ML18046A711

Objects to Impending Approval of Permit to Erect Temporary Barge Slip for Arrival of Generator.Similar Const Resulted in Devastation of Shore Area

ML18046A711
Person / Time
Site:	Palisades
Issue date:	04/21/1981
From:	Molyneaux M AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:	Wambach T NRC
Shared Package
ML18046A710	List: ML18046A711
References
NUDOCS 8106100019
Download: ML18046A711 (4)

Text

- - .....

""-JJ ...

\J April 21, 1981-338 Taft Cou'rt Glenview, 11. '60025 Mr. Tom Wambech Nuclear Regu~atory Com.mission ,.

j 7920 Norfolk Bethesda, Maryland 20014

Dear Mr. Wambach:

I J *'

I am sorry for the delay in writing to yo4, but I have just returned.

from the hospital.

I On February 16 I wrote to Mr. C .s. Thompson, J'r., Deputy District Engineers, LTC Corps of Engineers, Det~oit office, for clarification of specific items in which we as a coIJUTlittee of property owners are interested. The impending approval of a permit to erect a temporary barge slip or sink steel piling to prepare a pathway for the arrival of a generator via barge on the lake to Consumers Power plant at Palisades Park, Michigan is the cause of our concern.

We are very concerned if anyone is permitted to erect any type of barrier in the lake North of our Park. One needs only to know the history of the erection of the pier at Michigan City, Inl.iana by the Army Corps of Engineers and the devastation that resulted from it to the entire Heverly Shores area to the South of the pier to realize what can happen. Of course the Michigan City residents *were delighted by their new found land which they have used as a recreation area. B,ut the utter destruction of the entire Heverly Shores area is a .mute warning to anyone who understands the currents in the lake and what happens to the shoreline when the littoral drift is prevented from nourishing the beaches.

According to Mr. Thompson my questions should be directed to you. I am enclosing a copy of my February 16 letter to alert .you to our items of concern. The 167 property owners of our park would like the answers to our questions. J.i'or example: we are not su~e what is meant by "moni taring".

Does it include photographing regularly any changes in _saifdh§"r~5":l)~i31 across the extent of Palisades Park property? Please see paragraph-four of my letter of February 16,. 1981 *..

In order to protect the pro*perty owners of Palisades Park, we would like to request that you insist tha.t Consumers Power Company post a $10,000,000 bond to guarantee the protection they are claiming.

. I~~.

I look forwaijd to your answers to this and the .tt'ebruary 16 letter which I hope will al'ieviate our con'.cerns.

Sincerely, .*

ie Bi. Molynea , President Palisades Park Safety and Environmental Protection Committee 8116100019

• .ARTMENT OF THE.ARMY

• DETROIT DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS BOX 1027 DETROIT, MICHIGAN 48231 REPLY TO ATTENTION OF NCECO-LP Ms. Marjorie B. Molyneaux, President Palisades Park Environment & Safety Committee 338 Taft Court Glenview, IL 60025

Dear Ms. Molyneaux:

Reference your letter of 16 February 1981 concerning a Department of Anny permit issued to Consumers Power Company (CPC) to construct temporary

• off-loading facilities at the Palisades Nuclear Power Generating Station in Lake Michigan near South Haven, Michigan.

Prior to issuance of the Department of Army permit, my staff analysed the potential effects the proposed activities could have on adjacent shoreline properties. The analysis indicated that adjacent properties would not be damaged since CPC owns 2400 feet of shoreline property to the north and 2900 feet of shoreline property to the south of the generating facility. The CPC will be required to submit a shoreline monitoring program that must be approved by the District Engineer before construction can begin. The CPC will provide mitigation if necessary as directed by th.eJ.District Engineer.

CPC is also required to coordinate the entire project with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC). By Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) definition in CEQ regulations, the NRC is considered to be the lead Federal agency. Therefore, the Corps' evaluation of the proposal concerned only the activities covered by Section 10 of the 1899 River and Harbor Act and Section 404 of the 1977 Clean Water Act. Duplication of review at both agency levels is an added burden and expense. I suggest that you contact NRC on any other matters pertaining to the overall project. The address and point of contact at NRC is:

Mr. Tom Wambach.

Nuclear Regulatory Commission 7920 Norfolk Bethesda, Maryland 20014 I have advised them.of your interest and concerns.

As always, our records and files of permit applications are available for public review at any time during our regular office hours. You are invited to review the record as it now stands and any additional information as it develops in the future. We are located on the 7th floor of the McNamara Federal Building at 477 Michigan Avenue, Detroit, Michigan.

C. 8. THOMPSON, JR.

LTC~ Corps of Engineerg Aoting District Engineer;

.. -v

.,: "' ,, -.i J:rn T:1 f t I j .l e 11 vi P. w ,

C1111 rt I l * (i ()[) ?. ~i fl e :

• Yo 11 L' Lr. '- t I'! r 1-?. J- l '1 !I .l

-Fr.hru*ir-y lG, l~lfll

[ 0 '.i. Tliomp!1011, Jr.

LTC, Corps of Lnginer.rs Dr.puty District [nginP.er De;ir ~1r. Thompson:

NF.edless to say I .nm very disappointed at your decisinn to p~rmit Consumers Pnwrr Cnrnp<rny to er,,ct a tF.mporAry h<lHJf! A.lip in d1P. :u1kP.

cidji1cl'!nt to Prilisnrles Park, MichiCJiln and to run thP. r.hnrir.~ nf rl~struction to our shor.P.lin~.

Your reasons for turning down the p.leils of lli7 fnrTli.liF.!J in Pn.lis,:Hif!R Pa r k c.rn d de c id in I) in f i1 v o :r:- of a l Ar I) e Lind po \-.J e r f 1J l co .r: po r ri -1: j_ n n w P. H? :

economics, physicril lirni tntioris, nVnilcibl1'3 transrrnr.tcii:.ion nnrl ~ovP.rnment rPstrir.tions Tlir.sri are illl 1-.iorrls and do not exp.lain wl1i1t you .i-1.r:-P. irTJplyinf) .. PlF-~asP.

rr.spond tellirHJ 1Js whilt is nct1J;illy mr.nnt hy t~1n;,n fn11.r: s 1 :..it.~!rr11~rit.s.

An cl i n th P. f o u r t h n n P. , wh a t r e s t r i r. t i n n s e x i s t 7 A :r:- P. 1: t1f'! ~' f P. d r. r Fl 1 ,

.t<Jte or local'?

I t is al s o ex tr em el y i 111 port ant f o r us to k n n w w h rlt. y n 1J in 1: P. *n rl t ri do when you s n y monitor in IJ.* You 111 n k e no men ti o n n f ri r. r.i_ al p I 1n to s ht= f o re construction begins so there is evidence to chP.ck Ha<1inst. Tn wl1~t

!] P. ti!] r CJ p hi c l i mi ts wi 11 th P. p ho to s b e t a k e n lfo r. th .A n d Sc 11 th r-rn d how far intc the lakP.7 \hll you includ.e the ShOrP.lin8 tn thP. thirrl

• sandbar? And After the temporary brirge slip is re111nved wt1At cnmpRrison w i 11 b e mi1 d E 1*1 :i~ th

• p ho to s t a k e n b e f o re i n i ti n 1 r. o n s t r u r. tin n , ;, n rl ~ i 11 Consumers be ~equired to replace any diminution tn Ann~har~ 1 ,2,3 thi1t has occurrnd, and to what lirTJits North nr.rl South? /'\nrl 1.;ill t:hnsP.

photos be availnhle to the public for reviP.w? Anrl if so, wher.e nnrl wh~n?

':lhP.n yow sny "any Adverse f::ffectR 11 whi1t do you 111P.an? ';JhAt S"T;nnrlilrds will be used to d!!tl!rmine whnt is cirlverse? Anrl who will 111AkP. thP.

dr?tArr.iinatl.on - your officl'l or thP. courts? And who :i.s r.r.sronsih1P.

for that expense?

You h.-ivP. st;1terl th;1t "Uveril.ll irnpncts of *cnnstr1Jr.tion **

• nr.~ ;1 r.P.sro11-

!1ii.>ility of anotl1~r Fr!rl!R..r.<11 il1Jl!11r.y'l \vill you plP.<1s1~ rid,1isP. 11s wliir.h

<HJP.nr.y tlii1t is .i.n r..l!if'l wn lrnvf'l to r.nritnr.t it?

It in olJvious th.-1t your lP.ttf'lr. h11s crP-<ltP.rl mnr.P. 1inP.;1si11Ass tli.-=in. it hi!~ settlP.tl i11 thP. 111inds of l 1 ulis<HJ~n f>a.rk rP.!lirfonts. ll11r r.orr1r1ittP.n now hils the responsibility to P-Xp.lnin to 1111 fi1mi.lie~ whnt; thP.

• decision un our n~quf'lst to dl'!ny the pr?rrnit rl'!a.lly MP.Ans. ~fo <1r.P. VP.ry concerned.

5i:~er~ly . /f'Q f *

/ ,L~ ... 1 ~.~ /;9, ~~

Mi1r* ie B. MolynP.t:<<.ix, PrP.:>ident Pal s~des Park £nvironment nnd SafP.ty Com111itteP.

Marjorie B. Mol yneaux 338 Taft Court *.

L Glenview. IL 60025 '

• To v ambach Nuclear Regulatory Commissi on 7920 Norfolk Bethesda , ryland 20014