IR 05000219/1987007

Ack Receipt of Informing NRC of Steps Taken to Correct Violations Noted in Insp Rept 50-219/87-07

ML20216C160
Person / Time
Site:	Oyster Creek
Issue date:	06/22/1987
From:	Johnston W NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
To:	Fiedler P GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP.
References
NUDOCS 8706300228
Download: ML20216C160 (1)

Text

, , 7 .. z- ...m _7 % ,

, ,

.

< x j

'}

.\.

-4 '

,

l

,

. .

]

'

,ly . Jt)N 2 2i1987

,

Docket No. 50-219 s

GPU Nv. lear Corporation JATTN: Mr. P. B, Fiedler j i Wice President and-Director '

l 4 >

'0yster' Creek Nuclear Generating .St'ation d

P. - 0.- Box- 388 9 For'ked River, NJ 08731

'

-

'

n m- Gentlea.en; s'a

"

,. ,

s

-

Sublict: sInspyctiqnN c

. 50-219/87"07 - 'l This -refers to r9hur ' letter da'ted May 14, 1987., in response to.our~_ letter e, dated April:7, 1987, Our letter forwarded the-subject inspection report - i and-our Notice of Violation relating to 1 design change drawing' omissio ~

s '

,

Thank yo'u lfor inform'ing .'us of- the correctiva .~ arid:, preventive: actions documented - m s

in your . letter. These actions will be. examined-during a' future; inspection o your licensed progra .g

_ v  :

Y6ur cooperation with us is appreciate '

q Si ncerei.V , :

.

.. -

,

, ,

.]

t, Crisinal Signed By L . , :s

.

t

'

,

.

. .,m

'

.

_

fLg lcl ,,_)[ s

,

,y

', j

' ^' ' '

' '

-

'W

-

liam Johnston,IActingfirectorf  !

. . . .Divisien of Reactor. Safety * x:-

'

\.s \ '

N .1

'

y '. 1 ff

'

\ k' lid Document Room!(Pb '

<

N'ue; lear Safety.Informatioq Ces3e${NSIC) X-State of New Jersey - l

. . . .. 1 s9 -

-

bec: 1 -

"

V - '

}l Region'I Dockst Room (w/ conc rr.k;cen):

(foc k ..

-

-

o RIiDRSI RI:0RS dI:)RS I ..J J[, ]

G /mk Strosn Durr ~

L';f ;; f. 9gb i

.. ,, ~: s(de)r

.

,

7,.6//8/87 M . , i,.

.

.P -) 4 6//9/87 ' .

0FFICIAL RECORD. COPY,

@ WV2 . .. .

i p

• -RL OC 87 07i- 0001. : ,. j

.,

• ;d6/18/87 . f . ,

'm .y <

. .

Jhk i- j ww g ,

',

'

'

'

'

. j 1- >

,

,

.

-

,

a ' '

. m ..

g .. 4

_

' -

_ , __

,

_ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _

- I

. .

.s t

,.

f\'

• glgp GPU Nuclear Corporatics 100 interpace Parkway Parsippany. New Jersey o%54. I 1 (20 0 263 650o May 14, 1987 TELEX 136 482 I 5000-87-1/% Writer's Direct Dial Number U.S. fluclear Regulatory Commission '

Attention: Document Control Ocek '

Washington, DC 20555 <

Gentlemen: -

Subjec t: Oyster Creek tiuclear Generating' Station Docket flo. 50-219 ,

i flRC Inspection Repcrt 50-219/87-07 ', ,/ .

Response to Notice of Violationi  ;, (;

^ '

/ .

. c . '

,

,* - ,

Attachment A'to this letter provides our response to the Ncdce of VioMich' ,

described in the subject inspection repor ShouldyourequirefurtherinformationpleasecontactBrendaDeMerchc.jt,OC 1 Licensing Engineer at (6C9)971-4642.- ,

.

Very truly yours,.

~

\

m ~

M.F,M1how '

\

Vice Frender.t , "t

, ,

T,echnical Functions l

,

.

,

, 3. g 3-

'

RFW:BD:dnd -

1 ,q ',

(0490A) .

s +\ ,

\t g

'

,

a if .

,

I

( f r f

cc: ftr. William T. Russell, Administrator V "t:RC Resjdyi'p InspN,N1or Region I- Oyster Creen t!uclear'Geograting Stktica U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission .' ?<rked >R iv er , N 08731  :

631 Park Avenue- o *

. I l King of Prussia, PA 19406 i- %,- "\ I' s ,d',

.

'n .,,. i 11r. Alexander Dromericx .

WilliamV,Jchnston;ActingDirpcpr;I>; "

U.S..fluclear Regulatory Conmiss;cn Division cf Reactor Safety '

-

7920 fiorfolk Avenue, Pni! Tips Bld U.S. tiuclear Regulatory Concissiorg / , *

Cethesda,:ItD 20014 / 1 i Itegion I s ay l' ail Stop tio. 3F +

631 Park. Avenue ]j J

'

_

,

> ting of Prussia, PA 19406 ,

'-

!

.

, ,

&

,

.,,. f . o

$bbb9- s

. ,y r' , .. -

,,\'t f ,, i j' ,.o, (' - n  ;

' '*, '

c

. '{

,

,

'

..

_r *

i ) ,y .

,

h -

<

.

[  :

' 'u s ;[ ' ;"x,jj

. , .

+

): s. ( ' ,)? 4

-

.

M i

'a

- ,- n- --

-

y

., . , .

'

}, v$,. ATTACHitENT A pf fCqw et

.

,

y Dg:7 y * Violation:

a 10 CFR 50, Appendix.B, Criterion VI' require's.that'neasures shall be W(' [$.Eb

)

\: established to control the issuance of drawings affecting quality. The-neasures shall assure that drawings, including changes, are reviewed for.

[ p adequacy and approved for releas "i [ 7(e'lcensee'sprocedure'no,5000-Adit-7312.02,'titledAsBuiltDrawings:

NN requires updating of dirmings to incorporate changes to the plant

cont'jyyration. The licensee's standard DS-010, titled Chec. king Drawings

^

>

A)so c6ntains pyvisionf to reference all affected drawing .<

f Contrad to the a$ivoi bhtrol room drawing, GE 237E726,:was not. updated flangathatprovideco(ntainment.isolationfor.themain?steamdrain.to' in

,

The work package. BA 323402 chd Safety Evaluation llo' 323402-001 Rev.'.1, also-

.

., neglected.to reference this app 71 cable'Ldrawing, c , 1

,

Response a

( Clarification:

~

Flanges Y-1-57 and Y-1-58 were incorporated in' revision 34 of drawing-0' '

,

GE-237 E-726 under authority of FCN C04962. dated February ~26, 1987. The:

'

',

cause for the initial failure was identified in the f.inding eg;- the did not11dentify the drawing as affecte >

.

modificatfor addition, thel flenge package,TnThrmation is; duplicated on In'two drawings, .

and SE-237-E;726J The checker of drawing BR-2002, revision 25. (which did -

incorporate thejchange) provided correct r.otificationiin.a' timely manne ,

However, he fa Jied at turnover to_ identify the subjectidrawing las being affected'.

Cause: i '

GPUN believes this-is an: isolated occurrenc GPUll judges that thel

. principal cause was the failure of_the modification packagelto identify?

L the directly affected reference-' drawing. :In addition, the Designt and:

Drafting staff failed to recognize thet GE-237-E-726' required revision'

whentthey completed the As-Built'docubentation. . Technical Functions'

Engineering Services has taken si:eps to ensure that the1 requirements of-D3-002, section 5.2.1.5.e are strictTy eriforcedL Drafting' Standard 05-002'has beei reMsed to require that bc construction. drawings mustLall carry"a noteLstating which other

. drawing ~s are affected.by construction'of:the sub' ject 1 drawing. ^: ,

.

order to ensure no~nisunderstanding,Ethe wording.;of the: note has bee .

prescribed. Uhere-no drawings;are affected the note.is still-required and will'statf 'none".

f 4688 9 p 4 -

,

(f e

4 s'

~

4.- -y

}

, i s .

• -

)

a

.

1. # # o , < .- ,

Il l - F w

<

- p , ,. 3 . . , -

-

-g-j

~2 . .- 'GPUN Managers, Project Engineering,.have been advised tha ,

. Engineering Services ED&CC personnel'are being required to audit for o the existence of-the (above)~ note. Releases which do not comply will L

- '

be rejecte .. GPUN Supervisors, Design and Drafting,'have been directed to; specifically ~ review checkedL As Built: Drawings to ensure. that affected drawings are. identified asia part-of future As Duilt Drawin revision-releases. Additionally, they.will be sensitized to the-existence of Lduplicate. information on .some Oyster Creek drawings such that'more than one drawing may be affecte The appropriate: revision to DS-002 will be released before May 30, 198 Memorandum EPS-131'(notifying Managers-Project Engineering) was released on. April 16, 198 Additionally, GPUN had previously initiated a' drawing update program intended in partsto reduce the amount of redundant information contained in controlled . drawings. This program is ongoing and will continue into 1988. This program should also serve to reduce the' likelihood o repetition of this violatio .y

- Future ~ Prevention:

GPUN. judges that the immediate corrective action steps 'escribed.above-d will.also minimize further violation .

t

'0490A)

(

40889

>

I 'r

-

.

-.

'I