ML20041F087

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Motion for Postponement of 820412 Hearing on Tx Pirg Addl Contention 31 & Quadrex-related Matters.Addl Time Needed to Complete Discovery.Certificate of Svc Encl
ML20041F087
Person / Time
Site: Allens Creek File:Houston Lighting and Power Company icon.png
Issue date: 03/10/1982
From: Doherty J
DOHERTY, J.F.
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
ISSUANCES-CP, NUDOCS 8203160177
Download: ML20041F087 (3)


Text

}p

. , i '

a Y

. g.
e. ,

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

' r/

F. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION . MarchK10, 1982 c . uwr l

,a17s. BEFORE THE A'TOMIC' SAFETY &' LICENSING BOARD 99 T

}

e p':V In the Matter of: p gg g g g i W

.Docketi No. 50-466. cpi HOUSTON LIGHTING -& POWER CO. . p, .i pi ., (Allens Creek Nuclear Generating. S n.9 );< * :0F.FICI 0F NCNE , .'? hb gs, @m g ,.,.'.. .Station, , ,.,.

Unit.1) Jl., 4 msu

,;,,,m . -

d.W.w, 9v N ~V-i 00CdETmG.,-  ; BMNCH & SEue' & .svw 9 4 :m . e-gs L rn. D v, w n.,.. m .. ..n3 g% > im;yW:.9:<@ ..&,4PMW:

  • O'. L .s . A '%mQ' #p t A.yf G .* ~ ,' . KINTERVENOR 'DOHERTT'S MOTION . FOR . 'POSTPONEM d? , Q CONTENTION Q Q @;^f RELATED MATTERS.3..~ , l; M z ., %198P_ HEARING ,,lp. ~.ON TE p .E.a n y ' W " p .. ' ' E.. , .

11- , ; A p.', H g J - ' G5'd.

. ; , b.Q;Je

{Q;gj$.y-e_.._

~. ,q'gOn t .

January 28,3 1982f the Boardyin;this1_ . . . . .. .z m p p proceeding?,.m*or., ....., TY, MMJ g

,M k r.g k ,m..n.

' dered" '(Hereinafter: W 4.u.._. Order) that ...

'additionalc

< :u.w:3. evidence h . &c% on' TexPI.RG t MR. ':

?fn.N~ 4 , Additional. '

~ Contention.31 v.% nbe'taken,in/orderitF.'

. . ,, . : = x. go g . : utilize.tbeh..

e s. w. 7,. . . +'.<4,,u\.. .

L n,h p.n

%5Mk.%.

Mk, - .J ~Texas ,, .

Quadrer u .

Report"i a review a ~of t the. design.~ofy , .. .w g Applicant '..s; South; .:,0 ' % %.

o W, 4

% mm ' Nuclear Pro;iect, UI nits.'1 & 2 2 i(50- 498,,,499) by Appli-J r ,. w.q,- -

c - f. -

de M;i ',  : cant '.s M,g . ~ ..:, .

consultant,

,, w - . ~ s . the Quadrer y<cw- Cornorationy.T m.w.w 1. :The Board ~statedi +< &zf; .A gn +

(Orderi:p.: 3),."If. problems duelto; Brown?&a Root E

.-.c.

on;were

.vy encountered  :.c v w. ' :.e ,:atJthe t:LSTNPm . 's actionsLor despite:. wr HL&:P's' m a,. m":. su

.ina,cti.~ e,n: -

$ . dW;;

%y y ,.

. w .v.s . ;w: q n.sy w rM ,is n.  :

y% ?n.... m . g the)  : m aBoard.g m .. - most certainl +wants to.;knowJwhat i spec. . . wmificlMW NMW

$ pW f M. vision, w :v.* m:.  : : . ' w . : v . v v . . ..yg . /.m acun . ~F . . + . ~v -

vc y# ,pl a.h Jcorrectivef or preventati:ve1 .vv. . .. . a r /-m procedures HI&P,[will' v.

followJ tod W:J v

,. m -m ssureothat th , c . . m , mq. e . a Nr l

u:llp@:M"

., /*

a'a :.w w w = L ; ;.Q,#y .

not w.www W .v.w'ACNGS.

occurta .w m.m:n.pn p..,.;n.,ese, "/cThe< Boar 6

pro y ptpt=.y $twalsoldesignatedithis-Intervenor'beflead; w v. w .i. w w . n .w.,m m m s-m.* party #.with,; discovery:A $ fi d.w& g gjgwiC..

p ..a immediately,

m. . ,, , , , ,init.iated;and,%"-

. . m .. v.;S5h.timelyr;mpu.w.w , ;w. ; v,q.m .w.w.,e v: m.m. . m ~ e compye 1'et ds.in7 4 .m order, i.;~y g.. , 5thate.th_. ?~ March 26th..; e dueid. ate . 9%y m,;.yCc3

.. ~ . . . , . ,o ~. n . ~t.sh.n.s.beS

~

allt nvmet..M8(Orderp,pV6)WG.y:

n- .

.%~ a y s 8, s

^

$pc.Q

\  :

- . . This;Intervenor,*linToider

w. ..

. :.u .. {toTeomp'12t'e)diAc~o'very

. . - - * .- ~ 4 w.:.. -

hh's"founO, YN'

< - . c a ,' :>d M..

b,#

wa. .it :neces.sary ..w.

to' move . : ?.for...

. n. e.m ans . .,~additional,'two r.~ - 3

. weeks ' . time . . : ,:2andPt 7 " V '. t -i>

M. T . u sets:forth below his reasons for the request.C - 4 'W W W O, ,

p toft $e

^

X '2

h. . ,n h.b. . $First',[ast$eBbdi'dnoted',(Orderh..k..:iththepeEi'od

.set,1aside

. time. for di,scovery was concur ~ren..t;

, ~. w. . ~ .

. n w

2 gQl,h.c .

a D. ,MJ . . . . ...

, w .,/

w for completi'n o of findings of facts'and conclusions of Iaw;

[

fo,r the eviilentiary hearing completed December 9,1981C. e ' "x M:q 7 T m

m . .. .

Thid. Intervenor fileda 28 page item on February 13, 1982, "

., which pre-cluded his efforts on the Quadrex issue to then.

L L' This Intervenor then followed.through on a ammitment made in July 1981, to take the semi-nnnual Texas Bar Examinatio to n.

on February 24th and 25th, and was largely unable to wm  %

on discovery during the period from February 13th to 2 t .

%CS.,s cD .9 '

W'R1 379g % -

D Vg6 5 q'%%l# 4 lf*

8203160177 820310 PDR ADOCK 05000466 bol @

G PDR g

. , - , , .m.. - pw - -m-,

- 2- .

(See: This Intervenor's letter to the Board of December 30,

. ~ 1981, with regard to scheduling)

Since the Bar Examination, this Intervenor has worked dilligently' at developing discovery, filing three.interrog-atory sets based on'the Quadrex ReporI:,(dealing mainly with b ,

~.a

,,y.., ~

. c ' the nuclear analysis and radiological.. areas ~ of ' the repo:r::, ~P e.T with incomplete treatment on the computer ~ code and mechanical- ,-

m, . .

. . .s m ,-

The other ; areas, .weil over one-halfi;

[. Q ; g -design. .p[a, reas. - '

. .['.

c

'Y of this thAee'-volume report of appro$timately 65O pages of #

F ' ? ~uch m highly. relevant information to Applicant's competence,,..  : '

. x.m m .

D.

u..u C.nhas.not.been LeP/A. . . . . - - > . . . .

,dealt with, and cannot~te

. - w~. in theitime remainingi -

.a ...

. This Intervenor,,fo11owing 10 CPR 2 740b(b) -

s 3 'for- In,terrogatories.

-y .,. . ; , .

s.v.: ..

$. . ,... ',., . . estimates theie is until 3/17/82 to .f,ile. . Interrogatories,. and '

.)

,(

),

3/21/82 [to] file requ'ests for admissi'onsC to receive replies ~_

';; _'-M u on April .10,.1982, two,,daysbeforejthkh' earing. -The current l,- .'

7,' g l (. . p1'an'which gives this' Intervenor 'one] add'i'tional week for inm "' >

. . ,. . . . ~ ., . .

W

'.n terrogatories will not be sufficient for this:Intervenor tol o.

. >,  ? , . . . .~ . .

, w:, ~ - .; .

. n -

M. M's.a

...,.......h. r ave a' fair. chance ~to complete discove..-ry.on thetQuadrer:Reporte. 'y e n -. -

. "gAA - for STNPc'and< the': Quadrer'

...nn Report,.forcAC. s NGSi w y.which.was.. s;; submitted ,ca .P. -
m. 4.g . . _ .

. . ,.n ., ..

wffFebruary612}jd982,'?two

. . p3' 4 a. _ ; . .x  :- weeks

.x ,. .. _, after..; .,thel. z . . p, Board Orderr-

~ -

n N, cv m -r M i Q:rc_.,

x Xp y g 2il m ' 9 +F. ue, r t uh ew r ,Y, -+..,:.. ,.andfan: imp;ortant '

.%consideration mm m 9 r 1her_e,.is)that,.?s - ' '

.c  ;;-,y, , ,

f. qd the.issuerof + . xw.- competences .e w .. to ". construct . .c w ,- m a .. nuclear

~ .

facility a ..

in .e W ' %L

. . . r

.p.Q@-

fjfQ3y .. c ."directly..effacts!alltsafetyf. aspects orithe~propos'd'ACNGS'.

f e  %..n.g  : Q. '- ..

1. & -

. .:.. .. .. n . w .. .

- m- . . .. - . . . , . ,

T"'s.

dJ:Im. .?.

plied'infall-of s.

the:6 Tsafe.ty:nissues,,.and'some

u. _. v.y 15 Board =~ W .

t{' 7. \,! ,' Questions;f.was.thatfplantTsystems.'and:' structures'would be"' C ~

3.

~

i!,!@w :Oa- , ' competently'. .,. , s designed nw , s. land {construcUedj . ,,. . w Tm8 m e,, nit'o' red (by the~ Appli-5 vn ., -

.. cant,*and function as'pr,edicted for the public safety. Any W 4 .

( f g.p l dou$t of. $$1s is 'of' mucOgreater significari~ce' than doubt: ~ ' W 'C 1 -

s. ww -

~

^ ;~ -

'about a single structure or syster because lack of compe- ,

~

ql tentmonitoring may spread it's harmful effect over many plant aspects.

Of course, it may strongly benefit Applicant to have this issue oromptly litigated, but this Intervenor maintains i the current schedule will not permit him a- fair opportunity to conduct discovery on a vital issue to plant safety, which l

e

.*1

- . , , . . -, m,. ,-- -- - . ,-

wy m s,.:

, - y. .

>(' -

1 W

, f,9 >. . .

e ..

n.~ 3. - .

as~

i J g. N' ,, . -

1 j.,.

{' can only decrease this Intervenor's and the Board's ability i

lr#

to reach a proper determination. , _

k.. This Intervenor therefore mov'es that hearings not ? r . '. ,

a.#

5 r

%e s,.

be6i n prior to April 26,3982.

~... .

<..e. .. re.9~. ~ .g.4. . . , ,

w. s ~v.

M.

a n.

.',o .*

LM i n

, . , . ,. i . M: i M :.a; m p. ..

e 4[p es .

. ~ ~ .n . . . c. m ,yJ f.pp.em.1 w. so. ..~ - g .

74W6

~

" D-fa.w.) f e -

.- SERVICE.OF. PROCESS-a;p". 0*

. 1 e: m.p W. 6 W~ pw.  !. A W .+ , 7. ,

.,,M,ym

-.4 ,. . ..: , u c. .w. . ." , .c. . <-. :: . .

. me

< w r . .. . .: . .

m .W ~ .e , a . ,. . y m , . -

N.y.fFm . iI certify?that' copies ofQINTERVENOTDUHERTY'S MOTION' POR@x.,@ t;$ m -

Ms}

M kdDN

%.m" '

7TIONAL'E & POSTPONEMENT'OF CONTENTION ~ 31_A. ND',QUADREI,

'RE THE Cl.

TERS L. ATED APRILM2; 1WereF erved

~ rv MAT. Post. A1982 l:Se...s. ic MK

. 1 on the parties below,;yiaiFirst; ass.U. .

S. a .... ..

$.g; , t . Jthi,s- /o7% .ofqMarch,q.1982l.from.-Houston,.

Texasy; W.:gg 4p;gg.

.e

- ., w . ;5 . . _

. j f< .. ,. m . . , . m .J- %r . w .

. ru, wn. ,+.nw,u.e

, .  % .. < . .. . . . g.... c.

m,. e . + .,,:.. ..

. . . , -.. w. . s. h. ,g.,...a nn ..A, ~ a, .,. e .. at..

. - . . s . . m m...>,..

. +s - s: , <.ai.wu,n.o..w

. . . - . ..e.~.. ,c; e . .

., c a. ~

?

. . .. - v . .,a- -e .e .

(Judgeg$ p g1' 1,' Sheld'otDJ.? Wolfe ,%Esq U,...Administy~ative,nJudg'e d3,.

A , c. ; Dr. E. Leonard:Cheatum; Administrative grf., $p#n,,_

GustaveiA.'Linenberger' Administrative 1Jud e dfc Q 4 W g y %gp.ty W ..'

Eg h* >

Richard AP Black,M Esq. Staff <.' O.l , A L @f.t,f%

6

.i.M.~ s .

g;.% / . ,. - Jack

'.J.. Gregory Copeland, .Esq. A.

R.' S wman',-Esq.:Appli. cant:3. %y,u'

. MS%. -

pplic. 5 M% a.nt%.W.y 32 *pg, y .ti *

..'The Several%InterveningjPartiesL.j g.% M,g.' U. QQS. , N.p :R. C e% -

d.'O 4. qi M9 RQCM.n*M@.hy n.

w o.-

pw,~. .

'" .+~ Atomic u.; + ,, -

' _ . , , . . -,,"7, 3,y:.

. .w. .n.~: .n.uSafety t;a ~n;e : '.5 LLi'

.x.x. w:, ,y. ,.;.p. .~:;;>, ;a;m .o ..:

x, . n..n u; censing

.w p . 3 47 . c q. A'44Appeal .w 4 %,,p

v. 1 Bo3

,, uyom ..

m ,w..;rpygMyq.m,f pg%4hp,, wcn 'f,;N y,.g+

& mm% w,g%.+%g%g)hn.p'p

%b. ~ . , , . 3, ; . s * .9

% 7. w#4; a . ;&.: Respe.ctfull P.4.r,n an.%{s;W w.. . c s 4..

i. b *
  • n i.y u. s.j % > ' ;

y Jf

  • yz 4 j . . - r-C -
, 3 ' Wf.%.M r .hr.

$L '

nvM

%N gytyf p sy f up%:~ 3NWeg .

- . .. y;;Qr,.., a ' w.';n .^l ' j, ' *

  • ' , q:...,;,'Y:*
  • - t .:n ~ r 9f9j .k%..Q 1

m o. -

. Po6%HN/dQc. n p.9,m.,MtY.

A,/y% 6

.n u 4phlw.* ?.,^ 4, -@W

+ru

'" S'c" M .

^ John

  • Pi DohertyW, .

L .; w%.m.f.y;g.,

y,;!d < W w  : W i. .~ u . , 'K. ^ ' %

s, a , .c m.7..

g.

v '~".?.h .

. a mm,y.u.w .,'sm d;c. . w L v.v.r ua.. pg..%; .

wg : pgt*k!Q:r ps.ma wp.Mm '~k,a'M it n.

n.

g.ms ,

. n. %

n .c.n p t ;m.y . e# vy. wa q,g q... r y . .u4.ec. g., s. g>m.m.n u

. <m . g%. ,

n.,m.s.s pw.y .

.43.. ;4: ,..o.,.,4 e 3-

..+ -

.y ,.- .o m.,.,4.x.. 41 ww ss.

4. ".e

. m + . . .. .

.-: %. &,, m. .m .. <:

m r t c ,; . ' ...e .g% ,

e w-p @ -* > . , * , , r %. . m.- . ) ,.. . .. ' ?r ',: w was. ,.: a -

~

.s -

.s 3 9 'm , ',

  • _. 5- *r -,'~,* ~c 4 ' .'

.;m .t . "Y

' d; ' m .m',*@T w  ; 2 6 * % .2 : s<

Wl7'.

6 6

  • a .4 * *

-' ,'. ;'. -~ #

r '4e.; ~ P

!4' ' ' #

~#

I *

  • ' a-
  • d.N ***ig4

>+ . . 'w ,*/

'.'.g

, , - - . . ' . g,a=. 2-~ *, j <.. " <

g l .-

, f .,.%

.,.?..d M.f . .; f@...

.w. .. *..,>>s y~ /,a.. TP .."'c i.

. 6 e

r e (;g..n . * /1 .

% .m. .I, s;,. ;..m

, . . ' ;.' S 4

, g -

< i.( 4 - ; '.

,. t. -

o. . ns. . . .* >c: t ..4 4 < i* .; 7,.*v. *t .". . a..T ' A. .",. .

.g ,d A.

  • ? ..--::; <* - 73 , m .,%,m. *;9 + [ .,. . '

i ;w; t 4 ; - ,

(n  ? , . . 1

,-- .. 3 .] .. -';. , j,,2.g J

<,,S--

. , . % k. ,, . .,. . ./j y , ' ', ; g ; g ;,w

,s

,- . < ' re w' , , ,e 4 5

.G ' L* j ;

.y .S ".%.g.; f p; ,.. r-9 Q. % j f(

Lt ,,,s

> w -

L yn. .-*  : p. ; . s.

  • _ y, pp . g7

)..s ,

,cg;

' t "s

. -., + ..** y- y' . ~.cs.-j;* WW_

f li

, e r

F",~,

  • --A

.; g;Y gr .w b*(-

J J ,lM f *L . *'

d.sp I 1,hc sn e.1 s .~ , F.'

,; ; ua

_[a), -e

,','r' ,

r,--

. . . i rl M s e [. 4 -4,.', { , [ ., O 2 Y . *&

  • O .T d
19 s' ; ,

.stL .. . . ,~.; ... ~.

^

..; w. . , '

rt

"; ;&43 O'

~ -

.- W,.

#1 ~ .
*

v< : ~ ,w

.n c 7 elt . .

. b 5 4 '

4 ed f {,

s'uj

.. . .-' ey 4

. . c' p .~e 1

I

/

N l

i 1

  • i .

5 e

4 1

i . %r'.'-W ~w" ,

r

'> * . m..

n e A-* s gd a%

t s* r i e9

'T , dj ( ,.-

L

.-1 , ,.

' ,, .y 1P. . , y* 'r.4+.

( ,

'm < s t #. , +

  • I

, r'+.'M # I d, ' h. [f.<-

/. , ' . ' ' . .

fv

[* G' ':p.

.4' p p. ',,

..$., , ,y 4

4 s a s a s

f. , '4, g. ke[J j l

.,,..rn y

.j we

'd ' M - , h a. >

4 . . , p .e .n V1 4 #

  • g
  1. d e e

.5p ' s*

  • d ..d  %

-V.ai , .' *4.* 5 . 4 , t' I

3

,e r

s . 8, . ,'t J i v ..  ; }. *,, ?- a t, ll ~ ~ ** , v;; , e s k, ' R ' . .

A

. j Qp,, s

, , i ' s +

a _'C' ~

, /* v Wf' -%gWp ,..

. ; L v:,& @'. %l x .

?

.,m." .

. 7b'~'- , . , . . J;.. ~ & . 4 . e r ; 3:n ~ c t - W*

p

~..

'f 1 1, a '4W .C  :.

~.,_'f s

c . . ~m...

.-@: w > . f. & .

.1

,-- f .' - . *44 <a 0

{ y:l'.wW. s y via ' '. m .

'4

,' 4i

.m% h t y h ',p , :g1' -t * .- y,*. *4 ? W 5

' 7,g- j -

n 2.'L f.e -'% " *Q:;t. * 'b'.J 1 4 t- 3 , *

%:.Q,"**%.'4

  • s.s; t r. -

=s

>p e . <

. r.> .s

-p.q ,.e. _~4 -;4 . s " ' u,e .,

~

s M. s ./,'.

.4- ' ^

-f-

. ) t i 7- [p <, i t,3, .sp ' V., . ,.,s ,. *#,;c

, . j. . r. ) *.

s, ,

3 n.c #7 Qg W ;P..7L%..Lt J.,L i?,9, w .. ;.p *- v1 .

> . , n -

Ms e

. WL ~ .

Lmef .', g g* 3 -. .. ,1; s  :, 3, : 2

, c , ye ,,, ,

, _.A + q'.4 Qq n 4 9 Al t  ! % '

- - r'f%

n ~r+-

  • WA = M .. V d f #-

.t

<l e{ '7}sh '. .,

c $, <  ; . , ' ,,s, . s2, . b.* W,, .

M ... Ni 4:t . . ', 6' 'M.t ' + .ev. 9fr,f ' ' 'o ; w8.WL n >

c a.N ( .vM if

'., d ' *A.*; ^ w ; _ ,- -g %. 8

( 4 9 , . . *r* e .>e, &**+

, . g

  • s .3-s 7'j,g jf p* q*W, g ._**% .q

., p ra t ;* ,

,ig'

, a .3- .,,,. ,f. . t .. -

y- ,e

~ss2,,.g-t.sda j% ]

  • g< , J' {:-

, . y ,4.- y -

(

' .4. ,?, W:,j_n n.

. 3 a. a.

% W fn  ; z.L. .r. 4,~,s. 5 1 , '

,> .,.A & %, a~ M* p'm,~w.p 4 A.

4., s >,. . . , -o 4 .d+ x t

- m q4-..

o

W ~ .?
  • Q .  ?
,i ,1, ,.

h >r a i}6* , . - e fg i #

j'> , ,fd-*

h .

  • sa, $,N J
-," > < >. .t .t ; y . 4 %j # Lt. 4 *q~

,R ,.4

.%, .a* s e l., q = Jg g . t r . , e e.1' 4,

,Me e .

e . , ,i y-k*

$ s o -- s. .,5'*,y. -ys l t' ;

q 8 i It iCO r r, %qlp sis;, . nge- ..

y  %"y d, '

  • s p . 3* u ' d '.,t i.x. w  : g  %>W<= w.W.?sy kh' L? .-.9*. &y a ep p ~ ; ygA -e.
  • ?. -

-g ..d.,g' s . .g-hj[j g &i +

a v

+^ .

,, ."iG_c n. ,

P, s , .N{T *- .? .- ' ~

s 4, 9 6

'b ' '^ v ,' ' . [,1*l5-b, '4hh* % A. 3 'M.

, x Q- ,

3. 7 3 s e35 # 4 .

?*P . .

c > ., 2 r, '4 p *mm . .. p p . '.C v a: rg- ;[ k *MM C' ,~y , P.l ;ny , J' -

  • 'c.*. . .+ > ~g r ? n' s -

<q y g%,*". m' w-  %.* <

.g r ~,, -

, ,4  ?.

, ./. 3, . . ':y y <

t . " .,4 ') M,r 3 v.g. '

.e ow. . 3 .$,1 +-' W.v. . < ,> -~ v, . .wQc J +c 4 v m. n,. , / .,ys.

,s.. s: . r., g

,m.n . . . .  ;

px. .

,A , . e:. .. ,.r. .- . , . , . . . .p q. *

,.- t .,,,y,.

+ . - -

a

, , , i.4.,

- g '#'

e .s .. .

q **

')." y s, N

  • uI *

$d -. -' ; \

f J *q$ % *" ' ! ~ - > -*?\.'-+,..y '**1

-* '+s

^* cN, t *

.4., W+m e ** *,y g % *1'4 'a e * . et w e to ' e- 'm .a 4 *b[( ?

s

- ' /v7s%-b

,,. f ., # # g , 's' A" . 6ie4ma ! *.p, a

e

. -e e, 4 -

<.h ? ' aa r ' "

,y t <8 N' ' V *

  • t , r*' ' t %* , Mi '7* *3 'v ' Nd ^ '-

/:*d%. O*

t

< i. .e- dc l, ~.% ..y *o

-p.- , ?, n. ' , ), t- c , 4...'.' u <'..'.['s .> r u:, . *

-. ( ), -ey,,

a * *

r. , , % g. .3, .,.-t ., . L. gw, .,. +'[,u,,,..'

.1 f ,, ts s. n g. wmje%.ggfn. ,., . .N ,. . '[R, q. s . <. ,

I, e

.s.

y s- ., .f', a v.

y.

,. g u- ,  :.

4

- e uq . - p".A,9 *

  • (

2

-s .

1 e

,, .s , + s - , . 9 ,,g .< > . . d'*

. . ', 8. yl9 , y s ,g ', '..;  ;

* ,i;j,ggM*' j , 'ajk . ;e #,,$. ;." y,'s c 4.;

,y.,

,J.- p

,,S,,a**.j ,; ,1,.g k , p ( g. ,.

M-tr j *.! 4 w. pq 3..,,

,.4., (. l' ., .

z y , b

.,c.

4

. ' , s , -* . e v3 n - .

.= a,* . A. a. > , **b~ h. c;\s+ i.ta..

/el4, :,4 .p w* g%.h ., J D:K a 1, y (. a 6 f; .J g ,

+- <A ,-,

y'>v', ** . .t g,.< ) . 2 N,/ g.<pg a , y g n , 7p,, c, .y' u c.e rAv f'*g 4 Oy- .*W p 'y.

. s 4 * ,

  • Z . v, ".m' ,,qr
  • g . ' so .x &,,*

~-~ kx. / d- s -h ' k %',Y k,1^ e ! s w *4 *  ? ?!; ,grY a y"l'Y 'R C ,'.,  %.

  • ' i *N h J 1r / I - ., *Qa-+.w.-ny n, , A.

[g M.+d[d ,D Nik .* #. 'JI J M ,

n, , ~w+, [, h, ,

s s t

,i . u. 6 .4, . , , ._ ~h [ a m.

t

. . + . e su/.C f f y,  %..,

  • 11 7,
    • r,.

- 4'ty+

m-s,

.,E @' , * ;8 ..*' .'C.

'"<**-?- er- 4 ad.-

, ; t' d4*; b J,sr a M *?

, f,aM . Pm. - wg AW .

  • "[,%l.w
5. i.f.4.y- *] Jrh&f .e.%h 1 **., W ' Ps., 3 p '.i ,t 'q 'n. . /c N -

' . } h. [ ,,s ~ k h ~b , <* ~9 g.=-hh h. em . , . f 6;, * ' * '

.g ~t'.'V sng

' , ' ' ' 4"y*d , b A Q j . A a gfN,,

f  ?-5 hh *

'h [,& -* . Y )6,ps

{h[/' *y V s. %,' . pWe * ;p X{ YY

_y

'k dy #

6 *.;"' i er * ' e. , , 3 4 a 4j i 6(* # i k -

s ': W2 L j* JL.& & y I,gf#7n t? y :- *

[ h=l E*j && =; @

F '\!' d, ,

DWdj#,1YHW ;lw&@&'* 4 V djT

n. e n,g m **N+& .m a\ww.jf[i&&&idq$$. & ,:@; s ME

,.f- -$. G x.Z -

%y,A J:s * (.6 "'U;@; M%Es  ; 'O.]yw,  : mg 4 + jp,

-- .* . m4 " s h>*- -* -+t =4 + *

~-+ f ,Pag, . .n c %I W

>'t,.s u *i :m.. .ss.) * . .r' y m. d J.& a. h. < ,+ j e g . i 9

o. 4. , a ' ?.  % +3 - 4 s t.4 .r ,'c , 4 * :..) e 4w3 J .* sw ,% A s Ar* rr a 4-

,...,r . , $ .-. ., ,,

. f. f 4.,A .

g" t ~ y. 4 .,. a

.. d (j jl*;

/,;_w(e f yI, 6 . <., i

' e

.

  • b g - - ] =" * .  : .? T:

=y *c )Q 5 *

,,,n.e '. :

[ yk k'ty;wifh. p'[g./,-.m y "w f " ] * , ;,w{.g..+

.t -, e.,; c3 o

-QM} *f t ;d , ,gt; -[ _ 4

.wggl . m ,e..e'

" . g,.

. 'AQ -dc+, 4, 3, , - ,

.p?

7' (,, .y *

's f =

  • 9lL 4 .M [ '.' * , 1 a.f. , ' ',W ,. "M 9"m . ,# A. " 1. .

f,

,, i . . .H 4 ,

., M

- ~k.4 ~' < ,.y*.*. *~ 11 2

L 7 , * / ',.. . r,. , s P . ..-8'

. . . eMN,:

_PW 8 ;v & - .c

'4 %, v '~4 d6- -  %,.pg 3 4- "'r.J:p%

.-v" . 4 '- . -[ ,

/* L_ 4* i* , Q Nv ' J Pi. _ . . t g g, ', # 41gg.1,.. s,7 4, r J, p,,., ' MOYe ,W.

. .L

. 7 4 f g,

,p[ .E< M.,. >

AiNg eW

  • 1 ey'; ' * d*-/ *P."

s*

  • j*g *$

5v., - f-

. ; 'E . , s '. p.\ , '.i - i *' < N4 4. .$ U N-[5. r,

.1. i M..

.e *

  • y, - ^ *%

t.2 - Y17 .g "* ,M R p. *'. .*MJ*) *;**b A.

^

< '*.*'l *1. f h. - ,,'

't^. -

a A' vz a

,.,,y,, a,." -w .-

(z1 s . . ' . . , .,- ~.,,.,

yi ~-s .. J' ~  :" %

~< . . 'p.r . . y s * ,.= 1 nc m.

_ $. . . , ,.pume$,

.w w

-,,, y ;r e.p.

g

- ,x < . ,_

,.;. t . . .n',.,.-

., g , #.

y *.Qs Jmf [r

- 6 *

,d* U- ' ' # ll j #.df, * ,*-14

'.j'?%

' , f " /stg *Q%ay ,M N'$y n

-ff
T *'NDD5 QN

% .' ; '.. i .a, Att a

m. .WJ N #

-y,,."*

s . . - < , -a

, s. s+f *-yei3n+s

+N,+ .

w

..;+.,

8

,,s.

..~.,<v..,g... ,q

< r kg t- ee .;r .

' e .,n -.v 3 ,

y*.-

  • yz r , 4, *+ , <., '

w.

i

,s s . % , . a v.- 4

, , s,

  • p. . y e ,

. ' , y .3 . _,

p . ,; g n p

& . s. .. , . . *_ 1. . .q , m.

e .. s-

.(..'jW-

.E '^ < 4

. J F;

  • , 6 r s

. 4 ., -

h- m , *y re y r _+ 1--* -

[, '.

7 E S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION DOCKETING & SERVICE BRANCH OFFICE OF THE SECRETAR.Y.

OF THE COMMISSION Document Statistics Postmark Date Copies Recci.ed /

Add 1 Co;,bs Rproduced SpecW D.StrAJon, [ /MJ i

eo