ML19338C087

Motion of Intervenor,Lloyd Harbor Study Group,Inc,Re Visit to Natl Reactor Testing Station,Id & Depositions Re ECCS Tests.Aec Should Produce Copies of All Documents & Data Re Evaluation of Eccs.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML19338C087
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	07/09/1971
From:	Like I LLOYD HARBOR STUDY GROUP, INC., REILLY & LIKE
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML19338C084	List: ML19338C083 ML19338C087
References
NUDOCS 8007310669
Download: ML19338C087 (4)

Text

y...e -- -

. . , . . , g, k APPENDIX'A T

,; . %e M

_

,, : w.. - +

. .v., , . i 8

d~

_

.,. .aw f.;, ,,-

.

.

p w 30 W . '

. , ...u uu;.u..

j F

O- .

< -- c a c t r i s o \\ man.abin, ta 5'o-M2.J --

' ' =

.

CSEC

-

~

7"a' ..

..

9 $ @I "I &

7 // -

.i-(TdITED STATE!! CP AMERICA r JUL121971 >h ms'a be t=ttm

.tmrm'N'

-

Sf ATOM 1C EUBRGY CUMl1LD!l10N

• grau, .

R

/ Q' v\

• r, o y6 .

J

-

oi

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _w_ _ _ __'_ _ .)__ _ _ __ax_y (-

_ _

Ng$il _ u Y,~

-

-

i

..

w.. .

'

~ . - -

~

~

- .

. ,. <

z...o . ,, s.

r.;c ,. / m oj  !

p In.the Matter of. '

' ' ' ' '

..

~

h .Q\

C

. . LONG ' ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY ~ ^ ["i

_

. e (Shoreham Nuclear Power Plant  : Docket No. 50-322 #

S ta tion, Unit'l)

.;  : .

,

- -

o , .

, e.

__ _ __ 5

__ ________ . ___ .

-

> ___ .

x ,

, ,.

'..

,

' ' "

,1

,~.'.

I .! .[

.

.

NOTION OF INTERVENOR, THE LLOYD HARDOR ~*

,

- STUDY GROUP, ' INC. , REGARDING VISIT TO ~ .

_ NATIONAL REACTOR TESTING STATION, IDAHO, -

'

.

AND DEPOSITIONS RE~ECCS TESTS

- -

'

• q i

.. .

. * - -

,

.

PLEASE.TAKE NOTICE that, pursuant to 10 CFR Part 2. ..

,

.

,.

Sec' tion 2.741, intervenor, THE LLOYD HARBOR STUDY GROUP ,

INC.,' moves-for an order:

,

!

.

-

1 .-

Directing that the Staff produce copies of all 3

{

documents-and data which will.be relied upon in'its re

,

,

-

.  !

3. . . . -

,'

evaluation .of the emergency c' ore cooling system of the pro

-

'

[, ,

-

t

~ posed Shoreham plant, Jincluding, but nct limited t6 the . ,

.

.

documents and data . relating to tests r

.

845-850 and the re' .

,

. .

sults of the series 'of experiments conducted for the AEC

,.

.

.

-

.

. at its National' Reactor Testing' Station in Idaho, tin Nov_

..

.

2

.

.

tember an.-d December of:1970. -

.

,

,

.

~

'

-

h, 2.: . w

., t

', --

Granting intervenor permission to visit the .

.

,

National Reactor Testing Station in l Idaho to take' the de -

,

07 ' .. ..; p 9, 4

.

.

-

'. - "

. _. e . ~m

.

._

m_. , , ,. _. . . _- z .= - -

_ - _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ . - _ _ _ _

,_ _

b, . '

=

y

', . s,5 ' * ,.3

l. * . ;I

,R " * ~

• . *; . :. , .~;

,

_'

,'fn *j.':-;'u .

. , .

'. w

....

. . -

.'o .. .. ::.e*

., , ,

.. -

.

'

..

-

-

9, ,

.

-

q) -

.

-

.

. . .

, , , ,

-

, , . . , p

- ,

.

!

'

-

. i

. position of the personnel who: conducted such tests and ex- l

1

'

4.

periments,- and to examine an'd receive copien of t.he docu- ] ,

'

ments and data generated by such tests and experimentn.

. . - - . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . -

7 -  ;--

3

. . . .

>

'

.

,

.

-PLEASE TAKE-FURTHER N.OTICE that intervenor requests' ..

.

, , ,

the Board to visit said Idaho facility, at its earliest - .

_ ,

.

~

.l . . . convenience, and to fam'111ar'ize 'itself firsthand win ' the

-

.

.- -

,.

. .

.. ,

,

sources of.information being ut .ized by the Staff in its .

'

I reevaluation-of t1e 3 emergency core cooling system and, if '

'l

..

,

, , - - .,rw _;

1. -

possible, that the Board be present during- the taking of .c -

,

.

,

>. ,

..

-

4 - . ... .

..

,

• '

j/. depositions by the' intervenoi. ,, . l. g .' . ,

'g  : 4 .

-

. .

' -

-

, .

-

, ,

, 1 .

.

,.y

^

~ '

,

. The failure.-of the ECCS tests at the Idaho facility '

,,

'

' * '

} .. s ..  ;

'

't

'

" -

have become.a matter of widespread public concern and has

• ,, ; ,

'

,, , . . .

- . . . s .- .,'

'

'

'*

rai. sed anew the question. of khether nuclear plants are , , .,

.

-

,

'

w. " ' . e, .  : <,

. unsafe. An example of this anxi,ety is the article entiticd. , 4

> . .

. . .

a- ..- _,'

. . .

.

1 .

'

" Nuclear Power. Plants are Unsafe" by Wilson Clark, published , .>.. -

,

,

. ,

' '

in "Not-Man Apart",, July 1971, Vol.-1, No.f7, a publication ,

~, , ,, . ..: .

'

- *; '

,

'

r.- .,.

'

issued by the' influential and respected organization, Friends

.

,

• I '

~. . .. ,. . f a

.j, of th.e : Earth. This article, . a copy of which is attached ..

' -' ^:; -

-

,

'

'o 1 ..

,. . . .

.

. ,

4

,,,,..-. hereto, written by_an outspo!:en critic of nuclear power, ,

,  ;- : U

n. . . .,_ .

,

, ,

reflects the - growing anxi'ety of .~the- public on the . question

.

- -

p .- .; .

- .

- '

I of the safety of. nuclear power plants and points up the.

.: a, , . . ~, , .J g ,.

~

need for a thorough dishlosure of all relevant facts con

~

U ,' . .

$ .

...' ..  ;  :. r.',.

h..q

., . .

'.

,

• -

cerning thel effectiveness of the' ECSS.

.

.

.

g, -

,,

..

,

.

.g .

9.; ,

.

,

~ ' *

'

.tl . - . -3

.

- .Intervenor requests this relief so that -it can obtain ,

{g 'q*; .

'

,; . . -

-

.e < ,,

w , ' ' , . ,

, ,

'

h, [* *

.j. .<

. .- -.r. * [,e . - e

.",-s. w nI ,, . , , .

,

,'

,

-

,

.. ( .

14 .

4 3

--4

.

.

'

. R_

.>..__"_. .

.,.,p' -- _A' ~k

-

.

. - ~ . , , .

- -.

..

_

-

. ..

3. <- 4

- m . . . . .

.

. . ~7

. .

fn , ' ',' . # ~],  ; ; . . .- <

.b hu < : ... e .. ys c,,-g

-

^ - '* , . . g . j t

.m ,.-j . 3.

" "

.. e ,s' * ..

, . .

. , s.

c . 4. . .

• I.

~

..

. . . ,

4 .

'

' " -

.

, , ,

. ,

~[

- evidence necessary.to enable'it to prepare 6dditional cross--

- pximlimt. loir on . the embjont of',- the emergency core cooll na ' , , Q

'

l

.... system and the Staff's report of its reevaluation of the 4

.

.-

,7 -.;ECCS, and tol prepare intervenor's additional affirmat.ivo ,

- . . . . . .

.,

,

,,

. , J ['

~

.

testimony .

and supplemental findings of fact on the ECCS. . .

,

.

-

,

.

.  :

.. .

.- ,. -

.

(

-

, ,

,

--;

'

. If this application {sgranted, intervenor' intends'

.

,

,

.

. .

'

to, bring with it to the . Idaho f acility one or more technical . ,

,

f.~

~

consultants competent to evaluate the results and data eman ~ . , }s

'.

,

,

.' .  ; y

. 4

. . .

ating'from-such tests'and experiments, and to participate.in ,

,

p.

.

.

., ,

the interrogation of the personnel who were involved in such.

. .

..

. .

,. . ,

'

I

'

tests. ,

'3 ln ' - -

.

,

,. c f I, >. .

y , : . . , i . * , .,

,

.

. . . , .

.; w

. . .

-

2. . ... .'C,,-. .'.. -' '

n...

,

,

.

.

, ., ,r- -

~, " ' '

In view of the - tremendous -potential. damage that,' could . , ' -

, y

.

.~r. *

, ,' .

result from -a failure of the ' emergency core coolindy system, +'

~

'

.,

.

-

. ... .,

.'- .

'

-

and the importance of such s'ystem in preventing major acci -

< >?

. .

-

.:

^i. .

.

. . a. , '

. .

dents,J it is the duty of this, Board in evaluating the pro-

.

.

,,

.

,

s.

, ;. . - t

, ,

,,  ;-

. posed Shoreham reactor to do-its uttaost to learn as much as ;

.

T ..j . ',

--

.

b. .- , -

-

-

s. .

.

,

'd

-

it can about the.. unsuccessful! results experienced in the ,[-

o. , - t .

,

t c;,

'I -

-

November.and December 1970 series of tests of the ECCS at '

!ij' -< ) l. l ..

,,. J' . ;- .

, , ? '. th e. . Idaho facility. .

'1

-

, . .

.' -

..'h-r i. -

w .

,. *

.

e

.

,.- . ..

. ..,

.n , :.

^t*- * .

,,

. . .. .,

.

..

.

. p

.

a,

.

, -

n .) ;-

ry2

' J' . , . Dated: July 9/1971.

,

'

,

- {t Respectfully submitted , , ,., .W- T .,

...

, ,.

-

=3 r ., ; . .t -

s .

g .-.

, .

, , .*

. ,

,

'....,,'.' ,e

-

- -

. .- .c

. .

ITHE:.LLOYD HARBOd ST' TIDY GROUP J .

5

' s ~ -

t.4s

,: ' ,x ,,e l-

-

- ..

.

- nl 3  :.

( 6..

., i,- ,

INC.

,

-

.

'

>

.

'.

'

j j a ;.; -

.. ". , V'.r l ..BY:; REILLY, LIKE & SCHNEIDER. .; , t

. , ,

,

-' .

o i

-

, -

.

'~94 c ai _ a . .' '

.

t l.. ;~ *v.;,T,9 :.J  : .

"$ :,.~  ; .a . - ..

Yli; ) ,.

',- l' , ,, by:'

1.

'

li,! '

'

d.

(;f .* ,m ,- .._ .*;*

-

Irving.Like- .

, .,: ,

v. , J.J

.

-

., . . .

, ' ' -

.py ,  % t .- . i -Attorneys for Intervenor. .

4

'

200 West Main. Street ' .  ;;; '

.. ~ ' ,';,:,1. ' 0

.

, *. - 7

.

p;

f. ">. 7gf g,q. .J'. ' -

. Babylon,'New York 11702 ,'~~ v, ,

w.; , .m. .,

,

. ,

,

.

-. ,- .-

f>,t ,. F

fv . . i

.

_'

-

- . . LW} '.

.. 1- , , n

, n _.~ ,mg, _ -,

.'. t t-

).

- -

~ _.,7 w 4y :7' .):. .

, m.g,ng ,3 ;. , , . , ,.g .

,

-

.

-t .. .

.. .

. -DOCXE

.

.'- ., - ,

q)gggg,TtlU@th' 7,

.

,

-s 'c

.

,

, .

..

.

.;

g,ygq, y n gg_%Q,

,

.( . .

s,

-

- u

,

( - ----- ;i

" ...

.

,

-

. . . , . -

.. <

y . . , t- . .. .q

.

, ,

.

,

. s j-

,

. ..

. .

. .

. .

g:

UNITED STATES OF' AMERICA  :

'

i-ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION.; .'

~ '

.? .

c ,

-

, l.

. .

- -

.

,

.

( .,

, , _x -

-

-

.

,

-

.

(In the Matter of; .

.t

-

.

..

,

.

,

.

4 .

.

-

.

, ."  !

r, 7. - LONG ISLAND ' LIGHTING CddPANY. ,

" ~

' .

., _....,.......,.......-r.__,.y.,-.--l.i- i . .-

- (Shoreham. Nuclear Power y.ant Docket No. 50-322 . T Station,' Unit 1)' ^ < _

7 -

.j)

. '

- .

/L l

a- .-

. -

-. .,

,

- -

,

.

.% {

.;

,

, , , '

,. . t. , a. .,: .,-

_x ',c ;

, . .

- . , . ,

';

• _

. .

.

.. .r ~ .y s i

. .

. ;-

-

. -

, ,,

{

'

t ' CERTIFICATE OF_- ERVICE ".

, <

.. .

,'<. .

.

.

.

<.

,,

.,'. .  ;

- . p

<

'

-I lereby . certify that copieslof ' the " Motion ~of Intervenor,' The - r:

,

1

-Lloyd Harbor ~ Study Group, Inc.;,- Regarding . Visit to National ~ '

'

.

Reactor Testing ?-Station,- Idaho, and Depositions Re ECCS Tests",

T

~

dated July 9,1971, in the' cap,'tioned matter, have been served - 2 on tL he. following by deposit 'in the United States mail, first .

.

.

'.

,

class or airmail,.this 9th' day of July-1971:

' .

-' '

,

,

.

... ' -

..,

-

,

• , , ,.

.., ,

• * ' * ~ '

g. .

,, ,s. . e.,,

- -

-

-

,

g 5  :

' '.. y. ... 7

.

,

.

- ,

~

Hon. J&mes R. Yore '

_ .

86cr4tary -

.

.

.... . - ..

. . . .

~

Atomi.c Safety & Licensing Board 4_

~

,

U.S. Atomic Energy Commission'.' M

_

Atomic Energy Commission' -

,

Washington, D.C. 20545,  ;

} Washin,gton,.D.C. 20545  ! , .

' ^

'D'r. A'. Dixon Callihan [ -

Joseph.Scinto, Esq. .. ... [ ,. /'

'

-

Atobic Energy Council-

' Union Carbide' Corporation *

.- 112 State Street .,

P.O. Box Y . I. - Albany,'New York 1 't r

~ '

..

1' . . Oak Ridge; Tennessee

-

~

37830 -, "..

'

'

,,s

.,

. Martin'G. Halsch, Esq.

,,

l ..

- 3

/ t .Dr..Hugh'C.:Paxton .'*  !

Trial Counsel--

'

i ,; .

• '

Los AlamosJSciontific-Laboratory, ' ~ , ;U.S.JAtomic Energy Commission

_ _ , _

4

' Box 1663~- .- '! Washington, D.C. 20545.- /

-

Los Alamos,'New' Mexico '875448- t ..

%

'

.

.

-

! Edward J. Walsh, Jr.., Esq.- "

.

Dr.: John C. Geyer,EChairman"  ?.' -

[LongiIsland Lighting cCompany '

,. ' . -

. Dept.'of, Geography.&:  ! ~%. 250,Old Country Road *-

,7 . Environmen tal ; Engineering - '

'! Mincola, ' Nc'v/ York i11501 '

.

-

,_

THe' Johns;Ilopkins ~Universit'y f f ' *

-

Jrj ,3 ' Baltimore, ~ Maryland - 21210 ~ V l'

'

'T

,

.~

_

Zwissler, Dicdolf '& Volkmanh,Esq:,

cn One Sout.h Ocean Avenuc- "'

.f_,[ -

.

.

.

.

,

C !Patchogue, New York 11772

'

w.

.

'

- ' .

.

. .

..

't - 8 0 C I E T E'D . \\ ' '

4

w.- ,

-

guig *- -

• *. :.

-

'..s S . ~ ,.

, . _

.

. ' ,~

' ~ * ~

• m W. ' - . 3r ving Liko- . _

- s, '*

D [ JUL121971 c* f torney for Tho Lloyd !!ar)'of, ',' ' . d ~

av (J ' '

- o --

"

$

smie son sees::rr M u Pran::s , udy Group, Inc.- ,

~

R ~" . ; !

., * 'r c ..

.y -

nc ~

.

irQ ^' [] _

- .

• _ l4 .