ML20204H146: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot insert) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
||
Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter:}} | {{#Wiki_filter:.- -- .- - .- | ||
t 1 | |||
Design Analysis Title Page | |||
==Title:== | |||
Seismic Qualification of Hot Leg RTD, Hot leg PDT and Hot leg Sarroling MNSA Hardware i | |||
Docunent Number: C-NOME-CALC-0107 Resision Number: 0 Quality Class: | |||
E QC-1(Safety-Related) O QC-2 (Not Safety-Related) QC-3 (Not Safety-Related) | |||
!. Approval of Completed Analysis This Design Analysis is complete and verifitxi. Management authorizes the use ofits results. | |||
Printed Name Signature Date ! | |||
Cognizant Engineer (s) G. E. Falvo f, /J 3. v-9 Mentor None Independent Reviewer (s) K.R. Grieff g y,g,77 | |||
/ e Management Approval J.T. McGarry pph J.M. Burger | |||
% gv[ff | |||
: 2. Package Contents (this section may be compleed after Mans _ ement approval): | |||
Totalpages in Calculatica 31 Psges Pages in Appendix Al 9 Pages l Pages Total page count 40 Pages Total number of sheets of microfiche: G Ncne Number of sheets i | |||
Note CD-ROM Files are Not Applicable to this Analysis. | |||
Other attachments (specify): | |||
: 3. Distribution: | |||
E. D. Boland (NOME J. M. Burger J. T. McGarry K. R. Graeff B. Boya (OA - 2 Copii | |||
~ | |||
9903290021 990323 PDR ADOCK 05000302 | |||
,P ,. | |||
PDR Li | |||
Sk !I I 7%95 C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 2 of 31 Page Number Record of Revisions N_st DLats Pages Involved Pmpared By Anoroved By 00 All, OriginalIssue G. E. FALVO J.T. McGany J.M. Burger ; | |||
1 l | |||
l 1 | |||
1 l | |||
1 1 | |||
ABB Combustico Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
AL EB ER l MEDED l | |||
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. ; | |||
Page 3 of 31 i Page Number i | |||
Table of Contents Section Iitle h@ ! | |||
1.0 Objective 4 1 2.0 Analytical Techniques (Method) 4 1 3.0 References 5 4.0 Calculation of Bottom Pressurizer (BP) MNSA 6 Overturning Moment 5.0 Calculation of Hot Leg PDT (HLP) MNSA Overturning 13 Moment 6.0 Calculation of Hot Leg Sampling (HLS) MNSA 17 Overturnmg Moment 7.0 Comparison between DP MNSA and HLP MNSA 21 8.0 Comparison between BP MNSA and HLS MNSA 23 9.0 Conclusion 24 10.0 Assessment Of Significant Design Changes 25 11.0 Design Input 25 List of Firures | |||
& Title Eage 1 Bottom Pressurizer Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assenably 26 2 Hot Leg PDT Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly 27 3 Hot Leg Sampling Mechanical Nozzle Sect Assembly 28 List of Tables | |||
& Iltle Eage 1 Bottom Pressurizer MNSA Weight 29 2 Hot Leg PDT MNSA Weight 30 3 Hot Leg Sampling Weight 31 List of Anoendices l | |||
& Iille Eus Al Q.A. DOCUMENTATION Al | |||
! ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power l | |||
l | |||
Sk ISI MED D | |||
~ | |||
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Pace 4 of 31 Page Number LO Obiective The scope of this calculation is to analyze the ovenurnmg moments in the Bottom Pressunzer MNSA, the Hot Leg PDT MNSA, and the Hot Leg Sampling MNSA, resulting fmm a 1 G seismic loading applied to each design. The calculated values for the Bottom Pressunzer MNSA will be compared to the two new design's values. | |||
NOTE: The Hot Leg RTD nozzle MNSA is not evaluated here. It is id .itical to the fully qualified Southem Califomia Edison, San Onofre Units 2 & 3's RTD MNSA clamp (See reference 3.2). | |||
Under seismic conditions the inen:ase in load reacts against the preload in the Hex Head Bolts, which would result in a loss of sealing pressure, or anti-ejection capability. By showing that the overtuming moment of the Bottom Pressurizer MNSA, subjected to the seismic load, is equal or greater than either the overtummg moment values of the Hot Leg PDT, or Hot Leg Sampling MNSA, we can conclude that seismically testing the two new MNSA assemblies is unnecessary because the loadings in the two new designs will be less than the loadings the Bottom Pressurizer MNSA was subjected to during qualification testing (Reference 3.1) 2.0 Analvtical Techniaues (Method) | |||
The method used to calculate the overturnmg moments is hand calculations, utilizing the principles of mechanical design. Further calculations will be performed to detemline the force acting to offset the Preload in the four Hex Head Bolts, created by the overturmng moments, Hot Leg PDT, and Hot Leg Sampling MNSA's. The unloading force values for the Bottom Pressurizer MNSA will be compared to both the Hot Leg PDT MNSA and Hot Leg Sampling MNSA values, since there geometry and bolt circles are different. | |||
Definitions used in this calculation are as follows: | |||
RTD - | |||
Resistor Temperature Detector. | |||
PDT - Pressure Differential Transmitter. | |||
MNSA - Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly. | |||
BP - | |||
Bottom Pressunzer. | |||
SG - | |||
Steam Generator. | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
Ak ED D MND C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Pace 5 of 31 Page Number 3.0 References 3.1 ABB Report No. TR-PENG-033, Rev. 00, " Test Repon, Seismic Quahfication of the San Onofre Units 2 & 3 MNSA Clamps for Pressurizer Instrument No2cles and RTD Hot Leg Nozzles". | |||
3.2 ABB Calculation No. S2-NOME-CALC-085, " Seismic Quahfication of the Steam Generator PDT, Hot Leg PDT, and Hot Leg Sampling MNSA Hardware." | |||
3.3 ABB CENO Drawing No. E-MNSA-228-001, Rev. 02, " Bottom Pressunzer Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly". | |||
3.4 ABB CENO Drawing No. E-WFDMNSA-228-002, Rev. 01, " Hot Leg PDT MNSA". | |||
3.5 ABB CENO Drawing No. E- WFDMNSA -228-003, Rev. 01, " Hot Leg Sampling MNSA" 3.6 ABB CENO Drawing No. E-MNSA-228-0(M, Rev. 05," Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly Details". I l | |||
I l | |||
1 l | |||
l ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
Eh C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 6 of 31 Page Number | |||
$0 CAtcate-rroN c?C Bornm 192Csyw:St. fe&h mns A omera>cisms mm ~ ' | |||
p*c ra ,vr a we sv.;,w ge m is 7ssurm ho CAcc.utArm /N 7)n te .1, | |||
= foe0 CdtcutArrug /%tAou;1, M AfrKmal.y gau CC | |||
$t C.fr / W O 7kIO $36AYS ,' $.) TNC Ut'Yt%t A$$Q ANb | |||
.2.) w e o et,arg. | |||
4.1 rw unen. ,as.cg ,%u.s 4 cueicars ,+se: M 7mut.1) . | |||
Orscaiprick ?or*. | |||
. k wnim (< ar') | |||
d 7w Pare .t 3.43 b.) 172 Anos 4 La | |||
: c. NCt Mars j2 O.27 | |||
: d. W eer m s. w u us, n. +- c.11. | |||
W,=tPat Asv war = s ce i.as f2 OvKr.rumia: r%svr o so mara- u =x. Aksy - M0"*'n | |||
* T mar e x, Case /2 2 | |||
$1.1 TVitNoNC j% 47NC ~ | |||
Asweis A .fg/*f0*4)*NT" <DVM 'JD Stsst*ttC. %. | |||
14 = W,(Q) ist = | |||
zuas .ns saan,- r-a.zr - aa.) - | |||
/y G | |||
= .r.6sI.ss (M. raw) - (2- me ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
i | |||
$k SISI M EDER C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 7 of 31 Page Number ! | |||
l | |||
$'' | |||
* M "axmac ru nrias m tu m gm ,y m Avg - . | |||
= | |||
4 tat &Hr ta$ % | |||
=W -W l l | |||
(.nz u,) 89 8% ' | |||
l w, = . Ccs u s - 3.ss a s = 2xtas i | |||
* f a c E A Cr.1 *%twow ~M CG r.c p4c 7hc psasl toenran | |||
[0wsaus % Am.1) g, ._ [.&so + a.ze + .on)-f. mo +. sm. mezons)] | |||
J J | |||
(.700 s.m +. zez +r.ou) ca, = A*')-l2*7)+3.s,7 =- g132 - | |||
2 42.s p,mer GAssumaac d .1 g .snesa.c ca m | |||
% " Wep , CG , | |||
eoj Vig= 2.os as (8,3tm Nyg = / 7. 9 te-to.5 ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
I JL unus ; | |||
n upus - | |||
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 8 of 31 Page Number f.5 14 LOWEn. AMY PAArs c wmcers M&.'':ffwe wm 1} | |||
@ ras b e-s c m p n c H | |||
: 4. f.bwE,l. fME QTv wour(m) 1 24.64 | |||
: b. 34r /lG.rANf.dl 1 0.14 | |||
: c. deAti!.sreon OuAt. 1 d. Tr2. | |||
: j. 7. f o d UPPE/L | |||
: e. VMeit. fw- ftANct 70 ) ((gamn) | |||
.t. G. % | |||
f) He>c axr (18nr.r 2- 0. </4 NfX (30er b.os% 2 d.~72 | |||
) h tlETAtHSn WAsaft 4 ). O. II Nyy = 1.CMM. 4LSY WEICHT = W/.6l:> lBS 4.5.1 fat. CALew 4vcd PunfosG.1, "iFC BP Mnsalowet4ssy 15 DWoDGD inTo Two SKc rickus * | |||
.SacrauV j WITH A 'TRIANG ALAd CAsss-CitLTtoN | |||
- see-naa - | |||
wern a sa*)vez. csass -see-rioN | |||
) | |||
7IIG ASSUNPTioN /s 1%1M "fkAT gk 6/ *?HC OVGrt. .Asty' 4/S!'"T Is Accoasvrea W | |||
An- & sserecN CD, ,< 7he QErsrANiNc. | |||
. At C BY SELTtoN Q. | |||
& On 9 55 = 20.96Slas 2.4. Sac-noN ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
$k !ISI 7%EDER C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 9 of 31 Page Number 4,f Pk<*:TiktNiNG Mom &vr CS 3P Musi$ Owohi: sos:</ | |||
44.L wsvr Aw ex c.cwe.c hasy, secrraitD - | |||
Tru m u c9<t- e 3 7) rD s*crrcw e@ wim p Ormewein-W,2 & trs | |||
'%b y f' - | |||
{4 "N Vs'///b | |||
* WW ;& | |||
b | |||
# J22E k- ~ Pr 8 - case. x cuc- | |||
? | |||
x 1 <- t,s,- | |||
(L | |||
+-by Q -ta tterMNu.Naas 4 7.sd a-u w | |||
* perswxc'W - im ('n.r') = f,,, | |||
-> H = w (1,.s')[7ce] | |||
R = .?. 904 | |||
* _ | |||
l | |||
- berea ~ive ! / - | |||
y = 4,irc," .. y l Xv 4 rec' - 1.90y | |||
* X = d,2rr2. | |||
~ | |||
* perew,me *Jjn ' - 48 = 0.nz/r,904 ) | |||
( | |||
fit := g;ot ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
AL EB ER 7%EFED C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 i Calculation N ~.ter Rev. | |||
Pace 10 of 31 Page Number 1 | |||
1 4.f.1 (am.) | |||
. nsret.~,ac | |||
* y ) - | |||
7 7aa. [27. r () = .Rrr,t i.zu ,) -- | |||
y= nw(m'){4.w | |||
* ys z.rez' a zwrnnnwe ''O n - | |||
b y-. .qq b = zses "- /.soi' | |||
</ | |||
b = lut Asamonk. sva<anr- oA suc Kernner axew awm As,va *@ . Aers : - er4 s Aor Awr ree-Mrmw.mm n m,. | |||
j -tM ,' nk | |||
._,_ . pp | |||
* oeistmd'7 y - | |||
,/ ,m4 r ts- l t- . | |||
# yY , | |||
3 q. pg _ | |||
. CP = | |||
Y -[/.<W . m''] | |||
w,pl 9 = as>s"-Quf O - /,32i " | |||
Swnu.g 'i - 2= /, 4'03 -Q g = /,40s" ~ / sti g . d. o t-z " | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
Jk ER ER 7%INED C-NOME. CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 11 of 31 Page Number e.1 6w) l | |||
::) HMS.vr Astet i D = D y. 3 b' = 4 zez ''' O. 0Pz. | |||
* Z) ' r /,EG5f M.2. SierysN Q.' L . nsnruvr - O Awnm A L S cs ,.,,c. | |||
44o, 7 M = 20 76S MS /s EG9w yD | |||
'b.,p = 2P. 3 /+us @ | |||
9.1.5 N m e a r < w m u s t A rs y , seway CD - | |||
(GM/EC Caen-SRcrug WilH DmtWstav.S ~ fpo~ /MC 27 | |||
,.prA, f.on. & FIG.I fjv r f zmr (///A - Sacrev GD s't 4 _ _ | |||
o L 5/ ' | |||
: t. 'k | |||
* DETSitshiivE / - | |||
i | |||
,f Q-unu me ca.rre) Lc w 4. = 6m + g. n>v. sco)- | |||
th?U AMC ]_. - d.?f/ w c ne) 9 nowar nam : s" =[oss 2.ah .m'+ .wo+. sin]- t-d"=[f./y?']-0.7% =2% | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
- \ | |||
$k SI5k M5559 l | |||
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Pace 12 ef 31 Page Number 4A.+ SEenoit@ nome nr - @4%na. A.1g seu~<c. | |||
w.>. , | |||
Mywg = 20.,sr tak .f3.4% m) | |||
Mpwg = | |||
'70. '7 in-ms - | |||
l | |||
$.6 -)ornt O/EATukNiNG A1outmr [BP) o' Nw | |||
* %. 0% + Me * '%.c g, = S z. m ,t /27 m f 2G3.m + 70.7m Mgp = 168.9 In-Lbs OR /4 / 4~r-da.r ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
Ak ED ER 7% EDEN C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 13 of 31 Pa.e Number | |||
# 5.0 6Atevur m At kar se+ ro r' (NAE | |||
* erd I | |||
. OrtT4Td4N<M Ato,weser M 7kB USIGHT OC 1ME KN5144 /hlP MME4- I$ 7ASrL44av f CAi M *o Av 7hst.s ). | |||
Au.caa M voM %sss 1T+E /4tfM*3< y you. GE | |||
.TPur /Nro 1ko f4ses j k 7N6 Hmst Ass 1, AND z.) m m . | |||
' S.) ; 146 (6Y64 Assy Amer y ments ,9tg : (pkm 7pe.c2) | |||
DEfcAWH10v OTY W.asw1 (Las) | |||
Q WM $ f.9? | |||
7?6 @ e.5 Y _ l.81 . | |||
l abCc NUTS /2 0.27 | |||
_ d -Pi* azrwa.muus e +g Wg= O/HGc. 44y vcor = 5.82 Lbs S.1 over nnenwr, momsar iv. lw musa. uana. Assu m or wer: , | |||
$.2,.l . W W NfNtG !*t M G NM Oue? 10 TW PM9tlt ~ | |||
A w ~ m ,4 .i g. s c a n << eaeo. | |||
M4=Ug [% | |||
N,,,=359un(iLan'so.m"'<nrD i%,, = gS7 c.os (nn.c.es) = sis 4 in-w e | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
. .. - -- . . = . _ . . . - .. .. | |||
Ak EDID | |||
; M EDID | |||
\ | |||
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
l Page 14 of 31 Page Number 5.2.2 Ovrut.r.wvM momnwr curi ro ampxos UWGA 44y - | |||
a. | |||
e Wker .' = | |||
(ge oj) W"in W""- W"" l | |||
\ | |||
s N = .5.82t os - 3 Ti us =. 2.23 ar 2 | |||
M rs. - | |||
f%4t* ACr5 7MouGH RE CG Of 75ME 77C MA2 S * | |||
- Ocei?od f Dowums pre, Asvaa.1 (G = | |||
(al2.2+.W) ~ N.Co0+.!3S+.380) .;. (gpa+,qs +,sso) | |||
' 2 | |||
= | |||
('s h11'1']~fZ.OlG p (g,o,g 7.143 _y : | |||
7 6.2.3 00MGif - NS&'mWG A & S*'NtC W M | |||
m % M | |||
/$f , 2.23 , gg 7.143 in ] | |||
15.93 dD N H% ~ /n-us.s-ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
l l | |||
Sk !III M EDED l i | |||
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 l Calculation Number Rev. I Page 15 0f 31 1 Page Number l l | |||
SS 79K 4WZ.t Msy Aurs r une rskr.t | |||
~-: | |||
f% ?>Dur2) l MC"'Pf!M OTY uniaNr-(es) | |||
Q)stwoA' fwuG J. . &W b Snes. M T M M.- .t. O. /W C. CbnPNE.tsov GuA1. $ . | |||
6.45 I44Ytt AAME W) .i f.64 l C. tW wt. fu* M C 75) $ 4 24 | |||
: f. BEx S4.r 1 & 79 tt&T4/NfA. R.grgs | |||
} + _0. 06 W =AW AMy 4W#per = 12.06 Lbs S4 av&cru%nd MckmvT- OS. Hl MNs4 tewrirA Assy Hw MNstr marc assy nomirarj prm Aecur P<errPr jo Mut.6 2~l | |||
&(Dassium A- Q Seco ec. c . | |||
Mp ,,, = Wg@ppu, et, c 12.06 Lbs d/3r#7 G350 +/. Sb | |||
.:t. | |||
/,0dPfPj, | |||
/$% =12.06 Lbs Mgya = /4 S im ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
$k SISI MEDID C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Pace 16 of 31 Page Number | |||
& NTN $WAWM/% MOM M NU : | |||
/9y=N y lN &M m 4 = 45.4 In-Lbs. + 15.93 In-Lbs. + 12.2 In-Lbs Ng | |||
* 73.53 In-Lbs. Or 6.13 Ft-Lbs. , | |||
l ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
i - | |||
A Et b 7%ED D i C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 | |||
: Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 17 of 31 i Page Number i | |||
i i hO _ | |||
CAccou4 rnw d4 AorW ww fm.C) MN54 ' ' | |||
j ontwM Momovr 1. | |||
l | |||
- FMC IMcKMr 041M'SWAS his MAese /s 1;wsue.Aino l A%) CAlutt.4'TKO /N 7FFtN K .m1 i | |||
FM cwrnw & Mass , 7xe taumes.y uu. as wr l lNTO 7kto lhnt"$ ' d) 7NE WVkrA. Assy, />to A) 7kst | |||
/oMEA Assy. | |||
I g' ~P6 JMn. Actv Awe f wetem ,4er l [AumpHa;.g) . | |||
; 7ersu DeccAttmaN Ort tonsrcar $Ad | |||
! 4) Tv'st+rg .g. 493 l' D F6 Moos 4 2 o t. | |||
l d jex Nurs /s. O,27 l d) N | |||
* naso m u. uu m s ? +g g (awa Axy wear < 7.41 Lbs. | |||
i l 1?' onurum mcar oc as Mkca imu. Auv. - Wk l . Asse.3 1 p.I? omrmsu nowr M 10 rof Paw - | |||
l~ | |||
: 6) Anv~4 " 4. Jg k ~ee. | |||
M ," Mg [b,,) - | |||
/%., = q.9s ta f 3W' ssI) - | |||
4 | |||
/(, - 41s c.a3 [15.6751n) = M /* *: | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
Sk !ISI M Ep!D C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Pace 18 of 31 | |||
; Page Number h AA W 'T*tAtNG MO&AWr 006 7D A&wA M oc:. | |||
v/PhCc. ,4srr - | |||
~ | |||
fgl "*u m " %a. ~ Ws Wg =. ,.4 u ss - 4 9 s e.a s 1 | |||
: U '= 2AS '.65 6 | |||
: 14ince Acrs TainswH prs ca os 74sc '7mAmps e | |||
4tA*tted fOmtMSeONr & /Q< void 4h a= . ( w.>)-(um.nss | |||
* se) + 4.w.arueo) b*4 ' | |||
N) "h M [2.otc w 8.66 In. | |||
l b | |||
G.Z 3 Mom gpr7 - N5ilMNG A W%!C CC3D M44.tr % ng | |||
$g = 2A5 465 8.66 In v dN% Ya. | |||
* 21.48 In-Lbs s | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
Sk !h!I MIp!D C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 19 of 31 Page Number 63 1hc w a A-ssy Pasus E Wacsis MS: h M'e 3) 2.5cee'r<aN CTv 3"fut 6w) a e mm 4 e6s-b)> SW Asmiwa1. C.Ie-c <%ver.srei cbu4e J 0i5 (A%t. AAMSS(Bonans,L J,(do e 4 M*L ru w.e ( so) 1- 4 24 | |||
-t* A k 8'o c r 4 nem,nar A.eres, y + 0.o. cx,n y = M Assy: Und/rr = 12.06 Lbs. | |||
b.4 dvfkrme mommvr-OS- Hcs hA && Asw. 1 NLs a avrusaceaae m 3': | |||
Asc@ywmmmr; w - w +Amrs q sr.a ,4~e. | |||
earwwar u. | |||
i M =Wyby ' | |||
Mnw - 12.06 Lbs. s dir.r's. d.ne'+ t,scof s | |||
N/A.sw | |||
* 12.06 Lbs. !Zo/rM bs | |||
~ | |||
s | |||
%= 293 m-<as ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
AL EB ER 7%IDER C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Pace 20 of 31 Page Number b$ 1DTAt dth*'AMNtat. MMNY fMt.4 : | |||
N,* | |||
ag **,, #g ( Ng Ogg = 7Q /N-sos 021.48 In-Lbs 0 2Y3 W | |||
#)pg = _ 123.1 In-Lbs. Or 10.3 Ft-Lbs ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
Jk D D M 959 C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 21 of 31 Page Number i | |||
*l.0 Gw%etsw OA m nusa. m .41Jo Miuc^_ | |||
* 1ME- %Hs Cf Me SP Mn64 l /tLP nfNia* 16%6 &"'"^=^8 e mm- 4. ow-44 oe twommw c% ras enes (su twas bwe A=t. 'Re kmnse ikpense p an m%es 7Ns. rse (MarcNf, ME m tr/.a:w 7ME 4040 &=4w Isr 7Anr | |||
&W,erswteM Mestivr 1Nor uu.013wo 70 Qousr ne Heneoxn M. | |||
* Tdeasa fa accvxe cwsaw ^>ew Rashpe. | |||
GW-sarno A' w A4CH CW.stcN. If Rs Pas 133 /M.P ms4 5 tass MM oix. BM9t- 70'?R+1 A;w. 73r @ MNse ,1sw /kP w uu..se c:nsouico swam ao yo u rnsr Gerwic ONO:rie4T f*n 7W6 M MMCG AM.t.1). | |||
f.) A0. C. . Kw- BP MNsa ' | |||
- hrue,*,vc mmwr.[Aum ps) = /0:$ ws | |||
- 4msr encew mer our a ma.r wu.ee Essenont $w eMrs.rmwnc nmierr-era . | |||
40.7 = | |||
% isp Amr A* g, r I 'll | |||
- "l' | |||
/cg:& ix.sss ~ M9the gu 6' 4 , , | |||
(lu'+.1st') 4.9L/** | |||
uar | |||
% P.GR *~~ 9 m am ff,fse=. .91. Y 44C ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
AL EB ER 9% BEE C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 22 of 31 Page Number | |||
_1. L . AC. A AR W htMC& | |||
- CV6.d.7tecwNg ftcow4wT (From 5.5) = 73.53 In.Lbs. | |||
- umr cess ic pk crue Ik.r acservan- vs*E twnns onruxm ner. | |||
# 1 i (o.p. ==. | |||
/*l,'+ | |||
k I #p4 am + k u" RaK = ' '' * "' - | |||
-, aoa Y | |||
n (i.avme) Coasa | |||
= 27.72 ' gag O I R O. F.Sw . | |||
]3 6~/%usw (* BP To Ik.P | |||
- a.msna RQn sc Tw M:r.:ws: . i 5 7ms Tuc3 80.5.o i P.oA w l i | |||
ff&r 9.1) 27.72 Jas 6 -(tho~ 7.1) 37.9486 W | |||
. i nut srere-avr is rnas l rserwsa rns HLP !s .cros>noceur %qusto. | |||
{ | |||
i ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
_.__._._.__..._._....______7...__....___.___.._._ | |||
Jk k D | |||
!- 7% 9 p C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev 1 | |||
j Page 23 of 31 i Page Number i | |||
i 40 j | |||
UMP 4ttsov 66 9 htinQ 7D HLS M9tG4 w+ | |||
'fftC D*St'CN G df. 7ME Bf,hMsk MO His MNM KAME sets / Getarita. d%<st,t<cAs. m49serac54, 7mwie.or, | |||
! /PE. /s SKc.frew 7.0 , '/Aes. cfNc.y Witifyvans/..<. IM9M/w l | |||
\ . 5 70Sacy fcit. 6/MK 1WE Arnla90 14.scM. // Pil Ras. O'estrnNG M 72/6 kl.G Avtc6 AMsA l$ath' | |||
/S f.sss htivs4 746 Re.1 1kM 04./5 Cue % rHfr os 'TkC 2P nv4/1) | |||
.birsicssto %eenLLY t;heunna, N 4C foe. Mf6 Ansa-l' A l | |||
$( | |||
- eMm'%tnisK nty.ai;er x | |||
% 6.5 *) | |||
l I pp = .123.08_ | |||
CM' -> < N-/.sts" - t 4wsr ewyr tr t.e. cwr 3.tr P (4rsevnog 't?Ve AVvwas dens.rm M m. | |||
ptf** . | |||
123.05__tN us Raf- = = | |||
s nm eu Ltwss-) | |||
46.4 gd.f, as e Agg n | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
Ak ER ED M EDER C-NOME-CALC '>107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 24 of 31 Page Number 4 Z. . %)>usid M BP TD /LS | |||
- cW+te QMsg 5 no pesc.ns ; | |||
l3 14.5 7?Ly,E f MA m . RO.f. | |||
ff* ton /0./ , 46.4 | |||
? f k 7.1 _37.7 Lar | |||
==9.0 CONCLUSION== | |||
Under a representative IG load, the offseting loads created in, Hot Leg PDT MNSA's is less than the loads created in the BP MNSA. Therefore the statement can be made that the Hot Leg PDT MNSA designs is "seismicaly qulified" since it would be tested to the same response specturm as the EP MNSA in Reference 3.1 The Preload O..seting Force calculated above are sumarised in the below table Clamp P.O.F. Section BP MNSA 37.8 Lbs. Section 7.1 H.LP. MNS A 27.7 Lbs. Section 7.2 HLS MNSA 46.4 Lbs. Section 8.1 The offseting load calculated for the Waterford Sampling Nozzle MNS A is greater than the offseting load calculated for the Bottom Pressu izer MNS A that was test :d. Therefore the Waterford response spectra will be compared to the test spectra. Then thc ratio of the two calculated moments will be used to establish a "g" loading to demonstrate that the test conditions envelope the Waterford design conditions. This will be done in ABB Rep]rt No. C-NOME-ER-0120," Design Evaluation of MNSA for Various Applications at Waterfrrd Unit 3". | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
Ak D ED M. DED C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 25 of 31 Page Number 10.0 ASSESMENT OF SIGNIFICANT DESIGN CHANGES This calculation evaluates the MNSA design for Waterford and is based on previous designs of MNSA clamps for San Onofre Units 2 & 3. The only significant design change is the length of the tie rods. This calculation incorporates the new lengths of the tie rods. | |||
11.0 Design Input This calculation uses the references of Section #3 as design inputs. | |||
1 1 | |||
1 ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
Jk IR ER 7%BBER C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 26 of 31 Page Number FIGURE 1 l Bottom Pressurizer Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly (From References 3.3 & 3.6) | |||
/ ) | |||
I | |||
_ l l | |||
/f_l AkV / | |||
l l | |||
*h l | |||
1 | |||
, h .. | |||
r- f; W w sm ' | |||
"" 1 F"" f I | |||
.-w= - | |||
um , , | |||
l' | |||
\. | |||
\ | |||
l l 1 u \ s | |||
,_ "l I f l LJ. . 1. | |||
4 Note: Reference Dimensions (W/ "()" are calculated values based on a 27.5 Angle. | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
JL ED ED MEDIN C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Pace 27 of 31 Page Number FIGURE 2 Hot Lee PDT Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly (From References 3.4,3.6 & 3.7) 0-I I I lt} g l o.75 -W | |||
% ) r g i i | |||
I I | |||
I I | |||
I | |||
$2.2s LL | |||
:",.s0-e.- | |||
n t j + | |||
" Tiss k7 f ^ | |||
_y, ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power 4 | |||
Ak ED ER 7%IDER C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 28 of 31 Page Number FIGURE 3 Hot Lee Samnline Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly I (From References 3.5,3.6 &3.7 I r I | |||
' - o.02 o.75 l l , | |||
t ur;2 3 afjf L .- - | |||
l | |||
'., =;= | |||
I i | |||
15.30 1 | |||
1 1 L_k l l | |||
, 3-- | |||
I I( ) E xm__q | |||
_ o.3.o 1 | |||
, - 0.135 //J j [t ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
Nhh 7% B B - | |||
^ | |||
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 29 of 31 Page Number TABLEI Bonom_Pressuri7er MNS A (E-MNS A-7.28-001-1, Assembly) Weight Name Detail Part No. Volume (cu.in.) Density (liveu.in.) Weight / Piece (Ibs) Quantity Total Weight (Ibs) | |||
Lower Flange E-MNSA-228-004-1 87.057 0.283 24.64 1 24.64 Seal Retainer -004-2 2.614 0.283 0.74 1 074 Compression Collar -004-3 2.899 0.283 0.82 1 0.82 Upper Flange (Bottom: -004-29 25.100 0.283 7.10 1 7.10 Ur.ner Flange (Top) -004-5 24.593 0.283 6.96 1 6.% | |||
Top Plate -004-6 12.826 0.283 3.63 1 3.63 Hex Bolt (Short) -004-25 0.773 0.283 0.22 2 0.44 Hex Bolt (Long) -004-24 1.266 0.283 0.36 2 0.72 Tie Rod -004-15 1.381 0.283 0.39 4 1.56 Hex Nut -004-27 0.081 0.283 0.02 12 0.27 IT2" Retainer Washer -004-22 0.093 0.283 0.03 4 0.1 I 3/8" Retainer Washer -004-21 0.066 0.283 0.02 12 0.22 Total: 47.21 Notes: | |||
: 1. Weight of Grafoil Seal is negligible. | |||
: 2. All calculations are based on dimensions from referenced drawings. | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
$k I I 7% B B - | |||
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 30 of 31 Page Number TALBE 2 IIot Irg PDT MNS A (E-MNSAWFD-2.28-002-1, Assembly) Weight Name Detail Part No. Volume (cu.in.) Density (Ib/cu.in.) Weight / Piece (Ibs) Quantity Total Weight (lbs) | |||
Lower Flange E-MNSA-228-013-13 9.477 0.283 2.68 I 2.68 Seal Retainer -004-32 0.628 0.283 0.18 1 0.18 Compression Collar E4tNSA%TD-228-0033 I.603 0.283 0.45 1 0.45 Upper Flange (Bottom) -013-12 12.925 0.283 3.66 1 3.66 Upper Flange (Top) -013-24 14.973 0.283 4.24 1 4.24 Top Plate -013-06 12.670 0.283 3.59 1 3.59 flex Bolt -013-21 0.701 0.283 0.20 4 0.79 Tie Rod -013-27 1.601 0.283 0.45 4 1.8 I flex Nut -004-27 0.081 0.283 0.02 12 0.27 Retainer Plate -013-20 0.054 0.283 0.02 4 0.06 3/8" Retainer Washer -004-21 0.066 0.283 0 02 8 0.15 Tetal: 17.88 Notes: | |||
: 1. Weight of Grafoil Seal is negligible. | |||
: 2. All calculations are based on dimensions fmm referenced drawings. | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
ADD 7% B 5 - | |||
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. | |||
Page 31 of 31 Page Number TABLE 3 Hot Leg Samnling MNSAWFD (E-MNSA-228-003-1 Assembly) Weight Name Detail Part No- Volume (cu.in.) Density (Ib/cu.in.) Weight / Piece (Ibs) Quantity Total Weight (Ibs) | |||
Lower Flange E-MNSA-228-013-13 9.477 0.283 2.68 I 2.68 Seal Retainer -008-32 0.628 0.283 0.18 1 0.1 S Compression Collar F MNSAWm.22mna 1.603 0.283 0.45 I O 45 Upper Flange fBottom) -013-12 12.925 0.283 3.66 1 3.66 Upper Flange (Top) -013-24 14.973 0.283 4.24 I 4.24 Top Plate -013-15 17.430 0.283 4.93 1 4.93 Hex Bolt -013-21 0.701 0.283 0.20 4 0.79 Tie Rod -013-25 1.822 0.283 0.52 4 2.06 Hex Nut -004-27 0.081 0.283 0.02 12 0.27 Retainer Plate -013-20 0.054 0.283 0.02 4 0.06 3/8" Retainer Washer -004-21 0.066 0.283 0.02 8 0.15 Total: 19.43 Notes: | |||
: 1. Weight of Grafoil Seal is negligible. | |||
: 2. Seismic effect of the weight of Clamp (Detail -013-22), Hex Hd Bolts (Detail -016-15). and 1/2" Retainer Washers (Detail -004-22) is addressed in the Design Report, Ref. 3.2 | |||
: 3. All calculations are based on dimensions from referenced drawings. | |||
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power | |||
- _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _. - _ _ _ _ _- _ _ -}} |
Latest revision as of 14:58, 30 December 2020
ML20204H146 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | Waterford |
Issue date: | 03/11/1999 |
From: | Falvo G, Graeff K, Mcgarry J ABB COMBUSTION ENGINEERING NUCLEAR FUEL (FORMERLY |
To: | |
Shared Package | |
ML20204H122 | List: |
References | |
C-NOME-CALC-010, C-NOME-CALC-0107-R00, C-NOME-CALC-10, C-NOME-CALC-107-R, NUDOCS 9903290021 | |
Download: ML20204H146 (31) | |
Text
.- -- .- - .-
t 1
Design Analysis Title Page
Title:
Seismic Qualification of Hot Leg RTD, Hot leg PDT and Hot leg Sarroling MNSA Hardware i
Docunent Number: C-NOME-CALC-0107 Resision Number: 0 Quality Class:
E QC-1(Safety-Related) O QC-2 (Not Safety-Related) QC-3 (Not Safety-Related)
!. Approval of Completed Analysis This Design Analysis is complete and verifitxi. Management authorizes the use ofits results.
Printed Name Signature Date !
Cognizant Engineer (s) G. E. Falvo f, /J 3. v-9 Mentor None Independent Reviewer (s) K.R. Grieff g y,g,77
/ e Management Approval J.T. McGarry pph J.M. Burger
% gv[ff
- 2. Package Contents (this section may be compleed after Mans _ ement approval):
Totalpages in Calculatica 31 Psges Pages in Appendix Al 9 Pages l Pages Total page count 40 Pages Total number of sheets of microfiche: G Ncne Number of sheets i
Note CD-ROM Files are Not Applicable to this Analysis.
Other attachments (specify):
- 3. Distribution:
E. D. Boland (NOME J. M. Burger J. T. McGarry K. R. Graeff B. Boya (OA - 2 Copii
~
9903290021 990323 PDR ADOCK 05000302
,P ,.
PDR Li
Sk !I I 7%95 C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 2 of 31 Page Number Record of Revisions N_st DLats Pages Involved Pmpared By Anoroved By 00 All, OriginalIssue G. E. FALVO J.T. McGany J.M. Burger ;
1 l
l 1
1 l
1 1
ABB Combustico Engineering Nuclear Power
AL EB ER l MEDED l
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev. ;
Page 3 of 31 i Page Number i
Table of Contents Section Iitle h@ !
1.0 Objective 4 1 2.0 Analytical Techniques (Method) 4 1 3.0 References 5 4.0 Calculation of Bottom Pressurizer (BP) MNSA 6 Overturning Moment 5.0 Calculation of Hot Leg PDT (HLP) MNSA Overturning 13 Moment 6.0 Calculation of Hot Leg Sampling (HLS) MNSA 17 Overturnmg Moment 7.0 Comparison between DP MNSA and HLP MNSA 21 8.0 Comparison between BP MNSA and HLS MNSA 23 9.0 Conclusion 24 10.0 Assessment Of Significant Design Changes 25 11.0 Design Input 25 List of Firures
& Title Eage 1 Bottom Pressurizer Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assenably 26 2 Hot Leg PDT Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly 27 3 Hot Leg Sampling Mechanical Nozzle Sect Assembly 28 List of Tables
& Iltle Eage 1 Bottom Pressurizer MNSA Weight 29 2 Hot Leg PDT MNSA Weight 30 3 Hot Leg Sampling Weight 31 List of Anoendices l
& Iille Eus Al Q.A. DOCUMENTATION Al
! ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power l
l
Sk ISI MED D
~
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Pace 4 of 31 Page Number LO Obiective The scope of this calculation is to analyze the ovenurnmg moments in the Bottom Pressunzer MNSA, the Hot Leg PDT MNSA, and the Hot Leg Sampling MNSA, resulting fmm a 1 G seismic loading applied to each design. The calculated values for the Bottom Pressunzer MNSA will be compared to the two new design's values.
NOTE: The Hot Leg RTD nozzle MNSA is not evaluated here. It is id .itical to the fully qualified Southem Califomia Edison, San Onofre Units 2 & 3's RTD MNSA clamp (See reference 3.2).
Under seismic conditions the inen:ase in load reacts against the preload in the Hex Head Bolts, which would result in a loss of sealing pressure, or anti-ejection capability. By showing that the overtuming moment of the Bottom Pressurizer MNSA, subjected to the seismic load, is equal or greater than either the overtummg moment values of the Hot Leg PDT, or Hot Leg Sampling MNSA, we can conclude that seismically testing the two new MNSA assemblies is unnecessary because the loadings in the two new designs will be less than the loadings the Bottom Pressurizer MNSA was subjected to during qualification testing (Reference 3.1) 2.0 Analvtical Techniaues (Method)
The method used to calculate the overturnmg moments is hand calculations, utilizing the principles of mechanical design. Further calculations will be performed to detemline the force acting to offset the Preload in the four Hex Head Bolts, created by the overturmng moments, Hot Leg PDT, and Hot Leg Sampling MNSA's. The unloading force values for the Bottom Pressurizer MNSA will be compared to both the Hot Leg PDT MNSA and Hot Leg Sampling MNSA values, since there geometry and bolt circles are different.
Definitions used in this calculation are as follows:
RTD -
Resistor Temperature Detector.
PDT - Pressure Differential Transmitter.
MNSA - Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly.
BP -
Bottom Pressunzer.
SG -
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
Ak ED D MND C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Pace 5 of 31 Page Number 3.0 References 3.1 ABB Report No. TR-PENG-033, Rev. 00, " Test Repon, Seismic Quahfication of the San Onofre Units 2 & 3 MNSA Clamps for Pressurizer Instrument No2cles and RTD Hot Leg Nozzles".
3.2 ABB Calculation No. S2-NOME-CALC-085, " Seismic Quahfication of the Steam Generator PDT, Hot Leg PDT, and Hot Leg Sampling MNSA Hardware."
3.3 ABB CENO Drawing No. E-MNSA-228-001, Rev. 02, " Bottom Pressunzer Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly".
3.4 ABB CENO Drawing No. E-WFDMNSA-228-002, Rev. 01, " Hot Leg PDT MNSA".
3.5 ABB CENO Drawing No. E- WFDMNSA -228-003, Rev. 01, " Hot Leg Sampling MNSA" 3.6 ABB CENO Drawing No. E-MNSA-228-0(M, Rev. 05," Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly Details". I l
I l
1 l
l ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
Eh C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 6 of 31 Page Number
$0 CAtcate-rroN c?C Bornm 192Csyw:St. fe&h mns A omera>cisms mm ~ '
p*c ra ,vr a we sv.;,w ge m is 7ssurm ho CAcc.utArm /N 7)n te .1,
= foe0 CdtcutArrug /%tAou;1, M AfrKmal.y gau CC
$t C.fr / W O 7kIO $36AYS ,' $.) TNC Ut'Yt%t A$$Q ANb
.2.) w e o et,arg.
4.1 rw unen. ,as.cg ,%u.s 4 cueicars ,+se: M 7mut.1) .
Orscaiprick ?or*.
. k wnim (< ar')
d 7w Pare .t 3.43 b.) 172 Anos 4 La
- c. NCt Mars j2 O.27
- d. W eer m s. w u us, n. +- c.11.
W,=tPat Asv war = s ce i.as f2 OvKr.rumia: r%svr o so mara- u =x. Aksy - M0"*'n
- T mar e x, Case /2 2
$1.1 TVitNoNC j% 47NC ~
Asweis A .fg/*f0*4)*NT" <DVM 'JD Stsst*ttC. %.
14 = W,(Q) ist =
zuas .ns saan,- r-a.zr - aa.) -
/y G
= .r.6sI.ss (M. raw) - (2- me ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
i
$k SISI M EDER C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 7 of 31 Page Number !
l
$
- M "axmac ru nrias m tu m gm ,y m Avg - .
=
4 tat &Hr ta$ %
=W -W l l
(.nz u,) 89 8% '
l w, = . Ccs u s - 3.ss a s = 2xtas i
- f a c E A Cr.1 *%twow ~M CG r.c p4c 7hc psasl toenran
[0wsaus % Am.1) g, ._ [.&so + a.ze + .on)-f. mo +. sm. mezons)]
J J
(.700 s.m +. zez +r.ou) ca, = A*')-l2*7)+3.s,7 =- g132 -
2 42.s p,mer GAssumaac d .1 g .snesa.c ca m
% " Wep , CG ,
eoj Vig= 2.os as (8,3tm Nyg = / 7. 9 te-to.5 ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
I JL unus ;
n upus -
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 8 of 31 Page Number f.5 14 LOWEn. AMY PAArs c wmcers M&.:ffwe wm 1}
@ ras b e-s c m p n c H
- 4. f.bwE,l. fME QTv wour(m) 1 24.64
- b. 34r /lG.rANf.dl 1 0.14
- c. deAti!.sreon OuAt. 1 d. Tr2.
- j. 7. f o d UPPE/L
- e. VMeit. fw- ftANct 70 ) ((gamn)
.t. G. %
f) He>c axr (18nr.r 2- 0. </4 NfX (30er b.os% 2 d.~72
) h tlETAtHSn WAsaft 4 ). O. II Nyy = 1.CMM. 4LSY WEICHT = W/.6l:> lBS 4.5.1 fat. CALew 4vcd PunfosG.1, "iFC BP Mnsalowet4ssy 15 DWoDGD inTo Two SKc rickus *
.SacrauV j WITH A 'TRIANG ALAd CAsss-CitLTtoN
- see-naa -
wern a sa*)vez. csass -see-rioN
)
7IIG ASSUNPTioN /s 1%1M "fkAT gk 6/ *?HC OVGrt. .Asty' 4/S!'"T Is Accoasvrea W
An- & sserecN CD, ,< 7he QErsrANiNc.
. At C BY SELTtoN Q.
& On 9 55 = 20.96Slas 2.4. Sac-noN ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
$k !ISI 7%EDER C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 9 of 31 Page Number 4,f Pk<*:TiktNiNG Mom &vr CS 3P Musi$ Owohi: sos:</
44.L wsvr Aw ex c.cwe.c hasy, secrraitD -
Tru m u c9<t- e 3 7) rD s*crrcw e@ wim p Ormewein-W,2 & trs
'%b y f' -
{4 "N Vs'///b
- WW ;&
b
- J22E k- ~ Pr 8 - case. x cuc-
?
x 1 <- t,s,-
(L
+-by Q -ta tterMNu.Naas 4 7.sd a-u w
- perswxc'W - im ('n.r') = f,,,
-> H = w (1,.s')[7ce]
R = .?. 904
- _
l
- berea ~ive ! / -
y = 4,irc," .. y l Xv 4 rec' - 1.90y
- X = d,2rr2.
~
- perew,me *Jjn ' - 48 = 0.nz/r,904 )
(
fit := g;ot ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
AL EB ER 7%EFED C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 i Calculation N ~.ter Rev.
Pace 10 of 31 Page Number 1
1 4.f.1 (am.)
. nsret.~,ac
- y ) -
7 7aa. [27. r () = .Rrr,t i.zu ,) --
y= nw(m'){4.w
- ys z.rez' a zwrnnnwe O n -
b y-. .qq b = zses "- /.soi'
</
b = lut Asamonk. sva<anr- oA suc Kernner axew awm As,va *@ . Aers : - er4 s Aor Awr ree-Mrmw.mm n m,.
j -tM ,' nk
._,_ . pp
- oeistmd'7 y -
,/ ,m4 r ts- l t- .
- yY ,
3 q. pg _
. CP =
Y -[/.<W . m]
w,pl 9 = as>s"-Quf O - /,32i "
Swnu.g 'i - 2= /, 4'03 -Q g = /,40s" ~ / sti g . d. o t-z "
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
Jk ER ER 7%INED C-NOME. CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 11 of 31 Page Number e.1 6w) l
- ) HMS.vr Astet i D = D y. 3 b' = 4 zez O. 0Pz.
- Z) ' r /,EG5f M.2. SierysN Q.' L . nsnruvr - O Awnm A L S cs ,.,,c.
44o, 7 M = 20 76S MS /s EG9w yD
'b.,p = 2P. 3 /+us @
9.1.5 N m e a r < w m u s t A rs y , seway CD -
(GM/EC Caen-SRcrug WilH DmtWstav.S ~ fpo~ /MC 27
,.prA, f.on. & FIG.I fjv r f zmr (///A - Sacrev GD s't 4 _ _
o L 5/ '
- t. 'k
- DETSitshiivE / -
i
,f Q-unu me ca.rre) Lc w 4. = 6m + g. n>v. sco)-
th?U AMC ]_. - d.?f/ w c ne) 9 nowar nam : s" =[oss 2.ah .m'+ .wo+. sin]- t-d"=[f./y?']-0.7% =2%
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
- \
$k SI5k M5559 l
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Pace 12 ef 31 Page Number 4A.+ SEenoit@ nome nr - @4%na. A.1g seu~<c.
w.>. ,
Mywg = 20.,sr tak .f3.4% m)
Mpwg =
'70. '7 in-ms -
l
$.6 -)ornt O/EATukNiNG A1outmr [BP) o' Nw
- %. 0% + Me * '%.c g, = S z. m ,t /27 m f 2G3.m + 70.7m Mgp = 168.9 In-Lbs OR /4 / 4~r-da.r ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
Ak ED ER 7% EDEN C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 13 of 31 Pa.e Number
- 5.0 6Atevur m At kar se+ ro r' (NAE
- erd I
. OrtT4Td4N<M Ato,weser M 7kB USIGHT OC 1ME KN5144 /hlP MME4- I$ 7ASrL44av f CAi M *o Av 7hst.s ).
Au.caa M voM %sss 1T+E /4tfM*3< y you. GE
.TPur /Nro 1ko f4ses j k 7N6 Hmst Ass 1, AND z.) m m .
' S.) ; 146 (6Y64 Assy Amer y ments ,9tg : (pkm 7pe.c2)
DEfcAWH10v OTY W.asw1 (Las)
Q WM $ f.9?
7?6 @ e.5 Y _ l.81 .
l abCc NUTS /2 0.27
_ d -Pi* azrwa.muus e +g Wg= O/HGc. 44y vcor = 5.82 Lbs S.1 over nnenwr, momsar iv. lw musa. uana. Assu m or wer: ,
$.2,.l . W W NfNtG !*t M G NM Oue? 10 TW PM9tlt ~
A w ~ m ,4 .i g. s c a n << eaeo.
M4=Ug [%
N,,,=359un(iLan'so.m"'<nrD i%,, = gS7 c.os (nn.c.es) = sis 4 in-w e
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
. .. - -- . . = . _ . . . - .. ..
Ak EDID
- M EDID
\
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
l Page 14 of 31 Page Number 5.2.2 Ovrut.r.wvM momnwr curi ro ampxos UWGA 44y -
a.
e Wker .' =
(ge oj) W"in W""- W"" l
\
s N = .5.82t os - 3 Ti us =. 2.23 ar 2
M rs. -
f%4t* ACr5 7MouGH RE CG Of 75ME 77C MA2 S *
- Ocei?od f Dowums pre, Asvaa.1 (G =
(al2.2+.W) ~ N.Co0+.!3S+.380) .;. (gpa+,qs +,sso)
' 2
=
('s h11'1']~fZ.OlG p (g,o,g 7.143 _y :
7 6.2.3 00MGif - NS&'mWG A & S*'NtC W M
m % M
/$f , 2.23 , gg 7.143 in ]
15.93 dD N H% ~ /n-us.s-ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
l l
Sk !III M EDED l i
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 l Calculation Number Rev. I Page 15 0f 31 1 Page Number l l
SS 79K 4WZ.t Msy Aurs r une rskr.t
~-:
f% ?>Dur2) l MC"'Pf!M OTY uniaNr-(es)
Q)stwoA' fwuG J. . &W b Snes. M T M M.- .t. O. /W C. CbnPNE.tsov GuA1. $ .
6.45 I44Ytt AAME W) .i f.64 l C. tW wt. fu* M C 75) $ 4 24
- f. BEx S4.r 1 & 79 tt&T4/NfA. R.grgs
} + _0. 06 W =AW AMy 4W#per = 12.06 Lbs S4 av&cru%nd MckmvT- OS. Hl MNs4 tewrirA Assy Hw MNstr marc assy nomirarj prm Aecur P<errPr jo Mut.6 2~l
&(Dassium A- Q Seco ec. c .
Mp ,,, = Wg@ppu, et, c 12.06 Lbs d/3r#7 G350 +/. Sb
.:t.
/,0dPfPj,
/$% =12.06 Lbs Mgya = /4 S im ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
$k SISI MEDID C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Pace 16 of 31 Page Number
& NTN $WAWM/% MOM M NU :
/9y=N y lN &M m 4 = 45.4 In-Lbs. + 15.93 In-Lbs. + 12.2 In-Lbs Ng
- 73.53 In-Lbs. Or 6.13 Ft-Lbs. ,
l ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
i -
A Et b 7%ED D i C-NOME-CALC-0107 00
- Calculation Number Rev.
Page 17 of 31 i Page Number i
i i hO _
CAccou4 rnw d4 AorW ww fm.C) MN54 ' '
j ontwM Momovr 1.
l
- FMC IMcKMr 041M'SWAS his MAese /s 1;wsue.Aino l A%) CAlutt.4'TKO /N 7FFtN K .m1 i
FM cwrnw & Mass , 7xe taumes.y uu. as wr l lNTO 7kto lhnt"$ ' d) 7NE WVkrA. Assy, />to A) 7kst
/oMEA Assy.
I g' ~P6 JMn. Actv Awe f wetem ,4er l [AumpHa;.g) .
- 7ersu DeccAttmaN Ort tonsrcar $Ad
! 4) Tv'st+rg .g. 493 l' D F6 Moos 4 2 o t.
l d jex Nurs /s. O,27 l d) N
- naso m u. uu m s ? +g g (awa Axy wear < 7.41 Lbs.
i l 1?' onurum mcar oc as Mkca imu. Auv. - Wk l . Asse.3 1 p.I? omrmsu nowr M 10 rof Paw -
l~
- 6) Anv~4 " 4. Jg k ~ee.
M ," Mg [b,,) -
/%., = q.9s ta f 3W' ssI) -
4
/(, - 41s c.a3 [15.6751n) = M /* *:
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
Sk !ISI M Ep!D C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Pace 18 of 31
- Page Number h AA W 'T*tAtNG MO&AWr 006 7D A&wA M oc
- .
v/PhCc. ,4srr -
~
fgl "*u m " %a. ~ Ws Wg =. ,.4 u ss - 4 9 s e.a s 1
- U '= 2AS '.65 6
- 14ince Acrs TainswH prs ca os 74sc '7mAmps e
4tA*tted fOmtMSeONr & /Q< void 4h a= . ( w.>)-(um.nss
- se) + 4.w.arueo) b*4 '
N) "h M [2.otc w 8.66 In.
l b
G.Z 3 Mom gpr7 - N5ilMNG A W%!C CC3D M44.tr % ng
$g = 2A5 465 8.66 In v dN% Ya.
- 21.48 In-Lbs s
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
Sk !h!I MIp!D C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 19 of 31 Page Number 63 1hc w a A-ssy Pasus E Wacsis MS: h M'e 3) 2.5cee'r<aN CTv 3"fut 6w) a e mm 4 e6s-b)> SW Asmiwa1. C.Ie-c <%ver.srei cbu4e J 0i5 (A%t. AAMSS(Bonans,L J,(do e 4 M*L ru w.e ( so) 1- 4 24
-t* A k 8'o c r 4 nem,nar A.eres, y + 0.o. cx,n y = M Assy: Und/rr = 12.06 Lbs.
b.4 dvfkrme mommvr-OS- Hcs hA && Asw. 1 NLs a avrusaceaae m 3':
Asc@ywmmmr; w - w +Amrs q sr.a ,4~e.
earwwar u.
i M =Wyby '
Mnw - 12.06 Lbs. s dir.r's. d.ne'+ t,scof s
N/A.sw
- 12.06 Lbs. !Zo/rM bs
~
s
%= 293 m-<as ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
AL EB ER 7%IDER C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Pace 20 of 31 Page Number b$ 1DTAt dth*'AMNtat. MMNY fMt.4 :
N,*
ag **,, #g ( Ng Ogg = 7Q /N-sos 021.48 In-Lbs 0 2Y3 W
- )pg = _ 123.1 In-Lbs. Or 10.3 Ft-Lbs ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
Jk D D M 959 C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 21 of 31 Page Number i
- l.0 Gw%etsw OA m nusa. m .41Jo Miuc^_
- 1ME- %Hs Cf Me SP Mn64 l /tLP nfNia* 16%6 &"'"^=^8 e mm- 4. ow-44 oe twommw c% ras enes (su twas bwe A=t. 'Re kmnse ikpense p an m%es 7Ns. rse (MarcNf, ME m tr/.a:w 7ME 4040 &=4w Isr 7Anr
&W,erswteM Mestivr 1Nor uu.013wo 70 Qousr ne Heneoxn M.
- Tdeasa fa accvxe cwsaw ^>ew Rashpe.
GW-sarno A' w A4CH CW.stcN. If Rs Pas 133 /M.P ms4 5 tass MM oix. BM9t- 70'?R+1 A;w. 73r @ MNse ,1sw /kP w uu..se c:nsouico swam ao yo u rnsr Gerwic ONO:rie4T f*n 7W6 M MMCG AM.t.1).
f.) A0. C. . Kw- BP MNsa '
- hrue,*,vc mmwr.[Aum ps) = /0:$ ws
- 4msr encew mer our a ma.r wu.ee Essenont $w eMrs.rmwnc nmierr-era .
40.7 =
% isp Amr A* g, r I 'll
- "l'
/cg:& ix.sss ~ M9the gu 6' 4 , ,
(lu'+.1st') 4.9L/**
uar
% P.GR *~~ 9 m am ff,fse=. .91. Y 44C ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
AL EB ER 9% BEE C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 22 of 31 Page Number
- CV6.d.7tecwNg ftcow4wT (From 5.5) = 73.53 In.Lbs.
- umr cess ic pk crue Ik.r acservan- vs*E twnns onruxm ner.
- 1 i (o.p. ==.
/*l,'+
k I #p4 am + k u" RaK = ' * "' -
-, aoa Y
n (i.avme) Coasa
= 27.72 ' gag O I R O. F.Sw .
]3 6~/%usw (* BP To Ik.P
- a.msna RQn sc Tw M:r.:ws: . i 5 7ms Tuc3 80.5.o i P.oA w l i
ff&r 9.1) 27.72 Jas 6 -(tho~ 7.1) 37.9486 W
. i nut srere-avr is rnas l rserwsa rns HLP !s .cros>noceur %qusto.
{
i ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
_.__._._.__..._._....______7...__....___.___.._._
Jk k D
!- 7% 9 p C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev 1
j Page 23 of 31 i Page Number i
i 40 j
UMP 4ttsov 66 9 htinQ 7D HLS M9tG4 w+
'fftC D*St'CN G df. 7ME Bf,hMsk MO His MNM KAME sets / Getarita. d%<st,t<cAs. m49serac54, 7mwie.or,
! /PE. /s SKc.frew 7.0 , '/Aes. cfNc.y Witifyvans/..<. IM9M/w l
\ . 5 70Sacy fcit. 6/MK 1WE Arnla90 14.scM. // Pil Ras. O'estrnNG M 72/6 kl.G Avtc6 AMsA l$ath'
/S f.sss htivs4 746 Re.1 1kM 04./5 Cue % rHfr os 'TkC 2P nv4/1)
.birsicssto %eenLLY t;heunna, N 4C foe. Mf6 Ansa-l' A l
$(
- eMm'%tnisK nty.ai;er x
% 6.5 *)
l I pp = .123.08_
CM' -> < N-/.sts" - t 4wsr ewyr tr t.e. cwr 3.tr P (4rsevnog 't?Ve AVvwas dens.rm M m.
ptf** .
123.05__tN us Raf- = =
s nm eu Ltwss-)
46.4 gd.f, as e Agg n
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
Ak ER ED M EDER C-NOME-CALC '>107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 24 of 31 Page Number 4 Z. . %)>usid M BP TD /LS
- cW+te QMsg 5 no pesc.ns ;
l3 14.5 7?Ly,E f MA m . RO.f.
ff* ton /0./ , 46.4
? f k 7.1 _37.7 Lar
9.0 CONCLUSION
Under a representative IG load, the offseting loads created in, Hot Leg PDT MNSA's is less than the loads created in the BP MNSA. Therefore the statement can be made that the Hot Leg PDT MNSA designs is "seismicaly qulified" since it would be tested to the same response specturm as the EP MNSA in Reference 3.1 The Preload O..seting Force calculated above are sumarised in the below table Clamp P.O.F. Section BP MNSA 37.8 Lbs. Section 7.1 H.LP. MNS A 27.7 Lbs. Section 7.2 HLS MNSA 46.4 Lbs. Section 8.1 The offseting load calculated for the Waterford Sampling Nozzle MNS A is greater than the offseting load calculated for the Bottom Pressu izer MNS A that was test :d. Therefore the Waterford response spectra will be compared to the test spectra. Then thc ratio of the two calculated moments will be used to establish a "g" loading to demonstrate that the test conditions envelope the Waterford design conditions. This will be done in ABB Rep]rt No. C-NOME-ER-0120," Design Evaluation of MNSA for Various Applications at Waterfrrd Unit 3".
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
Ak D ED M. DED C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 25 of 31 Page Number 10.0 ASSESMENT OF SIGNIFICANT DESIGN CHANGES This calculation evaluates the MNSA design for Waterford and is based on previous designs of MNSA clamps for San Onofre Units 2 & 3. The only significant design change is the length of the tie rods. This calculation incorporates the new lengths of the tie rods.
11.0 Design Input This calculation uses the references of Section #3 as design inputs.
1 1
1 ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
Jk IR ER 7%BBER C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 26 of 31 Page Number FIGURE 1 l Bottom Pressurizer Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly (From References 3.3 & 3.6)
/ )
I
_ l l
/f_l AkV /
l l
- h l
1
, h ..
r- f; W w sm '
"" 1 F"" f I
.-w= -
um , ,
l'
\.
\
l l 1 u \ s
,_ "l I f l LJ. . 1.
4 Note: Reference Dimensions (W/ "()" are calculated values based on a 27.5 Angle.
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
JL ED ED MEDIN C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Pace 27 of 31 Page Number FIGURE 2 Hot Lee PDT Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly (From References 3.4,3.6 & 3.7) 0-I I I lt} g l o.75 -W
% ) r g i i
I I
I I
I
$2.2s LL
- ",.s0-e.-
n t j +
" Tiss k7 f ^
_y, ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power 4
Ak ED ER 7%IDER C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 28 of 31 Page Number FIGURE 3 Hot Lee Samnline Mechanical Nozzle Seal Assembly I (From References 3.5,3.6 &3.7 I r I
' - o.02 o.75 l l ,
t ur;2 3 afjf L .- -
l
'., =;=
I i
15.30 1
1 1 L_k l l
, 3--
I I( ) E xm__q
_ o.3.o 1
, - 0.135 //J j [t ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
Nhh 7% B B -
^
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 29 of 31 Page Number TABLEI Bonom_Pressuri7er MNS A (E-MNS A-7.28-001-1, Assembly) Weight Name Detail Part No. Volume (cu.in.) Density (liveu.in.) Weight / Piece (Ibs) Quantity Total Weight (Ibs)
Lower Flange E-MNSA-228-004-1 87.057 0.283 24.64 1 24.64 Seal Retainer -004-2 2.614 0.283 0.74 1 074 Compression Collar -004-3 2.899 0.283 0.82 1 0.82 Upper Flange (Bottom: -004-29 25.100 0.283 7.10 1 7.10 Ur.ner Flange (Top) -004-5 24.593 0.283 6.96 1 6.%
Top Plate -004-6 12.826 0.283 3.63 1 3.63 Hex Bolt (Short) -004-25 0.773 0.283 0.22 2 0.44 Hex Bolt (Long) -004-24 1.266 0.283 0.36 2 0.72 Tie Rod -004-15 1.381 0.283 0.39 4 1.56 Hex Nut -004-27 0.081 0.283 0.02 12 0.27 IT2" Retainer Washer -004-22 0.093 0.283 0.03 4 0.1 I 3/8" Retainer Washer -004-21 0.066 0.283 0.02 12 0.22 Total: 47.21 Notes:
- 1. Weight of Grafoil Seal is negligible.
- 2. All calculations are based on dimensions from referenced drawings.
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
$k I I 7% B B -
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 30 of 31 Page Number TALBE 2 IIot Irg PDT MNS A (E-MNSAWFD-2.28-002-1, Assembly) Weight Name Detail Part No. Volume (cu.in.) Density (Ib/cu.in.) Weight / Piece (Ibs) Quantity Total Weight (lbs)
Lower Flange E-MNSA-228-013-13 9.477 0.283 2.68 I 2.68 Seal Retainer -004-32 0.628 0.283 0.18 1 0.18 Compression Collar E4tNSA%TD-228-0033 I.603 0.283 0.45 1 0.45 Upper Flange (Bottom) -013-12 12.925 0.283 3.66 1 3.66 Upper Flange (Top) -013-24 14.973 0.283 4.24 1 4.24 Top Plate -013-06 12.670 0.283 3.59 1 3.59 flex Bolt -013-21 0.701 0.283 0.20 4 0.79 Tie Rod -013-27 1.601 0.283 0.45 4 1.8 I flex Nut -004-27 0.081 0.283 0.02 12 0.27 Retainer Plate -013-20 0.054 0.283 0.02 4 0.06 3/8" Retainer Washer -004-21 0.066 0.283 0 02 8 0.15 Tetal: 17.88 Notes:
- 1. Weight of Grafoil Seal is negligible.
- 2. All calculations are based on dimensions fmm referenced drawings.
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
ADD 7% B 5 -
C-NOME-CALC-0107 00 Calculation Number Rev.
Page 31 of 31 Page Number TABLE 3 Hot Leg Samnling MNSAWFD (E-MNSA-228-003-1 Assembly) Weight Name Detail Part No- Volume (cu.in.) Density (Ib/cu.in.) Weight / Piece (Ibs) Quantity Total Weight (Ibs)
Lower Flange E-MNSA-228-013-13 9.477 0.283 2.68 I 2.68 Seal Retainer -008-32 0.628 0.283 0.18 1 0.1 S Compression Collar F MNSAWm.22mna 1.603 0.283 0.45 I O 45 Upper Flange fBottom) -013-12 12.925 0.283 3.66 1 3.66 Upper Flange (Top) -013-24 14.973 0.283 4.24 I 4.24 Top Plate -013-15 17.430 0.283 4.93 1 4.93 Hex Bolt -013-21 0.701 0.283 0.20 4 0.79 Tie Rod -013-25 1.822 0.283 0.52 4 2.06 Hex Nut -004-27 0.081 0.283 0.02 12 0.27 Retainer Plate -013-20 0.054 0.283 0.02 4 0.06 3/8" Retainer Washer -004-21 0.066 0.283 0.02 8 0.15 Total: 19.43 Notes:
- 1. Weight of Grafoil Seal is negligible.
- 2. Seismic effect of the weight of Clamp (Detail -013-22), Hex Hd Bolts (Detail -016-15). and 1/2" Retainer Washers (Detail -004-22) is addressed in the Design Report, Ref. 3.2
- 3. All calculations are based on dimensions from referenced drawings.
ABB Combustion Engineering Nuclear Power
- _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _. - _ _ _ _ _- _ _ -