ML17209B258

Withdraws Petition to Intervene in Proceeding

ML17209B258
Person / Time
Site:	Saint Lucie
Issue date:	06/12/1981
From:	WELLS H S HUTCHINSON ISLAND COALITION
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel, NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY)
Shared Package
ML17209B257	List: ML17209B258
References
NUDOCS 8106190217
Download: ML17209B258 (6)

Text

'~~0XNTHEMATTEROFFLORIDAFOWER8.LIGHTCO.ST.LUCIEPLANT,UNITNO.2PETXTXONFROMHLENSHEAWELLS;,"'""<4vga.ATTENTXONATOMICS'AFETY8.LICENSINGBOARDATTENTIONSECRETARYOFNUCLEARREGULATORYCOMMISSIONATTENTIONMEMBERSOFTHESERVXCELISTMY'PETITIONOFMARCH23,1981BEGANASASIMPLEALTRUISTICMOVEMENTTOATTEMPTTOSEEKTHEHELPOFTHENRCTOCORRECTCERTAINCONDITXONSEXISTINGWITHINSXXMILESSOUTHOFTHENUCLEARPLANTSONHUTCHXNSONISLAND,ST.LUCIECO.FLORXDA.SINCETHATTIME,IHAVEBEENDELUGEDWITHMATERIALBOTHFROMNRCANDFLORIDAPOWER8:LXGHTSOMUCHSO>THATITWOULDTAKEAFULLTIMESECRETARYTOHANDLEALLOFIT.INADDITIONIWASVISITEDBYTHREEPEOPLE,ONEANASSISTAiNTMANAGEROFTHELOCALFPLOFFXCE,THEOTHERSBOTHLAWYERSREPRESENTINGFPL)7HOSEMAXNPURPOSEWASTOTALKMEOUTOFFILINGANYPETITION!ITWOULDSEEMTHATEVERYONECONCERNEDXSMAKINGXTASDIFFXCULTASPOSSXBLEFORANYCITIZENWITHTHESAFETY'FTHEPUBLICINMXitD.IAMFULLYAWAREOFTHENEEDTOXPEDXTETHEHEARINGSSXNCETHEMATERIALRECEIVEDFROMFPLGIVESAMPLEEVIDENCEOFTHECOSTRESULTINGFROMTHEDELAYINLICENSINGTHEST.LUCIEPLANTUNITNO.2.INFACT,MONEYISTHEIRMAINCONCERN.HOWEVER,UFONANALYZINGMi>TERIALFROMNRCITISEVIDENTTHATTHISBOARDISVERYCONCERNEDWXTHTHEHFALTHANDSAFETYOFTHEPUBLIC.IAMPARTICULARLYXMPRESSEDWITHTHESTATE-MENTINDOCKETNO.$0-$89OFJUNE3THATSTATES",THELICENSEWXLLNOTBEISSUEDUNTILTHECOMMISSXONHASMADEFINDINGSANDHASCONCLUDEDTHATTHEISSUANCEOFTHELICENSEWILLNOTBEINXi~iICALTOTHECOMMONDEFENSEANDSECURXTYORTOTHEHEALTH8rSAFETYOFTHEPUBLXC."ITWASAMATTEROFINTERESTTOMETOREADINANNRCOFFICEOFPUBLICAFFAIRSBULLETINNO.81-38,MARCH9,1981THAT,WHETHERORNOTTHEREIS'AHEARING,ANOPERATINGLICENSEWOULDNOTBEISSUEDUNTILAFTERCOMiPLETIONOFTHESAFETYANDENVIRONMENTALREVIEWSBYTHENRCSTAFF.ALSO,INFORMATIONINTHEFEDERALREGISTER,VOL.45,NO.123,JUNE24,198oSPELLSOUTTHEACTIONTHATMUSTBETAKENBYFE@lBEFORELICENSEAPPROVAL.8X061903l7,C1-<</er:

4~~

INTHEMATTEROFFPLST.LUCIEPLANT,UNITN0.2PETITIONFROMHELENSHEAWELLSPAGE2.IWOULDALSOREFERYOUTOACOPYOFTHELETTERIMAILEDYOUTHATWASSENTTOMEBYJAMESPENDLAND,GOVERNMENTALAFFAIRSADVISORONAPRIL21,1981WHICHAGAINSTATESNRCISREQUIREDTOBASEITSFINDINGONAREVIEWOFFEMAFINDINGSASTOWHETHERSTATEANDLOCALEMERGENCYPLANSAREADEQUATE.THECOALITIONWILLDEPENDONNRCTOFOLLOWTHROUGH.PLEASEBEAWARETHATIAMONLYONEOFMANYPEOPLEANDORGAN-IZATIOiNSWORRIEDABOUTTHESAFETYOFTHEISLAND.JAMESW.MAY,CHIEFBUREAUOFLAND8cWATERMANAGEMENT,DEPARTMENTOFCOMMUNITYAFFAIRS,TALLAHASSEESTATEDINALETTERTOMEOFJAN.6,1981,THATHEWASHIGHLYCONCERNEDWITHTHEIMPACTOFDEVELOPMENTINRECENTMONTHS.THETREASURECOASTPLANNINGCOUNCIL,AGOVERNMENTGROUPCONFOSEDOFOFFICIALSFROMFOURCOUNTIESHASBEENWORKINGFORMONTHSTOBRINGADIALOGUEWITHOURLOCALCOUNTYGOVERNMENT.TO'NOAVAIL.EDITORIALSINALL..FOURCOUNTYNEWSPAPERSHAVETAINTEDOUTTHEFAILUREOFLOCALGOVERt'MENTTOCOOP"RATE.AREPORTERFROMTIthEMAGAZINEHASBEENXNCONSTANTTOUCHWITHMESINCETHEBARRIERISLANDSANDTHEIRGROWTHHAVEBECOtlENEWS~THESTATEAUDUBONSOCIETYALONGWITHCONSERVATIONALLIANCESANDMANYOTHERCITIZENGROUPSHAVEGONEBEFOREPUBLICMEETINGS'WITHCOUNTYCOMMISSIONERSTOVOICECONCERNABOUTSUCHINDISCRIMINATEAPPROVALOFBUILDINGSINANAREATHATISUNIQUESINCEIT'STHEONLYBARRIERISLANDINTHEUS.CONTAININGTWONUCLEARPLANTSlSTILLTHEDEVELOPMENTCONTINUESRAPXDLY.lYOURATTENTXONXSCALLEDTOTHETWOENCLOSURESPARTOFMATERIALSENTTOMEBYTHEOFFICEOFSENATORLA%TONCHILES.IFNRCISUSINGTHEMAPENCLOSEDASTRUTHFULLYSTATINGTHELANDAREASHEREYOUAREBEXNGSADLYMISLEADlTHEMAPLEAVESOUTANAREAOFAPPROXIMATELYTHREEMILESWHICHCONTAINSTHEGREATESTGROWTH.THEREISAPOTENTIALOF40>000PEOPLEWHENALLTHEAPPROVEDCONSTRUCTIONISXNHABITED,ALLWITHINASIXMILEAREASOUTHOFTHEPLANTS.FALSEMAPSSUCH-ASTHISANDFALSEADVERTISINGHASGONEONTOOLONGTOMANIPULATETHEPUBLICl!THESECONDENCLOSURECONTAINSERRONEOUSFIGURESONTHEPOPULATION.INTHISLETTERSENTTOSENATORCHXLESDATEDFEB.171981,MR.WILLIAMDIRCKS,EXECUTIVEDIRECTORFOROPERATIONSOFNRCBASESHISFIGURESON1974POPULATIONANDHASNOCONCEPTIONOFTHEGROWTHTHATHASOCCUREDSINCETHATTIME.

~~XNTHEMATTEROFFPLST.LUCIEPLANT,UNITN0.2PETITIONFROMHELENSHEAWELLSPAGE$.ATTHEPRESENTTIMETHEADMINXSTRATIONDEPARTMENTOFMARTINCO.STUART,FLA.ISATTEMPTINGTOOBTAINGRANTMONEYFROMTHESTATEOFFLORIDAINORDERTOCONDUCTATHOROUGHSTUDYOFSAFETYASPECTSOFST.LUCIEPLANTNO.2.ACCORDINGTOOFFICIALSOFTHXSDEPARTMENT\THEMATERIALTHATTHEYHAVERECEIVEDTODATEFROMNRCENVIRONMENTALREPORT1SCONTAINEDXNLARGEVOLUMESMUCHOFt(('HIGHXSINCOMPREHENSIBLETOTHEREADER.,THEYALSOANTICIPATETHAT,WHENANDIFTHEGRANTMONEYISOBTAINED,SOMUCHTIMEWILLHAVEELAPSEDTHATTHEWHOLEPROJECTWILLHAVELOSTITSUSEFULNESS!IWOULDSUGGESTTHATTHISISA)YASTEOFTIMEANDTAXPAYERSMONEY!INREPLYTOYOURORDEROFJUNE5,1981ANDAFTERDUECONSXDERATIONOFALLTHEFACTORSINVOLVED,YOUMAYCONSIDERMYFINALANSWERTOBEONEOFI((AKINGASTATEMENTTONRCOFMYCONCERNSANDTHECONCERNSOFTHEMEMBERSOFTHEHUTCHINSONISLANDCOALITION.MYSTATUSASANINTERVENORXNANEVXDENTIARYHEARINGXSWITHDRAWNASOFTHISDATE.HELENSHEAWELLSDIRECTORHUTCHINSONISLANDCOALITIONJUNE12,1981ENCLOSURES2CCSTUARTNEWSPETERMOTTSANDRAHINSON 0'~t)~)~Ie)IC)~~~

~lgdoyjyfPmgjgI4',cabl%+l<s%5/clCo-mpgrou~4Dn~~gwQNdg4Mg~F<SiJmrri./Thenearestcampgroundislocatedapproximately'milesfromtheSt.LuciesiteTheapplicantestimatedthecapacityofthiscamp-~~is$s~groundtobeabout15persons.Apublicbeachandparkarelocatedapproximately7milessouthofthenucleargeneratingstaoTheapplicantestimatesthatwhile50-100personswillwalkalongthenarrowoceanbeachadjacenttotheplantsiteeachdaytheirwalkdurationwillnotexceedanhour.DucksarehuntedinseasonbyasfewhuntersonHutchinsonIslandwithinafewmilesoftheplant.ShellfishingintheIndianRiveriscurrentlyprohibitedbyanorder\oftheFloridaStateBoardofHealth.TheFortPierce-St.LucieCountyChamber.ofCommercereportsthat-two-thirdsofthecountyisdevotedtoag'riculturalindustry;41percentpastureland,23percentcitrusr>crops,and1percentvegetables.TheRegulatorystaffperformedanindependentstudyof1974popu-lationdistributioninthevicinityofthesite.Weestimatedapopulationof71,900within10milesoftheplant,14,100within&-1/2milesand7,100within5miles.Ofthe7,100within5miles,5,200arerlocatedonthemainlandd1,900arelocatedonHutchinsonIslandbetween4and5milessouthoftheplant.mu~Onthebasisof10CPRPart100definitionsofthepopulation+Q~centerdistance(8nd.les),theexclusionareadistance{5100feet),eandtheLPZdistance(5miles),ourestimateof1974populationS(~cc/gg~