ML030070619
| ML030070619 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Millstone  |
| Issue date: | 12/16/2002 |
| From: | Wilson M Dominion Nuclear Connecticut |
| To: | Conte R NRC/RGN-I/DRS/OSB |
| Conte R | |
| References | |
| -nr, 50-336/02-301 50-336/02-301 | |
| Download: ML030070619 (91) | |
Text
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: MP2 Scenario No.: ESO2LI1 Op-Test No.: 1 Examiners: Operators:
Initial Conditions: 100% power, MOL, Eq. Xe., 821 ppm Boron SGBD (D 25 cqpm per SG, 24E aligned to 24C, TDAFP OOS for bearing replacement Turnover: 100% power, MOL, Eq. Xe., 821 ppm Boron, blend ratio: 6.3 to 1 SGBD (D 25 .pm per SG, 24E aligned to 24C, TDAFP OOS for bearing renlacement in TSAS 3.7.1.2.a and TRM II. 3.0. item 2, no other equipment OOS and no surveillance in progress or due.
Event Malf. Event Event Description No. No. Type*
1 N/A N Pump containment sump 2 CH07 N/A Earthquake causing CEA #28 to slip 35 steps into the core.
RD0328 R 3 N/A R Downpower to < 70%power for CEA recovery 4 RX11D I #2 SG Alternate steam flow transmitter failure 5 RD01 32 M 2n" dropped CEA - Manual reactor trip 6 ED02 C RSST Fault - loss of off-site power 7 EG08A C A DG breaker failure to close 8 FW30B M Degradation/loss of the 'B' AFW pump FW20B 9 I/O C Breaker A505 trip/failure to close
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor 39 of 40 NUREG-1021, Revision 8, Supplement 1
[ Millstone Unit 2 Operator StationTraining SIMULATOR EXERCISE GUIDE 1.
Title:
Simulator Evaluation ID Number: ES02LI I Revision: 0 IL. Initiated: rý 11/22/2002 (J Developer Date 111. Reviewed: /
R. J. Ashev 11/25/2002 RevieWer Date IV. Approved:
/D2at Training Supervisor
/( Date I
Title:
Simulator Evaluation Ll)Numher: FS02LII1 Revision: 0 TABLE OF CONTENTS SECTIONS LISTED IN ORDER:
I. Cover Page
- 2. Table of Contents
- 3. Exercise Overview
- 4. Instructor Guide / Summary
- 5. Scenario Initial Conditions Attachments
"* Validation Checklist
"* Training Turnover Sheet EXERCISE OVERVIEW
Purpose:
- a. Evaluate the licensees' ability, as a team and individually, to safely and responsibly operate the plant during normal plant operations. abnormal operating conditions and emergency operating conditions.
- b. Evaluate licensees in the following areas, as applicable:
I) Ability of the crew to perform crew-dependent (and time-critical) tasks.
- 2) Ability of individuals to perform critical tasks.
- 3) Ability of the crew to:
a) Understand/interpret alarms/annunciators b) Diagnose events/conditions based on signals/readings c) Understand plant/systems response d) Comply with/use procedures and Technical Specifications e) Properly communicate information/proper crew interactions f) Perform control board operations
- 4) Ability of each individual to:
a) Respond and correctly interpret annunciators b) Correctly diagnose events c) Properly interpret integrated system response d) Comply with and use Technical Specifications e) Comply with and use procedures t) Properly perform control board operations g) Demonstrate a responsible attitude h) Properly communicate information and interact with the rest of the crew
litIc: Simulator Evaluation
- 11) Number: ES02LJI Revision: 0
- 2. Exercise Brief:
The simulator will be prepared for the evaluation and the licensees ",iII be briefed on the conduct of the evalLiation and the areas in which they will be evaluated.
The simulator will be initialized at 100% power. MOL, Eq Xe. 821 ppm boron. The TDAFP is out of service for bearing replacement. TSAS 3.7.1.2.a and TRM 11 3.0 item 2 are in effect. The containment sump has been filling slowly due to a verified secondary system leak and has required pumping at approximately 18 hour2.083333e-4 days <br />0.005 hours <br />2.97619e-5 weeks <br />6.849e-6 months <br /> intervals. The surmp is presently 78% and needs to be pumped to avoid entry into a TSAS for loss of an RCS leak detection mechanism. There is no surveillance in progress and no other equipment out of service.
Shortly following the pumping of the containment sump a seismic event will be experienced.
Various vibration alarms will come in and a PEO will call in to report feeling ground movement.
The seismic event will cause a CEA partial drop > 20 steps. The crew will enter AOP 2562 Earthquake and AOP 2556 CEA Malfunctions, perform the checks of 2562 and balance primary and secondary power. After the required notifications the crew will perform a downpower for CEA recovery. During the downpower, the alternate steam flow transmitter for #2 SG will start to fail low. Feed flow to #2 SG will trend down. The SPO must diagnose the problem, take manual control, deselect the failed transmitter and restore the FRV to auto. Later a second CEA will drop fully into the core. A manual trip is required in response to 2 dropped CEAs. On the trip the RSST will fault. Both EDGs will start. but the 'A' output breaker will not close automatically or manually. Due to no cooling water the 'A' EDG must be emergency tripped.
The 'B' AFW pump will be started to feed the SGs and air will be x-tied from Unit 3. During 2525 the 'B" AFW pump will degrade such that feed will be inadequate during performance of the diagnostic flowchart. Degraded performance leads to a trip of the 'B' AFW pump. The US should diagnose a Loss of All Feed and transition to EOP 2537.
Main feed is unavailable due to the LNP. TheFDAFP and 'B" AFW pump cannot be restored in time. When 4160V bus 24E is attempted to be restored fromn Unit 3 to power bus 24C and the
-A' AFW pum-p . breaker A505 for Unit 3 to bus 24E will trip. Electrical maintenance will provide a repair estimate that %\ill require initiation of Once-Through-Cooling (OTC). Early initiation is appropriate, especially lacking a second HIPSI pump. The OTC option must be implemented if'either SG level reaches 70". Once OTC is initiated the crew must transition to
-l'(P 2540. Safety Functions must then be assessed and prioritized. The crew should enter 2540D for success path I R-3.
I tIc: SimulatorEvaluation
\umber:
ill) FS02LI I Rex ision: 0 After OTC is initiated, electrical maintenance will contact the control room informing them that tbreaker A505 xwasjust mis-aligned and can be used to power 24E and 24C. Ihe crew should bring power in froom unit 3, start the "A' AFAW pump. restore at least one SG as a heat sink, and take actions to secure from OTC.
The scenario may be terminated when feed has been restored to at least one SG with level >70" and increasing, the crew in [OP 2540D pursuing success path IHR-3. and actions being taken to Secure from0 OTC.
- 3. Plant/Simulator differences that may affect the scenario are:
None
- 4. Dluration: 2.0 hours AII Control Room Conduct. Operations and Communications shall be in accordance with Master M\lanual 14 (MP-14). Review the Simulator Operating Limits (design limits of plant) and Simulator MNodeling Limitations and Anomalous Response List prior to performing this training scenario. The instructor should be aware if any of these limitations may be exceeded.
j
SI..C IION 4
- 11) NuMIer I:.S(21.1 I R*evision: 0 Task Tinme I ),\/Ma NI Instructor lInlorination ,/\cti\itv i'Yssign E.,xpected Actions Standard Simulator Setup and Initial Conditions: Inst.
100 % Power, NM101.. E'quilibrium Xenon, RCS Boron 821 ppm IJse malfunction CCI OA (CEI)M cooler leak) Inst.
to til CTIMT SLUl1p to -78%, then delete malfunction and allow RBCCW surge tank to refill & stabilize.
\VI)R07 0.5 I.Usc Remote for a I gpm secondary system Inst.
leak in CTNIT to the normal sump.
Note: minimizc Rulnl time before session start to cnsure that the CTMT sump doesn't alarm.
- 1 +/-
I"WRI22 CI( Simulate placing the TDAFP OOS by placing Inst.
MNISR12 RI its control in L.ocal, ensuring both steam isolation valves MS-201 & 202 are racked in, N1SR13 RI place simulator in Ru., close 201 & 202, use remotes to rack out both steam stops. then yellow tag 2-MS-201, 201 and SV-4188.
I E"nter mallunction for loss of the RSST on a Inst.
TM1, EMI, plant trip.
A E1 5
SIC'TIION 4
- 11) ,ulilhcr l{ I)2l II R ision: 0 Iask lime ll),\ NlallI Instructor In lorma ion "ActivhtN Assign Expected Actions Standard t
___________________________________________ -I 4 lnter mal function to prev.ent tile A, FDG Inst. TIM2, EM,12 output breaker from closing in Auto or Manual.
_______________________________ + + I CS-,/_ 1$S3 l'.nter 1/O over-rides to prevent breaker A5(5 Inst. TMN7, FNII4 241"2 Trip (IMP3 to bus 241F) from closing and simulate a 0)n trip signal
('S-2,'2 I"S3 2412 ('Is
( )lf
______________ -I t I Brief the crew on their roles and the conduct Inst.
of the exam. 1'nsure that any questions are Iv resolved prior to starting the exam.
For Turnover Brief: Note: If asked. the CTM'lT lcakage is stable at 0.3 gpm and has been determined by sample 0 100% power, MOI.. Equilibrium to be secondary based on lack of'boron or Xenon activity and no loss from the RBCCW surge 0 821 ppm boron / Blend ratio - 6.3:1 tank or PWST.
0 SG Blowdown - 25 gpm each 0 24F aligned to bus 24C If asked how many support staff:
0 II)AIFP out for bearing replacement
- 2 I&C techs 0 In TSAS 3.7.1.2.a. and 1RM I1, 3.0, item 2
- 1 mechanic
______________________ 4 J ___________________________
6
Sl("I ION 4
- 11) \ujnhncr lIS021I1 Rcision: 0 l'asl Instructor In ormation /Activity A~ssig', tExpccted Actions Standard linc ll).\ lNalt"
('1107 Shortly after taking the watchl. (or as Inst. -I"M13, AI2 directed bh the lead examiner), enter R1)0328 3~p/i malfunction to simulate an earthquake.
(various transitor\ vibration alarms),
immediately enter mal 'unction to slip CEA 4 28 by 35 steps into the core. and call the control room as the lurbine Bldg. PEO to report minor ground movement.
.1 _____________
8
SIlU'ICI()N 4 It) N\unbcI 1{5)211I Revision: 0 I ask "I1111c l),,\ Mall Iorniation / Acti\ it Instructor Infl A\ssign Lxpected Actions Standard NOTE: Vibration alarms associated with the Crew Respond to annunciators and reports. ,"\)1* 2562 main turbine and S(iFPs \\ill immediately diagnose occurrence of a seismic event and reset. Vibration alarms for the CiAR fans & enter AOP 2562. If (I A drop indications are RCls \kill reset Ohen their reset pushbuttons identified at this time the crew may enter are depressed. The key diagnostic alarm is the AOP 2556 as well. If not. directions in 2562
",SlISMIC'INSTRIJNIMINI TRIGGERED" will direct the crew\ to check for CFA drop alarm. Key indications for the slipped CFA and 2556 will be entered at that time.
will be the red "Iflashing" C'A Group I bar on the CAI.APDS display and various CFLA group deviation alarms on C'04 annunciator panel.
-I- + t f +/- AOP 25)56 Note: With the exception of the slipped CEA, US If the slipped CEA is identified immediately, key plant equipment and parameters are all may direct SPO to balance secondary load to Al()I 2562 acceptable. halt RCS cooldown.
Query/direct board operators regarding the status of key plant equipment and parameters.
Note: As a site event, MIP3 Would take the lead for l-pha purposes. "* Pzr level. Pzr pressure
"* SG levels
"* Check for dropped CFAs
"* 1Turbine vibration
"* Changes in Radmonitors Loose parts monitor 9
'II()N 4 II) wInhCr !-ciS,)21. I I\ c\iSIo~j ()
l iNC 11-Isr Ctor ) lnfIIk 111aýt10n1 .\CtI\vIt\, A.ssi (II 1 \peCtedl .ctioIS Standard II)A MialI,
- MllP3
- Nianagcmeni Direct 'P(P) to initiate do\\ npomer of reactor and SPO to fbillow With turbine load
-. 4- 4 4 1-Note: loration from the RWAST is listed as PPO Initiate forcing spraN s. (if' not already in A0,' 2575 the preferred method and \\ill result in a progress). b\ starting all available backup pox\er reduction rate of-32% I at M()lI with heaters and lox\ering PlTr pressure controller I charging puMP. 11 boration is selected. setpoint to --2200 psia.
should determine an addition rate of 12 to 17 lay use boration to chg. Pp. Suction or alien "gpm. (possihl\ higher depending on time) to R '\ST for suction to achie\c NMay opt to use 2 charging pumps from recommended S/l) rate.
RWSl. then -64% per hour. If using RWSI suction:
Note: l)uc to slipped CF'A. no CE.\ "* Power reduction rate With I charging ml mcnlclt. (fbr ASI control or initial drop). is pump \\ill be -32% per hour (M)C) allowed during doxw\nlow0er.
"* Ulnlsure \CI h\ pass ('II- 192 closed
"* LnISULre Il 1-504 MS F suction to charging (Tpen.
", Close CI 1-501, VCTI outlet isolation
"* Check proper flo\w rate OR II using boration from BAST tanks:
12
,J C
K- 5-,
C I.-)
I-
-t 5:
I-,
K 7 7.
1 Cr: 4-0 S 0 S 5 0 S 0 C C - _
- &; C C o 0-1 7 Z -I 0 C C C -5 C
C - ' - C C r.
-4 I..) CT r.
- C C 0>
V 0
-. 0 r.
1 C- C 5- 0
'-5 0 C 4 -5 l.) ,-
7 I.)
C-(A 5 0 I-) - 5-
-- 4
-4 SC -z -5 r
/-,
(3
- r. c-I (-I 3.
rH
-S r- I -1 -, -4 -
-'-.3
.3
)
3 -3 -3 3
.3 3 p
3-.)
Ii c-i '-'-3 C
-. 3
'-'C
-W 3- D-J -
0
.3
-.3 C
'I" 3-C
-3 3 3- -3.3-3 C C J
I)
-.3 i C ('1 C 3- 3
-3 -3.
- - '3 -z
.3
-3.3-3-' '3 -
'3 -z C 3 C
--I p
7 I2
-t
-6 3
- I3 Z-- - - . - ;* - - -*
3- -..
c-li
('2
.3
.3 p
I-3.-'
7 I.
>W.)-(* Il()'K4 II) \uinhci I SUI II l'c\ i'iufl U Task I inc ll):\ NIall 1).lýtruCtolr III IornMat1011 .\ctl I It\ A\ss III I \pected Action>1 Stmiahndi cond itijons req uiring atprompt manual 2)52-)5.
trip. Nhanual reactor trip requiredl < I min.
F foIlow~ino 2 ""(TA verification.
Note. t S \\ Ill pose Lquestions re-arding these US Quers\ ITO)and SP() on1 the Status 01' Sa let\ 1)l2) 5')5 aspects ol each sa I'et\ lunction. ITO~( mid SlP( I unCtIOnS ais delineated inI R)IOP)5' r-esponses cri-tical to pr-oper- diag,,nosis and kcN
"* Reacti It\ ( ontr-ol ( PO) actions ar~e contained inI theiri Ind\\idUal sect ions. i 1mmcd atclkbll\in
- Reactor
"* Nlai ute~anIce of'Vital \uxIXI ar-ieS (S P()
- I ur11hinei
- 'Ilc~tr-ical buIses
- SW &IRIMWE
"* RE'S Ifl\ entorv\ Contr-ol (lPlO)
P/*IClVel & S('N, \.aILue & trenId
"* RC'S PreCssure- (onti l (Il)lO(
- lPZr preCssure-. Value & tr-end
"* ('ore Heat Removal ( POO
"* RCP status
" ILoop dlelta- I
" 'Ihl SCNI
"* R(CS Heat Removal (SlPO)
- SG3 pressures 880-9204 I --
15
' IýION 4 R c \ I'sI()!I: ()
H) II)fl\ NWH 1>1sk IIS t I'Ll C t ( )I' I I 11'() I'l I I i It 10 11 C t IV M A\ssi I I \plcctcJl Act*10n>s
"* R(S Ic 53)0-535 OF
"* rGIe\ CIS. value &, trend
"* R( s SCNI
- Containment (('IN I ) Isolation (1PO()
"* Radmonitors Inside C IAT N Iutside (i IANil . steam plant. not In aflarm or
"* CTM 11preSSure-; I
- (1 i'Ml VcIpeIl)rature &, PIrcssLIre Control0 WPO)
- (" I NI]T ,n('11)I)f 11 -~
CINM ppreSSure I I IT Combustihle (Gas C ontrol ( PPf3) 0 C IN/E temperature I1( I1'1 (C IT pl psure SL1IC < 1 I I ITO0 Carr\ out actions of F'( )J) 2525: F'lP 2525
"* Trip RX
"* \erilx all CHAS inserted
"* SU.R necLative and pow~er decreasing"
___ ________________________________ ________ I ___________________________________ I _________
16
,i'.("IlION 4 il) \' u mhI r I l: I .i Iý \ IsiIon 11 I inlIC ID)A N1,11l 11 Str LIC ctr
. -11n Itio I ..\ICt I\ It Task
\SS-ig'n SI() (Carr\ out actions of () P 2525: I ()1'S'I 2525; ilkl. I SI)rip turbine. ensLIre \ al \CS chOsed. NI\\\ c [(CI
- 0. and 8I&9T open
- ldentil\ loss o0 RSST v\ ith buses 25A&B. 24A.B,&C dead
- ldentil\ bus 241) being carried b\ Il)GI 1 Identify FIDG 'A' running but not.closed OfltO bus 24C
- D)etermi ne need to trip "A I'II)G after attempting to close ouItputl breaker
- MSIVs closed and main1 feed lost due to loss of (ires and condensate
- \ttempted feeding S(is m\ith B AFAW pump. inadequate discharge pressure
- X-tie air from MPP3
- Should dispatch PIO to check ruininZ 1 IiG (not procedurallv directed)
I ________________
17
,>1(1 ION 4
\CW iion: ()
I 1N 1
I iic IDA. Miall, IIs t I LICt I' I I I I-I I i t II Ct t I,-\fpCteJ .\ction>s S tzmiiJ1-d 1A 1()(
I I NC r-emote Innct ionl to open Air- clross tic fr-oml Inlst.
()PI \ MI M ~hnIC I( is dispatched to perfrm111 Idigicinnet.
I-\\ 2 MI tiher the pnmTp has been identi ted. insert Ilst.
MaI11t inOello to CaLISe tie brecaker- to tr-ip.
SM Id en tl\y inadCLq nate 1`edC/degrlaCIed porn pl 1A252 per'orn-11anlcepun111p tr-ip.
r US IPertorm-11 diagnostic Ilo\\char-t. di agnose a ILOAF\ . and tr-ansit ion to F)OP 25~37.
r Note: The SM wýould classify this event as an ,Alert/C-I based on IPA2, 'Single AC Source' I i 1
Is
(0 K - '-I.- 7 A- C..
A
-C J
I K)
K- -,
- A 4-.:
'C' (0
(0
-- (0 Cf (0
Cf V.)
V.)
4-.
I (0
J I -i K Cf
.1-
'7
¶ C'.
(10 p- 4
- - 0 0 0(0
- - (00- -'- C
' CL 0
- Cf Cf C.. C-'
- c:;- - -- K)
,- I-.
Cf 3 I
-N (0 r
K)
V-i K
(0 (0
C-C.
0
,--C: <2 I>
C- (0 (0 -4.
(0 H .T r I C'
K) ,- V.)
V.. (F - (0 (C
- -(0 r -I C. C; (0 K)
A (0 - (0 K)
.3 2..)
-4 -4
C-.
-rI
(-I 1
9-. 19
--9 19 19 p 19 1) 19
-r 19
(-I 19
- 1, 19 11 9 19 19 I-,
19 19 (C I-'
9 If, 1, 19 19 19 19 7 (C 19 z 19 C
(-19 19 19 19
-r 19 CO C-' 19 19 19 19 -c Cr 19
-A) 19 19 C- 19 91 19 91 19 19 I-0 0 0
- 9 Ir
-I, 9-9-.
7 9
(-I
'Cr- __________
9- 19 ,)
I)
/ 19 -)
19 I) C
- 19
-9 I)
'91 19 If, 19 -9 1' p -9 19
-3/4 - 19 9- -
19
-V I- -I
/
-I
-9 19
,-i (I C II ()N -4 RC\ Islow ()
.I ý1,ý 1,
I Ii \a II iDA M In-,ti-Lictol. 1111,01-111,1tioll An \ M VS s i II ixý,pected .\ctiolB" St I I Iý-I 1k Note: 11, 11eces5si r-N to 'et tile scenario ti S I ýascd on the i abi Iit\ to re'dol c I SOLUre of' III() Ing, 111:1N c11l its Ops D~ept head for Iced aind icss than a ILbill comiincp men of*()']'('
status upd(ate andl recommendI early OTC equipHmen1t (1I IISI ) dCcis10on Thonid be ma1,de rathier thani "hope', fOr Feed. to Initiate ()U I(cari-\
-- I 4-( T-2 ("HR-I1): Establish OTC. NMust be I jS D)i ret the fbi io\\ I2 1`0i P 7 in itiatedI it' either SG e elcdi(ecreases to <
0 XIil irhaters 01il ('I-2 70 inchtes N% ide range leveciN~ itli no feed Not] reCe to either SG.
- B~oth A DVs Clli \ openi 0 /2 SIAS actuated
- Alil a\ ailabie I IPS1 &,Chu. Pumps
$ Both P( RV block \ alvcs open
- Open both PORVS LSIMin ie\S
- I'ransit ion to [.')OP 254(
-4 Note: Initiation of ()T(' is still an Alert/C-I hased on RC132 RCS Barrier loss.
I-21,)
Ikl()\ 4i I)
IDA \kti!* t I-LIC t( ) F I I 1 1-111d I i II An \ It\ (-, II S.ý I I \p~cctcl .\cli k) W lPCIkrn0-11 direct Initial actions"' ()1 -'()112 >40:
- >aImpl) S(iS FOP 2l5>4()
- Place 1121 anal \ Cr III SCIAxcc SlP( )penl SG Sample isolationis anld Contact
('henl"istr\ to sample S( Is lfOr boron. actix Itv arid a ClUick IlrISk\l\ x j (qUIcl rcport.
Place 11V 11V nal\ InSCI CI Iii Cc Icr uiCL III 1741 Appcndi\ 19 ol lOP)[ 254 1 li)l
"* In1SUre RIM fani F3,)l3 o)IT
"* 1'SLuure RNI inlet & oLutlet ( *\( -ý27 AC-528) close:d
" FInsure opcin lB89 ;-47. & \C-2h
"* Place 112 anlal xiCr Control S\\ Itch monientaril\ to RI SI IV
"* Ch ec k R ed pum U~ I xc I 14I)\\CI'IIý]I I )N
"* Check all alarm lights not ( )N j
- C
~ ,! -- __
1+" t I "*+ 'I S- - ,I.'
,j . __ -
.-* - C) ,-. _
. -- o]-
/. - .p ... ,
-- c-I
_, ! ,.r* " -- / . . 1
- 1) -- .. _ _ * .
C)+ C r- I t -- "*!r U- C) -'
- - 9 .r , -j
= -- "-1 ;r -r
/-I 0 J- .)3
SIiJ1 I()N 4 II
<iiIIcA Mal!' IWASfl: ()
Ia A\
Insti-Lictm. lillm-Inatiml cti t 1.*,Xl)ectcd Aclion.s I ii I4 1 (IS As~ess steps I thrirtiu0h 4 ()1 25~401) 1I R3.
(Steps I througfh 4 are cepeatsý Citact ions Mien in FOP 2537)
Is I)C"ternt n that reCstloi uci' piM er to buIS 24C
\011I aIlo\v pomoerhng -A- AM pulup and ircstoring Wced.
(!mntct U n it 3 to req ILICet per-mission to X-tic
[)uses Irlonll .10I3.
1,0 1)2__4n()1 A. I nit 3 SM ILUtKzc NIieP2 to Wte buses Inst.
and pov\CleL1up 241-, and 24(
\ ftr icei in autlli.ri/ation horn IUnit 3 to take pow4xer. ci ect SPIN to, \-tie thu Uonit 3 to) 24Li then pox~ r up 24(C and start 'A'
.\I\'A pLiflip.
24
f 1 13 I p
- I 3
-)
I -r 3
r -.,
-) -, r r
- 1)
- 3
- - 1)
C- *) * * - 0 0 0 p
r
- I
-F f -J. I I
Kr -
I I I
C 7
S..( I !fuN 4 1W ision: ()
I imt: II)D \ N111f IIN ILuCk ) IIIt WM~r t it)~n I .A \l it\ I lI I-,.\pCC1CJ Actioný-, > ,t 'I I' lid 1
SP() t Tsing 'AIV.\I,\ PUMtP cd one or both S(is. 1,() )2 4())
(as directed). to ,70"0, Ie\ el and report completion to U s. \li\ \Cril\ ability of
,.\I)V(s) to establish stcamiuin, 4 i -
IT(O Rlcport (T1. Fs (00(1, and not rising, IJ )1)2540)1 Report ,\NIAMS IC\ .
I ;11'ý Since success path P0-3 is not iWuse and 1{()t254(d1 other conditions arc met. direct closure 01 N()R Vs.
-t PP() (lose both P( , h,; Stining kc- s to close.
\When the 11)*0\s have been closed, the Inst.
scenario ma' he terminated. The scenario ma- be terminated at an earlier time at the evaluators' discretion based on time and completion of critical tasks.
\kIUII(\I I \K
- ( 'I - 1: ( riliudil IHI"C( on the corv ibciig outsitd of dflalvyc(I WOY react iv iQ, coniditions~
wQ 02 a~~i1 prom1ffpt manualtd IQi.
- ( T -2 (11 R- 1): Es t a 11is h ()T(C \lust Jhe i n i tialt c( if ei thecr S( leve I (Ieccreases to < 701 i nch11es iý i (Ie rangie level with io feed source to either SO.
- (TI-3 ( [A)A [-4): Establish a prima ry to seconda ry heat sink.
,7.
-Zr T -I-, . I*_ ->
I--I -r "I":'I ,-- - L -,
I-
- _- ,)
7A CI
-N
~ - Si 1 >1 C
I1)2 SI vLM L TO I TRA IN IN G SHIlFT I 'TRNOX'FR RETPORT I (M llRA1k.N*N,(, 11SF1 ONIV S11i1i,11,1t0t SCen,1i 10: I ýxti l II PLANT STATUS:
./(tL)E. 1 RXk'POIIER: 10"t tI/ ItV,1I fS: 1hcimiil:'O69 \l's I 1'/I PRESS: 2250) psa Iccii icý 900 Ml\\ I l&'S YI-WE. ý7 dceucs, I 1C '//Ik.(;I Idilitililedl 0(02_ -' n ( LOll 1011,N " 15] 2 tur il~sl il I it dent fi tid 0. 147 '11pin p' 1 1I s Mi II II)trs Bi/ F\/R, I~ 1110 I iý l. :i RC'S /301/ON' 8? 1 ppmn 1-V0.\ il/i iXD. stable L.IT 1,2 SI C'P0S.S'IE: Isolatied 1.5/7 Rl',\N!). tiahlc i10t" SE [I/. I7 TIN:. S\mip lied bKI 3 AUXm. NI LW!I/,e tt'I Weic', lic'nutmenlemtdor C'STIa (l100 1 Is LC() aind TRNM ACTION Statements Coming Due D)ale Timte LCO I ACTIONI ACTION REQUIREMENT EQU IPMENT I REASON X N\ XtIf2 2 miS 37. 1 a W~ith I AN FN pumfip inloperable. i estare to I PtAFVp Pl'i bearitte wsork 0IlTlRABLI" SILI stts ithin '72 haiti or bie int at leaist I 10TSI 'sAND1Yssithiit the rite\t 6 macLirs and in I 1To SHllTD(A)WN ssithiit the t'ot lossinuc 6 hour11Sý a Recstore operabi Iits 01 at lected I I),AIP 1711-1111 bean n\xar XW hr, (L 'M_ tentm com1ponent wi thin 7 das s onmintinuos i's ECOan TRM ACTION Statements in effect
____1 ACTION REQUIREMENT ILCO I ACTION I EQUIPMENT I R EASO)N iimlie fiat inloperable S ent path closed w5ith po'~tce IM R~,S P/Rl %etit 'Mannais isolated dueIto ittii(\ ed Ii-ll amlte s alses. Main1tainl onec PO0RN' &_block x .h.l so IcItoid~~s leakace ~2 RC-441) is a'ls e oper able. closed).
I S'SiV I/(ONPON ENT AVAILA13ILITY: (systemns, components oflt of'serN ice, dev'iations from required system) atitnIn~ents. the nieedi for valv~e lineuips or other restoration activities)
.ICOMPONENT V\~ STATUS I I Ppmip 1()hiit tciice kw1hcar imi \ko rk I-1i -2111'3 CROSS UNIT EQUIPMENT STA~TUS list the status at all U nit I and U nit _3equipment alionmnitts that effect I lit I.k lire- pr-otection. BuIs .34A B. CirclaC~tine- %Vater(dilutionl floss) etc.
i2e
\ýYS VE\1 STATUS Ui\ SIC;Iot U-3-1 S pli) 111- c U- aMIX steam (tram1 i nlit :: A\i' Ilailci-f
-1 1Z MI)WASTE SYSTEM STATUS (AR\V, CLRWI, CPF,' GRVV) (identify water'gaseous inv~entory' problems. discltarles in pao'-r'ess at- planned.)
S~s I- , S1A US 1\ W 1i11111,i11y,( IM \ V siiip (111 I1 houri li'qC~IICn \ puaine- pl ilir lo hjIi Ic t,1 :111m i,) oldt I '. ~ '
~.1R\'ILANC~iEOI'TINSIN PROG;RESS / ('(d 0h'1 -
FORZ TR.INI\(; I SF ONLI N
.Attlach filent SC_'!NARI() ATRIMITES (CIHIECKISTI c'-c,_n iio [ic. SimlulIt[ion FV\QauIL]i,,n Num hcr: I-'Si21 11 Ichicllii 1 \ e\\er: Richurd N Spurr )ate.: 11 22,__)0_
\ I,...HI\T1 VI- ,r'\T FR' 113][:
iT1'S'
" 1. The initial conditions are realistic, in that some equipment and/or instrumentation may be out of service, but it does not cue the crew into expected events.
Y .... 2. The scenario consists mostly of related events.
Y 3. Each event description consists of:
- the point in the scenario when it is to be initiated
- the malfunction(s) that are entered to initiate the event
- the symptoms/cues that will be visible to the crew
- the expected operator actions (by shift position)
- the expected Emergency Plan classification the event termination point (if applicable)
...Y-... 4. No more than one non-mnechanistic failure (e.g.. pipe break) is incorporated into the scenario without a credible preceding incident such as a seismic event.
Y 5. The events are valid with regard to physics and thermodynamics.
S_ 6. Sequencing/timing of events is reasonable, and allows for the examination team to obtain complete evaluation results commensurate with the scenario objectives.
N_/A_.__ 7 If time compression techniques are used, scenario summary clearly so indicates.
Operators have sufficient time to carry out expected activities without undue time constraints. Cues are given.
Y 8. The simulator modeling is riot altered.
Y 9. The scenario has been validated. Any open simulator performance deficiencies have been evaluated to ensure that functional fidelity is maintained while running the scenario
t hIn el lt (;uide No.: IS0I.21AI I SC(
(\'TT 1INI, () CI
! 'I"1C IS I Note: Following criteria list scenario traits that are numerical (quantitative) in nature. Credited malfunctions tasks and procedures should be bolded in the evaluation guide.
1 Total Malfunctions (TM) - Include EMs - (5 - 8) 7
- 1. RSST Loss
- 2. 'A' EDG Output Breaker Failure
- 3. CEA #28 Slipped 4 #2 Steam Flow Transmitter Failure
- 1. RSST Loss
- 4. Breaker A505 trip/failure to close Abnormal Events (AE)-(2-4) 2 1 Loss of Off-site Power 2 CEA Malfunctions
- 4. Major Transients (MA) - (1 - 2) 2
- 1. Trip due to 2 dropped CEA's
- 2. Loss of All Feed 5 EOPs entered requiring substantive actions (EU) - (1 2)
- 4
- 6. EOP Contingencies requiring substantive actions (EC) - (0--2)
- 1. Trip 'A' EDG-No SW 2 Initiate OTC
- 3. Restore Bus 24C for 'A AFW Pump
- 4. Terminate OTC
Critical Tasks (CT)- (2 - 3) 3 1 Trip due to 2 dropped CEA's 2 Establish OTC
. Establish Primary--to-Secondary Heat Sink
. Approximate Scenario Run Time: 60 to 90 min. Total 120 q Technical Specifications exercised during the scenario (Y/N) Y
,4
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Op-Test No.: 2 Facility:
Facility- MP2 MVP2 Scenario No..- ESO2LI2 Scenario No.: ES02LI12 Op-Test No.:- 2 Examiners.- Operators:
Initial Conditions: 100% power, MOL, Eq. Xe., 821 ppm Boron SGBD (0) 25 qpm per SG, 24E aligned to 24C Turnover: 100% power, MOL, Eq. Xe., 821 ppm Boron, blend ratio: 6.3 to 1 SGBD ( 25 qpm per SG, 24E aligned to 24C, no equipment OOS and no surveillance in progress or due.
Event Malf. Event Event Description No. No. Type*
1 N/A N Swap CTMT penetration cooling fans 2 CW02C C C Traveling Screen DP high 3 SG01B C SGTL in #2 SG 4 CV04A C Backup charging pump trips 5 N/A R Downpower due to SGTL 6 SG02B M Steam generator tube rupture 7 RX01A C Main spray valve stuck open on trip 8 RX14A, C SD&BV's to condenser fail closed when rapid RCS cooldown B,C,D is attempted
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor 39 of 40 NUREG-1021, Revision 8, Supplement 1
[* Millstone Unit StationTraining 2 Operator SIMULATOR EXERCISE GUIDE I.
Title:
Simulator [Valuation
[D Number: ES02L12 Revision: 0 II. Initiated:
11/22/2002 Developer Date Ill. Reviewed:
Re'ie 11/25/2002 Date IV. Approved:
1 toi Iraminin Supervisor Sate
It I,2 Sin LuHatorI aluatlon Ii) *\ul ein cr lS02(_l llC\ IislOn: ()
IFA\BILE OF CONTENTI S "SI;ClI" NS LISTE1) IN OR)l)R:
- 1. Co\ er Page
- 2. TIahle of 'ontents
-. :I\ercise ()\ \rviex
- 4. Instructor Guide . SUmLml1arv Scenario Initial Conditions A\ttachmenlts
"* Validation Checklist
"* Training TIurnover Sheet XFERCISEI OVERVIEW
Purpose:
- a. 1'Valu-ate the licensees' abilitv. as a team and indixidualhx. to safely and rCsponsibly operate the plant during normal plant operations, abnormal operating conditions and emergency operating conditions.
- h. ELvaluate licensees in the flollowing areas, as applicable:
I) Ability ofthe crew to perform crexx-dependent (and time-critical) tasks.
- 2) Ability of'irdividuals to pert'rm critical tasks.
- 3) Ability ol the ere\x to:
a) t Inderstand&interpret alarms/annunci ators b) l)iagnose events'conditions based on signalsreadings c) Understand plants>systems response d) Conmply \N ith/use procedures and Technical Speci fications e) trope-rl\ comimunicate inlormation,'proper cre\x interactions f) Perlborm control board operations
- 4) ..\biitx ofeach Individual to:
a) Respond and correctly interpret anllnluncilattors b) Correctl\ diagnose ev ents C) lroperl, interpret integrated systein iesponrsc d1) C'oil)py \\ ith and use Technical Speci ftcat ions c) ComplN \with anld use procedLIuCrS C') liroperl\ pei1rf'orm control board opcratil)lns
- 1) D)Cmonstrate a responsible attitude h1) Properly communicate in lo lnlatioll and interact \\ith the rest of the crex\
titIC: S iIIIt I110r -\ alI Imi t
II) Nuner: 021 12 Rexision: 0
- 2. 1t\xcrcisc Briel:
lh si viul]Iator \\ill be prelrpnCd or l he Cx ail atioli and the licensees \Nill be briefed on tlhe conduct otthe eCValuation and the areas in x\hich the) \\ill he exalUated.
hIe simlulatOr xwill he initiali/ed aLt 100% o po\\cr. N10I.. lq Xe. 821 ppm boron.
\Vork control requnCsIs that the 13' Penetration ( Iing fan C00be placed in service and the 'A' secured due to cleaning actixitics in the oxvrhead of the West piping penetration room. There is no equipment out of service and no surxeCillance in progress.
S"hortlI after shifting the penetration cooling lans, the "C' traveling screen D11 wiii start a ramp increase due to a sheared pin in the drive gear. In response to the alarm, the crey,. ,.ll enter A()P 2517. Circulating Water NMalfunctions. The crew will need to x-tWe xater-boxes due to the loss o1 the C("(imrC pLunp.
Next a 2 gpn S(aII. "All cause an N I6 radmonitor alarm followed bh a S. I., alarm. The crex\
xxill enter ,\e1P 2569. \xcrif\ the leak. log TS.\S 3.4.6.2.c. and enter AOP 2575 to commence a Rapid I)o\xxnpo\xxer. When forcing pressurizer sprays. one oflthe \ ai cs xvill stick partially open.
lihis \\rill not he noticeable until the plant is tripped. During the downpower the lead charging pump Nwill trip. This must be diagnosed and an alternate pump started or charging and letdown restored (if lost on high letdown temperature). [he SGTI. x ill become a SG'IR. The crewx should respond to the increased loss rate and MS1 RNM alarm and manually trip the plant. The PPO should identify the failed open spray valve during EOP 2525 and stop the associated RCPs. The I "Sshould perform the diagnostic flowvchart diagnose a SGTR and transition to EOP 2534. A cooldo\\ n to :-.515' 1Fon both loop 1hots must be performed. All 4 of the SD&-BV valves xx ill tail closed \when a cooldown to the condenser is attenipted. This xxill require that the crew use the
\I)Vs to pcn'orni the cooldown. The ruptured generator must then be isolated. Fol io\x inc ISalution ofthe ruptured generator. the primary-to-secondart leak rate should he milnimized b\
control ling RCS pressure at the loxxcr end of the allowable pressure range and the RCS cooldoWni
,should be resumed.
\Vhcn the ruptured gcenrator has been isolated, the cooldoxvn resulmed. and RCS pressure beinc controlled at the lovxer end the exam scenario may be terminated.
PIant Simulator cli Iferences that max alffect the scenario arc:
None D)uration:
- l. 1.5 hours Ai (Contirol Room tConduct. Operations and C'ommuntications shall be in accordance with N-laster Sanulunl I 4 (l 1P-4). Reviexx the SiAW=lator ()perating LIimits (design limits of plant) and Simulator
\ lodelini X limitations and .\nomlaJious Response INist prior to performing this training scenario. lhe ilistHmc toi should be ahxare ifanx oflthese Ii itations m1a\ be exceeded.
SI:C"I IMN 4 II ) \ LI H 11)C I I ý ý, ( ) -' 1. I -) i1\)C\ l 1)lo I ask\
IDA \NIall IllStFLICtOl' ACtI\ it% I xpcctcd cIoi >taillaLrd W-4or Si1mu1'a1101 SetupJ and Initial Ciond itions: Inlst.
equiL\ aIlent 10 '/"() 1Pov\ er. NE)! I (]u ii hri urn XenIon.
RCS B~oron 82 1 ppm- no I S. S. no equipmenIICt ( )( )S- andC no0 SurI-\CII! Ice inl proere'l-SS. UnISure- "B' (TaringI11ý12 pump11 is al (,iced to I-aci Ii P 2) aind the ('0)2 am icoid aeree'cs.
RXO1\ 2 I nlter malflunction to stick spray \aI \e RC' Inlst. TNI 2, F-N I I 131T1 I ()()1: 2 5ý0 ope o~iCl o a plant tri-p.
F i i i BI ie F the crew\ onl their roles and the condcIIt Inlst.
oF the exam. 1 nsure that anN queIstions are' rcsol%ccl prior to starti nu the exam.-
t .4 4 For Iuri-io\,l erlIeie :
0 10W/0 pow\er. NIOLI . hLiilibrium111 Xenion
.2 82)1 ppm boron / Blend ratio - 6.3:1 01S( T' 1311ox'~domi - 2 5 (,Pil each
)241 al'-igned to bus 24C' No equLipmen~lt 005 and 110 ISAS
- 1) No surveillance in1progre1'SS or duIc 4
C-.
I- 7 C.
-I Cf -C
- C 7 C C-.
-C C;
C; C-(C; I
C; C- C: V.
C; C. I C
C; C; C- C C-.
C- C.
-C 7
C- Cr C-.
C- 'C:
C; C C-.
C-
- r. C-C; C-.
C:
ci I
7 V. 7 V
C;: A.
_____ 7
- - r.
C:
- r _ C-.
'-' r rr C-.
C-.
(f C- p C-.
- -, r r
.- r C
C C-.,
I ___L._______ ______ _______
C w
-I-i-i I-' [-3
-I' -3,
-I -- 2
SI (* l( )\ 4 I I) \ LI lI~y I) IS I i I
I aisk I MA II11 Mall 111':ýtl'LICI[0 1' 1111'0 1'111ý11[10 11 A CH \ It\
1 \pectCJ \ciion> ,-,,tum ji rd SP() SeCCLre -C C(i ire. PrIm pJand \-t ic %\\aterboxesh,0om .\OI'25 17 T rip oi. \ eni t\ri pped the ( Iirc. Pp.
0 Close 'C" \atcrhox inlet O pen T, to 1D) \-tic I) S(10)1I1 200~ Insmert m1a! u'Lnctionl or0a 2,gpmI S( ii I[. inst. TN 14, FE2 C'reC\\ Identikl SG tube leakatce h\ N- 106 alarm and/or MNINI 4 I S.IAL' radmonitor alarm.
I _______
7
s:,I 1lu\ 4 II\LiIll~ I Si 12I l<c\klolljo Q)
I I S I I-LIC I I- I I I I-I II ýI t I II I I\ It I:Xpkeetcd \ct'l01InS St~tn),Lird I'jS 1-nierl A0, )P 69: \t)l269 VeriIx \Val \ ClOSL~res d LIe to SJI.\ RbNI a!arm11
"* S(G Blo\\ do\\ NIS 220\&B
"* B10\\ dx\Vn QuenchI~ tank J isci troe M S
"* SGi llowdo\\ ni tank dr1alin NIS- 15 As N 0O report that IfV\-4287 and IIV-4288 "* Secondlar\ sample panel SG sam pie arfClo (sedI. isolations IIV-4287 &NI lV-4288 ( ocal
- VCr-il\ S(113 F) input to calori metric at 0 opm per
- Conifirm leakauce In 42 SG. N-I 16 RN I. as >7a upd an1d ri-sing( bN ->I 5 gpd per //-hour and dirct plant doxk flpo\\ er at -50% perI hour11 (dIispla\ ed oil PIT)
Di rect P1t0 actionls to prc\ Cili 1,nmoni toreCd recleases:.
"* Veritl\ ('N--3,34 closed
"* SecureF condenser pit sumplj pumpIIs
"* Realli e SJAI' altcrcon Icr Jrai us
"* 1stahl ish Chem. Salinpijue oF OSumps11.S
sL I t()~ \
Kc\u i: 0 I IDA Nhil III-StRICtOl- LXpcctc(I A.V,1tIiu SIlmdilr SNI Itis ()uanltif sI" (ITl leak rate in excesS of, I'S I.('( ) of, 0.()'5 gpm per SG1 and enter I SA\S 3 .4.0.2.c V 4-SN IMa\ be reqILIeSted to ak~hoe Sor1 1 all Of tIS 1uiner AN')25 75. Rapid Domi pon er the ruiredLIICC noflticatiouls
- [irect/remind cre\\ to rcl'cr to \ tutchinents I. 5.
& 6 duine (ilol I\\ IIPO\\ CerW RapId I)0\\ 111)0\\ er Note: SM N)IITou Id claSSI i\ aIS Ich1O dueI to p~lant Parameters, Temperature \ S. l~o\\ er lProe'-raita &'
ShutdO\\ I-t requCire b\ I ech SpeCcs. Rapid lPowc r ()vet\ie\\)
- Make not if-cations reuarditw downpo\\ er 0 [P1re: chat 1"ctdlo\\
ine 1I lcrea',e 0 CONVI'X & Iso -NI, A()P 2575
- N4I1 1 0 NilanaoC1cmet D~irect PP() to initiate dm\\ flo\\ct* of ceactor and StP( to 1`lto\\ Mth turb-ine load
_f- -
P110( Initiate f'orcinlg Spray's ii n1ot at read\ In prog; ess.S) by startine. all availtable backup heaters and 1moweri tie A F23 tZr pre-ssure' con~trllerCI Setpoittt to 2200 psia.
Nia\' Use boration to ch(,. Pp). SUtIct1 0o1o-aie to RW\ST tI1 frsuICtion to achie\ e recommended SAI) 1 rate.
k)
l ( I It i\
t\it\
A A sg ',lC tdA tOI
- l0\ cricd u-CIon raic I-M ithi 2 charti ne: P l, \\il he 6~4) Oper hour ( NR)()(
- Ensure VC1Fb\ pass (Al1- 192 closed
- ,InSure-CI 1-504 R\\ S I sulction to chargin2,, open.
- ('lose C'I 1-501.ý VC IoLItlCt iýSolationl (heck proper llo\\ rate 1or 2 pumips:
C Ifusing0 boizitoi fRom RAN!\S tanks:
- Insert (T'.As an initial 5 to 10 steps Del~termine boration rate olF 20 gpm
- korate to charging pp. >uLCt ion h\
0 LInsure- N/1I I iode Select. S\%iteh inl Dlkite
- Linsure xake s M1I Stop \'alxc (11- 12.
ICM/ i llýpa~ss ClI1-l196. and RV'S I Vsol. Cii 1192 aill closed.
- EnISurIe BA C'ontollerICI lk-210)'Y inl A\uto
- AdjuIst EC-21I Y to 20(1g pm d* OpenI CI 1-50-l
C-"
7 f*
'1
-f C E C;
CL - _
c Cf CC; r C C - C r
r C;
C C r.
Cf Cf -
Cf J Cf Cf.
r Cf Cf r; - C-.
'CL V
C I C-.
C; Cf CL c q-
'*1 7-K> 7-
'Cf.
C-.
CfGr
..'1
..-. C
- 0 0
- Y CL - - - r A C;
'-p C-
- C- . C-, -* ., .,cr C-.
I' . C-_
_ - C
- -, C C** -,. - 'I C-.
'- C
'CL r I Cr- - r .1 A
-. C; Cf 7
-. I C-' -
I'- C; C;
-C z
- I z I-C r
-CC
-- 'ii
Sk I 1()\ 4 1\".,\ Islom. ()
1ýIý,:I\
IIIM I'LlCtol' III 16FIlIdtIO11 A Ctl\ It\ \Ssi 1-111 LXI)CCtcd w*1011.1, stmldmd Place loll l`.\Chll1_(_,c 1ý\ pýiss. (A 1-5 III B pLlss
" ()I)Cll!,CIISLIIc Open Letdom l I,;o1,ttI0I1S CI 1_ý I CI 1-ý 16ý and CI 1-089
" Acl*ust HIC-1 10 1,01. 1_ý"pill lctdom i. CI)SUI-I'll" lctdomi backl)l-CSSUrc 40().-
olic chal-LIllu, pump Alter -40 scconds. adjUSt I.Ctdo%\II I)LlCkl)I-CSýýUFC to - ,)Oo-t,,, and slill't PIC-201 to Auto IW-I 10 1`61' 40 lCtClOMI Ad'LIS C71 Place Lctdoml 1,11111ter III Normal Adjust HIC-] 10 to restorc 11/1. Ic\el to 11ormal Place lon Lxchangc B\ pass to Auto Verlk Char"Illu,pump all'-,11111clit to he LAW PS 0 P2304A i.c.ý one Opcrahlc chm-ging I)Llllll) ý111(111(2(i to cach facIlItN .
( 10 -)I i I So/ Insert limil'Unction 1`61- tile SGAA, to to list.
MO sec ramp a S( I I R 450 upm In :1C SO mcr a 5 mliIII-ItC period.
\;1 ( ilhl 1ý ,
i\<C\ [,, flol: (
I ýý,4 I IDA M.\1\! 111, t I' LI(ý Ii I F I II I'( ) I I I I ýI [ I t ) I I A CH\ It\ 1.I\pctcJ, \ctill.'1 ll 4ýlll
- Chlic. Illiisnxitch. or
- NRisinl" riidninntur'ý. or WIl146
- N ainl Steam IncRdwtr(NS151 RN I alarm11 S I*
Direct plant trip and IJl 2>> oin verified N\S k1'l alarill onl CO01 alarm panllýI P~erform mlanlual recacito 11,11) h\ dcpiressi no 4 tinp button" oil ('04.
Note: [ !S \\1ill pose qu estionts radinthese ()uer\ PIP( and SPO( onl theC suatti a! of, Sact\
a'spccts a! cad sal~t Icixfnctionl. j) P( and S P( Fun ctions~ as dei n1CaIted In H W ~3 response,ýs ciii call to prapcr di(I lacsi s and kex
"* Rcaeul\ It\ (Cantrol (1P)()H aIctions ate COntained InI thir11 1111x idaL4
\ýCdtiai.imc aexI Ilaxx inc.
- Reactor
"* NlaI IItI c atIIC 01' IaL \n~LIN JHCSS POl~)
II T*Lrhinle ELietrical bu'c>
- SW\ & RlIW(\V
- RCS [nvclntor\ Contrrol 1)(
P(
- PZ1r lex e &' S('.\ Ia ILne & trend 13
C
,r-J r
I C 4--
- 0 0 2
- *
- 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
- 0 0
- 2- C-
_ - ,-.- z ,-- 2: C - - _
-I r C-m '-C 1 C _
t-' C r j - c -
C
- - C- C
') - C r C.
- ,- C K -, C r.
- I -C;
.1
[-2 C.
I 2-2-
rf
-f
-CItl ION -1 11 II)
N ,\mnclL.A S 02 1.1 S.\ isilon: (0 I d~k I IniN zlI'
~ l)A.\ I nStructtoi Inlrn1atio / A\ctiM\ it\ A\ssiOn l~xpctcd\ction'il, K - *Ci NI )l-cSSLII1C1 SP() Perlfornm SPIA and reporlt icsults w\.henl queried: ! ( )1 2525 SLIurb tripped. valves closed. SI & 9T1 open All electrical buses energized A
2 SW. 2 R13, feeding \\ithl main feed
IA 1 normal PPO Pcrfornm Sl'I'A and report results \v hen queried: 1()1> 2525
- Rx trip, all CEAs iII. I)\ver dropping, SURJ neCative.
P/1rlevel & pressure low and dropping.
- Spray valve RC-1001' partiail open. wonit close in manual, trip 'A& C Rl(Is. B & D RCPs may be secured as well if pressure continues to lOwCer and I-IIC-4165 in Manual closed if all R(.Ps secured.
Verify or initiate SIAS/(lAS/'I13FS \when pzr pressure approaches 1714 (ma. be actuated approx. 1800# decreasing IAW,,\Master Manual MM-1 4 instructions I5
Si(I I)N 4 II) >UIHI)CI >)2I.l2 \,Cisioll: ()
Lime II ),.\ NlaI Instructor Inlormation A\ctivitv 's'];k-)l Expected Actions
"* Verify one train of('ontrol Room Air Conditioning (CRA('S) in recire.
"* RCS temperature norma l
"* Radmonitors inside & outside ofCTMI not in alarm or rising
"* Secondary system radmonifors in alarm or elevated.
", CTlMT pressure and temperature normal.
1 VS Query PPO & SPO regarding the status of (OP2525 subsequent actions t I* 1( 1' 2525 SPO Report subsequent actions complete and verified when accomplished.
+ Report subsequent actions complete and verified when accomplished.
i
[iS Perform diagnostic flowchart and diagnose S(GilR.
(based on N-I 6 response and MSLRNM should idenuifv #2 SO). direct enry into 1-£OP 2534 S(iTR.
_ - I___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
16
S IX Il( )\ 4 I\C\ 5101). (
1 ý[.-ý
ýý I ii.nc MA) M all, Io'~tructol. II 1ni1rnLt loll .\Acti\ It\ L-,xpcctcd Action', id
'I8fl(II fvSikva 'R vvt samlpi ini) o I S(GS. 1 1) 2 )s4 Note: A\'tl I~Ini ruites 1(i]O\l lovin re(quest 15e SP() Open SG sample isolation \ aI\ es. contact C'hemist. I'UW 2534 and. opening of sample v alves. report samples and request SG samples For boron. activ ity. and a taken and qui~ck I'rnsk reCSuLt ShIo\V 42 S(G quilck frisk to \ erilk SG FR( and COIfl l-11 the ruLptUreJ
-150 ( 'PN aho\ e back,,rou~nd and 4' 1 SG SG.
read ing, backgIro L1n1l.
_______F I*
t Note: Ski Wonid claSSIfy this event as Alert/c- I.
Depending On a IIumbltcr' of' variables the uinit 2 stack radmonitor Ka~mani RN -8 168) may r-each a \ aIlue W\hich \Wl-uld trigger a Noiger level clIassif-icatilonl. Tauck ing of this parameter and noitifcation of the SIM wvould be pci FIn iicd by the STIA.
L ________ L__________________________________________
17
-I.~-- - --.
'A z-J C-j.
If 1
H- 4 _________
I-'
- z. IA ,.
- u,J - ..
CA -.)
1.-
K I _ -I I(1:
C ° Cr * . *
- C c- * 'i ,- ,
C--
C-- -- " o .F K-C-.
. 0..._ I -.
r.
-A IF K)* K-.)
rI)
'-I,)
4- 4-
i .( iIk ', 4 I\C\ Ist)II. 0)
Iinc II).\ M III Il FLI In~ l co lIII-IrnItI II , Ctl t
\ I Itix tilxpcctcd Actions r -
SFP()
-'---1 Identil\ loss of the 4 Sl)&13\'s and shift to the ADVs to perlorm the irapid Cooltdown to -515 1*
Itf lI'()dispatched to SID)&IV's to Inst.
Investitate. report back that there is a branch air header that has separated at a solder joint.
1 I- -I I()H 2534 NMaintain p/I' lressLIre >NIPSI 1. <920#. Crew Perform cooldown at max controllable rate to lhl within 50#i of #2 S(Oi. and lAW P/T curve. 515' F. monitor SCNI and lR(Tl* NPSII. Minimize
- NPSFI N/A if all R(T's off. pri-sec DP* to limit transfer to SG.
Note: Since AI)'Vs are being iUsed, this step I is not reqCuirCd. but may be perlormed based I* Crew -1
_______________________________________ L 1!01 Monitor lor MSIS and block ý\hen allowable.
) '2534 If MS I actuates. may perform actions to mainntail onl the expectation that the SD&13V's may be vaculum11 in the main condenser:
restored to operable.
- Close disconnects lor NlS-65A&,1, FEnsure SD&BV's fully closed SR'e-pressurize steam header
- Re-open M'ISIVs 119
5,1 H0\
1 4 ll) *tIocM N> ]t12 Re\isiol: ()
Inllsructor Inl,011rn 111lc /..\cti\vitv .\sslgn £tmktaM I Apcctcd \ctiuus F-. CT-2 (S(GTR-2): iEstablishl RCS pressure control such that primary-to-secondar' delta-P is maintained IloN such that the C're\\ NIMi ni mize the pri mary 1.0 scCOidar\ deIta-Pl the rupItured ,( i does not o\erljill.
such that 1()l1 2534 ruptured SG doesn'i overfill (>100%
actual level).
(-[3 (SC(TR-5): Isolate most affected SC. Isolate 42 S(G xvhcni both Tb arc less than 5 15' I:
'1T3 SC must bie isolate(d in < 54) minutes fronm
"* ADV in Auto 41, 9204 & closed the time of the SCTR. FOP~234
"* MSIV & Bypass closed
"* Main FRV & block valve closed
"* Main ed'ccd air-assist chcck closed
"* SGI,[) isolated (NMS-220W)
"* AA\FAS s\w itches in PTI.
"* Aux 17RV FW-4311 closed 2()
I I) '\ Lill illci S' I 2 2k Run\iii:ision: 0 I wkI I I11161-111ýltioll , Acti\ it\ I .\1)CCtCJ A\ctions Siinji: d PIN) NIon Ior for I IlS I iiirut le 'stop OWter and perform IJ )P 2534 actions to throttle and/'or stop I IPS I to miirmm i/ pie r
to-sec delta-P to prex eni S( iover-ill1.
"* RC'S SCNIM \\ ithill P/ I' Curxe
"* Pzr lev'el >2'o%and NOTI dropping,
"* At least I S(G remnovi ng heat.
"* Rs xessel level .>431o HIheNeUIll scenario m~ay he terminated when Inst.
hi th 'Ill lha\ e I)een reCdl need- to <515' F.2 SOi has heen successfblix isolated, and RCS presSUr-e is hein,ý, maintai ned l2A" pr1ocedur1al "tL iidanIce.
I. -- -
21
0
_. ,-. 7 0-- . . -*-
- '6
- 7 / i ~f y
AT\T IC HIENT VALIDATION CHEI-CKLIST I fle. Sonimlator EXalLiation ID Nurnbr): LS021-12 Re vision.: 0 Verified By:
Remole uliuctions:
All remote Iunctions contained in the u!ide are ccrti [led.
X,¢IIlnctiolns:
\11 mal functions contained in the Luide are certlified Initial C orditions:
Fhe initial condition(s) contained in the guide are certified or have been developed from certified ICs.
S-;ilttlator ()peratin<4 Limits.
Fhc *itnulator guide has been evaluated fOr operating limins and/or anJomalous response.
- c>[tRun
The scenario contained in the guide has been test run on the simulator. Simulator response is reasonable and as expected.
\ ci (oIV ( rei eted D)ate
MiPP2 S IM U LATO R TRA IN ING SH IFT TURNO)VER. REPORT I.( tRTIRAININ, 0NSL Y Si-;tolrator Scenario: I152 LI2 I'LANI S*IAIUS:
.A/)DE: I lV POWIER: 100%
IIE. IIi ,ITTS." -hcrmial:2695 M'1WTll PZR PRESS: 22a0 p.ia Flectric: 900 MWI RCS T-, IFIF: 572 deglrees F R(S LEA FK.K; E. ldentilictl: 0.024 gpmi SIG BLOWDO)IN: 1 25 .pm I I.2 lturns small I niclentilit (.1.7 glni *. 2 25* epi0 I I.2 turil sa ll,
/,1 .:\'nV R.. TIO: BAST 6:1 RCS BORON: 82"1 ppm
/_'\,V TREND: stable UNIT 1/2 SA CROSSTIE." Isolated I.S/ TREND.: stable HO)S'E HEA TING: Sg_'Uplfied b%[U3 Aux. Boiler F;,S/ IuIl:e. -.0(05 Hater Trealment .c'ndvr: CSa, I', 100 .- p_ ._
"I I.CO and ITRNI ACTION Statements Coming Due l)atc Time LCO ACTION ACTION REQUIREMENT EQUIPMENT REASON F(.onlinuous TS LCO and TRM ACTION Statements in effect ACTION REQUIREMENT LCO ACTION EQUIPMENT REASON "I 'mit.ntie inopelable vent path closed with power TFRMAS a IIZR \enti Manuall\ isolated due to i, nox ed Ilam th' valves. Maintain oine PORV & block 3.4. I l.b solenoids leakae (2-RC-440 is alt\e operable. closed).
\s)'fsI'FFI:/COMPONENT AVAILABILITY: (systems, comnponents out of service, deviations from required system ah'maimcnts, the need for valve lineups or other restoration activities)
SYSTEM/COMPONENT STATUS U-tI/1 I-2/11-3 CROSS UNIT EQUIPMENT STATUS List the status of'all Unit I and Unit 3 equipment alignments that effect
[Huit 2. i.e.. lire protection, Bus 34A/B, Circulating Water (dilution flow) etc.
SYSTEM __STATUS
\ Stl u t "I- suppxyin, U-2 aus steam (firom 1IInit _3 Atix\. Boilen.
R(\ I)M ,0TI- SYSTEM STATUS (ARW, CLRW, CPF. (;RW) (identify, watergasCous inventory problems, dischairges in
,i ces or tit planned.)
SYSTEMN STATUS jSt-.Lr'EILIA..,,NCI1ES/EVOLUTIONSIN PROGRESS Lead D)ep FOR TRAINING USE ONLY
Attachment SCENARIO ATTRIIIIITES CHECKLIST qcenario litle: Si mLulator Evaluation N umLber: IS02L [2 lectMical Reviewer: Richard N Spurr Date: 11 22'2002
( *.\ll I .I lIVI: .l\TTRI BU [S Y___ 1.
The initial conditions are realistic, in that some equipment and/or instrumentation may be out of service, but it does not cue the crew into expected events.
Y _ 2. The scenario consists mostly of related events.
Y 3. Each event description consists of:
- the point in the scenario when it is to be initiated
- the malfunction(s) that are entered to initiate the event
- the symptoms/cues that will be visible to the crew
- the expected operator actions (by shift position)
- the expected Emergency Plan classification
- the event termination point (if applicable)
Y 4. No more than one non-mechanistic failure (e.g., pipe break) is incorporated into the scenario without a credible preceding incident such as a seismic event.
Y 5. The events are valid with regard to physics and thermodynamics.
y 6. Sequencing/timing of events is reasonable, and allows for the examination team to obtain complete evaluation results commensurate with the scenario objectives.
_NA 7 If time compression techniques are used, scenario summary clearly so indicates.
Operators have sufficient time to carry out expected activities without undue time constraints. Cues are given.
S.Y 8. The simulator modeling is not altered.
Y__ 9. The scenario has been validated. Any open simulator performance deficiencies have been evaluated to ensure that functional fidelity is maintained while running the scenario.
AttachInlCt Guide No.: ES021_,12 SC*iNARIO ATTRIBUTES CHECK LIST Note_ Following criteria list scenario traits that are numerical (quantitative) in nature. Credited malfunctions tasks and procedures should be bolded in the evaluation guide.
- 1. Total Malfunctions (TM) - Include EMs - (5 - 8) 6
- 1. Lead Charging Pump trips
- 2. RC-100E Failed Open 3 'C' Traveling Screen Fouling
- 4. B SG Tube Leak
- 5. *B' SGTR 6 SD& BV's fail closed
- 1. RC-100E Failed Open
- 2. SD&BV's fail closed
. Abnormal Events (AE) - (2 - 4) 3
- 1. Circ. Water Malfunctions
- 2. 'B' SG Tube Leak 3 Rapid Downpower Z4 Major Transients (MA) - (1 - 2) 1
- 1. EOP 2525
- 2. EOP 2534
'- FOP Contingencies requiring substantive actions (EC) - (0-2) 1 1 EOP 2534 Critical Tasks (CT)- (2 - 3) 3 I Perform RCS C/D for SG Isolation 2 Control RCS pressure/avoid SG overfill
- 3. Isolate Most Affected SG 8ý Approximate Scenario Run Tirne: 60 to 90 min. Total 90
', Technical Specifications exercised during the scenario. (Y/N)__Y_
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: MP2 Scenario No.: ES02LI4 Op-Test No.: 4 Examiners: Operators:
Initial Conditions: 100% power, MOL, Eq. Xe., 821 ppm Boron SGBD (a 25 gpm per SG, 24E aligned to 24C, 'B' EDG OOS - cleaning and refilling oil sump Turnover: 100% power, MOL, Eg. Xe., 821 ppm Boron, blend ratio: 6.3 to 1 SGBD @ 25 gpm per SG, 24E aligned to 24C, 'B' EDG OOS - cleaning and refilling oil sump, in TSAS 3.8.1.1.b, TDAFP has been verified operable & line surveillance due in 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />, no other equipment OOS and no other surveillance in progress or due Event Malf. Event Event Description No. No. Type*
1 N/A N Swap running TBCCW pumps 2 RP19C I 'C' RPS Lower NI Fails low 3 CW04C C 'C' Waterbox Condenser Tube Leak 4 FW01 C Isolated condenser tube leak becomes vacuum leak 5 N/A R Downpower due to vacuum leak 6 TC04 M Turbine load shed causes trip 7 ED02 C RSST Fault - Loss of Off-site Power 8 ES031 C 'A' HPSI Pump failure to start on SIAS 9 RC06B M Stuck open PORV - LOCA 10 PCO1 C Plant Process Computer lost on trip (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor 39 of 40 NUREG-1021, Revision 8, Supplement 1
[/ Millstone Unit StationTraining 2 Operator SIMULATOR EXERCISE GUIDE I.
Title:
Simulator Evaluation ID Number: ES02LI4 Revision: 0 II. Initiated:
11/21/2002 Date 1[I. Reviewed:
11/25/2002 Reviewer Date IV. Approved:
" /Ite O rator Training Supervisor I
I tiC: Simulator Evaluation ID N[)ume.r: ESO21I4 Revision: 0 FABLE OF CONTENTS SECTIONS LISTED IN ORDER:
I Cover Page
- 2. Table of Contents 3.ixercise Overview
- 4. Instructor Guide / Summarv Scenario Initial Conditions Attachments
"* Validation Checklist
"* Training Turnover Sheet EXERCISE OVERVIEW I.
Purpose:
- a. Evaluate the licensees' ability, as a team and individually, to safely and responsibly operate the plant during normal plant operations, abnormal operating conditions and emergency operating conditions.
- b. Evaluate licensees in the following areas. as applicable:
- 1) Ability of the crew to perform crew-dependent (and time-critical) tasks.
- 2) Ability of individuals to perform critical tasks.
- 3) Ability of the crew to:
a) Understand/interpret alarms/annunciators b) Diagnose events/conditions based on signals/readings c) Understand plant/systems response d) Comply with/usc procedures and Technical Specifications e) ProperlV communicate in lormation/proper crew interactions
- 0) Perform control board operations
- 4) Ability of each individual to:
a) Respond and correctly interpret annunciators b) Correctly diagnose events c) Properly interpret integrated system response di) Comply \with and use Technical Specifications c) Comply- with and use procedures f) Properly perlbrm control board operations
,, ) l)emonstrate a responsible attitude h) PIroperly communicate inlormation and interact with the rest of the crex\
tFitIC: Simulator [valuation
- 11) NuI1bher: FS02LI14 Revision:
- 2. Exercise Brief:
lhe simulator wxill be prepared for the evaluation and the licensees will be briefed on the conduct of the evaluation and the areas in which they will be evaluated.
I he simulator will be initialized at 100% pover, MOL. Eq Xe. 821 ppm boron. The -B EDG is OOS for cleaning and rcfilling of the lube oil sump due to trace contaminants found in the most recent sample. The unit is in TSAS 3.8.1.1 .b. A sample of the WALDG lube oil was taken and lound to be free of any contaminants and the TDAFP has been proven Operable. Bus 24E is aliuned to 24D. Off-site lines surveillance was performed 5 hours5.787037e-5 days <br />0.00139 hours <br />8.267196e-6 weeks <br />1.9025e-6 months <br /> earlier, therefore due in 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />. There is no other surveillance in progress and no other equipment out of service, however maintenance has just notified the control room that the 'A' TBCCW pump should be secured and the spare started in its place due to a chirping noise in the pumnp end of the motor which is believed to be a fhilinu bearing.
Shortly after the crewx shifts TBCCW pumps the Channel 'C' RPS lower power range NI will fail low. This will actuate a number of annunciators associated with RPS C' trips as well as a "CEA Dropped - NIS" alarm. The crew will need to diagnose the cause of the alarms, bypass affected bistables on RPS 'C' and enter Tech Spec 3.3. 1.1, table 3.3-1. Action 2.
A\ small condenser tube leak will develop in T' waterbox. The crew will enter AOP 2516.
Condenser Tube Leak and take action to secure 'C' circulating water pump. isolate and drain the "CT waterbox, and monitor vacuum. After the waterbox is isolated the tube leak will become a small vacuum leak and the crew should enter AOP 2574. Loss of Vacuum. By starting the mechanical vxacuum pumps the vacuum loss will be slowed. but not stopped. The crew will need to enter AOP 2575 to perform a rapid downpower. When the SPO is reducing turbine load, a relax for the load set motor will stick. driving load set downscale. The unit will trip on high pressurizer pressure due to the rapid backing up of RCS heat. PORV(s) will open on high pressure with the #2 PORV sticking open. The RSST will fault on the trip. Additionally. the PPC xxill be lost on the trip. With the -B EDG out of service only bus 24C/22E will be energized.
therefore the PORV cannot be isolated. SIAS will actuate (manual or auto) as pressure drops. but actuation module AM514 fails to actuate. This prevents the 'A' HJPSI pump from starting on the SIAS signal. but it can be started manually once the failure is identified.
\fIter performing EOP 2525 the U.2S should diagnose a LOCA and transition to EOP 215 32. In the L)CA EOP the crew should identify that the leak may be isolated by restoring power to bus 24D/2F1. 4160 V power should be cross-tied from MP3 and the PORV block valve should be closed. Once the leak has been secured the crew will need to take actions to avoid PTS.
\Vhcn the aboxe have been completed. the exam scenario may be terminated.
hikc: SiIIulatorI[ValIUation 11)\utImber: HS02L14 Re%ision: 0 S. Plant/Simulator differences that may affect the scenario are:
None
- 4. Duration: 1.5 hours All Control Room Conduct, Operations and Communications shall be in accordance with Master NManual 14 (MP- 14). Review the Simulator Operating Limits (design limits of plant) and Simulator Nlodeling Limitations and Anomalous Response List prior to performing this training scenario. The instructor should be aware if any of these limitations mav be exceeded.
4
SIlf'tI\
IN 4 II) tnn i IhS()211t--11, C\ ision: ()
Task IlinC I I)..\ NluI IItLIruCtor lnil'1lrnalliOnl ACti\it\ Asslign l'jpCCtcd Actions Sta icr 0 In TSAS 3.8.1.1.hb 0 No other equip ()()S
- 0) (ff-sie lines sur\CeilancC (Lue in 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> Mkilntenance has Just notified the control room that the ...V I[K'('V, pump shoLld be I secured and the spare started in its place due to a chirping noise in the pump end of'thc motor which is believed to he a Ihiling hearing}
,sing the intb above and I/O sheet, provide Inst.
the crew with turnover inibo. allow the crew to walk-down the boards, and perform brieling.
I lie crew should indicate that they have Itaken the watch'.
US Direct SPO to shift FB('('W PumpS lAW OP
""3O0B.
SPO Secure 'A' TBCCW & start 13' by: (-P233O1
- I)ispatch PFO to mon0itor pump start 0 Start "B' TBCCW pump
- Check amps & discharge pressure on 7
SlC(' JOUN 4
- 11) Numhi~f~~ sU-1 R'?C\ isionl: 0 I'asl\
lIIStIruCtOr- 11n 1`61-11,11oll \CtI'\ It\.\ in 1','Nl)cctccl ACIINIS F ('06 D~irect P11) to check for noise.
v'ibration. &, linoral f'low (local lv)
I R I)\N ial
"* Place -A' BC ptlimp I IS InI stop
"* Release PIX) f-I T Fnitr Imal funlctloll to cause the C hannel 'C' finst.
RPS linear range Io%\\r NI detector to Su~ddenv Fll*Ih lo\\.
I- I PP() Respond to annunIICiator'S 1'0r: \Ml N1-14
" -CFA Droppcd-NIS'
"* _RIS "C' LPlD[ Trip,
Cre v~ Diagnose failed lower NI onl RPS 'C' \RP1 22: 9()C L _________ L ______________________________
8
,S ,(' l(1 4 10 N hC 1 1 1.1-4 RC\ lsiml.- 0 l'isk.
I in*ie "Intnt n",u[o1 \tvt \ssiol lFNI)CCted .\cti(Ol>
-\tPndard(
pJý,)(7) Pr ARP~ 25Q0C B\'pass RPS*':
- TM//LP li-1xxr I
0 L,1)1.
F t JS Log TSAS 3.3. 1 I - table 1.3- I . :\ctoi-n 2
. h R 29(
InserCIt mnal I'unCtIO1n tbrI a I ()Wmtbe leak i Inlst.
H)il00 24) the (` w~aterhox to ramp inI oxver 4 miniutes. TN\'15,A[I See raýmp Respond to an nuntc iator COS5 `BA 17. -C' SýPO flotwel I Cond I lugh and (1INIS Coldeniser N1IM -14 tu~be leak in- -C- xaterhox\.
Us niter AXOl 25 16 to respond to con-den-ser tube leak in 'C' w-aterbox.
SP() lertorin actions to halt Chloride intrLlSion: A\O) 215 1 0 Secure 'C' Circ Pp.
Dispatch PEO to secure vacuumII primingZ.- venit the 'vaterbox. and secure SJAE suIction from11
.1 9
,ýI"(.' I I() "N4 R'Cý Isioll: ()
1wsk IIISII-L[CtOl- It\ Assi"I'l I:Xllcctccl ActiOlls ,Stalldm-d
\VIICII I-CCILlestcd Lis PIJ). LISC I-CIMACS to Ilist.
Vent SCCLII'C \'(ICLILIIII prInilm,C,and vent -C
ý\dtCl-I)OX 211d SCCLII-C the SJAF, SLICtloll.
II%V R C Io'se d I
I-AIVOI 200"o \Vhcn the \\aterbo,\ is ventcd. Insert Inst, TIN'16, AE'2 11WHIHICtioll to CLILISC the Wbe leak to become J VýICLRIIII leak.
Cre \v Identlk decreasim, vaCLILIIII hV 10\\CI-1110 N/I 1\,'f - 14 Ill"her VaCLILIIII readillo. ol. al"11-111.
10
S ik I P)o, 4
[cINIc~ni ()
Il.S, Iic II) \ N'",fl I stirICtt() r I-II r tII(l ,1\cti\ it\ ssig11 l;xpectcd A\ctirs stmldnud
[iS lknItcr i\()OP 2574, Loss o1 ('ondCnsCr VacuunL AOlP 2574 and direct actions:
- Start Mech. Vac. Tps.
- 2'd set SJAF Start I-55A and Cnsurc Ian discharge aligned.
Check Circ. Pp. Operation. gland seal.
Atmospheric Drain Collecting l'ank. and Cond. Surge Tank Check \acutrm breaker and boot seal filled
- In-plant Iistial cheelks, etc.
I. . J.___ -
When requested. rise rernIOtC functions to Insl.
F.\v1ýI20t (W)1 alhici rniechan ical VacLILrl pumps.
f__
Adj uIst Mal 'unctioni severity to a\ (id manual Inst.
trip criteria ( -6" backprcssure).
t ____
- SNI may be requested to make some or all of [iS Frnter AOP 2575 and direct a rapid downpower AOP 2574 the reClirired n10tifcationIS to attempt to maintain v\acuum and avoid a I _
plant trip:
[Dircct/remind crew to refer to Attachments
- 5. & 6 during do\\npower (Rapid
7 C
C I
Id' r
Zr K.)
I
'./
- i. C: 7
'1 ry 4--
0 0 0 (C(C -
-C" 0.
-4 C--
'. - 'S
-4 '- t;c. -.
-z 0 0CC - C (C (C
-c
)L LI)
Cr -. C'6 s 0 0 0
- 0 - C- LI)
(C (C
-, 0'
- (C - C' .5 (C -4
-- 4 C '-0 Ud 0 C N.) 0 Z -4 'S C q
N(C
/'
K) r Z LI) 0-0 C z (C 0<
t;c (C
__ 0 '
LI) ((C (C (C z- - 0 .5 z
'- (C 0 I))
.5 (C (C C- q tic rr CL 0CC Zr '(C cC (C C', (C C..
(C (C
- '/.
z C' I
(C _ (C' o -
(C (C C' nrc (C
nc o C- (C (C
(C (C
- 7;-z 0 0 (C C (C C (C A C tic (C (C 0- nc (C (C C,,
(C C
'Zr
'U
'-'I
'U'
SI..+ ItI ()N 4 11I) *' I~ hr it> 214 R'n ,+ o. 0 I iai.' IDA. ýkll: lIStruLICtK IIlIlMUI at ikl .\cti\ it\ ASSi1 1 IExpcctCd Act* )I Stildaird C.lose (C.I 1-501. V("C outl,.tt isolation Check proper flow rate lar 2 puonps:
0 R uising boration From RAS i tanks:
Insert CEAs an initial 5 to 10 steps
[)etcrrr inc desired horation rate 0
Borate to charging pp. suction hy:
SEInsire N'M/U Nlode Select switch in Dilutc S*EnSLUreC valves NII Stop ValVe U 1 512, VCT M!Ij 1.vpass ('I 1-196 and RWST Isol. C11- 192 all closed.
SE11nsure BA\ Controller IC-210Y in A'\djust FC-2 1OY ItMr selected horation rate
- Open CI 1-504
- Place I/I N Mode Select s\\ itch in Mantual
- Start a Boric Acid pp. & veril\
dischargeC PressuI, .-98 psig
- Open VCT NI/I j Ilvpass CI 1-196 13
Sl V! l()N -t, II) Nti111
!),.! I. ýý 1-, -14, i\,C\ islon: 0 II)A/ ,\ IýlII lI)StI'LICtOl' 1111'OHMIkOll ACLI\ ItN* Stail&lrd SPO DCCI-CUSC tLIl-t-)IIIC lo"ICI III I-cspollse to RCS tClIll)Cl-,ItLll'C.
WhCll SPO LISCS the 1,0ýld 1.111111 I)ot to IOVCI 111 St. TIM 7, N1. 2
[LIO-MIC 10ýld. elltCl' IM1111111CtIoll to CaLISC ýl tLII-hIIIC 101AI -SIIC(I. S11111.11"11CS L'lStUck contact CVS CIOSCd. LOLId ShCd OCCLII-S at a rate of' I 33(Vo I)CI- 111111LItC CILIC to speed ofload Set 1110tol'. It IS UIllikek, that examinees will ic1clit1k: CmIctiv \%*Ilat is Crew Identify rapidly 1-Isill-'-' IZ('S te'llperatures and pressul*cs. MaY I'lltiate a manual trip if qLIIck enow0i. Respond to trip LAW' 1`01) -2525.
Note: [ IS \vIII pose qL[CStl()IIS I-COLIR11110 these UIS (I)LICI-N' ITO ýllid SPO on the Stýitus of Sal'cty
,,isl-)ccts ofcach sal'et\ functlon. ITO and SPO FLIIlCtI0IIS ýIS CICIII1eItCkI III I:()P responses criticzil to proper diamosis and keN
" [\,CLIctl\:It\ Control (11110)
'IctiOlls MC C011talned III thcIr Individual 111111ledlatck 0 Reactor
" N/IýlillteMIIICC Of'VIWI A(INIIiLlI-ICS (SPO) 0 TLIl'bille Electrical bLISCS I
14
S(I 1W. -1.
- 11) .\omhflJ >u1 i'Rc\ isoHl.
I 1.,1, I lim: II)A NkIll Ilist ructor III[,M 111"Itioll , Actl\ It\ Assi UH LAcle ctIou-S
- SW &R1C('\\
"* RCS Ifl\eflorv C.ontrol (lPPO)
- I-t lexC &i~< SuhIC~OOIlc u1MIrei u (SCNvI ). aIluC & trenld
"* RCS P~ressure Control (1PP) 0 lPZi pressure. xili & trenld
"* Core Ileat Remiox al (ITO())
"* RCP StaIuS
"* Loop delta-T
" 'I'l SCMN/
- 0 RCS Ileat Removal (SF'())
"* SG preCssures 880-920ot
"* RCS ITe T'-35~
"* SGY levels, valueC & trendIC
"* RCS SCM cContainment (CI'NlI) Isolation (PPN))
- Radmonitors Inside (1 NI . outIside CTM F. steam plant. not in alarm or ri 51 110, 0 CTWIT PVprssureC I 0 C'I'MT Temperature SL PIreSSure-Control0 15
Sl( I l)N 4 L1111C 1\)C\Isl()Il: ()
I JSI
,1 I inc IDA; NkIll lIlStI-LICt0I 111161,111alloll , Activitv Ass" CU I :xpcctcdl A\tiOnIS (PPO) llL~tbC(1SCM-0 PO
"* (livT temlperature - I -0, IF
"* CTINTI IPeCSSLIreCý I,-
-4 -t
('rew Durnn,- 11"01 2525. the loss M,IPIC should be idlent, bedl by plant parameters, notchnn.
Operators will need to usc al tcniatc indieatioi iS.
i - --- .
C"IA (IA)(A-2): [stablish Iprimlary-to S1P0 Perl'orm actions of F,01) 2)525~. idenlti lx the secondary hecat sink. Start TI)AFIP due to i~olloxviiv'l inability to Feed S( s with bo0th X )F' Et 11,
("IIl
- RSST~ lost dluringaitSIB I( A. (Should he atccompipshed w~ith in I0()in ut s)
- 24C' encr- iz'.d on F(I.
0 241) de-cnereoi/.cd a I stablish APN\/ A NID. i) P-& lIAIP InI I'I( Perlbfrni actions of W'l-'l 25215. idlenti fy the
- #2 PORV StLick open and no0 power to 16
I C.
- 4 --- K- -- -
C.
I
- 4-I J- -I C
4-
- .1 r.
'-I 4- 4 I>
CL
-I.
I-
-I--- -I W 0. Cf -
V.) /
- C A., C CC (C J, ;c V.) C cc V.) _ 0 C
Cf (C - - - C 0 0 C,; -z z C -
A W Cf. C
-J -, C CL r c (C C - (C (C -r I z q Cs C
- C 77
-C CC - r.
C C C.
C C
'1 (C C Cf C-.
C. C; I-. -
C-. (C - CC Cf.
Cf
-S C- C-' '-, 0 -
- r-,
__________________ £ .£.-- *.-.----4
.1 CI
-I I4 4,
-'I I41 I.)' WI -1;i I
SýI' IH1 1Q\-i it I NI1 14 1\,C\ Islon: ()
I ime MA).N1,11 In'~truchuInI It11'W111iti011 \CtI \it\ ")týmdLlrd A IS1111 lPerf'orm initial steps ol I '( )I' 52
"* Confirm diaunosls
"* Initiate plaeek.piIM
"* Restore fr'om alarm silenee
"* EnIsure- SIAS/(.'IA,\S/I WAS and C'RA('S Oil rCcireC
"* Optimize SI (II) &. Start 'A' I IPSI 1t nlot done earlier).
"* EnISUre all avai lable charuine"
- EnIsurIe SW\ItChgear C00tM-oli in1 operatiOnl.
"* Perform steps to locate/isolate L(X A 1 - P1)() Identify actu-ationl module fi'alure and start -A JA)2)51 -
IIPSI pumip. (II not done earlier), while perf'orming actions to %\erifI>and optimiz.e SI tlowv.
C re \\ I )etermine that the R(.'s leaik is vi'a the 142 I'ORV and can he isolated h\ restoring' PO\\ci to buIs 241)/-?122".
Review board alarms and conditions to determine bus 241) not faul~ted.
ft -
Is
K- -- -
p
-C
"" - --r -
S'., Cf ,,"
C
'.. -- -* - CF.
,r; _ ,.; .;- -s
"- _ - ; u. - -*
I.aC (C-C C I.) '*
IJ IJ 4 -.. -
..kI*,1 ) \ -4 k\ision: 0 Assa 1 Instructor liil(11-111ý111oll Actl\ It\ l~xpCC[CCd .\ctonl' ' tl id Ir IS Dir'eCt lbllo\\-up actions ol' h( )P2532): rop_
.Veril\v no RB('('A' iin-leakae
- R\14-6038 F`or RKW(A('V
- RtBCC\X SUrI-1 tank lC\ el
- Ar-ea radmonitors
.ra SUM iCplvels
"* Place 112 analyier (s) In serv ice
('T2(IACA-I): EtstablIish RZCS pressure crev\: Pl101 '~2 control. Prevenft or correct 2001F response and perflorm action as necessarN to avoid PTI : ( " F2 sLIbcooled margin lPTS IAN\V EOI')
"* Restor-e letdox)\A,1
"* SecuelIPSC I/chai ni pumS Note: S(-'Nil &Ll'IS cr1tl-, 11riaust be plotted
"* Initiate pressurizer spra\
nIana l due to P'IT loss. STIA ma\'I be Used 1MIW to obtain \ial LICS andI peru0111 Ipots. "* Perl-rm e(1 ooldlow~n.
I hie scenario mm, be tcrininated wheni the I lst.
aho\ c Is Cornplete oi- ait the discretion of' the lead e'Nailiincr'.
.)o
0 t t'j I
- I tJ cI K) z z
- 4-0 1
9 z
- C
.9 9
1 - I C
9 C 9-C C
0 'I C
C C
AT.\CI I N('I FN11 VAALi)' fIDA CHI-'CkLC [IST nc: Simulator I aluation\ ______________________
II) '\urnher: J-4YI 14 __________ R)e vi'Slon: (1I
\/erifiled 13v:
Remonte Iue L 1cI0ioS' I 1\n1 I-00 lLJIlICtIOIS Con1tai tied III the guildc are ccrti be[d.
\11 mmii fUnctions contained inI the cutide are certified nilial1 Cond1(itionls:
[he miit a condition(s) contained inI the fauide are certiftied Or nave h~een developed from certi lied [Cs.
HI .me i1L~a iiaoruid has been evaluatedC [o1r op)crarIngl(
lilwS and 1or anomallous response.
c IIZ I,.)t unI:
I Hi he ccnario contained InI the tudeCI lIhabeen test runli Ol Ilie silInn at or1. SMIILnulato r-esponse is reasonable aid as expected. /aýr
\cllol)-ý Icled \ciu'usetIDate
N\II.2. SIMJULATORT'RAINING SHIFT TUýRNQVER REPORT (M FIR \I\IN( USEK ()N,1N itun1L]M01 SCcMatjoý f[.5021J1 PLANT STIATUS:
3 lOL)E; Rx P(')1'R:- I00F, i'hcr ilia :2095 M \\'l II ['71 PRESS: !P'0 psia "1-lectric: 001) \'I\ RCS T-, I IL`E. 2 deres R('S' LI.-.. I A', I(GE: Ident ificcd: 0.02-I gpivt LOW)ID('l ,\WN':u 2trs ua 1n1idelittilfled: 0.I14'7 21)[1 "pillp 1 1'2 ttrii's stun II 3AS'l6.1 : I RCS BOW,%': 82 1 ppm
\ '\()\ REND: stable I CROSS TIE Isolated iS/ 7R EAJ): stableý E hIE,4 TiW SpVid \13.\x 13oi niewi Ve(ndor': ('SiT 50
'IS I.C( arnd TRM ACTION Statements ComingDue Iae Tinme LCO ACTION ACTION REQUIREMENT EQUIPMENT -REASON x xx-0 I ' rs 1...
). \'erifV off-site linies ev'erv 8 11rs.. [V FOG (oil S1.1p1 clean ago DAFP verified operable. restore to& S, efill operable inl 72 lu's or FI[SR inl nex\t 6 burs I- ____& CSD next 3 0hirs.
('niiiuu%'TS LC()and TRM ACTION Statements in effect AC IlOiN REQUIRE-MENT I 1CO IACTION I EOIIIPNIEN-r I 11 F A 4YINT iŽI.A'CNY 1 HI il 1t1c pt closed \\iiil po%\ýer Will'bl Mill I RMiAS YVR ct Malaniial I\ isolated (Inc to
!,!-,! hIloit the 'aI vcs. Maintain one IN)RV &. b lock 1.'4.1 1 b "0 litnoids leakaLce -R-40 valve operable.
closcd).
S N'STE[N/(ONIPON ENT AVAILABILITY: (s~'stenms, components out or service, dev'iations from required sN'stem Ilkfignments, the neced for v'alve lineups or other restoration activities)
-sSYSTFNI/COM PONE NT STATUS I
l13 Out of service tor oil sumlp clean &, refillI
['- i2I/Ui-3 C ROS S U NI T EQ U I PNIENT STA TUS Li st t he staftu S ofiaIll n i t I and U nit 3 cqttiipillellt aIi gnmrnen ts thla t effectI I nlit '>I.C., tireC prIotecion. Bu1.s 34A./B, Circttlating Water (dilution [lowý) etc.
~ \'YUE ~ ISTAT US otu li'-1 muppk iv'.ý t*-2 at\ steaml (I-'roll 1I nit ý2 '\u\. Boiler-)
KUVL UWA ~ I L !'. :! I tL .iTATUSI (ARW, CLLK, CPI'. (,W) (tdlentity water/g1aseous inventory problems, dischargýes inl Nt uviess or plant'ed.)
SYS'EMN1 STATUIS xl k\ HLLA.1-iNCES/EV"OLLjTIONS IN PROG'RESS
)I I -ýit. litH' cril-icatioti c%L't'\ 8 bout's I I 'guI I),'nj I
_____I -W- O' i__
FOR TrRAIN IN-, UISE ONLY
Attachnment SCEN.ARIo() k-VrTTIRII3I TES CHECK1IST Scenario
Title:
Simulation E valuation Number: ES()2LI4 Fechnical Reviewer: Richard N Spurt D)ate: 11/22/2002 c)1.I.ITi\;
l AlAFRIBUTI"ES Y__ 1. The initial conditions are realistic, in that some equipment and/or instrumentation may be out of service, but it does not cue the crew into expected events.
_.....Y__ 2. The scenario consists mostly of related events.
Y 3. Each event description consists of:
- the point in the scenario when it is to be initiated
- the malfunction(s) that are entered to initiate the event
- the symptoms/cues that will be visible to the crew
- the expected operator actions (by shift position)
- the expected Emergency Plan classification
- the event termination point (if applicable)
_.....Y- . 4. No more than one non-mechanistic failure (e.g., pipe break) is incorporated into the scenario without a credible preceding incident such as a seismic event.
Y 5. The events are valid with regard to physics and thermodynamics.
S---- Y___ 6. Seq Lien cing/timing of events is reasonable, and allows for the examination team to obtain complete evaluation results commensurate with the scenario objectives.
N/A 7. If time compression techniques are used, scenario summary clearly so indicates.
Operators have sufficient time to carry out expected activities without undue time constraints. Cues are given.
Y__ 8. The simulator modeling is not altered.
Y*__ 9. The scenario has been validated. Any open simulator performance deficiencies have been evaluated to ensure that functional fidelity is maintained while running the scenario.
Iý
.\ttachliment Gi(Ie No.: ES021-I4 SC-NARIO ATTIBI [1TES ('II(K[.,I" Note: Following criteria list scenario traits that are numerical (quantitative) in nature. Credited malfunctions tasks and procedures should be bolded in the evaluation guide.
- 1. Total Malfunctions (TM) - Include EMs - (5 - 8) 8
- 5. Condenser Tube Leak
- 6. Condenser Vacuum Leak
- 7. Turbine CV's Ramp Closed
- 8. Loss of PPC
- 3. #2 PORV Stuck Open
- 4. Loss of PPC
- 3. Abnormal Events (AE) - (2 - 4) 2
- 1. Condenser Tube Leak
. Condenser Vacuum Leak Malor Transients (MA) - (1 - 2) 1 #2 PORV Stuck Open-SBLOCA
- 2. Turbine CV's Ramp Closed-Full Load Shed EOPs entered requiring substantive actions (EU) - (1 - 2) 2 1 EOP 2525 2 EOP 2532 Ij
Attiach ment G iuide No.: ES021,1-4 SCENARIO ATTRIBUFTES CHECKLIST
'. EOP Contingencies_requiring substantive actions (EC) - (0-2) 1
- 1. Establish Primary to Secondary Heat Sink
? Establish RCS Pressure Control I. Approximate Scenario Run Time: 60 to 90 min. Total 90
- 9. Technical Specifications exercised during the scenario. (Y/N) Y