09-597).The exceptions describedintheSERaretheprogramelementsaffectedbytheoneexception.

Comment#6Section3.0.3

.2.19Page3-144 1 st bullet Delete"linear discontinuities "fromthisbullet.Withthischange

,thedescriptionofcrackingin stainlesssteeldiesel exhaust componentswillbeconsistentwithDEKlettertotheNRCdated September 25 ,2009(SerialNo.09-597).

SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305 CommentsonSERwithOpenItems Attachment1/Page3of10 Comment#7Section3.1

.2.2.2Page3-203 2nd paragraph Delete"the applicant's stress calculationsindicatedthat "fromthesixthsentence.Withthischange,theSERwillbe consistentwiththeDEKresponsetoNRCRAI 3.1.2.2.2.4-2providedinDEKlettertotheNRCdated December 28 ,2009(SerialNo.09-760).

Comment#8Section3.0

.3.1.5Page3-22 4th paragraph Change"130 OF"to"139 OF"inthesecondsentence.Withthischange

,theSERwillbe consistentwiththeresponsetoNRCRAI82.1.19-1inDEKlettertotheNRCdated August 17 ,2009(SerialNo.09-469).

Comment#9Section3.0.3.1

.5Page3-22 4th paragraph Revise"between1E4rads"to"between<1E4rads"inthefifthlineand"between 1.5E4 rads"to"between<1.5E4rads"intheninthline.ThischangewillmaketheSER consistentwiththeresponsetoNRCRAI 82.1.19-1inDEKlettertotheNRCdated August 17 ,2009(SerialNo.09-469).

SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305 CommentsonSERwithOpenItems Attachment1/Page4of10 Comment#10Section3.0.3.1.7Page3-28,1stparagraphPage3-29,4th paragraph DEK suggeststhatthesentence,The staffnotedthatthe revisrontoLRASectionA2.1.21,asamendedbyDEKlettertotheNRCdated December 28,2009,isidentifiedas Commitment No.4.",bedeleted.

CommitmentNO.4inthis statement actuallyreferstothefourth commitmentcitedinthelistof CommitmentsidentifiedinDEKlettertotheNRCdated December28,2009(SerialNo.09-760).The CommitmentNo.4indicatedhereshouldnotbeconfusedwithLicenseRenewal CommitmentNO.4onSERpageA-2.

Comment#11Section3.0.3.1.11Page3-36LastsentenceIncludethe"ASMESectionXIInserviceInspection, SubsectionsIW8,IWC,andIWDprogram"andthe"Steam GeneratorTubeIntegrityprogram"asprogramsthatverifythe effectivenessofthe Secondary Water ChemistryProgram.Withtheadditionoftheseprograms,theSERwillbe consistentwiththeKPSLRA,Section82.1.28,'Secondary WaterChemistryprogram'.

Comment#12Section3.0.3.1.12Page3-37 t h paragraph DEK recommendsthatthediscussion,"Summary of TechnicalInformationinthe Application,"bemodifiedtoindicatethatthe SelectiveLeachingofMaterialsprogramwilldefineaone-time examination methodology and acceptance criteria,andwillinspecta representativesampleofselected componentsthatmaybe susceptible to selectiveleaching.ThisclarificationwillmaketheSERconsistentwiththeKPSLRA,Section82.1.29.

SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305CommentsonSERwithOpenItems Attachment1/Page5of10 Comment#1 3Table3.3-1Page3-261Item3.3.1-15 Delete"FireProtectionProgram"fromthefifthcolumnanddelete"Consis tentwiththeGALLReport "fromtheStaffEvaluationcolumn.Withthesechanges,theSERwillbe consistentwiththeKPSLRA,Table3.3.1,Item15.

Comment#1 4Table3.3-1Page3-262Item3.3.1-16Delete"WCPProgram "fromthefifthcolumnanddelete"ConsistentwiththeGALLReport"fromtheStaffEvaluationcolumn.WiththesechangestheSERwillbe consistentwiththeKPSLRA,Table3.3.1

,Item16.Comment#15Table3.3-1Pages3-267through270Items3.3.1-53,3

.3.1-54,3.3.1-58,and3.3.1-68Delete"WCPProgram"fromthefifthcolumn.Withthischange,theSERwillbeconsistentwiththechangesidentifiedfortheseitemsintheKPSLRA,Table3.3.1inDEKlettertotheNRCdated September25,2009(SerialNo.09-597).

Comment#1 6Section3.3.2

.2.12,Item1Page3-310 2nd paragraphDelete"FuelOilTanksInspectionProgram"inthelastsentence.Withthischange,theSERwillbeconsistentwithSERTable3.3-1,Item3.3.1-32andLRATable3.3.1,Item32.

SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305 CommentsonSERwithOpenItems Attachment1/Page6of10 Comment#17Table3.4-1Page3-358Item3.4.1-16 Add"Primary Water Chemistry Program"tothefifthcolumnofTable3.4-1,Item3.4.1-16.Withthischange

,theSERwillbe consistentwithLRATable3.4.1,Item16.Comment#1 8Table3.4-1Page3-359Items3.4.1-24

,3.4.1-25,3.4.1-26,3.4.1-31,and3.4.1-32 Delete"WCPProgram"fromthefifthcolumn,"AMPinLRA,Supplements,or Amendments".

Change"ConsistentwiththeGALLReport

" to"NotapplicabletoKPS"inthe StaffEvaluationcolumn

.Withthesechanges,theSERwillbe consistentwiththechangesidentifiedfortheseItemsintheKPSLRA,Table3.4.1inDEKlettertotheNRCdated September25,2009(SerialNo.09-597).

Comment#19Section3.5.1Page3-393BulletedlistAdd"ASMESectionXI

,SubsectionIWFprogram"tothelistofprogramscreditedformanagingtheagingeffectsforthestructuresand componentsupports.WiththischangetheSERwillbe consistentwiththeKPSLRA.

SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305CommentsonSERwithOpenItems Attachment1/Page7of10 Comment#20 Table 3.5-1Page3-397Item3.5.1-10Change"ASMESectionXI,SubsectionIWEProgramand10CFRPart50, Appendix JProgram"to"NotApplicable"inthefifthcolumn.Change"ConsistentwiththeGALLReport"to"NotapplicabletoKPS"intheStaffEvaluationcolumn.WiththesechangestheSERwillbeconsistentwiththeKPSLRA,Table3.5,1,Item10.Comment#21Table3.5-1Page3-399Item3.5.1-25Add"FireProtectionProgram"and"ExternalSurfacesMonitoringProgram"tothefifthcolumn,"AMPinLRA

,Supplements,or Amendments".WiththesechangestheSERwillbe consistentwiththeKPSLRA

,Table3.5-1,Item25.

Comment#22Section3.0.3

.2.1Page3-44 5th paragraphChangethesecondsentencefrom"Theapplicantclarified

...00'atotalof24weldswillbeexaminedpriortotheperiodofextendedoperation."to"Theapplicantclarified.....,atotalof24weldswillbeexaminedpriortotheendoftheperiodofextendedoperation."WiththischangetheSERwillbe consistentwiththeDEKresponsetoNRCRAI82.1.2-1providedinDEKletterdatedFebruary2,2010(SerialNO.10-033).

SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305 CommentsonSERwithOpenItems Attachment1/Page8of10 Comment#23Section3.0.3.2.1Page3-48 Operating ExperienceReplacethe1 stand2ndparagraphswitha discussionofOperatingExperiencefortheASMESectionXIInserviceInspection, SubsectionsIWB,IWC,andIWDProgramintendedforthissection.The current paragraphs discuss Operating Experienceforthe Alloy600Program.WiththischangetheSERwillbe consistentwiththeoperating experiencediscussionfortheASMESectionXIInserviceInspection, SubsectionsIWB,IWC,andIWDprogramintheKPSLRA,SectionB2.1.2.I Comment#24Section3.0.3

.2.1Pages3-48and3-49 USAR Supplement and Conclusion DEK recommendsthatadiscussionand/orreferencetolicenserenewal CommitmentNo.42,providedinDEKlettertotheNRCdatedFebruary2,2010(SerialNO.10-033),beincludedinthesesections

.W iththischangetheSERwillincludeallthelicenserenewal commitmentsrelatedtotheASMESectionXIInserviceInspection, SubsectionsIWB,IWC,andIWDProgramthatwillbeintheKPSUSAR Supplement.

Comment#25Section3.0

.3.2.5Page3-64LastparagraphDEKsuggeststhatthediscussionoftheDEKresponsetoNRCRAIB2.1.8-2inthefirstsentence,providedinletterdated August17,2009,beclarified.DEKsuggeststhattheparagraphbemodifiedtoindicatethattheheatexchangersincludedinthe componentcoolingsystemcoolingloop

'that are part of other systems'aretheheat exchangersthatarein continuous operation.

SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305 CommentsonSERwithOpenItems Attachment1/Page9of10 Comment#26 Section 3.0.3.2.10Page3-90 1st paragraph (continuedfrompreviouspage)Deletetheword "cleaning"fromthethirdsentence.Withthischange,theSERwillbe consistentwiththediscussionofException2providedintheKPSLRA

, Section 82.1.14.Comment#27Section3.0.3.2

.11Page3-97Nexttolastparagraph Change"FuelOilTanksInspectionProgram"to "WorkControlProcessProgram "inthethirdsentence.WiththischangetheSERwillbe consistentwiththeresponsetoNRCRAI82.1

.15-1andthe associated Commitment No.31providedinDEKlettertotheNRCdatedAugust17

,2009(SerialNo.09-469).

Comment#28 Appendix APageA-2 Commitment NO.4DEKlettertotheNRCdatedJuly22

,2010(SerialNO.10-366)has extensivelyrevisedthis commitment.Assuch , DEK recommends that Commitment NO.4 intheSERbeupdatedtoreflectthatrevision.

SerialNo.10-450DocketNo.50-305 CommentsonSERwithOpenItems Attachment1/Page10of10 Comment#29 Appendix APageA-6 CommitmentNo.36Changethe implementation schedule from"PriortothePeriodofExtended operation"to"Priortotheendofthefirst10yearsof extended Operation.

" Withthischange,theSERwillbe consistentwiththeresponsetoNRCRAI5aprovidedinDEKlettertotheNRCdated December 28 ,2009(SerialNo

.760).Comment#30 Appendix APageA-6 CommitmentNo.41DEKlettertotheNRCdatedJune1,2010(SerialNO.10-324)notifiedtheNRCthatthiscomm itmenthasbeencompleted.

Comment#31 Appendix APageA-7Anew commitment,LicenseRenewal Commitment No.47 ,hasbeenaddedbyDEKlettertotheNRCdatedMay13,2010(SerialNO.10-286).

Therefore , this new commitmentshouldbeaddedto AppendixAoftheSERwithOpen Items.

ATTACHMENT 2STATUSOFOPENITEMS KEWAUNEE POWER STATION DOMINION ENERGY KEWAUNEE, INC.SerialNo.10-450 DocketNo.50-305 SerialNo.10-450 Docke tNo.50-305StatusofOpenItems Attachment 2/Page1of1Section1.5oftheNRCSERlistsfouropenitemsandidentifiestheinformationrequired to satisfactorilyresolveeachopenitem

.Each oftheopenitemnumbersbelowdirectlycorrelatestotheNRCRequestforInformation(RAI)number.Providedbelowisa summaryofthe informationthathasbeenprovidedtotheNRCtoresolveeachofthefouropenitems

.OpenItem3.0.3.2.20-1(SERSections3.0.3.2.20and4.3,Useofthe Non-ConformingSoftwareFatiguePro)TheresponsetoNRCRAI83

.2-2wassubmittedbyDEKlettertotheNRCdat edJune1,'2010(Serial NO.1 0-324).OpenItem 82.1.32-1(SERSection3

.0.3.19-WorkControlProcessProgram)Parts1throug h 5TheresponsestoNRCRAI82

.1.32-5,Parts1through5,weresubmittedbyDEK lettertotheNRCdatedMay13,2010(Serial NO.1 0-286).OpenIte m 3.1.2.1.7-1 (Nickel-Alloy Steam Generator DividerPlateCra ckingdueto PWSCC)TheresponsetoNRCRAI3.1.2

.2.13-1wassubmittedbyDEKlettertotheNRCdatedJu ly22,2010(Serial NO.1 0-366).OpenItem3.0.3.2.4-1 (RA Iconcerningrecentoperating experienceforburiedandundergroundpipingandtanks)TheresponsetoNRCRAI82

.1.7-3wassubmittedbyDEKlettertotheNRCdat edJuly22 ,2010(Serial NO.1 0-366).