ML20153G697

Redirects Info Encl & Previously Considered as Proprietary, Per 970210 Ltr.W Ltr NSD-NRC-98-5756 Dtd 980814 Stated That Encl Rept Is No Longer Considered Proprietary.Encls Originally Submitted as Part of 9702200289

ML20153G697
Person / Time
Site:	05200003
Issue date:	09/21/1998
From:	Huffman B NRC
To:	NRC
References
NUDOCS 9809300181
Download: ML20153G697 (7)

Text

.

September 21,1998 TO: AP600 Docket Files52-003 FROM: Bill HuffmanbM

SUBJECT:

Redirection of Previously Proprietary Material into the Public The information provided in Enclosure 1 of this memo was originally sthmitted with Westinghouse letter NSD-NRC-97-4970 dated February 10,1997 and was identified as proprietary (See Accession #9702200289). Westinghouse letter NSD-NRC-5756 dated August 14,1998, (Enclosure 2), states that the mformation in Enclosure 1 is no longer considered proprietary.

Therefore, I have removed the Westinghouse proprietary markings from Enclosure 1 so that it <

can be placed into the public files.

I Enclosure 1: AP600 Drawings show'.ng how RTNSS Systems are Protected From -

Floods and Missiles attached to Westinghouse Letter NSD-NRC-97-4970 dated February 10,1997 (Proprietary markings removed)

Enclosure 2: Westinghouse letter NSD-NRC-5756 dated August 14,1998 cc w/o enclosures: TRQuay l JSebrosky .

l l'

I l

l 9809300181 980921 h PDR ADOCK 05200003 4 A .PDR (

. ~ . .,- -. - , . . , . , , .. ,. , . . - . . ,

a .rl< , l r

1

- i = i . i . - l 8 . 1 - 1 . t .

i

, .I  !

.um ___.

= . . .... . . .

3 *

• 3 -3 **3 =

.4 .

g 4 3 j j I )] { I ! I

• 2 -

l

! j 3 i l i !  ! l 0 E E a  %-

g

~

lg !4 !0 a 9

l!

Q j

.IlM ^h .

(: 23 ? Ss 8 8!!!li!

p-

--]:

..lL' O O' I N 95 ! $plai 8 l ill"

,r

..t

[T 98 5 *jpg *)g

$ a"?

lbcr , e  ;

I:

rgg g;' g: e g r -u-d-

i i

- w!a!;;i!,a

is l

i. -

a n_gl 2 --

F l i

J _ i gs -

= Jrp 3 ll :i si :ga l l

(...-.

?!) "1 1 r -

4e a 5

, .. ,5 ,5 ,

=,.m y t.,.._

s!E --- % i

.' . t m: .:,: : 1 -

znr WLL, v

J1 -

j IC hj ta.1%,!- -

S)Q

[-

m i ,.

.~.

, ..J

.__a .% s g

)$ f:S M q

as =.

m.

,t f

• F l-y sw j

• Ne c a ..is . //

- ~.Q.{-.'-.:: ,

}'.[

3

• ::1 e, m.

_ e. . -

+p,y.j .en,:m u ,h i.4 L -

I I ll a (j O ' -

'J a 3 mzumr

l ,

. n,. g

, n..a. n WM x g-I

--[ I.

yp ql i _r_.

, n - ~

u

- i . , ,

s n r

i 4

_)l' e, g -

, T 4 p.

lr Sjillbl!

glj , c -

I I

W .

Eo ca,3 eme l

.,-,.,=_1. .

. . v .

t

. l . .

1 l . g . i . l .

7. --.l l

1. sn*

e l l l !l ! !

iii i! ! !

E E [ O 1

l l 313 y :pp_g}

! l' i la

}

_eo  !

ql uM;.. j

g. "

_ove j

- tr w w h f g .

g ,gg mm<a im 3 . i s i.

4-T- FriIl g g O' fN k':.f..

E3  !!!! _ I!! I g; g!!!!33

~

U1 '5 W ~

11 -.g_i.2  ;

e sb

. vio 1 .g' y fp+. q 3 g y m. w llj 3 .

s. <.6 :3 g

9 op a

. 1 e

E2

- t 'i -

nen# == s@ mc E i tgr 6 _C=z i  !

aw>w -

= = I) mas

~ '

r

g 9

g d ;9-==_

hxxx- ll gsQ a

, l d_ l ., DjTd , m ,-

=alI[.3 j3f..- .

3 [.. -- )

h (.... >. ..e Cl

~

~g et;:.: p. ,

grga _

-M Q1Q.a r:fp Lc i i

' .. hvm

. x e<,--l'~vr en,s:o! g i

. l' i d.l' ,g)) .3 W% - r 3: n 15 4

.. . ; - s% .7 _ :~,

e g'Ta ..J y i

_0 . .: -

i -

,,.- Em. Ii -

p -

4.','N ,Has LU @

j _

~

1

' I i e g

_t j' i

= -

1 '

~

1.q si !j

. . i - . -

l i e i

• i . i -

i.. . i

?

I J

~

. - - l . I a  ;

.. l . I a 1 S 1 m.._

3 5 i a 3  :! l I  ! .I I I [ j#

5 , , , , , -

s j

~

l a E a E g

5 E-  !

a 1 ;1

'c g i 2 5

i ai g

a y

sig na - 3;a.

_ii.,.,,1illi;ji

!n 8.lil!. _

+e 1sa;i; a si :4 s. i

/.. i,!!.s,. e_ D..i!il 1.:li!!!B . .a

' g. - -

a V

\\ )l' E A' EER ' i ' <

d )j" I iI" i 1

\e . . !F L  :

5.8:

is 5

.: e

,laV- la.f i

l l

e e't I

[ l B e  !

. i b~ . 1 f

WJ li

l),

- ,L 00 ~

A l Q

%=g

. a -

" i o

~

r I

_ s ,O '

i e

i.

l l __

L- g i I

. I' l l 1l:

l-l  ; 1 6 .  !

, i

' ~

1 h

' d i g

,; il e: a[ -

t 1 ist ll f

,, a~

., i as 3

1

-n it p! E l lI l

._i l .

^

^ - -

O 7

+4 r

.(

. i . i i . a - i - i . i --._

_- _i Iu_._syd

- i11si e i *l _

i I I I I  ! j:

5 e i , s a .

a ! i 8 !

E

]2 1 j 1

~ '

- i~

2 i~ a i^ a 8  !

g-=g

.7, wg co-  ; ; i eg i jia ,I ga pal:1

1. - j J

g II1=s 8 2:81  :<

.oo 8 l 38 i' s!

S '.

.#, 4

. _ .J MJ, g' ' 5i il nsn 1

-.v Eni _

ln.

j LhW M_d,E 7

g....-m

_m.2. 1%r

__ h d

! l y p.; re- mM

- ' ~

r., 9l

.11 v "x]-W5sd:JiR

.. n s., . ;- , _ -:Q,

_4p1 ,l g -

gm - &m.N- r 'i .J I d5 hb r m, "

-kr s n, .

, _ .J

_i e e L - -

l, ij$_i f l

{

r, i

I., i

. . i - i . e - o -

i . i .

.sde,--.==an.mw,- e._e,. -4+ .

-ew . qw6 .,

rn , e.k;( .

W ,

, a .t, c;r : , , .g , , . s o- *

"~

o ,,,.c,.544+ ebo,we,saa M v#vis t d %Ws s- 4.> :++W .;

s anu a m. 4.~.4 ,ivse er -

,p a n , e , > . .,9

. - . . . . - .e i ;_e_l

• - l = .l' a t - 8 - I - I . 1 .

-! i rmi

. 1 a

l 1

- m m g y g -

l A 4 4 M M " ~ e m I i

i I A E E A

E A

E A

a*

, g l

~

h # #

$ $ h j -

l

$ $ $ $ 8

l 2

, a y 5..  ;

a , 8 , '

-

• 8 4 8 .1 0 4 n 0 4 -

n 9.. 2 g 9.. g

• E t#EE E 9R$x5 AA A" 8$$l*!

z y kg 2. m E"55 5 Et=Me EE gE E

-- " 5 55{C EC B ~# 08t"E 5 zH " g51 R .go% 5 ~k nss$aE.' A. ,g" lgs* *SC#~A B

n s .a gg tEg -

l

>FM4 If-+-0 , *G=ES S A~e, A A*

t fz ~t fPFA55 gam" 55*

g w?" "w y g GS 9 BC f y.y '@ w

~

g 0--  ;' *

• y s E en gg

.. e y EDie mgS! $Uj c-a $..

kk ,

g

$?

"ge e 5ES! y-g eg "*~

E!

g

• A ag

$9d .f '

4 E. gg" "85 5 E R

~

E ETG G J 2 R ::l .. x

. E w / 5 Ag,1 .

~L

[D .

l '

IR ,. .

~

,EU *

!N lll I

[1 3ll ii ij k.Fp ._ly .

{ -

t i

, , i i

4 I

i

~~l l 'f] $ ~

8 l l 1 .< l .

. . o i i . 9 .

i . , .

t i

, - - - - . - . ;- = -

- , . ,, n , vu . ; n w: .e ,,n  ;

,,  %> ~. ~ e -4ev>q'yryt, ph yn .y9 y o +w m . tr e >* <<1 i l

4 m494 p#e , 4./:.7 4 2 *: j e -

4 a;

y y

> <+ . -pr n ,, . a~ . . .= .y + n

. . . ey,. 4 V s

ws > , . + + ,

(  :-- :

. , . i Li . a - i - i . I -

i w

'a mmi. }

.j

.Q

.i ,

' e e e e e e mJ e

n  :

i, =s. ,11,  :,:s. t

• 3 0 3 f

' j c g

E  !" ~5 P a l 1i 2

m

~ ~

, g3 i; b Y N i i i i ! lll i' E h,.::M h::. ......c --

. ,, a*A*,

gs

!?

mf

=! ! -

.. .. . o- g =

_e - . 2 .s g, mg dvr 8 g

wl[Tg . r.

n' ieil pi silij9 ic4y(:.9)Rl

~ - -

BH 1 r ig al.

w ~

s=isie m...

uks *: E6@ $  :+: 0j,'iy.s..lli.e! l _

4, _- e7 +0] ai  !!i

m. S;A 9.g a> j!i e = e p 111,

. si gi.gg .a i

_n e n .e n&sa b f_

==

p )aN *b ; / j g

l b ....j Jii g* L...)!,

ai

,.g- , n I

^

n i

- . - - . . - , . - - , s_<r--.W i p c _,Qg 1 9 ? rg rq

.Iqt Lm '.m..N. 15<. 3y"l.j!,g, ~--

' .I f.

4-

• f + '

j h

n&

..,f y1 m m'h*Ji_

4 ....

g.... _...sq

.3.y q',

I J i + *g ge.h. 1.,g, ,

u d

i a wIML l ,

k e _

l N/ E I

e o-

,/

s,. %g{j i e i e

- 8 3 _

l

\ m -

. IJ "

l, >

SlL '

ljlj}g l WF .

1 0i [

m,

. . , - , . , . , . , . , . ,1 a

] gi ~f j 3 , _ _ .

, . _. ~. ., . . .. .-. . . . _ - _ . . _ _ _ . _ ~ . . . . . _ _ _ . . - _ _

I $ -

g y+

s -

Westinghouse: Energy Systems Box 355 Pittsturgh Pemsylvania 15230-0355 Electric Corporation -

DCP/NRCl412 NSD 'NRC-98-5756 Docket No.: 52 003

- '~

August 14,1998 4

Document Control Desk" '

Ui S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 ATTENTION:. T. R. Quay 1

SUBJECT:

= RESPONSE TO NRC LETTERS CONCERNING REQUEST FOR WITHHOLDING INFORMATION ' ,

Reference:

. 1. Letter, Sebrosky to McIntyre, " Request for withholding proprietary information for Westinghouse AP600 letters dated October 10,1994, March 30,1995, October 3,

1996, and December 18, 1997," dated July 21,1998.

2. Letter, Huffman to McIntyre, " Request for. withholding information from public  ;

disclosum for Westinghouse AP600 design letters," dated July 14,1998.

Dear Mr. Quay:

' Reference 1 provided the NRC comments that the Westinghouse letter of October 10,1994, appeared Lto contain proprietary information that was not clearly identified other than being marked

- "Wert!nghouse Proprietary Class 2" on the page and also that there was no affidavit included with the letter. The October 10,1994, letter centained errata for WCAP-14135, which is a proprietary report.

In accordance'with Westinghouse company policy, each page of a proprietary report has

" Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" on the page header. Specific information that is proprietary is then indicated with brackets, it is possible that there will be no information on a page that is marked

-as.being proprietary. In the case of the October 10,1994, letter, none of the errata pages contained

< Westinghouse proprietary information, thus no affidavit was necessary and the letter can N placed in the NRC public document room.

Reference 1 also provided the NRC comments that the Westinghouse letter of March 30,1995, appeared to contain proprietary information that was not clearly identified other than being marked

.  : " Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" .and also that there was no affidavit included with the letter. The 3

' March 30,1995, letter contained AP600 main steam line isometric drawings which have the standard

Westinghouse title block that contains a standard Westinghouse proprietary statement which should

have been deleted in this case. The deadweight analysis results had no proprietary markings. Dese

. drawings are nonproprietary, thus no affidavit was necessnry and the letter can be placed in the NRC L

i- , public document room. -

,~ > 3799swrf c r

L E% :L

~

- .- - - - . .-~

~

S. ~

c DCP/NRCl412

.NSD-NRC-98-5756 August 14,1998 Reference I further provided the NRC comments that the Westinghous letter of October 3,1996, appeared to contain propw.ary information that was not clearly identified other than being marked

" Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" on the page and also that there was no affidavit included with the letter, The October 3,1996, letter contained pages that were missing f rom some copies of WCAP-14407, which is a proprietary report. In accordance with Westinghouse company policy, each page of l a proprietary report has " Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" on the page header. Specific information I that is proprietary is then indicated with brackets. It is possible that there will be no information on a

. page that is marked as being proprietary. In the case of the October 3,1996, letter, none of the rnissing pages contained Westinghouse proprietary information, thus no affidavit was necessary and the letter can be placed in the NRC public document room. i Reference 1 additionally provided the NRC comments that the Westinghouse letter of December 18, 1997, appeared to contain proprietary information that was not clearly identified other than being marked " Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" on the page and also that there was no affidavit included with the letter. The December 18,1997, letter documented NRC agreed to revisions to WCAP-14326, J Revision 1, WCAP-14812, Revision 1, and WCAP-14845, Revision 2, which are Westinghouse i proprietary reports. In accordance with Westinghouse company policy, each page of a proprietary report has " Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" on the page header. Specific information that is proprietary is then indicated with brackets. It is possible that there will be no information on a page that is marked as being proprietary. In the case of the December 18,1997, letter, none of the errata pages contained Westinghouse proprietary information, thus no affidavit was necessary and the letter can be placed in the NRC public document room.

Reference 2 provided the NRC comments that the Westinghouse letter of February 10,1997, appeared to contain proprietary information that was not clearly identified other than being marked

' " Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" and also that there was no affidavit included with the letter. The iebruary 10,1997, letter contained drawings which were intended to assist the staff in their understanding of the Regulatory Treatment of Nonsafety Related Systems (RTNSS) implementation for the AP600 and contained the standard Westinghouse drawing title block that includes a standard Westinghouse proprietary statement which should have been deleted in this case. These drawings are nonproprietary, thus no affidavit was necessarv and the letter can be placed in the NRC public document room.

Reference 2 also provided the NRC comments that the Westinghouse letter of August 18,1997, appeared to contain proprietary information that was not clearly identified other than being marked

" Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2"' on the page and also that there was no affidavit included with the letter. The August 18, 1997, letter was issued to correct a printing error in several copies of proprietary report WCAP-14727, Revision 1, that were provided to the staff in advance of the normal mailing to the NRC. WCAP-14727, Revision 1, was provided to the staff by letur DCP/NRC0979, dated August 7,1997, which included affidavit AW-97-ll50. In accordance with Westinghouse company policy, each page of a proprietary report has " Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" on the page header. Specific information that is proprietary is then indicated with brackets. It is possible that there will be no information on a page that is marked as being proprietary. In the case of the August 18,'1997, letter, any of the pages which contained proprietary information, would have had that l material bracketed and should be covered by affidavit AW-97-Il50, which was dated August 11, )

1997. 1 me..e

.4 t

9 DCP/NRCl412 NSD-NRC-98-5756 August 14,1998

' Revision 2 further provided the NRC comments that the Westinghouse letter of November 11,1997, appeared to contain proprietary information that was not clearly identified other than being marked

" Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" on the page and also that there was no affidavit included with the letter.The November 11,1997, letter contained Revision 3 to WCAP-14776, which is a Westinghouse

. proprietary report. In accordance with Westinghouse company policy, each page of a proprietary report has " Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" on the page header. Specific information that is proprietary is then indicated with brackets. It is possible that there will be no information on a page that is marked as being proprietary. In the case of the November 11,1997, letter it was indicated that "although the change pages contain no bracketed proprietary information, they are marked

' Westinghouse Proprietary'." Since none of the revision pages contained Westinghouse proprietary information, no affidavit was necessary and the letter can be placed in the NRC public document room.

Revision 2 further provided the NRC comments that the Westinghouse letter of March 13, 1998, appeared to contain proprietary information that was not clearly identified other than being marked

" Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" on the page and also that there was no affidavit included with the letter. The March 13,'1998, letter contained errata for WCAP-14807, which is a proprietary report. In accordance with Westinghouse company policy, each page of a proprietary report has " Westinghouse Proprietary Class 2" on the page header. Specific information that is proprietary is then indicated with brackets. It is possible that there will be no information on a page that is marked as being proprietary.

In the ense of the March 13, 1998, letter, none of the errata pages contained Westinghouse proprietary information, thus no affidavit was necessary and the letter can be placed in the NRC public document room.

A large number of proprietsry evaluations covering the time period February 14,1992 to May 5,1998, have been received over the past several months, the most recent on July 22,1998. These evaluations are being processed. As a result of discussions with NRC management, Westinghouse will provide proper proprietary documentation for the proprietary material supporting the AP600 design certification

- review by August 21,1998. The responses will be provided as they are developed. It is our understanding that providing the nonproprietary versions of documents wil! not constrain issuing the AP600 FSER or FDA.

This response addresses the proprietary issues delineated in the references.

/

r A

Brian A. McIntyre, Manager Advanced Plant Safety and Licensing jml '

cc: J. W. Roe - NRC/NRR/DRPM J. M. Sebrosky - NRC/NRR/DRPM W. C. Huffman - NRC/NRR/DRPM H. A. Sepp - Westinghouse mne

. _ _