ML023050229

Mcguire/Catawba - October 31, 2002 - Letter to Administrative Judges and Updated Case File

ML023050229
Person / Time
Site:	Mcguire, Catawba, McGuire
Issue date:	10/31/2002
From:	Uttal S NRC/OGC
To:	Kelber C, Rubenstein L, Austin Young Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Byrdsong A T
References
50-369-LR, 50-370-LR, 50-413-LR, 50-414-LR, ASLBP 02-794-01-LR, RAS 4977
Download: ML023050229 (11)

Text

RAS 4977 DOCKETED 11/01/02 October 31, 2002 Ann Marshall Young, Chair Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop: T-F23 Washington, D.C. 20555 Charles N. Kelber Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop: T-3F23 Washington, D.C. 20555 Lester S. Rubenstein Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop: T-3F23 Washington, D.C. 20555 In the Matter of DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION (McGuire Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2, and Catawba Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2)

Docket Nos. 50-369, 370, 413 and 414

Dear Administrative Judges:

Pursuant to the Commissions Order Referring Petitions for Intervention and Requests for Hearing to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel, CLI-01-20, (October 4, 2001), the NRC staff (Staff) is, by this letter, updating the case file in the above captioned matter.

Enclosed you will find the following documents and an updated index of documents:

3/27/2002, Letter to M. Tuckman, RE: Issuance of Environmental Scoping Summary Report, Catawba 5/28/2002, Notice of Public Meeting, RE: Draft SEIS, McGuire 6/4/2002, Notice of Public Meeting, RE: Draft SEIS, Catawba 7/26/2002, Letter from Dept. of Interior, RE: Comments on DSEIS, McGuire 8/2/2002, Letter from Duke, RE: Comments on DSEIS, McGuire 8/2/2002, Letter from EPA, RE: Comments on DSEIS, McGuire 8/8/2002, Letter from Duke, RE: Comments on DSEIS, Catawba 8/9/2002, Letter from Duke, RE: Comments on DSEIS, Catawba 8/13/2002, Letter from Dept. of Interior, RE: Comments on DSEIS, Catawba 8/19/2002, Letter from Duke, RE: Comments on DSEIS, Catawba 8/29/2002, Letter to M. Tuckman, RE: Revised Review Schedule 9/9/2002, Letter to M. Tuckman, RE: Inspection Report and copy of Inspection Report By copy of this letter, I am filing a copy of this update in the docket and with OCAA, and, serving copies, by regular mail, upon David Repka, Esquire, attorney for the applicant, Duke Power Corp., Mary Olson, Nuclear Information and Resource Service, and Diane Curran, Esquire, attorney for Blue Ridge Environmental Defense Fund. Copies of this letter and the updated index of the case file, are being served on the remainder of the service list.

Sincerely,

/RA/

Susan L. Uttal Counsel for NRC Staff cc w/encls: As stated cc Index only: Lisa F. Vaughn, Esq.

ASLB Lou Zeller Paul Gunter

DUKE ENERGY CORP.

MCGUIRE/CATAWBA LICENSE RENEWAL CASE FILE DOCKET NOS. 50-369, 50-370, 50-413, 50-414 DOCUMENT NUMBER DESCRIPTION I S S U E DATE ADAMS ACCESSION #

SAFETY REVIEW CD License Renewal Application (LRA) and Appendices 06/13/2001 ML011660301 01 Transmittal Letters:

LRA Highlighted Flow Diagrams LRA on CD 06/13/2001 06/13/2001 06/28/2001 ML011660138 ML011661068 ML011840032 02 Conference Call Summary - Mechanical ESF AMR 07/24/2001 ML012070063 03 Conference Call Summary - Structures 09/10/2001 ML012530283 04 Conference Call Summary - Aux Sys Scoping 10/10/2001 ML012830102 05 Conference Call Summary - Aux Sys Scoping 10/15/2001 ML012880370 06 Conference Call Summary - Aux Sys Scoping 11/02/2001 ML013060438 07 Conference Call Summary - ESF Scoping 11/14/2001 ML013190029 08 Conference Call Summary - Mechanical Aging Management Programs 11/23/2001 ML013310117 09 Conference Call Summary - Inservice Inspection 11/29/2001 ML013300361 10 Conference Call Summary - Structures 11/30/2001 ML013379544 11 Conference Call Summary - Reactor Coolant System and Engineered Safety Features Scoping 12/05/2002 ML013400357 12 Conference Call Summary - Structures 12/11/2001 ML013460154 13 Conference Call Summary - Mechanical AMPs 12/11/2001 ML013460269 14 Conference Call Summary - Mechanical AMP 12/12/2001 ML013460417 15 Conference Call Summary - Mechanical AMPs 12/13/2001 ML013470364 16 Conference Call Summary - Chemistry Control Program 12/14/2001 ML013520129

-iv-DUKE ENERGY CORP.

MCGUIRE/CATAWBA LICENSE RENEWAL CASE FILE DOCKET NOS. 50-369, 50-370, 50-413, 50-414 DOCUMENT NUMBER DESCRIPTION I S S U E DATE ADAMS ACCESSION #

17 Conference Call Summary - Electrical 12/27/2001 ML013650428 18 Conference Call Summary - Structures 01/10/2002 ML020110099 19 Conference Call Summary - Ventilation Systems 01/15/2002 ML020170132 20 Conference Call Summary - Aux Sys Scoping 01/15/2002 ML020160418 21 Request for Additional Information (RAI) -

Scoping Methodology Audit 01/17/2002 ML020220034 22 RAI - Electrical 01/17/2002 ML020180061 23 RAI -Scoping Results 01/23/2002 ML020290102 24 RAI - Mechanical - ESF Scoping 01/23/2002 ML020240249 25 RAI - Mechanical - Auxilliary Systems AMR 01/24/2002 ML020240265 26 RAI - Mechanical - AMP 01/28/2002 ML020310200 27 RAI - Mechanical - Aux Sys Scoping 01/28/2002 ML020320212 28 RAI - Mechanical - ESF AMR 01/28/2002 ML020320010 29 RAI - Reactor Coolant System 01/28/2002 ML020310255 30 RAI -Structures 01/28/2002 ML02032016521 31 RAI - Reactor Coolant System II 01/30/2002 ML020350542 32 Notice of Meeting to Discuss Schedules 05/08/2001 ML011290008 33 Notice of Meeting to Discuss Schedules 06/05/2001 ML011560744 34 Summary of Meeting to Discuss Schedules 06/06/2001 ML011590263 35 Teleconference Summary - Inspection Schedules 06/07/2001 ML011590499 36 Summary of Meeting to Discuss Schedules 07/10/2001 ML011930405

-v-DUKE ENERGY CORP.

MCGUIRE/CATAWBA LICENSE RENEWAL CASE FILE DOCKET NOS. 50-369, 50-370, 50-413, 50-414 DOCUMENT NUMBER DESCRIPTION I S S U E DATE ADAMS ACCESSION #

37 Meeting Summary - LRA Orientation 07/26/2001 ML012080051 38 Editorial Changes to LRA ML011980527 39 NEI/Management Meeting Notice 08/31/2001 ML012430275 40 Meeting Notice - Scoping Methodology Audit Exit 10/03/2001 ML012770008 41 NEI/Management Meeting Summary 10/21/2001 ML012840369 42 Meeting Summary - Scoping Methodology Audit Exit 11/15/2001 ML013190507 43 Notice of Meeting to discuss LR Emerging Issues 11/30/2001 ML013370001 44 e-mail re: minor questions on Aux Sys AMR 12/10/2001 12/13/2001 ML020040015 45 e-mail re: minor questions on Aux Sys Scoping 12/13/2001 ML020170427 46 NEI/Management Meeting Notice 12/14/2001 ML013510294 47 Notice of Meeting to discuss Station Black Out Scoping 12/18/2001 ML013600335 48 Summary of Meeting on LR Emerging Issues 01/17/2002 ML020300004 ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 49 Letter re: maintenance of documents - McGuire 06/12/2001 ML011640049 50 Memorandum: Acceptance Review Results -

McGuire 07/10/2001 ML011920220 51 Determination of Acceptability and Sufficiency -

McGuire 07/15/2001 ML012270107 52 Notice of Intent - McGuire 08/16/2001 ML012280471

-vi-DUKE ENERGY CORP.

MCGUIRE/CATAWBA LICENSE RENEWAL CASE FILE DOCKET NOS. 50-369, 50-370, 50-413, 50-414 DOCUMENT NUMBER DESCRIPTION I S S U E DATE ADAMS ACCESSION #

53 Notice of Public Meeting, Environmental Scoping

- McGuire 09/07/2001 ML012500389 54 Meeting Summary - Environmental scoping; transcript -McGuire 10/12/2001 ML012850194 55 RAI - SAMAs -McGuire 11/19/2001 ML013250535 56 RAI - Environmental Report - McGuire 11/19/2001 ML013300544 57 Telecommunication RE: RAIs - McGuire 12/06/2001 ML013420001 58 Response to RAIs 01/17/2002 ML020440709 59 Response to RAIs 01/31/2002 ML020450466 60 Letter re: maintenance of documents - Catawba 06/11/2001 ML011620533 61 Memorandum: Acceptance Review Results -

Catawba 07/10/2001 ML011920167 62 Determination of Acceptability and Sufficiency -

Catawba 08/15/2001 ML012270107 63 Notice of Intent - Catawba 09/14/2001 ML012570124 64 Notice of Public Meeting, Environmental Scoping

- Catawba 10/03/2001 ML012760475 65 Summary of Site Audit - Catawba 11/13/2001 ML013170360 66 Meeting Summary - Environmental scoping; transcript - Catawba 11/29/2001 ML013330257 67 RAI - SAMAs - Catawba 12/10/2001 ML013460491 68 RAI - Environmental Report - Catawba 12/12/2001 ML013470594 69 Response to RAIs 02/01/2002 ML020450479 70 Response to RAIs 02/08/2002 ML020450547

-vii-DUKE ENERGY CORP.

MCGUIRE/CATAWBA LICENSE RENEWAL CASE FILE DOCKET NOS. 50-369, 50-370, 50-413, 50-414 DOCUMENT NUMBER DESCRIPTION I S S U E DATE ADAMS ACCESSION #

UPDATES to CASE FILE 71 Note regarding telecommunication with Duke Energy Co. (Duke) regarding Requests for Addition Information 03/06/2002 ML020660073 72 Response to Request for Additional Information, 03/08/2002 ML020780025 73 Note regarding information provided to NRC by Duke regarding SAMAs 03/14/2002 ML020740318 ML020740179 73a Attachment 2, Catawba Modified Case 03/14/2002 ML020770301 73b Attachment 3, McGuire Modified Case 03/14/2002 ML020770345 74 Timetable for Responses undated ML020530403 75 Response to RAI - Auxiliary systems 03/15/2002 ML020810451 76 Response to RAI - Reactor Coolant System 04/15/2002 ML021120015 77 Request for Comments on Draft Plant-Specific Supplement 8 to the [GEIS] Regarding McGuire Nuclear Station.

05/6/2002 ML021280559 78 Letter from NRC to U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, RE: Draft Supplement 8 to the [GEIS] Regarding McGuire Nuclear Power Station.

05/06/2002 ML021280667 79 Letter to M. S. Tuckman, Duke, RE: Notice of Availability of the Draft Plant-Specific Supplement to the [GEIS] Regarding McGuire Nuclear Station.

05/07/2002 ML021280687 80 Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants, Supplement 8, Regarding McGuire Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2.

05/2002 ML021300281 81 Meeting Summary for December 12, 2001 public meeting regarding license renewal emerging issues.

01/17/2002 ML020300026 ML020290446 ML020300004 82 e-mails 7/2001 through 8/2001 ML021490046 83 e-mails 9/2001 through 10/2001 ML021490069 ML022200671

-viii-DUKE ENERGY CORP.

MCGUIRE/CATAWBA LICENSE RENEWAL CASE FILE DOCKET NOS. 50-369, 50-370, 50-413, 50-414 DOCUMENT NUMBER DESCRIPTION I S S U E DATE ADAMS ACCESSION #

84 e-mails 11/2002 ML021490095 ML021490064 ML021490089 ML022200662 ML022200659 ML022200650 ML022200648 ML022200643 85 e-mails 12/2001 ML021490006 ML022210073 ML022210048 ML022210046 ML022210042 ML022210037 86 e-mails 1/2002 ML021490011 ML022210034 ML022210062 87 e-mails 2/2002 ML021490117 ML021440321 ML021440327 ML022210029 ML022210026 88 Letter to M. S. Tuckman, Duke, RE: Notice of Availability of the Draft Plant-Specific Supplement to the [GEIS] Regarding Catawba Nuclear Station.

05/13/2002 ML021340817 89 Letter from NRC to U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, RE: Draft Supplement 8 to the [GEIS] Regarding Catawba Nuclear Power Station.

05/13/2002 ML021350068 90 Letter from NRC to M. Tuckman, RE: Request for Comments on Draft Plant-Specific Supplement 9 to the [GEIS] Regarding Catawba Nuclear Station.

05/14/2002 ML021350023 91 Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants, Supplement 9, Regarding Catawba Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2.

05/2002 ML021400063 92 Summary of Telecommunication between NRC staff and Duke regarding reactor coolant system 02/11/2002 ML020420453 93 Summary of meeting regarding license renewal between NRC and License Renewal Working 02/21/2002 ML020560022.

-ix-DUKE ENERGY CORP.

MCGUIRE/CATAWBA LICENSE RENEWAL CASE FILE DOCKET NOS. 50-369, 50-370, 50-413, 50-414 DOCUMENT NUMBER DESCRIPTION I S S U E DATE ADAMS ACCESSION #

Group.

94 Response to RAIs.

03/01/2002 ML020640428.

95 Response to RAIs.

03/11/2002 ML020770266.

96 Notice of meeting regarding license renewal.

03/13/2002 ML020720270.

97 Letter RE: Issuance of Environmental Scoping Summary Report for McGuire.

03/27/2002 ML020870574 98 Summary of License Renewal Meeting between NRC and License Renewal Working Group.

04/22/2002 ML021130114.

99 NRC Inspection Report for McGuire and Catawba RE: License Renewal.

05/6/2002 ML021280003.

100 Lake Water Data for Lake Norman and Lake Wylie.

Undated ML021090060.

101 e-mails 4/2002 ML021440276 ML021440270 ML022200679 102 e-mails 5/2002 ML021440217 ML021440263 ML021440229 ML021440236 ML021440245 ML021440255 ML021440259 ML022200618 ML022200627 ML022200607 ML022200632 ML022200601 ML022200676 ML022200618 ML022200627 ML022200607 ML022200632 ML022200601 103 Notice of Public Meeting to Discuss the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS)....,

06/06/2002 ML021610474.

104 Telecommunication with Duke Energy Corporation to Discuss the Response to a Request for Additional Information Pertaining to Section 3.5 of the License Renewal Application.

06/07/2002 ML021620496.

105 Telecommunication with Duke Energy Corporation to Discuss the Response to a Request for Additional Information Pertaining to 06/07/2002 ML021620457

-x-DUKE ENERGY CORP.

MCGUIRE/CATAWBA LICENSE RENEWAL CASE FILE DOCKET NOS. 50-369, 50-370, 50-413, 50-414 DOCUMENT NUMBER DESCRIPTION I S S U E DATE ADAMS ACCESSION #

Section 2.1 of the License Renewal Application.

106 Telecommunication with Duke Energy Corporation to Discuss the Response to a Request for Additional Information Pertaining to Section B.3.26 of the License Renewal Application.

06/19/2002 ML021700648 107 Revision to Schedule for the Conduct of Review of the McGuire, Units 1 and 2, and Catawba, Units 1 and 2, License Renewal Application.

06/19/2002 ML021710625 108 Telecommunication with Duke Energy Corporation to Discuss the Response to a Request for Additional Information Pertaining to Section 4.3 of the License Renewal Application.

06/19/2002 ML021700621 109 Telecommunication with Duke Energy Corporation to Discuss the Response to a Request for Additional Information Pertaining to Sections 3.6 and B.3.19 of the License Renewal Application.

06/24/2002 ML021750433 110 Summary of Meeting Held in Support of Review for the McGuire Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application 06/25/2002 ML021820069 ML021780452 ML021820069 ML021780452 111 e-mails 6/2002 ML022200661 ML022200597 ML022200608 ML022200611 ML022200593 ML022200655 ML022200653 ML022200652 ML022200647 ML022200642 ML022200636 ML022200665 ML022200658 ML022200656 ML022200637 ML022200634 ML022200626 ML022200615 ML022200610 ML022200667

-xi-DUKE ENERGY CORP.

MCGUIRE/CATAWBA LICENSE RENEWAL CASE FILE DOCKET NOS. 50-369, 50-370, 50-413, 50-414 DOCUMENT NUMBER DESCRIPTION I S S U E DATE ADAMS ACCESSION #

ML022200660 ML022200674 ML022200673 112 e-mails 3/2002 ML022210020 ML022200682 ML022200684 113 FAX from Duke to NRC 6/4/2002 ML022200595 114 Letter to Duke Re: Draft Safety Evaluation with Open Items 8/14/2002 ML022270049 115 Draft Safety Evaluation with Open Items 8/14/2002 ML022260949 116 Issuance of Environmental Scoping Summary Report 3/27/2002 ML020870376 117 Notice of Public Meeting on DSEIS - McGuire 5/28/2002 ML021500686 118 Notice of Public Meeting on DSEIS - Catawba 6/4/2002 ML021570597 119 DOI Comments of draft EIS - McGuire 7/26/2002 120 Duke Comments on draft SEIS - McGuire 8/2/2002 ML022210233 121 EPA Comments of draft SEIS - McGuire 8/2/2002 ML022270355 122 Duke Comments on draft SEIS - Catawba 8/8/2002 ML022330373 123 Duke Comments on draft SEIS - Catawba 8/9/2002 ML022270455 124 DOI Comments on draft SEIS - Catawba 8/13/2002 ML022380016 125 Duke Comments on draft SEIS - McGuire 8/19/2002 ML022470024 126 Revised Review Schedule 8/29/2002 ML022410304 127 McGuire and Catawba Inspection Report 9/9/2002