|
---|
Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20063N7471982-10-0606 October 1982 Motion for Termination of Proceedings.Util Decided to Cancel Plant.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20063N7591982-10-0606 October 1982 Withdrawal of Application for CP ML20055A7221982-07-15015 July 1982 Memorandum & Order Denying Jf Doherty 820615 Submittals, Treated as Motion to Reconsider ASLB 820602 Order.Motion Untimely Filed & Failed to Show Significance or Gravity of Issues ML20055A3551982-07-12012 July 1982 Amended Contention 59.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20054L4521982-07-0202 July 1982 Response Opposing J Doherty 820615 Motion to Reopen Record to Add Contention 59.Motion Fails to Establish Timeliness &/Or Significance of Issues Sought to Be Raised.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20054L5531982-07-0202 July 1982 Response Opposing Doherty 820615 Motion to Reopen Record to Add Contention 59.Motion Should Be Considered Motion for Reconsideration of ASLB 820602 Order.Timeliness & Significance of Issues Not Established.W/Certificate of Svc ML20054J9371982-06-28028 June 1982 Response Opposing J Doherty 820615 Request to Reopen Record. Request Improper & Insufficient to Support Relief.Commission Rules Cannot Be Circumvented by Refiling Same Argument After ASLB Ruling Issued.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20054F9861982-06-15015 June 1982 Motion to Reopen Record to Take Evidence on Contention 59. Gravity of Issues Warrants Reopening ML20054G0171982-06-15015 June 1982 Contention 50 Re Brown & Root Deficiencies in Quadrex Rept. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20053D0861982-05-24024 May 1982 Response in Opposition to Util 820519 Motion to Strike Doherty Contention 58 Re Applicant Conduct on Reporting Violations.Contention Should Be Treated as Such,Not as Motion.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20052H8621982-05-19019 May 1982 Motion to Strike J Doherty Reply to Applicant 820507 Response to Doherty 820422 Motion to Add Contention 58. Commission Rules Do Not Allow Reply.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20052H4441982-05-14014 May 1982 Reply Opposing Applicant 820507 Response to J Doherty 820422 Motion to Add Contention 58.Contention Should Be Admitted W/Amends.Aslb Should Judge Conduct of Applicants. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20052F3121982-05-0707 May 1982 Response Opposing J Doherty 820422 Motion to Add Contention Re Alleged Failure to Rept Design Defects.Substantively, Motion Is Motion to Reopen Record & Stds Have Not Been Met. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20052D1221982-04-29029 April 1982 Findings of Fact on Supplemental Issues to Tx Pirg Addl Contention 31 Re Technical Qualifications.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20052A4541982-04-22022 April 1982 Submittal of Contention 58 Re Applicant Conduct on Reporting Violations at Plant.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20054E0561982-04-21021 April 1982 Supplemental Findings of Fact on Tx Pirg Addl Contention 31 Re Technical Qualifications.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20050J1111982-04-0606 April 1982 Answers to Second & Third Sets of Interrogatories,Questions 29 & 8 Respectively,Re Quadrex Rept.Certificate of Svc Encl. Related Correspondence ML20050E2961982-04-0505 April 1982 Answers & Objections to Seventh Set of Interrogatories. Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20050E2891982-04-0505 April 1982 Answers & Objections to Doherty Sixth Set of Interrogatories.Related Correspondence ML20050C4211982-04-0202 April 1982 Objections to Request for Admissions.Requests Untimely, Irrelevant to Issues Before ASLB & Extremely & Unduly Burdensome.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20050C4081982-03-31031 March 1982 Answers & Objections to Fifth Set of Interrogatories. Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20050C4791982-03-29029 March 1982 Answers & Objections to Jf Doherty Fourth Set of Interrogatories Re Tx Pirg Contention 31 & Quadrex Matters. Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20042C6181982-03-29029 March 1982 Response Opposing J Doherty 820315 Motion for ASLB to Subpoena Quadrex Corp Employee Witnesses as ASLB Witnesses. Request Is Based on Misperception of Scope of Reopened Hearings.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20042C6431982-03-29029 March 1982 Motion for ASLB to Call DE Sells as Witness for Tx Pirg Addl Contention 31 & Quadrex-related Matters.Testimony Needed to Explain Why NRC Did Not Immediately Obtain Quadrex Rept. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20050C5091982-03-26026 March 1982 Response to Jf Doherty 20th & 21st Requests for Documents. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20050C5041982-03-26026 March 1982 Testimony of Lj Sas on Tx Pirg Addl Contention 31 Re Quadrex Rept.Rept Raises No Issue as to Whether Ebasco Can Properly Engineer Project.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20050C5011982-03-26026 March 1982 Supplemental Testimony of Jh Goldberg on Technical Qualifications.Brown & Root Terminates Due to Lack of Engineering Productivity,Not Due to Allegations in Quadrex Rept ML20042C5201982-03-25025 March 1982 Motion to Compel Discovery from Applicant & to Postpone Evidentiary Presentations at 820412 Hearings.Applicant Objections to Interrogatories Unsupported & Necessitate Hearings Be Delayed.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20049K0671982-03-25025 March 1982 Reply to Tx Pirg 820315 Addl Proposed Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20049K0801982-03-25025 March 1982 Answers & Objections to Interrogatories.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20042C5481982-03-23023 March 1982 Fourth Set of Requests for Admissions Re Quadrex Rept & Tx Pirg Contention 31.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20049K0841982-03-23023 March 1982 Answers & Objections to Third Set of Interrogatories. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20049K0941982-03-23023 March 1982 Answers & Objections to Second Set of Interrogatories. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20042A4791982-03-17017 March 1982 Response Opposing J Doherty 820310 Motion for Postponement of 820412 Hearings.Sufficient Grounds Not Provided to Justify Delay.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20042B2351982-03-17017 March 1982 Seventh Set of Interrogatories Re Tx Pirg Addl Contention 31 & Quadrex Rept Matters.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20042B2381982-03-15015 March 1982 Sixth Set of Interrogatories Re Tx Pirg Addl Contention 31 & Quadrex Rept Matters.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20042B2451982-03-15015 March 1982 Motion for Subpoena of Quadrex Corp Employees.Testimony Necessary for Clear Understanding of Brown & Root Deficiencies Despite Util Supervision & Specific Steps Needed to Correct & Prevent Problems.W/Certificate of Svc ML20041F0761982-03-10010 March 1982 Fourth Set of Interrogatories Re Tx Pirg Contention 31 & Quadrex Rept.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20041F0871982-03-10010 March 1982 Motion for Postponement of 820412 Hearing on Tx Pirg Addl Contention 31 & Quadrex-related Matters.Addl Time Needed to Complete Discovery.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20049J6571982-03-0808 March 1982 Answers to First Set of Interrogatories Re Tx Pirg Contention 31 & Quadrex Matters.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20041E1001982-03-0505 March 1982 First Set of Interrogatories & Request for Production of Documents.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20041E1071982-03-0505 March 1982 First Set of Interrogatories & Request for Production of Documents Re Tx Pirg Contention 31.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20041E1181982-03-0505 March 1982 Third Set of Interrogatories Re Tx Pirg Contention 31 & Quadrex Rept Matters.Related Correspondence ML20041E1201982-03-0505 March 1982 Motion for Order Directing Applicant to Provide Forthcoming Bechtel Quadrex Rept Review.Rept Pertinent to Remaining Issue.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20041E1741982-03-0505 March 1982 Brief Opposing R Alexander Appeal from ASLB 820112 Order Denying Petition to Intervene.Aslb Did Not Abuse Discretion in Denying Petition.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20041E0711982-03-0404 March 1982 Second Set of Interrogatories Re Tx Pirg Contention 21 & Quadrex Rept Matters.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20049H8881982-03-0101 March 1982 Response Opposing D Marrack 820213 Motion for Review of Dates for Reopening Hearings & Continuance.No Commission Regulations or Atomic Energy Act Provisions Require Applicant Irrevocable Commitment.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20041B5381982-02-22022 February 1982 Reply to Intervenors Proposed Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20041C0671982-02-22022 February 1982 Response Opposing Tx Pirg 820209 Motion for Addl Time to File Proposed Findings of Fact & Conclusion of Law.Motion Mooted by Tx Pirg Filing Proposed Findings on 820212. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20041B5421982-02-17017 February 1982 First Set of Interrogatories Re Tx Pirg Contention 31 & Quadrex Matters.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence 1982-07-02
[Table view] Category:TRANSCRIPTS
MONTHYEARML20050C5011982-03-26026 March 1982 Supplemental Testimony of Jh Goldberg on Technical Qualifications.Brown & Root Terminates Due to Lack of Engineering Productivity,Not Due to Allegations in Quadrex Rept ML20050C5041982-03-26026 March 1982 Testimony of Lj Sas on Tx Pirg Addl Contention 31 Re Quadrex Rept.Rept Raises No Issue as to Whether Ebasco Can Properly Engineer Project.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009H2161981-07-30030 July 1981 Suppl Testimony of D Marrack Re Viable Fishery ML20009E3641981-07-24024 July 1981 Transcript of Rc Iotti Testimony on Behalf of Util on Bishop Contention 17 Re Tnt Detonation ML20009E8661981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of DA Hamon Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Public Interest Research Group Addl Contention 55 (Rapid Depressurization - Steam Break).Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E2941981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Wf Mercurio Testimony on Behalf of Applicant Re ASLB Question 8 (Reactor Bldg Subsurface Soil Mechanics) ML20009E2961981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of R Cheng Testimony on Behalf of Applicant Re ASLB Question 10 (Drywell Pressure Testing).Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3531981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Wf Mercurio Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Doherty Contention 29,blockage of Intake Canal ML20009E3591981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Cg Robertson Testimony Re Doherty Contention 8 & ASLB Question 3 on Atws.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3031981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of GL Sozzi on Doherty Contention 32 Re ECCS Vaporization Rate ML20009E3151981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Rl Call 810720 Testimony on Doherty Contention 26 (Stud Bolts).Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E4351981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Gw Oprea & Jh Goldberg Testimonies on Technical Qualifications & Tx Public Interest Research Group Addl Contention 31.Corporate Nuclear Organization Chart Encl ML20009E3481981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of G Martin Testimony on Behalf of Util on Mccorkle Contention 9 Re Chlorine Monitoring.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3451981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of G Martin Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Doherty Contention 40,10CFR100 Releases.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3431981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Rc Iotti Testimony on Behalf of Util on Bishop Contention 6 & ASLB Question 12 Re Shell Oil Co 6-inch Liquid Petroleum Gas Pipeline ML20009E3171981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Jc Elliott,Tc Cheng,Md Weingart,Pa Ranzau & Cg Robertson 810720 Testimony on Tx Public Research Interest Group (Prig) Addl Contention 53,ASLB Questions 4B & 4A & Pirg Contentions 28 & 52.W/prof Qualifications ML20009E3211981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of SA Hucilk & Jj Boseman Testimonies on Doherty Contention 17,RL Huang Testimony on Tx Public Research Interest Group Addl Contention 41 & Jn Bailey Testimony on Doherty Contention 42.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3111981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of MR Lane 810720 Testimony Re Doherty Contention 41 (Reactor Water Level Indicators).Prof Qualifications Encl ML19347F5361981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of DG Tees Re Doherty Contention 47,turbine Missiles.Related Correspondence ML19347F5391981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Fj Meyer Re Doherty Contention 30, Interconnection/Grid Stability.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5201981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of DC Papone Re Board Question 6,ability of Applicant to Demonstrate Compliance w/10CFR50,App A.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5241981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of RA Clarke & Jf Montalbano Re Doherty Contention 10,diesel Generator Reliability.Prof Qualifications Encl. Related Correspondence ML19347F5271981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Rc Iotti & Ws Carnes Re Doherty Contention 47, Turbine Missiles.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5291981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Ma Ross Re Doherty Contention 48,control Rod Drive Return Line.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5301981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Cw Dillman Re Doherty Contention 6, Recirculation Pump Overspeed.Prof Qualifications Encl. Related Correspondence ML19347F5311981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Mf Alesky Re Doherty Contention 50,jet Pump Beams.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5341981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of s Ranganath Re Tx Pirg Contention 39,Generic Task A-11,fracture Toughness.Prof Qualifications Encl. Related Correspondence ML19347F5351981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Rl Baron Re Tx Pirg Addl Contention 21, Occupational Exposure.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5321981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Jf Montalbano & FP Barbieri Re Tx Pirg Contention 12,cable Fires.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5371981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Ma Ross Re Board Question 8,Seismic Category 1 Control Rods.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5221981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of MD Weingart & F Barbieri Re Tx Pirg Addl Contention 10 & Mccorkle Contention 30,charcoal Adsorber Fires.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5151981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of R Williams & N Horton Re Doherty Contentions 14 & 25,on Main Steam Line Radiation Monitor & Fuel Failure/ Flow Blockage,Respectively.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML20003G6781981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Tx Pirg Addl Contention 26 Re Computer Code Error.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20003G6711981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Doherty Contentions 3,39 & 20(a) Re Fuel Specific Enthalpy,Fuel Swelling & Gap Conductance,Respectively.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6751981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Tx Pirg Contention 6 (Mccorkle Contention XI) Re Aircraft Hazards.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6761981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Doherty Contention 9 Re Containment Buckling.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6771981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Doherty Contention 27 Re Reactor Pedestal.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6741981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Bishop Contentions 4,5,7,9 & 10 Re Tx Electric Svc Co 24-inch Natural Gas Pipeline & Pipelines Crossing Brazos River Upstream from Facility.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6731981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Doherty Contention 7 Re LPCI Cold Slug.Prof Qualifications Encl ML19345H1121981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony Supporting Doherty Contention 3 on Inadequacy of Design Safety Limit of Applicant Fuel Rods.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20003B2381981-02-0606 February 1981 Errata Sheet for L Perl Testimony,Page 12,Line 13 & Table 9. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20003A2101981-01-27027 January 1981 Errata Sheet to s Michaelson Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML19343B8481980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Bishop Contention 1 Concerning Population Projections ML19340D1401980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony Re Tx Pirg Contention 1(f) Re Population Risks. Pp 1-8 ML19343B8451980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Hinderstein Contention 5 Concerning Coastal Sites ML19343B8491980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Hinderstein Contention 5 Concerning Coastal Site.Tera Corp Coastal Site Comparison Rept, Encl ML19343B8391980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Pirg Contention 5 Concerning Solid Waste Combustion ML19343B8471980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Pirg Contention 1 Concerning South Texas Project 3 Versus Allens Creek 1. Analysis of Prime Farmland Soils Encl ML19343B8461980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Hinderstein Contention 5 Concerning Coastal Sites ML19343B8441980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Pirg Contention 1 Re South Texas Project 3 Versus Allens Creek Site.Listing of Cost Savings Encl 1982-03-26
[Table view] Category:DEPOSITIONS
MONTHYEARML20050C5011982-03-26026 March 1982 Supplemental Testimony of Jh Goldberg on Technical Qualifications.Brown & Root Terminates Due to Lack of Engineering Productivity,Not Due to Allegations in Quadrex Rept ML20050C5041982-03-26026 March 1982 Testimony of Lj Sas on Tx Pirg Addl Contention 31 Re Quadrex Rept.Rept Raises No Issue as to Whether Ebasco Can Properly Engineer Project.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009H2161981-07-30030 July 1981 Suppl Testimony of D Marrack Re Viable Fishery ML20009E3641981-07-24024 July 1981 Transcript of Rc Iotti Testimony on Behalf of Util on Bishop Contention 17 Re Tnt Detonation ML20009E8661981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of DA Hamon Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Public Interest Research Group Addl Contention 55 (Rapid Depressurization - Steam Break).Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E2941981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Wf Mercurio Testimony on Behalf of Applicant Re ASLB Question 8 (Reactor Bldg Subsurface Soil Mechanics) ML20009E2961981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of R Cheng Testimony on Behalf of Applicant Re ASLB Question 10 (Drywell Pressure Testing).Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3531981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Wf Mercurio Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Doherty Contention 29,blockage of Intake Canal ML20009E3591981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Cg Robertson Testimony Re Doherty Contention 8 & ASLB Question 3 on Atws.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3031981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of GL Sozzi on Doherty Contention 32 Re ECCS Vaporization Rate ML20009E3151981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Rl Call 810720 Testimony on Doherty Contention 26 (Stud Bolts).Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E4351981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Gw Oprea & Jh Goldberg Testimonies on Technical Qualifications & Tx Public Interest Research Group Addl Contention 31.Corporate Nuclear Organization Chart Encl ML20009E3481981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of G Martin Testimony on Behalf of Util on Mccorkle Contention 9 Re Chlorine Monitoring.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3451981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of G Martin Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Doherty Contention 40,10CFR100 Releases.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3431981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Rc Iotti Testimony on Behalf of Util on Bishop Contention 6 & ASLB Question 12 Re Shell Oil Co 6-inch Liquid Petroleum Gas Pipeline ML20009E3171981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Jc Elliott,Tc Cheng,Md Weingart,Pa Ranzau & Cg Robertson 810720 Testimony on Tx Public Research Interest Group (Prig) Addl Contention 53,ASLB Questions 4B & 4A & Pirg Contentions 28 & 52.W/prof Qualifications ML20009E3211981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of SA Hucilk & Jj Boseman Testimonies on Doherty Contention 17,RL Huang Testimony on Tx Public Research Interest Group Addl Contention 41 & Jn Bailey Testimony on Doherty Contention 42.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3111981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of MR Lane 810720 Testimony Re Doherty Contention 41 (Reactor Water Level Indicators).Prof Qualifications Encl ML19347F5361981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of DG Tees Re Doherty Contention 47,turbine Missiles.Related Correspondence ML19347F5391981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Fj Meyer Re Doherty Contention 30, Interconnection/Grid Stability.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5201981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of DC Papone Re Board Question 6,ability of Applicant to Demonstrate Compliance w/10CFR50,App A.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5241981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of RA Clarke & Jf Montalbano Re Doherty Contention 10,diesel Generator Reliability.Prof Qualifications Encl. Related Correspondence ML19347F5271981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Rc Iotti & Ws Carnes Re Doherty Contention 47, Turbine Missiles.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5291981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Ma Ross Re Doherty Contention 48,control Rod Drive Return Line.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5301981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Cw Dillman Re Doherty Contention 6, Recirculation Pump Overspeed.Prof Qualifications Encl. Related Correspondence ML19347F5311981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Mf Alesky Re Doherty Contention 50,jet Pump Beams.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5341981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of s Ranganath Re Tx Pirg Contention 39,Generic Task A-11,fracture Toughness.Prof Qualifications Encl. Related Correspondence ML19347F5351981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Rl Baron Re Tx Pirg Addl Contention 21, Occupational Exposure.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5321981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Jf Montalbano & FP Barbieri Re Tx Pirg Contention 12,cable Fires.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5371981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Ma Ross Re Board Question 8,Seismic Category 1 Control Rods.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5221981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of MD Weingart & F Barbieri Re Tx Pirg Addl Contention 10 & Mccorkle Contention 30,charcoal Adsorber Fires.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5151981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of R Williams & N Horton Re Doherty Contentions 14 & 25,on Main Steam Line Radiation Monitor & Fuel Failure/ Flow Blockage,Respectively.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML20003G6781981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Tx Pirg Addl Contention 26 Re Computer Code Error.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20003G6711981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Doherty Contentions 3,39 & 20(a) Re Fuel Specific Enthalpy,Fuel Swelling & Gap Conductance,Respectively.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6751981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Tx Pirg Contention 6 (Mccorkle Contention XI) Re Aircraft Hazards.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6761981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Doherty Contention 9 Re Containment Buckling.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6771981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Doherty Contention 27 Re Reactor Pedestal.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6741981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Bishop Contentions 4,5,7,9 & 10 Re Tx Electric Svc Co 24-inch Natural Gas Pipeline & Pipelines Crossing Brazos River Upstream from Facility.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6731981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Doherty Contention 7 Re LPCI Cold Slug.Prof Qualifications Encl ML19345H1121981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony Supporting Doherty Contention 3 on Inadequacy of Design Safety Limit of Applicant Fuel Rods.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20003B2381981-02-0606 February 1981 Errata Sheet for L Perl Testimony,Page 12,Line 13 & Table 9. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20003A2101981-01-27027 January 1981 Errata Sheet to s Michaelson Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML19343B8481980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Bishop Contention 1 Concerning Population Projections ML19340D1401980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony Re Tx Pirg Contention 1(f) Re Population Risks. Pp 1-8 ML19343B8451980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Hinderstein Contention 5 Concerning Coastal Sites ML19343B8491980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Hinderstein Contention 5 Concerning Coastal Site.Tera Corp Coastal Site Comparison Rept, Encl ML19343B8391980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Pirg Contention 5 Concerning Solid Waste Combustion ML19343B8471980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Pirg Contention 1 Concerning South Texas Project 3 Versus Allens Creek 1. Analysis of Prime Farmland Soils Encl ML19343B8461980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Hinderstein Contention 5 Concerning Coastal Sites ML19343B8441980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Pirg Contention 1 Re South Texas Project 3 Versus Allens Creek Site.Listing of Cost Savings Encl 1982-03-26
[Table view] Category:NARRATIVE TESTIMONY
MONTHYEARML20050C5011982-03-26026 March 1982 Supplemental Testimony of Jh Goldberg on Technical Qualifications.Brown & Root Terminates Due to Lack of Engineering Productivity,Not Due to Allegations in Quadrex Rept ML20050C5041982-03-26026 March 1982 Testimony of Lj Sas on Tx Pirg Addl Contention 31 Re Quadrex Rept.Rept Raises No Issue as to Whether Ebasco Can Properly Engineer Project.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009H2161981-07-30030 July 1981 Suppl Testimony of D Marrack Re Viable Fishery ML20009E3641981-07-24024 July 1981 Transcript of Rc Iotti Testimony on Behalf of Util on Bishop Contention 17 Re Tnt Detonation ML20009E8661981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of DA Hamon Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Public Interest Research Group Addl Contention 55 (Rapid Depressurization - Steam Break).Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E2941981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Wf Mercurio Testimony on Behalf of Applicant Re ASLB Question 8 (Reactor Bldg Subsurface Soil Mechanics) ML20009E2961981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of R Cheng Testimony on Behalf of Applicant Re ASLB Question 10 (Drywell Pressure Testing).Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3531981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Wf Mercurio Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Doherty Contention 29,blockage of Intake Canal ML20009E3591981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Cg Robertson Testimony Re Doherty Contention 8 & ASLB Question 3 on Atws.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3031981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of GL Sozzi on Doherty Contention 32 Re ECCS Vaporization Rate ML20009E3151981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Rl Call 810720 Testimony on Doherty Contention 26 (Stud Bolts).Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E4351981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Gw Oprea & Jh Goldberg Testimonies on Technical Qualifications & Tx Public Interest Research Group Addl Contention 31.Corporate Nuclear Organization Chart Encl ML20009E3481981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of G Martin Testimony on Behalf of Util on Mccorkle Contention 9 Re Chlorine Monitoring.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3451981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of G Martin Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Doherty Contention 40,10CFR100 Releases.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3431981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Rc Iotti Testimony on Behalf of Util on Bishop Contention 6 & ASLB Question 12 Re Shell Oil Co 6-inch Liquid Petroleum Gas Pipeline ML20009E3171981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of Jc Elliott,Tc Cheng,Md Weingart,Pa Ranzau & Cg Robertson 810720 Testimony on Tx Public Research Interest Group (Prig) Addl Contention 53,ASLB Questions 4B & 4A & Pirg Contentions 28 & 52.W/prof Qualifications ML20009E3211981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of SA Hucilk & Jj Boseman Testimonies on Doherty Contention 17,RL Huang Testimony on Tx Public Research Interest Group Addl Contention 41 & Jn Bailey Testimony on Doherty Contention 42.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20009E3111981-07-20020 July 1981 Transcript of MR Lane 810720 Testimony Re Doherty Contention 41 (Reactor Water Level Indicators).Prof Qualifications Encl ML19347F5361981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of DG Tees Re Doherty Contention 47,turbine Missiles.Related Correspondence ML19347F5391981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Fj Meyer Re Doherty Contention 30, Interconnection/Grid Stability.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5201981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of DC Papone Re Board Question 6,ability of Applicant to Demonstrate Compliance w/10CFR50,App A.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5241981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of RA Clarke & Jf Montalbano Re Doherty Contention 10,diesel Generator Reliability.Prof Qualifications Encl. Related Correspondence ML19347F5271981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Rc Iotti & Ws Carnes Re Doherty Contention 47, Turbine Missiles.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5291981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Ma Ross Re Doherty Contention 48,control Rod Drive Return Line.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5301981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Cw Dillman Re Doherty Contention 6, Recirculation Pump Overspeed.Prof Qualifications Encl. Related Correspondence ML19347F5311981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Mf Alesky Re Doherty Contention 50,jet Pump Beams.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5341981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of s Ranganath Re Tx Pirg Contention 39,Generic Task A-11,fracture Toughness.Prof Qualifications Encl. Related Correspondence ML19347F5351981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Rl Baron Re Tx Pirg Addl Contention 21, Occupational Exposure.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5321981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Jf Montalbano & FP Barbieri Re Tx Pirg Contention 12,cable Fires.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5371981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of Ma Ross Re Board Question 8,Seismic Category 1 Control Rods.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5221981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of MD Weingart & F Barbieri Re Tx Pirg Addl Contention 10 & Mccorkle Contention 30,charcoal Adsorber Fires.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML19347F5151981-05-11011 May 1981 Testimony of R Williams & N Horton Re Doherty Contentions 14 & 25,on Main Steam Line Radiation Monitor & Fuel Failure/ Flow Blockage,Respectively.Prof Qualifications Encl.Related Correspondence ML20003G6781981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Tx Pirg Addl Contention 26 Re Computer Code Error.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20003G6711981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Doherty Contentions 3,39 & 20(a) Re Fuel Specific Enthalpy,Fuel Swelling & Gap Conductance,Respectively.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6751981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Tx Pirg Contention 6 (Mccorkle Contention XI) Re Aircraft Hazards.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6761981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Doherty Contention 9 Re Containment Buckling.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6771981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Doherty Contention 27 Re Reactor Pedestal.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6741981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Bishop Contentions 4,5,7,9 & 10 Re Tx Electric Svc Co 24-inch Natural Gas Pipeline & Pipelines Crossing Brazos River Upstream from Facility.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20003G6731981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony on Behalf of Util on Doherty Contention 7 Re LPCI Cold Slug.Prof Qualifications Encl ML19345H1121981-04-20020 April 1981 Testimony Supporting Doherty Contention 3 on Inadequacy of Design Safety Limit of Applicant Fuel Rods.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20003B2381981-02-0606 February 1981 Errata Sheet for L Perl Testimony,Page 12,Line 13 & Table 9. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20003A2101981-01-27027 January 1981 Errata Sheet to s Michaelson Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML19343B8481980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Bishop Contention 1 Concerning Population Projections ML19340D1401980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony Re Tx Pirg Contention 1(f) Re Population Risks. Pp 1-8 ML19343B8451980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Hinderstein Contention 5 Concerning Coastal Sites ML19343B8491980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Hinderstein Contention 5 Concerning Coastal Site.Tera Corp Coastal Site Comparison Rept, Encl ML19343B8391980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Pirg Contention 5 Concerning Solid Waste Combustion ML19343B8471980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Pirg Contention 1 Concerning South Texas Project 3 Versus Allens Creek 1. Analysis of Prime Farmland Soils Encl ML19343B8461980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Hinderstein Contention 5 Concerning Coastal Sites ML19343B8441980-12-18018 December 1980 Testimony on Behalf of Util Re Tx Pirg Contention 1 Re South Texas Project 3 Versus Allens Creek Site.Listing of Cost Savings Encl 1982-03-26
[Table view] |
Text
. .
,o
( )
, 5-11-81
%
p?mI;n CORRESPONDENCB // .
Was 3
'
-
'UN --
1
_-
MAy I b ~
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA - I981 >
'
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION om ,
BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD f/ $@& W. 8 3 % s N
4 In the Matter of S 5
5 HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER COMPTSY S Docket No. 50-466 S
6 (Allens Creek Nuclear Generating S Station, Unit 1) S 7
8 DIRECT TESTIMONY OF DAVID G. TEES ON BEHALF OF HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER COMPANY 9 REGARDING DOHERTY CONTENTION 47/ TURBINE MISSLES 10 Q. Please state your name and address, 11 A. My name is David G. Tees and my business address 12 is 611 Walker, Houston, Texas.
13 Q. By whom are you employed and in what capacity?
14 A. I am employed by Houston Lighting & Power Company 15 as Manager of Central Mechanical Maintensnee in the Energy 16 Production Department.
17 Q. How long have you been employed by Houston Light-18 ing & Power Company?
19 A. Frcr.: June, 1966 through September, 1972 and Jan-20 uary, 1974 to the present.
21 Q. Please give a brief description of your educa-22 tional background and experience.
23 A. I received a Bachelor of Science Degree in Mechan-24 ical Engineering from Texas A&M University.in May, 1966 and
,
810519o @
,,
.
.
1 a Master of Engineering Degree in Mechanical Engineering.
2 from Texas A&M University in December, 1973. I served as 3 supervisor of mechanical Maintenance Personnel performing 4 maintenance on boilers, turbines, and auxiliary equipment 5 until July, 1977. Since July, 1977 I have had responsibility 6 for scheduling and implementing all maintenance on HL&P's 7 power plants. Since 1968 I have been responsible for all of 8 HL&P's steam turbine internal inspection scheduling, includ-9 ing turbine reblading, inspections procedures, and field 10 balancing. this capacity, I am familiar with the 11 different varieties of turbine designs and the maintenance 12 requirements thereof.
13 Q. Have you read Doherty contention 47 regarding 14 turbine missics?
15 A. Yes.
16 Q. Are you familiar with the problem of turbine 17 cracking alluded to in the contention?
18 A. Yes. To the best of my knowledge, turbine wheel 19 failures have occurred in turbines manufactured from steels 20 referred to as chrome-molydenum (Cr-Mo) or an early version 21 of nickle-molydenum-vanadium (Ni-Mo-V) alloys. These wheels 22 were on older units which had a much smaller critical crack
'
23 size because they did not use the newer steels such as 24 Nickel-Chromium-Molydenum-Vanadium (NiCrMoV) , which is used
.
.
1 in the Allens Creek turbines.
2 Q. What do you mean by critical crack size?
3 A. Critical crack size refers to the size flaw that 4 must exist in the wheel material for a failure to occur at 5 operating conditions.
6 Q. What are the mechanisms for initiating and/or 7 growing cracks in nuclear wheels in service?
8 A. The two possible mechanisms are stress cycling and 9 stress corrosion cracking. The likelihood of initiating and/
10 or growing a crack due to stress cycling associated with 11 starts, stops, and load change is remote. Variations in 12 scress amplitude resulting from operating transients are too 13 low to produce crack initiation or significsnt crack growth.
14 The manner in which wheels are forged essentially precludes 15 the possibility of producing an internal crack-like defect 16 in the plane normal to the maximum stress (the axial-radial 17 plane). Furthermore, in additi6n to a complete visual and 18 magnetic particle inspection of all bore and external 19 surfaces, all modern nuclear wheel forgings are subjected 20 to a stringent 100% volumetric ultrasonic inspection at the time of manufacture. All modern nuclear wheels are spin 21 22 tested during manufacture at 20% overspeed, which further 23 minimizes the probability of having an undetected crack or 24 crack-like flaw with a critical size which would lead to
o 1 spontaneous propagation at normal rotating speeds. Thus, 2 there is a very low probability that modern turbine wheels 3 will be placed in service with defects of sufficient size to 4 grow in service due to stress cycling. Accordingly, the 5 most probable method of in-service initiation and growth of 6 cracks is that associated with stress corrosion. This was 7 the cause of the Yankee-Mowe failure and cracking found in 8 the Zion turbine.
9 Q. Where does the problem occur in the turbine?
10 A. For the generation of the large turbine wheel 11 missles that are of concern, the most likely region for the 12 initiation and growth of stress corrosion is the bore re-13 gion. The nominal rotational and shrink stresces are maxi-14 mum at the bore. The presence of the axial keyway at this 15 location introduces a region of stress concentration. The 16 material properties are generally somewhat lower in the 17 keyway region (the critical crack size is smaller). In 18 other regions of a nuclear turbine wheel, such as the 19 Periphery, stresses are considerably lower, so that crack 20 growth rates would be slower. Critical crack sizes would be 21 much greater, so that cracks would be, detectable during 22 periodic surface inspections before reaching critical size.
23 Q. What design changes have been nade to address this 24 problem?
_ _ -_-_-______
4
.
s 1 The design of the keyways used to attach the
,A.
2 wheels to the shaft is extremely important in determining 3 the likelihood of the initiation of stress corrosion cracks 4 in the bore region of th'e turbine wheel. Studies in the 5 United Kingdom, following the turbine failure at the Hinkley
$ Point "A" Power Station in 1969, showed that keyways with a 7 quasi-rectangular shape exhibited a strong resistance to 8 stress corrosion cracking, when operated in essentially the 9 same manner as the wheels with other keyway designs. No 10 keyway stress corrosion cracks were found in wheels with 11 quasi-rectangular keyways. The ACNGS turbine has the quasi-
- 12 rectangular keyway design.
13 0 Is it possible to design the turbines to totally 14 preclude the possibility of stress corrosion cracking?
15 A. No. That is the reason that we have a very 16 thorough testing and inspection program. In addition, the 17 turbine is aligned to reduce damage from missles in the 18 unlikely event they occur.
19 0 Would you describe the maintenance and inspection 20 procedure?
21 A. Although many design and operational techniques 22 have been used to minimize the possibility of stress corro-23 sion cracking, and even though no verified incidents of ,
24 stress corrosion cracking have occurred in GE nuclear turbine
- ,- - . , . . - . _ _ . - ... -
.
9 1 wheels, test equipment has been developed to detect stress 2 b corrosion cracking wel) before cracks cou'd grow to the size 3 necessary to cause wheel failure. For peripheral portions 4 of the wheel, the critical crack size is very large, ap-5 proachna the axial thickness of the wheel. Through the 6 ! periodic use of surface inspection techniques, cracks on the 7 periphery would be detected before they could grow to crit-8 ical size.
9 The bore and keyway regions of the wheels cannot be 10 tested by surface or magnetic particle tea: techniques 11 without removing them from the shaft. Therefore, an ultra-12 sonic test has been developed to detect cracks in these 13 regions with the wheels in place on the shaft. Tests are 14 made by pre;ecting an ultrasonic beam at various angles to 15 the bore from the surfaces of the turbine wheel. The ultra-16 sonic beams are projected and received by transducers placed 17 on the wheel surfaces. Radial and/or axial defects will be 18 detected by reflections of '.5e Seam that occur when a defect 19 is encountered. By vary.ng the transducer positions, essen-20 tially the entire length of the wheel bore can be tested.
21 To cbtain maximum coverage, each whee,1 may receive as many 22 as 40 individual scans.
23 0 IIas the use of newer steels f acilitated the ab-24 ility to detect cracks?
__,
.
_
1 A. Through the use of the new NiCrMoV steeis in 2 manufacturing the turbine wheels, the si;c of the flaw 3 necessary to cause wheel failure has greatly increased, 4 compared to the critical crack sizes of any of the.cheels 5 that have burst. Critical crack sizes in modern turbine 6 wheels are thus many times larger than the detectable sizes.
7 Q. Would you please summerize your test.imony?
8 A. In summary, the thorough pre-service inspections, 9 designs which result in low stresses and thus permit use of 10 lower strength materials, and the in-service inspection 11 program, all combine to produce a very low probability of 12 failurc of General Electric modern turbine wheels. Added 13 protection is achieved by alignment of the turbine to reduce 14 the probability of impacts in the unlikely event that c 15 missle ever occurs.
16 17 18 19 20 21 ,
22 23 24
.