ML19338C087
| ML19338C087 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 07/09/1971 |
| From: | Like I LLOYD HARBOR STUDY GROUP, INC., REILLY & LIKE |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19338C084 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8007310669 | |
| Download: ML19338C087 (4) | |
Text
y...e g, k APPENDIX'A T
%e M
+
.v.,
d~
.,..aw f.;,,,-
,, : w..
8 i
30 W.
- p w
.,...u uu;.u..
j O-
< -- c a c t r i s o
\\\\
man.abin, ta 5'o-M2.J F
=
CSEC
~
7"a' 7 //
.i-JUL121971 >h 9
@I "I &
ms'a be t=ttm Sf (TdITED STATE!! CP AMERICA
.tmrm'N' ATOM 1C EUBRGY CUMl1LD!l10N
- r grau,.
/
Q' v\\
R y6 Ng$il y Y,~
J
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.)_ _ _ _ _ _
w _ _'_ _ _ _ _ x (-
o r,
oi
- u i
oj a
w..
~. - -
r.;c,. / m z...o.,, s.
~
p In.the Matter of.
.Q
~
~
h
\\
.. LONG ' ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY
~ ^ ["i C
(Shoreham Nuclear Power Plant e
- Docket No. 50-322 S ta tion, Unit'l) o e.
5 x
, ~. '.
.[
I
,1 NOTION OF INTERVENOR, THE LLOYD HARDOR
~*
- STUDY GROUP, ' INC., REGARDING VISIT TO ~
_ NATIONAL REACTOR TESTING STATION, IDAHO,
- AND DEPOSITIONS RE~ECCS TESTS q
i PLEASE.TAKE NOTICE that, pursuant to 10 CFR Part 2.
Sec' tion 2.741, intervenor, THE LLOYD HARBOR STUDY GROUP INC.,' moves-for an order:
1 Directing that the Staff produce copies of all 3
{
documents-and data which will.be relied upon in'its re 3.
evaluation.of the emergency c' ore cooling system of the pro
[,
~ posed Shoreham plant, Jincluding, but nct limited t6 the.
r t
documents and data. relating to tests 845-850 and the re'.
sults of the series 'of experiments conducted for the AEC at its National' Reactor Testing' Station in Idaho, tin Nov_
2 tember an.-d December of:1970. -
~
h, 2.:.
w Granting intervenor permission to visit the t
National Reactor Testing Station in l Idaho to take' the de 07 p
9, 4
. _. e.
~m m_.
- z
.=
b,.
,.3
=
y
~
s,5 ' *
- l. *. ;I
,R
- . *;. :.,.~;
.'o.. : *
,'fn *j.':-;'u w
.. :.e 9,
q) p i
. position of the personnel who: conducted such tests and ex-l 1
4.
periments,- and to examine an'd receive copien of t.he docu-
]
ments and data generated by such tests and experimentn.
7 -
3
-PLEASE TAKE-FURTHER N.OTICE that intervenor requests' the Board to visit said Idaho facility, at its earliest -
l convenience, and to fam'111ar'ize 'itself firsthand win ' the
~
.ized by the Staff in its sources of.information being ut I
reevaluation-of t1e emergency core cooling system and, if
'l 3
.,rw 1.
possible, that the Board be present during-the taking of.c 4
j/.
depositions by the' intervenoi.
. l. g.'.
'g 4
,.y 1
^
The failure.-of the ECCS tests at the Idaho facility
~ '
}
.. s..
't have become.a matter of widespread public concern and has s.-
rai. sed anew the question. of khether nuclear plants are
- w. " '.
e,.
unsafe.
An example of this anxi,ety is the article entiticd.,
4 a-1.
" Nuclear Power. Plants are Unsafe" by Wilson Clark, published,
in "Not-Man Apart",, July 1971, Vol.-1, No.f7, a publication issued by the' influential and respected organization, Friends
~,
r.-
I
~.
f a
.j, of th.e : Earth.
This article,. a copy of which is attached..
'o 1
^:; -
4 hereto, written by_an outspo!:en critic of nuclear power,
- -
- U
- n..
reflects the - growing anxi'ety of.~the-public on the. question p
I of the safety of. nuclear power plants and points up the.
,.J g
a,
- U need for a thorough dishlosure of all relevant facts con
~
~,
~
r. ',.
h..
cerning thel effectiveness of the' ECSS.
g, q
.g 9.;
.tl
~
-3
{g 'q
.Intervenor requests this relief so that -it can obtain
- .e
- w, ' ',.,
.",-s.
w nI,,.,,
[*
-.r. * [,e.
- e h,
.j.
4
--4
.. (
14 3
R_
.,.,p'
_A'
~k
. - ~.
4
~7 3.
fn, ' ','.
- m
...b
~],
e.. ys c,,-g hu < :
g
,.-j 3.
^ - '*,
e,s' j
.m t
c 4.
, s.
- I.
~
4.
- evidence necessary.to enable'it to prepare 6dditional cross--
~ [
- pximlimt. loir on. the embjont of',- the emergency core cooll na '
Q l
system and the Staff's report of its reevaluation of the 4
,7
-.;ECCS, and tol prepare intervenor's additional affirmat.ivo
~
testimony and supplemental findings of fact on the ECCS.
., J ['
(
{sgranted, intervenor' intends' If this application to, bring with it to the. Idaho f acility one or more technical f.~
, }s
~
consultants competent to evaluate the results and data eman ~
y 4
ating'from-such tests'and experiments, and to participate.in p.
the interrogation of the personnel who were involved in such.
I y, :.., i. *,.,
'3 ln ' -
tests.
,. c f I,
.; w
- 2......,,-..'..
n...
In view of the - tremendous -potential. damage that,' could., '
~, " ' '
'C
,r-
.~r.
y
~
result from -a failure of the ' emergency core coolindy system,
+'
and the importance of such s'ystem in preventing major acci.
>?
.. a., '
^i.
.dents,J it is the duty of this, Board in evaluating the pro-s.
t
. posed Shoreham reactor to do-its uttaost to learn as much as ;
..j. ',
T
- b..-
s.
'd it can about the.. unsuccessful! results experienced in the
,[-
t t c;,
- o., -
November.and December 1970 series of tests of the ECCS at
'I
!ij'
) l.
l J'
..'h r i. -
,, ? '.
th e.. Idaho facility.
'1 n
.n, :.
w p
ry2
{ Respectfully submitted,,,. - T
^t*-
e
., W a,
.) ;-
=3
' J'
. Dated: July 9/1971.
t t -
g r
s ITHE:.LLOYD HARBOd ST' TIDY GROUP
,e 5
.c s
J
- nl 3
( 6..
- INC.
~
t.4s ',x l-
., i,-,
,,e
"., V'.r l BY:; REILLY, LIKE & SCHNEIDER..;, t i
- j j a ;.;
t l..
.. o
- ;,T,9 :.J
' c ai _ a..'
by:'
li,!
- ~
v.
1.
"$ :,.~
.a. -
~94 d.
Yli;
)
l',,,
Irving.Like-(;f.*,m
, J.J t.-
i
-Attorneys for Intervenor.
v.
.py,
';,:,1.
.. ~ ', ' 0 200 West Main. Street '
p; ">. 7gf g. J '.
- , *. - 7
. Babylon,'New York 11702,'~~
4 f.
,q.
v, w.;
.m.
f F
i:.
- fv >,t
. W} '.
L 1-n
_.~,mg, _ -,:.'. t t-n 4 :7'.):.
~ _.,7
- ).
, m.g,ng,3 ;.,,.,,.g w
y
-t q)gggg,TtlU@th'
-DOCXE
'c
-s 7,
g,ygq, y n gg_%Q,
.(
u
(
s,
- i
...q s
y t-j-
g:
UNITED STATES OF' AMERICA i-
~
ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION.;.'
.?
c l.
(
_x 4
(In the Matter of;.
.t r, 7. -
LONG ISLAND ' LIGHTING CddPANY.,
_....,.......,.......-r.__,.y.,-.--l.i-i.
~
- (Shoreham. Nuclear Power y.
Docket No. 50-322 T
ant Station,' Unit 1)'
)
/L l
^
7
.j
- a-
{
,.. t., a..
',c ;
_x
.r
~.y s i t
' CERTIFICATE OF_
ERVICE
-I lereby. certify that copieslof ' the " Motion ~of Intervenor,' The -
p r:
-Lloyd Harbor ~ Study Group, Inc.;,- Regarding. Visit to National ~
Reactor Testing ?-Station,- Idaho, and Depositions Re ECCS Tests",
1
T dated July 9,1971, in the' cap,'tioned matter, have been served -
on L he. following by deposit 'in the United States mail, first.
2
~
t class or airmail,.this 9th' day of July-1971:
g.
,s.
e.,,
~
' '.. y.... 7 5
g Hon. J&mes R. Yore 86cr4tary
~
~
~
4_
Atomi.c Safety & Licensing Board U.S. Atomic Energy Commission'.' M Atomic Energy Commission' Washington, D.C.
- 20545,
}
Washin,gton,.D.C.
20545
[
Joseph.Scinto, Esq......
[,. /'
' ^
'D'r.
A'.
Dixon Callihan Atobic Energy Council-
' Union Carbide' Corporation 112 State Street 1
't P.O. Box Y
. I. -
Albany,'New York
~
r 1'.
. Oak Ridge; Tennessee 37830
,,s
~
l
. Martin'G. Halsch, Esq.
3 i,;
.Dr..Hugh'C.:Paxton Trial Counsel--
/
t Los AlamosJSciontific-Laboratory,
' Box 1663~-
~,
- U.S.JAtomic Energy Commission 4
Washington, D.C.
20545.-
/
- Los Alamos,'New' Mexico '875448-t
?.' [LongiIsland Lighting cCompany Edward J. Walsh, Jr.., Esq.-
Dr.: John C. Geyer,EChairman"
. Dept.'of, Geography.&:
! ~%.
250,Old Country Road Mincola, ' Nc'v/ York i11501
. Environmen tal ; Engineering -
,7 THe' Johns;Ilopkins ~Universit'y f f '
Jrj,3
' Baltimore, ~ Maryland - 21210 ~ V l' Zwissler, Dicdolf '& Volkmanh,Esq:,
'T cn
.~
One Sout.h Ocean Avenuc-
.f_,[
C
!Patchogue, New York 11772 w
't
- 8 0 C I E T E'D.
\\\\
4
- w.-
guig *-
,~
' ~ * ~
- m W. '..s S. ~,.
-. 3r ving Liko-s, '*
D
[
JUL121971 c* f torney for Tho Lloyd !!ar)'of, ',' '. d
~
(J smie son sees::rr
~
.y nc M u Pran::s,
udy Group, Inc.-
R ~". ; !
o --
av irQ ^'
[]
., * 'r c l4
~
.