ML17093A661: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
||
(5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
| issue date = 03/06/2017 | | issue date = 03/06/2017 | ||
| title = Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC Responses to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Environmental Request for Additional Information - Letter Dated January 25, 2017 | | title = Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC Responses to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Environmental Request for Additional Information - Letter Dated January 25, 2017 | ||
| author name = Haass | | author name = Haass C | ||
| author affiliation = Northwest Medical Isotopes | | author affiliation = Northwest Medical Isotopes | ||
| addressee name = Balazik M | | addressee name = Balazik M | ||
| addressee affiliation = NRC/Document Control Desk, NRC/NRR | | addressee affiliation = NRC/Document Control Desk, NRC/NRR | ||
| docket = 05000609 | | docket = 05000609 | ||
Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter: | {{#Wiki_filter:.*:.**.*.*. NWMI | ||
NORTHWEST MEDICAL ISOTOPES U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ATTN: Document Control Desk 11555 Rockville Pike Washington, DC 20555 Mr. Michael Balazik Research and Test Reactors Branch A Division of Policy and Rulemaking Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation | .:~.-.~* . | ||
.....*..*:-=* | |||
*: ~~-~~:. NORTHWEST MEDICAL ISOTOPES March 6, 2017 NWMI-LTR-2017-001 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ATTN: Document Control Desk 11555 Rockville Pike Washington, DC 20555 Mr. Michael Balazik Research and Test Reactors Branch A Division of Policy and Rulemaking Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation RE: Docket No. 50-609, Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC Responses to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Environmental Request for Additional information - | |||
Letter Dated January 25, 2017 | |||
==References:== | ==References:== | ||
: 1. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission letter to Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC, dated January 25, 2017, Docket No. 50-609 (ADAMS Accession No. ML16056A122), "Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC -Request for Additional Information for Construction Permit Application Regarding Emergency Response Plan Regarding Application For Construction Permit (TAC No. MF6138)" 2. Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC Letter NWMI-LTR-2015-006 to U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, dated July 20, 2015 (ADAMS Accession No. ML16056A122), ''NRC Project No. 0803 -Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC, Submittal Part 2 Construction Permit Application for a Radioisotope Production Facility" | : 1. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission letter to Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC, dated January 25, 2017, Docket No. 50-609 (ADAMS Accession No. ML16056A122), "Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC - Request for Additional Information for Construction Permit Application Regarding Emergency Response Plan Regarding Application For Construction Permit (TAC No. MF6138)" | ||
: 2. Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC Letter NWMI-LTR-2015-006 to U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, dated July 20, 2015 (ADAMS Accession No. ML16056A122), ''NRC Project No. 0803 - Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC, Submittal Part 2 Construction Permit Application for a Radioisotope Production Facility" | |||
==Dear Mr. Balazik:== | ==Dear Mr. Balazik:== | ||
Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC (NWMI) is providing the attached response (Attachment | |||
Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC (NWMI) is providing the attached response (Attachment 1) to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission request for additional information dated January 25, 2017. | |||
Sincerely, Carolyn C. Haass Chief Operating Officer | NWMI is submitting this response to the NRC in accordance with 10 CFR 50.30(b), "Oath or Affirmation," and 10 CFR 50.4, "Written Communications." | ||
I solemnly declare and affirm that the foregoing information is true and correct under the penalty of perjury; executed on March 6, 2017. | |||
Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC I 815 NW 9th Ave, Suite 256 I Corvallis, OR 97330 | |||
Mr. Michael Balazik page2 If you have questions, I can be reached at (509) 430-6921 or carolyn.haass@nwmedicalisotopes.com. | |||
Sincerely, c~c.~ | |||
Carolyn C. Haass Chief Operating Officer | |||
==Enclosures:== | ==Enclosures:== | ||
Attachment 1 cc: Mr. Alexander Adams Research and Test Reactors Branch A Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation | |||
.;....;*. NWMI | |||
.*:.**.*~** | |||
.....****l:* | |||
* *. ~~.~~ ." | |||
* NORTHWEST MEDICAL ISOTOPES ATTACHMENT 1 Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Request for Additional Information for Construction Permit Application Regarding the Emergency Response Plan (TAC No. MF6138) | |||
Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC Construction Permit Application Docket No. 50-609 (Document No. NWMl-2017-RAl-001, March 2017) | |||
Information is being provided via hard copy | |||
.:....~**.:*. NWMI | |||
. *. ~~**.~;. NORTHWESTMEDICALISOTOPES This page intentionally left blank. | |||
*/e**.e . | |||
* | |||
* 0 * | |||
* 8 0..*** ****.**** | |||
* c. | |||
*~** | |||
0 | |||
* *f.)* ~ . | |||
0 | |||
* NORTHWEST MEDICAL ISOTOPES Response to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Request for Additional Information for Construction Permit Application Regarding the Emergency Response Plan (TAC No. MF6138) | |||
NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 March 2017 Prepared by: | |||
Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC 815 NW gth Ave, Suite 256 Corvallis, OR 97330 | |||
This page intentionally left blank. | |||
.:;*... NWMI | |||
~~:. | |||
*.*.*~~.~~*~.* | |||
NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 | |||
* *. .". f.IGRTHWESTMEDl£Al ISOTOPES Response to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Request for Additional Information for Construction Permit Application Regarding the Emergency Response Plan (TAC No. MF6138) | |||
NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 Date Published: | |||
March 6, 2017 Document Number: NWMl-2017-RAl-007 I Revision Number: 0 | |||
==Title:== | |||
Response to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Request for Additional Information for Construction Permit Application Regarding the Emergency Response Plan (TAC No. Mf6138) | |||
Approved by: Carolyn Haass Signature: | |||
CUJ>J~e..~ | |||
.:..-.~*:.*. NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 | |||
**.~~--~~;* fJOITTHWE.STMmlCALISOTIJPfS REVISION IDSTORY Rev Date Reason for Revision Revised By 0 3/6/2017 Issued for submittal to the NRC NIA | |||
.:;~*~~*-. | |||
......... *.* NWM I NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 | |||
* *.~~.~~.'. NORnlVlESTMEDJCALISOTOPES TERMS Acronyms and Abbreviations ANS American Nuclear Society ANSI American National Standards Institute CFR Code of Federal Regulations EAL emergency action level EPZ emergency planning zone ERP Emergency Response Plan ISG Interim Staff Guidance NRC U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission NWMI Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC PSAR preliminary safety analysis report RPF Radioisotope Production Facility U.S. United States Units km kilometer m1 mile | |||
.:;.*.~:.:. NWMI | |||
.......... NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 | |||
. *. ~~.~! ," | |||
* NURTHWESTMfDICAL ISDlllPES This page intentionally left blank. | |||
ii | |||
... .. NWMI | |||
.*:.**.*~ ~:..*. | |||
-:* -.*.*~~-~~ | |||
. | ***..".*=*NOITMW£STM£mCAI. tSOTOfU NW Ml-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 CHAPTER 12.0- CONDUCT OF OPERATIONS Request for additional information RAI 12A-1 As required in Appendix E.11 to Title JO of the Code ofFederal Regulations (JO CFR) Part 50, the PSAR should address the site layout and location, consideration of access routes, surrounding population distribution, land use, and jurisdictional boundaries. Guidance in the ISG augmenting NUREG-1537, Section 12. 7. 1, "Introduction," states that the application should include a general area map covering a radius of approximately 16. 1 km (10 mi); a US. Geological Survey topographical quadrangle (7.5-minute series, including the adjacent quadrangles if the site is located less than 1.61 km (1 mi) from the edge ofthe quadrangle); and a map or aerial photograph indicting on-site and near-site structures within a radius ofapproximately 1.61 km (1 mi). PSAR Chapter 12, Appendix A, Section A6.0, "Emergency Planning Zone," Figure A-3, "Radioisotope Production facility Complex in the Columbia Area, " is not legible and does not provide sufficient details ofthe area. | ||
* | Additional information is needed to meet the requirement ofAppendix E. 11 to JO CFR Part 50, and conform to the guidance ofNUREG-0849, Section 1.0, Evaluation Item J.b. , and the ISG augmenting NUREG-153 7, Part 2, Chapter 12, Section 12.7. /, "Emergency Planning. " | ||
RAI 12A-1a Provide a legible figure ofthe facility and/or an electronic copy that could be manipulated to facilitate resolution ofbuilding names/numbers and labels, roads and parking lots, site boundaries showing fences and gates, major site features, access routes, and water bodies within approximately 1 mile of the site. | |||
A legible copy of the proposed Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC (NWMI) Radioisotope Prod uction Facility (RPF) is provided in Figure 1. This figure wi ll replace Figure A-3 in NWMI-2013-021, Construction Permit Application for Radioisotope Production Facility, Chapter 12, "Conduct of Operations," Appendix A, "Emergency Respon se Plan." In addition, Figure 2 and Figure 3 on subsequent pages provide additional detail of the RPF site (including roads, fences, gates, access routes) (Chapter 19, Figure 19-7) and water bodies within 1 ki lometer (km) (1-mile [mi]) of the RPF, respectively. | |||
1 of 12 | |||
* | |||
* | |||
. | |||
. | |||
. | |||
NWMl-2017-RAl-001 , Rev. 0 Rough estimate of Operations Boundary and Emergency Planning Zone CJ Site boundary, area directly under the NRC Facility Operating License, Controlled Area 0 0.03 0.06 0.12 0.18 0.24 | |||
- c:=-m:=-----c=====-----Miles Figure 1. Radioisotope Production Facility Complex in the Columbia Area (Replacement for Figure A-3) 2of12 | |||
... ..NWMI | |||
: | ;.-.~* | ||
*~ ~:~~:-~~ . | |||
NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 | |||
* *. * ,* | |||
* NOflTlfWHT MftHC.Al ISOTOPES DISCOVERY RIDOE LOT IS PROPERlY LINE 7.4ACRES WASTE MANAGEMENT BUil..DING WASTE MANAGEMENT CANOPY SIDE SETBACK. - IS FEET SIDE SET BACK. = IS FEET STEP VAN GUARDHOUSE N | |||
PL CURVE L=l17.7S' R=-74.30' FRONT SETBACK SITE PLAN | |||
= 35 FEET PARKING LOT 24 TOTAL 0 100' 200' BERM PARKING SPACES P.L.CURVE L=3S9.84' R=IS42.83' Figure 2. Radioisotope Production Facility Site Plan 3 of 12 | |||
, | ...... -.;-*.:**. .*.NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001 , Rev. 0 | ||
~~.~ ! ' NomtWEST MEDICAL tsOTOPU Source: Google Maps, 20 17 Figure 3. Water Bodies within 1.6 kilometers (1 mile) of the Site Request for additional information RAI 12A-1 b Provide a general area map covering a radius ofapproximately 16. 1 km (10 mi) consistent with the information discussed above. The map should also include the location ofsensitive facilities near the site, such as hospitals, schools, nursing homes, nearest residence, fire department, prisons, environmental sampling locations, and other structures and facilities that are important to emergency management. | |||
. | An area map covering a radius of 8 km (5-mi) was provided in Chapter 19, Figure 19-41 . Figure 4 is a new area map covering a radius of 16.1 km (10 mi). The map includes the location of sensitive facilities near the RPF site, such as hospitals/medical facilities, schools, nursing homes/retirement communities, nearest residence, fire stations, and other structures and facilities that are important to emergency management. | ||
4 of 12 | |||
.*.........;*...*.*.. NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001 , Rev. 0 | |||
. *. ~~.~! .' , N°"THWEST MEOICAUSOfOl'fS | |||
.l fl m | |||
* - | RPF Site + 0nni.no-* | ||
C) 16.1 km (10 mile) Rad ius from RPF Site * -Ful-Tuno Rosident l C:ducallOnal N cb Highet" EduCllion 0 | |||
+ 1.25 2.5 5 | |||
*c:::Jlm:=:J-----==========----- 7.5 10 Miles | |||
[:::J m | |||
ll'Odoeal Parl<I | |||
= Airport Figure 4. Sensitive Receptors within 16.lkm (10 mile) Radius of the Radioisotope Production Facility Site 5 of 12 | |||
.:........-.~*..NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 | |||
* ** * . * | |||
* NOITHWEST MEDICAL ISOTIJPD Request for additional information RAI 12A-2 As required in Section llB to Appendix E of I 0 CFR Part 50, the PSAR should address contacts and arrangements made and documented with local, State, and Federal governmental agencies with responsibility for coping with emergencies, including identification of the principal agencies. | |||
Concerning this requirement, the JSG augmenting Section 12. 7. 3, "Organization and Responsibilities," to NUREG-1537, Part 2, provides the guidelines for reviewing applications and references in NUREG-0849. Section 3. 0, "Organization and Responsibilities, " to NVREG-0849 states, in part, that the plan should describe the emergency organization that would be activated to cope with radiological emergencies. | |||
PSAR Chapter 12, Appendix A, Section A3. 0 describes the authorities, responsibilities, and support functions of Federal, State, county, and local government agencies in an emergency situation. It also provides the statement: "Written support agreements have been obtained from the City of Columbia, Police and Fire Departments, Boone Hospital, and University Hospital to ensure a clear understanding ofthe emergency support responsibilities of key support organizations, " but the NRC staff determined additional information is needed Information required to meet the requirement ofSection II. B to Appendix E of JO CFR Part 50. | |||
RAI 12A -2a Describe what contacts and a"angements have been made and documented with local, State, and Federal governmental agencies with responsibility for coping with emergencies. | |||
The statement, " Written support agreements have been obtained from the City of Columbia, Police and Fire Departments, Boone Hospital, and University Hospital to ensure a clear understanding of the emergency support responsibilities of key support organizations," in Chapter 12, Appendix A, Section A3 .l was in error. Appendix A was intended to illustrate a draft emergency plan so it was written, perhaps misleadingly, as if the support agreements have been put in place. No formal support agreements have been established; however, these support agreements will be in place for the NWMI Operating License Application. The sentence in Section A3 .1 has been revised as follows, "Written support agreements obtained from the City of Columbia, Police and Fire Departments, Boone Hospital, and University Hospital ensure a clear understanding of the emergency support responsibilities of key support organizations." | |||
RAI 12A-2b ClarifY the organizational responsibility for the support fanction ofthe Missouri Office of Emergency Coordination, as stated in Section A3. J.2, "State Agencies," to the NWMI ERP, in relation to the a formal radiological emergency preparedness program. | |||
The listing of the Missouri Office of Emergency Coordination as the primary contact for radiological emergencies is in error. The Missouri Office of Emergency Coordination will be replaced with the Missouri State Emergency Management Agency in Section A3 .1.2 of Appendix A. | |||
RAI 12A-2c ClarifY whether the Missouri State Emergency Management Agency, under the Missouri Department of Public Safety, has responsibility for the State 's formal radiological emergency preparedness program. If applicable, the NWMI ERP should be revised to include the organizational responsibility of the Missouri State Emergency Management Agency, or explain why this is not necessary. | |||
The Missouri State Emergency Management Agency has responsibility for the State' s formal radiological emergency preparedness program. Sections A3 .1.2 and A3 .3 .3 of Appendix A will be updated to include the organization responsibility of this agency. | |||
6of12 | |||
....*.:**...*NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 | |||
.......:~.-.~* | |||
* *. * , * | |||
* NORTNWEST MEDICAL tSOT'OfU Request for additional information RAI 12A-3 As required in Section 11. C to Appendix E of I 0 CFR Part 50, the PSAR shall address the protective measures to be taken within the site boundary and within each emergency planning zone (EPZ) to protect health and safety in the event ofan accident and the procedures by which these measures are to be carried out. PSAR Chapter I 2, Appendix A, Section A 6. 0 describes the EPZ and provides Figure A-3 to indicate the operations boundary. Protective measures, procedures, and notifications are provided in Section A7.0. | |||
Section 10.0, "Maintaining Emergency Planning, " to NUREG-0849 states , in part , that the emergency plan should describe the elements necessary for maintaining an acceptable state of emergency preparedness. | Jn support of around-the-clock emergency response, identify the 24-hour on-shift staffpositions designated and trained to perform the initial responsibilities of the Emergency Director, Emergency Coordinator, Radiation Safety Officer, and Radiological Assessment Team until these positions are filled by responding emergency personnel. | ||
PSAR Chapter 12, Appendix B, Section A 10. 0 describes the elements necessary to maintain an effective emergency preparedness plan which include training, review and updating of the emergency plan and associated implementing procedures, and maintenance and inventory of equipment and supplies that would be used in emergencies. | The staff positions were intended to be by title, not by individual. It was envisioned that individuals who fill these staff positions would be identified in implementation procedures. Implementation procedures will be developed and submitted as part of the NWMI Operating License Application. | ||
Section A 10. 0, "Maintaining Emergency Preparedness, " to NUREG-0849 states, in part, that the emergency plan shouldprovide the elements necessary for maintaining an acceptable state of emergency preparedness. | RAI 12A-4 JSG augmenting NUREG-1537, Part 2, Section I 2. 7.3 "Organization and Responsibilities, " | ||
While all the elements ofNUREG-0849 are listed in Section AJO.O of the NWMI ERP, with the exception | specifically calls for prompt notification of off-site response authorities, normally within I 5 minutes ofthe declaration of an emergency classification, and notification ofthe NRC Operations Center as soon as possible but no later than I hour after a declared emergency. | ||
* Administration | Confirm if these specified notification times are included in the NWMJ emergency response plan. If not in the NWMJ ERP, revise the NWMJ ERP to include these notification times. | ||
The following sentence will be added to the first paragraphs of Sections A4.2, A4.3, A4.4, and A4.5, "The Emergency Director, Radiation Safety Officer, Public Information Officer, and Historian should be notified within 15 minutes of the emergency being declared. Notification shall be made to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) Operations Center as soon as is reasonably possible, but no later than one hour after the declared emergency." | |||
RAI 12A-5 PSAR Chapter I 2, Appendix A, Section A3. 3. 2, list the responsibilities of the Emergency Director and Emergency Coordinator. It appears that these positions share similar responsibilities. | |||
NUREG-0849, Section 3.0, "Organization and Responsibilities," Evaluation Item 1.0j, in NUREG-0849, states that the emergency plan should identify the individual who may authorize reentry into the NWMJfaci/ity (or portion thereof) that required evacuation during the emergency. | |||
This responsibility appears to be assigned to both the Emergency Director and the Emergency Coordinator positions. | |||
Information is required to meet the requirement ofSections fl.A and Jf.C to Appendix E of JO CFR Part 50, and conform to the guidance ofNUREG-0849, Section 3.0. | |||
Clarify if the Emergency Director and Emergency Coordinator share this responsibility, and if so, does the authorization for reentry into the RPF that required evacuation require a joint decision. | |||
The eighth bullet under the responsibilities of the Emergency Director will be deleted in Section A3.3.2. | |||
Authorization for reentry after an evacuation will rest with the Emergency Coordinator only. | |||
7 of 12 | |||
.:.;.-.;:.NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001 , Rev. 0 | |||
. *. ~ ~.~! .' . lllORTNWtST MflNCAl ISOTOPES Request for additional information RAI 2.5-2 As required in Section 11.F to Appendix E of 10 CFR Part 50, the PSAR should address the need for | |||
[RAI 12A-6) a training program for employees ofthe licensee. Concerning this requirement, ISG augmenting Section 12.7.10, "Maintaining Emergency Planning," toNUREG-1537, Part 2,provides the guidelines for reviewing applications and references NUKEG-0849. Section 10.0, "Maintaining Emergency Planning, " to NUREG-0849 states, in part, that the emergency plan should describe the elements necessary for maintaining an acceptable state of emergency preparedness. | |||
PSAR Chapter 12, Appendix B, Section A 10.0 describes the elements necessary to maintain an effective emergency preparedness plan which include training, review and updating of the emergency plan and associated implementing procedures, and maintenance and inventory of equipment and supplies that would be used in emergencies. | |||
Section A 10. 0, "Maintaining Emergency Preparedness, " to NUREG-0849 states, in part, that the emergency plan shouldprovide the elements necessary for maintaining an acceptable state of emergency preparedness. While all the elements ofNUREG-0849 are listed in Section AJO.O of the NWMI ERP, with the exception offirst aid and rescue personnel, Section 12. 7. 10, "Maintaining Emergency Preparedness, " ofthe ISG augmenting NUREG-153 7 Part 2, calls for the applicant to provide the following supplemental details and information: | |||
* Administration ofthe training program, including responsibility for training, pertaining to all required staff members; | |||
* Schedule for training; | * Schedule for training; | ||
* Frequency | * Frequency ofretraining; | ||
* Estimated number | * Estimated number ofhours of initial training and retraining; and | ||
* Training to be provided on the use | * Training to be provided on the use ofprotective equipment, such as respirator, protective clothing, monitoring devices, and other equipment used in emergency response. | ||
RAI 12A-6a Provide the details | RAI 12A-6a Provide the details ofthe training program to include the above criteria. | ||
In Section A3.3.2 , the ninth bullet under the Emergency Coordinator will be amended to read, " Ensure the implementation of an emergency preparedness program for facility equipment and personnel , including the scheduling and performance of equipment maintenance , personnel training , and drills associated with the emergency plan." The first item in Section AlO.l will be amended to read , " Initial and annual retraining will be conducted for emergency response personnel to maintain the ability to perform their assigned functions during an emergency event." The third item in Section Al 0.1 will be amended to read , " Training will also include , as appropriate , information on the use of protective equipment , protective clothing, and monitoring devices used in emergency response relevant to the personnel listed above. Initial training on the emergency plan should nominally take two hours and annual retraining should take one hour to perform." RAI 12A-6b Describe the training to be provided for first aid and rescue personnel. | In Section A3.3.2, the ninth bullet under the Emergency Coordinator will be amended to read, "Ensure the implementation of an emergency preparedness program for facility equipment and personnel, including the scheduling and performance of equipment maintenance, personnel training, and drills associated with the emergency plan." | ||
Training for first aid responders is described in Section A8.3. I. Additionally , because they are members of the RPF emergency organization , first aid personnel would participate in annual training , as described in Section Al 0.1. Rescue personnel are not specifically identified in the emergency plan but are assumed to include individuals whose training is described in Section Al 0.1. 8of12 | The first item in Section AlO.l will be amended to read, "Initial and annual retraining will be conducted for emergency response personnel to maintain the ability to perform their assigned functions during an emergency event." | ||
. | The third item in Section Al 0.1 will be amended to read, "Training will also include, as appropriate, information on the use of protective equipment, protective clothing, and monitoring devices used in emergency response relevant to the personnel listed above. Initial training on the emergency plan should nominally take two hours and annual retraining should take one hour to perform ." | ||
RAI 12A-6b Describe the training to be provided for first aid and rescue personnel. | |||
Training for first aid responders is described in Section A8.3. I. Additionally, because they are members of the RPF emergency organization, first aid personnel would participate in annual training, as described in Section Al 0.1. Rescue personnel are not specifically identified in the emergency plan but are assumed to include individuals whose training is described in Section Al 0.1. | |||
8of12 | |||
...:;. -.;. ..NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 | |||
* '. ~ ~.~ ~ .' . NORTlfWln MEDICAL tsO'T'Of'£S Request for additional information RAI 12A-7 ISG augmenting NUREG-1537, Part 2, Section 12. 7, states that an adequate emergency plan should demonstrate the following: | |||
* Qualified individuals for each position in the emergency response organization demonstrate task-related knowledge through periodic participation. | * Qualified individuals for each position in the emergency response organization demonstrate task-related knowledge through periodic participation. | ||
* Emergency drills demonstrate that resources are effectively used to control the site, mitigate further damage , control radiological releases, perform required on-site activities under simulated radiation or airborne and other emergency conditions , accurately assess the facility's status during an accident, and initiate recovery. | * Emergency drills demonstrate that resources are effectively used to control the site, mitigate further damage, control radiological releases, perform required on-site activities under simulated radiation or airborne and other emergency conditions, accurately assess the facility's status during an accident, and initiate recovery. | ||
* Emergency drills demonstrate personnel protection measures, including controlling and minimizing hazards to individuals during fires, medical emergencies, mitigation activities , search and rescue , and other similar events. | * Emergency drills demonstrate personnel protection measures, including controlling and minimizing hazards to individuals during fires, medical emergencies, mitigation activities, search and rescue, and other similar events. | ||
* Emergency drills demonstrate that on-site communications effectively support emergency response activities. | * Emergency drills demonstrate that on-site communications effectively support emergency response activities. | ||
* Emergency drills demonstrate that the emergency public information organization disseminates accurate, reliable, timely, and understandable information. | * Emergency drills demonstrate that the emergency public information organization disseminates accurate, reliable, timely, and understandable information. | ||
* Provisions are made for conducting quarterly communications checks with off-site response organizations. | * Provisions are made for conducting quarterly communications checks with off-site response organizations. | ||
* Offsite organizations are invited to participate in the biennial on-site exercise , which tests the major elements of the emergency plan and response organizations. This information is required to meet the requirement | * Offsite organizations are invited to participate in the biennial on-site exercise, which tests the major elements of the emergency plan and response organizations. | ||
Drills should be conducted such that: Qualified individuals for each position in the emergency response organization demonstrate related knowledge through periodic participation. Emergency drills demonstrate that resources are effective and used to control the site , mitigate further damage , control radiological releases , perform required on- | This information is required to meet the requirement ofSection Il.F to Appendix E of 10 CFR Part 50, and conforms to the guidance ofthe ISG augmenting NUREG-153 7 Part 2, Section 12. 7. 10. | ||
While the Interim Staff Guidance (ISG) augmenting NUREG-1537 , Part 2 , Section 12.7 describes the need for checking quarterly communications with off-site agencies, it is unclear at this point in the licensing process whether dedicated communications lines (beyond common cell , network, and landlines) to off-site response organizations is necessary. The participation with off-site emergency response organizations is described in item three of Section Al0.2. 9 of 12 | Clarify how the conductance ofdrills, as described in PSAR Chapter 12, Appendix A, Section Al0.2, "Emergency Drills, " demonstrates the above guidance. | ||
.:;.-.;-.. NWMI | Item one of Section A 10.2 will be amended to read, "Annual on-site emergency drills will be conducted as action drills, with each required emergency measure being executed as realistically as is reasonably possible. Drills should be conducted such that: | ||
Concerning this requirement, the 1SG augmenting NUREG 1537, Part 2, Section 12. 7.5, "Emergency Action Levels, "provides the guidelines for reviewing applications and references NUREG-0849, Section 5.0, "Emergency Action Levels." PSAR, Chapter 12, Section A5.0 does not contain action levels with initiating conditions such as effluent monitor set points appropriate to the facility and consistent with NUREG-0849 Appendix I. SpecifY the effluent monitors used to project dose rates and radiological effluent releases, and include the set points in the emergency action levels (EALs) to initiate protective actions as per guidance ofNURG-0849, or explain why this information is not necessary. | Qualified individuals for each position in the emergency response organization demonstrate task-related knowledge through periodic participation. | ||
Effluent monitors used to project dose rates and radiological effluent releases and any associated setpoints for such systems will be identified in the NWMI Operating License Application. | Emergency drills demonstrate that resources are effective and used to control the site, mitigate further damage, control radiological releases, perform required on-site activities under simulated radiation or airborne and other emergency conditions, accurately assess the facility ' s status during an accident, and initiate recovery. | ||
The manufacturer, detection methodology, and (therefore) instrument setpoints will also be identified in the Operating License Application. | Emergency drills demonstrate personnel protection measures, including controlling and minimizing hazards to individuals during fires, medical emergencies, mitigation activities, search and rescue, and other similar events. | ||
RAI 12A-9 PSAR, Chapter 12, Section A5.0, "Emergency Action Levels" contains Table A-1, " Emergency Classes and Action Levels. "NWM1 did not provide a basis for the General Emergency classification listed in Table A-1. Additionally, the Site Area Emergency and General Emergency classifications have the same EALs listed in Table A-1. This information is inconsistent with information in Section A 4. 5 | Emergency drills demonstrate that on-site communications effectively support emergency response activities. | ||
.16-2015. RAI 12A-9a ClarifY the basis for the inclusion | Emergency drills demonstrate that the emergency public information organization disseminates accurate, reliable, timely, and understandable information." | ||
Section Al0.4.2 describes functional testing of emergency communications and emergency health physics equipment. While the Interim Staff Guidance (ISG) augmenting NUREG-1537, Part 2, Section 12.7 describes the need for checking quarterly communications with off-site agencies, it is unclear at this point in the licensing process whether dedicated communications lines (beyond common cell, network, and landlines) to off-site response organizations is necessary. | |||
The participation with off-site emergency response organizations is described in item three of Section Al0.2. | |||
9 of 12 | |||
..:;.-.;-. .NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 | |||
. '. ~~.~~ ." . NOflTHWUTMfDCWISOTOPES Request for additional information RAI 12A-8 As required in Section ll.H to Appendix E of 10 CFR Part 50, the PSAR should provide a preliminary analysis reflecting the need to include facilities, systems, and methods for identifYing the degree ofseriousness and potential scope ofradiological consequences ofemergency situations. | |||
Concerning this requirement, the 1SG augmenting NUREG 1537, Part 2, Section 12. 7.5, "Emergency Action Levels, "provides the guidelines for reviewing applications and references NUREG-0849, Section 5.0, "Emergency Action Levels." | |||
PSAR, Chapter 12, Section A5.0 does not contain action levels with initiating conditions such as effluent monitor set points appropriate to the facility and consistent with NUREG-0849 Appendix I. | |||
SpecifY the effluent monitors used to project dose rates and radiological effluent releases, and include the set points in the emergency action levels (EALs) to initiate protective actions as per guidance ofNURG-0849, or explain why this information is not necessary. | |||
Effluent monitors used to project dose rates and radiological effluent releases and any associated setpoints for such systems will be identified in the NWMI Operating License Application. The manufacturer, detection methodology, and (therefore) instrument setpoints will also be identified in the Operating License Application. | |||
RAI 12A-9 PSAR, Chapter 12, Section A5.0, "Emergency Action Levels" contains Table A-1, "Emergency Classes and Action Levels. "NWM1 did not provide a basis for the General Emergency classification listed in Table A-1. Additionally, the Site Area Emergency and General Emergency classifications have the same EALs listed in Table A-1. This information is inconsistent with information in Section A 4. 5 ofthe NWMJ ERP. | |||
This information is required to meet the requirement ofAppendix E to JO CFR Part 50, and conform to the guidance ofNUREG-0849, Section 5.0; 1SG Augmenting 1537, Part 2, Section 12. 7.5; and ANSI-ANS-15.16-2015. | |||
RAI 12A-9a ClarifY the basis for the inclusion ofa General Emergency classification in PSAR Chapter 12, Appendix A, Section A5.0. | |||
For the Construction Permit Application, all classes of emergencies included in ANSI/ANS 15.16 (2015), | |||
Emergency Planning for Research Reactors, were included in the NWMI draft emergency plan. If, at the Operating License Application stage, NWMI finds that the emergency action levels (EAL) for a given emergency class cannot be reached, the final emergency plan will be amended and those emergency classes will be removed. | |||
RAI 12A-9b Explain why the Site Area Emergency and General Emergency EALs are identical in Table A-1 of the NWMI ERP. | |||
Table A-1 will be amended such that the EALs for each emergency class are consistent with that found in ANSI/ANS 15.16. | |||
RAI 12A-9c Explain why there are no security-related action level as discussed in ANSI!ANS-15.16-2015, "Emergency Planning for Research Reactors, " associated with an Alert. | |||
Table A-1 will be amended such that the EALs for each emergency class are consistent with that found in ANSI/ANS 15.16. Security-related action levels are described in this standard. | |||
10 of 12 | |||
........ . NWMI | |||
.:;*.-~~* NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 | |||
~.* | |||
. '-~~.~~.'. NllRTHWESTMEOICALISCTDPES REFERENCES 10 CFR 50, "Domestic Licensing of Production and Utilization Facilities," Code of Federal Regulations, Office of the Federal Register, as amended. | |||
\ | |||
ANSI/ANS-15.16, Emergency Planning/or Research Reactors, American Nuclear Society, La Grange Park, Illinois, 2015. | |||
NRC, 2012, Final Interim Staff Guidance Augmenting NUREG-1537, "Guidelines for Preparing and Reviewing Applications for the Licensing ofNon-Power Reactors," Parts 1 and 2, for Licensing Radioisotope Production Facilities and Aqueous Homogeneous Reactors, Docket Number: | |||
NRC-2011-0135, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C., October 17, 2012. | |||
NUREG-0849, Standard Review Plan for the Review and Evaluation ofEmergency Plans for Research and Test Reactors, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Inspection end Enforcement, Washington, D.C., October 1983. | |||
NUREG-153 7, Guidelines for Preparing and Reviewing Applications for the Licensing ofNon-Power Reactors - Format and Content, Part 1, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Washington, D.C., February 1996. | |||
NUREG-1537, Guidelines for Preparing and Reviewing Applications for the Licensing ofNon-Power Reactors: Standard Review Plan and Acceptance Criteria, Part 2, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Washington, D.C., February 1996. | |||
NWMI-2013-021, Construction Permit Application for Radioisotope Production Facility, Rev. 0, Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC, Corvallis, Oregon, June 29, 2015. | |||
11 of 12 | |||
NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 This page intentionally left blank. | |||
12of12}} | |||
Latest revision as of 14:56, 24 February 2020
ML17093A661 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | Northwest Medical Isotopes |
Issue date: | 03/06/2017 |
From: | Haass C Northwest Medical Isotopes |
To: | Michael Balazik Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
References | |
NWMI-LTR-2017-001, TAC MF6138 | |
Download: ML17093A661 (22) | |
Text
.*:.**.*.*. NWMI
.:~.-.~* .
.....*..*:-=*
- ~~-~~:. NORTHWEST MEDICAL ISOTOPES March 6, 2017 NWMI-LTR-2017-001 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ATTN: Document Control Desk 11555 Rockville Pike Washington, DC 20555 Mr. Michael Balazik Research and Test Reactors Branch A Division of Policy and Rulemaking Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation RE: Docket No. 50-609, Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC Responses to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Environmental Request for Additional information -
Letter Dated January 25, 2017
References:
- 1. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission letter to Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC, dated January 25, 2017, Docket No. 50-609 (ADAMS Accession No. ML16056A122), "Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC - Request for Additional Information for Construction Permit Application Regarding Emergency Response Plan Regarding Application For Construction Permit (TAC No. MF6138)"
- 2. Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC Letter NWMI-LTR-2015-006 to U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, dated July 20, 2015 (ADAMS Accession No. ML16056A122), NRC Project No. 0803 - Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC, Submittal Part 2 Construction Permit Application for a Radioisotope Production Facility"
Dear Mr. Balazik:
Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC (NWMI) is providing the attached response (Attachment 1) to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission request for additional information dated January 25, 2017.
NWMI is submitting this response to the NRC in accordance with 10 CFR 50.30(b), "Oath or Affirmation," and 10 CFR 50.4, "Written Communications."
I solemnly declare and affirm that the foregoing information is true and correct under the penalty of perjury; executed on March 6, 2017.
Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC I 815 NW 9th Ave, Suite 256 I Corvallis, OR 97330
Mr. Michael Balazik page2 If you have questions, I can be reached at (509) 430-6921 or carolyn.haass@nwmedicalisotopes.com.
Sincerely, c~c.~
Carolyn C. Haass Chief Operating Officer
Enclosures:
Attachment 1 cc: Mr. Alexander Adams Research and Test Reactors Branch A Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
.;....;*. NWMI
.*:.**.*~**
.....****l:*
- *. ~~.~~ ."
- NORTHWEST MEDICAL ISOTOPES ATTACHMENT 1 Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Request for Additional Information for Construction Permit Application Regarding the Emergency Response Plan (TAC No. MF6138)
Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC Construction Permit Application Docket No. 50-609 (Document No. NWMl-2017-RAl-001, March 2017)
Information is being provided via hard copy
.:....~**.:*. NWMI
. *. ~~**.~;. NORTHWESTMEDICALISOTOPES This page intentionally left blank.
- /e**.e .
- 0 *
- 8 0..*** ****.****
- c.
- ~**
0
- *f.)* ~ .
0
- NORTHWEST MEDICAL ISOTOPES Response to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Request for Additional Information for Construction Permit Application Regarding the Emergency Response Plan (TAC No. MF6138)
NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 March 2017 Prepared by:
Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC 815 NW gth Ave, Suite 256 Corvallis, OR 97330
This page intentionally left blank.
.:;*... NWMI
~~:.
- .*.*~~.~~*~.*
NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0
- *. .". f.IGRTHWESTMEDl£Al ISOTOPES Response to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Request for Additional Information for Construction Permit Application Regarding the Emergency Response Plan (TAC No. MF6138)
NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 Date Published:
March 6, 2017 Document Number: NWMl-2017-RAl-007 I Revision Number: 0
Title:
Response to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Request for Additional Information for Construction Permit Application Regarding the Emergency Response Plan (TAC No. Mf6138)
Approved by: Carolyn Haass Signature:
CUJ>J~e..~
.:..-.~*:.*. NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0
- .~~--~~;* fJOITTHWE.STMmlCALISOTIJPfS REVISION IDSTORY Rev Date Reason for Revision Revised By 0 3/6/2017 Issued for submittal to the NRC NIA
.:;~*~~*-.
......... *.* NWM I NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0
- *.~~.~~.'. NORnlVlESTMEDJCALISOTOPES TERMS Acronyms and Abbreviations ANS American Nuclear Society ANSI American National Standards Institute CFR Code of Federal Regulations EAL emergency action level EPZ emergency planning zone ERP Emergency Response Plan ISG Interim Staff Guidance NRC U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission NWMI Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC PSAR preliminary safety analysis report RPF Radioisotope Production Facility U.S. United States Units km kilometer m1 mile
.:;.*.~:.:. NWMI
.......... NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0
. *. ~~.~! ,"
- NURTHWESTMfDICAL ISDlllPES This page intentionally left blank.
ii
... .. NWMI
.*:.**.*~ ~:..*.
-:* -.*.*~~-~~
- ..".*=*NOITMW£STM£mCAI. tSOTOfU NW Ml-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 CHAPTER 12.0- CONDUCT OF OPERATIONS Request for additional information RAI 12A-1 As required in Appendix E.11 to Title JO of the Code ofFederal Regulations (JO CFR) Part 50, the PSAR should address the site layout and location, consideration of access routes, surrounding population distribution, land use, and jurisdictional boundaries. Guidance in the ISG augmenting NUREG-1537, Section 12. 7. 1, "Introduction," states that the application should include a general area map covering a radius of approximately 16. 1 km (10 mi); a US. Geological Survey topographical quadrangle (7.5-minute series, including the adjacent quadrangles if the site is located less than 1.61 km (1 mi) from the edge ofthe quadrangle); and a map or aerial photograph indicting on-site and near-site structures within a radius ofapproximately 1.61 km (1 mi). PSAR Chapter 12, Appendix A, Section A6.0, "Emergency Planning Zone," Figure A-3, "Radioisotope Production facility Complex in the Columbia Area, " is not legible and does not provide sufficient details ofthe area.
Additional information is needed to meet the requirement ofAppendix E. 11 to JO CFR Part 50, and conform to the guidance ofNUREG-0849, Section 1.0, Evaluation Item J.b. , and the ISG augmenting NUREG-153 7, Part 2, Chapter 12, Section 12.7. /, "Emergency Planning. "
RAI 12A-1a Provide a legible figure ofthe facility and/or an electronic copy that could be manipulated to facilitate resolution ofbuilding names/numbers and labels, roads and parking lots, site boundaries showing fences and gates, major site features, access routes, and water bodies within approximately 1 mile of the site.
A legible copy of the proposed Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC (NWMI) Radioisotope Prod uction Facility (RPF) is provided in Figure 1. This figure wi ll replace Figure A-3 in NWMI-2013-021, Construction Permit Application for Radioisotope Production Facility, Chapter 12, "Conduct of Operations," Appendix A, "Emergency Respon se Plan." In addition, Figure 2 and Figure 3 on subsequent pages provide additional detail of the RPF site (including roads, fences, gates, access routes) (Chapter 19, Figure 19-7) and water bodies within 1 ki lometer (km) (1-mile [mi]) of the RPF, respectively.
1 of 12
NWMl-2017-RAl-001 , Rev. 0 Rough estimate of Operations Boundary and Emergency Planning Zone CJ Site boundary, area directly under the NRC Facility Operating License, Controlled Area 0 0.03 0.06 0.12 0.18 0.24
- c:=-m:=-----c=====-----Miles Figure 1. Radioisotope Production Facility Complex in the Columbia Area (Replacement for Figure A-3) 2of12
... ..NWMI
- .-.~*
- ~ ~:~~:-~~ .
NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0
- *. * ,*
- NOflTlfWHT MftHC.Al ISOTOPES DISCOVERY RIDOE LOT IS PROPERlY LINE 7.4ACRES WASTE MANAGEMENT BUil..DING WASTE MANAGEMENT CANOPY SIDE SETBACK. - IS FEET SIDE SET BACK. = IS FEET STEP VAN GUARDHOUSE N
PL CURVE L=l17.7S' R=-74.30' FRONT SETBACK SITE PLAN
= 35 FEET PARKING LOT 24 TOTAL 0 100' 200' BERM PARKING SPACES P.L.CURVE L=3S9.84' R=IS42.83' Figure 2. Radioisotope Production Facility Site Plan 3 of 12
...... -.;-*.:**. .*.NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001 , Rev. 0
~~.~ ! ' NomtWEST MEDICAL tsOTOPU Source: Google Maps, 20 17 Figure 3. Water Bodies within 1.6 kilometers (1 mile) of the Site Request for additional information RAI 12A-1 b Provide a general area map covering a radius ofapproximately 16. 1 km (10 mi) consistent with the information discussed above. The map should also include the location ofsensitive facilities near the site, such as hospitals, schools, nursing homes, nearest residence, fire department, prisons, environmental sampling locations, and other structures and facilities that are important to emergency management.
An area map covering a radius of 8 km (5-mi) was provided in Chapter 19, Figure 19-41 . Figure 4 is a new area map covering a radius of 16.1 km (10 mi). The map includes the location of sensitive facilities near the RPF site, such as hospitals/medical facilities, schools, nursing homes/retirement communities, nearest residence, fire stations, and other structures and facilities that are important to emergency management.
4 of 12
.*.........;*...*.*.. NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001 , Rev. 0
. *. ~~.~! .' , N°"THWEST MEOICAUSOfOl'fS
.l fl m
RPF Site + 0nni.no-*
C) 16.1 km (10 mile) Rad ius from RPF Site * -Ful-Tuno Rosident l C:ducallOnal N cb Highet" EduCllion 0
+ 1.25 2.5 5
- c:::Jlm:=:J-----==========----- 7.5 10 Miles
[:::J m
ll'Odoeal Parl<I
= Airport Figure 4. Sensitive Receptors within 16.lkm (10 mile) Radius of the Radioisotope Production Facility Site 5 of 12
.:........-.~*..NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0
- ** * . *
- NOITHWEST MEDICAL ISOTIJPD Request for additional information RAI 12A-2 As required in Section llB to Appendix E of I 0 CFR Part 50, the PSAR should address contacts and arrangements made and documented with local, State, and Federal governmental agencies with responsibility for coping with emergencies, including identification of the principal agencies.
Concerning this requirement, the JSG augmenting Section 12. 7. 3, "Organization and Responsibilities," to NUREG-1537, Part 2, provides the guidelines for reviewing applications and references in NUREG-0849. Section 3. 0, "Organization and Responsibilities, " to NVREG-0849 states, in part, that the plan should describe the emergency organization that would be activated to cope with radiological emergencies.
PSAR Chapter 12, Appendix A, Section A3. 0 describes the authorities, responsibilities, and support functions of Federal, State, county, and local government agencies in an emergency situation. It also provides the statement: "Written support agreements have been obtained from the City of Columbia, Police and Fire Departments, Boone Hospital, and University Hospital to ensure a clear understanding ofthe emergency support responsibilities of key support organizations, " but the NRC staff determined additional information is needed Information required to meet the requirement ofSection II. B to Appendix E of JO CFR Part 50.
RAI 12A -2a Describe what contacts and a"angements have been made and documented with local, State, and Federal governmental agencies with responsibility for coping with emergencies.
The statement, " Written support agreements have been obtained from the City of Columbia, Police and Fire Departments, Boone Hospital, and University Hospital to ensure a clear understanding of the emergency support responsibilities of key support organizations," in Chapter 12, Appendix A, Section A3 .l was in error. Appendix A was intended to illustrate a draft emergency plan so it was written, perhaps misleadingly, as if the support agreements have been put in place. No formal support agreements have been established; however, these support agreements will be in place for the NWMI Operating License Application. The sentence in Section A3 .1 has been revised as follows, "Written support agreements obtained from the City of Columbia, Police and Fire Departments, Boone Hospital, and University Hospital ensure a clear understanding of the emergency support responsibilities of key support organizations."
RAI 12A-2b ClarifY the organizational responsibility for the support fanction ofthe Missouri Office of Emergency Coordination, as stated in Section A3. J.2, "State Agencies," to the NWMI ERP, in relation to the a formal radiological emergency preparedness program.
The listing of the Missouri Office of Emergency Coordination as the primary contact for radiological emergencies is in error. The Missouri Office of Emergency Coordination will be replaced with the Missouri State Emergency Management Agency in Section A3 .1.2 of Appendix A.
RAI 12A-2c ClarifY whether the Missouri State Emergency Management Agency, under the Missouri Department of Public Safety, has responsibility for the State 's formal radiological emergency preparedness program. If applicable, the NWMI ERP should be revised to include the organizational responsibility of the Missouri State Emergency Management Agency, or explain why this is not necessary.
The Missouri State Emergency Management Agency has responsibility for the State' s formal radiological emergency preparedness program. Sections A3 .1.2 and A3 .3 .3 of Appendix A will be updated to include the organization responsibility of this agency.
6of12
....*.:**...*NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0
.......:~.-.~*
- *. * , *
- NORTNWEST MEDICAL tSOT'OfU Request for additional information RAI 12A-3 As required in Section 11. C to Appendix E of I 0 CFR Part 50, the PSAR shall address the protective measures to be taken within the site boundary and within each emergency planning zone (EPZ) to protect health and safety in the event ofan accident and the procedures by which these measures are to be carried out. PSAR Chapter I 2, Appendix A, Section A 6. 0 describes the EPZ and provides Figure A-3 to indicate the operations boundary. Protective measures, procedures, and notifications are provided in Section A7.0.
Jn support of around-the-clock emergency response, identify the 24-hour on-shift staffpositions designated and trained to perform the initial responsibilities of the Emergency Director, Emergency Coordinator, Radiation Safety Officer, and Radiological Assessment Team until these positions are filled by responding emergency personnel.
The staff positions were intended to be by title, not by individual. It was envisioned that individuals who fill these staff positions would be identified in implementation procedures. Implementation procedures will be developed and submitted as part of the NWMI Operating License Application.
RAI 12A-4 JSG augmenting NUREG-1537, Part 2,Section I 2. 7.3 "Organization and Responsibilities, "
specifically calls for prompt notification of off-site response authorities, normally within I 5 minutes ofthe declaration of an emergency classification, and notification ofthe NRC Operations Center as soon as possible but no later than I hour after a declared emergency.
Confirm if these specified notification times are included in the NWMJ emergency response plan. If not in the NWMJ ERP, revise the NWMJ ERP to include these notification times.
The following sentence will be added to the first paragraphs of Sections A4.2, A4.3, A4.4, and A4.5, "The Emergency Director, Radiation Safety Officer, Public Information Officer, and Historian should be notified within 15 minutes of the emergency being declared. Notification shall be made to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) Operations Center as soon as is reasonably possible, but no later than one hour after the declared emergency."
RAI 12A-5 PSAR Chapter I 2, Appendix A, Section A3. 3. 2, list the responsibilities of the Emergency Director and Emergency Coordinator. It appears that these positions share similar responsibilities.
NUREG-0849, Section 3.0, "Organization and Responsibilities," Evaluation Item 1.0j, in NUREG-0849, states that the emergency plan should identify the individual who may authorize reentry into the NWMJfaci/ity (or portion thereof) that required evacuation during the emergency.
This responsibility appears to be assigned to both the Emergency Director and the Emergency Coordinator positions.
Information is required to meet the requirement ofSections fl.A and Jf.C to Appendix E of JO CFR Part 50, and conform to the guidance ofNUREG-0849, Section 3.0.
Clarify if the Emergency Director and Emergency Coordinator share this responsibility, and if so, does the authorization for reentry into the RPF that required evacuation require a joint decision.
The eighth bullet under the responsibilities of the Emergency Director will be deleted in Section A3.3.2.
Authorization for reentry after an evacuation will rest with the Emergency Coordinator only.
7 of 12
.:.;.-.;:.NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001 , Rev. 0
. *. ~ ~.~! .' . lllORTNWtST MflNCAl ISOTOPES Request for additional information RAI 2.5-2 As required in Section 11.F to Appendix E of 10 CFR Part 50, the PSAR should address the need for
[RAI 12A-6) a training program for employees ofthe licensee. Concerning this requirement, ISG augmenting Section 12.7.10, "Maintaining Emergency Planning," toNUREG-1537, Part 2,provides the guidelines for reviewing applications and references NUKEG-0849. Section 10.0, "Maintaining Emergency Planning, " to NUREG-0849 states, in part, that the emergency plan should describe the elements necessary for maintaining an acceptable state of emergency preparedness.
PSAR Chapter 12, Appendix B, Section A 10.0 describes the elements necessary to maintain an effective emergency preparedness plan which include training, review and updating of the emergency plan and associated implementing procedures, and maintenance and inventory of equipment and supplies that would be used in emergencies.
Section A 10. 0, "Maintaining Emergency Preparedness, " to NUREG-0849 states, in part, that the emergency plan shouldprovide the elements necessary for maintaining an acceptable state of emergency preparedness. While all the elements ofNUREG-0849 are listed in Section AJO.O of the NWMI ERP, with the exception offirst aid and rescue personnel, Section 12. 7. 10, "Maintaining Emergency Preparedness, " ofthe ISG augmenting NUREG-153 7 Part 2, calls for the applicant to provide the following supplemental details and information:
- Administration ofthe training program, including responsibility for training, pertaining to all required staff members;
- Schedule for training;
- Frequency ofretraining;
- Estimated number ofhours of initial training and retraining; and
- Training to be provided on the use ofprotective equipment, such as respirator, protective clothing, monitoring devices, and other equipment used in emergency response.
RAI 12A-6a Provide the details ofthe training program to include the above criteria.
In Section A3.3.2, the ninth bullet under the Emergency Coordinator will be amended to read, "Ensure the implementation of an emergency preparedness program for facility equipment and personnel, including the scheduling and performance of equipment maintenance, personnel training, and drills associated with the emergency plan."
The first item in Section AlO.l will be amended to read, "Initial and annual retraining will be conducted for emergency response personnel to maintain the ability to perform their assigned functions during an emergency event."
The third item in Section Al 0.1 will be amended to read, "Training will also include, as appropriate, information on the use of protective equipment, protective clothing, and monitoring devices used in emergency response relevant to the personnel listed above. Initial training on the emergency plan should nominally take two hours and annual retraining should take one hour to perform ."
RAI 12A-6b Describe the training to be provided for first aid and rescue personnel.
Training for first aid responders is described in Section A8.3. I. Additionally, because they are members of the RPF emergency organization, first aid personnel would participate in annual training, as described in Section Al 0.1. Rescue personnel are not specifically identified in the emergency plan but are assumed to include individuals whose training is described in Section Al 0.1.
8of12
...:;. -.;. ..NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0
- '. ~ ~.~ ~ .' . NORTlfWln MEDICAL tsO'T'Of'£S Request for additional information RAI 12A-7 ISG augmenting NUREG-1537, Part 2, Section 12. 7, states that an adequate emergency plan should demonstrate the following:
- Qualified individuals for each position in the emergency response organization demonstrate task-related knowledge through periodic participation.
- Emergency drills demonstrate that resources are effectively used to control the site, mitigate further damage, control radiological releases, perform required on-site activities under simulated radiation or airborne and other emergency conditions, accurately assess the facility's status during an accident, and initiate recovery.
- Emergency drills demonstrate personnel protection measures, including controlling and minimizing hazards to individuals during fires, medical emergencies, mitigation activities, search and rescue, and other similar events.
- Emergency drills demonstrate that on-site communications effectively support emergency response activities.
- Emergency drills demonstrate that the emergency public information organization disseminates accurate, reliable, timely, and understandable information.
- Provisions are made for conducting quarterly communications checks with off-site response organizations.
- Offsite organizations are invited to participate in the biennial on-site exercise, which tests the major elements of the emergency plan and response organizations.
This information is required to meet the requirement ofSection Il.F to Appendix E of 10 CFR Part 50, and conforms to the guidance ofthe ISG augmenting NUREG-153 7 Part 2, Section 12. 7. 10.
Clarify how the conductance ofdrills, as described in PSAR Chapter 12, Appendix A, Section Al0.2, "Emergency Drills, " demonstrates the above guidance.
Item one of Section A 10.2 will be amended to read, "Annual on-site emergency drills will be conducted as action drills, with each required emergency measure being executed as realistically as is reasonably possible. Drills should be conducted such that:
Qualified individuals for each position in the emergency response organization demonstrate task-related knowledge through periodic participation.
Emergency drills demonstrate that resources are effective and used to control the site, mitigate further damage, control radiological releases, perform required on-site activities under simulated radiation or airborne and other emergency conditions, accurately assess the facility ' s status during an accident, and initiate recovery.
Emergency drills demonstrate personnel protection measures, including controlling and minimizing hazards to individuals during fires, medical emergencies, mitigation activities, search and rescue, and other similar events.
Emergency drills demonstrate that on-site communications effectively support emergency response activities.
Emergency drills demonstrate that the emergency public information organization disseminates accurate, reliable, timely, and understandable information."
Section Al0.4.2 describes functional testing of emergency communications and emergency health physics equipment. While the Interim Staff Guidance (ISG) augmenting NUREG-1537, Part 2, Section 12.7 describes the need for checking quarterly communications with off-site agencies, it is unclear at this point in the licensing process whether dedicated communications lines (beyond common cell, network, and landlines) to off-site response organizations is necessary.
The participation with off-site emergency response organizations is described in item three of Section Al0.2.
9 of 12
..:;.-.;-. .NWMI NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0
. '. ~~.~~ ." . NOflTHWUTMfDCWISOTOPES Request for additional information RAI 12A-8 As required in Section ll.H to Appendix E of 10 CFR Part 50, the PSAR should provide a preliminary analysis reflecting the need to include facilities, systems, and methods for identifYing the degree ofseriousness and potential scope ofradiological consequences ofemergency situations.
Concerning this requirement, the 1SG augmenting NUREG 1537, Part 2, Section 12. 7.5, "Emergency Action Levels, "provides the guidelines for reviewing applications and references NUREG-0849, Section 5.0, "Emergency Action Levels."
PSAR, Chapter 12, Section A5.0 does not contain action levels with initiating conditions such as effluent monitor set points appropriate to the facility and consistent with NUREG-0849 Appendix I.
SpecifY the effluent monitors used to project dose rates and radiological effluent releases, and include the set points in the emergency action levels (EALs) to initiate protective actions as per guidance ofNURG-0849, or explain why this information is not necessary.
Effluent monitors used to project dose rates and radiological effluent releases and any associated setpoints for such systems will be identified in the NWMI Operating License Application. The manufacturer, detection methodology, and (therefore) instrument setpoints will also be identified in the Operating License Application.
RAI 12A-9 PSAR, Chapter 12, Section A5.0, "Emergency Action Levels" contains Table A-1, "Emergency Classes and Action Levels. "NWM1 did not provide a basis for the General Emergency classification listed in Table A-1. Additionally, the Site Area Emergency and General Emergency classifications have the same EALs listed in Table A-1. This information is inconsistent with information in Section A 4. 5 ofthe NWMJ ERP.
This information is required to meet the requirement ofAppendix E to JO CFR Part 50, and conform to the guidance ofNUREG-0849, Section 5.0; 1SG Augmenting 1537, Part 2, Section 12. 7.5; and ANSI-ANS-15.16-2015.
RAI 12A-9a ClarifY the basis for the inclusion ofa General Emergency classification in PSAR Chapter 12, Appendix A, Section A5.0.
For the Construction Permit Application, all classes of emergencies included in ANSI/ANS 15.16 (2015),
Emergency Planning for Research Reactors, were included in the NWMI draft emergency plan. If, at the Operating License Application stage, NWMI finds that the emergency action levels (EAL) for a given emergency class cannot be reached, the final emergency plan will be amended and those emergency classes will be removed.
RAI 12A-9b Explain why the Site Area Emergency and General Emergency EALs are identical in Table A-1 of the NWMI ERP.
Table A-1 will be amended such that the EALs for each emergency class are consistent with that found in ANSI/ANS 15.16.
RAI 12A-9c Explain why there are no security-related action level as discussed in ANSI!ANS-15.16-2015, "Emergency Planning for Research Reactors, " associated with an Alert.
Table A-1 will be amended such that the EALs for each emergency class are consistent with that found in ANSI/ANS 15.16. Security-related action levels are described in this standard.
10 of 12
........ . NWMI
.:;*.-~~* NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0
~.*
. '-~~.~~.'. NllRTHWESTMEOICALISCTDPES REFERENCES 10 CFR 50, "Domestic Licensing of Production and Utilization Facilities," Code of Federal Regulations, Office of the Federal Register, as amended.
\
ANSI/ANS-15.16, Emergency Planning/or Research Reactors, American Nuclear Society, La Grange Park, Illinois, 2015.
NRC, 2012, Final Interim Staff Guidance Augmenting NUREG-1537, "Guidelines for Preparing and Reviewing Applications for the Licensing ofNon-Power Reactors," Parts 1 and 2, for Licensing Radioisotope Production Facilities and Aqueous Homogeneous Reactors, Docket Number:
NRC-2011-0135, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C., October 17, 2012.
NUREG-0849, Standard Review Plan for the Review and Evaluation ofEmergency Plans for Research and Test Reactors, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Inspection end Enforcement, Washington, D.C., October 1983.
NUREG-153 7, Guidelines for Preparing and Reviewing Applications for the Licensing ofNon-Power Reactors - Format and Content, Part 1, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Washington, D.C., February 1996.
NUREG-1537, Guidelines for Preparing and Reviewing Applications for the Licensing ofNon-Power Reactors: Standard Review Plan and Acceptance Criteria, Part 2, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Washington, D.C., February 1996.
NWMI-2013-021, Construction Permit Application for Radioisotope Production Facility, Rev. 0, Northwest Medical Isotopes, LLC, Corvallis, Oregon, June 29, 2015.
11 of 12
NWMl-2017-RAl-001, Rev. 0 This page intentionally left blank.
12of12