ML031070452

Document 2 Dated 03/26/2003

ML031070452
Person / Time
Site:	Robinson
Issue date:	03/26/2003
From:	Clements T - No Known Affiliation
To:	Emch R, Palla R Division of Regulatory Improvement Programs, Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Emch R, NRR/DRIP/RLEP, 415-1590
Shared Package
ML031070230	List: ML031070343 ML031070351 ML031070357 ML031070368 ML031070397 ML031070410 ML031070421 ML031070452 ML031070463 ML031070472 ML031080417
References
TAC MB5226
Download: ML031070452 (1)

Text

From: "Clements, Talmage" <talmage.clements@pgnmail.com>

To: "rlp3@nrc.gov" <rlp3@nrc.gov>, "rle@nrc.gov" <rle@nrc.gov>

Date: 3/26/03 1:36PM

Subject:

Document2 This table give an indication of the huge difference between the NUREG and EPRI curves for RNP. Note in the range of interest the values of the curves differ by a factor of 15 to 55. This is the difference between cost effective and who cares. The spread is largest is where the most dollars are and where the NUREG indicates it may be unrealisticly conservative.

<<Doc2.doc>>

CC: "Kozyra, Jan" <jan.kozyra@pgnmail.com>, "Dolan, Brad"

<brad.dolan@pgnmail.com>, "Laur, Steve" <steve.laur@pgnmail.com>

ML031070452