ML12173A202: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 5: Line 5:
| author name = Lampert M
| author name = Lampert M
| author affiliation = Pilgrim Watch
| author affiliation = Pilgrim Watch
| addressee name = Borchardt R W
| addressee name = Borchardt R
| addressee affiliation = NRC/EDO
| addressee affiliation = NRC/EDO
| docket = 05000293
| docket = 05000293
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:" T~~o~. LeccO NOQ_, f2&_ (.5Zý012ý32_7 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA DEDMRT DEDR DEDCM NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION AO BEFORE THE EDO, U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION -r June 20, 2012 Oyc , R. William Borchardt i iN Executive Director for Operations Z04.1J" 9, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mkf t t C&O Washington, DC 20555-0001----,. Via Email hearingdocket@nrc.gov SUPPLEMENT TO 2.206 ENFORCEMENT PETITION REGARDING LABOR DISPUTE- PILGRIM NPS (SUBMITTED MAY 16, 2012) -MONTHLY COMMUNICATION TEST FAILURE Pilgrim Watch ("PW") respectfully requests to supplement its 2.206 enforcement petition submitted originally on May 16 regarding the labor dispute at Pilgrim Station highlighting its public safety implications.
{{#Wiki_filter:"                                                                 T~~o~. LeccO NOQ_,
We submit the following pertinent new information that supports PW's request for NRC to order Pilgrim closed for operations until the labor dispute is resolved with all 369 union workers reinstated in their original jobs onsite.This morning we were informed that during the monthly scheduled radio test, no DNN Fax came through to any of the test participants in Pilgrim Station's EPZ. This is important because when EOC's get a notification of an event it comes through the BECONS radio and DNN fax and the system is supposedly redundant for obvious safety reasons. During this morning's test, no fax was received by any of the EPZ 24 hour answering points or the EPZ EOC's. This was out of the ordinary; usually one or two miss-fire due to issues on the receiving point end such as no toner or paper.11RM~A-v&
f2&_ (.5Zý012ý32_7 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA                                       DEDMRT DEDR DEDCM NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION                                       AO BEFORE THE EDO, U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION                                 -r June 20, 2012                                       Oyc     ,
t=-MoO( IsLM0 We naturally were curious if the lock-out had anything to do with it. Tom White, Pilgrim Emergency Planner, said the lock-out had no impact on the communication failure in an email to the Emergency Response Directors, dated Wed, 20 Jun 2012 16:43:32.
i    iN R. William Borchardt Executive Director for Operations                                                             Z04.1J"         9, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission                                                             Mkf       t t C&O Washington, DC 20555-0001----,.                                                                               NQ*,
He said that the test is normally performed from the Control Room and because there was another evolution there, the test was moved to the EOF as allowed by procedure.
Via Email hearingdocket@nrc.gov SUPPLEMENT TO 2.206 ENFORCEMENT PETITION REGARDING LABOR DISPUTE- PILGRIM NPS (SUBMITTED MAY 16, 2012) - MONTHLY COMMUNICATION TEST FAILURE Pilgrim Watch ("PW") respectfully requests to supplement its 2.206 enforcement petition submitted originally on May 16 regarding the labor dispute at Pilgrim Station highlighting its public safety implications. We submit the following pertinent new information that supports PW's request for NRC to order Pilgrim closed for operations until the labor dispute is resolved with all 369 union workers reinstated in their original jobs onsite.
It appears to be a remarkable coincidence that all EOC's reported the same problem and that it occurred for the first time during the lock-out.
This morning we were informed that during the monthly scheduled radio test, no DNN Fax came through to any of the test participants in Pilgrim Station's EPZ. This is important because when EOC's get a notification of an event it comes through the BECONS radio and DNN fax and the system is supposedly redundant for obvious safety reasons. During this morning's test, no fax was received by any of the EPZ 24 hour answering points or the EPZ EOC's. This was out of the ordinary; usually one or two miss-fire due to issues on the receiving point end such as no toner or paper.
We request that NRC investigate.
11RM~A-v& t=-MoO(                                                                                         IsLM0
Our original filing and each of our supplemental filings may appear not be such a "big deal" if looked at individually;" but when looked at collectively, they paint a clear picture that reasonable assurance is not adequately protected during this lock-out.
 
Further, we believe that the filings provide valuable lessons learned for NRC to apply to subsequent lock-outs industry-wide.Respectfully submitted on behalf of Petitioners, (Electronically signed)Mary lampert Pilgrim Watch, Director 148 Washington Street Duxbury, MA Tel. 781-934-0389 Email: mary. jamperticomcast.net June 20, 2012 2}}
We naturally were curious if the lock-out had anything to do with it. Tom White, Pilgrim Emergency Planner, said the lock-out had no impact on the communication failure in an email to the Emergency Response Directors, dated Wed, 20 Jun 2012 16:43:32. He said that the test is normally performed from the Control Room and because there was another evolution there, the test was moved to the EOF as allowed by procedure.
It appears to be a remarkable coincidence that all EOC's reported the same problem and that it occurred for the first time during the lock-out. We request that NRC investigate.
Our original filing and each of our supplemental filings may appear not be such a "big deal" if looked at individually;" but when looked at collectively, they paint a clear picture that reasonable assurance is not adequately protected during this lock-out. Further, we believe that the filings provide valuable lessons learned for NRC to apply to subsequent lock-outs industry-wide.
Respectfully submitted on behalf of Petitioners, (Electronically signed)
Mary lampert Pilgrim Watch, Director 148 Washington Street Duxbury, MA Tel. 781-934-0389 Email: mary.jamperticomcast.net June 20, 2012 2}}

Latest revision as of 02:46, 12 November 2019

G20120327 - Mary Lampert Ltr. Supplement to 2.206 Enforcement Petition Regarding Labor Dispute-Pilgrim NPS (Submitted May 16, 2012) - Monthly Communication Test Failure
ML12173A202
Person / Time
Site: Pilgrim
Issue date: 06/20/2012
From: Lampert M
Pilgrim Watch
To: Borchardt R
NRC/EDO
References
2.206, G20120327
Download: ML12173A202 (2)
v • d • e


Text

" T~~o~. LeccO NOQ_,

f2&_ (.5Zý012ý32_7 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA DEDMRT DEDR DEDCM NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION AO BEFORE THE EDO, U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION -r June 20, 2012 Oyc ,

i iN R. William Borchardt Executive Director for Operations Z04.1J" 9, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mkf t t C&O Washington, DC 20555-0001----,. NQ*,

Via Email hearingdocket@nrc.gov SUPPLEMENT TO 2.206 ENFORCEMENT PETITION REGARDING LABOR DISPUTE- PILGRIM NPS (SUBMITTED MAY 16, 2012) - MONTHLY COMMUNICATION TEST FAILURE Pilgrim Watch ("PW") respectfully requests to supplement its 2.206 enforcement petition submitted originally on May 16 regarding the labor dispute at Pilgrim Station highlighting its public safety implications. We submit the following pertinent new information that supports PW's request for NRC to order Pilgrim closed for operations until the labor dispute is resolved with all 369 union workers reinstated in their original jobs onsite.

This morning we were informed that during the monthly scheduled radio test, no DNN Fax came through to any of the test participants in Pilgrim Station's EPZ. This is important because when EOC's get a notification of an event it comes through the BECONS radio and DNN fax and the system is supposedly redundant for obvious safety reasons. During this morning's test, no fax was received by any of the EPZ 24 hour2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> answering points or the EPZ EOC's. This was out of the ordinary; usually one or two miss-fire due to issues on the receiving point end such as no toner or paper.

11RM~A-v& t=-MoO( IsLM0

We naturally were curious if the lock-out had anything to do with it. Tom White, Pilgrim Emergency Planner, said the lock-out had no impact on the communication failure in an email to the Emergency Response Directors, dated Wed, 20 Jun 2012 16:43:32. He said that the test is normally performed from the Control Room and because there was another evolution there, the test was moved to the EOF as allowed by procedure.

It appears to be a remarkable coincidence that all EOC's reported the same problem and that it occurred for the first time during the lock-out. We request that NRC investigate.

Our original filing and each of our supplemental filings may appear not be such a "big deal" if looked at individually;" but when looked at collectively, they paint a clear picture that reasonable assurance is not adequately protected during this lock-out. Further, we believe that the filings provide valuable lessons learned for NRC to apply to subsequent lock-outs industry-wide.

Respectfully submitted on behalf of Petitioners, (Electronically signed)

Mary lampert Pilgrim Watch, Director 148 Washington Street Duxbury, MA Tel. 781-934-0389 Email: mary.jamperticomcast.net June 20, 2012 2

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML12173A202&oldid=2098669"