ML16116A365: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
| issue date = 03/23/2016
| issue date = 03/23/2016
| title = 2016 Byron Nuclear Station Initial License Examination Outline and Operating Test Changes
| title = 2016 Byron Nuclear Station Initial License Examination Outline and Operating Test Changes
| author name = Bielby M E
| author name = Bielby M
| author affiliation = NRC/RGN-III/DRS/OB
| author affiliation = NRC/RGN-III/DRS/OB
| addressee name =  
| addressee name =  
Line 15: Line 15:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:Item Change d Reason for Change CR-b Added "alternate path" designation Overlooked that it is an "alternate path" JPM on original outline.
{{#Wiki_filter:Item                 Changed                                  Reason for Change CR-b   Added alternate path designation     Overlooked that it is an alternate path JPM on original outline.
CR-e Changed event from "Switch Running SX Pumps (with failure to develop pressure)" to "Respond to 1A SX Pump Trip (Standby Pump Trips)". The originally chosen JPM (a newly developed one) did not have clear procedural guidance, and could have resulted in 4 different operator responses.
CR-e   Changed event from Switch Running     The originally chosen JPM (a newly developed SX Pumps (with failure to develop      one) did not have clear procedural guidance, pressure) to Respond to 1A SX Pump    and could have resulted in 4 different operator Trip (Standby Pump Trips).            responses.
CR-h Removed "alternate path" designation The response is contained in the BAR with little decision making required.
CR-h   Removed alternate path designation   The response is contained in the BAR with little decision making required.
RA-c Changed from bank JPM to new JPM RM-11 system was changed to a Windows based Radiation Monitoring System and the actions are different.
RA-c   Changed from bank JPM to new JPM       RM-11 system was changed to a Windows based Radiation Monitoring System and the actions are different.
Scenario N16-1 Swapped events # 2 & 3 Ensures control rod control is in AUTO before instrument failure that affects rod control Scenario N16-4 Changed Event 2 from TS evaluation of SI pump failed surveillance to AF pump failed surveillance CR-c is operation of a SI pump and the relevant TS is entered when a valve is closed in the surveillance. This could lead the students to the answer on scenario event.
Scenario Swapped events # 2 & 3                 Ensures control rod control is in AUTO before N16-1                                          instrument failure that affects rod control Scenario Changed Event 2 from TS evaluation     CR-c is operation of a SI pump and the N16-4  of SI pump failed surveillance to AF    relevant TS is entered when a valve is closed pump failed surveillance                in the surveillance. This could lead the students to the answer on scenario event.
Scenario 16-5 Changed event 6 from "I" to "C" Error on original outline. This is a component failure, not an instrument failure.
Scenario Changed event 6 from I to C         Error on original outline. This is a component 16-5                                          failure, not an instrument failure.
Question #72 Rejected K/A and replaced question K/A is at a General Employee level, not suitable for licensed operator exam discrimination.
Question Rejected K/A and replaced question     K/A is at a General Employee level, not
Question #92 Rejected K/A and replaced question This K/A is very applicable to ROs and difficult to apply as a "generic" K/A not linked to a system. Asking a "basis" question fits the SRO model much better.
  #72                                          suitable for licensed operator exam discrimination.
RA-a Replaced "Perform Shutdown Margin Calculations" JPM with "Perform Offsite AC Power Availability Surveillance".
Question Rejected K/A and replaced question     This K/A is very applicable to ROs and difficult
Little discriminatory value, replaced with JPM requiring more evaluation.
  #92                                          to apply as a generic K/A not linked to a system. Asking a basis question fits the SRO model much better.
IP-i Removed Alternate Path designation from JPM JPM is not alternate path.
RA-a   Replaced Perform Shutdown Margin       Little discriminatory value, replaced with JPM Calculations JPM with Perform Offsite requiring more evaluation.
AC Power Availability Surveillance.
IP-i Removed Alternate Path designation     JPM is not alternate path.
from JPM


Item Change d Reason for Change CR-b Added "alternate path" designation Overlooked that it is an "alternate path" JPM on original outline.
Item                 Changed                                  Reason for Change CR-b   Added alternate path designation     Overlooked that it is an alternate path JPM on original outline.
CR-e Changed event from "Switch Running SX Pumps (with failure to develop pressure)" to "Respond to 1A SX Pump Trip (Standby Pump Trips)". The originally chosen JPM (a newly developed one) did not have clear procedural guidance, and could have resulted in 4 different operator responses.
CR-e   Changed event from Switch Running     The originally chosen JPM (a newly developed SX Pumps (with failure to develop      one) did not have clear procedural guidance, pressure) to Respond to 1A SX Pump    and could have resulted in 4 different operator Trip (Standby Pump Trips).            responses.
CR-h Removed "alternate path" designation The response is contained in the BAR with little decision making required.
CR-h   Removed alternate path designation   The response is contained in the BAR with little decision making required.
RA-c Changed from bank JPM to new JPM RM-11 system was changed to a Windows based Radiation Monitoring System and the actions are different.
RA-c   Changed from bank JPM to new JPM       RM-11 system was changed to a Windows based Radiation Monitoring System and the actions are different.
Scenario N16-1 Swapped events # 2 & 3 Ensures control rod control is in AUTO before instrument failure that affects rod control Scenario N16-4 Changed Event 2 from TS evaluation of SI pump failed surveillance to AF pump failed surveillance CR-c is operation of a SI pump and the relevant TS is entered when a valve is closed in the surveillance. This could lead the students to the answer on scenario event.
Scenario Swapped events # 2 & 3                 Ensures control rod control is in AUTO before N16-1                                          instrument failure that affects rod control Scenario Changed Event 2 from TS evaluation     CR-c is operation of a SI pump and the N16-4  of SI pump failed surveillance to AF    relevant TS is entered when a valve is closed pump failed surveillance                in the surveillance. This could lead the students to the answer on scenario event.
Scenario 16-5 Changed event 6 from "I" to "C" Error on original outline. This is a component failure, not an instrument failure.
Scenario Changed event 6 from I to C         Error on original outline. This is a component 16-5                                          failure, not an instrument failure.
Question #72 Rejected K/A and replaced question K/A is at a General Employee level, not suitable for licensed operator exam discrimination.
Question Rejected K/A and replaced question     K/A is at a General Employee level, not
Question #92 Rejected K/A and replaced question This K/A is very applicable to ROs and difficult to apply as a "generic" K/A not linked to a system. Asking a "basis" question fits the SRO model much better.
  #72                                          suitable for licensed operator exam discrimination.
RA-a Replaced "Perform Shutdown Margin Calculations" JPM with "Perform Offsite AC Power Availability Surveillance".
Question Rejected K/A and replaced question     This K/A is very applicable to ROs and difficult
Little discriminatory value, replaced with JPM requiring more evaluation.
  #92                                          to apply as a generic K/A not linked to a system. Asking a basis question fits the SRO model much better.
IP-i Removed Alternate Path designation from JPM JPM is not alternate path.}}
RA-a   Replaced Perform Shutdown Margin       Little discriminatory value, replaced with JPM Calculations JPM with Perform Offsite requiring more evaluation.
AC Power Availability Surveillance.
IP-i Removed Alternate Path designation     JPM is not alternate path.
from JPM}}

Latest revision as of 21:16, 30 October 2019

2016 Byron Nuclear Station Initial License Examination Outline and Operating Test Changes
ML16116A365
Person / Time
Site: Byron  Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 03/23/2016
From: Bielby M
Operations Branch III
To:
Exelon Generation Co
References
Download: ML16116A365 (1)


Text

Item Changed Reason for Change CR-b Added alternate path designation Overlooked that it is an alternate path JPM on original outline.

CR-e Changed event from Switch Running The originally chosen JPM (a newly developed SX Pumps (with failure to develop one) did not have clear procedural guidance, pressure) to Respond to 1A SX Pump and could have resulted in 4 different operator Trip (Standby Pump Trips). responses.

CR-h Removed alternate path designation The response is contained in the BAR with little decision making required.

RA-c Changed from bank JPM to new JPM RM-11 system was changed to a Windows based Radiation Monitoring System and the actions are different.

Scenario Swapped events # 2 & 3 Ensures control rod control is in AUTO before N16-1 instrument failure that affects rod control Scenario Changed Event 2 from TS evaluation CR-c is operation of a SI pump and the N16-4 of SI pump failed surveillance to AF relevant TS is entered when a valve is closed pump failed surveillance in the surveillance. This could lead the students to the answer on scenario event.

Scenario Changed event 6 from I to C Error on original outline. This is a component 16-5 failure, not an instrument failure.

Question Rejected K/A and replaced question K/A is at a General Employee level, not

  1. 72 suitable for licensed operator exam discrimination.

Question Rejected K/A and replaced question This K/A is very applicable to ROs and difficult

  1. 92 to apply as a generic K/A not linked to a system. Asking a basis question fits the SRO model much better.

RA-a Replaced Perform Shutdown Margin Little discriminatory value, replaced with JPM Calculations JPM with Perform Offsite requiring more evaluation.

AC Power Availability Surveillance.

IP-i Removed Alternate Path designation JPM is not alternate path.

from JPM

Item Changed Reason for Change CR-b Added alternate path designation Overlooked that it is an alternate path JPM on original outline.

CR-e Changed event from Switch Running The originally chosen JPM (a newly developed SX Pumps (with failure to develop one) did not have clear procedural guidance, pressure) to Respond to 1A SX Pump and could have resulted in 4 different operator Trip (Standby Pump Trips). responses.

CR-h Removed alternate path designation The response is contained in the BAR with little decision making required.

RA-c Changed from bank JPM to new JPM RM-11 system was changed to a Windows based Radiation Monitoring System and the actions are different.

Scenario Swapped events # 2 & 3 Ensures control rod control is in AUTO before N16-1 instrument failure that affects rod control Scenario Changed Event 2 from TS evaluation CR-c is operation of a SI pump and the N16-4 of SI pump failed surveillance to AF relevant TS is entered when a valve is closed pump failed surveillance in the surveillance. This could lead the students to the answer on scenario event.

Scenario Changed event 6 from I to C Error on original outline. This is a component 16-5 failure, not an instrument failure.

Question Rejected K/A and replaced question K/A is at a General Employee level, not

  1. 72 suitable for licensed operator exam discrimination.

Question Rejected K/A and replaced question This K/A is very applicable to ROs and difficult

  1. 92 to apply as a generic K/A not linked to a system. Asking a basis question fits the SRO model much better.

RA-a Replaced Perform Shutdown Margin Little discriminatory value, replaced with JPM Calculations JPM with Perform Offsite requiring more evaluation.

AC Power Availability Surveillance.

IP-i Removed Alternate Path designation JPM is not alternate path.

from JPM