IR 05000354/1989021

Exam Rept 50-354/89-21OL on 891206-07.Exam Results:Two Senior Reactor Operators Passed Requalification re-exams

ML20005E070
Person / Time
Site:	Hope Creek
Issue date:	12/19/1989
From:	Conte R, Todd Fish NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
To:
Shared Package
ML20005E069	List: IR 05000354/1989021 ML20005E068
References
50-354-89-21OL, NUDOCS 9001030200
Download: ML20005E070 (6)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:p+7 . ' - ...

e

.

• c.

i U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION "

REGION I

C OPERATOR LICENSING RE-EXAMINATION Report No.

50-354/89-21(OL) ' Docket No.

50-354 License No.

NPF-57 Licensee: Public-Service Electric and Gas Company P. O. Box 236 Hancocks Bridge, New Jersey 08038 Facility Name: Hopa Creek Generating Station Examination Dates: December 6-7, 1989-Examiner: Todd Fish, Senior Operations Engineer Chief Examiner: doMd / /8!97 < t Todd FT. Fish, Senior 0perations Engineer date ~ , BWR Section, Operations Branch, DRS h AL//9

Reviewed by: /r co

1. ..

Richard J. Conte, Ch1A date BWR Section Opera d ons Branch, DRS Summary:

Written and operating (simulator section only)' re-examinations were administered to'two senior reactor operators (SR0s) who had failed these sections of the initial requalification exams which were administered

+ during the week of June 19, 1989. As graded by the NRC, both SR0s passed ' their applicable portion of the re-examinations.

Since only two operators were examined, this review did not constitute a program evaluation. The licensee was effective in remediating the operators with respect to their respective previous examination results.

, v . , .

. - - - - - - - . - - - - - - - . - - -

- -_ . ' . p:

• -

,

• -

. , '

.. ,.. l / Report Details 1.

Introduction During the examination period, the NRC examiner conducted a requalification re-examination of two senior reactor operators (SR0s) at Hope Creek Generating Station.

The examiner used the process and criteria in NUREG 1021, " Operator Licensing Examiner Standards," specifically, ES-601, " Administration of NRc Requalification Program > , Evaluation," Revision 5, dated January 1,1989. All NRC and facility ' personnel that attended the entrance and exit meetings are listed in Attachment 1.

2.

Individual Examination Results The'following is a summary of the individual re-examination results for , the requalification examination.

Only NRC results were used as the basis I ~i for a Pass / Fail decision. Note: Candidates were only re-examined _in the.

I' - area that they failed as a result of requalification exams administered in June 1989.

NRC l l Grading l Pass /Faill I l l l Written l 1/0 l l I l l Operating l ! l (Simulator) l 1/0 l l l

I l l l Overall l 2/0 l l

l ' l l Facility l l j ~ Grading l Pass /Faill l l' l I l . l Written l 1/0 l . l l l l l-l Operating l l , ! l (Simulator) i 1/0 l l-

I I l l l l l Overall l 2/0 l l I I

.

, k I . . --- . - . , .;9 -

, - , One SRO was evaluated in the written portion, another SRO in the simulator portion.

Therefore, no accurate basis exists to make a fair determination of whether there were identifiable strengths or deficiencies. Also, since only two operators were examined, this revie'w did not_ constitute a program evaluation. The licensee was effective in remediating the operators with respect to their respective previous examination results.

3.

Exit Interview An exit interview was conducted on December 7, 1989 following the t ' administration of the examinations. The licensee representatives that attended the meeting are listed in Attachment 1 of this report.

Details of the examination week were discussed.

< ?

l

_ +, ., u p -:

-

..

_ t ATTACHMENT 1 Persons Contacted During Re-Examination . 1.- Public Service Electric and Gas R. Hovey, Operations Manager, Hope Creek-(2) G. Mecchi, Plant Operations Training (2) W. Gott, Operations Training, Hope Creek (1,2) , ! 2.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory _Cofmy.ission l T. Fish, Senior Operations Engineer (1,2) . Notes: ' (11 Preser;t ou -ing antracce meeting ^n Decemsei 4,1989 (2) Present dui'f og exit meeting en December 7,1989

f e i fE ' ' .

• /&

1- " s ', - ' v: ,- <, -

5 N> . ,

ATTACHMENT-2 i REQUALIFICATION EXAMINATION TEST' ITEMS i . P SCEN NO.

SIMULATOR SCENARIO -{ ' ESG-010-Main Turbine High Vibration w/ LOP

> Written Examination-- Part A , i L; Scenario A1: SS-001 ' QNUM-TEST ITEM N0.

QVAL' . ' ~1 2990170105C 1.0;

' '2 4000080401 1.0 !

2000360502C 1.0

-

4 4000190401 1.0-

-.5 4000640401 1.0 L

2120030101 1.0' n

2990210301.

-i .

8 2000760501'

1;0 ' 9' 2990210301 1.0-10-2990210301 1.0 - , Scenario A2: SS-021 0NUM TEST ITEM NO.

QVAL

!

2990210301CCC 1.0-i

2590240101A 1.0: 3-2990210301 1.0 f

4000680401 1.0 e

4000640401B 1.0 6.

2990210301 1.0

4000690401 1.0

2990210301 1.0 I

2000360502C 1.0 , ' 10' 2020010101 1.0 t t l l l y.

. ,

R?W c, : hI!IL ',.

' e ' ??+ r, {l J. O ' ( ' Attachment 21

-

. ' 0NUM TEST ITEM NO.

QVAL ' . - .I' 2050070101 2.0 n

4000400401 2.0

?

2990640302 2.0

2990640302-12 2.0

4000540401 2.0

2990060105 2.0 7' 4000450401 2.0

2990210301 2.0 -; ,,_

'2000370502 2.0 '

2000360502 2.0 ! , e . t i , , - }}